M/S. TRIDEV INDUSTRIES
Transcription
M/S. TRIDEV INDUSTRIES
RISK ASSESSMENT STUDY REPORT FOR M/S. TRIDEV INDUSTRIES Plot No. D-2/CH/134, GIDC Industrial Estate, Dahej, Taluka: Vagra - 392130, Dist.: Bharuch, Gujarat. PREPARED BY BHAGWATI ENVIRO CARE PVT. LTD. [ISO 9001, ISO 14001 & OHSAS: 18001 CERTIFIED COMPANY] CORPORATE OFFICE 28, 29, 30, Parmeshwar Estate II, Opp. AMCO Bank, Phase I, GIDC Estate, Vatva, Ahmedabad – 382445. Gujarat, India Phone No: +91 79 29295043, 40083051/52 Fax: +91 79 40083053 , Email: bhagwatienviro@gmail.com , bhagwatienviro@yahoo.com URL: www.bhagwatienviro.com Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. INDEX Sr. No. Chapter Page No. 1. Introduction 240 2. Risk Assessment Process 243 3. Basic Environment 249 4. Storage & Handling of Hazardous 274 Chemicals 5. Various Hazards & its control 281 6. Health & safety measures 286 7. Occupational health scheme for the 289 workers 8. Risk Reduction Measures 290 9. Fire Fighting system 293 10. Hazards Identification, major hazards & 294 Damage criteria 11. Risk Analysis & Consequence analysis 308 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 239 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 1 INTRODUCTION M/s. Tridev Industries has decided to start manufacturing activity of “various kinds of Resins” at Plot. No. D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist- Bharuch, Gujarat. As a manufacturer, the management’s objective is to build confidence among their customers by regular and reliable supplies at competitive prices and consistent quality, complying with their technical requirements. Company’s purpose is to build a comprehensive range of products for each specific market segment with the objective to be the most reliable manufacturer in the market. The company is intending to start proposed manufacturing facility by new products which falls under Category “B” of Project Activity 5(f) – ‘Synthetic Organic Chemicals Industry’ of EIA Notification issued in September – 2006. For this the unit needs environmental clearance from Ministry of Environment & Forests. New Delhi. As per the TOR no. 24 of the said letter, the Risk Assessment with following emphasis is required to be carried out: Purpose The purpose of this risk assessment is to evaluate the adequacy of the proposed products and raw materials which is used as raw material to ink, Paint and coating industries. This risk assessment provides a structured qualitative assessment of the operational environment. It addresses sensitivity, threats, vulnerabilities, risks and safeguards. The assessment recommends cost-effective safeguards to mitigate threats and associated exploitable vulnerabilities. Scope The scope of this risk assessment assessed the system’s use of resources and controls (implemented or planned) to eliminate and/or manage vulnerabilities exploitable. This Risk Assessment Report evaluates the confidentiality (protection from unauthorized disclosure of system and data information), integrity (protection from improper modification of information), and availability (loss of system access) of the system. Recommended security safeguards will allow management to make decisions about security-related initiatives. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 240 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Mission The production plant of resin manufacturing is basically used as raw material for the production of ink, Paint and coating industries.. Proposed project will require some chemical like Cyclohexanone, Formaldehyde, Xylene, N –Butryaldehyde, Butanol, etc. our main aim to focus the entire plant to estimate the risk assessment of all hazardous chemical and try to avoid some consequences accident in internal premises of surrounding area of production plant. Geographical Information of Project Site Latitude : 21O 43' 34. 428 ’’ N Longitude : 72O 37' 17. 472 ” E LOCATION MAP OF THE COMPANY ON GOOGLE MAP Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 241 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Layout Plan Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 242 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER :2 RISK ASSESSMENT PROCESS RISK ASSESSMENT Identification analysis and assessment of hazard and risk are very useful in providing information to risk management. It provides basis for what should be type and capacity of its on-site and off-site emergency plan also what types of safety measures are required. Risk and consequence analysis is carried out considering storage and handling of various hazardous raw materials, intermediates and product as well as manufacturing process. This section details the risk assessment process performed during this effort. The process is divided into pre-assessment, assessment, and post assessment phases. PHASE I – PRE-ASSESSMENT Step 1: Define the Nature of the Risk Assessment This initial risk assessment provides an independent review to help Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) determine the appropriate level of security required for the system to support the development of a System Security Plan for intermediate chemical resin plant. The risk assessment is based on interviews, documentation and, as necessary, some automated technical review. Step 2: Data Collection The data collection phase included identifying and interviewing key personnel within the organization and conducting document reviews. Interviews focused on the operating environment. Document reviews provided the risk assessment team with the basis on which to evaluate compliance with policy and procedure. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 243 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Step 3: Templates The following templates were used by the risk assessment team and are included in the appendices: • Security Baseline Worksheet: Completed by the analysts using information extracted from questionnaires and interviews. • Risk Calculation Worksheet: Converts the raw vulnerabilities into risks based on the following methodology: • Risk Mitigation Worksheet: Lists the risks and the associated recommended controls to mitigate these risks for the Business Steward to review. PHASE II – ASSESSMENT Step 1: Document Review The assessment phase began with the review of documents provided by the members of the various Resin manufacturing system team. Detailed interviews with members of the CDC Resins manufacturing system team allowed completion of the system questionnaire and identification of specific threats inadequately identified in the Enterprise Threat Statement. Step 2: System Characterization In this step, the analyst defined the boundaries of the IT system, along with the resources that constitute the system, its connectivity, and any other elements necessary to describe the system. Dependencies were clarified. Sensitivity of the system and data was discussed in the final section of the characterization. Step 3: Threat Identification Through the interview process, it also identified “most likely” system and location-specific threats. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 244 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Step 4: Vulnerability Identification In this step, the risk assessment team developed a list of system vulnerabilities (flaws or weaknesses) that could be exploited by the potential threat vectors. Step 5: Risk Determination (Calculation/Valuation) In this step, the risk assessment team determined the degree of risk to the system. In some cases, a series of vulnerabilities combined to create the risk. In other cases, a single vulnerability created the risk. The determination of risk for a particular threat source was expressed as a function of the following: • • • • • Likelihood Determination: The following governing factors were considered when calculating the likelihood of the probability that a potential vulnerability might be exploited in the context of the associated threat environment: Threat source motivation and capability Nature of the vulnerability Existence and effectiveness of current controls The following table defines the likelihood determinations. Table1. Likelihood Definition Level Likelihood Definition High The threat source is highly motivated and sufficiently capable, and controls to prevent the vulnerability from being exercised are ineffective. Moderate The threat source is motivated and capable, but controls are place that may impede successful exercise of the vulnerability. Low The threat source lacks motivation or capability, or controls are in place to prevent, or at least significantly impede, the vulnerability from being exercised. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 245 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Impact Analysis: The next major step in measuring level of risk was to determine the adverse impact resulting from successful exploitation of vulnerability. The adverse impact of a security event can be described in terms of loss or degradation of any, or a combination of any, of the following three security goals: • Loss of Confidentiality – Impact of unauthorized disclosure of sensitive information (e.g., Privacy Act). • Loss of Integrity – Impact if system or data integrity is lost by unauthorized changes to the data or system. • Loss of Availability – Impact to system functionality and operational effectiveness. Table 2. Impact Definition Magnitude of Impact High Impact Definition Exercise of the vulnerability (1) may result in the highly costly loss of major tangible assets or resources; (2) may significantly violate, harm, or impede an organization’s mission, reputation, or interest; or (3) may result in human death or serious injury. Moderate Exercise of the vulnerability (1) may result in the costly loss of tangible assets or resources; (2) may violate, harm or impeded an organization’s mission, reputation, or interest; or (3) may result in human injury. Low Exercise of the vulnerability (1) may result tangible assets or resources; (2) may organization’s mission, reputation, or interest. in the loss of some noticeably affect an Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 246 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. • Risk Determination: The following were used to assess the level of risk to the IT system: • • • The likelihood of a given threat source’s attempting to exercise a given vulnerability. The magnitude of the impact should a threat-source successfully exercise the vulnerability. The adequacy of planned or existing security controls for reducing or eliminating risk. The following table provides a definition for the risk levels. These levels represent the degree or level of risk to which an IT system, facility, or procedure might be exposed if a given vulnerability were exercised. Table 3. Risk Level Definition Magnitude of Impact Risk Level Definition High There is a strong need for corrective measures. An existing system may continue to operate, but a corrective action plan must be put in place as soon as possible. Moderate Corrective actions are needed and a plan must be developed to incorporate these actions within a reasonable period of time. Low The system’s Authorizing Official must determine whether corrective actions are still required or decide to accept the risk. Step 6: Risk Mitigation Recommendations: During this step of the process, controls that could mitigate or eliminate the identified risks, as appropriate to the organization’s operations, were provided. The goal of the recommended controls is to reduce the level of risk to the IT system and its data to an acceptable level. The risk assessment team considered the following factors when recommending controls and alternative solutions to minimize or eliminate identified risks: • • • • • • Sensitivity of the data and the system Effectiveness of recommended options Legislation and regulations Organizational policy Operational impact Safety and reliability Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 247 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. PHASE III – POST ASSESSMENT Risk Mitigation The elimination of all risk is usually impractical, senior management and business stewards should assess control recommendations, determine the acceptable level of residual risk, and implement those mitigations with the most appropriate, effective, and highest payback. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 248 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER :3 BASIC ENVIRONMENT Details of Products: No. Name of Product Total Quantity MT/MONTH 01 Drying of Ketonic Resin 100 02 Drying of poly Vinyl Butyl Resin 50 03 Printing Ink & Coatings 300 04 Ketonic Resin 250 05 Polyamide Resin 100 06 Maleic Resin 100 07 Poly Vinyl Butyl Resin 100 08 Adhesion Permoter (TA-10) 50 09 MF Resin 100 10 Water Based Additive 200 Total 1350 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 249 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. NAME OF BY – PRODUCT: No. Name of By Product Total Quantity MT/MONTH 01 Turpentine (From Maleic Resin) 2.0 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 250 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. PROPERTIES OF PRODUCTS Name of the Products State B.P. º C Sr. No. Drying of Ketonic Solid Resin 1 2 Main Properties (refer MSDS) Flash Point º C LEL UEL % TLV ppm or mg/m3 LD50 mg/kg NA 95 > 149 NA NA NA NA 105‐ 125 300 F ND NA 10000 mg/kg Rat NA NA NA NA NA ND Drying of Poly Vinyl Solid Butyl Resin 3 Printing Coatings 4 Ketonic Resin Solid NA 95 >149 NA NA NA 5 Polyamide Resin Solid NA NA NA NA NA NA Solid 100‐ 110 NA NA NA NA NA NA 105‐ 125 300 F ND NA 10000 mg/kg Rat NA NA 30 NA NA NA NA >200 F NA 0.75 ppm 500 mg/Kg NA NA >100 C NA NA NA 6 Maleic Resin ink& M.P. º C Liquid 7 Poly Vinyl Resin 8 Adhesion Permoter Liquid (TA‐10) 9 Powde r MF Resin Water Additive 10 Butyl Solid Based Liquid Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 251 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Sr. No. 1 2 Full Name of the Products State Main Properties (refer MSDS) Pressure mm/Hg Drying of Ketonic Resin Drying Vinayl of Solid poly Temp ºC Ambient Ambient Ambient Ambient Ambient Specific Gravity Vapour Density Odour Threshold (water =1) (air 1) ppm or mg/m3 ¾ 1 = NA NA NA NA NA Ambient -- NA NA Solid Butyl Resin 3 Printing Coatings 4 Ketonic Resin Solid Ambient Ambient >1 NA NA 5 Polyamide Resin solid Ambient Ambient 0.97 NA NA 6 Maleic Resin Solid Ambient Ambient NA NA NA 7 Poly Vinyl Butyl Resin Solid Ambient Ambient NA NA NA 8 Adhesion Permotor(Ta-10) Liquid Ambient Ambient 0.98 NA NA Ambient Ambient 0.6-0.7 NA NA Ambient Ambient NA NA NA 9 10 Ink& MF Resin Water Additives Liquid Powder Based Liquid Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 252 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. PACKING AND FINAL APPLICATION OF PRODUCTS & BY-PRODUCTS Sr. No 1 2 Name of proposed Product Drying of Ketonic Resin Type of Packing 25 kg Paper bag 3 Drying of poly Vinyl Butyl 10 kg Paper bag Resin Printing Ink & Coatings 15 kg Drum 4 Ketonic Resin 15 Kg Paper bag 5 Polyamide Resin 20 Kg Paper bag 6 Maleic Resin 25 kg Paper bag 7 Poly Vinyl Butyl Resin 10 Kg Paper bag 8 Adhesion Permoter(TA-10 9 MF Resin 200 kg HDPE Drum 25 kg Paper bag 10 Water Based Additive 200 kg Drum Final application of Product Ink, paint & coating industries Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 253 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. NAME AND QUANTITY OF RAW MATERIAL CONSUMPTION Sr. No. Name of product Capacity TPM 1 Drying of Ketonic Resin Drying of poly Vinyl butyrl Resin Printing Ink & Coating 100 Wet Ketonic resin 50 Wet Poly Butyl Resin Vinyl 1.176 58.8 300 4 Ketonic Resin 250 5 Polyamide Resin 100 6 Maleic Resin 100 7 Poly Vinyl Butyl Resin 100 8 Adhession Permoter (TA‐10) 50 Dry Pigment Solvent Varnish Additives Cyclohexanone Formaldehyde Caustic Soda Dimmer Amine Fatty Acid Xylene Gum Rosin Fumeric acid Penta erythritol Poly Vinyl alcohol n‐Butryaldehyde Additives Acetyl aceton t‐Iso propyl titanate Additives Melamine Formaldehyde Butanol Xylene Butyl acrylate Methyl acrylic acid Acrylic acid Vinyl acetate 0.15 0.4 0.4 0.05 0.7737 1.1315 0.05 0.5806 0.339 0.113 0.032 0.800 0.125 0.125 0.75 0.4 0.08 0.53 0.4 45 120 120 15 193.425 282.875 12.5 58.06 33.9 11.3 3.2 80.0 12.5 12.5 75 40 8 26.5 20 0.07 0.219 0.756 0.405 0.081 0.367 0.0128 0.0285 0.19 3.5 21.9 75.6 40.5 8.1 73.4 2.56 5.7 38 2 3 9 M F Resin 10 Water additives 100 based 200 Name of R.M. Raw Material Consumption MT /MT of MT per product Month 1.176 117.6 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 254 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. DIbutyl maleate Additives 0.0928 0.022 18.56 4.4 CHEMICAL NAME & PHYSICAL FORM OF RAW MATERIAL: Cyclohexanone Physical Form Liquid Container Type Tank MOC of container SS 304 Formaldehyde Formaldehyde Liquid Tank HDPE Sodium Hydroxide solid Bags HDPE 4. Caustic soda Flakes Dimmer ------ Liquid Tank SS 5. Amine ------ Liquid Tank HDPE 6. Fatty acid Carboxylic Acid Liquid Tank HDPE 7. Xylene xylene Liquid Tank HDPE 8. Gum Rosin Rosin solid Drum HDPE 9. Fumeric acid (E)-Butenedioic acid solid Bags HDPE 10. Penta Erythritol solid Bags HDPE 11. solid Bags HDPE 12. Poly vinyl Alcohol n- Butaldeyade n- Butaldeyade Liquid Tank HDPE 13. Acetyl acetone 2,4-Pentanedione Liquid Tank HDPE 14. t-Iso propyl titrate Liquid Tank HDPE 15. t-Iso propyl titrate Melamine solid Bags HDPE 16. Butanol 1,3,5Triazine2,4,6 triamine Butanol Liquid Drum HDPE 17. Butyl acrylate Butyl acrylate Liquid Tank HDPE 18. Methyl acrylic acid Methacrylllic Acid Liquid Drum HDPE 19. Acrylic acid Prop-2-enoic acid Liquid Drum HDPE 20. Vinyl acetate Vinyl Acetate Liquid Tank HDPE 21. DIbutyl maleate DIbutyl maleate Liquid Drum HDPE No. 1. Name of Raw Material Cyclohexanone 2. 3. Chemical Name -----Ethanolhomo polymer Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 255 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. PROPERTIES OF RAW MATERIAL 1. Cyclohexanone : 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Cyclohexanone 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size MS Tank 03 No. : 01 04 MT : 10 KL : Keep container in cool ,well ventilated areas Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 155 0C 08 Flash Point : 43.880 C 09 LEL , UEL % : LEL:1.1% UEL:9.4 % 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : Not Available 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 1516 mg /Kg (Oral – Rat) 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.9478 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 3.24 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : 0.88 ppm Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 256 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 2. Formaldehyde: 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Formaldehyde 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size MS Tank 03 No. : 01 04 MT : 10 KL : Keep away from heat, flame and oxidizer Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm Temp 0C : Ambient Boiling Point : 960C Flash Point : 600C LEL , UEL % : LEL :7 % UEL :73 % Storage Parameters 3. 4. 05 5. 6. 7. 06 8. 9. 07 10. 11. 08 12. 13. 09 14. 3 3 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM : 1.5 mg/m 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 800 mg /Kg (Oral – Rat) 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.038 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg : 2 PPM 3 /NM Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 257 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 3. Sodium Hydroxide: 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Sodium hydroxide 02 State : Solid No. of Containers & Size HDPE bags 03 No. : 100 04 MT : 2.5 : keep in cool dry well ventilated places Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 318.4 0C 08 Flash Point : NP 09 LEL , UEL % : NP 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 2 mg/m3 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : NL 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 2.12 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : Odorless Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 258 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 4. Dimmer 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Dimmer 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Tank 03 No. : 1 04 MT : 10 : Keep tightly closed ventilated place Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : NA 08 Flash Point : NA 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg : NA 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : NA 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : Odorless in dry well Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 259 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 5. Amine 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Amine 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 25 04 MT : 0.2 : Store in original container in locked storage areas Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 214 0F 08 Flash Point : 1250F 09 LEL , UEL % : NL 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : NA 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.16 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : >1 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 260 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 6. Fatty Acid ; 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Fatty acid 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 10 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 10 drum = 2.0 Mt : Store in accordance with local regulation. Store in original Protected from direct sunlight in a dry, cool, well ventilated area Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : >300 08 Flash Point : 185 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 10 mg/m3 11 LD50 mg /Kg, LC50 mg /L : 4640mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : NA 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 261 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 7. Rosin: 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Rosin 02 State : Solid No. of Containers & Size Bags 03 No. : 200 04 MT : 25 kgs x 200 bags = 5.0 MT : Keep Container tightly closed, keep container in cool, well -ventilated area Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : NA 08 Flash Point : 187 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 3805 mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.06-1.07 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : odorless Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 262 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 8. Polyvinyl Alcohol : 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Polyvinyl alcohol 02 State : Powder No. of Containers & Size Bags 03 No. : 100 04 MT : 25 kgs x 100 bags = 2.5 MT : Store in cool dry well –ventilated place area Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : NA0C 08 Flash Point : 79 0C 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 14700 mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.19-1.31 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 263 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 9. Xylene : 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Xylene 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 drum = 1000 Kgs : Storage in well ventilated, dry area, away from heat, flame And oxidizing materials Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 