pdf Bay of Fundy RMA Study - Municipality of the County of Colchester
Transcription
pdf Bay of Fundy RMA Study - Municipality of the County of Colchester
Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Attraction Development Plan Proposal March, 2010 Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Attraction Development Plan Executive Summary Introduction This report is an interpretation and development plan for the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia. The Bay of Fundy is a dramatic and diverse coastline and a natural phenomenon with international tourism potential. As is the case with many of the worldʼs greatest nature tourism destinations, the Bay of Fundy is an extraordinary classroom of globally significant topics. The Bay of Fundy can teach visitors about the relationship between the moon and earth, about one of the worldʼs rarest mammals and its struggle for survival, or about the greatest extinction since life emerged on this planet. These lessons are all found within the intricacies of the Bay of Fundy landscape and environment. This report was prepared as a planning document for interpretation and development of attractions within the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia. The Bay of Fundy region in Nova Scotia has suffered from a confusing mix of regional identities, overlapping tourism regions (administratively), assorted scenic travel ways and a general lack of a unifying theme and identity. Glooscap Trail, Evangeline Trail, Fundy Shore Scenic Drive, Fundy Shore, Fundy Shore Ecotour are all names used to promote various sections or the whole region of Fundy. The Bay of Fundyʼs human history is ably interpreted at Wolfville and Annapolis Royal, and, more recently, its geological history at Parrsboro and Joggins. Yet the visitor who seeks to comprehend the world-record phenomenon of the tides is left adrift to piece the tide story together on their own through visiting a series of un-interpreted lookoffs and harbours. When travelers come here they seek opportunities to see, experience, and learn about the worldʼs highest tides. The tidal theme lacks sites with professional interpretation, defined tidal experiences, and safe access for visitors. The visitor experience of Nova Scotiaʼs Fundy coast is largely self-guided and random. By contrast, New Brunswick has invested considerable effort toward creating several staffed, iconic tidal experiences. Over the past several years, there has been several key new developments in the northern region of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy. A new UNESCO World Heritage Site was designated in 2008 at Joggins and has become one of Nova Scotiaʼs newest attractions. The Fundy Geological museum at Parrsboro, already a popular attraction, was undergoing a complete upgrade at the time of writing. At Cape Chignecto, a natural environment park designated 15 years ago, the new Three Sisters Day Use area opened in 2009 1 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited and provides access to extraordinary rock formations near Apple River, Nova Scotia. Prior to these developments, the most highly visited attractions in the Bay of Fundy region have been three national historic sites located in the vicinity of Annapolis Royal and Wolfville. Yet, it is the tidal phenomenon that makes the Bay of Fundy a “Natural Wonder” and positions the Bay in the global nature-tourism arena. The potential of the Bay of Fundy to be a tourism attraction of international status and to play an effective role in generating tourism visitation to Nova Scotia, is contingent upon highlighting and interpreting outstanding tidal landscapes and developing the tidal theme. Based on these observations and on an assessment of the existing product, we prepared the following gap assessment in the attractions and interpretation mix of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy. Elements that are absent include: A) Interpreted Tidal Sites and Attractions Anchor attractions are needed that focus on the tidal theme or experience in locations offering good potential for tide-related activities, significant and extraordinary tidal features and diverse scenic coastal and inter-tidal landscapes. B) Bay of Fundy Marine Environment Centre The Bay of Fundy is, by definition, a marine ecosystem, and (except during whale watch tours) there is no interpretation of the marine environment or wildlife within the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia. A significant opportunity exists to develop such an attraction in the Digby area. C) Network of Viewpoints A consistent network of viewpoints is needed to offer adequate amenities to visitors and to reinforce the Bay of Fundy theme. Viewpoints should meet minimum standards and be linked by a common identity. D) Way-finding and Orientation (Strengthen the Identity) A comprehensive system of way-finding and an orientation sign program is needed to support a harmonious Bay of Fundy identity for Nova Scotia. E) Identification and Market Readiness Standards for Secondary Attractions All key sites, whether tidal experience sites, should meet minimum market readiness and capacity standards and be featured in a comprehensive identity program. Similarly, there are a number of significant smaller interpretation facilities that can play an important role in the Bay of Fundy product. Standards for these sites should be established. 2 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Development Plan The attraction is the Bay of Fundy itself. It is the location and the phenomenon that collectively creates the attraction (in the same way that the Grand Canyon or a National Park is an attraction in itself). The tide is the artist of the Bay of Fundy, the sculptor of the landscape, and the creator of mystery. ʻTideʼ is the central theme of the area and the fundamental reason why this vast tidal zone is an interesting place to explore. Yet in itself, the tide isnʼt a particularly alluring idea. Instead, the focus needs to be on the drama of the landscape, the changes brought about by the action of the tides. The following are a few ideas that share the same fundamental highlights and messages, but from slightly different angles: Canadaʼs Tidal Shoreline Living with the Worldʼs Giant Tides Canadaʼs Natural Wonder Based on these thematic guidelines, this report recognizes the need for key activity-based attractions focusing on the worldʼs highest tides. At the same time, it is a priority to more strongly define and promote the identity of the region (the Bay of Fundy) as a whole, through consistent signs, infrastructure, amenities, etc., and by defining boundaries. Provincial Parks – The Untapped Resource Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy coastal parks have expanded by acquisition and designation by more than 300% since 1995 making them (currently) one of the most important, if underdeveloped, coastal park systems in Canada. The extent to which the extraordinary coastal features of the Bay of Fundy are now within a significant network of Nova Scotia Parks is not fully recognized within the Province, nor is it promoted effectively to prospective visitors from outside the region. It is the recommendation of this report that Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy Parks should offer interpretation and programming that demonstrate and showcase their unique tidal, coastal and terrestrial features and thus become key attractions within the Bay of Fundy region. Cape Split Coastal Discovery Site Blomidon and Cape Split together represent a key Bay of Fundy themed development opportunity in the Annapolis Valley region. While Cape Split and Blomidon are two distinct land areas, they are essentially considered a single unit by the Parks Division, DNR. A third site can be included in this cluster: Look-off Provincial day-use park. 3 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Cape Split has the qualities of an internationally significant landmark. The tidal phenomenon at the Split makes it unique in the world. Cape Split provides views of the Bay of Fundyʼs most visible and powerful tidal rip, as well as, a panoramic view of its narrowest, most turbulent section: the Minas Channel. In addition, scenic attributes such as the vertical drop and geological features here are outstanding. Walking Experience The principle walking trail should be designed to a front-country standard and a moderately low-level of difficulty. The principle feature of the park would be a walking trail (although the water tours may be a significant part of the experience, as well). Cape Split will have a walking distance of at least 10-12 kilometers and an overall duration of two to four hours. It is recommended that the trail be designed to a front-country standard and a moderately lowlevel of difficulty. Development Recommendations This report recommends that the planning concept for the development zone at Cape Split be revisited with the intention of providing improved access, parking, viewpoints and the development of a high quality visitor orientation and education facility. Five Islands Tidal Discovery Site Five Islands is one of the best sites in the Bay of Fundy for interpreting and experiencing the tidal and inter-tidal phenomena. Tides at Five Islands are third highest of monitored sites within the Minas Basin, and the inter-tidal zone at Five Islands is one of the most expansive, dramatic and diverse in the Bay. This park also has a vast geological history, visible in the cliffs and islands that can be told and interpreted from this location. As is often the case, where there is a geological story, there is also outstanding rock collecting. Since the beginning of the “Not Since Moses” race across the ocean floor in 2007, there has been a significant increase in national recognition of the breathtaking inter-tidal landscape offered at Five Islands. Development Recommendations Five Islands Provincial Park could have high market appeal as a tidal experience viewing and interpretation site, as well as, a staging zone for adventure or experiential programs. Program infrastructure components should include: 1. Visitor Interpretation and Orientation Centre 2. Viewpoints and Shoreline Access 3. Tidal Adventure Tours and Excursions 4 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Digby Marine Discovery Centre Other Key Attractions The Town of Digby is a suitable location for interpreting the Bay of Fundy marine environment. The town is an active seaport and has a large fishery with a history closely linked to the Bay. It has a tourism-friendly town centre and a strong base of accommodations, the most notable of which is the premium resort hotel: the Digby Pines. Brier Island Enhancements to hiking ʻproductʼ on Brier Island will naturally draw visitors along the Neck and Long Island as part of the adventure of making it to the tip of this intriguing land formation. Development Concept Consistent with the goals of the Digby Area Tourism Association, this report recommends the creation of a multi-faceted activity centre with potential to attract a significant market. Location Options It is absolutely essential that the centre establish or maintain a connection with the fishing community and the town centre. Other factors such as the flow of pedestrian traffic into and through the commercial centre of the community, parking, etc., must be evaluated in a site-specific development plan. Parks Canada Marine Park Parks Canada has had a mandate to create National Marine Conservation Areas (NMCA) across Canada since the concept was established in 2002. This report recommends that Brier Island participate in the research process with Parks Canada to determine the opportunities and fit of a marine park in the region. Cape Chignecto Provincial Park Cape Chignecto is a key component of the trio of Bay of Fundy parks, strongly representing a coastal wilderness hiking experience. It has potential to build its market to 10,000 (similar to the visitor numbers for the West Coast Trail), if it is part of a larger integrated system. In addition to the upgrading of the wildernesshiking trail, the priority is to provide shoreline access at Eatonville. As in the above case, this was being reviewed at the time of this report and programming options were being considered. 5 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Touring Network In addition to Anchor Attractions, this report has identified a network of interpretation sites, viewpoints and hiking trails. Interpretation Sites Most Interpretation sites listed in this report are staffed facilities, each representing key Bay of Fundy themes and meeting common market readiness standards. These sites donʼt have the level of facilities, interpretation, programming, etc. of anchors, yet they are important sites offering a particular interpretation topic or story. The use of a common identity and wayfinding program serves to link them into an overall touring network. Tidal Technology Sites Annapolis Tidal Power Station Tidal Power Centre at Black Rock (planned) Themed Tidal Sites Burncoat Head Cape dʼOr Lighthouse South Maitland Tidal Interpretation Park Halls Harbour Bear River Tidal Estuary Heritage – Culture & Marine Age of Sail Heritage Centre Cobequid Interpretation Centre Glooscap Heritage Centre Lawrence House Museum Avon River Heritage Museum & Avon Spirit Shipyard Blue Beach Fossil Museum (planned) Prescott House Museum Historic Gardens (salt marsh) Viewpoints Viewpoints are proposed to reinforce the identity of the travel region, through a graphic program, provide basic amenities (washroom facilities) between larger attractions and communities, and focus on site-specific themes, creating an interpretation framework for the area as a whole. Hiking Trails The final component is a system of hiking trails to complement the touring network of attractions and viewpoints. They are self-guided and offer a nature-based experience of the Bay of Fundy. Wayfinding and Identity Program The wayfinding and identity program has an extremely important role in defining the Bay of Fundy region, helping to create the allure and sense of place that will develop a long term and sustainable growth in visitation. The purpose of a way-finding and identity program can be stated as follows: 1. Provide directions 2. Reinforce the identity of the region 3. Unify and link the region 6 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited The required components include: • gateway entry point • regional entry signs • route markers • site-specific entrance signs The author of this report believes that there is potential for substantial growth in tourism numbers to the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia. Certainly, there is evidence from New Brunswick that tourism growth focused around well-rounded Bay of Fundy experiences can approach the visitation numbers of a National Park (such as visitation to Hopewell Rocks). Given the phenomenal quality and accessibility of the Bay of Fundy coastline in Nova Scotia, it is believed that, with the enhancement of several key assets in this province, visitation can be significantly increased and can ultimately make a valuable contribution to the Provinceʼs tourism future. 7 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction……………………………....................... 1 PART A – Situation Analysis 1. Context…………………………………………….. 1.1 Defining Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy………………………….……... 1.2 Tides……………………................... 1.3 New Brunswickʼs Bay of Fundy Product…………………………… 1.4 Weaknesses of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy Product……………………….. 4 4 2. The Tourism Market…………………………..….. 2.1 Global Tourism………………….…… 2.2 Tourism in the Bay of Fundy…..…... 2.3 Travel Patterns………………..…….. 12 12 14 17 3. Potential as a Nature Tourism Destination…….. 3.1 What is a Tourism Destination?....... 3.2 Natural Attractions as Destinations... 3.3 Developing a Nature Tourism Destination………………….………… 21 21 22 28 4. Current Bay of Fundy Product……….…….…….. 4.1 Attractions………………….…………. 4.2 Activities………………….......…..…... 4.3 Parks…………………………….……. 4.4 Gap Evaluation………………….……. 29 29 31 33 35 5 7 6. Anchor Attractions…………………………..………….. 6.1 Provincial Parks – The Untapped Resource………………………………. 6.2 Criteria…………………………………. 6.3 Cape Split Coastal Discovery Site………………………………..……. 6.4 Five Islands Tidal Discovery Site……………………………………... 6.5 Digby Marine Discovery Site…..…………………………………... 43 46 7. Other Key Attractions……………………….………….. 7.1 Brier Island……………………………. 7.2 Cape Chignecto………………………. 74 74 79 8. Touring Network……………………………..…………. 8.1 Interpretive Sites………………………. 8.2 Viewpoints………………………………. 8.3 Hiking Trails…………………………….. 81 81 96 112 9. Identity Program………………………………………… 9.1 Wayfinding and Identity….................... 9.2 Entry Concept……………………......... 9.3 Orientation…………………………........ 9.4 Identity Program Concept……….......... 120 120 120 126 129 10. Conclusion……………………………………………... 10.1 Conclusions and Implementation Guidelines………………………………. 10.2 Implementation Framework…………... 131 131 61 69 10 PART B – Development Plan Appendices 5. Thematic Concept……………………………….... 5.1 Experiences…………………………... 5.2 Creating the Allure…………………... 5.3 Thematic Sub-Regions………...……. 5.4 System vs. Icon………………....…… 5.5 Recommended Strategy…………………………......… 50 51 38 39 40 41 41 42 A1 A2 Concept Illustrations Viewpoint Charts 132 Introduction The Bay of Fundy, with its giant tides, is one of Nova Scotiaʼs most valuable tourism assets. The Bay of Fundy tides are recognized globally, a fact that could position it as an internationally alluring destination with great potential. Indeed, at the time of writing this report, the Bay of Fundy had emerged as a top 28 finalist in the New7Wonders of Nature campaign (from an original roster of 440 global nature sites). The New7Wonders Foundation reported (March, 2010) that 97.18% of votes in favour of the Bay of Fundy had come from outside the country. Therefore, it is surprising that the Bay of Fundy has not played a larger role as a tourism generator and major attraction for the Province of Nova Scotia. Given the international awareness of the Bay of Fundy, why has it not become a mecca for tourists? Simply put, it is because Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy product has not been adequately developed to entice visitors. Nova Scotia Tourism focuses on attracting the ʻcultural touristʼ, but examination of its most recent visitor exit survey reveals that visitors to the province are twice as interested in hiking and walking than they are in visiting museums and historic sites. They are also more interested in nature observation, beach exploring and visiting nature parks than watching live music or dance. Heavy promotion of Nova Scotiaʼs culture, particularly to international visitors, may not be enough to boost and sustain visitation to the province in the long term. Competition from increasingly exotic ʻcollectibleʼ global vacation destinations means Nova Scotia needs to bring its unique, world-renown features to market. Indeed, the Nova Scotia 2010 Tourism Plan acknowledges the need to “make our products and experiences stand out amid aggressive competitors and seemingly unlimited consumer choices.” Other locations, such as Australia, have established themselves firmly on the international tourism stage through a policy of improving and promoting Australiaʼs natural and cultural attractions at the same time (2009 Long Term Tourism Strategy). Nova Scotia is not alone in its observation that the cultural traveler and the nature traveler are often one in the same. Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy product has yet to be fully developed as a world-calibre experience. Among many pristine, well-operated natural regions throughout the world, Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy lacks a clear identity when it comes to market ready product. It has not yet fully captivated the imaginations of nature travelers, possibly because prospective visitors are not provided with clear expectations about how to see and become immersed in the tidal experience of the Bay of Fundy in Nova Scotia. Although rafting ________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Bay of Fundyʼs tidal bore receives some profile in Nova Scotia marketing, on its own it lacks full tidal experience appeal for the non-adventure visitor. Indeed, there is no top-of-mind, signature, or exciting, memorable experience of the Bay of Fundy for which Nova Scotia is renown. Interestingly, there are other tidal attractions in the world, boasting 2nd or 3rd highest tides that capitalize on tidal phenomena as a key hook and that have developed market ready product to connect visitors to the tides. Currently, there is ample room for the Bay of Fundy product to grow: current occupancy rates in the region are barely sufficient to sustain the small hotels and inns that are situated here and there, and many businesses along Bay of Fundy coastal communities struggle with a lack of customers. Similarly, current Bay of Fundy attractions are not at capacity visitation, whether they be nature, cultural or historical. 2 Development of the Bay of Fundy as a Destination In 2007, the Nova Scotia Tourism Partnership Council (NSTPC) began looking at the potential to promote the Bay of Fundy as a tourism destination. The NSTPC felt that the Bay of Fundy had great potential as a destination. The first step was taken when the Bay of Fundy “Star Generator” Inventory Report was commissioned that year. Based on this first report, it was proposed that a full development concept be prepared for the Bay of Fundy. In 2009, a steering committee of regional development and municipal associations was formed to oversee this next step. The steering committee consists of the following: Devin Trefry ~ Central Nova Tourist Association Liz Morine ~ Destination Southwest Nova Creston Rudolph ~ Colchester RDA Viorica Sporea ~ Hants RDA Ron Robinson ~ Cumberland RDA Marianne Gates ~ Kings RDA Joy OʼNeill ~Annapolis-Digby RDA Lori Blackburn ~ Nova Scotia TCH Lisa MacIsaac ~ Nova Scotia TCH Brian Banks ~ ACOA Jerry OʼNeill ~ ACOA This report provides a plan for developing the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia in response to, and on behalf of, the current steering committee. The plan examines the raw product, defines a development concept, and identifies steps for creating outstanding visitor experiences of the Bay of Fundy. To put things in context, an introspective on some major international nature tourism destinations is offered. Used as relevant examples are some of the most successful and immensely popular national parks in the US and Canada. An overview of tourism in the region and perceptions of the Bay of Fundy, vis-à-vis international tourism, are also explored. This report also proposes a touring framework. An earlier version of this model was set up as the Fundy Shore Ecotour, but had limited scope and lacked market readiness standards. The program concept developed within this report identifies a network of smaller existing sites, including interpretation sites, viewpoints and hiking trails and includes market readiness standards and development guidelines. The framework is linked together by a Bay of Fundy Identity Program. This program would provide a consistent identity concept and image throughout the Bay of Fundy region. Such a network offers complementary, branded touring options for visitors. As part of the process for determining the potential of the Bay of Fundy, established regional attractions with significant visitation, and the system of coastal provincial parks (within the Bay of Fundy) are examined. Following the product review and gap analysis, this report defines a development concept for the Bay of Fundy. The concept presented includes: recommendations for significant enhancement of key anchor sites and the development of a new site. The new tidal-themed sites identified would be completed by major existing geological and historical attractions, resulting in a well-rounded group of themed products. 3 PART A - Situation Analysis PART A – Situation Analysis 1. Context 1.1 Defining Nova Scotia’s Bay of Fundy The geographic boundaries of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy region encompass the coastal region from Amherst to Cape St. Marys. The region comprises (more or less) of the watershed of the Bay of Fundy (within Nova Scotia). The Bay of Fundy region includes the coastal communities on Chignecto Bay and the Minas Basin (Amherst, Parrsboro, Truro and Windsor) as well as communities within the Annapolis Valley region and parts of Southwest Nova (Digby area). The tourism industry in this region includes over 500 businesses and is a vital part of the rural economy of the region. 4 Within this report, for the purposes of tourism development under a ʻBay of Fundyʼ theme, coastal product is preferred over inland product. The Provincial Travelways Map defines the “Fundy Shore/Annapolis Valley Region” as an area mapped by county boundaries. 