Research Book

Transcription

Research Book

John Katko (NY-24) Research Report
The following report contains research on John Katko, a Republican member of Congress in New
York’s 24th district. Research for this research book was conducted by the Democratic
Congressional Campaign Committee’s Research Department between November 2015 and April
2016.
By accepting this report, you are accepting responsibility for all information and analysis included.
Therefore, it is your responsibility to verify all claims against the original documentation before you
make use of it.
Make sure you understand the facts behind our conclusions before making any specific charges
against anyone.
Table of Contents
Top Hits ..................................................................................................... 4
Key Moments on Video ........................................................................... 33
Biography ................................................................................................ 36
Personal Finance ...................................................................................... 37
Assistant United States Attorney ............................................................. 40
… Gang Prosecutions .............................................................................. 40
… Police and Political Corruption ........................................................... 56
… Drug Crime ......................................................................................... 65
… Other Prosecutions .............................................................................. 75
Political Career ........................................................................................ 78
Office Operations................................................................................... 101
Abortion and Family Planning Issues .................................................... 105
Agriculture And Food Safety ................................................................. 114
Budget Issues ......................................................................................... 117
Campaign Finance and Election Law Issues .......................................... 131
Criminal Justice ..................................................................................... 135
Defense .................................................................................................. 143
Education Issues .................................................................................... 151
Energy ................................................................................................... 162
Environment .......................................................................................... 181
Foreign Policy Issues ............................................................................. 197
Gun Issues ............................................................................................. 206
Health Care Issues ................................................................................. 225
Homeland Security ................................................................................ 242
House Administration ............................................................................ 258
Immigration and Border Issues .............................................................. 263
Labor and Working Families ................................................................. 272
LGBT Issues .......................................................................................... 281
Regulatory Reform ................................................................................ 282
Senior’s Issues ....................................................................................... 308
Small Business ....................................................................................... 312
2
Tax Issues .............................................................................................. 314
Trade ...................................................................................................... 319
Transportation Issues ............................................................................. 331
Veterans ................................................................................................. 348
Women’s Issues ..................................................................................... 352
Appendix I – Campaign Finance ........................................................... 355
Appendix II – Paid Media Summary ..................................................... 374
Appendix III – Case List ........................................................................ 387
Appendix IV – Bill Sponsorships .......................................................... 414
Appendix V – Bill Co-Sponsorships ...................................................... 416
Appendix VI – Office Expenditures And Travel ................................... 427
Appendix VII – AUSA Travel Expenditures ......................................... 430
3
Top Hits
Private Law And Prosecutorial History In El Paso And Puerto Rico
Said He Felt “Stifled” at a Private Law Firm, Public Service was Calling Him
In April 2014, in a biographical video on his campaign website Katko said that he felt stifled working at
a private law firm and that public service was calling him.
“I felt stifled, and I felt I knew I didn’t want to be a partner at a big law firm. It wasn’t the life for me,
and public service was really gnawing at me,” Katko said. [Meet John and Robin Katko, 4/17/14]
Worked As Part Of A Task Force In El Paso To Investigate Juarez Cartels, And Prosecuted An
Eight-Person Murder In Puerto Rico
Worked As Part Of A Task Force In El Paso To Investigate Juarez Drug Cartels. “Early in his career,
Katko was assigned to a task force in El Paso, Texas, that investigated drug cartels across the border in
Juarez, Mexico.” [Post Standard, 12/02/14]
Worked As A Special Prosecutor For The Justice Department In El Paso In 1995 And 1996. “‘I
think we need to take a step back to see how this happened,’ said Katko, who served as a special
prosecutor for the Justice Department in El Paso, Texas in 1995 and 1996, assigned to a secure border
initiative.” [Post Standard, 7/08/14]
Prosecuted An Eight Person Murder In Puerto Rico. “While he was prosecuting an eight-person
murder in Puerto Rico, he said he sent his wife and son back to Syracuse to live with his parents for eight
months. ‘It got very sticky, very quickly,’ he said. He brought up the threats to his family earlier this year
in an unsuccessful effort to stop the newspaper from publishing a story about the time he lost a gun that
was later used in a crime.” [Post Standard, 10/24/14]
Actions As Assistant United States Attorney
Appealed Case to Seek Life Sentence without Parole for Non Violent Offender
In January 2006, Justin Powell was sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole after
Katko appealed Powell’s original sentence of 20 years.
Katko claimed that federal law mandated a life sentence because Powell had two prior felony drug
convictions and was held responsible in the instant case for more than 50 grams of crack cocaine. [U.S.
Department of Justice press release, 1/12/06]
Katko Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member that Murdered a Toddler
In July 2013, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Evans, in which he pleaded guilty to racketeering charges
and faced a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.
4
In April 2014, Evans was sentenced to 400 months in prison, approximately 33 years, to be served
concurrently with a sentence he was already serving in Onondaga County. [United States District Court of
Northern New York, 5:2011-cr-00198]
Secured Lesser Sentence for Gang Member Who Confessed to Murder
In November 2004, Katko asked U.S. District Judge Norman Mordue for a lesser sentence for Rodney
Hill, a gang member who confessed on the witness stand to homicide, because of Hill’s cooperation with
prosecutors in Brown’s. Hill was facing 12 to 15 years in prison on a racketeering conviction.
Judge Mordue sentenced Hill to 105 months behind bars for conspiring with other Boot Camp members
to use violence to control the drug trade within its turf for eight years. [Post-Standard, 11/17/04]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Police Officer Accused of Rape
In July 2001, Katko chose not to prosecute a rape accusation in exchange for a plea deal with Officer
Michael Siler.
Siler accepted the plea deal offered by Katko, which included counts of drug distribution, drug
possession, extortion and racketeering. Prosecutors said Siler regularly shook down drug dealers and
then supplied the crack cocaine to informants. The racketeering charge also accused him of falsifying
police records and intimidating a witness to avoid detection and prosecution. [Associated Press, 7/23/01]
Officer Allegedly Lured Woman to Bachelor Party with Crack Cocaine and then Raped
Her
In June 2001, Renee Rickson testified before the grand jury that Siler offered her crack cocaine in
exchange for attending a bachelor party, where she alleged to have been raped by Siler and
another officer.
“I will never forget what they did to me, until the day I die,” Rickson said.
Rickson claimed that Siler had followed and harassed her for weeks, once taking her to his
apartment. Rickson alleged that when Siler made sexual advances on her in his apartment she
asked to be taken home but he laughed at her and said, “What are you doing to do, call the cops?”
[Albany Times-Union, 6/05/01]
Rickson, who had recently been released from a year in prison for selling drugs, she said she has
straightened out her life, was going to drug and alcohol counseling and worked at Mont Pleasant
Middle School in Schenectady. [Albany Times-Union, 12/28/01]
Defense Attorneys Referred to Officer as a “Rapist” and “Drug User”
In December 2001, while Siler was testifying on behalf of the government, defense attorneys
referred to him as a “rapist, perjurer, and drug user, who implicated his colleagues to stay out of
jail.” [Albany Times-Union, 12/19/01]
5
Officer Under Investigation by Katko Committed Suicide
In October 2001, Schenectady Police Officer William Marhafer committed suicide due to an ongoing
police corruption investigation for which Katko was the lead prosecutor. [Times Unions, 10/07/01]
Threatening and Coercive Tactics Used During Investigation
In October 2001, Defense Attorney Paul DerOhannesian – who defended another officer
prosecuted by Katko – said, “A lot of lives and reputations are being threatened by federal
investigative tactics. A common technique is to threaten police officers with public humiliation if
they don’t cooperate.”
“Marhafer wasn’t even charged, but he was under a lot of pressure, so what you have is lives
being sacrificed at the altar for investigative expediency,” he continued.
DerOhannesian said police officers besides Messere and civilians have come to him regarding the
federal investigation. “Threatening and coercive tactics are being used by the people running this
investigation.” [Times Unions, 10/07/01]
Helped Secure Reduced Sentence for Leader of Largest Drug Ring in Central New York
In May 2007, Alexander Cammacho, the mastermind behind the largest marijuana selling ring ever in
Central New York was sentenced to 15 years in federal prison. Cammacho, who was being prosecuted by
Katko, could have been sentenced to life imprisonment but his sentence was reduced because he
cooperated with prosecutors. [Associated Press, 5/22/07]
The massive drug ring was believed to have bought and sold about $13.5 million in marijuana over the
course of several years, Katko said.
Cammacho and 14 others were arrested in 2005, ending a months-long investigation. When it was all
over, investigators had seized nearly $1.8 million in cash, 30 vehicles and more than 100 pounds of pot,
Katko said. [Post-Standard, 5/22/07]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member who was Then Convicted of Assault, Drug Possession
In December 2008, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Uptown gang member Bennie Jackson. Jackson had
been indicted on charges of crack distribution and the use and possession of a firearm. In the plea
agreement, the weapons charge was dropped and Jackson faced a maximum term of life imprisonment.
In February 2011, Jackson was sentenced to 46 months in prison. Jackson was released from federal
prison in July 2011. [United States District Court of Northern New York, 5:2008-cr-00293; Federal
Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator, accessed 4/14/14]
In July 2012, Jackson violated the terms of his parole and was charged and convicted of 2nd degree
assault and 3rd degree criminal possession of a controlled substance. Jackson was sentenced to 3 years in
prison for the assault and 2 years in prison for the drug possession to be served consecutively. Jackson
6
would be eligible for a parole hearing in February 2015. [Onondaga County Court, Indictment No.
201200371, Indictment No. 201205181; New York State Department of Corrections Inmate Information
Search, accessed 4/14/14]
NOTE: Public records requests for the documents from the Onondaga County Court case against
Jackson are ongoing.
Additionally, there are three other gang members prosecuted by Katko who are potential recidivists.
Further research is necessary
Gosek Case
Agreed to Drop Charge Against Mayor Gosek Who Allegedly Solicited Sex with Minor;
Documents Which Became Unsealed After The 2014 Elections Showed Gosek Provided
Information Spurring The Investigation Of A Public Official
In March 2006, Katko agreed to drop a charge of soliciting sex from a minor against former Oswego
Mayor John Gosek part of a plea bargain.
Gosek pleaded guilty to a felony charge of using his city cell phone to induce what he thought were two
15-year-old girls to have sex with him. In exchange, Katko agreed to drop a second charge of soliciting
sex from a woman Gosek thought was 14 years old in 2004.
Under his plea deal, Gosek was expected to receive five years in prison, the mandatory minimum
sentence for his crime. [Post-Standard, 3/14/06]
Helped Secure Lower Sentence for Gosek
In July 2006, Katko recommended a lower sentence for Gosek because of his “substantial
assistance.” Gosek was facing a mandatory minimum sentence of five years in prison under
federal sentencing guidelines, but Katko asked U.S. District Judge Thomas McAvoy to depart
from the guidelines.
Gosek was sentenced to 37 months in prison.
The details of what Gosek told investigators were removed from a sentencing memorandum filed
by Katko. [Post-Standard, 7/19/06]
…But Said he Had a “Very Dark Side” and was a “Danger”
In September 2005, Katko said Gosek posed a danger to the community. [Post-Standard,
9/20/05]
In July 2006 after the trial, Katko said Gosek had a “very dark side.” “The wiretap
showed that the defendant routinely engaged in incredibly selfish, self-indulgent,
manipulative and morally repugnant conduct that was criminal in nature,” Katko wrote.
[Post-Standard, 7/19/06]
7
Maffei Attacked Katko Over The Gosek Case. “Maffei repeated his charges against Katko at a news
conference this morning in Syracuse's Clinton Square, where he was joined by a group of Central New
York mothers and community activists. … ‘The fact is that John Katko put politics ahead of community
safety, seeking a plea deal with a known child sexual predator,’ Maffei campaign manager Kane Miller
said. ‘A mayor who had a long history of soliciting children faced 30 years in prison. Katko dropped one
of the charges, and persuaded a Republican judge to give the mayor a shorter sentence putting our
community at risk.’” [Post-Standard, 10/01/14]
Noted In Previously Sealed Documents That Gosek Began Providing Information And Though
“Much Of The Information Provided By The Defendant Was Of Little Value To The Government,
The Defendant Has Provided Information That Has Produced Leads That We Are Now Pursuing,”
And “While The Defendant Had No Concrete Information Of Wrongdoing … An Investigation
Into Possible Wrongdoing Is Ongoing.” “Soon after his arrest, the defendant began attempting to
provide substantial assistance to the government. In that regard, the Defendant was extensively debriefed
regarding his conduct in this case as well as in his position as Mayor of the City of Oswego. While much
of the information provided by the Defendant was of little value to the government, the defendant has
provided some information that has produced leads that we are now pursuing. In particular, the defendant
provided information regarding the possible ‘fixing’ of real estate valuations of at least one high level
Oswego public official who own multiple rental properties. While the Defendant had no concrete
information of wrongdoing, he did provide information regarding the fact that the property values for all
of the properties in question had in fact been reduced in the most recent assessment. Subsequent records
checks confirmed this and an investigation into possible wrongdoing is ongoing.” [Sentencing
Memorandum Of The United States, 7/07/06]
Unsealed Documents Post-Election Showed Katko Gave Gosek A Lighter Sentence Because Gosek
Gave Information About Alleged Wrongdoing On Another Public Official. “We know negative
advertising is nasty. It also can be false, as we learned last week when a federal judge unsealed
documents pertaining to former Oswego Mayor John Gosek. U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei, D-Syracuse, used
the Gosek plea agreement in a negative attack ad against his Republican op-ponent, John Katko. As an
assistant U.S. attorney in 2006, Katko prosecuted Gosek on charges he tried to entice what he thought
were two 15-year-old teen age girls to have sex. Maffei’s ad accused Katko of working with a federal
judge to give the mayor a lighter sentence. Why? Because they were all Republicans. The allegations in
Maffei’s ad prompted syracuse.com and The Post-Standard to renew a request to see the mayor’s
sentencing documents. We first asked for them in 2005 and subsequently sought them two more times.
Each request was denied on the grounds the investigation was ongoing. The fact U.S. District Judge
Thomas McAvoy unsealed them this time is an indication the probe is over. The unsealed documents
show that Gosek was given a lighter sentence in return for giving prosecutors information about alleged
wrongdoing involving another Oswego public official. Katko maintained there was nothing hinky about
Gosek’s sentence. He was right.” [Editorial, Post Standard, 11/23/14]
Gun Theft And Burt Street Killings
Said “In Response To Confirmed And Credible Threats” He Obtained “A Protective Weapon”
Said “In Response To Confirmed And Credible Threats” He Obtained “A Protective Weapon.” “In
8
response to confirmed and credible threats against my family and me and at the urging of the United
States Marshals Service and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Robin and I have incorporated their
recommended total protection package into our daily lives. Part of that plan required me to legally obtain
a protective weapon, which I did with proper approvals and training from the United States Department
of Justice and the United States Marshals Service.” [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Katko’s Gun, Issued by U.S. Attorney’s Office, Stolen from His Car; Presidential Directive
Required Use Of A Gun Lock,
On April 3, 2000 Katko’s 1989 Chevy EFI pick-up truck was broken into on the 300 block of Marks
Ave. in Syracuse, New York sometime between 7:00 and 10:00 pm. The passenger side window was
smashed in with a rock and among the items stolen was Katko’s Glock model 40, .40 caliber automatic
pistol that was loaded with 9 rounds of ammunition. [Syracuse Police Dept., Case # 00-097007]
The gun was issued through the U.S. Attorney’s office and was on Katko’s Onondaga County pistol
permit. U.S. Attorney Daniel French said, "Firearms are issued to federal prosecutors under very limited
circumstances." The gun had been issued in December after receiving "a credible death threat."
French said Katko and his wife had been attending an evening meeting at St. Mark’s Episcopal Church
and Katko had left the gun in a locked case under the front seat of his locked car. [Syracuse Herald-Journal,
4/28/00]
NOTE: In the article French declined to mention Katko by name. But the police reports confirm it was
Katko.
Said “In Response To Confirmed And Credible Threats” He Obtained “A Protective Weapon.” “In
response to confirmed and credible threats against my family and me and at the urging of the United
States Marshals Service and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Robin and I have incorporated their
recommended total protection package into our daily lives. Part of that plan required me to legally obtain
a protective weapon, which I did with proper approvals and training from the United States Department
of Justice and the United States Marshals Service.” [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Katko’s Gun Traded for Drugs
According to a follow-up police report, Katko’s stolen gun was traded for drugs. [Syracuse Police
Dept., Case # 00-097007]
Katko’s Gun Used in Double Homicide
According to a follow-up police report, Katko’s gun was used in a robbery homicide on Burt St in
Syracuse, New York. [Syracuse Police Dept., Case # 00-097007]
On April 21, 2000, two men were shot and killed during a robbery at 222 Burt. Street. Vernon
Griffin, 39, was dead when police responded to the scene and Henderson Griffin, 62, passed
away later that night at Crouse Hospital. Robert Anderson, 47, was critically injured and taken to
University Hospital. The Griffin’s were not related. [Post-Standard, 4/22/00]
9
Investigators who recovered the gun said it was used in the robbery but was not involved in the
deaths of the Griffin’s, or the wounding of Anderson. [Syracuse Herald-Journal, 4/28/00]
1997 Presidential Directive Required All Federal Law Enforcement Officials Use Gun Lock
In 1997, President Bill Clinton issued a directive that required safety locks be provided with each
handgun issued to Federal law enforcement officials. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
US Attorney’s Manual Explicitly Required Compliance With The Presidential
Directive. “A section of the U.S. Attorney's Manual updated in May 1999, before Katko
was issued his gun, states that … ‘Everyone, especially those with young children, is
required to comply with the presidential directive to secure their firearms with safety
locking devices (gun locks) and receive proper instruction for the use of approved
firearms.’” [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Said “I Have Always Complied With Written Protocols And Department Procedures And
Followed The Personal Safety Advice And Training Of Federal Law Enforcement
Professionals.” “‘Legal gun safety is a responsibility all gun owners have. I have always
complied with written protocols and department procedures and followed the personal safety
advice and training of federal law enforcement professionals,’ Katko said in his statement.” [Post
Standard, 8/28/14]
… But Failed “To Have A Trigger Lock On his Handgun When It Was Stolen.” “His
statement was issued hours after syracuse.com published a story about the gun theft, examining
whether the then-federal prosecutor violated federal policy by failing to have a trigger lock on his
handgun when it was stolen from his pick-up truck in April 2000.” [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Said His Gun Was Stolen From A “Locked Briefcase” In His “Locked Vehicle.” “‘Fourteen
years ago, I, too, became the victim of a crime. My protective weapon was stolen from a locked
briefcase concealed from view in my locked vehicle.’” [The Citizen, 8/28/14]
… But Reports Said The Gun Was Stolen From A Green Canvas Bag. “Katko told
syracuse.com that the gun was locked in a briefcase under the seat. But reports indicate
10
that the gun was in a green canvas bag that was stolen from the truck.” [The Citizen,
8/28/14]
Positions On Gun Safety Legislation
Said He Wanted to Prevent Principals of the SAFE Act from Getting into Federal Legislation
In February 2014, Katko said, “The SAFE Act at the state level is a huge issue. People are upset about it.
One of the things that I want to make sure to get out is that I want to make sure that I do everything I can
to ensure that the SAFE Act and the principles of the SAFE Act don’t creep their way into federal
legislation.”
“I fear that if it’s a Democratic-controlled House, that’s exactly what’s going to happen. I’m going to do
everything I can to fight against that,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said Gun Control Laws have not Been Shown to Reduce Crime
In April 2014, when asked his thoughts on the Second Amendment and proposed restrictions Katko said,
“I am a lifelong outdoorsman – a hunter and a fisherman – and a gun owner. Limiting the Second
Amendment rights of law-abiding citizens has not been shown to reduce crimes.”
“Criminals are by definition people who will not follow laws. My first-hand experience as a prosecutor
demonstrates that the weapons used in crimes are usually stolen or smuggled guns. We need to work
harder to prevent weapons from getting into criminal hands or those with mental health issues.” [Eagle
Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Opposed Any New Federal Restrictions On Firearms
Opposed Any New Federal Restrictions On Firearms. “He opposes any new federal restrictions on
the purchase of firearms, including a proposal that failed in the U.S. Senate in April 2013 that would
have expanded federal background checks.” [Post Standard, 7/21/14]
Opposed Any New Federal Gun Control
In July 2014, Katko said that he would oppose any new federal restrictions on the purchase of
firearms, including expanded federal background checks.
“A lot of the gun laws work, and some do not,” Katko said. “But I don’t think additional bans
on guns are going to solve the problem. I am for stepping up enforcement for those people who
illegally obtain guns—criminals—and I will do everything in my power to make sure the New
York SAFE Act never becomes a federal law.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Said He Was Working To “Improve Background Check Systems”, But Voted For Blocking
Consideration Of A Bill To Strengthen Background Checks For Gun Purchases
Said He Was Working To “Improve Background Check Systems,” “But Katko, R-Camillus, doesn't
believe Obama's approach is the right one to combat gun violence. Bypassing Congress to implement
these policies is a ‘divisive tactic,’ he said. ‘Meaningful and effective reform will only come if we do
11
more to improve background check systems, actually identify those individuals who pose threats,
improve access to mental health care and work to counter radical extremism,’ he said. ‘I have and will
continue to work on these types of bipartisan, common sense solutions in Congress so that our nation can
come together and make a difference to protect our communities from gun violence.’” [The Citizen,
1/06/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Background Checks For Gun Purchases. In October 2015,
Katko voted for to block consideration of a vote “on the bipartisan King-Thompson Public Safety and
Second Amendment Rights Protection Act to strengthen the life-saving background checks that keep
guns out of the wrong hands.” The previous question passed, 244-183. A vote against the previous
question was to force a vote on background checks. [H Res 466, Vote #541, 10/8/15; Democratic Leader
– Previous Questions, 10/23/15]
“Stated His Support For A Bill That Would Prevent Terrorists From Buying Guns” But Voted
Against Such A Measure
Auburn Citizen Newspaper: “Katko Also Stated His Support For A Bill That Would Prevent
Terrorists From Buying Guns.” And Noted Rep. King’s Bill. “Katko also stated his support for a bill
that would prevent terrorists from buying guns. U.S. Rep. Peter King, a New York Republican, has
introduced a bill that would prohibit individuals who have provided material support to a terrorist group
or may have ties to terrorism from purchasing firearms.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Voted Ten Times To Block Legislation To Prohibit Suspected Terrorists From Buying Guns
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Prohibiting Suspected Terrorists From Buying Guns. In
December 2015, Katko voted for a motion to order the previous question (thus ending debate and
possibility of amendment) on the rule H Res 539. “The Democratic Previous Question would call for an
immediate vote on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying Firearms and Explosives to
Dangerous Terrorists Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by closing the terrorist gun
loophole and preventing people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.” [H RES 539, Vote #646,
12/1/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 4/14/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Stopping Suspected Terrorists From Buying Firearms.
In December 2015, Katko voted for to block consideration of a vote “to protect the American people by
closing the terrorist gun loophole and preventing people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.”
The previous question carried, 243-179. [Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 2/03/15; H Res 542,
Vote #653, 12/02/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Close Terrorist Gun Loophole And Prevent People
On Terrorist Watchlist From Buying Firearms. In December 2015, Katko voted for to block
consideration of a vote to “call for an immediate vote on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying
Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by
The previous question carried, 243-179. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on
Rep. Peter King’s bill. [H Res 546, Vote #666, 12/03/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions,
12/03/15]
12
Voted For To Block Consideration Of A Bill Allowing Those Listed On The Terror Watch List To
Own Firearms. In December 2015, Katko voted for blocking a measure to prohibit an “immediate vote
on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists
Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by closing the terrorist gun loophole and preventing
people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms. The previous question failed 242-178. [H Res 556
Vote #682 12/8/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 12/9/15]
King’s Bill Would Prevent People On U.S. Terrorist Watch Lists From Buying Firearms.
“At about the time Wednesday that two shooters under investigation for potentially having
terrorist ties were gunning down people at a community center in San Bernardino, House
Republicans blocked legislation that would help prevent people on U.S. terrorist watch lists from
buying firearms legally.” [San Francisco Chronicle, 12/3/15]
Voted For Tabling The Appeal Of The Chair Which Ruled Against Scheduling Vote On A Bill To
Prohibit Those Listed On The Terror Watch List From Purchasing Firearms. In December 2015,
Katko voted for a motion to table the appeal of the ruling of the Chair that the “Pelosi privileged
resolution is out of order. The Pelosi privileged resolution would direct the Speaker to place on the
calendar the Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act (HR 1076), which would
allow the Attorney General to deny the sale or transfer of firearms to individuals suspected of engaging
in or assisting terrorist activities. The motion failed 242-173. [Motion to Table, Vote #688 12/8/15; CQ
Floor Votes, 12/10/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill To Close The Terrorist Gun Loophole. In December
2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of the Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous
Terrorists Act, a bill “to protect the American people by closing the terrorist gun loophole and preventing
people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.” The previous question carried, 236-177. A vote
against the previous question was to force the vote on closing the loophole. [H Res 560, Vote #690,
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Legislation To Close Terrorist Watchlist Gun Loophole. In
January 2016, Katko voted for blocking consideration of legislation that would deny the purchase of a
firearm or explosive to know or suspected terrorists. A no vote would have The previous question
carried, 239-175. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on closing the loophole. [H
Res 579, Vote #2, 1/06/16; Democratic Leader – 114th Previous Questions, 1/06/16]
firearm or explosive to know or suspected terrorists. The previous question carried, 241-176. A vote
1/06/16; Democratic Leader – 114th Previous Questions, 1/06/16]
13
On Terrorist Watchlist From Buying Firearms. In January 2016, Katko voted for consideration of a
vote to “call for an immediate vote on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying Firearms and
Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by closing the
terrorist gun loophole and preventing people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.” The
previous question carried, 236-176. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to
be considered. [HRes 581, Vote #21, 1/07/16; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 1/07/16]
firearm or explosive to known or suspected terrorists. The previous question carried, 239-175. A vote
against the previous question was to force the vote on closing the loophole. [H Res 583, Vote # 36,
Touting His Prosecutorial Experience
Said His Experience as a Federal Prosecutor was Good Training to be a Congressman
In January 2014, Katko said his experience as a federal prosecutor would help him stand out from the
other four Republicans who have announced.
“The training you get as a prosecutor, I’ve learned, is the best training for this job (as a congressman),”
Katko said. “You’ve got to think on your feet, be able to resolve conflict, and you’ve got have thick skin.
I feel very comfortable doing this. Conflict is a daily part of my job.” [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Ties To Washington
Traveled to Washington Day After Announcing Run for Congress
In January 2014, a day after resigning as a federal prosecutor, Katko announced that he intended to run
for the Republican nomination in the 24th Congressional District.
The following Monday, Katko traveled to Washington to begin assembling his campaign team, meet
with national Republican leaders and visit with members of New York’s Republican congressional
delegation. Katko also stopped in to visit the Washington office of former Rep. James Walsh who
represented the Syracuse area in Congress for 20 years until 2008. [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Traveled to DC for Meetings with Special Interests, Republican Establishment
In March 2014, Katko traveled to Washington, DC “for a series of meetings with GOP leaders.” Former
Rep. James Walsh served as Katko’s guide on Capitol Hill.
Walsh introduced Katko to elected officials at a bipartisan Irish Lobby Day event. Katko also met with
senior staff at the National Republican Congressional Committee, the campaign arm of House
Republicans. A campaign spokesman said Katko did not raise any money while in town, but he attended
14
a series of meet-and-greets with influential Republicans and had policy briefings with a think-tank and
healthcare association.” [Post-Standard, 3/17/14]
Walsh Named a “Top Lobbyist” in 2013
In November 2013, the Post-Standard reported: “Former U.S. Rep. James Walsh, five years after
leaving Congress, has transformed himself into one of Washington’s top lobbyists, according to
one Capitol Hill publication.” [Post-Standard, 11/09/13]
Said He Decided to Run for Congress after He was Contacted by Political Backers
In January 2014, Katko said he received the final push to run for Congress when he was approached by
political backers, who asked if he would run for the 24th District seat. Katko declined to identify those
who called him.
“I couldn’t be an idle spectator any more, given the state of our leadership both federally and locally,”
Katko said, explaining why he agreed to run for the House seat.
“When I did that, I started getting a lot of positive feedback,” he said. “I realized now is the time to take
the shot.” [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Said Former Rep. Ann Marie Buerkle “Planted the Seed” for His run for Congress
In March 2014, Katko appeared on former Congresswoman Ann Marie Buerkle’s radio show and when
asked why he was running for Congress, Katko confirmed that had had a conversation with Buerkle
“who planted the seed” to get him to run. [The Ann Marie Buerkle Show – WSYR 570, 3/08/14]
Visited The NRCC, And Took Instruction From DC Leaders
Visited The NRCC After Securing The Republican Party Endorsement. “The former federal
prosecutor visited Washington on Wednesday and Thursday for a series of meetings with GOP leaders.
