TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD
Transcription
TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD
TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD COUNCIL AGENDA November 2, 2015 "Inspire confidence, wonder and a sense of possibility – deliver today’s services and realize tomorrow’s promise." A meeting of Council will be held Monday, November 2, 2015 in the Council Chambers, Town Hall, Collingwood commencing at 5:00 p.m. ORDER OF BUSINESS 1. CALL OF COUNCIL TO ORDER 2. ADOPTION OF AGENDA THAT the content of the Council Agenda for November 2, 2015 be adopted as presented. 3. DECLARATIONS OF PECUNIARY INTEREST 4. a) ADOPTION OF MINUTES, Regular meeting of Council held October 19, 2015. (p.5) (errors & omissions) b) BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE PREVIOUS MINUTES 5. COMMUNITY ANNOUNCEMENTS 6. DEPUTATION Role and initiatives of Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC), Rebecca Webb, Regional Manager, Municipal and Stakeholder Relations, Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC) Thurst-T’s Cycle, Collingwood Hearing Clinic and residents re: Parking concerns on Elliot Avenue and Highway 26, Paul Thurston, Len Vermulen and Robert Mulhall 7. CONSENT AGENDA General Consent Items A.1 Ontario Good Roads Association re: Board of Directors nominations due: November 6, 2015 (p.11) A.2 Highlights of the NVCA Board of Directors Meeting No. 10-15 – October 23, 2015 (p.15) A.3 Ministry of Economic Development Employment and Infrastructure re: David C. Onley Award for Leadership in Accessibility. Deadline for nominations: December 3, 2015 (p.17) A.4 L. Jeffrey, Head Coach, Special Olympics Collingwood – Thank you re: Generous donation (p.21) A.5 K. Currie, Vice President, Ontario Federation of Agriculture re: Backyard chickens (p.22) A.6 Hon. Randy Pettapiece, MPP Perth-Wellington re: Resolution for Fairness in Provincial Infrastructure Funds (p.24) 8. REPORTS/MINUTES OF OTHER COMMITTEES/BOARDS 9. STANDING COMMITTEE REPORTS 9.1 ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES STANDING COMMITTEE – OCTOBER 20, 2015 STAFF REPORTS Town of Collingwood Water - Ontario Regulation 453/07 Financial Plan THAT Council approve the Watson & Associates Water Regulation 453/07 Financial Plan as presented. November 2, 2015 Council Agenda - Page 1 of 4 1 of 212 ES2015-10-C Water Turn On/Offs (p.27) THAT Council receive Staff Report ES2015-10-C, and further authorize proceeding with implementation of fix water and sewer charges while curb stops are turned off, in accordance with By-law 2015-58, section 6.13, effective immediately. ES2015-11-C Back Up Generator Repairs – Wastewater Treatment Plant (p.30) THAT Council receive Staff Report ES2015-11-C entitled “Back Up Generator Repairs – Wastewater Treatment Plant” for information. PW2015-19-C Award of Contract for Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program (p.33) THAT Council receives Staff Report PW2015-19-C to award the RFP PW2015-09 entitled “Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program” and award the RFP to C.C. Tatham & Associates for the total cost of $300,703.15 plus HST which includes a 15% contingency. STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT – ENV2015-03 THAT Council receive Environmental Services Standing Committee Report ENV2015-03 from its meeting held October 20, 2015, as presented. (p.37) 9.2 DEVELOPMENT & OPERATIONS SERVICES STANDING COMMITTEE – OCTOBER 26, 2015 REPORTS/MINUTES OF OTHER COMMITTEES/BOARDS THAT the BIA Board of Management minutes of October 1, 2015 and the Collingwood Heritage Committee minutes of October 7, 2015 be hereby received. (p.40) STAFF REPORTS C2015-25-C Parking By-law Amendments (p.49) THAT Council enact and pass an amending By-law for Parking By-law No. 2003-062 to prohibit parking in Town laneways and to amend Schedule “A” to include additional no parking zones; and further that the proposed parking restriction for Elliot Avenue be restricted to one side of the street. (Staff original recommendation was to restrict parking on both sides of Elliot Avenue) THAT By-law No. 2015-093, being a by-law to amend By-law No. 03-62 for the regulation of parking within the Town of Collingwood, be enacted and passed this 2nd day of November, 2015. (p.53) P2015-31-C Extension of Draft Approval for Plan of Subdivision Mountaincroft (D1202615) (p.57) THAT Council extends the draft approval for the proposed Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision for a further year (January 11th, 2017). P2015-32-C Extension of Draft Approval for Plan of Subdivision Mair Mills Villages (D1202515) (p.68) THAT Council extends the draft approval for the proposed Mair Mills Villages Plan of Subdivision for a further three (3) years (April 29th, 2019). November 2, 2015 Council Agenda - Page 2 of 4 2 of 212 P2015-33-C Proposed Land Sale – 507 Ontario Street (p.82) THAT Council hereby declares a portion of town lands adjacent to 507 Ontario Street as surplus to the needs of the municipality and directs Staff to provide the required notice to sell the subject properties in accordance with the Town’s Land Sale and Notice By-laws. P2015-34-C Backyard Chickens in the Town of Collingwood (p.85) THAT Council authorize the initiation of an application for Official Plan and Zoning By-law amendments and the required public consultation process and allow a moratorium of enforcement for existing properties with backyard chickens, limiting the moratorium to a maximum of four hens. PW2015-26-C Award of RFP PW2015-07 – Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting (p.112) THAT Council receive Staff Report PW2015-26-C entitled “Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting” and award the RFP to RealTerm Energy with a total cost of $1,475,617.99 plus HST; AND THAT Council authorize the use of County of Simcoe Landfill Settlement monies to fund the LED street light retrofit project. PW2015-28-C Adoption of the Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy and Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments (p.122) THAT Council receive Staff Report PW2015-28-C entitled “Adoption of The Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy and Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments”; AND THAT Council adopts the Town of Collingwood Winter Control Plan dated October 16, 2015; AND THAT Council amends By-Law 2010-056 to include O.Reg 47/13, amendments to the Minimum Maintenance Standards for Municipal Highways. THAT By-law No. 2015-094 being a by-law to amend by-law 2010-056 A by-law to adopt Ontario Regulation 239/02, as amended, being the minimum maintenance standards for the roads within the Town of Collingwood, be enacted and passed this 2nd day of November, 2015. (p.154) STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT – DEVT2015-10 THAT Council receive Development and Operations Services Standing Committee Report DEVT2015-10 from its meeting held October 26, 2015, as presented. (p.159) 10. STAFF REPORTS 2014 Audited Financial Statements Presentation (p.165), Sue Bragg, Collins Barrow THAT Council hereby approve the 2014 Audited Financial Statements. PRC2015-28-C Updating Motorized Snow Vehicles Bylaw (p.195) (Staff report approved by Council October 19, 2015) THAT Council receive Staff Report PRC2015-29-C Updating Motorized Snow Vehicles Bylaw; AND THAT Council enact and pass a by-law to amend By-law No. 2008-164, being a by-law to regulate and govern the use of motorized snow vehicles within the Town of Collingwood, to prescribe the rate of speed a snow vehicle may travel while using municipal trails not designated November 2, 2015 Council Agenda - Page 3 of 4 3 of 212 as official OFSC trails to a maximum 20 km/hr, and to amend Schedule B to reflect changes to the permitted municipal trail locations described herein. 11. THAT By-law No. 2015-095, being a by-law to amend the permitted municipal trail locations and speed limits for motorized snow vehicles within the Town of Collingwood, be enacted and passed this 2nd day of November, 2015. (p.210) MOTIONS THAT Council appoint Councillor Doherty to the NVCA Board of Directors. THAT this Council proceeds in camera in order to address a matter pertaining to: security of the property of the municipality or local board; a proposed or pending acquisition or disposition of land for municipal or local board purposes; Items for Discussion: Proposed property acquisition 12. BY-LAWS 13. NOTICE OF MOTION 14. COUNTY REPORT 15. OLD or DEFERRED BUSINESS 16. OTHER BUSINESS Update re: Collingwood Animal Rights Advocate Group 17. CONFIRMATORY BY-LAW THAT By-law No. 2015-096, being a by-law to confirm the proceedings of the regular meeting of Council held November 2nd, 2015, be enacted and passed this 2nd day of November, 2015. (p.212) 18. ADJOURNMENT *Presentations using electronic devices must be submitted to Clerk Services 48 hours prior to the scheduled meeting. After this deadline, electronic presentations will not be permitted. November 2, 2015 Council Agenda - Page 4 of 4 4 of 212 TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD COUNCIL MINUTES October 19, 2015 "Inspire confidence, wonder and a sense of possibility – deliver today’s services and realize tomorrow’s promise." A meeting of Council was held Monday October 19, 2015 in the Council Chambers, Town Hall, Collingwood commencing at 5:00pm. DEPUTY MAYOR SAUNDERSON CALLED COUNCIL TO ORDER Members of Council Present: Staff Present: Mayor Sandra Cooper (regrets) Deputy Mayor Brian Saunderson Councillor Tim Fryer Councillor Mike Edwards Councillor Cam Ecclestone Councillor Kathy Jeffery Councillor Deb Doherty Councillor Madigan Councillor Lloyd John Brown, CAO Sara Almas, Clerk Marjory Leonard, Treasurer Nancy Farrer, Director of Planning Services Dean Collver, Director of Parks, Recreation and Culture Brian MacDonald, Director of Public Works and Engineering Services Jennett Mays, Communications Officer Melissa McCuaig, Human Resources Manager ADOPTION OF AGENDA No. 444-15 Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone THAT the content of the Council Agenda for October 19, 2015 be adopted as amended. CARRIED DECLARATIONS OF PECUNIARY INTEREST Deputy Mayor Saunderson declared a pecuniary interest with Staff Report PRC2015-32 as it’s a client of his firms. ADOPTION OF MINUTES No. 445-15 Moved by Councillor Edwards Seconded by Councillor Fryer THAT the minutes of the regular meeting of Council held October 5, 2015, be approved as presented. CARRIED BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE PREVIOUS MINUTES - Nil October 19, 2015 Council Minutes - Page 1 of 6 5 of 212 COMMUNITY ANNOUNCEMENTS Council reported on various community events they had attended and announced upcoming events. DEPUTATIONS - Nil PUBLIC MEETING Deputy Mayor Saunderson welcomed those in attendance and introduced the Public Meeting format. Clerk Sara Almas confirmed notices for all the public planning meetings being heard this evening were provided in accordance with the Planning Act. Notice was provided on September 25, 2015. Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment (Town wide) Trevor Houghton, Senior Planner provided a detailed review of the proposed amendment to modifications to the Collingwood Zoning By-law, as amended. The Collingwood Zoning By-law was approved by Council on April 12th, 2010. The Collingwood Zoning By-law is a land-use planning document that applies to all land within the boundaries of the municipality and contains a wide range of regulations such as; The control of the location and use of buildings including height, bulk, location and size, The protection of natural features and sensitive or vulnerable areas, The requirement to provide loading or parking facilities, The minimum and maximum density permitted on land, To prohibit the use of land subject to the availability of municipal services, and The use of maps to indicate what zone classification is applicable on land. THE PURPOSE AND EFFECT of the proposed Amendment is to delete, revise or insert regulations and provisions of the Collingwood Zoning By-law. The Collingwood Zoning By-law was last updated in July 2013. As this proposed Amendment may result in modifications throughout the Collingwood Zoning Bylaw no key map has been included with this Notice. Deputy Mayor Saunderson called three times for comments from the public. Don Ellis, 48 Highlands expressed concern with the C1-7 Zone, suggesting it needs clarification on what “Illustration 7b” is and why it needs to be changed. Trevor Houghton, Senior Planner noted that the C17 zone is relative to the Admiral Collingwood Development and that the approved building height and setbacks of that zone where not being changed, just that “Illustration 7b” was being relabeled to “Illustration 10”. Mr. Ellis questioned if the Zoning By-law was being changed regarding any property density. Nancy Farrer, Director of Planning Services confirmed density is not being discussed in this review. Deputy Mayor Saunderson called for the last time for comments from the public. No further comments were presented. The public meeting closed at 5:46p.m. Trevor Houghton, Senior Planner addressed questions from Council with respect to height provisions, and regulations regarding “snout houses”, and marina parking. CONSENT AGENDA No. 446-15 Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Fryer THAT the General Consent Agenda, having been given due consideration by Council, be received. General Consent Items A.1 NVCA Draft Budget Booklet October 19, 2015 Council Minutes - Page 2 of 6 6 of 212 A.2 A.3 A.4 A.5 A.6 Ministry of Tourism, Culture & Sport re: Culture Talks – Ontario’s First Culture Strategy Town of Parry Sound re: AMO’s Call to Action – Syrian Refugees Local Initiative - South Georgian Bay Community Cook Book Ministry of Citizenship, Immigration and International Trade re: June Calwood Outstanding Achievement Award for Volunteerism in Ontario. Deadline for nominations: December 5, 2015 T. Chatterson, Owner, Home Furniture re: Request to remove Trees at his expense CARRIED No. 447-15 Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Fryer THAT Council refer Consent Item A.6 regarding Home Furniture Collingwood’s request to remove and replant five spruce trees to a location of the Town’s choice at their expense, to staff and report back to Council. CARRIED REPORTS/MINUTES OF OTHER COMMITTEES/BOARDS - Nil STANDING COMMITTEE REPORTS COMMUNITY SERVICES STANDING COMMITTEE – OCTOBER 8, 2015 REPORTS/MINUTES OF OTHER COMMITTEES/BOARDS No. 448-15 Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Madigan THAT the minutes of the Trails Advisory Committee held August 13 and September 10, 2015 and Museum Advisory Committee held September 17, 2015 be received. CARRIED STAFF REPORTS PRC2015-29-C No. 449-15 2015 Collingwood Elvis Festival Report Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Madigan THAT Council receive Staff Report PRC2015-29-C titled Collingwood Elvis Festival Annual Review, and approve continuation of the three-year planning commitment to the Collingwood Elvis Festival that was approved in February 2015. CARRIED PRC2015-30-C No. 450-15 2015 Collingwood Sailing School Report Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Madigan THAT Council receive Staff Report PRC2015-30-C titled Collingwood Sailing School Report for information. CARRIED October 19, 2015 Council Minutes - Page 3 of 6 7 of 212 PRC2015-31-C No. 451-15 Jazz at the Station Support Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Doherty THAT Council receive Staff Report PRC2015-31-C and approve the transfer of $2500 from the Marketing and Business Development annual budget to the annual budget for Parks, Recreation, and Culture; AND FURTHER THAT Council endorse the commitment of these funds to Jazz at the Station for the 2016, 2017, and 2018 time frame in addition to the existing in-kind support that is currently provided by the department of Parks, Recreation, and Culture. Current in-kind support has averaged approximately $2000 in value over the past several years. CARRIED Deputy Mayor Saunderson left the meeting during the below discussion and vote with respect to his previously declared conflict of interest. Councillor Fryer assumed the Chair. PRC2015-32-C No. 452-15 Award RFQ Trail Resurfacing (Train Trail) Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Doherty THAT Council receive Staff Report PRC2015-32-C regarding RFQ PRC2015-16 to resurface approximately 930 metres of the Train Trail, and that Council award the contract to Dale Ottewell Construction for the total cost of $29,680.20 which includes a 10% contingency allowance. CARRIED Deputy Mayor Saunderson resumed the Chair. STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT – COMM2015-09 No. 453-15 Moved by Councillor Fryer Seconded by Councillor Doherty THAT Council receive the Community Services Standing Committee Report COMM2015-09 from the meeting held October 8, 2015, as presented. CARRIED STAFF REPORTS C2015-22-C Revision to the Integrated Accessibility Standard Regulation Policy No. 454-15 Moved by Councillor Edwards Seconded by Councillor Lloyd THAT Council receive Staff Report C2015-22-C, and approve the amendment to Section 4.1.5 titled “Training” of the Integrated Accessibility Standards Regulation (IASR) Policy described herein. CARRIED C2015-23-C Syrian Refugee Crisis Support No. 455-15 Moved by Councillor Doherty October 19, 2015 Council Minutes - Page 4 of 6 8 of 212 Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone THAT Council receive Staff Report C2015-23-C, and support the recommendations contained herein in an effort to provide support for the Syrian Humanitarian efforts through the Association of Municipalities of Ontario and to the local Syrian Sponsorship Community Group; AND FURTHER THAT Council petition and encourage all Ontario and Canadian municipalities to support local, provincial and federal Syrian humanitarian initiatives as deemed appropriate within their sphere of jurisdiction. CARRIED MOTIONS No. 456-15 Moved by Councillor Madigan Seconded by Councillor Lloyd THAT this Council proceeds in camera in order to address a matter pertaining to: security of the property of the municipality or local board; litigation or potential litigation, including matters before administrative tribunals, affecting the municipality or local board; a proposed or pending acquisition or disposition of land by the municipality or local board. Items for discussion: Airport, Potential Property Acquisition CARRIED No. 457-15 Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Fryer WHEREAS public libraries provide residents with a community space where they can freely access a wide variety of information in both print and digital format; AND WHEREAS municipal governments are key funders of public libraries, appoint public library boards and work in partnership with public library boards to deliver library services that are responsive to community needs; AND WHEREAS electronic books (e-books) are becoming an increasingly preferred medium for library users to access content and information; AND WHEREAS major multi-national publishers are charging public libraries significantly higher costs to purchase e-books for their collections than they charge consumers; AND WHEREAS imposing unreasonably high costs on public libraries to purchase e-books is not an appropriate solution to the publishing industry’s concerns regarding the evolution of digital technology, including piracy; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Town of Collingwood requests the Minister of Tourism, Culture and Sport work with the federal and the other provincial and territorial governments to find a solution that will allow public libraries to purchase e-books from publishers at a fair and reasonable price and that a copy of this resolution be sent to the Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM) and the Association of Municipalities of Ontario (AMO). CARRIED BY-LAWS - Nil NOTICE OF MOTION - Nil OLD or DEFERRED BUSINESS - Nil October 19, 2015 Council Minutes - Page 5 of 6 9 of 212 OTHER BUSINESS Council proceeded to in-camera session as previously resolved. (6:43p.m.) Moved by Councillor Jeffery Seconded by Councillor Doherty THAT Council rise from in-camera and return to public session. (8:20p.m.) CARRIED Councillor Jeffery withdrew the motion with respect to redesignating lands to permit a hospital and related uses until further information is available pertaining to the Hospital expansion/relocation. CONFIRMATORY BY-LAW No. 458-15 Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone THAT By-law No. 2015-092, being a by-law to confirm the proceedings of the regular meeting of Council held October 19, 2015, be enacted and passed this 19th day of October, 2015. CARRIED ADJOURNMENT Moved by Councillor Jeffery THAT the meeting of Council be hereby adjourned at 8:22p.m. CARRIED _______________________ MAYOR _______________________ CLERK October 19, 2015 Council Minutes - Page 6 of 6 10 of 212 A.1 11 of 212 12 of 212 13 of 212 14 of 212 A.2 HIGHLIGHTS of the NVCA BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING No. 10-15 – October 23, 2015 Reduced board size governance transition plan approved The board approved, for implementation in January 2016, a governance transition plan which outlines transition steps, responsibilities and timelines for the board reduction pilot project. At their September 2015 meeting, the board approved a one-year pilot project that will see the membership go from 27 to 18 members in 2016. The pilot project requires the support of all 18 member municipalities. The CAO and Chair will visit those municipalities who request a deputation regarding the pilot project. The Minister of Natural Resources and Forestry supports the NVCA in an application for leave to the Court of Appeal for Ontario NVCA submitted an Application for Leave with respect to a Superior Court decision naming the NVCA as the respondent/moving party. The Minister of Natural Resources and Forestry has agreed to provide financial assistance for the leave application and, if the leave is granted, seek support for Crown intervention. In brief During this meeting, the board also: Recognized staff for their professional accomplishments in instructing and liaising with their peers. Received a presentation from NVCA Solicitor Ken Hill of Hill Hunter Losell about board member roles, responsibilities and liability, with respect to Section 28 Hearings under the Conservation Authorities Act. Thanked the Township of Adjala-Tosorontio for their funding support for the Pine River Fisheries Enhancement Plan and Phosphorus Reduction Strategy. Received the third quarter budget status report. NVCA Board Meeting Highlights No 10-15 – October 23, 2015 15 of 212 1 of 2 For more information D. Gayle Wood, CAO, gwood@nvca.on.ca, 705-424-1479 ext. 225 For the full meeting agenda including documents and reports, visit the NVCA website at nvca.on.ca/about/boardofdirectors. Future meetings & events Nature at Night – Family Event October 29, 6 to 9 pm Tiffin Centre for Conservation, Utopia Day of the Living Stakes – Volunteer Work Day October 30, 9:30 am to 3 pm Minesing Conservation Area (with Nature Conservancy of Canada) Nature Days for Homeschoolers November 13, 10 am to 3 pm, Tiffin Conservation Area, Utopia (New education program for homeschooling families) Latornell Conservation Symposium November 17-19 Alliston Hunting Lottery Open House October 31 & November 1, 9 to 11 am Township of Springwater NVCA Board of Directors Meeting November 27, 9 am to 12 pm Tiffin Centre for Conservation, Utopia Friends of Minesing Wetlands AGM and Curling FunSpiel November 7, 6:30 to 11:30 pm Stroud Curling Club Caring for your Horse and Farm Workshop November 28, 10:30 am to 2:30 pm Cookstown Public Library Adopt-A-Stream Habitat Restoration Workshop November 12, 7 to 9 pm Tiffin Centre for Conservation, Utopia (with Ontario Streams) Caring for your Horse and Farm Workshop December 5, 10:30 am to 2:30 pm Mel Lloyd Centre, Shelburne Reminder – Planning Fee Review, 2015 – Public Comment NVCA’s planning fees are under review to consider their effectiveness and fairness. Members of the public are invited to comment on the fees as part of the review process. NVCA has created a short survey (www.nvca.on.ca/planning-permits/planning-feereview) to gather these comments. The results of the survey, along with the feedback from the fee review stakeholder subcommittee, will be incorporated into a draft fee schedule. NVCA anticipates circulating this draft schedule to municipal planning staff for their comment in late fall. NVCA Board Meeting Highlights No 10-15 – October 23, 2015 16 of 212 2 of 2 A.3 17 of 212 18 of 212 19 of 212 20 of 212 A.4 21 of 212 A.5 October 28, 2015 Mayor Sandra Cooper Town of Collingwood 97 Hurontario St., P.O. Box 157, Collingwood, Ontario L9Y 3Z5 Dear Mayor Cooper Thanks so much for the quick conversation a few weeks ago at Queen’s Park. As you know I was interested in a media story pertaining to the Garbutt family and the raising of back yard chickens. As an 8th generation farmer in the area(west of Nottawa, Clearview township) and more importantly, Vice President of the Ontario Federation of Agriculture, an organization who represents 37,000 farm families across the province, I expressed to you some concerns with this story, more specifically about citizens wishing to raise poultry in their back yards. While I applaud those who wish to take on this type of initiative as it(farm animal husbandry) adds a sense of value for people who may not otherwise have such opportunity, I would like to caution you and your council on the unintended consequences that may arise from such a venture. Agriculture in this province is leading edge and has some of the best producers/farms in the world. We have attained this claim through continuous improvements in food production standards, including biosecurity measures that are second to none. The supply management sector(which includes poultry) has been particularly diligent in this area and are world leaders in setting the standard(s) to be followed. As I mentioned to you in our conversation, my particular concern with the backyard chicken issue is amongst others, the concern around the very highly contagious Avian Influenza(HPAI H5). HPAI H5 viruses infect the respiratory and gastrointestinal tracts of birds, can spread rapidly, and cause high mortality in infected poultry. Ontario has just recently come through a devastating Avian Influenza outbreak this past spring/summer in which a quarter of a million birds had to be destroyed and a number of farms still remaining under quarantine, ultimately leaving these birds unmarketable due to not being able to reach market in a timely fashion. All of which have had devastating financial effects on the producers and their families caught in this outbreak. Avian Influenza is most commonly transferred by wild birds, particularly waterfowl. While the viruses often do not cause illness in waterfowl the effects on domestic poultry(chickens, turkey and pheasants) can be devastating. Although wild birds always pose a risk of disease to domestic poultry, past surveillance has identified the highest prevalence of influenza virus to be in younger migratory waterfowl in the fall (August – November) as they congregate in feeding and staging areas prior to and during migration. Massive movement of wild birds during migration increases the risk of potential Avian Influenza virus in poultry farms. The virus can be spread to domestic poultry through direct contact with wild birds or their droppings and secretions. With cooler and damper fall weather, the virus can survive 22 of 212 for longer periods in the environment, which increases the risk of transmission. This disease can also be spread by humans through contact with contaminated surfaces and droppings, and the improper protocols not being followed in cleaning themselves, clothing and footwear prior contact with domestic birds. It is also believed that some strains of the virus could potentially be carried airborne as well. Given the geographic location of the Town of Collingwood(on Georgian Bay), this only increases, in my mind, the potential opportunity for the avian influenza virus to be potentially spread. Being home to many species of migratory birds and many waterfowl species, exposure to this virus by both birds and humans is extremely high! While I applaud and admire the Garbutt family for their want to be responsible pet owners and seizing the opportunity to raise farm animals, keep in mind that farming is more than just an occupation but is in fact a profession, one that requires training, certification and in the case of poultry production, very regimented and strict biosecurity protocols put in place by both government and the commodities themselves. These rules are put in place to best protect themselves and their livestock from such diseases like avian influenza along with many others, that can/could ultimately financially wipeout a business. Beyond avian influenza, there is a multitude of other concerns. Backyard hens are especially vulnerable to predation. Dogs, cats, snakes, coyotes, wolves, hawks, raccoons are all natural predators and while the loss of these animals may be devastating to the owners proper removal and destructing of the carcasses if this occurs is vitally important. The farm community is continuously under attack from activists who think they are more knowledgeable on animal husbandry than those who raise them. This type of experience can be far more devastating than the loss of an animal through predation or disease. Is the family prepared for a visit from OSPCA? Is the family aware that humans can contract avian influenza? I am not trying to fear monger with these comments, but to make you and your council aware of some of the negatives surrounding these types of requests made by your ratepayers. Decisions by municipal councils on these types of matters are never easy. The good news story like Declan and Brodie Garbutt tugs on our human emotions. Having society have a better understanding of what I do and what agriculture is all about has been a life- long goal of mine. However as a council I ask that you take the time to consider the potential ramifications any decision on this matter. I would respectfully ask that the raising of livestock be left in the hands of those who do it for a living. Sincerely, Keith Currie Vice President Ontario Federation of Agriculture 23 of 212 A.6 24 of 212 25 of 212 26 of 212 STAFF REPORT Report #ES2015-10-C Reviewed by Environmental Services Standing Committee on October 20, 2015 Recommendation: The report proceed to Council Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Peggy Slama, Chief Operating Officer (Acting) and Manager of Water Services Subject: Water Turn On/Offs PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to provide Council with information on the historical practice of allowing customers to turn off water services, while being exempt from the water and sewer fixed monthly charge, in order that it may recommend that staff cease this practice effective immediately. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Staff Report ES2015-10-C, and further authorize proceeding with the implementation of fixed monthly water and sewer charges while curb stops are turned off, in accordance with By-law 2015-58. 1. BACKGROUND As per Section 6.13 of the Water By-law, customers may request their curb stop be turned off by Water Department/Operators while they are not occupying a premise. This is done to protect their property from potential leaks while the home is left unoccupied. The turn-off is completed for a fee of $43.00 as per the 2015 Water Fees and Service Charges. Operators follow a Standard Operating Procedure to complete this work. -1- 27 of 212 For some time now, it has been a practice to not charge the fixed monthly fees for the duration of the service shutoff. The customer will incur the shutoff fee but has been exempt from the monthly fixed portion of their bill. The practice of not charging a fixed monthly fee was discussed by the CPUSB in 2014 however a decision was not reached and the policy remained under review. The Water By-law was amended in 2015 and the provision to charge fixed monthly fees when a service is turned off was included; as it was in the previous By-law. Staff are asking for a clear direction from the Committee to proceed with the intent of the By-law and charge the fixed monthly portion of the water and sewer bill during any customer initiated turnoff in accordance with the by-law. In 2014, the Water Department turned curb stops on 159 occasions for a variety of reasons including the completion of internal plumbing work, rental properties being vacant between tenants, as well as customers leaving their property vacant for a season while they leave Collingwood. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES This matter has been discussed extensively with all involved departments; billing and finance, water operators and water administration. Information has been obtained from neighboring municipalities including Town of the Blue Mountains, Wasaga Beach, Clearview and Barrie, all of which have a large population of seasonal customers. In all instances, none of the surveyed municipalities provide an exemption from fixed monthly charges. Department Heads reviewed this report at their regular meeting on Tuesday October 13, 2015 and the report was recommended to proceed to the Environmental Services Standing Committee. The report was reviewed by the Environmental Services Standing Committee on October 20th, 2015 and recommended to proceed to Council for approval. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION Section 6.13 of the Water By-law states: “… The owner or occupant may apply in writing to Collingwood Public Utilities to have the shut-off valve turned off to stop water supply. The valve will be turned on only at the owner‘s request and in the owner‘s presence. The owner shall pay for this service at the rate as indicated in the current Town‘s Fees and Service Charges By-Law. The owner will continue to be responsible for the fixed monthly charges as indicated in the current Town‘s Fees and Service Charges By-Law. 4. ANALYSIS The fixed monthly service charges, as dictated by the Water and Wastewater Rate Study, account for the basic costs to provide the service, regardless of volume. This -2- 28 of 212 basic cost includes the maintenance of water and wastewater infrastructure, including treatment facilities. The Rate Study looks at the total number of service connections to determine fixed monthly charges, not the number of services with curb stops in the ‘on’ position. A fixed monthly rate is intended to support the fixed cost regardless if the service is used or not. Waving this fee for approximately 100 residents annually is being absorbed by the remainder of the customer base and is unfair to other users. When a curbstop is turned off water is still available in Town owned watermains for other uses which a customer has the benefit of, such as firefighting. It should also be noted that customers who experienced water interruptions for prolonged periods, such as frozen services, were not exempt from their fixed rates. If Council accepts this recommendation and fixed monthly rates are applied, it is expected that we will receive fewer requests to complete turnoffs. A curb stop is a connection point and should be used for emergency purposes only. Continual operation as an isolation valve can cause damage, resulting in emergency repairs and leaks that would not normally occur. These repairs are fixed at 100% cost to the Utility. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES Using 2014 as an example, we can expect to see revenues of more than $32,461.00 per year by enforcing the By-law and not allowing exemptions from fixed monthly rates. It should be noted that we did collect $6837.00 in 2014 from the $43.00 Fees and Services Charge. Presumably this revenue would decrease if Council agrees to support this recommendation, as fewer residents would request this service if there are no fixed charges savings. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Resource 1 Water By-law No. 2015-058 SIGNATURES Submitted by: Peggy Slama Chief Operating Officer (Acting) Manager of Water Services Town of Collingwood Department head: Brian MacDonald Director of Engineering Town of Collingwood -3- 29 of 212 STAFF REPORT Report #ES2015-11-C Reviewed by Environmental Services Standing Committee on October 20, 2015 Recommendation: The report proceed to Council Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Peggy Slama, Chief Operating Officer (Acting) and Manager of Water Services Subject: Back Up Generator Repairs – Wastewater Treatment Plant PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to provide Council with information on an emergency repair to the backup diesel generator which has been completed at the Wastewater Treatment plant. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Staff Report ES2015-11 entitled “Back Up Generator Repairs – Wastewater Treatment Plant” for information. 1. BACKGROUND Backup power at the Wastewater Treatment plant is provided through a Detroit Diesel 800kWa backup generator. This piece of equipment is named in the Certificate of Approval and is essential to the safe operation of the plant. It is also considered vital to the Emergency Response Plan. Through a competitive bid process, Toromont Cat has been contracted to conduct annual preventative maintenance in accordance with CAN/CSA-232-a-M86 & CSAC282, as well as manufacturer’s recommendations, on all generators in water and -1- 30 of 212 wastewater facilities in 2015 and 2016. During the inspection on July 13, 2015 at the Wastewater Treatment plant, major leaks were discovered on all cylinder heads which needed to be repaired immediately. This work was deemed necessary to ensure the reliability of the wastewater treatment system and safety of the Operators. Staff obtained a quotation from Toromont Cat and authorized the work to be complete. Repairs were completed over a ten week period, during which time a replacement generator was rented. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES Department Heads reviewed this report at their regular meeting on Tuesday October 13, 2015 and the report was recommended to proceed to the Environmental Services Standing Committee. The report was reviewed by the Environmental Services Standing Committee on October 20th, 2015 and recommended to proceed to Council for approval. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION • • • Bylaw No. 2006-42: A By-Law to Provide for the Purchase of Goods and Services Section 6.7 pertaining to Emergency Purchasing Procedures Certificate of Approval MOECC Bypass Guidelines 4. ANALYSIS In the event of power loss without a backup generator, the influent pumps would cease to work resulting in customers’ sewers backing up within 30 minutes. No power would also mean no aeration, no circulation of the wastewater in the tankage and no UV disinfection. Wastewater would flow through the plant hydraulically, with minimal treatment, within 6 hours. This situation would be similar to a plant by-pass; meaning discharge from the plant would enter Georgian Bay without treatment. This is a nonconforming adverse condition that the MOECC deems a high risk environmental aspect. Had the leaks not been found during routine maintenance, a complete breakdown of the generator would have been imminent. This would have resulted not only in a $500,000 replacement cost of the equipment, but at least a year of rental costs totaling $213,200 as this generator is not readily available. Staff authorized Toromont Cat to complete the work by following the Emergency Purchasing Procedure. As such, we are providing Council with this information report. Staff will be recommending a complete replacement of the generator at the Wastewater Treatment plant as part of the 2019 budget. -2- 31 of 212 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES The repairs totaled $77,372.72 while the rental generator cost will be approximately $41,000.00. Wastewater Treatment has a ‘Major/Emergency Repair’ balance of $60,000.00. The remainder of the monies will come from surplus within the 2015 operating budget; which is primarily the result of significant changes to processes which have drastically reduced costs allocated to ‘Chemicals’. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES N/A Submitted by: Peggy Slama Chief Operating Officer (Acting) Manager of Water Services Town of Collingwood Department head: Brian MacDonald Director of Engineering Town of Collingwood -3- 32 of 212 STAFF REPORT Report PW2015-19 Reviewed by Environmental Services Standing Committee on October 13th, 2015 Recommendation: Forward report to Council Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Brian MacDonald, Director of Public Works and Engineering Subject: Award of Contract for Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to present the Request for Proposal results and award the contract for Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program. RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receives Staff Report PW2015-19 to award the RFP PW2015-09 entitled “Engineerng and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program”; and THAT Council awards the RFP to C.C. Tatham & Associates for the total cost of $300,703.15 plus HST which includes a 15% contingency. 