1.2 Tides The core element that distinguishes and sets apart the Bay of Fundy region is the natural phenomenon of the tides. The Bay of Fundy features the highest tides in the world, and (importantly for Nova Scotia) the world-recordlevel was recorded in the Minas Basin at Burncoat Head (17 meters). The Bay of Fundyʼs tides are five to ten times higher than tides on the rest of the planet. For example, Fundyʼs tides are ten times higher than tides on the eastern seaboard USA and at least five times higher than the Pacific Coast of North America. Although tidal bores exist elsewhere in the world, some can only be viewed in spring (in Wales) or only at night (Russia). While the Bay of Fundy may boast the highest global tides, other tidal attractions around the world have been more proactive in the development of tide-centered tourism experiences. For example, there are two sites in Europe that claim the “2nd highest tides in the world” or “highest tides in Europe”: 1. Mont Saint-Michel is an abbey located on a tidal island on the Northwest coast of France. The visitor experience includes a park and a walk along a sandbar road leading to the abbey. Interpretation tours are offered of the inter-tidal zone at low tide around the base of the tidal island. This natural attraction, with tours also of the abbey, receives 3.5 million visitors per year, making it the second most visited area in France after the Eiffel Tower. 2. The Severn Estuary is a tidal river located in Wales. In addition to year round walking tours of the tidal river, linking several communities, the region also strongly promotes tidal bore surfing. Tidal bore surfing only takes place during the spring equinox, as the bores are not significant (or non-existent) the rest of the year. To compensate for this, the Severn region hosts an annual summer “Magnificent Severn” Festival that ʻcelebrates every aspect of the tidal Severnʼ. The event includes: a tidal bore triggered running race along the banks of the river, an art display of tidal bore surfers, a tidal bore photography exhibit, a painting with mud workshop, weir fishing demonstration, local cuisine, concerts & agritourism, etc. The three-day festival attracts over 100,000 visitors. One of the Bay of Fundyʼs greatest, but least promoted, assets is the predictable two high and two low tides in one 24-hour period, 365 days of the year. Traditionally, Nova Scotia Tourism has focused on its tidal bore as its Bay of Fundythemed product. While the bore experience in the Bay of Fundy is certainly exhilarating as part of the Fundy tidal experience, it is not of great worldwide 5 significance. In fact, there are over 60 bores in such places as the UK, France, India, Brazil, and Alaska, with the largest occurring in China. The bore in Chʼientʼangʼkian, China, is 25.9 feet (7.5 meters). The Shubenacadie tidal bore at its maximum spring or fall equinox height is less than half that size. The Bay of Fundy Tourism Partnership, the interprovincial organization charged with promoting the Bay of Fundy as a Canadian nature tourism icon, has identified three tidal effects comprising the full Bay of Fundy experience: 1. tidal bores/rapids 2. vertical tides 3. horizontal tides It is interesting to note that the most visited site in the entire Bay of Fundy, Hopewell Rocks, focuses and interprets the vertical and horizontal aspects of the tides (not the bore at all). The Bay of Fundy tides cause a number of extraordinary phenomena, including tidal rips and whirlpools, harbours emptying of water, tidal bores on several rivers, and expansive inter-tidal areas (more than 5 kilometers wide in some areas) where the ocean bottom is exposed at low tide. The effects of the tide are noticeable in the coastal landscape of this region. In the upper bay, the coast is diverse and exhibits striking features such as islands, arches and sea stacks. Moreover, the 6 landscape changes between tides, with a vast, teaming, ocean floor emerging at low tide. Although the Bay of Fundyʼs tidal effects are largely under-interpreted and disconnected for visitors at the current time, there is no doubt that they are extraordinary in the global context. To complement its tidal phenomenon, the Bay of Fundy region is already quite well served by several significant geological and historical attractions. Geological features situated in the upper bay include: • sites near Parrsboro where remnants of Triassic age dinosaurs and the worldʼs smallest dinosaurs were discovered and are interpreted at the Fundy Geological Museum • world renowned coal age fossil deposits at Joggins (interpreted at the Joggins Fossil Cliffs UNESCO World Heritage Site) • fossil deposits near Hantsport (interpreted at Blue Beach Fossil Centre) • outstanding geological features (such as the worldʼs best location for witnessing the breakup of the super continent, Pangaea) at Cape Chignecto, Five Islands and Blomidon Historic sites are situated around the bay; ranging from early Paleo-Indian sites, pre-European aboriginal history, Acadian settlement and deportation sites, and later European and early Canadian settlements. Interpretation of early European settlement takes place at Port Royal, Acadian deportation at Grand Pré, and Miʼkmaq history and culture at the Glooscap Heritage Centre. 1.3 New Brunswick’s Bay of Fundy Product The Province of New Brunswick embraced the Bay of Fundy in the mid 1990s with a strong emphasis on vitalizing its Bay of Fundy product and branded it “New Brunswickʼs Bay of Fundy”. For several years now, tourism operators in the upper Bay of Fundy in Nova Scotia report ʻspilloverʼ across the border from the more popular New Brunswick sites. When considering development and strengthening of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy product, it is important to evaluate the context and success of the product in the neighbouring province. Hopewell Rocks This exercise began with the redesign of Hopewell Rocks Provincial Park as Hopewell Rocks Tidal Exploration Site. The site expanded from a small day-use park, with minimal services in the late 1980s, to become New Brunswickʼs top tourism icon, gracing the cover of their provincial travel guide for ten years, from 1998 to 2008. Consequently, Hopewell Rocks is now a ʻmust seeʼ New Brunswick attraction. The branding of this site has been so strong that Nova Scotia Visitor Information Centres observe visitors frequently asking for directions to Hopewell Rocks, while visiting Nova Scotia. The Hopewell Rocks product consists of: • interpretation centre (topics: Fundy tides, tidal erosion, formation of the Rocks, formation of the Bay of Fundy, whale habitat and migrations, shorebird habitat and migration) • full amenities (cafe, snack bar, gift shops) • wheelchair accessible hiking trails • shuttle service • upper & lower entrances • washrooms at both entrances and along the trail • parking for hundreds of cars and motor coaches • visitor services for public and coaches • viewing decks • beach access with beach interpreters and beach sweeps (for safety) • sea kayaking (concession) The Hopewell Rocks receive over 200,000 (estimated) visitors per year, are open from midMay to mid-October, and charge an adult admission fee of $8.50. The site is managed by the Province of New Brunswick. The site receives 7 continuous media exposure and has won many national and international awards, such as, the Attractions Canada Award and the British Airways Tourism for Tomorrow Award. Fundy Trail The Fundy Trail is a 15-kilometer long coastal access network in St. Martins, 40 minutes east of Saint John. It includes a low-speed autoroute with a wheelchair accessible pedestrian/bicycle trail running parallel to the roadway. Features of this site include: • access to 10 parking lots scattered along the trail • accessible scenic lookouts • footpaths to beaches and river estuaries • suspension footbridge • fully staffed interpretation centre • washrooms, rest stops, and water stations all along the trail • bicycle rentals • guided hikes & guided historical walks • additional wilderness hiking (day & multi-day) • food services and accommodations at a wilderness lodge • access to the Fundy Footpath: extreme wilderness hiking trail that connects the Fundy Trail to Fundy National Park (42 kilometers away) • fully staffed for group, school, or individual tour packages (itinerary planning services) Phase II expansion of the park has begun which will see the continuation of the low-speed roadway 8 and coastal trail to connect directly to Fundy National Park. Completion of the Fundy Trail Parkway will integrate the Fundy Trail, Fundy National Park and the Hopewell Rocks into a consolidated group of first-class coastal tourism attractions, which, collectively, are expected to create a World Class “Signature” Destination Area. Current visitation to the Fundy Trail is 50,000 (estimated). Itʼs open from mid-May to midOctober, with an adult admission rate of $4. It is operated by a non-profit association: the Fundy Trail Development Authority. Reversing Falls Reversing Falls are one of New Brunswickʼs oldest tourism attractions. Currently the site consists of: • interpreters & interpretation panels on geology and tidal effects • visitor information • viewing decks • 2 restaurants • interpretation film • daily boat tours of the rapids • popular sea kayaking location • geology interpretation • linked to downtown by boardwalk • services for motor coach tours • adjacent to Fallsview Park Annual visitation to Reversing Falls Interpretation Centre is 200,000. Admission to the attraction is free (there is a fee charged to watch the film). In November, 2008, a concept plan to fully redevelop the site as the Fundy Vortex was revealed. The natural attraction is managed by the City of Saint John and the restaurants and outdoor adventure are concessions. Cape Enrage Cape Enrage is a New Brunswick "top attraction' heritage lighthouse operated seasonally (May to October) by a not-for-profit group. Cape Enrage has been named #1 View in Canada by Frommerʼs Travel Guide and has won the Attractions Canada Award. It is located between Fundy National Park and Hopewell Rocks. The site offers visitors a panoramic view of the upper Bay of Fundy coast, as well as, day adventures consisting of rappelling, climbing, initiative games, obstacle course and multi day adventure packages by appointment. Customized itineraries are available for groups of all types and ages and may include all or any of the day adventures. Other site amenities include: • a Studio / Gallery of local artisans' work • a fossil beach • sea kayaking • walking trails • restaurant featuring local/regional cuisine • lighthouse accommodations UNESCO Geopark An application was made in the winter of 2010 to establish North Americaʼs first UNESCO Geopark in the Saint John area. Fundy National Park Fundy National Park is another significant New Brunswick attraction and is profiled in section 4.3 of this report. 9 1.4 Weaknesses of Nova Scotia’s Bay of Fundy Product Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy is not capitalizing on its potential as an internationally recognized nature tourism destination. Indeed, visitation is low compared with many of the coastal destinations or iconic nature based attractions. Despite the fact that the Bay of Fundy is within two days drive of 30 million people, the most frequented parts of the Bay of Fundy see fewer than 500,000 visitors annually. In the less traveled parts of the bay, such as the Parrsboro and Noel shores, the number of non-residents is more like 60,000. This is well below capacity for these areas, and given what appears to be a potent mix of tourism assets, there is certainly potential for higher visitor numbers. In travel publications, travel trade programs, and often in the media (which influences the perception of consumers) the Bay of Fundy experience exists in New Brunswick alone. There are a number of reasons for the low recognition, low occupancy rates and undercapacity outside main corridors. 10 The Bay of Fundy region in Nova Scotia has suffered from a confusing mix of regional identities, overlapping tourism regions (administratively), assorted scenic travel ways and a general lack of a unifying theme and identity. Glooscap Trail, Evangeline Trail, Fundy Shore Scenic Drive, Fundy Shore, Fundy Shore Ecotour are all names used to promote various sections or the whole region of Fundy. This problem has existed for years, and was in part, the impetus behind the formation of the Bay of Fundy Tourism Partnership in 1998. Such fragmentation affects the perception of the Bay of Fundy, not only by visitors, but as importantly, by the travel media. Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy is probably not seen so much as a destination, but perhaps as an off-the-beaten path diversion. One need only to talk to frontline staff at Nova Scotia s Visitor Information Centres to gain insight into the gaps in Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundythemed product offerings. In November, as part of the research for this report, managers at Nova Scotiaʼs three busiest Visitor Information Centres responded to the following questions: 1. What are people looking for who seek a Bay of Fundy experience? • places to go to ʻsee the worldʼs highest tidesʼ • places where they can learn about the tides • tidal bore (but they often think this is the only feature of the tides: i.e. that the bore is 50 feet in height) • places where you can safely walk on the ocean floor • Hopewell Rocks (thinking it is on the Nova Scotia side) • whale watching • places where they can see the tides but be safe from the ʻtidal waveʼ 2. What could be done at the product level to improve visitor experiences of the Bay of Fundy in Nova Scotia? • more things to do - related to the tides - on the Bay of Fundy (not just places to drive by to look at) • more interpretation at various locations to describe the tidal experience offered • ways to educate people so they can go exploring on their own • identify locations with flowerpot rocks or other rock formations with ocean floor walking and • easy access to compete with Hopewell Rocks • • • • • more sites need staff and interpretation centres or programs (too much left to selfguiding) better wayfinding signage for Fundy sites Bay of Fundy attractions with staff longer season for Bay of Fundy attractions specific promotion of where key Bay of Fundy sites are with best tidal experiences Another issue in Nova Scotia is the limited number of interpreted tidal experiences. Visitors who come to the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia ask, “Where can I see the tides?” and there is no clear answer. Although the Minas Basin alone has over 200 kilometers of tidal shoreline, it lacks sites with professional interpretation, defined tidal experiences, and safe access for visitors. The visitor experience of Nova Scotiaʼs Fundy coast is largely self-guided and random. By contrast, New Brunswick has invested considerable effort toward creating several staffed, iconic tidal experiences. There is no reason why the Bay of Fundy canʼt be a national icon for Nova Scotia - attracting international visitors and making a substantial contribution to the economy of the Province. 11 The Tourism Market 2. The Tourism Market 2.1 Global Tourism In any analysis of tourism, where the scope of the discussion includes international markets, it is useful to become re-acquainted with the dynamics of global tourism. internationally in 2002, generating more than US $472 billion in earnings. Forecasts predicted 1.6 billion international tourists by the year 2020, spending more than US $2 trillion annually – or US $5 billion every day. By 2008, the number of people traveling had grown to 922 million generating $1.2 trillion. A dip in international travel in 2009 caused by a world-wide recession is likely to give way to renewed growth in the coming years. In 2009, the worldʼs largest tourism destinations were: 1 2 France 79.3 million United States 58.0 million 3 Spain 57.3 million 4 China 53.0 million 5 6 Italy 42.7 million United Kingdom 30.1 million 7 Ukraine 25.4 million 8 Turkey 25.0 million 9 Germany 24.9 million 10 Mexico 22.6 million th According to the World Tourism Industry, there were more than 715 million people traveling 12 Canada is 12 on this list, falling below Mexico in recent years as American consumers seek new, more exciting destinations in the global market. Similar influences have affected the tourism industry in Atlantic Canada. Many regional travelers have given up their three-week summer holiday in favour of a winter week or two in a southern ʻsunʼ destination, and occasional long weekends in the Maritimes through the summer and fall. Indeed, while tourism in the international market has been expanding, Nova Scotiaʼs tourism economy has not grown significantly in the past decade. Regardless of whether you call tourism an industry or a social movement, Nova Scotiaʼs success in the tourism market will depend on how effectively it can present and promote the unique and extraordinary features of its vast coast. Few dispute the positive impact that tourism has on the global economy. Tourism is an industry relevant to every country in the world, is an important source of foreign exchange, is a tool for economic diversification, and is responsible for increased standards of living the world over. The benefits of tourism in communities, whether in Nova Scotia or in countries around the world, are significant. Tourism supports local industries from artisans to agri-tourism and helps to sustain local economies. Tourism is referred to by some researchers, not as an industry, but as a social movement. The sustainability of tourism in Atlantic Canada has been affected by recent trends as tourism has shifted towards an increasingly global industry. To respond to this shift, Nova Scotia should offer world-calibre, unique experiences to visitors. 13 2.2 Tourism in the Bay of Fundy The following illustration shows visitation to Nova Scotia over a ten-year period from 2000 – 2009. While international tourism is growing, the overall numbers of visitors to Nova Scotia have been relatively unchanged over the past ten years. Automobile traffic changed little over the period while air visitors increased by almost 20%. Consistent with trends in international tourism, air visitors to Nova Scotia reached a record level in 2008 before retreating slightly in 2009. On the other hand, Motor coach and recreational vehicle traffic declined by approximately 40% in the past ten years. 14 Tourism Activity in the Fundy Shore Region Using room/night sales as an indicator, the Fundy Shore/Annapolis Valley region accounts for approximately 13% of the tourism activity in the Province. This is based on total room nights sold of 339,000 in 2009. Occupancy rates in the region are 35%, substantially lower than the provincial average of 47%. The largest proportion of visitors to the Fundy Shore region is from Atlantic Canada (45%) followed by Ontario (20%). International visitors accounted for 24% of all visits. Decreases in visitation from the US have reduced the number of international visitors somewhat, although it would have been partially offset by increased overseas travel. Approximately 65% of Fundy Shore visitors from outside the Atlantic region are traveling for general pleasure and recreation (compared with the provincial average of 50%). Source: Nova Scotia Department of Tourism, Culture and Heritage, Aug 2005 15 Since most Bay of Fundy visitors are leisure travelers, it follows that a high proportion of visitors to the Fundy region participate in leisure activities. This concurs with the most recent Nova Scotia Visitor Exit Survey, which shows that the most frequent activity for Bay of Fundy visitors is “leisure hiking and walking” (10% higher than the provincial average). Interestingly, as the following chart demonstrates, visitors to the Fundy region are significantly more likely than the provincial average to participate in nature observation, and more likely to visit national and provincial historic sites. These broad indicators suggest that visitors are drawn to the Bay of Fundy because of its unique blend of outdoor experiences, natural features, parks and cultural/historical sites. 16 Fundy Shore Leisure walking/hiking 79% Visiting craft shops/studios 58% Nature observation 53% Visiting a national/provincial 52% historic site Visiting museums 47% Beach 35% exploring/beachcombing Visit a national or provincial 34% natural park Live performing music or 32% dance presentations Visiting nightclubs, lounges 25% or pubs N.S. Overall 70% 56% 44% 39% 36% 33% 29% 22% 26% Source: Nova Scotia Department of Tourism, Culture and Heritage, Aug 2005 2.3 Travel Patterns International Travel In 2008, the top eight European travel-generating countries accounted for nearly two-thirds of the worldʼs entire trip volume. Europe looms large as a generator of outbound travel to other parts of the world (including Nova Scotia) and the Province has spent a considerable amount of money in the past two years to market to Europeans. Also worth mentioning are the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India and China). While not currently a large proportion of the Canadian travel market, these countries are among the most productive generators of new international travel. While international travel is only a small proportion of the overall tourism market, the international market provides a revealing look at the Bay of Fundy. If attractiveness of a destination has sufficient cache to draw international travelers, the task of successfully promoting and generating interest from regional markets is likely manageable. International visitors are less likely to be limited by factors related to proximity, cost, travel-time, language, currency, family ties, etc. International visitors rarely come to Nova Scotia for reasons of convenience. How are overseas visitors attracted to the Bay of Fundy and where do they go/what do they do when they get here? A large proportion of international travelers coming to Nova Scotia is influenced by travel trade programs (travel packages sold by wholesale tour operators). International travelers generally either purchase a coach tour or a more independent fly-drive or they use a travel agent to help arrange a trip (the same travel agents who sell coach tours). Travel trade patterns are helpful in an analysis of the current state of tourism in any region because they are: • measurable (because they show up as packaged itineraries) • strongly influenced by international demand and travel preferences, therefore are revealing of the international market • indicators of historic visitation patterns and often reflect preferred destinations They also show how many first-time visitors see the region. In the Bay of Fundy, there are two key segments of the travel trade: motor coach tours and FIT travelers. 17 Motor Coach Tours Motor coach is the largest component of the travel trade in Nova Scotia. The coach tour market generally involves 45-seat coaches on fixed itineraries. Coach tour consumers are guided by what they see in traditional tour operator brochures or corresponding websites. Coach tours need to be full; every unsold seat is a perishable product. Less than 100% occupancies on a frequent basis mean the operator will look at other means to address the bottom line issue. As indicated earlier Motor Coach traffic to Nova Scotia has declined over the past decade. Typically, coach tour companies are slow to review or change many of their itineraries, some of which have been operated virtually unchanged for many years. Presumed reluctance to change might be due to the fact that most of these itineraries still sell. In other words, while consumers might read about unique travel experiences, the majority of them still buy the regular brand and most promoted offers. The Bay of Fundy region in New Brunswick has an advantage with coach operators in terms of the proximity of its key Bay of Fundy attractions to clusters of hotel rooms. For example, the Disneyesque Hopewell Rocks is 30 minutes away from Moncton, and the Reversing Falls attraction is on Saint Johnʼs doorstep. 