CrvrNG YouR oPrNroN - iblanguage2015-2016
Transcription
CrvrNG YouR oPrNroN - iblanguage2015-2016
v ly \, \. CrvrNG YouRoPrNroN \- A Argument page69 \, B Reviews page72 \- advice C Personal page76 = Readthe followingextracts(A-G),then matchthemwiththe contextstrom whichthevweretaken(1-7) tr I wasn'tat all surprisedto hearthat Mum and Dad are against the marriage.The thing is,Jutta,both of you are reallymuch too young to get married.what'sthe harm in waiting,at feast u n t i l M i k eh a sf i n i s h e dc o l l e g e A ? n d h o w d o y o u t w o p l a nt o set up home together,when neitherof you has a job? 0 couldn't a shame all this technotogy *", interesting' slightly ' make the music even Son Of Mine Although recent pieces like'No down Genesis's at least have " i""t, a trip is like being lane memory interminable charnber' where locked in a musical-aversion and guitars huff synthesiz.r, piot't aimlessly' in the face' but and bluster "ntit they're btue bearnorelationtoanythinggoingonaround rock'? them. And they ca[ed this'progressive tr E if' don'tblameYourfather knowingYourmotheris therefor him,he usesher' Rememberthat she too for musttake resPonsibilitY the Positionin whichsne findsherself.In other words,be very carefulnot to takesides' I thinkthebestthingYou can do is to urgethemboth ano to helPthemselves findhelPoutside possiblY 68 . Typesof writing No matter where in the world you go, You'll find some deranged Brit setting up a donkey-sanctuary. Isn't iCtime we tuned the dial to a better recePtion, started caring a bit more about humanity, a bit less about donkeys? We ought, as a nation, to grow up and stoP tryiry !o pretend that Peter Rabbit is itill our best friend. In the greater scheme of things, [tre worst of humanitY is worth considerabiY more than the best of bunnies. tr E ,n.r. are three different ways of buying a from, a dealer' and second-hanocar: f iuitety' advantagesand rts at an auctlon' Each has disadvantages' BuYing PrivatelY ., L. ... buying from a This is usually thttptt than weaker' lt's protection,is legai your but dealer, with you alonq torntone a good idea to ttlit to wttness a as when you 90 to look at a car' tt' about what the sellertellsYou I was both surprisedand saddenedto read your recent publication of a letter from V. Meldrew regarding what was describedas the 'appalling conditions that exist at Jericho Hospital'. Direct referencewas made to Ward C9. I feel very strongly that I should reply to the criticisms. I was recently a patient on Ward C9, where I received a liver transplant.I have the utmost admiration and appreciationfor the professionalism,dedication and patient care I received. GI Louis Sarno's account of his stranEe ;'ourney away from modern civilization is disarmingly frank and completely lacking in self-importance. Longingio be-acceptej by these people, but ashamed at his lack of basic skills, he appears to be the ultimate innocent in paradise. rerieu' I .\ c'ortcert 2 .\ lltiiqazine tlrticle 3 Consttmer adrice itr it consutller tnagazine ,l -\ book rer-ieu' 5 -\n informal letter 6 The advice paqe of il magazine 7 .\ Ietter to zrneu'sPaPer - \/ Argument . Module 4A v \- 1.0 Argumentsfor and against Here we look at the type of writingwhere the writerarguesa case, or expresses an opinion,by lookingat a problemfrom two sides. In this type of writing,the way rdeasare connectedis very important;this is achievedby the use of connectingwords, by the way the ideas are grouped togetherinto paragraphs' and by the way the paragraphsthemselvesare ordered,The followingminicompositionis an exampleof the basic structure' Telline the trut| rnavbe trr-irtue.but is it not ntoreiruportantto knori'hos to tell lies? Obr.ioirsh.nroderncirilized societvcorrlcln'texistif even'bodvlied all the tinie. Btrt at if even'bodvalu'avstolclthe trutli? So the sanretinre.u,ouldit not be equalh'disastrous it seerlsto r1e tliat hing is an essentialskill.and tliat sciroolsarrequite rigltt to teacii childrenhou'to do it. T h i s e x p re ssesthe w hol e argumenti n four sentences.A l ongerpi ece of wr it ing would developthe ideasin each of these sentencesintofour (or more)paragraphs, but the same basic structurewould be retained. Use your imaginationand