Story by Liam Quirk Pics by Scott Stoneman
Transcription
Story by Liam Quirk Pics by Scott Stoneman
head porting explained Port Of Call Let’s look at the physics behind the VN V8 cylinder heads, and how to work them to maximum effect Story by Liam Quirk Pics by Scott Stoneman Head Work 101 The cast-iron cylinder heads fitted to the top of the VN 5L V8 are commonly regarded as the best heads Holden ever fitted to its V8s for a number of reasons. The airflow figures from the factory and potential for increased flow with minor work, the size and shape of the factory ports and the sheer amount of material in the heads all point to one thing – a great pair of metal chunks to have bolted to the top of your V8. George uses VN heads atop his boosted stroker in TUFUTE and has worked them to flow phenomenal figures. Well-known car owner Sean Fardell of MR HDT fame says that he has seen the heads flow up to 595hp, and that’s obviously before exploring the alloy heads where figures of 700hp and above can be obtained. So desirable is the design of the VN cylinder head that Yella Terra has based its Holden V8 alloy head on it. When it comes to heads, the VN items are the bee’s knees. “The VN heads are pretty accurate except for where the pushrods holes are,” Sean from Allports says of the late-’80s cylinder heads. “The HQ heads were average. They got into the pollution thing and were crap. Once the VL ones came around, they were good. The VN one on the whole is a very high-quality piece of equipment. Holden did its job well with those heads … The VN heads are a very good casting.” Before we go any further, let’s clear one thing up. Unlike most things in life (cubic capacity, for example), bigger isn’t always better when it comes to porting cylinder heads. Take too much metal from the walls or floors of the ports and you will either break through and cause structural issues, or end up with an oddly sized equation. Then, you come to the sad realisation that there’s physically no way you can make them all the one size. If you’ve taken the heads off your bog-stock 5L to port them, you don’t need to take masses of material out and prep the heads as if they were being strapped to MR HDT. Let’s face it, your standard motor simply doesn’t need that much air, and providing it may very well cause it to run worse. Sean is quick to point out that too many people become obsessed with getting their heads to flow huge horsepower figures. In fact, this figure accounts for little more than bragging rights at the pub. Instead of focusing on flashy numbers and the heads’ potential for flow, concentrate on the quality of the work done to the ports and appropriately sized valves. Above all, look at the quantity of air your motor requires. The theory behind expanding the ports in the cylinder head is simple. On a small scale, porting tidies up the dags and mess left around by the casting process, and it equalises the sizes of the ports. The factory margin for error and variances in port sizing mean that no Here you can see the work Sean has done through the roof of the port. “Normally they have a distinctive channel in the roof area through the injector notch. You can see the area I’ve worked on, and my goal was to reduce that notch because, as far as I’m concerned, it upsets things. I like things to be as smooth as possible,” Sean explains wWWW.STREETCOMMODORES.COM 143 head porting explained two factory heads flow the same, even when untouched. The first thing to do is bring all ports out to the same size to ensure a solid base to work on. Slight overhangs and irregularities inside the ports can disrupt airflow, and as is known, turbulent air is harder to move than air flowing on a smooth surface. Once the inside of the ports have been tidied and worked to the same specs, we can focus on extensive porting with performance in mind. The basic idea goes further than simply moving air efficiently; it’s about moving bulk amounts of air as well. We can all appreciate that a bigger person is going to be able to fit through a bigger door, and with small ports on an angry motor, it’s like trying to walk a horse through a cat door – you’re just making life harder than it really needs to be. The Facts For all the info, we talked to Sean. He is the man behind Allports and the artist responsible for the spectacular work done to the VN heads for Phoenix. He kindly took us through, in detail, the process of working the specific heads that will be strapped to the motor. He explained to us his techniques, and why these heads are going to help us make bulk grunt. “Firstly, you need to know what you’re doing with the engine, which means the basic