Session 1
Transcription
Session 1
Mentorship for Healthcare Professionals Session 1 1 Roles and responsibilities of a mentor By the end of the session you will be able to critically analyse : The role and responsibilities of the mentor in relation to the 8 NMC Domains (NMC 2008) The complexities of the mentorship role. The role and responsibilities of the sign-off mentor 2 Course Structure 6 study days 3 face to face days (in classroom) 3 online learning Credit bearing and Non credit bearing course (see Frequently Asked Questions page in the Module Study Guide) 3 Writing Support • Self study material to help with your assignments, click on to ‘Writingdevelopment’ on Blackboard. • 30-minute 1:1 Tutorials To book an appointment at Paragon on Thursday afternoons or at Fountain House on Wednesdays between 11am-5pm, please e-mail Christine Powell at christine.powell@uwl.ac.uk 4 Blackboard 5 Assessment To be placed on the mentor register you will need to demonstrate that you meet all 8 NMC Domains in Standards to Support Learning and Assessment in Practice (SLAiP 2008). To qualify for 20 academic credits at level 6 / 7, you must demonstrate achievement of the course learning outcomes Course Assessment: 1. 2. 3. Workbook (all students) Reflective essay (Level 6) Develop an Innovative Learning Resource. Oral presentation . Submit the PowerPoint Presentation together with the Annotated Bibliography (Level 7) Workbook • All students will gather evidence throughout the course demonstrating achievement of the NMC Standards • Activities which relate to real learners in you practice area must be verified by a ‘live’ mentor (which means the Mentor has had at least 3 students in the last 2 years, has had an update within the last 12months and a triennial review) You must pass the Workbook in order to mentor students 7 Workbook To Pass the Workbook: 1. You must read the Module Study Guide on Blackboard 2. Read the Workbook Feedback Rubric on Blackboard 3. Please read each section of the Workbook carefully. 4. All sections of the Workbook must be completed in order to Pass. 5. The Workbook must be submitted electronically through Turnitin 8 Level 6 - Reflective Essay 2000 words reflective essay Critical analysis of your mentorship learning experience of the virtual student (Chris). The reflective essay must be submitted electronically through Turnitin 9 Level 6 - Reflective Essay Introduction Include an outline of the key points for discussion in the essay. The key points should be in the order they will be discussed. 10 Level 6 - Reflective Essay cont.. Main Body Your critical analysis on the mentorship of the virtual student (Chris) should include the following: -Your role as an effective role model and which skills you adopted throughout the mentorship of the virtual student. -Planned learning activities such initial, mid-point and final interview processes (follow the same format in your Workbook) 11 Level 6 - Reflective Essay cont.. Main Body -Factors which influenced how you helped the virtual student integrate into practice e.g. orientation. -How you developed your mentoring relationship with the virtual student. -How did you identified learning needs appropriate for the virtual student’s stage of learning with reference to learning styles e.g. Honey and Mumford, practice assessment document and ongoing achievement record. 12 Level 6 - Reflective Essay cont.. Main Body -Your role as an advocate in supporting the virtual student in accessing appropriate learning opportunities with other professionals, patients, clients and carers. -The effectiveness of the use of various coaching styles e.g. ‘Joint Experimentation (Schon’s Model). -The component and the essential principles that were used to underpin the assessment e.g. validity. 13 Level 6 - Reflective Essay cont.. Main Body -How you monitored the student’s progress and provided constructive feedback. -How you managed poor performance in practice with reference to the action plan. -Factors that may influence your decisions. 14 Level 6 - Reflective Essay cont.. Main Body -Your professional accountability and how it relates to the assessment of practice. -Support mechanisms available for you as a mentor Conclusion: The conclusion should be used to summarise the main points of the essay. No new information should be introduced. 15 Level 7 – Innovative Learning Resource Development of an innovative learning resource for your practice setting and accompanying presentation. The learning resource should offer students or mentors new insights into their chosen discipline. The resource must cover at least one of the NMC (2008) 8 domains. 