1400C 08 Flash Point : 1870C 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 100 PPM 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 4300mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.864 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 264 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 10. Fumeric Acid : 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Fumeric Acid 02 State : Solid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 10 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 10 drum = 2000 Kgs : Keep container dry, keep in a cool place Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : NA 08 Flash Point : NA 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 10700 mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.635 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : NA 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 265 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 11. N Butryaldehyde ; 01 Full Name of Raw Material : N- Butryaldehyde 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 50 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 50 Nos. = 10 MT : Protect cylinder from physical damage Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 75.6o C 08 Flash Point : -10.15 o C 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : NA 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.803 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 2.48 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 266 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 12. Butanol 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Butanol 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 5 drums = 1000 Kgs : Store in cool in a dry, cool, well ventilated area, away from heat and frame Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 117.7 o C 08 Flash Point : 36.1 09 LEL , UEL % : LEL:1.4% UEL:11.2% 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 50 ppm 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 790 mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.81 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 2.55 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : 2.5ppm Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 267 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 13. Butyl Acrylate: 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Butyl Acrylate 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 Nos. = 1000 Kgs : Store in a cool, dry, well ventilated, away from heat, frame, Oxidizer materials Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 148.8o C 08 Flash Point : 48.80C 09 LEL , UEL % : NA 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 10 ppm 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 900 mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.899 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 4.42 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 268 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 14. Acetyl Acetone 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Acetyl Acetone 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 Nos. – 1.0 Mt : Keep tightly closed, keep away from heat Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 136o C 08 Flash Point : 38o C 09 LEL , UEL % : LEL:1.7% UEL;11.2% 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 55mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : NA 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 3.5 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 269 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 15. T- Iso Propyl Titanate 01 Full Name of Raw Material : T- Iso Propyl Titanate 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 = 1000 Kgs : Keep away from heat, keep away from source of ignition Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 163 0C 08 Flash Point : 77 0C 09 LEL , UEL % : LEL-1.6%, UEL-8.1% 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 2600mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.82 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 3.18 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 270 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 16. Methacrylic Acid 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Methacrylic Acid 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 Nos. = 1000 Kgs : Store in metallic or coated fiber board drum Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 163 0C 08 Flash Point : 77 0C 09 LEL , UEL % : LEL:1.6% UEL-8.1% 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 1060mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.015 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 2.97 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : NA Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 271 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 17. Acrylic Acid : 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Acrylic acid 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 Nos. = 1000 Kgs : Keep container cool, well ventilated area, keep container Tightly closed Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 141 0C 08 Flash Point : 50 0C 09 Melting Point : 14 0C 10 LEL , UEL % : NA 11 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : NA 12 LD50 mg /Kg : 1060 mg /Kg 13 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 1.05 14 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 2.97 15 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : 0.092 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 272 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 18. Vinyl Acetate : 01 Full Name of Raw Material : Vinyl acetate 02 State : Liquid No. of Containers & Size Drum 03 No. : 5 04 MT : 200 Kgs x 05 = 1000 Kgs : Store in a cool, dry and wellventilated area, away from heat, flame, and oxidizing agent Storage Parameters 05 Pressure kg /cm2 : Atm 06 Temp 0C : Ambient 07 Boiling Point : 730C 08 Flash Point : -50C 09 LEL , UEL % : LEL -2.6% UEL-13.4% 10 TLV ppm or mg /NM3 : 10 ppm 11 LD50 mg /Kg, : 2920 mg /Kg 12 Specific Gravity (water = 1) : 0.934 13 Vapor Density (Air = 1) : 3.0 14 Odour Threshold ppm or mg /NM3 : 0.12ppm Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 273 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 4 STORAGE AND HANDLING OF HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS The properties of the important raw materials and the safety precautions to be taken to prevent an accident are detailed in ‘Material Safety Data Sheets’ and described in Chapter: 02. The details of storage of Hazardous chemicals along with measures taken during storage are given in Table. HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS Details of raw material, which are termed as Hazardous Chemicals as per Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical (Amendment) Rules 2000 are given in the below table Toxicity details of raw materials are given in the below Table. TABLE DETAILS OF HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS Hazardous Chemicals Reference The Manufacturer, Storage & Import of Hazardous chemical Rules 1989 Maximum Quantity to be Stored at a time Threshold Storage quantity in MT as per schedule 3 for application Rules 10-12 Cyclohexanone Sr.No. 162 (part II, Sch 1 of MSIHCR, 1989 19.5 MT --- Formaldehyde Sr.No. 285 (part II, Sch 1 of MSIHCR, 1989 37 MT --- Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 274 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Caustic Soda Sr.No. 571 (part II, Sch 1 of MSIHCR, 1989 0.5 MT --- STORAGE FACILITY OF RAW MATERIAL Sr. No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Name of Raw Material Container Type MOC Container Physical form Max. Storage Capacity in MT At a time storage in MT Cyclohexanone Formaldehyde Caustic Soda Dimmer Amine Fatty Acid Xylene Gum Rosin Fumeric Acid Penta Erythritol Poly Vinyl Alcohol N – Butryaldehyde Acetyl Acetone T – Iso propyl titanate Melamine Butanol Butyl Acrylate Methyl Acrylic Acid Tank Tank Bags Tank Tank Tank Tank Drum Bags Bags Bags Tank Tank Tank Bags Drum Tank Drum SS 304 HDPE HDPE SS HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE HDPE Liquid Liquid solid Liquid Liquid Liquid Liquid solid solid solid solid Liquid Liquid Liquid solid Liquid Liquid Liquid 25 40 3 16 1 1 1 10 1 1 20 16 1 1 5 10 20 1 19.5 37 0.5 5 0.2 0.2 0.2 2 0.1 0.1 10 5 0.2 0.2 10 10 20 5 Acrylic Acid Vinyl Acetate Di Butyl Maleate Drum Tank Drum HDPE HDPE HDPE Liquid Liquid Liquid 5 20 10.0 5 20 20.0 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 275 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Sr. No. 1 Name of R.M. Cyclohexanone Place of Its storage State Operating Pressure, Temp. Possible Type of hazards Storage Tank Norma( Liquid) at RT Flammable Normal(Liquid) at RT Skin sensitivity, SS 304 2 Formaldehyde Storage Tank HDPE Control measures provided Fire extinguisher, double earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc. provided. Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask, closed system Suspected 3 Caustic Soda RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT 4 Dimmer Yard/bags RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Carcinogen Skin sensitivity None Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask, closed system Use Rubber gloves goggles Yard/SS Storage tank RM Storage at RT Normal (Liquid) Irritant Wear gloves, Safety goggles, dust mask 5 Amine 6 Fatty Acid Yard/Storage tank RM Storage at RT Normal (Liquid) None Use Rubber gloves &goggles Xylene Yard/Storage tank RM Storage at RT Normal (Liquid) Flammable Yard/Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT Fire existingusher, double Earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc Wear Gloves ,safety goggles, dust mask 7 8 Gum Rosin None Yard/ drum Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 276 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 9 Fumeric Acid RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT Irritant Wear gloves, safety goggles, dust mask 10 Penta Erythritol Yard/bags RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT Irritant Wear gloves, Safety goggle, dust mask 11 Poly Vinyl Alcohol Yard/bags RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT None Use Rubber gloves 12 N – Butryaldehyde Yard/bags RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Flammable Yard/Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal (Liquid) None Fire extinguisher, double earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc Use Rubber gloves & goggles Yard/Storage tank RM Storage at RT Normal (Liquid) None Use Rubber gloves & goggles Yard/Storage tank Bags at RT Normal (Powder) Toxic Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask, closed system 13 Acetyl Acetone 14 T – Iso propyl titanate 15 Melamine at RT 16 Butanol Drum Normal (Liquid) Non flammable Flammable at RT 17 Butyl Acrylate Tank Normal (Liquid) Flammable Monomer Non Flammable Non Flammable 18 Methyl Acrylic Acid Drum at RT Normal (Liquid) 19 Acrylic Acid Drum at RT Normal (Liquid) 20 Vinyl Acetate Tank at RT Normal (Liquid) Flammable at RT monomer Fire extinguisher, double earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask ,closed system Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask ,closed system Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask ,closed system Fire extinguisher, double earthing , bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 277 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Di Butyl Maleate 21 Drum Normal (Liquid) Flammable at RT monomer water shower etc Fire extinguisher, double earthing , bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 278 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. SAFETY PRECAUTIONS DURING STORAGE OF CHEMICALS Storage & Handling of Hazardous Chemicals: • • • • • • • • Company will do planning to stock all the necessary material as minimum as possible. All containers with hazardous chemicals have labels indicating the contents and warning of the hazard. Necessary information on safe handling and first aid measures and antidotes of major hazardous material will be available on the label. Workers dealing with hazardous chemicals will be trained on health risks and safe handling. Exposure to hazardous chemicals will be minimized. Liquid Hazardous chemicals will be transferred in closed piping system. Separate storage section will be provided for storage of hazardous and non-hazardous raw materials. Flame arrestors are provided to all hazardous storage equipment. Vessel and other Equipment related: • • Checking of process vessels and equipment will be carried out regularly. Records related to maintenance and its planning schedule will be maintained. Fire related • Overhead water storage tank with adequate capacity will be provided to ensure 24 hr. supply. • Fire water tank with sufficient capacity of 100 KL will be provided with fire pump (02 Nos.). One no. being diesel operated pump and another is operated by power. • Fire hydrant piping will be provided with water ring man covering all individuals’ plants and tank farms. • Adequate hydrant points will be provided at specific locations. • Sprinkler system will be provided over hazardous area. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 279 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. • • • • • • • • • • • Emergency power supply to EMS and also for storage tanks will be ensured. Fire extinguisher will be provided. Contact numbers of nearest fire agency will be provided. Electrical related All electrical fitting and motors in the tank farm areas will be flameproof. Checking of all earthings, wiring & connection will be carried out regularly. Proper earthing will be provided at all equipments. Adequate Nos. of earth pits will be provided. Lighting arrestors will be provided at peak points. Safety related Adequate types of personal protective equipment will be provided. And also safety training will be provided to workers. Emergency showers and eye wash stations will be available at the worksite. Arrangement for 24 hr. medical facilities by contact with nearest health care centre/ hospital. Pre-employment medical check-up and annual medical check up will be carried out and its records will also properly maintained. Monitoring of occupational hazards like noise, ventilation, chemical exposure etc. will be carried out regularly and its records will be maintained. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 280 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 5 VARIOUS HAZARDOUS & ITS CONTROL Sr. No. 1 Name of R.M. Cyclohexanone Place of Its storage State Operating Pressure, Temp. Possible Type of hazards Storage Tank Norma( Liquid) at RT Flammable Fire extinguisher, double earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc. provided. Normal(Liquid) at RT Skin sensitivity, Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask, closed system SS 304 2 Formaldehyde Storage Tank HDPE Suspected Control measures provided Carcinogen 3 Caustic Soda RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT Yard/bags 4 Dimmer 5 Amine 6 Fatty Acid 7 Xylene RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Yard/SS Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Yard/Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Yard/Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Skin sensitivity Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask, closed system None Use Rubber gloves goggles Irritant Wear gloves, Safety goggles, dust mask None Use Rubber gloves &goggles Flammable Fire existingusher, double Earthing, bonding on flange Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 281 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 8 Gum Rosin Yard/Storage tank at RT joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc RM Storage Normal(Solid) at RT None Wear Gloves ,safety goggles, dust mask Normal(Solid) at RT Irritant Wear gloves, safety goggles, dust mask Normal(Solid) at RT Irritant Wear gloves, Safety goggle, dust mask Normal(Solid) at RT None Use Rubber gloves Flammable Fire extinguisher, double earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc None Use Rubber gloves & goggles None Use Rubber gloves & goggles Toxic Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask, closed system Yard/ drum 9 Fumeric Acid RM Storage Yard/bags 10 Penta Erythritol RM Storage Yard/bags 11 Poly Vinyl Alcohol RM Storage Yard/bags 12 13 14 15 N – Butryaldehyde Acetyl Acetone T – Iso propyl titanate Melamine RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Yard/Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Yard/Storage tank at RT RM Storage Normal (Liquid) Yard/Storage tank at RT Bags Normal (Powder) at RT 16 Butanol Drum Normal (Liquid) at RT Non flammable Flammable Fire extinguisher, double earthing, bonding on flange joint, level indicator, Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 282 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. flame proof fitting, water shower etc 17 Butyl Acrylate Tank Normal (Liquid) at RT 18 19 Methyl Acrylic Acid Acrylic Acid Drum Drum Normal (Liquid) Vinyl Acetate Di Butyl Maleate 21 Tank Drum Monomer Non Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask ,closed system Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask ,closed system at RT Flammable Normal (Liquid) Non Flammable Wear gloves, goggles, gas mask ,closed system Normal (Liquid) Flammable at RT monomer Fire extinguisher, double earthing , bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc Normal (Liquid) Flammable at RT monomer at RT 20 Flammable Fire extinguisher, double earthing , bonding on flange joint, level indicator, flame proof fitting, water shower etc Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 283 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. TABLE OTHER HAZARDS AND CONTROL SR. NO. ITS SOURCES NAME OF THE & POSSIBLE HAZARD OR REASONS EMERGENCY 1 BOILER Over pressure (1) Burning in the boiler if (2) Physical safety valve injury not working. (3) Explosion Water level indicator not working. Low water level indicator fail. High temp. System fail. 2 ELECTRICITY (1). Burning (2). Fire (3). Shock ITS EFFECTS ON PERSONS, PROPERTY & ENVIRONMENT Minor/Major Injury Loss of human life Loss of property (Loss of Main/ Machine Material) Loose Burning, Shock, Death Contacts, Weak earthling Short Circuit Improper PLACE OF ITS EFFECT CONTROL MEASURES PROVIDED Boiler House and surrounding places Lower & Upper Level Indication System provision. Safety valves for pressure control fixed temp. & pressure indicator provided. Blow down & blowing system provided for cleaning tube and shell. Soft water used. Inter locking provided on pumps, FD fan, ID fan. Periodical checking & inspection maintenance done. Yearly inspection done by Boiler Inspector Surrounding the accident area Proper Earthing, Periodical Checking of joints, proper insulations of Equipments, etc. Flame proof fitting in solvent storage area, bounding and jumpers to all solvent barrier lines provided. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 284 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Insulation 3 Bad House Physical / Chemical Thermal HOUSE Burn Injury (Major / Minor) KEEPING keeping (1). Physical (2). Buring (3) Fire (4) Chemical Exposure In all surrounding areas i.e. Storage, Plants Proper Handling, regular cleaning, Proper placement of material (RIGHT THING AT THE RIGHT PLACE) 4 PIPE LINE Leakages of Physical / Chemical Thermal pipe line due Burn Injury (Major / Minor) LEAKAGES Spillages to corrosion, etc. Loose contact (1) Corrosion etc. (2) Toxic gas release Plant area Proper maintenance, Proper Selection of Material for pipe lines, Immediate attention, Earthing provided, flame proof fitting, NO SMOKING Boards displayed. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 285 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 6 HEALTH & SAFETY MEASURES For handling hazardous chemicals and to take care of employees’ health, M/s. Tridev Industries shall adopt a practice of preventive and predictive maintenance looking to the nature of hazardous chemicals being handled / processed. All the equipments in the plant areas shall be inspected/ tested by an outside agency. The various safety equipments like breathing apparatus and critical instrumentation provided on various equipments will be inspected and tested frequently to ensure their operability all the time. Besides, all the first aid, fire fighting devices shall also be inspected, tested and maintained by a competent third party and kept all the time in ready to use condition. Health of all the employees in plant area shall regularly monitor by outside physician. If any abnormality shall found necessary treatment shall be given. Necessary history cards, records will be maintained and up-dated time to time. Some of the safety measures shall carry out by M/s. Tridev Industries. to ensure prevention of occupational hazards is delineated below. ¾ Flameproof equipments and fittings will be provided for handling of hazardous chemicals. ¾ Tanks and all pump motors shall be earthed. ¾ Road tanker earthing lines shall provide near the unloading pumps. ¾ Independent dykes will provide for hazardous chemicals storage to contain leakages. Floors of the dyke area shall of impervious finish. ¾ Housekeeping of the plant shall as per prescribed norms. Floors, platforms, staircases, passages will be kept free of any obstruction. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 286 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. ¾ All hazardous operations shall explain to the workers. They will periodically trained on the hazardous processes. ¾ Dedicated supply of firewater shall available in the plant. ¾ Only authorized persons shall be allowed inside the plant. ¾ All instrument and safety devices will be checked and calibrated during installation. They will also be calibrated, checked at a frequent interval. Calibration records shall maintain. ¾ All electrical equipments will be installed as per prescribed standards. ¾ All the equipments of the plant shall periodically tested as per standard and results shall documented. All equipments undergo preventive maintenance schedule. ¾ The area will fence to isolate the same from all other departments. ¾ Proper Earthing will be provided to each tank. Also earthing would be taken care during solvent transfer from tanker into the underground vessel. ¾ Flame arrestors shall provide on each tank. ¾ Flameproof pumps & motors shall provide for solvent transfer. ¾ D.G. Set will be available which can supply power in case of grid power failure. ¾ In addition to fire hydrant system, nos. of fire extinguishers will be installed at different locations within premises. ¾ Adequate ventilation arrangement shall provide for safe and better working in the plant as per the standard. ¾ Process, equipments, plant involving serious fire hazards are designed as per prescribed guideline. ¾ Sufficient access for firefighting shall provide in the plant. ¾ Protection against lightning will be taken care in the plant. ¾ Precautions against ignition will be taken. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 287 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. ANTIDOTES OF CHEMICALS Sr. No. Name of Chemical Antidotes 1 Formaldehyde Milk, Activated Charcoal or water 2 Caustic Soda Lye (48%) Apply Water 3 Xylene Wash the skin area plenty of water if affected. Fresh air or Oxygen, 0.1 mg/kg slowly through injection rest in bed. Don’t apply Epinefrin, Ifridin etc. Don’t apply milk, vegetable oil or alcohol. 