gs tv y media quarterly
Transcription
gs tv y media quarterly
GS TV y Media Quarterly 3Q 2012 • Bruno Rangel / Elena Arceo * 03/01/00 = 100 Índice TVAZTCA Índice TLEVISA 10/10/12 9/11/11 25/4/12 25/5/11 6/12/10 21/6/10 7/7/09 28/12/09 0.5 13/1/09 0.7 0 22/7/08 4.48% 30/1/08 -1.90% 10/8/07 59.52 21/2/07 TLEVISA CPO 0.9 40 9/3/06 1.86% 30/8/06 -6.48% 5/4/05 8.23 31/5/02 AZTECA CPO 1.1 80 21/9/05 40.27% 1.3 120 18/10/04 0.29% 1.5 160 4/11/03 155.95 D% 12 M 30/4/04 GS US Media Index D% 3M 1.7 200 16/5/03 Last TV / TZA 240 18/11/02 GS Medios CPO Prices Índices* GS Medios TV/TZA Azteca (In Millions of Real P$) 2010-III BALANCE SHEET Total Assets Current Assets Total Liabilities Debt Stockholder's Equity 12M INCOME STATEMENT Revenues Operating Income EBITDA Net Income 2010-IV 2011-I 2011-II 2011-III 2011-IV 2012-I 2012-II 2012-III D%Q/Q D%Y/Y D%TACC 28,078 29,576 32,614 34,226 34,949 36,272 37,034 35,284 32,851 -6.9% -6.0% 7.5% 10,355 12,400 15,429 16,567 16,296 17,913 19,300 17,644 15,529 -12.0% -4.7% 13.5% 20,859 21,076 24,101 25,266 25,366 25,567 26,439 24,792 22,427 -9.5% -11.6% 5.3% 10,065 10,029 9,705 11,721 12,274 12,062 10,955 11,173 10,548 -5.6% -14.1% 2.3% 7,219 8,500 8,513 8,960 9,583 10,705 10,737 10,455 10,578 1.2% 10.4% 13.9% 11,856 12,249 12,289 12,043 12,253 12,155 12,496 12,635 12,572 -0.5% 2.6% 2.0% 4,281 4,448 4,450 4,383 4,585 4,505 4,548 4,449 4,114 -7.5% -10.3% -0.5% 4,845 5,008 5,000 4,907 5,104 5,009 5,054 4,977 4,646 -6.6% -9.0% -0.4% 2,047 2,457 2,484 2,485 2,441 2,266 2,539 2,164 2,475 14.4% 1.4% 4.9% *of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by the Mexican Stock Exchange (1) Since 4T 1996 Televisa (In Millions of Real P$) 2010-III 2011-III 2011-IV 2012-I 2012-II 2012-III 144,681 144,671 153,068 152,423 158,038 153,065 151,285 147,370 -2.6% -3.3% 8.9% 63,444 66,940 51,743 48,028 51,732 50,050 46,628 42,887 -8.0% -10.7% -1.7% 89,704 91,664 96,413 95,413 97,936 91,880 89,076 81,981 -8.0% -14.1% 10.0% 51,518 56,272 56,697 60,439 58,626 54,977 54,950 53,292 -3.0% -11.8% 12.8% 54,978 53,007 56,655 57,010 60,102 72,308 70,633 77,150 9.2% 35.3% 11.2% 61,338 62,055 62,246 63,364 63,906 65,388 66,527 66,678 0.2% 5.2% 6.3% 16,520 16,460 16,281 16,750 17,178 17,865 18,268 18,406 0.8% 9.9% 1.4% 23,495 23,696 23,771 24,440 24,765 25,643 26,185 26,439 1.0% 8.2% 4.8% 8,146 7,914 7,846 7,658 7,035 7,299 7,149 7,819 9.4% 2.1% -2.4% EBITDA 12M EV* EV/EBITDA TLEVISA TLEVISA 5,181.13 2,054.43 15,944.76 7.76 AZTECA AZTECA 976.87 361.02 2,191.40 6.07 • • • * Azteca and Televisa’s market capitalization value considers information taken on 30/10/12 Index D%TACC 2011-II *of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by the Mexican Stock Exchange Strategic Report ------------------2 News - -----------------------------5 Balance Sheet -------------------- 8 Leverage and Liquidity -----------9 Activity and Operativity - ------10 Income Statement ---------------11 D%Y/Y 2011-I BALANCE SHEET 129,114 Total Assets 63,027 Current Assets 76,042 Total Liabilities 45,953 Debt 53,072 Stockholder's Equity 12M INCOME STATEMENT 60,972 Revenues 16,396 Operating Income 22,880 EBITDA 6,715 Net Income 12M Net Revenue D%Q/Q 2010-IV • Margins ---------------------------12 Profitability -----------------------13 Valuation --------------------------14 US & Hispanic Media -------------15 Glossary - -------------------------17 • (2) Since 1T 1991 Azteca registered mixed results during 2012-III. Sales increased +2% YoY; however, during the period the EBITDA decreased -13% with respect to 2011-III. Net sales of Tlevisa, during 2012-III increased +8.7% YoY as a result of positive variations in the business lines of content and distribution in +4.4%. The fair price of the Azteca CPO, as of December 4th 2012 is of P$11.68. On December 4th, the CPO presented a price of $8.39. According with the exercise, the potential appreciation is of 39.2%. The media sector in USA, faces a lower foreign demand, mainly in Europe and China. The automotive sector, among others, has reduced its advertisement expenditure and the consumer’s confidence starts to show good signals in USA. It is worth to mention that the satisfactory results of the sector were driven by the Presidential Elections and the debates among candidates. In the coming quarters the sector faces the challenge of reaching larger audiences through the redesign of new content which is liked by the public to compensate for the lower advertisement space demand as a consequence of the weak foreign demand. GS TV y Media Quarterly Highlights 3Q 2012 3Q 2012 Azteca Televisa • Azteca registered mixed results during 2012-III. Sales increased +2% YoY; however, during the period the EBITDA decreased -13% with respect to 2011-III. • Despite the cost and expense reduction strategy, during 2012-III they increased +12% YoY. • The costs and expenses generated due to the broadcasting of the Olympic Games, put pressure in the margins. • The EBITDA during the period increased to P$1,060 million with a decrease in the margin that was of 33% during 2012-III. • The net debt as of September 30th was P$2,114 million, 15% lower than the amount registered in the same period of 2011. • The license granted to Azteca by the Government of Colombia for the construction and maintenance of the optical fiber network will be reflected on the following quarter’s results. • Net sales during 2012-III increased +8.7% YoY as a result of positive changes in the business lines of content and distribution of +4.4%. • It stands out the weakness in the results of advertising revenue which increased marginally in +1% YoY during 2012-III; more than 80% of these, were advancements of advertisement budgets and the rest were sales on the spot market. • The EBITDA during 2012-III increased to P$6,969 million, +10.5% YoY with respect to 2011-III. • The Net Income in the quarter was of P$3,224.6, which represented an increase of +44.7% YoY and a Net Margin of 18.6%, meaning a change of +460 basis points with respect to the 2011-III results. • The total debt as of September 30th 2012 increased to P$53,014 million, slightly lower than the balance at the end of 2011, so it has remained stable in the last three quarters. 