16 The resource must cover at least one of the NMC domains: Domain 1 Establish effective working relationships Domain 2 Facilitation of learning Domain 3 Assessment and accountability Domain 4 Evaluation of learning A resource which helps students to integrate into your practice area. A resource which helps mentors to assess and facilitate students’ learning styles. A tool which helps students review their own performance and identify further learning needs. A tool to help students evaluate your performance as a mentor. Domain 5 Create an environment for learning Domain 6 Context of practice Domain 7 Evidence-based practice Domain 8 Leadership A resource which indicates how an aspect of the learning environment in your area of practice could be further enhanced to meet students’ needs. A resource which assists students in your area to develop appropriate professional attitudes. A resource which helps A planned pathway which students to link evidence students can undertake based theory with an aspect with members of the of practice they commonly inter-professional team in undertake in your area of your area of practice to practice. enhance students’ learning. 17 Level 7 - Presentation Brief 20 minute PowerPoint Presentation of your innovative learning resource to a panel. 18 Level 7 - Presentation Brief Presentation must include: An introduction. This should include: - A brief profile of your clinical area (maintain confidentiality), your role and responsibilities. - Who the innovative learning resource will benefit (students /mentors) - Identify which one/s of the NMC (2008) domain/s apply to your innovative learning resource. - Aims and objectives - this should be ‘Specific, Measurement, Achievable, Realistic and Timely’ (SMART). 19 Level 7 - Presentation Brief Main Content should include: - An evaluation of your learning and assessment approaches in the practice setting. This should include a SWOT analysis of your practice setting and mentoring skills. 20 Level 7 - Presentation Brief Main Content should include: - A brief overview and rationale for the development of the innovative learning resource. Critically discuss your approach to the development of the innovative learning resource. This should include steps taken to develop the learning resource (such as involvement of key stakeholders, people who would benefit from the resource and those who would implement it). 21 Level 7 - Presentation Brief Main Content should include: - Discuss the innovative learning resource with reference to learning theories and current evidence base which informs the innovative learning resource. This should include learning theories. Also, learning and coaching styles where appropriate. 22 Level 7 - Presentation Brief Main Content should include: - A critical evaluation of the challenges and competing influences you might encounter implementing your innovative learning resource. This should include factors which may prevent your innovative learning resource from being successfully implemented in your practice area. 23 Level 7 - Presentation Brief Main Content should include: Accountability issues faced when implementing the innovative learning resource 24 Level 7 - Presentation Brief The conclusion should: - Highlight the key issues in the development and implementation of your innovative learning resource in practice and include recommendations to overcome these challenges. 25 Level 7 - Presentation Brief The Appendix should include: - A draft of your innovative learning resource. - An Annotated Bibliography. - The Panel’s feedback following the presentation. Don’t forget: -References must be included in the PowerPoint presentation. -The notes section in your PowerPoint must be referenced. 26 Level 7 – Annotated Bibliography The annotated bibliography: - Is an organised list of resources cited adhering to Harvard’s Referencing System. - Should be followed by a brief descriptive and evaluative paragraph (the annotation). The following aspects should be included in the annotated bibliography: • AUTHORITY- Who wrote it? What are their credentials? (i.e. Professor) • AUDIENCE - Who are the intended audience – e.g. Students? • USEFULNESS - How useful is it to your resource ? e.g. Is it a research article? • COMPARISON - Is it similar to another work? • CONCLUSIONS - Have the author(s) made any conclusions? What methods were used for evaluation? • LIMITATIONS - Are there any limitations? 27 Sign-off Mentor To be a Sign-off Mentor you must successfully: 1. Complete an approved mentorship programme 2. Be supervised on at least 3 occasions signing off proficiencies at proficiency points and/or at the final placement. 3.Supervision must be undertaken by an existing sign-off Mentor. Only the Sign-Off Mentor can: 1. Sign the Confirmation of Proficiency at Progression Points for Midwifery students 2. Sign the Confirmation of Proficiency for Nursing Students on their Final Placement 28 (NMC 2008) What is a mentor? Definition: ‘A person who is required by a professional association to be appointed to guide a candidate through their programme of study, leading to a professional qualification .’ (Parsloe & Wray 2005) 29 What is a mentor? cont… Definition: Registrant who …. facilitates learning and supervises and assesses students in practice settings.’ (NMC 2008) 30 Role of the Mentor? Role model Facilitator Supporter Supervisor Resource person Teacher-coach Assessor 31 Leadership & Mentorship Nursing leadership must first understand the "whole picture" by recognising the close inter-relationships between leadership, mentorship, and organisational culture. As leaders in the acute and community care settings, professional nurses should ensure that mentoring is embedded in the culture within which it is to exist, such that mentoring goals and values are aligned with the organisational values. (Jill & Bally 2007) 32 Transformational Leadership 4 elements of transformational leadership: 1. Individualised Consideration – the degree to which the leader acts as a mentor or coach and listens to the individuals concerns and needs. The leader gives empathy, support and keeps communication open. 2. Intellectual Stimulation – Such leaders encourages the individual to be innovative and creative. They encourage new ideas and never criticise them publicly for the mistakes committed by them. The leaders focus on solving problems and do not focus on blame. They have no hesitation in discarding an old practice set by them if it is found ineffective. 33 Transformational Leadership 3. Inspirational Motivation – the degree to which the leader articulates a vision that is appealing and inspiring to others. Leaders with inspirational motivation, challenge individuals to leave their comfort zones, communicate optimism about future goals, and provide meaning for the task at hand. 4. Idealised Influence – the degree to which the leader acts as a role model. If the leader gives respect and encourages others to be better, those influenced will then go to others and repeat the positive behaviour, passing on the leadership qualities for other followers to learn. 34 Learning Theories 35 Theory Proponent Main Belief Behaviourist Pavlov, Skinner Repetition is important in learning, especially skills -Positive reinforcement and praise cement learning and shapes behaviour Social learning Bandura People acquire behaviours through the observation Experiential Kolb, Dewey Learning is an active process that occurs as a result of experience and reflection Humanist Rogers, Maslow, Knowles -People learn best by participation and cooperation -Atmosphere & climate of the classroom is important -The relationship with the teacher is important -Anxiety affects learning Cognitive Gagne, Brunner Cognitive theories argues that learning involves mental processes such as perception, reasoning, memory and information processes. Material should be presented in a logical sequence. Move from the simple to the complex. (Walsh 2014) Establishing effective working relationships You are a new student on a placement & you are meeting your mentor for the first time. What is the worst possible thing that could happen at this first encounter? What is the best possible thing that could happen at this first encounter? 37 The Student Students describe their first day as: Scary Frightening Terrifying Anxiety provoking And they feel uncertain how ward functions & what they are going to learn 38 Student & Mentor Relationship Levett-Jones et al (2009) in their study found staff student relationships were the most important influence on students’ sense of belonging and learning. 39 Meeting the student for the first time The first meeting between mentor and student should establish rapport How do we achieve a rapport with the student? 40 Meeting the student for the first time “befriending” your student encourages him/her to feel welcome & confident in the environment and to ask questions or reveal worries leading to increased confidence and greater likelihood of interaction with other team members and effective participation in general activities 41 It is YOUR workplace! You are familiar with the environment, routine and culture. The student is a visitor! 42 Learning Opportunities Make a list of learning opportunities available in your practice area - i.e. what experiences, resources, activities etc. are available to students that will help increase their professional competence? 43 Key characteristics - mentor/mentee relationship Patience Maturity Sense of humour Enthusiasm Assertiveness Non-threatening/nonjudgmental Positive attitude Knowledgeable Respectful of peers Flexibility Clinical expertise Advocate for learner Objectivity Professionalism Organisation 44 Learning styles People learn in different ways and may have more than one learning style (Honey & Mumford, 1988) Honey & Mumford (1988) identified 4 key learning styles: 1. Activists, 2. Theorists 3. Reflectors 4. Pragmatists.. 