creativityto completethe sentencesin the minicompositionsbelow. Note that A-E look at both sides of the argument,whereas F and G are one-sidedand simplylist reasons. A Students often u'onder u,hether it's u,orth goinq to Britairl to studv Enqlish. I u'ould sav it depends ort Sclnrestudents Others. hou'ever. All in all. This is onlv the third tin-re I'r'e realh'enjov it. ancl I still don't hros'if I In sotne \\'avs. Also But artthe satrte titrle. Bl'ar-rd large. I tliink ['rn often to]d I'rn luc]n'to be a ntan / u,ot'natt.but in fact it's a n'rixedblessing. \\'hile it is true to sar that I nevertheless On balance. I suppose Typesof writing ' 69 v ! v v \\' Unit 4 . Givingyouropinion \, D llanv vollng actors anci itctressesdreirni of ltecomilig sttlrs, but in reillitv stalrclotrt has its drarvbaicksas well as its attractions. v \- On the orte hand. \- Also. On the otlter liirntl. Not onl'u'that.but arlso Ultimatelr E As an Olvmpic Gold \ledallist, I arn olten askeclrvhat is the best rvtlv to spend the night before a big race. On the one hand. On the other hand. though, Personallv, F There are rttanv reasons rvhv I love One reason is Another Wliat is more. Above all. G Of erllthe soap pou,ders in the rvorlcl. I rvould recornltlentl that votl tlse In the first plzrce, \lore iuroorternth.'. On top of that. h-r sliort. v v \' \' v 70 . Types of writing A rgument . Module 4A Expandingyour argument 1.1 Below is the mini-compositionon page 69 developedinto a magazinearticle. A The connectingwords that signalthe structureof the argumenthave been re m o v e d .For each of the numbers(1, 2,3) w hi ch four of the fol l ow i nqa dver bials would be appropriate? f " I ,f I r I i \ Adnritteclh' C)f't'orrrse (lrantecl To srrrnrnr ' ' b e lr k Bv rrndlarge lil in all C.onverseh On tlie otherhand f i I Tlren iigrrin But in the saule n'av \rrturerlh' Ultinrateh' r t , 3 B What is the functionof each paragraph? Theimportance (1) _ modern civilized society couldn't exist if everybody lied all the time. Before a business deal could be concluded, lawyers rvould have to be brought in to make sure there was no trickery; but the lawyers themselves would be lying, and leave both companies bankrupt. And how could democracy operate unless politicians occasionally kept at least some of their electoral promises? of nofbeingearnest elling the truth may be a virtue, but is it not more important to know how to tell lies? Any idiot can tell the truth, but lying is a skill, a science, an art. Fortunately schools, with the unrealistic expectations that they have of young people, provide early training in the art of lying. For example, is it realistic to expect a lS-year-old to write a 250-word composition and spend six hours watching television in the same evening? So we watch television but tell the teacher we did our homework, but that the dog I cat I baby got hold of it . . . Then, later in life, when the really uncomfortable questions come, like 'I know you're 18 years old now, but wouldn't it be nice if we all went on a family holiday together, with grandma and grandpa?', we know better than to say that frankly it would be our idea of hell. Instead, we're really sorry we ' can't come but we've got that project to finish for school, plus fitness training, piano practice, or even English grammar exercises. (2) _ would it not be equally disastrous if everybody always told the truth? How many families depend for their stability on the little white lie? How much unhappiness, how many wars are avoided simply becausepeople have the good taste to hide the hatred and contempt they feel for other people? And as for love and desire, could these emotions not be ultimately more destructive to society than any negative feelings? (3) it seems to me that lying is an essential skill, and that schools are quite right to teach children how to do it. And if the editor of this magazine wonders why this article reached her so late this week, please note that I did in fact write it on time, but unfortunately the dog, the cat and the baby ganged up together, mugged me and buried the article in the garden. Note that in this articlethe key sentences('topicsentences')are the first sentencesin each paragraph;this is often, but not always,the case. Similarly, many adverbialconnecting words are not necessarilywritten at the beginning a sentence. Types of writing . 