Häggström hävdar Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion

Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
0
Ещё
Стр. 1
Следующий блог»
Создать блог
Войти
Häggström hävdar
En medborgare och matematiker ger synpunkter på samhällsfrågor, litteratur och vetenskap.
ti sd a ge n de n 26 : e no ve mb er 20 13
Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable
pawn promotion
That chess is simultaneously art, science and sport is an oft-repeated claim with a
great deal of truth in it. In my two recent blog posts about the recent world
championship match in which the young Norwegian chess genius Magnus Carlsen
defeated reigning champion Viswanathan Anand, I emphasized the sports aspect of
chess. To make up for this one-sidedness, I am happy to publish the following guest
post, in which my friend and colleague Johan Wästlund (known to regular readers
of this blog from the posts Back to basics and Om schack och matematik)
demonstrates some more artistic aspects of the game.
I am sure most readers know that the rules of chess allows a player whose pawn
reaches the eighth and final rank to promote the pawn to a queen. What perhaps
not all of you know is that the player may alternatively choose to promote the
pawn to one of the lesser pieces: rook, bishop or knight. Doing so may sound silly,
because the queen is known as the strongest piece, and indeed such minor
promotions occur only rarely in tournament chess, but there are exceptional
situations where they make good sense. Please enjoy Johan's exploration of some of
these cases! /OH
***
A remarkable pawn promotion
Johan Wästlund
The evening's first batch of coffee was almost ready, and in the thirsty crowd, T had
found a victim. After a course for aspiring tournament referees, he now knew
everything about "insufficient material". B, who felt he knew how the pieces move,
found himself listening to a lecture about the rules of chess.
"So you mean", said B with a slightly disturbed but still amused voice, "that if my
flag falls in an ending King + Bishop versus King + Bishop, then with bishops of the
same color the game is drawn, but with opposite colors, I lose?"
Om mig
Olle Häggström
Medborgare och
matematiker. Professor
i matematisk statistik
på Chalmers. Författare
till bl.a. Slumpens skördar
(Studentlitteratur, 2004) och Riktig
vetenskap och dåliga imitationer
(Fri Tanke, 2008). Nås enklast på
olleh@chalmers.se
Visa hela min profil
Bloggarkiv
► 2014 (4)
▼ 2013 (105)
► december (8)
▼ november (8)
Guest post by Johan Wästlund:
A remarkable pawn pr...
Verdens beste Carlsen!
Mitt föredrag i Falkenberg om
naturvetenskapens vä...
Halvtid i Chennai
Läsvärd bok om
högerpopulismen
Hofstadter!
Schemaläggningskrock
Om rekreationellt kontra
reproduktivt sex
► oktober (9)
► september (9)
"That's right, same color is insufficient material, you can't construct a sequence of
legal moves leading to checkmate."
► augusti (11)
"But with opposite colored bishops, I could in theory put my king in a corner of the
color of my opponent's bishop, and block one of the flight squares with mine. Like
this." He quickly set up the following position on one of the analysis boards:
► juni (7)
► juli (10)
► maj (9)
► april (9)
► mars (9)
► februari (8)
► januari (8)
► 2012 (109)
► 2011 (53)
Senaste kommentarer
Olle Häggström on viktigt att
veta om vetenskap
En fråga? Jag räknar till... få se...
(more)
Anonymous on viktigt att veta om
vetenskap
Tack. Precis vad jag tänkte säga i
en...(more)
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28
Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
"Because of that possibility, if my flag falls I have lost the game. That's ridiculous!"
T went on with the other endings of one piece each, knight against knight, bishop
or rook, bishop against rook (where it turns out the bishop can't win).
"You also lose with a pawn against a piece", he continued, unable to conceal his
excitement.
"Aha, because I could promote to a knight or maybe a bishop, and then corner my
king. That's the silliest use of under-promotion I've ever heard of!"
The moment he pronounced the word "under-promotion", the problemist G entered
the discussion. G's favorite topic was helpmates, but under-promotion would do.
"In fact there are only two possible motives for promotion to bishop or rook", he
explained, "at least if one excludes things like ridiculing one's opponent. One is
offensive, to avoid stalemating the opponent in a winning position. The other is
defensive, to draw by getting stalemated. You see, except when it comes to
stalemate, a queen will be at least as good as a rook or a bishop." He showed them
a rare example of a serious under-promotion, the famous game Bremel - Kertis,
Budapest 1948:
Стр. 2
efterslantare i
Hm, Tottenham... tänkte inte på
det!
