Cigarettes are Very Kool - Center for the Study of Tobacco and Society
Transcription
Cigarettes are Very Kool - Center for the Study of Tobacco and Society
Cigarettes are Very Kool byAIan Blum, M.D. Whenyou'rea Jet,you'rea J€t all the way, 'tilyourlastdyingday. . . . Fromyourfirstcigaretle, - l,YeslSide Slory, 1957 Alan Blum, M.D., is a family physicianin Chicago, He is also president of DOC ( Doctors Ought to Care), a national organization that assistscommunitles in developingncw approaches to health education lor children and leenagers. (OPPosite)CourtesY,DOC Archive T h e p i c t u r eo f a c i g a r e t t e - s m o k i ns g t r e e tg a n g m e m b e ri s n o t q u i t e a n anachronismin the 1980s, but comparedwith the range of hard drugs availableto teenagerstoday,cigarettesseem like little more than leftover forbiddenfruit of lhe halcyonfifties.Hardlya day passes without a news reportaboutangeldust,alcohol,marijuana, cocaine,or Quaaludes.Newspapers print"The AlarmingTruthAboutMarijuanaand YourChild";professional athletesvisitschoolsto denouncedrugabuse;politiciansrailagainstdope dealerson schoolgrounds;and parentsgroups mobilizeto rid their communityof "head shops" that sell drug paraphernalia. The seriousness of illicitdruguse amongyoungpeoplecannotbe denied. Althoughthe mediaare fearlessin their zeal to exposeteenagedrug and alcoholabuse,theyare conspicuously silentaboutwhatWilliamPollin,director of the NationalInstituteon DrugAbuse,has calledthe nation'snumber one form of drug dependence:cigarettesmoking. Tobacco, of course,is a drug. Althoughit is not known just how its principalactivecomponent,nicotine,acts on the brain,people do become "addicted" to cigarettesmoking.As many as 90% of cigaretteus6rs say they wish they had not started,and they wish they could stof-tut for some reasonthey cannotsucceed.On the other hand,the unpredictabilityof those who do win the battle-most say they did it on their own (without fancy programs,hypnotism,or other gimmicks),many by going "cold turkey" without experiencingthe withdrawalone would expect in a true addictionsuggeststhat socialand psychological factorsmay play a far greaterrole in perpetuatingcigarettesmokingthan physiological dependence. ls there anotherproductas irredeemablyharmfulthat is as eKensively promoted?In spiteof cigarettesmoking'sdevastatingphysicaland financial toll-350,000 deaths in the UnitedStates each year, includingmore than a quarterof all deathsdue to heart disease,and at least one out of every five dollars spent on health cara-the manufacturersof cigarettes still recelve tax write-offsfor advertisingexpenses. 148 Phorog.aohs M!seufi ol Modorn A.l Cigarette advertising : creating complacency Advertising,it wouldseern,has helpedmakesure that cigarettesrnokingis not even consideredmuch of a healthissue.By encouraging the publicto believethat "everythingcausescancer,"the cigaretteindustryhelpsportray its productas iust anothervictimof Big Brother'stryingto tell peoplohow to run theirlives.The massmedia,whichcarrythe cigaretteads,havedone nothingto alter the situation.Publicoutcry(eggedon by bannerheadlines) over a mere handfulof casesof botulism,toxicshocksyndrome,or Legionn a i r e sd' i s e a s ec a n c l o s eb u s i n e s s eO s .n em i l l i o nc a r sc a n b e r e c a l l e da f t e r Yet newspapersrun one death due to a malfunction of a singleautomobile. full-pagecolor advertisements for the productthat has been describedby t h e W o r l d H e a l t hO r g a n i z a l i oans t h e s i n g l em o s t p r e v e n t a b lcea u s e o f dealhand disability. " E v e r yc i g a r e t t ea d c a r r i e st h e s u r g e o ng e n e r a l ' w s a r n i n gt h a t s m o k i n g may be harmfulto your health,"saidone executiveof a leadingnewspap€r when asked why his paper could not exert more controlover cigaretle advertising."We remainconfidentthat the public,lully informed,ultimately w i l l m a k e t h o s ed e c i s i o n tsh a ta r e i n i t s o w n b e s ti n t e r e s t s .T" h e p u b l i s h e r lVhy do adolescents take up smoking? Identif cation wirh role models who symbolize ronence and sophistication is one undeniable motivating factor. ( OverleaJ) Counteradvertisement is lhe creation of sixth-grader Helen Kernodle lrom Des Moines, Iowa. ol Better Homes & Gardens,whosemagazineaimsto be a health-oriented familypublication,has statedthatin his opinion"thosereaderswho do not smoke will turn past the cigaretteadvertisements that are of no interestto them." Just as emphysema,heartdisease,and lung cancerhave reachedepidemicproportionsin the UnitedStates,the tobaccoindustryhastriedto see to it that cigjarette smokingis notviewedas a healthissue.The June 1, 1981 issue of fime, with a cover story on heart attacks,featureda six-page fold-outad iust insidethe cover for Vantagecigarettes.The back cover promotedWinstonLights;Eelair,Carlton,Kentlll, and Marlborow€readvertised withinthe magazine.Adolescents, lookingfor role rnodelsand at the same time rebellingagainstauthorityfigures,are a particularlyimpressionable group.Any adolescentwho readsa magazineor a newspaperlearns with goodlooks,sexiness, from the advertising that smokingis synonymous athleticprowess,sophistication, individuality, and even(with"low tar") good health.The purposeof cigaretteadvertising is not just to sellcigarettesbut also to create complacencyaboutthe dangersof smokingthem. At leastthis is the gamethe tobaccoindustryhas been playing,particularly since 1964,when U.S.SurgeonGeneralLutherTerry and a committeeof physiciansreleased th€ report that irrefutablylinked cigarettesmoking to emphysema(a generallyincurable diseasein whichthe patientslowlysuffe cates to death-fully aware of what is happening'over months or years) and lung cadcer (the literaleatingaway of the lungs and possiblyother organssuch as the brainto whichthe cancerspreads).The RoyalCollege of Physicians in the UnitedKingdomhadreleaseda massivereporton thes€ dangerseven earlier-in 1962. "Everybody'sdoingit" It is a myth that cigarettesmokingis thousandsof years old and a tim€' honoredtradition,if not an inalienabte right.Actually,whereastobaccohas r50 Phorog'aohs. courtesy OOC Arch,yo . u.