Former Rep. James Walsh, a Republican who held the Syracuse-based House seat for 20 years, served as
Katko's guide on Capitol Hill. Walsh introduced Katko to elected officials at a bipartisan Irish Lobby
Day event. Katko also met with senior staff at the National Republican Congressional Committee, the
campaign arm of House Republicans. The NRCC spent about $2 million supporting former Rep. Ann
Marie Buerkle's campaign in 2012.” [Post Standard, 3/17/14]
Said Washington Leadership Instructed Him To Pursue The Narrative Of A Broken, Inactive
Congress. Host: You mentioned a few minutes ago that part of the problem are Republicans. That might
not endear you to Republicans who might not have opened up their wallets. But I mean, its, I don’t know
how to phrase it. Do you find that that level of honesty and openness on the campaign trail, do you think
that will translate if you win, will you be as honest about both sides of the system as you have been on
the campaign trail? Katko: Yes, and you know what, the people in Washington get it too. Believe it or
not, I was just down there last week, and the leadership is saying the same thing. They’re saying look,
that is a narrative you have to pursue. They understand it, they understand the perception. It’s not as one
sided, it is absolutely not as one sided. I’ll give you an example, I mean everyone is talking about the
15
house republicans, well the House has sent three hundred twenty one bills over to the Senate. three
hundred twenty one bills that are sitting there and haven’t been acted upon in this term alone. So, and
that’s a Democratically controlled Senate. Nothing’s going on over there either. So, it’s both sides, and
they recognize it too. They recognize its gotta get better, y’know. And so, to answer your question, I
don’t know. I don’t think so. I think people are sick and tired of the sniping and want people that are
going to be pragmatic and go down and get things done. [Finger Lakes Morning News Interview,
7/31/14]
Was Elated By The NRCC’s Commitment Of Money To His Race, Said That Was The Turning
Point Of His Race. “As for turning points in the campaign, Katko looked back to Sept. 22. A PostStandard/syracuse.com/Siena poll released the day before had shown him down by only 8 percentage
points. He went to Washington to accept an award for his work as a federal prosecutor - a moment that
put him in front of Democratic Attorney General Eric Holder. The same day, he said, he found out the
National Republican Congressional Committee would commit money to his race. That would give him
enough of a boost to compete with Maffei on television and boost his name recognition. ‘I don't even
know that I needed a plane to come home, I was so high. I was so happy,’ Katko said. ‘I looked them
right in the eye and said 'We're going to win this race' because all I needed was a remotely level playing
field.’” [Post Standard, 11/06/14]
Republican Operative: Katko A Rising Star. “Ian Prior, a spokesman for the National Republican
Congressional Committee, offered a different view. ‘In just five months, John Katko has established
himself as a rising star in Congress who will work in a bipartisan manner to deliver for Central New
York,’ Prior said in an email.” [The Citizen, 5/08/15]
Republican House Leaders Raised Funds For Katko
Boehner Raised Funds For Katko. “When Katko first ran for Congress in 2014, Boehner visited
central New York and was the special guest at a fundraiser for the GOP challenger. After Katko won the
24th Congressional District race and was sworn into office, Boehner continued to support him. Just last
month, the House speaker made another trip to central New York to headline a fundraiser for Katko’s reelection campaign.” [The Citizen, 9/26/14]
McCarthy Raised Funds For Katko. “House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy visited Auburn in
October 2014 to headline a fundraiser for U.S. Rep. John Katko, who was a Republican challenger at the
time.” [The Citizen, 9/26/14]
Rep. Walden, Rep. Westmoreland Made Visits To Help Katko. “NRCC Chairman Greg Walden, who
made a stop in Syracuse in September to support Katko, and U.S. Rep. Lynn Westmoreland, deputy chair
of the NRCC, will attend a get out the vote rally at 6 p.m. Thursday at the local GOP’s Victory Center,
2910 Erie Blvd. East, Syracuse.” [The Citizen, 10/28/14]
Received “Rare Honor” Being Named Chairman Of A Subcommittee. “Katko, whose congressional
district includes Wayne County, received a rare honor for a freshman on Monday when he was named
chairman of the Homeland Security Subcommittee on Transportation Security. The post will call on his
experience prosecuting drug trafficking and organized crime cases.” [Rochester Democrat and Chronicle,
1/16/15]
16
Was Among Those Who Agreed To Privately Share Their Legislative Strategy With The NRCC.
“U.S. Reps. John Katko and Elise Stefanik are among nearly two dozen House members who agreed to
privately share their legislative strategy with a Republican political group supporting their re-election,
according to a Washington Post report. Katko, R-Camillus, and Stefanik, R-Willsboro, are House
freshmen enrolled in the National Republican Congressional Committee's Patriot Program, which
provides financial and campaign support for vulnerable incumbents.” [Post Standard, 9/09/15]
Washington Post: NRCC MOU “Offers A Window Into How Much Autonomy Lawmakers
Often Must Forfeit To Unelected Washington Insiders. “The closely-held document offers a
window into how much autonomy lawmakers often must forfeit to unelected Washington
insiders.” [Washington Post, Sept. 2015]
Confirmed He Submitted His Legislative Plan To The NRCC, But Said It Was The Same Plan
Made Public In February. “Erin O'Connor, speaking for Katko, confirmed he agreed to submit his
legislative plan to the NRCC. But she said it's the same plan – an 11-point agenda -- that Katko first
made public in February.” [Post Standard, 9/09/15]
CQ: Voted With His Party 81.0 Percent Of The Time. According to Congressional Quarterly, Katko
had voted with his party 81.0 percent of the time through April 21, 2016. [CQ.com, accessed 4/21/16]
Said Voters “Know What My Record Is. They Can Tell Me Whether Or Not I’m An
Independent.” “He's leaving it up to voters to decide whether he's worthy of a second term in Congress.
‘I've got a record now,’ he said. ‘They know what my record is. They can tell me whether or not I'm an
independent. They can tell me whether or not I've acted independently like I said I was going to do. Let
the chips fall where they may. But my priority from the beginning has been to represent my constituents
and that will never, ever change.’” [The Citizen, 1/10/16]
On Legislative Accomplishments And Ambition
Said He Gave Up a “Strong and Lucrative Career” Because of Maffei’s Failed Leadership
In February 2014, Katko said Rep. Maffei’s “terrible leadership” concerned him so much that he gave up
his career to run for Congress.
“It’s not just with him. It’s with others in Washington. But he’s the one in our district and I felt
compelled enough about it to give up a very good and strong and lucrative career for this and I don’t
know if anybody else has done that,” Katko said.
“It’s not like I was at retirement age because I’m not. I’m doing this on my own. I don’t regret it for a
second because I think it’s very important to stand up for things when you’re very concerned […] I’m
giving up more than anybody to do this, but I feel that strongly about it,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen,
2/18/14]
Katko: “I’m Not Sure What [Maffei’s] Done”
17
In February 2014, Katko said he was not sure what Maffei’s record was. “The honest assessment of the
job he’s done is I’m not sure what he’s done. The only thing I know he’s done is trumpeted and
supported supposed landmark legislation on health care and then turning around and trying to repeal the
very portions of the bill he passed. To me, that is a perfect snapshot of failed leadership on his part,”
Katko said.
“And I don’t think he’s brought much back for our district. He just hasn’t,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen,
2/18/14]
Said That If The Affordable Care Act Isn’t “Addressed” In His Term, “Then It Is Time For You
To Throw Me Out.” GR: A question now about the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare. Mr. Katko,
you brought this up a little while ago, and this question is for you. It’s extremely unlikely that there will
be any chance of a significant revision of this legisla-tion during what would be your first term in
Congress. So why then is changing this law an apparent pillar of your campaign? JK: We could never
account in its mediocrity, we could never account in its bad bills. It has to be addressed, and if two years
from now I would come back to you and nothing’s done, then it is time for you to throw me out. We
have to start working on these types of things. We can’t accept ... your premise is what’s wrong with
Washington. When you sit there and say it is extremely unlikely. [Debate Transcript, Syracuse New
Times, 10/29/14]
Said The Transportation Bill, FAA Bill, And Dealing With The Affordable Care Act Had To Get
Done. “The transportation bill, for example, this year. It’s gotta get done. It’s time. It’s up this year.
We’ve gotta do that. The FAA bill. We’ve gotta do that. You gotta deal with Obamacare. There’s a lot of
bipartisan support for repealing the medical device tax and I’m already working on that with (U.S. Rep.
Erik Paulsen of Minnesota) and some others. We’re already starting to talk about that.” [Interview, The
Citizen, 12/02/14]
Said He Would Not Participate In Extremism, And That Since Republicans Have Both Houses Of
Congress, They Had “No Excuses” Not To Get Things Done, Or Voters Would Judge Them.
Speaking to reporters the morning after his 2014 election, Katko stated, “I am not going to take part in
extremism. It’s just not going to happen. And if they think I am they’ll be sorely disappointed. I think
that Republicans have, we have both houses now. We have no more excuses. Right? We have no more
excuses. We have to do things and get things done. And it’s a wonderful opportunity but solves, also a
pretty significant responsibility. We have to uh, we have to uh, we have to be up for it. Because in two
years, people are going to say, ‘you had the House and the Senate, what have you got done?’ Y’know,
and we’ve gotta get some things done.” [Interview, Post Standard, 11//05/14]
Special Interest Money
Said, “You Are Where You Get Your Money From” While Criticizing Maffei For Washington
Contributions. “Katko said a vast majority of the contributions to his campaign -- 80 percent -- came
from central New Yorkers. He noted that a large portion of the money Maffei received during the
campaign has come from outside of the district. ‘You are where you get your money from,’ he said. ‘I
am central New York and that’s where my money came from.’” [The Citizen, 11/03/14]
Criticized Special Interest Money During The Campaign, Accepted It, And Made No Apologies.
18
“Now Katko is reaping the same benefits of incumbency that he once criticized, taking advantage of a
campaign finance system where wealthy special-interest groups line up to donate millions of dollars to
influence members of Congress. Katko makes no apologies for accepting the money, and emphasizes
that two-thirds of his donors (not total cash contributions) are people who either live or work in the 24th
District.” [Post Standard, 5/08/15]
Headline: Washington’s New PAC Man. [Post Standard, 5/12/15]
62 Percent Of Fundraising During His First Quarter In Congress Was From PACs, After
Criticizing Maffei For Taking Mostly Outside Money. “The PAC money accounted for 62 percent of
the total Katko’s campaign raised during his first three months in Con-gress, according to a PostStandard analysis of reports filed with the Federal Election Commission. … During his 2014 campaign,
Katko criticized his opponent, Rep. Dan Maffei, for taking most of his campaign cash from donors
outside of Central New York. Katko called Maffei, D-Syracuse, a Washington insider who had lost touch
with voters in Onondaga, Cayuga, Oswego and Wayne counties.” [Post Standard, 5/12/15]
April 2016: 63.2 Percent Of Katko’s Itemized have Been From Outside New York State. According
to FEC data, 63.2 percent of Katko’s itemized donations came from donors outside New York State.
[FEC.gov, accessed 4/18/16]
Received $121,498.00 From Air Travel And Air Travel Security Interests. According to FEC Records,
Katko received $121,498.00 in donations from Air Travel and Air Travel security interests for his 2016
campaign through the first quarter of 2016 . [FEC.gov, accessed 4/18/16]
On Political Philosophy
Described Himself as Conservative and a Moderate
In January 2014, Katko described himself as a moderate Republican who is fiscally conservative. [PostStandard, 1/14/14]
In February 2014, Katko said, “I’m a conservative, but a moderate at the same time. I have conservative
values, but moderate in that I recognize the need that you have to work with your counterparts. I
recognize that fact.” [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Katko: “I Don’t Know if I Consider Myself a Moderate”
In July 2014, when asked by TWC News’ Liz Benjamin if he would consider himself a “moderate” who
would take a more “pragmatic approach,” Katko responded by saying “I don’t know if I consider myself
a moderate. I don’t know about labels.” [TWC News “Capital Tonight”, 7/3/14]
Said He Was A Fiscal Conservative, And Basically A Social Conservative. “JK: I don’t want to give
myself a label. I am a fiscal conservative. I think I am basically a social conservative, but I am also a
pragmatist.” [Interview, Syracuse New Times, 5/28/14]
Said He Looked Forward to Pushing Forward Conservative Agenda
19
In March 2014, Katko said he was looking forward to pushing the conservative agenda of the Central
New York Republican party.
“I am proud to have received the endorsement of the Cayuga, Onondaga, Oswego and Wayne County
Conservative parties and look forward to carrying their business-friendly, controlled spending, reduced
taxes and pro-Second Amendment platform to voters this fall,” Katko said. “With their support, help and
enthusiasm, we will restore the 24th District seat back to Central New York voters.” [Auburn Citizen,
3/04/14]
Katko Would Uphold Radical Conservative Party Platform
The Conservative Party platform called for racial profiling by police, banning same-sex marriage,
carrying out the death penalty, banning abortions except to save the mother’s life, permitting
hydrofracking, and adopting a flat income tax. [Post-Standard, 3/09/14]
On Choice And Women’s Issues
Said He Opposed Abortion
In April 2014, when asked where he stood on women’s reproductive rights Katko said, “That is an easily
voiced yet complex issue. My position on abortion is consistent with my Catholic faith. I believe that all
life has worth, every individual has potential, and every child deserves opportunity. Put as simply as I
can, my opponent supports abortion on demand. I do not.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Called Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby Ruling the “Right Decision”
In July 2014, when asked about the Supreme Court’s decision exempting certain companies from a
provision in the Affordable Care Act that required businesses to provide coverage for contraception in
health insurance plans Katko told the Auburn Citizen, “Obamacare is loaded with overreaches like that. I
think it’s the right decision.” [Auburn Citizen, 7/01/14]
Said He Would Repeal Roe V. Wade. “At a Thursday Morning Roundtable debate, he was pressed for
a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer on repealing the Roe v. Wade decision that made abortion a legal right. Katko said
he would vote to repeal the law. After the debate, his spokeswoman stressed that Katko would not make
it a priority; it is not a top issue on his agenda.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Voted To Defund Planned Parenthood After Promising Not To Do So, Saying Videos Changed His
Mind. “U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, joined the majority of Republicans in voting 241-187 to pass
the mostly symbolic measure, which would cut off about $500 million in aid to Planned Parenthood. …
Katko had promised during his 2014 campaign for Congress that he would not vote to defund Planned
Parenthood. … ‘In the past, I have taken the position that I would support federal funding for Planned
Parenthood to continue to provide these important services,’ Katko said. ‘However, like many of my
constituents, I am concerned by the gruesome and potentially illegal content of the recently released
videos exposing some of the practices of this organization.’ Katko added that he until congressional
investigations are complete, he can't support providing taxpayer dollars to Planned Parenthood.” [Post
Standard, 9/20/15]
Factcheck.org: Unedited Video “Isn’t Evidence That Planned Parenthood Or Its Affiliates
20
Are Selling ‘Body Parts’ Or Fetal Tissue For Profit.” “Several Republican presidential
candidates have claimed that Planned Parenthood is ‘profiting’ from abortions. But the full,
unedited video they cite as evidence shows a Planned Parenthood executive repeatedly saying its
clinics want to cover their costs, not make money, when donating fetal tissue from abortions for
scientific research.’ At one point in the unedited video (which was also released by the group),
Nucatola says: ‘Affiliates are not looking to make money by doing this. They’re looking to serve
their patients and just make it not impact their bottom line.’ … In the edited video, Nucatola says
the cost for fetal tissue specimens was between $30 and $100, ‘depending on the facility and
what’s involved.’ She defined ‘specimen’ as, ‘one case. One patient.’ … Nucatola’s comment,
though, isn’t evidence that Planned Parenthood or its affiliates are selling ‘body parts’ or fetal
tissue for profit.” [Factcheck.org, 7/21/15]
Opposed the Paycheck Fairness Act
In July 2014, the Post-Standard reported “Katko opposes the Paycheck Fairness Act, a bill in Congress
that that would require employers to demonstrate that wage differences among employees are based on
factors other than gender.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of The Paycheck Fairness Act. In April 2015, Katko voted for
blocking consideration of the Paycheck Fairness Act, a bill that would end the pay gap between men and
women and insure equal pay for equal work. “The legislation would protect workers from retaliation for
sharing information about their wages, require employers to explain any pay disparities among workers
performing the same job, and allow employees to seek unlimited punitive damages in wage bias cases.”
The previous question passed 239 to 183. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the
bill to be considered. [H. Res. 189, Vote #148, 4/14/15; Bloomberg, 4/14/15; Congressional Record,
On Immigration
Said All Undocumented Immigrants Were “Criminals.” “As far as the other issues, it’s a sticky issue
- immigration reform. People that are involved in crimes, sorry, there is no path to citizenship for them in
my mind. We have to deal with the reality that the people that are here are here illegally. They’re here
breaking the law. They’re criminals. By design, our laws say they’re criminals. We can’t just look away
from that. But we’ve also got to realize that the reality is 11 million people you’re not going to put on
buses and ship out of the country. It’s going to be hard to do that.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Blamed An Increase In Violent Crime On Softening Mandatory Minimums In Drug Crimes And
Inaction On Immigration. KATKO: I have a huge background in law enforcement. But the big thing
that is kind of a secret that really hasn’t been made public yet is that under the Obama administration,
after 20 years of steady decline in violent crime rates, they’re going back up. I think there’s a direct
correlation between that and their softening of some of the mandatory minimums in drug crimes and also
some of the things they are doing - or not doing - with respect to immigration and other things.
[Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Katko Opposed Comprehensive Immigration Reform
In April 2014, New York conservative blogger Lonely Conservative wrote that Katko does not support
21
comprehensive immigration reform.
“I spoke to Mr. Katko a few months ago and asked him about immigration reform. He said (I’m
paraphrasing) ‘We shouldn’t reward people who break the law,’” he wrote. [Lonely Conservative, 4/19/14]
Said He Opposed The Bipartisan Immigration Reform Bill Due To The Pathway To Citizenship.
“Katko said he would support a bipartisan immigration reform bill in Congress, but not the one passed by
the U.S. Senate by a 68-32 vote in June 2013. He disagrees with the bill’s provision to provide a path to
citizenship for 11 million immigrants in the U.S. without legal status.” [Post Standard, 7/10/14]
Said The Weakest Point In The American Immigration System Was That Unaccompanied Minors
Were Allowed To Have Deportation Hearings To Cut Down On Human Trafficking. “But now,
Katko said, smugglers target the weakest point in a U.S. immigration system that allows unaccompanied
mi-nors from Central America to have deportation hearings under a law aimed at cutting down on human
trafficking. ‘They are simply trying to take advantage of us and our generosity as a country,’ Katko said.
‘If we had more secure borders, we wouldn’t be having this problem.’” [Post Standard, 7/10/14]
Suggested Deporting Children From Non-Contiguous Countries Home Faster. “Katko, 51, of
Camillus, is the Republican candidate for the 24th Congressional District. He is seeking to unseat Rep.
Dan Maffei, 46, a Syracuse Democrat. In discussing other issues with the editorial board: … He also said
one solution is to change the law to be able to ship children from non-contiguous countries home right
away.” [Post Standard, 9/11/14]
On Marriage Equality
Said That Marriage Equality was a States’ Rights Issue
In July 2014, Katko said that the federal government shouldn’t have a say in same-sex marriage: “I think
it’s a state’s rights issue,” Katko said. “I don’t think the federal government has any role in this, other
than ensuring that people are not discriminated against.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
On Working Families
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Allowing Workers In Businesses With 15 Or More
Employees To Accrue Up To Seven Sick Days A Year. In October 2015, Katko voted for
consideration of H. Res. 491, an ordering of the previous question on HR 1090 to call for an immediate
vote on the Healthy Families Act. “The Democratic Previous Question on the Rule providing for the
consideration of H.R. 1090, So-Called ‘Retail Investor Protection Act,’ would call for an immediate vote
on the Healthy Families Act, which would allow workers in businesses with 15 or more employees to
earn up to seven job-protected sick days each year.” The previous question carried 242 to 185.
[H.Res.491, Vote #570, 10/27/15; Democratic Previous Question, HR 1090, 10/27/15]
Huffington Post: Healthy Families Act “Would Allow Workers At Larger Employers To
Accrue Up To Seven Sick Days Per Years.” “To address the private sector, Obama will begin
stumping for the Healthy Families Act, a Democratic proposal in Congress that would allow workers
at larger employers to accrue up to seven sick days per year. Such laws tend to draw heavy
22
opposition from employer lobbies, and the proposal is all but certain to fail while Republicans control
both the House and Senate.” [Huffington Post, 1/14/15]
Opposed “A Current Proposal” For Family Leave As A Tax. “A current proposal on the federal level
would implement new taxes and regulations on working families and small businesses to fund a
government-run, one-size-fits-all paid leave program. Nearly every American, regardless of their income
or need for family leave, would see an additional tax taken out of their paycheck to form another
government trust fund. This misguided proposal even taxes the working poor struggling with every-day
expenses. It taxes Americans who are nearing retirement and have already raised their families. Every
business, large and small, would be subject to a new payroll tax. This plan is an empty promise. It taxes
the very families it claims to help and is fiscally unsustainable.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post
Standard, 4/18/16]
Said He Proposed “Parental Savings Account[s]” As A “Flexible” Plan. “In Congress, I've
introduced bipartisan legislation to provide a compromise that both sides can get behind. The plan, which
is entirely optional, allows men and women to create a Parental Savings Account. Just like a health
savings account, Americans can choose to affordably contribute money, tax-free, to support their family
during the first year of parenthood. Funds can be withdrawn and spent on childcare, doctor's visits,
diapers or simply to pay the rent or mortgage. It covers more than just the 12 weeks of leave provided
under federal law and helps to ease the financial burden during the first year of parenthood. Americans
who choose to participate, but do not end up starting a family, are able to roll unused funds into a
retirement account or college savings plan.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post Standard, 4/18/16]
Opposed Increasing The Minimum Wage To $10.10 Per Hour, Supported Incremental Increases
In The Minimum Wage. “Here’s a look at where U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei and challenger John Katko
stand on some of the issues in their campaign for the 24th Congressional District seat. Compiled by
Washington correspondent Mark Weiner. JOHN KATKO … MINIMUM WAGE Opposes President
Barack Obama’s proposal to raise the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 per hour. Supports
unspecified incremental increases over time.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Opposed Raising The Minimum Wage To Fifteen Dollars Per Hour. “Katko Opposes $15 Wage …
Congressman John Katko is weighing in on the fight to raise the minimum wage in NY State. The
governor has been pushing for the minimum wage to reach $15 an hour, but critics say it will cost hours
and jobs for workers at small businesses. Congressman Katko warns of the same thing.” [WSYR,
3/10/16]
On The Affordable Care Act
Said He Wanted to See the Affordable Care Act Repealed, Called it a Train Wreck
In January 2014, Katko said he opposed the Affordable Care Act and wanted to see it revised or
repealed.
“The Affordable Care Act is a train wreck and it’s going to have long-term negative effects on the
Central New York economy,” Katko said. “I think it’s the poster-child for government incompetence.”
23
Said Problems with the Affordable Care Act Could Not be Fixed
In February 2014, Katko said problems with the Affordable Care could not be fixed. “I’m going to go
through and try and identify the issues and then try and figure out whether or not they can be fixed or
not. My conclusion is that they probably aren’t going to be able to be fixed in its current state,” Katko
said.
“You have all these things going out there that I think work against it. I think, in the end, it makes it so
I’m not sure it can be fixed. Should we try and fix it? Sure. I don’t think it can be fixed,” Katko said.
[Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said the Affordable Care Act Would Kill 2.3 Million Jobs
In February 2014, Katko said, “In its current state, [the Affordable Care Act is] a job killer. It’s not a job
creator. The very middle class they say they are trying to help are the ones that are getting screwed on
this the most.”
“The Congressional Budget Office came out and estimated that it’s going to lead to the loss of 2.3
million jobs. Did anybody anticipate that?” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Voted For Repeal Of The Medical Device Tax, HIT Tax
Voted For Repeal Of Medical Device Tax Under The Affordable Care Act. In June 2015, Katko
voted for repealing the medical device tax implemented under the Affordable Care Act. “The House
defied a White House veto threat and voted Thursday to abolish a tax on medical device makers as a
group of Democrats uncharacteristically joined Republicans in moving to kill part of President Barack
Obama's health care law … The Republican-led House has voted more than 50 times since 2011 to void
all or part of Obama's health care overhaul, usually along party lines.” The bill passed 280 to 140. [HR
160, Vote #375, 6/18/15; Associated Press, 6/18/15]
Called For Repealing The Medical Device Tax And HIT Tax. “A critic of the Affordable Care Act,
Katko also called for the repeal of the medical device tax and the so-called ‘HIT Tax’ on health insurers
that opponents say raises premiums for small businesses. Both taxes were included in the Af-fordable
Care Act when it was signed into law in 2010.” [The Citizen, 9/24/14]
Voted Against A Full Repeal Of The ACA
Voted Against A Full Repeal Of The ACA. In February 2015, Katko voted against repealing the ACA.
“The House voted … to abolish the 2010 health care law in Congress’ first repeal vote of the year … The
House has voted more than 50 times to roll back all or portions of the law.” The bill passed 239 to 186.
[HR 596, Vote #58, 2/03/15; CQ News, 2/03/15]
Vote Was Republicans 56th Attempt To Repeal Affordable Care Act. “In Tuesday’s repeal effort
by House Republicans — their first of this Congress and their 56th overall — it became clear that
they had succeeded at one thing: They had bored even themselves into a slumber.” [Washington Post,
2/03/15]
24
Said He Voted Against Repealing The ACA To “Fulfill His Campaign Promise To Only Support
Repeal The Law Only If Republicans Offered A Viable Alternative.” “Katko said in an interview
with syracuse.com that he broke ranks with his party in order to fulfill his campaign promise to repeal
the law only if Republicans offered a viable alternative.” [Post Standard, 2/04/15]
Voted To “Gut Obamacare” By Repealing Key Sections Of The Law. In October 2015, Katko voted
for a “budget reconciliation bill that seeks to gut Obamacare by repealing key sections of the law,
including the individual and employer mandate and the so-called ‘cadillac’ tax, which targets high-end
employer-sponsored health plans. In addition, it would block funding for Planned Parenthood for one
year and divert that spending to other women’s health programs.” The bill passed 240-189. HR 3762,
Vote #568, 10/23/15; Washington Post, 10/23/15]
On Reforming Or Replacing The Affordable Care Act
Said A Replacement For The ACA Must Maintain Universal Coverage, Keep Wellness Provisions,
The 26-Year-Old Policy, And Portability From Pre-Existing Conditions. JK: No, I don’t think I’m
talking about repealing the bill. I’m talking about fixing it. I think there’s great portions of Obamacare,
there’s great principles. First of all, everyone has health insurance. No matter what happens, we have to
make sure everyone has health insurance. And we have to take a look at some of the great provisions,
like the wellness provisions in there, and the 26-year old policy and portability from pre-existing
conditions. Those are all good things, and there’s a lot of good things in Obamacare. [Debate Transcript,
Syracuse New Times, 10/29/14]
Proposed Replacing The Affordable Care Act With A System That Offers Credits To Incentivize
People To Buy Insurance From The Private Market. “‘Getting government out of the way,’ he said in
an interview Friday. ‘Getting government out of the business of health care, I think, it’s a big thing and
returning it back to a private setting with certain incentives and certain credits and what have you to let
the marketplace handle it, but provide an ability for people that couldn’t afford insurance to somehow
afford insurance and incentivize them to do that.’” [The Citizen, 2/11/15]
Discussed A The GOP Plan To Replace The Affordable Care Act Would Replace Subsidies With
Tax Incentives If Supreme Court Had Ruled ACA Unconstitutional. KATKO: Yes. There was an
editorial in the Wall Street Journal about a month ago from (U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan) and some others
providing a conceptual framework. And since then, we’ve had meetings with Paul Ryan and with the
gen-eral counsel -- some of the folks who argued the Supreme Court case on Obamacare. There is a plan
developing into place as an alternative to Obamacare if the Supreme Court rules against Obama on this.
It’s going to be more mar-ket-based -- interstate competition, replacing subsidies with tax incentives to
get insurance. Incentivizing instead of mandating. It’s going to be market-based. They’re calling it kind
of an off-ramp to Obamacare. It’s taking shape. Paul Ryan has been working very hard on it. I think that
will be coming out very soon. [The Citizen, 4/20/15]
Suggested The GOP Short-Term Replacement For The ACA Would Privatize Insurance, And
Replace Health Insurance Exchanges With Tax Credits. “Katko said Republicans have been working
on a short-term plan for revisions to the Affordable Care Act while working on a longer-term solution.
‘The short-term gap would be bridged by basically privatizing the insurance, and basically replacing
exchanges with substantial tax credits to individuals who bought health insurance,’ Katko said. He said
25
Republicans also would like to increase competition among health insurers by allowing companies to sell
policies across state lines.” [Post Standard, 7/21/15]
The Affordable Care Act Provides Tax Credits To Subsidize People To Purchase Insurance.
“When people buy insurance for themselves and/or their families through the government's health
insurance marketplace, they may be eligible for a tax credit. That credit can be applied directly to their
insurance provider to offset their monthly premiums.” [US News, 1/14/14]
Voted Against A Reconciliation Bill To “Repeal Much” Of The Affordable Care Act That Some
Described As A “Repeal” Bill
Voted Against A Reconciliation Bill To “Repeal Much” But Not “Entirely Dismantle The
Affordable Care Act.” In January 2016, Katko voted against “legislation that would repeal much of
ObamaCare, the first such measure to reach his desk since it became law in 2010. … The legislation does
not repeal all of ObamaCare, because the reconciliation rules forced Republicans to choose certain
elements to eliminate.” The bill passed 240-181. [HR3762, Vote #6, 1/06/16; The Hill, 1/08/16]
The Legislation Would “Repeal Much Of Obamacare”. “President Obama on Friday vetoed
legislation that would repeal much of ObamaCare, the first such measure to reach his desk since
it became law in 2010. Obama used his veto pen without fanfare on a legislative package rolling
back his signature healthcare law and stripping federal funding from Planned Parenthood.”
The Legislation Would Have Repealed Medicaid Expansion, Insurance Subsidies, The
Individual mandate, “As Well As A Litany Of Taxes.” “The bill still attacks core parts of the
law, including an expansion of Medicaid and federal subsidies to help people purchase health
insurance. It also scraps mandates on individuals to buy insurance and employers to provide it, as
well as a litany of taxes, including levies on medical devices and high-cost plans, known as the
‘Cadillac Tax.’” [The Hill, 1/08/16]
The Legislation “Would Retain The Requirement That Insurers Offer Coverage …
Without Regard To … Pre Existing Conditions. Also Untouched Would Be The Revisions
In Medicare.” “The measure wouldn’t entirely dismantle the Affordable Care Act. For example,
it would retain the requirement that insurers offer coverage and set premiums without regard to
someone’s pre-existing conditions. Also untouched would be revisions in Medicare that reward
the value of procedures, rather than the volume of procedures and reduce excessive provider
payments.” [Bloomberg, 1/06/16]
The Legislation Would Have Defunded Planned Parenthood. “President Obama on Friday
vetoed legislation that would repeal much of ObamaCare, the first such measure to reach his desk
since it became law in 2010. Obama used his veto pen without fanfare on a legislative package
rolling back his signature healthcare law and stripping federal funding from Planned
Parenthood.”
