Children`s Healthcare of Atlanta
Transcription
Children`s Healthcare of Atlanta
Child Sex Trafficking and Commercial Sexual Exploitation In America Jordan Greenbaum, MD, Stephanie V. Blank Center for Safe and Healthy Children Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta Objectives • Be familiar with risk factors and possible indicators of child sex trafficking • Be aware of trauma-informed techniques used to speak with suspected victims and to gather information while maintaining the safety and well being of the child • Be aware of how to make a report of suspected victimization as appropriate, and knowledgeable of available resources for victims and healthcare providers. 2 What is Sex Trafficking? • Involves the recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for the purpose of a commercial sex act – (any sex act on account of which anything of value is given to or received by any person.) – If person is >18 yo, must show force, fraud, coercion – If person <18 yo, no force, etc required TVPA, 2000 3 Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children (CSEC) • Occurs when a person induces a minor to engage in a sex act in exchange for remuneration in the form of money, food, shelter or other valued entity. – Survival sex – Trafficking child for commercial sex act (on account of which anything of value is given to or received by any person) – Pornography – Sex tourism – Use of child in sexually oriented business • Does NOT require force, coercion, violence, etc Trafficking and CSEC in the U.S. • No reliable estimates of prevalence/incidence • Majority of identified child victims are domestic 5 When we think of child sex trafficking and commercial sexual exploitation, we think of….. Girls and ‘Pimps’ 6 But, there’s more to it…. • Girls and • Direct exchange of sex for item of value • Survival sex • Luxury items • Pornography • Sex-oriented businesses • What about boys?? What about LGBTQI youth? 7 The “Invisible Boy” • Boys largely ignored in articles, studies of HT • Why? Some studies show predominance of girls Public discomfort with male-to-male sex Males not viewed as powerless, vulnerable Males are not objectified Friedman, 2013; US Dept. of State, TIP, 2013; UNODC, 2014; Dennis, 2008 8 What Are The Consequences? ‘Offender’ vs ‘victim’ status Lack of services 9 Children At Increased Risk for Sex Trafficking Child welfare involvement Looking for love Poverty Abuse/Neglect Family Dysfunction Runaway/Throwaway Increased Risk Parent with substance abuse ‘Easy money’ Mental health problems Drug/Alcohol abuse Gang involvement Adult prostitution in home LGBTQI status IOM, 2013; Smith 2009; Edinburgh, 2015; Greenbaum 2015; Gragg 2007; Bigelson 2013 Risks for Transgender Youth • Family and societal rejection • Seek acceptance • Job discrimination • Substance use to cope • Need money for treatment • High risk survival sex 11 Grossman, 2006 Pathways to Entry • Seduction and coercion (boys and girls) • False advertising for modeling, acting, or dancing • Internet : Chat rooms or social media • Offered food, safety while en route to U.S. • Mechanism for survival Pathways to Entry • Peer recruitment • Parents selling children • Violence and force, kidnapping • Drugs/alcohol 13 How can the child be a victim when they freely agree to sell sex? 14 How can you have a ‘compliant’ victim? • Children have needs, just like adults. • Easily manipulated. • Lack experience and maturity to understand implications. • Lack psychological, cognitive ability to ‘consent’. • Lack legal ability to consent. When you think of a ‘typical’ adolescent, what do you imagine? Rebellious Curious about sex Easily sexually aroused Adolescent Needing to break away from parents Influenced by social media Unsure of self Eager to ‘grow up’ Eager for acceptance What do we know about adolescent behavior? • Show increased risk-taking behavior. • Increased impulsive behavior. • Not so good at… – Suppressing inappropriate thoughts or actions. – Favoring goal-directed behavior. – Delaying gratification. 