&'.lto*t+*le? . t*l&b**q-q _-r-rdkH .: "'.': So nild, athletessmoke as illcutl as they please-arul that's 79g! nildness! .;;;"^"rtl beenused for centuries,cigarettes-the only tobaccoproductthat requires inhaling-were not mass-produceduntil a century ago; moreover,while nearly4,000cigaretteswere smokedfor everyadultin the UnitedStatesin 1 9 8 0 ,t h e p e r c a p i t ac o n s u m p t i o n i n 1 B B 0w a s 2 5 . W h e n t h e 1 9 t h - c o n t u r y GermanbacteriologistRobert Koch suggestedthat spitting-such as was practicedby cigarsmokersand plugtobaccochewers-spreadtuberculosis (the most dreadeddiseaseof the time) and a numberof antispitting ordinanceswere passed,the tobaccoindustryin the UnitedStatesshiftedgears and beganto producecigarettes.To consummatethe switch,it had to use mass mediaadvertisingto teach peoplehow to smoke cigarettes:"Do you inhale?Everybody'sdoing itl" insistedthe AmericanTobaccoCompany. Even well into the 20th century,cigarettesstill had not caughton-and definitelynol among women. But with adverlising.the tobaccocompanios beganto appealto women: "To keep a slenderfigure,reach for a Lucky insteadof a sweet." A well-promotedaura of romanceand sophistication made a Camel smoker-man or woman-a "social success."Throughout the '30s, '40s,and '50s on radioand in everyleadingmagazinea plethora of our prettiestpeoplewere the modelsin the ads: DouglasFairbanks,Jr., Jean Harlow,FredricMarch,JoanCrawford,ClaudetteColbert,TyronePower, Eva Gabor,FrankSinatra,MaureenO'Hara,GregoryPeck,LindaDarnell, DeanMartin,JerryLewis,Bob Hope,the Duchessof Windsor,Mrs.John D. Rockefeller,and Santa Claus."l'm a singer and my throat comes first. I pickedCamelsas my steadysmoke," said Anne Jeffreysin an advertisement in Lile in the 1940s.lt is sad but poignantthat GaryCooper,Rosalind Russell,John Wayne, Dick Haymes,RobertTaylor,and Nat King Cole all promotedone brand or anotherof cigaretteand subsequently developed lung cancer or other fatal smoking-related diseases. The cigarettecompaniesalso appealedto the all-American boy,who, of course,was likelyto be an aspiringathlete.A ten-year-oldboy growingup l5l Up until the late 1960s,movieand sports stars wereamongthe heroesand heroines featured in adsfor everybrand of cIgaret! e. Today's cigarett e-promoIi ng modelsare active,healthy,sexy, fas hionable, and tough-but nameless. Prir.rl'ron: cr,,'rdly OOC Archvo ll'hen they saw tha( smoking had not caught on equally between the sexes, the cigareue companias began to appeal to w'onten.Today it seems astounding, bu! cigarette ads used to appear in medical )ournals, and snroking was promoted by doctors. i n l h e 1 9 3 0 sc o u l d p i c k u p t h e S u n d a yc o m i c p a g e sa n d s e e h i s f a v o r i t e a t h l e t e s - Y a n k e e ss' t a r sJ o e D i M a g g i o r L o u G e h r i g - s a y i n gs u c ht h i n g s a s " C a m e l sd o n ' t g e t m y w i n d " a n d " A t h l e t e ss m o k ea s m a n y a s t h e y please."Accordingto sluggersTed Williamsand StanMusial,Chest€rli€lds wer€ "the baseballman's cigarette."SkaterlrvingJaffee,an Olympicgold m e d a l i s ts, a i d , " l t t a k e s h e a l t h yn e r v e st o b e a c h a m p i o nT. h a t ' sw h y I smoke Camels."In the sportingworld,track stars,deep-seadivers,sharpshooters,archers,tightropewalkers,jet pilots,waterskiers,footballplayers, tennischampions,speedboatracers-even chess,billiards, and bridgeplaye r s - s e e m e d t o a t t r i b u t et h e i rs u c c e s st o s m o k i n gc i g a r e t t e s . A n d h o w d i d t h e i n d u s t r yr e s p o n dt o e a r l yr e p o r t si n t h e I 9 4 0 s a n d ' 5 0 s thatassociated c i g a r e t t es m o k i n gw i t h a v a r i e t yo f l e t h a la i l m e n t s ?" M o r e doctorssmokeCamelslhan any othercigarette,"proclaimed R. J. Reynolds. " N o t o n e s i n g l ec a s e o f t h r o a ti r r i t a t i o nd u e t o s m o k i n gC a m e l s . "I n t h e J o u r n a l o l t h e A m e r i c a n M e d i c a l A s s o c i a t i o n( w h i c ha c c e p t e dc i g a r e t t e a d v e r t i s i nugn t i lw e l l i n t o t h o 1 9 5 0 s ) ,P h i l i pM o r r i s ' sb e l l h o pl,i t t l eJ o h n n y , g u a r a n t e e dt h a t s m o k i n gP h i l i pM o r r i sw a s " s a f e r " a c c o r d i n gt o " m a n y l e a d i n gn o s e a n d t h r o a ts p e c i a l i s t s . " Advertisingfor AmericanTobacco's Lucky Strike suggestedthat some smokersmight not realizethat they inhale.To be safe,they shouldselect a "light" smoke,the one "found less irritatingby 20,769doctors."Lorillard claimedits Old Gold contained"less irritatingtars and resins";it was "fresh as a new springcrocus." For anotherbrand, Lorillardproclaimed,"More scientistsand educatorssmoke Kent." Kent's widelypromotedMicronite filter,which was made out of asbestos,was advertisedas containinga material"so safe, so pure, it's