2% 8% 18% 33% 21% 90% 23% 5% TV abierta Azteca America Otros TV abierta Cable y Telecom Editoriales Sky Otros Quarterly Revenues Δ% A/A 0% -5% 2012-III 2012-I 2012-II 2011-III -10% 2010-III 2012-III 2012-I 2012-II 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III -30% 5% 2011-IV -20% 10% 2011-I -10% 15% 2011-II 0% Δ% A/A 10% 20,000 18,000 16,000 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 2010-IV 20% 4,000 3,500 3,000 2,500 2,000 1,500 1,000 500 0 Quarterly EBITDA 20% 8,000 -20% Δ% A/A 10% 3,000 2,000 0% 0 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-I -10% 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-III 2011-IV 2011-II 2011-I 2010-III 4,000 1,000 -30% 2010-IV 20% 5,000 2011-II -10% 6,000 Δ% A/A 0% 30% 7,000 10% 2010-IV 2,000 1,800 1,600 1,400 1,200 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 12M EBITDA Margins 41% 1.0 38% 2012-II 2012-III 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-II 2011-III 36% 0.0 2011-I 37% Δ bp T/T 0.5 39% 2010-IV Δ bp T/T 40% 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5 -2.0 -2.5 -3.0 2010-III 43% 42% 41% 40% 39% 38% 37% 36% 35% 34% -0.5 -2- GS TV y Media Quarterly News 3Q 2012 Mexico • Cofetel postpones on the bid ruling of decoders for digital TV. The Federal Telecommunications Commission (Cofetel) postponed for November 21st. the ruling on the bid for decoders and/or antennas for the signal reception of digital television in Tijuana, Baja California. On a statement, the regulator points out that the “decision of differing the ruling was taken after an evaluation of feasibility of the received technical and economic proposals and a deep revision of the bidding basis and its appendix”. • Cofetel reviews proposals for the bidding of TV decoders. The Cofetel received eight proposals regarding the bidding process for the hiring of visitation services and, if it’s the case, the delivery and installation of decoders and/or digital antennas for the reception of digital television signals in the city of Tijuana, Baja California. • Mony de Swaan searches for approval of bidding in TV. The president of the Federal Telecommunications Commission (Cofetel) unilaterally expected the approval of the bidding project of open TV frequencies, which, for its technical and juridical inconsistencies do not guarantee an efficient allocation and put in risk the legality of the bidding process, said related sources. • Consultations for open TV are asked. The Consulting Council of Cofetel recommended the regulator to make a public consultation on the bidding basis for the digital open TV. “To present the project of the bidding basis for the concession granting of open television stations to public consultation” is what is requested in the document delivered to the Cofetel last September 17th. • Mexico is on the 79th place on telecommunications development. Mexico is on the 79th place in the telecommunications development, a category in which the leader is South Korea, according to the UIT. The document Measurement of the Information Society 2012 shows that the assimilation of the information and communications technologies are raising worldwide, driven by a progressive reduction in the price of the telephony and broad band Internet services • The band of 700 MHz turns out to be cheap. The band of 700 MHz, which can be used to provide mobile broad band services, turns out to be 70% cheaper compared to using specter in a higher zone as the band 2.5 GHz which can be used for the same purpose, assure experts and authorities. • Deceitful advertisement in the “Buen Fin” is denounced. A few hours after the Canaco started the annual sales program “El Buen Fin”, the Consumers Federal Attorney (Profeco) received two complaints for deceitful advertisement of some establishments, within the program of especial surveillance made to watch that the retailers on the plan really abided with the promotions and sales that were announced in this strategy to drive sales. • Google TV is already a reality. The search engine firm says it has more than 100,000 movies and television programs on demand, also several channels on YouTube and Netflix, as well as many applications and content. The service works by adding an accessory connected to the television, which must have a High- Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI) entry or with a television that already has this gadget. In both cases it is possible to use the mobile phone, with Android System, as a remote control. • Televisa will launch the social network VivaFut. It is about a way in which the football fans may be able to share pictures, make posts and experiences derived from their passion, in PC and mobile devices. VivaFut will work as a downloadable application and a Web page, in which the users can create their profile, follow their favorite teams and create communities, consult news and statistics, watch photos and videos and check in the games and other functions. • Televisa brags about quadruple play.