18 Saint John has also had some success in its “Cruise to the Bay of Fundy”. This impacts coach tours because receptives have successfully positioned shore excursions with up to five hours of transport time (well above the normal cruise day trip average). Fundy-themed cruise shore excursions from the port of Saint John include: Hopewell Rocks, the Fundy Trail and whale watching. In Nova Scotia, there are also some Bay of Fundy-area shore excursions for cruise visitors. These encompass the Wolfville-area wine region, as well as, Hallʼs Harbour lobster tours and dinner. FIT (Fully Independent Travel) Fully Independent Travel (FIT), on the other hand, consists of fly-drives where consumers have time to stop and spend time in places of their choice at their leisure. This kind of program also allows for the use of a much wider range of accommodation, since there is no need to find rooms for a full coach load. Tour operators are not as inventive as they could be with FIT programs. Since there is more money in coach tours, travel trade companies often reposition coach tour itineraries as their product offerings for their FIT customers. Often FIT itineraries are essentially carbon copies of what the operator offers with a coach, except that the means of transportation is a rental car, and, they can sell into the same room block they already have inventoried for coach itineraries. Travel Trade Demand for Bay of Fundy Product Most international tours that touch on the Bay of Fundy originate in Halifax and travel the Annapolis Valley as far as Digby. Travel itineraries, it seems, rarely include other parts of the Bay of Fundy, for example, Route #215 (the Noel Shore) and Route #2 (the Parrsboro shore). While it is common for travel trade itineraries, that include Nova Scotia, to highlight a visit to the “Worldʼs Highest Tides” it must be noted that the sole Bay of Fundy “tidal attraction" featured is during the New Brunswick portion of the multi-province itinerary. shown as the most heavily traveled corridor. Also heavily traveled (although less so) is the corridor from Halifax to Wolfville and on to Annapolis and Digby. The Parrsboro Shore (route #2), the Noel Shore (route #215), side roads to Scots Bay and Halls Harbour and route #217 to Digby Neck, are all shown as dotted lines to indicate that they are not travel trade routes and have lighter visitor traffic. In a search for Bay of Fundy-related travel programs offered for 2010, Digby, Wolfville and Annapolis Royal are the three key overnights in Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy. Very likely, this is a direct result of available room accommodation and proximity to the 100 series highway. Among the itineraries provided by 16 different companies (including a mix of coach and FIT), 12 had overnight stops in Digby, seven in Wolfville and three in Annapolis Royal. Truro and Cape dʼOr were each mentioned once. Most tours continue on to New Brunswick and PEI. The following map is an illustration of travel patterns based on the assumption that travel trade itineraries are an indicator of general patterns of travel. The route between the Nova Scotia border at Amherst and Halifax (the TransCanada Highway route #104 and route #102) is 19 It should be recognized that the established patterns exist due to the configuration of services, (accommodations and dining) as well as attractions, between Halifax and Digby. The Digby Pines Resort, for example, provides destination for motor coach tours. Similarly, the National Historic Sites are frequently cited as one of the primary points of interest by visitors to the Province. It is assumed that this pattern, generally reflects the status quo of visitor traffic in the Bay of Fundy region. This assumption can be tested by examining traffic flow data for the Bay of Fundy region. Looking at historic visitor traffic flow patterns (based on 2004 figures), it shows that the overall flow of visitors is more or less the same. 20 Traffic into the region generally originates from the metropolitan area of Halifax, Halifax International airport (probably the main entry point for many international travelers), from the Amherst border crossing, or to a lesser extent, from the PEI and Newfoundland ferries and the ferry from Saint John. Yarmouth and Digby Ferries The Yarmouth ferry has played a major role as a point of entry to the Bay of Fundy region in the past. Indeed, with the cancellation of the Scotia Prince in 2004, both motor coach and independent visitor traffic to the Digby area has likely been affected. For example, Motor coach business at the Digby Pines Resort has declined significantly since then. Occupancy rates in Yarmouth County have been negatively affected and it is expected this has had an affect on the Digby area as well. Potential as a Nature Tourism Destination 3. Potential as a Nature Tourism Destination 3.1 What is a Tourism Destination? A tourism destination is an attraction or region that becomes the purpose or motivation for travel. Many of the worldʼs most popular tourism attractions are either highlights of the human achievement (several sources rate Times Square as the # 1 attraction) or human creations of fantasy and entertainment (Disney is rated #2). These key features are reflected in the Forbes Traveler 2007 List of Top 10 Worldwide Attractions: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Times Square (New York City, NY) 35 million National Mall & Memorial Parks (Washington, D.C.) 25 million Disney Worldʼs Magic Kingdom (Lake Buena Vista, FL) 16.6 million Trafalgar Square (London, England) 15 million Disneyland Park (Anaheim, CA) 14.7 million Niagara Falls (Ontario, Canada & New York State) 14 million Tokyo Disneyland/DisneySea (Tokyo, Japan) 12.9 million Notre Dame de Paris (Paris, France) 12 million Disneyland Paris (Marne-La-Vallee, France) 10.6 million The Great Wall of China (Badaling area, China) 10 million 21 3.2 Natural Attractions as Destinations Natural attractions, while not topping the above list of worldʼs most popular attractions, are still extremely important for tourism and the world economy. In some countries, such as Canada, most top attractions are nature-based. Niagara Falls is Canadaʼs most visited attraction with 14 million visitors per year. However, surrounded as it is by hotels, casinos, Ripleyʼs Believe it or Not, etc., itʼs hard to claim that Niagara is a natural site in the true sense. Casino Niagara itself reports visitation of 10 million per year. Either way, the casino and supporting tourism products were developed to capitalize upon the natural appeal of the Falls. Over a billion dollars in tourism revenues is generated annually in the Niagara Falls area. National Parks The US National Parks provide a set of exemplary, well-developed natural attractions. They are internationally recognized, frequently offer unique and phenomenal natural landscapes, attract large numbers of domestic and international visitors, and are a source of national pride. Several of the US National Parks receive over 3 million visitors each annually. Similarly in Canada, at least one National Park, Banff, has the same quality of development and visitor experiences. Although Banff is Canadaʼs oldest park, it is really within the past 40 years that Banff has witnessed (and sustained) exponential growth. The number of visitors to Banff National Park has tripled since 1970 to an annual visitation of 4 million visitors. Key characteristics of both Canadian and US National Parks are as follows: 1. they exist to both protect and promote outstanding natural landscapes 2. they provide an interpretation and educational role of national significance 3. they are internationally recognized 4. they have clearly defined boundaries 5. they are promoted through iconic images 22 Here are several examples of US and Canadian National Parks that provide valuable lessons in creating and promoting natural attractions; lessons that are transferable to the Bay of Fundy. Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona The Grand Canyon, part of the US National Park system, is situated about 800 kilometers (500 miles) east of Los Angeles. It is over 0.5 million hectares (1.2 million acres) in size and attracts about 5 million visitors each year. Approximately 80% of visitors come from across the US, but the park also attracts close to a million international visitors. It is one of two candidates in North America for the New7Wonders of Nature campaign (as previously indicated, the Bay of Fundy is the other). Undoubtedly, the Grand Canyon is one of the best-known scenic landscapes in the world. “below the rim” each year (approximately 8% of total visitor numbers). Indeed, 50,000 take overnight trips. Trails into the canyon are neither easy nor are they for the faint-hearted. This demonstrates that there is a large segment of the population who seek a more adventurous experience. In addition, to those who venture out on foot, there are 56,000 air tours a year (aircraft offering flights over the canyon). The admission fee to the Grand Canyon is $25 for a 7-day pass. Buses pay a fee of $300. Summer is peak season, whereas winter, when there is often snow, is low season. While the majority of Grand Canyonʼs visitors stay close to their cars, about 300,000 people hike 23 Yellowstone National Park, Wyoming Yellowstone National Park is almost a million hectares (2.2 million acres) in size (roughly twice the size of PEI). Yellowstone is a brand 24 recognized by most Americans, but unlike the Grand Canyon, the Yellowstone name represents a collection of natural attractions including: Mammoth Hot Springs, Old Faithful Geyser and Yellowstone Falls. The Yellowstone identity has high market awareness. This can be demonstrated by the fact Canadians would list this as a top US nature site, yet may not realize in which state it is located. The brand of the product area is stronger than any state borders or regional identity. Despite the fact that Yellowstone is far from any population centre, (almost 1,500 kilometers - 1,000 miles - from the major cities of California) it attracts over 3.3 million visitors each year. Furthermore, Yellowstone is a seasonal park. Located at northern latitude with high elevation, it has winters that are more severe than most parts of east coast Canada. Despite this, winter visitation averages over 25,000 per month. Like the Grand Canyon, the admission fee to Yellowstone is $25 for a 7-day pass. As is the case with many of the US National Parks, visitor numbers have increased over the past ten years. (from 2000-2010). Yosemite National Park, California Yosemite is only 300 kilometers (220) miles from San Francisco, and therefore, is not surprising that it attracts almost 4 million visitors per year. The admission fee, like the previous two examples, is $25 per vehicle. However, backcountry hikes are significantly higher in cost. One of Yosemiteʼs famous landmarks, the halfdome, is a mile high rock peak overlooking the Yosemite Valley. As many as 1,000 hikers per day climb the dome on a summer weekend, adding up to about 50,000 hikers who climb it every year. This is notable since the half-dome hike is a round-trip hike of 22 kilometers (17 miles) and considered extremely strenuous. 25 Banff National Park, Alberta As in the case of Yellowstone, Banff has an identity that supercedes provincial or regional brand and identities. Banff truly embodies the idea of a nature tourism icon. Fundy National Park, New Brunswick Fundy National Park in Alma, New Brunswick, shares many of the characteristics of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy region, and therefore, is an appropriate model for comparison. It is 20,000 hectares (almost 50,000 acres in size). Visitation to Fundy National Park is significantly lower than other Canadian or US parks of the same calibre. Approximately 203,000 people visited the park in 2006. This is interesting, given that Acadia National Park in Maine, exhibiting many of the same characteristics, attracts over 2 million visitors annually. Banff was the first National Park developed in Canada, and the second in North America (after Yellowstone). Visitor data indicates that visitation at Banff is close to 4 million annually. There are more than 5,600 hotel rooms, 60 restaurants, and 175 specialty shops within the park boundary. In all, more than 1,300 businesses are licensed to operate in the Park. There is no doubt that Banff is Canadaʼs most popular National Park and one of the most visited parks of its type in North America. 26 While Fundy National Park is closely linked to the Bay of Fundy landscape, it doesnʼt have the iconic images that we find associated with the major parks listed above. Hopewell Rocks, nearby, (approx 170,000 visitors in 2006) offers these images and it appears that the two work together to generate and promote tourism to the area. Cape Breton Highlands National Park, Nova Scotia Cape Breton Highlands National Park is located within the Province of Nova Scotia. It is 94,000 hectares in size (slightly more than 200,000 acres) and has roughly 50 kilometers of coastline facing both the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of St. Lawrence. Visitor numbers averaged around 350,000 annually from 2001- 2006. These numbers are the highest among the Atlantic regionʼs National Parks. The attraction of Cape Breton Highlands National Park (for most visitors) is the Cabot Trail, a 350kilometer long roadway that runs along both the Atlantic and Gulf coasts. Indeed, by driving the Cabot Trail, visitors can experience the park to a great extent without having to leave their cars. The scenic landscape (and the touring experience) is the real attraction, rather than a specific natural feature. While the geography of Cape Breton Highlands is similar to Bay of Fundy, Fundyʼs tidal phenomena: geology/paleontology and tidesculpted coasts, are distinctly different. Source: NS travel indicators (Dept Tourism and Culture) 27 3.3 Developing a Nature Tourism Destination Visitation numbers at many international attractions are staggering and they make overall visitor numbers to Nova Scotia pale by comparison. For example, almost four times as many people visit the Eiffel Tower in Paris each year than all the visitors to Nova Scotia. This is true for many other large attractions, including museums in London and Paris. Similarly, the large National Parks in Canada and the US attract two to three times as many visitors as all of Nova Scotia. Importantly, the National Parks do so while being governed by a strict conservation mandate. Due to this mandate, the National Parks are often scrutinized on their success in minimizing impacts, but overall, they have been highly effective in managing, protecting and interpreting some of the most extraordinary landscapes in both the US and Canada. The role of National Parks in attracting visitors and offering an interpreted experience is very much part of their success. The educational/interpretation role, economic benefits provided by tourism, and the direct contribution to financing park management and staff through visitor fees collectively, have helped to validate the existence of the National Parks in both countries. 28 These attributes are key guidelines for development of a nature tourism destination: Attracting visitors The destination must have the capacity to attract and appeal to visitors by: a) focusing on unique and extraordinary natural features b) developing a strong identity (including defined boundaries) c) using evocative, iconic images of the landscape to promote the area invariably, the images of a place shape visitors pre-conceptions and influence the perceived appeal of the destination. Protecting key landmarks There must be a program to manage visitor traffic and expectations, offer educational and experiential programming, sustain the core values of the landscape, and protect key sites. Management of nature sites should be funded (at least in part) by user contributions. These key attributes of successful natural attractions have shaped the strategy proposed in this report. Current Bay of Fundy Product 4. Current Bay of Fundy Product 4.1 Attractions This section looks at the specifics of the actual product: what visitors do, where they go, what attractions they visit and what themes are presented. A complete inventory has been done in earlier reports, so this report focuses on a product framework consisting of three categories: Within the Bay of Fundy region, there exists a range of attractions, from small community museums to national historic sites. While even the smallest interpretation site may contribute to the Bay of Fundy product, it was necessary to establish a benchmark for attractions that are of international value and can be considered significant tourism generators. 1. Attractions 2. Activities 3. Parks The purpose of this framework is to focus on interpretation themes and attractions and thus identify product gaps. Services, including accommodations, food and beverage, transportation, etc. are part of the larger inventory and are not covered in this profile. The existing product framework has been identified on a series of map illustrations (that follow). In addition, the visitor traffic pattern maps (that were Therefore, profiled are only those key attractions that receive more than 20,000 visitors annually. This includes three attractions that focus on history, two that focus on geology and one focusing on tidal technology. There are no sites that represent the theme of the Bay of Fundy marine environment (although whale-watching operators offer such interpretation during their tours). derived in the preceding section) help to fully illustrate the product as it exists. 29 Historic sites Three key attractions in the Bay of Fundy region focus on the theme of human history. All are national historic sites, managed by Parks Canada and are located within the Annapolis Valley area (Kings and Annapolis counties): 1. Grand Pré National Historic Site 2. Port Royal National Historic Site 3. Fort Anne National Historic Site Geology There are two geology themed sites, both located in the upper Bay of Fundy region (in Cumberland County). One is a UNESCO World Heritage Site: Joggins Fossil Cliffs Fundy Geological Museum Tidal There is one site in the product framework that has a tidal theme ( “tidal technology”). This is a specific topic which is unique to Nova Scotiaʼs side of the bay and which attracts a large number of visitors: Annapolis Basin Tidal Generating Station 30 These six key Bay of Fundy attractions are shown in the following illustration, historic sites in blue, geological sites in violet, and tidal sites in yellow. Two other sites that meet the benchmark number for visitors are: Upper Clements Theme Park and Kejimkujik National Park. Both are key tourism assets for the province and for the Annapolis Valley region. While Kejimkujik National Park is potentially a tourism generator, its thematic context is not Fundy-focused and it is an inland park. Upper Clements Park is within the zone and is illustrated on the map. However, the family entertainment theme is unrelated to the Bay of Fundy tides, so it is also not included as an existing Fundy-themed attraction in this assessment. 4.2 Activities Also included, within this Bay of Fundy product framework, are themed tourism activities. In all cases, these operations, while perhaps individually small, are clustered in geographic areas with sufficient critical mass to be Bay of Fundy tourism generators: season is long: officially from June to October, with occasional tours in May and November. River Rafting White water rafting of the Shubenacadie Riverʼs tidal bore is an experience unique to Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy product. There are three river rafting companies, all extensively promoted individually and in provincial literature. River-rafting takes place from late May to the end of October. Culinary/Wine The wine and agri-tourism experiences in the Annapolis Valley are becoming a significant tourism product for Nova Scotia. It is related to the Bay of Fundy theme because farming in this area is influenced by the Bayʼs ecosystem and weather. The primary season for these products is spring through fall, although some farm markets and wine shops are open year round. Whale Watching The whale-watching industry on Digby Neck and Islands is a significant tourism product consisting of approximately twelve tour operators. Whale watching in the Bay of Fundy is a fairly well known adventure option for visitors to Nova Scotia and it is extensively promoted by the industry and the provincial tourism materials. The whale-watching 31 The following illustration indicates, approximately, the location of the above key activity clusters within the Bay of Fundy region. 32 4.3 Parks The final component of the existing Bay of Fundy product assessment is parks within the Provincial Park system. It is the opinion of the author that this component is largely undeveloped ( consisting of coastal walking, hiking and camping areas). In Nova Scotia, Provincial Parks are administered and managed by the Department of Natural Resources. Provincial Parks located within the Bay of Fundy region comprise some of the most interesting and significant coastal lands in the Bay of Fundy region; indeed, some of the most interesting coastal landscape on the eastern seaboard. The components of the Nova Scotia park system located within the Bay of Fundy region are shown in the following illustration, where small green circles are picnic parks, larger light green circles are camping parks and large dark green circles are significant coastal parks with hiking and coastal exploring (as well as camping). 33 There are three Bay of Fundy coastal Provincial Parks that are of particular interest to this strategic planning initiative: Cape Chignecto, Five Islands and Blomidon/Cape Split. These parks have been identified by the Parks Division of the Department of Natural Resources as core coastal parks with special significance. While there is currently minimal interpretation and limited programming at these parks, except Cape Chignecto, they provide access to some of the most unique coastal and inter-tidal landscapes in Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy region. The illustration on the right shows the complete existing framework with all of the above components; attractions, activities, and parks. 34 4.4 Gap Evaluation The existing Bay of Fundy product is strong in two themes: human history and geology. While they are both attractive concepts, they are secondary to the primary theme and thus the motivation for visitors to the Bay of Fundy: to experience the worldʼs highest tides. Although these secondary themes provide variety, if visitors canʼt locate, understand, access or experience the tides in a meaningful way, many will be disappointed or look to the neighbouring province. With the exception of the Tidal Generating Station in Annapolis Royal, the Bay of Fundy currently has cursory interpretation, (Joggins for example, has a section devoted to the power of the Bay of Fundy, how the tides expose the fossils, how the Bay was formed and an explanation of the tides). Overall, there is a gap in full programming of experiences related to the worldʼs highest tides. As this report emphasizes, it is the tidal phenomenon that makes the Bay of Fundy a “Natural Wonder” and positions the Bay in the global nature-tourism arena. The potential of the Bay of Fundy to be a tourism attraction of international status and to play an effective role in generating tourism visitation to Nova Scotia, is contingent upon highlighting and interpreting outstanding tidal landscapes and developing the tidal theme. The following products or programs are needed in Nova Scotia to fill gaps in the Bay of Fundy product: A) Interpreted Tidal Sites and Attractions This report recommends anchor attractions that focus on the tidal theme or experience be developed in locations offering good potential for tide-related activities, significant and extraordinary tidal features and diverse scenic coastal and intertidal landscapes. These key sites will connect the visitor to the tidal experience and be highly visible destinations around which tourists can plan their visits. Not withstanding the adventure-based tidal experience offered by rafting operators on the Shubenacadie River, the best opportunities for tidal interpretation are largely undeveloped. The highest tides (not only in Nova Scotia but in the entire Bay of Fundy) are in the Minas Basin where the tidal range is 2-3 meters (as much as 10 feet) greater than elsewhere in the Bay. Not surprisingly, sites having a phenomenal tidal landscape are found within this area. 35 Anchor tidal attractions must offer: • opportunities for a combination of tidal experience, viewscapes, walks/hikes and shoreline excursions • high quality interpretation exhibits • provide or facilitate guided and escorted tidal-experience tours 36 B) Bay of Fundy Marine Environment Centre In contrast to the need for tidal interpretation in the upper Bay, a centre for interpretation of the Bay of Fundyʼs marine biology should be developed in the outer Bay of Fundy region in the vicinity of Annapolis Royal--Digby--Brier Island. The Bay of Fundy is, by definition, a marine ecosystem, and (except during whale watch tours) there is limited interpretation of the marine environment or wildlife within the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia. A significant opportunity exists to develop such an attraction in the Digby area. C) Identification and Market Readiness Standards for Secondary Attractions All key sites, whether tidal experience sites, the marine environment interpretation sites or the historical and geological sites should meet minimum market readiness and capacity standards and be featured in a comprehensive identity program. Similarly, there are a number of significant smaller interpretation facilities that can play an important role in the Bay of Fundy product, and standards for these sites should be established. Smaller sites that meet rigorous market readiness standards can also be featured in an identity program. Based on these needs, a development concept for the Bay of Fundy is revealed in the following section, (Part B). The concept will move Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy to a leadership position in nature tourism development and will significantly expand its market. D) Network of Viewpoints The Bay of Fundy region currently has an assortment of stopping points and look-offs. Some of these were organized into the Fundy Ecotour several years ago, but have fallen into disrepair. Others were developed by municipalities or community groups or are provincial day-use parks. Where such viewpoints and look-offs exist, there is a mix of standards, signs, identities and amenities. A consistent network of viewpoints is needed to offer adequate amenities to visitors, to connect the Bay of Fundy region together and to reinforce the Bay of Fundy theme. Viewpoints should meet minimum standards and be linked by a common identity. E) Way-finding and Orientation (Strengthen the Identity) A comprehensive system of way-finding and an orientation sign program is needed to support a harmonious Bay of Fundy identity for Nova Scotia. The identity program is needed to help clarify the Bay of Fundy region as a destination area and to raise the profile and awareness of the region among visitors, travel writers and even among residents who can reinforce the Bay of Fundy theme and message. 