used to filter the air in many hospitals."By portrayingnewer cigarettesas "even safer" the tobaccoindustryeffectively eliminatedearlyconcernsabout the dangersof smoking.Probablythe only real advance was in lhe advertisingpsychology.Believingthat Americans would regard the cigarette filter as analogousto an oil or air-conditioning filter,Liggett& Myersproduceda white-coatedsageto assertthat L & M's cellulosetip was "just what the doctor ordered." Whensurveysshowedthat filtersmokersmightbe lookeduponas sissies -since, after all, cigarettesmoking was meant to show adult courage, risk-taking,and antiauthoritarianism-Philip Morris led the way with a tattooed cowboy, an inhabitantof "Marlboro Country."Just a few months earlierMarlborohad been advertisedas a ladiessmoke,"mild as May." A babywas shown in one advertisement saying,"Gee, mommy,you surelike your Marlboros."Throughoutthe 1950sand '60s, th€ cigarettecompanies were the most predominantadvertiserson youth-orientedtelevisionshows such as "Seventy-Seven SunsetStrip,""The Rebel,"and most maiortelevised sportsev6nts. Followingthe famed surgeongeneral'sreport,all cigarettessold in the U.S.beginningin 1966had to carrythe warning"Caution:CigaretteSmoking May Be Hazardousto YourHealth."In 1971that messagowas strengthened to: "Warning:The Surgeon General Has DeterminedThat CigaretteSmoking ls Dangerousto Your Health."ln 1970the governmentbannedclgarette is the advertisingfrom radioand television.But forgottenor misunderstood 152 f a c tt h a ti t w a s t h ec i g a r e t t ec o m p a n i e st h e m s e l v e s - a g h a satt t h es u c c e s s o f c o u n t e r a d v e r l i s i tnhga t a p p e a r e df r o m 1 9 6 7 t o 1 9 7 0a s t h e r e s u l to f a s i n g l ec o m p l a i nbt y t h e f o u n d e ro f A c t i o no n S m o k i n ga n d H e a l t h J, o h n Banzhaf-who removedtheir own ads to avoid havingto be shownup by the cleverads that spoofedcigarettesrnoking.KennethWarnerof the Univ e r s i t yo { M i c h i g a np o i n t e do u t i n t h e A m e r i c a nJ o u r n a l o l P u b l i cH e a l t h t h a t t h e c o u n t e r a d v e r t i s e m e nf e t sa, t u r i n gs o m e f a m o u sp e r s o n a l i t i ebsu t jingles runningin off-hoursand in low frequencycomparedto the prime-time f o r M a r l b o r oK, e n t ,S a l e m ,a n dW i n s l o nc, u t e x p e c t e dc i g a r e t t sea l € sg r o w t h b y u p w a r d so f 3 0 % i n j u s t t h r e ey e a r s . Smokingin the 1980s T h e 1 9 8 0 sa r e m a r k i n ga n e w e r a .A m e r i c a n sa r e h e a l t h i etrh a ne v e r ,s a y s t h e U . S .g o v e r n m e nTt .h e i m p r e s s i oins w i d e s p r e a d t h a tp e o p l ea r eq u i t t i n g s m o k i n gi n d r o v e sa, n d t h e n u m b e ro f t e e n a g e r tsa k i n gu p c i g a r e t tsem o k i n g is going down.Cigaretteadvertisingno longerappearson television. Cigar e t t e c o m p a n i e sa r e d i v e r s i f y i n sgo r a p i d l y ,i t i s s a i d ,t h a t t h e c i g a r e t t e i n c o m ed o e s n o t e v e n m a t t e r .B e s i d e st,h e c i g a r e t t e st h e ya r e m a k i n ga r e s a f e rt h a ne v e r .T h e n o n s m o k e r rsi g h t sm o v e m e n its w i n n i n gi t s b a t t l e sf o r clean indoorareas,and the women'shealth movementis in the vanguard . o d a y ' sa t h o f t h o s ed i s c o u r a g i ncgi g a r e t t es m o k i n ga m o n gt e e n a g eg i r l s T l e t e sd o n o t p o s e f o r c i g a r e t t ea d s .J o e D i M a g g i oi s b e t t e ri d e n t i l i e w d ith "Mr. Coffee"thanwith baseball,and MickeyMantleand LouGehrigareonly names jn lhe recordbook to today'steenagers. Theseimpressions are, for the most part,wrong.ln fact,the problemmay be worsethaneverbefore.lt is so discouraging to contemplatethe problem of cigarettesmokingamongadolescentsthat the AmericanCancerSociety, for example,has concentratedthe greaterpart of its antismoking campaign on adults.Althoughthere have been scatteredeffortsto developcurricular materialsconcerningthe dangersof smokinglor gradeschools,thereis not a singlepenny'sworthof paidadvertising aimedat teenagersto counlerthe While cigarettecompanies'nearlyone billiondollars'worth of advertising. teamsof medicalresearchersare well subsidizedto studyways of combating iuvenileonset diabetesand .juvenilerheumatoidarthritis-seriousdiseases that affect thousandsof childreneach year-there is not a single physicianemployedfull-timein the UnitedStatesto counterjuvenile onsel cigarette smoking-a conditionafflictingone millionteenagersa year. Overlookedin the much-heraldedstatementsabout Americans'supposedlyimprovedhealthstatusis that the problernof heartdiseaseamong womenis on the rise-an increasethat closelyparallelsnot onlythe number ol womenenteringthe workplacebut alsothe numberwho take up cigarette smoking.A Californiastudy of 17,000women publishedin lhe Journal ol the American Medical Assoclalion in 1980 found that the risk of heart attackamongwomenwho smokeis threetimesthat of nonsmokers; the risk of strokeis fivefold.Althoughthe total numberof malesmokersis lessthan it was in'l 964, black and Hispanicteenageboys have probablyincreased theircigarettesmoking.Per capitaconsumptionof cigaretteshas declined only slightlyin the last few years,and total sales are undiminished. 