- Emilio Azcárraga Jean, CEO and president of the Board of Directors of Grupo Televisa, assured that the firm is the main provider of quadruple play in the country by offering pay TV, fixed telephony, mobile telephony and Internet. • Televisa will try to take “Memín Pinguín” to the TV. During the exposition in honor of the writer Yolanda Vargas Dulché, creator of the character of “Memín Pinguín” the Content President of Televisa, José Bastón, said the firm will try to take this comic to television. • Televisa asks Google to remove 490 pages. The media conglomerate Televisa has asked Google to stop promoting and to remove from its search index 490 Internet pages during this year, arguing that these sites illegally offer material protected by author rights. • Piracy steals P$18 million per movie. The physical piracy and the illegal digital downloads cause losses between P$15 million and P$18 million per movie, so if every year there are around 350 to 400 movies, according to the Motion Picture Association, the amount is almost of P$7,200 million, accused Gabriel Rivapalcio, director of the Mexican animation firm Huevocartoons. • AMEDI asked for protection against the multiprogramming. The Jury of the Ninth District in Administrative Affairs of the Distrito Federal accepted the protection asked by the Asociación Mexicana de Derecho a la Información (AMEDI) against the service of multiprogramming approved by the Telecommunications Federal Commission. • Mexican Soccer Team generates US$250 million. The president of the FMF, Justino Compeán, revealed that the concept “Selección Nacional” generates in a World Cup US$250 million exceeding the investment of US$150 million made on several issues related with the national players. • FOX expects to increase tariffs: Cablemás.- The cable television firm Cablemás warned that Fox expects to increase its tariffs and this will cause an increase in the monthly rent of its service. On a statement, Cablemás said that after long negotiations, FOX took the decision of removing the signals from its TV programming, affecting the coverage in 85 cities in the country. • CNN openly launches CNN Latino in search of the Hispanic market. CNN in Spanish, leader in cable during 15 years, -3- GS TV y Media Quarterly News with success in Latin America and United States, will launch CNN Latino, a new programming block in Spanish made for the Hispanic market in the United States. CNN Latino is a new extension brand targeted to the growing and diverse Hispanic market in the United States, with an ample specter in the programming. • Televisa and Univision will have the content of Caracol. UniMás, the television chain Univision formerly known as TeleFutura, will issue in its prime time a minimum of annually hours produced by Caracol, among them they can choose soap operas, series and entertainment programs. Televisa, on the other hand can produce and broadcast original programs of Caracol in the open and pay television signals of Televisa in Mexico and Latin America. 3Q 2012 Marissa Mayer. Facebook came out and denied the rumors that said it was holding conversations with Yahoo! for the creation of a search engine. • Google signs agreement with European record companies. Google Inc. The firm signed a license agreement with representatives of European record companies, artists and composers by which the on line giant and its clients will have access to 5.5 million songs from 35 countries with artists such as Lady Gaga and Rihanna. • Google and Dish could form a new telephony operator. Google could turn into a mobile telephony and Internet operator. The firm Dish Network, which offers satellite TV service, has started to negotiate with the search engine company to cooperate and create a new telephony network. Internet • Alibaba buys back half of the share of Yahoo. Alibaba received financing for US$1,000 million from eight banks, including Braclays Bank, Citi, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank and Morgan Stanley and other US$1,000 million from the China Development Bank. Alibaba Group has the right to buy back the remaining share of Yahoo after an initial public offering. Until the transaction is completed, Yahoo already had 40% in the Chinese website. • Google Maps says it is not waiting for the iPhone 5.- Google Inc. has not made any move to offer Google Maps for the iPhone 5 of Apple Inc. after there was an application made by Apple which was controversial, said the CEO of Google Eric Schmidt. • Google reaches an agreement with publishers in USA. Google and the Association of American Publishers (AAP) announced a friendly agreement that will allow the Internet giant to integrate pieces protected by author’s rights in its digital library. • Facebook has one thousand million “friends”. The social network Facebook exceeded the barrier of the one thousand million active users, announced its CEO, Mark Zuckerberg. “This morning there are more than one thousand million people using Facebook actively each month”, said on a statement. • Earnings of Facebook exceed expectations. Facebook registered earnings that slightly exceeded expectations and pointed out that it was making money since the advertisement displays on mobile devices. With these results, the shares increased more than 8% almost immediately in trading after market close. • Google asks for support of users to maintain free Internet. The future of Internet will be decided on December on the ITU. In Dubai will take place the reunion of 193 representatives of the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) where specialists will decide on fundamental changes on the way of administrating, governing and regulating Internet. • Facebook denies any alliance with Yahoo! After the rumor spread on the web, the site of Mark Zuckerberg denied he wanted to build a social search engine together with the firm of International • The regulators approve the acquisition of EMI by Universal. The American and European regulators approved a reduced version of the US$1,900 million acquisition of Universal Music of EMI Music, allowing Universal to expand its dominium as the largest firm in the music world. • New channel of Univision and ABC will be based on Miami. The new chain will have a life style and news format. The publishing coverage will be focused on relevant themes for the Hispanics in USA, including economics, politics, health and more. Its official launch will take place in 2013 when the name will be released. Presented documents by the chain to the Miami-Dade County, expect a payroll of 350 people within five years, with an initial investment of US$275 million. • News Corporation could acquire publisher Simon & Schuster. The communications giant News Corporation, has among its