17 Homeless Youth and Survival Sex • Very common behavior: ~10-50% • More likely if live on street (rather than shelter) • Boys more likely than girls? Study results conflict Walls, 2011; Greene, 1999; Chettiar, 2010 18 Homeless youth and survival sex Older youth Antisocial behavior More time on the street Drug use (esp. injection drugs) Hx sexual or emotional abuse Young age when first ran away Increased Risk of Survival Sex Hx psychiatric hospitalization Hx suicide attempt Hx STI or pregnancy LGBTQI 19 Wall, 2011; Greene, 1999; Stoltz, 2007; Kerr, 2009, Chettiar, 2010; Whitbeck, 2004 Conditions in “the Life” • Lots of variation – – – – – – – Survival sex on the streets Work alone or with group Live at home Live with trafficker Involvement with gang Freedom may vary Brothel vs motel vs trailer in field vs street 20 Case example- Paul Paul is a 15 yo boy who ran away from home because his mother told him that his being gay disgraced the family. He started out living with a friend, but this did not work well and he ended up on the street. He slept in the park for a few days but his money ran out and he didn’t know what to do. He was approached by some other boys who allowed him to join their group. He watched Joel ‘turn some tricks’ and Joel told him what he needed to do. It seemed like all the boys were doing it so Paul did, too. 21 Paul Paul had been using marijuana for years but when living on the streets he began using cocaine and alcohol. After awhile he could only see clients if he was ‘high’. He seldom used a condom although he saw up to 4 clients per day. He and his friends went to the public STI clinic every few months to get tested, although Paul did not agree to HIV testing. 22 Case Example: Sherise and Elsa • Sherise is 17 years old, has a 6 month old baby, and is living on the streets after being thrown out of the house because of her pregnancy. She dropped out of school and is struggling to support herself. She is staying with a female friend, who suggests she work as an exotic dancer. She does this for a few months and one night is approached by a man who tells her he loves her dancing. He invites her outside on her break and kidnaps her. He rapes and beats her and tells her now she is working for him. She works at his club and eventually is told she must engage in prostitution as well as dancing. • Elsa is 14 years old, and an A and B student. She loves track and painting. She meets a 17 year old boy on Facebook and they become friends. She tells him everything, all about her frustration with her mother and her abandonment by her father. After 2 months he asks to meet her. But before he does, he wants her to know that actually he’s 25 years old. She is shocked but she is in love…..she goes to meet him. 23 CSEC in New York City Boys (n-111) Girls (n-119) Transgender (n-19) ‘Living on the street’ 44% 24% 11% Family home 16% 29% 5% Friend’s home 19% 26% 11% Another home 6% 18% 16% Shelter 28% 18% 42% Market facilitator home 0% 4% 0% Living alone 52% 26% 42% Living situation Curtis, 2008 24 CSEC in New York City Boys (n-111) Ave age of initiation 15.28 years Girls (n-119) Transgender (n-19) 15.15 years 16.16 years How recruited? Friends 44% 46% 68% Relative 3% 1% 0% Trafficker 1% 16% 0% Customer approached child 32% 16% 11% Internet 4% 3% 5% Curtis, 2008 25 New York City Study • • • • Extensive peer networks for boys/girls Most had <5 clients per day Violence a way of life Drugs of choice Marijuana>alcohol>cocaine>heroin None: 24% girls; 12% boys; 53% transgender Curtis, 2008 26 “Why Don’t they just leave?” • Threatened by trafficker • Loyal to trafficker, feel indebted • Trafficking life perceived as preferable • ‘Perks’, sense of belonging, • May feel that is only skill they have • Home is worse What are the consequences of child sex trafficking? 