153 Smoking has long been equated with r i sk- t a ki ng and ant i aut hori tarianism. T his counleradverlisemenl mimics the macho Winston smoker who boasts " I smoke lor taste." (L6lt) Vandef Cobb. (r€hr) Rchlr(l Ydnkor In 1970the U.S. government banned clgarette advertlslng [rom radlo and television, but the cigarette companies found other ways !o convince people to smoke; today their ads are bigger, brighter, more persuasive, and more in e v i d e n c el h a n e v e r . E v e n t h e g o v e r n m e n t 'osw n f i g u r e ss h o w t h a t t h e r ea r e e i g h tt i m e sa s m a n y g i r l sa g e d 1 2 t o I 4 w h o a r e s m o k r n gt o d a ya s i n 1 9 7 0 - t h e y e a r i n o n t e l e v i s i oann d r a d i o - a n d f o r w h a c hc i g a r e t t e commerciala s s ta p p e a r e d t h e f i r s tt i m em o r ef e m a l e si n a m a j o ra g e g r o u p( 1 7 - 1 8 )a r e s m o k i n gt h a n m a l e s .A n e d i t o r i ai n l C a - A C a n c e rJ o u r n a ll o r C l i n i c i a n si n 1 9 8 1e x p r e s s e da l a r mt h a t s o m a n yg i r l sw e r e s t a r t i n gt o s m o k eb e f o r e1 3 , a n d f o r t e e n a g eg i r l s . "I n C o n n e c t i c u t , c a l l e ds m o k i n g" t h e t i c k i n gt i m e - b o m b where the Departmentof Healthhas kept the most accuraterecordsin th€ U n i t e dS t a t e s t, h e d e a t hr a t e{ r o ml u n gc a n c e ra m o n gw o m e nh a s a c t u a l l y thatof men. surpassed g u s i n e s sw l r o n i c a l l yt,h e p u b l i s h i n b , h i c h h a d r a i l e da g a i n s t e l e v i s i o n years, grew as it becamethe chiefbeneficiary advertising for silent cigarette of the switch into print advertising.Today the cigarettecompaniesar€ spendingthreetimeswhat they spentin the last year of televisedcigarette advertising. But the cigarettecompaniesnever reallywent off the air. They shifted insteadto the sponsorship of sportingeventsthat are televised-a far less costly,subtler,and possiblymore effectivesellingtechnique.The showing of PhilipMorris'sVirginiaSlimsTennisCircuit,far from being opposedby w o m e n ' sg r o u p s ,h a s b e e n p r a i s e dl o r h e l p i n gt o b r i n gw o m e n i n t o t h e big-time,big-moneysportsera. Eventhoughno maiorleaguebaseballclub wouldadmitto directsponsorship by a cigarettecompany,nearlyeveryclub receiveslucrativeincomefrom cigaretteadvertisingin programsand on scoreboards(at the bestcameraangles).The MarlboroCup horserac€has becomeone of the top sportseventsof the year.lts annualtelecastincludes dozens of mentionsof the brandname,picturesof the familiarlogo, and even the old Marlborojingle.The insertionof the Marlborobrandname on that is not even perceivedas advertising race cars is low-costadvertising as the cars flasharoundthe trackand acrossthe viewers'screensdozens cigarettecompanieshave of times during a telecast.Not coincidentally, or reb€l' becomethe leadingsponsorsoi eventsthat appealto risk-taking lious adolescentinstincts:racingof dirt bikes,motorcycles,and hot rods' r o d e o ,a n d b a l l o o n i n g . 154 A l t h o u g ho n e m i g h tt h i n kt h a t t e l e v i s i o p n l a y st h e m a j o rr o l ei n m o l d i n g leenagelife-styles, thepowerol theprintedmediumshouldnot be underestimated.Perhapsbecausethe tobaccoindustryknowsthat the incidenceof l u n gc a n c e ri s l i k e l yt o s u r p a s st h a to f b r e a s ct a n c e ra m o n gw o m e nb y 1 9 8 3 , it has become the numberone financierof women'smagazines,with th€ n o t a b l ee x c e p t i o nos f G o o d H o u s e k e e p i n gP, a r e n t sM a g a z i n e a , ndthe variousbrides magazines.The more ostensiblyhealth-oriented women's magazinesbecome,the mor€ cigaretteads crop up alongsidethe health columns,as if to denythe verynotionthatsmokingis a majorhealthproblem. Magazinesthat appealexpresslyto teenagegirls,such as Mademoiselle, are full of ads that exhortthem to "smoke prettyEve," be "a Thinnerwith S i l v aT h i n s , " " c o m e a l o n g w a y ,b a b y " w i t h V i r g i n i aS l i m s ,a n d " w e a r a M a x - G r e a t l o o k i n gG . r e a tt a s t i n gt,o o . L o n g ,l e a n ,a l l - w h i t M e a x 1 2 0 ' s . "A girldoes not evenhavelo smokethem-she canjustwearlhem.Mademoipromotesitself to advertiserswith the slogan,"Good se//e, incidentally, h e a l t h ,g o o d l o o k s ,g o o d l i v i n g . " W h e n R o l / i n g S t o n e , a m a g a z i n ew i d e l yr e a d b y t e e n s ,r a n a c o v e r photographof John Lennonin the nude,it receivediratemailfrom parents. One wonderswhetherparentshave expressedany outrageover the Marlboro cowboyon the back coveror the many otherads for differentbrands o f c i g a r e t t e s - a sw e l l a s f o r l i q u o rr, o l l i n gp a p e r s a, n d s n u f f( f e a t u r i ntgh e witha day'sworthof angrytelephonecalls, CharlieDanielsBand).Similarly, Chicagoanssucceededin removingfrom all city busesa BonjourAction Jeansad campaignthat featureda youngfemale'sunzippedpantsand bare s k i n b e n e a t h .U n o p p o s e ds,t i l l ,a r e t h e a d s f o r c i g a r e t t e tsh a t a p p e a ri n almost every bus and subwaycar of the transitsystem. One is temptedto suggestthat the leadinghealtheducatorin Americaby virtueof its positive, excitingappealto consumers-isthe cigaretteindustry.The companieseven outdoone anotherto become"lowestin tar" and to proclalmthishonoron the sportsand lashionpagesof dailynewspapers. But what does "low tar" mean?Low poison."Tar" is a compositeof over 4,000 separatesolid poisons,includingat least 35 known carcinogens. Would one go into a supermarketand buy a loaf ot breadthat contained "only two ouncesof poison"or a can of soup that was "lowestin carcinogens"? AmericanBrands says that 17 