71 Unit 4 o Givingyouropinion 1.2 Writing Opiniortsttre likeballtlhrmots, atenllxtrltllvs got ortc.lnft do otlrcr pet4ilercurt ttt lrcur yott talk ubori ytrur's,) This writingof opinionsonly becomes interestingwhen the writer has somethtng to say. Your opinionwill not be interestingor worth expressinguntilyou have thought about the subject.So the first stage in writingyour opinionhappensIn your head, while you get your ideas straight.Many of the best writersfind it usefulto make notes of all their ideas beforethey start writing. Section B writing task A-E on pages 69-70, and developit into a Choose one of the mini-compositions full-lengthmagazinearticle (about 250 words) using The lmportance of Not Being . Earnestas a model. ' For furtherwritingpractice,see the Task bank on page 142. Consumerreviews 1.0 A When reviewinga consumerproduct,whetherfor publicationin a magazineor in a let'rerto a friend, it is necessaryto look at the product's bad points as well as its good points.What does this producldo, and what does itnot do? What are the advantagesof one particulardictionary?Are there any ways in which other dictionariesare preferable? ln this reviewof a new car: what is the functionof the first sentence? what does the rest of the first paragraphdo? what does the second ParagraPhdo? thought about multi-pqqgt" There are two schools of SpaceWagon' Critics NlitsuSishi as the vehicles (MpV; ;h rvith ito,,tor,ttd technical dismiss them as marketing-pioys m e r i t . W h y w a s t e e n e r g y p . . ' r ' i ' ' g a t a l l , v penetrating a n - l i k e b o done y Iower'- ToI-9 through tfre air when a tighter' issomuch-o."eflicientandstable?WhycreateSpace not wanted? uno"" )-our head where it is lofty MPVIs down-to-earth the ,o Advocat"r"]li.ri l.u*tl view - over hedges (an^d advantages.You get a better Sitting irprieht, the need for and blind brows, for instance. veriatiiity: comes into the leg-stretching space is,reauced. a third row you can-squeeze reckoning,too, especialll'when car. famill'ionger than a of seatsinto a vehicle thht is no 72 . \Z v Types of writing 48 _ _f-l:r: : Y:-dure B Modellingyour writing very closelyon the Space wagon review,use these notes to write two paragraphslookingat the advantagesand disadvantagesof a new mountainbike calledthe LamiaAnboto. Starl your review,'Thereare two s c h o o l so f thoughtabout mountai nbi kessuch as . . .' Against tlre Lamia Anboto o e'rpensivetf400) . 2l geirrs:lilrnec'essiln'incities of' rnorrrtuirrlrikes rrsecl onh'in c'ities) . attrlirc'tiveto thier-es.scr selclonrtrsed For the Lamia -{nbotcr useful irr c'ih' s h o c k , i b s , , , l r e , 'trl.r i c , kt v r e s :t o o d , l ) 5 % for rough surfirc'esrurclpotlroles of cih'roircls . ciln clinrb onto pavenrent o ec'olo$'' "r, u.r',,"rstenrpterl into . . cvclinq bv fasliionrlble nrachine 1.1 Filmreview A Complete the reviewby writingthe missingword in eachgap.Useonlyone wordfor eachspace.Thefirstone hasbeendoneas an example. B Thisfilmrevrewis mainlythe writer'sopinion,but he neversays'l' or 'in my opinion',How doeshe conveysucha strongopinionwithoutusingthe first person? PedroAlmodovar, institution in almosta national Spainandcertainly the onlySpanish director knows,comesup with a nastysurpriie everybody This in HighHeels.(0) isthat he'sno longercapable of surprising us. Thereare, (1) moments in his newfilm,(2) mountain of pesetas in Spain, whenthingshappen Butit doesn'texactly rollalongin the fluentway as WomenOn TheVergeOf A Neruous Breakdown does.itcontainthe frissons of TieMe Up, TieMe Down.(9) it is not abovea certainflatnessin placesand is (10) distinctly somefunnyjibesat the are, to saythe least,odd. mediaandsomesuitably eccentric minor as when VictoriaAbril,as a characters, thisis a melodrama that not onlylacks newscaster, announces television the murderof her realemotionbut,dareonesayit, husband on the box,calmlyaddingthat it isshe hasn'ta lot of realflair.lt is who isthe culprit. worthseeing; Almodovar wouldhaveto growa differentskinactually to be garishly Almodovar's film isstylish, decorated, (1a) dull inspiration the isn't anddressed with qreatandfashion-conscious anymeansconsistently there, with a equipped aplomb.lt is(5) andit showsin the film'sslightlydisorganized and starsto realcapacity to allowitstwo splendid spray-gun approach. (5) display actinqandotherassets. Types of writing . 