Fox News Headline: “Congress Sends Health Law Repeal To Obama's Desk For First
Time.” [Fox News, 1/06/16]
26
CNN Headline: “House Sends Obamacare Repeal Bill To White House.” [CNN, 1/06/16]
Speaker Ryan: HR3762 A “Bill That Repeals Obamacare.” “For five years, Senate Democrats
have blocked our efforts to repeal Obamacare. That ends today. With this vote, we are keeping a
promise and putting a bill that repeals Obamacare and defunds Planned Parenthood on the
president’s desk.” [Press Release, Speaker Ryan, 1/06/16]
On The Estate Tax
Said He Had No Intention Of Tax Breaks For Billionaires, But Voted For Repealing The Estate
Tax
Said He Had No Intention Of Tax Breaks For Billionaires. KATKO: … One of the things that drives
me nuts: I have never once said anything about tax breaks for billionaires. I have no idea what the heck
they are talking about. I have never mentioned that and I have no intention of doing that. [Interview, The
Citizen, 10/04/14]
Voted For Repealing Estate Tax. In April 2015, Katko voted for repealing the estate tax. “The measure
also would repeal the generation-skipping transfer tax and reduce the top marginal rate for the federal
gift tax from 40 percent to 35 percent.” The bill passed, 240-179. [HR 1105, Vote #161, 4/16/15; CQ
News, 4/16/15]
USA Today: “Repealing Estate Tax Would Reward Two-Tenths Of One Percent.” “Of the
nearly 3 million Americans who die every year, only about two-tenths of 1% have enough assets to
qualify. It's a rather exclusive group. This isn't to disparage people who worked hard enough (or, in
some cases, were lucky enough) to have estates that big. It's just that, at a time when income
inequality is one of the nation's most vexing problems, the 0.2% hardly need extra help from
Congress.” [Editorial, USA Today, 4/16/15]
On Entitlements
Said We Should Not Make Cuts to Social Security for Those Near Retirement
In July 2014, the Syracuse Post-Standard reported Katko “said ‘anyone at or near retirement age
should not face cuts’ in their benefits. He would not specify what age groups would be
acceptable for diminished or changed benefits.” [Syracuse Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Suggested “Doing Something” With Medicare And Social Security For Younger People, Not Those
At Or Near Retirement. “One of the funda-mental things I think is important is that if you have planned
your life and your budgets around Medicaid or Medicare or Social Security, in particular, you can’t go
and on the eve of someone retiring, on the eve of someone taking advantage of those programs, to yank
the rug out from underneath them. … Maybe it’s doing something with the benefits for people coming
into the system early on so that they know, 30 years down the road, things aren’t going to be like what
they were for my parents, so I’ll be able to plan for that. Maybe that’s what we need to do. But if we
don’t start doing that soon, I’m concerned that those programs are going to go away.” [Interview, The
Citizen, 5/15/14]
27
Said He Would “Vote ‘No’” On Any Budget That Had Cuts To Medicare Or Social Security. “John
Katko (JK): … I would vote ‘no’ on principles, on that budget, which included ... I would have the
courage to stand against my party. Let me finish, Mr. Maffei, and calm down. I am going to vote ‘no’
against any budget that has cuts to Medicare or Social Security, period.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse
New Times, 10/29/14]
On The Debt And Budgets
Said His Number One Issue was the National Debt
In February 2014, at a candidate forum in Syracuse hosted by Central New York Conservatives, Inc,
Katko said the number one issue in his mind is the national debt.
“It’s crushing America. We have a $17 trillion debt as Ian (Hunter) mentioned earlier,” he said. “In the
last year alone, they raised the debt ceiling twice. The last time I’m not ever sure they put a cap on it.”
“Basically, what America is offering is a pocket of maxed out credit cards and are doing nothing about it
except borrowing more and spending more and not acknowledging the problem.” [Auburn Citizen, 2/27/14,
2/28/14]
Said Increasing the Debt was Immoral
In April 2014, Katko said, “Our national debt is burgeoning at an unsustainable rate. Raising the debt
without curtailing spending is not fiscally sensible or logical. Delaying huge debts for future generations
is immoral.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Said he Would Not Support The Fiscal Brinksmanship That Brought The US Close To Default.
“But he said he would not support the fiscal brinksmanship that brought the United States close to
defaulting on its debt. ‘I would not let my vote be the one that causes us to default on our debt,’ Katko
said.” [Post Standard, 7/22/14]
On Homeland Security
Was Named To Head A Task Force On Combatting Terrorist Travel. “Today, U.S. Rep. Michael
McCaul (TX-10), chairman of the Committee on Homeland Security, and U.S. Rep. Bennie Thompson
(MS-2), ranking member of the Committee on Homeland Security, announced the creation of a
bipartisan ‘Task Force on Combating Terrorist and Foreign Fighter Travel’ in response to the threat from
extremists fighting overseas and the danger they pose to the United States. Rep. John Katko (NY-24) was
named the Republican Lead for the Task Force.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 2/25/14]
Journeyed To The Middle East And Europe To Learn About The Flow Of Foreign Fighters Into
The Middle East. “Katko is a part of an eight-member congressional delegation that is touring Israel,
Iraq, Turkey and several European countries this week as part of an effort to learn more about the flow of
foreign fighters into the Middle East.” [Post Standard, 5/07/15]
28
Criticized Maffei For Voting Against A Measure To Provide Assistance To Syrian Rebels. “Katko
also criticized Maffei, D-Syracuse, for voting against a measure that would provide assistance to Syrian
rebels fighting ISIS.” [The Citizen, 10/30/14]
Declared His Support For Rep. McKeon’s Amendment To Train Syrian Rebels. “President Barack
Obama had requested authorization for $500 million from Congress to train and equip about 5,000
moderate Syrian rebels. The amendment sponsored by Rep. Buck McKeon, R-Calif., passed 273 to 156.
… Republican John Katko, Maffei’s opponent in this year’s election, criticized the congressman after
Wednesday’s vote. Katko said in a statement that he would have voted to pass the amendment.” [Post
Standard, 9/18/14]
Voted For Amendment That Eliminates $600 Million In Funding For Syria Train And Equip
Fund. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would “eliminate the $600 million appropriated
for the Syria Train and Equip Fund and transfer the savings to the spending reduction account.” The
amendment failed, 107-323. [H.R. 2685, Vote #343, 6/10/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15]
On Transportation
Opposed Additional Spending for I-81 Project in Syracuse
In February 2014 in an op-ed piece published in the Post-Standard, Katko criticized Rep. Maffei’s for
wanting additional funding for a more extensive construction project on Interstate 81 that runs through
downtown Syracuse.
“Maffei held his first invitation-only ‘study session’ to brainstorm creative plans on digging up Interstate
81 through downtown Syracuse. You may recall that Maffei previously criticized the state Department of
Transportation’s presented options - estimated to cost between $650 million and $900 million - as
‘unsatisfactory’, instead encouraging planners to reconsider more extensive alternatives that would cost
taxpayers more than double the others,” Katko wrote. [Katko Op-ed, Post-Standard, 2/23/14]
Opposed High Speed Rail Project in Upstate New York
supporting a costly high speed rail project across Upstate New York.
“Wasn’t it just two years ago during his last campaign that Maffei championed spending $4 billion in
federal tax dollars on a high-speed train across Upstate? Maffei called that project a needed ‘lifeline’ that
would help all of us in Central New York feel less ‘isolated.’ The AP reported last week that the project
could end up costing as much as $6.2 billion - and that’s before a shovel has even hit the ground,” Katko
wrote. [Katko Op-ed, Post-Standard, 2/23/14]
Said He Was Committed To Being A Strong Voice On I-81, But Didn’t Advocate Any Particular
Option
September 2015: Said He Was Committed To Being A Strong Voice On The Reconstruction Of I81. “‘I had the privilege of speaking directly with Secretary Foxx on local projects of importance, and I
29
appreciate his willingness to learn more about the infrastructure needs of our region,’ Katko said. ‘I am
committed to providing a strong voice for central New York on local infrastructure projects -- and
especially on the reconstruction of Interstate 81.’” [The Citizen, 9/24/15]
April 2015: Said The I-81 Project Needed Leadership, But He Wasn’t Advocating Any
Particular Option. “Yes. Everybody thinks it’s a political hot potato. I don’t think it’s a political
hot potato. You need some lead-ership in this area. If we hadn’t stood up, we would’ve been
stuck with two options and I think a lot of people would’ve been upset. I’m not advocating for
any particular one, but I don’t think, at this early stage, you can cut out entire categories of
options like they were thinking of doing.” [The Citizen, 4/20/15]
Did Not Object To Eliminating The High Density States Program, Said Its Restoration Was A Win
For Central New York.
Did Not Object To Eliminating The High Density States Program On The House Floor. “Here’s the
back story: U.S. Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler, R-Washington, sponsored an amendment to the highway
bill that would eliminate the High Density States Program. The program provides federal funding to
states, including New York, with high populations and heavy mass transit use. The amendment was
approved by voice vote. No one objected to the measure on the House floor. After the highway bill’s
passage, Democrats criticized Katko, R-Camillus, for failing to speak out against Herrera Beutler’s
amendment.” [The Citizen, 11/15/15]
Said He Decided To Allow A Voice Vote On High Density States Funding As A Political
Calculation. “Ultimately, Katko decided it would be better to allow a voice vote rather than force a
roll call vote on the amendment. He believes it would’ve received bipartisan support from
representatives who live outside of the Northeast -- the region that benefits most from the funding -and that strong showing would’ve been tough to overcome in final negotiations.” [The Citizen,
11/15/15]
Rep. Hanna Was “Disappointed” That No One Objected To The Elimination Of The High
Density States Program. “The U.S. House of Representatives ‘ approval of a longterm federal
transportation funding bill Thursday could mean an $820 million cut in funding for the state’s public
transportation systems. … ‘Congressman Hanna is deeply disappointed that this amendment passed
and was done so in the middle of the night with no one present to object to it,’ said Renee Gamela,
Hanna’s communications director.’” [Observer-Dispatch, 11/07/15]
House Amendment Would Have Cut $12 Million From Centro; Centro Official Called Said “It
Would Be Very Devastating For Us.” “The House of Representatives approved a long-term highway
bill Thursday that strips billions in public transportation funding from New York and six other
Northeastern states. A last-minute amendment, approved by a voice vote Wednesday night, would
effectively cut off $820 million over six years in public transportation aid to New York state. Centro,
which provides public bus service in Central New York, would lose about $12 million in aid during the
same period – forcing potentially steep cutbacks for a struggling urban transportation system. ‘It would
be very devastating for us,’ said Rick Lee, Centro's deputy executive director, noting that such a large
loss of aid would force operating budget cuts and delay the replacement of old, high-mileage buses.”
[Post Standard. 11/05/15]
30
Claimed “Continued Funding For Centro” In The Transportation Bill Was A Win For Central
New York. “Katko, R-Camillus, a member of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee,
served on the conference committee which negotiated the final highway bill agreement. ‘Today’s
legislation includes significant wins for central New York, including the designation of Interstate 81 as a
high priority corridor, continued funding for Centro and the overall stability that our community needs to
plan for long-term investment in our infrastructure,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 12/04/15]
On The Ryan Budget
Katko Refused to Take a Position on the Ryan Budget, But Said The “General Concepts” Were In
Line With What He’d Discussed On The Budget
In May 2014, during an interview with the Auburn Citizen Katko refused to take a position on the Ryan
Budget:
THE CITIZEN: Democrats have targeted you looking for a position on (U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan's)
budget proposal being that it is the Republican budget plan and you're a Republican. What are
your views on the plan outlined by Congressman Ryan?
KATKO: I will confess that I haven't read the entire thing and I'm not familiar with all the
contours of it. Unless and until I get into Congress, I'm not going to start issuing opinions on
something that is basically a working paper. [Auburn Citizen, 5/15/14]
Katko Doubled Down on Not Taking a Position on the Ryan Budget
In July 2014, Katko continued to refuse to take a position on the Ryan Budget for FY 2015. “I'm
not in Congress and wouldn't have an opportunity to vote on that,” Katko said of the Ryan budget
proposal. [Syracuse Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
October 2014: Declared Opposition To The Ryan Budget. JK: The Ryan budget: Listen, he has had
his plants going to every single town hall, and I have had tons of people asking me, where do you stand
on the Ryan budget? They want to be able to take that, to show that I support the Ryan budget because I
hate the elderly and I’m going to cut Medicare. Well, it’s not true. I have made it perfectly clear, I am
absolutely against … GR: So you are not for the Ryan budget? JK: No. GR: You don’t support the Ryan
budget? JK: Absolutely not. [Debate Transcript, Syracuse New Times, 10/29/14]
On Campaign Finance
Katko’s Campaign Raised $1,029,766 In 2014, Including A $45,000 Loan From Katko. FEC Data
shows Katko’s campaign raised $1,029,766 in 2014, including a $45,000 loan from Katko. [FEC.gov,
accessed 10/22/15]
Katko Raised $792,908 In The First Three Quarters Of The 2016 Cycle. FEC data notes Katko has
raised $792,908 in the first three quarters of the 2016 cycle. [FEC.gov, filed 10/15/15]
31
Katko Had $664,307 Cash On Hand On October 1, 2015. FEC data notes that Katko had $664 cash
on hand on October 1, 2015. [FEC.gov, filed 10/15/15]
32
Key Moments on Video
Said He Would Not Participate In Extremism And That, Since Republicans Have Both Houses Of
Congress, They Had “No Excuses” Not To Get Things Done, Or Voters Would Judge Them
Said He Would Not Participate In Extremism And That, Since Republicans Have Both Houses Of
Speaking to reporters the morning after his election, Katko stated, “I am not going to take part in
extremism. It’s just not going to happen. And if they think I am they’ll be sorely disappointed. I think that
Republicans have, we have both houses now. We have no more excuses. Right? We have no more
years, people are going to say, ‘you had the House and the Senate, what have you got done?’ Y’know, and
we’ve gotta get some things done.” [Interview, Post Standard, 11//05/14]
NOTE: this video has been saved to the DCCC drive.
Katko Said Migrant Laborers Were Necessary to Take the Burden off Agricultural Planters
In 2014, Katko said that he supported allowing temporary workers to enter and exit the country legally
because season labor was important to the agricultural industry.
Katko mentioned specifically that he had dealt with “migrant camps” while working with his father-inlaw, who was a potato farmer. Katko added that seasonal laborers took a burden of “planters” in the state.
“Temporary workers, the apple workers in the western part of this district, temporary help in the fields
here, my father-in-law was a potato farmer his whole life. We dealt with those migrant camps there. The
seasonal labor is important to our economy. It fills jobs that some people just don’t fill. You need a way
for those seasonal laborers to come in and out of the United States, and make it easier to take a burden off
those planters,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Katko Supported Amnesty
In 2014, Katko said that he supported amnesty and potentially a path to citizenship for immigrants who
entered the country illegally, but were living productive lives.
“The main question is what to do with the millions of others that are here illegally, but are living
productive lives, law abiding lives. That’s a tough question. I don’t just pretend to have all the answers
with that, but I don’t think it’s, it’s rational to think of it as we can take each and every one of them and
send them out of here. It’s physically incapable of doing that. So we need to sit down and take a sensible
approach to doing that. What exactly it is, I don’t know. But I’d like an amnesty, a citizenship, where
everybody is not absolutely, positively not out of the question,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Advocated Lowering the Corporate Tax Rate
33
In 2014, Katko said that he was in favor of lowering the corporate tax rate to prevent companies from
moving oversees. Katko also advocated lowering deductions, and closing tax loopholes.
“Lower tax rate. Lower deductions, and closing the deductions for them, so some corporations don’t end
up paying so much and others end up paying a lot. Even the playing field for all corporations. Alright.
Lower it, and the model will open up everywhere else,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Admitted He Had Not Read Affordable Care Act in its Entirety
In 2014, Katko said that he had read portions of the Affordable Care Act, but had not read the bill in its
entirety. Katko then called out Dan Maffei for having voted for the bill despite also not having read it.
“I have read it. Some of it- but not all of it- so I’m not going to pretend that I have,” Katko said. [Fulton
Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Supported the Supreme Court Decision on Hobby Lobby
In 2014, Katko expressed his support for the Supreme Court’s decision on the Hobby Lobby case. Katko
said that it was wrong for the government for force people to pay for certain kinds of contraception that
violated their religious beliefs.
“Like forcing someone against religious beliefs to provide one of those things in there is abortion. Ok. If
people feel that way- it’s their religious beliefs. They shouldn’t have to be forced to do that. But heyguess what! The Supreme Court agreed with them today. They Supreme Court said just that- that if you
believe that’s against your religious beliefs- you don’t have to provide coverage. This is what the
Democrats have done with that. And this I think is terrible. To making it sound like we’re preventing
women from getting contraception, which is absolutely, completely inaccurate. The very company that
brought this case, the Hobby Lobby, has 16 types of contraception they’re not objecting to Obamacare.
Ok. There just certain types of contraception that they feel is abortion related like the morning after pill
and those types of things,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Supported Fracking as Long as It Was Safe
In 2014, Katko said that he supported fracking, as long as it was safe and did not compromise water
quality. Katko said that fracking would allow the U.S. to become a net energy exporter.
“Fracking is safe, why not let it in the non-watershed areas. And see how it goes and try it. And as long as
it’s safe. Companies have every incentive to make sure it’s safe. And it’s starting to show that if fracking
continues as it has in North Dakota, we’d be a net energy exporter of Natural gas. And we could send that
gas to Germany instead of the Russians,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Opposed the SAFE Act
In 2014, Katko said that he was opposed to the SAFE Act because it did very little to prevent crime.
Katko added that 98.5 percent of fun crimes were committed by people who didn’t legally own guns.
34
“And I can tell you right now that I know that’s directed at the SAFE act, the SAFE act doesn’t do very
little of anything to percent crime in this country. 98.5 percent of gun crimes in this country are
committed by people who don’t own that gun legally. And what you’re doing with the SAFE act is just
going to aggravate the rights of law-abiding citizens,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
Mentioned He Received Campaign Donations from John Boehner and Eric Cantor
In 2014, Katko mentioned that he had received campaign donations from both John Boehner and Eric
Cantor.
“Some money came from outside the district: John Boehner sent me a check, Eric Cantor before he got
bounced sent me a check,” Katko said. [Fulton Listening Session, 6/30/14]
35
Biography
Birth Date
John Michael Katko was born November 9, 1962 in Syracuse, New York. [Various]
Education
Bishop Ludden High School, a private Roman Catholic school in Syracuse, NY
BA, Niagara University
JD, Syracuse University School of Law, 1988
Career
The following provides a brief overview of Katko’s professional career.





Associate Attorney, Howrey & Simon, Washington, DC (1988 – 1991)
Senior Trial Attorney - Enforcement Division US Securities and Exchange Commission (1991 1995)
US DOJ AUSA - Narcotic & Dangerous Drug Section (1995 - 1998)
Northern District of NY US Attorney's Office (1998 - 2014)
Northern District of NY US Attorney's Office - Narcotics Chief and Organized Crime Drug
Enforcement Task Forces Coordinator (2008 - 2014)
36
Personal Finance
2015 Personal Financial Disclosure
Between January 1, 2014 and December 31, 2014, Katko reported an earned income of $59,896.26 split
between his salary from the US Attorney’s Office and his wife’s work as a nurse at Dr. Sopp’s office. For
2013, he reported an income of $175,429 primarily from his salary from the US Attorney’s Office, and
partially from his wife’s work at Dr. Sopp’s.
Earned Income
Source
Type
US Attorney’s Office – Syracuse NY
My
salary
Spouse
salary
Dr. Shane Sopp
Amount current year to filing
Income
preceeding year
$26,332
$136,769
$33,564.26
$38,660
$59,896.26
$175,429
TOTAL
[Federal Personal Financial Disclosure, 5/14/15]
Assets And Unearned Income 2013-2014
On his PFD, filed in July 2014 and revised in May 2015, Katko reported assets totaling between $3,003
and $45,000. Katko also reported between $2,503 and $5,400 in income between January 1, 2014 and
July 27, 2014 and between $5,003 and $15,400 in all of 2013.
Asset And Description
JP Morgan 529 College Age-Based
Portfolio
Mobile Home
Description: rent mobile home to a
tenant.
Value Of
Asset
Income Type
$1,001$15,000
None
$1,001$15,000
Rent
TOTAL
Income current year to
filing
Income
preceding
year
$5,001-$15,000
$5,001$15,000
$5,0001-$15,000
$5,001$15,000
Liabilities 2013-2014
Owner Creditor
Geddes Federal Savings & Loan
Association
Geddes Federal Savings & Loan
Association
TOTAL
Date
Incurred
Type
Amount of Liability
May 1998
Mortgage on
primary residence
$100,001-$250,000
May 2013
Home equity loan
$15,001-$50,000
$115,002-$300,000
37
2014 Amended Financial Disclosure
Between January 1, 2014 and July 27, 2014, Katko reported an earned income of $47,429.41 split
between his salary from the US Attorney’s Office and his wife’s work as a nurse at Dr. Sopp’s office. For
2013, he reported an income of $175,429 primarily from his salary from the US Attorney’s Office, and
partially from his wife’s work at Dr. Sopp’s.
Earned Income 2014
Source
Type
My
salary
Spouse
salary
Dr. Shane Sopp
TOTAL
Amount current year to
filing
Income
preceding
year
$26,332
$136,769
$21,097.41
$38,660
$47,429.41
175,429
On his Candidate PFD, filed in July 2014 and revised in May 2015, Katko reported assets totaling
between $3,003 and $45,000. Katko also reported between $2,503 and $5,400 in income between January
1, 2014 and July 27, 2014 and between $5,003 and $15,400 in all of 2013.
JP Morgan 529 College Age-Based
Portfolio
Mobile Home
Description: rent mobile home to a
tenant.
UBS Account
Value Of
Asset
Income Type
Income current year to
filing
Income
preceding
year
$1,001$15,000
Dividends,
Interest
$1-$200
$1-$200
$1,001$15,000
Rent
$2,501-$5,000
$5,001$15000
$1,001$15,000
Dividends,
Interest
$1-$200
$1-$200
$2,503-$5,400
$5,003$15,400
TOTAL
July 2014 Personal Financial Disclosure
Between January 1, 2014 and July 27, 2014, Katko reported an earned income of $40,00 exclusively from
his wife’s work for Dr. Sopp. For 2013, he reported an income of $34,568.54 mostly from his wife’s work
at Dr. Sopp’s, and partially from his work as an Assistant United States Attorney.
Earned Income 2014
38
Source
Type
My
salary
Spouse
salary
Dr. Shane Sopp
TOTAL
Amount current year to
filing
Income
preceding
year
$13,471.13
$40,000
$21,097.41
$40,000
$34,568.54
[Federal Personal Financial Disclosure, filed 7/29/14]
On his Candidate PFD, filed in July 2014 and revised in May 2015, Katko reported assets totaling
between $3,003 and $45,000. Katko also reported between $2,503 and $5,400 in income between January
1, 2014 and July 27, 2014 and between $5,003 and $15,400 in all of 2013.
Income Type
Income current year
to filing
Income
preceding
year
$1,001$15,000
Dividends,
Interest
$1-$200
$1-$200
Mobile Home
Description: rent mobile home
to a tenant.
$1,001$15,000
Rent
$2,501-$5,000
$5,001$15000
UBS Account
$1,001$15,000
Dividends,
Interest
$1-$200
$1-$200
Value Of
Asset
JP Morgan Account
TOTAL
$5,003$15,400
$2,502-$5,400
39
Assistant United States Attorney
Significant Findings
 Received commendations and awards for prosecuting seven gangs and reducing
crime in Syracuse
 Agreed to plea deals with nearly all 150 gang members
 Agreed to plea deal with gang member who was release from federal prison and
then convicted of assault and drug possession
 Secured a lesser sentence for gang member who confessed to murder
 Agreed to plea deal with gang member who murdered a toddler
 Agreed to a plea deal with a corrupt cop accused of rape
 Police officer under investigation committed suicide, attorney said it was due to
Katko’s threatening and coercive tactics
 Agreed to drop a charge of soliciting sex from a minor for Oswego mayor
 Helped secure a reduced sentence for the leader of the largest drug ring in Central
New York
Note: The following chapters provide an overview of Katko’s time as an Assistant United
States Attorney in the Northern District of New York from 1998 to 2014. According to a
search on PACER, Katko was listed as the attorney on 1070 federal cases. The cases
highlighted in this section are the ones that received the most news coverage and were the
most influential on Katko’s career. For a full list of Katko’s cases, please see Appendix III.
… Gang Prosecutions
40
 Agreed to plea deal with gang member who was release from federal prison and
then convicted of assault and drug possession
 Secured a lesser sentence for gang member who confessed to murder
 Agreed to plea deal with gang member who murdered a toddler
 Agreed to plea deal with gang member that murdered a local star athlete
In 2008, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Uptown Gang Member Bennie Jackson
who had been charged with crack distribution and the use and possession of a
firearm. In the plea agreement, the weapons charge was dropped. Jackson was
sentenced to 46 months and was released from federal prison in July 2011. In July
2012, Jackson violated the terms of his parole and was charged and convicted of
second degree assault and third degree criminal possession of a controlled
substance. Jackson was sentenced to three years in prison for the assault and two
years in prison for the drug possession to be served consecutively. He is eligible for a
parole hearing in 2015.
Katko also agreed to plea deals with two other gang members who violated the
terms of their supervised release and went back to jail for drug possession and
distribution.
In 2004, Katko asked a judge to hand down a lesser sentence to Rodney Hill, a Boot
Camp Gang member who confessed on the witness stand to homicide, because of
Hill’s cooperation in the prosecution of Karo Brown. Prosecutors were seeking to
prosecute Brown as the ring leader of the Boot Camp Gamp even though gang
members who testified said they never acted under anyone’s orders. Katko agreed
to plea deals with all Boot Camp Gang members who admitted to racketeering and
punished those who refused to assist in Brown’s prosecution by seeking stiffer
sentences.
In 2013, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Saquan Evans, a Bricktown Gang
member who was responsible for the shooting death of 20 month old Rashaad
Walker, Jr. Evans pleaded guilty to racketeering charges and faced a maximum
sentence of life imprisonment. Evans was only sentenced to approximately 33 years,
to be served concurrently with a sentence he was already serving in Onondaga
County.
Also in 2013, Katko agreed to a plea deal with V-Not gang member Kahari Smith
who was charged with murdering local high school star athlete, Kihary Blue. Smith
admitted to firing multiple shots into a moving car known to be used by a rival
41
gang. Blue was not a gang member but was in the car at the time. Smith was
sentenced to 35 years in prison.
During his tenure as an Assistant United States Attorney Katko has received much
praise for his work prosecuting gangs in Syracuse under the federal Racketeer
Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act. Katko has received awards and
commendations for his prosecutions and work as a member of the Gang Task Force.
He prosecuted seven gangs and sent over 150 gang members to jail. In 2011 the
Post-Standard reported that crime in Syracuse had dropped by 18 percent in the
six-years Katko had been prosecuting gangs under RICO.
Katko Prosecuted Seven Gangs, Over 150 Members
In February 2014, Katko said over the next decade, they prosecuted seven gangs and sent more than 150
gang members to prison. Once gangs were removed from an area, Katko said it helped improve conditions
in that neighborhood.
“When you took out the gang for that area, the quality of life for the people in those areas really increased.
It was a noticeable change,” he said. “I was very proud of that. It really is an example of teamwork. You
take these law enforcement agencies. They all have different priorities. They all have different concerns.
And when you put them together to go after a goal, good things can happen.”
Katko received several awards and honors for his work with the Syracuse Gang Violence Task Force,
including a director’s award in 2005 for “superior performance as an assistant U.S. attorney” which was
awarded by then-U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member who was Then Convicted of Assault, Drug Possession
In December 2008, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Uptown gang member Bennie Jackson. Jackson had
been indicted on charges of crack distribution and the use and possession of a firearm. In the plea
agreement, the weapons charge was dropped and Jackson faced a maximum term of life imprisonment.
In February 2011, Jackson was sentenced to 46 months in prison. Jackson was released from federal
prison in July 2011. [United States District Court of Northern New York, 5:2008-cr-00293; Federal Bureau of Prisons
Inmate Locator, accessed 4/14/14]
In July 2012, Jackson violated the terms of his parole and was charged and convicted of 2nd degree assault
and 3rd degree criminal possession of a controlled substance. Jackson was sentenced to three years in
prison for the assault and two years in prison for the drug possession to be served consecutively. Jackson
would be eligible for a parole hearing in February 2015. [Onondaga County Court, Indictment No. 2012-0037-1,
Indictment No. 2012-0518-1; New York State Department of Corrections Inmate Information Search, accessed 4/14/14]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member who was Then Convicted of Drug Possession, Distribution
42
In August 2006, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Elk Block gang member Skyler Willis. Willis had been
indicted on charges of racketeering which included selling crack cocaine, and possession of a gun related
to a dispute with a rival gang member. Under the plea agreement, Willis faced up to life imprisonment.
In March 2008, Willis was sentenced to 56 months in prison, but in April 2008, Willis’ sentence was
reduced to 46 months.
After his release in 2009, Willis violated the terms of his parole twice: in 2009 and again in 2010. He was
caught using cocaine, driving a car with a suspended license, and he refused to participate in a drug
testing program. Willis was sent back to prison for a total of 24 months and was released in September
2011. [United States District Court of Northern New York, 5:2005-cr-000322; Federal Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator,
accessed 4/14/14]
In October 2011, Willis was caught selling crack cocaine, cocaine and marijuana. Syracuse police had
placed surveillance on Willis after they received complaints that he was again selling drugs on Elk St.,
territory frequented by the Elk Block gang. Willis was convicted of 3rd degree criminal sale of a
controlled substance, and three counts of criminal possession of a controlled substance. Willis was
sentenced to two years in jail with 1½ years post-release supervision. [Onondaga County Court, Indictment No.
2011-1220-1; New York State Department of Corrections Inmate Information Search, accessed 4/14/14]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member who was Then Convicted of Drug Possession
In December 2008, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Uptown gang member Shawn Reed. Reed was
indicted on two charges of crack cocaine possession with the intent to distribute. Under the plea
agreement, Reed faced 20 years in prison.
In March 2009, Reed was sentenced to three years, but in October 2011, Reed’s sentence was reduced to
time served and he was released from prison.
In 2013, Reed violated the terms of his parole and was indicted in Onondaga County Court on three
counts criminal possession of a controlled substance and resisting arrest. Reed also failed to report for
drug testing, was kicked out of Syracuse Pavilion Residential Reentry Center, a halfway house, for poor
compliance, and was fired from his job.