37 PART B - Development Plan PART B – Development Plan 5. Thematic Concept Throughout this report, it has been shown that the attraction is the Bay of Fundy itself. It is the location and the phenomenon that collectively creates the attraction (in the same way that the Grand Canyon or a National Park is an attraction in itself). The features that make the Bay of Fundy attractive can be summarized as follows: Lowest/biggest/highest tides in the world • dramatic changes in landscape (astonishing change when the tides go out and again when they return) • the mystery of the disappearing tide (where does the water go?) hints at the beautiful mysteries of Nova Scotia waiting to be discovered • highest tides in world recorded at Burncoat Head, Nova Scotia World-class fossils and geology • UNESCO world heritage site • opportunities for exploration, learning, and discovery 38 Authentic seacoast experience • scenic beauty • fishing communities (present-day and historical) • real life, local (e.g. watch your supper being caught in front of you, interact with locals, this is not an interpretation centre or a historic village) • potential for unmediated experience 5.1 Experiences Visitors can discover the Bay of Fundy through a variety of experiences: walking along coastal cliffs or out onto the ocean floor (inter-tidal zone), hunting for fossils and rocks, going out on a whale watching boat, eating lobster in a wharf restaurant, rafting the tidal bore, digging clams at low tide (or watching clam diggers from the shore), and so on. These experiences share several significant features: • they are active (about doing and interacting with the place – landscape and people) • they are nature-based • and, they take place within a broad ʻtidal zoneʼ - that area that can be considered to be under the influence of the tides. This includes Fundyʼs beaches, walkable coasts and tidal rivers flowing into the fertile agricultural areas Given the variety of tourism themes offered around the Bay of Fundy (from tide-based sporting activities, such as rafting, to Acadian history; from tidal power to gastronomy), a broad thematic concept is needed: one that reflects existing products without restricting the development of new enterprise. Such a concept must have something to do with the tide. The tide is the artist of the place, the sculptor of the landscape, and the creator of mystery. ʻTideʼ is the central theme of the area and the fundamental reason why this vast tidal zone is an interesting place to explore. Yet in itself, the tide isnʼt a particularly alluring idea. Instead, the focus needs to be on the drama of the landscape, the changes brought about by the action of the tides. The following broad constructions are a few ideas that share the same fundamental highlights and messages, but from slightly different angles: Canada’s Tidal Shoreline • • • • vast amounts of water come in and out of the Bay of Fundy twice a day, which results in eroding shorelines, cold water, warm mudflats, rich fishery, tidal power, etc. sense of magic/mystery: where does the water go? how low can you go? (The highest tides are also the lowest tides in the world) dramatic change when tide goes out, and again when it returns 39 Living with the World’s Giant Tides • Five Islands, Cape Split, the Grand Pré dykes, the Digby area whales, the various fisheries, the Joggins geology, tidal power, the rivers… all are either here because of the tide itself, or are unique because of the way they are influenced by the tide, or cope with the tidal effect • even the flavour of the grapes at the wineries is influenced by the tides! • sense of magic/mystery: where does the water go? Canada’s Natural Wonder • • • • vast amounts of water come in and out of the Bay of Fundy twice a day, which results in (eroding shorelines, cold water, warm mudflats, rich fishery, tidal power, etc.) awesome power, wonder of nature focused on nature, wonder, exploration Bay of Fundy has the highest tides in the world 5.2 Creating the Allure The following messages can be used to build on and enhance any and all of the above thematic concepts. These messages, as hooks or ideas, can be used both in marketing and programming. Mystery of the disappearing tides (conceptual hook): • dramatic striking landscape • mystery (where does the water go? how?) Drama/ beauty of coastal landmarks such as Five Islands and Cape Split (physical/visual hook): • hiking/running around the Five Islands (Not Since Moses Run) • hike out to the end of Cape Split to see the swirling waters • potential signature image Whale-watching (habitat/environmental hook) Cape Chignecto kayaking, Shubenacadie river rafting (adventure hook) 40 5.3 Thematic Sub-Regions The broad tidal zone can be divided into loose (and overlapping) thematic sub-regions, each with an associated attraction and a hub or semi-hub for accommodations and amenities: Geology (Joggins/Parrsboro) • fossils, geology museum Adventure (Five Islands/South Maitland) • river Rafting on the Shubenacadie River • run/walk on the bottom of the sea • wilderness adventure (Cape Chignecto) Human (Wolfville/Annapolis) • how our ancestors coped with living in this tidal zone (Grand Pré, Annapolis) • how we live here today (fishery, food, wine, theatre) Marine Richness (Digby) • biodiversity, endangered right whales, rich fishing area, whale watching 5.4 System vs. Icon Based on these thematic guidelines, this report recognizes the need for key activity-based attractions focusing on the world s highest tides. At the same time, it is a priority to more strongly define and promote the identity of the region (the Bay of Fundy) as a whole, through consistent signs, infrastructure, amenities, etc., and by defining boundaries. This report suggests that this is the most sustainable strategy with the greatest dissemination of benefits to the region. One-Anchor Attraction or System Approach? The possibility of developing a single “iconic” attraction as an option for building tourism visitation and revenues in Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy region was examined in the preparation of this study. Developing and branding a single site is appealing, based on the theory that a site with a strong identity can impact international markets, and thus draw significant new visitation into the province or region. Once visitors are here for the icon attraction, they will be attracted to other Bay of Fundy attractions, activities and services. Indeed, this is the principle behind the Hopewell Rocks development. Hopewell was intentionally developed as the iconic attraction used in the New Brunswick tourism marketing plan. It was especially well-suited for this role because the adjacent Fundy National Park (FNP) consistently attracts (and has attracted) over 200,000 visitors annually, (thus the two attractions support each other). Hopewell Rocks is also located strategically within the Province of New Brunswick where visitors from the US or central Canada pass on their way to/from Prince Edward Island and Nova 41 Scotia. Iconic attraction development is a common strategy, and is seen in many countries. Well known examples around the globe include Machu Pichu in Peru, Petra in Jordan, and the Taj Mahal in India. Certainly, the concept of an anchor attraction or the use of iconic images has value. However, a review of National Parks suggests that a single site is not the only strategy. There are several examples of Parks that feature a series of exceptional or unique landscape values positioned under a single brand. Banff National Park and Yellowstone National Park are both good examples of this. Provided boundaries of a region are defined, and the brand message and graphics are used and repeated throughout the tourism travel area, the region can collectively assume the role of a destination. Without question, one or more iconic images within the branded area are essential for successful promotion of a nature tourism site. Indeed, a distinct identity or brand and effective promotion are essential to attract attention in the international market. However, while a single site provides ease in management and promotion, a network of attractions grouped under a strong identity has been proven to be highly effective. 42 5.5 Recommended Strategy This report recommends an approach based on the following tasks: 1. Develop visitor facilities and programming at the best sites associated with the tidal landscape offering extraordinary interpreted activities related to the tides and the inter-tidal zone. 2. Build recognition in the global tourism market through outstanding images of these key iconic attractions. 3. Consistent with these key sites, establish a tiered network of themed attractions, interpretation and amenities. Similarly, the system will incorporate wayfinding, site entry and on-site visual components that will create a visually integrated identity for the region. Anchor Attractions 6. Anchor Attractions This report recommends that the first priority and the key strategic initiative be the development of two major tidal experience sites at Bay of Fundy coastal Provincial Parks. This will provide the lure for visitors to Nova Scotia. The tidal experience sites will directly fulfill the need for visitors to see and experience the tidal phenomenon. The two sites proposed are different, but in both cases, phenomenal experiences. This diversity will be a fundamental strength of the product. These sites are shown on the following map, along with the third Bay of Fundy region core Provincial Park, Cape Chignecto. Complementing the tidal experience sites will be the Marine Interpretation Centre in Digby (described in 6.2). Each of the three themed Bay of Fundy attractions will be referred to as “discovery sites as follows: Five Islands Tidal Discovery Site Cape Split Coastal Discovery Site Digby Marine Discovery Centre These three Bay of Fundy themed discovery sites will be part of a larger framework that includes major existing themed attractions within the Bay of Fundy region (as referred to in section 5), including the following: Geology – (Existing) • Joggins UNESCO Site • Fundy Geological Museum Human History (Existing) • Grand Pré National Historic Site • Fort Anne National Historic Site • Port Royal National Historic Site In its entirety, the plan will include eight key attractions or anchor sites, the three newly 43 developed sites with five existing sites. This framework is shown in the following illustration. For all attractions in this category, there must be comprehensive and rigorous standards for market readiness. Anchor attractions will have correspondingly high visual and wayfinding elements. Market Readiness Criteria All Bay of Fundy discovery sites must meet or consist of the following criteria: 1. Capacity Anchor sites should have the capacity to accommodate a minimum of 25,000 visitors annually. It is likely that some sites will exceed this, possibly reaching 40,000 – 50,000. The parking should be designed to accommodate a minimum of 30 vehicles with overflow capacity (roadside, etc.) of a least 30 more. The following table indicates parking requirements for visitor flows ranging from 10,000 – 40,000 per season. For visitor numbers of 40,000, parking capacity should be 50 with overflow capacity of an additional 50. 44 Visitor numbers 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 Average (peak season) 100 200 300 400 Peak days 250 500 750 1000 Visitors/car 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 # vehicles (peak day) 100 200 300 400 # vehicles (avg day) 40 80 120 160 Museums Turnover/day 4 4 4 4 Parking utilization (peak) 25 50 75 100 Parking utilization (avg) 10 20 30 40 Required 15 25 35 50 Overflow 10 25 35 50 Turnover/day 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 Parking utilization (peak) 40 80 120 160 Parking utilization (avg) 16 32 48 64 Required 20 40 60 80 Overflow 20 40 60 80 Parks 2. Other Criteria • revenue program (admissions, parking, etc.) • open: mid-May to end-October (year round preferred) • staffed storefront location with welcome area • indoor public washrooms • communication tools: phone, fax, email, website • liability, safety equipment, risk management policies (as appropriate) • staffed, scheduled interpretation programs available • on-site orientation signage and/or visitor map • staff trained in customer service • professional mystery shop 45 6.1 Provincial Parks – The Untapped Resource Analysis of the natural and tourism resources of the Bay of Fundy, the travel patterns and opportunities, all point toward the conclusion that the Bay of Fundy region Provincial Parks offer the best opportunity for interpreting the Bay of Fundy tidal phenomena. The parks have a significant land-base, an established management program, and already have certain amenities in place. Indeed, four coastal parks have been designated by the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources (DNR), Parks Division as core sites within the Bay of Fundy theme region (2009). These include: Cape Chignecto Five Islands Cape Blomidon Cape Split (undesignated) These four park areas occupy 6,000 hectares of coastal property (almost 15,000 acres). Collectively, they amount to more than 60 kilometers of the most dramatic coastline on the Bay of Fundy (if not the Province). It should be noted that this is more than the linear coastline of the two combined New Brunswick National Parks Fundy National Park and Kouchibouguac. Similarly, these Provincial Parks include more coastline than Cape Breton Highlands National Park. While Cape Split has yet to be designated as a Provincial Park, it is generally seen as linked to Blomidon Provincial Park due to their close proximity. For this reason, this report refers to Blomidon/Cape Split as a single park unit. Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy coastal parks are relatively new. Indeed, in both land area and coastline, Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy coastal parks have expanded by acquisition and 46 designation by more than 300% (since 1995) making them (currently) one of the most important, if underdeveloped, coastal park systems in Canada. The extent to which the extraordinary coastal features of the Bay of Fundy are now within a significant network of Nova Scotia Parks is not fully recognized within the Province, nor is it promoted effectively to prospective visitors from outside the region. It is the view of the author that the coastal landscape that they occupy is diverse, spectacular and representative of the Bay of Fundyʼs tidal phenomenon. In other Canadian Provinces, Provincial Parks feature much more prominently as partners in the growth, diversity and quality of the overall tourism product. In Quebec, for example, they refer to Provincial Parks as their National Parks. In Alberta, Provincial Parks are developed and managed by the Department of Tourism, Parks and Recreation. Strategic development of infrastructure, programs and interpretation in Alberta Provincial Parks mean that they compare favourably to National Parks in quality and visitor perception. Similarly, Manitobaʼs vast system of Provincial Parks involve a network of ecological reserves, heritage rivers and outdoor recreational opportunities. High levels of staffed interpretation in these three sample provinces insure maximum visitor usage and appreciation of their provincial parks system. It is the recommendation of this report that the Bay of Fundy Parks should be seen as a vital part of Nova Scotiaʼs nature tourism product. This group of parks can and should collectively present the Bay of Fundy tidal and inter-tidal landscape to the country. Each park should offer programming that demonstrate and showcase their unique tidal, coastal and terrestrial features. Expanding the Role of Bay of Fundy Provincial Parks Historically, the functions of parks such as Five Islands and Blomidon have largely been to provide a camping experience. Not discounting this role, the Bay of Fundy region parks have the potential to offer programming well beyond their function as campgrounds. This report recommends that dayuse coastal/tidal exploration and interpretation programming should be a primary focus of these parks. The Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources (DNR) administers and delivers the provincial park system under the legislative mandate of the Provincial Parks Act. The Act sets standards for site management and conservation. Parks are staffed, have roads, amenities, maintenance programs, etc., through the management mandate of DNR. 47 DNR recently designated the Fundy region as a “Theme Area”. (Five Islands, Blomidon/Cape Split and Cape Chignecto are considered core sites). Consistent within this planning arena are major themed developments at Cape Split and Five Islands, and a large second phase development of a day-use area recently completed at Cape Chignecto Provincial Park. potential nature tourism attractions, with unique and phenomenal landscapes. Modifications or adaptations to visitor management would enable the development of a full program of activities and interpretation. While Parks has limited capacity for management of new roles, increased visitation and new facilities, it is likely that there are willing partners such as the Department of Tourism, Culture and Heritage who could contribute to the enhancement of the Bay of Fundy Parks within its existing destination development priorities. Development The Bay of Fundy Parks collectively have potential to fill the gaps in Bay of Fundy interpretation and provide a complete program of education and interpretation relating to the Worldʼs Highest Tides. They should be Anchor Attractions within the Bay of Fundy region. This report recommends Five Islands and Cape Split, in particular, be the themed tidal anchor attractions and activity sites, expanded to provide high quality day-use visitor facilities along with complete interpretation and programming. Cape Split offers the stunning coastal experience and awe-inspiring tidal rip while Five Islands will offer programs and interpretation to experience the drama of the inter-tidal landscape. As Anchor Attractions, they must be capable of providing activities for a minimum of a half-day visit. This will require an investment in infrastructure and programming that will, in turn, create a legacy of a dynamic and diverse Bay of Fundy Parks network. Located in between these two core attractions are numerous smaller tidal interpretation opportunities and activities, including the tidal bore rafting zone on the Shubenacadie River. These smaller sites will complement the two anchors and would diversify the product for visitors. Nova Scotia Parks are potentially outstanding nature tourism attractions that are currently used by only 10% of Nova Scotians (and even less by visitors). Yet in this report, the assessment of the Fundy ones in particular, are of national calibre as Cape Chignecto should be further developed to fulfill the role of a multi-day coastal wilderness park. 48 Partnerships A larger role in tourism for Cape Split and Five Islands entails a larger scope of management. This will require additional resources and may be beyond Parks current management capacity. It is recommended, therefore, that a partnership approach be used with each of these two projects. This could be based on the partnership model for Cape Chignecto Provincial Park. By engaging a local partner, federal funding opportunities may become available. This division of roles does not have to precisely follow the partner roles at Cape Chignecto. For example, partnerships could be as follows: Parks Division: • natural resource management issues • site development • wayfinding • campground operation • site maintenance • enforcement and security • waste management • interpretation planning • staffing Regional/Municipal: Cape Split – Kings CED Agency Five Islands – CORDA • interpretation facility development • interpretation programming • interpretation facility operation • program management (directly or private sector licensing) The exact nature of the partnership and roles must be determined through a consensus with the partners. It is clear, however, that without such a partnership, and if the Park Division of DNR must assume an expanded responsibility, they must have additional staff and resources. DNR staff participated in initial planning sessions and a special meeting with Nova Scotia Tourism to discuss the development of Provincial Parks within the Bay of Fundy region. The consultant also met specifically with DNR staff to discuss options for the development of Cape Split and Five Islands. Tourism and Culture: • facility planning • promotions and marketing • interpretation infrastructure • staffing 49 6.2 Criteria Season Day-use facilities must be designated to accommodate a longer season. At Cape Split, trails should be open year round. At Five Islands and Cape Chignecto, a 6-month season (May 1 to November 1) is recommended. 50 Operating Revenue The idea of a user-pay system within Provincial Parks inevitably raises questions. It is recommended to use a modified user pay system that is based on an environmental ethic. User fees, (day-use) should be confined to vehicle parking fees only. Walk-in, cyclists, etc., would enter without cost. An hourly fee system would help to manage load by encouraging visitors to carpool, and reduce the number of visitors who spend extended periods of time at the site, on trails, etc. Parking fees would provide an important source of revenue to cover operating costs. 6.3 Cape Split Coastal Discovery Site 51 Cape Split/Blomidon Blomidon and Cape Split together represent a key Bay of Fundy themed development opportunity in the Annapolis Valley region. While Cape Split and Blomidon are two distinct land areas, they are essentially considered a single unit by the Parks Division, DNR. A third site, Look-off Provincial dayuse park, can be included in this cluster. Cape Split has the qualities of an internationally significant landmark. The tidal phenomenon at the Split makes it unique in the world. Cape Split provides views of the Bay of Fundyʼs most visible and powerful tidal rip, as well as a panoramic view of its narrowest, most turbulent section; the Minas Channel. In addition, scenic attributes such as the vertical drop and geological features here are outstanding. The Split is part of a narrow and precipitous tenkilometer long peninsula that gracefully arches out into the Bay of Fundy, separating the inner Minas Basin from the outer Bay. It is approximately 200 meters high, and, at its most extreme point, is fractured into a series of massive columnar pinnacles. The outer point is accessed on foot by a safe, well-worn woodland trail from the park boundary. Cape Split is referred to in DNR s preliminary management plan as “most ecologicallyintact portion of the North Mountain and one of the most important undisturbed areas on the Bay of Fundy.” The combination of its high narrow peninsula, and the sea-stacks and pinnacles that break off from its tip, 52 make Cape Split comparable to many of the great coastal viewpoints in the world. However, it is the Bay of Fundyʼs tidal rip rushing around and through the base of the rock pinnacles that make it truly unique. These factors provide opportunities for experiential and interpretation programming that could make Cape Split a truly inspiring destination and one of Nova Scotiaʼs ʻmust seeʼ nature sites. 