combo,” Sean begins. “What the intended purpose and use of the engine is, what vehicle it’s going into and what the owner expects from it.” In the case of Phoenix, we know that the heads will be above a rebuilt 304ci motor and below the Yella Terra supercharger. We know that with the manual box, there will be the potential to wind the revs out a little higher, but what we didn’t know was the style of driving it would be subjected to. “From there, you work off a rev range. Where’s the engine going to be used from, and what is the peak engine speed you’re going to be running? You can convert this into feet per second and calculate the port sizes. “I like to plot my numbers out first and work to a plan. In the case of the Phoenix, being supercharged, I could work on using larger ports than are normally found in an NA 304ci engine. I’m not talking stroker in this case as that’d be different again. “So, I set the intake mean gas velocity average at 272fps at 6000rpm, 294fps at 6500rpm and 317fps at 7000rpm. Then, I worked it out with the camshaft, which is why it’s good to know cam specs at the start. “It’s good to work around the cam instead of working the heads and then getting a cam to suit. The guy working the heads might calculate the air speed at a This shot allows us to appreciate the work done to the exhaust port and to the bowl area. The bowl itself hasn’t been enlarged, or ‘hogged out’. The exhaust port has been extensively smoothed to calm airflow. This shot also highlights the three-angle-machined valve seats Here is Sean in action. He is working the exhaust port using an oval-style cutter to gain the desired shape inside the port. The aim here is to give the area a greater radius 144 wWWW.STREETCOMMODORES.COM Here is the work being done to the power wall. One of the first things to go is the mini pushrod lump that is cast in there from the factory. “I like to remove that, as it sets up the straight-line shot into the bowl. It’s one of the first areas I work on,” Sean says certain amount for a specific lift, and then the cam might not give that lift or will give more. It upsets the apple cart. “I like to have things set in concrete before doing anything,” Sean says. From here, we talk with Sean about porting. “I don’t agree with people flowing the exhaust and increasing that flow. It’s like piercing a pressure vessel, and that’s what an engine is like, a pressure vessel. “The instant you crack a tinny, the pressure is gone, and an engine is no different. It doesn’t extend its pressure. When it’s gone, it is gone and it happens instantaneously.” Back pressure, no matter what the circumstances, is imperative. It just depends on how much back pressure in question. “I try to keep the exhaust as small as possible, but granted some form of flow bias is needed.” Qualifying this, Sean explains. “Everything starts at the exhaust with the engine. Some people prefer to talk about the inlet first; I like to talk about the exhaust. Without that action, there isn’t the induction. The exhaust exiting the chamber at speed, if it is maintained, helps pull the intake that charges or fills the cylinder.” So where’s the best place to start? “On the inlet side, keep things as straight as possible. Some heads can’t do this, but the VN heads can. With the particular heads we’re talking about, if you look at the port entrance to the valve face, it is almost a straight line on the active side of the port,” Sean says. This straight wall he’s talking about will also be referred to as the power wall, and it is an extremely integral part of the head design. “Assuming that the heads are already cleaned and the guides are done, I prefer to do my valve seat work first.” This work is heavily affected by the spring rate of the chosen valve springs and the height of said springs. “It’s important to have all the parts on hand. The collets, the retainers; have everything there so that you’re not working blind and there is a chartered course. Therefore, you don’t finish a pair of heads and then have to fight to get compression, or fight with springs and shims,” Sean says. The Ports Port sizing is very important. At the end of the day, it’s not about going as big as possible, it’s about controlling air speed. “Go in and measure them with some dividers, work out the square-inch area of the port and convert that into a feet-per-second (FPS) air speed. This is the mean average gas velocity. Depending on the engine, it can run from 280fps at peak power to 350fps in some cases, though that number tends to be a little bit high,” Sean explains. But what of Phoenix? Where does it lie on the spectrum? “An engine like the VN-headed one we’re doing