Olle Häggström on viktigt att
veta om vetenskap
Tack för din kommentar, Kjell.
Jag...(more)
Anonymous on viktigt att veta om
vetenskap
Jag såg hela filmen från
Falkenberg och...(more)
bosjo on skarpsinnig efterslantare
i
Åkej; vi lägger fråga 2 åt sidan -med...(more)
Olle Häggström on skarpsinnig
efterslantare i
Fråga 1: Det bror på vad som
menas med...(more)
Widgets by Tips for New Bloggers
Sabine Hossenfelder
Shooting strings
38 minuter sedan
Practical Ethics
Three Arguments Against the
Belgian Child Euthanasia Bill
Criticised
2 timmar sedan
Lars Wilderäng
25% höjda avgifter i ny
bostadsrättsförening
2 timmar sedan
Patrik Lindenfors
Livet börjar vid den första snön
2 timmar sedan
Lars Grahn
"In this position, White won with 1. a8R+! Kb4, 2. Rb8+ Kc3 3. Rxb1. If the rook had
been a queen, Black would have been stalemated at this point."
Wijk aan Zee – rond 2
10 timmar sedan
"The defensive motive, getting oneself stalemeted, is even more exotic. It's been
demonstrated numerous times in problems and studies, like this one by Traxler and
Dedrle from 1909:"
Robin Hanson
Tech Regs Are Coming
11 timmar sedan
IEET
Personhood Beyond the Human:
On Posthuman Personhood
11 timmar sedan
Paul Krugman
The Anti-Scientific Revolution in
Macroeconomics
14 timmar sedan
Timothy Gowers
Introduction to Cambridge IA
Analysis I 2014
1 dag sedan
Eric Schwitzgebel
Skeptical Fog vs. Real Fog
2 dagar sedan
"White draws with 1. Ra2+ Kxa2 2. Bxf7+ Qxf7 3. g8B! Rxf8 stalemate. But the
defensive under-promotion is a unicorn of chess. Easy to imagine, yet nobody has
seen a real one! Amazing, isn't it? Not a single defensive under-promotion is known
from the millions of recorded games of chess history."
"The most spectacular demonstrations of under-promotion are the realizations of
the so-called Babson theme..."
And here he was interrupted by P, who reminded everyone that it was six o'clock
and the games were about to start. It turned out that B was playing white against T.
Their game became the longest of the evening, and when it was about to be
decided, a small crowd had gathered in silence around the table. Black would
clearly queen first, but his other race, that agianst the clock, was less certain.
Karim Jebari
Frige Lucy, Himlen och
Diamanterna!
2 dagar sedan
Uppsalainitiativet
"Klimatskeptiker" gör bort sig
2 dagar sedan
bosjo
Verkligheten är större
3 dagar sedan
Ekonomistas
Orättvis rättvisesyn
3 dagar sedan
Less Wrong
The mechanics of my recent
productivity
4 dagar sedan
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28
Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
Стр. 3
Curie
Ännu en runda i GM-karusellen
4 dagar sedan
Kristen opinion
En vandring till Betlehem
5 dagar sedan
What If?
T-rex Calories
6 dagar sedan
RealClimate
A Bit More Sensitive…
1 vecka sedan
Björn Bengtsson
In this position the game continued 61. b6 c1Q 62. b7 Qc5+ 63. Ka8 Qc6 64. a7. T
now realized he would have had mate in two with 64. - Qh1 65. Kb8 Qh8 if not the
stupid bishop had blocked the eighth rank. So he decided to get it out of the way.
64. - Be7 65. Kb8. With time running out, T had already forgotten his plan and was
thinking about 65. - Bd6+, but didn't see how to continue after 66. Ka8. So instead
the game went 65. - Qc7+ 66. Ka8. A few minutes later in the calm of the analysis
room, he would realize not only that the back-rank mate had still been possible
with 65. - Qd6+ 66. Ka8 Qd5 and 67. - Qg8, but also that after 65. - Bd6+ 66. Ka8
Qa6 67. b8Q+ Bxb8, the idea that White gets yet another queen is an illusion.
Tre dystopiska actionrullar
2 veckor sedan
Christian Munthe
This Was Philosophical Comment
2013
2 veckor sedan
Katja Grace
Discussions for information
2 veckor sedan
Anders Sandberg
Pardon, but is this reciprocal?