53 Cape Split showing viewpoint: The meadow visible at the top is over 100 m wide (about the side of a football field). The cliffs are at least 150 meters high (about 500 ft). Measured vertically, thatʼs about a city block in height. Cape Split illustrating basalt pinnacles that form a series projecting into the Minas Basin Cape Split illustrating the tidal Rip. The intense whitewater shown here is one of the most exteme tidal rips in the world. Next page - aerial view of the Cape Location Cape Split (and Blomidon) are just 70 minutes from metro-Halifax and 90 minutes from the Halifax International airport. Cape Split and Blomidon are also 20 minutes from a principle travel artery (Highway 101) and close to services (within the Wolfville hub). Road access to both park areas is paved. Current Status Cape Split was recently acquired by the Province and had not been formally designated as a provincial park at the time of this study. A preliminary management plan was prepared for Cape Split in 2009 and presented at open house sessions in Wolfville and Scots Bay. However, development cost and funding is yet to be confirmed. The preliminary management plan for Cape Split indicates that vehicle traffic will be limited to a small development zone in the vicinity of the park boundary. The Split itself will be accessible by foot via a walking path. The duration (one-way) for the average walker is three hours. This limits the market potential somewhat since a relatively small proportion of visitors travel more than a few meters from their cars. However, Cape Splitʼs many intriguing features promise a walking experience with high market appeal. Currently, the development zone designated within the draft management plan is confined to a limited area close to the road. This restricts development of parking, visitor orientation and trails in the vicinity of the trailhead. The plan and development proposal are preliminary at this stage and it is recognized that there are planning issues and problems that must be overcome if Cape Split is to fulfill its role as one of the Nova Scotiaʼs most important parks. Development Recommendations This report recommends that the planning concept for the development zone at Cape Split be revisited with the intention of providing improved access, parking, viewpoints and the development of a high quality visitor orientation and education facility. With adequate programming and infrastructure, Cape Split has potential to become one of Nova Scotiaʼs pre-eminent natural attractions. Program infrastructure components should include: • visitor centre/orientation • parking • walking experience • tidal observation • boat tours 57 Visitor Centre/Orientation A visitor orientation, amenity and interpretation centre should be developed within the development zone (in the vicinity of the park entrance) along with a well-developed short trail system with exceptional viewpoints in the vicinity of the visitor centre. If road access or parking can be developed on the upper slope, this visitor orientation facility could be located where there are viewing opportunities toward all points of the compass. The following illustration indicates two potential viewing sites that could be developed in conjunction with a visitor centre. The visitor orientation centre should include the following: • washrooms • rest/waiting area • interpretation and orientation Interpretation themes at the centre should include: • the physical aspects of Cape Split (this could include a map diorama) • the tidal rip (and Bay of Fundy tides, in general) • the geological history of the North Mountain • the flora and fauna of Cape Split • the Nova Scotia Park System • complete orientation and safety information If vehicle access and parking at an upper elevation is not possible, the visitor/orientation centre should be developed close to the water with views and shoreline access. 58 Parking As a major nature tourism site, parking at Cape Split must be available for at least 60 vehicles, with the potential for up to 60 overflow spaces. Assuming this parking is to be located on site, it will require a re-evaluation of the development zone concept. Adequate parking could also be available in Scots Bay, but this will necessitate a shuttle service to the trail-head, incurring additional operating costs, management challenges, etc. While these costs could be recovered through a fee for the shuttle service, fees generated from on-site parking could be better used for maintenance and staff. A tiered parking program would be an alternative if parking for 200 vehicles on site were clearly not possible. In this case, on-site could be limited to 60 vehicles with an overflow site at Scots Bay. In this case, a shuttle may still be needed, but perhaps only for 3-4 weeks annually, during the peak season. Walking Experience The principle walking trail should be designed to a front-country standard and a moderately low-level of difficulty. Currently, the Cape Split walk is inaccessible to people with slight mobility issues as a result of the 1.5 kilometer steep uphill climb and descent near the trail-head. As one of the Parkʼs planning staff indicated, it is a relatively easy walking trail with a steep 30-minute hike at the beginning and end. If hikers could embark on this walk from a higher elevation, it would be a more accessible hike to a wider segment of the population. This does not diminish the role of the park as a “walking” experience, nor does it diminish the health benefits. With or without the steep climb, Cape Split will have a walking distance of at least 10-12 kilometers and an overall duration of two to four hours. Tidal Observation A viewing platform at the water level at the end of Cape Split, if feasible, would allow visitors to view tidal rips up close (the most prominent interpretation and experiential aspect of the site). Stairs and a lower viewing area would also reduce visitor loads on the upper viewing area. The feasibility of stairs in this location must be evaluated. Currently, close examination of the site reveals that some visitors are unsafely accessing the beach via a rope in a rocky gorge. Water-based Guided Tours to Cape Split A tour program by boat will be a key part of the Cape Split experience. It is likely that water-craft such as zodiacs that can embark from the beach would be needed, as otherwise, the tides will affect the logistics of the tours. It is recommended that the tour program be done under license to a private sector operator and with a staging area (embankation) situated on the park property. 59 Visitor Numbers While actual visitor numbers will depend on factors such as marketing, quality of programming and the variances of the tourism market, it is proposed that the park should be designed to accommodate a minimum of 30,000 visitors annually. The principle feature of the park would be a walking trail (although the water tours may be a significant part of the experience, as well). The walking distance will be at least 12 kilometers which is beyond the normal range of most touring visitors. However, when a landmark as dramatic as Cape Split is recognized as an internationally significant site, the number of visitors who will participate in a more adventurous experience is surprisingly high. At the Grand Canyon, 300,000 visitors venture below the rim (almost 10% of visitors). At Yosemite, 80,000 visitors navigate the hazardous climb to the summit of El Capitan. Kejimkujik National Park (the least visited of the National Parks in Atlantic Canada) attracts roughly 50,000 visitors annually for active exploration. Fees/Load Management Parking fees would provide an important source of revenues to cover operating costs. Based on 5,000 - 10,000 vehicles per year, we would estimate revenues of $30,000 – $100,000, depending on the parking fee. At the high end, this would be equivalent to almost one third of the 60 current revenues from the entire Nova Scotia park system. Blomidon Blomidon Provincial Park (15 kilometers from Cape Split) overlooks the south quadrant of the Minas Basin. It is primarily a camping park (70 sites) encompassing 760 hectares (1,900 acres) offering a network of hiking trails along the upper parts of Cape Blomidon. Blomidon is a complement to Cape Split, both in terms of visitor experience, services, etc., and in terms of management. At this stage, it is not proposed to expand the day-use facilities at Blomidon since programming at Cape Split would fulfill this need. The possible exception is the beach access point where there are possibilities for inter-tidal and geological interpretation. Linked to Cape Split from a promotional perspective, it is anticipated occupancy rates at Blomidon to increase from the current level of 40% to at least 60% (and an equivalent increase in revenues). The Look-off The final segment in the Cape/Split Blomidon park set is the Look-off. This small, but well-known, day-use park has significant interpretation potential focusing on human adaptation, specifically the transformation of the tidal salt marshes to dyked farmland. This could be a selfguided program delivered within an open interpretation kiosk. 6.4 Five Islands Tidal Discovery Site 61 Five Islands Provincial Park Five Islands is one of the best sites in the Bay of Fundy for interpreting and experiencing the tidal and inter-tidal phenomena. Tides at Five Islands are third highest of monitored sites within the Minas Basin. Tides in the Minas Basin are roughly 2 m (7 feet) higher than sites outside the Minas Basin, and the inter-tidal zone at Five Islands is one of the most expansive, dramatic and diverse in the Bay. Since the beginning of the “Not Since Moses” race across the ocean floor in 2007, there has been a significant increase in national recognition of the breathtaking inter-tidal landscape offered at Five Islands. The locationʼs ability to captivate and astonish visitors has been well-documented through this now top-rated Canadian adventure“sport” tourism event. The Bay of Fundy experience here includes: coastal hiking (cliff-side and shoreline at low tide) as well as many seastacks, sandbars, islands, and sea-caves to explore. Five Islands Provincial Park offers access and views of the tidal landscape that are among the best in the Bay of Fundy region (including both the Provinces of Nova Scotia and New Brunswick). The Park has huge potential for engaging in dramatic tidal adventures through guided programs. With a well-developed tidal experience tour, visitors could very well finally and confidently 62 say: “this is where you go to see the tides in Nova Scotia”. Five Islands Provincial Park: Not Since Moses run showing Diamond and Pinnacle Islands Five Islands Provincial Park: Not Since Moses Run (various at medium and low tide) This park also has a vast geological history, visible in the cliffs and islands that can be told and interpreted from this location. As is often the case, where there is a geological story, there is also outstanding rock collecting. Park information states the following: “Volcanic action, massive erosion, flooding and glacial scouring, created the spectacular scenery and interesting geological formations found here…. Agate, the provincial gemstone, along with amethyst, jasper and stilbite, are found along the beaches and cliffs. Fish fossils, as well as ornithopod dinosaur tracks, have been discovered in the loose blocks on the beach… The park features 90 metre (300 ft.) sea cliffs overlooking the world's highest tides, a spectacular setting for camping or any of the many opportunities that abound for hiking, beachcombing, rock collecting, clam digging, and ocean kayaking. Five Islands Park offers a 90-site, fully serviced campground. The park is only open in the summer (2009: May 21 - Sept. 6). Day-use at Five Islands Park is substantially under-utilized. Only 10% of day-use visitors are from outside the local area, although this is higher among camping visitors. This is not surprising since the parkʼs season is quite short and it has focused almost exclusively on camping over the years. There is a small designated day-use area, but it needs to be redesigned to allow for proper visitor management, as well as to connect visitors more meaningfully to viewpoints along the parkʼs cliff-lined shore. While the camping area may have affected the day-use potential of the site, it provides certain benefits, including an established management program, staff, paved road access and amenities. The park is 1,573 acres in size and has completed a recent campsite upgrade, but is awaiting funding for a second phase of development. Five Islands is 30 minutes from the Trans-Canada Highway at Glenholme and 90 minutes from the Halifax International airport. Development Recommendations Five Islands Provincial Park has high market appeal as a tidal experience viewing and interpretation site, as well as, a staging zone for adventure programs. Although not as well-located as Cape Split (relative to Halifax), its proximity to the Trans-Canada Highway may offset this. More importantly, it does not have access to the same quality of tourism services within close proximity as Cape Split. On the accommodations side, there is a moderately large accommodations base in 65 Truro (40 minutes away) as well as cottages and bed & breakfasts along the shore, and a cluster of services in Parrsboro (15 minutes away). Unfortunately, there is a lack of unique and experiential culinary attractions near the park. With adequate programming and infrastructure, Five Islands Park has potential to become a major Bay of Fundy-themed natural attraction in the region. Program infrastructure components should include: Visitor Interpretation and Orientation Centre A visitor orientation, amenity and interpretation centre should be developed within the day use area in close proximity to the shoreline access point, viewing areas and within an easy walk from the parking area. The centre should provide the following: • • • • orientation and information well-designed staging area for guided tidal excursions interior visitor rest/viewing area interpretation Interpretation will focus on the following themes: • • • 66 Five Islands landscape Five Islands seascape (inter-tidal zone) highest tides • natural history of Five Islands • Aboriginal and settlement history The proposed location for the centre is shown on the following illustration: Visitor Numbers As with Cape Split, actual visitor numbers will depend on factors such as marketing, quality of programming, and the variances of the tourism market. However, as an integrated tidal site, accessible to all with tiered programming, the park should be designed to accommodate a significant number of visitors, probably in the range of 20,000 - 30,000 visitors annually. One of the strengths of Five Islands Provincial Park that factors greatly into its appeal for broader markets, is the instant accessibility of the tidal beach (walk out) and viewpoints. Parking As was the case for Cape Split, if Five Islands is developed as a major tourism nature site, parking capacity for day use must correspondingly be designed to accommodate that level of traffic. This report recommends that a parking capacity of 25 -30 vehicles with an overflow area of an additional 30 would be needed. The parking area should be linked to the orientation centre by a direct walking path. Walking Trails, Viewpoints and Shoreline Access A well developed short trail system in the vicinity of the visitor centre with exceptional viewpoints needs to be developed. A fog horn-type device would be installed on a prominent viewpoint location to signal the low tide (and to warn of the incoming tide). Refurbishment of existing coastal trails (now closed) that were damaged by previous hurricanes is necessary. Tidal Adventure Tours and Excursions Activities at Five Islands Provincial Park should focus on the tidal experience, but would also include interpretation of the remarkable geological formations, rock collecting opportunities, and nature observation. The tidal experience should include a tiered system of engagement from passive self-guided viewing to guided beach walks and excursions onto the inter-tidal zone (possibly involving zodiacs, kayaks, etc.). The site itself should be designed to follow a tide timetable with appropriate signals, warnings, or beach sweeps before the incoming tide. Guided tours must be supported by zodiac and follow a similar pattern to the “Not Since Moses Run”, taking visitors out to the outer island on the outgoing tide and allowing them to walk their way back in as the tide disappears. Fees/Load Management As with Cape Split, it is recommended to use a modified user pay system for day users confined to vehicle parking fees only (cyclists, etc. would enter without cost). Parking fees would be needed to cover operating costs. Revenue potential would 67 be slightly less than Cape Split, but still in the range of $40,000 annually. The impact on the existing camping aspect of Five Islands Provincial Park will be significant. Occupancy rates would certainly rise, possibly by a factor of two. Consequently, revenue from camping could double. Camping visitors would benefit significantly from the addition of new facilities and programs, and there may be an argument to increase fees as a result. Indeed, if demand on the camping area increases enough, an increase in daily rates at the park could help to manage the demand. 68 6.5 Digby Marine Discovery Site 69 Marine Interpretation While the drama of the Bay of Fundy tides is most explicit in areas with extreme tidal zones, it s story canʼt be complete without interpreting the dynamics of the Bay itself, the extraordinary characteristics of its marine ecosystem, and the marine life that thrive in its abundant environment. Most important to the touring visitor may be the whales that feed at the entrance to the Bay of Fundy, just off Digby Neck. The Bay of Fundy is habitat to over 15 species of whales. Probably the most unique among them are the North Atlantic Right Whales, one of the rarest mammals on earth. Most of the worldʼs population of Right Whales come to the entrance to the Bay of Fundy each summer to breed. An active whale-watching industry has developed on Digby Neck (and in New Brunswick in St. Andrews/ Passamaquoddy Bay area). Until recently, the Bay of Fundyʼs marine ecosystem was an interpretation topic also underpromoted on the New Brunswick side of the Bay of Fundy. In October, 2009, a $5 million upgrade to the Huntsman Ocean Centre in St. Andrews, New Brunswick was announced. Until now, the Huntsman was a biological research centre, but the new development includes: a public aquarium (themed around the diversity of the Bay of Fundy), a public lecture theatre, conference spaces, and public programs. 70 It is more important than ever for Nova Scotia to provide visitors with the opportunity to learn more about the Bay of Fundyʼs world-renown marine ecosystem. The Digby Area The Town of Digby is a suitable location for interpreting the Bay of Fundy marine environment. The town is an active seaport and has a large fishery with a history closely linked to the Bay. It has a tourism-friendly town centre and a strong base of accommodations, the most notable of which is the premium resort hotel: the Digby Pines Resort. Digby is also an entry-point into the Province with daily arrivals of the ferry, the Princess of Acadia from Saint John, New Brunswick. It is suggested that the interpretation facility be close to, or immersed within, the town centre and waterfront area. This will build upon and enhance the critical mass and viability of the town centre. Since the Digby fishery is a tangible link with the marine interpretation story (in addition to the whale-watching operators), it would be ideal if the centre was in proximity to the wharf. Development Considerations The role of tourism development, and in particular destination development, is vital in Digby. The community has a history as a tourism destination, due to the presence of the ferry at a time when road travel was more primitive than today. Indeed, tourism in Digby remains an important part of the townʼs economy. However, without investment and revitalization of the tourism infrastructure, the future will be uncertain. series of interpretation programs leading to actual experiences… coastlines/scenery, culture and heritage, birding, whale watching, ferry access, wine/cuisine and access to fresh seafood” The development of an interpretation facility in Digby cannot alone transform the town, although it can be the catalyst to set this transformation in motion. Equally important is to enhance the attractiveness of the town, waterfront and wharf and make this area visitor friendly. Observations in the recent report by Roger Brooks point out a need to enhance the character of the town centre. Annapolis Royal, 15 minutes from Digby in the direction of Halifax, has a town centre which exhibits all the charm, character and aesthetic quality that can attract visitors and would inevitably generate positive word of mouth. The success of this proposal will depend on active efforts to revitalize the Digby centre, both through planning and development. Consistent with these goals, this report recommends the creation of a multi-faceted activity centre with potential to attract a significant market. This concept of a visitor plaza may consist of a mix of fully enclosed and partially enclosed terrace and/or atrium spaces. For example, it may consist of a roofed plaza or open atrium looking out toward the harbour, surrounded by small units styled as traditional seaport buildings. These components could include: • washrooms • information and orientation • interpretation of physical phenomena of the Bay of Fundy • whale-watching sales and promotion • shopping Within the atrium, public art and opportunities for recreation for children and youths could be integrated. Development Concept The Digby Area Tourism Association has already given some consideration to the development of an interpretation centre and has established preliminary goals, as follows: “A proposed centre would act as a major visitor portal and orientation point for the multi-faceted phenomena of the Bay of Fundy… the concept of the centre is a Interpretation Outline The focus of interpretation will be on the unique aspects of the Bay of Fundy marine environment and the influences on the people who have lived and worked here. Interpretation should focus on 71 region specific characteristics of the lower Bay, the marine environment and the landscape, and stories that are relevant to the Digby area. The centre should fulfill the role of interpreting the marine environment and do it well. As such, it will be part of the larger Bay of Fundy concept, complementing geological and tidal attractions at the other end of the Bay. Specifically, the interpretation concept should include: 1. The Ocean Meets the Bay of Fundy (the affect of the tides) 2. The Marine Mammals 3. The Digby Fishery 4. The Annapolis Basin 1. The Ocean Meets the Bay – (affect of the tides) • how the tides make the mouth of the Bay of Fundy a productive marine ecosystem (i.e. deep water currents are forced to the surface, nutrient rich, support abundant marine life); the reason why fishery is so productive • why whales come to the Bay of Fundy with their young to feed on plankton, tiny marine creatures • the Gulf of Maine and the Labrador current (influence on climate of Nova Scotia) 72 2. The Marine Mammals • whales as an indicator of marine productivity • the story and the tragedy of the northern Right Whale – the era of whaling, the verge of extinction, the current population • other species of whales • promotion of the whale-watching industry • other marine mammals 3. The Digby Fishery • how the tidal bay supports a rich fishery • size of the fishing fleet • species and fish products from the region • the scallop fishery, all about scallops, how they grow, how they are caught, cuisine, how to eat them, etc. 4. The Annapolis Basin • geography of the Basin - diorama • birthplace of Canada • tidal power Location Options A 2009 waterfront development study prepared by Cormier Management and Fundy Engineering included a concept for the construction of a waterfront expansion. Specifically, it was proposed that this site would accommodate a tourism interpretation and orientation centre. It is absolutely essential that the centre establish or maintain a connection with the fishing community and the town centre. The proposed location fulfills these criteria reasonably well. Other factors such as the flow of pedestrian traffic into and through the commercial centre of the community, parking, etc., must be evaluated in a site-specific development plan. 73 Other Key Attractions 7. Other Key Attractions 7.1 Brier Island Digby Neck, Long Island and Brier Island may well be Bay of Fundyʼs hidden gems due to the undisturbed natural features and the geographic location at the mouth of the Bay. This scenic peninsula and islands are part of a dramatic basalt headland stretching from the town of Digby to the tip of Brier Island in Southwestern Nova Scotia. The area lies between Fundyʼs extreme tidal currents where the Bay meets the Gulf of Maine and the calmer St. Marys Bay edging the mainland. The region is largely undeveloped, although a series of small hiking trails, lighthouses, whale watch tour companies and small fishing villages are scattered along its length. While efforts have been made by local tourism groups to brand this part of Nova Scotia as an ecotourism destination, visitors are largely left on their own to discover the Neck and Islandsʼ natural features. There are no guided tours. The hiking trails, with a couple of exceptions, are under promoted, under developed and under signed. If the Neck and Islands are the hidden jewels of the Bay of Fundy, then Brier Island, at its furthermost tip, could very well be the “the rugged diamond in Nova Scotiaʼs crown”. For the 74 purposes of this study, Brier Island has two particularly enticing features: • it is the physical entrance to the Bay of Fundy • one third of the island is designated by the Nature Conservancy of Canada Admittedly, the Nature Conservancyʼs relationship with the island has been somewhat awkward over the years, but the fact that the Nature Conservancyʼs area exists here is symbolic: it validates Brier Island as being a nationally renown, ecologically significant area of biodiversity. These features become important when anchoring this section of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy product. Roger Brooks, in his 2009 destination assessment, suggests the importance of applying the “4X Rule” to this area: “Visitors will make a point of stopping or staying in a community if it has enough activities that appeal specifically to them and will keep them busy four times longer than it took them to get there. “ In order to lure visitors from Halifax (3 hours away), the Brier Island area needs to have 12 hours worth of things for them to do. A whale watching tour currently accounts for three to four hours. As Mr. Brooks also noted, visitors want things to do, not just things to look at. This report suggests that enhancements to the vast existing network of trails in the Nature Conservancy area may well be the missing link of six additional hours of activity needed to make Brier Island a stronger nature loversʼ destination within the proposed, stronger network of Bay of Fundy anchor attractions. Enhancements to hiking ʻproductʼ on Brier Island will naturally draw visitors along the Neck and Long Island as part of the adventure of making it to the tip of this intriguing land formation. There are complementary sites enroute such as Gullivers Cove, Balancing Rock and Boarʼs Head Lighthouse that will add to the exploring experience. Brier Island will be more successful in drawing visitors once it has more market ready hiking trails. It must work hard to become a destination: there are no ʻaccidental touristsʼ on Digby Neck and Islands. Visitors who venture out there are not passing by on their way to anywhere else: in order to entice them to make the trek, the experience must be clearly defined, well-organized and wellpresented. Improvements to the hiking experience of this area would harmonize with neighbouring sites (such as Kejimkujik National Park) and also complement its well-established whale watching industry. 