why you need to change the way you work
Transcription
why you need to change the way you work
THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK Agency edition TABLE OF CONTENTS Change or die – what are you waiting for? 3 Agencies remaking themselves as AOR model changes 4 The impact of industry consolidation on how agencies work together 7 The state of agency-client collaboration9 How the transition to digital affects agencies’ current processes 11 Eight scary stats about your email habits 13 R.I.P., FTP? 15 Cloud collaboration is saving agencies money – a case study Don’t stop now ! 16 CHANGE OR DIE– WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR? From the biggest behemoth to the tiniest specialty shop, agencies have to adapt and change the way they work in order to survive. Old business models – like AORs – are crumbling. Clients no longer accept archaic work processes or “that’s just the way we’ve always done business” as an excuse for lackluster communication and collaboration. Failing to involve and empower clients will put an agency on a sure path to lost business. What are agencies to do? How can they foster a deeper relationship with its clients and try to end the fickle cycle of continuous churn? We investigate herein – and hear from a number of forward-thinking agencies that are finding the answers. § THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 3 | 17 STEVE HALL IS A MARKETING PROFESSIONAL, PUBLISHER, WRITER, COMMUNITY MANAGER, PHOTOGRAPHER AND ALL-AROUND LOVER OF ADVERTISING. AGENCIES REMAKING THEMSELVES AS AOR MODEL CHANGES Back in the day…actually not so long ago, clients would choose an agency, dub them agency of record, sign a contract, pay a monthly retainer and the partnership would last for years. Everything was “hunky-dory” to use a term from back when things in the advertising business were, well, “hunky-dory.” Both sides trusted the other would hold up their end of the bargain. The agency would live up to its promise to deliver campaigns that worked and the client would reward that dedication and success with business commitment to the agency. Then a few things happened. CMOs begin changing jobs every 12 to 18 months. Hoping to make a mark at their new company and impress their bosses, they’d promptly fire the agency, hold a review and choose a new agency. Agencies unbundled splitting off services which begat media agencies, creative agencies, interactive shops and, today, social media agencies. Each offshoot had specialized skills to offer brands and brands liked what they saw. Specialization became the name of the game and the mentality that no single agency could possibly handle every client need became prevalent. It’s unlikely we’ll ever return to the glory days of the AOR landscape –at least in a world where agencies are perceived as vendors versus true business partners . THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 4 | 17 AGENCIES REMAKING THEMSELVES AS AOR MODEL CHANGES To a certain degree, this was true. With the advent of the internet, the myriad opportunities it added to the plate and the speed at which business was now able to move, a fickle, “shiny new object” mentality set in. Couple that with the aforementioned 18 month CMO tenures and, perhaps even more paradigm-shifting, the rise in importance of procurement and its balance sheet-heavy mentality, and a lowest bidder model versus a trusted relationship became the standard. Of these monumental changes in the agency-client relationship, CAHG Project Leader Mona Heggem said, “We just celebrated our 50th anniversary, which is a huge milestone for an agency to achieve. We’ve had long-standing clients – one for 50 years, another for 30 years, another for 22 years. We’ve always worked under the AOR model, but now we are seeing that procurement is taking the lead on finding agencies. We have to pitch for every single job now. We’re investing so much more in our new business efforts because we have to pitch for everything; the clients are no longer going with the AOR model because procurement is running the show. We’re pitching up against 18 agencies to keep business that we would have normally gotten from the AOR model.” Now, some might argue the continuous fight to determine the best agency for any given job at any given time is a good thing. After all, why wouldn’t a brand want the best work for every campaign? Others might argue that continuous change never allows for the two entities, agency and client, to form the kind of deep relationship that fosters trust, dedication and loyalty. The kind of relationship committed humans have with one another. The kind of So what can an ad agency do to foster a deeper relationship with its clients and, perhaps, end the fickle cycle of continuous churn? One such agency (and we’re sure there are many others) thinks it has the answer. relationship in which one can complete the other’s sentences. OK, so businesses aren’t people, but there is certainly something to be said for a relationship in which both sides innately understand each other’s needs before they are expressed. Alas, cyclical as things are, it’s unlikely we’ll ever return to the glory days of the AOR landscape – at least in a world where agencies are perceived as vendors versus true business partners. THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 5 | 17 AGENCIES REMAKING THEMSELVES AS AOR MODEL CHANGES Boston-based Winsper has recast itself within the management consultant space and is touting a focus on enterprise marketing ROI. Winsper Founder and CEO Jeff Winsper says marketing organizations “must use the language of the boardroom.” To