packs of Carltonare equal in tar (poison)to just one pack of Kent.Does that mean that the consumercan smoke 17 packsa daywithoutan increasedriskof disease?The hoaxis that certainbrandsaresafer.Saferthanwhat?Thanfreshair?Studiesshowthat smokerswho switchto a low-larin the beliefthat theywillbe saferare likely to smokemorein orderto maintainthe levelof nicotine.Evenon a pack-perpack basis,low-tarsmokerstradeoff slightlyless tar (carcinogen) for more carbon monoxide(heartdiseaserisk factor). What elsewillthesmokergetbesidesa strongriskfor lungcanceror heart disease?Ammonia,formaldehyde, and hydrogencyanideare just a few of in cigarettesmoke. the noxiousgasesfound in significantconcentrations just These gasesare not the resultof burningtobaccobut also a resultof chemicaladditives-mor€than 1,500of them,includingnitratesas preservatives and propyleneglycol,the solvent used as antifreeze--designedto 155 Emphysema, hear! dlsease, and lung cancer have become epldemlc ln the Unlted States and other coun(ries. Meanwhile, lhc tobacco lndustry ls trylng to see that smoHng ls not vlewed as a health lssue-ln part, by placlng clgarette ads alongside artlcles that discuss these very killers, Cdlory. OOC Arctivr k e e p t h e c i g a r e t t eb u r n i n gs m o o t h l ya n d e v e n l y .B e c a u s ec i g a r e t t e sa r e designedto burn so well,in the UnitedStateseachyear they are the leading cause of home, hospital,and hotelfires,whichtake the lives of moro than 2 , 0 0 0 p e r s o n sa n d m a i ma n d i n j u r em a n ym o r e The failure to reachteenagers ! r o n i e s a b o u n d , a s i n t h e s c e n ea b o v e . N o ! only do cigarettes couse concer and hearl disease,but becausethey are designed to burn so v,ell, they are a leading cause of fres in the United Stares With all that is known aboutthe dangersol cigaretlesmokingand all the publicheaithhand-wringing, why havewe failedto preventteenagers--gids especially-from takingup cigarettes? How do we explainthe reasoningof a 16-year-oldgirlwho choseto keepsmokingratherthan receivea fr€€ trip to Washington,D.C.,paidfor by formerHEW secretaryJosephCalifano?"l could have quit for good,but I didn'twant to," she said."lt's somethingto do with my hands." Obviously,smokingis initjaledby many social influences.lmitationof peers,and significantadults (parents,teachmodels-media stereotypes, most school-basedcigar€tte ers, doctors)-plays a big role.Unfortunately, educationprogramslackimmediacy lor students. The programsspellout the Yet to any adolescentwho dangers and emphasizeeventualdisabilities. feels fine and has good health,illness-especiallycancer-js an abstract thing.lt is difficultto sellhealthto someonewho alreadybelieveshe has it. Moreover,adolescenceis a highlystressfulperiod of developmentcomplicatedby reactionsto puberty.Teensmay not be able or willingto see beyondthe immediatepresent.And when lookingfor role modelsthe disciplinarianparentor teacheror doctordoes not hold a candle to the cattlegal who gets her Barclayciga-, ropingMarlboroman or sleek,clear-skinned rette lit by a dashinggentleman.(Brown& Williamson,incidentally,spent $150,000,000in less than a year to introduceBarclay,a new brand, an amounl that is probably grealer than all the money that has €ver r56 g o n e i n t o r e s e a r c ho n t h e e f f e c t so f s m o k i n ga n d e f f o r t st o p r e v e n itt . S c h o o l sh a v ea l s oc o n c e n t r a t eodn t h e i d e at h a ts m o k i n gi s s e l f - d e s t r u c t i v e b e h a v i o ra n d e m p h a s i z e d" n o t b e c o m i n go n e o l t h e c r o w d . "B u t a s D a n i e lH o r n ,a l e a d e ri n t h e f i e l do f s m o k i n ge d u c a t i o nh,a s c o m m e n t e idn r e g a r dt o s c h o o l - b a s epdr o g r a m s":T h e r ea r e s e r i o u sd i f f i c u l t l ei ns a t t e m p t i n g t o i n f l u e n c ey o u n gp e o p l eb y t e a c h i n gt h e m i n t h e c l a s s r o o m to adopt b e h a v i o ro p p o s e dt o p r a c t i c e st h a t a r e e n c o u r a g e idn t h e l a r g e re n v i r o n m e n t . "C i g a r e t t e c o m p a n i e sc a n k e e pu p w i t h t h e l a t e s tf a d s( a n di n s o m e i n s t a n c e sc r e a t et h e m )i n t h e i rd e p i c t i oonf s m o k i n ga n ds o r e m a i ni n v o g u e far better than the schools.Indeed,the tobaccoindustryalliancehas put t o g e t h ea r s e e m i n g luy n c h a l l e n g e a bm l eu l t i b i l l i odno l l a rs m o k i n gp r o p a g a n da effort. Camouflagedin all the cigaretteads and often laughedat by t e e n a g e r si s t h e h e a l t hj o k e o f t h ec e n t u r y":W a r n i n gT: h e S u r g e o nG e n e r a l H a s D e t e r m i n eT d h a t C i g a r e t t eS m o k i n gl s D a n g e r o u tso Y o u r H e a l t h . " As it there were any doubt, the U.S. FederalTrade Commission(FTC) c o n c l u d e di n m j d - 1 9 8 1l h a t l h e m e s s a g eo n c i g a r e t l ep a c k a g e sh a d n o t discouragedsmokers.The FTC proposedchangesin the sizeand shapeof the printedwarningas well as a moredirectstatement,referringspecifically to cancer and heart attacks. The tobaccoindustryhas been stunningly successfulin its oppositionto any government-sponsored smokingeducationprogramsdirectedat young people,in its refutationof evidencethatsmokingis particularly damagingin pregnantwomen,in its contention-havingnever admittedthat smokingis dangerousin the first place-that it can be made safer,and in its attempt to cover up the cripplingtoll takenby smoking.Fear arousalhas