75 Key Features The key natural features of Brier Island include: • bird habitat & migratory pathways (Atlantic Flyway) • wide variety of many common wildflowers • favourable habitat for rare and endangered plant species • high proportion of coastal hiking • seal habitat (seal watching from shoreline) • geology (basalt flows & vertical columns) • proximity to whale (and other marine mammals) habitat • tidal village on stilts at low tide • local fishery • accessible lighthouses Wayfinding Many trails are currently lacking trailheads and trail orientation for the islands. Some trails, as evidenced by the signage sample below, are marked intermittently with homemade signage. The researcher for this study spent several days tracking down trail locations and routes by checking with local citizens and exploring back roads: tourists would likely not be as persistent. Roger Brooks, for example, reported never finding the Islandsʼ advertised hiking and biking trails. A full system of branded wayfinding signage is recommended, including trailhead signage with distances and level of difficulty marked. 76 Interpretation Although Brier Island has a couple of historical interpretation panels near the general store, it is recommended that panel interpretation about its natural features be developed as part of the trails or trailhead system. A self-guided map or booklet (with more detail than the current map) should also be available. Trail enhancements The Nature Conservancy trails are clearly being used: both for hiking and, in some areas, for fourwheeling. Four-wheeling is a popular pastime in rural Nova Scotia and a balance needs to be achieved between both uses in these sensitive but appealing areas. There is visible damage from 4-wheelers on various sections of the trail and also there are many areas of ʻtrail braidingʼ where hikers have tramped out new routes around existing trails (often due to the main trail being wet or muddy). In the long run, these practices are damaging to the ecosystem. Most of the trails on Brier Island would benefit from better definition and built tread in some areas. A system also needs to be established for garbage removal on the beaches and trails (this function is currently being undertaken on a occasional basis by community members). Tidal observation More interpretation could be made of the tidesʼ influence on the weather, fishing and coastlines of the Neck and Islands. This could include be interpretation panels aboard the two ferries or waiting areas for the passages between the islands. There is a huge volume of water moving through these passages, the movement of which varies according to the tide cycle. By times these small ferries appear to make their voyages at full throttle combating the sideways thrust of Fundyʼs heavy tidal movement. Parks Canada Marine Park Parks Canada has had a mandate to create National Marine Conservation Areas (NMCA) across Canada since the concept was established in 2002. An NMCA in Canada is like a ʻwatery national parkʼ: available for a mix of recreational, tourism and commercial use while at the same time preserving and sustaining some core areas of habitat. There are currently three National Marine Parks in Canada: • Five Fathom National Marine Park, Georgian Bay, Ontario - celebrates a Great Lakesʼ ecosystem, rugged coasts, rock formations, 22 shipwrecks, historic light stations • Lake Superior National Marine Conservation Area, Ontario - celebrates • over 70 species of fish, gull-heron-eaglepelican habitat, 50 shipwrecks, geology & geomorphology, flora & fauna, aboriginal history Saguenay-St Lawrence Marine Park, Quebec - sea bottom topography, fjords, 15 species of marine mammals, biological diversity, human history The Bay of Fundy has recently been identified by Parks Canada as a possible location for an NMCA, the first in eastern Canada. In the spring of 2010, the lengthy research process to determine the feasibility of establishing a Marine Park somewhere in the Bay of Fundy will begin. The designation of a Marine Park includes: the seabed, the water above it and the species which occur there. It may also take in wetlands, estuaries, islands and other coastal lands. Since one third of Brier Island is already protected by the Nature Conservancy, it may be the one place in the entire Bay of Fundy that most easily matches the criteria for a marine park. This appears to be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to complement and validate the existing complex marine ecosystem of the Brier Island area with a prestigious national designation. This report recommends that Brier Island participate in the research process with Parks Canada to determine the opportunities and fit of a marine park in the region. 77 Partners Key to the general enhancement of hiking and nature tourism product on Brier Island will be the Nature Conservancy of Canada, who owns one third of the island. In early March 2010, the Nature Conservancy held an open house meeting in the region to discuss pending trail development based on funds recently received for trail and signage upgrades. Other potential partners for the development of this region as a Nova Scotia Bay of Fundy destination include: the Municipality of Digby, Annapolis-Digby Development Association, Digby Area Tourism Association, ACOA, Department of Economic Development and the Department of Tourism. 78 7.2 Cape Chignecto Cape Chignecto, the third of Nova Scotiaʼs Fundy coastal parks, designated in 1995 and developed over the past 15 years, has become one of the best hiking trails in Eastern Canada and has won several awards, including the prestigious Gulf of Maine, and Parks Canada Sustainable Tourism Awards. This park is the largest of the three Bay of Fundy region parks, encompassing 4200 hectares (10,500 acres) and well over 25 kilometers of coastline. Cape Chignecto is a bit further off the beaten track than Five Islands Provincial Park and Blomidon Provincial Park/Cape Split. It is 70 minutes from the Trans Canada Highway and a little over 2.5 hours from the Halifax International airport. Indeed, it is closer to Moncton airport and there is value in seeing Moncton as a key point of entry for this site. Recently, Cape Chignecto completed the development of a day-use visitor area at Eatonville, to provide access to the Three Sisters rock formations. This includes a relatively large and fully equipped visitor centre, day-use trails and viewing lookouts. The Three Sisters are a striking set of rock pinnacles that stand just off shore within the inter-tidal zone. The Eatonville day-use trail also offers access via an extensive boardwalk and two viewing platforms to a very rare raised beach at Squally Point that offers a panoramic view of the Cape Chignecto coastline (crescent beaches, sea stacks, seals, etc.). Cape Chignecto offers beach access at various locations. The principle attraction of Cape Chignecto is a 50kilometer coastal hiking trail. It is a multi-day wilderness hiking experience and ranks among the best in Canada. This type of experience appeals to a smaller niche market but still has significant market appeal. In addition, day use trails and interpretation facilities at both ends of the park broaden its market appeal. 79 While Cape Chignecto has been open for slightly more than 10 years, it is probably still maturing as an attraction. This is evident in the incremental development of private sector tourism businesses attracted by the park users. For example, a privately operated kayak company started providing tours off the coast a few years ago. Tourism development creates critical mass and contributes to the appeal of the area to visitors. There is no doubt that Cape Chignectoʼs market growth would be greatly accelerated by the destination appeal created by branding these parks as Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy parks. As previously discussed, enhancements to the other parks and high profile sites or attractions described in this report, and stronger promotion of the Bay of Fundy product in Nova Scotia, will result in more exposure and appreciation for this phenomenal Fundy product. Given the access and the more specialized nature of the product, Cape Chignecto is a key component of the Bay of Fundy product, strongly representing a coastal wilderness hiking experience. It has potential to build its market to 10,000 (similar to the visitor numbers for the West Coast Trail), if it is part of a larger integrated system. 80 Fees Cape Chignecto has a user pay system in place. This includes a park entry fee of $5.00 per person and wilderness campsite fees of $23.00 per site/night. Development Development priorities for Cape Chignecto had been recognized by the Management Board at the time of this report and were in progress. The first priority is remediation of the coastal trail system itself. In 2009, a trail assessment was completed and a plan developed for upgrading the coastal trail. This was to bring the trail up to a standard whereby it would provide a high quality wilderness experience to all visitors. In addition to the upgrading of the wildernesshiking trail, the second priority is to provide shoreline access at Eatonville. As in the above case, this was being reviewed at the time of this report and programming options were being considered. Eatonville Harbour (the site of a fully functioning shipyard, lumber mill and company town), in particular, has great interpretation potential. Access to the site would provide several benefits: it would allow visitors to see and experience the former shipyard, provide access to the tidal estuary, and offer opportunities for the adventurous to get closer to the Three Sisters. Touring Network 8. Touring Network In addition to Anchor Attractions, this report has identified a network of interpretation sites and viewpoints. This section explores how a combination of tidal sites, natural and human history sites, scenic viewpoints and hiking trails can combine to create an informative self-guided touring route along Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy. The touring network consists of interpretation sites, smaller attractions and viewpoints that can be linked (with the anchor attractions) through a common wayfinding system and common standards that extend throughout the entire Bay of Fundy region. In this way, it can potentially play a similar role to the former Fundy Eco-tour by encouraging touring visitors to explore and spend time in the region. 8.1 Interpretation Sites Interpretation sites listed in this report are staffed facilities, each representing key Bay of Fundy themes and meeting common market readiness standards. They are generally operated by local or regional organizations. These sites donʼt have the level of facilities, interpretation, programming, etc. of anchors, yet they are important sites offering a particular interpretation topic or story. The use of a common identity and wayfinding program would serve to link them into an overall touring network. Travelers who visit anchor sites can explore via interpretation site. Market readiness criteria for interpretation sites are as follows: • • • • • • sites must be staffed and offer basic interpretation programming publicly accessible extended season: late May to mid-October offers essential amenities: parking, signage, and washrooms close proximity to support services (food, accommodation clusters) participant in Bay of Fundy Recommended Program It is acknowledged that, in the long-term, sites that have the ability to charge admission will be more sustainable. Most of the interpretation sites identified are completely or nearly market ready (although one site is still in the planning stages). Specific requirements to achieve market readiness are noted with each site description. Sites that cannot be fully developed as Interpretation sites, may meet the criteria to currently be considered as Viewpoints in Section 8.2 of this report. 81 Tidal Technology Sites Visitor centres that interpret the technology of tidal power have an important role in the interpretation of the tides in the Bay of Fundy. The popularity and high visitor numbers at the Annapolis Tidal Power Station show that there is significant interest among visitors. They are referred to as tidal technology sites because they have particular appeal to the “techie” in each travel party as well as the interest in green technology that exists in most people. There are two tidal technology sites identified, one developed site and one in the planning stages. 1. Annapolis Tidal Power Station This centre is North Americaʼs only tidal power generating station where the Bay of Fundy tides are harnessed. The site is home to the largest straight-flow turbine in the world. The Visitor Centre offers views of the turbulent Annapolis River above the turbine, interpretation, general visitor information, and occasional plant tours. The attraction currently receives 35,000 (est.) visitors per year making it among the top visited visitor attractions around the Bay of Fundy. It is owned by Nova Scotia Power but operated by the Annapolis Area Board of Trade. No admission is charged. Key tidal effects : tidal rips and rapids Season : staffed May to October 82 Recommendations: • enroll in the Bay of Fundy Recommended • Program • improve the scheduling, reliability, staffing and • professionalism of the interpretation program • enhance interpretation space and curb appeal • improve wayfinding and site signage 2. Tidal Power Centre at Black Rock Construction of a research/interpretation centre is currently underway at the new tidal power demonstration site near Parrsboro. At this time, the mandate, staffing and season for this centre are unknown. This particular section of the Bay of Fundy has been identified as the best site in the world for green energy. The demonstration project marks the first Canadian deployment of commercial-scale tidal turbines. The idea is to prove that tidal power can be successfully drawn from the bay. In five to ten years, it is expected that 2,000 megawatts of electricity could be drawn from the bay, enough to power all the homes and industry in Nova Scotia. With proper development of the Black Rock tidal power centre, the authors of this report believe there is a ʻgreenʼ technology product that can be very successfully positioned for a growing ecotourism market. Recommendations: • Provincial Tourism Department to work with municipal representatives and FORCE (Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy) to encourage tourism & economic benefits of the site (not just resource extraction) 83 Themed Tidal Sites High among visitor requests to Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy are accessible, interpreted tidal exploration sites. Bay of Fundy Tourism identifies three aspects of the tidal experience around the Bay: 1. Vertical effects (where the 40 - 50 foot rise is illustrated). 2. Horizontal effects (where the ocean floor is exposed for exploration for several hours during the tide cycle). 3. Tidal bores, rips and rapids (where the rapid, turbulent movement of Fundyʼs tides can be witnessed). All three tidal effects are rarely visible in a single location: itʼs not much wonder that our visitors are confused! Criteria for becoming an Interpretation Site in this network include: • demonstrates at least one of the three tidal effects (preferably 2/3) • offers scheduled, staffed interpretation of the tidal effects Due to the complexities of the Fundy tides, sites that offer staffed interpretation (as opposed to interpretation panels) are preferred. Five tidal sites are listed. 84 1. Burncoat Head Burncoat Head is a site that is currently not market-ready but has the potential to become a good tidal interpretation site under this networkʼs guidelines. Burncoat Head is a community-owned interpretation site on the south shore of the Minas Basin. It is the site where measurements of the record high tides in the Minas Basin were taken. For that reason, it has a unique role as an interpretation site. Burncoat could have particular relevance to the visitor and increase its visitor numbers substantially, by becoming a permanent tidal monitoring and research station. This would require the organization of a partnership with the tidal research staff of Department of Fisheries and Oceans, potentially co-funded through ocean research and/or environmental monitoring programs. The site is reasonably accessible with a seasonal interpretation centre and stair access to the beach. The beach consists of sandstone ledges and rock formations (flowerpots). Key tidal effects: vertical and horizontal effects Season: mid-May to mid-Oct (staffed in peak season only) Recommendations: • installation of tidal monitoring equipment throughout the summer season and continuous monitoring • development of an improved interpretation facility with focus on tidal measurement, the purpose of ongoing tidal monitoring vis-a- vis sea level rise, storm surge impacts etc. • improve exterior site signage for park orientation • better trail markers & add to existing trails to encourage visitors to stay longer • interpretation panels outdoors to add to off-season experience • interpretation tours offered in the summer • washroom & other facility upgrades • add food services on site • extend length of staffed season Requirements to become market-ready: • • • • stable funds for operations capital funds to implement existing strategic plan manager (at least seasonal) to coordinate site operation additional staff to offer interpretation 85 2. Cape dʼOr Lighthouse Cape dʼOr is a working lighthouse on a basalt cliff jutting out into the upper Bay of Fundy, dividing Chignecto Bay from the Minas Basin. The regional economic development association manages the site, leasing it for the operation of a cafe and guesthouse, which makes it Nova Scotiaʼs only lighthouse location that visitors can stay in. At clifftop, the site includes two trails and a sometimesstaffed VIC. No admission is charged to the site at this time. There are interpretation panels about the tidal rip in the parking lot. Key tidal effects: Rip tide (visible at specific times) Season: end-May to mid-October Local context: Other accommodations and food services offered in nearby Advocate Harbour, 15 minutes away. Also in close proximity to Cape Chignecto Provincial Park, Advocateʼs tidal harbour and Nova Scotiaʼs only Fundy coast sea kayaking company. In same region as Fundy Geological Museum & Joggins UNESCO World Heritage Site (1 hr). Recommendations: • • • • • 86 refresh outdoor interpretation panels, perhaps add more panels on general tidal effects to info kiosk add chart for times during the tide cycle when best riptide occurs (add seasonal tide cycle) regularly staff and train visitor information kiosk about all three tidal effects charge admission to the site for long-term sustainability consider developing or more strongly promoting the Sinclair Trail to Advocate Harbour for 4-wheeling & day hiking 3. South Maitland Tidal Interpretation Park The South Maitland Tidal Interpretation Park is the most market-ready and best-interpreted site around the whole Bay of Fundy for experiencing a tidal bore. The site consists of an interpretation centre (which tells the full story ʻwhyʼ and ʻhowʼ story of the Fundy tides), a wheelchair accessible walking trail, visitor information, gift shop, interpretation programs and a viewing deck. The attraction is a current Bay of Fundy Recommended Experience program participant. The site currently charges a small admission fee. Key tidal effects: Tidal bore & vertical tidal effects Season: (staffed) mid-May to mid-October Local context: minutes from popular tidal bore rafting sites, minutes from Burncoat Head (site of official recorded tides), near local accommodations and restaurants, 20 min from provincial highway . Recommendations: • improve wayfinding & site signage • ensure funding available to deliver reliable, daily interpretation at viewing deck as well as in centre for the full season • add exterior tide FAQ interpretation panels on viewing deck • improve curb appeal (replace chain link fence) 87 4. Halls Harbour Wolfville, 30 minutes from other major natural attractions: Cape Split, Cape Blomidon, Lookoff. While there are many tidal harbours around the bay in both provinces, Halls Harbour is the best serviced, the best known, and the most marketready for the following reasons: 1. Only tidal harbour offering panel interpretation of the tides. 2. Working tidal harbour with a cobble beach for low tide walking. 3. Public eating areas (outdoor picnic tables & restaurant). 4. Lobster pound with tours and takeout. 5. Accommodations and artisansʼ studios/galleries in the village. 6. Public washrooms. 7. Experienced host to motor coach tour hosting site (spring through fall). There are no guided tide tours, but there is a webcam on the harbour and a seasonal Fish House Museum. Key tidal effects: vertical tidal effect, some horizontal beach Recommendations: • • • add tidal interpretation tours try to lure sea-kayaking company encourage private sector operator to set up boat tours to Cape Split Season: mid-May to mid-October Local context: within 30 to 45 minutes of additional accommodations and services in Kentville and 88 Note that other tidal harbours around Bay of Fundy (not as well serviced as Halls Harbour) are included in the Section 8.2 - Viewpoints. 5. Bear River Tidal Estuary Although Bear River is not the only tidal river on Bay of Fundy, it is the one of the most accessible, intriguing and well rounded. Low-tide views of Bear Riverʼs tidal harbour reveal a quaint village on stilts. The village has become a beacon for artisan studios and related attractions (wineries, cafes, and shops). Accommodations are available in the village and nearby Digby. There is a visitor information centre with public washrooms on the riverfront, as well as a small park. Key tidal effects: vertical & horizontal Season: river is visible year-round, interpretation could be seasonal or year-round Recommendations: • create interpreted walking trail/ lookoffs and tours of riverfront • add sense of arrival for tidal viewing access • add wayfinding signage to parking area beside visitor centre (trail start) • add publicly viewable tide chart indicating times for dry vs. full harbour during the tide cycle • enhance downtown parking area • attract adventure tourism operator (kayaks?) to set up business at the waterfront Requirements to become market-ready: • • • identify local group to take on project development extended research on tidal estuary needed traffic & safety challenges (perhaps private property issues) if roadside lookoffs are created (although it is clear from tire marks that people are pulling off to look at the view) If Bear River had the ability to offer staffed tours from the waterfront location, it could become an Interpretation Site for this network, otherwise, it currently qualifies as a viewpoint (see section 8.2) 89 Heritage – Culture & Marine There are several sites pertaining to the natural and human history of the region that should be considered for inclusion in this Bay of Fundy themed network. They, too, have to meet qualifying criteria to ensure that they ʻadd toʼ the visitorsʼ experience and appreciation of the Bay of Fundy. Criteria for Natural & Human History sites includes: • • • • • • thematic connection to Bay of Fundyʼs natural history or human adaptation offers staffed tours and interpretation display areas season: late May to mid-October offers essential amenities: parking, signage, and washrooms close proximity to support services (food, accommodation clusters) website Sites that do not meet the Interpretation Site criteria should be evaluated for their suitability as unstaffed trails or lookoffs (see sections 8.2. or 8.3). 90 1. Age of Sail The Age of Sail Heritage Centre overlooking the tidal Greville River pays tribute to the shipbuilding and seafaring heritage of the communities along the Minas Channel. Through interpretation panels, tours, videos, models, artifacts and hands on exhibits, the museum brings to life the history of shipbuilding, lumbering and community. Key Fundy experience: • museum in an 1854 church • local blacksmith shop • 1908 lighthouse • boat house • tea room Season: end- May to mid-October Recommendations to become market-ready: Age of Sail Centre is market-ready. 