assets the publisher HarperCollins and wants to acquire Simone & Schuster, the book publishing business of the CBS group, according to the newspaper The Wall Street Journal. • News Corp acquires 49% of the Yanquis channel. The media group News Corp. announced an agreement to take over 49% of the television channel YES, which broadcast the games of the baseball team the New York Yankees and the Brooklyn Nets of professional basketball. The agreement still has to be approved by the Major League Baseball (MLB) detailed the company on a statement. • News Corp triples earnings in the first quarter. News Corp. one of the largest communications groups in the world, earned during the first fiscal quarter 2013 a total of US$2,223 million, triple than in the same period a year ago. The firm, owned by mogul Rupert Murdoch, obtained a net income per share of 94 cents -4- GS TV y Media Quarterly News from July to September, compared to the 28 cents earned in the same three months of last year, when the income increased to US$738 million. • Time Warner expects increase in advertisement. The American Media Conglomerate loss less advertisement than expected during the broadcasting of the Olympic Games to its rival NBC and said it expects that the advertisement expenditure increases in the current quarter. • CNN creates Documentary Unit. CNN, working to become more relevant, has decided that part of the answer has to do with movies – at least in the non fiction kind – and expects to announce the creation of CNN movies. • NBC is in unknown territory. Numerous unexpected factors have played an important role on this amazing change, some of which probably won’t last, but the numbers are clear. Among the preferred viewers by most advertisers: 18 to 49 years old – NBC has beaten its rivals on the network each weak of the new television season. • Disney acquires Lucasfilm for US$4 thousand million. Walt Disney Company in a movement that gives it a leadership position in the fantasy movies agreed on the take over of Lucas Film Ltd. from its founder George Lucas for 4.05 thousand million dollars in cash and shares. • Disney takes over Lucasfilm and will continue the saga of Star Wars. The entertainment giant Walt Disney Co announced the acquisition for more than 4,000 million dollars from the producer Lucasfilm, owner of “Star Wars” and the launch in 2015 of the seventh episode of the saga. 3Q 2012 • Disney acquires German television Das Vierte. The telecommunications regulator in Germany agreed on the acquisition of the channel Das Vierte by Disney. The American firm takes over the control of the firm, until now in the hands of REN Media Group, from Russian producer Dimitry Lesnevsky. The agreement, announced for the first time on September, allows the entrance of Disney to the German market of open TV. • Univision associates with Xoom for Money Deliveries on Internet. Xoom Corporation, a world supplier of money deliveries through Internet, has got together with Univision Communications Inc. the main media communications firm providing service to the Hispanic community in the United States, for being its preferred service for money deliveries on line for the Latin community. • Netflix protects its shares against hostile take overs. Netflix Inc. adopted the defensive strategy of the poison pill against a hostile take over days after the investor Carl Icahn revealed it has a share in the movie rental firm. • Netflix reached 30 million users Worlwide. Netflix, the subscription service on Internet to watch movies and series, informed that it has more than 30 million members around the world, 25 of them in United States. The expansion registered in the last 22 months is attributed to the continuous growth of subscribers in United States and Canada, as well as the launch of the service in new markets in Latin America and Europe. -5- GS TV y Media Quarterly BALANCE SHEET 3Q 2012 The 2012-III results of both firms seem to be more even regarding their expansion and acquisition processes, even though at different pace. On one hand, there were reductions in Total Assets, Azteca of -6% and Tlevisa of -3.3% YoY as a result of lower levels in Cash and Temporary Investments and Accounts Receivable. On the other hand, since the second half of 2011 both firms have gradually reduced their liabilities, mainly the long term ones; in line with this trend, during 2012-III the Total Debt of Azteca decreased in -11.6% YoY and the one of Tlevisa -14.1% YoY. In this way, the Total Liabilities of Azteca registered a decrease of -14.1% and the ones of Tlevisa -11.8% annually. Azteca - figures in real terms in millions real P$* Total Assets Current Assets Cash and Cash Equivalents Accounts Receivable Other Current Assets Prop. Plant and Equip. Total Liabilities Current Liabilities Long Term Liabilities Other Liabilities Stockholder's Equity Total Debt 2010-III 28,078 10,355 2010-IV 29,576 12,400 2011-I 32,614 15,429 2011-II 34,226 16,567 2011-III 34,949 16,296 2011-IV 36,272 17,913 2012-I 37,034 19,300 2012-II 35,284 17,644 2012-III 32,851 15,529 D%Q/Q -6.9% -12.0% D%Y/Y -6.0% -4.7% D%TACC 7.5% 13.5% 3,610 5,303 5,936 7,626 7,575 8,473 8,332 7,866 6,896 -12.3% -9.0% 27.7% 3,742 3,003 3,377 20,859 4,596 8,249 8,014 7,219 10,065 4,489 2,608 3,311 21,076 4,494 8,153 8,429 8,500 10,029 6,438 3,055 3,179 24,101 4,553 19,547 11,852 8,513 9,705 5,728 3,213 3,241 25,266 3,096 22,169 10,986 8,960 11,721 5,704 3,017 3,419 25,366 3,394 21,972 10,284 9,583 12,274 6,779 2,661 3,454 25,567 2,920 22,648 11,266 10,705 12,062 7,489 3,479 3,511 26,439 3,009 23,430 13,064 10,737 10,955 5,875 3,903 3,655 24,792 3,344 13,683 7,765 10,455 11,173 4,695 3,937 3,577 22,427 3,621 13,006 5,800 10,578 10,548 -20.1% 0.9% -2.1% -9.5% 8.3% -4.9% -25.3% 1.2% -5.6% -17.7% 30.5% 4.6% -11.6% 6.7% -40.8% -43.6% 10.4% -14.1% 3.2% 12.4% 0.3% 5.3% -4.5% 7.5% 9.3% 13.9% 2.3% *of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by the Mexican Stock Exchange (1) Since 4T 1996 D%Q/Q