28 Physical Violence Fractures, head injury, Lacerations, bruises, Beat, choke, whip Abdominal trauma, Burns Anogenital trauma Torture (ice-baths, burns, suspension, salt in wounds Physical restraint and/or confinement Shock, bleeding, infection Scarring, disfigurement, loss of function Deprivation (sleep, food, light) Malnutrition Homicide Exhaustion Chronic pain Zimmerman, 2006l Lederer, 2014 29 Sexual Abuse/Assault Anogenital injury STI, HIV Pelvic inflamm. disease Rape, gang rape UTI Forced prostitution Cervical CA Forced unprotected sex Infertility Pregnancy, abortion Sex without lubricants Misuse of contraceptives Humiliation PTSD Chronic pain with intercourse Chronic pain/IBS Zimmerman, 2006l Lederer, 2014 30 Sexually Transmitted Infections • May have to buy condoms from trafficker • Problems negotiating condom use • May not use condom with trafficker (‘boyfriend’) • Client pays more without condom • Limited knowledge of STIs, importance of condoms 31 HIV Risk Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific. (2000) CDC website, 2014; Patel et al, 2014 32 Pregnancy • Contraception is unusual • Morbidity higher for adolescent girls than adults • Many unsafe abortions 10-50% of women who have unsafe abortions have complications • Infants born with acute and chronic conditions Willis & Levy, 2002; Deisher, Farrow, Hope, & Litchfield, 1989 33 Psychological Abuse PTSD Chronic fear, anxiety Threats Intimidation/Terrorizing Depression Stockholm syndrome Blackmail Suicide Deception, deceit Memory loss Unpredictability Somatic complaints Lack of control Aggression, violence Isolation Guilt, shame, hopelessness Forced dependency Substance misuse Zimmerman, 2006l Lederer, 2014 34 Substance Use/Misuse • • • • • Pre-existing use or introduced by trafficker Method of control, manipulation Self-medication Heroin, benzo’s, meth, others Intoxication, overdose or withdrawal Untreated Chronic Conditions • Poorly controlled chronic conditions (e.g. asthma) • Dental problems • Chronic pain (HA, abd, pelvic) • Chronic fatigue • Problems associated with prior traumatic brain injury Lederer & Wetzel, 2014; Zimmerman, 2006; Cooper, 2005 36 So, how will I know a victim when I see one? Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta 37 Challenges to Victim Identification • Victims don’t self-identify • Reluctant to disclose • Few clinically validated quick screening tools and these are cumbersome 38 Possible Indicators of Sex Trafficking/CSEC: First Impressions • Youth appears afraid of adult, or overly submissive, anxious • Youth gives false demographic information, inconsistent history • Youth cannot describe where she/he is staying, doesn’t know city 39 Youth at Risk Child welfare involvement Truancy, school problems Poverty Abuse/Neglect Runaway/Throwaway Mental health problems Drug/Alcohol abuse Gang involvement Family Dysfunction Parent with substance abuse Adult prostitution in home LGBTQ status 40 Possible Indicators of Sex Trafficking/CSEC • Think about the adverse health effects of trafficking…. Multiple sexually transmitted infections Pregnancies, abortions, or miscarriages Illicit drug use Current or past history of: • Sexual assault • Inflicted Injury • Multiple expensive items (clothing, jewelry, etc) • Tattoos • Visible signs of physical abuse 41 Interview Challenges Child may: • Be hostile, uncooperative, manipulative • Be fearful and untrusting of authorities • Be afraid of trafficker • Not see self as victim 42 Sex trafficking and CSEC cause traumatic stress. 43 Symptoms of Traumatic Stress • • • • Symptoms may not manifest immediately. Variable period to resolution. Some children don’t show obvious symptoms. Over control may be as symptomatic as acting out. NCTSN 44 Potential Signs of Traumatic Stress • Physical – – – – Nightmares and sleep problems. Altered appetite and eating patterns. Chronic pain complaints. Irritable bowel syndrome. • Emotional – – – – Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Depression and withdrawal. Anxiety or panic. Dissociation and numbness. NCTSN 45 Potential Signs of Traumatic Stress • Behavioral – – – – – – – Hyperarousal. Aggression and antisocial behavior. Hypervigilance. Lack of control of mood and behavior. Misinterpretation of others’ intentions. Distrust of others. Difficulty with authority and criticism. NCTSN 46 Trauma-Informed Approach • Sexual abuse/exploitation causes traumatic stress. • Trauma can lead to variety of behaviors and reactions. • Need to interpret child’s behavior in context of stress. • Talking can trigger memories and stress. • Need to take steps to: – Ensure child feels safe. – Minimize re-trauma. 