45 Learning Styles Why are learning styles important? Students learn better and more quickly if the teaching methods used match their preferred learning styles. As learning improves, so too does self esteem. This has a further positive effect on learning. Students who become bored with learning may become interested once again. The student-mentor relationship can improve because the student is more successful and is more interested in learning. (Sue Davidoff and Owen van den Berg 1990) http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/think/methodology/learning_style.shtml 46 Learning Styles cont.. Activists – are those people who learn by doing. They like to get ‘stuck in’ and actively involved in their learning experience. More receptive to simulation, case studies and role modeling. Reflectors – More cautious, learn by observing and thinking about their learning experience. Reflective journal help them to learn Pragmatists – “Like to try out new ideas and engage in problem solving” (Walsh 2014 page 99) Theorists – “They like to consider problems and try to understand concepts and integrate them into their thinking. They learn from logic and facts via lectures and reading” (Walsh 2014 page 99) (Walsh 2014) 47 Learning styles cont.. Visual Students may prefer a visual way of learning. - look at the teacher's face intently - like looking at wall displays, books etc. - often recognize words by sight - use lists to organize their thoughts - recall information by remembering how it was set out on a page Originates from the work of Dr's Bandler, R. and Grinder, J. in the Field of Neuro-Linguistic Programming http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/think/methodology/learning_style.shtml 48 Learning Styles cont.. Auditory Students may prefer an auditory way of learning. - like the teacher to provide verbal instructions - like dialogues, discussions and plays - solve problems by talking about them - use rhythm and sound as memory aids Originates from the work of Dr's Bandler, R. and Grinder, J. in the Field of Neuro-Linguistic Programming http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/think/methodology/learning_style.shtml 49 Learning styles cont.. Kinesthetic & Tactile Students may prefer a kinesthetic (moving) or tactile way of learning. Kinesthetic - learn best when they are involved or active - find it difficult to sit still for long periods - use movement as a memory aid Tactile - use writing and drawing as memory aids - learn well in hands-on activities like projects and demonstrations Originates from the work of Dr's Bandler, R. and Grinder, J. in the Field of Neuro-Linguistic Programming http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/think/methodology/learning_style.shtml 50 Preparing for the Orientation and the Initial Interview 51 The Initial Interview Initial interview The student’s initial interview must take place with the mentor during the first week of the placement . You will now watch a video clip. In small groups discuss the following:• What is your overall impression of the interview? • What would you do if a student behaved like this? • What skills did the mentor use to get the student on track? • Do you think it was an effective first interview? • What would you do differently? 52 What Next? 53 What next? 1. Read Chris’ On-going Achievement Record (OAR) 2. Identify 5 essential skills the student can complete in your practice area. One of these must be an essential skill that the ‘student’ has not achieved in the previous placement. 3. Complete Sections A, B, C, D in the Workbook 54 Consider How you are going to achieve the coaching and Assessment activities in your work place. If you foresee any issues with completing these talk to your group tutor. 55 References Honey, P., and Mumford, A. (1988) Setting the scene for learning styles: In Walsh, D. (2014) The Nurse Mentor’s Handbook. Supporting students in clinical practice. Berkshire. Open University, p.99. Levett-Jones, T., Lathlean, J., Higgins, I., and McMillan, M. (2009) Staff – Student relationships and their impact on nursing students’ belongingness and learning. Journal of Advanced Nursing 65 (2), p. 316 – 324. Nursing Midwifery Council (2008) Standards to support learning and assessment in practice settings. London: NMC. Parsloe, E., and Wray, M. (2005) Coaching and Mentoring: Practical Methods to Improve Learning. London: Kogan Page Limited. Walsh, D. (2014) The Nurse Mentor’s Handbook. Supporting students in clinical practice. Berkshire. Open University. 56