Televisa - figures in real terms in millions real P$* 2011-I 2011-II 2011-III 2011-IV 2012-I 2012-II 2012-III 129,114 144,681 144,671 153,068 152,423 158,038 153,065 151,285 147,370 -2.6% -3.3% 8.9% 63,027 63,444 66,940 51,743 48,028 51,732 50,050 46,628 42,887 -8.0% -10.7% -1.7% 33,810 22,203 27,819 19,564 18,098 16,620 18,538 16,284 16,693 2.5% -7.8% -11.2% 10,877 18,340 40,459 76,042 16,245 43,567 16,230 53,072 45,953 18,766 22,476 40,977 89,704 15,607 49,664 24,433 54,978 51,518 16,616 22,504 40,632 91,664 14,763 54,888 22,013 53,007 56,272 14,021 18,158 41,075 96,413 23,442 54,210 18,761 56,655 56,697 11,251 18,679 41,917 95,413 22,116 58,779 14,517 57,010 60,439 19,651 15,461 42,377 97,936 15,395 57,041 25,500 60,102 58,626 16,231 15,281 41,435 91,880 34,523 57,357 7,501 72,308 54,977 13,183 17,161 41,790 89,076 30,414 54,421 4,241 70,633 54,950 9,933 16,260 42,084 81,981 25,111 52,772 4,098 77,150 53,292 -24.7% -5.2% 0.7% -8.0% -17.4% -3.0% -3.4% 9.2% -3.0% -11.7% -12.9% 0.4% -14.1% 13.5% -10.2% -71.8% 35.3% -11.8% 4.4% 13.6% 9.5% 10.0% 23.5% 13.1% -21.4% 11.2% 12.8% 40,000 35,000 20% 30% 50,000 Televisa TV Azteca Televisa´s Growth TV Azteca´s Growth 40% 30% 25,000 20% 20,000 15,000 10% 10,000 0% 5,000 -10% 2012-II 2012-III 2012-I 2011-III 2011-IV 2011-I 2011-II 0 2010-III 2012-III 2012-I 2012-II -20% 2011-III 0 2011-IV -10% 2011-I 10,000 Δ% A/A 0% 20,000 2010-IV 2012-III 2012-I 2012-II -10% 10% 30,000 50% 30,000 20% 40,000 2010-III Δ% A/A -5% (2) Since 1T 1991 Δ% A/A 40% 60,000 0% Stockholder’s Equity 70,000 5% 2011-IV 25% 10% 2011-III 30% 15% 2011-I Total Debt 180,000 160,000 140,000 120,000 100,000 80,000 60,000 40,000 20,000 0 2011-II 2010-IV Total Assets 2010-III D%TACC 2010-IV *of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by the Mexican Stock Exchange 2010-IV D%Y/Y 2010-III 2011-II Total Assets Current Assets Cash and Cash Equivalents Accounts Receivable Other Current Assets Prop. Plant and Equip. Total Liabilities Current Liabilities Long Term Liabilities Other Liabilities Stockholder's Equity Total Debt -6- GS TV y Media Quarterly Liabilities and Liquidity 3Q 2012 In general the Leverage and Liquidity Ratios are slightly pressured for both firms, despite the decreases in debt and total liability. The Total Debt / Total Assets ratio for Azteca slightly increased to 32.1% from 31.7% during the previous quarter; meanwhile, the ratio for Tlevisa was of 36.2% without relevant changes. With respect to the solvency ratios, both firms showed decreases during 2012-III. The one of Azteca was of 5.01x, accumulating a year Debt / Total Assets of decreases and the one of Tlevisa was of 6.39x, after having reached a maximum level of 6.68x in the last quarter. This was a result of a higher level in the cost of debt for both firms; for Azteca of 9.18% meaning an increase of +45 basis points with respect to the last quarter; meanwhile, for Tlevisa the cost of debt had a change of +78 basis points reaching 8.10%. Debt / Stockholder’s Equity 44.0% 180% 40.0% 150% 36.0% 120% 32.0% 90% 60% 28.0% 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-III 2011-IV 2012-III 2012-III 2012-I 2011-IV 2012-II Current Assets / Current Liabilities 2011-III 2011-II 2012-III 2011-IV Televisa TV Azteca 2012-II Televisa 2011-I 3.00% 2010-IV 4 2010-III 6.00% 2012-II 5 2012-I 9.00% 2011-III 6 2011-II 12.00% 2011-I TV Azteca Cost of Debt 7 2010-IV 2011-II Televisa TV Azteca Debt Payment Capacity* 2010-III 2011-I 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III Televisa 2010-IV 30% 24.0% TV Azteca EBITDA Var. coeficient (8 quarters)** 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 40% 30% 20% Televisa TV Azteca Televisa 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III 10% TV Azteca -7- GS TV y Media Quarterly Activity and Operations 3Q 2012 The Accounts Receivable Turnover for both firms present minimum increases in the last quarters; however, the breach increases quarter after quarter. In the last couple of years, the small increases in sales of Azteca, as well as larger accounts receivables days (180.3 in 2012III) have pressured this ratio below 2x; at the end of the quarter it reached 2.02x. On the other hand Tlevisa registered a decrease of -24.7% QoQ during 2012-III in Accounts Receivable resulting in a 12M Net Revenues / Accounts receivable (i) maximum level in the last couple of years of 4.52x in the Accounts Receivable Turnover. With respect to the Accounts Payable Turnover the changes were in opposite directions; the ratio of Tlevisa slightly decreased to 4.3x meanwhile for Azteca it increased to 59.7x. Collecting days 3.0 4.6 4.5 4.4 4.3 4.2 4.1 4.0 3.9 3.8 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 TV Azteca 1.05 1.00 150 2012-III 2012-II 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-III TV Azteca 2012-III 90 2012-II 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 0.85 2012-I 0.00 120 2011-IV 0.90 6 4 2 (2) (4) (6) (8) (10) (12) 2011-III 0.02 210 180 0.95 Televisa (der) Cost of debt (collecting days - payment days) 2011-II 0.04 Televisa (der) 2011-IV 70 2011-II 75 0 2011-I 80 2 2011-I 0.06 2011-II 85 4 2010-IV 1.10 2011-I 90 6 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 1.15 0.08 2010-IV 95 8 TV Azteca 0.10 2010-III 100 10 Televisa (der) (Rev / Acc. Receivable) (Cost of Sales / Acc. Payable) (V / CxC) (CV / CxP) = (i)/(ii) TV Azteca 12 2010-III TV Azteca 2011-IV 2011-II 2011-III 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III 4.6 4.4 4.2 4.0 3.8 3.6 3.4 3.2 2010-IV 64 56 48 40 32 24 16 8 0 Televisa (der) Payment days 2010-III Cost of debt (12M Cost of Sales / Payable accounts) (ii) 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-II 2011-III Televisa (der) 2011-I 50 2010-IV 2012-II 100 2010-III TV Azteca 90 88 86 84 82 80 78 76 150 2012-III 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-I 2011-II 2010-IV 2010-III 0.0 200 Televisa (der) -8- GS TV y Media Quarterly INCOME STATEMENT 3Q 2012 The growth in 12 Month Earnings was