47 Safety Issues • Primary concern during visit (child, yourself and staff) – Protocol needed • Interview youth alone – “Is it okay for you to talk to me?” – “Is there anything I can do to make you feel more comfortable while we talk?” Polaris Project, 2013 48 Tips for Talking to Possible Victims • Treat child with respect • Accept child as she/he is • Don’t forget: she/he is a victim/survivor, not an offender • Review limits of confidentiality early on 49 Tips for Talking to Possible Victims • Be sensitive to child’s reactions and to possible stress • Tell her/him what you need to do and why • Allow child control when feasible 50 Direct Questions About Possible Trafficking/CSEC 1) Has anyone ever asked you to have sex in exchange for something you wanted or needed (money, food, shelter or other items)? 2) Has anyone ever asked you to have sex with another person? 3) Has anyone ever taken sexual pictures of you or posted such pictures on the internet? 51 What Do You Say If…. • Child is obviously not telling the truth “I’ve only had sex once before” (police report she has been trafficked for a year) “I don’t do drugs” (child has positive drug screen from prior ED visit) • Youth refuses to allow sexual assault kit and curses out medical staff; LE is insisting on kit • Youth decides he/she wants to leave 52 What questions should I ask? This depends on your situation and your role. 53 Keep in mind…. • Only seek information that you need to know • Why are you asking? – – – – – To investigate? To assess physical and emotional health? To assess safety at home? To determine appropriate services and referrals? To provide important information to the child? Reproductive History • • • • • • Current anogenital symptoms/signs Sexual identity (avoid making assumptions) Prior sexual experiences Condom use and other contraception Prior STI’s, pregnancies, procedures Prior anogenital injuries 55 Questions About Physical Assault/Injuries • Anyone ever hit, kick, slap, choke, beat you? • Tell me about what happened • Who and when? • What was done about it? Investigation? Medical care? 56 Safety Issues: Family History • • • • • • • • Family roles IPV Mental health issues Criminal activity Is family supportive? Ever run away? Why? Any gang involvement? Are you afraid of anyone? 57 If Youth Is Not Living at Home • Where are you staying? • How do you get food and money? • Do you owe anyone money? • Have you gotten hurt while out on the streets? • Has anyone approached you and asked you to do something you didn’t want to do? 58 Safety Issues: Mental Health • Screen for symptoms/signs Depression PTSD Anxiety, panic • Thoughts of hurting self, others? • Prior self-harm? • Make appropriate referrals 59 Other Good Screening Questions for Drugs/Alcohol • CRAFFT, HEADSS screens • Has anyone ever given you drugs when you didn’t know about it? • Have you ever been forced to take drugs, use alcohol? • Ever felt really bad after you’ve been using drugs, or when you’re ‘coming down’? (depressed, agitated, craving drugs, feeling sick) • Types, frequency of drug use; circumstances of use 60 A suspected victim needs a medical evaluation promptly. 61 Exam and Diagnostic Evaluation Focus on: 1. Assessing and treating acute and chronic conditions 2. Documenting acute/remote injuries, genital and extragenital 3. Assessing overall health, nutritional status and hydration 4. Obtaining a sexual assault evidence kit as indicated 5. Testing for pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections and providing prophylaxis 6. Testing for alcohol and drugs, as indicated Obtain patient assent for exam, kit, testing 62 Important Considerations for the HCP Have a chaperone! Exclude suspected trafficker Explain steps before doing them Monitor for signs of distress Ask if child has any questions/concerns during exam • Explain results of your exam • • • • • 63 Possible Inflicted Injuries • Often located in ordinarily protected areas Cheeks Neck Torso Genitals Inner thighs Upper arms • Restraint injuries 64 There may be no evidence of genital trauma. Why? 65 Healing of Hymenal Injuries • 239 girls, 4 months to 18 years old • Accidental and inflicted injury • Left NO residual, except deep lacerations; no scar tissue seen McCann, Miyamoto, Boyle, & Rogers, 2007 66 Possible Medical Referrals Drug rehab Behavioral health assessment and treatment Follow up surgical care HIV PEP monitoring OB/GYN care Primary care provider Child Advocacy Center 67 Complex Needs of Victims • • • • • • • Housing, food, clothing, etc. Emotional support Legal advocacy (immigration issues, T visa…) School enrollment Life skills and job training Family services, potential reunification Transition services • Multidisciplinary approach!!! 