not been (lt does appearto havesome suflicientto thwartsmokingin adolescents. years effect in childrenunderten of age.)lt is the veryrisk-taking, antisocial tendencyof adolescentsto whichtheindustryis appealing. Teenagersprob- 157 It is hoped that concerned citizens from every age group will join in !he crusade to prevent smoking among Joung people. But leenagers themselvesmust be in lhe vanguard of eforts to unsell cigaretles, as !hey were in designing this ad bench in S pa r !anburg, Sout h Carolina. T o b a c c o c o m p a n l e sk n o w h o w t o r e o c h teenagers. They sponsor ma)or sporting ond muslcal eventssuch as the Kool Jazz Festlvals, >+,hlchtake place ln many clties a c r o s s t h e U n l t e d S t a t e s .T h l s , t o o , l s advertising. a b l yd o n o t h a v ea n o v e r w h e l m i ndge s i r et o b r e a t h ei n h o t c a r c i n o g e nasn d p o i s o n o u ss,m e l l yg a s e s R . a l h e rt,h e ya r es i m p l yi d e n t i f y i nwgi t ht o u g hc o w b o y sa r d s o p h j s l i c a t el d a d i e sl t i s n c t l u s ta r n a l t e ro f s m o k i n ga c i g a r e t t e b u t o f p i c k i n ga n i m a g e - - - - o nbeu y s M a r l b o r o so r V i r g i n i aS l i m s ,a n d o n e s e l e c t so n e ' s b r a n dc a r e f u l l y . O n er e p o r td o n efo r t h e N a t i o n alln s t i t u t e o n D r u gA b u s eb y U n i v e r s i toyf M i c h i g a rne s e a r c h e rssh o w e da d e c l i n eI nt e e n a g es m o k i n gO . f 1 7 , 0 0 0h i g h s c h o o ls e n i o r s2 9 % s m o k e di n 1 9 7 7 ;2 i ' , ' "i n 1 9 8 0 .E v e nt h o u g hg i r l sw e r e 'l s m o k i n gl e s s j n 9 8 0 l h e y c o n t i n u e dt o b e h e a v i e rs m o k e r st h a n b o y s ( 3 0 1% s m o k e di ^ 1 9 7 7 ,2 3 5 " h i n 1 9 8 0 ) A . m o n gb o y s ,2 7 . 2 " hs m o k e di n 1 9 7 7 , 1 8 . 5 %i n 1 9 8 0 .T h e r e s e a r c h e rast t r i b u t etdh e o v e r a ldl e c l i n ei n t h i s g r o u p i,n p a r l ,t o g r e a l e p r u b l i cd i s a p p r o v a o lf s m o k i n gT. h i ss u r v e yu n f o r t u n a t e l ym a y n o t a c c u r a t e l rye f l e c t h e h a b i t so l c e r t a i np o p u l a t i o n sw,h e r e p e r c e n t a g eosf s m o k e r sa r e p r o b a b l ys t g n i f i c a n thl yi g h e r - s u c ha s a m o n g , i s p a n i c sa,n d i n n e r - c r tbyl a c k s . s c h o o ld r o p o u t sH p M o r e o v e rt ,h e r o b l e mi s b y n o m e a n sg o n e .A n d a n y g o o dn e w ss h o u l d n o t l u l lt h e p u b l i ci n t o b e l i e v i n vgi g i l a n c ea n d c o u n t e r a t l a cakr e n o l o n g e r c r u c i a l .E v e r yo n e o f t h e t h o u s a n d so f u n o p p o s e db i l l b o a r d sa n d o t h e r a d v e r t i s e m e nat sc h i l dg r o w su p s e e i n gr e p r e s e n ttsh e c i g a r e t t ceo m p a n i e s ' d e n y i n gt h ef a c t sa n du n d e r m i n i nmge d i c asl c i e n c eE. d u c a t i nw g i t ht h e f a c t s l s i m p o r t a nat n d n e c e s s a r yB. u l b e c a u s et e e n s a r e t e e n s ,b e c a u s st h e tobaccoindustryis rich, powerful,and unwillingto acknowledgethat lts p r o d u c it s a m a j o rk i l l e r a , n d b e c a u s ea d v e r l i s i nigs s u c h a p e r v a s i v ea n d f o r mo f p e r s u a s i o ns,o m ee f l c r t sm u s tb e m a d et o u n d oc i g a r e t t e effective promotion. I t g o e sw i t h o u ts a y i n gl h a t t h o s ew h o c h o o s et o d e a lw i t ht h e p r o b l e m and it is hopedthat theywill come from everyage groupand occupatiorlm u s t b e m i n d f u lt h a t c i g a r e t t es m o k i n gi s t h e n u m b e ro n e t e e n a g €d r u g p r o b l e mB . u t t h e y n e e da l s o r e m e m b etrh a ts m o k i n gi s a s m u c ha s e r l o u s p r s o c i e t a l o b l e ma s a h e a l t hp r o b l e mT. h ec i g a r e t t ies a s y m b ofl o rw h a l e v e r t h e t o b a c c oi n d u s t r yw a n t si t t o b e . 158 \t \\ Ad.olrd l.m'O.ng.r! ol Sfrkiog. ganclit! ol Ouilhg.. amdf,rn Crncd 56ty Spreadingthe antismoking message How does the UnitedStatesmeasureup to othercountriesin the eflort to discouragecigarettesmokingamongyoung people?Fair,al best. In spite of activist€ffortsfor clean indoorair by the organization ASH (Actionon Smokingand Heatth)and variouschaptersof GASP(GroupAgainstSmokers' Pollution)as wellas the development of poslersand othermaterialsby such groupsas lhe AmericanCancerSocietyand lhe AmericanLungAssociation,and repeatedpublic statementson the cigaretteproblemby surgeons generalLutherTerry,JesseSteinfeld,and JuliusRichmond,and by a few outspokenphysicians likeAltonOchsner,the UnitedStateshas largely failedto reachlargenumbersof childrenand teenagers.In fact,the United Statesappearsto lagbehindnumerousothercountries-onlysomeof which are mentionedhere-in providingincentiveslor a smoke-freegeneration. Canadahas laredsomewhatbetter,largelydue to the outspokenCanadian Councilon Smokingand Health,which is supportedby both gov€rnmental and charitablegroups from every province.The governm€ntsof Quebecand Saskatchewan havepioneeredin paid advertisements on radio and lelevisionthat discouragesmoking(as well as other lethallife-styles such as drunkendrivingand poornutrition). Toronto'sNon-Smokers' Rights Association, whichhas widelypublicizedthe hazardsto childrenof secondhand smoke, succeededin lobbyingfor one of the most restrictivebans anywhereon smokingin publicplacesas well as a ban on cigaretteadvertising on the city'stransitsystem.Winnipegwill be the site of the lifth World C o n f e r e n c eo n S m o k i n gi n 1 9 8 3 . The WorldHealthOrganization has declaredthat in industrialized nations "the control of cigarettesmokingcould do more to improvehealth and prolong life than any other singleaction in the whole field of preventive medicine."Butin thevastmajorityof thirdworldnations,wheregovernments equate tobacco sales with lucrativerevenuesand where Americanand Britishtobaccocornpanieshavesaluratedthe mediawith advertising, there are no governmentofficialsor charitieschargedwith tacklingthe cigarette problem.While there is acrimoniousdebate over the ethicsof promoting in{ant formulaand U.S.