modest despite the two special events: (1) the London Olympic Games and (2) the Presidential Elections in Mexico. So, Azteca experienced an annual increase of +2.6% in 12 month sales and a decrease of -0.5% QoQ during 2012III. Despite its cost control strategy, the transmission rights of the Olympic Games pressured the Operating Result which decreased -10.3% with respect to 2011-III. In consequence the EBITDA decreased -9% annually. On the other hand, the 12 Month Earnings of Tlevisa were driven, during 2012-III, by the segments of Sky and Cable and Telecom achieving a change of +5.2% with respect to the same quarter of 2011. The EBITDA, in its quarterly comparison, increased 1% for an annual increase of +8.2%. Azteca - figures in real terms 2010-III Total Assets Current Assets Cash and Cash Equivalents Accounts Receivable Other Current Assets Prop. Plant and Equip. Total Liabilities Current Liabilities Long Term Liabilities Other Liabilities Stockholder's Equity Total Debt 2010-IV 2011-I 2011-II 2011-III 2011-IV 2012-I 2012-II D%Q/Q 2012-III D%Y/Y D%TACC 2,976 3,727 2,441 2,899 3,186 3,629 2,782 3,038 3,123 2.8% -2.0% 2.6% 1,029 1,732 686 937 1,231 1,651 729 837 896 7.0% -27.2% -3.0% 444 1,170 589 1,454 1,866 1,694 170 816 321 417 1,056 528 400 1,366 289 1,279 1,771 1,299 443 860 777 42 980 -29 712 1,035 1,044 1612.2% 5.7% -3761.2% 77.8% -24.2% 260.8% 6.5% -2.0% 9.6% 11,856 4,281 2,047 4,845 2,720 12,249 4,448 2,457 5,008 3,128 12,289 4,450 2,484 5,000 3,133 12,043 4,383 2,485 4,907 3,132 12,253 4,585 2,441 5,104 2,833 12,155 4,505 2,266 5,009 2,437 12,496 4,548 2,539 5,054 2,894 12,635 4,449 2,164 4,977 2,337 12,572 4,114 2,475 4,646 3,092 -0.5% -7.5% 14.4% -6.6% 32.3% 2.6% -10.3% 1.4% -9.0% 9.1% 2.0% -0.5% 4.9% -0.4% 5.4% *of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by the Mexican Stock Exchange (1) Since 4T 1996 2012-I 2012-II D%Q/Q D%Y/Y Televisa - figures in real terms in millions real P$* 2011-III 2011-IV 2011-IV 2012-I 16,786 17,181 15,329 17,232 16,937 -1.7% 0.9% 5.6% 4,729 2,672 4,468 4,880 5,157 3,359 4,872 5,018 3.0% 2.8% 1.3% 2,340 6,147 4,175 2,679 6,690 4,557 913 4,535 2,564 1,913 6,399 3,791 2,152 6,815 3,678 2,056 7,016 3,592 1,177 5,413 3,576 1,763 6,941 3,490 2,822 7,070 4,884 60.1% 1.9% 39.9% 31.1% 3.7% 32.8% -0.7% 4.2% 4.0% 60,972 16,396 6,715 22,880 12,366 61,338 16,520 8,146 23,495 14,632 62,055 16,460 7,914 23,696 14,453 62,246 16,281 7,846 23,771 15,088 63,364 16,750 7,658 24,440 14,591 63,906 17,178 7,035 24,765 13,625 65,388 17,865 7,299 25,643 14,638 66,527 18,268 7,149 26,185 14,337 66,678 18,406 7,819 26,439 15,542 0.2% 0.8% 9.4% 1.0% 8.4% 5.2% 9.9% 2.1% 8.2% 6.5% 6.3% 1.4% -2.4% 4.8% 3.0% 2010-II 2010-III 2011-I 2011-II 2011-II 2011-III 2011-III 2011-IV 2011-IV 2012-I 17,559 7,480 2010-IV 2011-I 25,252 11,084 **of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by Grupo Televisa Real P$ millions 25,166 11,064 24,835 10,895 0% 24,672 10,363 9,000 -3% 6,000 -8% 2012-III 0 2012-I -5% 2012-II 3,000 Televisa TV Azteca D%Y/Y 0.8% 0.0% D%TACC 1.1% -2.6% 18.9% 22.6% (3) Since 1T 1999 10,000 50% 8,000 35% 20% 5% Δ% T/T 3% 12,000 2011-III -4% 2012-III 0 2012-I -2% 2012-II 10,000 15,000 2011-IV 0% 20,000 (2) Since 1T 1991 D%Q/Q 6,000 5% 18,000 Δ% T/T 2% 30,000 8% 21,000 4% 40,000 2011-III 24,471 10,364 2012-II 2012-III 12M net income 24,000 2011-I 6% 50,000 2011-IV 10% 2010-III 60,000 2011-I 24,117 10,306 27,000 2010-IV 8% 2011-II 24,186 10,366 2012-I 2012-II EBITDA 12M 70,000 2010-III Televisa´s Growth TV Azteca´s Growth 4,000 -10% 2,000 -25% 0 -40% 2010-III 12M Revenues 2010-IV 24,411 10,642 2011-II 3M Network TV Revenues Operating Income 2010-III 2010-IV Δ% T/T 4,411 D%TACC 2012-III 16,092 2012-I 13,847 2012-II 16,639 2012-II 2012-III 2011-III 15,668 *of purchasing power to 2012-I • As reported by the Mexican Stock Exchange 2011-II 2011-III 2011-IV 2011-I 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2011-I 2011-II 2010-III 2010-IV 2010-IV 2010-II 2010-III Total Assets Current Assets Cash and Cash Equivalents Accounts Receivable Other Current Assets Prop. Plant and Equip. Total Liabilities Current Liabilities Long Term Liabilities Other Liabilities Stockholder's Equity Total Debt -9- GS TV y Media Quarterly 12M Margins* 3Q 2012 2012-III 2012-III 2012-III Cash Income Margin 2012-II Televisa 2012-II TV Azteca 2012-II 2010-III 2011-IV 2011-III 2010-IV Televisa 2012-I 36% 2011-IV 37% 44% 2012-III 38% 45% 2012-II 39% 46% 2012-I 40% 47% 2011-II 41% 48% 2011-I 42% 49% 2010-III 50% 2011-III EBITDA Margin 2011-II Gross Margin 2011-I the Gross Margin of Azteca was of 45%; meanwhile the one for Tlevisa was of 47% in the same period. In this way, the EBITDA Margin of Azteca was of 37% below the one of Tlevisa of 39.7%, during 2012-III; reaching their minimum and maximum levels in the last couple of years, respectively. 2010-IV Due to the modest increases in total sales as well as the costs and expenses derived from the broadcasting of the London Olympic Games, the margins were pressured downwards. For the first times in two years the margins of Azteca were below the ones of Tlevisa. So, with a decrease of 2 percentage points with respect to 2012-II, TV Azteca Net Margin 25% 30% 20% 25% 15% 20% 10% Televisa TV Azteca 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III Televisa 2010-IV 5% 15% TV Azteca Information considering only network TV Estimated Operating Margin** EBITDA Margin 51.0% 45.00% 48.0% 40.00% 45.0% 42.0% 35.00% 39.0% Televisa 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III Televisa 2010-III 36.0% 30.00% TV Azteca TV Azteca *The margin is the result of dividing the 12M figure by the 12M Total Revenue **Currently, Televisa does not publish EBITDA by business segment, therefore from 2007 on, the figures are estimated. - 10 - GS TV y Media Quarterly Profitability 3Q 2012 The profitability ratios reflected mixed results among both firms. The ROIC, the most important ratio, increased for both: Tlevisa went from 4.7% in 2012-II to 5.1% in 