In April 2013, Reed was sentenced to another 11 months in federal prison. In March 2014, after release
from federal prison, Reed was moved to Onondaga County jail to serve a two year sentence. [United States
District Court of Northern New York, 5:2008-cr-00297; Onondaga County Court, Indictment No. 2013-0158-1]
Prosecuted Syracuse Boot Camp Gang
In October 2003, Katko was prosecuting members of the Boot Camp Gang from Syracuse. Authorities
had arrested the last four alleged members of the gang in Connecticut after a five-month manhunt.
“We put hundreds, if not thousands of hours, into catching these guys. But we can say we got all 26,”
Katko said.
43
Prosecutors alleged that since 1995 the men conspired to run a criminal enterprise selling crack and bulk
amounts of marijuana in Syracuse and Cincinnati. The indictment accused the gang of one murder,
attempted murder and witness tampering, as well as drug trafficking.
All of the men were indicted under federal racketeering laws that could result in life in prison. [Associated
Press, 10/23/03]
Opposed Bail for Accused Gang Members
In June 2003, Katko argued for the continued confinement of seven men arrested in Syracuse and
accused of belonging to a violent street gang.
Katko outlined several factors he said justified the men’s detention. He noted all had multiple
prior arrests and criminal convictions, many involving weapons and acts of violence, including
some episodes as recent as early June. He also cited the substantial prison time the men faced if
convicted - penalties anywhere from 20 years up to life.
Additionally, Katko raised the likelihood for witness intimidation if the men were released. “If this
is a successful prosecution, their gang will be destroyed. Quite frankly, they are going to be
desperate,” Katko told the federal magistrate.
“It can’t be underscored enough, this group has terrorized the community since 1995. They believe
they own this neighborhood, and they resort to violence repeatedly to prove it,” Katko said.
U.S. Magistrate Gary Sharpe denied bail to the seven suspects. [Associated Press, 6/26/03]
Secured Lesser Sentence for Gang Member Who Confessed to Murder
In November 2004, Katko asked U.S. District Judge Norman Mordue for a lesser sentence for Rodney
Hill, a Boot Camp Gang member who confessed on the witness stand to homicide, because of Hill’s
cooperation in the prosecution of Katro Brown. Prosecutors were seeking to prosecute Brown as the ring
leader of the Boot Camp Gamp.
Hill was facing 12 to 15 years in prison on a racketeering conviction. Judge Mordue sentenced Hill to 105
months, or approximately 9 years, behind bars for conspiring with other Boot Camp members to use
violence to control the drug trade within its turf. [Post-Standard, 11/17/04]
NOTE: A request has been made for documentation related to potential subsequent arrests and
convictions of Hill. Further research is necessary.
Pursued Conviction of Brown as Boot Camp Gang Leader
In August 2004, Katko pursued charges against Karo Brown as the leader of the violent Syracuse
Boot Camp street gang. Brown was convicted on federal racketeering charges that could put him
in jail for life.
44
Katko told jurors they had seen enough evidence that Boot Camp had a common purpose and was
an organization with a framework that allowed its members to act in a coordinated way. Boot
Camp terrorized the neighborhood with daily drug dealing on street corners, multiple shootings
and four homicides of rival gang members, Katko said. [Associated Press, 8/03/04]
…Even Though Members Say They Did Not Follow Orders
In August 2004, Brown’s lawyer, Simon Moody, argued during closing statements
Monday that the government had failed to prove that Boot Camp fit the legal definition of
a criminal enterprise under RICO.
Moody noted the gang members who testified said they never acted under anyone’s orders,
although one of them said there were suggestions from gang members about committing
crimes.
They all said they kept the profits of their drug sales and didn’t have to pay anything to the
gang. One gang member said there were no leaders. [Associated Press, 8/03/04]
Helped Secure Lesser Sentence for Gang Member Who Cooperated with Prosecutors
In November 2004, Katko helped secure a lesser sentence for a gang member who was facing at
least 10 years in prison on a racketeering conviction. Katko said Ridwan Othman was among the
first members of the Boot Camp street gang to cooperate with prosecutors in the racketeering case
against him and 25 other members of the gang.
“He’s one of the few people in this case who has truly turned his life around,” Katko told U.S.
District Judge Norman Mordue. Othman had made other attempts to change his ways before his
arrest and “tripped up many times,” Katko said.
Judge Mordue sentenced Othman to four years in prison. [Post-Standard, 11/18/04]
Agreed to Plea Deals with Gang Members who Admitted to Racketeering
In November 2004, Katko agreed to plea deals with eight gang members who admitted to using
violence to tightly control defined gang territory where members sold drugs.
The members were Walker Betts, Charles Myles, Leonard Holby, Sean Southland, Rause Barnett,
Dudley Harris, Akim Betsey, and Anthony Jackson. [U.S. Attorney’s office for the Northern District of
New York press release, 11/19/04, 11/29/04, 12/02/04, 12/13/04, 1/05/05]
Sought Stiffer Sentence for Gang Member who Refused to Cooperate in Brown Case
In November 2004, Katko said he asked U.S. District Judge Norman Mordue to give Christian
Williams, a Boot Camp gang member accused of murdering a rival gang member, a stiffer
sentence because Williams refused to testify at the trial of Boot Camp member Karo Brown last
summer, as he had agreed to do.
45
Williams faced up to life imprisonment. [Post-Standard, 11/25/04]
Objected to Claim by Gang Member’s Mother that the System “Failed” her Son
In November 2004, Katko objected to the claim made by Veronica Williams, mother of
Boot Camp gang member Christian Williams who was accused of murder, that the system
failed her son.
“I’m not saying I know everything about my son, but I feel the system has failed my son,”
she said. She blamed officials at the Beard School, where Syracuse students in trouble go,
for not challenging her son.
Katko said her remarks were a discredit to the young men who grew up on Syracuse’s
South Side, stayed out of trouble, went to college and made something of themselves.
Christian Williams has himself to blame, Katko said.
“He grew from a small child into a killer,” he said. “And he did it in the most cowardly
way - by shooting his victim in the back.” [Post-Standard, 11/25/04]
Katko Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member that Murdered a Toddler
In July 2013, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Saquan Evans, a Bricktown Gang member who was
responsible for the shooting death of 20 month old Rashaad Walker, Jr. Evans pleaded guilty to
racketeering charges and faced a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.
In April 2014, Evans was sentenced to 400 months in prison, approximately 33 years, to be served
concurrently with a sentence he was already serving in Onondaga County. [United States District Court of
Northern New York, 5:2011-cr-00198]
Death Penalty Not Sought for Death of Toddler
In January 2012, Katko said the U.S. Attorney General’s office decided that Saquan Evans would
not face the death-penalty for the death of 20 month old Rashaad Walker, Jr.
Katko said the U.S. Attorney General’s office in Washington conducted an extensive review of the
aggravating and mitigating factors in the two cases in evaluating whether to authorize deathpenalty prosecutions.
Katko said he recently received a one-sentence letter from Washington saying he was not to seek a
death-penalty prosecution in those matters. [Post-Standard, 1/06/12]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Member Who Shot Local High School Star Athlete
In September 2013, Katko agreed to a plea deal with V-Not gang member Kahari Smith who was charged
with murdering local high school star athlete, Kihary Blue. Smith admitted to firing multiple shots into a
moving car known to be used by the Bricktown gang in 2010. Blue was not a member of the gang but was
in the car at the time.
46
In March 2014, Smith was sentenced to 35 years in prison. [Post-Standard, 3/25/14; United States District Court
of Northern New York, 5:2011-cr-00317]
Prosecuted Elk Block Gang under RICO
In August 2005, Katko prosecuted 16 alleged members of the Elk Block gang on a charge of running the
gang as a criminal enterprise under the federal Racketeering Influenced Corrupt Organizations (RICO)
Act.
The Post-Standard wrote that the case epitomized the tack that federal prosecutors were using to combat
Syracuse street gangs: Instead of trying to overcome intimidated witnesses to prove one charge in state
court, the feds try prove the gang members were part of an ongoing criminal enterprise.
Katko said the gang members should be held in jail at least until trial because they presented a risk of
fleeing. [Post-Standard, 8/03/05]
Agreed to Plea Deals with Gang Leaders
In October 2005, Katko agreed to a plea deal with the accused ringleader of the Elk Block gang,
Billy Applins, who pleaded guilty in federal court to racketeering charges.
Katko said, “It was significant because he was the first guy to plead, and it’s very unusual for
someone of his stature to do that. He’s the number one defendant in this case and, usually, they’re
the last to come forward.” [Post-Standard, 10/06/05]
In December 2005, Katko agreed to a plea deal with James Kelly, the Elk Block gang’s alleged
No. 2 man. Kelly pleaded guilty in federal court to racketeering charges and faced up to life in
prison. “This is a very significant plea,” Katko said.
“Fourteen cases remain pending in various stages of plea negotiation,” Katko said. [Post-Standard,
12/23/05]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Members
In August 2006, Katko had agreed to a plea deal with eleven members of the Elk Block gang. As
part of the plea, the members admitted that through their membership in the Elk Block Gang they
were responsible for distributing crack cocaine and possessing weapons.
The men pled guilty to racketeering activity that included multiple acts of drug trafficking,
murder, attempted murder, conspiracy to commit murder and witness tampering. [U.S. Attorney’s
office for the Northern District of New York press release, 8/29/06; Post-Standard, 12/20/06]
Five Gang Members Found Guilty on Charges of Drug Trafficking to Murder
47
In December 2006, five members of the Elk Block gang being prosecuted by Katko were found
guilty in federal court on charges ranging from drug trafficking to murder. They faced life
imprisonment and fines of up to $250,000 each Katko said.
They used violence to control their crack cocaine trade, intimidate witnesses and were responsible
for the deaths of at least two others in rival gangs, Katko said. “The violence in this case was
really kind of jaw-dropping,” Katko said. [Post-Standard, 12/20/06]
Balked at Gang Member’s Protestation of Charges
In May 2007, former member of the Elk Block gang, Gregory Thomas, protested the charges
against him at his sentencing hearing citing case law and claiming that he did not commit some of
the charges on which he was convicted.
Thomas’s lawyer, James Long, said Thomas was “a small-time street-corner dealer.” His client
had a “tough and difficult life,” Long said, but Thomas “is not un-salvageable. He grew up with
no guidance. He sought his guidance from peers on the street.”
Katko said he was not buying it. “His criminal history is absolutely staggering,” Katko
“He has an utter contempt for authority of any sort,” Katko said. “So many people tried to
straighten him out, and all he did was thumb his nose at them and was completely defiant with no
remorse whatsoever.”
Thomas was sentenced to 30 years in prison. [Post-Standard, 5/24/07]
Katko said Prosecuting Elk Block Gang Would Solve Open Murder
In August 2005, Katko told a judge that the prosecution of the Elk Block gang would solve the open
murder of Delmar Everson. Everson was a member of the rival Boot Camp gang and was shot to death in
2003.
“We will solve that murder, certainly,” Katko told U.S. Magistrate Gustave DiBianco. [Post-Standard,
8/07/05]
Lawyer Said Katko’s Evidence Did Not Prove Who Committed the Murder
In August 2005, Edward Dunn, lawyer for Will Robinson, cited a “wide range of potential
problems” with the evidence linking a casing found on Robinson’s car to Everson’s slaying.
Katko said police had a shell casing from a .40-caliber handgun that a county sheriff recovered
from the bottom of the windshield of Will Robinson’s car. The casing matched shell casings found
at the scene of Everson’s slaying two months later, Katko said. “The same gun was used to kill
Delmar Everson,” Katko said.
“There are plenty of .40-caliber handguns” that the casings at the scene of Everson’s slaying could
have come from, Dunn said in court.
48
Robinson’s name surfaced as a shooting victim in last year’s prosecution of the Boot Camp gang.
Katko cited those shootings in court as proof that Robinson was a gang member.
“The fact he’s been shot twice doesn’t make him a racketeer,” Dunn said. “It makes him a victim.”
Prosecuted Members of the Brighton Brigade Gang
In February 2007, Katko was prosecuting members of the Brighton Brigade gang. Three Syracuse
defendants pleaded guilty to being involved in the Brighton Brigade gang. The men also admitted to
racketeering charges, prosecutors said.
That gang also was involved in drug trafficking, attempted murder and witness tampering, said Katko.
Agreed to Plea Deal with Gang Members
In July 2007, all fourteen of the Brighton Brigade gang members had pled guilty to racketeering
charges, admitting to helping the gang operate a crack cocaine distribution ring. Katko said the
indictment accused the gang members of using violence, attempted murder, robbery and witness
tampering to maintain their drug business.
When sentenced, they faced up to life in prison and fines of up to $250,000 each, Katko said. [PostStandard, 6/06/07, 7/21/07]
Prosecuted Members of Gangs on Syracuse’s East Side
In March 2008, Katko prosecuted eleven men that were alleged gang members on Syracuse’s East Side.
Authorities said the accused were members of two groups: Uptown, which included gangs called DBlock, Thunz and Croly; and the Lexington Diamonds.
Unlike previous gang prosecutions in Syracuse - Elk Block, Boot Camp and the Brighton Brigade - the
men charged did not face federal racketeering charges.
The groups would come together to commit violence in support of each other or their territory, Syracuse
Police Sgt. John Savage said. The men were arraigned on drug and federal weapons charges. [Post-Standard,
3/19/08]
Agreed to Plea Deal with East Side Gang Members
In May 2009, Katko agreed to a plea deal with East Side gang members.
As part of his plea, one member admitted that in December 2008, he had 17 grams of crack
cocaine, packaged for distribution and a 9 mm pistol in his home, Katko said. [Post-Standard, 5/06/09]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Members of the 110 Gang
49
In 2010, Katko agreed to plea deals with members of the 110 gang who were charged conspiring to
engage in a pattern of racketeering activity. The men admitted to possession of crack cocaine with the
intent to distribute and using violence to protect gang territory and further gang activities.
The men faced up to life imprisonment, a $250,000 fine, and up to five years of supervised release
following any period of incarceration. [U.S. Attorney’s office for the Northern District of New York news release,
2/03/10, 3/01/10, 3/15/10, 4/05/10, 4/14/10, 6/23/10, 7/21/10, 7/30/10]
Said He Had Never Heard a Gang Member Denounce his Membership Before
In March 2011, Reddell Smith, former 110 gang member, publicly condemned his membership in
the gang at his sentencing hearing. “I, Reddell Elijah Smith Sr., denounce the 110 gang as being a
destructive force that’s currently holding my community as well as the youth back from
prospering,” Smith read from a written statement in court.
Katko, who prosecuted Smith and 11 other 110 gang members, said he’d never before heard a
gang member denounce his membership. [Post-Standard, 3/05/11]
Prosecuted Bricktown Gang, More Violent than other Syracuse Gangs
In April 2011, Katko prosecuted the fifth Syracuse gang since 2003, the Bricktown gang. Katko said the
first four gangs limited their victims to rival gang members, but Bricktown was different, taking the lives
of two innocent victims.
The victims were 20-month old Rashaad Walker, Jr. and Anthony Ford, 32, who was mistaken for a rival
gang member. Katko said the public outcry over Rashaad’s murder provided prosecutors with added
incentive. “It motivated us more, of course,” he said. “But we were already focusing, moving forward.”
Agreed to Plea Deals with Bricktown Gang Member on RICO Charges
Between 2011 and 2013, Katko agreed to plea deals with members of the Bricktown gang who
were charged with racketeering.
Gang members admitted that, among other things, the Bricktown gang maintained territory within
Syracuse where they distributed crack cocaine, cocaine and marijuana and that they protected their
territory with violence. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release, 7/13/11, 12/12/11,
2/09/12, 7/19/12, 10/15/12, 11/01/12, 6/27/13]
Prosecuted Members of V-Not Gang on RICO Charges
In May 2012, Katko prosecuted members of the V-Not Gang on racketeering charges. The racketeering
activity described in the indictment included murder and other shootings, drug trafficking, firearms
possession, robbery and witness tampering.
50
If convicted, each defendant faced up to life imprisonment, a $250,000 fine, and three years of supervised
release following any period of incarceration. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release,
5/01/12]
Syracuse Police Chief Said City was Safer After V-Not Arrests
In May 2012, Syracuse Police Chief Frank Fowler said, “The city of Syracuse is a much safer
place right now than it was yesterday.” Eleven V-Not members had been arrested and charged for
violating the federal Racketeer Influenced Corrupt Organizations Act.
Fowler called V-Not a “very dangerous street gang.” [Post-Standard, 5/02/12]
Agreed to Plea Deal with V-Not Members
In 2012, Katko agreed to a plea deal with V-Not gang members. They pled guilty to conspiring to
exploit their membership in the V-Not gang to engage in a pattern of racketeering activity which
included acts of murder, drug trafficking, and robbery.
The members faced up to life imprisonment, a $250,000 fine, and three years of supervised release
following any period of incarceration. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release,
9/26/12, 12/06/12, 12/11/12, 12/12/12, 6/28/13, 9/11/13]
Katko Asked to Ban Introducing Former Gang Members Community Outreach Program at Trial
In September 2013, Katko asked U.S. District Judge Norman Mordue not to allow former V-Not gang
member Habakkuk Nickens to introduce his community outreach involvement at his trial. In his plea
agreement, Nickens admitted to his role in the shooting death of local high school football and basketball
star, Kihary Blue.
After Blue’s death, Nickens tried to distance himself from the V-Not gang, Katko wrote in court papers.
Nickens started a community outreach program that he called “Help Breakdown the Silence” and claimed
it was intended to help troubled inner-city youths.
But multiple V-Not gang members were prepared to testify that Nickens got involved in the program
solely to prepare for his defense against racketeering charges that he knew would be coming as a result of
Blue’s death, Katko wrote. [Post-Standard, 9/19/13]
Judge Gave Nickens a Reduced Sentence Because of Community Work
In April 2014, U.S. District Judge Norman Mordue sentenced Nickens to 20 years in prison.
Under federal sentencing guidelines, Mordue could have sentenced Nickens to more than 30 years
in prison. But the judge cited the work that Nickens did in the community to try to turn teens away
from violence and gangs.
Mordue said he received 31 letters from people, many of them jail inmates, praising Nickens for
his spiritual guidance. According to court papers filed by his lawyer, Nickens formed a Bible
study group at the Cayuga County Jail. [Post-Standard, 4/26/14]
51
Prosecuted Man for Threatening Gang Task Force Detectives with Gun
In September 2013, Katko prosecuted Terrell Wright for pointing his gun at two Syracuse Gang Violence
Task Force (GVTF) members. Wright pled guilty to assaulting two detectives, carrying a handgun during
the assault, and being a convicted felon in possession of a handgun.
Wright acknowledged that he had two prior felony drug convictions and was currently on parole. Thus, he
qualified as a career offender under the federal sentencing guidelines and he would face greater
punishment. [United States Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of New York, 9/19/13]
Convict’s Wife Said He Was Innocent Due To New Evidence, Alleged Katko Had A Vendetta, But
Convict Lost An Appeal After The New Evidence Was Uncovered
Convict’s Wife Said He Was Innocent, Alleged Katko Had A Vendetta Against Him. “That’s after
Alfred Robinson’s wife, Nicole, posted a petition on Change.org proclaiming her husband’s innocence
and attacking the prosecutor for his 2002 conviction. What the petition fails to mention is that Alfred
Robinson, of 6535 Route 298, was implicated as a Boot Camp gang member who attempted to murder a
witness to keep him from testifying at trial, former federal prosecutor and current U.S. Rep. John Katko
said at the time. Robinson’s wife argues that prosecutors went on a vendetta against her husband after he
failed to testify the way they wanted him to at an earlier trial. She said new evidence, discovered in 2007,
shows he’s innocent.” [Post Standard, 1/24/15]
… But Robinson Had An Appeal Rejected After The New Evidence Came To Light.
“Robinson appealed his attempted murder verdict, but an appeals court rejected his claims. He
took the case to federal court, where a judge also dismissed his appeal. But the federal judge did
overturn an additional conviction of bribing a witness on a legal technicality. The judge's decision
to uphold the attempted murder conviction came in 2009, two years after Nicole Robinson said the
new evidence came to light.” [Post Standard, 1/23/15]
RICO Act
Said Using RICO to Prosecute Gangs was Becoming a Trend in Criminal Prosecutions
In April 2003, Katko said using the RICO Act to prosecute gangs is starting to become a trend in criminal
prosecutions throughout the state and the country.
“You’re seeing a rise in the violence in street-level gangs [...] (the RICO Act) has a major effect on those
gangs,” Katko said about using the statute to prosecute local groups.
Since 2003, Katko had used the RICO Act to successfully prosecute three gangs in the Syracuse area Boot Camp Gang in 2003, the Elk Block in 2005 and the Brighton Brigade in 2006. He said those gang
members who have been convicted were facing between 30 years to life in prison.
Katko said that after the Boot Camp Gang, which consisted of 27 members, was dismantled, homicides
dropped 40 percent and drug-related arrests dropped 92 percent in the gang’s territory. [Rochester Democrat
& Chronicle, 4/29/09]
52
Gave Lecture on Using RICO to Prosecute Gangs at DA’s Advisory Council Meeting
In December 2009, Katko gave a lecture at the District Attorney’s Advisory Council monthly meeting
about how they have been using federal racketeering laws to prosecute street gangs in Syracuse.
Katko explained how federal authorities first targeted the Elk Block gang after that group imported
seventy guns from Georgia for an anticipated battle with rival Boot Camp. Authorities then targeted the
violent Boot Camp gang before moving on to several additional groups.
But the indictment of two dozen Boot Camp gang members in June 2003 was like “dropping a nuclear
bomb on gang violence in Syracuse,” Katko said. The prosecution of Boot Camp led to a 40 percent drop
in the city’s murder rate and a 92 percent drop in crime in the Boot Camp neighborhood, he said.
Katko said the gangs still operating in Syracuse are much more circumspect about flashing gang signs,
sporting gang colors and painting signature graffiti on their turf because federal authorities used those
things to build the racketeering cases.
“We have the gangs on the run,” he said. [Post-Standard, 12/04/09]
Prosecution of Gangs in Syracuse Contributed to Drop in Violent Crime
In June 2011, the Post-Standard reported that Syracuse’s violent crimes – homicides, robberies, assaults
and rapes – had fallen nearly 18 percent in six years. Likewise, property crimes – burglaries and thefts –
had reached their lowest level in at least 26 years.
A pushback against street gangs, grassroots efforts to reach at-risk youth and a burgeoning refugee
population may have contributed to the downturn in crime, the paper wrote.
The prosecution of Syracuse’s street gangs had taken more than 100 hardened criminals off the streets,
said Katko. Members of seven Syracuse gangs had been sent to prison on racketeering, drug and guntrafficking charges since 2003, Katko said. [Post-Standard, 6/10/11]
Katko Created Timeline Linking Drop in Violent Crime to Gang Arrests
In June 2011, Katko pieced together a timeline using FBI statistics linking violent crime to the rise
and fall of city gangs.
The city’s gangs first started trafficking illegal guns around 1999. A year later, the violent crime
rate jumped nearly 9 percent.
The rate remained high until 2003, when authorities arrested members of the Boot Camp gang.
Since 2003 Katko had prosecuted five Syracuse gangs and violent crime fell after each round of
arrests. [Post-Standard, 6/10/11]
Participated in Online Question-and-Answer Session on Prosecution of Street Gangs
53
In September 2013, Katko, who was described as the U.S. Attorney’s office top gang prosecutor,
participated in an online question-and-answer session hosted by the Post-Standard to answer questions
about prosecuting street gangs. [Post-Standard, 9/25/13]
Gang Violence Intervention Programs
Participated in Launch of “Syracuse Truce” Program Targeting Gang Violence
In February 2013, Katko participated in the launch of the “Syracuse Truce” program that was aimed at
combating gang violence. The “focused deterrence” program was funded with a $300,000 federal grant
over two years. City police would work with federal and state law enforcement, social service agencies
and community groups.
Twenty gang members attended and were told if they wanted help, they could get it. But if they killed
again, their entire gang would be targeted by police.
Katko, who had prosecuted many of the men sitting in front of him, promised that he’d prosecute them
again. “You have dozens of highly skilled professionals watching you all the time,” Katko told the men.
“They know a hell of a lot more than you can imagine.” [Post-Standard, 2/28/13]
Grant Funded Through DOJ Project Safe Neighborhoods
In February 2008, the grant used to the fund the “Syracuse Truce” was awarded by the U.S.
Department of Justice’s Violent Gang and Gun Crime Reduction Program, also known as Project
Safe Neighborhoods (PSN). [Syracuse Police Press Release, 2/27/13]
PSN is a nationwide commitment to reduce gun and gang crime in America by networking
existing local programs that target gun and gun crime and providing these programs with
additional tools necessary to be successful. The funding is being used to hire new federal and state
prosecutors, support investigators, provide training, distribute gun lock safety kits, deter juvenile
gun crime, and develop and promote community outreach efforts as well as to support other gun
and gang violence reduction strategies. [USDOJ US Attorney’s Office Northern District of New York,
accessed 5/20/14]
U.S. DOJ Awarded Syracuse $1.5 Million for Gang Intervention Program
In September 2013, the U.S. Department of Justice awarded Syracuse $1.5 million to start a new gang
intervention program. [Post-Standard, 9/25/13]
In January 2014, Larry Williams, a former education and probation officer, was appointed as the
program’s director and would be coordinating recources to offer young people a way out of gang life.
[WSYR, 1/29/14]
Grant Funded Through OJJDP Community –Based Violence Prevention
54
In September 2013, the grant awarded to Syracuse for gang intervention was through the Justice
Department’s Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention’s Community-Based
Violence Prevention program.
"OJJDP's Community-Based Violence Prevention program focuses youth violence prevention
efforts on what research shows works," said OJJDP Administrator Robert L. Listenbee. "Through
a combination of prevention, intervention, enforcement, and reentry programs, these sites will
promote alternatives to violence and make communities safer." [OJJDP Press Release, 9/24/13]
Awards and Commendations
Received Three Awards From The Justice Department, Including One In September 2014
Attorney General Holder Recognized Katko For Prosecution Of Bricktown And V-NOT Gangs.
“Former Assistant United States Attorney John Katko was recognized for the investigation and
racketeering prosecution of 25 members of the ‘Bricktown’ and ‘V-NOT’ street gangs. Both gangs were
involved in multiple murders, armed assaults, and robberies, as well as firearm and cocaine base
trafficking. The investigations solved numerous acts of violence that had occurred during a 2010 gang
war, including the tragic drive-by murder of an uninvolved high school basketball star and the killing of a
20-month-old child in a misguided act of retaliation.” [Press Release, Attorney General’s Office, 9/11/14]
Katko Received Three Major Awards From The Justice Department. “This will be Katko’s third top
honor from the Justice Department. He received the Distinguished Service Award in 1997 for his work in
a nationwide wiretap investigation of international drug trafficking. He also received a Director’s Award
for Superior Performance in 2005 for his work leading the Syracuse Gang Violence Task Force.” [Post
Standard, 9/09/14]
Received Executive Office of U. S. Attorneys Director’s Award for Superior Performance as AUSA
In February 2014, Katko received the 2014 Executive Office of United States Attorneys Director’s Award
for Superior Performance as an Assistant U.S. Attorney in recognition of his work prosecuting street
gangs in Syracuse.
Katko used the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, or RICO Act, to prosecute the gang
members. Katko’s work helped solve several murders and led to the conviction of nearly 150 gang
members for RICO offenses, among other charges. [Auburn Citizen, 2/27/14]
Syracuse Police Chief: Katko “A Bulldog” for Gang Prosecutions That has Left an “Impact” on
Community
In January 2007, Syracuse Police Chief Gary Miguel praised Katko, whom he called “a bulldog,” for his
part in prosecuting Elk Block, Boot Camp and Brighton Brigade members. “These cases aren’t easy, but
you can see the impact they’ve had on our community,” Miguel said.
Syracuse had experienced a drop in crime in 2006. “This is a good day. We’ve had some dramatic
reductions in crimes,” Miguel said. There was a 27 percent drop in homicides, a 37 percent drop in calls
55
reporting gunshots, a 24 percent drop in rapes and a 27 percent drop in motor vehicle thefts. [Post-Standard,
1/12/07]
Katko Received Commendation for Gang Prosecutions
In March 2007, Katko, along with 14 other members of an interagency anti-gang squad, received a
commendation for prosecuting local gangs.
“They’ve taken down the Boot Camp Gang, the Elk Block Gang and, recently, the Brighton Brigade,”
Chief Gary Miguel said. By using federal anti-racketeering laws to bust the gangs, the anti-gang squad’s
prosecutions have reduced violence in the city, Miguel said. [Post-Standard, 3/03/07]
Was Guest Speaker at Chiefs of Police Association Award Ceremony
In April 2010, Katko was the guest speaker at the Central New York Association of Chiefs of Police
award ceremony. Twenty-four officers were honored at the ceremony. [Post-Standard, 4/30/10]
Appointed Narcotics Chief and Lead Organized Crime Task Force Attorney
In May 2010, Katko was appointed narcotics chief and lead organized crime task force attorney for the
U.S. Attorney’s office in Syracuse. [Post-Standard, 5/16/10]
… Police and Political Corruption
 Agreed to a plea deal with a corrupt cop accused of rape
 Police officer under investigation committed suicide, attorney said it was due to
Katko’s threatening and coercive tactics
 Agreed to drop a charge of soliciting sex from a minor for Oswego mayor and
helped him secure a reduced sentence even though he posed a danger to the
community
In 2001, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Schenectady police officer Michael Siler
who was accused of rape after luring the victim to a bachelor party with crack
cocaine. Siler was also being investigated for corruption and under the plea deal
Siler plead guilty to racketeering and Katko dropped the rape charge.
Also during the corruption investigation in Schenectady, Officer William Marhafer
committed suicide. An attorney for another officer said Katko had been using
threatening and coercive tactics.
56
Katko agreed to drop a charge of soliciting sex from a minor against former Oswego
Mayor John Gosek part of a plea bargain. Gosek pled guilty to a felony charge of
using his city cell phone to induce what he thought were two 15-year-old girls to
have sex with him. In exchange, Katko agreed to drop a second charge of soliciting
Gosek was expected to receive five years in prison, the mandatory minimum
sentence, but Katko recommended a lower sentence because of Gosek’s “substantial
assistance” and he was sentenced to 37 months in prison. However, previously
Katko had said Gosek had a pattern of soliciting sex frim minors, posed a danger to
the community and had a “very dark side.”
