U ero xapaKrepHo Ann ra44ofr c$epul B ycnoBurx ne$opruaflb

oT3btB
Ha Anccepraquto
u aBTopeSepar Axnaa,qeeBa ,flenuca
bre ycno B hF neQo p rtaan uxoil 3a HRTocrH B coBpeMeH
npegcraBneHHylo Ha concraHue yu€nofi creneHn KaHAuAara oKoHoMt4
cneqnanbHocrr4 08.00.01 - <<eroHoMr4qecKafi reopurn>.
<<VlncruryqiloHan
bH
[4ccnegoBaHne
A.P.
Ha
Paungoe
Vt Poccntt>>,
HayK no
Axnna4eeaa nocBrlrleHo pa3Bnru]o
ne$opuranunoil 3aHRTocn4 B coBpeuennofr Poccr,rr,r. ArryanbHocru eur6
o6ycnoBneHa Heo6xoAr4Mocruro 6onee qerKoro perynnpoBaHnn u npo
pbrHKe rpy4a, paspa6orKe ageKBarnoil rocygapcrBennoft noflnrilKr4 B
qro HeBo3MoxHo 6es noHuMaHlrfl TeKy[qero cocrof,Hr4fi n Han
ne$opruanbHoro pHHKa rpyga. ,flononnureflbHy]o aKTyanbHocrb Aa
npuo6peraer B cBere BBeAeHnr gKoHoMl4qecKux canrqnil n
neo6xo4rdMocrn HaxoxAeHnr AononHureflbHux BHfrpeHHux pecypcoB pa
3acnyrofr aBTopa RBnFercF Aeraflbnurfi aHaflH3 ocHoBHbrx
norqxorqoB K r,r3yqeHlrrc xe$opManbHofr eronoMl,rKr4, nperqcTaBneHHbril e
Anccepraqnil (c. 23-32 gnccepraqun). I-lpn oroM A.P. AxuageeB Bbrgen
qepTbr, cxoAcTBa n pa3nuqnf,, iqocTot4HcTBa u HeAocTaTKu, a TaKXe
flaHHbre noAxoAbr Morrr Ha pa3nuqHbrx gTanax rccneAoBaHuf, iqo
Ha ocuoBe npoBegeHHoro aHannsa ,Q.P. AxnaageeB npr4xo.qur K BaxHoMy
nau6onee e$$eKT'rBHbrM 14 pe3ynbrarnBHbrM f,Bnf,ercn MapKcr4crcKufi n
nocnegnnfr no3Bonner aHa.nu3upoBarb ne$oprvranbHyro 3aHrrocrb B
nepcneKTnBe 14 uccneAoBarb f,BfleHue nan6onee KoMnneKcHo.
HecouneHnofr nayunoil Hosr4gf-tofr o6nagaer paspa6oraHH
opn ru Han b H aR rnaccu$ nKaUuA ne$op rvran unofr oKoHo M uqecrofi aa
Bocnpolr3BogcrBa (c. 42-44 Ruccepraqmu), Koropan no3Bonf,er He ron
pa34eneHne neSopnaanunofi 3aHflrocn4 Ha orgeflbHbre cSepul,
npoAeMoHcrpl4poBaTb ee opraHuqecKylo B3auMocBF3b v1
(ne$opManbHoro npou3Bo,qcrBa B neSoprvranbHoe pacn
ne$oprtranunurfr o6nnen, B neSopruaflbHoe norpe6nenne). l-lpn oro
t4crstloqaer B3anMocBR3b c $opuanbHbrm ceKTopoM gKoHoMvrnvl,
He$opnaanbHoro npousBoAcrBa Morfr 6urr peann3oBaHbr (qenrarou nnu
e SopnaanbHoM pacnpeneneHun, SoprrranbHoM o6nnene, SopruranbHoM
U ero xapaKrepHo Ann ra44ofr c$epul B ycnoBurx ne$opruaflb
eKoHoMtARu. PesynuraroM groro craHoBr4Tcf, TaKafl curyaqn*,
npou3BogcrBa, pacnpegeneHnf,, o6rueua u norpe6nenuf, Hoct4T
Qopruan uHo-ne$opManbxurfi xapaKrep.