2012-III; meanwhile for Azteca it went from 6% to 7% in the same period. The breach in the ROE has increased since 2010-IV; in 2012-III it went from 4.2 percentage points, placing Azteca in 13.1%, below the average of the last couple of years of 15.3%. Ventas 12M / Activos Prom (rotación activos) Margen EBITDA 12M 2012-II 2012-III 2012-II 2012-III 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III Televisa TV Azteca ROIC contable 2011-II 2011-I 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III Televisa 2010-IV 43% 42% 41% 40% 39% 38% 37% 36% 35% 48% 46% 44% 42% 40% 38% 36% 34% 32% TV Azteca ROE 18% 9.0% 8.0% 16% 7.0% 6.0% 14% 5.0% 12% 4.0% Televisa 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-III 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III Televisa 2010-IV 10% 3.0% TV Azteca TV Azteca Rendimiento Accionario 12M ROA 60% 10% 40% 8% 20% 6% 4% 0% Televisa 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-II 2011-I 2010-IV 2012-III 2012-II 2012-I 2011-IV 2011-III 2011-I 2010-IV 2010-III 2011-II Televisa 2010-III 2% -20% TV Azteca TV Azteca - 11 - GS TV y Media Quarterly Valuation 3Q 2012 The fair price of the CPO as of December 4th 2012 is of P$11.68. The multiples for the media and communications sample showed divergent behavior. The multiple VE/EBITDA discounted by country risk decreased from 7.4 times to 7.1, meanwhile the ratio P/BV re- mained in 2.5x. On December 4th, the CPO of Azteca presented a price of $8.39. According to the exercise the potential appreciation is of 39.2%. Sum of the Parts Valuation for Azteca (in millions of US$) BROADCAST & ENT. TV Azteca Production & Distribution Multiple Used Network & KAZA-TV VE/UAIIDA 2012’3T (1) EBITDA 12M 1Q 2012 (US$, millions) TOTAL Azteca America P/VL 2012’3T $366 Book Value 1Q 2012 (US$, millions) $154 Value Line Sample Multiples 3Q'12 7.1 Fair EV (US$, millions) 2.5 $2,593 Less Net Debt 3Q 2012(2) (US$, millions) $284 Fair Value (US$, millions) $2,309 $380 29,718.6 5,885.1 CPOs (millions) 2,984.0 2,984.0 2,984.0 Fair CPO Value (P$) $9.96 $1.64 $11.60 Fair Value (P$ millions)(13.95P$*US$) Current CPO Market Price (P$) (3) $8.28 Potential Appreciation (4) 40.05% (1) Adjusted for Mexico’s country risk at 133 basis pts. (2) Net of cash value of Channel 40 investment (US$25 million), Net Debt = Debt-Cash = (US$847 million including US$120 million (American Tower liability) (Total Debt) - US$594.9 million (Cash position) = US$252.1 million) (3) As of November 5th, 2012. Broadcasting and Entertainment Sample Enterprise Value / EBITDA (3Q-2012) * Weighted Average Weighted average discounted by country risk, adding Televisa Broadcasting and Entertainment Sample Price / Book Value (3Q-2012) * Weighted Average BLC: Belo Corp., CBS: CBS Corp., DIS: Disney, NWS: News Corp., SNI: Scripps Network. - 12 - GS TV y Media Quarterly International Comment 3Q 2012 The weak economic recovery in USA, has not completely overshadowed the performance in the media sector. Some economic data provide some light of economic recovery; the unemployment decreased in November to 7.7% after having remained above 8% for several months of 2012; at the same time, the housing sector returned to a sustained growth. However some factors play against the sector. The Obama reelection was not liked in the economic and the financial sectors and the debate regarding the “Fiscal Cliff” between the Democrat and Republican parties have spread uncertainty on the financial markets and this will continue until the end of the year. On the other hand, the debt crisis of the Euro Zone is far from ending. Countries as Spain and Italy have turned into the center of attention because in the first one the banking system is still contaminated by risky assets in the housing sector as a result of the crisis of 2008-2009, and the second one faces a political turmoil which puts in doubt the continuity of fiscal austerity measures. Under these circumstances the media sector in USA faces a lower foreign demand mainly from Europe and China. The automotive sector, among others, has reduced its advertisement expenditure and the consumer’s confidence starts to show good signals in USA. It is worth to mention that the satisfactory results of the sector were driven by the Presidential Elections and the debates among candidates. Meanwhile, the firms in the sector continue with their effort to reinforce their balances through the reduction of liabilities. Firms such as Disney, CBS, News Corp. and Time Warner have made major buybacks in previous quarters. In the coming quarters the sector faces the challenge of reaching larger audiences through the redesign of new content which is liked by the public to compensate for the lower advertisement space demand as a consequence of the weak foreign demand. Azteca Market Summary Last AZTECA CPO (P$) Max Oct 8.23 Min Oct Δ% 1M 8.23 -7.22% 9.00 Δ% 3M s (1) Δ% 12 M Δ% 2012 -6.48% 1.86% 13.09% -7.42% 21.97% 1.35% INDUSTRY PEERS (in US$, unless otherwise stated) TLEVISA CPO 59.52 62.20 59.02 -2.06% -1.90% 4.48% 155.95 167.90 155.95 -5.83% 0.29% 40.27% 7.48 8.17 7.48 -4.47% 9.20% 17.98% 18.32% 18.73% Disney 49.07 52.97 49.07 -6.14% -0.14% 40.68% 16.64% 30.85% Time Warner 43.45 46.50 43.45 -4.15% 11.07% 24.18% 15.41% 20.23% Radio One 0.92 0.92 0.81 13.58% 0.00% -28.68% 55.16% 10.84% 12.60 12.92 11.35 12.40% 23.53% 31.52% 35.56% 11.11% ÍGS Broadcast Ind. Belo Sinclair Bcsting. 