-madedrugsin developingcountries,cigaretteswith no redeeminghealthvalue--continueto be far more widelypromoted than any other product.To cultivatesmokingamong the populationsof impoverished countries,the tobaccocompaniesgive awayenormousquantitiesol cigarettesand-using childrenas streetvendors-sell cigarettesnot just by the pack but by the piece.In poorernationsof the worldsmokingis most popularamongthe wealthier,bettereducated,and more "sophisticated." Among male medicalstudentsin Nigeriain 1976,72o/owe'e cigarette smokers. One of the most progressiveefforts to combat smoking among children is under way in Nicaragua,where the governmenthas made health and literacymajorpriorities. ln the restof Centraland SouthAmericathe picture is less sanguinebecausetobaccois simplytoo culturallyengrained.Although Venezuelahas banned cigaretteadvertisingfrom radio and television and Brazil is beginning to counteradvertise,Mexico is home of the world's largestMarlborobillboards. 159 Rirks of uuoking rnd bene0tr of quitting chorteoed life expectancy after l0 to l5 yean cx-smoker'srisk ap proachesthat of thoscwho neversmoked lung cencer after l0 to 15 yean risk approachesthat of thosc who neversmoked larynx cancer gradual reduction in risk, reachingnormal after l0 years mouth cancer reducing or eliminating smoking,/drinking lowen risk in fint few years; risk drops to level of norsmoken in l0 to l5 years cancer of esopbagu.c sincc risk is proportional to dose,reducing or eliminating smoking/drinking should lower risk canctr of bladder risk decreasesgraduslly to that of nonsmoken over 7 yean cancrr of pancreaS sincr risk seernsrelated to dosc' stopping smoking should reduceit coronary beart di.*ar risk decrcascssharply after one year; after l0 years risk is the same as for those who never smoked bronchitic and emphysema cough sputum disappean within few weeks; lung functionmay improvg deterioration slowed ctillbinh and low birth weiglt if smoking is stopped before fourth month of pregnancy, risk to fetus is eliminated peptic ulccr ex-smoken get ulcers too, but they hcal faster and more complctely than in smokers drug end test effects most blod factors raiscd by smoking return to normal; norsmokers on birth control pill have much lower risk of hazardousclots snd heart sttacks Serg€ Ldmo6o-Ga|lld Many European countries are /ar ohtat! of the United States ln el|orts to d i s c o u r a g es m o k i n g a m o n g t h e i r y o u r h . Most notableare Norway, Swtden, Fronce, and Great Britain. Prince Chorles, an outspoken nonsmoker, has b e e n a p e r s u a s i v em o d e l f o r B r i t i s h younSSters J a p a ni s s e c o n do n l yt o t h eU S i n p e rc a p i t ac i g a r e t tceo n s u m p t i oYn e. t J a p a nh a s p u t m o r ee n e r g yi n t oc o m b a t i ncgi g a r e t t e - b u l i t t e trh a ni t h a s i n c o m t j a t i ntgh e p r o b l e mo f c i g a r e t t sem o k r n g a m o n gy o u n gp e o p l eC. h i n a , w h r c hr a n k sh i g hi n t h ep r o d u c t r oonf t o b a c c oh, a ss e e na 1 5 - f o lrdi s ei n l u n g c a n c e ri n S h a n g h aai n d o t h e ra r e a ss i n c et h e m i d - 1 9 6 0asn d h a s f i n a l l y b e g u nw a r n i n gi t s c i t i z e nos f t h e h a z a r d o s f s m o k i n gN. o n e t h e l e si sn ,' l 9 8 0 P h r l iM p o r r i sb e c a m eo n eo f t h ef i r s tU . S .c o m p a n i epse r m i t l etdo o p e ns h o p i n C h i n a .B i l l b o a r d sh a v e m a d e i t o f f i c i a lP: e k i n gi s M a r l b o r oC o u n t r y . A l l h o u g ht h e U S . S R . d o e sn o t h a v ea d v e r t i s i npge r s e , t h e g o v e r n m e n t s t r isl e e k st o p r o fi ( f r o mc i g a r e t t e s a l e s .M o s c o wh a sb a n n e ds m o k i n gi n t h e c i t y ' sr e s t a u r a n t sb,u t S o c h i ,a B l a c kS e a r e s o r t h a t a t t e m p t e d to become t h e c o u n t r y ' sf i r s tn o n s m o k i ncgi t y ,w a s n o t s u c c e s sufl . I n m a n yC o m m u n i s t c o u n t r i e sU, . S c i g a r e t t e s e r y ea s c u r r e n c y . P a r t l yo w i n gl o M u s l i mr e l i g i o u b s e l i e f sA , r a bc o u n t r i e sh a v eb e e nw o r l d l e a d e r si n c o u n t e r a c t i ncgi g a r e t t es m o k i n ga n d p r o m o t i o nS. a u d iA r a b i a d o e s n o t p e r m i tc i g a r e t t ea d v e r t i s i n gK.u w a i tf i n e ss t o r eo w n e r sw h o p o s t p r o m o t i o n adli s p l a y sf o r c i g a r e f t e sB.a h r a i nb a n sa d v e r t i s i nfgo r c i g a r e t t e s ; i n D u b a i ,a d v e r t i s e rcsa n p l a c eb i l l b o a r dfso r c i g a r e t t e isn s p o r t ss t a d i u m s , b u t o n l y w h e r e t h e y c a n n o tb e p i c k e du p b y t e l e v i s i o nc a m e r a s A . nwar S a d a t ' sw i f e ,J i h a n ,i s h e a do f t h e E g y p t i a C n a n c e rS o c i e t ya n dh a s l e d t h e d