68 Reports and Referrals • Know your mandated reporter laws in your state – Report to Law Enforcement – Child Protective Services • Potential issues reporting to local authorities – Victim services available – CPS understanding of issues facing victims – Law enforcement response • Emphasize victim status 69 Reports and Referrals • National Human Trafficking Resource Center Hotline (1-888-3737-888) • U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (1-866-872-4973) 70 Example 1: • • • • • • • 71 16 yo female comes to ED Man hanging around outside CC: bruising, flank pain & blood in urine Vague history of ped vs. auto incident What questions do you ask? Would you ask her about the guy outside? Eventually she discloses situation Example 1 • Physical exam: Bruising to back, upper arms, lip Chipped tooth Contusion to right kidney Trich positive; HIV, other STI & pregnancy negative Once you treat her, what do you do? Reporting, referrals? What about the guy lurking outside? 72 Example 2: 12 yo female comes with her mother to your clinic for a sports physical. She is a good student and you have known the family since the patient was an infant. Mother allows you to speak alone to the child and the latter tells you she is worried about ‘stuff’ coming from her ‘privates’. What do you say? How would you obtain more information? 73 Sample 2: • • • • • Depressed Tired Poor grades recently Abdominal pain, headaches Vaginal discharge x 2 weeks 74 Sample 3: • What do you do with respect to referrals and reports? • What about the mother (who knows nothing?) • What kinds of resources might help this child? 75 Sample 3: • 14 yo male comes to clinic for STI testing. He is gay and having many problems with discrimination and rejection by parents and peers. He ‘meets’ men online and arranges to have dates with them. He has had sex with many men but denies any exchange of money or other valuables. He reports the sex is ‘consensual’. 76 What do you do??? 77 Other Resources • Polaris Project (www.polarisproject.org -sponsors the hotline above) • Shared Hope International (www.sharedhope.org) • National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (www.missingkids.com) 78 My contact info: Jordan Greenbaum, MD jordan.greenbaum@choa.org 79 References • The Alan Guttmacher Institute. (1999) Facts in brief: teen sex and pregnancy. New York: The Alan Guttmacher Institute. • Bigelsen, J., & Vuotto, S. (2013). Homelessness, Survival Sex and Human Trafficking: As Experienced by the Youth of Covenant House New York. Available at: http://www.covenanthouse.org/sites/default/files/attachments/CovenantHouse-trafficking-study.pdf Accessed June 15, 2014. • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2014) HIV/AIDS. Available at: www.cdc.gov/hiv/. Accessed on June 24, 2014. • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2010) Sexually Transmitted Diseases Treatment Guidelines, 2010. MMWR 59(No. RR-12). Available at http://www.cdc.gov/std/treatment/2010/STD-Treatment-2010-RR5912.pdf. Accessed July 21, 2014. • Center for Adolescent Substance Abuse Research. (2009) CRAFFT Screening Tool. Available at: www.ceasar-boston.org. Accessed July 21, 2014. 