73 Unit 4 . Givingyouropinion 1.2 Concertreview A Six sentenceshave been removed from this extract from a review of a concert.Match the gaps (1-6) with the sentences(A-H) givenbelow. Note that two of the suggestedsentencesdo not fit at all. B How many words can you find which show how the writerfeelswithout him ' l n my oP i ni on' ? n e e d i n gto say In a fickle world, one certaintv remains. Every year at this time Eric Clapton returns to the Albert Hall lor a dozen shows sold out months It in advance. (1) could easily becomea cosy ritual, an annual report from that everreliable trading company, Clapton It began as PLC. (2) expected, then develoPed into an extraordinory, emotional blend of the tragic and triumphant. He and his band strolled on in grey and suits immaculate buttoned-up shirts, with onlY the dark granny glassesof percussionist Ray Cooper pror-iding a clue that this wasn't a meetine of smart citv Not executives. (5) attack and melod.v that was almost welcome as defence against the lyrics. thoughtful anguished, great songs, any of them, but the playing was tight and the guitar solos as effortless and perfectly crafted as ever. (4) Clapton has had more publicif"v for his painful private life than his music since h e l a s t pl ayed here, as he acknowledged with three songs about the death of his four-year-old son. His finser(5) picking was rolling and slick, now lvith a Spanishedge,but the lyrics of 'The Circus Left Town' were at times almost unbearably painful. This lvasn't a blues but a lament with the personal heartfelt intensity of a great blues, and it quite literally reduced some of the audience to tears. (6) A B C D E F G H t L t L t t 1.3 ' N Iy Father' s E yes' had speed. (The ret,iew continues) But then he sat clorm and srvitclied to acoustic quitar. '89 trlbum,Jounteynmn. Thev hcked off uith a trio of biuesv pieces fron the 'Tettrs In Heaven'had rnuch the same effbct. Ticket touts line the entrances. ;rnd'Crossroticis'isthe encore. What ii change froni those wild dtn's of the sixties. But the first night tliis vear r,vasttnforgettrible. In fact, it's one of'tnv favotttite songs. Suddenlr.',the noisilv soporific, easr.'goingttrooclchanged' Writinga book review A This reviewof the novel Heat and Dust is spoiled by a number of weaknesses. Undedineexamplesof where the writerfailsto followeach of the numbered piecesof advicegiven below. L t Write for the reader. Alwaysbear in mind who you are writingfor. lf you're writingfor a magazine, think of the kind of people who read that particularmagazine.A book review is intendedfor peoplewho have not read the book, so don't assumethat your readersalreadyknow the story. L L L LL L Don't talk about yourself. When givingyour opinion,whetherin a reviewor elsewhere,be carefulnot to fall into the trap of talkingabout yourself.Try to be objective.One way of testingfor objectivityis to check your writingfor the words l, me, my, myself, Srmilarly,phrases SUchaS in my opinion, to my mind, I think should be used as littleas possible;any more than once in the first paragraphand once in the last,and your reviewseems to focus on yourself,not your subject. P Write in an impersonal style. Many studentsspoiltheir articlesand reviewsby writingin a chatty,informal styleas if they were talkingto a friend.On the contrary,essays,arliclesand Lt 74 . Types of writing - Reviews . Module 48 reviewsshould be relativelyimpersonal.Your readersare not parlicularly interestedin you: they need information,descriptionand narrativemore than you don' t know your reader,so be car ef ul th e y n e ed your opi ni on,Fi nal l y, about usingthe word you. Use precise, descrrptive vocabulary. Generalizations such as Ihrs book is boring communicatevery littleto the reader.Specificobservationsand concretefacts, on the other hand, help the readerto share your experience.lf you have strong feelingsabout your subject,this should make your r,vriting more interesting- but be carefull