HeconaneHHo, o6oraruno pa6ory paccMorpeHue pa3nhLrHbtx M
BenuquHu ne$oprttanunofr 3aHRTocTl4, cpegn KoTopbtx aBTopbt Bbtgen
KocBeHHbre (c. 55-61). l-lpn sroM A.P. Axnnageea cnpaBegnnBo
Bo3MoxHocrvt oqeHKu ne$oprvranunofr 3aHnTocrn B gHal{urenbHofi naepe
ra4gutil Mero4 ee oqeHrn HMeer cBor4 npenMyu{ecrBa u HeflocrarKn no
ApyrnMu. Bur6op xe roro unu nHoro Meroga oqeHKn 3aqacrylo An
KoHKperHoro uccnegoBaHnf,, a raoKe naOopoM pacnonaraeMbtx AaHHbtx.
TeMy
14HCTl4Tyra
nofi reuur
poBaHnR Ha
fi cSepe,
pa3BLrrl4f,
uril
Bonpoc
Poccutt
u
rnaBe
N
OCHOBHHE
, qTO
Apyr Apyra.
BblBoAy, tlTo
ofl, TaK KaK
aBTOpOM
no craAnnM
npoBecru
HO
TAKXE
nMonepexoA
,B
aBTOp He
nnoAbl
uacrnvno)
ceKTopa
Ra
util,
qacrb
to ecrb
oB oqeHKu
npfMbre u
,
t{TO
nqeHbf,
14
BHEHNIo
C
qennMrl
Bo eropofr rnaee AlrccepraHr nccnegyer pa3Burrue neSopnaanb
3AHfiTOCTN B
pbrHoqnoil.
Poccuu B npoqecce nepexo4a or KoMangnofi oKoHoMr4Kr4 K
BAET
BHnMaHuf, peTpocnerrueHurfr aHanu3 nHcTuryTa He$oprtranunoil 3aHf,TOCT14,
npoBeAeHnufr aBropoM. A.P. Axuageee onpe4eflf,er HeKoropbre oco6enHocrrl
peAeneHHylo
$yurqnoHupoBaHtt+ oreqecreeHFrofi oKoHoMvtKt, o6ycnaBnuBapu{ne
npegpacnonoxeHHocrb K pa3Bnruto ne$oprr,ranunofi 3aHfiTocrr4 (c.
), a raKxe
(BTopafl
noKa3btBaeT, KaK uMeHHo coBeTcKaf,
oKoHoMHKa>
nna BeKrop
pa3BuTnn nocTcoBeTcKol4 TeHeBo[ 9KoHoMuKvl, a BMecTe c Heu u
pManbHoH
qro
3aHf,Tocrn (c. 77-79). Burogno ornuqaer pa6ory ro,
aBrop Aaer He
uro o6rqyn
xapaKrepncrr4rry ne$opuranunofi 3aHf,rocrn B coBpeMenHofr
, HO TaKXe
aHann3upyer ne$opnaanbHyro 3aHf,rocrb B pa3p$e orpacneBoil, Bo3pacrHoil,
o6paaoearenuuofi, rengepnofi crpyKTypbr, a rau(e npoBoAHT
BHCHNE C
BflNBAET
$oprtlanbHbtM ceKropoM 3KoHoM14K1.t (c. 80-97). l-lpn sroM aBrop
HecooTBercTBne Me)|(Ay oTpacneBou crpyKrypol,r 3aHRTocTr4 B
oM ceKrope
gKoHoMr4Kr4
qenoM:
oKoHoMr4Kr4 n
B
Aonf, 3aHf,Tbrx B c$epe roproBn'l u 6uffoaoro
o6cnyxnBaHnfl, a rapKe B celrbcKoM xosRficrse B ne$opnaanb
ceKTope
gKoHoMuKe,
LteM
qenoM
3HaqnTenbHo Bbtule,
B
no
B To BpeMg KaK A
3AHf,TbIX B