r i v et o e l i m i n a t ec i g a r e t t ea d v e r t i s i n lgr o m T V , r a d i o ,a n d b i l l b o a r d sI.n returnthe cigarettecompanieshave resortedto puttinglree movietickets in cigarettepacks to boost sales.In Turkey,with one of the world'shighest p e r c e n t a goef s m o k e r st,h eg o v e r n m e ndto e sn o ts e e ma s w o r r i e da b o u tt h e h e a l t ho f i t s c i t i z e n sa s i t d o e sa b o u tV i r g i n i at o b a c c o ' so v e r t a k i nTgu r k i s h t o b a c c oa s t h e s m o k e r ' sc h o i c e . S i n c e1 9 8 0G r e e c ew , h i c hh a s t h e h i g h e sst m o k i n gr a t eo n t h e E u r o p e a n continent,has curbed publicsnroking,bannedmost cigaretteadvertising, and startededucationalcounterefforts. ltalyhas alsobannedmostadverilsing for cigarettes,but Americanand Britishcigarettecompaniesare openly v i o l a t i n gt h e b a n , p a y i n gs m a l lf i n e si n o r d e rt o c o n t l n u et o a d v e r t i s e . Someof the most hopefulsignsin Europecome fromGreatBritain,where A c t i o no n S m o k i n ga n d H e a l t hi s a n o f f i c i a a l r m o f t h e R o y a lC o l l e g eo f 160 P h y s i c r a n sa, n d w h e r e t h e B l t r s h M e d t c a l J o u r n a l a n d T h e L a n c e l h a v e m o b r l r z ep d h y s i c i a na t t e n t i o nt o t h e p r o b l e m .H a v i n gp o i n t e do u t t h a t o n e i n t h r e e B r i t i s hs m o k e r ss t a r t e d b e f o r e t h e y w e r e n i n e y e a r s o l d , t h e g o v e r n m e n t - s u p p o r t e dB r i t i s h H e a l t h E d u c a t r o nC o u n c i l h a s d e v e l o p e d s e v e r a l y o u t h - o r i e n t e dc a m p a i g n s ,i n c l u d i n go n e f e a t u r i n gS u p e r m a n . M a n y o f t h e l e a d i n g a t h l e t e s i n G r e a t B r i t a i n h a v e t a k e n o u t p a i d a d v e r t i s e m e n t si n n e w s p a p e r sc a l l r n go n t h e B r i t i s h - A m e r i c aTno b a c c o C o . t o g e t o u t o f a t h l e t r c s s p o n s o r s h i p .l n a d d i t i o n ,t h e B r i t i s hA r m y i s s t r o n g l yd i s c o u r a g i n gs m o k i n g i n i t s r a n k s a n d P r i n c e C h a r l e s ,p u b l i c l ys t a t i n gh i s d i s t a s t ef o r c i g a r e t t e s m o k i n g ,h a s b e e n a s u p e r b r o l e m o d e l f o r c h i l d r e na n d t e e n a g e r s .S c o t l a n d h a s a l s o g o n e a b o u t i t s e f f o r t v r r t hv e r v e , r e c r u i t i n gp o p u l a r r o c k s t a r s f o r i t s a d s l r e l a n dh a s b e q u n p l a c i n ga l a r g ew a r n i n go n a i l c r g a r e t t ep a c k s a n d a d v e r t r s e m c n t s" .S m o k e r s D i e Y o u n g e r . " A l t h o u g h A u s t r a l i aw i e l d s o n l y a f r a c t i o no l t h e p o w e r o f t h e t o b a c c o r n d u s t r y ,a n u m b e r o f o r g a n i z a t i o n sh a v e e x p r e s s e d c o n c e r n a b o u t t h e h e a l l ha n d v u l n c r a b r L o r lfyy o u n gp c o p l e I h e A u s t r a l i a nM e d i c a A l ssociation h a s l a k e n a l e a d i n gr o l e i n c u r t a i l i n cg i g a r e t t es m o k i n g A . g r o u pc a l l e dM O P t p p o s e d t o t h e P r o m o t i o no f U n h e a l t h yP r o d u c t s )s u c c e e d U P ( l v l o v e r n e nO e d r n h a v i n g a p o p u l a rc h i l d r e n ' se n t c r t a i n e rr e m o v e d a s a c i g a r e t t eb r a n d s p o k e s m a n .N i n e c f t h e c o u n t r y ' st o p r u g b y p l a y e r SS t a r r e di n a p o p u l a r 1 9 8 0a n t i s m o k i n gc a m p a i g n( " G i v ey o u r s e l fa s p o r t i n gc h a n c e .S t o p s m o k r n g l " ) t h a t a n g e r e dl e a g u e o f f i c i a l sc o n c e r n e da b o u t l o s i n g t o b a c c o i n d u s t r y s p o n s o r s h i p .A l s o i n 1 9 8 O t h e E a s t T o r r e n s D i s t r i c tC r i c k e t C l u b o f S o u t h A u s t r a l i as h o c k e d t h e s p o r l s w o r l d b y r e j e c t i n ga l l t o b a c c o s p o n s o r s h i pa n d b y m a k i n g t h e i n t e r n a t i o n asl t o p - s m o k r n gs y m b o la p a r t o f i t s o f f i c i a lu n i f o r m . T h e c l u b w a s c e n s u r e db y t h e I n t e r n a t i o n aC l r i c k e tC o n l e r e n c e f o r i t s " i n g r a l r t u d e " a n d f o r t u r n i n go v e r s o r n e t o b a c c o i n d u s t r y f u n d i n g t o t h e A n t i C a n c e r F u n d . T h e m o s t v i s i b l ea c t i o n sh a v e b e e n t a k e n b y t w o A u s t r a l i a n g r o u p s . B U G A U P ( B i l l b o a r d - U t i l i z i nGgr a f f i t i s t sA g a i n s t U n h e a l t h yP r o m o trons)a , p h y s i c i a n - l e do r g a n i z a t i o nd, e f a c e sb i l l b o a r d sa d v e r t i s i n gc i g a r e t t e s w i t h s p r a y p a i n t . T h e B l a c k L u n g L i b e r a t i o nF r o n t g o e s e v e n l a r t h e r ; t h i s g r o u p c h o p s d o w n a n d b u r n s b i l l b o a r d st h a t p r o m o t e c i g a r e t t e s .P a r o d y i n g t h e s l o g a n f o r a p o p u l a rb r a n d , t h e g r o u p ' s m o t t o i s : " L i g h t u p a b i l l b o a r d y o u ' l lb e g l a d y o u d i d . " ln terms of widespread public support, Australia is a leader in the fght against cigarette advertising. A group called BUCA U P ( Billboard-Utilizing Grafitists Against Unhealthy Promotions) takes to the streets al night with spray paint to delace billboards. The police have been tolerant of this vandalism, which is largely practiced by doctors.