is calculated at around 300fps–320fps peak speed,” Sean says. With the numbers plotted, pull out the tools. “When working on the port, I make measurements and decide whether or not to increase the port size. I use the verniers and go through the valve opening area or bowl to take a measurement wWWW.STREETCOMMODORES.COM 145 head porting explained from the floor of the port to the deck of the cylinder head. “I record that reading and go through all of them. Whichever is the lowest, I’ll probably start on first because I can always bring the others down to suit,” Sean says. One of the first things to do to the ports involves working the pushrod choke area, which is where the highest inlet speed is needed. Air should be entering this part of the head at around 320fps. From here, the walls of the ports can be straightened up (keeping in mind that removal of too much material will mean a broken pushrod wall). “Sometimes ports are that far out in their casting that you can go through. That’s the only area of the VN head that can be ticklish,” Sean says. “Some only have 20thou’ worth of material there, and as soon as it is touched, it’s gone.” After this, the air needs to begin decelerating. “You don’t have a truck making a turn without slowing down. Air is the same as a truck, it has to change speed. If we’re at 320fps, I like to try to slow that down to 270–280fps by opening up that area,” Sean says. The particular area opened is the window above the short turn. By making this area larger physically, it takes more air to fill. Thus, it slows the air down and allows it to turn into the port at a reasonable rate. “In the case of the VN head, about 80thou’ has already been taken off the floor material. This is roughly 2mm measuring from both sides through the seat and through the outside of the 146 wWWW.STREETCOMMODORES.COM port. I record the measurement and go from there,” Sean says. One of the token phrases when you ask someone if they have had head work done is ‘yeah mate, fully ported and polished’. The latter would be quite detrimental in the quest for power. “Smooth is not an option [for the ports]. Currently, the myth has probably been dispelled about polishing ports – it’s the last thing you want to do. It’s the surest way to have a slow engine as far as I’m concerned – one that’s hard to tune and doesn’t burn fuel properly. “Generally, a rough grinded finish is left on, or a sanding sleeve is used to create a coarser surface than a polished finish. To look at it, it might be shiny, but in effect it’s putting sanding lines in the port and leaving the fuel and air in suspension,” Sean says. While the ports may not need to be silky smooth, some areas of the head should be polished. The short turn area into the bowl and the radius from the wall (as it makes its way into the bowl and seat area) can be polished, Sean admits. “The most bump-free smooth thing you can have on the cylinder head is the short turn. Grind a short turn as close as possible to a smooth area, and then use some inch-wide emery paper and polish the hell out of it. “That area receives a lot of attention as it’s basically free power. You polish it up because the air is moving generally in the high side of the port as it’s coming around the short turn area. For this reason, that is where most of the Sean goes to work on the pushrod wall. The cutter being used is wedge shaped, and this makes the material easier to remove. It also allows Sean to resize the area as he sees fit Sean then moves all his attention to the ‘short turn’ area. The wedgeshaped cutter comes out again so Sean can remove material from the floor and the base of the port, plus smooth the area out work is done. The short turn is an area where a lot of power can be made,” Sean explains. it to travel. “It isn’t ever perfectly straight, but you can almost see from the port to the bowl how straight the line is,” Sean says. Port Potential? Flow Bias One thing Sean was kind enough to explain to us was ‘port potential’. For those unfamiliar with the term, it’s a measure of how much flow one port is good for with the major restriction (the valve) removed. The test is done on a flow bench with the valve out and a finger blocking the guide. “Your 0.800in [at 10in] reading is 160.1CFM. Without the valve in the hole, it’s only 160.2CFM. In many heads, you will pick up lots of CFM, but it didn’t pick up any. Only 0.1 of a CFM isn’t even worth talking about. From 600thou’ and up, it was basically the same,” Sean says. Port potential could also be called a flow coefficient, and it is a good way to measure how efficiently a port has been made to work. “In this case, it is 95-percent