o6pa6aruBarorqnx npou3BogcrBax B ne$opnaaflbHoM ceKrope Hr4xe,
B qenoM no
eKoHoMnKe. Tapre 3acn)pKl'rBaer BbrBorq aBTopa o cyqecrBoBaHn
cABUra B
yqacrH
pMaflbHoro
Bo3pacrnofr crpyrrrype ueSoprvtan unoil 3a Herocrr : cpegn
KoB
ceKTopa oKoHoMl4KH CHU)KaeTCR AOnf, CarrAOil CrapUeil eOapaCrHOfi
nbf (60-72
ro4a), npn groM nponcxo4r4T yBenuqeHne flonn camofi tonofi Bo3pacrHo rpynnbr (1519 ner). [.P. AxnaageeB cBR3HBaer gro c KaqecrBeHHbrMr4 r43MeHeHunM B crpyKrype
orpacnefi, Bxognqnx B coBpeMennulil ne$opnaanunufr ceKTop. B ux cocraBe
coKpau{atorcf, TpaAnLlHoHHbre Bu4br AeerenbHocrt4, rge 6ulnn
nloAu
Bo3pacrHbrx rpynn, n yBerrnqnBaercn Aonr orpacnefi, 6onee aKTnBHo
b3yroulnx
AocrhxeHnfl HTn, B Koropbrx 3aHf,Tbr B ocHoBHoM ntclgn Mono4oro
Tperun nraBa Anccepraqr4n nocBfirqeHa paccMorpeHuto
aKqnoHHbrx
u3iqepxeK BeAeHnf, 6ngHeca B coBpeMennoil Poccyrr,r, TaK KaK, no MHe ytlo aBTopa,
14
cHnxeHne STnx TpaH3aKqnoHHbrx H3AepxeK f,Bnf,eTcf, rnaBHbrM ycnoBll
ypoBHn neSopnaanunofi saHf,rocrn B crpaHe. Aerop cnpaBeg,nnBo
TpygHocrr4 fleranil3a1un 6hsxeca B Poccuu co34alor ycnoBnr
neSopnaanunofi flef,renbHocn4. Burcorue rpaH3aKquoHHbre H3rqepxKr4
HeKoropbrx gKoHoMr4qecKux areHToB nepexo4r4Tb e He$opuanunurfi
B anann3e rpaH3aKqnoHHbrx r434epxeK BeAeHun 6nsueca B Poccnu aBTop
Ha rqoKnaAax <Doing Business>>, nolqroraBnuBaeMbx a
BcenaupHoro 6anra. A.P. Axuageee nogpo6no paccMarpnB
cocraBnf,pulylo AaHHoro pefirunra, cpaBHnBaer nonoxeHne Poccuu
crpaHaMn, onpe4enser naubonee npo6fleMHbre c$epur BeAeHnn 6nsHeca
3acnyxuBaer BHr4MaHhf, aHanns B3auMocBf,3n pf,Aa
MaKpooKoHoMr4qecKnx noKa3areneil c neSopmanuxoil 3aHflTocrbto
Auccepraqnn). flpoanann3mpoBaB KoHKperHbte iqaHHbte A.P. Axna
Mogeflb Bnuf,HuA t4ccnerqyeMbtx Saxropoe Ha ne$oprvranbHylo
KparKocpot{HoM nepnoge, yqurbrBaf, npu oroM perroHanunuil acneKT. T
MOAenU B AOnTOCpOqHOM nepnoAe nO3BOnUnO BbrflBl4Tb HeKOTOpHe AO
cHt4xeHuf,
qTo
pa3Br4THf,
BbrHyxAalor
OKOHOMURN.
ocHoBbrBaeT
rpynnoil
KaxAylo
c rqpyruMu
c. 128-142).
tsiloqeBbrx
c.