Schenectady Police Department Corruption Case
Investigated Corruption at Schenectady Police Department, Said Investigation was Sacred
In August 2000, Katko, who had been directing a grand jury investigation into the Schenectady Police
Department for the past year said the investigation was at the start of “a very long road.”
“We are looking into a lot of very, very serious allegations,” said Katko. “It takes time to build cases.
Some people may not like that, but that’s how we have to proceed in order to do things properly. The
investigation is sacred to us.”
Schenectady officers Michael Siler and Richard Barnett were charged with extortion and drug dealing for
allegedly taking crack cocaine from a person on the street and then selling the drug. The officers pleaded
not guilty to the charges at an arraignment before U.S. Magistrate Judge Ralph W. Smith Jr. [Albany TimesUnion, 8/12/00]
Katko Said He Was Aware of Officers Harassing Grand Jury Witnesses
In September 2000, Katko said he was concerned about witness tampering.
“Since we last met here, one of our most important witnesses has been harassed or tampered, for lack of a
better word,” Katko said. [Albany Times-Union, 9/28/00]
In March 2001, Katko said he was aware of police officers harassing witnesses on the street who had been
cooperating with federal authorities. “It’s a big concern [...] threatening witnesses is a felony,” Katko said.
“We are so concerned, it’s become one of the focuses of this investigation.” [Albany Times-Union, 3/01/01]
Katko Troubled by Police Harassment of Man Wearing FBI Hat
In June 2001, a group of Schenectady police officers was accused of harassing a man wearing an
FBI hat shortly after a highly decorated fellow police officer had appeared in court on federal
corruption charges.
“This type of conduct, if true, is deeply troubling to us, especially since it came on the heels of a
lieutenant being arraigned on criminal charges,” said Katko. [Albany Times-Union, 6/26/01]
57
Agreed to Plea Deal with Officer Accused of Extorting, Dealing Drugs
In September 2000, Officer Richard Barnett pleaded guilty to extortion of crack cocaine from a drug
runner and distribution of the drugs to police informants in a plea agreement that Katko said included
Barnett’s decision to cooperate with the federal investigation. [Albany Times-Union, 9/28/00]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Police Officer Accused of Rape
In July 2001, Katko chose not to prosecute a rape accusation in exchange for a plea deal with Officer
Michael Siler. Siler accepted the plea deal offered by Katko, which included counts of drug distribution,
drug possession, extortion and racketeering. [Associated Press, 7/23/01]
Siler Could Have Faced 30 Years in Prison, but Was Sentenced to 24 Months
In March 2002, Siler was sentenced to 24 months in prison and three years probation on each of
four charges, extortion, cocaine distribution, marijuana and heroin distribution, and racketeering.
His sentences were concurrent. Prosecutors said Siler could have faced a maximum of 30 years in
prison if he had gone to trial. [Associated Press, 3/06/02]
Siler Was Released in 2002
According to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, Siler was released from prison in January 2004.
[Federal Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator, accessed 7/17/14]
Officer Allegedly Lured Woman to Bachelor Party with Crack Cocaine and then Raped Her
In June 2001, Renee Rickson testified before the grand jury that Siler offered her crack cocaine in
exchange for attending a bachelor party, where she alleged to have been raped by Siler and
another officer.
“I will never forget what they did to me, until the day I die,” Rickson said. According to the
Times-Union, “Every time attorneys tried to get the witness to discuss details, she burst into tears.
So after two hours on the stand, Renee Rickson never fully detailed for a federal court jury her
allegations that former Officer Michael Siler, who was fired after pleading guilty to extortion and
drug distribution, raped her.” [Albany Times-Union, 6/05/01, 12/28/01]
Rickson Claimed Siler Stalked and Harassed her for Weeks
Rickson claimed that Siler had followed and harassed her for weeks, once taking her to his
apartment. Rickson alleged that when Siler made sexual advances on her in his apartment she
asked to be taken home but he laughed at her and said, “What are you doing to do, call the cops?”
[Albany Times-Union, 6/05/01]
Rickson Claimed She Had Straightened out Her Life
58
Rickson, who had recently been released from a year in prison for selling drugs, she said
she has straightened out her life, was going to drug and alcohol counseling and worked at
Mont Pleasant Middle School in Schenectady. [Albany Times-Union, 12/28/01]
Defense Attorneys Referred to Officer as a “Rapist” and “Drug User”
In December 2001, while Siler was testifying on behalf of the government, defense attorneys
referred to him as a “rapist, perjurer, and drug user, who implicated his colleagues to stay out of
jail.” [Albany Times-Union, 12/19/01]
NOTE: Federal Prison Bureau and New York State Department of Corrections inmate searches were
performed for the name Michael Siler. Siler was released from federal prison in 2004 and has not been
back to jail.
Documents from Siler’s case are unavailable because the case is sealed.
Officer Prosecuted by Katko Committed Suicide
In October 2001, Schenectady Police Officer William Marhafer committed suicide in the police station
locker room in front of fellow officers due to an ongoing police corruption investigation for which Katko
was the lead prosecutor. [Times Unions, 10/07/01; Albany Times-Union, 2/01/02]
Threatening and Coercive Tactics Used During Investigation
In October 2001 Defense Attorney Paul DerOhannesian who defended another officer prosecuted
by Katko said, “A lot of lives and reputations are being threatened by federal investigative tactics.
A common technique is to threaten police officers with public humiliation if they don’t
cooperate.”
“Marhafer wasn’t even charged, but he was under a lot of pressure, so what you have is lives being
sacrificed at the altar for investigative expediency,” he continued.
DerOhannesian said police officers besides Messere and civilians have come to him regarding the
federal investigation. “Threatening and coercive tactics are being used by the people running this
investigation.” [Times Unions, 10/07/01]
Attorney Said New Testimony Would Fit in with Katko’s Spin on the Case
In February 2002, lawyer for convicted Schenectady Police Lt. Michael Hamilton, Joseph Tacopina, took
Katko to task after the prosecutor suggested that another officer’s new testimony would mesh nicely with
the defense’s “spin” on the case.
Throughout the trial, the defense alleged Hamilton and Officer Nicola Messere were framed by the vice
squad and the assistant chiefs, who were jealous of their arrests and awards. “I am not trying to be a
defense lawyer,” Tacopina shot back. “I am not trying to blow smoke. I have a police officer who has
served his community who happens to be innocent and I am on trial with him. So when I hear about spins,
I take offense.” [Albany Times-Union, 2/01/02]
59
Katko Said Officer Agreed to Testify After Witnessing Colleague Commit Suicide.
Officer Patrick Horan came to Katko after he witnessed another officer involved in the case
commit suicide in the police station locker room. Katko argued that Horan came forward, not to
get even, but to do the right thing. “No. He saw a fellow officer take his life, and he saw his body
fall and he saw him die. That is what affected him,” Katko said. [Albany Times-Union, 2/01/02]
Schenectady Police Association Complained about Extension of Katko’s Investigation
In March 2001, Tony Brown, president of the Schenectady city police union said he was perplexed at the
six-month extension of the federal grand jury investigation into corruption in the Schenectady Police
Department.
“I can’t believe it. I have no idea what they’re going after, but having this cloud hanging over the
department without closure of the investigation is not good for the officers or the community,” Brown
said. [Albany Times-Union, 3/24/01]
Said Siler’s Guilty Plea Dispelled Criticism of Federal Investigation
In July 2001, Katko said Siler’s own admission to committing several crimes helped to dispel accusations
that the FBI and prosecutors have been leading a witch hunt against a group of hard-charging, motivated
cops.
A guilty plea is even more definitive than a jury verdict, because a jury could be criticized for not
reaching a fair verdict, said Katko. “There’s absolutely no way someone can say now, the jury got it
wrong. It vindicates what we’ve been saying all along.” [Albany Times-Union, 7/24/01]
Katko: “No One […] is Above the Law, and That Includes Those Who Enforce the Law”
In December 2001, Katko said, “No one in the United States of America is above the law, and that
includes those who enforce the law.” [Associated Press, 12/18/01]
Defense Attorney Said Katko was “Drooling” Over Racketeering Charges
In December 2001, Defense Attorney Paul DerOhannesian said his client, Officer Nicola “Nick” Messere,
was the victim of a long, expensive federal investigation that was desperate to produce results.
“They’re drooling for Hamilton and Messere like you couldn’t believe,” he said. “Two and a half years,
hundreds of thousands of dollars, they’re not going to leave without something else.”
Messere and Lt. Michael Hamilton were indicted on charges of racketeering and could face at least 10
years if in prison if convicted. [Associated Press, 12/18/01]
Officers Acquitted of Racketeering, Convicted on Lesser Charges
60
In January 2002, Messere and Hamilton were acquitted of racketeering but convicted on drug
charges. They both faced up to 20 years in prison
Katko said “It’s a sad day for law enforcement but a great day for the justice system because it
shows that no one is above the law.” [Albany Times-Union, 1/17/02]
Said Prosecution Relied on Testimony of Criminals Because Police Chief Undermined Investigation
In December 2001, Katko said the government was forced to build a case around people with credibility
problems after Police Chief Gregory Kaczmarek and Mayor Al Jurczynski undermined the federal
investigation.
In August 1999, when investigators were quietly building a criminal case against two other Schenectady
officers, the chief and mayor announced that they planned to call in the FBI. “Chief Kaczmarek and the
mayor in their infinite wisdom announced, ‘Hey world, guess what? We’re looking into allegations of
corruption in the department,’” Katko said.
After that, any plans to send in undercover agents to catch other rogue officers in the act were discarded.
“What the FBI was left to do was canvas the streets of Schenectady,” said Katko. [Albany Times-Union,
12/19/01]
Katko Said Defendants Built Their Careers on Witnesses they were Trying to Discredit
In December 2001, during his opening remarks Katko told the jury to remember that the people
the officers on trials were now calling “liars, drug users and thieves,” were the same people they
relied on for information when they patrolled some of Schenectady’s most drug-ridden streets.
“They built their careers on the backs of these people,” said Katko. [Albany Times-Union, 12/19/01]
Katko: “You Can’t Let Cops Break the Law”
In January 2002, Katko said, “You can’t let cops break the law. You can’t let cops cross the line.”
[Associated Press, 1/15/02]
Katko did Not Prosecute Insurance Fraud in Plea Deal with Officer Convicted on Drug Charges
In March 2002, as part of a plea agreement with Officer Richard Barnett who was convicted on extortion
and drug charges, Katko did not pursue criminal charges against Barnett’s wife, Lara Andrew, for filing a
false insurance claim over damages to a boat the couple owned. Andrew had her law license suspended
for a year because of the claim.
Katko sought a lesser sentence for Barnett. “We need to provide a strong incentive for individuals like
Mr. Barnett who come through the door first,” said Katko. [Associated Press, 3/06/02; Albany Times-Union,
3/07/02]
Praised Demotion of Schenectady Chief of Police
61
In March 2002, Katko, who prosecuted four Schenectady cops o drug-related charges, said he hope that
Police Chief Gregory Kaczmarek’s demotion would user in change for the department.
“This is a necessary move to insure real reform in the department,” he said. [Albany Times-Union, 3/21/02]
Katko Criticized Assistant Chief of Police for Pushing for Lesser Sentence for Lt. Hamilton
In May 2002, Katko had stern words for Schenectady Assistant Chief of Police Mark Chaires who was
among the more than 100 people who wrote letters on behalf of Lt. Michael Hamilton seeking leniency in
his sentencing.
“He was offering his opinion on the quality of the evidence without ever stepping foot in the courtroom,”
said Katko, noting that Chaires’ letter minimized the seriousness of Hamilton’s crime.
Prosecutors and probation officials recommended Hamilton serve six to eight years in prison for his
conviction of aiding and abetting a crack house. U.S. District Judge David Hurd sentenced Hamilton to
four years citing all the letters he received departing from the guidelines. [Albany Times-Union, 5/17/02]
Asked Federal Appeals Court to Uphold Convictions of Ex-Cops
In December 2002, Katko asked the federal appeals court to uphold the convictions of Nicola Messere
and Michael Hamilton, former Schenectady police officers. “There was ample evidence to convict the
defendants of all the charges they were convicted of,” Katko said.
Attorneys for Hamilton and Messere claimed the cases were plagued with irregularities. [Albany TimesUnion, 12/19/02]
Court Upheld Convictions
In July 2003, U.S. Court of Appeals upheld the drug convictions of former Schenectady police
Officers Hamilton and Messere. “We have considered all of the defendants’ arguments on these
appeals, and have found them to be without merit,” the judges wrote. The decision left the two
men with few legal options for further appeal.
“This is closure. It’s closure for the victims in this case and those individuals who were brave
enough to stand up to these guys at the Schenectady Police Department,” Katko said. “And it’s
closure for anyone that’s been affected by the case.” [Albany Times-Union, 7/03/03]
Oswego Mayor Solicitation of Sex with a Minor Case
Agreed to Drop Charge Against Mayor That Allegedly Solicited Sex with Minor
In March 2006, Katko agreed to drop a charge of soliciting sex from a minor against former Oswego
Mayor John Gosek part of a plea bargain.
62
Gosek pleaded guilty to a felony charge of using his city cell phone to induce what he thought were two
15-year-old girls to have sex with him. In exchange, Katko agreed to drop a second charge of soliciting
Under his plea deal, Gosek was expected to receive five years in prison, the mandatory minimum sentence
for his crime. [Post-Standard, 3/14/06]
…But Said Gosek Had a Pattern of Soliciting Sex
In September 2005, Katko said “It’s not just talk. There’s a pattern of him using the cell phone and
attempting to entice women. Sometimes the women are adults, sometimes they’re not.” [PostStandard, 9/18/05]
Gosek Indicted on Two Charges of Soliciting Sex from a Minor
In November 2005, Gosek was indicted on charges of soliciting sex from two 15-year-old girls
and a girl he believed to be 14-years-old. [Post-Standard, 11/04/05]
In September 2005, Gosek was caught by the FBI for attempting to have sex with two teenage
girls. Gosek paid a woman $250 in an attempt to have sex with two 15-year-olds, according to an
FBI affidavit. Gosek had used his city cell phone to call the woman to arrange the meeting the
girls at a hotel.
In November and December 2004, state police recorded conversations between Gosek and a 14year-old girl, whom he promised drugs in exchange for sex, according to the court papers. [PostStandard, 9/18/05]
Secured Lower Sentence for Gosek
In July 2006, Katko recommended a lower sentence for Gosek because of his “substantial
assistance.” Gosek was facing a mandatory minimum sentence of five years in prison under
federal sentencing guidelines, but Katko asked U.S. District Judge Thomas McAvoy to depart
from the guidelines.
Gosek was sentenced to 37 months in prison.
The details of what Gosek told investigators were removed from a sentencing memorandum filed
by Katko. [Post-Standard, 7/19/06]
…But Said he Had a “Very Dark Side” and was a “Danger”
In September 2005, Katko said Gosek posed a danger to the community. [Post-Standard,
9/20/05]
In July 2006 after the trial, Katko said Gosek had a “very dark side.” “The wiretap showed
that the defendant routinely engaged in incredibly selfish, self-indulgent, manipulative and
morally repugnant conduct that was criminal in nature,” Katko wrote. [Post-Standard, 7/19/06]
63
Gosek was Released in 2009
According to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, Gosek was released from prison in May 2009. [Federal
Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator, accessed 7/17/14]
performed for the name John Gosek. Gosek was released from federal prison in 2009 and has not been
back to jail.
Documents Unsealed After The 2014 Election Showed Gosek Provided Information On A Public
Official Who May Have Been A Tax Cheat
2014: Katko Said The Mayor Of Oswego Cooperated To Lead To Other Investigations; That
Subsequently The Police Chief Was Removed. “John Katko (JK): … “He cooperated with us, which is
a standard procedure in federal cases. And he cooperated with us to lead us to other investigations in the
Oswego area. And I can’t say any-thing other than subsequently to that, the police chief was removed
from Oswego. And in subsequent investigations and for that, Mr. Gosek received two points off his
sentence.” [Interview, Syracuse New Times, 10/22/14]
Unsealed Documents Showed Katko Gave Gosek A Lighter Sentence Because Gosek Gave
Information On Other Public Officials. “We know negative advertising is nasty. It also can be false, as
we learned last week when a federal judge unsealed documents pertaining to former Oswego Mayor John
Gosek. U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei, D-Syracuse, used the Gosek plea agreement in a negative attack ad against
his Republican op-ponent, John Katko. As an assistant U.S. attorney in 2006, Katko prosecuted Gosek on
charges he tried to entice what he thought were two 15-year-old teen age girls to have sex. Maffei’s ad
accused Katko of working with a federal judge to give the mayor a lighter sentence. Why? Because they
were all Republicans. The allegations in Maffei’s ad prompted syracuse.com and The Post-Standard to
renew a request to see the mayor’s sentencing documents. We first asked for them in 2005 and
subsequently sought them two more times. Each request was denied on the grounds the investigation was
ongoing. The fact U.S. District Judge Thomas McAvoy unsealed them this time is an indication the probe
is over. The unsealed documents show that Gosek was given a lighter sentence in return for giving
prosecutors information about alleged wrongdoing involving another Oswego public official. Katko
maintained there was nothing hinky about Gosek’s sentence. He was right.” [Editorial, Post Standard,
11/23/14]
Noted In Previously Sealed Documents That Gosek Began Providing Information And
Though “Much Of The Information Provided By The Defendant Was Of Little Value
To The Government, The Defendant Has Provided Information That Has Produced
Leads That We Are Now Pursuing,” And “While The Defendant Had No Concrete
Information Of Wrongdoing … An Investigation Into Possible Wrongdoing Is
Ongoing.” “Soon after his arrest, the defendant began attempting to provide substantial
assistance to the government. In that regard, the Defendant was extensively debriefed
regarding his conduct in this case as well as in his position as Mayor of the City of Oswego.
While much of the information provided by the Defendant was of little value to the
government, the defendant has provided some information that has produced leads that we
are now pursuing. In particular, the defendant provided information regarding the possible
64
‘fixing’ of real estate valuations of at least one high level Oswego public official who own
multiple rental properties. While the Defendant had no concrete information of wrongdoing,
he did provide information regarding the fact that the property values for all of the properties
in question had in fact been reduced in the most recent assessment. Subsequent records
checks confirmed this and an investigation into possible wrongdoing is ongoing.”
[Sentencing Memorandum Of The United States, 7/07/06]
Reduced Gosek’s Sentence Due To Gosek Providing Information On A Public Official Who May
Have Been A Tax Cheat. “In response to Maffei’s accusations, The Post-Standard/syracuse.com asked
U.S. District Judge Thomas McAvoy to unseal all the documents in Gosek’s criminal case. The judge for
the first time last week released Katko’s full sentencing memorandum on Gosek, including the reason for
the reduced sentence. ‘The defendant provided information regarding the possible ‘fixing’ of real estate
valuations of at least one high-level Oswego public official who owns multiple rental properties,’ Katko
wrote in the 2006 document. ‘While the defendant had no concrete information of wrongdoing, he did
provide information regarding the fact that the property values for all the properties in question had in fact
been reduced in the most recent assessment. Subsequent records checks con-firmed this and an
investigation into possible wrongdoing is ongoing.’ During his campaign for Congress, Katko said there
was nothing unusual about how the Gosek case was handled. He received a commendation from the FBI
director for his work on the case.” [Post Standard, 11/20/14]
… Drug Crime
 Helped secure reduced sentence for leader of largest drug ring in Central New
York
 Appealed case to seek life sentence without parole for non-violent offender
Even though Katko has called marijuana smuggling a “gigantic problem,” in 2007,
Katko helped secure a reduced sentence for Alexander Cammacho, the mastermind
behind the largest marijuana selling ring ever in Central New York, because he
cooperated with prosecutors. The drug ring, which was run on a Native American
reservation, was believed to have bought and sold about $13.5 million worth of
marijuana over the course of several years.
In 2006, Katko appealed the 20 year prison sentence of Justin Powell, a non-violent
drug offender, to seek a life sentence without parole. Katko said federal law
mandated a life sentence because it was Powell’s third offense.
Worked As Part Of A Task Force In El Paso To Investigate Juarez Drug Cartels. “Early in his
career, Katko was assigned to a task force in El Paso, Texas, that investigated drug cartels across the
border in Juarez, Mexico.” [Post Standard, 12/02/14]
65
Worked As A Special Prosecutor For The Justice Department In El Paso In 1995 And 1996. “‘I
think we need to take a step back to see how this happened,’ said Katko, who served as a special
prosecutor for the Justice Department in El Paso, Texas in 1995 and 1996, assigned to a secure border
initiative.” [Post Standard, 7/08/14]
Marijuana
Said Marijuana Smuggling was a “Gigantic Problem” in Central New York
In June 2010, Katko said, “Smuggling is a gigantic problem.”
Katko cited a recent national crime estimate that 50 to 52 metric tons of marijuana were being smuggled
through the region monthly. Federal prosecutors opened an office in Plattsburgh because there are so
many cases, he said. [Associated Press, 6/10/10]
Helped Secure Reduced Sentence for Leader of Largest Drug Ring in Central New York
In May 2007, Alexander Cammacho, the mastermind behind the largest marijuana selling ring ever in
Central New York was sentenced to 15 years in federal prison. Cammacho, who was being prosecuted by
Katko, could have been sentenced to life imprisonment but his sentence was reduced because he
cooperated with prosecutors. [Associated Press, 5/22/07]
The massive drug ring was believed to have bought and sold about $13.5 million in marijuana over the
course of several years, Katko said.
Cammacho and 14 others were arrested in 2005, ending a months-long investigation. When it was all
over, investigators had seized nearly $1.8 million in cash, 30 vehicles and more than 100 pounds of pot,
Katko said. [Post-Standard, 5/22/07]
performed for the name Alexander Cammacho. Cammacho is set to be released from federal prison in
September 2018.
The plea agreement for Cammacho is unavailable because the document is sealed.
Prosecuted Drug Trafficking Ring in Utica-Rome Area
In March 1999, Katko prosecuted a massive cocaine and marijuana-trafficking ring that moved drugs
from Florida, California and New York City into the Utica-Rome area.
The ring generated at least $1.6 million in drug sales over three years, Katko said. The Organized Crime
Drug Enforcement Task Force arrested Keith Jennings, the leader of the group, and about 30 others in
September after raiding his home in Utica and seizing $3,845 in cash. [Post-Standard, 3/19/99]
Prosecuted Two Canadian Women for Drug Smuggling
66
In May 2002, Katko prosecuted two Canadian women charged with smuggling 48 pounds of marijuana
into the United States. Katko said the marijuana was hidden in the trunk of their car and covered with
laundry detergent to mask the smell. The 48 pounds had an estimated street value of more than $150,000,
he said.
The two women faced up to 20 years in prison and a $1 million fine if convicted. [Associated Press, 5/24/02]
Prosecuted Canadian Trucker for Marijuana Trafficking
In January 2003, Katko prosecuted a Canadian truck driver charged with importing marijuana into the
United States. According to court papers three large duffel bags containing 103 pounds of marijuana were
found in the cab of his rig.
Katko said Alain P. Jacques was freed on $2,500 cash bail. [Associated Press, 1/28/03]
Prosecuted County Supervisor for Growing Marijuana
In September 2002, Katko prosecuted former Cortland County supervisor Kenneth Burlingame for
running a marijuana plantation. Burlingame was sentenced to 31 months in prison for growing 307 highgrade marijuana plants, some as tall as 10 feet, in fields hidden by large trees on his 160-acre farm. His
wife was sentenced to 18 months.
The Burlingame’s agreed to forfeit their farm, five ATVs and 27 handguns, shotguns and rifles. The
government seized them because they were either bought with drug-trafficking profits or were used to run
the operation, said Katko. [Post-Standard, 9/06/02]
Prosecuted Men for Drug-Related Murder
In June 2010, Katko prosecuted a group of men from New York and Canada in a drug related robbery and
murder.
In May 2008, the men planned to rob Daniel Simonds of a large amount of marijuana and money at his
home in Stockholm, NY. During a confrontation at Simonds home he was shot and later died at the
hospital. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release, 6/09/10]
Katko was Pushing for Maximum Penalties
In May 2011, Katko said he was pushing for maximum penalties in the prosecution of the shooting
death of Simonds.
“We are very pleased with the results to date of this prosecution and will continue pushing for
pleas to the maximum charges and penalties in order to assure that justice is done in this case,”
Katko said in an e-mail. [Watertown Daily Times, 5/07/11]
Men Sentenced Between 10 to 25 Years
67
In September 2012, the last of seven men convicted of taking part in attempted robbery and
murder of Simonds was sentenced. Chad Edwards was sentenced to 10 years in prison.
Previously, Brian Latulipe was sentenced 14 years, Kaientanoron Swap to 12 ½ years, Bryan
Herne to 11 years, Alan Jacobs to 25 years, and Anson Edwards to 11 years. [Ogdensburg Journal,
9/26/12]
Cocaine
Appealed Case to Seek Life Sentence without Parole for Non Violent Offender
In January 2006, Justin Powell was sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole after
Katko appealed Powell’s original sentence of 20 years.
Katko claimed that federal law mandated a life sentence because Powell had two prior felony drug
convictions and was held responsible in the instant case for more than 50 grams of crack cocaine. [U.S.
Department of Justice press release, 1/12/06]
Prosecuted Syracuse Cocaine Ring
In June 1999, Katko prosecuted a Syracuse cocaine ring that federal prosecutors said moved up to 100
kilograms of cocaine in 1998. Thirteen people, including ring leader Michael Prevo, plead guilty to their
involvement in the ring. [Post-Standard, 6/04/99]
Prosecuted Operator of Campus Sandwich Truck for Selling Drugs from Food Stand
In December 2000, Katko prosecuted Mark Ziegler for selling drugs from a popular Syracuse University
food truck, Ziggy’s Wagon. Ziegler pleaded guilty in April to conspiring to sell cocaine as part of a major
drug-trafficking ring. He was sentenced to 27 months in federal prison.
“This individual abused a high-profile position he had on campus by selling drugs on campus and from
his home,” said Katko. [Associated Press, 12/05/00]
Prosecuted Members of Cocaine Distribution Organization
In February 2005, Katko prosecuted members of a vast cocaine and crack cocaine distribution
organization located in Rome, New York.
Thomas Rudd, Jennifer Bachman and Mark Varano each pled guilty to conspiracy to distribute and
possess with intent to distribute cocaine and crack cocaine. [U.S. Attorney’s office for the Northern District of New
York press release, 2/07/05]
Prosecuted Brothers Who Ran Drug Distribution Ring
In November 2005, Katko prosecuted two brothers, Hector and Victor de la Vega, who were identified as
the head of a large scale cocaine, crack cocaine, and heroin distribution ring who peddled drugs obtained
in New York City to a network of dealers operating in and around Syracuse.
68
That investigation culminated in the arrest, prosecution, and conviction of the de la Vega brothers and 16
other persons for narcotics trafficking conspiracy in violation of federal law. [U.S. Department of Justice’s
DEA New York field office press release, 11/29/05]
Prosecuted VA Hospital Employee for Drug Trafficking
In May 2006, Katko prosecuted Darrell Mosley in connection with drug trafficking activities at the VA
Hospital in Syracuse. Mosley was charged with distributing and possessing with intent to distribute
cocaine base (crack) and cocaine. If convicted he faced up to twenty years in prison.
Mosley was arrested at the VA Hospital after a search of his person revealed 22 baggies of crack cocaine
and over $2,000 in his pocket. A search of Mosley’s home revealed more drugs, weapons, paraphernalia,
and ledgers detailing his transactions. [Post-Standard, 5/06/06]
Katko Opposed Bail for Mosley
In May 2006, Katko opposed Mosley being released on bail. Mosley said he would put up his
house as collateral for bail and agree to home confinement or electronic bracelets if a federal
magistrate will let him out of jail.
Katko argued that the crimes were serious enough to warrant incarceration. “This case appears to
be mushrooming on a daily basis,” Katko said. A pretrial report indicated Mosley may have at
least two prior felony convictions, said Katko. [Post-Standard, 5/09/06]
Mosley Pled Guilty to Possess and Distribute Crack Cocaine
In February 2007, Mosley pled guilty to the charge of conspiracy to possess and distribute crack
cocaine, Katko said.
Mosley faced up to 40 years in federal prison and fines of up to $2 million. [Post-Standard, 2/01/07]
Mosley Sentenced to Five Years in Prison
In June 2007, Mosley was sentenced to five years in prison. Katko said Mosley’s sentence also
included eight years of post-release supervision. [Post-Standard, 6/27/07]
Prosecuted Two Syracuse Men on Cocaine Trafficking Charges
In June 2008, Katko prosecuted two Syracuse men on charges of cocaine trafficking. Jack Miesner and
James Merritt were arrested after a wiretap investigation.
The men were charged with conspiring to distribute and possess with intent to distribute cocaine and
cocaine base, specifically crack cocaine, Katko said. [Post-Standard, 6/19/08]
Methamphetamines
69
Prosecuted Man for Money Laundering, Purchasing Home for Drug Dealer
In April 1999, Katko prosecuted Syracuse real estate broker, Philip Olenych, for laundering $50,000 in
drug profits for the accused leader of a cocaine-trafficking ring by falsely representing himself as the
buyer of a city home last year.
The case demonstrates the lengths to which drug traffickers must go to spend their profits without tipping
off the Internal Revenue Service, Assistant U.S. Attorney John Katko said. “It’s like golden handcuffs,”
Katko said. “They get all this money, and they can’t spend it.” [Post-Standard, 4/30/99]
Prosecuted Bridgeport, NY Methamphetamine Ring
In October 1999, Katko prosecuted eight members of a Syracuse drug ring that was distributing a type of
methamphetamine known as “crank.” All of the defendants plead guilty.
The methamphetamine was shipped from California and New Mexico to a home in Parish, and then to a
home in Bridgeport, court papers state. Agents recovered more than a pound of methamphetamine and 14
rifles, shotguns and handguns, Katko said. [Post-Standard, 10/02/99]
Prosecuted Hospital Officials Charged with Making Meth
In October 2001, John J. Falitico Jr., University Hospital’s former director of autopsy services, was
charged with stealing chemicals to make methamphetamine at the hospital. Falitico operated a meth lab
out of the hospital for three years.