Winsper, campaign ROI in a vacuum is, for the most part, irrelevant. What is important are hard business metrics such as sales, revenue, inventory turnover and geographic sales volume. This Enterprise Marketing ROI offering, as Winsper calls it, aims to directly tie advertising spend to financial performance on an aggregate basis. In Winsper’s mind, “soft KPIs” such as leads, likes, retweets, direct mail response rate, CTR, pins, reach, frequency, CPMs, GRPs, awareness, recognition, preference and other marketing KPIs are meaningless if not tied to “hard KPIs.” It’s simply not the language of the C-Suite. The C-Suite speaks the language of the hard KPI, factors directly tied to the financial wellbeing of the company. Winsper’s goal is to position itself as a company that can examine a business’s many data stores such as enterprise resource planning, sales automation, customer relationship management, marketing automation and point of sale, pull it all together and provide the insight a brand needs to run its marketing department like a business. In this way, the agency becomes more of a business consultant. An entity that can directly map a spend to the bottom line. For Winsper, their success doesn’t depend on whether or not a campaign worked or not. It depends on the ability to answer a question that is always there and will never go away: what effect did my marketing budget have on revenue? This, of course, has been the unattainable Golden Egg. However, with the rise of Big Data and affordable business intelligence tools to make sense of the data, tying marketing ROI to business ROI has become much easier than ever before. § THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 6 | 17 STEVE HALL IS A MARKETING PROFESSIONAL, PUBLISHER, WRITER, COMMUNITY MANAGER, PHOTOGRAPHER AND ALL-AROUND LOVER OF ADVERTISING. THE IMPACT OF INDUSTRY CONSOLIDATION ON HOW AGENCIES WORK TOGETHER With (now denied) rumors swirling about the advertising industry that giant advertising holding company Publicis Groupe would swallow up Interpublic Group, the notion of agency consolidation has become almost comical. It wasn’t so long ago that independent advertising agencies ruled the industry. Today behemoths like Publicis, MDC, Interpublic, Publicis WPP and Omnicom now control the lion’s share of ad agencies. This consolidation has wreaked havoc in many areas of agency operations – not the least of which are the numerous client conflicts that arise when one agency buys another and then the two realize they now handle competing brands, a no-no in the ad world. Almost losing a client isn’t a place you want to go just to find out you need to get a handle on your workflow. But an area of concern that receives much less press and attention is agency operations – the plain, old, boring notion to how an agency gets work done. It’s not sexy but, believe me, the fastest way to lose a client is complicated and confusing operational methodologies. As account director at an agency that had just been bought by a much larger agency, I once lost an account because the account planner (who came from the acquiring agency) was having separate conversations with the client that ran contrary to the conversations creative and account service were having. It’s not that the content of the conversations were wrong, but it made the agency look stupid. THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 7 | 17 THE IMPACT OF INDUSTRY CONSOLIDATION ON HOW AGENCIES WORK TOGETHER Don’t worry, I won the client back with the most concise analysis of the brand’s business (basically doing the account planner’s job) along with a huge promise internal communication errors would never again lead to an agency that spoke out of both sides of its mouth. But the important point to note is that the process got away from us. Oh sure, we had processes and procedures in place, but they weren’t good enough. And they were at odds with those processes and procedures of the agency that acquired us. And almost losing a client isn’t a place you want to go just to find out you need to get a handle on your workflow. We patched things up, but that’s just one small example of what’s going on in the advertising industry today where, conceivably, one holding company could, suddenly, own another. You can just imagine the procedural headaches an acquisition like that would cause, let alone the ongoing procedural headaches that exist within agencies that were acquired years ago and are still trying to figure out how to work together seamlessly. With agency consolidation, most attention and headlines center on client conflicts and the dumbing down of originality. It’s my humble opinion far more attention should be paid to figuring out (and fast) how to work seamlessly together because, as we all know, a well-oiled machine works much better than a bunch of chickens running around with their heads cut off. § THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 8 | 17 LINDA SOUZA IS CENTRAL DESKTOP’S VP OF MARKETING. THE STATE OF AGENCYCLIENT COLLABORATION We all know relationships are hard, whether personal or business. And the agency-client relationship can sometimes be contentious. I know – I’ve lived it. While I’ve mostly been on the client side of marketing, I dabbled briefly on the agency side many years ago. One of the big challenges I’ve seen and experienced first-hand is just the day-to-day struggle of working together when we’re coming from two different angles: speaking the same lingo so we come to an understanding (the same understanding) on the goals and needs for a specific project, knowing where a project stands at any moment (long