80 References • Chettiar J, Shannon K, Wood E, Zhang R, Kerr T. Survival sex work involvement among street-involved youth who use drugs in a Canadian setting. J Pub Health, 2010;32(3):322-327 • Curtis R, Terry K, Dank M, Dombrowski K & Khan B. (2008) The Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children in New York City, Volume One, The CSEC Population in New York City: Size, Characteristics, and Needs Final report submitted to the National Institute of Justice. New York, NY: Center for Court Innovation and John Jay College of Criminal Justice. • Cooper SW. (2005). The medical expert and child sexual exploitation. In Cooper SW Estes RJ, Giardino AP. Kellogg VD, & Vieth VI(Eds.), Medical, legal and social science aspects of child sexual exploitation: A comprehensive review of pornography, prostitution, and internet crimes (Vol. 2, pp. 799-834). St. Louis: G.W. Medical Publishing, Inc. 81 References • Deisher RW, Farrow JA, Hope K, & Litchfield C. (1989) The pregnant adolescent prostitute. Am J Dis Child, 143(10), 1162-1165. • Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific. (2000) Sexually abused and sexually exploited children and youth in the greater Mekong subregion: a qualitative assessment of their health needs and available services. United Nations: Geneva. • Edinburgh L, Pape-Blabloil J, Haprin SB, Saewyc E. Assessing exploitation experiences of girls and boys seen at a child advocacy center. Child Abuse Neg, 2015: in press. • Gragg F, Petta I, Bernstein H, et al. New York prevalence study of commercially sexually exploited children: Final report. New York State Office of Children and Family Services2007. • Greenbaum J, Crawford-Jakubiak J, Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect. Child sex trafficking and commercial sexual exploitation: Health care needs of victims. Peds,2015:135(3). 82 • Greene JM, Ennett ST, Ringwalt CL. Prevalence and correlates of survival sex among runaway and homeless youth. Am J Public Health, 1999;89:1406-1409. • Institute of Medicine and National Research Council. Confronting commercial sexual exploitation and sex trafficking of minors in the United States. Washington, D.C.: The National Academies Press; 2013. • Kerr T, Marshall BDL, Miller C, Shannon K, Zhang R, et al. Injection drug use among street-involved youth in a Canadian setting. BMC Public Health, 2009;9:171-177. • Knight JR, et al. A new brief screen for adolescent substance abuse. Arch Pediatric Adolesc Med. 1999 Jun;153(6):591-6. PMID: 10357299 • Lederer LJ, Wetzel CA. (2014) The health consequences of sex trafficking and their implications for identifying victims in healthcare facilities. Annals of Health Law. 23:61-91. 83 • McCann J, Miyamoto S, Boyle C, Rogers K. (2007) Healing of hymenal injuries in prepubertal and adolescent girls: A descriptive study. Pediatrics. 119:e1094. • Polaris Project. (2013) National Human Trafficking Resource Center. Available at: http://www.polarisproject.org/what-we-do/national-humanTrafficking-hotline/the-nhtrc/overview. Accessed on June 24, 2014. Silverman, J. G. (2011). Adolescent female sex workers: invisibility, violence and HIV. Arch Dis Child, 96(5). • Smith L, Vardaman S, Snow M. The national report on domestic minor sex trafficking: America's prostituted children. In: International SH, ed. Accessed at http://sharedhope.org/wpcontent/uploads/2012/09/SHI_National_Report_on_DMST_2009.pdf • Stoltz JM, Shannon K, Kerr T, Zhang R, Montaner JJS, Wood E. Associations between childhood maltreatment and sex work in a cohort of drug-using youth. Soc Sci Med, 2007;65(6):1214-1221 84 • Walls NE, Bell S. Correlates of engaging in survival sex among homeless youth and young adults. J Sex Res,2011;48(5):423-436. • Whitbeck LB, Chen X, Hoyt DR, Tyler KA, Johnson KD. Mental disorder, subsistence strategies and victimization among gay, lesbian and bisexual homeless and runaway adolescents. J Sex Res, 2004;41(4):329-342. • Willis BM, Levy BS. (2002) Child prostitution: Global health burden, research needs, and interventions. Lancet. 359; 1417-1422. • Yates GL, Mackenzie RG, Pennbridge J, & Swofford A. (1991). A risk profile comparison of homeless youth involved in prostitution and homeless youth not involved. J Adolesc Health, 12(7), 545-548. • Zimmerman C. Stolen smiles: A summary report on the physical and psychological consequences of women and adolescents trafficked in Europe. London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine;2006 85
Similar documents
View Dr. Greenbaum`s PowerPoint presentation.
Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children in New York City, Volume One, The CSEC Population in New York City: Size, Characteristics, and Needs Final report submitted to the National Institute of J...
More information