2 veckor sedan
Tom Murphy
A Physics-Based Diet Plan
3 veckor sedan
Thore Husfeldt
In the 1950s, w…
4 veckor sedan
Thomas Svensson
Tanklös satsning på
kongressanläggning?
4 veckor sedan
Ekologistas
With only seconds left for the entire game, T was jumping up and down in his chair.
How could it be so difficult to finish the opponent off with queen and bishop
against a couple of silly pawns? He finally sighed and realized he might have to
settle for a draw. With a helpless look on his face, he took a last glance at the
clock, 3, 2, 1 second left. And played 66. - Qc8+.
Only at this point did B realize he might actually promote one of his pawns. With his
last move, Black was clearly offering a draw, but the gentleman he was, B would
still not miss an opportunity of a little prank. He reached out for the white queen,
but with his eyes still focused on the board, accidentally pushed her over the edge
of the table. She bounced through the little crowd and disappeared under a chair.
Never mind. For the desired effect, the move would have to be played instantly. B
put one of his rooks upside down on b8, removed his b-pawn, and pressed the clock.
With his hands flying nervously all over the board, T knocked his own king over,
picked it up and managed to put it on d8, but the clock was already flashing with a
row of zeros on Black's side.
Effektdeklarera energi
4 veckor sedan
Magnus Westerstrand
Konspirationsteoretiker
konspirerar om
klimatförändringarna
5 veckor sedan
Gil Kalai
Many triangulated three-spheres!
1 månad sedan
Aron Vallinder
Recent reads
4 månader sedan
Bo Jonsson
Avfolkning och loserstämpel
5 månader sedan
George Dvorsky
How Much Longer Until Humanity
Becomes A Hive Mind?
7 månader sedan
The dullest blog in the world
Going for a walk
8 månader sedan
Anders Emretsson
På resa med Arbetet
11 månader sedan
Vetenskap och Folkbildning
Årets utmärkelser 2012: God
journalistik avgörande för
folkbildningen
1 år sedan
David Sumpter m fl
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28
Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
Стр. 4
"I seem to have lost on time", he confessed, but all of a sudden recalled what he
had learnt in the weekend.
"No, wait, it's a draw because of insufficient material!"
The following conversation was a bit confused. Some spectator argued that a rook
upside down is a generally accepted substitute for a queen, while another pointed
out that even a rook is sufficient material. Meanwhile, T tried to explain that since
no sequence of legal moves can lead from the current position to one where the
black king is checkmated, the game is drawn even though Black's flag has fallen.
They were interrupted by G, the problemist. "I'll be darned! Gentlemen..."
As he spoke, he swiftly turned the rook on b8 back to its normal orientation and, as
the club's chairperson S had joined the group, continued:
"...and ladies, this moment goes to history. For centuries, problemists and study
composers have thought that the only motives for promotion to rook or bishop are
forcing or avoiding stalemate. But tonight our friend B has demonstrated, with his
extraordinary 66:th move, that there is another motive: retaining sufficient
material."
"In the final position, with White to move after Black overstepping time, White has
sufficient material because on the forced continuation 67. Rxc8+, Black has the
legal move 67. - Kd7 after which he can in principle be checkmated. Had the rook
on b8 been a queen, the only legal continuation would have been 67. Qxc8+ Kxc8
stalemate, and therefore 66. - Kd8 would have ended the game. The manoeuver
Be7 - Kd8 was brilliant too, and would have saved the game against..."
"I don't quite follow", said B, eager to get some coffee and gossip about the other
games of the evening, "but in any case the position is dead drawn, everyone can see
that."
With those words he shook T's hand, signed the protocol saying 1/2-1/2, and went
to the analysis room, unaware of his unique contribution to chess history.
Epilogue
As the problemist G realized later that evening, there is yet another motive for
under-promotion, that of forcing insufficient material. A while later, he published a
strange little chess problem, clearly inspired by that evening's events:
The task was unusual: Draw in 1 move.
Acknowledgments
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28
Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
Стр. 5
This story was inspired by the wonderful people and events that happened or might
have happened at the chess club LASS, Linköping, around ten years ago. While there
is no clear correspondence between characters and real people, similarities might
not be entirely accidental. Another source of inspiration was a blog post of Bo
Sjögren (another former LASS player). Many other examples of under-promotion can
be found among the wonderful Chess Curiosities of Tim Krabbé.