periods of no communication = you’re busy creating brilliance for me or you’re off to another project?), keeping everyone on track (sometimes agencies have to become client-wranglers…I admit to being an offender). And that’s just the start. So it was no surprise to me when looking through the results of our recent survey on the state of agency-client collaboration that communication and difficulties working together would be a major theme. What did surprise me, however, is how much pressure clients like me are applying to agencies to get collaboration tools in place to help deal with those problems. And apparently, clients are hitting agencies where it counts most – their wallets. THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 9 | 17 THE STATE OF AGENCY-CLIENT COLLABORATION A few of our findings... • 71% consider it a competitive differentiator over other agencies if an agency has a single collaboration system to manage project work online. • 4 1% of agencies have had a client or prospect require them to have a collaboration system to keep or win a major account. of brands have not awarded business to an agency for lack of adequate tools for managing work and communications on the account. Click for the infographic. . . THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 10 | 17 STEVE HALL IS A MARKETING PROFESSIONAL, PUBLISHER, WRITER, COMMUNITY MANAGER, PHOTOGRAPHER AND ALL-AROUND LOVER OF ADVERTISING. HOW THE TRANSITION TO DIGITAL AFFECTS AGENCIES’ CURRENT PROCESSES When I was working for a high tech and B2B ad agency that was experiencing growing pains caused by the transformation from small to mid-sized to large, I developed a aspects of the job, due dates, production specs and, if lucky, the creative brief. traffic and production management system using a Mac and FileMaker Pro. Prior to that system, there were nothing more than memos and email to convey information from account management to creative to production to traffic and back. It was inefficient, and many times information was lost in transit. rife with the limitations of early-stage FileMaker Pro. At other agencies I worked for, trafficking jobs and managing workflow ranged in sophistication from a simple phone call to a handwritten note to typed, four-part forms to email to clunky dumb terminal antiquation. The FileMaker Pro system introduced job tickets and a workflow that, to the best of FileMaker Pro’s limited capabilities, aided in making sure the right people saw the right information and that the process was properly documented. This included a listing of those responsible for various It was far from a perfect system and Sadly, even to this day, few agencies feel the need to invest in systems that would vastly improve the efficiencies and performance of everyone at the agency. Agencies are famous for making bold promises, touting cutting-edge strategies, hyping the latest and greatest shiny object and generally promising they can do just about anything at all. THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK Sadly, even to this day, few agencies feel the need to invest in systems that would vastly improve the efficiencies and performance of everyone at the agency . 11 | 17 HOW THE TRANSITION TO DIGITAL AFFECTS AGENCIES’ CURRENT PROCESSES But when it comes to noting what they need internally in terms of advanced thinking, most fall short, don’t feel the need to invest and generally think Dropbox and Evernote are all they need. Not to knock those products, but they are far from the full-fledged solution most agencies need. the creative process. When an agency shifts to digital collaboration and/or workflow management, they must be sure whatever solution they put in place doesn’t completely supplant the human element. With much of the industry’s work shifting to digital, managing non-physical assets including their location, approval status and transition to outside vendors becomes ever more important. There are no physical “job jackets” any longer and While agencies are far more conservative than their dress, office space, liberal mindset or advanced strategic thinking would lead one to believe, they need to wake up and drink the Kool Aid they’ve been shilling their clients since Don Draper made his Carousel presentation to Kodak in the early sixties. OK, so holding onto that antiquated system (many agencies still do by – believe it or not – printing out digital assets) will leave those agencies in a dust cloud of their more digital-savvy competition. that never actually happened, but you understand what I’m saying. Times have changed. The work product has changed. And it’s time agencies adopt processes suited to those changes. § However when shifting over to digital communications, agencies must be mindful not to eliminate the all important human touch that is ever so important in THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 12 | 17 ADAM MCKIBBIN IS CENTRAL DESKTOP’S CONTENT MARKETING MANAGER. EIGHT SCARY STATS ABOUT YOUR EMAIL HABITS Are you at war with your inbox? My Facebook and Twitter feeds regularly contain friends commiserating over email avalanches, celebrating alarming milestones (“only 1000 unread emails to go!”) or gleefully announcing that they’ve done the digital equivalent of sweeping all their piled-up papers off the desk and into the trash. Email isn’t going away any time soon – rumors of its demise are greatly exaggerated – but there are new ways to make it a more efficient part of your life, particularly for those of us who rely on email in the workplace. By 2014, Gartner estimates that 20% of business users will switch to enterprise social networking