1. BACKGROUND The Engineering Department called for proposals for engineering services for the Sanitary Sewer Renewal Program. This is the next phase in the Town’s long term sanitary sewer renewal program. As Council may be aware the Town recently completed the three year Phase 2 of the program. This was a three year program where the Town completed between $1 to $2 million worth of sewer related work each year. In this next three year phase, Engineering is proposing a less aggressive program of between $1.0 and $1.2 million of work each year. Engineering Services has reviewed and prioritized the streets for the next phase of the program. The consultant will assist the Town in the rehabilitation of sanitary sewers as outlined in the proposal. Due to the nature of the work and associated excavations, water main replacement and road reconstruction will form part of the work. The following streets have been identified for renewal: -1- 33 of 212 Year 1 East Street - Ontario Street to Simcoe Street. West Street - Ontario Street to Simcoe Street Niagara St. - Huron Street to Simcoe Street Year 2 Seventh Street - Birch Street to Hurontario Street Year 3 Eighth Street - Birch Street to Hurontario Street Request for Proposals (RFP) No. RFP2015-09 for Engineering and Consulting Services was issued on August 24, 2015. The opportunity was by invitation only and was circulated to 5 local firms. There were four (4) submissions received by the Closing Date of September 11, 2015. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES Department Heads reviewed this report at their regular meeting on Tuesday, October 13, 2015, and the report was recommended to proceed to the Environmental Services Standing Committee meeting. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION Municipal Procurement Policy 2006-42 4. ANALYSIS The objective of this RFP was to seek proposals from Proponents that would provide the following services on behalf of the Town for the Sanitary Renewal Program project. - Detailed design - Agency approvals - Construction drawings and specifications - Project tender preparation - Contractor qualification - Assistance with tender administration - Project schedule and coordination - Construction supervision as required - Coordination with 3rd party consultants (geotechnical, utility, etc.) - Contract administration Evaluation and Recommendation of Consulting Services -2- 34 of 212 The four (4) submissions were evaluated by three (3) Staff members from the Engineering department. Pre-established technical criteria were used to rank the Proponent (40 points) and the Proposal (40 points) in the absence of Pricing information. The three (3) highest ranked firms then proceeded to the Pricing evaluation (20 points) to establish a final ranking. Below are the evaluation results: Proponent Points Before Pricing Rank Before Pricing Points Rank Including Including Pricing Pricing C.C. Tatham & Associates 72.7 1 92.0 1 Proponent No. 2 65.0 2 85.0 2 Proponent No. 3 65.0 2 84.7 3 The Pricing evaluation was based on a Lump Sum Consulting Fee for the project. The consensus of the Evaluation Team after the technical review was that only three (3) Pricing envelopes be opened for the highest ranked firms. The Lump Sum Consulting Fees provided were as follows. Proponent Lump Sum Consulting Fee 15% Contingency Total Cost C,C, Tatham & Associates $261,481.00 plus HST $39,222.15 $300,703.15 Proponent No. 2 $232,253.88 plus HST N/A N/A Proponent No. 3 $247,676.00 plus HST N/A N/A Staff recommends the inclusion of a 15% contingency on the Lump Sum Consulting Fee due to the potential for unforeseen circumstances in sewer projects of this nature. C.C. Tatham & Associates is a well established local firm with significant experience on projects in the Town of Collingwood and a vast resume of experience specific to similar projects. C.C. Tatham & Associates completed all prior phases of the project and are well versed in the Town’s requirements and potential challenges that can be expected. This prior experience, combined with a strong team, thorough understanding of the project, and innovative work program add value to the project that will more than compensate for the cost difference between the lower priced bids. The Evaluation Team recommends that C.C. Tatham & Associates be awarded the contract for the Sanitary Renewal Program project for the total cost of $300,703.15 plus HST. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES The Sanitary Renewal Program project is a budgeted capital expenditure for 2015. -3- 35 of 212 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES N/A SIGNATURES Submitted by: Trevor Harvey Project Coordinator Town of Collingwood Department Head: Brian MacDonald Director of Engineering Town of Collingwood -4- 36 of 212 ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT TO COUNCIL ENV2015-03 November 2 , 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Subject: October 20, 2015 Environmental Services Standing Committee Meeting RECOMMENDATION: That Council receive the Environmental Services Standing Committee Report from the meeting held October 20, 2015, as presented. 1. BACKGROUND Listed below are the actions resulting from the Environmental Services Standing Committee meeting held on October 20, 2015. They are before Council for consideration. 2. MEETING ATTENDANCE / ADOPTION OF AGENDA / BUSINESS ARISING Members of Council Present: Councillor Tim Fryer, Chair Deputy Mayor Brian Saunderson Councillor Cam Ecclestone Councillor Kathy Jeffery Councillor Deb Doherty Moved by Deputy Mayor Saunderson Seconded by Councillor Jeffery Resolution No. ENV2015-03-01 THAT the content of the Environmental Services Standing Committee Agenda for October 20, 2015 be adopted as presented. CARRIED BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE SEPTEMBER 21, 2015 MEETING Peggy Slama, COO provided a review of the difference between the Safe Water Drinking Act training that was provided to all of Council during orientation versus the training that was provided to the Committee at the last meeting with respect to Quality Management System.(QMS) Treasurer Leonard noted that she will report back at the next meeting regarding the form of financial reporting consistent with all Standing Committees. DECLARATION OF CONFLICT OR PECUNIARY INTEREST – Nil -1- 37 of 212 3. STAFF REPORTS Town of Collingwood Water - Ontario Regulation 453/07 Financial Plan, Watson & Associates Economists Ltd. Mr. Dan Wilson , Watson & Associates Economists Ltd. provided a detailed presentation on the Water Regulation 453/07 Financial Plan as part of the five submission requirements of obtaining a municipal drinking water licence as per the Safe Drinking Water Act, 2002. The report included sustainable financial planning, methodology, financial plan, process for provincial approval and recommendations. Mr. Wilson addressed questions from the Committee. Moved by Councillor Jeffery Seconded by Deputy Mayor Saunderson Resolution No. ENV2015-03-02 THAT the Environmental Services Standing Committee support and refer the Watson & Associates Water Regulation 453/07 Financial Plan to the next regular meeting of Council for consideration and approval. CARRIED ES2015-10 Water Turn On/Offs Purpose: To provide the Standing Committee with information on the historical practice of allowing customers to turn off water services, while being exempt from the water and sewer fixed charge, in order that it may recommend that Council cease this practice effective immediately Moved by Councillor Doherty Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone Resolution No. ENV2015-03-03 THAT the Environmental Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council receive Staff Report ES2015-10, and further authorize proceeding with implementation of fix water and sewer monthly charges while curb stops are turned off, in accordance with By-law 2015-58 section 6.13, effective immediately. CARRIED ES2015-11 Back Up Generator Repairs – Wastewater Treatment Plant Purpose: To provide the Standing Committee with information on an emergency repair to the backup diesel generator that has been completed at the Wastewater Treatment Plant. Moved by Deputy Mayor Saunderson Seconded by Councillor Jeffery Resolution No. ENV2015-03-04 THAT the Environmental Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council receive Staff Report ES2015-11 entitled “Back Up Generator Repairs – Wastewater Treatment Plant” for information. CARRIED PW2015-19 Award of Contract for Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program Purpose: To present the Request for Proposal results and award the contract for Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program. -2- 38 of 212 Jane Palmer, Greenland Engineering, addressed the Committee and expressed concern with the evaluation of the proposals. Steve Berman asked if this program is being reviewed with the new procurement by-law. Clerk Almas addressed Mr. Berman’s question and the importance of a transparent process and being open and accountable for the public to understand the rationale for decisions. The Standing Committee requested that Greenland Engineering be debriefed after the award of contract and this matter be reviewed in the new purchasing by-law. Moved by Deputy Mayor Saunderson Seconded by Councillor Jeffery Resolution No. ENV2015-03-05 THAT the Environmental Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council receives Staff Report PW2015-19 to award the RFP PW2015-09 entitled “Engineering and Consulting Services for the Sanitary Renewal Program” and award the RFP to C.C. Tatham & Associates for the total cost of $300,703.15 plus HST which includes a 15% contingency. CARRIED 4. DEPARTMENTAL UPDATES Staff provided an update to the Standing Committee on various initiatives and projects they are working on including: Water Agreement with Town of Blue Mountains: Peggy Slama provided an update on the status of the agreement and accounts with The Blue Mountains for water services. Chair Fryer left the meeting at 2:30pm. Vice Chair Doherty assumed the Chair. Peggy Slama provided an update regarding Frozen Services including the plan for preventing and addressing this matter should it occur in 2016. 5. PUBLIC DELEGATION(S) - Nil 6. OTHER BUSINESS - Nil 7. ADJOURNMENT Moved by Councillor Jeffery THAT the Environmental Services Standing Committee meeting adjourns at 2:51p.m. CARRIED -3- 39 of 212 Town of Collingwood Collingwood Downtown BIA Board of Management Minutes October 1, 2015 BOARD OF MANAGEMENT Bradley Green – Chair Charles Brand – Vice Chair Patricia Boyce - Regrets Michael Christie - Regrets David Conning Catherine Durrant Christine Evanoff - Regrets Penny Skelton Alex Yuen RESOURCE Susan Nicholson – BIA General Manager Martin Rydlo - Director of Marketing and Business Development - Regrets Monica Gal - Recording Secretary A meeting of the Downtown Collingwood Board of Management Business Improvement Area (BIA) was held on Thursday, October 1, 2015 at the hour of 7:30 a.m. in the Braniff Room, Town Hall, 97 Hurontario Street. WELCOME / CALL TO ORDER Chair Green welcomed all in attendance, determined that a quorum was present, then called the meeting to order at 7:36 a.m. ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA Moved by Board Member Brand Seconded by Board Member Yuen THAT the Collingwood Downtown Board of Management Business Improvement Area (BIA) adopts the October 1, 2015 Agenda as presented. CARRIED CONFIRMATION OF THE ADOPTION OF THE MINUTES THE September 3, 2015 Collingwood Downtown Board of Management Business Improvement Area (BIA) Minutes were adopted electronically and received by the Development & Operations Standing Committee at their September 28, 2015 meeting and would be received by Council at their October 5, 2015 meeting. DECLARATIONS OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST OR PECUNIARY INTEREST - Nil 40 of 212 BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE SEPTEMBER 3RD MEETING RED Project / Economic Development Strategy Mr. Rydlo sent regrets. The General Manager advised that the Director of Marketing and Business Development is preparing a Staff Report for the October 26th Development & Operations Standing Committee in which he will report on the findings of the BC Hughes and McSweeney & Associates studies as contained in the Draft ‘ Downtown Opportunities / Major Themes’ summary. The General Manager will circulate the PowerPoint version to the Board, with deadline for completion, so that they have the opportunity to comment and provide input. Board Visioning Session – Notes from August 31, 2015 session The Board will review and comment on Catherine Oosterbaan, Agriculture and Rural Economic Advisor’s notes and comment at the November meeting. Boundary Expansion The General Manager confirmed that as requested by the Board, the Town has begun the process to allow the Collingwood Downtown Business Improvement Area (BIA) into the area between Pine Street and Heritage Drive to the waterfront. The Property Owners List has been updated in advance of the official notice being mailed. Trip to Theatre Orangeville The Board discussed Theatre Collingwood’s proposal and request for ongoing financial contribution and determined that they would defer the request for budget deliberation. COMMITTEE REPORTS Invoices Paid The General Manager elaborated on the listed invoices. The Board having reviewed the list of invoices paid since the last meeting approved them as follows: Moved by Board Member Yuen Seconded by Board Member Conning THAT the Accounts Payable Vouchers of the BIA up to October 1, 2015 in the amount of $12, 327.77 be endorsed as presented. CARRIED Finance and Administration - Alex Yuen Treasurer Yuen and the Board reviewed the financials for the period ending September 3, 2015 and confirmed that the Board’s financial position is sound. Moved by Board Member Skelton Seconded by Board Member Yuen THAT the Collingwood Downtown BIA Board of Management accepts the Financial Statement for the period ending October 1, 2015 as presented. CARRIED Maintenance/Capital Expenditures - Michael Christie sent regrets The General Manager reported that she is trying to schedule the fall walkabout with town staff to inventory the status of the Downtown. October 1, 2015 Downtown Collingwood BIA Board of Management Meeting Minutes Page 2 of 4 41 of 212 Beautification/Decorating – Board Member Boyce sent regrets The General Manager reported that the fall décor is being installed by Parks staff. Parks staff’s wages for this work will be covered by the BIA. Banner changeover has been scheduled for immediately after Thanksgiving and then in time for Remembrance Day. The General Manager confirmed that some additional Christmas Décor will be purchased for the 2015 season. Storage space for the Street Pianos in preparation for the 2016 season has been secured. Communication - Charles Brand Communication Chair Brand reported that the September edition of the newsletter was emailed. The rate at which the newsletters are opened by the members has increased significantly. The Board suggested that the upcoming edition of the newsletter include an article which promotes the benefits of sponsoring the Ice Sculpture Event and encourages members to collaborate with neighbouring businesses to reduce costs. Promotions – Board Member Evanoff sent regrets The General Manager reported that planning for the Thanksgiving and Black Harvest events are completed. Planning continues for the Santa Claus Parade and Ice Sculpture events. Marketing - Dave Conning Marketing Chair Conning and the Board reviewed and provided input into the Draft Member Snapshot Feedback Survey. The Board commented positively on the layout of the cooperative advertisements in the fall edition of the On The Bay Magazine. The Board suggested that the BIA’s Facebook page be updated to allow for increased promotion of events. Marketing Chair Conning reported that the Directory has been sent to the printers for the final proofing. Sign up for the CTV Christmas cooperative advertising is going well. Parking and Bylaws Parking and By-laws Chair Skelton reported that she continues to work on the binder. Future Planning Penny Skelton / Charles Brand Future Planning Co-Chair Skelton reported that she is in the process of gathering information regarding costs for the renovations of the laneways in preparation for the 2016 budget. Marketing and Business Development – The Director of Marketing and Business Development sent regrets. General Manager - Susan Nicholson The General Manager reviewed her circulated report. COMMITTEE REPRESENTATIVE REPORTS Heritage Advisory Committee Board Member Durrant advised that the Committee will meet on the October 7th. Board Member Durrant suggested that the newsletter include mention that applications for the 2016 Heritage Grant are to be submitted by the end of February of 2016. CORRESPONDENCE SENT BY THE BIA GENERAL MANAGER SINCE THE AUGUST 6TH MEETING 1. 2. 3. 4. Media Release regarding The Tale of a Town Media Advisory regarding The Tale of a Town Member Newsletter – September 17 Media Release regarding The Tale of a Town – Performance October 1, 2015 Downtown Collingwood BIA Board of Management Meeting Minutes Page 3 of 4 42 of 212 CORRESPONDENCE RECEIVED BY BIA GENERAL MANAGER SINCE THE AUGUST 6TH MEETING 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Email correspondence from Farmers’ Market vendor regarding Moonlight Market Copy of news story regarding Urban Park in Timmins RTO7 Newsletter Email correspondence from BIA member regarding maintenance issues Proposal from Theatre Collingwood regarding 2016 funding Email correspondence regarding 84 Hurontario Street Copy of Notice sent by Clerk’s Office regarding BIA Boundary Expansion NEW BUSINESS 2016 Budget Planning The Board agreed to hold a Budget Planning meeting on Monday, October 26th at 6:30 p.m. – in the Business Development Centre’s Board Room. Annual General Meeting Agenda – November 25th – Temple Building. The General Manager confirmed that the AGM has been scheduled for Wednesday, November 25th at 6:30 p.m. in the Temple Building, 126 Hurontario Street. Board Members Durrant and Yuen will extend an invitation to a guest speaker to the AGM. Once the speaker is confirmed, the General Manager will send an invitation to Mayor, Council and Senior Staff. OTHER BUSINESS Eddie Bush Arena Contract The Board requested that Chair drafts a letter to the Director of Parks, Recreation and Culture requesting a meeting to discuss concern with the lack of resolution regarding rental of the Eddie Bush Memorial Arena. The Board also requested that the Director be invited to the next Board meeting. NEXT MEETING The next meeting of the Board of Management of the Collingwood Downtown BIA will take place on Thursday, November 5, 2015 at 7:30 a.m. in the Braniff Room, Town Hall. ADJOURNMENT Moved by Board Member Skelton THAT the meeting adjourns at 9:59 a.m. CARRIED _________________ Bradley Green, Chair BG: mg October 1, 2015 Downtown Collingwood BIA Board of Management Meeting Minutes Page 4 of 4 43 of 212 Town of Collingwood COLLINGWOOD HERITAGE COMMITTEE MINUTES October 7, 2015 COMMITTEE: Margaret Mooy, Chair Paul Andrews Candice Currie - Regrets Betty Donaher Catherine Durrant- Regrets Malcolm Willins Eugene Zenger RESOURCE: Ron Martin, Technical Consultant Kandas Bondarchuk, Planner Cathy de Ruiter, Staff Resource Monica Gal, Recording Secretary A meeting of the Heritage Committee was held on Wednesday, October 7, 2015 at 8:30 a.m. in the Building / Planning Department Conference Room of the Collingwood Public Library Building & Municipal Offices, 55 Saint Marie Street. CALL TO ORDER Chair Mooy welcomed all in attendance, established that a quorum was achieved and called the meeting to order at 8:33 a.m. ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA Moved by Committee Member Mooy Seconded by Committee Member Zenger THAT the October 7, 2015 Heritage Committee Agenda be adopted as amended. Delete: Deputation - Andrea Rinaldo was unable to attend the meeting. Add: Community Outreach - Posters CARRIED CONFIRMATION OF THE ADOPTION OF THE MINUTES The September 2, 2015 Heritage Committee Minutes were adopted electronically and received by the Development and Operations Standing Committee at their September 28, 2015 meeting and by Council at their October 5, 2015 meeting. CARRIED DECLARATIONS OF CONFLICT OR PECUNIARY INTEREST - Nil 44 of 212 WELCOME NEW MEMBER Chair Mooy welcomed recently appointed Committee Member Andrews. DEPUTATIONS Andrea Rinaldo, Art Crawl Mural Administrative Assistant de Ruiter advised that Ms. Rinaldo was unable to attend the meeting. However, she mentioned that she had a seven (7) page petition to the for the Committee’s attention in which the petitioners request that the Heritage Committee allows the ‘Bee Have’ Mural to remain permanently installed on the north façade wall of 119 Hurontario Street. The Committee agreed to invite Ms. Rinaldo to the November meeting so that she has the opportunity to make the request directly. Mark Cairns, Jamie Wright – Victoria Annex property proposal Mr. Mark Cairns and Mr. Jamie Wright thanked the Committee for inviting them to the meeting and provided a PowerPoint presentation of the proposed development. Mr. Wright explained the scope of the proposed addition to the former Victoria Annex and noted that the addition as well as the new homes has been designed so that they are sympathetic to existing architecture within the Town. Planner Bondarchuk confirmed that the developer will have to create and register a block plan of subdivision for a legal description in order to correctly designate the original portion of the Victoria Annex. Planner Bondarchuk advised that she is working on amending By-law 2010-100 to include the first homeowner of condominiums, as eligible for the Major Redevelopment and Restoration tax incentive grant. It was confirmed that the heritage designation of the Victoria Annex could not be completed until the correct legal description was available. The Committee thanked Mr. Cairns and Mr. Wright for meeting with them and excused them from the meeting at 9:50 a.m. CORRESPONDENCE Ministry of Citizenship, Immigration & International Trade – circulated at the meeting. Ministry of Tourism, Culture & Sport – Cultural Heritage Conservation workshop – Wed. Nov. 25th, 6:00-10:00 p.m., Barrie City Hall – circulated at the meeting. BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE MINUTES By-law 2015-86 – Adding 3 properties to significant list & Simcoe County participation in Heritage Tax Relief Chair Mooy confirmed that at the October 5th meeting of Council, By-law 2010-020 was amended to identify the following properties from being Non-significant to Significant Heritage Buildings: Collingwood Downtown Heritage Conservation District (Part V of the Ontario Heritage Act) namely, the properties located at 25 Second Street and 45 & 47 Fourth Street East. October 7, 2015 Heritage Committee Minutes Page 2 of 5 45 of 212 Chair Mooy also confirmed that in order to be consistent with Simcoe County Council’s decision for tax refunds to eligible heritage properties, Town of Collingwood By-law No. 2010-020 needed to be amended so that property owners were also able to access further funds from the province (education tax credit, which has already been included in the current by-law) and to also include the County of Simcoe’s additional ten percent (10%) portion. Proposed new heritage district Chair Mooy, advised that she attended the Development and Operations Standing Committee meeting at which she explained that the Heritage Advisory Committee wished to host a public information session, noting it is for educational purposes only at this point to advise of the merits of the creation of a new Heritage District and that this public information session would not incur any additional costs at this time. Chair Mooy requested that given the recent appointment of members Currie and Andrews that they conduct a walkabout along the proposed new district and also consider an alternative area of expansion as part of long range strategic planning. Heritage Newsletter Administrative Assistant de Ruiter advised that the Heritage Newsletter is expected to be mailed out the week of October 12th. ACO Event – “Main Street as Old Growth Forest” – 65 Simcoe Street – 7:30 Tuesday, Nov. 10th p.m. request to partner Chair Mooy advised that the Collingwood branch of the Architectural Conservancy of Ontario (ACO) was requesting that the Heritage Advisory Committee assists with the sponsorship of their November 10th Main Street as Old Growth Forest event. The Committee put forward the following resolution: Moved by Committee Member Donaher Seconded by Committee Member Zenger THAT the Heritage Committee supports the upcoming ACO event and agree to allocate $150 from its budget towards the event. CARRIED Chair Mooy will advise the President of the Collingwood Chapter of the ACO. Beild House – 64 Third Street Planner Bondarchuk reported that the application for a Zoning by-law amendment, to permit residential on the ground floor, has been withdrawn and that the building will remain a hotel. Property Standards Terminal Planner Bondarchuk will follow up with the Clerk and report back at the next meeting. Property Standards 61 & 65 Hurontario Street Consultant Ron Martin provided a status report on the subject properties and confirmed that both remain with the Town’s Property Standards Department. October 7, 2015 Heritage Committee Minutes Page 3 of 5 46 of 212 NEW BUSINESS 2015 Heritage Awards The Committee suggested properties which should be considered for the 2015 Heritage Awards. 2016 Heritage Grants – applications accepted until December 15th Administrative Assistant de Ruiter confirmed that applications for the 2016 Heritage Grant Program will be accepted until December 15th. Request for designation – 328 Pine Street The Committee reviewed the letter and supporting photographs requesting designation of the subject property and then put forward the following resolution: Moved by Committee Member Zenger Seconded by Committee Member Donaher THAT the Heritage Committee recommends that a Statement of Culture Value or Interest be prepared for the property located at 328 Pine Street. CARRIED OTHER BUSINESS Community Outreach Committee Member Donaher advised that a potential sponsor has approached her to sponsor the updating / consolidating of the walking tour maps. The Chair will invite the Director of Marketing and Business Development to the November meeting to discuss potential marketing opportunities. HERITAGE PERMITS Permit # 426-2015 427-2015 443-2015 458-2015 480-2015 487-2015 488-2015 489-2015 490-2015 500-2015 Location 198 Pine Street 50 Street Paul Street 119 Hurontario Street 124 Hurontario Street 114 Ontario Street 38 Street Paul Street 163 Hurontario Street 84 Hume Street 74 Hurontario Street 27 Third Street Type Paint & Fascia repair Windows & Paint Mural - Temporary Roof repair – Heritage Grant recipient Addition Roof repair Façade repair & paint – Heritage Grant recipient Paint doors Replace door Paint Moved by Committee Member Willins Seconded by Committee Member Andrews THAT the Collingwood Heritage Committee endorses the above identified Heritage Permits as presented. CARRIED October 7, 2015 Heritage Committee Minutes Page 4 of 5 47 of 212 NEXT MEETING The next meeting of the Heritage Committee will take place on Wednesday, November 4, 2015 at 8:30 a.m. in the Building & Planning Conference Room, 55 Ste. Marie Street. ADJOURNMENT Moved by Committee Member Donaher THAT the Heritage Committee meeting adjourns at 10:30 a.m. CARRIED _________________________ Margaret Mooy, Chair MM: mg October 7, 2015 Heritage Committee Minutes Page 5 of 5 48 of 212 STAFF REPORT Report #C2015-25 11/02/2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Sara Almas, Clerk Subject: Parking By-law Amendments PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to amend the Parking By-law No. 2003-062 to prohibit parking in Town laneways and to amend Schedule “A” to include additional no parking zones. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council enact and pass an amending By-law for Parking By-law No. 2003-062 to prohibit parking in Town laneways and to amend Schedule “A” to include additional no parking zones. 1. BACKGROUND On July 28th, 2003, the Town of Collingwood enacted and passed By-law No. 2003-062, a By-law for the regulation of parking within the Corporation of the Town of Collingwood. Since that time, the Town of Collingwood has enacted and passed several Parking Bylaw amendments as necessitated. The Town of Collingwood currently owns several laneways in various parts of the Town of Collingwood. The primary purpose of these laneways is access to the adjacent properties. Concerns have been raised by residents along these laneways of vehicles parking and obstructing their access and a permanent solution is required. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES A number of residents have been contacted regarding this change and most are in support, with one person in opposition. It has been observed that some tenants of nearby properties may utilize these laneways for parking. -1- 49 of 212 The Development and Operations Services Standing Committee considered the recommendations at its meeting held October 26, 2015, and requested consideration be given to restricting parking on one side of Elliott Avenue only. If Council agrees with the recommendation of the Standing Committee, Staff would recommend the west side be restricted only to allow people to park on the side of the road closest to the effected businesses. It should also be acknowledged that current restrictions within the Parking By-law restrict parking within 15.25 metres of an intersection abutting a through highway when signs are on display. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION The Municipal Act allows for a local municipality to pass a By-law relating to Highways, including parking and traffic on those highways. Part 2, Section 15(1) of the Provincial Offences Act allows Municipal Law Enforcement officers to issue parking infraction notices. 4. ANALYSIS No Parking Zones – All Laneways In previous years, parking complaints have been received regarding vehicles obstructing several public laneways across the Town of Collingwood; specifically in the downtown area where lanes are most common. Parking Enforcement has in the past issued warning tickets for ‘Park – Obstruct Traffic’ to warn operators of the issue. It would assist motorist and enforcement staff to have signs posted indicating no parking in these areas. Laneways in the Town are to be used by vehicles to access adjacent properties, not as additional parking. Some owners rely on these laneways remaining clear and unobstructed for access to driveway parking. The Parking Department recommends amending the Parking By-law to include no parking zones be created in public laneways in the Town of Collingwood. These areas would be signed accordingly and enforced by parking staff as required. No Parking – Additions to “Schedule A” Location: Ste. Marie Street at Hume Recommendation: No parking zone on the West side of Ste. Marie Street from Hume Street to a point approximately 40 meters south. The redevelopment of Hume Street has seen some changes to the intersection at Ste. Marie and Hume and the entrance/exits of the nearby business. Parking concerns have been raised by tenants of obstructions to driveways and cars parking close to the intersection on a narrow road causing safety concerns. -2- 50 of 212 The Parking Department recommends amending the Parking By-law to include a no parking zone of approximately 40 meters to ensure no vehicles park close to the intersection and do not obstruct vision and access of the adjacent commercial driveway. Location: First Street and Maple Street North Recommendation: No parking zone on Maple Street North Due to an increase in recent commercial activity, an increase of on street parking has been periodically observed by officers on Maple Street North adjacent to several businesses. This surge in activity is observed on weekends and holidays and has caused traffic obstructions and safety concerns when vehicles have parked on both sides of Maple Street North. A signed no parking zone would increase the traffic safety and ensure the intersection and driveways remain unobstructed. Location: Oak Street and Cedar Street Recommendation: No Parking zone on Laneway between Oak Street and Cedar Street. Safety concerns have been raised regarding vehicles and buses parking along the laneway beside Harbourview Park. This is a heavily used trail by bikes and pedestrians and suitable sightlines should be maintained for bikes and pedestrians entering and exiting the trail at this point to access the nearby parking. The Parking Department recommends amending the Parking By-law to include a no parking zone along the north side of this laneway between Oak Street and Cedar Street. Location: Ste. Marie Street South of Collins Recommendation: No Parking Zone along narrow section of two cul-de-sacs Concerns have been raised regarding access of services vehicles and emergency vehicles at the narrow portion of road between two abutting cul-de-sacs. When parked vehicles are left on either or both sides of this road access to the rear dwelling by larger vehicles -3- 51 of 212 is obstructed. A limited no parking zone at the most narrow portion of road would relieve these issues. Location: Elliot Avenue Recommendation: No Parking Zone on both sides of street Several residents and business owners in the area have brought to the Town concerns regarding safety due to the parking issues on Elliot Avenue. During peak times it is reported that cars have been observed parked on all sides of Elliot Avenue and in close proximity to entrances, driveways and intersections of roads and businesses causing obstructions and safety concerns for motorists and pedestrians in the area. Staff originally proposed no parking on both sides of Elliott Avenue. After discussions at the Development and Operations Services Standing Committee (refer to Input from Other Sources), if Council agrees with the Standing Committee, Staff would recommend a no parking zone on the west side of Elliot Avenue only at this time. This would begin to relieve these issues and will proactively prevent any snow removal issues in the winter months. The area will be observed by the parking department for further issues relating to parking and snow removal. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES Laneway No Parking areas and new no parking zones will have minimal impact with respect to signage, installation, and enforcement as required. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Appendix A By-law 2015-093, A By-law to amend the Parking Regulations including Schedule “A” with current amendments highlighted SIGNATURES Prepared by: Department head: Scott Gordon Municipal By-law Enforcement Officer Sara Almas Clerk Town of Collingwood Town of Collingwood -4- 52 of 212 BY-LAW No. 2015-093 OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD BEING A BY-LAW TO AMEND BY-LAW NO. 03-62 FOR THE REGULATION OF PARKING WITHIN THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD WHEREAS Section 11(3)(1) of the Municipal Act, 2001, S.O. 2001, c. 25 as amended, provides Council the authority to enact by-laws to regulate parking and traffic subject to the Highway Traffic Act; AND WHEREAS Council deems it expedient to amend By-law No. 03-62; NOW THEREFORE THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD HEREBY ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. THAT Schedule “A” of By-law No. 03-62, being a schedule respecting No Parking Areas in the Town of Collingwood, be hereby deleted and replaced with Schedule “A” as attached hereto. 2. THAT Part I – Definitions, of By-law No. 03-62 be amended to include: “Public Laneway” means a narrow street or passageway, less than 6.0m wide between or behind buildings or properties, designed, constructed and intended to provide access to and service at the rear of places of residence or business and owned by a government authority. 3. THAT Part III – Parking Prohibited, of By-law No. 03-62 be amended to include: (A) In Specified Places Where Authorized Signs are on Display (4) On a Town of Collingwood Laneway 4. THAT this By-law shall come into full force and effect on the date of final passage hereof at which time all By-laws and/or resolutions that are inconsistent with the provisions of this Bylaw and the same are hereby repealed or rescinded insofar as it is necessary to give effect to the provisions of this By-law. ENACTED AND PASSED this 2nd day of November, 2015. ____________________________ MAYOR ____________________________ CLERK 53 of 212 By-law No. 2015-093 Schedule “A” – No Parking Areas STREET BEECH ST BEECH ST BIRCH ST CALLARY CRES CAMERON ST CAMPBELL ST COLLINS ST CRANBERRY TRAIL WEST DAWSON DR EIGHTH ST ELGIN ST ELLIOT AVENUE ELM ST ERIE ST ERIE ST FAIRGROUNDS RD FIRST ST FOURTH ST W FOURTH ST E HARBOUR ST W HARBOUR ST W HIGH ST HIGH ST HUME ST HURON ST HURONTARIO ST HURONTARIO ST HURONTARIO ST HURONTARIO ST Page 2 of 4 BETWEEN FIRST ST & THIRD ST 60 M SOUTHERLY FROM THE NORTHERLY LIMIT OF FIRST ST CAMERON ST & TENTH ST FROM THE SOUTHERLY INTERSECTION OF ST. PAUL STREET AND CALLARY CRESCENT TO A POINT OF APPROXIMATELY 60 METERS EAST ON CALLARY CRES. HURONTARIO ST & BIRCH ST HURONTARIO ST & MAPLE ST KATHERINE ST TO AN EASTERLY POINT APPROXIMATELY 240 M FROM KATHERINE ST CUL DE SAC AT THE SOUTHERLY LIMIT OF CRANBERRY TRAIL W TO THE PATHWAY 55 M FROM THE CENTRE OF THE CUL DU SAC ALONG GREEN BRIAR DR 500 M NORTH WESTERLY FROM KEITH AVE BIRCH ST & WALNUT ST STE.MARIE ST & ONTARIO HIGHWAY 26 TO ST. CLAIR ST. FIRST ST & SECOND ST PEEL ST & RAGLAN ST NIAGARA ST & RAGLAN ST BEACHWOOD RD AND ITS LIMIT WITH THE TOWNSHIP OF CLEWARVIEW HIGH ST & HURONTARIO ST HURONTARIO ST & MAPLE ST STE MARIE ST & ST PAUL ST HWY 26 W TO THE NORTH WESTERLY LIMITS OF HARBOUR ST 250 M EASTERLY FROM THE SOUTHERLY LIMIT OF DAWSON DR FIRST ST & SIXTH ST CAMPBELL ST & TENTH ST HURONTARIO ST & MINNESOTA ST HURONTARIO ST & ALBERT ST FIRST STREET & SIDE LAUNCH WAY FOURTH ST & SIXTH ST FAIR ST & CAMPBELL ST COLLINS ST & LOCKHART ST SIDE EAST WEST PERIOD ANYTIME ANYTIME WEST SOUTH ANYTIME MONDAY TO FRIDAY 8:00AM TO 4:00PM BOTH NORTH SOUTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME BOTH WEST WEST BOTH SOUTH NORTH BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH BOTH SOUTH BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME BOTH EAST BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME EAST ANYTIME BOTH WEST EAST ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME 54 of 212 STREET KATHERINE ST BETWEEN COLLINS ST & BRYAN DR SIDE WEST KATHERINE ST COLLINS ST & BAKER ST BOTH KRISTA CRT LOCKHART RD TO DEY DR NORTH KRISTA CRT FROM DEY DRIVE TO A POINT APPROXIMATELY 25 METERS EAST SOUTHERLY BOUNDARY OF HARBOURVIEW PARK BETWEEN OAK ST AND CEDAR ST SECOND ST & THIRD ST SOUTH LANE (HARBOURVIEW PARK) LANE (WEST OF HURONTARIO) LANE (EAST OF HURONTARIO ST) LANE (EAST OF HURONTARIO ST) LANE (EAST OF HURONTARIO ST) MAPLE ST MARKET LANE MARKET LANE MINNESOTA STREET MOBERLY ST MOUNTAIN RD NAPIER ST NORTH MAPLE ST NORTH MAPLE ST NORTH PINE ST OAK ST ONTARIO ST PATERSON ST PATTON ST PINE ST PINE ST PINE ST RAGLAN ST RAGLAN ST RAGLAN ST RAGLAN ST RAGLAN ST Page 3 of 4 PERIOD MONDAY TO FRIDAY 8:00AM TO 4:30PM MONDAY TO FRIDAY 8:00AM TO 4:30PM MONDAY TO FRIDAY 8:00AM TO 4:00PM MONDAY TO FRIDAY 8:00AM TO 4:00PM NORTH ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME SIMCOE ST & THIRD ST BOTH ANYTIME SIMCOE ST & HURON ST BOTH ANYTIME 88.5 M SOUTHERLY FROM ONTARIO ST FIRST ST & SIXTH ST STE. MARIE ST & ST PAUL ST STE. MARIE ST & MARKET ST HURON ST & ONTARIO ST BOTH ANYTIME WEST NORTH SOUTH BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME WEST ANYTIME EAST ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME EAST BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME WEST SOUTHEAST ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME EAST WEST BOTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME EAST WEST WEST ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH ANYTIME HUME ST TO PEEL ST 300 M EAST & WEST OF SILVER CREEK RODNEY ST TO THE NORTHERLY LIMITS OF NAPIER ST FIRST STREET TO A POINT 35 METERS NORTH FIRST STREET TO SIDE LAUNCH WAY FIRST STREET & SIDE LAUNCH WAY EIGHTH ST & NINTH ST STE. MARIE ST & MINNESOTA ST HUME ST & LORNE AVE BARR ST TO A POINT 100 M FROM BARR ST 25.5 M SOUTHERLY FROM FIRST ST THIRD & FOURTH THIRD ST & FIFTH ST PRETTY RIVER PARKWAY & ST. LAWRENCE ST ERIE ST & HUME ST ONTARIO ST & ERIE ST SOUTHERLY PROPERTY LINE OF 49 RAGLAN ST & HUME ST FROM POPLAR SIDE ROAD TO A POINT OF APPROXIMATELY 350 METERS NORTH 55 of 212 STREET SECOND ST SECOND ST SEVENTH ST SIXTH ST SPRUCE ST ST. LAWRENCE ST ST. PAUL ST ST. PAUL ST ST. PAUL ST ST. PAUL ST STE. MARIE ST STE. MARIE ST STE. MARIE ST STE. MARIE ST STE. MARIE ST TENTH ST THIRD ST THIRD ST TROTT BLVD Page 4 of 4 BETWEEN PINE ST & OAK ST PINE STREET & MAPLE STREET BIRCH ST & OAK ST HURONTARIO ST & HIGH ST THIRD ST & FOURTH ST RAGLAN ST & NIAGARA ST ONTARIO ST TO A POINT 100M SOUTH OF ONTARIO ST HURON ST & SIMCOE ST FROM SIMCOE STREET TO A POINT APPROXIMATELY 50 METERS SOUTH FROM SIMCOE STREET TO A POINT APPROXIMATELY 25 METERS NORTH ONTARIO ST & FOURTH ST HUME ST & HAMILTON ST HUME ST TO A POINT APPROXIMATELY 40 METERS SOUTH BETWEEN THE DRIVEWAYS OF UNITS 726 AND 728 BETWEEN THE DRIVEWAYS OF 727 AND 725 HIGH ST & SPRUCE ST MAPLE ST & BEECH ST PINE ST & BIRCH ST FROM 70 M NORTH OF SHEFFIELD TERRACE TO 250M SOUTHERLY SIDE NORTH SOUTH PERIOD ANYTIME ANYTIME BOTH BOTH WEST BOTH EAST ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME EAST WEST ANYTIME ANYTIME WEST ANYTIME EAST EAST WEST ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME SOUTH ANYTIME NORTH ANYTIME BOTH BOTH SOUTH SOUTH ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME ANYTIME 56 of 212 STAFF REPORT P2015-31-C Reviewed by Development and Operations Services Standing Committee on October 26, 2015 Recommendation: The report to proceed to Council. Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Nancy Farrer, Director of Planning Services Subject: Extension of Draft Approval for Plan of Subdivision Mountaincroft (D1202615) PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to provide Council with an analysis regarding a request to extend draft approval for the proposed Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision. RECOMMENDATION That Council extends the draft approval for the proposed Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision for a further year (January 11th, 2017). 1. BACKGROUND The proposed extension to the Mountaincroft Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision (Town File No. D1202615) pertains to lands located at the northeast corner of Poplar Side Road and High Street. The 374 unit Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision was given draft plan approval on January 11, 2006. The eastern portion of the subdivision was registered on September 26, 2008 as Plan 51M-920 for 174 single detached dwelling units (Instrument # SC685425) and is now approaching build out. The draft approval for the remaining portion of the subdivision (approximately 200 single detached dwelling units) lapses on January 11, 2016. With the completion of the first three phase of the subdivision (Plan 920) the applicant is now actively pursuing registration of the rest of the subdivision (phases 4, 5 and 6) (File No. D1208115). The applicant is looking for a minor extension to draft approval to provide additional time for completion of the registration process if needed. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES This report was forwarded to Department Heads on October 20th, 2015 for review and it was recommended to proceed to the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee for consideration. 1 57 of 212 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION Matters of Provincial Interest Section 2 of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c .P. 13, as amended, provides that Council in carrying out their responsibilities under the Planning Act shall have regard to matters of provincial interest. Planning staff is satisfied that the extension of this Draft Plan, if granted, shall not offend any matters of provincial interest. Provincial Policy Statement (PPS - 2014) Section 3(5) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c .P. 13, as amended, provides that the Council of a municipality, in exercising any authority that affects a planning matter, shall ensure that those powers are exercised in a manner that is consistent with the policy statements issued by the Province. Planning staff is satisfied that the extension of this Draft Plan, if granted, will be consistent with the 2014 Provincial Policy Statement. Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe The Growth Plan emphasizes the creation of compact, transit-supportive and complete communities and sets a minimum greenfield density target of 50 residents and or jobs per hectare (on a townwide/county wide basis). The proposed plan of subdivision is located within a designated greenfield area adjacent to the identified built boundary of the Town (June 2006) and forms a reasonable extension of the existing built-up urban part of the Town in terms of the transportation, servicing and parks and trail networks. The plans anticipated density is approximately 35 persons per hectare, based on the projected dwelling unit count multiplied by a person per unit average of 2.31 (taken from the 2011 Census) as well as assumptions for future secondary units (apartments in house) and employment from home occupations. Notwithstanding the density target of the Growth Plan, it is acknowledged that the draft approval of this plan of subdivision predates the Growth Plan and that stormwater management, parkland dedication and transportation/servicing planning have already been completed. County of Simcoe, Official Plan Schedule 5.1 entitled Land Use Designations of the County of Simcoe Official Plan, as amended, identifies the Town of Collingwood as a Settlement Area. The County of Simcoe Planning Division has provided no specific comments with respect to this proposal. Planning staff is satisfied that the extension of this Draft Plan, if granted, will conform to the general intent and purpose of the County of Simcoe Official Plan. Town of Collingwood Official Plan Schedule “A” entitled Land Use Plan of the Town of Collingwood Official Plan identifies the subject lands as being designated Residential and further defined as Low and Medium Density Residential on Schedule ‘C’ entitled Residential Density Plan in the Town of Collingwood Official Plan, as amended. 2 58 of 212 Planning Services Staff advise that the draft approved Plan of Subdivision maintains the general intent and purpose of the Town of Collingwood Official Plan. Town of Collingwood Zoning By-law No. 2010-040, as amended Schedule “A”, Map 9 of the Town of Collingwood Zoning By-law No. 2010-040, as amended, identifies the subject property as being zoned Holding Twelve Residential Third Density (‘H12’R3) and Holding Twelve Residential Third Density Exception Three (‘H12’R3-3). The Zoning permits the proposed single detached residential dwelling units, with appropriate zone provisions. 4. ANALYSIS The Owner of the lands has requested an extension to their draft approval for a further year (1) year (January 11th, 2017). Planning staff have reviewed the Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision and are of the opinion that the development and associated conditions of draft plan approval continue to have planning merit and are appropriate under the Town’s Official Plan policies and Zoning provisions, as well as County of Simcoe and Provincial planning policies. The request for an extension to the existing draft plan approval was circulated to internal departments and external agencies for comment. No objections or requests for revisions to the existing draft plan conditions were received. Conclusion At this time Staff would support a Draft Plan extension to January 11th, 2017, for the plan of subdivision, thus an extension of a further one (1) years. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES Directly there are no impacts on Town finances as a result of the review of these applications as costs are covered as part of the requisite application fee. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Appendix “A” Appendix “B” Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision Conditions of Draft Approval SIGNATURES 3 59 of 212 Appendix A: Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision Already Registered 51M-920 Still subject to Draft Approval 4 60 of 212 Appendix B Conditions of Draft Plan Approval Applicant: 1355046 Ontario Inc. File No: D1202412, D1202615 Subject Lands: Part Lot 40, Concession 7 Original Date of Decision: January 11, 2006 Revised Lapse Date: January 11, 2017 No. Conditions __________________________________________________________________________________ 1. That this approval applies to the draft plan of subdivision located at Part of Lot 40, Concession 7, Registered Plan No. 446, Town of Collingwood, County of Simcoe prepared by Meridian Planning Consultants, revision dated September 23, 2005 and showing a total of: 374 Residential lots (Lots 1 to 374) One Municipal Stormwater Block (Block 375) One Municipal Parkland Block (Blocks 176) Two 8.0 metre Road Widening Blocks (Blocks 377 & 378) Four 0.3 metre Reserves (Blocks 279, 380, 381 and 382) One Walkway Block (Block 383) Roads are noted as Streets A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H and I 2. That the Owner agrees in writing to satisfy all the requirements, financial and otherwise of the Town of Collingwood. 3. That prior to final approval and registration, the appropriate zoning shall be in effect for the proposed subdivision. 4. That the Owner will enter servicing, development and other necessary agreements, satisfactory to the Town of Collingwood or any other appropriate authority before any development or site alteration within the plan. These agreements shall deal with matters including but not limited to the following: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) (j) (k) Engineering and conservation works which include municipal services; Professional services including preparation of reports, plans, inspections, certifications and approvals; Hydro, storm water management; Storm sewers, road widening and reconstruction; Monitoring wells, cash contributions, levies (development charges) Securities or letters of credit, emergency services; Land dedications and easements, reserves, noise abatement; Fencing, berming, buffer blocks and planting; Grading and sodding, signed entry features; Warning clauses, hoarding, parkland and tree preservation; The details of which are indicated in correspondence from appropriate commenting agencies and departments. 5. That the municipality shall confirm that the Subdivision Agreement has been registered, by the municipality against the lands to which it applies as provided for in the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990. A copy of the executed agreement shall be provided to the Approval Authority. 6. The Owner agrees that development charges, processing and administrative fees be paid prior to building permit issuance in accordance with the current Town of Collingwood policies and the bylaws. 5 61 of 212 7. The Owner agrees that the road allowances shown as Streets “A” through to “I”, on the draft plan, shall be built, dedicated as public highways, and named to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood with regard to 911 emergency servicing. 8. The Owner agrees that any dead ends and open sides of road allowances created by this draft plan, as described above, shall be terminated in 0.3 metre reserves, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, to be conveyed to, and held in trust, by the Town of Collingwood. 9. All temporary turning circles are to be constructed with a minimum turning radius of 13 metres. The property required to construct the temporary turning circles will be dedicated to the Town and will be shown as a Block, and will be held by the Town of Collingwood until the roadway is extended. 10. The Owner agrees to convey to the Town of Collingwood, Block 375, for Stormwater Management to the satisfaction of the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority (NVCA) and the Town of Collingwood. 11. The Owner agrees that the 0.3 metre reserve shown as Blocks 379, 380, 381 and 382 shall be deeded to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 12. That all roads within the proposed development will be constructed to Town Standards including curb & gutter, hot asphalt, granular, storm sewers, sanitary sewer, watermain sub-drawings, sidewalks, street lights, traffic signs, driveway approaches, sodded boulevards, boulevard trees and landscaping. 13. The Owner agrees to provide to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, sidewalks, and/or trails as required. 14. That prior to final approval, the Owner shall carry out a Traffic Impact Study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and that the Owner will agree to carry out the recommendations of this study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 15. That prior to final approval, the Owner shall agree to carry out a Noise Assessment Study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. The Owner will agree to carry out the recommendations of this study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, including the possibility of a Standard Ministry of Environment (MOE) proximity clause on purchase agreements advising that noise may be audible from time to time. 16. That the Owner will be responsible for carrying out the works recommended above to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. Without limiting the general or specific requirements of the above referenced Noise Assessment Study, the Owner shall agree in the subdivision agreement to provide a standardized fence and/or landscaping treatment along all residential lots abutting High Street and Poplar Sideroad to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 17. The Owner agrees in the Subdivision Agreement to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and the appropriate agencies, to enter into an agreement, which shall be registered on title, with respect to external works for the provision of sewer and water servicing to the subject property. These works shall include the extension of the sanitary sewers from Hurontario Street and watermain including supply and pressure from Poplar Sideroad. 17a) That the Owner agrees in the Subdivision Agreement, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, that the extension of the trunk watermain on Findlay Drive between Clark Street and High Street shall be constructed as part of site servicing for the next phase of the subdivision (subsequent to December 17, 2012). The Town of Collingwood shall reimburse the Developer in 6 62 of 212 accordance with the Town’s Development Charge By-Law, subject to any local servicing and oversizing adjustments as stipulated therein. 18. The Owner agrees to provide, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, fencing of the Walkway Blocks (Block 383), Park Block (Block 376), and Stormwater Management Block (Block 375), where required. 19. The Owner will accommodate all existing drainage within and external to the subject plan according to the Town’s Stormwater Management Policies and to the satisfaction of the Town’s Engineering Department. Where improvements and/or adjustments to the existing systems are necessary to facilitate this development, it will be the Owner’s responsibility to provide the necessary works, including outlet improvements as required. 20. The Owner will be responsible for the preparation of a Stormwater Management Study that will recommend the means by which the stormwater within and external to the site should be accommodated, all to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority. 21. The Owner will be responsible for carrying out the works recommended above to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority. Without limiting the general or specific requirements of the above referenced Stormwater Management Report, the Owner will provide appropriate erosion and sediment control within the development areas to protect applicable watercourses from the impact of run off from the development. The Owner will maintain the erosion and sediment control facility in a fashion suitable to the Engineering Department and any safety devices, if required, will be provided by the Owner at the direction of the Town’s Engineering Department in their sole and unfettered discretion. 22. The Owner will provide storm sewers suitably designed and of sufficient depth to provide for the proper drainage of the lands within and external to the subdivision and to discharge to drainage outlets as directed by and to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 23. The Owner will provide sanitary sewers suitably designed and of sufficient depth to provide for the proper collection of the lands within and external to the subdivision as directed by and to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 24. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in wording acceptable to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority and the Town of Collingwood, to ensure that all storm water management facilities and sediment and erosion control measures will be in place prior to any site alteration. 25. The Owner agrees that in order to provide proper and reliable water distribution systems within the development, reasonable looping of these systems shall be provided to the satisfaction of Collingwood Public Utility. 26. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement, that such easements and land dedications as may be required for access, drainage, servicing, stormwater management, utilities and construction purposes shall be designed to the satisfaction of, and granted to the appropriate agencies or authorities, free and clear of all encumbrances to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and all appropriate agencies or authorities. 27. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement, that the applicant has made satisfactory arrangements for the installation of mail facility(s), if required, in the development to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood with confirmation to be received by Canada Post. 7 63 of 212 28. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide to the Town of Collingwood, a soils report recommending the material necessary for road construction to meet Town standards. This report shall also address any potential groundwater issues as they relate to the proposed development of homes, roads and stormwater management facilities. 29. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement to make arrangements to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood for a suitable construction traffic route. 30. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement that, prior to final approval, a municipal numbering system be assigned to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood with regard to 911 emergency servicing; and that the Owner agrees in the Subdivision Agreement to display the lot number and corresponding municipal address in a prominent location on each lot. 31. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement that, prior to final approval, arrangements will be made to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood for the relocation of any utilities required by the development of the subject lands to be undertaken at the expense of the Ownert. 32. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement that, prior to final approval, the Owner is to submit a Landscape/Streetscape and Storm Water Management Landscape Plan to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 33. That the Owner will agree by agreement to designate lands for parkland as required in accordance with Town policy and Section 42 and 51.1 of the Planning Act, as amended. 34. The Owner shall carry out an archaeological assessment of the subject property and mitigate, through preservation or resource removal and documentation, adverse impacts to any significant archaeological resources found. No grading or other soil disturbances shall take place on the subject property prior to the Town of Collingwood and the Ministry of Culture confirming that all archaeological resource concerns have met licensing and resource conservation requirements. 35. That prior to any site alteration, the following shall be prepared to the satisfaction of the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority and the Town of Collingwood: a) b) c) d) e) A detailed Storm Water Management Report An Erosion Control Plan A detailed Grading Plan A detailed Geotechnical Report for the stormwater pond A detailed Landscaping Plan for the proposed storm water pond 36. That the owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in wording acceptable to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority and the Town of Collingwood, to carry out or cause to be carried out the recommendations and measures contained within the plans and reports set out in Condition 35. 37. That the owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to engage a qualified professional to certify in writing that the works were constructed in accordance with the plans, reports and specifications, as approved by the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority and the Town of Collingwood. 38. That any easements required for stormwater drainage purposes shall be granted to the Town of Collingwood, free and clear of all encumbrances. 8 64 of 212 39. That the Owner shall agree, prior to final plan approval, to pay all development fees to the conservation authority as required in accordance with the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority’s fee policy, under the Conservation Authorities Act. 40. That the Subdivision Agreement between the Owner and the Town of Collingwood contain staging arrangements to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood 41. That the Subdivision Agreement between the Owner and the Town of Collingwood shall include provisions whereby all offers of Purchase and Sale will include information that satisfies section 59(4) of the Development Charges Act. 42. That prior to any tree removal or site alteration, the Owner may be required to submit a Tree Cutting Permit to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and all site works shall be in strict accordance with the approved permit. 43. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to the preparation and implementation of architectural guidelines to govern the character of residential structures and commercial structures in a manner acceptable to the Town of Collingwood. The Owner shall submit, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, architectural guidelines that conform to the Town of Collingwood Subdivision Guidelines, including design principles and architectural styles. The Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to construct all buildings and structures in conformity with the approved architectural guidelines, and to the inclusion of the approved architectural guidelines as a schedule to the Subdivision Agreement. 44. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, with wording to the satisfaction of the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board, to include in all offers of purchase and sale a clause advising prospective purchasers that pupils from this development attending educational facilities operated by the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board may be transported to / accommodated in temporary facilities out of the neighbourhood school’s area. 45. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, with wording to the satisfaction of the Simcoe County District School Board, to include in all offers of purchase and sale a statement that advises the prospective purchaser that the public schools on designated site in the community are not guaranteed. Attendance at schools in the area yet to be constructed is also not guaranteed. Pupils may be accommodated in temporary facilities and/or be directed to schools outside the area. 46. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, with wording acceptable to the Simcoe District School Board, to include in all offers of purchase and sale a statement that advises the prospective purchaser that school buses will not enter cul de sacs and that pick up points will not be located within the subdivision until major construction activity has been completed. That prior to final approval and plan registration, the Owner is to co-ordinate the preparation of an overall utility distribution plan to the satisfaction of all effected authorities. 47. 48. The Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement that all of the natural gas distribution system will be installed within the proposed road allowances. 49. The Owner shall grade all streets to final elevation prior to the installation of the gas lines, and provide the necessary field survey information required for the installation of the gas lines, all to the satisfaction of Enbridge Gas Inc.. 50. That prior to final approval, the Owner will have made arrangements satisfactory to both the Town of Collingwood and the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board with respect to the grading plan, the Stormwater Management Plan and the widening of the traveled portion of 9 65 of 212 Findlay Drive, as they relate to the current St. Mary’s Elementary School site located at 18 Saunders Street. 51. That prior to final approval, a copy of the proposed final plan is to be forwarded to the Town of Collingwood for review and approval. 52. That prior to Final Approval the approval authority be advised, in writing, how conditions 2 to 38, 40 to 43, and 50 have been satisfied. 53. That prior to Final Approval the approval authority be advised, in writing, by the Ministry of Culture how condition 34 has been satisfied. 54. That prior to Final Approval the approval authority be advised, in writing, by the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority how conditions 10, 21, 24, 35 to 37, and 39 have been satisfied. 55. That prior to Final Approval the approval authority be advised, in writing, by the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board how conditions 44 and 50 have been satisfied. 56. That prior to Final Approval the approval authority be advised, in writing, by the Simcoe County District School Board how conditions 45 and 46 have been satisfied. 57. That prior to Final Approval the approval authority be advised, in writing, by Enbridge Gas Distribution how conditions 47 to 49 have been satisfied. 58. That the draft plan approval is for a period of three (3) years. The Owner shall apply for any extension at least sixty (60) days prior to the lapsing date. Notes to Draft Approval 1. It is the Owner’s responsibility to fulfill the conditions of draft approval and to ensure that the required clearance letters are forwarded to the Town as approval authority, quoting file number CW-T-0501, D1202412, D1202615 2. It is suggested that the Owner should review section 144 of the Land Titles Act and section 78 of the Registry Act. Subsection 144(1) of the Land Titles Act requires that a plan of condominium of land that is located in a land titles division be registered under the Land Titles Act. Exceptions to this provision are set out in subsection 144(2). 3. Subsection 78(11) of the Registry Act indicates that a description as defined in the Condominium Act, 1998 in respect of land that is within an area to which the Land Titles Act applies but not within an area designated under subsection 144(3) of the Land Titles Act shall not be registered under the Registry Act. 4. The Town requires all engineering drawings to be submitted in AutoCAD 14 format as well as hardcopy. 5. All measurements in final plans must be presented in metric units. 6. Bell Canada will utilize the existing easement over what is designated as Lot 28 within the draft plan of subdivision for the required digital equipment cabinet installation necessar5y to provide service to this subdivision. The Owner will be required to contact Bell Canada’s Engineering Department regarding the details for servicing within the subdivision as well as the necessary Letters of Understanding. The Bell Canada contact is Rick DeBokx 705-722-2354. 10 66 of 212 7. If applicable, the Owner shall agree, prior to final approval, to pay all development fees to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority as required in accordance with the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority’s fees policy established under the Conservation Authorities Act. 8. Clearance is only required from the Town. 9. The approval of this draft plan is for a period of one (1) years and will lapse on January 11, 2017. If final approval is not given to this plan within the draft approval time period above the draft approval will lapse under subsection 51(32) of the Planning Act. Draft approval may be extended pursuant to subsection 51(33) of the Planning Act, but no extension can be granted once the approval has lapsed. If the Owner wishes to request an extension to draft approval, a written explanation, together with the completed application form and fee, must be received by the Town sixty (60) days prior to the lapsing date. 10. The Final Plan approved by the Approval Authority must be registered within 30 days or the County may withdraw its approval under subsection 51(32) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, as amended. Subject to the conditions set forth above, approval for this Draft Plan is extended under Section 51 of the Planning Act R.S.O 1990, Chapter 13, as amended, this 2nd day of November, 2015. Sara Almas, Clerk Town of Collingwood Sandra Cooper, Mayor Town of Collingwood 11 67 of 212 STAFF REPORT P2015-32-C Reviewed by Development and Operations Services Standing Committee on October 26, 2015 Recommendation: The report proceed to Council. Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Nancy Farrer, Director of Planning Services Subject: Extension of Draft Approval for Plan of Subdivision Mair Mills Villages (D1202515) PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to provide Council with an analysis regarding a request to extend draft approval for the proposed Mair Mills Villages Plan of Subdivision. RECOMMENDATION That Council extends the draft approval for the proposed Mair Mills Villages Plan of Subdivision for a further three (3) years (April 29th, 2019). 1. BACKGROUND The proposed extension to the Mair Mills Villages Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision (Town File No. D1202515) pertains to land located southwest of the Tenth Line and Mountain Road intersection, and is commonly referred to as the ‘Mair Mills Villages’ Plan of Subdivision. The Mair Mills Subdivision is currently draft approved for a three hundred and two (302) dwelling units, consisting of ninety-nine (99) single-detached units, thirty-six (36) semi-detached units and one hundred and thirty-two (132) multiple dwelling units (i.e. 4 blocks for townhouses or apartments) and includes a 0.378 ha local convenience commercial block. The current draft plan approval expires on April 29th, 2016. The draft approval was originally given on May 19, 2009 and was subsequently revised and given an extension on April 29, 2013 to increase the overall density and make a number of minor changes to the configuration of streets and lots. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES This report was forwarded to Department Heads on October 20th, 2015 for review and it was recommended to proceed to the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee for consideration. 68 of 212 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION Matters of Provincial Interest Section 2 of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c .P. 13, as amended, provides that Council in carrying out their responsibilities under the Planning Act shall have regard to matters of provincial interest. Planning staff is satisfied that the extension of this Draft Plan, if granted, shall not offend any matters of provincial interest. Provincial Policy Statement (PPS - 2014) Section 3(5) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c .P. 13, as amended, provides that the Council of a municipality, in exercising any authority that affects a planning matter, shall ensure that those powers are exercised in a manner that is consistent with the policy statements issued by the Province. Planning staff is satisfied that the extension of this Draft Plan, if granted, will be consistent with the 2014 Provincial Policy Statement. Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe The Growth Plan emphasizes the creation of compact, transit-supportive and complete communities and sets a minimum greenfield density target of 50 residents and or jobs per hectare (on a townwide/county wide basis). The proposed plan of subdivision is located within a designated greenfield area adjacent to the identified built boundary of the Town (June 2006) and forms a reasonable extension of the existing built-up urban part of the Town in terms of the transportation, servicing and parks and trail networks. The plans anticipated density is approximately 40 persons per hectare, based on a projected dwelling unit count of 302 townhomes or apartments multiplied by a person per unit average of 2.31 (taken from the 2011 Census) as well as assumptions for future secondary units (apartments in house), home occupations and employment associated with the local convenience block. County of Simcoe, Official Plan Schedule 5.1 entitled Land Use Designations of the County of Simcoe Official Plan, as amended, identifies the Town of Collingwood as a Settlement Area. The County of Simcoe Planning Division has provided no specific comments with respect to this proposal. Planning staff is satisfied that the extension of this Draft Plan, if granted, will conform to the general intent and purpose of the County of Simcoe Official Plan. Town of Collingwood Official Plan Schedule “A” entitled Land Use Plan of the Town of Collingwood Official Plan identifies the subject lands as being designated Residential and further defined as Low and Medium Density Residential on Schedule ‘C’ entitled Residential Density Plan in the Town of Collingwood Official Plan, as amended. Planning Services Staff advise that the draft approved Plan of Subdivision maintains the general intent and purpose of the Town of Collingwood Official Plan. 69 of 212 Town of Collingwood Zoning By-law No. 2010-040, as amended Schedule “A”, Map 9 of the Town of Collingwood Zoning By-law No. 2010-040, as amended, identifies the subject property as being zoned, Residential Third Density (R3), Residential Third Density Exception Forty-Nine (R3-49), Recreation (REC), Environmental Protection (EP) and Convenience Commercial (C6). The Zoning permits low and medium density residential dwelling units, with appropriate zone provisions. 4. ANALYSIS The Owner of the lands has requested an extension to their draft approval for a further three (3) years (April 29th, 2019). Planning staff have reviewed the Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision and are of the opinion that the development and associated conditions of draft plan approval continue to have planning merit and are appropriate under the Town’s Official Plan policies and Zoning provisions, as well as County of Simcoe and Provincial planning policies. The request for an extension to the existing draft plan approval was circulated to internal departments and external agencies for comment. No objections or requests for revisions to the existing draft plan conditions were received. Conclusion At this time Staff would support a Draft Plan extension to April 29th, 2019, for the plan of subdivision, thus an extension of a further three (3) years. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES Directly there are no impacts on Town finances as a result of the review of these applications as costs are covered as part of the requisite application fee. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Appendix “A” Appendix “B” Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision Conditions of Draft Approval SIGNATURES 70 of 212 Appendix A: Draft Approved Plan of Subdivision 71 of 212 Appendix B: Conditions of Draft Plan Approval Applicant: 2038170 Ontario Inc. and Antonio Caravaggio Files: SDR-2005-04,(CW-T-0502) D1203112, D1202515 Subject Lands: Part N 1/2 of Lot 44, Concession 11 Original Date of Decision May 19, 2009, Last Revision/Extension given April 29, 2013 New Lapse Date for Conditions: April 29, 2019 No. Conditions ____________________________________________________________________________ 1. That this approval applies to the Draft Plan of Subdivision located on Part of the North Half of Lot 44 Concession 11 former Geographic township of Nottawasaga now Town of Collingwood, County of Simcoe prepared by Patten & Thomsen Limited., dated August 14, 2012 and showing a total of: a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. j. k. l. m. 99 Single detached residential lots (Lots 1 to 99) 36 Semi-detached residential lots (Lots 100-135) 37 Freehold Townhouse residential lots (Lots 136-172) 4 Multi-unit residential blocks (Blocks 173-176) 1 Block for Neighbourhood Commercial Uses (Block 177) 1 Municipal Stormwater Management Block (Block 178) 1 Block for Park purposes (Block 179) 1 Block for a Future Street (Block 180) 1 Block for storm servicing and a walkway (Block 181) 3 Blocks for 0.3m Reserves (Block 184, 185 and 186) 2 Blocks for Road Widenings (Blocks 187 & 188) 2 Blocks to be dedicated to the adjacent Owner for buffering (Block 182 & 183) and, Lands for future public streets are noted as Streets A through E, inclusive, and the Thomas Drive 2. That the Owner shall agree in writing to satisfy all the requirements, financial and otherwise of the Town of Collingwood prior to final approval. 3. That prior to final approval and registration, the appropriate zoning shall be in effect for the proposed subdivision. This will include the zoning of Block 178 (stormwater management block) as Environmental Protection (EP) to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority 4. That the Owner shall enter into a Subdivision Agreement and any other necessary agreements, satisfactory to the Town of Collingwood or any other appropriate authority before any development or site alteration within the plan, excepting approved remediation works and general site earth works. These agreements may deal with matters including but not limited to the following: a. b. c. d. e. Engineering and conservation works which include municipal services; Professional services including preparation of reports, plans, inspections, certifications and approvals; Hydro; Storm sewers, stormwater management; Road widening and reconstruction; 72 of 212 f. g. h. i. j. k. l. m. Monitoring wells,; Securities or letters of credit, cash contributions, levies (development charges); Emergency services; Land dedications and easements, reserves; Noise abatement; Fencing, berming, buffer blocks and planting; Grading and sodding, signed entry features, parkland and tree preservation; and Warning clauses, hoarding. The details of which are indicated in correspondence from appropriate commenting agencies and departments. 5. That the Subdivision Agreement shall be registered against the lands to which it applies as provided for in the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990. 6. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement that development charges, processing and administrative fees be paid prior to building permit issuance in accordance with the current policies and by-laws of the Town of Collingwood, County of Simcoe and School Boards. 7. That the Owner shall agree that the road allowances shown as Thomas Drive, Street “A” through “E” and Blocks 186, 187 and 180 on the draft plan, shall be constructed, dedicated as public highways, and named to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood with regard to 911 emergency servicing and that the Owner agrees in the Subdivision Agreement to display the lot number and corresponding municipal address in a prominent location on each lot. 8. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement that the Owner will be required to complete to Town specifications, at the Owner’s expense, the following external works: a) Extend the sanitary sewer from its existing location at Mountain Road and the Tenth line down the Tenth line to the site at the new proposed road; and b) Extend the trunk watermain from its existing location on the Sixth Street at Georgian Meadows Drive to the site at the Tenth Line and the new proposed road; c) Design and construct the Stewart Road booster facility, if and when required. d) Make the necessary adjustments and reconnections to the existing Blue Mountain Golf & Country Club sewer and water connections located within an easement on the subject lands; and, e) Proportionally share in all costs associated with the urbanization of Tenth Line along the development’s frontage. 9. The Owner shall agree in the subdivision agreement, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, to enter into a cost sharing agreement with Consar Development (Collingwood) Inc. for the necessary Taylor Creek Channelization improvements. These works are a requirement of development and are to be constructed prior to any site works being completed. 10. All temporary turning circles are to be constructed with a minimum turning radius of 13 metres. The property required to construct the temporary turning circles will be dedicated to the Town and will be shown as a Block on the final M-Plan, and will be held by the Town of Collingwood until the roadway is extended. 73 of 212 11. That all roads within the proposed development will be constructed to Town of Collingwood Standards including curb & gutter, hot asphalt, granular, storm sewers, sanitary sewer, watermain, subdrains, sidewalks, street lights, traffic signs, driveway approaches, sodded boulevards, boulevard trees and landscaping. 12. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide public walkways, sidewalks and trails to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 13. The Owner agrees to convey to the Town of Collingwood, Block 178, for Storm Water Management to the satisfaction of the NVCA and Town of Collingwood. 14. That the Owner agrees that the 0.3 metre reserves shown as Block 184, 185 and 186 shall be deeded to the Town of Collingwood. 15. That the Owner will agree by agreement to designate lands for parkland as required in accordance with Town policy and Section 42 and 51 of the Planning Act, as amended. 