115-126
nocTpoufl
Hf,TOCTb B
ne
bHbre
yroqHn
MOMeHTbl, KOTOpbte qacTultHo AononHf,toT, a qacTnr.rHo
uccnenoBaHuf, B KpaTKocpor{HoM nepHoAe.
SesycnoaHurfr uHrepec
npeflcTaBJrfieT
AOKa3aren
KoMnneMeHTapHocrr'r SopuanbHoro
ne$opuanbHoro ceKropoB B
Poccnu (117-127), 3aKntoqatoqancn B roM, qro He$oprvranbHan
pe3ynbraTbl
aBTOpOM
u
oit
HflTOCTb B
onpegenenxofr creneHn f,Bnflercfi cne,qcrBneM pocra Sopuan
ceKTopa
eKoHoMnRn. B ro xe BpeMf,, Kor4a sKoHoMuqecruil pocr orcyrcrByer nponcxoAnr
cHr4xeHue ypoBHfl ue$opuanunoil 3aHfirocnr c onpegeneHHbrM B
HbtM traroM.
9ro noATBepXAaer re3hc aBropa o cyqecrBoBaHnn BnnAnnn $opMan ro ceKTopa
gKoHoMr4Ku Ha ne$oprtaanuxuril ceKTop oKoHoMuRV.
[Jo uneHnto aBropa, cyry6o AnpeKrHBHue u 3anpernrenbHbre
AOBOnbHO
nee$SeKrnBHbr
orHoueHnn ne$opruanbHoro ceKTopa oKoHoM
noeToMy
nan6onee npo4yKruBHbrM
cropoHbr rocyAapcrBa 6uno 6ur
nocreneHHylo Jreraflu3aqnto xe$opuanbHbrx Br4AoB lqenrenbHocrr4. Ta M o6pasou
B
ro
co
npovrcxo4uno 6u onpegeneHHoe B3auMHoe ABnxeHue Sop
bHoro u
xe$opuanbHoro ceKTopoB, no3Bonf,pqee B KoHeqHoM r,rrore
nau6onee
rapMoHr4rrHylo crpyKrypy eKoHoMl4Kr4 rocyrqapcrBa. OAnH n3 cn
B CHN)KCH]4R
TpaH3aKqnoHHbrx r43gepxeK fleranbHoro BeAeHuf, 6ngxeca a
BUAVTT B
coBepueHcrBoBaHuvt u noBuueHun e$$emuBHocn4 3aKoHogaren
o 3aquTe
3aHf,rocn4. 3ro no3BoJrnno 6ur pbrHKy rpyga crarb 6onee AuHaMuq M, TO CCTb
ycKopr4rb npoqecc nepepacnpegeneHnf, pa6ouefr chlrbr B 6onee
BHbIE HA
3HaqeHHe
.qannufi MoMeHT orpacnn oKoHoMuRu. Asrop no.qqepKuBaer, '.{To
uMeeT He TonbKo caMo coAepxaHne cooTBeTcTByror4r4x HopMaTuBHo-n
aKTOB,
Ho 14 e$$exrnBHocrb MexaHn3MoB nnSopcMeHTa rpyrqoBoro 3a
[lonyueHHbre aBTopoM pesynbrarbr AocroBepHbr, BbrBo.qbt u 3aKfllor{eHug
o6ocnoBaHbr. OcHoaFrHe nonoxeHun u BbrBogbr rqnccepraqnoHHoro
BAHUA
nonyqunr anpoOaqnto B pflAe xon$epenqnil, n Haulnn orpaxeHue B HayqHbrx
ny6nnraqunx Begyu{r'rx oKoHoMr4qecKnx }KypHanax Poccuu, TaKt4x KaK <<Terra
Economicus>>, <<t{enoaeqecrnfr KanilTan u npo$eccuoHanbHoe o6
BaHne)) n
Apyrnx.