as their main method of communication. Overreliance on email leads to lost time, lost documents and even lost IQ points . Of course, the first step to recovery is to admit you have a problem. Not convinced? Check out these eye-opening stats and studies... THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 13 | 17 SOURCES 1. research.microsoft.com 2. news.bbc.co.uk 3. journalstar.com 4. blogs.atlassian.com and radicati.com 5. radicati.com 6. newsroom.accenture.com 7. lifehacker.com 8. mckinsey.com g as they think. It typically takes People aren’t as good at multitaskin . ject following an email interruption 10-15 minutes to refocus on a pro Email distraction docks your IQ by 10 points. t workers an hour of lost time eve On average, email interruptions cos ry day. 36 times in an hour, The average worker checks email per day. sending and receiving 105 emails 19% of that email: spam and grayma il. able information every 59% of middle managers miss valu it or never see it. day – simply because they can’t find ee times less efficient Email folders and folder rules? Thr than a simple search. makes high-skill employees Failing to implement social technology ductive. and management 20-25% less pro THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 14 | 17 ADAM MCKIBBIN IS CENTRAL DESKTOP’S CONTENT MARKETING MANAGER. There’s no going back. Files aren’t getting smaller. R.I.P., FTP? If you’re relying on FTP for large files or sensitive information, you’re keeping one foot planted in the past. FTP was born in 1971, the same year as Mark Wahlberg and Jon Hamm. Technology, unfortunately, doesn’t age quite as well as Hollywood stars. What’s more: FTP hasn’t had a significant overhaul in decades; the guts of 2013’s FTP are identical to 1985’s FTP. Remember what computers looked like in 1985? That’s basically what FTP would look like if it had a body. It’s a little clunky, a little past its prime. You’ve almost surely never met someone who’s enthusiastic about FTP; it’s a sequence of letters that elicits about the same response as “IRS.” The phrase “I hate FTP” returns 21,900 results on Google. So why do we keep entrusting our large files to it? FTP is flawed, but functional – and, perhaps even more importantly, familiar. If speed and security aren’t major Bosses and clients concerns, FTP still gets the job done. Again, it’s not going to win any popularity or efficiency awards, but it will get you and your files from A to B. But what if speed and security are major concerns? FTP, in its defense, was never designed to transmit massive files or protect confidential information; in 1971, a gigabyte would have sounded like something out of a sci-fi novel to most people. With a solution like Central Desktop’s SocialBridge, users benefit from serious security – the same kind of encryption used by banks. aren’t getting more patient. Security risks aren’t getting less severe. There’s no going back. Files aren’t getting smaller. Bosses and clients aren’t getting more patient. Security risks aren’t getting less severe. As technology continues to evolve, a wait time that once seemed reasonable will become intolerable. Previously unavoidable risks will become unacceptable. FTP had a good, long run – but, again, some things don’t age as well as others. § THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 15 | 17 CLOUD COLLABORATION IS SAVING AGENCIES MONEY – A CASE STUDY When Engauge formed via acquisition, bringing together three agencies from different disciplines and different cities, Raj Choudhury knew it would take a little time to standardize processes across the agency. When it came time to audit the systems in place, he found a dizzying number of tools in place – working in tandem and sometimes in conflict. For file sharing alone, employees were using SharePoint, Box, Dropbox, FTP and YouSendIt. “With that amount of data replication, it’s hard to know where to find things and which version is correct. And that makes it hard to produce the best product for clients across disciplines,” says Choudhury. “My goal was to make Engauge an easier place to work.” Central Desktop’s SocialBridge is helping him do just that. Originally considered just as a client-extranet solution, SocialBridge replaced more than 10 different collaboration tools, cutting software licensing costs in half. Download this case study to learn: • H ow Engauge designed its intranet to bring people together and streamline operations • Which features are most popular • How the agency uses SocialBridge with clients SocialBridge replaced more than 10 different collaboration tools, cutting software licensing costs in half . Click to download the case study . . . THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 16 | 17 ABOUT CENTRAL DESKTOP Central Desktop helps people work together in ways never before possible. Our social collaboration platform connects people and information in the cloud, making it possible to share files, combine knowledge, inspire ideas, manage projects and more. Our SocialBridge collaboration solution centralizes the way people work, teams collaborate and managers lead. Central Desktop serves half a million users worldwide. Key Central Desktop customers include CBS, MLB.com, Harvard University, the Humane Society of the United States, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Javelin Marketing Group, Upshot, Engauge, WD-40 and Workday. Founded in 2005, Central Desktop is a privately-held company with headquarters in Pasadena, California. Learn more about SocialBridge . . . THE FUTURE OF THE WORKPLACE WHY YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE WAY YOU WORK 17 | 17