Then in March 2002, another hospital worker, David Welker, was also charged with conspiring to run a
methamphetamine lab out of a state-run teaching hospital. Authorities said Welker helped Falitico concoct
a phony research proposal that they submitted to the purchasing department to get the chemicals they
needed.
Upstate officials had no knowledge of the meth lab and have cooperated fully with investigators, Katko
said. If convicted, both men faced up to life imprisonment. [Associated Press, 10/02/01, 3/01/02; Post-Standard,
10/27/01, 3/01/02]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Falitico
In September 2002, as part of a plea pleaded guilty to conspiring to make and sell
methamphetamine in a lab at Upstate’s Weiskotten Hall. Under federal sentencing guidelines,
Falitico would be sentenced to between 11 and 14 years in prison, Katko said.
As part of his plea agreement, Falitico agreed to forfeit $5,100 in cash, $55,972 in a credit union
account and his 2000 Corvette, which he bought for $30,000. But he balked at forfeiting the car
when U.S. District Judge Norman Mordue questioned him about the plea agreement. Falitico
disagreed with Katko’s claim that the Corvette was either paid for with drug profits or was used to
transport the drugs. [Post-Standard, 12/11/02]
Prosecuted Three Men Arrested in Meth Lab Raid
70
In January 2003, Katko prosecuted three men that were arrested after of a police raid on their illegal drug
lab. Inside, police found a “substantial” methamphetamine lab, Katko said. “The best way to describe it is
a converted storage facility. It looked like an office, but it wasn’t,” he said.
James Hazlitt, Charles Whitcher, and Jason Ford were charged with conspiracy to manufacture
methamphetamine Katko said. If convicted, all three men would face up to 20 years in prison and a fine of
up to $1 million. [Associated Press, 1/31/03]
Prosecuted Police Chief’s Son after 6-Year-Old Nephew’s Meth Overdose
In May 2010, Katko prosecuted Jason Hastings, the son of Sherrill Police Chief James Hastings, for
violating the Combat Methamphetamine Epidemic Act of 2005 (CMEA).
Hastings had purchased 13.76 grams of pseudoephedrine base from six pharmacies in Madison and
Oneida Counties which was over the 9 grams per month limit. Pseudoephedrine is a key ingredient in
making methamphetamine.
Less than a month later, Hastings 6-year-old nephew suffered hallucinations following a meth overdose.
After his arrest, Jason Hastings told federal agents he had cooked methamphetamine during the past two
weeks, Katko said. Because of a prior drug conviction, Hastings faced up to two years in prison. [U.S.
Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release, 5/05/10; Post-Standard, 5/06/10]
Prosecuted Nine Individuals for Violating the Combat Meth Act
In August 2008, Katko was prosecuting nine individuals charged with crimes relating to purchasing in
excess of the monthly limit of medications containing pseudoephedrine and ephedrine as specified by the
Combat Methamphetamine Epidemic Act of 2005 (CMEA). [U.S. Department of Justice press release, 8/27/08]
Prosecuted Utica, New York Crack Distribution Ring
In October 2008, Katko was prosecuting fifteen individuals in connection with a major cocaine and crack
cocaine distribution organization located in Utica, New York, that trafficked narcotics throughout the
Mohawk Valley.
All of the individuals were charged with conspiring to possess with intent to distribute more than 500
grams of cocaine and more than 50 grams of crack cocaine. If convicted, they each faced up to a
maximum of life imprisonment. [FBI Albany Field Office press release, 10/28/08]
Agreed to Plea Deal with Utica Gang Leader
In July 2009, Katko agreed to a plea deal with Andrew Wymes, the leader of the Utica drug
trafficking gang. As part of his plea, Wymes pled guilty to conspiracy to distribute and possess
with intent to distribute cocaine. He also pled guilty to using and carrying a firearm during and in
relation to a drug trafficking crime.
71
Wymes admitted to selling between 2 and 3.5 kilograms of cocaine to mid-level dealers in the
Utica area, and possessing a .45 caliber handgun in furtherance of his drug trafficking activity.
Wymes faced a minimum of 15 years imprisonment, a maximum of life imprisonment, up to
$4,250,000 in fines and 8 years of supervised release following any period of incarceration. [FBI
press release, 7/09/09]
Prescription Drug Ring Prosecution
Prosecuted Members of Prescription Drug Trafficking Organization
In June 2007, Katko was prosecuting 16 members of a prescription drug trafficking organization. They
were all charged with conspiring to distribute and possess with intent to distribute controlled substances,
and acquiring or obtaining possession of controlled substances by misrepresentation, fraud, forgery,
deception and subterfuge.
A DEA special agent said the group was responsible for distributing large quantities of oxycontin and
amphetamines throughout the Syracuse area. [U.S. Department of Justice press release, 6/07/07]
Dr. Harry Black was accused of running the ring by writing prescriptions for thousands of pills to patients
who would then give some of the drugs back to the doctor. [Associated Press, 6/08/07]
Opposed Transfer of Suspects to Treatment Facility
In June 2007, Katko opposed the transfer of Dr. Harry Black and his wife Lisa from county jail to
drug treatment facilities.
With regard to Lisa Black, Katko said, “At any point, she can walk out the door. It’s not a secure
facility.” Katko said Harry Black had enough money to flee. When Lisa Black’s lawyer Ken
Moynihan said she was not a risk to the public, Katko said, “She knows what she’s facing. With
the charges against her, there’s a virtual certainty she’s going to do prison time.”
Katko also said it’s unfair to allow Black to enter a private treatment program because he can pay
for it, when other defendants charged with similar crimes can’t. “It’s a bit unfair when he can buy
his way into the facility,” he said.
On June 15, U.S. Magistrate Gustave DiBianco granted Lisa Black’s request to move to Tully Hill
treatment facility for a 30-day program.
On June 25, Black was moved from federal court in Syracuse to Marworth Chemical Dependency
Treatment Center in Waverly, Pennsylvania where he would be treated for at least eight weeks.
Katko said he couldn’t remember a similar case since he started in 1994 when a central figure had
been released to a treatment center pending trial. [Post-Standard, 6/16/07, 6/26/07]
Katko Reprimanded Black’s Son After He Stuck His Middle Finger at Him
72
In June 2007, at a hearing considering Lisa Black’s request to be transferred to a treatment
facility, Katko reprimanded one of her sons.
One of her sons stuck up his middle finger toward Katko, who stormed over to a group of
family members and warned them to control themselves. [Post-Standard, 6/16/07]
Post-Standard Editorial Board Agreed with Katko
In July 2007, the Post-Standard editorial board agreed with Katko’s argument that the Black’s
should not have been released to drug treatment facilities.
“Katko pointed out the obvious,” they wrote. “He said it was unfair that Black got such treatment
because he could pay it for it - while other, less-affluent defendants charged with similar crimes
could not.”
“How many non-violent offenders, many of whom have addiction problems, wished they could
have had an opportunity like the Blacks’? […] Justice is supposed to be blind, but most citizens
realize that it looks very favorably on people with money.” [Post-Standard, Editorial, 7/07/07]
Black Kicked out of Rehab
In July 2007, Harry Black was kicked out of his drug treatment program for violating a number of
rules at the facility. Black was arrested again for violating the terms of his release.
“The plain fact is that (Black) had an absolutely golden opportunity to go to this facility and do
what he needed to do,” prosecutor John Katko said. “Plain and simple? He blew it and he blew it
in a big way.”
“These were systemic violations, with repeated interventions in which it was strongly requested
that he follow all rules and protocols,” Katko said. “With all he had on the line, he still wasn’t able
to follow the rules, and that speaks volumes.” [Post-Standard, 7/06/07]
Katko Concerned About Lisa Black’s Release after Rehab
In July 2007, Katko was concerned about Lisa Black’s release after completing a drug treatment
program, particularly given her admission that she typically took 30 prescription pills a day.
“That’s a staggering amount of narcotics to be taking every day,” Katko said.
He questioned her ability to face the challenges of parenting while keeping her sobriety. “There’s
a long pattern of her not being able to do her job with her kids,” he said.
Katko recommended that the probation officers keep Lisa Black “on a very short leash,” adding
that she should be tested for alcohol and drugs several times a week. [Post-Standard, 7/18/07]
Other Defendants Agreed to Plea Deals, to Testify Against Black
73
In December 2007, eleven of the 17 defendants in a Syracuse prescription fraud and drug
distribution ring had pleaded guilty and agreed to testify against Black, Katko said.
Those who pleaded guilty acknowledged they had filled prescriptions written by former Dr. Harry
Black for controlled drugs they later shared with Black and his wife, Lisa. [Post-Standard, 12/11/07,
12/18/07]
Agreed to Plea Deal with the Blacks, Would Not Reduce Sentences
In August 2006, Katko agreed to a plea deal with the Blacks’. Dr. Harry Black and his wife Lisa
admitted to prosecutors they conspired to obtain prescription drugs by fraud or subterfuge, Katko
said.
“On sheer size alone, this is unique to Central New York,” Katko said. Prosecutors made it clear
they wouldn’t reduce charges in exchange for a plea. “(Dr. Black) was at the center of the
conspiracy,” Katko said. “His charges should reflect that.”
By pleading guilty to the indictment, Black also faced losing his $400,000 house, his doctor’s
office in Syracuse and his medical license. [Post-Standard, 8/06/08]
Black Sentenced to Four Years in Prison, Was Facing up to 20 Years
In January 2009, Henry Black was sentenced to four years in federal prison. Black was also forced
to give up his medical license, forfeit his home and former office, and he agreed to pay $38,000 in
restitution.
In February 2009, Lisa black was sentenced to one year in prison.
Under the sentencing guidelines, they had been facing up to 20 years in federal prison and fines of
up to $1 million, Katko said. [Post-Standard, 1/31/09, 2/18/09]
Heroin
Prosecuted Syracuse Heroin Trafficking Ring
In June 2010, Katko prosecuted 17 individuals on federal drug trafficking charges in connection with a
vast heroin distribution network operating between Newark, New Jersey and Syracuse, New York. The
defendants were arrested in police raids as part of “Project Deliverance,” the Justice Department’s
nationwide attempt to combat the sale of drugs from Mexican cartels.
All the defendants were charged in U.S. District Court in Syracuse with multiple conspiracy and
substantive heroin trafficking charges. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release, 6/10/10;
Post-Standard, 6/11/10]
Said Heroin Addicts Sent from Newark to Syracuse Fueled Drug’s Resurgence
74
In June 2010, Katko said that heroin addicts from Newark sent to Syracuse by Rev. Anthony
Hawthorne to receive treatment through the Syracuse Salvation Army influenced a resurgence of
the drug. “They certainly helped fuel the resurgence” of heroin in the Syracuse area, he said.
Newark Rev. Anthony Hawthorne, who had built a good relationship with the Salvation Army in
Syracuse, estimated as many as 700 New Jersey addicts were sent to attend the six-month drug
rehabilitation program.
The members of a Syracuse heroin trafficking were originally from New Jersey. [Post-Standard,
6/13/10]
Salvation Army Asked to Stop Taking Referrals from Outreach Groups
In June 2010, Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner asked the Salvation Army to stop taking referrals
from the outreach groups at the heart of the heroin trafficking investigation.
One of the men arrested in connection to the heroin ring, Derrick Campbell, came to the Salvation
Army drug rehab program after serving three years in prison in New Jersey for his seventh felony
drug conviction.
“In my 18 years as a prosecutor, I’ve never seen a defendant with seven prior felony drug
convictions,” John Katko said at a hearing. “He’s used to the revolving door of justice in New
Jersey. He’s used to short sentences, then getting out on probation or parole and he’s back at it
again.” [Post-Standard, 6/20/10]
… Other Prosecutions
 Prosecuted gun traffickers
 Prosecuted tax evasion
 Prosecuted theft and robbery
In 2003, Katko prosecuted a gun trafficking ring that was illegally dealing firearms
from Georgia.
He has also has prosecuted cases of tax evasion, theft, and bank robbery.
Prosecuted Man for Threatening Federal Judges
In February 2012, Katko prosecuted Seven Willette who pleaded guilty to one count of mailing
threatening communications.
75
In October 2010, Willette mailed threatening letters from Mohawk Correctional Facility to a United States
District Court Judge, a New York Supreme Court Judge, a Clinton County Supreme Court Judge, and a
Franklin County Supreme Court Judge, all of whom had been involved in the defendant’s previous sexual
assault convictions. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release, 2/27/12]
Prosecuted An Eight Person Murder In Puerto Rico
Prosecuted An Eight Person Murder In Puerto Rico. “While he was prosecuting an eight-person
murder in Puerto Rico, he said he sent his wife and son back to Syracuse to live with his parents for eight
months. ‘It got very sticky, very quickly,’ he said. He brought up the threats to his family earlier this year
in an unsuccessful effort to stop the newspaper from publishing a story about the time he lost a gun that
was later used in a crime.” [Post Standard, 10/24/14]
Gun Crime
Prosecuted Man Charged with Gun Trafficking
In April 2003, Katko prosecuted Darell Harlow, the leader of a gun-trafficking ring that federal
investigators said sold 50 weapons to street gangs. Harlow pleaded guilty to illegally dealing in firearms,
admitting that he had his girlfriend buy 44 guns for him in Georgia as a straw purchaser from September
1999 to December 2001. [Associated Press, 4/29/03]
Prosecuted Felon Who Purchased a Weapon from Gun Trafficking Ring in Georgia
In April 2003, Katko prosecuted Paul Clemons who pleaded guilty to being a felon in possession of a
firearm. He admitted he paid $600 for a pistol to a gun trafficking operation led by Brian Turner, 25, of
Atlanta.
Clemons faced up to 27 months in prison under federal sentencing guidelines, Katko said. [Associated Press,
4/29/03]
Tax Evasion and Robbery
Prosecuted Woman for Tax Evasion
In July 2011, Katko prosecuted Rosalie Jacobs for conspiracy to structure over $2 million in currency
transactions. Jacobs pled guilty to eight tax evasion charges. As part of her plea, Jacobs admitted that she
conspired with others to structure a series of cash deposits in less than $10,000 increments to avoid
federal Currency Transactions Reports.
For 13 months, Jacobs operated Jacobs Tobacco on the Akwesasne Indian Reserve. In an effort to avoid
IRS reporting requirements, Jacobs or one of her employees would package cash in separate bags at
Jacobs Tobacco and then gave it to someone who was instructed to make the deposits.
Jacobs was sentenced to five months probation and 12 months home confinement. She was also ordered
to forfeit the $2,634,190 to the Internal Revenue Service. [U.S. Attorney’s office for Northern District of New York
press release, 7/08/11; Daily Courier-Observer, 1/05/12]
76
Prosecuted Man for $700,000 Theft and Tax Evasion
In August 2012, Katko prosecuted William Stiles for the felony crimes of wire fraud and tax evasion.
Stiles admitted that, as chief operating officer and part owner of Aeden Waterford, Inc. (AWI), a payroll
and human services company, he stole a total of more than $700,000 from approximately 100 business
clients of AWI between 2005 and 2010.
Stiles faced a maximum penalty of twenty years imprisonment and a $250,000 fine. [U.S. Attorney for the
Northern District of New York news release, 8/23/12]
Prosecuted Oswego Police Chief for Possession of Stolen Property
In March 2006, Katko prosecuted former Oswego Police Chief William Ruggio who was charged with
four counts of possessing stolen property. The FBI and state police recovered stolen snowmobiles and an
ATV from raids at Ruggio’s two properties.
Oswego County District Attorney Donald Dodd ceded jurisdiction to Katko and two other assistant U.S.
attorney’s because Dodd was concerned about a perceived conflict of interest. [Post-Standard, 3/23/06]
Prosecuted Man for Two Bank Robberies
In September 2012, Katko prosecuted Samuel Parrotti who was arrested in connected with two Broome
County bank robberies. Parrotti was also a suspect in two additional bank robberies in Pennsylvania.
Parrotti faced a maximum term of 20 years imprisonment on each of the robberies, and maximum fines of
$250,000. [U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York news release, 9/18/12]
77
Political Career
 Traveled to Washington for advice at the beginning of his campaign, after the
convention.
 Said the turning point of his campaign was the news that the NRCC would invest
in his race, embraced Boehner, McCarthy, Walden, Westmoreland and their help
 Campaigned against Washington noting that leaders in Washington told him it
was “a narrative you have to pursue”
 Was part of the NRCC’s Patriot Program, exchanging aspects of autonomy for
NRCC funding for 2016; NRCC asked for his legislative agenda, Katko said he
publicized his agenda, and that was what he gave the NRCC
 Said if the ACA wasn’t addressed by the end of his term, voters should “throw
[him] out”
 Claimed “every one of my bills has a Democratic co-sponsor,” but sponsored a
bill which did not have a Democratic co-sponsor, and as of December 2015 still
does not
Kato resigned from his position in the US Attorney’s office to run for congress in
December, 2013, and announced his campaign for Congress in January 2014. The day
after announcing his run, he traveled to Washington to meet with DC interests.
Katko again traveled to DC in March 2014 after securing the Republican
endorsement. Katko campaigned against Washington, noting that “leaders” in
Washington told him it was “a narrative you have to pursue.”
Katko was part of the NRCC’s patriot program, exchanging aspects of autonomy for
NRCC funding for his 2016 campaign. The NRCC asked for Katko’s legislative
agenda and the political rationale. Katko said he previously publicized his agenda,
and that was what the NRCC received.
During the 2014 campaign, Katko criticized Maffei’s productivity, and promised
legislative results. He vowed that if the ACA wasn’t addressed by the end of his term,
“then it is time for you to throw me out.” He noted that Republicans “gotta start
78
passing laws.” And that since Republicans controlled congress, they had “no excuses”
not to get things done, or voters would judge them.
Katko falsely claimed every bill he had sponsored had a Democratic co-sponsor, his
Tax Administration Integrity Act did not have a Democratic co-sponsor. As of
December 2015, the bill still lacked a Democratic co-sponsor.
2014 Campaign
Expressed Interest in Running for Congress
In December 2013, Katko expressed interest in running for Congress against Rep. Dan Maffei in New
York’s 24th Congressional District. [Auburn Citizen, 12/07/13]
Resigned from U.S. Attorney’s Office to Run for Congress
In December 2013, Katko resigned as assistant U.S. attorney in Syracuse, but would not say why. Sources
speculated that Katko handed in his resignation to run for Congress.
Onondaga County Comptroller Robert Antonacci said he’s heard from “two credible sources who told me
that John is running for Congress.”
Katko was among at least a dozen Republicans who spoke to GOP leaders about possibly running against
Maffei for the 24th Congressional District. [Post-Standard, 12/26/13]
Katko Praised by U.S. District Judge
In January 2014, Katko received high praise on his last day as a federal prosecutor from U.S. District
Judge Norman Mordue.
“Mr. Katko, this is your last opportunity to serve as a prosecutor,” Mordue told Katko at a sentencing
hearing. “I’ve got to say, you will be missed,” Mordue said. “I think you’re one of the premier prosecutors
that I have ever had the opportunity to judge cases with.” [Post-Standard, 1/13/14]
Traveled to Washington Day After Announcing Run for Congress
In January 2014, a day after resigning as a federal prosecutor, Katko announced that he intended to run for
the Republican nomination in the 24th Congressional District.
The following Monday, Katko traveled to Washington to begin assembling his campaign team, meet with
national Republican leaders and visit with members of New York’s Republican congressional delegation.
Katko also stopped in to visit the Washington office of former Rep. James Walsh who represented the
Syracuse area in Congress for 20 years until 2008. [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Traveled to DC for Meetings with Special Interests, Republican Establishment
79
In March 2014, Katko traveled to Washington, DC “for a series of meetings with GOP leaders.” Former
Rep. James Walsh served as Katko’s guide on Capitol Hill.
Walsh introduced Katko to elected officials at a bipartisan Irish Lobby Day event. Katko also met with
senior staff at the National Republican Congressional Committee, the campaign arm of House
Republicans. A campaign spokesman said Katko did not raise any money while in town, but he attended a
series of meet-and-greets with influential Republicans and had policy briefings with a think-tank and
healthcare association.” [Post-Standard, 3/17/14]
Walsh Named a “Top Lobbyist” in 2013
In November 2013, the Post-Standard reported: “Former U.S. Rep. James Walsh, five years after
leaving Congress, has transformed himself into one of Washington’s top lobbyists, according to
one Capitol Hill publication.” [Post-Standard, 11/09/13]
Walsh Worked for K&L Gates
As of May 2014, Walsh was working as a Government Affiars Counselor for the lobbying firm
K&L Gates. [K&L Gates, accessed 5/22/14]
K&L Gates Sought to Profit from the Financial Crisis
In September 2008, Politico reported that K&L Gates were among the lobbying firms that
sought to profit off of the financial bailout. “Already, lobbyists are using the rescue plan to
drum up business from financial services companies fearing a regulatory push by Congress
and the new administration,” the paper wrote.
K&L Gates announced financial markets groups formed to represent clients in litigation,
lobbying and government enforcement efforts related to the economic crisis. [Politico,
9/30/08]
Said He Had Been Thinking About Running for Congress for Years
In January 2014, Katko said he had always had an interest in politics and considered running for the
Syracuse-area congressional seat for years.
“I always thought I would do it toward the end of my career as a prosecutor,” Katko said. [Post-Standard,
1/14/14]
Said He Decided to Run for Congress after He was Contacted by Political Backers
In January 2014, Katko said he received the final push to run for Congress when he was approached by
political backers, who asked if he would run for the 24th District seat. Katko declined to identify those
who called him.
“I couldn’t be an idle spectator any more, given the state of our leadership both federally and locally,”
Katko said, explaining why he agreed to run for the House seat.
80
“When I did that, I started getting a lot of positive feedback,” he said. “I realized now is the time to take
the shot.” [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Hired Former Walsh Staffers for Campaign
In January 2014, Katko hired two of former Rep. James Walsh former staffers – Robert T. Waters, the
longtime chairman of the Walsh for Congress campaign committee, and Dan Gage, Walsh’s former chief
of staff. [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Claimed to be Simultaneously Moderate and Conservative
In January 2014, Katko described himself as a moderate Republican who is fiscally conservative. [PostStandard, 1/14/14]
In February 2014, Katko said, “I’m a conservative, but a moderate at the same time. I have conservative
values, but moderate in that I recognize the need that you have to work with your counterparts. I
recognize that fact.” [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said His Experience as a Federal Prosecutor was Good Training to be a Congressman
In January 2014, Katko said his experience as a federal prosecutor would help him stand out from the
other four Republicans who have announced.
“The training you get as a prosecutor, I’ve learned, is the best training for this job (as a congressman),”
Katko said. “You’ve got to think on your feet, be able to resolve conflict, and you’ve got have thick skin.
I feel very comfortable doing this. Conflict is a daily part of my job.” [Post-Standard, 1/14/14]
Said He Would Stand Out in the Primary Because of Ability to Articulate the Issues
In February 2014, Katko said he would stand out from the crowd in the Republican primary
because his experience as a prosecutor prepared him to better articulate the issues.
“I think my training as a prosecutor has prepared me very well for this endeavor. As a prosecutor,
you’re an advocate by nature. You have to learn to think on your feet. You have to learn to
articulate your views,” Katko said.
“I think all of our candidates, to some extent or another, are pretty good on the issues. I think
what’s hopefully going to separate me is my ability to articulate those issues in a way that others
maybe are not able to. My training has prepared me well for this. There’s no question about it,”
Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Katko Appeared To Be a Republican Frontrunner
In February 2014, the Post-Standard reported that Katko was one of the frontrunners in a wide-open
Republican primary with eight candidates vying for the nomination.
81
Katko’s early supporters included Syracuse Republican Committeeman Danny Fitzpatrick, son of
Onondaga County District Attorney Bill Fitzpatrick, who was barred from endorsing candidates.
Katko was also invited by Cayuga County’s Republican committee to return for a second interview after
all the candidates made initial presentations, according to several sources. [Post-Standard, 2/09/14]
Katko Not Able to Self Fund
In February 2014, the Post-Standard reported that Katko would not be able to self fund, unlike one of his
opponents, Jane Rossi. [Post-Standard, 2/09/14]
Was Not Worried About Fundraising Because Republicans Would Coalesce Around Nominee
In February 2014, Katko said he was not worried about his low fundraising because Republicans would
rally behind the nominee.
“Do I see this as a big issue in the long run?” Katko said. “No. Once the Republican candidate is selected,
I think the Republican Party will coalesce behind the nominee.”
Katko said he had been gathering pledges from potential donors in advance of accepting donations. “We
have a lot of very experienced fundraisers on our staff,” Katko said. “They have all been highly successful
people in the past.” [Post-Standard, 2/11/14]
Touted Gang Task Force on Campaign Trail
In February 2014, Katko touted his role in Katko also touted his role in establishing the Syracuse Gang
Violence Task Force, which he led until his retirement.
“We put together a task force of federal, state and local law enforcement,” Katko said. “We devised a plan
on how to go after these gang members. The plan was to use the federal racketeering laws like what you
would use to dismantle organized crime - cases like the Mafia, for example - and try and use that to go
after these gangs. These gangs were nowhere near as organized, but they were still very violent and they
had a cohesiveness to them that would allow us to prosecute them. So, we did that.” [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said He Gave Up a Strong, Lucrative Career Because of Maffei’s Failed Leadership
In February 2014, Katko said Rep. Maffei’s “terrible leadership” concerned him so much that he gave up
his career to run for Congress.
“It’s not just with him. It’s with others in Washington. But he’s the one in our district and I felt compelled
enough about it to give up a very good and strong and lucrative career for this and I don’t know if
anybody else has done that,” Katko said.
“It’s not like I was at retirement age because I’m not. I’m doing this on my own. I don’t regret it for a
second because I think it’s very important to stand up for things when you’re very concerned […] I’m
giving up more than anybody to do this, but I feel that strongly about it,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen,
2/18/14]
82
Katko: “I’m Not Sure What [Maffei’s] Done”
In February 2014, Katko said he was not sure what Maffei’s record was. “The honest assessment of the
job he’s done is I’m not sure what he’s done. The only thing I know he’s done is trumpeted and supported
supposed landmark legislation on health care and then turning around and trying to repeal the very
portions of the bill he passed. To me, that is a perfect snapshot of failed leadership on his part,” Katko
said.
“And I don’t think he’s brought much back for our district. He just hasn’t,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen,
2/18/14]
Said Having a Minority Member as Representative was Bad for the District
In February 2014, Katko said,” The reality part of it is the fact that [Rep. Maffei is] in the Democratic
minority in the House and that’s not going to change. Having a minority member in the House is not good
for your district.”
“It’s not good to try and get programs and services for your district when you’re in the minority. He
hasn’t really done a good job reaching across the aisle to the other side. He’s been more divisive than he
has been productive in my mind,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said Republicans and Democrats Need to Work Together
In February 2014, Katko said, “I recognize the need that you have to work with your counterparts. I
recognize that fact. Members of Congress have failed miserably with that lately.”
“It’s so divisive that Democrats and Republicans rarely work together. They need to. They need to
address the major issues. They need to address the deficit together. They need to address the entitlement
programs without using scare tactics like saying we’re out to destroy Medicaid, Medicare and Social
Security. We’re not,” Katko continued.
“We’re here to fix it to make sure that not only we have it, that our kids have it and our children’s
children have it. In the current state, it’s not going to happen. We’ve got to be fiscally responsible and I
think everyone can agree that we have to be fiscally responsible,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said He Would Not Attempt to Get on the Ballot if he Was Not Endorsed by the Party
In February 2014, Katko said he would not attempt to get on the ballot for the Republican primary in June
if he was not endorsed by the party.
“No, and I think that’s critical for our party to unite behind whomever the candidate is that’s selected.
While I’ve made a personal sacrifice to get into this campaign, I will still honor the committee’s decision
and I will rally behind whoever it is if it’s not me,” Katko said.
83
“I’m hoping it’s me, but if it’s not me, I will rally behind whoever it is because I think the issues are that
important we need to be a united team on the Republican and Conservative side,” Katko said. [Auburn
Citizen, 2/18/14]
Endorsed by Fulton Republicans
In February 2014, Katko was endorsed by the Republican Committee in Fulton, a city in Oswego County.
“Republicans have a great slate of candidates, but the committee felt that the best candidate by far was
Katko,” Fulton Republican Chairman Mark Aldasch Sr. said in a statement. “I am pleased with the
committee’s choice. I believe John Katko is the best and strongest choice for the city of Fulton, the county
of Oswego and the entire 24th District.” [Auburn Citizen, 2/19/14]
Criticized Rep. Maffei for Lack of Town Hall Meetings
In February 2014 in an op-ed piece published in the Post-Standard, Katko criticized Rep. Maffei for his
lack of town halls.
“When Dan Maffei first ran for Congress in 2006, he criticized the then-incumbent for not holding
enough live and in-person town hall meetings or public forums with free and open exchanges between
him and his electorate. Eight years later, Congressman Dan Maffei holds his own weak record regarding
open meetings,” Katko wrote.
“To distract from that fact, Maffei has mailed out surveys at taxpayer expense and conducted closed-door
‘listening tour’ events on a variety of issues. Earlier this month, he announced the need for another formal
advisory panel (this time for agriculture). And Tuesday, Maffei held his first invitation-only ‘study
session’ to brainstorm creative plans on digging up Interstate 81 through downtown Syracuse,” Katko
Said He was More Concerned about the Job Security of Constituents than His Own
In February 2014 in an op-ed piece published in the Post-Standard, Katko wrote, “It’s time that Central
New York has a congressman who is worried more about your job security than his own. I will be that
congressman.” [Katko Op-ed, Post-Standard, 2/23/14]
Attended Central New York Conservatives Candidate Forum
In February 2014, Katko attended a candidate forum hosted by Central New York Conservatives, Inc.
Katko Dropped in Straw Poll after Candidate Forum
In February 2014, Katko placed fourth in a post-candidate straw poll, with 14 first place votes. Katko fell
three places after he had won the pre-forum straw poll. [Auburn Citizen, 2/28/14]
Was the Favorite Going into GOP Nominating Convention
84
In February 2014, Katko was the favorite of eight candidates going into the Central New York Republican
nominating convention.