Strong feelrngsmust be givenform and coldlytranslatedinto precisewords. Heat and Dust, by Ruth PrawerJhabuala 'A writer of genius. . . a writer of world class- a masterstoryteller. . .' it sayson the dustjacket.Can they really be talking about the same writer, the samebook? Personally,I can't seewhat distinguishesHeat And Dust from any of those cheap romantic novelsthat you get at railway stations. What on eafth is so remarkable about the story of a bored expatriate who leavesa dull husbandfor someonericher, more intelligent and totally exotic? In my opinion, if Jhabvalawas really a good writer she would have written insteadabout a much more interesting phenomenon, the rypicalcolonial who clings absurdlyto the behaviour,traditions and even dress of his mother country. Alternatively, Olivia could have really 'gone native',insteadof just being seduced by a Nawabwith a Rolls-Royce, an Alfa Romeoand an intimate knowledgeof the best hotels of Paris and London. The plot too is corny: the idea of someoneretracingsomeoneelse's life, and then (surprise,surprise!) finding parallel eventshappeningin their own lives. Thousandsof writers have usedthis device,and to much befter effect. So what makes Jhabvalasuch a great writer? It can't be her prose,surely,which is quite boring.The words 'heat' and 'dust' appearfrequently,but I for one certainly never get any impressionof heat or dust.I don't know aboutyou, but the impressionI get is of a very literary, upper-classwoman sitting at her typewriter drinking tea. Finally, what really annoys me personallyabout this book is the writer's moraliry. You can seeshe'sa romanticand a moralist:shelooks down on her narrator with a patronizing attitude,and paints a degradingpicture of modern love by giving her narrator a kind of abject promiscuiryin the place of a love life. And incredibly,the messageof the book seemsto be that the best thing that can happento a woman even an unmarriedwoman, without a boyfriend,travelling abroad- is to get pregnant.I'm sorry, but if you think that, you're living in another world. B Rewritethe last26 linesfrom 'lt can'tbe her prose four paragraphs of advice. 1,4 bearinoin mind the Writing Section B writing tasks A A friendof yours is thinkingof buyinga consumeritem (e.9.a personalstereo, a bicycle,a tennis racket,a pair of shoes, a musicalinstrument,an English dictionary).Your friend knows that you have one, and writesto you asking if the one you have is a good model to buy, or whetheryou would advisethem to choose a differentmodel. Writeyour reply in about 250 words. B A Britishfriend of yours isstudyingyour language.Usinga satellitedish, they are capable of receivingW programmesfrom your country. Write a letter of about 250 words recommendingtwo programmesyour friendshould watch to help improvetheir language,bearingin mind that your friend'slevelin your languageis about the same as your levelin English. For furtherwritingpractice,includingfilm and concert reviews,see the Task bank on page 142. Types of writing . ,... 4" $f !#trEir 75 n'1:3!Ff.Fl4Fdffi*F*I .f,lry Unit 4 . Givingyouropinion - is anotheropportunity to express Writingadvice- to friends,or in a magazine in thisunit writing from most other of the this an opinion.But whatdistinguishes basis.Unlikein the argument is thatyouare oftenwritingon a person-to-person the readeras you - and the readeris often and the review,the writeraddresses justone individual. 1.0 Problempage 'Problempage' of a women's magazine, The followingadvicewas printedon the in responseto a reader'sletter.Study the advice,and decidewhat the reader's oroblemis. In a partnershipwhere both of you expectto do well, successalmostnevercomesfor two people at the same time. You are at the crucial breakthroughstageof your career,so -it's only natural to feel unsure. Your boyfriend must also be feeling vulnerableas he is building his career,too. No matter how much ..men may accept intellectually that women are entitled to succeed,it can still be hard for them when we push ahead. Talk this over honestly and establish precisely what is bothering him. Reassure 1.1 him of your confidencein him and remind him. too, that it's much better to be with a successfulwoman than with a dissatisfied one. Make sure he reapsthe benefit of your new prosperityin the form of fun and treats, so that he seesa tangiblereward for his loyal support.Then give him time to adjust. But don't let his problem of confidence undermine you. If he can't cope with a woman who makesmoney,you may have to look for someonewho can. Advicestructures When givingadvice,a range of structuresmay be used. Some of them are strongerthan others - Do this!