16. That prior to final approval, the Owner shall carry out a Traffic Impact Study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and that the Owner will agree to carry out the recommendations of this study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 17. That prior to final approval, the Owner will agree to carry out a Noise and Vibration Assessment Study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. The Owner will agree to carry out the recommendations of this study to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. including the possibility of a Standard MOE proximity clause on purchase and sale agreements advising that noise may be audible from time to time. 18. That the Owner will be responsible for carrying out the works recommended above to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. Without limiting the general or specific requirements of the above referenced Noise Assessment Study, the Owner agrees to provide a standardized fence and landscaping treatment along all residential lots abutting Mountain Road and the Tenth Line to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 19. That prior to final approval, the Owner will agree to carry out studies with respect to Dust and/or Odour, if necessary, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. The Owner will agree to carry out the recommendations of these studies to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, including the possibility of a Standard MOE proximity clauses on purchase and sale agreements advising that dust and or odour may be noticeable from time to time. 20. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to appropriately dedicate Blocks 182 and 183, as identified on the Draft Plan of Subdivision, to the Town or to the adjacent Golf Course land Owner, as directed by the Town, in furtherance of addressing certain golf ball spray mitigation measures. 21. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to include an appropriately worded warning clause in agreements of purchase and sale for all affected Lots advising Purchasers of their lot’s proximity to the adjacent golf course and to the potential adverse impacts that might arise from the use, operation and maintenance of said golf course. 74 of 212 21a). That the Owner shall agree that the aforementioned Notice provision be registered against title to the subdivision lands either by way of restrictive covenant or by way of the creation of a right in the nature of an easement for entry of golf balls and golf related noise. 22. The Owner agrees in the Subdivision Agreement to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, to enter into a front ending financing agreement, which shall be registered on title, with respect to the construction Stewart Road booster station and the trunk watermain extension outlined in Condition 8. This agreement may deal with matters including, but not limited to the following, engineering standards, professional services, scope of work, best efforts for cost recovery from benefiting land owners, Development Charge credits, securities, and recovery for front-ended works. 23. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement that all dedications of land the Town of Collingwood requires shall be at no cost to the municipality. 24. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide fencing to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood, where required, including, but not limited to, interfaces between residential lots and Town owned lands such as park lands, open space, walkways, stormwater ponds and the Tenth Line. 25. That the Owner shall accommodate all existing drainage within and external to the subject plan according to the Town of Collingwood’s Stormwater Management Policies and to the satisfaction of the Engineering Services Department. Where improvements and/or adjustments to the existing systems are necessary to facilitate this development, it will be the Owner’s responsibility to provide the necessary works, including outlet improvements as required. 26. That prior to any site alteration within the plan, the following shall be prepared to the satisfaction of the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, and the Town of Collingwood: a) b) c) d) e) A detailed Stormwater Management Report; An Erosion Control Plan; A detailed Grading Plan; A detailed Geotechnical Report for the stormwater pond; and A detailed Enhancement and Landscaping Plan for the stormwater management ponds. 27. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in wording acceptable to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, to carry out or cause to be carried out the recommendations and measures contained within the plans and reports set out above. 28. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in wording acceptable to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, to ensure that all stormwater management facilities and sediment and/or erosion control measures will be in place prior to the creation of impervious areas such as roads and buildings being undertaken. 29. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in wording acceptable to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, to engage a qualified professional to certify in writing that the works were constructed in accordance with the plans, reports and specifications, as approved by the Conservation Authority. 75 of 212 30. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in wording acceptable to the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, that the necessary drainage easements be established and granted to the Town of Collingwood. 31. That prior to any site alteration or development at this location, required permits, under Ontario Regulation 172/06 and the Conservation Authorities Act, will be obtained from the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority and any necessary authorization from the Department of Fisheries and Oceans for any harmful alteration, disruption or destruction of fish habitat. 32. That the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority is notified in writing through a copy of the passed zoning by-law including its text and schedule that the stormwater management facilities have been restrictively zoned (e.g. Environmental Protection (EP)). 33. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide storm sewers suitably designed and of sufficient depth to provide for the proper drainage of the lands within and external to the subdivision and to discharge to drainage outlets as directed by and to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 34. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide sanitary sewers suitably designed and of sufficient depth to provide for the proper collection from the lands within and external to the subdivision as directed by and to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 35. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement that in order to provide proper and reliable water distribution systems within the development, reasonable looping of these systems shall be provided to the satisfaction of Collingwood Public Utilities Services. 36. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide electrical servicing suitably designed and of sufficient capacity to provide for the proper servicing of the lands within and external to the subdivision as directed by and to the satisfaction of the COLLUS PowerStream Corp. 37. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, that such easements and land dedications as may be required for access, drainage, servicing, stormwater management, utilities and construction purposes shall be designed to the satisfaction of, and granted to the appropriate agencies or authorities, free and clear of all encumbrances to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and all appropriate agencies or authorities. 38. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to provide to the Town of Collingwood, a soils report recommending the material necessary for road construction to meet Town standards. This report shall also address any potential groundwater issues as they related to the proposed development of homes, roads and stormwater management facilities. 39. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to make arrangements to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood for a suitable construction traffic route. 40. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement that prior to final approval, 76 of 212 arrangements will be made to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood for the relocation of any utilities required by the development of the subject lands to be undertaken at the expense of the Owner. 41. That the Owner will agree in the Subdivision Agreement that prior to final approval, the Owner is to submit a Streetscape and Stormwater Management Landscape Plan to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. The Streetscape/Landscape Plan shall conform to the Town of Collingwood Subdivision Guidelines and shall also address such matters as the location of driveways. 42. That prior to any tree removal or site alteration, the Owner shall submit an Application to Destroy Trees to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood and all site works shall be in strict accordance with the approved Permit and/or associated Agreement. 43. That prior to any tree removal or site alteration, the Owner shall be required to submit a Tree Preservation Plan to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. The Tree Preservation Plan shall be consistent with any and all applicable recommendations of the reports required to be prepared under Condition 25. 44. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to the preparation and implementation of architectural guidelines that conform to the Town of Collingwood Urban Design Manual and Subdivision Guidelines which govern the character of residential structures and commercial structures in a manner acceptable to the Town of Collingwood. The Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to construct all buildings and structures in conformity with the approved architectural guidelines, and to the inclusion of the approved architectural guidelines as a schedule to the Subdivision Agreement. 45. That the Subdivision Agreement between the Owner and the Town of Collingwood contain phasing arrangements, if required, to the satisfaction of the Town of Collingwood. 46. That prior to final approval, the Owner shall carry out an archaeological assessment of the subject property and mitigate, through preservation or resource removal and documentation, adverse impacts to any significant archaeological resources found. No tree cutting, stump removal, grading or other soil disturbances shall take place on the subject property prior to the Town of Collingwood and the Ministry of Culture confirming that all archaeological resource concerns have met licensing and resource conservation requirements. 47. That prior to final approval the Owner shall carry out a Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment and if deemed necessary Phase 2 and 3 studies. No grading or other soil disturbances shall take place on the subject property prior to the Town of Collingwood confirming satisfaction with the recommendations of the Environmental Site Assessment(s). 48. That the Owner shall co-ordinate the preparation of an overall utility distribution plan to the satisfaction of all effected authorities and the Town of Collingwood. 49. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, with wording to the satisfaction of the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board, to include in all offers of purchase and sale a clause advising prospective purchasers that pupils from this development attending educational facilities operated by the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic 77 of 212 District School Board may be transported to / accommodated in temporary facilities out of the neighbourhood school’s area. 50. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, with wording to the satisfaction of the Simcoe County District School Board, to include in all offers of purchase and sale a statement that advises the prospective purchaser that the public schools on designated sites in the community are not guaranteed. Attendance at schools in the area yet to be constructed is also not guaranteed. Pupils may be accommodated in temporary facilities and/or be directed to schools outside the area. 51. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, with wording to the satisfaction of the Simcoe County District School Board, to include in all offers of purchase and sale a statement that advises the prospective purchaser that school buses will not enter cul de sacs and that pick up points will not be located within the subdivision until major construction activity has been completed. 52. That the Owner shall provide Canada Post with two copies of the above-ground utility coordination plans. Furthermore, that the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement to the following: 53. a) work with Canada Post and the Town of Collingwood to determine and provide temporary suitable location prior to occupancy for the placement of the Centralized Mail Facility/Community Mailbox. b) work with Canada Post and the Town of Collingwood to determine the location of the Centralized Mail Facility/Community Mailboxes and to ensure that they are properly identified on all appropriate maps and plans; and, c) provide an appropriately sized sidewalk section (concrete pad) where applicable, to Canada Post’s and the Town of Collingwood’s specifications, any required walkways across the boulevard, and any required curb cuts for wheelchair access for the placement of the permanent Community Mailbox locations and include said requirements on the appropriate plans/maps. That the Owner shall insert the following conditions in the Subdivision Agreement to the satisfaction of Enbridge Gas Distribution: a) b) c) 54. Streets are to be constructed in accordance with the municipal standards; The Owner shall rough grade all boulevards as necessary prior to the installation of the gas lines and provide the necessary field survey information and references to final elevation required for the installation of the gas lines, all to the satisfaction of Enbridge Gas Distribution; All of the natural gas distribution system will be installed within the proposed road allowances therefore easements will not be required. The Owner is hereby advised that prior to commencing any work within the Plan, the Owner must confirm that sufficient wire-line communication / telecommunication infrastructure is currently available within the proposed development to provide communication / telecommunication service to the proposed development. In the event that such infrastructure is not available, the Owner is hereby advised that the Owner may be required to pay for the connection to and/or extension of the existing communication / telecommunication infrastructure. If the Owner elects not to pay for such connection to and/or extension of the existing communication / telecommunication 78 of 212 infrastructure, the Owner shall be required to demonstrate to the municipality that sufficient alternate communication / telecommunication facilities are available within the proposed development to enable, at a minimum, the effective delivery of communication / telecommunication services for emergency management service (i.e., 911 Emergency Services). 55. That the Owner shall agree in the Subdivision Agreement, in words satisfactory to the communication/telecommunication service provider, to grant the communication/telecommunication service provider any easements that may be required for telecommunications services. Easements may be required subject to final servicing decisions. In the event of any conflict with existing communication/telecommunication service provider facilities or easements, the Owner/Developer shall be responsible for the relocation of such facilities or easements. 56. That prior to final approval, a copy of the proposed final plan is to be forwarded to the Town of Collingwood as the Approval Authority for review and approval. 57. That prior to final approval the Town of Collingwood confirm, in writing, how conditions 225, 33 - 45, 47, 48, and 56 have been satisfied. 58. That prior to final approval the Town of Collingwood as the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority how conditions 26 to 32 inclusive have been satisfied. 59. That prior to final approval the Town of Collingwood as the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by the Ministry of Culture how condition 46 has been satisfied. 60. The prior to Final Approval the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by the Simcoe Muskoka Catholic District School Board how condition 49 has been satisfied. 61. That prior to Final Approval the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by the Simcoe County District School Board how conditions 50 & 51 have been satisfied. 62. That prior to final approval the Town of Collingwood as the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by Enbridge Gas Distribution how condition 53 has been satisfied. 63. That prior to final approval the Town of Collingwood as the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by Canada Post how condition 52 has been satisfied. 64. That prior to final approval the Town of Collingwood as the Approval Authority be advised, in writing, by communication/telecommunication provider how condition 54 & 55 have been satisfied. 65. That draft plan approval is for a period of three (3) years. The Owner shall apply for any extension at least sixty (60) days prior to the lapsing date. Notes to Draft Approval 1. It is the Owner’s responsibility to fulfill the conditions of draft approval and to ensure that the required clearance letters are forwarded to the Town as approval authority, quoting file SDR-2005-04, CW-T-0502 and D1202515 79 of 212 2. It is suggested that the Owner should review section 144 of the Land Titles Act and section 78 of the Registry Act. Subsection 144(1) of the Land Titles Act requires that a plan of condominium of land that is located in a land titles division be registered under the Land Titles Act. Exceptions to this provision are set out in subsection 144(2). 3. Subsection 78(11) of the Registry Act indicates that a description as defined in the Condominium Act, 1998 in respect of land that is within an area to which the Land Titles Act applies but not within an area designated under subsection 144(3) of the Land Titles Act shall not be registered under the Registry Act. 4. The Town requires all engineering drawings to be submitted in AutoCAD 14 format as well as hardcopy. 5. All measurements in final plans must be presented in metric units. 6. All lands to be conveyed must be free and clear of all encumbrances. 7. The Town of Collingwood Waste Water Treatment Plant and Water Treatment Plant capacities are subject to the registration of the plan and entering into the associated agreement. . 8. The Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority will require a copy of the executed Subdivision Agreement prior to the clearance of the draft plan conditions. 9. The Owner shall agree, prior to final approval, to pay all development fees to the Conservation Authority as required in accordance with the Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority’s fees policy, under the Conservation Authorities Act. 10. Bell Canada will utilize the existing easement over what is designated as Lot 28 within the draft plan of subdivision for the required digital equipment cabinet installation necessary to provide service to this subdivision. The Owner will be required to contact Bell Canada’s Engineering Department regarding the details for servicing within the subdivision as well as the necessary Letters of Understanding. The Bell Canada contact is Rick DeBokx 705-722-2354. 11. If agency draft plan conditions concern conditions within the Subdivision Agreement, a copy of the Agreement should be sent to them to expedite the clearance of the final plan. 12. The approval of this draft plan is for a period of three (3) years and will lapse on April 29, 2019. If final approval is not given to this plan within the draft approval time period above the draft approval will lapse under subsection 51(32) of the Planning Act. Draft approval may be extended pursuant to subsection 51(33) of the Planning Act, but no extension can be granted once the approval has lapsed. If the Owner wishes to request an extension to draft approval, a written explanation, together with the completed application form and fee, must be received by the Town sixty (60) days prior to the lapsing date. 80 of 212 13. The Final Plan approved by the Approval Authority must be registered within 30 days or the County may withdraw its approval under subsection 51(32) of the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, as amended. Subject to the conditions set forth above, approval for this Draft Plan is extended under Section 51 of the Planning Act R.S.O 1990, Chapter 13, as amended, this 2nd day of November, 2015. Sara Almas, Clerk Town of Collingwood Sandra Cooper, Mayor Town of Collingwood 81 of 212 82 of 212 83 of 212 84 of 212 STAFF REPORT P2015-34-C Reviewed by Development and Operations Services Standing Committee on October 26, 2015 Recommendation: That Council authorize the initiation of an OPA and ZBA Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor & Council Submitted by: Nancy Farrer, Director of Planning Services Subject: Backyard Urban Chickens PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to review a resident request to permit backyard chickens received by the Development and Operations Services Standing Committee, and to provide information related to urban chickens for Council’s consideration. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Staff Report P2015-34 for information purposes. OR THAT Council authorize the initiation of an application for Official Plan and Zoning By-law amendments and the required public consultation process and allow a moratorium of enforcement for existing properties with backyard chickens. 1. BACKGROUND Our region has recently seen a trend of residents seeking to raise backyard/urban chickens which has resulted in many area municipalities reviewing the issue with varying policy decisions. On September 28, 2015 a Collingwood resident brought to the Development and Operations Services Standing Committee a deputation outlining a request for the Town of Collingwood to amend its by-laws to allow for backyard chickens. Keeping of chickens and other varieties of livestock is currently a contravention of the Town’s Official Plan and Zoning By-law 2010-040. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES This report was forwarded to Department Heads meeting for review on October 20th, 2015 and it was recommended to proceed to Development & Operations Services Standing Committee for further consideration. -1- 85 of 212 Comments have been received from the public both in support and in opposition to changing Town policies. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION Town of Collingwood Community Based Strategic Plan (2015) – Supporting local food initiatives The Town of Collingwood Official Plan does not list the keeping of chickens as a specifically permitted use in Residential areas. In addition, in Rural areas intensive agricultural uses which are defined to include buildings for the raising of chickens, turkeys or other fowl, fish, fur bearing animals, hogs, and cattle, the keeping of horses, are not permitted. Section 4.7 of Zoning By-law 2010-040 and Town of Collingwood By-law 2012-016 – Responsible Pet Ownership By-law. 4. ANALYSIS Development and Operations Standing Committee Deputation The Deputation received on September 28, 2015 from Felicity Garbutt formally requested that the Town change Zoning By-law 2010-040. Section 4.7.1 (vi) currently prohibits “The use of a lot for the raising, breeding, keeping or intensive feeding of livestock or any prohibited animal or private zoo”. The request cites the Sustainable Community Plan (2008), specifically 3 of the 4 Pillars - environmental, economic and cultural. Ms. Garbutt explained “I believe small-scale chicken keeping is a healthy, economic and sustainable way to feed and enrich our families and our community”. The request recommended the Town regulate the keeping of hens and she provided some examples of limitations that could be imposed, such as specifying a maximum number of birds, a prohibition on roosters, sanitary requirements and license fees to remain revenue neutral. A petition was presented in support of backyard chickens with approximately 432 names (Appendix B). Not all were Collingwood residents. Staff Report P2014-20 On May 5, 2014 Council received staff report P2014-20 from the Planning Department outlining the general prohibition for livestock in the Town and the required changes to the Town’s Official Plan and Zoning By-law if Council wished to permit backyard chickens. At that time, no residents had come forward requesting the changes and no complaints of chickens in Town had been reported to the By-law Department. The report stated that “to investigate, develop and enact new policies and regulations, either supportive or prohibitive, would likely require a minimum of six to nine months”. Analysis In reviewing information provided by a number of sources including, news articles, numerous websites such as backyardchickens.ca and http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca, staff have prepared the following outlining some of the benefits and concerns of keeping backyard chickens in urban settings. Many of the benefits are centered on economic and locally -2- 86 of 212 sourced food and value as pets, while the concerns are primarily related to biosecurity, nuisances and public/animal health. Benefits Access to high quality eggs that are of higher nutritional value than those typically provided through our dominant food system; Access to eggs that come from a local, known source and help with food security; Friendly pets; Present a learning experience for families and neighbours and foster an understanding of where food comes from; and, Provide high quality fertilizer and may be used to dispose of weeds and kitchen scraps to avoid landfills. Concerns The Ontario Ministry for Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs’ website states four main issues municipalities should consider prior to developing by-laws around keeping poultry. “Animal Health and Public Health: Livestock and poultry can be sources of diseases that are passed to humans. These animals require health management and veterinary care, as well as basic biosecurity measures, to minimize the occurrence and spread of diseases. Animal Care: Basic hygiene is essential when caring for animals, who also need proper shelter, food, water and adequate space to stay healthy. Manure must be disposed of in a safe and environmentally responsible manner. But even with the best care, some animals will die, which means there have to be plans for disposing of dead animals. Predators: Livestock and poultry can attract predators such as coyotes, rats, skunks, raccoons, foxes and neighbourhood pets. Food Safety: Municipal Councils should also be aware of provincial and federal regulations regarding food safety. For example, regulations under the Food Safety and Quality Act, 2001 govern the sale of ungraded eggs.” By-law Enforcement and Planning Staff appreciate that many of these issues may be addressed with an appropriate by-law setting out for example that this use may only be permitted accessory to single detached homes, that there be minimum residential lot sizes for the keeping of chickens; and, required standards of care and limitations on coops and their placement. However consideration should be given to enforcement and the possible outcomes if these regulations are not willingly followed. Staff generally have fewer concerns with the keeping of a limited number of a variety of animals on the lands within Town that are designated and zoned rural. Some animal control related concerns would be: • Chickens running at large and abandoned chickens (where to take them); -3- 87 of 212 • • • • • Predators (Coyote/Raccoons) getting into substandard coops or at unsecure birds; Proper disposal of dead chickens, and slaughter practices; Financial and staffing impacts to run a licensing program with coop inspections; Pest concerns with insecure feed and unsanitary conditions; and, Potential for odours and noise that may bother other residents. Policy/By-law Amendments Required Should Council deem it appropriate to invest time and resources into further exploration of the issue, staff would prepare a draft Official Plan Amendment, a draft Zoning By-law Amendment, and details relating to the proposed regulation and oversight of an urban chicken program; such as limiting the number of chickens, not permitting roosters (noise), and minimum distances from neighbouring homes. Staff would advertise a public meeting so that there would be an opportunity for community consultation and the local health unit would be contacted for input. Staff would recommend that a decision to adopt an OPA and amend the Zoning By-law would not be made until after the above noted documentation is drafted and circulated widely for public comment. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES By-law and Administration costs for running a licensing/registration program and enforcement of the by-law, if approved. [Cost unknown] 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Resource A P2014-20 - http://www.collingwood.ca/node/10207 Appendix A Deputation and Petition - 2015-09-28 Chickens_Petition w deputation.pdf SIGNATURES Prepared by: Department head: Scott Gordon Municipal By-law Enforcement Officer Nancy Farrer Director, Planning Services Town of Collingwood Town of Collingwood -4- 88 of 212 89 of 212 90 of 212 91 of 212 92 of 212 93 of 212 94 of 212 95 of 212 96 of 212 97 of 212 98 of 212 99 of 212 100 of 212 101 of 212 102 of 212 103 of 212 104 of 212 105 of 212 106 of 212 107 of 212 108 of 212 109 of 212 110 of 212 111 of 212 STAFF REPORT PW2015-26 Reviewed by Development & Operations Standing Committee on October 26, 2015 Recommendation: Forward the report to Mayor and Council Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor & Council Submitted by: Brian Macdonald, Director, Public Works and Engineering Subject: Award of RFP PW2015-07 - Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to present the Request for Proposal results and award the contract for the Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receives Staff Report PW2015-26 to Award the RFP PW2015-07 entitled “Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting”; and THAT Council awards the $1,475,617.99 plus HST; and RFP to RealTerm Energy with a total cost of THAT Council authorizes staff and the Mayor to sign all necessary documents to execute the contract; and THAT Council authorizes the use of County of Simcoe Landfill Settlement monies to fund the LED street light retrofit project. -1- 112 of 212 1. BACKGROUND Over the past several years, LED lighting technology has advanced to a point where it matches or exceeds existing lighting technologies from both a technical and financial perspective, all while providing significant energy savings. As such, and with provincial incentive programs available, staff believe it an opportune time to retrofit the Town’s street lighting system. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES Reviewed at Department Heads meeting on October 20, 2015. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION The completion of the LED street light retrofit project was a recommendation outlined in the Town of Collingwood Public Works and Engineering Services Review Report (August 14, 2015), conducted by BMA Management Consulting Inc. The Province's Green Energy Act, regulation 397/11 mandated that the Town create an Energy Conservation and Demand Management plan for its facilities (i.e. buildings). Since street lighting does not fall under the “facilities” category, the LED retrofit was not included in this plan; however, the retrofit initiative can be considered a complimentary program and in line with the spirit the act and regulation. 4. ANALYSIS The Engineering department called for proposals for the LED retrofit of the Town’s existing street light system. A public Request for Proposal (RPF) was issued August 20, 2015, on Biddingo.com and closed September 16, 2015, at 3PM in the Clerk’s office. Four proposals were received. A staff committee independently evaluated and ranked each of the proposals taking into consideration the firm’s corporate capabilities and experience, understanding of the project objectives, work program and innovation, proposed schedule, references, product and warranty, project team, and finally their fees and disbursements. The chart below indicates the combined committee evaluation rankings: Firm RealTerm Energy Consultant B Consultant C Consultant D Technical Financial Total Ranking Ranking Ranking 69.3 18.7 88.0 67.0 17.8 84.8 49.3 20.0 69.3 Did not meet minimum requirements RealTerm Energy will be working in collaboration with Local Authority Services (LAS), a not-forprofit organization that was created by the Association of Municipalities of Ontario (AMO) to help municipalities realize lower costs and higher revenues through co-operative procurement efforts and innovative programs and services. -2- 113 of 212 RealTerm Energy has contracted with Barrie, Owen Sound, Innisfil, Georgina, Blue Mountains, Wasaga Beach and 125 other municipalities for a full turn-key LED street lighting service (mostly in Ontario). They are an experienced firm who are more than capable of carrying out a successful project. Investment Grade Audit Phase 1 of the project is the creation of an Investment Grade Audit (IGA). This includes a survey and inventory of the Town’s existing street lights; a photometric study to determine the wattage and type of replacement fixtures; IESO incentive amounts; a financial breakdown of the exact cost to complete the retrofit; and anticipated electricity and maintenance savings. For bidding purposes, the Town provided an inventory of the Town’s street lighting system. Due to the age of the system, the Town’s inventory is expected to be somewhat inaccurate. As a result, the supplier will be paid based on the number of units installed at the unit rate provided in their proposal, as opposed to an upset limit. This means that the price quoted of $1,475,617.99 could fluctuate. If the IGA yields a lower price, staff will proceed with the project; however, if the IGA yields a higher price, staff will seek approval from council to proceed. In any event, Council has the option to cancel the project altogether, with the supplier being paid only for work done to prepare the IGA. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES Staff Report T2015-07-C (attached) proposed to utilize the County of Simcoe Solid Waste Landfill Settlement monies to fund the LED retrofit – these monies total $1,657,133. Staff was instructed to defer the decision whether to utilize these funds for this project until more information was known. While it is anticipated that the total project cost will fluctuate based on the actual number of existing fixtures, it is not anticipated that the price will exceed the $1,657,133 available. It is therefore requested that these monies be used to fund the LED retrofit project. Staff is not aware of any other capital project that could provide comparable betterment to the Town. The LED retrofit provides the best return on investment as it provides savings to the Town in perpetuity. Savings on electricity and maintenance costs could amount to approximately $135,000 per year, with this number being refined as part of the Investment Grand Audit. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Appendix A Staff Report T2015-07-C SIGNATURES Prepared by: Department head: John Velick, P.Eng. Manager, Engineering Services Brian Macdonald Director, Public Works and Engineering Town of Collingwood Town of Collingwood -3- 114 of 212 115 of 212 STAFF REPORT T2015-07-C Reviewed by Strategic Initiatives Standing Committee March 28, 2015 Recommendation: Amended Date: April 7, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Dennis Sloan, Treasury Financial Planning & Policy Development Brian MacDonald, Director Public Works and Engineering LED technology streetlight upgrade project Subject: PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to receive Council approval to: RFP a proposed capital project to retrofit Collingwood’s streetlights with LED technology. This project was included in the 2015 Budget Accept a Settlement proposal from the County of Simcoe for Collingwood’s Solid Waste Landfill Use Landfill Settlement monies to fund the LED Streetlight retrofit project. STRATEGIC INITIATIVES STANDING COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: THAT the Strategic Initiatives Standing Committee support and refer the following recommendation to the next regular meeting of Council. THAT Council direct an RFP be issued for upgrading of all existing streetlights with LED technology, and if the project is accepted and awarded that an application be made for the Ontario Power Authority (OPA) Grant opportunity. THAT Council accept the County of Simcoe’s Landfill Settlement Proposal and defer the decision to utilize the funds for the LED light project until additional information regarding the RFP and the LED technology/opportunities are provided to Council. ………………………………………………………………………………………………….. Staff Recommendation: THAT Council direct an RFP be issued for the upgrading of all existing streetlights with LED technology; AND THAT Council direct an application be made for Ontario Power Authority (OPA) Grant; AND FURTHER THAT the Council accept the County of Simcoe’s Landfill Settlement -1- 116 of 212 Proposal in order to fund the LED light project. 1. BACKGROUND A proposal to upgrade Collingwood’s streetlights to LED technology has been included as part of the 2015 Capital Budget for the Public Works Department. The project has obvious merits in that it creates significant operating efficiencies in the form of reduced energy consumption and significantly reduced annual maintenance requirements. Also, there are incentives and rebates from the OPA. However, there is a significant up front project cost of $1.4m net of the OPA rebate which cannot be accommodated from the existing capital reserves. These existing reserves are primarily earmarked for asset replacement and refurbishment. An alternate option to use vendor financing was considered but this approach increases the overall cost of the project significantly and, as such, was deemed unacceptable. The funding approach we have investigated and are recommending for Council’s approval is to use the proceeds from a settlement proposal from the County of Simcoe for Collingwood’s solid waste landfill site to finance the LED project. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES 1) Proposed Landfill Settlement Methodology – County of Simcoe 2) LAS Streetlight Program 3) Strategic Initiatives Standing Committee reviewed the information and provided alternative direction to staff. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION NOT APPLICABLE 4. ANALYSIS LED Lights LED lights offer many benefits over traditional street lighting technology. The main advantage is energy consumption; LED lighting typically consumes 40-70% less energy than existing systems. Another advantage is the long life span of the LED “bulbs” themselves. LED lights have a typical lifespan of over 100,000 hours, or approximately 22 years. This translates into substantial maintenance savings as lights will require replacement less often. The light given off by LED technology is also improved. Existing High Pressure Sodium bulbs give off an orange like glow while LEDs emit a colour spectrum that mimics that of the moon, providing brighter and cleaner illumination that can help improve roadway safety. Not only is the light of a better quality, but it can be directed more efficiently. LED lighting is more controllable than the old style, meaning more light can be directed out of people’s yards and windows and onto the roadway. In addition, most LED manufacturers produce International Dark Sky -2- 117 of 212 Association Compliant units that emit very little light upwards into the atmosphere, reducing overall light pollution. The dollar savings based on the above noted efficiencies is estimated to be $135,000 per year based on our streetlights current average annual consumption of 1.5m kWs and a billing rate of $0.15/kWs. A 50% energy savings would therefore equate to $113,000 annually. An estimated 80% savings on maintenance would be a further $22,000 for a combined savings of $135,000 annually before factoring in inflation. Collingwood Solid Waste Landfill The County of Simcoe assumed responsibility for all waste collection in 1991 which included the assumption of the waste management assets of the member municipalities. At that point in time, the County entered into agreements with the municipalities for the repayment of the deemed value of the assets. These agreements generally follow a format which repays the settlement amount with a discount from the tipping fee multiplied by the municipality’s annual residential tonnage. However, in the past decade (and mainly due to the success of recycling diversion programs) annual waste tonnage has been reduced significantly as has the resulting annual repayments based on the tipping fees. This has effectively extended significantly the time frame of the settlements values, in some cases in excess of 100 years. Some of the impacted municipalities requested the County accelerate this timeframe and, as a result, in 2013 the County came up with a settlement proposal in the form of onetime lump sum payments for each municipality. Simcoe’s proposal to Collingwood was $1.7m calculated as follows: Settlement Calculation Detail Landfill Settlement Balance as of Dec 31,2013 Average Annual Payment over last 5 years Estimated Years to payback $2,526,248 $110,314 23 Interest Rate to Calculate net present value1 Present Value of Remaining Payment 3.50% $1,718,250 Financing Proposal The merits of the financing approach being proposed is perhaps most simply illustrated by comparing the present value of the repayment income stream we currently receive 1 A discount rate is used to determine the present value of the payments. Due to the long payment term, 30-year rates are used. The 30-year Infrastructure Ontario Municipal lending rate is currently 4.06% and the 30-year Canada Bond investment yield is currently 2.93%. To be fair to both the County and the Municipality, the average of these borrowing and investment rates (3.50%) is used as the discount rate. -3- 118 of 212 from the County for the landfill with the present value of the operational savings to be realized from the LED streetlights efficiencies. Based on the above calculations we already know the present value of the landfill repayment stream to be $1.7m whereas the present value of the $134,000 estimated annual operational savings from the LED light discounted indefinitely at 5% is $2.7m. A discount rate of 5% is used as this is the current estimated inflation rate for electricity and the $135m annual savings is assumed to continue indefinitely 2. Based on the two present value calculations, it is clearly more beneficial by $1m for Collingwood to pursue the proposed funding approach. In addition, it should be noted that only $1.4m of the $1.7m received from the County for the landfill is required for the LED project. The remaining $300m is available for other capital needs or can be added to the Lifecycle Capital Reserve Fund for future capital asset requirements. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES This item has been included in the 2015 Transportation Capital Budget Estimated annual savings of $135,000 in electricity consumption Eliminate revenue for next 23 years in the form of Landfill tipping fee royalty which has averaged $110,000 annually for last five years. The estimated payback period for the LED streetlight project would be 10.4 years based on a investment of $1.4m and annual savings of $135,000. The annual rate of return on the investment of $1.4m would 9.6%. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Appendix A Simcoe County Solid Waste Management landfill settlement proposal letter Resource 1 https://saveonenergy.ca/Business/Program-Overviews/LightingIncentives/Available-Lighting-Incentives/LED-Incentives.aspx https://www.las.on.ca/Services/Streetlight-Program.aspx Resource 2 SIGNATURES Prepared by: Dennis Sloan Department head: Marjory Leonard Dennis Sloan Deputy Director Financial Planning & Policy Development Town of Collingwood Marjory Leonard Treasurer Town of Collingwood 2 Another way to understand this amount is to think about what amount of money you need in a bank account at 5% interest to return an annual interest income of $135,000. That amount is $2.7m -4- 119 of 212 120 of 212 121 of 212 STAFF REPORT Report # PW2015-28 Reviewed by Development & Operations Standing Committee on October 26, 2015 Recommendation: The report proceed to Mayor & Council Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor & Council Submitted by: Brian MacDonald, Director, Public Works and Engineering Subject: Adoption of The Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy and Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments PURPOSE The purpose of this report is to provide Council with the proper information to adopt a Winter Control Policy to set and maintain a level of service for winter maintenance within the Town of Collingwood. Additionally, amendments to the current Minimum Maintenance Standards (MMS) are required to be amended to include recent updates. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Staff Report PW2015-28 entitled “Adoption of The Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy and Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments ”and, THAT Council adopts the Town of Collingwood Winter Control Plan dated October 16, 2015; and, THAT Council amends By-Law 2010-056 to include O.Reg 47/13, amendments to the Minimum Maintenance Standards for Municipal Highways. -1- 122 of 212 1. BACKGROUND The Town is obligated to maintain its road and sidewalk network under the provisions of the Ontario Municipal Act. Such maintenance activities include winter control services to ensure at least a minimum level of safety for motorists and pedestrians. Providing a safe road and sidewalk network mitigates liability for the Town and ensures accessibility and efficient mobility of persons, goods and services throughout the municipality. The Public Works Department is responsible to deliver winter control services, including snow plowing, sanding & salting, winter drainage and sweeping & cleaning. Winter maintenance levels of service for the road system are based on a road classification priority system. Higher order roads such as arterials are highest priority; roads such as residential streets are lower priority. Additionally, specific snowfall thresholds apply for the plowing requirements of roads and sidewalks. The Ontario Municipal Act gives municipalities jurisdiction over the maintenance of their road and sidewalk network. A municipality is responsible to reasonably maintain its road system throughout the year, including maintenance activities relating to winter control. Should a municipality neglect to reasonably maintain its road system, it can be found liable for all damages any person may sustain. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES OGRA Winter Manuals: A Guideline to Developing a Level of Service Policy A Guideline for Patrolling Representative Roads in Winter A Guideline for Preparing and Decommissioning Winter Operations A Guideline for Training Patrol Staff A guideline for Weather Monitoring 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION Ontario Regulation 239/02 Minimum Maintenance Standards 4. ANALYSIS A. Winter Control Policy A municipality’s best defense against claims of default of maintenance is the establishment and implementation of Minimum Maintenance Standards. Although, the Town of Collingwood has established and implemented such standards including those for winter maintenance of our road and sidewalk network, the attached Winter Control Plan, dated October 2015, is intended to provide greater clarity with respect to the implementation of the Minimum Maintenance Standards (MMS); and more specifically, as it relates to the Town of Collingwood. -2- 123 of 212 The objective of the Winter Control Plan and Policy is to allow Committee and Council to: 1. Establish the level of service that it considers adequate for winter control operations for municipal roads and parking lots and to allocate the appropriate budget and resources that are needed to provide that level of service; 2. Provide general direction to Staff with respect to winter maintenance operations for roads, sidewalks and parking lots and to outline a systematic and consistent approach to providing winter control; and 3. Provide direction to Staff when dealing with complaints and concerns raised by the public and others. The Winter Control Plan sets out the level of service for winter maintenance operations for roads, sidewalks and municipal parking lots. It further establishes the discretion that is necessary and appropriate to enable the Director of Public Works, or designate, to address abnormal winter storm events. The policy recognizes that operational decisions will need to be made based on local conditions in the field depending upon the extent and severity of a winter storm event, and as a result, there may necessarily have to be some reasonable deviations from this Plan. Despite what is stated in this Winter Control Plan, as a minimum, the Town will adhere to the Minimum Maintenance Standards for Municipal Highways as prescribed by the Ontario Ministry of Transportation under Regulation 239/02, as amended from time to time. All other regulatory requirements will also need to be met, including but not necessarily limited to those set out in the Highway Traffic Act. The Winter Control Plan will be used to educate, not only staff, but the general public, with regards to winter maintenance activities in the Town of Collingwood. B. Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments Some of the main revisions under this new Regulation include the following: 1. Section 1(1) was revised by adding new definitions. The ice definition makes clear that “ice” means all kinds of ice, and takes into account that ice can form by snow bonding to the road surface, humidity in the air precipitating out of the air, freezing rain or water on the road (e.g. broken watermain) freezing and/or refreezing. 2. Section 3.1 was added to set out a standard for weather monitoring between October 1st and April 30th as once per shift or 3 times per calendar day, whichever is greater. At all other times, the standard is once per calendar day. 3. Section 4 underwent revision to add a deeming clause that makes it clear that a road is in a state of repair if the snow accumulation on a roadway is less than or equal to the depth set out in the Table to the section for the class of roadway in question. This does not mean that municipalities can standby and do nothing until the trigger depth has been -3- 124 of 212 exceeded. The revised regulation strengthens the relationship between section 4 and 5 with the inclusion of the prevention of ice formation in section 5(1). 4. Revisions to Section 5 Icy Roadways have been extensive: a) In Giuliani v. Region of Halton et. al., the Court of Appeal upheld the judge’s reasoning that the municipality should have taken reasonable steps to avoid the formation of ice on a roadway. As stated above, section 5(1) provides a minimum standard for the prevention of ice formation on a roadway. Prevention steps include monitoring the weather, patrolling as required, and if the municipality determines that there is a substantial probability of ice forming on the roadway in question, to have treated the roadway starting from the time the municipality determines is appropriate. The addition of section 5(1)(3) provides the flexibility needed to time the response and local procedures with the weather forecast provided; b) Section 5(2) recognizes that in spite of municipality’s efforts to prevent ice from forming, sometimes there will be icy roadways. If a municipality has complied with section 5(1) then until a municipality has become aware of the fact that a roadway is icy, or until ice has been present on the roadway for an amount of time greater than the time set forth in the Table to section 5 of MMS for the class of roadway in question, whichever is sooner, the roadway is deemed to be in a state of repair; c) To ensure that municipalities can select the appropriate treatment, a definition of “treating” is provided in section 5(4). “Treating” a roadway means applying material to the roadway, including but not limited to, salt, sand or any combination of salt and sand. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES The adoption of the Winter Control Policy and the Amendments to the current MMS will not have a direct impact on the winter maintenance budget. 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy Rev. October 2015 O.Reg 239/02 Minimum Maintenance Standards for Ontario Highways SIGNATURES Submitted by: Kris Wiszniak Engineering Technician Town of Collingwood Department Head: Brian MacDonald Director of Engineering Town of Collingwood -4- 125 of 212 THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT WINTER CONTROL POLICY October 2015 Rev. No. 1 TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page1 126 of 212 SECTION 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 5.0 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 8.0 9.0 11.0 12.0 13.0 14.0 15.0 TABLE OF CONTENTS DESCRIPTION PAGE NO. POLICY OBJECTIVES RESPONSIBILITIES WINTER CONTROL OPERATIONS – GENERAL INFORMATION EQUIPMENT HOURS OF WORK VISIBILITY & DRIVER SAFETY EMERGENCY AND POLICE SERVICES WINTER PREPARATIONS SNOW PLOWING OPERATIONS – PUBLIC ROADS, LANEWAYS, CUL‐DE‐SACS & PARKING LOTS SNOW CLEARING OPERATIONS ‐ SIDEWALKS MUNICIPAL‐OWNED FACILITIES AND PARKING LOTS SNOW CLEARING OPERATIONS – PUBLIC TRANSIT SANDING AND/OR SALTING OPERATIONS STOCK PILING OF WINTER SAND & SALT ICE FORMATION ON ROADWAYS AND TREATING ICY ROADWAYS APPLICATION OF SAND / SANDING APPLICATION OF SALT / SALTING PEELING OPERATIONS SNOW REMOVAL & HAULING WINTER DRAINAGE WINTER SAND REMOVAL INTERFERENCE WITH WINTER CONTROL OPERATIONS DAMAGE RESULTING FROM WINTER MAINTENANCE OPERATIONS INQUIRIES AND/OR COMPLAINTS 5 5 6 6 7 7 8 8 8 9 11 12 13 14 14 14 15 16 16 17 17 18 18 19 20 TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page2 127 of 212 DISCLAIMER This Policy is based on normal winter weather conditions, reliability and availability of resources both human and physical. The Town does not guarantee a level of service under abnormal or extreme winter conditions nor in the event of a work stoppage. It is acknowledged that conditions may occur which temporarily prevent achieving levels assigned. In such cases, efforts will be made to keep roads open, consistent with available resources. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page3 128 of 212 Definitions “Average Annual Daily Traffic” (AADT) is a measure used primarily in transportation planning and transportation engineering. Traditionally, it is the total volume of vehicle traffic of a highway or road for a year divided by 365 days. “Director of Public Works” means the Director of Public Works and Engineering for the Town of Collingwood. “Manager of Public Works” means the Manager of Public Works for the Town of Collingwood. “Patrolling Representative Roads” means the field observation and recording of road and weather conditions on select roads within a municipal jurisdiction to determine if a winter event response is required to a winter event. Patrolling may or may not be supplemented by electronic surveillance. “Winter Event” means a weather condition affecting roads such as snowfall, wind blown snow, sleet, freezing rain, frost or ice, to which an event response is required. “Winter Season” means the season when the Municipality normally performs winter highway maintenance as identified in the Winter Control Plan. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page4 129 of 212 THE TOWN OF TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT WINTER CONTROL POLICY SECTION 1.0 POLICY 1.1 The Town of Town of Collingwood will ensure that roadways are maintained in such a manner as to minimize economic loss to the community, prevent or reduce accident and injury and facilitate access for emergencies by the emergency responders and police services. 1.2 The Town will establish a level of service that is adequate for winter control operations for municipal roads and parking lots and to allocate the appropriate budget and resources that are needed to provide that level of service. 1.3 As a minimum, the Town will adhere to the Minimum Maintenance Standards (MMS) for Municipal Highways as prescribed by the Ontario Ministry of Transportation under O.Reg. 239/02, as amended from time to time and as adopted by Collingwood Council as per By‐Law 2010‐056 1.4 The Town acknowledges that there may be times when, due to the severity of a winter event, the level of service may not be achieved within the usual time allotted. Under such circumstances, the Town will endeavour to recover winter maintenance operations in accordance with the Winter Control Policy as soon as practicable. SECTION 2.0 OBJECTIVES The objective of the Winter Control Policy is to define standards to be maintained and procedures to be followed, to reduce the hazards resulting from winter snow and ice, in order to maintain the Town’s roadways and sidewalks in a safe condition. Winter control standards establish levels of service for snow and ice control based on classes and priorities of roadways and sidewalks, to ensure the safe and efficient movement of people, goods and services, throughout the Municipality. The standards take into account the difference in traffic conditions and associated required risk management, on the various classes of roadways and sidewalks. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page5 130 of 212 Winter control procedures indicate the actions to be taken in order to maintain the above noted standards. The procedures, in conjunction with the standards, recognize that winter control measures cannot be carried out on all roadways and sidewalks at the same time, and due to the associated required risk management, must follow the priorities as defined by the classifications of the roadways and sidewalks. SECTION 3.0 RESPONSIBILITIES 3.1 The Director of Public Works is ultimately responsible for the winter control operations within the Town of Town of Collingwood. 3.2 The Manager of Public Works, reporting to the Director of Public Works, is directly responsible for winter control operations. 3.2 The Manager of Public Works or designate is responsible for ensuring the winter storm response is in accordance with this Winter Control Policy. The Manager of Public Works, along with supervisory staff, will be familiar with this Policy and will conduct winter maintenance tasks to achieve and maintain safe driving and ease of traffic flow. 3.3 Public Works staff, including Labourers, Truck Drivers and Heavy Equipment Operators, will operate in a safe and efficient manner at all times. They are responsible for ensuring their vehicles and/or equipment is in a safe and mechanically ready state. Drivers and Operators will also be responsible to ensure that their route is completed in accordance with the Winter Control Policy. The Drivers and Operators will report to their immediate supervisors if there are any problems or difficulties with their equipment, both at the start of or during the storm response. SECTION 4.0 WINTER CONTROL OPERATIONS – GENERAL INFORMATION The Municipalities’ season to monitor and perform winter maintenance is between October 1st and April 30th. On average, the Town of Town of Collingwood receives over 250 centimetres of snow each winter. A major snowfall can produce an accumulation of 30 centimetres or more. The Town of Town of Collingwood currently has approximately 338 lane kilometers of road, including 25 bridges(1). All of these streets are asphalted, with the exception of a few gravel and chip sealed streets. The Town of Town of Collingwood has over 79 km of concrete sidewalks, most of which are cleared of snow. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page6 131 of 212 As the municipality continues to grow, the maintenance of streets and sidewalks is reviewed each year and adjusted, as necessary, to take into account the addition of new infrastructure. (1) A ‘Bridge’ is defined as a structure with a span of more than 3.0 metres in accordance with the Public Transportation & Highway Improvement Act. The Town’s 19 bridges consist of 9 vehicular bridges and 10 culverts with a span >3.0m. SECTION 4.1 EQUIPMENT The following is a breakdown of the vehicles used for winter operations. The number of equipment can vary due to major break down, replacements and reassignments. 6 Plow Trucks (3 equipped with sander units) 3 Contracted Plow/Sander Combination Units 1 Contracted Pickup Truck with plow 1 Motor Grader 1 Loader equipped with blade 4 Multi‐Purpose Sidewalk plows or blowers 3 Sander Trucks The Public Works Department undertakes certain steps and procedures to have the snow removal equipment ready and operators prepared for service and in place by October and includes the following: a) Assigning equipment to staff. b) Calibrating material application equipment. c) Allowing operators (staff and contract) time to familiarize themselves with any new equipment, material application rates, material application equipment and their route (driving the route and noting obstacles along the route). d) Assigning staff to monitor and record weather forecasts on a daily basis. Upon the forecast of an approaching winter event, schedule a patrol of a route of representative roads. e) Having a reasonable % of the fleet ready to respond to a winter event. f) Having sufficient staff available to operate the fleet if conditions warrant a winter event response. SECTION 4.2 HOURS OF WORK Regular Shift Depending on the start time and duration of a winter storm event, winter control activities will generally commence at 4:00am and continue until all roads have been serviced. It is recognized that this may be amended under abnormal weather (i.e. wet snow, icy conditions) and/or heavy snowfall conditions; whereby staff may be called in to initiate winter control operations. Alternatively, shift starting times may be adjusted at the discretion of the Manager of Public Works or designate. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page7 132 of 212 There is no regular shift on Saturday or Sunday. Winter control activities during the weekend are initiated by the On‐Call Supervisory staff, including the Supervisor, Lead Hand, or Manager of Public Works. Maintenance staff will be called in at the discretion of Supervisory staff. Connecting Link route has twenty‐four (24) coverage for winter control operations which is carried out under contract with a qualified contractor. Connecting Link route also has twenty‐ four (24) hour winter patrol coverage. NOTE: The Town of Town of Collingwood only allows employees to work a maximum of 13 hours during a shift unless an employee must work due to an emergency. Working hours shall be in accordance with the Highway Traffic Act (O. Reg. 555/06) Hours of Service Legislation. SECTION 4.3 VISIBILITY & DRIVER SAFETY Winter control activities may be suspended on some or all of the roads at the discretion of the Director of Public Works, or designate, when it is deemed to be unsafe for the staff and the equipment to be on the road due to weather conditions such as, but not limited to, drifting snow or freezing rain. Winter control operations may also be suspended in local areas when vehicles or other obstructions make snow plowing operations ineffective or difficult. If winter control operations are suspended, roads may be temporarily closed to vehicular traffic at the discretion of the Ontario Provincial Police. SECTION 4.4 EMERGENCY AND POLICE SERVICES Public Works staff will respond to requests for winter control from the O.P.P. and the Fire Department, as it deems appropriate and when practical to do so. In the event that roads are impassable, public works staff will maintain direct communication with emergency services. SECTION 5.0 WINTER PREPARATIONS Weather Monitoring From October 1st to April 30th, the minimum standard is to monitor the weather, both current and forecast to occur in the next 24 hours, once every shift or three times per calendar day, whichever is more frequent, at intervals determined by the Manager of Public Works or their designate. At the start of each shift the weather forecast will be documented by each patroller, with continued monitoring throughout the duration of their shift. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page8 133 of 212 For the purposes of this section, “Weather” is defined as air temperature, wind and precipitation. Patrolling The minimum standard for the frequency of patrolling roadways shall be in accordance with the Minimum Maintenance Standards, as amended from time to time, and set out in Table 5.1 below. TABLE 5.1 PATROLLING FREQUENCY Class of Roadway Time 2 Twice every 7 Days 3 Once every 7 days 4 Once every 14 days 5 Once every 30 days O.Reg. 239/02, s.3, Table; O.Reg. 23/10, s.3 (2) If there is a substantial probability of snow accumulation on roadways, ice formation on roadways or icy roadways, the minimum standard for patrolling highways is, in addition to that set out in the Table above, to patrol roadways that the municipality selects as representative of its roadways, at intervals deemed necessary to check for such conditions. A map of the representative roads are illustrated in Appendix ‘E’. Snow Markers Snow markers are placed by Public Works Staff in order to identify hazardous conditions or for outlining the turning radii on roads and sidewalks. Markers are typically 1”x2” wooden stakes driven into the ground with the ends spray painted orange for visibility. SECTION 6.0 SNOW PLOWING OPERATIONS – PUBLIC ROADS, LANEWAYS, CUL‐DE‐SACS & PARKING LOTS The levels of service for the Minimum Maintenance Standards vary according to the classification of the road, street or highway. The standards classify roads, streets or highways based on Average Annual Daily Traffic (AADT) and on the posted or statutory Speed Limit, in six (6) roadway classifications. Snow clearing equipment is deployed when snow accumulation exceeds the depths noted in Table 6.0 based on the designated road classification. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page9 134 of 212 “snow accumulation” means the natural accumulation of any of the following that, alone or together, covers more than half a lane width of a roadway: 1. Newly‐fallen snow 2. Wind‐blown snow 3. Slush After the snow accumulation has ended, the duration to clear the snow to a depth less than or equal to the depth set out in the Table within the time set out in the Table. TABLE 6.0 SNOW ACCUMULATION Class of Roadway Depth Time 1 2.5 cm 4 hours 2 5 cm 6 hours 3 8 cm 12 hours 4 8 cm 16 hours 5 10 cm 24 hours O. Reg. 47/13, s. 4 For the purposes of this section, addressing snow accumulation on a roadway includes, but is not limited to, (a) plowing the roadway; (b) salting the roadway; (c) applying abrasive materials to the roadway (sand); or (d) any combination of the methods described in clauses (a), (b) and (c) It is important to note that there are no Class 1 Roads within the Town of Town of Collingwood. The Town is comprised of Class 2, Class 3, Class 4 and Class 5 Roads. For the purpose of the Winter Control Policy, Class 2 Roads include major arterial roads, including, but not limited to the following: First Street, Huron Street, Pretty River Parkway otherwise know as the Connecting Link. For the purpose of the Winter Control Policy, Class 3 Roads include arterial and major collector roads, including, but not limited to the following: Third Street Mountain Road Collins Street Ontario Street Hume Street Peel Street S. Of Hume TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page10 135 of 212 Hurontario Street Second Street Highway 26 West Sixth Street High Street Class 4 Roads include minor collector roads, including, but not limited to the following: 10th Line Campbell Street Spruce Street Lockhart Road St. Marie Street Oak Street Maple Street St. Paul Street Class 5 Roads include all remaining residential local streets, laneways and cul‐de‐sacs. For the purpose of snow clearing, the roadways within the Town of Town of Collingwood have been sub‐ divided into designated plow routes (See Appendix A ‐ Snow Plow Routes). Public Works staff will begin winter control operations in the general priority sequence set out in prescribed plow routes or as directed by the Public Works Manager, or designate, taking into account the start and expected duration of a winter storm event. Each route takes approximately eight (8) hours to complete, depending on weather, traffic, available staff & equipment and number of vehicles parked on the street. The following is the general priority for snow plowing and sanding/salting operations within designated plow routes: Roadway Priorities a) Priority 1 Arterial and Major Collector Roads (Class 2 & 3 Roadways) Roads providing access to emergency services b) Priority 2 Collector Roads (Class 4 Roadways) Access to Municipal Offices and Facilities c) Priority 3 Local Roads, Side Streets and cul‐de‐sacs (Class 5 Roadways) It is acknowledged that in the event of emergencies, mechanical breakdowns, accidents or other operational problems, objectives set forth may not be met. SECTION 6.1 SNOW CLEARING OPERATIONS ‐ SIDEWALKS TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page11 136 of 212 Sidewalks are classified in accordance with the associated pedestrian traffic and proximity to high volume roadways, in addition to the ease with which they can be cleared. A map entitled Town of Town of Collingwood – Sidewalk Plow Routes is included in the appendices (Appendix B) and consists of the following classifications as shown in Table 6.1. TABLE 6.1 SIDEWALK CLASSIFICATIONS CLASS DESCRIPTION Class 1 Class 2 Sidewalks adjacent to high volume roadways with high pedestrian volumes, including School Zones and Downtown BIA areas Balance of sidewalks that can be cleared with mechanized plow and/or blower equipment. Class 2 Sidewalks consist of the majority of the Town sidewalks that can be cleared with mechanized plow equipment and are not adjacent to high volume roadways and/or have high pedestrian volumes. Sidewalk operations will begin with snow clearing on Class 1 sidewalks. As weather conditions allow, Class 2 sidewalk operations will follow, and typically will continue on a regular shift basis, until complete. Typically, during a winter storm event, sidewalk clearing operations will commence thee(3) to four(4) hours following the start of the road plowing operations. It is the objective to clear sidewalks as soon as possible after a storm has ended and normally within 24 hours from the end of the storm event. Sanding and/or salting of the sidewalks will occur along all sidewalks and to address icy/slippery conditions freezing rain events, at the discretion of supervisory staff. SECTION 6.2 MUNICIPAL‐OWNED FACILITIES AND PARKING LOTS The following parking lots are maintained by qualified contractors during the winter season. Maintenance includes snow removal and stockpiling as well as application of abrasives and de‐icing materials. 1. Town Hall 5. Fire Hall 2. Arena Parking Lot 6. Centennial Pool 3. St. Marie Parking Lot 7.Library 4. Central Park 8.Pine Street Parking Lot 9. Harbourview Parking Lot 10.Leisure time club 11.Pawplar Dog Park TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page12 137 of 212 Snow will be stockpiled at strategic locations in the parking lots to minimize lost parking spaces. Snow removal operations from the parking lots during the day and evening are expected to be extremely inefficient, not only because of parked cars and traffic conflicts in the work areas, but also because of delays experienced traveling to and from the snow dumps. Therefore, snow removal operations will be performed at night. Travelled portions of the parking lots will be cleared in the event of heavy accumulation. Noise associated with backup alarms on snow clearing and removal equipment may be considered a nuisance to adjacent properties; however, must be installed to comply with legislative requirements of the Occupational Health & Safety Act. SECTION 6.3 SNOW CLEARING OPERATIONS – PUBLIC TRANSIT Colltrans routes have been designed where possible to maintain service along arterial and collector roads within the Town of Collingwood. Arterial and collector roads are among the Town’s initial priorities for snow clearing operations, and as such the majority of the transit routes will be cleared earlier within the scheduled plow shift. It is recognized that there are some routes that utilize local roads and will not be cleared as efficient has the collector and arterial roads, however Colltrans will maintain a regular scheduled service as snow clearing operations are underway. In the event of a major event transit operations will be suspended until a time that Public Works can provide safe access on the municipal roadways. Any notices on service disruption will be relayed through the local radio stations and through the Town’s transit operator. Snow clearing adjacent to Public Transit Stops (signs) is the responsibility of a hired qualified contractor. Transit stops situated adjacent to the roadway will simply be cleared using the snow plow as it travels past the designated location. The sidewalks adjacent to Transit stops are generally cleared following the sidewalk clearing operations. For mid‐block transit stops (where a boulevard exists), efforts will be made during the sidewalk clearing operations to remove a portion of the snow bank to facilitate access to/from the transit bus. Efforts will be made to minimize the blowing of snow from Public Works operations onto the bus benches. Transit may have to be diverted to adjacent roads to allow for winter operations to clear snow on designated transit routes. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page13 138 of 212 SECTION 7.0 SANDING AND/OR SALTING OPERATIONS SECTION 7.1 STOCK PILING OF WINTER SAND & SALT Sanding preparation begins with the placement of approximately 3,500 tonnes of Ministry of Transportation (MTO) specified winter sand in the storage facility at the Public Works Yard, situated at 545 Tenth Line North. The sand is mixed with approximately 5‐10% salt to maintain the workability of the winter sand mix and to improve de‐icing capabilities. This operation takes place in October in preparation for the winter season. The Winter Sand tender makes allowance for replenishment of these stockpiles, should winter conditions require. Salt is delivered regularly as required throughout the winter and is also stored at the Public Works Yard in the storage facility. Storage capacity at the Public Works Facility is approximately 4,000 tonnes. SECTION 7.2 ICE FORMATION ON ROADWAYS AND TREATING ICY ROADWAYS SAND AND/OR SALT APPLICATION The minimum standard for prevention of ice formation on roadways is doing the following in the 24‐ hour period preceding an alleged formation of ice on a roadway: (1) monitor the weather in accordance with Section 5.0 (2) patrol representative roadways in accordance with Section 5.0 (3) if it is determined that there is a substantial probability of ice forming on a roadway, as a result from the activities noted above under paragraph (1) or (2), treat the roadway to prevent ice formation within the time set out in Table 7.2 to this section, starting from the time that the supervisor or designate determines is the appropriate time to deploy resources for that purpose. “Ice” is defined as all kinds of ice, however, formed. If the municipality meets the above noted minimum standard and, despite such compliance, ice forms on a roadway, ice forms on a roadway, the roadway is deemed to be in a state of repair until the earlier of: a) the time that the municipality becomes aware of the fact that the roadway is icy; or b) the applicable time set out in Table 7.2 to treat the roadway to prevent ice formation expires; TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page14 139 of 212 For the purposes of this section, treating a roadway means applying material to the roadway, including but not limited to, salt, sand or any combination of salt and sand. TABLE 7.2 ICE FORMATION PREVENTION AND ICY ROADWAYS Class of Roadway Time 2 4 hours 3 8 hours 4 12 hours 5 16 hours O. Reg. 47/13, s. 5. SECTION 7.3 APPLICATION OF SAND / SANDING The objective of sanding is to increase vehicular traction by applying sand/salt mixture either during or after the storm event. In the Town of Town of Collingwood, class 3‐5 roads are spot sanded on hills, curves and intersections only. Complete sanding on all streets is only carried out to address slippery conditions, freezing rain or general icy conditions, at the discretion of supervisory staff. Sand is also used on designated roadways as the temperatures drop below the levels of effectiveness for salt. However, when the temperatures do drop below these levels, the streets are sanded in the same manner, as they would have been salted. Most trucks have been equipped with automated sanding/salting units with spreader controls. Spreading operations should be conducted between 32 and 48 km/h. The recommended sand application rate is as follows: SAND: 570 kg per 2‐lane kilometre for single spinner 4m³; load will cover Twelve (12) 2‐lane kilometres 6m³; load will cover Nineteen (19) 2‐lane kilometers Sanding rates tend to be higher than salt because it is used as an abrasive rather than a de‐icer. Sanding impacts negatively on street cleanliness, sewer cleaning requirements and air quality. Sanding rates may also be adjusted to accommodate for different types of materials including treated salt. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page15 140 of 212 Sand spreaders are calibrated annually and adjusted as required, at the discretion of the Public Works Manager. SECTION 7.4 APPLICATION OF SALT / SALTING Generally, sufficient sand/salt will be applied as noted above and also to parking lots to provide adequate traction and will be completed by the contracted operator. It is not an objective of this policy to provide bare pavement conditions on all roads. Straight salt is applied to specified arterial roads only to achieve bare pavement. These roads include the following: Highway 26 Connecting Link Hurontario Street Normally, salt should never be applied when the temperature is below ‐12oC; however, in the presence of sun and heavy traffic volume, which creates higher road surface temperature, salt can sometimes be effectively applied to a temperature of ‐18oC. The recommended salt spreader application rate is as follows: SALT: 130 kg per 2‐lane kilometre for single spinner 4m³; load will cover Thirty‐five (35) 2‐lane kilometres 6m³; load will cover Fifty‐six (56) 2‐lane kilometres Salt spreaders are calibrated annually and adjusted as required, at the discretion of the Public Works Manager. SECTION 8.0 PEELING OPERATIONS Peeling will be initiated when severe rutting has formed along the hard‐packed snow surface. Rutting is defined as troughs in compacted snow and ice which make the manoeuvring of a vehicle dangerous. Ruts will usually be a minimum of 10 cm in depth before this condition warrants peeling. Peeling Operations consist of equipment that has the capability of applying a downwards force to remove the hard‐packed snow (i.e. Grader Blade, Loader Bucket). It is noted that standard snow‐plow trucks do not have the capability of applying a downward force. The blade and wing attached to standard snow plow equipment simply ride along the surface and rely on a combination of speed, blade/wing geometrics and gravity to displace the snow to the edge of the roadway. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page16 141 of 212 It is acknowledged that aesthetic damage to driveway surface may occur during the removal of the peeled hard‐pack (and/or ice chunks) between the edge of road and property line. The Town will not be responsible for any repair or reinstatement cost within the municipal road allowance. SECTION 9.0 SNOW REMOVAL & HAULING After the initial snow plowing operations are completed, snow banks could be removed, depending on conditions, from the sides of selected streets but primarily along the Downtown BIA corridor. This is accomplished by loading the snow into trucks and hauling it to specifically identified locations for disposal (snow dumps), or blowing the snow off the street and sidewalk to the adjoining area. Snow banks may be removed on streets where the following criteria are met: Where lack of adequate storage results in a reduction in the number of available traffic lanes thereby prohibiting the reasonable movement of vehicular traffic under normal winter driving conditions Where lack of adequate storage prohibits the reasonable movement of pedestrians using the adjacent sidewalk Impeding access to traffic safety devices, including pedestrian push buttons Notwithstanding the above, the Town shall take advantage of mechanical blowing snow to adjacent properties to accommodate snow storage wherever possible, rather than resorting to hauling. Snow banks across private driveways and entrances resulting from plowing operations shall not be removed. Some areas may necessarily receive more frequent snow removal due to blowing or drifting snow. Snow storage sites should meet Environmental Canada Codes of Practice established by Transportation Association of Canada and adopted by Environment Canada outlined in the Salt Management Plan. SECTION 11.0 WINTER DRAINAGE Over the course of the winter season, Public Works supervisory staff monitors the weather conditions on a daily basis. When the forecast predicts consecutive days of milder temperatures (typically 2‐3 days @ >0oC), supervisory staff will proactively investigate specified ditch locations to confirm whether snow and ice removal / clean‐out is warranted. The intent of the winter drainage program is to maximize the capacity of existing ditch systems in areas that are historically subject to higher run‐off rates from melting snow TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page17 142 of 212 and/or rain. Similarly, priority culverts and overland flow routes are inspected and cleaned‐out, as necessary. Sub‐contractors are also engaged and placed on stand‐by in the event that additional equipment is necessary to assist with winter drainage operations. SECTION 12.0 WINTER SAND REMOVAL Each spring, street sweeping equipment is deployed to collect the winter sand that was applied during the winter season. The Public Works street sweeping equipment includes the following: 1 mechanical street sweeper 1 contracted street sweeper 2 sidewalk machines equipped with front‐mounted brooms 1 water truck (dust suppression) The town‐wide winter sweeping program is typically completed by the middle of June. The sweeping schedule is developed based on three factors: 1. targeting areas of the Town where increased amounts of sand were used on the roads; 2. maintaining efficiency in the system, and 3. treating all areas as equitably as possible with service delivery Spring wet weather can impact the performance of flushing/cleaning equipment and parked cars can hamper operations and give the appearance that some areas may have been missed. Any of these factors may require operational adjustments that can impact the schedule. Street sweepings must be disposed to meet environmental guidelines. SECTION 13.0 INTERFERENCE WITH WINTER CONTROL OPERATIONS Parking situations that interfere with winter control operations may be referred to the O.P.P. and/or the By‐Law Department. When practical, a license plate number of a vehicle that is obstructing the winter control operations shall be recorded and reported to the Supervisory staff, who will forward the information to the appropriate office. When it is observed that owners or residents are pushing snow from private property onto the municipal right‐of‐way, the property address may be recorded and the resident may be advised in TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page18 143 of 212 writing that they were in contravention of the Highway Traffic Act. These situations may be referred to the O.P.P. for follow up. SECTION 14.0 DAMAGE RESULTING FROM WINTER MAINTENANCE OPERATIONS Boulevard Damage Sidewalk plowing presents many challenges. It is difficult to tell exactly where the edge of the sidewalk is and when the ground is not frozen, some sod damage may occur. Residents are advised to contact the Public Works Department at (705) 445‐1351 when damage is first noticed. The homeowner’s name and address will be added to a list for repair when temperatures permit and materials are available. Damage to municipal boulevard sod will be repaired in the spring. Boulevard reinstatement will be completed using topsoil and seed only. Residents are requested to assist by watering the areas that are repaired. Where a boulevard has been impacted by ‘winter kill’, no boulevard maintenance shall be done by the Town. Abutting property owners may, at their discretion, take steps to help expedite the re‐vegetation process. Winter kill is defined as areas of grassed boulevard that have been impacted by cold weather and sand/salt from winter control operations. Private Encroachments The Town will not be responsible for damage to items on municipal property by property owners. To prevent damage to private property, residents are required not to place cars, fences, posts, hedges, shrubs, driveway curbs or other obstructions, including garbage enclosures/bins on the road allowance. Should seasonal residents maintain their private garbage enclosure within the road allowance, the enclosures must be set back a minimum of 3.0 metres from the edge of pavement (including paved shoulder) or back of concrete curb. Similarly, the Town will not be responsible for any damage to irrigation systems, including sprinkler heads that have been installed within the municipal right‐of‐way. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page19 144 of 212 Property owners are discouraged from placing private markers and reflectors at the end of their driveways as these may be damaged from snow plowing operations. Property owners who install markers other than wooden stakes (1”x2”) or plastic reflectors will be asked to remove these obstructions as they pose safety concerns, cause damage to equipment and interfere with maintenance operations. SECTION 15.0 INQUIRIES AND/OR COMPLAINTS Inquiries and/or complaints related to winter control operations should be addressed to: Town of Collingwood Public Works Department 545 Tenth Line North, Town of Collingwood, ON L9Y 4N4 Office: (705) 445‐1351 Fax: (705) 445‐1286 Email: tdavision@collingwood.ca Complaints that are received from individuals about winter control operations will be addressed and followed up on, as required, by appropriate staff, within the context of the Winter Control Policy. TOWNOFCOLLINGWOOD–WINTERCONTROLPOLICY Page20 145 of 212 Appendix A – Plow Routes 2015 TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD – WINTER CONTROL POLICY Page 19 146 of 212 Collingwood Road Plowing Routes 2015-2016 M AD E LI N ED R IV Legend E LA NE LIND SAY LON G PO INT ROA D Contract A BO U LE R VA D Contract B ON SH TT C ET OR LE IN RT PR ES BA BO UL EV D AR Highway LIGHTHOUSE LA NE WEST EA ST PORT RO AD STA R BOA R D ROA D WA Y RA MB LIN GS DR IV NE OO CO D L A UR N D T DR IV E NC Route 2 L UB RO A D ROYA LTON LA NE TE W HI T EE ST R CR IV E Route 3 FAI DR IV E SH ER RY CRA NB QUAY Route 4 A LK BOA RDW AV EN UE NT W ATER FRO N ET EACH LE B PE BB URT CO UL BO C IVE T EET TR A IL W IAP AT H ES CR ER SILV ON ON GT PA BE A ET SID W ED R OO IVE GE DR OA D ORG IAN MA NO RIVE E CH RD DR IV LLO N RK SP UL EA VE SA ND NU E F OR D F LEM ING DRIV E SIX TH L EET CH ER TRAI L ET H ig hw ay 2 R EE T LA ST G LE A U LE MM AV ERV IE EN UE W VA RD ED IRK BO AD ET RO TH LK KE RO D ER AD ES N LA N CU RR IE A V EN UE BE LC HE R ST RE ET DO W 6 AD V IEW NE R ST RE ET KO HL STR EET BRA ES IDE ET ST RE EE STR T SA ND ELL ST RE ET D EROA AR SID ENT OA D 4TH L INE T KE R STA L T EE ST R T A WA NO TT SID ER OA D 147 of 212 FAIRGR OUNDS R RE ET STR E AD VA IN G LE D ST R TS ON RO BE SU SY L AN T STR EE PO PL EE T PER STR COO OO D CR AV ES EN UE T BRO DE RS EE T NS STR STEPHE ET RO MA C W ST RE GH ES PO RT EE E STR ET NE MA CA E L A NE RE TH AR DR IV CE Y A LL SO IS TE UT R S H T. V IEW ST IN D IA N TR A IL RK OA D YO DR D OO NE W UR RE ET INDI AN CH SE BE A NE T JA EE R ST R E ST ET ET FU TU ST RE ST RE T RY C STREET LA CO OK OA D SID ER DE L AV LP AR EN R UE CR ES S STR JAME KIN G N BRIA T CO UR E DR IVE ESC EN AR PO PL GEO RGIA N M A NOR LA NE NU DE Y CK CR TA N ST AV E ET T R EE KRIS HART ROAD LOCK BRO LYN DE RT CO U W ON LIN GT W EL EE T ST R S ST E RE ET V IE T ER RE M AM NT LA NE A LL IS N O TE R RT ST R H EE ILLI CE HE RS N E ON M LA SU MC P W AN MC KE NT CE CRES ST INE E STRE ET D VAR B ELL BO ULE LA K AV E VI EW EN UE RO KATH ERIN N PATE RSO STR EET RE ET DI IN EET A N STR R EE ST STRE DEN G OD UE RR RA GL RU N IE R STR HU R BA RIV ER T N R BE HA T UR CO R EE CE ST N AP AV EN EET AL ICE STR NN ING AY EL NT DR DR D ON RP SE IVE AC E NT EV IE W OU IN BH PL S UR C LU MA R RT PO RES CE FSI SI NE D E DE W AC H LA NE BAYSIDE COURT BE WA TE EET LD STR PE STR EET O NA EET T O STR EL L MA CD ER TY RIV H PRET Y SO UT WA PA RK MIN CO NN RE E R OBE RT A VE RV ICE H SE D RO A ST AR D IR EV LA NUE ST. C TT SO UT RO AD " HIG T CIRCLE "Q RE ET GE RS EA ST T E ST 26 HW AY R EE GLE N R O Y WA NU ES CE ST TH E WS AT M L L CR AV E T EET SPR UCE STR EET UR N CO RO NE ST R T EET R CON NO AV EN UE NN O AN LI NE SH A RA GL R EE STR BERLY TENT H ET LI NE RE T TENT H ST ET D RT RE OA BE ST EEN R NT STREET AL ST ST BU SH RE ET HU OU RN EET EY STR ST RE MA RY SA UN CRESC ENT SCEN EN T GARBU TT IE C RE ET CLA RK STRE NT LI NE ERB CRESC GARBUTT STRE ET BIE CR ESCE WILS ON EET TENT H LO CK CR ESC N STRE ET E VE BU TT GAR R ST E ST IE LESEL E DR IV DR IV BRY AN GO LF NE WB STA NL STRE ET CR IE U RT CO DRIV DL AY DA NCE ER BIE LOCK ER HIG H STR LO CK ER T R EE ET TR A FIN NT ES CE ST RE RE ET MA SON & DI CKSON RO AD T SCEN Y DRI FINDLA EA GR ET ER RE ROB INSO LL ST RAGLAN ST AN DU NC STR EET P BE CAM OSLE R CRE GILPIN INS CO LL EET R IO STR AY MA CK COU RT N RO AD R OA D TESKEY COU RT SM A RT COU RT GTO N HER RIN COU RT STR EET C RESCENT REID DI CKSO EET OA K STR T EX D SPR UCE TEL FER R OA MA SON ROA D EE ON STR OA D PA RK R AM ER F ERGU SON RE C N ST STR EET ON C FU TU IO TE NS NT SO N ON T STR EE R E CENT S T CE PAT ER CLARKS W WILLO STR EET EE T HUR O NTA ER CAM BA KE STR EET ET TENT H STRE STRE ET A IN EN CR ESC ST V IN EET R STR LO RN MA ST M A RIE D RY VIC TO E DR IV STR FAI R ET STRE ET PATT ON 19 B ERL CHAM GIBBA R EET E STR STRE ET EIGH TH EET NINT H STR C RESC ENT T TE ST PE STRE ET RG GEO TER RA CE COURT CR ESCE HUM STR EET EN T B ER EN T R EE EET STR EET R OLI V E EET L STR PA U EV NE TA ST MO EA ST HA M ILTON EET SIXT H STR WHIPPS COU RT R OA D BA RR STRE CH AM CR ESC LA IN GRIF FEN EET RUSS EL STR T T LA UR ER O TC A LB ET J UNI P E R C OU RT H R EE RE KE T E STR SIM CO E STR EET ET T ST ST NE MA R ET CE CR ESC ST RE RE ST STR EET A ST M ES O TA N ES NT ESCE CR RT H AL W N MI RY LLA SEV ENTH T CE NT 32 ESCEN T CR EN SC ET DA VIS STRE CO AD TY RO CRES FO U STR EET HU M EET FIF TH STR COU RTI E CR HO LDEN AD GRE Y RO SI M UN E CO INA T LA T SIXTH MA R NS E E IV K AY LA T R EE S TR EE ON R IO ST OD ET G IN WO DRIV WS DR S LA ND HI GH CE NT CRES S H ER RE EL UE EET R IO STR EET PINE STR STRE ET IAN MEA DO AV EN EN CU LL T CO UR WAT TS CRES CENT ALY SSA ORG OR D E ST Y WA NE ET CO NN GE A R T RO STE WA UE FOU RTH BIRC H STRE T COUR VIEW MOUNT EN E AV LA ET OK BRO CA E CO SIM EE T R ST MA PL E BEEC H STRE NT ES CE STR EET ET F BRA NIF COU RT CO ERA ST M A RIE HUR O NTA BEEC H STRE TH OM T SIM EET OA K STR CR TU RE Y STRE ET NE LON G LA DRI VE KE LLS FU R R EE RODNEY STREET STR EE T ET EET THI RD STR IVE RO WAY R KE MA HI CKOR FR AN CES OA D A S DR HU T NS VET CEDA R STRE STRE ET E STRE ET E Route 5 N SE M APLE WA LN UT STR EET FUTU R E MA IR MI LLS DRIV E ND D ILS EN R GATE E D STRE ET SPR UCE AILS TR A OM IV AS DR SECO N ET THO M EET TR SL AL HIG H STR ET MO UN TAIN RO AD AD IN RO HI LL STREET N TA MU RRA Y COURT RE GE ST ROA D MOU B RID CAM BL UFF RD EVA SIDE LA UNCH EET FIRS T STR EL M STRE OSLE R LAU BO UL AR D LANE SHIPY LAN E LAIR MO NTC ME WS NOR TH D SID ER E WAT LA N EET AW MAC KIN WEST A IN RO LANE P IN E S TR N O . 26 COLLSHIP FIRST STREETEXTENSION RE L PRET TY RI PA R KW V ER AY NOR TH OU NT WESTM ME WS W AY IG H N TA CRES CENT SE WHEEL HOU /H M OU RT RA GA N IA EE T E TH LIN OLD STRE ET SU E HAV EN S TR EL EVEN RT C OU NO IV INE RS WATER STR EET L LY HO ST. LAWRE NCE R ED EE MA R AM R STR ST T WE OA EA ST IO EE T EL R STR EVA CRE SC ENT BO U WA LK ER STR EET HA R BU R C O N SI UR D T E DE LS BO U R SI E BA HA R OU G ITA NT DR IV R HE ES CAR P ME KE IT H A HA R CA R M I C HEA L V F NT JE Y WA N E IE SO EN BB DA W U A IL STRE ET TR SE RO IL D IL F RE W TR A YS W AY COU R T PH SIE RR A TR AIL RO SE JO BA LSAM IL ER RY CRA NB SHO RES N NETTL ETO TRA ES CE W CR ER RY OXBO NB CRA NB ER RY SURF SHEF FIEL D CRESCENT E NT CRA T RO TT BO U LE VA RD TO E SC CR E G AT AY MC IN W R NBR DR IA R RR ES T GU ST LA EA DY A IL W AN TR R ROA D BR RY EL LE N LA NE RT WA Y TR A FA LGA W A IL D TIO N ROA PRES ERVA DR IVE GREE IN N M EDE VA LLEY COU RT R Y T RT A TI ON WAY CON SERV U LE ITH C O WESTW IND I ON T Route 1 INE RS MA R E EC OU T UR CR AN BE R R AL PIN D IA L CO UE LA NE SU N V A CA ARD UL EV BO VE CR AIG DRI RD ULEVA GLEN BO RT OU AN C EST SILV ER ORGI GE FO R ER EN AV FA LLS DO CKSIDE DRIV E BA RK JOH NSTON PARK WAT ER DR IVE B ER SILV ER CREEK SUN CREST CIRCL E GA W ES T AN O. 26 CEDA R P OINTE COURT AY N EVARD PRINCETO N SHORES BOUL HIG HW Appendix B – Sidewalk Plow Routes 2015 TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD – WINTER CONTROL POLICY Page 20 148 of 212 T Y RR E EA ST ER TR TS EE T SHA N ENT O NA REET ET E PE LS OU SE RESCE DR IV E LA N ET ST REE T DILLO IVE LE OU E AV AR D BELL BOULEV SA ND E NU T N DR R SP EET WIL EA N MC K N T CE CRES LIA MS EET CRES CENT REET RE FUT U STREE T E WD KR HART ROAD LOCK EN ST DRIV BRO CK VE LY ND RT CO U ISTA DEY EET T N DRI BRYA T CE N EE LIE LESE E DRIV STR R INS ST RIVE NE EY LA STREE T STREE O N ST ER TS REET RE E T R OB T D ST LA N HES T PO R SID E BE AC H LA SID NE E RAG RU N RE T T AR POPL BAYSIDE COURT RIV ER T BEN HAR RT CO U EE ST E ENU ALICE STR T REET NS ST STEPHE T TR R PIE NA STREE STREET STREE AV ING KATHERINE STREE EE ET TRE EN S GODD ER COOP REET REET ST R CL UB H LD ST STRE EET MA CD IV ER TY R H PRET Y SO UT WA PA RK MINTO STR N ELL CO N BUSH EET HUG N E ST Y ST IR C RO A D LA EV AR D ST. C TT SO Q" T" ST 2 6 EA E WAY HIGH UTH SERVIC EE GE RS RO AD R ST T TREE ME S GLE N RO ET Y STRE BERL Y WA S UR FS I DE RESC BO UL EET ET THEWS AT M ELL C PO RT ST R RE PATERSON STREET CO LL RO N NE W T LA N O UR T T NU E EE RAG TR C NO N TS ST SPRUC E STREET NT B AL S EA ST WE LIN E T TENTH EE CO NN OR AV ENUE T TR EET RAGLAN STR EET RUSSEL STR R OU NE AS E TC LA AR TENTH LIN E NS SU RT G NIA BE EE REET IVE O UR STREE CEN T CRESCENT GARBUTT REET ESCE CRES E ST R N MA N BA KER V IE GOLF B NEW DR LAY Y MA R RESCENT GARBUTTC CLA RK ST E CR ERBI U TT T STR DERS SA UN REET 1 GARB EE IE T UR FIND DA NC E ST CENT EET LIN E LO CK 0.5 NT T TRAC LE STA N STR WILSO N TENTH BIE CRES REET LO CKER HIGH ST ER LO C K E RE S C BIE C STR NT T L STR MASON & DICKSON ROAD NT CRESCE GILPIN RIVE LAY D FIND CE VIN ST ST RSON PATE P BEL CA M O OSLER C SM ART CO URT TESKEY CO URT GTON HERRIN T CO UR STREET RESCENT REID C Y MACKA CO URT OA D SP RUCE ER R TELF R EET MA SON RO AD N NSIO ROAD EXTE ET REET DIC KSON OA K ST RE N ST AD O MER PA RK RO E CA N RO AD FERGU SO R FUT U N ST ET ARIO STRE HURONT C CLARKSON CENT T STREE ERO CA M W WILLO STREET R E SCENT ER STREE EET TENTH STR RESCE RC OLI VE T TER FA IR T ET ST PE CRESCEN STREET N CR ES T GIB BA RD RY VICTO E DRIV EET NINTH STR REET PATTON ET REET RE DAVIS ST BERLAI CHAM H STREET LO RN CAN DUN T STREE N STR EET RO BINSO GR T ESC EN R REE GE ST STREET CR LAIN MBER GEO EIGHT EE ET L STRE PAU ST STREET ST MA RIE ENT CHA RE ET N HAMILTO REET STR EET TERRACE CO URT R ST MA HU REET ST AL SIM CO E STREET MO EAST REET E ST RE HUM SIXTH ST WHIPP S CO URT AD IFF EN RO ST ET ST ET E CR ESC STRE ET RIO TA ON EE TL K MA R FO URTH REET CO URTIC H SIXT R ST TA SO ET SEV ENTH 2 AD 3 Y RO 0 NT SCE CRE RY LLA RE FIF TH ST NT CE RE ST WATTS CRESCENT BA RR ST NT ES CR LA ST HOLDEN OU OE C SIMC Y KA T ESC EN KE E AN ET STRE E DRIV CR INA MA R E IV S LAN D HIG H CEN T CRES SH OA D ST IN EN CULL T R CO U ME AD OW SD R OOD ER W R ART ELG E EN U R AV NN O STEW A ALYSS GE OR GIA N UE AVEN STREET EET CO O KE CA REET BRO STREET BIRCH ST BRAN IFF CO URT T ET ARIO STRE HURONT T MA PLE STR IV E TH FO UR REET R AS D BEEC H ST OM PRE TT PAR Y RIVE KW R AY AY EW LAN ET REET STREET E TH E CO NE MIN ST MA RIE EE PINE STR OA K ST RE THIRD ST SIM E CO SIM EET STR R MA HIC KO RY S DRIVE N ESCE T UR FUR RODN EY STREET EN RESC T SC AN ER PLE STREET REET REET STREET ET STRE ET EET TR VET CEDA R ST STREET SP RUCE REET FRANCE NE S CR ET NS RO HU CH WAY BEEC H ST WA LNUT ET STRE SEC ON D HIGH ST REET STRE FUTURE SIDE LAUN REET FIRST ST ELM STRE G E ST MURRAY CO URT IR MONTCLA MEWS NO RTH MA OA D E LO NG LA KELL VE IDE RS TE WA LAN E PYARD W LANE SHI E MACKINA LAN BRID CA M HILL STREET MAIR MILLS DRIV A S DRI E STREET LANE COLLSHIP . 26 WEST TH LINE R TAIN ENT NO RTH PIN NO WAY IGH NT WESTMOU MEWS /H USE CR ESC WHEELHO FIRSTSTREETEXTENSION THOM AL AV EN EET STR ELEVEN N MO U OLD TH H NERS MA RI E T R IV WES WAT ER STREET MOUNTAIN ROAD R NO ED REET M R ST BO U ST. LAWRENCE AG RIT DR IV E AV E REET IO UR ST ROBER TA VEN UE O HARB EL E EVA CRESCENT ID WALKE R STREET UR S S TH HA RO LSA BA HAR K HE ESC AR P E M NT AL BOARDW AV ENUE CR E IV AV EN DR RRY CRANBE QUAY STREET N BA LSAM SO T JE F Y WA SE RO I LD A IL EY W TR SW AY RRY CRANBE SHORES ON CO UR DA W CEN T IE FR IL RA IL SIERRA TRA BB RO SE JO T PH C RES RA IL CRANBERRY SURF SHEFFIELD CRESCENT NETTLET RY T TR OT TB OU LEV AR D W OXBO CRA NBE R TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SIDEWALK PLOWING ROUTES 2015/2016 BU R CO NS UR IDE T T AD EN SC AY CRE CARMI CHEAL W BRIA N CO URT R MC IN T GA OSH TE RD UE RIA FAI R RO VATIO N ENB IV E KE I N WAY PRESER IND DR IVE GR E IT E WH T E STRE NB E W OO CO DLA UR ND T CR A SERVATIO WESTW D ROA NT 2 Kilometers 149 of 212 FO R D Appendix C – Roads By Maintenance Class TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD – WINTER CONTROL POLICY Page 21 150 of 212 Collingwood Roads By Maintenance Class Legend E LON G Maintenance Class PO INT ROA D R VA D C ET ON SH OR ES BO 2 UL EV D AR W ES T PORT RO AD STA R BOA R D ROA D 4 WA Y WA Y RA MB LIN GS NE GU ST LA DR EA DY IV E NC L UB RO A 5 D A IL AN OO CO D L A UR N D T TR R ROA D BR W ROYA LTON LA NE TE W HI T EE ST R CR ES T RY IV E FAI IV E A LK BOA RDW AV EN UE E DR EA ST NT W ATER FRO N ET EACH LE B PE BB URT CO UL BO C IVE T EET STRE DEN G OD A IL W IAP AT H ES CR ER SILV TR ON ON PA BE A ET E CH SID W ED R OO IVE GE DR OA D ORG IAN MA NO RIVE DR IV LLO N RK SP UL EA VE SA ND NU E F OR D F LEM ING DRIV E SIX TH L EET CH ER TRAI L R EE T LA ET H ig hw ay 2 ST A ES N LA BO U LE RD AD D OA RR MM AV ERV IE EN UE W VA RO GA IRK LK KE N CU RR IE A V EN UE BE LC HE R ST RE ET DO W 6 AD V IEW NE R ST RE ET KO HL STR EET BRA ES IDE ET ST RE EE STR T SA ND ELL ST RE ET D EROA AR SID ENT OA D 4TH L INE T KE R STA L T EE ST R T A WA NO TT SID ER OA D 151 of 212 FAIRGR OUNDS R RE ET STR E G LE ER VA IN G LE D ST R TS ON RO BE SU SY L AN T STR EE PO PL EE T PER STR COO OO D CR AV ES EN UE T BRO DE RS EE T NS STR STEPHE ET PO RT EE E STR ET ST RE GH ES TH MA C W HU OU RN EET EY STR NE MA CA E L A NE ED TH AR DR IV CE Y A LL SO IS TE UT R S H T. V IEW AD IN D IA N TR A IL ET OA D RO DR RE OO ST W UR RE ET INDI AN CH RK BE A NE T JA EE R ST R E ST ET ET FU TU ST RE ST RE T RY YO STREET D CO OK OA D SID ER NE CR ES S STR JAME KIN G N BRIA T CO UR E DR IVE ESC EN AR PO PL GEO RGIA N M A NOR LA NE NU DE Y CK CR TA N ST AV E SE T R EE KRIS HART ROAD LOCK BRO LYN DE RT CO U W ON LIN GT W EL EE T ST R S ST E RE ET V IE C ER LA M AM NT DE L AV LP AR EN R UE ILLI CE ET M T SU RE W AN MC KE NT CE CRES LA NE A LL IS N O TE R RT ST R H EE INE E STRE ET D VAR B ELL BO ULE LA K AV E VI EW EN UE RO KATH ERIN N PATE RSO STR EET RE ET DI GT RD UE IN EET A N STR R EE ST AV EN EET AL ICE STR N STRE ET NN ING RR RA GL RU N IE R STR HU R BA RIV ER T N R BE HA T UR CO R EE CE ST N AP BU SH RE ET AY EL NT DR DR D ON RP SE IVE AC E NT EV IE W OU IN BH PL S UR C LU MA R RT PO RES CE FSI SI NE D E DE W AC H LA NE BAYSIDE COURT BE WA TE EET LD STR PE STR EET O NA EET T O STR EL L MA CD ER TY RIV H PRET Y SO UT WA PA RK MIN CO NN RE E R OBE RT A VE RV ICE H SE D RO A ST AR D IR EV LA NUE ST. C TT SO UT RO AD " HIG T CIRCLE "Q RE ET GE RS EA ST T E ST 26 HW AY R EE GLE N R O Y WA NU ES CE ST TH E WS AT M L L CR AV E T EET SPR UCE STR EET UR N CO RO NE EET ROB INSO R CON NO AV EN UE NN O T ST R R EE AN LI NE SH A RA GL ST STR BERLY TENT H ET T LI NE RE ET TENT H ST RE D RT ST OA BE ST EEN R NT STREET AL EA GR ET ER RE AN DU NC STR EET E ST RE MA RY SA UN CRESC ENT SCEN EN T GARBU TT IE C RE ET CLA RK STRE NT LI NE ERB CRESC GARBUTT STRE ET BIE CR ESCE WILS ON EET TENT H LO CK CR ESC DR IV BRY AN GO LF VE BU TT GAR R ST E ST IE LESEL E DR IV RE ET NE WB STA NL STRE ET CR IE U RT CO DRIV DL AY DA NCE ER BIE LOCK ER HIG H STR LO CK ER T R EE ET TR A FIN NT ES CE ST STR EET LL ST MA SON & DI CKSON RO AD T SCEN Y DRI FINDLA NT SO N P BE CAM OSLE R CRE GILPIN ST RE EET R IO STR AY MA CK COU RT R OA D TESKEY COU RT SM A RT COU RT GTO N HER RIN COU RT STR EET C RESCENT REID N RO AD T EX D SPR UCE TEL FER R OA DI CKSO EET OA K STR EE ON STR MA SON ROA D AM ER OA D PA RK R RE C N F ERGU SON FU TU IO TE NS CE PAT ER ON C T ST V IN EET R STR CLARKS W WILLO STR EET ON T STR EE INS CO LL HUR O NTA ER CAM EE T R E CENT S STRE ET A IN EN CR ESC T TE ST PE ET TENT H STRE BA KE STR EET D STR FAI R ET STRE ET PATT ON 19 B ERL CHAM GIBBA R RY VIC TO E DR IV EET NINT H STR C RESC ENT R EE LO RN MA ST M A RIE EN T B ER EN T EET E STR STRE ET EIGH TH CR ESCE HUM STR EET STRE ET RG GEO TER RA CE COURT RAGLAN ST ST EET STR EET R OLI V E EET L STR PA U EV NE TA R IO MO EA ST HA M ILTON EET SIXT H STR WHIPPS COU RT R OA D BA RR STRE CH AM CR ESC LA IN GRIF FEN EET RUSS EL STR T T LA UR ER O TC A LB ET J UNI P E R C OU RT H R EE ON RE KE T E STR SIM CO E STR EET ET T ST ST NE MA R ET CE CR ESC ST RE RE ST STR EET A ST M ES O TA N ES NT ESCE CR RT H AL W N MI RY LLA SEV ENTH T CE NT 32 ESCEN T CR EN SC ET DA VIS STRE CO AD TY RO CRES FO U STR EET HU M EET FIF TH STR COU RTI E CR HO LDEN AD GRE Y RO SI M UN E CO INA T LA T SIXTH MA R NS E E IV K AY LA T R EE S TR EE ET ST OD RE G IN WO DRIV WS DR S LA ND HI GH CE NT CRES S H ER E ST EL UE EET R IO STR EET PINE STR STRE ET IAN MEA DO AV EN EN CU LL T CO UR WAT TS CRES CENT ALY SSA ORG OR D CO Y WA NE ET CO NN GE A R T RO STE WA UE FOU RTH BIRC H STRE T COUR VIEW MOUNT EN E AV CA E CO SIM EE T R ST LA ET OK BRO SIM MA PL E BEEC H STRE NT ES CE STR EET ET F BRA NIF COU RT T ERA ST M A RIE HUR O NTA BEEC H STRE TH OM R EE RODNEY STREET EET OA K STR CR TU RE IVE RO T NS WAY STR EE T ET EET THI RD STR Y STRE ET NE LON G LA DRI VE KE LLS FU R HU R KE MA HI CKOR FR AN CES OA D E VET CEDA R STRE STRE ET E STRE ET A S DR N SE M APLE WA LN UT STR EET FUTU R E MA IR MI LLS DRIV E ND D ILS EN R GATE E D STRE ET SPR UCE AILS TR A OM IV AS DR SECO N ET THO M EET TR SL AL HIG H STR ET MO UN TAIN RO AD AD IN RO HI LL STREET N TA MU RRA Y COURT RE GE ST ROA D MOU B RID CAM BL UFF RD EVA SIDE LA UNCH EET FIRS T STR EL M STRE OSLE R LAU BO UL AR D LANE SHIPY LAN E LAIR MO NTC ME WS NOR TH D SID ER E WAT LA N EET AW MAC KIN WEST A IN RO LANE P IN E S TR N O . 26 COLLSHIP FIRST STREETEXTENSION RE L PRET TY RI PA R KW V ER AY NOR TH OU NT WESTM ME WS W AY IG H N TA CRES CENT SE WHEEL HOU /H M OU RT RA GA N IA EE T E TH LIN OLD STRE ET SU E HAV EN S TR EL EVEN RT C OU NO IV INE RS WATER STR EET L LY HO ST. LAWRE NCE R ED EE MA R AM R STR ST T WE IO EE T EL R STR EVA CRE SC ENT BO U WA LK ER STR EET HA R BU R C O N SI UR D T E DE LS BO U R SI E BA HA R OU G ITA NT DR IV R HE ES CAR P ME KE IT H A HA R CA R M I C HEA L V F NT JE Y WA N EN IE SO U DA W 6 - Private ER RY CRA NB QUAY STRE ET BB SE RO IL D IL F RE W TR A YS W AY COU R T PH A IL SIE RR A TR AIL RO SE JO TR BA LSAM IL ER RY CRA NB SHO RES N NETTL ETO TRA ES CE W CR ER RY OXBO NB CRA NB ER RY SURF SHEF FIEL D CRESCENT SH NT CRA T RO TT BO U LE VA RD E E SC CR E TO AY G AT W R NBR DR IA R MC IN EL LE N LA NE RT INE RS MA R DR IV TR A FA LGA W A IL D TIO N ROA PRES ERVA DR IVE GREE IN N M EDE VA LLEY COU RT R Y T RT A TI ON WAY CON SERV U LE ITH C O WESTW IND I ON T E EC OU T UR CR AN BE R R AL PIN D IA L CO UE LA NE SU N V A CA ARD UL EV BO VE CR AIG DRI RD ULEVA GLEN BO RT OU AN C EST SILV ER ORGI GE FO R ER EN AV FA LLS DO CKSIDE DRIV E BA RK 3 JOH NSTON PARK WAT ER DR IVE B ER SILV ER CREEK SUN CREST CIRCL E LIGHTHOUSE LA NE WEST EA ST AN O. 26 CEDA R P OINTE COURT AY N EVARD PRINCETO N SHORES BOUL HIG HW AD LE U LE IN RT BO PR BA TT RO R IV HE RS N E ON ED LA N MC P E LI ST M AD LA NE LIND SAY Appendix D – Roads By Function Class TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD – WINTER CONTROL POLICY Page 22 152 of 212 Collingwood Roads By Function Class FunctionClass E LON G PO INT ROA D Arterial R VA D C ET ON SH OR ES BO Collector UL EV D AR W ES T PORT RO AD STA R BOA R D ROA D County WA Y WA Y RA MB LIN GS NE GU ST LA DR EA DY IV E NC L UB RO A Provincial D A IL AN OO CO D L A UR N D T TR R ROA D BR W ROYA LTON LA NE TE W HI T EE ST R CR ES T RY IV E FAI IV E A LK BOA RDW AV EN UE E DR EA ST NT W ATER FRO N ET EACH LE B PE BB URT CO UL BO C IVE T EET STRE DEN G OD A IL W IAP AT H ES CR ER SILV TR ON ON PA BE A ET E CH SID W ED R OO IVE GE DR OA D ORG IAN MA NO RIVE DR IV LLO N RK SP UL EA VE SA ND NU E F OR D F LEM ING DRIV E SIX TH L EET CH ER TRAI L R EE T LA ET H ig hw ay 2 ST A ES N LA BO U LE RD AD D OA RR MM AV ERV IE EN UE W VA RO GA IRK LK KE N CU RR IE A V EN UE BE LC HE R ST RE ET DO W 6 AD V IEW NE R ST RE ET KO HL STR EET BRA ES IDE ET ST RE EE STR T SA ND ELL ST RE ET D EROA AR SID ENT OA D 4TH L INE T KE R STA L T EE ST R T A WA NO TT SID ER OA D 153 of 212 FAIRGR OUNDS R RE ET STR E G LE ER VA IN G LE D ST R TS ON RO BE SU SY L AN T STR EE PO PL EE T PER STR COO OO D CR AV ES EN UE T BRO DE RS EE T NS STR STEPHE ET PO RT EE E STR ET ST RE GH ES TH MA C W HU OU RN EET EY STR NE MA CA E L A NE ED TH AR DR IV CE Y A LL SO IS TE UT R S H T. V IEW AD IN D IA N TR A IL ET OA D RO DR RE OO ST W UR RE ET INDI AN CH RK BE A NE T JA EE R ST R E ST ET ET FU TU ST RE ST RE T RY YO STREET D CO OK OA D SID ER NE CR ES S STR JAME KIN G N BRIA T CO UR E DR IVE ESC EN AR PO PL GEO RGIA N M A NOR LA NE NU DE Y CK CR TA N ST AV E SE T R EE KRIS HART ROAD LOCK BRO LYN DE RT CO U W ON LIN GT W EL EE T ST R S ST E RE ET V IE C ER LA M AM NT DE L AV LP AR EN R UE ILLI CE ET M T SU RE W AN MC KE NT CE CRES LA NE A LL IS N O TE R RT ST R H EE INE E STRE ET D VAR B ELL BO ULE LA K AV E VI EW EN UE RO KATH ERIN N PATE RSO STR EET RE ET DI GT RD UE IN EET A N STR R EE ST AV EN EET AL ICE STR N STRE ET NN ING RR RA GL RU N IE R STR HU R BA RIV ER T N R BE HA T UR CO R EE CE ST N AP BU SH RE ET AY EL NT DR DR D ON RP SE IVE AC E NT EV IE W OU IN BH PL S UR C LU MA R RT PO RES CE FSI SI NE D E DE W AC H LA NE BAYSIDE COURT BE WA TE EET LD STR PE STR EET O NA EET T O STR EL L MA CD ER TY RIV H PRET Y SO UT WA PA RK MIN CO NN RE E R OBE RT A VE RV ICE H SE D RO A ST AR D IR EV LA NUE ST. C TT SO UT RO AD " HIG T CIRCLE "Q RE ET GE RS EA ST T E ST 26 HW AY R EE GLE N R O Y WA NU ES CE ST TH E WS AT M L L CR AV E T EET SPR UCE STR EET UR N CO RO NE EET ROB INSO R CON NO AV EN UE NN O T ST R R EE AN LI NE SH A RA GL ST STR BERLY TENT H ET T LI NE RE ET TENT H ST RE D RT ST OA BE ST EEN R NT STREET AL EA GR ET ER RE AN DU NC STR EET E ST RE MA RY SA UN CRESC ENT SCEN EN T GARBU TT IE C RE ET CLA RK STRE NT LI NE ERB CRESC GARBUTT STRE ET BIE CR ESCE WILS ON EET TENT H LO CK CR ESC DR IV BRY AN GO LF VE BU TT GAR R ST E ST IE LESEL E DR IV RE ET NE WB STA NL STRE ET CR IE U RT CO DRIV DL AY DA NCE ER BIE LOCK ER HIG H STR LO CK ER T R EE ET TR A FIN NT ES CE ST STR EET LL ST MA SON & DI CKSON RO AD T SCEN Y DRI FINDLA NT SO N P BE CAM OSLE R CRE GILPIN ST RE EET R IO STR AY MA CK COU RT R OA D TESKEY COU RT SM A RT COU RT GTO N HER RIN COU RT STR EET C RESCENT REID N RO AD T EX D SPR UCE TEL FER R OA DI CKSO EET OA K STR EE ON STR MA SON ROA D AM ER OA D PA RK R RE C N F ERGU SON FU TU IO TE NS CE PAT ER ON C T ST V IN EET R STR CLARKS W WILLO STR EET ON T STR EE INS CO LL HUR O NTA ER CAM EE T R E CENT S STRE ET A IN EN CR ESC T TE ST PE ET TENT H STRE BA KE STR EET D STR FAI R ET STRE ET PATT ON 19 B ERL CHAM GIBBA R RY VIC TO E DR IV EET NINT H STR C RESC ENT R EE LO RN MA ST M A RIE EN T B ER EN T EET E STR STRE ET EIGH TH CR ESCE HUM STR EET STRE ET RG GEO TER RA CE COURT RAGLAN ST ST EET STR EET R OLI V E EET L STR PA U EV NE TA R IO MO EA ST HA M ILTON EET SIXT H STR WHIPPS COU RT R OA D BA RR STRE CH AM CR ESC LA IN GRIF FEN EET RUSS EL STR T T LA UR ER O TC A LB ET J UNI P E R C OU RT H R EE ON RE KE T E STR SIM CO E STR EET ET T ST ST NE MA R ET CE CR ESC ST RE RE ST STR EET A ST M ES O TA N ES NT ESCE CR RT H AL W N MI RY LLA SEV ENTH T CE NT 32 ESCEN T CR EN SC ET DA VIS STRE CO AD TY RO CRES FO U STR EET HU M EET FIF TH STR COU RTI E CR HO LDEN AD GRE Y RO SI M UN E CO INA T LA T SIXTH MA R NS E E IV K AY LA T R EE S TR EE ET ST OD RE G IN WO DRIV WS DR S LA ND HI GH CE NT CRES S H ER E ST EL UE EET R IO STR EET PINE STR STRE ET IAN MEA DO AV EN EN CU LL T CO UR WAT TS CRES CENT ALY SSA ORG OR D CO Y WA NE ET CO NN GE A R T RO STE WA UE FOU RTH BIRC H STRE T COUR VIEW MOUNT EN E AV CA E CO SIM EE T R ST LA ET OK BRO SIM MA PL E BEEC H STRE NT ES CE STR EET ET F BRA NIF COU RT T ERA ST M A RIE HUR O NTA BEEC H STRE TH OM R EE RODNEY STREET EET OA K STR CR TU RE IVE RO T NS WAY STR EE T ET EET THI RD STR Y STRE ET NE LON G LA DRI VE KE LLS FU R HU R KE MA HI CKOR FR AN CES OA D E VET CEDA R STRE STRE ET E STRE ET A S DR N SE M APLE WA LN UT STR EET FUTU R E MA IR MI LLS DRIV E ND D ILS EN R GATE E D STRE ET SPR UCE AILS TR A OM IV AS DR SECO N ET THO M EET TR SL AL HIG H STR ET MO UN TAIN RO AD AD IN RO HI LL STREET N TA MU RRA Y COURT RE GE ST ROA D MOU B RID CAM BL UFF RD EVA SIDE LA UNCH EET FIRS T STR EL M STRE OSLE R LAU BO UL AR D LANE SHIPY LAN E LAIR MO NTC ME WS NOR TH D SID ER E WAT LA N EET AW MAC KIN WEST A IN RO LANE P IN E S TR N O . 26 COLLSHIP FIRST STREETEXTENSION RE L PRET TY RI PA R KW V ER AY NOR TH OU NT WESTM ME WS W AY IG H N TA CRES CENT SE WHEEL HOU /H M OU RT RA GA N IA EE T E TH LIN OLD STRE ET SU E HAV EN S TR EL EVEN RT C OU NO IV INE RS WATER STR EET L LY HO ST. LAWRE NCE R ED EE MA R AM R STR ST T WE IO EE T EL R STR EVA CRE SC ENT BO U WA LK ER STR EET HA R BU R C O N SI UR D T E DE LS BO U R SI E BA HA R OU G ITA NT DR IV R HE ES CAR P ME KE IT H A HA R CA R M I C HEA L V F NT JE Y WA N EN IE SO U DA W Condo ER RY CRA NB QUAY STRE ET BB SE RO IL D IL F RE W TR A YS W AY COU R T PH A IL SIE RR A TR AIL RO SE JO TR BA LSAM IL ER RY CRA NB SHO RES N NETTL ETO TRA ES CE W CR ER RY OXBO NB CRA NB ER RY SURF SHEF FIEL D CRESCENT SH NT CRA T RO TT BO U LE VA RD E E SC CR E TO AY G AT W R NBR DR IA R MC IN EL LE N LA NE RT INE RS MA R DR IV TR A FA LGA W A IL D TIO N ROA PRES ERVA DR IVE GREE IN N M EDE VA LLEY COU RT R Y T RT A TI ON WAY CON SERV U LE ITH C O WESTW IND I ON T E EC OU T UR CR AN BE R R AL PIN D IA L CO UE LA NE SU N V A CA ARD UL EV BO VE CR AIG DRI RD ULEVA GLEN BO RT OU AN C EST SILV ER ORGI GE FO R ER EN AV FA LLS DO CKSIDE DRIV E BA RK Local JOH NSTON PARK WAT ER DR IVE B ER SILV ER CREEK SUN CREST CIRCL E LIGHTHOUSE LA NE WEST EA ST AN O. 26 CEDA R P OINTE COURT AY N EVARD PRINCETO N SHORES BOUL HIG HW AD LE U LE IN RT BO PR BA TT RO R IV HE RS N E ON ED LA NE LA N Legend MC P LIND SAY E LI ST M AD BY-LAW No. 2015-094 OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD BEING A BY-LAW TO AMEND BY-LAW 2010-056 A BY-LAW TO ADOPT ONTARIO REGULATION 239/02, AS AMENDED, BEING THE MINIMUM MAINTENANCE STANDARDS FOR MUNICIPAL HIGHWAYS AS THE MINIMUM MAINTENANCE STANDARDS FOR THE ROADS WITHIN THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD WHEREAS Section 44 of the Municipal Act, 2010, S.O. 2010 c. 25, as amended, requires municipalities to maintain roads and bridges in a reasonable state of repair; AND WHEREAS Council approved Ontario Regulation 239/02 Minimum Maintenance Standard for Municipal Highways as the Minimum Maintenance Standards for the roads and bridges within the Town of Collingwood through By-law No. 2010-056; AND WHEREAS Ontario Regulation 239/02 Minimum Maintenance Standard for Municipal Highways has since been amended by O. Reg 47/13; AND WHEREAS Council concur that Ontario Regulation 47/13 amendments regarding “Minimum Maintenance Standards for Municipal Highways” are considered reasonable standards; NOW THEREFORE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. THAT Ontario Regulation 47/13 amendments to the Minimum Maintenance Standard for Municipal Highways be hereby adopted as the Minimum Maintenance Standards for the roads and bridges within the Town of Collingwood and affixed hereto as Schedule “A”, as amended from time to time. 2. THAT this By-law shall come into full force and effect on the date of final passage hereof at which time all By-laws and/or resolutions that are inconsistent with the provisions of this By-law and the same are hereby repealed or rescinded insofar as it is necessary to give effect to the provisions of this By-law. ENACTED AND PASSED this 2nd day of November, 2015. ____________________________ MAYOR ____________________________ CLERK BL2015-094 Minimum Maintenance Standards 154 of 212 Schedule “A” – By-law No. 2015-094 ONTARIO REGULATION 47/13 made under the MUNICIPAL ACT, 2001 Made: January 25, 2013 Filed: January 25, 2013 Published on e-Laws: January 28, 2013 Printed in The Ontario Gazette: February 9, 2013 Amending O. Reg. 239/02 (MINIMUM MAINTENANCE STANDARDS FOR MUNICIPAL HIGHWAYS) 1. Subsection 1 (1) of Ontario Regulation 239/02 is amended by adding the following definitions: “ice” means all kinds of ice, however formed; “snow accumulation” means the natural accumulation of any of the following that, alone or together, covers more than half a lane width of a roadway: 1. Newly-fallen snow. 2. Wind-blown snow. 3. Slush; “substantial probability” means a significant likelihood considerably in excess of 51 per cent; “weather” means air temperature, wind and precipitation. 2. Subsection 3 (2) of the Regulation is revoked and the following substituted: (2) If it is determined by the municipality that the weather monitoring referred to in section 3.1 indicates that there is a substantial probability of snow accumulation on roadways, ice formation on roadways or icy roadways, the minimum standard for patrolling highways is, in addition to that set out in subsection (1), to patrol highways that the municipality selects as representative of its highways, at intervals deemed necessary by the municipality, to check for such conditions. 3. The Regulation is amended by adding the following section: Weather monitoring 3.1 (1) From October 1 to April 30, the minimum standard is to monitor the weather, both current and forecast to occur in the next 24 hours, once every shift or three times per calendar day, whichever is more frequent, at intervals determined by the municipality. (2) From May 1 to September 30, the minimum standard is to monitor the weather, both current and forecast to occur in the next 24 hours, once per calendar day. 4. Section 4 of the Regulation is revoked and the following substituted: Snow accumulation 4. (1) The minimum standard for addressing snow accumulation is, (a) after becoming aware of the fact that the snow accumulation on a roadway is greater than the depth set out in the Table to this section, to deploy resources as soon as practicable to address the snow accumulation; and (b) after the snow accumulation has ended, to address the snow accumulation so as to reduce the snow to a depth less than or equal to the depth set out in the Table within the time set out in the Table, (i) to provide a minimum lane width of the lesser of three metres for each lane or the actual lane width, or (ii) on a Class 4 or Class 5 highway with two lanes, to provide a total width of at least five metres. (2) If the depth of snow accumulation on a roadway is less than or equal to the depth set out in the Table to this section, the roadway is deemed to be in a state of repair with respect to snow accumulation. (3) For the purposes of this section, the depth of snow accumulation on a roadway may be determined in accordance with subsection (4) by a municipal employee, agent or contractor, whose duties or responsibilities include one or more of the following: 155 of 212 2 1. Patrolling highways. 2. Performing highway maintenance activities. 3. Supervising staff who perform activities described in paragraph 1 or 2. (4) The depth of snow accumulation on a roadway may be determined by, (a) performing an actual measurement; (b) monitoring the weather; or (c) performing a visual estimate. (5) For the purposes of this section, addressing snow accumulation on a roadway includes, but is not limited to, (a) plowing the roadway; (b) salting the roadway; (c) applying abrasive materials to the roadway; or (d) any combination of the methods described in clauses (a), (b) and (c). (6) This section does not apply to that portion of the roadway designated for parking. TABLE SNOW ACCUMULATION Class of Highway 1 2 3 4 5 Depth 2.5 cm 5 cm 8 cm 8 cm 10 cm Time 4 hours 6 hours 12 hours 16 hours 24 hours 5. Section 5 of the Regulation is revoked and the following substituted: Ice formation on roadways and icy roadways 5. (1) The minimum standard for the prevention of ice formation on roadways is doing the following in the 24-hour period preceding an alleged formation of ice on a roadway: 1. Monitor the weather in accordance with section 3.1. 2. Patrol in accordance with section 3. 3. If the municipality determines, as a result of its activities under paragraph 1 or 2, that there is a substantial probability of ice forming on a roadway, treat the roadway to prevent ice formation within the time set out in the Table to this section, starting from the time that the municipality determines is the appropriate time to deploy resources for that purpose. (2) If the municipality meets the minimum standard set out in subsection (1) and, despite such compliance, ice forms on a roadway, the roadway is deemed to be in a state of repair until the earlier of, (a) the time that the municipality becomes aware of the fact that the roadway is icy; or (b) the applicable time set out in the Table to this section for treating the roadway to prevent ice formation expires. (3) The minimum standard for treating icy roadways after the municipality becomes aware of the fact that a roadway is icy is to treat the icy roadway within the time set out in the Table to this section, and an icy roadway is deemed to be in a state of repair until the applicable time set out in the Table for treating the icy roadway expires. (4) For the purposes of this section, treating a roadway means applying material to the roadway, including but not limited to, salt, sand or any combination of salt and sand. TABLE ICE FORMATION PREVENTION AND ICY ROADWAYS Class of Highway 1 2 3 4 5 Time 3 hours 4 hours 8 hours 12 hours 16 hours 156 of 212 3 6. Subsection 6 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “shall be deemed to be repaired” and substituting “is deemed to be in a state of repair”. 7. Subsection 7 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “shall be deemed to be repaired” and substituting “is deemed to be in a state of repair”. 8. Subsection 8 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “shall be deemed to be repaired” and substituting “is deemed to be in a state of repair”. 9. The definition of “debris” in subsection 9 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “material or object on a roadway” at the end of the portion before clause (a) and substituting “material (except snow, slush or ice) or object on a roadway”. 10. (1) Subsection 10 (0.1) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “once per year” at the end and substituting “once per calendar year, with each inspection taking place not more than 16 months from the previous inspection”. (2) Subsection 10 (5) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “shall be deemed to be repaired” at the end of the portion before clause (a) and substituting “are deemed to be in a state of repair”. 11. (1) Subsection 11 (0.1) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “once per year” at the end and substituting “once per calendar year, with each inspection taking place not more than 16 months from the previous inspection”. (2) Section 11 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsection: (0.2) A sign that has been inspected in accordance with subsection (0.1) is deemed to be in a state of repair with respect to the retro-reflectivity requirements of the Ontario Traffic Manual until the next inspection in accordance with that subsection, provided that the municipality does not acquire actual knowledge that the sign has ceased to meet these requirements. 12. (1) Subsection 12 (1) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “once per year” at the end and substituting “once per calendar year, with each inspection taking place not more than 16 months from the previous inspection”. (2) Section 12 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsection: (1.1) A regulatory sign or warning sign that has been inspected in accordance with subsection (1) is deemed to be in a state of repair with respect to the retro-reflectivity requirements of the Ontario Traffic Manual until the next inspection in accordance with that subsection, provided that the municipality does not acquire actual knowledge that the sign has ceased to meet these requirements. 13. (1) Subsection 14 (1) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “every 12 months” at the end of the portion before paragraph 1 and substituting “once per calendar year, with each inspection taking place not more than 16 months from the previous inspection”. (2) Section 14 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsection: (1.1) A traffic control signal system sub-system that has been inspected, tested and maintained in accordance with subsection (1) is deemed to be in a state of repair until the next inspection in accordance with that subsection, provided that the municipality does not acquire actual knowledge that the traffic control signal system sub-system has ceased to be in a state of repair. (3) Subsection 14 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “twice a year” at the end and substituting “twice per calendar year”. (4) Section 14 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsection: (2.1) A conflict monitor that has been inspected, tested and maintained in accordance with subsection (2) is deemed to be in a state of repair until the next inspection in accordance with that subsection, provided that the municipality does not acquire actual knowledge that the conflict monitor has ceased to be in a state of repair. 14. Subsection 15 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “shall be deemed to be repaired” and substituting “is deemed to be in a state of repair”. 15. Section 16 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsections: (1.1) A surface discontinuity on a roadway, other than a surface discontinuity on a bridge deck, is deemed to be in a state of repair if its height is less than or equal to the height set out in the Table to this section. . . . . . (2.1) A surface discontinuity on a bridge deck is deemed to be in a state of repair if its height is less than or equal to five centimetres. 