4 Sodium Hydroxide Wash with plenty of water if eyes or skin is affected. Do not give chemical antidotes because it increases heat and injury with reaction. Do not induce vomiting. Milk, Lemon Water or milk of magnesia can be given. 5 Xylene Skin is affected then washes with plenty of water. Administer Oxygen in case of breathing operation. Diazepam 0.1 mg /Kg, bed rest. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 288 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 7 OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH SCHEME FOR THE WORKERS M/s. Tridev industries shall carry out following occupational health scheme for workers; • Personal protective equipment such as safety shoes, safety goggles, hand gloves, gum boots, safety helmet, air line mask, Breathing Apparatus set kit have been given to each workers & staff and additional PPE’s are kept in all related area, Fire fighting facilities, etc.. • Safety awareness training programmes are arranged regularly for staff & contractor workers working in the factory premises. • On site – Off site emergency plan shall be available. • Medical Examination as per GFR guidelines • Work Permit system procedure shall be adopted. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 289 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 8 RISK REDUCTION MEASURES TRAINING AND EDUCATION OF EMPLOYEES: Safety awareness training programmes are arranged regularly and safety-training programme are also arranged for workers & staff working in the factory premises. M/s. Tridev Industries shall give training on the following subjects; ¾ Accident Prevention Technique ¾ Basic fire fighting ¾ Use of Respiration PPE ¾ Handling of Hazardous chemicals ¾ First Aid program ¾ Breathing Apparatus practical programme ¾ General safety regulation ¾ Work Permit system ¾ Electrical safety ¾ On site emergency plan training ¾ MSDS Awareness Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 290 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Once in a month workmen shall be grouped together & practical classes shall be held to train them how to operate various types of fire extinguisher to wear the mask, SCBA apparatus, use of cylinder handling kits. Usefulness of each part of the chlorine kits is also explained. Fire dill is also conducted regularly. Personal protective equipment such as safety shoes, safety googles, hand gloves, gum boots, safety helmet have been given to each workers & staff. RISK REDUCTION MEASURES: Design: • Plant operator and staffs shall be selected well experience and qualified for chemical plant operation. • All key personals shall be trained for emergency handling procedures and regular Mock Drills will be conducted on various scenarios. • At design stage adequate care shall be taken for design, selection, fabrication, erection and commissioning of facilities and other equipment piping, pipe fittings, electrical equipment etc. Safety Devices at Storage Tanks: • Level gauge on storage tank. • Static bonding of pipeline flanges. • Dyke wall shall be provided above ground storage tank. • Safety valve rupture and other venting system will be provided on pressure storage vessels. • All pumps shall be provided flame proof type and double mechanical seal type. • All pipeline and tanks shall be painted as per IS color code. • Caution note and material identification, capacity will be displayed on all storage tanks. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 291 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Safety at Pumps: • Required outlet valve and NRV provided on pump outlet. • Modular fire extinguisher shall be provided near of most of pumps. • FLP type and mechanical seal type pump will be installed for flammable chemicals. Safety at Pipelines: • Jumper connections on flanges to prevent build up of static electricity charge. • Proper supports and clamping are provided. • Double earthing provided to all electrical motors. • Color code as per IS standard will be maintained. Safety during Operation & maintenance: • Periodic testing of hoses for leakages and continuity. • Earthing of all plant equipment and earthing of all vehicles of vehicles under unloading operation. • Annual testing of all safety relief valves. • Planned preventive maintenance of different equipment of their safety and reliable operations. • • Strict compliance of safety work permits system. • Proper maintenance of earth pits. Periodic training and refresher courses to train the staff in safety, fire fighting and first aid. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 292 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 9 FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEM M/s. Tridev Industries. Will take into consideration fire prevention measures during the project expansion planning to avoid any outbreak of fire. But looking to the hazardous nature of process and the chemicals that are handled and processed, the chances of outbreak of fire cannot be totally ignored. Hence to tackle such a situation a good well laid fire protection system will be provided in the factory. Overhead water tank storage capacity: 50 KL Underground water tank storage capacity: 50 KL No. of Fire Sand Storage: 25 No. The unit will provide fire extinguishers based on probability and type of fire hazards at strategic locations. The unit will install approximately 25 fire extinguishers (Dry powder type) to tackle the fire hazards of Class A, B & C at different levels of the plant. The unit will also provide fire protection arrangements in the form of fixed water spray system (1 No.) and fire hydrant systems (2 Nos.) to tackle any fire emergency arising due to storage of hazardous chemicals. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 293 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 10 HAZARDS IDENTIFICATION, MAJOR HAZARDS & DAMAGE CRITERIA HAZARDS IDENTIFICATION: Hazard is defined as a chemical or physical condition that has a potential of causing damage to the people, property or the environment. Hazard identification is the first step in the risk analysis and entails the process of collecting information on: • • • • The types and quantities of hazardous substances stored and handled, The location of storage tanks & other facilities, potential hazards associated with the spillage and release of hazardous Chemicals. Hazard is the associated term with material, which is a measure or the likely hood of the damage to human working with, or studying the material in question. The potential hazard and major risks associated with the plant will be identified using Hazard & operability study (HAZOP). MAJOR HAZARDS: A brief description of the following hazards generally encountered in handling hazardous chemicals is given in the section. • • • • • • • Pool Evaporation Vapor Cloud Explosion Vapor Cloud Dispersion Pool Fire Jet Fire BLEVE Toxic Release Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 294 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Pool Evaporation If the fluid, which escapes from containment, is a liquid, then vaporization must occur before a vapor cloud is formed. The rate at which vaporization takes place determines the formation of such a vapor clouds. Vaporization scenarios Vaporization can occur when there is a leak in any of the following situations: a) A liquid at atmospheric temperature and pressure. b) A liquid under pressure and above normal boiling point. The rates of vaporization of the liquid are different for each of the two cases. In the case • • The liquid after spillage is approximately at equilibrium and evaporates relativity slowly. In the case, the liquid flashes off when released, and the liquid remaining then undergoes slow evaporation. (I) Evaporation of a liquid at atmospheric temperature and pressure. Evaporation from a pool of liquid is essentially a mass transfer process that depends on the vapor pressure of the liquid, wind velocity across the surface of the pool and ambient weather condition. A spillage of this kind constitutes a steady continuous source of vapor. Unless the rate of evaporation due to the combination of vapor pressure and wind velocity is high enough, it is usually assumed that the heat transfer from the air and the ground is sufficient to provide the latent heat of vaporization. (II) Evaporation of a liquid under pressure and above normal boiling point When a pressurized liquid is released from containment a portion flashes off. This heat is obtained by cooling the remaining liquid to its boiling point thus reaching a state of equilibrium from the high in equilibrium prevalent immediately on loss of containment. In practice, it frequently happens that there is a significant amount of spray formation caused by the sudden release of pressure and the violent boiling of liquid. This spray vaporizes rapidly by taking heat for vaporization from air. This spray liquid formation is assumed to equal to the gas fraction generated by flash. The proportion of liquid airborne is thus considerably high. Following flashing, the residual liquid is at its boiling point. Vaporization then continuous by gaining heat from surrounding as an essentially heat or mass transfer limited process. This secondary stage of rate limited vaporization is usually relatively less Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 295 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. important compared with the flash off, particularly with respect to formation of flammable gas clouds. Vapor Cloud dispersion Following a continuous leak and formation of gas cloud, if cloud does not ignite it undergoes atmospheric dispersion in accordance with the prevalent wind direction, speed and stability category. The objective of carrying out analysis of cloud dispersion is two fold. First, it provides the distance (from the leak) at which the concentration of flammable material falls below the lower flammability limit (LEL). Second it provides the concentration of the toxic substance to which people may be exposed for short time, at varying distance (from the leak). Vapor cloud Explosion Release of energy in a rapid and uncontrolled manner gives rise to explosion. Identified locations having explosion hazards shall in tank farm and storage area (warehouse). Extra care shall be taken by providing rupture disc, Pressure release valve, and temperature controller. In addition to that Fire and explosion hazard will identified as catastrophic failure of storage tanks in solvent storage yard. Explosion is a sudden and violent- release of energy which may be in the form of physical energy or chemical energy. In case where a major leak continues from some time without ignition a substantial mass of the gas from a vapor of cloud which on finding a source of ignition may result in an vapor cloud explosion (VCE) before a cloud is diluted to the concentration below the lower explosion limit in air. The explosion will cause overpressure resulting in to damage to the surrounding area. Pool fire Since the Stone Age term 'fire' is associated with fear. It is very dangerous if occurs in uncontrolled manner. It should be clearly understood that when a liquid is used having flash point below the normal ambient temperature, it could, in suitable circumstances, liberate a sufficient quantity of vapour to give rise to flammable mixtures with air. Following an accidental release, chemicals will form either a confined pool within the bund area or an unconfined pool. Should the vapor above the pool ignite, the liquid will burn as a pool fire. The pool fire will result in thermal radiation. It cloud also damage all the storage tanks within the confined area of the dyke. In the present study, impact distances for various scenarios have been calculated. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 296 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Jet fire After a minor or major loss of containment following hardware failure, chemicals which are stored under high pressure would escape as liquid/ gas spray or jet which undergoes flashing evaporation and forms a dense flammable gas could in the air. The cloud, which initially moves forward in the spatial direction of the spray till the kinetic energy, is lost and gravity slumping of cloud occurs if the gas is heavier than the air. Should the flammable jet ignite very soon after development of leak? A jet fire will commence. The jet fire could damage the neighboring tanks by direct flame impingement. It would also cause thermal radiation in the surrounding area. Fire Ball / BLEVE Any fire in the vicinity of storage tank containing a liquefied gas may cause Boiling Expanding Vapor Explosion (BLEVE). Due to simultaneous increase of pressure as well as weakening of the material of the vessel because of a fire in the vicinity the tank. It may fail resulting in release of the entire inventory suddenly and result in a BLEVE and fireball. BLEVE results in serious thermal radiation to the plant equipment and surroundings. Damage may also result to the debris of the shattered vessel being thrown about. The major hazards in the M/s. Tridev Industries. are described below. • Toxic hazard due to leakage of hazardous chemicals. • Fire hazard due to leakage of flammable chemicals. • Electrical hazards due to the electrical major equipment/ machinery, operations, welding, motors, heavy lift devices, cabling, human intervention (short circuit possibility), maintenance work (due to machinery breakdown etc.), plant lighting related electrical hazards. • Possibility of human injury due to working with mechanical machines, manual handling etc. • Possibility of injury during chemicals handled, during operations and due to intoxication. • Major dropped objects hazard due to large number of physical handling steps / operations involved with crane/ overhead lifting/ hoisting equipment. • Fires in any part of the plant working areas – there is a possibility of rapid escalation if it is not brought under control quickly. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 297 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Toxic hazards Toxic substances affect in three ways by ingestion, absorption & inhalation. Adequate provision of safety along with personal protective equipment will be made, breathing apparatus and emergency kit shall be provided at various locations of the installation. Corrosion hazards Corrosion is a chemical reaction-taking place at the surface of metal. Corrosive chemicals have their typical hazard when it comes in contact with human tissues. Most corrosive substances will produce chemical burns, while certain chemical produce deep ulceration. Other has detailing effect on skin and may cause dermatitis. This has also adverse effects on weakening the strength of material in contact. M/s. Tridev Industries shall take due care to overcome the hazard. The complete structure of the manufacturing area shall be painted with special type of anticorrosive paint. Good quality materials will be used for transferring corrosives. Regular thickness testing of equipment, pipelines etc. shall carry out to have the exact picture of effect of corrosion. Biological hazards Effluent treatment process involves the biological activities so biological hazard’s can not be eliminated. The way of biological hazards is by hand to mouth contact during eating, drinking or by wiping the face with contaminated hands or gloves or by licking splashes from the skin or by breathing them in, as dust, aerosol or mist. The major source of biological hazard on site is biological sludge drying bed, filter press, biological storage sump etc. Practically, complete elimination of biological hazard can not be possible but it will be reduce by adopting the safe practice guards. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 298 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. DAMAGE CRITERIA: Damage estimates due to thermal radiations and overpressure have been arrived at by taking in to consideration the published literature on the subject. The consequences can then be visualized by the superimposing the damage effects zones on the proposed plan site and identifying the elements within the project site as well as in the neighboring environment, which might be adversely affected, should one or more hazards materialize in real life. In consequence analysis, use is made of a number of calculation models to estimate the physical effects of an accident (spill of hazardous material) and to predict the damage (lethality, injury, material destruction) of the effects. The calculations can roughly be divided in three major groups: a) Determination of the source strength parameters; b) Determination of the consequential effects; c) Determination of the damage or damage distances. The basic physical effect models consist of the following. Source strength parameters * Calculation of the outflow of liquid, vapour or gas out of a vessel or a pipe, in case of rupture. Also two-phase outflow can be calculated. * Calculation, in case of liquid outflow, of the instantaneous flash evaporation and of the dimensions of the remaining liquid pool. * Calculation of the evaporation rate, as a function of volatility of the material, pool dimensions and wind velocity. * Source strength equals pump capacities, etc. in some cases. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 299 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Consequential effects * Dispersion of gaseous material in the atmosphere as a function of source strength, relative density of the gas, weather conditions and topographical situation of the surrounding area. * Intensity of heat radiation [in kW/ m2] due to a fire or a BLEVE, as a function of the distance to the source. * Energy of vapour cloud explosions [in N/m2], as a function of the distance to the distance of the exploding cloud. * Concentration of gaseous material in the atmosphere, due to the dispersion of evaporated chemical. The latter can be either explosive or toxic. It may be obvious, that the types of models that must be used in a specific risk study strongly depend upon the type of material involved: - Gas, vapour, liquid, solid - Inflammable, explosive, toxic, toxic combustion products - Stored at high/low temperatures or pressure - Controlled outflow (pump capacity) or catastrophic failure? Selection of Damage Criteria The damage criteria give the relation between extent of the physical effects (exposure) and the percentage of the people that will be killed or injured due to those effects. The knowledge about these relations depends strongly on the nature of the exposure. For instance, much more is known about the damage caused by heat radiation, than about the damage due to toxic exposure, and for these toxic effects, the knowledge differs strongly between different materials. In Consequence Analysis studies, in principle three types of exposure to hazardous effects are distinguished: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 300 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 1. Heat radiation, from a jet, pool fire, a flash fire or a BLEVE. 2. Explosion 3. Toxic effects, from toxic materials or toxic combustion products. In the next three paragraphs, the chosen damage criteria are given and explained. Heat Radiation The consequence caused by exposure to heat radiation is a function of: 2 • The radiation energy onto the human body [kW/m ]; • The exposure duration [sec]; • The protection of the skin tissue (clothed or naked body). • The limits for 1% of the exposed people to be killed due to heat radiation, and for second-degree burns are given in the table herein: Damages to Human Life Due to Heat Radiation Exposure Radiation Duration 1% for Radiation lethality 2nd (kW/m2) for Radiation degree first for degree burns, (kW/m2) burns (kW/m2) 10 Sec 21.2 16 12.5 30 Sec 9.3 7.0 4.0 Since in practical situations, only the own employees will be exposed to heat radiation in case of a fire, it is reasonable to assume the protection by clothing. It can be assumed that people would be able to find a cover or a shield against thermal radiation in 10 sec. time. Furthermore, 100% lethality may be assumed for all people suffering Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 301 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. from direct contact with flames, such as the pool fire, a flash fire or a jet flame. The effects due to relatively lesser incident radiation intensity are given below. Effects Due To Incident Radiation Intensity RADIATION KW/m2 DAMAGE TO EQUIPMENT DAMAGE TO PEOPLE Equivalent to Solar Radiation 0.7 1.2 Solar heat at noon 1.6 *** No discomfort for long exposure , 2.0 PVC insulated cables damaged Minimum level of pain threshold *** 4.0 *** Causes pain if duration is longer than 20 secs. But blistering is unlikely. 6.4 *** Pain threshold reached after 8 secs. Second degree burns after 20 secs. 9.5 Minimum energy to ignite wood Minimum energy required for piloted ignition of wood, melting plastic tubing etc. Pain threshold reached after 8 sec. second degree burns after 20 sec. 12.5 With a flame; Melts plastic tubing. 1% lethality in one minute. First degree burns in 10 secs. 16.0 *** Severe burns after 5 secs. 25.0 Minimum energy to ignite wood at identifying long exposure without a flame. 100% lethality in 1 minute. Significant injury in 10 secs. 37.5 Severe damage to plant 100% lethality in 1 minute. 50% lethality in 20 secs. 1% lethality in 10 secs. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 302 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Explosion In case of vapour cloud explosion, two physical effects may occur: * a flash fire over the whole length of the explosive gas cloud; * a blast wave, with typical peak overpressures circular around ignition source. As explained above, 100% lethality is assumed for all people who are present within the cloud proper. For the blast wave, the lethality criterion is based on: * A peak overpressure of 0.1 bar will cause serious damage to 10% of the housing/structures. * Falling fragments will kill one of each eight persons in the destroyed buildings. The following damage criteria may be distinguished with respect to the peak overpressures resulting from a blast wave: FATAL RADIATION EXPOSURE LEVELS: RADIATION FATALITY LEVEL kW/m2 1% 50% 99% EXPOSURE IN SECONDS 4.0 150 370 930 12.5 30 80 200 37.5 8 20 50 Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 303 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Damage Due To Overpressures Peak Overpressure OVER PRESSURE mbar 300 Damage Type 0.83 bar Total Destruction 0.30 bar Heavy Damage 0.10 bar Moderate Damage 0.03 bar Significant Damage 0.01 bar Minor Damage MECHANICAL DAMAGE TO EQUIPMENTS DAMAGE TO PEOPLE 1% death from lung damage >50% eardrum damage Heavy damage to plant & structure 100 >50% serious wounds from flying objects >1% eardrum damage Repairable damage >1% serious wounds flying objects from 30 Major glass damage 10 10% glass damage Slight injury from flying glass *** Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 304 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. From this it may be concluded that p = 0.17 E+5 pa corresponds approximately with 1% lethality. Furthermore it is assumed that everyone inside an area in which the peak overpressure is greater than 0.17 E+5 pa will be wounded by mechanical damage. For the gas cloud explosion this