- whereas others are more tentativesuggestions - | wonder if you've ever considered doing fhr,s.Your choice of structure should suit the situation rather than just your strengthof character.Two of the following are particularlystrong and shouldonly be addressed,in momentsof anger and frustration,to a close friend or relative. Grade the advice structureson a scale of 1-5: 1 for very weak or tentative;5 for aggressiveor authoritarian. a I'd recorll-ttendthat vou jclittthe tlrttn. b It's not lbr n-reto sal,,of cotrrse.btrt I clon'tstrpposevotl ve ever cotrsidered lookinginto the possibilitvo1'trnlilitirn' c,rreeri if vou'r'eever thotrghtabotrtjoining the arrnr'? c I r,r,onder d Yott tnustjoin the arm\'. e Perhapsvou coulcljoin the ilrlll\'. f \lr-rrclriceis to ioin tlte ilrttlr'. clo? g \\'ell. u'hirtcloyorrthirrkt',rrishotrlcl h Yorrpirtltetics'orm! If rr;rr ltiitl artr pricle.r'otr'djoin the itfllr).. i I think votr'cibe rviseto joirt tlie lrttlr.. j I stronglvrecotnttrencl that votrjoin the artllr.. k Join the itnn\'. I I rerrllr,'thinkthat vou shouldjoin tlie anllv. rn lt's high tirne vorr stoppecif'eelinqsorn' f or vourself.got off vottr backsideand ioinerl the itrtttr'. 76 . Types of writing \.V Personaladvice . 1.2 Module 4C Givingadvice Someone has a problem,and asks us for advice.But note that this givesus neithera licenceto run that person's life nor an oppoftunityto talk about ourselvesand how we solve our own problems.The best advicecomes not from someonewho has all the answers,but from someonewho has listenedwith care and empathyto the other person's problem. A Work in a group of four and read the lettersbelow. 1 Discusseach problem. Do you fully understandit? What do you know, and what can you guess about the writer? 2 Discussthe possiblesolutions. 3 Decidewhat advicestructuresyou would use. B Each write an answer to a differentone of the letters. This may not seem to be a Problem, but my flatmate is too tidy. She arranges cans so the labels all face the same wa-v and straightens the bathroom mat every morning. Her mother is the same - she spends hours cleaning and ironing when she visits. I'm not untidy, but this is hard to live rvith. Hou'can I make m-v daughter see hou' unacceptable her boyfriend is? Everyone comments on his appearanceand asks what my daughter seesin him. He looks dreadful, unshaven and with long hair. He's unemployed and has a criminal record. My daughter, who's 18, has had everything she's ever wanted and lacks for nothing. After excellent results at college, she novv has a good job n'ith prosPects. In the two -vearsshe's been going steady with this bo-v,she's droPPed her on'n friends and only seeshis, who are much older. We've pointed out to her their different lifestvles, but to no avail. We live in an exclusive Part of town and m1'husband is a comPanY director. I don't $'ant to tell my daughter not to see this bol' again as I'm afraid she may leave home. Pleaseadvise me. I have just started my first job and do not object to working overtime because I am prepared to put in the effort to get on. But from the beginning I have found that I regularly work till 6.50 at night or later. This is becausemy boss is completely disorganized and leaves the most important items until very late afternoon. As the most junior person in the departmen! I feel powerless to change things. I am halfway through a course at college and I'm sick to death of it. My parents bulldozed me into taking this place and I've been unhappy since the beginning. I realize that a degree will stand me in good stead, but I want to give it up. I know that this means I will have wasted the last year, and could also jeopardize any future chances of higher education. But why should I struggle on to please my parents? All I want to do is start work. Types of writing ' 77