2. Cobequid Interpretation Centre This interpretation centre incorporates a World War II watchtower, which was moved from the shoreline when erosion threatened to drop it into the Bay. The interpretation centre has displays about the areaʼs natural and cultural history. Key Fundy experience: • • panoramic views of wide inter-tidal zone interpretation of tides and other natural features of the region Season: June to October Recommendations to become market-ready: • guided tours to Thomas Cove • longer season • better interpretation of inter-tidal zone, • clamming industry • needs own website • Bay of Fundy Recommended Experience • Program 91 3. Glooscap Heritage Centre 4. Lawrence House Museum This centre interprets Miʼkmaq history and culture through displays, programs, demonstrations and multi-media. Site hosts special events, group tours and schools for educational activities. The W.D. Lawrence, the largest full-rigged sailing ship ever built in Canada, was launched in this village in 1874. It was named for its builder and owner, William D. Lawrence. The Museum, a National Historic Site, was Lawrenceʼs home, built in 1870, and it is dedicated to his memory and to that of the great ship. The museum is located in Maitland, the provinceʼs first Heritage Conservation District. It is part of the Nova Scotia Museum family of museums. Season: year round Key Fundy experience: • • • history of First Nations Miʼkmaq legends of land use, tides and coastal formations Key Fundy experience: • • • guided house and history tours outdoor interpretation platform panoramic view of Maitland inter-tidal zone Season: June 1 to October 15 Recommendations: currently market-ready 92 Recommendations: currently market-ready 5. Avon River Heritage Museum & Avon Spirit Shipyard Avon River Heritage Museum and Avon Spirit Shipyard strive to recapture the art of shipbuilding, which so dominated our coastal region. While the museum specializes in the history of the Planters, early settlers from New England, the shipyard is involved in re-creating vessels from a variety of eras. Most recently, an Acadian schooner is the focus of construction. Recommendations to become market-ready: • • offer scheduled tours of the boathouse extend the season Key Fundy experience: • • • • • • shipbuilding history through panels and staff ship reconstruction viewing Avon River ecology interpretation tea room tidal harbour & waterfront park bird watching Season: mid-June to early October 93 6. Blue Beach Fossil Museum Blue Beach Fossil Museum is a private museum and public beach area near Hantsport. The area is now recognized internationally as the earliest known example of a terrestrial vertebrate community. In November 2009, a proposal was made for the development of a new Blue Beach Fossil Museum. Currently, the museum is housed on private property in a Quonset hut with funding from visitor donations. This new development proposes a research centre, tide viewing deck, and interpretation museum to house and display 10 s of thousands of fossils in the collection. Recommendations to become market-ready: Season: Mid-May to end October • Key Fundy experience: • • • • • • • • 94 wheelchair accessible tidal beach fossils older than Joggins complement the existing fossil record of Fundy great opportunity to bring the geology story of Fundy over to the valley side funding to transform the site into the proposed attraction and research centre improved facilities, signage, branding and amenities that would come with this transformation 7. Prescott House Museum 8. Historic Gardens (salt marsh) This museum is a historic early 1800s home of Charles Prescott, the originator of the apple industry in Nova Scotia. Located at Starrs Point, on the tidal Cornwallis River. The Historic Gardens is a 17 acre horticultural paradise located on a tidal river in historic Annapolis Royal. Historically, themed areas of the Gardens tell the story of a Nova Scotian settlement from an agricultural and horticultural perspective. This site includes a walking trail to town along the riverʼs salt marsh. There is some interpretation (text only) of the marsh and dykelands. Season: June 1 to October 15 Key Fundy experience: • horticultural and agricultural history of the • reclaimed (dyked) Bay of Fundy salt marshes Season: May to October (year round for walking) Key Fundy experience: • indigenous plants • salt marsh and dyking of coast Recommendations to become market-ready: • interpretation of dyked, reclaimed farm land Recommendations to become market-ready: • add pictorial interpretation panels to salt marsh • board walk (currently text only) • promote the salt marsh habitat more as part of the garden experience for visitors 95 96 8.2 Viewpoints Viewpoints serve to create linkages and unify the Bay of Fundy region (in Nova Scotia), especially for touring visitors. Their role goes beyond that of a rest stop. They reinforce the identity of the travel region, through a graphic program; provide basic amenities between larger attractions and communities and focus on site-specific themes, creating an interpretation framework for the area as a whole. In this respect (together with Interpretation sites) they play a similar role to the Fundy Shore Ecotour. 96 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Standards All viewpoints will be required to meet the following standards: • • • • • • • • • • • Dept of transportation approved entrance Class 1 gravel or paved parking (Suitable for motor-coach, travel trailer and/or minimum 8 cars) Perimeter barrier Appropriate landscaping to ensure view-planes are open and site is appropriately defined Site has a clearly defined theme Interpretation Kiosk or professionally designed outdoor interpretation panels Safety fence or barrier as per standards (chain-link fence is not acceptable) Designated organization or agency for maintenance Recycling and garbage container(s) Frequent, scheduled garbage removal Annual painting and grading etc. Where possible, although not a mandatory criteria, washroom facilities should be included within the development plan for viewpoints. These standards will be required in order to be included in Bay of Fundy themed wayfinding, orientation, touring programs and literature. Viewpoint Development Framework The following framework begins at the Nova Scotia border and follows the coast of the Bay of Fundy to Cape St. Marys. It includes existing and undeveloped sites. By in large, most of the existing sites (many are provincial day parks) will need work done to bring them to a consistent and appropriate standard. Parks are highlighted in blue. Note: Locations of “Anchor attractions” and Bay of Fundy interpretation sites are indicated for reference in the right hand column of each table. However, to avoid confusion only viewpoint locations are shown on the attached maps. Amherst to Parrsboro (via Joggins and Advocate) Distance Amherst – Parrsboro 135.6 km (via Joggins and Advocate) Driving Time 3:23 97 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited 98 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Distance (km from Amherst) 15.3 Existing market-ready Existing needs work Undeveloped Key Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Maccan - Tidal Bore 32.7 50.5 65.6 86.0 Joggins Shulie Sand River Cape Chignecto (West Advocate) 86.0 Advocate Driftwood beach 96.0 96.3 109.8 113.4 Cape dʼOr Spencers Island Age of Sail Centre Port Greville – Shipyard look-off Fox Point 119.2 Priorities: • • • Address infrastructure gap between Joggins and Advocate by developing a new viewpoint at Shulie or Sand River. Land ownership and coastal access will determine the best site. Advocate Beach requires improvements and adequate access must be provided to the beach after new breakwater construction. Upgrade sites at Nappan, Spencers Island, Port Greville and Fox Point. 99 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Parrsboro - Truro Parrsboro - Truro Distance 91.9 Viewpoint locations Distance (km Existing-marketfrom ready Parrsboro) 0 3.0 6.0 24.8 41.0 75.0 Driving Time 1:26 Existing – needs work Proposed Key Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Fundy Geological Museum First Beach Partridge Island Five Islands Thomas Cove MacElmonʼs Pond 100 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Distance (km from Parrsboro) 89.0 Existing-marketready Existing – needs work Proposed Key Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Tidal Bore Viewing Site (Truro) Priorities: • • • • Site options for Partridge Island be reassessed with possible relocation to the outer bar (adjacent to the Island) considered. There is a gap between Thomas Cove and Truro. The Provincial day use park at MacElmons Pond could fill this gap but has no coastal orientation. The regional partners should review this. Upgrade Thomas Cove and Tidal Bore site. 101 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Truro – Windsor (via Maitland and Walton) Truro – Windsor via Maitland, Burncoat Head, Walton Distance 144 km Driving Time 2:57 102 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Viewpoint Locations Distance (km Existing-marketfrom Truro) ready 33.0 Existing – needs work Caddel Rapids Proposed 26.5 Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites S Maitland Maitland 43.5 Anthony Park 64.8 82.6 Walton Burncoat Head Cheverie 124 144 Avondale St Croix River Tidal Bore Priorities • • • This region has two small but important tidal interpretation sites at South Maitland and Burncoat as well as an interesting heritage site at Avondale. Viewpoints at Maitland, Anthony Park and Walton fill gaps between these sites. All require some upgrading and/or additional elements. Caddel Rapids has significant potential although it is off the coastal route and requires improvements. It is best seen as an off-site viewing area vis a vis South Maitland Tidal Bore Interpretation (same is true of Tidal Bore Park). 103 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Windsor – Scots Bay (via Wolfville) Windsor- Scots Bay via Maitland, Burncoat Head, Walton Distance 62.1 km Driving Time 1:13 104 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Viewpoint Locations Distance Existing-market(km from ready Windsor) Existing – needs work Proposed Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Ft Edward, Windsor 20.0 Avonport 23.5 Grand Pre National Historic Site 25.0 Evangeline Beach 28.5 Wolfville waterfront 48.2 Kingsport 53.0 Look-off 56.2 62.1 Cape Blomidon Cape Split Priorities • • • • • Upgrade sites at Windsor, Evangeline Beach and Kingsport. Wolfville Waterfront is well developed and is an excellent location. Some additional interpretation of salt marsh to dike-land would be added-value. It could be upgraded to an interpretation site in the future. Kingsport not only has potential to interpret history of ferry service but also tidal flats and shorebird migration (Starrs Point) Look-off is fully developed but needs interpretation. There is potential for an excellent interpretation content illustrating the historic change of tidal areas to dyked farmland. At Blomidon, the waterfront day-use area is largely developed but interpretation is needed. 105 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Wolfville – Annapolis (via Halls Harbour, Morden, Margaretsville) Wolfville – Halls Harbour Wolfville - Annapolis (Direct) Wolfville–Annapolis Via Morden, Margaretsville, Port George Distance 31.1 km Driving Time 42 116 km 1:19 162 km 3:39 106 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Viewpoint Locations Distance (km Existing-marketfrom ready Wolfville) 31.1 Halls Harbour Existing – needs work 74.3 Proposed Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Morden/ French Cross 100.2 Cottage Cove 139 Valleyview 162 162 169 Historic Gardens Fort Anne Melanson Settlement (Nat Hist Site) 173.9 187.8 Port Royal Victoria Beach Priorities • • • • • While there is not a continuous drive along the Fundy Shore between Scots Bay and Port George (parallel to the Annapolis Valley), a good option is shown in this report. Development of the Morden site should interpret the story of Acadian refugees. Cottage Cove and Valleyview are both provincial parks and have good facilities. Victoria Beach has an interesting interpretation story of the Pony Express, is a pleasant day trip from Annapolis and can be combined with a visit to Annapolis Royal. There are several additional harbour communities in this region that were not listed as viewpoints but are good stopping points. They include Baxters Harbour, Margaretsville and Parkers Cove. These may be added to this framework at a later stage if there is sufficient local interest and they meet all the marketing readiness criteria including the development of a unique and relevant interpretation theme. 107 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Annapolis - Digby Annapolis - Digby Distance 37.2 km Driving Time 32 108 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Viewpoint Locations Distance (km from Annapolis) 8.5 28.5 26.5 Existing-marketready Existing – needs work Proposed Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Upper Clements Wildlife Park Bear River – Waterfront Park Smiths Cove Look-off 37.2 Digby Waterfront Priorities • • Upper Clements Wildlife Park is being redeveloped and the new plan was not available. If the park is opened as a recreational property it has potential for development of a picnic area and/or trail system. Bear River has excellent potential for interpretation, is a good side trip from Digby. Enhancements needed for both Bear River and Smiths Cove. 109 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Digby- Brier Island/Cape St. Marys Digby –Brier Island Digby – Cape St. Marys Distance 69.4 74.5 Driving Time 2:11 1:04 110 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Proposed Viewpoint Locations Distance (km from Digby) 5 km Existing-market-ready Existing – needs work Proposed Annapolis Basin Look-off 49.5 58.2 East Ferry Central Grove Provincial Park 69.4 70.5 Freeport Ferry North Head Lighthouse 25.0 Savary Provincial Park 37.9 Joseph et Marie Dugas Park Smugglers Cove 67.9 Priorities • • • • • • Digby to Brier Island is a 2-hour drive. Several provincial day-use parks are useful as rest stops and require only minor enhancements. The two ferries are both points of interest and viewpoints as both locations are recommended. Boreʼs Head Lighthouse on Long Island is probably the regionʼs most photographed lighthouse. At Brier Island, the North Head Lighthouse is a popular viewpoint but requires upgrading. If the Nature Conservancy trail system is developed as a key attraction (as mentioned), then it is possible that several other scenic spots could be enhanced such as Western Light, Southern Point/Big Cove and Pond Cove. On the Acadian shore toward Cape St. Marys there are also two provincial day-use parks. In addition, there is an excellent municipal interpretation park at Belliveau Cove. Specific recommendations for each of the viewpoint sites are included in Appendix 2. 111 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited 8.3 Hiking Trails The final component is a system of hiking trails to complement the touring network of attractions and viewpoints. They are self-guided and offer a nature-based experience of the Bay of Fundy. The trail network proposed includes excellent coastal trails within the provincial Coastal Parks. Cape Chignecto offers the most extensive trail network and should be highlighted in promotions. Cape Split and Blomidon also have good coastal trails, while at Five Islands the coastal trails are closed pending reconstruction. In addition, the trails network proposed extends outside the provincial parks throughout the region and includes trails developed by other groups that meet minimum standards and market readiness criteria. The focus in this section is on coastal trails and other good quality hiking trails where visitors can learn about the terrestrial landscape and ecology of the Bay of Fundy region. Hiking trails are generally considered to be trails that have a minimum distance of 3 km. Longer trails, including multi-day hikes, are included in the network. The following are criteria for inclusion in the network: Parking and trailhead standards • Department of Transportationapproved entrance • class 1 gravel or paved trailhead, parking (suitable for motor-coach, travel trailer and/or minimum 8 cars) • perimeter barrier • interpretive sign or kiosk • toilet (pit or full washroom) Trail design and construction standards • includes features (waterfalls, lookouts, landforms etc) • proper alignment on slopes • includes designated viewpoints • surfaced trail (inadequate drainage is not acceptable) _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited 112 Management and maintenance • organization or agency responsible for maintenance • contingency plan or partnership with local search and rescue • daily garbage removal • annual painting, grading. etc. • annual trail sweep Nearly all the trails idenfied as best trails around the Bay of Fundy need upgrading to meet the above standards. Key recommendations are noted in the chart. As sites are enhanced and upgraded, details pertaining to maintenance and management of the sites will need to be determined between local groups, municipalities, and possibly land owners. 113 Coastal & Wilderness Hiking Trails location Amherst Point Bird Sanctuary pk entra interp toilet landscape beach trail nce needed access dist 30 y y n n n 5 km Cape Chignecto 100 y y y n y Cape dʼOr 30 y y y n y Wards Falls 20 y n n n n highlights recommendations 433 ha wildlife area, add toilet facilities trails, bird watching, improve affiliated with John wayfinding Lusby Marsh as part of Chignecto National Wildlife Area 45 km 4200-ha coastal park, add beach access 600 ft cliffs, 29 km to Eatonville tidal coast, old growth estuary forest, coves, ravines, wilderness camping, geology, rock formations 3 km two short trails along create website or top of sea cliffs, good add trail info to views website, link to Sinclair Trail in Advocate Harbour 8 km wilderness trail along upgrade flat valley floor. good interpretive for hiking and cycling signage on this large waterfall, 10 foot site, add toilets bridges, caves 114 location Partridge Island pk entra interp toilet landscape beach trail nce needed access dist 60+ y y seas onal n Two Islands 4 y y n n Five Island Provincial Park 50+ y n y y Thomas Cove 12 y y n n Kenomee Trails 30 y y y n highlights recommendations drive on 5 km walkout tidal beaches, working improve fish weir, hike atop wayfinding island, salt marsh signage, add weir hiking, community interp, add toilets museum, interp panels long 5 km geological discovery redo panel, add path site, wide low tide tidal info, add intertidal zone to toilets, tide explore, guided hikes schedule with Fundy Geo Museum y 14 km 637-ha, 300 ft cliffs, reconstruct woodland trails damaged coastal (coastal trail closed), trail, improve good low tide walking, interp and 90 campsites, rock wayfinding formations, tidal signage islands, bird watching y 8 km two trails (4 km each) add tide info, add total broad intertidal zone, tide warnings, tide sandstone ledges, times, geology cliffside hiking interpretation n 28 km hilltop lookout to maintain road intertidal zone near access entrance, 3 wilderness trails, ravine hiking, waterfall, interesting geo features 115 location Cobequid Trail pk entra interp toilet landscape beach nce needed access 30 y n n n n Miʼkmawey 20 Debert Trail y y n n n Wolfville dykelands 20 y y n n y Blomidon 100 y y y n y trail dist highlights recommendations 14 km Walking & cycling better trailhead multi-use trail along signage, more Salmon River, features prominence in Acadian dykes, forest, provincial tourism river ecology, 6 advertising, more sections of trail in interpretation Truro and along river with various entrances 4.4 km interpretive trail add toilet, illustrating significance improve of site to Miʼkmaq, wayfinding national historic site designation (not serviced) 12 km excellent walking on mark trail and add dykes along tidal river, trail orientation access points from map, work out Port Williams & private property Wolfville waterfront issues 14 km 750-ha park, 600 ft more high cliffs, tidal beach, interpretation of rock hunting, 70 tidal effects and campsites, several geology coastal and woodland hiking trails 116 location Cape Split pk entra interp toilet landscape beach nce needed access 20 n n n n y Delaps Cove 15 y y y n n French Basin 12 Trail y y n n n Central Grove Trail 10 y n y n trail dist highlights recommendations 16 km woodland and coastal linear hiking, quite rough in spots, views of tidal rips and rock formations at end, beach access needs improving 7 km two coastal/woodland trails, 1 access road connecting, beachside waterfall y build tread, add interpretation centre, parking, toilets, safe viewing decks, beach access, other amenities improve access road quality, add wayfinding signage to site from Parkers Cove, add more trail signage 1.5 km Ducks Unlimited short this section loop trail attached to market-ready longer rail corridor that except for toilets, runs up entire valley fr rail corridor Annapolis Royal largely unsigned 3.2 km shore from provincial trail needs to be park picnic site to reviewed and shoreline. stepping-stones Provides needed added where it is coastal access. prone to flooding. 117 location pk entra interp toilet landscape beach nce needed access Northeast Cove 12 y y n y y Balancing Rock 15 y y y y n Fundy Trail to Beautiful Cove 10 y y seas onal n y trail dist highlights unknow series of interpretive n panels all around the cove, good low tide beach, not set up for walking trail, small parking lots for each sign 4.8 km trail leads to the Balancing rock basalt formation. There is an excellent coastal viewing, stairway and platform. 3 km recommendations develop or encourage walking from panel to panel trail needs to be reviewed and stepping-stones added where it is prone to flooding. Some landscaping needed at the trailhead. interpreted trail with needs trail panels and lookoffs, upgrades in some leads to Bay of Fundy sections, not well side advertised (no website presence) 118 Location pk entra interp toilet landscape beach nce needed access Brier Island, Northwest Head/Seal Cove 30 n n n y n Brier Island circumnavigation trail 40 n n n n n trail dist highlights recommendations unknow shoreline trail from n Northwest Head lighthouse along shore to Seal cove. Bird and marine mammal observation trail-tread needs to be constructed and trail markers set out. Orientation panel needed Toilets 15- 20 opportunity to link up trail-tread needs km various trails and to be constructed (est) Nature Conservancy and trail markers trails to circumnavigate set out. the island. Orientation panel needed Map of trails Toilets * note: there are many shorter trails and potential trails on Digby Neck, Long and Brier Islands, such as: Boars Head Light, French Beach Point, Red Head, Gullivers Cove, Sandy Cove. Many of these trails are currently ʻknown to localsʼ and are unsigned and undeveloped. Some cross private property. * other Brier Island trails owned by Nature Conservancy covered other sections of this report. 