“I think it’s safe to say he’s the favorite going into Saturday,” Onondaga County Legislature Chairman
Ryan McMahon said. “I haven’t heard of anyone who is an elected official supporting anyone other than
Katko.”
Michael Backus, chairman of the Oswego County Republican Committee, said that it was clear to him
where his committee members stood. “I really think this race comes down to two candidates for the
nomination - John Katko and John Lemondes,” Backus said. “They clearly have been the favorites of my
committee members” [Post Standard, 2/27/14]
Katko Won Republican Nomination
In March 2014, Katko won the Republican nomination with an overwhelming majority of the vote. There
were 129,095 weighted votes cast in the first round and Katko received more than the 64,548 weighted
votes needed to avoid a runoff.
Conservative Party leaders said they support Katko because of his “excellent qualifications.”
“Mr. Katko aligns with our conservative principles philosophically and understands the significance of
this election,” said Chuck Mancabelli, chairman of the Onondaga County Conservative Party. “Mr. Katko
has a strong command of the issues and more importantly, an ability to connect with the voters during the
campaign. This is a key element for any candidate to be credible in today’s political climate.” [Auburn
Citizen, 3/01/14, 3/04/14]
Said He Looked Forward to Pushing Forward Conservative Agenda
In March 2014, Katko said he was looking forward to pushing the conservative agenda of the Central
New York Republican party.
“I am proud to have received the endorsement of the Cayuga, Onondaga, Oswego and Wayne County
Conservative parties and look forward to carrying their business-friendly, controlled spending, reduced
taxes and pro-Second Amendment platform to voters this fall,” Katko said. “With their support, help and
enthusiasm, we will restore the 24th District seat back to Central New York voters.” [Auburn Citizen, 3/04/14]
Katko Would Uphold Radical Conservative Party Platform
The Conservative Party platform called for racial profiling by police, banning same-sex marriage,
carrying out the death penalty, banning abortions except to save the mother’s life, permitting
hydrofracking, and adopting a flat income tax. [Post-Standard, 3/09/14]
Said He Was Going to Shift Focus to Unseating Maffei
In March 2014, Katko said after winning at the Republican convention, his focus should shift to unseating
Rep. Maffei. Katko was hopeful that the other Republicans who were seeking the party’s support will
back his candidacy.
85
“It’s time to take the fight to Mr. Maffei,” Katko said in a speech. “We’re going to fight every minute of
every day until that election in November and I ask and I hope and I pray that my colleagues that I’ve
worked with over the last several weeks that were up for this election with me will be with me.” [Auburn
Citizen, 3/01/14]
Said He Had a “Huge Fundraising Committee”
In March 2014, Katko said, “We’ve got a huge fundraising committee. We’re ready to go,” he said.
“Getting our committee together. We’re ready to go with that. And getting petitions together and starting
to get our message out there.” [Auburn Citizen, 3/01/14]
Said Former Rep. Ann Marie Buerkle “Planted the Seed” for His run for Congress
In March 2014, Katko appeared on former Congresswoman Ann Marie Buerkle’s radio show and when
asked why he was running for Congress, Katko confirmed that had had a conversation with Buerkle “who
planted the seed” to get him to run. [The Ann Marie Buerkle Show – WSYR 570, 3/08/14]
Endorsed by Wayne County Board of Supervisors
In March 2014, Katko was endorsed by the Wayne County Board of Supervisors. “John Katko is the
representative Wayne County needs to make Washington work for us again,” said Board Chairman and
Williamson Town Supervisor James Hoffman. “John’s spent his entire professional life as a federal
prosecutor fighting to make our community safer and more secure for all Central New York families.
He’ll continue that fight on our behalf in Congress.”
“We support John Katko in this race because jobs and improving the economy will always be John’s
priorities,” said Majority Leader and Palmyra Supervisor Ken Miller. “He understands the importance of
low taxes and limited government. He knows Upstate families are hurting. And he recognizes that certain
decisions - like those concerning our children’s education - are best made here at the local level. John will
go to work for us in Washington; he won’t become Washington.” [Wayne Post, 3/26/14]
Katko Estimated to Raise $100,000 in First Month of Fundraising
In April 2014, Katko said he expected to meet or exceed his goal of taking in $100,000 in his first month
of fundraising.
However, Katko’s campaign did not start accepting online donations until three days before the Federal
Election Commission’s first quarter deadline. Katko’s campaign included a golden dollar sign on his
Facebook page to encourage donations. [Post-Standard, 4/01/14; John Katko for Congress e-mail, 3/28/14]
86
[John Katko for Congress Facebook, accessed 4/04/14]
Katko Named “On the Radar” Candidate by NRCC
In April 2014, the National Republican Congressional Committee added Katko to "On the Radar" status,
the first of three tiers for its "Young Guns" program.
“It's a very positive development,” Katko said. “If I can raise a substantial amount of money this quarter, I
think we'll have a lot of support” from the NRCC. [Post-Standard, 4/17/14]
Keynote Speakers at Palmyra Republican Committee 17th Annual Gala
In March 2014, Katko was the keynote speaker at the Palmyra Republican Committee’s 17th annual gala.
[Wayne Post, 4/11/14]
Maffei’s Lawyer Said Onondaga Republican Lawsuit was a Stunt by Katko
In April 2014, Onondaga County Republican Chairman Tom Dadey has filed a lawsuit in state Supreme
Court seeking to have Rep. Dan Maffei thrown off the Working Families Party ballot line.
Dadey said that local Republican Party leaders are challenging the legal residency of Maffei's campaign
manager, Kane Miller, who gathered 117 of the 177 signatures on the WFP petitions. “We're questioning
whether he's a duly registered voter in Onondaga County,” Dadey said. "Our contention is that he's just
here temporarily and intends to go back to Georgia after the election."
“This is nothing more than a political stunt by John Katko and his Tea Party allies to distract Central New
Yorkers from the fact that Katko won't take a position on tough issues and doesn't have a plan to create
jobs in Central New York,” said Frank Hoare, the attorney representing the Maffei campaign. [PostStandard, 4/17/14]
87
Said Congress is too Polarized, All Constituents Must be Represented
In April 2014, when asked what the problems in Congress were Katko said, “Congress is far too
polarized. Unless the individual members learn this, there will be no improvement.”
“Once elected, a senator or congress member must represent all members of his/her district. Compromises
can be made without sacrificing principles,” Katko said. “Life isn’t all or nothing, and government does
not represent the people if the legislature believes otherwise. We can find common ground, just as Tip
O’Neil and Ronald Reagan did.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Katko Attended Fair Haven Ceremony with Former Rep. Jim Walsh
In April 2014, Katko attended a ceremony celebrating the completion of a major sewer project in Fair
Haven with former Rep. Jim Walsh. Wash was honored at the ceremony and mentioned Katko in his
speech twice.
The Auburn Citizen wrote, “If you're a Republican running for Congress in central New York, it's not a
bad thing to get a shout-out from Walsh, who represented the Syracuse area in the House of
Representatives for 20 years.” [Auburn Citizen, 4/15/14]
Proposed Issue Focused Debates in Response to Maffei’s Proposal to Reject PAC Money
In April 2014, Katko proposed a series of issues-focused public debates with Rep. Dan Maffei in response
to a proposal by Maffei that the two candidates sign a pledge to reject “dark money” from political groups
and super PACs that do not disclose their donors.
“Debates could be hosted by independent, nonpartisan organizations in each county with rules and
moderators agreed to by both candidates,” Katko wrote in his response to Maffei. “The creation of a
healthy series of public exchanges will surely encourage the ‘clean campaign’ you now pledge to run,”
Katko wrote. [Post-Standard, 4/25/14]
Maffei Agreed to Debates
In April 2014, Maffei agreed to Katko’s proposal to host a series of debates. [Post-Standard,
4/25/14]
…But Declined Invitation from Grant Reeher
In May 2014, Katko said he had accepted an invitation from Grant Reeher, a political
science professor at Syracuse University and director of the Campbell Public Affairs
Institute, to appear on WRVO's "Campbell Conversations" scheduled for May 25. But
according to Katko's campaign, Maffei, D-Syracuse, declined the invite.
Katko said he also accepted debate invitations from WSYR-TV, Time Warner Cable
News, and Cayuga Community College to be held later in the year. [Auburn Citizen,
5/08/14]
88
…And Katko Slammed Maffei for Not Accepting Debate Invitation
In May 2014, Katko slammed Maffei for not accepting Reeher’s invitation to debate and
avoiding public discussion of the issues.
The same line of attack was made against Maffei in 2012 by Ann Marie Buerkle’s
campaign when he turned down two debates. [Auburn Citizen, 5/08/14]
Katko Yet to Engage with Voters on the Issues
In April 2014, Mark English, Chair of the Onondaga County Democratic Committee, wrote a
letter to the editor published in the Post-Standard criticizing Katko for not hosing any public
events where voters can engage with him on issues.
“Perhaps he simply isn't willing to share his positions on the Ryan Budget and other Tea Party
priorities with the voters,” English wrote.
“How can John Katko expect people in Central New York to vote for him if he's not willing to
take positions on issue that affect everyone in our communities?” English asked. “How can he
claim to want to represent this district when he seems more concerned with seeking
acknowledgment from the national party than actually meeting with members of the public?”
[Post-Standard, Mark English LTE, 4/30/14]
Katko Refused to Take Position on the Ryan Budget
In May 2014, Katko refused to take a position on the Ryan budget in an interview with the Auburn
Citizen. Katko said he was not familiar with all the details of the legislation and would not take an
opinion on something that was “basically a working paper” unless elected to Congress.
“I will confess that I haven't read the entire thing and I'm not familiar with all the contours of it. Unless
and until I get into Congress, I'm not going to start issuing opinions on something that is basically a
working paper. The general concepts to me are what I've just discussed. That is reducing the debt and
having responsible government spending. I don't care whose budget it is or what name is on the budget,
that's what I'm concerned about,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 5/15/14]
Katko Planned “Listening Sessions” Across the District
In May 2014, Katko announced that he would meet with voters in a series of public “listening sessions.”
"I want to take this opportunity to introduce myself to the Central New York community and to hear
directly from the residents and families of the 24th Congressional District about the specific issues
impacting their day-to-day lives," Katko said in a statement.
He added, "The best way to understand and represent the personal concerns of Central New York in
Congress is to have an open conversation with the people who live here." [Auburn Citizen, 5/16/14]
89
Said He Was A “Fiscal Conservative” And “Basically A Social Conservative”
Said He Was A “Fiscal Conservative,” And “Basically A Social Conservative.” “JK: I don’t want to
give myself a label. I am a fiscal conservative. I think I am basically a social conservative, but I am also a
pragmatist.” [Interview, Syracuse New Times, 5/28/14]
NRCC Named Katko a “Young Gun”
In July 2014, the National Republican Congressional Committee elevated John Katko to the “top tier” of
their recruitment program called the “Young Guns.” [NRCC Press Release, 7/08/14]
Katko: “I Don’t Know if I Consider Myself a Moderate”
In July 2014, when asked by TWC News’ Liz Benjamin if he would consider himself a “moderate” who
would take a more “pragmatic approach,” Katko responded by saying “I don’t know if I consider myself a
moderate. I don’t know about labels.” [TWC News “Capital Tonight”, 7/3/14]
Katko Wouldn’t Say Whether He Would Support Boehner for Speaker
In July 2014, When asked by TWC News’ Liz Benjamin on “Capital Tonight” whether he would support
John Boehner’s continued leadership, Katko responded “I don’t know until I get there. I hope I have the
chance when I get there to make that decision. But right now it’s still up in the air.” [TWC News “Capital
Tonight”, 7/3/14]
Katko Said “I Don’t Know” a Total of Seven Times During an 11 Minute Interview
In July 2014, over the course of his 11 minute interview with TWC News’ Liz Benjamin on “Capital
Tonight”, Katko said “I don’t know” a total of seven times. [TWC News “Capital Tonight”, 7/3/14]
Said He’s Not Interested in Labels, but Described Himself as a Conservative
In July 2014, Katko said in an interview with the Post-Standard that he was “not interested in doing the
labels,” but then went on to say “I’m very interested in everyone understanding that I’m a fiscal
conservative.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Congress
Congress. Host: You mentioned a few minutes ago that part of the problem are Republicans. That might
not endear you to Republicans who might not have opened up their wallets. But I mean, its, I don’t know
how to phrase it. Do you find that that level of honesty and openness on the campaign trail, do you think
that will translate if you win, will you be as honest about both sides of the system as you have been on the
campaign trail? Katko: Yes, and you know what, the people in Washington get it too. Believe it or not, I
was just down there last week, and the leadership is saying the same thing. They’re saying look, that is a
narrative you have to pursue. They understand it, they understand the perception. It’s not as one sided, it
is absolutely not as one sided. I’ll give you an example, I mean everyone is talking about the house
90
republicans, well the House has sent three hundred twenty one bills over to the Senate. three hundred
twenty one bills that are sitting there and haven’t been acted upon in this term alone. So, and that’s a
Democratically controlled Senate. Nothing’s going on over there either. So, it’s both sides, and they
recognize it too. They recognize its gotta get better, y’know. And so, to answer your question, I don’t
know. I don’t think so. I think people are sick and tired of the sniping and want people that are going to be
pragmatic and go down and get things done. [Finger Lakes Morning News Interview, 7/31/14]
Boehner, McCarthy, Walden And Westmoreland Raised Funds For Katko
Boehner Raised Funds For Katko. “When Katko first ran for Congress in 2014, Boehner visited central
New York and was the special guest at a fundraiser for the GOP challenger. After Katko won the 24th
Congressional District race and was sworn into office, Boehner continued to support him. Just last month,
the House speaker made another trip to central New York to headline a fundraiser for Katko’s re-election
campaign.” [The Citizen, 9/26/14]
Said He Had No Problems With Boehner. “‘As far as Boehner goes, I can only say that the guy
works very, very hard for everyone else,’ he said in an August interview. ‘He’s tireless at raising
funds and trying to promote and assist the young congressmen and women across the country and
he works tirelessly for that. I don’t have any problems with him.’” [The Citizen, 9/26/14]
Refused To Say If He’d Support Boehner For Speaker. “Katko said in an interview Monday
that he viewed the fundraiser as a good opportunity for Boehner, R-Ohio, to get to know him
better and a chance to better assess the current speaker of the House. ‘This is an opportunity for
me to evaluate him, because if I get elected, it’s the representatives that are going to elect the
speaker,’ Katko said. ‘By no means have I settled on one individual yet. But I’m going to
definitely evaluate him as I get to know him more. This is part of that evaluation process.’” [The
Citizen, 9/23/14]
McCarthy Raised Funds For Katko. “House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy visited Auburn in
October 2014 to headline a fundraiser for U.S. Rep. John Katko, who was a Republican challenger at the
time.” [The Citizen, 9/26/14]
Rep. Walden, Rep. Westmoreland Made Visits To Help Katko. “NRCC Chairman Greg Walden, who
made a stop in Syracuse in September to support Katko, and U.S. Rep. Lynn Westmoreland, deputy chair
of the NRCC, will attend a get out the vote rally at 6 p.m. Thursday at the local GOP’s Victory Center,
2910 Erie Blvd. East, Syracuse.” [The Citizen, 10/28/14]
Attacked Maffei For Where His Daughter Was Born, And Where His Wife Worked
Criticized Where Maffei’s Daughter Was Born. “New York Republican John Katko says there’s no
doubt that two-term Democratic Rep. Dan Maffei has gone Wash-ington. The proof: Maffei’s wife, Abby,
delivered the couple’s first child, Maya, at a Washington hospital this past summer, not in the central New
York district that includes Syracuse. … Katko said Maya’s birth was fair game because Maffei announced
it during the summer and mentioned the hospital.” [AP, 11/03/14]
91
Criticized Maffei For Where His Wife Worked, And Where His Daughter Was Born. “‘He’ll tell
you he lives here, but here’s the deal, his wife lives and works in Washington, D.C. That’s where her job
is,’ Katko said, according to the Citizen report. ‘He just had his first child in Sibley Hospital (in
Washington), which I con-gratulate him on. But the fact of the matter is the child was born there. He
bought a $700,000 house there. He’s got a much less expensive house here. And the fact of the matter is
he’s in D.C. He’s a D.C. person.” [Post Standard, 8/21/14]
Agreed To Participate In Debates In 2016
2014: Katko Agreed To Participate In Debates In 2016. “As a sign of what is to come, Katko agreed,
during the campaign, to participate in debates, including in Cayuga County, if elected, during 2016.” [The
Citizen, 11/07/14]
Said Trackers Recording Public Events Were Invading His Privacy, Discussed The Appearance
And Tactics Of Multiple Trackers
Said Trackers Recording His Remarks At Public Events Was An Invasion Of Privacy. “Katko said
his own family has put up with an invasion of privacy from Maffei campaign staffers who record them on
video at public events. ‘If you want to talk about family being off limits ... we’ve suffered far more
invasions of our privacy and we’re not complaining about it,’ Katko said.” [Post Standard, 8/21/14]
Criticized Maffei For Sending A Tracker To A Public Event, Suggested Reasons Why. “John Katko
for Congress Dan Maffei didn't attend my Listening Session last night, but he sent a staffer who did and
taped the whole thing. He didn't smile much... must be angry or worried or something. I suspect it was
taped for the incumbent for one of the following reasons: 1) Dan Maffei lives in suburban Virginia and
needs all the help he can get understanding what the concerns of CNY really are, 2) Dan Maffei is
dodging debates and joint candidate forums with me until he can better assess my public speaking skills
and platform, or 3) Dan Maffei is planning to tape and twist my own words to use them out of context in a
barrage of negative ads. Or maybe it's a combination of all three. What do you think? Please post your
thoughts below...” [Katko For Congress, Facebook, 5/23/14]
Criticized Maffei For Sending A Tracker To An Event. “Talk about crashing a party... Dan Maffei
didn't crash our HQ opening party last night, but he sent a campaign staffer with a video camera to do so.
Don't worry if you couldn't attend in person, I'm sure footage of our great event will show up on one of
his negative TV ads in the near future. Maybe I can debate these guys he sends after me since Dan Maffei
keeps dodging my one-on-one debate offers...”[Katko For Congress, Facebook, 6/06/14]
Noted The Appearance Of A Tracker, And That She Supported Obama. “We welcome my
opponent's newest tracker to the Katko campaign. She followed me all around downtown today and
apparently likes to display her support for President Obama while she works...” [Katko For Congress,
Facebook, 9/09/14]
Noted A Tracker Followed Him At A Veterans’ Event, But Didn’t Follow Him Into The Men’s
Room. “Spent a good portion of my day at the Fair with veterans activities. As usual, my opposition had
their tracker with a video camera follow me everywhere...except into the Men's Room. He courteously
waited outside for me...” [Katko For Congress, Facebook, 9/28/14]
92
Receieved The Endorsements Of Police Organizaitons
Received The Endorsements Of Police Organizations. “The Syracuse Police Benevolent Association,
Onondaga County Deputy Sheriffs’ Police Association and the Police Be-nevolent Association of the
New York State Troopers endorsed Katko at a news conference in Syracuse. In addition, the National
Association of Police Organizations and Upstate New York Police Benevolent Association said they are
backing Katko, a former federal prosecutor from Camillus.” [Post Standard, 10/21/14]
NRA Endorsed Katko
NRA Endorsed Katko. “The National Rife Association ‘s political arm is urging members to support
Republican congressional candidate John Katko in his bid to unseat U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei.” [The Citizen,
10/16/14]
City Official Switched Parties And Endorsed Katko
City Official Switched Parties, Endorsed Katko. “Eric Van Buren, vice president of the Oswego City
Council and a former chairman of the city ‘s Democratic committee, is changing parties and his vote in
the 24th Congressional District race. Oswego County Republican Chairman Michael Backus announced
Wednesday that Van Buren has joined the Republican Party and endorsed Republican congressional
candidate John Katko.” [The Citizen, 10/09/14]
Called On Maffei To Rebuke Wasserman-Shultz For Comments
September 5, 2014: Called On Maffei To Rebuke Wasserman-Schultz For Comments. “Republican
congressional candidate John Katko is calling on U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei to denounce comments made by
Democratic National Committee Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz about Wisconsin Gov. Scott
Walker’s posi-tions on women’s issues. … Katko, R-Camillus, said domestic violence ‘is not a joke’ and
shouldn’t be used ‘in an effort to score cheap political points.’ ‘Dan Maffei should immediately denounce
Ms. Wasserman Schultz’s alarming and offensive comments and suspend this practice of using domestic
violence victims as political pawns in their recycled ‘war on women’ message that at-tempts to
inaccurately define and slander those with whom they disagree politically,’ Katko said.” [The Citizen,
9/05/14]
September 4, 2014: Rep. Wasserman-Shultz Apologized For Her Comments Comparing
Gov. Walker’s Record On Women’s Issues To Domestic Violence. “A day after sparking
national headlines for using inflammatory language on Gov. Scott Walker's record on women's
issues, Democratic National Committee Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz retreated from her harsh
rhetoric in a statement issued Thursday. Wasserman Schultz used domestic violence language to
critique Walker's record. ‘I shouldn't have used the words I used,’ Wasserman Schultz said. ‘But
that shouldn't detract from the broader point that I was making that Scott Walker's policies have
been bad for Wisconsin women, whether it's mandating ultrasounds, repealing an equal pay law,
or rejecting federal funding for preventative health care, Walker's record speaks for itself.’ During
a women's roundtable event in Milwaukee on Wednesday, the Florida congresswoman said: ‘Scott
Walker has given women the back of his hand. I know that is stark. I know that is direct. But that
93
is reality.’ She added: ‘What Republican tea party extremists like Scott Walker are doing is they
are grabbing us by the hair and pulling us back. It is not going to happen on our watch.’”
[Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, 9/04/14]
Post-2014 Election
Said The Turning Point Of His Campaign Was A Trip To Washington, The Commitment Of
NRCC Money
Said The Turning Point Of His Campaign Was A Trip To Washington. “As for turning points in the
campaign, Katko looked back to Sept. 22. A Post-Standard/syracuse.com/Siena poll released the day
before had shown him down by only 8 percentage points. He went to Washington to accept an award for
his work as a federal prosecutor - a moment that put him in front of Democratic Attorney General Eric
Holder. The same day, he said, he found out the National Republican Congressional Committee would
commit money to his race. That would give him enough of a boost to compete with Maffei on television
and boost his name recognition.” [Post Standard, 11/06/14]
Said His Priorities Were The Judiciary And Financial Services Committees
Said His Priorities Were The Judiciary And Financial Services Committees. “Katko said his top
priorities are the Judiciary Committee and the Financial Services Committee. Both already have
Democratic members from New York.” [Gannett, 11/07/14]
Embraced By Leadership, Received “Rare Honor” Of Being Named Subcommittee Chair, Called
Rising Star
Received “Rare Honor” Being Named Chairman Of A Subcommittee. “Katko, whose congressional
district includes Wayne County, received a rare honor for a freshman on Monday when he was named
chairman of the Homeland Security Subcommittee on Transportation Security. The post will call on his
experience prosecuting drug trafficking and organized crime cases.” [Rochester Democrat and Chronicle,
1/16/15]
Republican Operative: Katko A Rising Star. “Ian Prior, a spokesman for the National Republican
Congressional Committee, offered a different view. ‘In just five months, John Katko has established
himself as a rising star in Congress who will work in a bipartisan manner to deliver for Central New
York,’ Prior said in an email.” [The Citizen, 5/08/15]
Ceremonially Retook His Oath Of Office In District
Ceremonially Retook His Oath Of Office In District. “Rep. John Katko has already been sworn into
office, but he decided to take the oath again in his hometown in front of friends, supporters and most
importantly, his parents.” [The Citizen, 1/24/15]
Chair Of The Fulton Republican Committee Said He Was Disgusted With Katko For Sitting With
Democrats, Voting For Boehner, And Voting To Keep Obamacare
94
Chair Of The Fulton Republican Committee Said He Was Disgusted With Katko. “My name is Marc
Holliday (formerly known as Mark Aldasch). I am the chairman of the City of Fulton Republican
Committee. Last year the Fulton Republican Committee was the first and only committee to
independently endorse John Katko for Congress. … It has now been almost three months since Katko
took his seat in Congress. I, like many, are disgusted by how he has voted and held himself in Congress.
Katko has completely abandoned his base and has ignored the voice of the people who put him where he
is.” [Post Standard, Marc Holliday LTE, 4/02/15]
Chair Of The Fulton Republican Committee Criticized Katko For Sitting With Democrats,
Voting For Boehner, Voting To Keep Obamacare, Voting To Keep “Illegals” Here, And Other
Unspecified Liberal Votes. “Katko is a Republican, or did he forget that? Yet he sat with the
Democrats during the State of the Union, he voted to keep RINO John Boehner as speaker of the
house, he voted to keep Obamacare, he voted to keep illegals here, and voted yes to a whole list of
other liberal agendas.” [Post Standard, Marc Holliday LTE, 4/02/15]
Said Obama Was Not A Good Candidate, Didn’t Know How To Make A Deal
Said Obama Was Not A Good President, Didn’t Know How To Make A Deal. “One concern
mentioned by those on both sides of the aisle is giving President Barack Obama too much power by
granting him ‘fast-track’ authority. … Katko said giving Obama that power is a concern. ‘I think that's not
a good thing on trade deals,’ he said. ‘Quite frankly, if you have a good president, it's OK. But if you have
a president like we have now who doesn't know how to make a deal, that's not a good thing.’” [The
Citizen, 4/29/15]
Attended The Pope’s Speech To Congress, Said It Was One Of His Greatest Experiences
Attended The Pope’s Speech To Congress, Said It Was One Of His Greatest Experiences. “Katko,
R-Camillus, was in attendance for Pope Francis’ historic speech at the U.S. Capitol. It was the first time a
pontiff has addressed a joint session of Congress. … When asked where it ranks among the his top
personal and professional moments, Katko said it was ‘probably one of the greatest experiences of my
life.’” [The Citizen, 9/25/15]
Was Among Those Who Agreed To Privately Share Their Legislative Strategy With The NRCC;
Claimed He Submitted A Plan He Had Made Public
Was Among Those Who Agreed To Privately Share Their Legislative Strategy With The NRCC.
“U.S. Reps. John Katko and Elise Stefanik are among nearly two dozen House members who agreed to
privately share their legislative strategy with a Republican political group supporting their re-election,
according to a Washington Post report. Katko, R-Camillus, and Stefanik, R-Willsboro, are House
freshmen enrolled in the National Republican Congressional Committee's Patriot Program, which
provides financial and campaign support for vulnerable incumbents.” [Post Standard, 9/09/15]
Washington Post: NRCC MOU “Offers A Window Into How Much Autonomy Lawmakers
Often Must Forfeit To Unelected Washington Insiders. “The closely-held document offers a
window into how much autonomy lawmakers often must forfeit to unelected Washington
insiders.” [Washington Post, Sept. 2015]
95
Confirmed He Submitted His Legislative Plan To The NRCC, But Said It Was The Same Plan
Made Public In February. “Erin O'Connor, speaking for Katko, confirmed he agreed to submit his
legislative plan to the NRCC. But she said it's the same plan – an 11-point agenda -- that Katko first made
public in February.” [Post Standard, 9/09/15]
As Of January 2015, Had Voted 81.0 Percent Of The Time With His Party
CQ: Voted With His Party 81.0 Percent Of The Time. According to Congressional Quarterly, Katko
had voted with his party 81.0 percent of the time through April 21, 2016. [CQ.com, accessed 4/21/16]
Liberal Group Filed Ethics Complaint Over Katko’s Agreement With The NRCC
Liberal Group Filed Ethics Complaint Over Katko’s Agreement With The NRCC. “A liberal group
has filed a House ethics complaint against U.S. Reps. John Katko, Elise Stefanik and 21 other
Republicans, alleging they violated House ethics rules in order to obtain financial support for the 2016
election. … Katko, R-Camillus, and Stefanik, R-Willsboro, joined fellow New York Reps. Lee Zeldin, RLong Island, and Daniel Donovan, R-Staten Island, in signing the agreement with the National
Republican Congressional Committee, the political group set up to support House Republicans.” [Post
Standard, 10/15/15]
Falsely Called Deacon A “Capitol Hill Staffer” When She Worked “Throughout Central New
York”
Falsely Called Deacon A “Capitol Hill Staffer” When She Worked “Throughout Central New
York.” “Katko, R-Camillus, sent an email to his campaign list Sunday informing his supporters of
Deacon’s entry into the race. ‘It’s now clear the Beltway Democrat Party bosses plan to throw the gauntlet
at me, and launch another phony war on women and families campaign next fall,’ Katko wrote. In the
email, Katko refers to Deacon as a ‘top Democrat political operative’ and a ‘Capitol Hill staffer.’ Deacon
actually never worked in Washington for Gillibrand. She worked out of Gillibrand’s Syracuse office and
often represented the senator at events in Auburn and throughout central New York.” [The Citizen,
10/06/15]
Rhetoric On Legislative Production
October 2015: Sponsored Two Bills Signed Into Law, Was The Only Freshman To Do So.
Sponsored Two Bills Signed Into Law, Was The Only Freshman To Do So.
“For the second time in a week, a bill sponsored by U.S. Rep. John Katko has been signed by President
Barack Obama. … This is the second Katko-sponsored bill to be approved by Congress and signed by
President Obama. In the 114th Congress, he is the only freshman member who has had two bills signed
into law.” [The Citizen, 10/02/15]
Congress They Had “No Excuses” Not To Get Things Done, Or Voters Would Judge Them
96
Speaking to reporters the morning after his election, Katko stated, “I am not going to take part in
extremism. Its just not going to happen. And if they think I am they’ll be sorely disappointed. I think that
Republicans have, we have both houses now. We have no more excuses. Right? We have no more
years, people are going to say, ‘you had the House and the Senate, what have you got done?’ Y’know, and
we’ve gotta get some things done.” [Post Standard, 11//05/14]
Defined Changing Washington As Productively Passing Laws; Said Republicans “Gotta Start
Passing Laws.”
Defined Changing Washington As Productively Passing Laws. KATKO: I think it’s going to be very
easy to because ‘change Washington’ means you get something done and be pro-ductive, which they
haven’t been. We have no excuses now. We control the House. We control the Senate. We’ve gotta start
passing laws. [Interview, The Citizen, 12/02/14]
Said It Was Not Leadership To Vote For A Bill And Look To Repeal Parts Of That BIll
Said It Was Not Leadership To Vote For A Bill, And Look To Repeal Parts Of That Bill. “KATKO:
… How do you vote for a bill and then immediately start looking for ways to repeal major portions of it?