3aarcraaHufl, KomopHe n xoqy eHcKagamb, o6ycnoeneH* HayqHHM uHmepecoM,
e*gbrcaeMHM peqeffiupyeM*M uccnedoeauueM:
1. npucoeghHnlocb K MHeHup fluccepraHTa o HehcqepnaHHoM noTeHqnane
Bocnpou3BogcrBeHHoro noAXoAa, ocHoBaHHoro Ha rpy4ax K. Maprca. Ho
qACTHOCTH
xorenocb 6ur HanoMHHTb BbtcoKoM ypoBHe a6crparcqt n,
n
o
nrHopr4poBaHm[ MopaflbHoro r3Hoca ocHoBHoro Kanurana K.
o6ecqeHuBaer npaKTrLrecKoe npnMeHeHHe ero cxeM
apKcoM, r{To
Bocnpolr3BogcrBa. He cnyvafruo B HeoKflaccuKe (
3aMeHeHo noHrrueM oKoHoMr4qecKoro rpyroo6opora, Koro
B3rflflA, r4Meer 6onuuyrfr gBpr4cn4qecrnfr noreHquan u
2.
I,I3BOACTBO)
, H? HallJ
6umu c
ycnexoM npfi MeHeHo rqnccepTaHToM.
Kar 6urno orMeqeHo BbtuJe, oco6oe BHHMaHne n nHTepec B
aBTopa o B3ahMocBH3l4 vI KoMnneMeHTapHocrH Sop
ne$opnaaflbHoro cerTopoB B coBpeMeHHoil Poccnr. Xenaren
Mbrcnd Haunu npogonxeHne. Oopuanunulfr ceKTop B oKoHoMH
MbtcnLl
bHoro
n
, qto6u otu
coBnaAaeT
rl
l
i)
c
o$nquanbHbrMr4 pbrHoqHbrMl4 cAenKaMu. He$oprrraflbHbl
noKa3arenfix 14t{P (no 2013r - l4Pqn ) n, KaK HaM
noreHquan uMeer cyqecrBeHHoe 3HaqeHue
B
qenoBeqecKoro Kannrana. eror cloxer rqnccepraHT
paccMarpnBarb, Ho MoxHo 6uno Bbrpa3urb cBoe
Mou
npo6neue.
3aMeqaHnn He Bnhf,tclr
Ha nonoxureflbHyro
oTpaxeH B
fleTcg, ero
poBaHun
BnpaBe
He
K 4anxoI
oqeHKy
Anccepraqun B qenoM.
,[uccepraqnf, <<VlncrnryqnoHaflbHbre ycnoBun ne$opuanunofi 3AHf,TOCTl4 B
brM BAK K
coBpeMennofi Poccnn>> orBeqaer BbrcoKnM rpe6oeaHr,tf,M, npegbr
KaHAnAarcKr4M flr4ccepraqnflM, a ee aBTop Axuageea fiennc PaurugoBr4q 3acnyxuBaeT
NPNCYXACHUA YL{CHOU CTCNEHil KAHANAATA 9KOHOMI4qCCKHX HAYK NO
08.00.01
- <eroHoMuqecKafl
reopufl
eqHanbHocTr4
)).
eegyp upr il ra$egpoil sroHoM r4qecrofi reo pnu u oKoHoM uqecro fr nonuTnKn
Bucuefr uKonH oKoHoMnRn u MeHeAXMeHTa
Ypanucxuil SegepanbHuil ynuaepcnrer
uMeHn nepBoro npean4eHra Poccun E.H. Enuquna
ereFr u il flerPoeu
A.e.H., npoQeccop
/,,,4
3a
ryI7il"E
/
620083, Erarep
ffipr,
rp. J lEp.
s
fi-1
Ten.: (343) 350-75-89
E-maif : dyatel 1 942@mail. ru
t