16.39% 30.30% (1) s, or sigma is the representation of volatility, a measure of risk calculated over a monthly sample of daily data, annualized. GS US Broadcasting Index Close Cierre 180 150 120 90 60 30 18/10/12 20/2/12 20/6/12 22/6/11 21/10/11 22/2/11 25/6/10 25/10/10 25/2/10 24/6/09 22/10/09 23/2/09 23/6/08 21/10/08 20/2/08 20/6/07 S&P 500 18/10/07 20/2/07 23/10/06 17/2/06 IB 21/6/06 21/6/05 20/10/05 15/2/05 18/6/04 18/10/04 13/2/04 9/6/03 9/10/03 4/2/03 1/10/02 30/5/02 25/1/02 21/9/01 15/5/01 7/9/00 10/1/01 5/5/00 3/1/00 0 - 13 - GS TV y Media Quarterly GLOSARIO D% Q/Q: Percentage change quarter to quarter. D% Y/Y: Percentage change year to year, this is important because it eliminates seasonality effects. Barter or Exchange: The Exchange of goods and services in the absence of cash. Generally, is the acquisition of air time or space in a communication media in exchange of merchandise. Book value: An accounting concept. The book value of a stock is determined adding all the company’s assets and subtracting liabilities and debt, including the liquidation price of whatever preferred issues. This result is then divided by the number of ordinary outstanding shares and the result is the book value per share. The book value of a company’s assets or value may have little relation to its market value. Capitalization Value: Is the actual market value of the equity and is obtained as the result of multiplying the stock price by the number of outstanding shares. Cash Income: Is the net income without taking into account the virtual items and it’s obtained by considering the result of monetary position and foreign exchange, depreciation and amortization and the effects after changes in the accounting principles. Collecting Days: The average number of days the company takes to gather its accounts collectible and it is obtained by dividing 365 and the Collectible Accounts Rotation. Commercial Audience: Azteca’s programming is designed to attract the commercial audience. The commercial audience is composed of TV viewers of the following socio-economic segments: ABC+, C and D, which represent 63% of Mexico’s population, controlling 92% of the available income, and tuning channels 2, 5, 7 and 13. 3Q 2012 Gross Rating Points (GRP’s): The addition of all the ratings offered by a list of media. Generally referred to a household base. Inventory Days: Is the average time in days that the company takes to displace its inventory and it’s calculated as the quotient of 365 between the inventory rotation. Payment Days: The average number of days the company takes to pay its accounts payable and it’s calculated by dividing 365 between payable accounts rotation. Price to Earnings Ratio: P/E ratio. The most common measure of how expensive or cheap a stock is. The P/E ratio is equivalent to the market capitalization of the stock, divided by its income after taxes for a 12 month period, usually a known period, but occasionally the actual or an estimate. Rating: Is the percentage of a population group that uses media in a given time. Generally used for broadcast media, but it can be used for any communication media. A rating point equals to one percent of a given audience. ROA: Return on assets, calculated as the quotient of 12 month net income by the average assets during the period. ROE: Return on Equity, is calculated as the quotient of the 12 month net income and the average stockholder’s equity at the end of the period. ROIC: Return on Invested Capital, is obtained as 12 month EBITDA over Total assets. The accounting ROIC is calculated with the accounting value of the assets, while the regular ROIC uses the market value (see capitalization value) Share or participation: The audience share is the percentage of homes or people watching TV that tune to a specific program. Cost of debt: It’s calculated as the quotient of the paid interests on the period over the debt. Stelar time or primetime: The time fringe which attracts more TV audience. Cost per rating point (CPR): The cost of an advertising unit (for example, a 30 second spot) divided by the average rating of a specific demographic group (women from 18 to 49 years). Upfront: Payment made upfront, a method used to buy advertising time in TV with anticipation to the transmission date and generally for a long period of time, such as a year. CPO: Ordinary Participation Certificate, Azteca’s CPOs include three shares, one of each series A, D-A and D-L. Virtual Items: Are those accounts that do not represent an outflow or income in cash, such as, depreciation, amortization, result for monetary position and foreign exchange. Debt: Liability with financial cost. EBITDA: Earnings Befote Interests, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization. - 14 - GS TV y Media Quarterly Contact 3Q 2012 Grupo Salinas Chairman and Founder: Ricardo B. Salinas CEO: Pedro Padilla TV Azteca CEO: Mario San Román Azteca America Presidente: Luis J. Echarte CEO: Martin Breidsprecher Grupo Elektra & Banco Azteca CEO: Carlos Septién Luis J. Echarte GS - Chief Financial Strategist (5255) 1720-5777 Afore Azteca y Seguros Azteca CEO: José Luis Paz Grupo Iusacell CEO: Adrian Steckel Bruno Rangel GS - Director of Investor Relations (5255) 1720-9167 jrangelk@gruposalinas.com.mx Elena Arceo GS - Financial Analysis (5255) 1720-7000 xt. 72510 mearceo@tvazteca.com.mx Design: Linda Garcidueñas S. News: Alejandro Vázquez M. Powered by www.signumresearch.com This document, and the information, opinions, estimates and recommendations expressed herein, have been prepared by Grupo Salinas to provide its partners, suppliers, clients and employees with general information regarding the date of issue of the report and are subject to changes without prior notice. Grupo Salinas is not liable for giving notice of such changes or for updating the contents hereof. This document and its contents do not constitute an offer, invitation or solicitation to purchase or subscribe to any securities or other instruments, or to undertake or divest investments. Neither shall this document nor its contents form the basis of any contract, commitment or decision of any kind. The contents of this report are based upon information available to the public that has been obtained from sources considered to be reliable but no warranty, either express or implicit, is given regarding its accuracy, integrity or correctness. Grupo Salinas nor any of its companies accept liability of any type for any direct or indirect losses arising from the use of the document or its contents. www.gruposalinas.com - 15 -