119 Identity Program 9. Identity Program 9.1 Wayfinding and Identity 9.2 Entry Concept The wayfinding and identity program has an extremely important role in defining the Bay of Fundy region, helping to create the allure and sense of place that will develop a long-term and sustainable growth in visitation. The purpose of a wayfinding and identity program can be stated as follows: • provide directions • reinforce the identity of the region • unify and link the region Gateway Entry The report provides an option for a main entry point at Joggins. During stakeholder input sessions there was some uncertainty about the value of this component. The report suggests that, due to the recent development of a UNESCO site at Joggins, there is value to a significant entry project. Therefore, an option for the Joggins entry should be considered. An increasing number of visitors enter at this location and the arrival at the community would benefit from visual enhancement. The entry point would influence awareness and may act as an intercept for visitors who make day trips to Joggins from other parts of Atlantic Canada (in particular, from Moncton). Wayfinding Definition Signs, maps, and other graphic or audible methods used to convey location and directions to travelers; also written as wayfinding. Etymology: coined in 1960 by urban planner/architect Kevin Lynch. Wayfinding signage should “lead” visitors to the various destination points and identify those points when they are there. A common theme or identifying image should be selected and used throughout, varying only the size/type of sign being used. 120 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited • • • • • • • • • Route 236 at South Maitland (westbound) Route 215 at Tidal Bore park (northbound) Route 215 at Newport Landing (eastbound) Route 14 at Windsor (northbound) Route 1 at Wolfville (westbound) Route 358 at Canning (northbound) Route 12 at Kentville (northbound) Route 8 at Annapolis (northbound) Route 1 at Digby (eastbound) The above entry concept is for illustration purposes only. Other entry points will have entry signs as shown. These should be positioned at key entry points including the following: • • Route 2: 10 km north of Parrsboro (southbound) Route 2 at Glenholme (westbound) sample sign concept 121 The current signs on 100 series highways should be reviewed and the Bay of Fundy concept consistently applied at all major entry points on the 100 series highway including Amherst, Masstown, Truro and Windsor. Route Markers Route markers should be positioned to establish and reinforce a sense of place throughout the Bay of Fundy region as defined in Section 1 of this report. The purpose of route markers is to provide recognition that the visitor is on a designated route and to indicate direction of specific sites and attractions. The proposed concept(s) for the route marker/sign is shown in the following illustration. Route markers should identify the following: • anchor attractions • interpretive sites • viewpoints • hiking trails • activity areas (rafting, whale watching) Route (or directional) markers should be located at all intersections as well as at reentry point for each anchor attraction (where entry or access roads rejoin principle routes). Markers located at intersections will indicate anchor attractions within 50 km, interpretive sites within 20 km and viewpoints within 10 km. In addition site locator markers will be located. • 5 km (prior to each site) • 0.5 km (prior to each site) sample sign concept 122 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Route markers are modularized to allow directional information to be added. Technical specifications are as follows: • • • sign panel and landscape features including boulders and planting. suggested dimensions of main sign: 24" square other components based on a derivative of that...e.g. 24" wide by 16" and 8" in height. standards must be worked out at a final phase to ensure consistency with DOT provincial tourism standards. Site Specific Entry Signs Site-specific entry signs have been developed as a hierarchy of sizes to identify sites and site features ranging from a gateway entry, interpretive site entry and viewpoint locations. Materials would be manufactured panels suitable for a text message and in some applications applied with a landscaped feature including boulders and/or plants. Anchor Site Signs: are designed for large interpretive facilities that provide a range of interpretation and programming. Identifying them, as “anchor” sites will allow development to continue in a logical and predictable manner. Signage would be a mix of constructed “iconic” The entry sign concept shown here is for illustrative purposes only. 123 Interpretation Site Signs are lower in the hierarchy than Anchor Site signage. They are identified by the “iconographic” marker shape with an additional panel listing site name. Could be simply landscaped depending upon the actual location. Viewpoints: Signage-identifying viewpoints would be located at entry roads to viewpoints. The simplest “icon” form would be used for secondary interpretation sites described in 8.1 that meet specified market readiness criteria. 124 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Cost factors: • • • The estimated cost of the "gateway" concept would be in the range of $10-15,000 to design and build plus landscaping costs. For reference, a regular sized billboard would cost approx $25,000 to $30,000 and solar light can add approx $7,000 An entry sign for an anchor attraction sign would be in the range of $7,000. Estimated costs for route markers are approximately $500 ea. Installed. 125 9.3 Orientation An orientation component is proposed to highlight and explain the tidal message and to cross-promote and link the various interpretive sites throughout the region. This will be specific to individual anchor sites, particularly those with a coastal or tidal orientation. This report recommends that this be applied to the three tidal and marine sites as well as the two geological sites. If deemed appropriate they could be used at the National Historic Sites as well. Arriving at the parking lot, trailhead, or foyer/lobby of the site, the visitor would encounter a welcome/orientation panel. The overriding message (consistent at all sites) is: Welcome to the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone – the Lowest Tides in the World. There are three main elements to the orientation panel: a) Tide Time: (What Tide is it Now?) A digital tide clock shows the time to low and high tides at this site. e.g. 1h 20 min 15 seconds to Low Tide 7h 50 min 15 sec to High Tide The tide time display could also include a more ʻtypicalʼ round clock-face tide clock (of the type likely to be encountered in local restaurants and accommodations), or an image of the same, however the digital display would be essential for the ʻquick and dirtyʼ visitor. A tidal variation ʻclockʼ could also be included here; it would give a graphical representation of where the tide is now, in terms of approximate number of feet/metres above and below mid-tide. A graphic of ʻstick figureʼ people standing on each otherʼs shoulders would be used along one side to convey the extreme tidal variation in terms of ʻpeople-heightsʼ (where a childʼs height is simply half that of an adults). A tide-timed ʻliquidʼ (e.g. antifreeze, or a simple sheet of blue acetate) would rise and fall with the actual time of the tide. Accompanying interpretive information (to the extent it is required) would explain generally the following key messages: • what a tide is • magnitude • why ours is the biggest in the world • how to calculate where you are in the tide cycle 126 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited b) Site specific: e.g. How Low Can You Go? (Five Islands) Tidal experience-related content that is specific to the host site would be included in this portion of the orientation kiosk. For example: Here at Five Islands Provincial Park, you can walk on the bottom of the sea at low tide. Some people even jog around the island. Explore. But keep an eye on the tide time. Itʼs not a tsunami, or even a big wave, but X feet (Y metres) of water will rise quickly… Make sure you visit the XYZ (and if you do, get your [travel program] stamped back at the gate) [or similar]. Text such as this would be accompanied by site-specific images (e.g. from the Not Since Moses Run) that relate to the tidal aspect of the site. Even where the primary story of the attraction/site is non-tidal (e.g. fossils/geology/history), the orientation kiosk would make the link back to tide – by telling how something was discovered at low tide; explaining how huge tidal variation contributes to shoreline erosion/fossil discovery; showing how people in history dealt with or took advantage of the tide in this area; etc. This part of the kiosk/panel could also include a tip to visit the same place or viewpoint twice, once at high tide, once at low (e.g. walk out on the mudflat at low tide, go eat a lobster dinner, come back a few hours later and see how far the water has come). c) Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone: Going Tidal At indoor locations, the wall of the kiosk/portion of the panel would include an interactive touch screen based on a map of the region. Information on specific operators, amenities, activities, and so on, would be included here and would be continually updated. This would be the same content as on the website. At outdoor locations, the display would consist of a map of the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone, including an inset blow up of this immediate area. Activity hubs would be shaded in different colours (fading out, no edges) for e.g.: rafting, history, geology, whales, and agritourism. An accompanying tourism guide could be picked up here or at related indoor sites. The key message here is ʻwhat to doʼ and ʻwhere to do it,ʼ (e.g. for whales, go to Digby; for rafting, go to S. Maitland, 127 for geology, go to Joggins/Parrsboro, etc.). It should also be clear from this map where you are relative to the other activities in the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone. Online (website/downloads) • Website (ʻlureʼ; with introductory info, basic facts, gorgeous pictures), clearinghouse for activity/accommodation/meals/services, info and links. • Downloadable (and fun) GPS-based mobile app that works out tide times, locations, ʻthings to do,ʼ and ʻfun(dy) factsʼ (kid-friendly). • Downloadable podcasts for each hub area within the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone with information, history and stories of the place. These should be local voices, inviting the visitor into their region, giving hot tips on ʻfavoriteʼ places, and a personal ʻfeelingʼ about how the tide affects their life (living life on ʻtide timeʼ). This fits with the overall ʻvibeʼ of the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone (people are local, friendly, welcoming; there are lots of things to do) In the community Orientation toolkits would be distributed to all tourism-related businesses within the ʻtidal zoneʼ (so that they are like a ʻliving orientation kioskʼ). This is to foster buy-in to the idea that there is a Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone, so that this message is consistently marketed by local businesses. The toolkits would include: the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone map (with coloured theme areas) – this could even be a mounted panel for them to display; information on the key highlights and visitor sites/attractions; a tide clock for the business to display prominently; the travel program. 128 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited 9.4 Bay of Fundy– Travel Program Concept Tide and Seek would be a tide-themed Bay of Fundy scavenger hunt. It can be downloaded from the Bay of Fundy Tidal Zone website; or picked up at one of the tidal zone attractions, the visitor information centres, or at the tidal zone businesses. More interactive than a travel passport, and less technology-dependent than a geocaching program, Tide and Seek could coax visitors to explore the tidal zone region, while at the same time connecting them always to the central theme: tide. The program would have two goals: • • encourage visitors to travel engage in tidal experiences immerse and educate the visitor in the tidal cycle, the time and frequency of the tide. Seeking tidal experiences The ʻitemsʼ to be collected on this scavenger hunt are experiences, for example: • • • • • • witness each of the tidal bores accumulate 50 meters of low tide (walk out at low tide in designated locations) listen to the voice of the moon find the place with the highest recorded tides in the world hike to Cape Split solve the mystery of the disappearing tide These ʻitemsʼ could be as simple or complex as desired, ideally with a mixture of easy and hard. When the ʻhunterʼ has completed a task, they get their booklet stamped at the relevant tidal zone attraction or amenity. In some cases, the activity can be ʻself-stampingʼ (e.g. Burncoat Head), where the stamp is attached to an interpretive panel or lookoff sign. The ʻstampsʼ can be custom-made punch-outs, stickers, or self-inking rubber stamps that are somehow thematically connected to the attraction/activity to be achieved. The scavenger hunt could be marketed as a ʻchallengeʼ with three classes of winners: • a hard-to-achieve ʻfirstʼ (gets all the stamps) that can win, for example, a collectible Fundy Tidal Zone t-shirt that is beautifully designed and funky. 129 This would not be available for purchase, and would serve as marketing for the area and for the challenge. Alternative types of prizes could be a tide clock, or Fundy water bottle, etc. • an easier-to-attain ʻsecondʼ (for e.g. gets 15 out of 20 activity stamps) with a lesser prize • a relatively easy ʻthirdʼ Everyone who participates could be entered in a draw (for e.g. for a return trip to the area), which would create motivation (and build a customer database). Where appropriate, some activities on the scavenger hunt list could be ʻsponsoredʼ with sponsoring attractions contributing to a fund for prizes. This is particularly relevant where the ʻto doʼ is some kind of tidal activity that requires an operator (e.g. ʻride the tideʼ), and the travel program is effectively providing them with advertising. The tide cycle component would involve simple tidecalculator. The passport would include a sliding scale that would determine the phase in the tide cycle. Users would set the time and date to calculate the height of the tide. 130 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited 10. Conclusion 10.1 Conclusions and Implementation Guidelines The recommendations of this report are designed to increase tourism in the Bay of Fundy region by accomplishing a number of objectives: 1. Enhance or create awareness of Nova Scotiaʼs Bay of Fundy within the broad tourism market place. 2. Attract visitors to the region. (the lure) 3. Keep visitors in the region. 4. Encourage visitors to explore and promote touring. The Bay of Fundy (The Attraction) A strong and well-defined identity will enhance or create awareness of the region as a tourism destination. The attraction is the Bay of Fundy as an overall phenomena and nature tourism experience. The Bay of Fundy identity would be the “destination” that visitors recognize in the tourism promotions. Anchors Anchors are the lure. They are attractions that have significant potential to bring new visitors to Nova Scotia. Anchors should be sites that can offer significant and extraordinary experiences and have potential to draw 50,000 visitors annually. These attractions should be of a caliber to be seen as unique, “must see” sites by prospective visitors both from within Canada and internationally. Experiential Tidal Anchor Attractions Tidal anchor sites must offer phenomenal and dynamic tidal experiences that exceed the expectations of visitors and the perception that the Bay of Fundy is a landscape where they can see the record-breaking tides. These sites must lure experience-seeking visitors by providing unique tidal activities. Bay of Fundy Interpretation Sites Interpretation sites keep visitors in the region longer. Along with the activity and adventure themes, they give visitors more things to do and to learn about by providing a complete natural and cultural interpretation of the region. Trails Trails diversify the product and also keep visitors in the region longer. They fit the desires of the traveler who seeks to explore the ecosystem of the region. 131 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Viewpoints Viewpoints consist of amenities and coastal stopping points that fill in the gaps between the interpretation sites. Their purpose is to encourage visitors to tour the region. 10.2 Implementation Framework Coordination and Planning It is recommended that the steering committee form a task force to oversee implementation. The goal of the task force should be to coordinate, set timelines and check in with each regional partner. Suggested membership/resources for a task force include 5 people: 2 provincial, 2 regional and (ideally) 1 industry or non-affiliated. Development of Anchor Attractions Development of new anchor attractions will require funds and time. However, they are key to gaining a higher profile. The task force should work with regional partners to: • set timelines for development • enter into discussions regarding partnerships (include RDAs as appropriate) review and provide agreement on development components, budget and schedule • Identity Program The long term goal for the identity program should be to establish a consistent identity or theme throughout the Bay of Fundy region. Tasks or steps will include: 1. Approve graphics that can be used consistently throughout the Bay of Fundy region. If images are not constant, then colours and type style should be. It is the recommendation of this report that “Bay of Fundy” be the consistent name throughout. 2. Provide graphic standards for interpretation sites and viewpoints as follows: a. Site identification signs to be installed in visible locations at the entrance to each site. b. Locator signs (minimum 6 for each interpretation site, and 4 for each viewpoint). 3. Approve concept for entry sign and implement at key entry points throughout. 132 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Market Readiness Review and monitor market readiness standards and benefit package for interpretation sites, trails, and viewpoints. Evaluate interpretation sites according to market readiness standards, prioritize and set goals for development. Prioritize viewpoint locations, evaluate according to market readiness standards and prepare goals, schedule, and development plan. Placement of wayfinding signage will also need to be planned and organized. In the long term, each site will have to be attached to a group that has the capacity and willingness to manage the site. Site management could include tasks such as: regular garbage removal, parking lot grading, painting, infrastructure maintenance and monitoring, seasonal removal and replacement of panels, scheduling of pit privy pumping, and privy cleaning and stocking. A small budget will be required to achieve normal tasks at each site. Similarly, prioritize hiking trail locations as per the criteria provided in this report. Set criteria and plans for signage according to graphic standards as indicated above. Site Maintenance In order to sustain the sites developed in this report, long-term partners for site maintenance will need to be identified. Such partners could include a mix of local groups (hiking groups, boards of trade, community development groups), municipal and regional organizations. Firstly, each site will need a local sponsoring organization to help it access funds and develop its identity according to the guidelines. This could include the development of parking, visitor amenities, viewing platforms, ramps, and railings in the construction phase. The author of this report believes that there is potential for substantial growth in tourism numbers to the Bay of Fundy region of Nova Scotia. Certainly, there is evidence from New Brunswick that tourism growth focused around well-rounded Bay of Fundy experiences can approach the visitation numbers of a National Park (such as visitation to Hopewell Rocks). Given the phenomenal quality and accessibility of the Bay of Fundy coastline in Nova Scotia, it is believed that, with the enhancement of several key assets in this province, visitation can be significantly increased and can ultimately make a valuable contribution to the Provinceʼs tourism future. 133 _________________________________________________________________________________________________ Bay of Fundy Interpretation & Development Plan, March 2010 RMA Tourism Limited Appendix 2: Viewpoint Site Recommendations Bay of Fundy Market Readiness Assessment Viewpoint locations (no beach access) location pk entrance interp signs y y y ? toilet recommendations Nappan Tidal Bore River Hebert Tidal Bore 15 Shulie no n n n y tidal estuary, coastal view Sand River no n n n y salt marsh, tidal estuary Advocate beach 10 y n n y Cape dʼOr 20 Y Y Y N long driftwood beach, view Cape Chignecto & Cape dʼOr headland Lighthouse, Tidal rip, cliff path to lookoff, cliff warning signs, scapes, views of Cape Split. parking Spencerʼs Island 20 y y restrnt n Port Greville 8 y y n n Fox Point 10 y y n y Black Rock 5 n n n y Parrsboro Harbour 30 y y restrnt y 94 n n landsc highlights needed n view of tidal bore n view of tidal bore panoramic view of upper bay, Spencerʼs Island shipbuilding site view of tidal estuary, old wharf, Cape Split panoramic view of tidal estuary, coast, Cape Split site of tidal turbine demo, view of narrowest section of Fundy, & Cape Split some tidal interp panels, good vertical & horizontal tidal effects, quick bore-like wave at certain times in tide cycle better entry sign better entry sign, landscaping, bore schedule create day-use area here or at Sand River part of proposed new Cumberland Wilderness proposal to add to Chignecto Game Sanctuary add tidal interpretive panel better entry sign, interpretive panel better entry sign fix fence, update interp panel, sign path to beach, fix approach road potholes interpretation, parking, tide info, wayfinding signage post tide times, interpret wave Appendix 2: Viewpoint Site Recommendations location 5 Islands - Broderick pk entrance interp signs 100+ n n field toilet landsc highlights recommendations needed n n panoramic view intertidal add tidal interpretive panel zone & 5 Islands, historic lighthouse n y mountain view of coast, 2 signed & interpreted pull off area islands, 5 islands, Cobequid Escarpment y n tower view of horizontal tides more interpretation of tidal effects in Economy (current interp is history/ecology) y/n y 2 locations, view of tidal bore better outdoor interpretation permanent signs with bore description and tide times N y provincial day-use park with add interpretation. Remove chain link views of tidal bore. Can be fence, add steps to viewing platform. viewed from S Maitland. Y Y provincial park with shore add Tidal Interpretation access and views of the upper Minas Basin n n historic lighthouse, improve signage, add more interp panoramic view of horizontal panels, improve curb appeal at Route tidal zone 215 restrnt y sandy beach, good intertidal tide interpretation and schedule zone width, easy access Economy Mountain no n n Cobequid Interp Centre 20 y y Truro Tidal Bore 20 y y Caddel Rapids 20 Y n Anthony Provincial Park 20 Y ? Walton Lighthouse 18 y y Cheverie Beach 8 n n St Croix River Tidal Bore no n n n n Windsor VIC, Fort Edward 30 y n y n Hantsport Wharf no n n n y Avonport Viewpoint ? ? ? ? ? viewing of tidal bore from interp signage, schedule, proper farm or Mantua Bridge roadside parking needed walk along dykes overlooking add interpretive panels re: tidal marsh tidal marsh good high/low tide wharf but add parking, welcome signage, interp in industrial setting (Gypsum panels (if, in fact, they want tourists in wharf - factory & chain link this area) fence) excellent views of Minas Improved wayfinding Basin and Blomidon 95 Appendix 2: Viewpoint Site Recommendations location pk Evangeline Beach 30 Wolfville Harbour 10 Delhaven 2 Medford Beach no Kingsport 30 The Lookoff 20 Port Williams bridge 10 y y n y Baxterʼs Harbour 10 n n n n Harbourville 30 y y restrnt y 96 entrance interp toilet landsc highlights signs needed y y restrnt y broad intertidal zone, muddy beach, feeding grounds for sandpipers in July, private property, campground & canteen onsite y y n n tidal harbour in town links to dyke trails n n n n good vertical tide harbour, access at public wharf, working wharf, not much parking n n n y bench view, dead end road, canʼt see best rock formations, Views of shorebird habitat y y y y boat launch, sandy beach, broad intertidal zone, boat launch, summer eatery n n n y panoramic view, dyked farm lands, tidal coast recommendations current interp panel about birds, add tidal interpretation sign and promote dyke trails as if they are accessible to public designate public parking, attraction signage (may have been tried before with Kings Tourism) beach access if possible to sandstone formations panels are mostly historical, add tidal panel more interpretation of tidal aspects that can be viewed from site, inc info on dyking add interpretive panel accessible site for vertical tidal effect, access to dyke trails low tide beach, wharf, rock orientation sign about tides & tide safety formations, beach waterfall, view of Cape Split working tidal harbour, fishing add tidal interpretive panel boats, restaurant, historical panels (above village) Appendix 2: Viewpoint Site Recommendations location pk entrance interp signs y y Morden (French Cross) 10 Margaretsville 12 Y Hampton Parkers Cove 10 20 n n Victoria Beach 4 n Gullivers Cove 6 n East Ferry 6 n Boars Head Light 8 y Freeport Ferry 8 n Western Light Northern Light 20 12 n y toilet landsc highlights recommendations needed n y Acadian interp plaque, add tide & geology panel panoramic beach access, basalt shoals, view of fish weir, Isle Haute Y y y public pit privvies add tidal interpretation (abandoned?), nice lighthouse, easy access n n n double tidal wharves add tidal interpretation n n y tidal wharf, fish market in add tidal interpretive downtown, shipbuilders architecture, cove n n y Fishing wharf, Digby gut add tidal interpretation views, Poney Express interpretation some n y Basalt Headlands, trails, wind add geological /tidal interpretation turbines, salt marsh, interp panels (historical) n restrnt y ferry waiting area - tidal add interpretive panel re: tidal currents currents between islands n n y lighthouse, unmarked coastal sign & develop trails trails n restrnt y ferry waiting area - tidal add interpretive panel re: tidal currents currents between islands n n y lighthouse, trail access better trail signage & interpretation n n y lighthouse,coastal trail to Seal better trail signage & interpretation Cove 97 Acknowledgements: This Interpretation and Development Plan for the Bay of Fundy was made possible with the generous support of: The Project Steering Committee Nova Scotia Tourism, Culture & Heritage Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources, Parks Division The Glenn Group Ideas Unlimited Individuals who submitted responses This document has been formatted for 2-sided printing in the interest of environmental practices.