efficient at 600thou’. At 700thou’ it’s over 98-percent efficient and at 800thou’ it is 99.93-percent efficient. This is all bearing in mind that it’s an L34-sized valve we are flowing. It’s not a 2.02, 2.05 or 2.08,” Sean concludes. So, what is this notion of flow bias? Flow bias is yet another way of controlling the way air enters the head and can be used to control direction, speed and a number of other things. Sean talked with us mainly about biasing the exhaust valve. He said, “If you’re talking flow bias, a lot of people are using 75–80 percent. I don’t like to work to those numbers. It changes if you’ve got a street exhaust system, if you’re open piped, if you’re short piped… I try to work an area to get the speed high.” So, while biasing a port to flow to meet one criterion, the minute those parameters change, the maths has been thrown out. If Sean has taught us one thing, it’s that when working cylinder heads, everything needs to add up. The Power Wall The power wall is the longer side of the port and is called so because it directs the majority of the air down the port and into the large, cavernous bowl. The most important thing to do here, according to Sean, is straighten the wall right out. That way, the path the air takes is quick and direct – the most efficient way for One of Sean’s most important tools is a pair of dividers and a digital vernier, which allows him to take a lot of important measurements. Maths is at the base of the power game in the heads, and sizing all the ports equally is imperative. “It’ll do nothing but help the engine as long as you can make everything as even as possible,” Sean says Valve Seats And Hogging The Bowl Sean’s first step, after cleaning the heads, is to cut the valve seats and tidy up the bowls. “I cut valve seats and do bowl hogging before I start the cylinder heads. I like to work to a known area rather than porting the heads and then cutting seats. Otherwise, there will be anomalies, undercutting etc. I don’t believe it’s a good way to work, and I prefer to work with the seats cut.” After the seats have been properly worked, it’s on to the bowls where the “You work the power wall and get it as straight as you possibly can as it exits into the bowl. You’ll find that you make nothing but power.” – Sean wWWW.STREETCOMMODORES.COM 147 head porting explained Behind the exhaust valve, you can see just how smooth Sean has made the port. Cast in from the factory is a sharp step area – one of the first things Sean removes. “The step can sometimes hurt things. You want it all to be gentle, not abrupt. Smoothness is everything when dealing with a cylinder head,” Sean says hogging process begins. For those that think hogging is a matter of stuffing some kind of swine into the heads, it is simply a matter of making the bowls bigger by removing material. Here, it’s all a matter of keeping things uniform. “When starting on the bowls, work on the ports first. Port it all the way to the 60° cut under the valve seat, which leaves 30–40thou’ material before the 60° cut” Sean says. “You can change the characteristics of a cylinder head and how it works by the way you port it and the way the seats are set up. The seats are everything,” Sean matter-of-factly concludes. “I like to keep the valve seats on the inlet as thin as possible, within reason. If they are too thin, they just chop the valve and pound the seat out. But, it’s good to have a thin seat because it also stops carbon build-up, or helps to prevent carbon build-up. You’re never going to stop it. “Back cutting valves is another option [putting a 20–30° chamfer on the back side of the valve above the seat area]. But, I didn’t back cut the valves on this engine because it is going to be a supercharged induction system, and I’d prefer to leave some of the integrity in the valve instead of machining it away. “When dealing with back flow or restricting back flow, then only a small back cut is used. If restricting it is not the issue, use the biggest back cut possible.” Chambers This is the finish Sean was talking about that helps keep the air/fuel mixture in suspension. “It looks shiny and smooth, and it is but it’s not mirror finish. It’s actually a little bit coarse,” Sean explains Sean had this to say about the VN chamber. “It’s a fairly efficient chamber. A lot of people gouge things out and grind things off, like the square area around the sparkplug. Personally, I don’t like to do that. “I like to scribe it out with the bore line in most cases. Basically, nothing incredible, just de-dag all the casting and smooth it up. I’m not one for absolutely polishing it, but a lot of people around do.” Other Tricks Number