Upplagd av Olle Häggström kl. 07:15
Rekommenderadettapå Google
Etiketter: Johan Wästlund, schack
4 kommentarer:
Olle Häggström
27 november 2013 17:31
The underpromotions discussed by Johan are of the most exotic kind where the
pawn is promoted to a rook or a bishop. A bit less exotic, and comparatively far
more common in tournament play, although on an absolute scale still very
uncommon, is the case of promotion to a knight. The reason why knight
promotion is by far the most common underpromotion is that the knight is not
dominated by a queen in the same crude sense as a rook or a bishop is - unlike
the two latter peices, the knight has moves at its disposal that are unavailable to
the queen.
Remarkably, a promotion to a knight nearly happened in the 6th game of the
Anand-Carlsen match. After white's (i.e., Anand's) 67:th move, black (Carlsen) had
the option to play 67.- f1Q, promoting his f-pawn to a queen. This would have
been a terrible mistake, because Anand would then have had 68. Rf8+ at his
disposal, checking the Carlsen's king from behind and picking up the newly
promoted queen, with a winning position. Instead the underpromotion 67.- f1N+
would have been enough for a winning position for black: because the knight
checks the white king, it has time to get out of harm's way (the X-ray threat on
the f-file from the white rook) and with careful play black can utilize his extra
knight to force win. Unfortunately, Carlsen had another move at his disposal 67.- Rg1 - which leads to a simpler win, so he chose that one and we didn't get
to see the (historic?) occurence of an underpromotion in a world championship
match.
Svara
Jim Bergquist 28 november 2013 02:16
Chess is a game with perfect knowledge and three outcomes: win, lose or draw.
In the endgame one has an opportunity to avoid a loss or resign gracefully. When
the outcome becomes predictable it's game over. Perhaps this is why Kasparov
quit the game against Deep Blue. It was the best way to deny the computer the
opportunity to learn from him and improve its game. Perhaps the best strategy
was "quit while you're ahead."
Svara
Steffen 28 november 2013 13:43
Excellent story. For those interested in more of the same I recommend Andrew
Buchanans website.
http://anselan.com/chess.html
Go to the section: "Dead Reckoning".
Svara
Steffen 2 december 2013 13:20
The topic is also being discussed at the Mat Plus Forum. Tricky stuff:
http://matplus.net/start.php?
px=1385989915&app=forum&act=posts&fid=gen&tid=1333&pid=11186
Svara
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28
Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
Kommentera som:
Publicera
Стр. 6
Välj profil...
Förhandsgranska
Senaste inlägg
Startsida
Äldre inlägg
Prenumerera på: Kommentarer till inlägget (Atom)
Etiketter
akademisk frihet Alan Sokal
Anders Sandberg
artificiell intelligens
Bertrand Russell
Bo Sjögren
Christer Sturmark
Chalmers
Barack Obama
Björn Bengtsson
Bill Joy
Daniel
Dennett
Derek Parfit
David Chalmers
domedagsargumentet Douglas Hofstadter
Eliezer Yudkowsky
Eric
Schwitzgebel
Fermis
evolutionsbiologi
forskningspolitik
paradox
fri vilja
Gud
humor
Ingemar Nordin
Jan Björklund
Jesus
klimatdebatt
klimatpolitik klimatvetenskap
kreationism
kärnvapen
Andersson
KVA
Lars Karlsson
Lena
Magnus Carlsen
matematik
medvetande
Mitt Romney
moralfilosofi
Nick Bostrom
Olof Palme
Patrik Lindenfors
psykologi Ray Kurzweil
Republikanska partiet
Robin Hanson robotar
sannolikhetsteori
Singulariteten
schack
statistik
Steven Pinker
teleportering teodicéproblemet terrordåden i Norge
Stuart Armstrong
the great filter
transhumanism
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28
Häggström hävdar: Guest post by Johan Wästlund: A remarkable pawn promotion
Стр. 7
Uppsalainitiativet USA-valet 2012 utbildningspolitik
utomjordingar
Vetenskapsrådet
xkcd
vetenskapsteori
Mallen Simple. Drivs av Blogger.
http://haggstrom.blogspot.com/2013/11/guest-post-by-johan-wastlund-remarkable.html
13.01.2014 11:56:28