will be inside a circle with the ignition source as its centre. Intoxication The consequences from inhalation of a toxic vapour/gas are determined by the toxic dose. This dose D is basically determined by: - Concentration of the vapour in air; - Exposure duration. Furthermore, of course, the breathing rates of the victim, as well as the specific toxic mechanism unto the metabolism play an important role. n The dose is defined as D = C .t, with: C = concentration of the toxic vapour, in [ppm] or [mg/m3]; t = exposure duration, in [sec] or [min]; n = exponent, mostly > 1.0; this exponent takes into account the fact that a high concentration over a short period results in more serious injury than a low concentration over a relatively longer period of exposure. The value of n should be greater than zero but less than 5. The given definition for D only holds if the concentration is more or less constant over the exposure time; this may be the case for a (semi) continuous source. In case of an instantaneous source, the concentration varies with time; the dose D must be calculated with an integral equation: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 305 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. D = ∫ Cn.dt For a number of toxic materials, so-called Vulnerability Models (V.M.) have been developed. The general equation for a V.M. (probit function) is: Pr = a + b.ln (Cn.t), with Pr = probit number, being a representation of the percentage of people suffering a certain kind of damage, for instance lethality Pr = 2.67 means 1% of the population; Pr = 5.00 means 50% of the population; a and b material dependent numbers; Cn.t = dose D, as explained above. The values for a and b are mostly derived from experiments with animals; occasionally, however, also human toxicity factors have been derived from accidents in past. In case only animal experiments are available, the inhalation experiments with rats seem to be best applicable for predicting the damage to people from acute intoxication. Although much research in this field have been done over the past decades, only for a limited number of toxic materials consequence models have been developed. Often only quite scarce information is available to predict the damage from an acute toxic exposition. Data transformation from oral intoxication data to inhalation toxicity criteria is sometimes necessary. Generally, in safety evaluations pessimistic assumptions are applied in these transformation calculations. The calculated damage (distance) may be regarded as a maximum. For the purposes of a response to a major incident, the IDLH value level has been chosen for the ‘wounded‘ criteria. This type of injury will require medical attention. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 306 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Toxic Effects: The effect of exposure to a toxic substance depends upon the duration of exposure and the concentration of the toxic substance. Short-term exposures to high concentration give Acute Effects while long term exposures to low concentrations result in Chronic Effects. Only Acute Effects are considered under hazard analysis, since they are likely credible scenarios. These effects are: a) Irritation (respiratory system skin, eyes) b) Narcosis (nervous system) c) Asphyxiation (oxygen deficiency) d) System damage (blood organs) Following are some of the common terms used to express toxicity of materials: TLV: Threshold Limit Value – is the permitted level of exposure for a given period on a weighted average basis (usually 8 hrs.for 5 days in a week). STEL: it is permitted Short Time Exposure Limit usually for a 15-minute exposure. IDLH: Immediately Dangerous To Life & Health LCLo: Lethal Concentration Low TCLo: Toxic Concentration Low Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 307 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. CHAPTER: 11 CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS & RISK ANALYSIS CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS In a plant handling hazardous chemicals, the main hazard arises due to storage, handling & use of these chemicals. If these chemicals are released into the atmosphere, they may cause damage due to resulting fires or vapour clouds. Blast Overpressures depend upon the reactivity class of material between two explosive limits. Operating Parameters Potential vapour release for the same material depends significantly on the operating conditions. Especially for any liquefied gas, the operating conditions are very critical to assess the damage potential. If we take up an example of ammonia, if it is stored at ambient temperature, say about 28oC, and then the vapour release potential of the inventory is much higher as compared to the case if it is stored at 0oC. Inventory Inventory Analysis is commonly used in understanding the relative hazards and short listing of release scenarios. Inventory plays an important role in regard to the potential hazard. Larger the inventory of a vessel or a system, larger the quantity of potential release. The potential vapour release (source strength) depends upon the quantity of liquid release, the properties of the materials and the operating conditions (pressure, temperature). If all these influencing parameters are combined into a matrix and vapour source strength estimated for each release case, a ranking should become a credible exercise. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 308 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Loss of Containment Plant inventory can get discharged to Environment due to Loss of Containment. Certain features of materials to be handled at the plant need to the clearly understood to firstly list out all significant release cases and then to short list release scenarios for a detailed examination. Liquid release can be either instantaneous or continuous. Failure of a vessel leading to an instantaneous outflow assumes the sudden appearance of such a major crack that practically all of the contents above the crack shall be released in a very short time. The more likely event is the case of liquid release from a hole in a pipe connected to the vessel. The flow rate is depending on the size of the hole as well as on the pressure, which was present, in front of the hole, prior to the accident. Such pressure is basically dependent on the pressure in the vessel. The vaporisation of released liquid depends on the vapour pressure and weather conditions. Such consideration and others have been kept in mind both during the initial listing as well as during the short listing procedure. In the study, Maximum Credible Loss accident methodology is to be used, therefore, the largest potential hazard inventories have been considered for consequence estimation. MAXIMUM CREDIBLE LOSS ACCIDENT SCENARIOS A Maximum Credible Accident (MCA) can be characterised as the worst credible accident. In other words: an accident in an activity, resulting in the maximum consequence distance that is still believed to be possible. A MCA‐analysis does not include a quantification of the probability of occurrence of the accident. Another aspect, in which the pessimistic approach of MCA studies appears, is the atmospheric condition that is used for dispersion calculations. As per the reference of the study, weather conditions having an average wind speed of 2.18 m/s have been chosen. The Maximum Credible Loss (MCL) scenarios have been developed for the Facility. The MCL cases considered, attempt to include the worst “Credible” incidents‐ what constitutes a credible incident is always subjective. Nevertheless, guidelines have evolved over the years and based Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 309 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. on basic engineering judgement, the cases have been found to be credible and modelling for assessing vulnerability zones is prepared accordingly. Only catastrophic cases have been considered and not partial or small failures (as is the case in Quantitative Risk Assessment where contributions from low frequency ‐ high outcome effect as well as high frequency ‐ low outcome events are distinguished). The objective of the study is emergency planning, hence only holistic & conservative assumptions are used for obvious reasons. Hence though the outcomes may look pessimistic, the planning for emergency concept should be borne in mind whilst interpreting the results. CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS CALCULATIONS The Consequence Analysis has been done for selected scenarios. This has been done for weather conditions having wind speed 2.18 m/s. In Consequence Analysis, geographical location of the source of potential release plays an important role. Consideration of a large number of scenarios in the same geographical location serves little purpose if the dominant scenario has been identified and duly considered. 6.7.3.1 SOFTWARE USED FOR CALCULATIONS Aloha 5.1.1.2 is the most comprehensive software available for performing Process Hazard Analysis (PHA), Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) and Financial Risk Analysis (FRA). Our extensively validated software for consequence and risk analysis is used by governments and industry helping them to comply with local safety regulation and their own corporate best practice. Aloha 5.1.1.2 contains all the discharge, dispersion, effects and risk models you will need to accurately assess all your major hazards and associated risks. Aloha 5.1.1.2 Consequence provides you with comprehensive hazard analysis facilities to examine the progress of a potential incident from the initial release to its far‐field effects. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 310 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 6.7.4 SCENARIOS TABLE ‐ 6.5 POSSIBLE ACCIDENT SCENARIOS AT M/s. Tridev Industries Scenario 1 MCL Scenario Release of Cyclohexanone Pressure & Temp. Stored qty in MT Normal Liq. At Rom 19.5 Temperature 2 Release of Formaldehyde Normal Liq. At Rom 37 Temperature 3 Release of Xylene Normal Liq. At Rom 0.2 Temperature 4 Release of N – Butryaldehyde Normal Liq. At Rom 05 Temperature 5 Release of Butanol Normal Liq. At Rom 10 Temperature Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 311 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 1. Release of Cyclohexanone (Pool Fire): SITE DATA: Location: Tridev Industries, Plot No. D-2 CH-134, GIDC, Dahej Building Air Exchanges per Hour: 0.69 (unsheltered double storied) Time: October 16, 2013 1410 hours MST (using computer's clock) CHEMICAL DATA: Chemical Name: CYCLOHEXANONE Molecular Weight: 98.14 g/mol PAC-1: 20 ppm PAC-2: 20 ppm PAC-3: 5000 ppm IDLH: 700 ppm LEL: 13000 ppm UEL: 94000 ppm Ambient Boiling Point: 311.2° F Vapor Pressure at Ambient Temperature: 0.0062 atm Ambient Saturation Concentration: 6,198 ppm or 0.62% ATMOSPHERIC DATA: (MANUAL INPUT OF DATA) Wind: 5.55 meters/second from ESE at 3 meters Ground Roughness: open country Air Temperature: 27° C No Inversion Height Cloud Cover: 5 tenths Stability Class: D Relative Humidity: 50% Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 312 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. SOURCE STRENGTH: Leak from hole in vertical cylindrical tank Flammable chemical escaping from tank (not burning) Tank Diameter: 3 meters Tank Length: 3 meters Tank Volume: 21.2 cubic meters Tank contains liquid Internal Temperature: 27° C Chemical Mass in Tank: 5,016 kilograms Tank is 25% full Circular Opening Diameter: 0.5 inches Opening is 5 inches from tank bottom Ground Type: Concrete Ground Temperature: equal to ambient Max Puddle Diameter: Unknown Release Duration: ALOHA limited the duration to 1 hour Max Average Sustained Release Rate: 2.38 pounds/min (Averaged over a minute or more) Total Amount Released: 82.0 pounds Note: The chemical escaped as a liquid and formed an evaporating puddle. The puddle spread to a diameter of 10.6 yards. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 313 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. THREAT ZONE: Threat Modeled: Flammable Area of Vapor Cloud Model Run: Gaussian Red : less than 10 meters(10.9 yards) --- (13000 ppm = LEL) Note: Threat zone was not drawn because effects of near-field patchiness make dispersion predictions less reliable for short distances. 2. Leak from Formaldehyde Tank: CHEMICAL DATA: Chemical Name: FORMALDEHYDE LEL: 7 ppm Molecular Weight: 30.00 g/mol UEL: 73 ppm Normal Boiling Point: 204.8° F Note: Not enough chemical data to use Heavy Gas option ATMOSPHERIC DATA: (MANUAL INPUT OF DATA) Wind: 5.5 meters/second from ESE at 3 meters Ground Roughness: open country Air Temperature: 27° C No Inversion Height Cloud Cover: 5 tenths Stability Class: D Relative Humidity: 50% Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 314 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. SOURCE STRENGTH: Direct Source: 100 kilograms/sec Source Height: 0 Release Duration: 60 minutes Release Rate: 13,200 pounds/min Total Amount Released: 793,664 pounds THREAT ZONE: Model Run: Gaussian Red : greater than 6 miles --- (10 mg/(cu m)) Orange: greater than 6 miles --- (10 ppm) THREAT AT POINT: Concentration Estimates at the point: Downwind: 100 meters Off Centerline: 100 meters Note: Concentration not drawn because there is no significant concentration at the point selected. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 315 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. 3. Leak from XYLENE Tank: CHEMICAL DATA: Chemical Name: XYLENE Molecular Weight: 106.17 g/mol AEGL-1 (60 min): 130 ppm AEGL-2 (60 min): 920 ppm AEGL-3 (60 min): 2500 ppm LEL: 10000 ppm UEL: 70000 ppm Normal Boiling Point: -unavailNote: Not enough chemical data to use Heavy Gas option ATMOSPHERIC DATA: (MANUAL INPUT OF DATA) Wind: 5.5 meters/second from ESE at 3 meters Ground Roughness: open country Air Temperature: 27° C No Inversion Height Cloud Cover: 5 tenths Stability Class: D Relative Humidity: 50% SOURCE STRENGTH: Direct Source: 100 kilograms/sec Source Height: 0 Release Duration: 60 minutes Release Rate: 13,200 pounds/min Total Amount Released: 793,664 pounds Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 316 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. THREAT ZONE: Model Run: Gaussian Red : 413 yards --- (2500 ppm = AEGL-3 (60 min)) Orange: 729 yards --- (920 ppm = AEGL-2 (60 min)) Yellow: 1.4 miles --- (130 ppm = AEGL-1 (60 min)) 4. Leakages from Butryaldehyde Tank : CHEMICAL DATA: Chemical Name: BUTYRALDEHYDE Molecular Weight: 72.11 g/mol PAC-1: 0.0014 ppm PAC-2: 0.016 ppm PAC-3: 2.8 ppm LEL: 19000 ppm UEL: 125000 ppm Ambient Boiling Point: 166.2° F Vapor Pressure at Ambient Temperature: 0.16 atm Ambient Saturation Concentration: 165,089 ppm or 16.5% ATMOSPHERIC DATA: (MANUAL INPUT OF DATA) Wind: 5.5 meters/second from ESE at 3 meters Ground Roughness: open country Air Temperature: 27° C No Inversion Height Cloud Cover: 5 tenths Stability Class: D Relative Humidity: 50% Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 317 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. SOURCE STRENGTH: Leak from hole in vertical cylindrical tank Flammable chemical is burning as it escapes from tank Tank Diameter: 3.0 meters Tank Length: 3.0 meters Tank Volume: 21.2 cubic meters Tank contains liquid Internal Temperature: 27° C Chemical Mass in Tank: 5000 kilograms Tank is 30% full Circular Opening Diameter: 0.5 meters Opening is 10 inches from tank bottom Max Flame Length: 30 yards Burn Duration: 4 minutes Max Burn Rate: 4,840 pounds/min Total Amount Burned: 7,937 pounds Note: The chemical escaped as a liquid and formed a burning puddle. The puddle spread to a diameter of 31 yards. THREAT ZONE: Threat Modeled: Thermal radiation from pool fire Red : 63 yards --- (10.0 kW/(sq m) = potentially lethal within 60 sec) Orange: 81 yards --- (5.0 kW/(sq m) = 2nd degree burns within 60 sec) Yellow: 113 yards --- (2.0 kW/(sq m) = pain within 60 sec) Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 318 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. THREAT AT POINT: Thermal Radiation Estimates at the point: Downwind: 100 meters Off Centerline: 100 meters Max Thermal Radiation: 0.907 kW/(sq m) 5. Leakages from Tank of Butyl Alcohol: : CHEMICAL DATA: Chemical Name: N-BUTYL ALCOHOL PAC-1: 20 ppm PAC-2: 50 ppm IDLH: 1400 ppm LEL: 17000 ppm Molecular Weight: 74.12 g/mol PAC-3: 8000 ppm UEL: 113000 ppm Ambient Boiling Point: 245.7° F Vapor Pressure at Ambient Temperature: 0.010 atm Ambient Saturation Concentration: 10,335 ppm or 1.03% ATMOSPHERIC DATA: (MANUAL INPUT OF DATA) Wind: 5.5 meters/second from ESE at 3 meters Ground Roughness: open country Air Temperature: 27° C No Inversion Height Cloud Cover: 5 tenths Stability Class: D Relative Humidity: 50% Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 319 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. SOURCE STRENGTH: Leak from hole in vertical cylindrical tank Flammable chemical escaping from tank (not burning) Tank Diameter: 2.5 meters Tank Length: 3.0 meters Tank Volume: 14.7 cubic meters Tank contains liquid Internal Temperature: 27° C Chemical Mass in Tank: 10 tons Tank is 77% full Circular Opening Diameter: 0.5 meters Opening is 1 feet from tank bottom Ground Type: Default soil Ground Temperature: equal to ambient Max Puddle Diameter: Unknown Release Duration: ALOHA limited the duration to 1 hour Max Average Sustained Release Rate: 73.5 pounds/min (averaged over a minute or more) Total Amount Released: 4,324 pounds Note: The chemical escaped as a liquid and formed an evaporating puddle. The puddle spread to a diameter of 55 yards. Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 320 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Source Strength of Cyclohexanone: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 321 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Source strength – Burn rate of Butryaldehyde: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 322 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Thermal Radiation of Butryaldehyde: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 323 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Thermal Radiation – Threat Zone of Butryaldehyde: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 324 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Toxic Threat Zone of Butanol: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 325 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Xylene – Source strength – Release Rate: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 326 Risk Assessment Study Report of Tridev Industries at Plot No.D-2/CH/134, GIDC Estate, Dahej, Ta – Vagra, Dist –Bharuch, Gujarat. Xylene – Direct – Release Rate: Prepared By M/s. Bhagwati Enviro Care Pvt Ltd. 327 Annexure: 02 National Ambient Air Quality Standards Annexure 2 of M/s. Tridev Industries. 328 Annexure: 02 National Ambient Air Quality Standards Annexure 2 of M/s. Tridev Industries. 329 Annexure: 03 Drinking Water Quality Standards DRINKING WATER QUALITY STANDARDS AS PER IS NO. 10500 (1991) Substance or characteristics Colour Hazen units Odour Taste Turbidity NTU, Maximum PH Total Hardness (as CaCO3) mg/l Iron (as Fe) mg/l Chlorides (as Cl) mg/l Residual Free Chlorine, mg/l Dissolved Solids, mg/l Calcium (as Ca) mg/l Magnesium (as Mg), mg/l Copper (as Cu), mg/l Manganese (as Mn), mg/l Sulphate (as SO4), mg/l Nitrate (as NO2 mg/l) Fluoride (as F), mg/l Phenolic Compound, mg/l Mercury, mg/l Cadmium, mg/l Selenium, mg/l Arsenic, mg/l Cyanide, mg/l Lead, mg/l Zinc, mg/l Anionic detergent, mg/l Chromium (as Cr+6), mg/l Polynuclear Aromatic Hydrocarbons, mg/l Mineral Oil, mg/l Pesticides, mg/l Radioactive materials 1 Alpha emitters Bq/l 2. Beta emitters Bq/l Alkalinity, mg/l Aluminum, mg/l Boron , , mg/l Annexure 3 of M/s. Tridev Industries. Permissible Limit 25 Unobjectionable Agreeable 10 6.5-8.5 600 1 1000 0.2 2000 200 100 1.5 0.3 400 100 1.5 0.002 0.001 0.01 0.01 0.05 0.05 0.05 5 0.2 0.05 -0.03 0.001 0.1 1 600 0.2 5 330 Annexure: 04 National Ambient Noise Quality standards NATIONAL AMBIENT NOISE QUALITY STANDARDS (CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD, INDIA) Area code A B C D Category of areas Industrial Area Commercial Area Residential Area Silence zone Leq in db(A) Day time Night Time 75 70 65 55 55 45 50 40 Note: 1) Daytime is reckoned in between 6 am and 10 pm 2) Night time is reckoned in between 10 pm and 6 am 3) Silence zone is defined as areas upto 100 meters around such premises as hospitals, educational institutes and courts. The silence zones are to be declared by the competent authority. 4) Mixed categories of areas should be declared as one of the four above mentioned categories by the competent authority and the corresponding standards shall apply. Annexure 4 of M/s. Tridev Industries. 331 Annexure: 05 SSI Certificate SSI Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries 332 Annexure: 06 CA Certificate CA Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 333 Annexure: 07 Undertaking Undertaking of M/s. Tridev Industries. 334 Annexure: 08 Proof of water supply Proof of Water supply for M/s. Tridev Industries. 335 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 336 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 337 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 338 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 339 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 340 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 341 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 342 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 343 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 344 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 345 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 346 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 347 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 348 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 349 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 350 Annexure: 09 Land Possession Documents Land Possession Documents of M/s. Tridev Industries. 351 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 352 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 353 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 354 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 355 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 356 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 357 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 358 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 359 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 360 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 361 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 362 Annexure: 10 Treatability Study Report Treatability Study Report of M/s. Tridev Industries. 363 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 364 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 365 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 366 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 367 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 368 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 369 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 370 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 371 Annexure: 11 Adequacy Certificate Annexure 11 : Adequacy Certificate of M/s. Tridev Industries. 372 Annexure: 12 NOC application copy for TSDF & CHWIF Membership Annexure 12 of M/s. Tridev Industries. 373