Crunching For those interested, Sean gave us the flow figures for the heads to be bolted to the Sam’s-built short motor going into Phoenix. He provided us with figures for the heads flowed at both 10in and at 28in. Flow at 10in (CFM) Intake 0.100 0.200 0.300 0.400 0.500 0.600 0.700 0.800 Exhaust 39.4 63.3 78.1 86.7 91.3 95.2 96.2 98 54.3 86 112 132.3 144.1 151.9 158.2 160.2 Flow at 28in (CFM) Intake 0.100 0.200 0.300 0.400 0.500 0.600 0.700 40.68 143.62 187.04 220.77 290.64 253.67 264.19 Exhaust 65.79 105.71 130.42 144.78 152.47 158.98 161.32 0.800 267.36 163.66 At 28in, the port potential was 267.53cfm, so under full load you can see that the heads on Phoenix are working at maximum efficiency. 148 wWWW.STREETCOMMODORES.COM There are numerous other secrets to making power inside a head – secrets that can only come from years of experience and pushing the boundary. For instance, there is a hump in the floor of the cylinder head from factory. When Sean ports a VN head, that hump is ground out. Another area where Sean uses a bit of trickery and experience is in working the guide boss area. “A lot of people like to narrow them and thin them right down. I’ve used that on many occasions, but with a lot of the racing stuff, I’ve never seen much of a correlation between performance and thinning it. I think the easiest way is to just drop the top of the guide down,” Sean says. The final method could best be described as over-engineering, or rather aptly, over-flowing. “Why I keep flowing a head beyond where it’s going to be used is because it is a very good yardstick. “If you’ve got 500 lift and the head falls over at 550, in many cases the engine will only make mediocre power. Especially if the head falls off a long way – some heads don’t, some heads do. “There might be people around that would dispute that, but that’s what I work to,” Sean says. In essence, by pushing the heads that little bit further, making them efficient even beyond their intended use, the results trickle down into the lower ranges for a head that performs across the board.” Back Flow One form of testing that is not often heard of is back flowing. As Sean explains, at low lift (0.100–0.300in) the head as a whole (but more specifically the intake valve) is still suffering the aftershock from the force of the piston propelling towards the top of its cycle. It has to deal with the resultant explosive forces, heat and other phenomena. “The more flow that is inhibited from going back up the port as the valve is taking off, the better. This means the valve is at 100–200thou’ on the overlap before the piston is accelerating away from the combustion chamber and pulling on the port. “Here an edge is put on the valve. As it’s coming up, if a valve has a deflector angle, especially around the 200thou’ region, it is better. Reverse flow is cut by at least 30 percent and anywhere up to 50 percent. “The idea is to keep the charge in the cylinder, and it does tend to make the engine run a little smoother, which helps when during street driving. As far as feel goes, it is fairly minimal. It takes a lot of power change in an engine to feel something. “On the exhaust side, there’s not a lot you can do. Suffice to say, if the exhaust is over ported, it will hurt power more so than make power. In the case of a carby engine, it will be less responsive to tune.” Valves “If the engine can run an oversized valve, buy an oversized valve. This doesn’t necessarily mean the biggest oversized valve, as bigger isn’t always better. It helps, but it’s not always the best way. “Consider that the valve is a variable venturi. It starts from zero and opens to anywhere between 450–700thou’ and even higher. Whatever the valve lift is, it has an organ effect on the inlet tract. “The speed will, albeit very momentarily, increase and decrease,” our expert Sean says. In the case of Phoenix’s heads, Pep Pro L34-spec stainless steel valves were chosen. The seats of the valves have been three-angle-ground – a 20–30° top cut, a 45° seat and a 60–70° drop into bowl area. With that in-depth exploration, hopefully you guys understand what’s going on inside the head a little better. Knowing the major restrictions inside those chunks of metal puts you in a better position to work in search of performance. We have to thank Sean of Allports for the work he did on the heads and the time he took to explain the process to us. Not to mention divulging trade secrets and his personal techniques, which would have taken years behind the cutting tool to develop and finetune. Thanks also goes to Thornleigh Cylinder Heads for allowing Sean to use their shop. sc Contact Allports Sean - 0404 780 630