16. (1) Subsection 16.1 (1) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “once per year” at the end and substituting “once per calendar year, with each inspection taking place not more than 16 months from the previous inspection”. (2) Section 16.1 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsection: 157 of 212 4 (1.1) A sidewalk that has been inspected in accordance with subsection (1) is deemed to be in a state of repair with respect to any surface discontinuity until the next inspection in accordance with that subsection, provided that the municipality does not acquire actual knowledge of the presence of a surface discontinuity in excess of two centimetres. (3) Subsection 16.1 (2) of the Regulation is amended by striking out “after becoming aware of the fact” at the end and substituting “after acquiring actual knowledge of the fact”. (4) Section 16.1 of the Regulation is amended by adding the following subsection: (2.1) A surface discontinuity on a sidewalk is deemed to be in a state of repair if it is less than or equal to two centimetres. Commencement 17. This Regulation comes into force on the day it is filed. Made by: BOB CHIARELLI Minister of Transportation Date made: January 25, 2013. Back to top 158 of 212 DEVELOPMENT & OPERATIONS SERVICES STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT TO COUNCIL DEVT2015-10 November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Subject: October 26, 2015 – Development & Operations Services Standing Committee Meeting RECOMMENDATION: That Council receive the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee Report from the meeting of October 26, 2015, as presented. 1. BACKGROUND Listed below are the actions resulting from the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee meeting held on October 26, 2015. They are before Council for consideration. 2. MEETING ATTENDANCE / ADOPTION OF AGENDA / MINUTES Members of Council Present: Councillor Jeffery, Chair Councillor Ecclestone Councillor Lloyd Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-01 THAT the content of the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee Agenda for October 26, 2015 be adopted as presented. CARRIED BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE PREVIOUS MEETING (September 28, 2015) - Nil DECLARATION OF CONFLICT OR PECUNIARY INTEREST Councillor Jeffery declared a conflict with respect to Staff Report P2015-31, Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision as the developer is a client of her employer. 3. DEPUTATIONS None -1- 159 of 212 4. REPORTS/MINUTES OF OTHER COMMITTEES/BOARDS Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Lloyd Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-02 THAT the BIA Board of Management minutes of October 1, 2015 and the Collingwood Heritage Committee minutes of October 7, 2015 be hereby received. CARRIED Councillor Lloyd requested clarification to the BIA ask regarding their concerns with the lack of resolution regarding rental of the Eddie Bush Memorial Arena. 5. STAFF REPORTS C2015-25 Parking By-law Amendments Purpose: To amend Parking By-law No. 2003-062 to prohibit parking in Town laneways and to amend Schedule “A” to include additional no parking zones. Kara Stone, on behalf of her daughter, advised the Standing Committee of her daughters issues with the lack of parking at the location where her business currently operates out of (corner of Elliot Ave and Highway 26) and the negative effect it would have on the success of her business as she would not be able to provide suitable parking for her clients should the proposed parking amendment along Elliott Avenue be passed. Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Lloyd Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-03 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council enact and pass an amending By-law for Parking By-law No. 2003-062 to prohibit parking in Town laneways and to amend Schedule “A” to include additional no parking zones. Amendment: Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone THAT the Development and Operations Services Standing Committee recommend that the proposed parking restriction for Elliott Avenue be restricted to one side of the street. CARRIED Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Lloyd Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-03 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council enact and pass an amending By-law for Parking By-law No. 2003-062 to prohibit parking in Town laneways and to amend Schedule “A” to include additional no parking zones; and further that the proposed parking restriction for Elliott Avenue be restricted to one side of the street. CARRIED -2- 160 of 212 Councillor Jeffery left the meeting during the below discussion and vote with respect to her previously declared conflict of interest. Councillor Ecclestone assumed the Chair. P2015-31 Extension of Draft Approval for Plan of Subdivision Mountaincroft (D1202615) Purpose: To provide Council with an analysis regarding a request to extend draft approval for the proposed Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision. Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-04 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council extends the draft approval for the proposed Mountaincroft Plan of Subdivision for a further year (January 11th, 2017). CARRIED Councillor Jeffery resumed the Chair. P2015-32 Extension of Draft Approval for Plan of Subdivision Mair Mills Villages (D1202515) Purpose: To provide Council with an analysis regarding a request to extend draft approval for the proposed Mair Mills Villages Plan of Subdivision. Don Ellis, Highlands Crescent questioned whether a pumping station would be required prior to the land being developed, and when development of the land is anticipated to commence. Staff confirmed development of the land should commence within three years, and no development can take place until the required pumping station is in place. Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-05 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council extends the draft approval for the proposed Mair Mills Villages Plan of Subdivision for a further three (3) years (April 29th, 2019). CARRIED P2015-33 Proposed Land Sale – 507 Ontario Street Purpose: To consider an expression of interest received for the purchase of a portion of town land adjacent to 507 Ontario Street. Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Lloyd Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-06 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council hereby declares a portion of town lands adjacent to 507 Ontario Street as surplus to the needs of the municipality and directs Staff to provide the required notice to sell the subject properties in accordance with the Town’s Land Sale and Notice By-laws. CARRIED -3- 161 of 212 P2015-34 Backyard Urban Chickens in the Town of Collingwood Purpose: To review a resident’s request to permit backyard chickens received by the Development and Operations Services Standing Committee, and to provide information related to urban chickens for Council’s consideration. Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Jeffery Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-07 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: THAT Council authorize the initiation of an application for Official Plan and Zoning Bylaw amendments and the required public consultation process and allow a moratorium of enforcement for existing properties with backyard chickens. Amendment: Moved by Councillor Jeffery Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone THAT the Development and Operations Services Standing Committee recommend limiting the moratorium to a maximum of four hens until a decision of Council is reached. CARRIED Moved by Councillor Ecclestone Seconded by Councillor Jeffery Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-07 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: THAT Council authorize the initiation of an application for Official Plan and Zoning Bylaw amendments and the required public consultation process and allow a moratorium of enforcement for existing properties with backyard chickens, limiting the moratorium to a maximum of four hens. CARRIED PW2015-26 Award of RFP PW2015-07 – Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting Purpose: To present the Request for Proposal results and award the contract for the Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting. Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-08 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council receive Staff Report PW2015-26 entitled “Turnkey Solution for Supply and Install of LED Street Lighting” and award the RFP to RealTerm Energy with a total cost of $1,475,617.99 plus HST; AND THAT Council authorize the use of County of Simcoe Landfill Settlement monies to fund the LED street light retrofit project. CARRIED -4- 162 of 212 PW2015-28 Adoption of the Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy and Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments Purpose: To provide Council with the proper information to adopt a Winter Control Policy to set and maintain a level of service for winter maintenance within the Town of Collingwood. Additionally, amendments to the current Minimum Maintenance Standards (MMS) are required to be amended to include recent updates. Moved by Councillor Lloyd Seconded by Councillor Ecclestone Resolution No. DEVT2015-10-09 THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee support and refer the following Staff Report to the next regular meeting of Council: Recommendation: THAT Council receive Staff Report PW2015-28 entitled “Adoption of The Town of Collingwood Winter Control Policy and Minimum Maintenance Standard Amendments”; AND THAT Council adopts the Town of Collingwood Winter Control Plan dated October 16, 2015; AND THAT Council amends By-Law 2010-056 to include O.Reg 47/13, amendments to the Minimum Maintenance Standards for Municipal Highways. CARRIED 6. DEPARTMENTAL UPDATES/DISCUSSION Staff provided an update to the Standing Committee on various initiatives and projects they are working on including: Engineering and Public Works: Brian MacDonald, Director of Engineering and Public Works provided a Progress Report on the Hume Street and Highway 26 construction projects, fall maintenance being undertaken, and repairs to hazardous sidewalks throughout municipality. Marketing and Business Development: Martin Rydlo, Director of Marketing and Business Development reviewed the Oktoberfest event held in Collingwood and its partnerships with local businesses, a promotional video supplied by the Collingwood Brewery highlighting Collingwood water; a tourism video with Breaking Down Barriers and RTO7 about accessibility in South Georgian Bay; announced that the Town will be seeking interested through an RFP for a social media consultant; and announced a number of upcoming events including the Santa Clause parade and market, speed networking, and Cultivating ARTpreneurship. 7. CORRESPONDENCE None 8. PUBLIC DELEGATIONS Betty Donaher addressed the Standing Committee expressing her support to permit backyard chickens and requesting consideration be given to expand the permitted fowl to include partridges and pheasants. Mrs. Donaher further requested the Standing Committee consider installing a street light and flood light at the pumping station on Poplar Sideroad to provide light to Pawplar Park, and a tap in the park. The Standing Committee requested Councillor Doherty bring forward the request at an upcoming Community Services Standing Committee meeting. 163 of 212 -5- Margaret Mooy, highlighted items from the latest Heritage Newsletter noting a change in date for ‘Preserving our Main Streets’ to November 17, potential partnerships to be discussed at the next Collingwood Heritage Committee meeting, thanking the Standing Committee for their support. Lindsay 9. OTHER BUSINESS None 10. ADJOURNMENT Moved by Councillor Ecclestone THAT the Development & Operations Services Standing Committee meeting adjourns at 5:58 p.m. CARRIED -6- 164 of 212 MEMO TO: Council, Town of Collingwood DATE: November 2, 2015 FROM: Sue Bragg RE: Consolidated Audited Financial Report for the Town of Collingwood Here are the highlights from 2014: Consolidated financial statements include Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board (CPUSB or “water board”) and others controlled by the Town. See Note 1(a) on Page 6 and Note 22 on Page 20 re: change to water board. Accumulated surplus of $192 million (Pages 2 and 3) compared to $186 million last year, which includes $152 million invested in TCA, $31.7 million in reserves and reserve funds, $5 million CPUSB surplus and $3.6 million portfolio investment in Collus PowerStream. See Note 13 on Pages 14 and 15. The following comments relate to balances as shown on the Consolidated Statement of Financial Position, Page 2: Cash of $24.9 million compared to $15.1 million last year. $1.8 million is restricted in use for obligatory reserve funds such as development charges and federal gas tax monies. See Note 3 on Page 10. Investments of $11.6 million the same as last year. All of these funds are restricted in use for obligatory reserve funds such as development charges and federal gas tax monies. See Note 4 on Page 10. Taxes receivable increased $479,000 during the year. 8% of total taxes levied were receivable at year end, up from 7% last year (other municipalities we audit range from 6% to 12%). Accounts receivable decreased $1.2 million during the year, due to receipts from North Bar and grant from Province. Long-term receivable increased by $903,000 as a result of new amounts due from land owners on Long Point Road, Madeline Drive, Lindsay Lane and Raglan Street. See Note 5 on Page 11. Note receivable (see Note 6 on Page 11) and portfolio investment (see Note 1 (e) on Page 7) regarding Collus PowerStream remained the same. New note receivable from the Collingwood Curling Club with balance at year end of $451,000. See Note 6 on Page 11. Accounts payable and accruals increased $2.3 million, mainly due to construction holdbacks and progress certificates payable on capital projects at year end. Developer deposits increased $377,000 from last year mainly due to new deposit from Mountain View Town Centre. Deferred revenue has decreased $946,000 compared to last year due to spending of Connecting Link and Municipal Infrastructure monies on Huron Street widening and Fourth and Fifth Street bridges. Obligatory reserve funds increased $4 million during the year. The $12.4 million balance includes over $10.5 million for development charges (DCs) and $1.3 million in gas tax monies. The main withdrawals from DCs during the year were 165 of 212 to finance: Fourth and Fifth Street bridges and Hume Street widening. See Note 10 on Page 13 Long-term debt increased by $162,000 as a result of $3.1 million in regularly scheduled repayments, off set by a new $3.3 million debenture to finance the new fire hall. See Note 8 on Page 12. Tangible capital assets (TCAs) have a net book value of over $194 million. There was over $10 million in new additions, off set by amortization of $9.1 million. Significant capital projects included: renovations at Eddie Bush arena and the Curling club, Fourth and Fifth Street bridges, widening Huron and Hume Streets and sanitary sewer improvements. See Schedules 1, 2 and 3 on Pages 21 to 23. Reserves and reserve funds, part of accumulated surplus (Note 13 on Page 14), were $31.7 million, up from $30.3 million last year. The following comments relate to balances as shown on the Consolidated Statement of Operations, Page 3: Revenue was $2 million more than last year at $49.8 million and exceeded the budgeted amount of $48.7 million: user charges exceeded budget by $576,000. Current expenses were $49.5 million compared to budget of $50.6 million and $46.5 million in the prior year. Amortization expense of $9.1 million is included. Capital revenue was $5.3 million compared to budget of $4.6 million due to timing of revenue recognition compared to progress of capital projects. The loss on disposal of tangible capital assets and land and buildings held for sale was over $9 million last year, mainly due to the transfer of Poplar Sideroad. For more information on the Statement of Operations, see Schedules 4, 5 and 6 on Pages 24 to 26. Many thanks to the Treasury staff for their assistance during both the interim and year end audits. Thank you for the opportunity to serve as your auditors and we look forward to many more years of association with you. 166 of 212 sio n CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD COUNTY OF SIMCOE us CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL REPORT Dr aft for Di sc DECEMBER 31, 2014 167 of 212 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD DECEMBER 31, 2014 us sio n CONTENTS sc Independent Auditor's Report Di Consolidated Statement of Financial Position Consolidated Statement of Operations 1 2 3 4 Consolidated Statement of Cash Flow 5 6 Schedule 1 - Consolidated Schedule of Tangible Capital Assets 21 Schedule 2 - Consolidated Schedule of Segmented Tangible Capital Assets 2014 22 Schedule 3 - Consolidated Schedule of Segmented Tangible Capital Assets 2013 23 Schedule 4 - Consolidated Schedule of Segmented Revenues and Expenses 2014 Actual 24 Schedule 5 - Consolidated Schedule of Segmented Revenues and Expenses 2013 Actual 25 Schedule 6 - Consolidated Schedule of Segmented Revenues and Expenses 2014 Budget 26 aft Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements Dr for Consolidated Statement of Change in Net Debt 168 of 212 COLLINS BARROW SGB LLP CHARTERED PROFESSIONAL ACCOUNTANTS INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT To the Members of Council, Inhabitants and Ratepayers of the Town of Collingwood: Report on the Consolidated Financial Statements We have audited the accompanying consolidated financial statements of the Town of Collingwood, which comprise the consolidated statement of financial position as at December 31, 2014, and the consolidated statements of operations, change in net debt and cash flow for the year then ended, and a summary of significant accounting policies and other explanatory information. Management's Responsibility for the Consolidated Financial Statements sio n Management is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of these consolidated financial statements in accordance with Canadian public sector accounting standards and for such internal control as management determines is necessary to enable the preparation of consolidated financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. us Auditor's Responsibility Di sc Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these consolidated financial statements based on our audit. We conducted our audit in accordance with Canadian generally accepted auditing standards. Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial statements are free from material misstatement. Dr aft for An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the consolidated financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the auditor's judgment, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the consolidated financial statements, whether due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the Municipality's preparation and fair presentation of the consolidated financial statements in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the Municipality's internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the consolidated financial statements. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our audit opinion. Opinion In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Town of Collingwood as at December 31, 2014, and the results of its operations and its cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with Canadian public sector accounting standards. Collins Barrow SGB LLP Licensed Public Accountants Collingwood, Ontario November 2, 2015 This office is independently owned and operated by Collins Barrow SGB LLP. The Collins Barrow trademarks are used under License. 169 of 212 1 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION AS AT DECEMBER 31 for Di sc us Liabilities Accounts payable and accruals (Note 7) Accrued interest payable Employee future benefits (Note 15) Developer deposits Deferred revenue Deferred revenue - obligatory reserve funds (Note 10) Long-term (Note 8) sio n Financial assets Cash (Note 3) Investments (Note 4) Taxes receivable Accounts receivable (Note 7) Long-term receivables (Note 5) Notes receivable (Note 6) Portfolio investment - Hydro companies Net debt Dr aft Non-financial assets Tangible capital assets - net (Schedule 1 and Note 14) Prepaid expenses Accumulated surplus (Note 13) Approved 2014 2013 $ $ 24,900,892 11,603,367 4,310,256 7,708,987 4,308,554 2,161,419 3,622,164 15,077,929 11,603,367 3,830,613 8,935,004 3,405,697 1,710,169 3,622,164 58,615,639 48,184,943 7,531,801 163,137 1,209,231 2,539,420 723,726 12,480,259 37,022,620 5,248,913 157,999 1,173,649 2,161,867 1,670,241 8,442,831 36,860,776 61,670,194 55,716,276 (3,054,555) (7,531,333) 194,564,701 735,217 193,594,826 779,971 195,299,918 194,374,797 192,245,363 186,843,464 __________________ __________________ The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 170 of 212 2 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31 Actual 2013 $ (Note 19) $ $ 27,644,325 117,870 15,237,144 528,128 629,664 532,000 306,000 480,000 3,222,903 27,452,815 141,777 15,813,160 812,316 840,637 258,166 545,433 602,738 3,299,814 25,909,278 136,567 16,008,347 399,429 776,123 356,029 320,372 563,010 3,285,184 48,698,034 49,766,856 47,754,339 5,712,119 12,212,279 8,579,422 13,287,928 258,800 8,668,808 1,855,937 5,161,969 11,611,466 9,029,102 12,826,235 248,540 8,737,392 1,847,552 4,751,564 10,787,536 8,840,498 12,728,407 245,894 7,571,079 1,620,274 50,575,293 49,462,256 46,545,252 (1,877,259) 304,600 1,209,087 2,282,335 1,716,681 607,000 - 1,798,128 1,540,737 53,201 1,948,988 (243,755) 1,009,981 4,020,247 241,484 392,309 (9,534,602) 4,606,016 5,097,299 (3,870,581) 2,728,757 5,401,899 (2,661,494) sio us sc Di aft Net revenues (expenses) for Expenses General government Protection to persons and property Transportation Environmental Housing Recreation and cultural Planning and development Actual 2014 n Revenues Net municipal taxation (Note 16) Payments in lieu of taxation User charges Government transfers Other municipalities Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Investment Penalties and interest on taxes Other (Note 17) Budget 2014 Dr Other Grants and transfers related to capital Government transfers Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Contributed tangible capital assets (Note 14) Other Loss on disposal of tangible capital assets Annual surplus (deficit) Accumulated surplus, beginning of year 186,843,464 189,504,958 Accumulated surplus, end of year (Note 13) 192,245,363 186,843,464 The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 171 of 212 3 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGE IN NET DEBT FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31 Annual surplus (deficit) Actual 2014 Actual 2013 $ (Note 19) $ $ 2,728,757 5,401,899 (2,661,494) (14,862,720) 9,197,161 182,000 - (10,412,198) 9,167,183 243,755 84,586 (53,201) 44,754 - (15,454,266) 8,573,100 9,534,602 873,995 (241,484) (36,096) (1,212,091) (2,754,802) 4,476,778 sio n Acquisition of tangible capital assets Amortization of tangible capital assets Loss on disposal of tangible capital assets Proceeds on disposal of tangible capital assets Contributed tangible capital assets Change in prepaid expenses Land and buildings held for sale Budget 2014 us Change in net debt sc Net debt, beginning of year (7,531,333) (6,907,599) (3,054,555) (7,531,333) Dr aft for Di Net debt, end of year (623,734) The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 172 of 212 4 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOW FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31 sio n Cash flows from (for): Operating activities Annual surplus (deficit) Non-cash items: Amortization of tangible capital assets Loss on disposal of tangible capital assets Contributed tangible capital assets Employee future benefits Change in net working capital (Note 2) aft for Net change in cash from capital Investing activities Long-term receivables Notes receivable Change in investments sc Di Capital activities Proceeds on disposal of tangible capital assets Acquisition of tangible capital assets Accounts receivable - tangible capital assets Accounts payable - tangible capital assets us Net change in cash from operations 2014 2013 $ $ 5,401,899 (2,661,494) 9,167,183 243,755 (53,201) 35,582 14,795,218 418,028 8,573,100 9,534,602 (241,484) 33,497 15,238,221 979,017 15,213,246 16,217,238 84,586 (10,412,198) 2,964,512 74,167 873,995 (15,454,266) (1,064,015) (1,206,762) (7,288,933) (16,851,048) (902,857) (451,250) - 2,093,060 (280,888) (1,354,107) 1,812,172 Financing activities Long-term liabilities issued Long-term liabilities repaid Deferred revenue - obligatory reserve funds Deferred revenue 3,300,000 (3,138,156) 4,037,428 (946,515) 2,252,000 (3,863,581) (1,071,708) 790,837 Net change in cash from financing 3,252,757 (1,892,452) Net change in cash and cash equivalents 9,822,963 (714,090) Dr Net change in cash from investing Cash and cash equivalents, beginning of year 15,077,929 15,792,019 Cash and cash equivalents, end of year 24,900,892 15,077,929 The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 173 of 212 5 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 Nature of operations The Town of Collingwood ("the Municipality") is a lower-tier municipality located in the County of Simcoe, Province of Ontario, Canada. It conducts its operations guided by the provisions of provincial statutes, such as the Municipal Act, Municipal Affairs Act and related legislation. 1. Summary of significant accounting policies n The consolidated financial statements of the Municipality are the representation of management prepared in accordance with local government accounting standards established by the Public Sector Accounting Board (PSAB) of the Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada. sc us sio The focus of PSAB financial statements is on the financial position of the municipality and the changes thereto. The consolidated statement of financial position includes all the assets and liabilities of the Municipality. Financial assets are those assets which could provide resources to discharge existing liabilities or finance future operations. Accumulated surplus represents the financial position and is the difference between assets and liabilities. This provides information about the Municipality's overall future revenue requirements and its ability to finance activities and meet its obligations. Significant aspects of the accounting policies adopted by the Municipality are as follows: Di (a) Basis of consolidation for These consolidated financial statements reflect assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses of the Municipality. They include the activities of all committees of Council and the following organizations which are accountable to, and owned or controlled by the Municipality: aft Corporation of the Town of Collingwood Public Library Board Corporation of the Town of Collingwood Business Improvement Area Collingwood Airport Services Board Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board (Note 22) Dr Excluded are Funds Held in Trust which are administered by the Municipality and reported on separately. All interfund assets and liabilities and sources of financing and expenses have been eliminated. (b) Basis of accounting Sources of revenues and expenses are reported on the accrual basis of accounting. The accrual basis of accounting recognizes revenues as they become available and measurable. Expenses are recognized as they are incurred and measurable as a result of receipt of goods or services and the creation of a legal obligation to pay. (c) Cash and cash equivalents Cash and cash equivalents include all cash balances and short-term highly liquid financial instruments with a maturity of three months or less at acquisition. (d) Investments Investments include guaranteed investment certificates (GICs) with a maturity greater than three months at acquisition. Investments are recorded at cost. 174 of 212 6 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 1. Summary of significant accounting policies (continued) (e) Portfolio investment The portfolio investment is the 50% equity investment in Collingwood PowerStream Utility Services Corp., which is not controlled by the Municipality. The investment was initially recorded using the cost method. The Municipality will only record any distributed income of the investee (dividends) when they are received or receivable. In the event there is a loss in value of a portfolio investment in the future, other than a temporary decline, it will be recognized in the period. (f) Non-financial assets sio n Non-financial assets are not available to discharge existing liabilities and are held for use in the provision of services. They have useful lives extending beyond the current year and are not intended for sale in the ordinary course of operations. The change in non-financial assets during the year, together with the annual (deficit) surplus, provides the consolidated change in net debt for the year. us (i) Tangible capital assets - 10 to 20 years - 15 to 50 years - 3 to 40 years - 5 to 15 years - 10 to 75 years for Land improvements Buildings Machinery and equipment Vehicles Linear assets Di sc Tangible capital assets are recorded at cost, which includes all amounts that are directly attributable to acquisition, construction, development or betterment of the asset. The cost, less residual value, of the tangible capital assets are amortized on a straight-line basis over their estimated useful lives as follows: aft Work in progress is not amortized until the asset is available for productive use. One half of the annual amortization is charged in the year of acquisition and in the year of disposal. Dr (ii) Contributed tangible capital assets Tangible capital assets received as contributions are recorded at their fair value at the date of receipt and also are recorded as revenue. (g) Deferred revenue Revenue restricted by legislation, regulation, or agreement and not available for general municipal purposes is reported as deferred revenue on the statement of financial position. The revenue is reported on the consolidated statement of operations in the year in which it is used for the specified purpose. (h) County and school boards The Municipality collects taxation revenue on behalf of the school boards and the County of Simcoe. The taxation, other revenues, expenses, assets and liabilities with respect to the operations of the school boards and the County of Simcoe are not reflected in these consolidated financial statements. 175 of 212 7 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 1. Summary of significant accounting policies (continued) (i) Revenue recognition Fees for water and waste water usage are recognized as user charges when consumed by the customer. Connection fee revenues are recognized when the connection has been established. sio n Government transfers are recognized in the consolidated financial statements as revenues in the period in which the events giving rise to the transfer occur, providing the transfers are authorized, any eligibility criteria have been met and reasonable estimates of the amounts can be made. Conditional government grants are recognized to the extent the conditions imposed on them have been fulfilled. Unconditional government grants are recognized when monies are receivable. Government grants for acquisition of tangible capital assets are recognized in the period in which eligible expenditures are made. Transfers are recognized as deferred revenue when transfer stipulations give rise to a liability. Transfer revenue is recognized in the consolidated statement of operations as the stipulation liabilities are settled. sc us Investment revenue (other than on obligatory funds) is recognized in the period earned. Investment revenue earned on obligatory reserve funds is added to the fund balance and forms part of the respective deferred revenue balances and is recognized in the period in which eligible expenditures are made. Di Other user charges, payments from other municipalities, gain on disposal of tangible capital assets and other revenue are recognized on an accrual basis. (j) Use of estimates Dr (k) Segment disclosures aft for The preparation of financial statements in conformity with Canadian generally accepted accounting principles requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements and the reported amounts of revenues and expenses during the period. Significant estimates exist in tangible capital assets with regard to historical costs and useful lives. Other significant estimates include amortization and employee future benefits. Actual results could differ from those estimates. Municipal services have been segmented by grouping activities that have similar service objectives (by function). Revenues that are directly related to the costs of the function have been attributed to each segment. Municipal taxation revenue is allocated based on the percentage of total budgeted expenses. 176 of 212 8 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 1. Summary of significant accounting policies (continued) (l) Pension plan The Municipality offers a pension plan for its full-time employees through the Ontario Municipal Employee Retirement System ("OMERS"). OMERS is a multi-employer, contributory, public sector pension fund established for employees of municipalities, local boards and school boards in Ontario. Participating employers and employees are required to make plan contributions based on participating employees' contributory earnings. The Municipality accounts for its participation in OMERS as a defined benefit plan and recognizes the expense related to this plan as contributions are made. n (m) Other post-employment benefits us sio Employee future benefits other than pension provided by the Municipality include medical, dental and life insurance benefits. These plans provide benefits to employees when they are no longer providing active service. Employee future benefit expense is recognized in the period in which the employees render services on an accrual basis. (n) Taxation and related revenues for Di sc The accrued benefit obligations and the current service costs are calculated using the projected benefit method, prorated on service, and based on assumptions that reflect management’s best estimates. The current service cost for a period is equal to the actuarial present value of benefits attributed to employees’ services rendered in the period. Past service costs arising from plan amendments are amortized on a straight-line basis over the average remaining service period of employees active at the date of amendment. The excess of the net actuarial gains or losses over 10% of the accrued benefit obligation is amortized to expense over the average remaining service period of active employees to full eligibility. Dr aft Municipal tax billings are prepared by the Municipality based on assessment rolls issued by the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation. Tax rates are established annually by the Municipal Council, incorporating amounts to be raised for local services. A normal part of the assessment process is the issue of supplementary assessment rolls, which provide updated information with respect to changes in property assessment. Once a supplementary assessment roll is received, the Municipality determines the taxes applicable and renders supplementary tax billings. Taxation revenues are recorded at the time tax billings are issued. Assessments and the related property taxes are subject to appeal. Taxes are recorded at estimated amounts when they meet the definition of an asset, have been authorized and the taxable event occurs. For municipal taxes, the taxable event is the period for which the tax is levied. Taxes receivable are recognized net of allowance for anticipated uncollectible amounts. The Municipality is entitled to collect interest and penalties on overdue taxes. These revenues are recorded in the period the interest and penalties are levied. 177 of 212 9 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 2. Change in net working capital Changes in the Municipality's net working capital are as follows: sio n Taxes receivable Accounts receivable Accounts payable and accruals Accrued interest payable Developer deposits Prepaid expenses $ $ (479,643) (1,738,495) 2,208,721 5,138 377,553 44,754 290,463 161,744 938,953 (16,468) (359,579) (36,096) 418,028 979,017 2014 2013 $ $ 23,060,519 1,840,373 11,379,202 3,698,727 24,900,892 15,077,929 2014 2013 $ 2,588,707 2,233,772 2,000,000 2,500,000 2,280,888 $ 2,000,000 2,588,707 2,233,772 2,500,000 2,280,888 11,603,367 11,603,367 aft for Di sc 3. Cash Cash consists of the following: Unrestricted Restricted 2013 us Change in net working capital 2014 Dr 4. Investments Guaranteed investment certificates included in investments are as follows: CIBC CIBC CIBC NBC CIBC CIBC Interest (per annum) 3.67% 1.82% 1.77% 1.21% 3.32% 1.91% Due May 28, 2014 January 6, 2015 January 16, 2015 June 23, 2015 February 29, 2016 May 29, 2017 Investments are recorded at cost which approximates fair market value. All investments are restricted. 178 of 212 10 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 5. Long-term receivables Benefiting land owners of water and sewer servicing completed in south Collingwood had the option to pay for their share of the cost in full in 2008 or finance over 20 years at 5.25% per annum with annual repayments commencing in 2009. In 2010, the bylaw was reopened and benefiting landowners had a second opportunity to pay the cost in full. Annual payments totaling $227,046 (2013 - $227,046) will be included on the remaining tax payers' property tax bills until 2028. The balance of the long-term receivable related to this was $3,169,220 at year end (2013 - $3,405,697). sio n Benefiting land owners of new water distribution works installed in lands abutting Long Point Road, Madeline Drive and Lindsay Lane had the option to pay in full or finance over 10 or 20 years with interest payable at the annual debenture rate published by Infrastructure Ontario. As at year end the balance receivable from land owners was $675,177 (2013 - $NIL). sc us Benefiting land owners of new water distribution works installed in lands abutting Raglan Street had the option to pay in full or finance over 10 or 20 years with interest payable at the annual debenture rate published by Infrastructure Ontario. As at year end the balance receivable from land owners was $449,105 (2013 - $NIL). 6. Notes receivable for Di The note receivable from Collingwood PowerStream Utility Services Corp. (CPUSC), a related party as described in note 1(e), in the amount of $1,710,169 (2013 - $1,710,169) bears interest at 4.88% (2013 5.58%) and is due on demand. The Town provided written notice to CPUSC that the note will not be called in the 2015 fiscal year. 7. Related parties aft During the year the Municipality issued a note receivable from the Collingwood Curling Club in the amount of $475,000, bearing no interest, with annual repayments of $23,750. As at year end the balance receivable was $451,250 (2013 - $NIL). Dr The Municipality owns 50% of the shares outstanding in CPUSC. Included in accounts receivable is $3,614,674 (2013 - $1,644,087) due from CPUSC. Accounts payable includes $541,715 (2013 - $456,715) due to CPUSC. Included in investment revenue is $83,456 (2013 $95,427) of interest earned on the note receivable from CPUSC. Other revenue includes $216,000 (2013 $216,000) from CPUSC administration centre facility rental, dividends received of $183,500 (2013 - $NIL) and other miscellaneous revenue sources totaling $94,717 (2013 - $133,853). Included in operating expenses is $3,295,493 (2013 $3,090,063) paid to CPUSC. 179 of 212 11 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 8. Long-term liabilities (a) Long-term liabilities consist of the following: Total long-term liabilities incurred by the Municipality and outstanding at the end of the year Total sc us 1,617,679 1,637,722 1,658,899 1,681,274 1,704,915 10,745,772 Di 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Thereafter sio n (b) Principal payments for the next 5 years and thereafter are as follows: $ Tax Supported 19,046,261 2013 $ $ 37,022,620 $ User Fee $ 36,860,776 $ Other 1,271,362 1,288,237 1,306,067 1,324,906 1,344,811 5,479,261 442,337 442,337 442,337 442,337 442,337 3,750,030 12,014,644 5,961,715 37,022,620 for Overall total 2014 aft The above long-term liabilities issued in the name of the Municipality have been approved by by-law. The annual principal and interest payments required to service these liabilities are within the annual debt repayment limit prescribed by the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. Dr (c) Interest is payable at rates ranging from NIL% to 5.58% per annum. (d) The Town also has an operating line of credit available for use in the amount of $6,000,000, with an interest rate of prime less 0.75%. At December 31, 2014, the balance for the line of credit was $NIL (2013 - $NIL). 9. Trust funds Trust funds administered by the Municipality amounting to $600 (2013 - $600) have not been included in the consolidated statement of financial position nor have their operations been included in the consolidated statement of operations. In the current year there were no transactions in the trust accounts. The trust funds are not audited. The trust funds are comprised of the following: Cultural Trusts 2014 2013 $ $ 600 600 180 of 212 12 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 10.Deferred revenue - obligatory reserve funds A requirement of the public sector accounting principles of the Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada is that obligatory reserve funds be reported as deferred revenue. This requirement is in place as provincial legislation restricts how these funds may be used and under certain circumstances these funds may be refunded. 11. Letters of credit Dr aft Obligatory Reserve Funds: Recreational Land Development Charges Act Building Code Act Parkland Levy Federal Gas Tax sio us sc for Deferred revenue, end of year Di Deferred revenue, beginning of year New deposits: Federal government Provincial government Private sources Investment income Capital and other transfers Development charges repaid to developers Development charge credits utilized n The net change during the year in the restricted deferred revenue balances is comprised of the following: 2014 2013 $ 8,442,831 $ 9,514,539 571,475 307,670 5,133,565 180,995 (2,132,957) (167,929) 144,609 536,904 203,365 2,870,365 118,766 (4,736,008) (424,832) 359,732 12,480,259 8,442,831 69,168 10,526,088 222,789 309,847 1,352,367 69,168 6,711,856 219,930 102,417 1,339,460 12,480,259 8,442,831 As part of various developments, the Town has received letters of credit to cover the costs of completing these projects. Letters of credit held by the Town at December 31, 2014 were $12,535,637 (2013 $13,440,614). 12. Contingencies (a) In the ordinary course of business, various claims and lawsuits are brought against the Municipality. No provision has been made for pending expropriations of land beyond the payments already made to affected property owners. Any payment made by the Municipality pursuant to claims, lawsuits or expropriations will be charged to the year of settlement. (b) The Municipality's landfill site was taken over by the County of Simcoe and, as compensation, the County will accept Municipal waste at a below market rate value of $79 per tonne. Based on maximum tonnes to be accepted by the County this reduced rate is estimated to last until 2029. Subsequent to year end, the Municipality and the County agreed to early payment of the outstanding landfill settlement in the amount of $1,657,133. 181 of 212 13 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 13.Accumulated surplus The accumulated surplus consists of individual fund surplus, reserves and reserve funds as follows: Current fund surplus: General area taxation (Note 20) Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board Di sc Total investment in tangible capital assets Unfunded liabilities: Employee future benefits aft for Reserves set aside for specific purposes by Council: Contingencies Post-employment benefits CPUSC note receivable Current purposes Acquisition of tangible capital assets Total reserves Dr Reserve funds set aside for specific purposes by Council: Current purposes Acquisition of tangible capital assets Total reserve funds Investment in hydro companies: Portfolio investment Total accumulated surplus sio us Investment in tangible capital assets: Net book value of tangible capital assets Tangible capital assets financed by long-term liabilities Unfinanced capital expenditures n Total current fund surplus 2014 $ 2013 $ 25,001 5,031,782 25,001 4,615,930 5,056,783 4,640,931 194,564,701 (37,022,620) (5,532,009) 193,594,826 (36,860,776) (8,330,301) 152,010,072 148,403,749 (182,139) (175,233) 363,239 1,027,092 1,710,169 1,861,737 20,197,533 359,651 1,019,177 1,710,169 1,365,793 17,412,820 25,159,770 21,867,610 2,592,890 3,985,823 2,449,477 6,034,766 6,578,713 8,484,243 3,622,164 3,622,164 192,245,363 186,843,464 182 of 212 14 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 13.Accumulated surplus (continued) us Total accumulated surplus sio Net book value of tangible capital assets Tangible capital assets financed by long-term liabilities Current surplus Unfunded employee future benefits n The accumulated surplus of the Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board (CPUSB), included above, consists of the following: 2014 2013 $ $ Restated 30,543,844 (6,868,559) 5,031,782 (182,139) 31,406,137 (7,209,215) 4,615,930 (175,233) 28,524,928 28,637,619 14. Tangible capital assets for Di sc Comparative CPUSB figures have been restated to correct revenue relating to the south-end servicing special charges that should have been recorded in the year the construction occurred. This has resulted in an increase to 2013 CPUSB opening accumulated surplus of $1,103,609, a decrease in CPUSB miscellaneous revenue of $81,661 and a decrease in CPUSB accounts payable to the Town of Collingwood of $1,021,948. These entries are eliminated on consolidation and as a result have no effect on the Town of Collingwood's balances. aft Schedules 1, 2 and 3 provide information on the tangible capital assets of the Municipality by major asset class and service segment, as well as for accumulated amortization of the assets controlled. The reader should be aware of the following information relating to tangible capital assets. Dr (a) Work in progress Work in progress with a value of $4,637,344 (2013 - $4,786,158) has not been amortized. Amortization of these assets will commence when the asset is put into service. (b) Contributed tangible capital assets Contributed tangible capital assets have been recognized at fair market value at the date of contribution. The value of contributed assets received during the year is $53,201 (2013 - $241,484). (c) Tangible capital assets disclosed at nominal values Where an estimate of fair value could not be made, the tangible capital asset was recognized at a nominal value. Land is the only category where nominal values were assigned. (d) Works of art and historical treasures The Library Board owns two special book collections. Due to their historical or valuable nature, they are not included in the Library's regular collection for circulation to the public. As such, these collections are also not included in tangible capital assets. (e) Schedule 2 and 3 Due to transfers between departments in 2014, opening balances on Schedule 2 may not agree to closing balances on Schedule 3. 183 of 212 15 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 15. Employee future benefits (a) Pension agreement sc us sio n The employees of the Corporation of the Town of Collingwood participate in the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement Savings Plan ("OMERS"). Although the plan has a defined retirement benefit for employees, the related obligation of the Municipality cannot be identified. The Municipality has applied defined contribution plan accounting as it has insufficient information to apply defined benefit plan accounting. The OMERS plan has several unrelated participating municipalities and costs are not specifically attributed to each participant. Amounts paid to OMERS during the year totaled $1,217,820 (2013 -$1,128,485). OMERS is a multi-employer plan, therefore any pension plan surpluses or deficits are a joint responsibility of Ontario municipal organizations and their employees. The most recent actuarial valuation of the Plan was conducted at December 31, 2014. The results of this valuation disclosed total actuarial liabilities of $77.2 (2013- $73.2) billion in respect of benefits accrued for service with actuarial assets at that date of $70.2 (2013 - $64.4) billion, indicating an actuarial deficit of $7.0 (2013 - $8.8) billion. (b) Workplace safety and insurance aft (c) Post-retirement benefits for Di In common with other Schedule 2 employers, the Municipality funds its obligations to the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board ("WSIB") on a "pay-as-you-go" basis. December 31, 2004 was the first period for which a WSIB accrued benefit was required to be reported. At December 31, 2014, the Municipality's accrued benefit liability related to future payments on WSIB is based on the 2004 WSIB calculation. The amount of the accrual is $NIL for both 2014 and 2013. No independent actuarial valuation is considered necessary. Dr The Town of Collingwood pays certain post-retirement benefits on behalf of its retired employees for extended health and dental benefits. The Municipality recognizes these post-retirement costs in the period in which the employees rendered the services. The accrued benefit obligation at December 31, 2014 is based on actuarial reports dated March 28, 2013 for the Municipality's employees and a separate report with the same date for the Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board employees. Actuarial valuations will be prepared every third year or when there are significant changes to the workforce. The current year expense is included in departmental expenses on a basis proportionate to the wages of the department. 184 of 212 16 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 15.Employee future benefits (continued) Information about the Municipality's defined post-retirement benefit plan is as follows: 2014 sio n Accrued plan liability, beginning of year Current service cost Interest cost Past service cost Actuarial gain Benefits paid for the year us Accrued plan liability, end of year Unrecognized gain Unrecognized past service cost $ 1,140,152 62,916 40,756 2,836 (15,074) (57,937) 1,209,231 (139,235) 8,507 1,173,649 (154,308) 11,343 1,078,503 1,030,684 2014 2013 Di The accrued plan liability consists of: $ 1,173,649 65,433 42,639 2,836 (15,074) (60,252) sc Accrued benefit obligation, end of year 2013 $ 1,027,092 182,139 $ 998,416 175,233 Total employee future benefits 1,209,231 1,173,649 aft for Town Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board The main actuarial assumptions employed for the valuations were as follows: Dr (i) General inflation Future general inflation levels, as measured by changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI), were assumed at 2.0% in 2012 and thereafter. (ii) Interest (discount) rate The obligation as at December 31, 2014, of the present value of future liabilities and the expense was determined using an annual discount rate of 4.0% (2013 - 4.0%). (iii) Health care costs Health care costs are to increase 6.94% in 2014 graded down 0.53% a year until 2017 after which the rate is assumed to increase 4.8% annually. (iv) Dental costs Dental costs were assumed to increase at 4.80% in 2012 and thereafter. 185 of 212 17 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 16. Net municipal taxation Net municipal taxation consists of: 2014 Taxation revenue Amount levied and remitted to School Boards Amount levied and remitted to the County of Simcoe $ 50,153,029 (11,823,578) (10,876,636) $ 48,102,602 (11,669,119) (10,524,205) 27,452,815 25,909,278 2014 2013 n Net municipal taxation 2013 sio 17. Other revenues sc us Other revenues consist of the following: $ 762,159 891,896 98,611 51,207 183,500 662,922 649,519 $ 688,331 1,384,705 46,532 25,462 638,272 501,882 3,299,814 3,285,184 Dr 18.Comparative figures aft for Di Licences and permits Facility rentals Fines Donations Dividends from portfolio investment Miscellaneous Miscellaneous - Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board Certain comparative figures have been reclassified to conform with the current year's consolidated financial statement presentation. 19. Budget amounts The operating budget approved by Council for 2014 is reflected on the consolidated statement of operations. The budgets established for investment in tangible capital assets are on a project oriented basis, the costs of which may be carried out over one or more years and, therefore, may not be comparable with the current year’s actual expenditure amounts. Budget figures have been reclassified for the purposes of these financial statements to comply with PSAB reporting requirements. The budget figures have not been audited. 186 of 212 18 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 20. General area taxation surplus reconciliation sio us sc Di Annual (deficit) surplus Net transfers from (to) reserves Net transfers from (to) discretionary reserve funds Capital acquisitions and disposals Amortization Proceeds from long-term liabilities issued Long-term liabilities principal repayments Change in unfunded liabilities Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board closing operating surplus n A reconciliation between annual surplus as transferred to reserves and general area taxation surplus as per the consolidated financial statements is reflected below. The need for this is generated by the actual recorded results complying with PSAB reporting requirements. aft for Subtotal Capital projects not funded Prior year Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board operating surplus Prior year current fund surplus Actual 2013 $ $ 5,401,899 (3,292,160) (2,661,494) 8,888,888 1,905,530 (7,403,340) 9,167,184 3,300,000 (3,138,156) 6,906 (888,079) (5,287,153) 8,573,100 2,252,000 (3,863,581) 6,702 (5,031,782) (4,615,930) 916,081 (5,532,011) 2,404,453 (5,509,347) 4,615,930 25,001 3,104,894 25,001 25,001 25,001 Dr General area taxation surplus Actual 2014 187 of 212 19 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2014 21. Future accounting pronouncements The PSAB has issued PS 3260, Liability for Contaminated Sites, which establishes recognition, measurement and disclosure standards for liabilities relating to contaminated sites. The section is effective for governments for fiscal years beginning on or after April 1, 2014; the Municipality is required to adopt this section for its fiscal year beginning January 1, 2015. Earlier adoption is permitted. sio n The PSAB has issued Section PS 3450, "Financial Instruments", which establishes recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure standards relating to financial instruments such as receivables, payables, and equity instruments. The section is effective for governments for fiscal years beginning on or after April 1, 2015; the Municipality is required to adopt this section for its fiscal year beginning January 1, 2016. Earlier adoption is allowed. The new standard is not expected to have a material effect on the consolidated financial statements. sc us The PSAB issued Section PS 3041, "Portfolio Investments", which replaces Section PS 3040. The new section establishes recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure standards relating to investments in organizations that do not form part of the government reporting entity. This section must be implemented upon the adoption of Section PS 3450. aft 22. Subsequent event for Di The PSAB issued Section PS 1201, "Financial Statement Presentation", which replaces Section 1200. The new section establishes reporting principles and standards for the disclosure of information in government financial statements. This section establishes the requirement of the Municipality's financial statements to include a statement of financial position, statement of operations, a statement of remeasurement gains and losses, a statement of change in net debt and a statement of cash flow. This section must be implemented upon the adoption of Section PS 3450. Dr On June 22, 2015 Council of the Town of Collingwood voted in favour of dissolving the Collingwood Public Utilities Service Board. 188 of 212 20 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SCHEDULE 1 CONSOLIDATED SCHEDULE OF TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31 Land Land Improvements Buildings Machinery and Equipment Vehicles Linear Assets 2014 Total 2013 Total $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ Cost Balance, beginning of year Additions Disposals Transferred (to) from held for sale 23,211,970 (317,745) - 17,231,473 1,296,836 (95,904) - 58,219,752 2,017,923 - 20,784,471 495,715 (205,233) - 9,316,842 452,392 (358,745) - 167,846,193 6,454,299 (1,264,089) - 296,610,701 10,717,165 (2,241,716) - 292,159,315 15,695,746 (12,764,557) 1,520,197 Balance, end of year 22,894,225 18,432,405 60,237,675 21,074,953 9,410,489 173,036,403 305,086,150 296,610,701 11,904,607 1,174,416 (205,233) - 5,366,778 772,477 (351,026) - 63,716,669 4,512,858 (1,009,446) - 103,015,875 9,167,183 (1,661,609) - 12,873,790 5,788,229 67,220,081 110,521,449 103,015,875 43,515,713 8,201,163 3,622,260 105,816,322 194,564,701 193,594,826 504,256 41,093 - 4,091,995 4,637,344 4,786,158 Accumulated amortization Balance, beginning of year Amortization Disposals Transferred (to) from held for sale - 7,232,981 780,310 (95,904) - 14,794,840 1,927,122 - Balance, end of year - 7,917,387 16,721,962 22,894,225 10,515,018 Net book value, end of year Work in progress included in cost r o tf - - i D s u sc n o si 96,490,633 8,573,100 (2,905,807) 857,949 f a r D The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 189 of 212 21 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SCHEDULE 2 CONSOLIDATED SCHEDULE OF SEGMENTED TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2014 General Government $ Fire Other Protective Transportation $ $ $ Environmental Recreation and Cultural Planning and Development Total $ $ $ $ Cost Balance, beginning of year Additions Disposals Transferred from held for sale 15,610,708 456,558 (444,523) - 8,742,468 38,160 (17,328) - 5,662,483 42,029 - 90,402,242 4,603,933 (358,051) - 128,753,366 2,892,987 (1,199,198) - 47,293,146 2,674,090 (222,616) - 146,288 9,408 - 296,610,701 10,717,165 (2,241,716) - Balance, end of year 15,622,743 8,763,300 5,704,512 94,648,124 130,447,155 49,744,620 155,696 305,086,150 Accumulated amortization Balance, beginning of year Amortization Disposals Transferred from held for sale 1,860,067 240,681 (126,778) - 1,368,586 450,655 (17,328) - 681,402 39,506 - Balance, end of year 1,973,970 1,801,913 720,908 13,648,773 6,961,387 4,983,604 41,093 - 100,711 Net book value, end of year Work in progress included in cost t f ra 53,052,565 3,559,088 (944,556) - 11,617,755 2,006,901 (222,615) - 59,189 14,564 - 103,015,875 9,167,183 (1,661,609) - 36,881,767 55,667,097 13,402,041 73,753 110,521,449 57,766,357 74,780,058 36,342,579 81,943 194,564,701 3,165,439 1,330,101 - - 4,637,344 s s u c s i D r fo n o i 34,376,311 2,855,788 (350,332) - D The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 190 of 212 22 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SCHEDULE 3 CONSOLIDATED SCHEDULE OF SEGMENTED TANGIBLE CAPITAL ASSETS FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2013 General Government $ Fire Other Protective Transportation $ $ $ Environmental Recreation and Cultural Planning and Development Total $ $ $ $ Cost Balance, beginning of year Additions Disposals Transferred to held for sale 15,430,435 217,956 (1,067,830) 1,513,422 6,543,157 3,128,210 (24,735) - 4,665,035 100,711 (7,425) - 98,693,451 1,332,610 (9,630,593) 6,775 127,519,113 2,005,937 (707,566) - 39,165,795 8,898,263 (1,318,308) - 142,329 12,059 (8,100) - 292,159,315 15,695,746 (12,764,557) 1,520,197 Balance, end of year 16,093,983 9,646,632 4,758,321 90,402,243 128,817,484 46,745,750 146,288 296,610,701 Accumulated amortization Balance, beginning of year Amortization Disposals Transferred to held for sale Balance, end of year Net book value, end of year Work in progress included in cost 882,317 258,434 (202,756) 857,949 1,549,118 352,188 (24,736) - 139,960 40,884 (7,425) - 1,795,944 1,876,570 173,419 14,298,039 7,770,062 4,584,902 41,093 - 100,711 t f ra 32,691,279 2,844,318 (1,159,282) - 50,320,835 3,481,415 (685,567) - 10,853,861 1,581,835 (817,941) - 53,263 14,026 (8,100) - 34,376,315 53,116,683 11,617,755 59,189 103,015,875 56,025,928 75,700,801 35,127,995 87,099 193,594,826 3,110,174 1,454,277 79,903 - 4,786,158 s s u c s i D r fo n o i 96,490,633 8,573,100 (2,905,807) 857,949 D The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 191 of 212 23 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SCHEDULE 4 CONSOLIDATED SCHEDULE OF SEGMENTED REVENUES AND EXPENSES ACTUAL FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2014 Revenues Net municipal taxation Payments in lieu of taxation User charges Government transfers Other municipalities Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Investment Penalties and interest on taxes Other Expenses Salaries, wages and employee benefits Interest on long-term liabilities Materials and supplies Contracted services Rents, financial expenses and external transfers Amortization Net revenues (expenses) Other Grants and transfers related to capital Government transfers Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Contributed tangible capital assets Other Gain (loss) on disposal of tangible capital assets Annual surplus (deficit) General Government Police Fire Other Protective Transportation Environmental Recreation and Cultural Planning and Development Other and Unallocated Total $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 4,953,075 25,580 445,364 - 5,958,960 30,774 99,882 6,500 4,344,583 22,437 - 985,290 5,088 10,175 159,116 5,014,786 25,899 1,277,647 355,892 125,137 147,689 505,119 602,738 523,196 22,040 27,082 23,555 605,748 422,886 7,202,761 6,145,238 4,390,575 1,765,417 5,016,553 25,907 900,417 153,351 48,851 1,099,620 5,679 138,209 172,813 74,034 79,948 413 - 27,452,815 141,777 15,813,160 812,316 840,637 s u sc 40,314 753,093 77,717 698,734 10,720 103,078 142,442 258,166 545,433 602,738 3,299,814 14,292,132 6,921,530 1,604,153 222,803 49,766,856 2,689,708 540,908 1,458,567 174,373 159,690 5,727,855 3,526,384 17,759 173,372 37,103 733,406 232,372 109,161 1,418 1,929,009 215,645 2,080,988 1,293,673 3,251,861 633,493 4,877,175 411,345 3,763,496 2,810,909 132,419 951,693 28,982 849,537 - 59,449 - 16,845,557 1,669,159 12,578,848 7,778,186 57,732 240,681 4,569 23,524 155,735 450,655 242,481 15,982 653,999 2,855,788 93,274 3,559,087 23,666 2,006,902 2,776 14,564 189,091 - 1,423,323 9,167,183 5,161,969 5,915,638 4,361,008 1,334,820 9,029,102 12,826,235 8,737,392 1,847,552 248,540 49,462,256 2,040,792 229,600 29,567 430,597 (1,806,855) 1,465,897 (1,815,862) 69,125 - - - 1,669,003 - 60,000 - - 1,798,128 - - - - 1,009,199 1,395,284 53,201 35,345 531,538 504,001 - 14,358 1,540,737 53,201 1,948,988 (255,325) - - - 11,570 - - - - (186,200) - - - 4,085,056 88,546 1,095,539 - 14,358 5,097,299 229,600 29,567 430,597 2,278,201 1,554,443 (11,379) 5,401,899 1,854,592 f a r r o tf D i D 7,222,247 13,041,348 30,378 426,999 n o si The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements (720,323) (243,399) (243,399) (25,737) 304,600 (243,755) 192 of 212 24 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SCHEDULE 5 CONSOLIDATED SCHEDULE OF SEGMENTED REVENUES AND EXPENSES ACTUAL FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2013 Revenues Net municipal taxation Payments in lieu of taxation User charges Government transfers Other municipalities Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Investment Penalties and interest on taxes Other Expenses Salaries, wages and employee benefits Interest on long-term liabilities Materials and supplies Contracted services Rents, financial expenses and external transfers Amortization Net revenues (expenses) Other Grants and transfers related to capital Government transfers Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Contributed tangible capital assets Other Gain (loss) on disposal of tangible capital assets Annual surplus (deficit) General Government Police Fire Other Protective Transportation Environmental Recreation and Cultural Planning and Development Other and Unallocated Total $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 4,202,369 23,483 428,160 30,847 - 5,877,282 30,618 65,347 6,500 4,064,567 21,175 1,815 - 1,099,694 5,729 9,400 164,938 4,719,274 24,585 1,379,979 36,136 94,156 13,200,107 42,464 472,962 4,728,395 24,633 615,023 125,190 30,067 1,136,580 5,921 373,863 99,445 7,500 81,117 423 - 25,909,278 136,567 16,008,347 399,429 776,123 49,089 295,370 563,010 513,571 6,105,899 24,237 6,003,984 19,130 4,106,687 21,679 552,241 1,853,681 203,375 515,294 6,972,799 81,886 25,002 743,945 14,566,366 753,174 6,276,482 17,150 1,640,459 146,442 227,982 356,029 320,372 563,010 3,285,184 47,754,339 2,355,236 580,256 1,530,029 3,698 1,490 93,465 5,359,755 3,340,908 289,843 35,500 620,920 250,793 157,589 153 1,904,037 235,924 2,037,754 1,175,354 3,364,386 656,088 4,603,575 532,193 3,358,307 1,932 2,566,286 23,931 843,522 28,468 730,335 - 59,931 - 15,788,806 1,753,461 12,068,807 7,130,584 23,909 258,436 3,201 23,490 5,651 352,188 643,111 2,844,318 90,751 3,481,414 38,789 1,581,834 3,923 14,026 185,963 - 1,230,494 8,573,100 4,751,564 1,354,335 5,481,401 522,583 4,024,090 82,597 8,840,498 (1,867,699) 12,728,407 1,837,959 7,571,079 (1,294,597) 245,894 (17,912) 46,545,252 1,209,087 - - 9,981 - 1,000,000 - - - - 1,009,981 - - 1,539,064 - 136,241 438,816 1,906,126 - - 4,020,247 93,476 57,831 - - - 137,295 94,611 10,713 54,200 185,667 - - 241,484 392,309 95,479 246,786 - 1,549,045 - (8,947,637) (7,579,490) (22,000) 481,729 (660,444) 1,431,349 - - 1,601,121 522,583 1,631,642 571,636 (9,447,189) f a r r o tf D s u sc i D 235,196 17,394 1,282,045 571,636 n o si 2,319,688 The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements 136,752 1,620,274 20,185 20,185 (17,912) (9,534,602) (3,870,581) (2,661,494) 193 of 212 25 CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD SCHEDULE 6 CONSOLIDATED SCHEDULE OF SEGMENTED REVENUES AND EXPENSES BUDGET FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2014 Revenues Net municipal taxation Payments in lieu of taxation User charges Government transfers Other municipalities Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Investment Penalties and interest on taxes Other Expenses Salaries, wages and employee benefits Interest on long-term liabilities Materials and supplies Contracted services Rents, financial expenses and external transfers Amortization Net revenues (expenses) Other Grants and transfers related to capital Government transfers Contributions from obligatory reserve funds Contributed tangible capital assets Other Gain (loss) on disposal of tangible capital assets Annual surplus (deficit) General Government Police Fire Other Protective Transportation Environmental Recreation and Cultural Planning and Development Other and Unallocated Total $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 4,987,628 21,266 407,625 - 6,000,530 25,585 90,898 6,500 4,374,891 18,654 - 992,163 4,230 8,700 130,000 5,049,768 21,532 1,530,890 78,600 101,000 235,000 300,000 480,000 412,800 18,800 10,500 10,000 543,500 260,000 345,214 6,844,319 6,142,313 4,404,045 1,688,593 2,680,971 548,462 2,000,875 217,131 167,590 6,094,213 3,476,148 138,755 361,267 41,000 763,466 233,344 157,126 25,000 24,000 240,680 23,525 15,900 450,655 5,712,119 6,285,328 1,132,200 (143,015) f a r D 4,483,725 (79,680) 5,051,548 21,539 564,910 71,649 22,000 1,107,291 4,721 139,200 138,900 57,500 80,506 343 - 27,644,325 117,870 15,237,144 528,128 629,664 6,000 806,547 27,000 836,250 71,200 178,092 532,000 306,000 480,000 3,222,903 13,859,111 6,594,896 1,518,812 258,941 48,698,034 1,526,894 245,570 2,102,932 1,405,751 3,605,937 645,953 4,985,368 483,277 3,814,552 2,777,381 56,165 950,589 26,950 860,184 - 67,600 - 16,818,557 1,839,034 13,480,323 8,322,537 248,305 15,985 442,487 2,855,788 (21,671) 3,589,064 13,810 2,006,900 3,650 14,564 191,200 - 917,681 9,197,161 1,443,226 8,579,422 8,668,808 1,855,937 258,800 50,575,293 r o tf n o si s u sc i D 245,367 12,585,819 148,081 312,664 7,387,004 (1,192,418) 13,287,928 571,183 (2,073,912) (337,125) 141 (1,877,259) 73,500 - - - 2,208,835 - - - - 2,282,335 - 194,000 - - - 949,381 32,000 31,500 45,000 541,800 530,000 - - 1,716,681 607,000 - - - - - - - - - - 73,500 194,000 - - 3,190,216 76,500 1,071,800 - - 4,606,016 1,205,700 50,985 245,367 1,997,798 647,683 (1,002,112) 141 2,728,757 (79,680) The accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements (337,125) 194 of 212 26 STAFF REPORT PRC2015-28-C Reviewed by Community Services Standing Committee on October 08, 2015 Recommendation: Report move forward to Council Date: November 2, 2015 Submitted to: Mayor and Council Submitted by: Dean Collver, Director, Parks, Recreation and Culture Subject: Updating Motorized Snow Vehicles Bylaw PURPOSE • The purpose of this report is to present changes to Bylaw 2008-164 being a Bylaw to govern the use of motorized snow vehicles within the Town of Collingwood. RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Staff Report PRC2015-29 Updating Motorized Snow Vehicles Bylaw. AND THAT Council enact and pass a by-law to amend By-law No. 2008-164, being a by-law to regulate and govern the use of motorized snow vehicles within the Town of Collingwood, to prescribe the rate of speed a snow vehicle may travel while using municipal trails not designated as official OFSC trails to a maximum 20 km/hr, and to amend Schedule B to reflect changes to the permitted municipal trail locations described herein. 1. BACKGROUND The Town of Collingwood works collaboratively with the Ontario Federation of Snowmobile Clubs (OFSC) to provide snow vehicle opportunities in our region. The OFSC route 703 and 704 travels through Collingwood by the Train trail at Poplar Side road and High Street through to the Black Ash trail. Where snow vehicles are permitted to travel on a municipal trail that is not designated as an official OFSC trail, the locations must be specified in a bylaw. Where snow vehicles are not permitted to travel on a municipal road, highway or sidewalk these locations must also be specified in a bylaw. The speed at which snow vehicles are allowed to travel is governed by the Motorized Snow Vehicle Act, R.S.O. 1990, cM44 but this is only applicable to roads regulated by the Highway -1- 195 of 212 Traffic Act. To regulate the speed of snow vehicles on municipal trails that are not a designated OFSC trail, they must be specified in a bylaw. 2. INPUT FROM OTHER SOURCES Collingwood OPP Ontario Federation of Snowmobile Clubs (OFSC) Collingwood Trails Network Public Works and Engineering Department Department Heads reviewed this report at their regular meeting on October 6, 2015 and the report was recommended to proceed to the Community Services Standing Committee meeting. 3. APPLICABLE POLICY OR LEGISLATION • 4. ANALYSIS Reviewing Schedule A of Bylaw 2008-164: Motorized Snow Vehicles on Highways: Respecting the Prohibited Operation of The Engineering Department has reviewed Schedule A and have not recommended any changes. Reviewing Schedule B of Bylaw 2008-164: Permitted Municipal Trail Locations: The Parks, Recreation and Culture Department have discussed with the Collingwood OPP, Trails committee members and the OFSC and recommend the following revisions to Schedule B: Trail Name Train Trail Train Trail From and To Points Warrington Road (Stayner) to the junction of Center Line Road to cross over Poplar Sideroad to Train Trail Link. Continue west to the Hamilton Drain Trail and continue southward and crossing Poplar Sideroad into Clearview Township. Continue trail and cross Poplar Sideroad west of Saunders Road. Travel on north side of Poplar Sideroad to High Street along marked snowmobile trail. Ontario Street to Train Trail Link Hamilton Drain Trail Highway 124 east to Poplar Sideroad Connection. High Street Trail Poplar Sideroad to Campbell Street along marked snowmobile trail. South end of Black Ash Trail to the Georgian Trail bridge along marked snowmobile trail. Black Ash Trail -2- Notes Regular Groomed Trail Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Regular Groomed Trail Regular Groomed Trail 196 of 212 Black Ash Trail From the Georgian Trail bridge along Balsam Street to Old Mountain Road. Harbourview Trail Cross Highway 26 to the Harbourview Trail to the Birch Street Trail northward to the parking lot along marked snowmobile trail. From the junction of the Black Ash Trail along the south side of Mountain Road to Mair Mills Mountain Road Trail Taylors Creek Trail Tenth Line Trail From the junction of the Black Ash trail, west along Taylors Creek, along east side (road allowance) of Tenth Line to cross at Blue Mountain Golf Course along marked snowmobile trail. Blue Mountain Golf Course west to Grey Road 19 along marked snowmobile trail north side of Sixth Street. Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Regular Groomed Trail Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Regular Groomed Trail Regular Groomed Trail Two major changes to Schedule B will greatly improve the safety for the snow vehicles and road vehicles: (1) The Train Trail at Poplar Sideroad: instead of traveling west along the road surface and over the narrow road bridge the snow vehicles can now travel north across Poplar Sideroad, along the Train Trail, over the Pretty River train bridge and follow the trail into Clearview. (photo 6 in Appendix B)This avoids having the snow vehicles share the road with cars and trucks over the narrow road bridge. (2) Harbourview Trail: instead of traveling the north side of the Black Ash Trail to Balsam Street and then travel on the narrow sidewalk of the Black Ash road bridge, the snow vehicles may now cross the Black Ash Creek using the Georgian Trail Bridge behind the Canadian Tire store. (photo 5 in Appendix B). The Georgian Trail Board of Management has approved this use. Reviewing snow vehicle speed on municipal roads and trails: The Motorized Snow Vehicle Act, R.S.O. 1990, cM44 sets the speed limit for snow vehicles traveling on roads, highways and official OFSC trails: Speed limit 14. (1) No person shall drive a motorized snow vehicle at a greater rate of speed than, (a) 20 kilometres per hour, (i) on a highway where the speed limit established pursuant to the Highway Traffic Act is 50 kilometres per hour or less, or (ii) in any public park or exhibition grounds; or (b) 50 kilometres per hour, (i) on any highway which is open to motor vehicle traffic, where the speed limit established pursuant to the Highway Traffic Act is greater than 50 kilometres per hour, or (ii) on a trail. R.S.O. 1990, c. M.44, s. 14 (1). Municipality may prescribe different rate of speed (2) The council of a municipality may by by-law prescribe, (a) a lower rate of speed for motorized snow vehicles upon any highway or part thereof under its jurisdiction; and (b) a higher or lower rate of speed for motorized snow vehicles upon a trail, public park or exhibition ground under its jurisdiction, -3- 197 of 212 than is prescribed in subsection (1). R.S.O. 1990, c. M.44, s. 14 (2). For roads posted less than and equal to 50 km/hr the speed limit for snow vehicles is 20 km/hr. For roads posted greater than 50 km/hr the speed limit for snow vehicles is 50 km/hr. Staff recommend the speed for snow vehicles on municipal trails be a maximum 20 km/hr where these trails are not a part of the OFSC 703 and 704 trail network. The Town will work with the OFSC to determine best locations for signage. 5. EFFECT ON TOWN FINANCES • There is no effect on town finances 6. APPENDICES & OTHER RESOURCES Appendix A Appendix B Bylaw 2008-164 Aerial photos showing revised route SIGNATURES Prepared by: Department Head: Wendy Martin Manager of Parks Dean Collver Director of Parks, Recreation and Culture Town of Collingwood Town of Collingwood -4- 198 of 212 199 of 212 200 of 212 201 of 212 202 of 212 203 of 212 Existing bylaw 204 of 212 205 of 212 X X X X X Proposed changes 2015 X X X X 206 of 212 X X X X Proposed changes 2015 X X X X 207 of 212 Existing snowmobile route Proposed snowmobile route Bridge Georgian Trail Canadian Tire store Black Ash Trail 208 of 212 Hamilton Drain Trail Train Trail Previous snowmobile route Proposed snowmobile route 209 of 212 BY-LAW No. 2015-095 OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD BEING A BY-LAW TO AMEND THE PERMITTED MUNICIPAL TRAIL LOCATIONS AND SPEED LIMITS FOR MOTORIZED SNOW VEHICLES WITHIN THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD WHEREAS it is deemed expedient in the interest of public safety to regulate and govern the use of motorized snow vehicles in the Town of Collingwood; AND WHEREAS Subsection 7(2) of the Motorized Snow Vehicles Act, R.S.O. 1990, c.M.44, as amended, (the Act) provides that a municipality may pass by-laws regulating, governing or prohibiting the operation of motorized snow vehicles within the municipality including any highways therein or any part or parts thereof. AND WHEREAS Subsection 14(2)(b) of the Act, provides that a municipality may by by-law prescribe a higher or lower rate of speed for motorized snow vehicles upon a trail, public park or exhibition ground under its jurisdiction, than is prescribed in subsection 14(1); AND WHEREAS By-law No. 2008-164, being a by-law to regulate and govern the use of motorized snow vehicles within the Town of Collingwood was passed and enacted by Council of the Town of Collingwood on December 8, 2008; AND WHEREAS the Trails Advisory Committee deems it advisable to amend the permitted municipal trail locations for motorized snow vehicles and apply a maximum speed limit when traveling on a municipal trail; NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. THAT Schedule “B” of By-law No. 2008-164, as amended be deleted and replaced with the following: PERMITTED MUNICIPAL TRAIL LOCATIONS Trail Name Train Trail Train Trail From and To Points Warrington Road (Stayner) to the junction of Center Line Road to cross over Poplar Sideroad to Train Trail Link. Continue west to the Hamilton Drain Trail and continue southward and crossing Poplar Sideroad into Clearview Township. Continue trail and cross Poplar Sideroad west of Saunders Road. Travel on north side of Poplar Sideroad to High Street along marked snowmobile trail. Ontario Street to Train Trail Link BL2015-094 Amend Snowmobile Trail Locations/Speed Limits Page 1 of 2 Notes Regular Groomed Trail Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) 210 of 212 Hamilton Drain Trail Highway 124 east to Poplar Sideroad Connection. High Street Trail Poplar Sideroad to Campbell Street along marked snowmobile trail South end of Black Ash Trail to the Georgian Trail bridge along marked snowmobile trail. From the Georgian Trail bridge along Balsam Street to Old Mountain Road Black Ash Trail Black Ash Trail Harbourview Trail Mountain Road Trail Taylors Creek Trail Tenth Line Trail Cross Highway 26 to the Harbourview Trail to the Birch Street Trail northward to the parking lot along marked snowmobile trail From the junction of the Black Ash Trail along the south side of Mountain Road to Mair Mills From the junction of the Black Ash trail, west along Taylors Creek, along east side (road allowance) of Tenth Line to cross at Blue Mountain Golf Course along marked snowmobile trail Blue Mountain Golf Course west to Grey Road 19 along marked snowmobile trail north side of Sixth Street Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Regular Groomed Trail Regular Groomed Trail Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Regular Groomed Trail Non Groomed (Residential access/egress only) Regular Groomed Trail Regular Groomed Trail 2. THAT Section 2 – General Provisions of By-law No. 2008-164 be hereby amended to include the following: “The maximum speed limit a motorized snow vehicle may be operated when on a municipal trail designated under Schedule “B” of this By-law and not forming part of the OFSC Trail Network, shall be 20 kilometres per hour.” 3. THAT By-law No. 2010-143 be hereby repealed. 4. THAT this By-law shall come into full force and effect on the date of final passage hereof at which time all By-laws and/or resolutions that are inconsistent with the provisions of this Bylaw and the same are hereby repealed or rescinded insofar as it is necessary to give effect to the provisions of this By-law. 5. ENACTED AND PASSED this 19th day of October, 2015. ____________________________ MAYOR ____________________________ CLERK BL2015-095 Amend Snowmobile Trail Locations/Speed Limits Page 2 of 2 211 of 212 BY-LAW No. 2015-096 OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD BEING A BY-LAW TO CONFIRM THE PROCEEDINGS OF COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD WHEREAS the Municipal Act 2001, S.O. 2001, c 25, Section 5(1), provides that the powers of a municipality shall be exercised by its council; AND WHEREAS the Municipal Act 2001, S.O. 2001, c 25, Section 5(3), provides a municipal power, including a municipality's capacity, rights, powers and privileges under section 9, shall be exercised by by-law unless the municipality is specifically authorized to do otherwise; AND WHEREAS it is deemed expedient that the actions of all meetings of Council of The Corporation of the Town of Collingwood be confirmed and adopted by by-law; NOW THEREFORE COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COLLINGWOOD ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. THAT the actions of the Council of The Corporation of the Town of Collingwood in respect of: a) each recommendation in the reports of the Committees; b) each motion, resolution or other action passed, taken or adopted at the meetings listed below are hereby adopted, ratified, and confirmed as if same were expressly included in this by-law, provided that such adoption and confirmation shall not be deemed to include the final passing of a by-law the requires the prior approval of a Minister, a Ministry, to the Ontario Municipal Board or any other governmental body: Regular Meeting of Council held November 2, 2015 2. THAT the Mayor and the proper officials of The Corporation of the Town of Collingwood are hereby authorized and directed to do all things necessary to give effect to the action of the Council referred to in Section 1. 3. THAT the Mayor, or in the absence of the Mayor, the Deputy Mayor, and the Clerk, or in the absence of the Clerk, the Chief Administrative Officer; a) are authorized and directed to execute all documents to the action taken by Council as described in Section 1; b) are authorized and directed to affix the seal of The Corporation of the Town of Collingwood to all such documents referred to in Section 1. 4. THAT this by-law shall come into effect upon the passing thereof. ENACTED AND PASSED this 2nd day of November, 2015. _________________________ MAYOR _________________________ CLERK BL 2015-096 Confirmatory 212 of 212