That’s not lead-ership. That’s running from leadership.” [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/14]
Said Just Introducing A Bill Was Not Leadership Nor An Accomplishment
Said Just Introducing A Bill Was Not Leadership, Was Not An Accomplishment. “‘If I introduce a
bill and have zero co-sponsors and know it’s going nowhere, you can’t use that to tout that you were
doing something in Congress,’ Katko said. ‘That’s not doing anything. That’s not leadership. Anybody
can introduce a bill at any time, OK. But when you introduce a bill and then use those bills to show that
you’re a crusader or show that you’re working for the middle class, that is as hollow as hollow can be.
That’s not right.’” [Post Standard, 10/07/14]
Said He Expected Voters To Oust Him If He Failed To Secure Enough Support To Get His Bills To
Become Law
Said He Expected Voters To Oust Him If He Failed To Secure Enough Support To Get His Bills To
Become Law. “Katko said if he were serving in Congress, introduced measures and failed to secure
enough support for the bills to become law, he would expect his constituents to vote him out of office.”
[The Citizen, 10/07/14]
Said Voters Should Oust Him If He Didn’t Have A Better Record At Passing Laws Than Maffei
After Two Years, But Backed Off That Statement
Said If He Didn’t Have A Better Record Than Maffei After Two Years, People Should Vote Against
Him. “Congressman-elect John Katko made a bold assertion as he campaigned for Democratic Rep. Dan
97
Maffei’s seat this year: If he didn’t have a better record than Maffei after two years, voters shouldn’t reelect him. The context for his statement was that Maffei hadn’t introduced any legislation that had been
signed into law. ‘If I have a similar record in two years, time to get me out,’ Katko said two weeks ago.
‘It’s called real accountability. There’s only so many measurables you can have. This is one of the
measurables. What would I have done differently? I would have worked across the aisle better.’” [USA
Today, 11/07/14]
… But Backed Off His Statements Suggesting He Would Author Laws In His First Term.
“On Friday, Katko seemed to equivocate, saying his statement shouldn’t be interpreted as a pledge
to author legislation that becomes law during his first term. He said he meant he would finish the
term with some concrete successes. ‘Part of that would be bills, but it would be the overall
package things,’ he said.” [USA Today, 11/07/14]
Said That If The ACA Wasn’t Fixed In His Term, “Then It Is Time For You To Throw Me Out.”
Said That If The Affordable Care Act Isn’t ‘Fixed’ In His Term, “Then It Is Time For You To
Throw Me Out.” “GR: A question now about the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare. Mr. Katko, you
brought this up a little while ago, and this question is for you. It’s extremely unlikely that there will be
any chance of a significant revision of this legisla-tion during what would be your first term in Congress.
So why then is changing this law an apparent pillar of your campaign? JK: We could never account in its
mediocrity, we could never account in its bad bills. It has to be addressed, and if two years from now I
would come back to you and nothing’s done, then it is time for you to throw me out. We have to start
working on these types of things. We can’t accept ... your premise is what’s wrong with Washington.
When you sit there and say it is extremely unlikely.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse New Times, 10/29/14]
Attacked Maffei For Failing To Enact Bills Into Law, Said If He Failed To Secure Enough Support
For Bills To Become Law, He Expected To Be Voted Out Of Office. “Katko, R-Camillus, held a press
conference Monday at his campaign headquarters in Syracuse to highlight what he views as Maffei's
failure to advance any of the 13 bills he's introduced during his second term in the House of
Representatives. … Katko said if he were serving in Congress, introduced measures and failed to secure
enough support for the bills to become law, he would expect his constituents to vote him out of office.
‘(Maffei's) been in four of the last six years. He's been fired once. It's time to fire him again,’ he said. ‘If I
had this same record, I should be gone too. Because this is not what leadership is about, particularly when
he's trying to give the public the impression that he's actually doing something.’” [The Citizen, 10/07/14]
Said, “There’s A Lot Of Knuckleheads” But Said Congress Wasn’t As Dysfunctional As People
Believe
Said, “There’s A Lot Of Knuckleheads” But “A Lot Of People Doing The Right Thing” And
Suggested Congress Wasn’t As Dysfunctional As People Believe. “‘There’s a lot of knuckleheads of
course, but there’s a lot of people doing the right thing,’ Katko said. ‘So, I guess I learned that, on both
sides of the aisle. So, that’s more encouraging than I thought.’ He touts legislative movement on things
like the transportation bill and the budget in the last Congress as proof that the legislative body isn’t as
dysfunctional as people believe.” [WRVO, 1/05/16]
Bipartisan Rhetoric And Actions
98
Claimed “Every One Of My Bills Has A Democratic Co-Sponsor.”
September 2015: Claimed “Every One Of My Bills Has A Democratic Co-Sponsor.” “JK: … I've
introduced a number of bills, and every one of my bills has a Democratic co-sponsor. And that's why I've
had four bills pass the House and there are many others in the hopper, because I reach across the aisle.
You work with the other side, you befriend them, you talk to them. It's not heresy, it's how things should
get done.” [WRVO, 9/27/15]
… But HR3167, The Tax Administration Integrity Act, Had Zero Democratic Co-Sponsors
At The Time—And, As Of December 2015, Still Has Zero Democratic Co-Sponsors. As of
December 2015, HR3167 had twelve Republican co-sponsors and zero Democratic co-sponsors.
[HR 3167, accessed 12/03/15]
Repeated His Claim That “Each Of The Bills He’s Introduced Has A Primary Democratic
Cosponsor.” “Being independent on issues has paid dividends. Katko said each of the bills he's
introduced has a primary Democratic cosponsor. That's helped him build support for his legislation on
both sides of the aisle.” [The Citizen, 1/10/16]
Sen. Schumer Said He Believed Katko Would Be A “Very Good, Hard-Working And Effective New
Congressman”
Sen. Schumer Said He Believed Katko Would Be A “Very Good, Hard-Working And Effective New
Congressman.” “‘I have spoken with John Katko and I believe he will be a very good, hard-working and
effective new congressman,’ Schumer said. ‘I have always believed that party differences should not
stand in the way of us working together. I had a great working relationship with former Republican
Congressman Jim Walsh, and hope to have the same good relationship with Congressman Katko.’” [Post
Standard, 12/04/14]
Sat With Democratic Rep. Deutch At The 2015 State Of The Union
2015: Sat With Democratic Rep. Deutch At The State Of The Union. “U.S. Rep. John Katko made his
latest show of bipartisanship Tuesday night when he sat with Democrats at President Obama’s State of the
Union address. Katko, R-Camillus, sat in an aisle seat, six rows back from President Obama. U.S. Rep.
Ted Deutch, D-Fla., sat to Katko’s right.” [Post Standard, 1/25/15]
Announced He Joined The ‘No Labels’ Group
Announced He Joined The ‘No Labels’ Group. “U.S. Congressman John Katko (NY-24) today joined
No Labels, a bipartisan congressional problem solvers group. The group’s membership consists of
Democrats and Republicans from both the House and Senate who meet regularly to build trust across the
aisle and to find common ground on issues before Congress.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 1/15/15]
Said He Frequently Worked With Reps. Rice, Stefanik, Gibson, And Reed
99
Said He Frequently Worked With Reps. Rice, Stefanik, Gibson, And Reed. “U.S. Rep. Kathleen
Rice, a Democrat from Long Island, is the ranking member on the Transportation Security subcommittee.
Like Katko, Rice is a freshman. And they're both former prosecutors. … Katko mentioned three other
New Yorkers — all Republicans — he spends a lot of time working with on legislative issues. He said he
consults daily with U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik, the youngest woman elected to Congress, on various
measures. ‘We have similar districts and we try to work in tandem as much as we can,’ he said. U.S.
Reps. Chris Gibson — Katko called him a ‘good buddy of mine’ — and Tom Reed are other members he
works with on a regular basis.” [The Citizen, 1/10/16]
Claimed He Was “Tagged As An Independent” And Voters “Can Tell Me Whether Or Not I’m An
Independent”
Claimed “I Think I’ve Been Tagged As An Independent. I Think That’s Really Been Solidified.”
“‘At times, you're walking a tightrope being an independent," he said. "But I think it's important to do
that.’ … Being independent on issues has paid dividends. Katko said each of the bills he's introduced has
a primary Democratic cosponsor. That's helped him build support for his legislation on both sides of the
aisle. ‘I think in the first six months, you get tagged as a hardcore conservative, you get tagged as a
hardcore liberal or you get tagged as a Washington insider,’ he said. ‘I think I've been tagged as an
independent. I think that's really been solidified.’” [The Citizen, 1/10/16]
Said Voters “Know What My Record Is. They Can Tell Me Whether Or Not I’m An Independent.”
“He's leaving it up to voters to decide whether he's worthy of a second term in Congress. ‘I've got a record
now,’ he said. ‘They know what my record is. They can tell me whether or not I'm an independent. They
can tell me whether or not I've acted independently like I said I was going to do. Let the chips fall where
they may. But my priority from the beginning has been to represent my constituents and that will never,
ever change.’” [The Citizen, 1/10/16]
100
Office Operations
 Complained about the cost of his health insurance as a congressman compared to
his health insurance as an employee of the Department of Justice.
 Sleeps in his office to fulfill a campaign pledge; selected his office for its location
near personal amenities
 Hired a lobbyist as a legislative staffer to work on the same areas she lobbied on
 Hired Maffei’s Director of Constituent Services and touted success on constituent
services
Katko complained about the cost of his health insurance as a congressman,
comparing it to his government-offered health insurance when he was an employee of
the Justice Department. At events surrounding his freshman orientation, Katko went
into great detail noting his awe and affinity for the trappings of office.
Katko slept in his office in order to keep his promise to not make D.C. his home. He
also described how he selected his office location to maximize its proximity to
amenities for his personal use.
Katko hired a former lobbyist to be a legislative staffer for the same issues she
lobbied on. He hired Maffei’s director of constituent services and has bragged about
the quality of constituent service he has provided.
Complained About The Cost Of His Insurance
Complained Health Insurance Tripled In Price Compared To A “Few Years Ago.” “The cost of
health insurance also is a concern for Katko. He cited his own health care as an example. He’s paying
triple what he paid a few years ago for health insurance coverage.” [The Citizen, 2/11/15]
Justice Department: Most Enrollees Of Their Health Care Plan Pay Only One Fourth Of
The Premium. “Most enrollees pay only one-fourth of the health benefit premium. The employee
contribution for health insurance premiums are made on a pretax basis.” [U.S. Justice Department
website, accessed 10/15/15]
Described His Affinity During Freshman Orientation For The Trappings Of Office
101
Described His Affinity For The Trappings Of Power During Freshman Orientation At Seeing Dress
Marines And Sitting Where Pres. Lincoln Did. “KATKO: They had an event the second night there (at
the Capitol) that was just unbelievable. Boehner had a dinner for the freshman Republicans. It was at the
old House of Representatives, which is just off the (Capitol dome). I was sitting 10 feet away from where
Abraham Lincoln used to sit. That was the first night I realized I’m a congressman, and I still don’t
believe it sometimes. We went over and there were dress Marines standing outside saluting you. I walked
into the Capitol and they had the Army band playing violins when you were checking your coat in and
everyone’s sa-luting you. It was just unbelievable.” [Interview, The Citizen, 12/02/14]
Described His Affinity For The Trappings Of Power And Being Awestruck By Boehner And The
Capitol Historian. “And then you walk into that room, the (old) House of Representatives. I think six or
seven presidents were in that room before they became presidents -- worked as House members before
they became presidents. They were in that room and their little plaques are on the floor. Boehner got up
there and started talking about it and you’re just like, ‘Oh my God.’ And then the Capitol historian came
up and gave a whole overview. That night, you walked out of there going, ‘Oh my god, this is the big
leagues.’ To be part of it is pretty exciting. ” [Interview, The Citizen, 12/02/14]
Described His Affinity For The Trappings Of Power Including Seeing Historical Documents
Unavailable To The Public. “A night or two later, Kevin McCarthy had an event at the National
Archives. It was closed to the public, of course. But they opened up the vault and they showed these
extremely rare documents. They had three of them lined up on the table. I’ll never forget them. The first
one was George Washington’s handwritten address to Congress, his first State of the Union address to
Congress signed by him. The second one was Thomas Jefferson’s one-page, handwritten letter to
Congress requesting money for the Louisiana Purchase, which he, himself, already committed to. The
third one was on tablet paper, just lined tablet paper that said on top ‘Execution Mansion,’ which was a
precursor to the White House. ‘I, Abraham Lincoln hereby assign Ulysses S. Grant to be lieutenant
general of the Union armies.’ Dated February of 1864. (Note: Katko was paraphrasing the letter.) I think
he replaced Mead then. But it’s like three lines there of handwritten Abraham Lincoln. Three great
presidents. Three huge things in our country’s history. I was just staring at them. That was good.”
Described His Affinity For The Trappings Of Power Of Seeing The “Spectacular” Documents In
The Library Of Congress. “Scalise had something at the Library of Congress, in the old part, and it was
really spectacular. Just getting a sense of history of it all and the documents there. Those things at night
were really kind of reinforcing what we were learning during the day.” [Interview, The Citizen, 12/02/14]
Promised During The Campaign He Would Never Live In Washington, Sleeps In His Office To
Fullfill That Promise, Said He Got A Pull-Out Couch To Sleep On In His Office
Promised He Would Never Live In Washington. “Republican John Katko made a campaign promise
Tuesday night in his race to unseat Rep. Dan Maffei, D-Syracuse. ‘I will never live in Washington and
visit back in the district if I am elected,’ Katko told about 100 supporters gathered over pizza and wings at
Knoxie’s Pub in Pompey.” [Post Standard, 6/19/14]
102
Slept In His Office In Washington. “While Katko is finding his footing as a member of Congress, he’s
still getting used to his new living quarters. When he’s in Washington for House sessions, he sleeps in his
office.” [The Citizen, 1/24/15]
Said He Was Going To Avoid The “Washington Game” And Sleep In His Office. “KATKO: I’m not
going to get caught up in the whole Washington game and stuff. I’m going to sleep in my office, I’m
going to be living in there. I’m down there to work. When I’m there, I’m going to work. I’m going to get
back home and spend as much time as I can in my district. It was reinforced to me. I already knew that.
But I’m mindful of it.” [Interview, The Citizen, 12/02/14]
Decided To Sleep In His Office Despite Lots Of Family And Friends In Washington In Order To
Stay True To Campaign Theme. “A nice suite is more important for Katko than for many other
lawmakers. The 52-year-old former federal prosecutor from the Syracuse suburb of Camillus plans to
sleep in his office when he’s in Washington. That will allow Katko to stay true to a campaign strategy that
hammered Democratic Rep. Dan Maffei for purchasing a detached townhouse in Alexandria’s Old Town
section for $669,000. … And what happens when his wife visits Washington? ‘She’s sleeping on the
floor,’ he joked, then added, ‘We have a lot of families and friends down there, so we’ll be fine.’” [USA
Today, 11/20/14]
Said He Slept On A Couch In His Office To “Return Home – To His Family And His District – As
Soon As Possible.” “When the House is in session, Katko travels to Washington for votes. While there,
he will sleep on a couch in his office. ‘It's not always restful,’ he said, noting that the night before this
interview, ‘a guy down the hall was drilling something all night.’ The decision to sleep in his office isn't
one he takes lightly. He believes that it's important to go to Washington, work and then return home — to
his family and his district — as soon as possible. ‘That benefits my district, but more importantly to me
personally, it benefits my family because I'm home at every possible moment,’ he said. ‘It's really hard,
but it's worth it.’” [The Citizen, 1/10/16]
Said He Got A Pull Out Couch And Sleeps On It. “Host: This is interesting, you’re down in DC quite a
bit of the year, and you actually sleep in your office? Why’s that? Katko: absolutely. … Host: So how
does this work, exactly, where do you do you sleep, do you sleep on the couch? Or where? Katko: Couch.
Yeah, I got a couch. It’s a pull out couch. And I just right there.” [CNYCentral Interview, via
youtube.com, 8/25/15]
NOTE: It has not been determined if Katko or his office paid for the couch on which he slept.
Selected His Office For Its Proximity To Amenities For His Personal Use
Selected His Office Location For Proximity To Amenities Benefiting Him Personally. “A nice suite is
more important for Katko than for many other lawmakers. The 52-year-old former federal prosecutor
from the Syracuse suburb of Camillus plans to sleep in his office when he’s in Washington. … Katko
focused on Longworth partly because it’s adjacent to the congressional gym in the Rayburn House Office
Build-ing, where he plans to shower. … A suite on a lower floor means less walking to get to the U.S.
Capitol for votes and gives staffers easier access to the basement cafeteria, which is likely to often serve
as Katko’s dining room.” [USA Today, 11/20/14]
103
Hired A Former Boehner Aide, Lobbyist, As A Legislative Staffer For Same Issue Areas On Which
She Lobbied
Hired Former Boehner Aide, Lobbyist, As A Legislative Staffer For Same Issue Areas On Which
She Lobbied. “Katko has filled out his legislative staff by hiring a former Capitol Hill lobbyist to work
on some of the same issues in which she represented private clients last year. Erin Boyle started work this
month as Katko’s legislative assistant covering health care, telecommunications, education and Social
Security. Boyle, a 2010 graduate of Wake Forest University, spent last year as a vice president at Petrizzo
Group Inc., a Washington lobbying firm, where she worked for clients on issues such as health
technology and cybersecurity. Previously, Boyle worked as a staff assistant for House Speaker John
Boehner, R-Ohio, and went on to work for his political committee.” [Post Standard, 2/22/15]
Katko’s District Director’s Salary Was Less Than His Pension As A Retired Police Officer
Katko’s District Director’s Salary Was Less Than His Pension As A Retired Police Officer. “Retired
Syracuse police Sgt. Tom Connellan, who now heads Rep. John Katko’s Syracuse office, will receive an
annual state pension 21 percent higher than originally estimated. In January, Chief Frank Fowler
estimated Connellan would receive an annual pension of about $62,000. But according to the state
comptroller’s office, Connellan’s gross monthly pension is $6,273 - $75,276 a year. The average pension
for a police officer statewide is $45,075, Nikki Jones, deputy press secretary for state Comptroller
Thomas DiNapoli, said earlier this year. Connellan’s pension will likely be higher than his annual salary
as district director of Katko’s Syracuse office. As district director, Connellan earned $17,111.10 over the
first quarter of 2015.” [Post Standard, 7/22/15]
Hired Maffei’s Director Of Constituent Services, Said He Thought His Constituent Services Were
“Doing Fantastic”
Said He Hired Maffei’s Director Of Constituent Services, Said He Thought His Constituent
Services Were “Doing Fantastic”. “QUESTION: In your 100 day report, that was a common these -- the
local accomplishments, the local achievements. What’s your assessment of constituent services provided
by your office? KATKO: It’s not me. It’s my staff. And I couldn’t be happier with them. We hired
someone who’s been doing constitu-ent service work on the federal level for congressmen on both sides
of the aisle. We hired Maffei’s director of constitu-ent services. Between the two of them, they’re just like
dynamos. They’re phenomenal... Everybody’s got a piece of it, so we’re all pitching in. I am most proud
of our constituent service work. I compare it to anybody’s in the nation. I think we’re doing fantastic. We
really are.” [The Citizen, 4/20/15]
104
Abortion and Family Planning Issues
 Opposed abortion, said he would overturn Roe v. Wade
 Reneged on promise to vote against defunding Planned Parenthood during 2014
campaign
 Called a Supreme Court decision that allowed employers to deny contraceptive
coverage the “right decision”
Katko opposed abortion, campaigning on the position that he supported protections
for rape, incest and the health of the mother. However he noted he would vote to
overturn Roe v. Wade. Katko campaigned promising to vote against defunding
Planned Parenthood, but broke that promise in Congress, voting to defund the
organization. Katko called the Hobby Lobby decision allowing employers to deny
contraceptive coverage the “right decision.”
Said He Would Repeal Roe V. Wade
Said He Would Repeal Roe V. Wade. “At a Thursday Morning Roundtable debate, he was pressed for a
‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer on repealing the Roe v. Wade decision that made abortion a legal right. Katko said he
would vote to repeal the law. After the debate, his spokeswoman stressed that Katko would not make it a
priority; it is not a top issue on his agenda.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Said He Opposed Abortion
In April 2014, when asked where he stood on women’s reproductive rights Katko said, “That is an easily
voiced yet complex issue. My position on abortion is consistent with my Catholic faith. I believe that all
life has worth, every individual has potential, and every child deserves opportunity. Put as simply as I can,
my opponent supports abortion on demand. I do not.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Opposed Abortion with Exceptions for Rape, Incest, and the Health of the Mother
In July 2014, Katko said that he was pro-life, with certain exceptions: “My position on abortion is
consistent with my faith in the Catholic Church, with the exception of rape, incest or the health of the
mother,” he said. [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Called Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby Ruling the “Right Decision,” Argued It Did Not Restrict
Rights As People Could Still Buy Contraception Themselves
105
In July 2014, when asked about the Supreme Court’s decision exempting certain companies from a
provision in the Affordable Care Act that required businesses to provide coverage for contraception in
health insurance plans Katko told the Auburn Citizen, “Obamacare is loaded with overreaches like that. I
think it’s the right decision.” [Auburn Citizen, 7/01/14]
Argued Hobby Lobby Didn’t Take Away To Right To Obtain Contraception Because They Could
Buy It Themselves. “Katko added that there are some forms of contraception Hobby Lobby doesn’t
object to, which has been noted in previous media reports. He disagreed with Democrats who contend that
the ruling will take away the right for women to obtain contraception. ‘No, it doesn’t at all. It’s not. It’s
just certain types that people object to on religious grounds,’ Katko said of decision’s impact. ‘It doesn’t
take away their right to get any of these products and to purchase it themselves.’ [The Citizen, 7/01/14]
Said He Needed The Results Of An Investigation Before Deciding On Planned Parenthood Funding,
Then Said He Couldn’t Support Funding Planned Parenthood Until Congressional Investigations
Finished, And Subsequently Broke A Campaign Promise By Voting To Defund Planned
Parenthood
Said He Needed The Result Of An Investigation Before Deciding On Whether Or Not To Defund
Planned Parenthood. Host: They’re asking you to pledge not to vote to defund Planned Parenthood. Can
you tell us exactly where do you stand on this issue? How would you vote? Katko: Well, I mean, you
can’t put the cart before the horse. You have to do the investigation first. And this whole discussion is
born out of the fact that some videos surfaced, undercover videos, which alleged to be showing that
Planned Parenthood is engaging in the sale of body parts and body tissues from aborted fetuses. And so, if
that’s true, violations of federal law may have occurred, and certainly of medical standards. So, we can’t
decide, you can’t really say what you want to do until you do the investigation. You have to do the
investigation first. I’m for a full and fair investigation, but I want to make clear there is a role for the
federal government to help women and their healthcare needs. So no matter what happens going forward,
we have to make sure we provide for that. [CNYCentral Interview, via youtube.com, 8/25/15]
Said He Could Not Support Funding Planned Parenthood Until Investigations Finished
Said He Could Not Support Funding Planned Parenthood Until Congressional Investigations
Finished. “‘There are several ongoing congressional investigations into this matter,’ Katko, R-Camillus,
said in a statement Friday. ‘Until these investigations are complete and we fully understand the depth of
these troubling practices, I cannot support providing taxpayer dollars to this organization.’ Katko said the
funds should be redirected to federally qualified community health centers to ensure women’s health
services will remain available.” [The Citizen, 9/18/15]
Mind; Videos Widely Panned As Misleading
Mind. “U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, joined the majority of Republicans in voting 241-187 to pass
the mostly symbolic measure, which would cut off about $500 million in aid to Planned Parenthood. …
Katko had promised during his 2014 campaign for Congress that he would not vote to defund Planned
Parenthood. … ‘In the past, I have taken the position that I would support federal funding for Planned
Parenthood to continue to provide these important services,’ Katko said. ‘However, like many of my
106
constituents, I am concerned by the gruesome and potentially illegal content of the recently released
videos exposing some of the practices of this organization.’ Katko added that he until congressional
investigations are complete, he can't support providing taxpayer dollars to Planned Parenthood.” [Post
Standard, 9/20/15]
Independent Investigator Found “Significant Gaps” Which Render “The File Unreliable.”
“Her letter was accompanied by a 10-page report commissioned by Planned Parenthood and
penned by an independent investigator, former Wall Street Journal reporter Glenn Simpson.
Through his firm Fusion GPS, Simpson enlisted experts who analyzed both the short, highly
produced videos publicized by the antiabortion group, as well as hours of ‘full’ footage the group
posted on YouTube. The implication is that the longer footage was unedited. But Simpson said he
found significant gaps. ‘Anytime someone removes a piece of audio or video tape . . . that renders
the file unreliable,’ Simpson said during a teleconference for reporters.” [Washington Post,
8/27/15]
New York Times Editorial: Videos Show “Something Very Different From What These
Critics Claim” And Were “Edited To Eliminate Statements.” “The full video of the lunch
meeting, over two hours long and released by the Center for Medical Progress, shows something
very different from what these critics claim. Clearly, the shorter version was edited to eliminate
statements by Dr. Nucatola explaining that Planned Parenthood does not profit from tissue
donation, which requires the clear consent of the patient. Planned Parenthood affiliates only accept
money — between $30 and $100 per specimen, according to Dr. Nucatola — to cover costs
associated with collecting and transporting the tissue. ‘This is not something with any revenue
stream that affiliates are looking at,’ she said. Under federal law, facilities may be reimbursed for
costs associated with fetal tissue donation, like transportation and storage.” [Editorial, New York
Times, 7/22/15]
Factcheck.org: Unedited Video “Isn’t Evidence That Planned Parenthood Or Its Affiliates
Are Selling ‘Body Parts’ Or Fetal Tissue For Profit.” “Several Republican presidential
candidates have claimed that Planned Parenthood is ‘profiting’ from abortions. But the full,
unedited video they cite as evidence shows a Planned Parenthood executive repeatedly saying its
clinics want to cover their costs, not make money, when donating fetal tissue from abortions for
scientific research.’ At one point in the unedited video (which was also released by the group),
Nucatola says: ‘Affiliates are not looking to make money by doing this. They’re looking to serve
their patients and just make it not impact their bottom line.’ … In the edited video, Nucatola says
the cost for fetal tissue specimens was between $30 and $100, ‘depending on the facility and
what’s involved.’ She defined ‘specimen’ as, ‘one case. One patient.’ … Nucatola’s comment,
though, isn’t evidence that Planned Parenthood or its affiliates are selling ‘body parts’ or fetal
tissue for profit.” [Factcheck.org, 7/21/15]
The Citizen: “DCCC’s Claim that Katko Broke His Promise When He Voted To Defund Planned
Parenthood: True.” “The DCCC's charge that Katko broke his promise when he voted to defund
Planned Parenthood refers to his comments made on the campaign trail last year. During the 2014
campaign for the 24th Congressional District seat, Katko said he wouldn't support defunding Planned
Parenthood. His position changed after a conservative group posted videos which raised questions about
107
whether Planned Parenthood was illegally selling fetal tissue. … DCCC's claim that Katko broke his
promise when he voted to defund Planned Parenthood: True” [The Citizen, 9/30/15]
Said Defunding Planned Parenthood May Lead To Increased Availability Of Women’s Healthcare
Said Defunding Planned Parenthood May Lead To Increased Availability Of Women’s Healthcare.
“It's not just defunding Planned Parenthood and saying ‘See ya later’ and capitalizing on this. No. It's
about temporarily suspending funding to them pending the outcome of an investigation. Its like a
preliminary injunction kind of thing, in my mind, that’s how I liken it. And see what happens when the
investigation is done. We have three committees investigating this issue, and it's a terrible issue all the
way around. But it's not like we're going to take those funds that were being used to help women with
women's healthcare issues and forget it. The money would be dedicated towards community health clinics
throughout this country. And interestingly, there’s ten times more community health clinics across this
country than there are Planned Parenthoods. So, in the end, it may lead to increased availability of
women’s healthcare that’s funded by the government.” [WVRO, 9/27/15]
CBO: Fifteen Percent Of Patients Could Lose Access Care If Planned Parenthood Were
Defunded, Increase Unplanned Births, And Drive Up Government Costs. “Cutting off
Planned Parenthood’s funding would result in a net savings of $235 million over a decade, while
also resulting in “several thousand” unplanned births that would drive up government costs
elsewhere, the Congressional Budget Office said Wednesday. … CBO warned that 15 percent of
patients would lose access to care. The people most likely to be affected are those living in areas
without other healthcare clinics that cater to low-income populations — most of Planned
Parenthood’s current clientele. … The report shows that available alternatives to Planned
Parenthood vary widely: Between 5 and 25 percent of Planned Parenthood’s estimated 2.6 million
clients would see “reduced access to care,” depending on where they live.” [The Hill, 9/16/15]
Rep. Hanna: Defunding Planned Parenthood “Will Deny Essential Healthcare To 2.7 Million
People.” “Hanna has also opposed Republican efforts to cut off federal funding for Planned
Parenthood, which he says will deny essential healthcare to 2.7 million people. ‘This bill will limit
women's access to health care, leaving many with few or no alternatives,’ Hanna said after
Wednesday's vote.” [Post Standard, 1/06/16]
Voted For Defunding Planned Parenthood
Voted For Defunding Planned Parenthood. In September 2015, Katko voted for the Defund Planned
Parenthood Act 2015 that “prohibits, for a one-year period, the availability of federal funds for any
purpose to Planned Parenthood Federation of America, Inc., or any of its affiliates or clinics, unless they
certify that the affiliates and clinics will not perform, and will not provide any funds to any other entity
that performs, an abortion during such period. The restriction will not apply in cases of rape or incest or
where a physical condition endangers a woman’s life unless an abortion is performed.” The bill passed
241 to 187. [H.R. 3134, Vote #505, 9/18/15; CQ, 9/23/15]
Defunding Planned Parenthood Would Increase Public Spending By $130 Million Over 10
Years. “Days before lawmakers must pass new legislation to fund the government, Republicans are
vowing to reject any proposal that includes public money for Planned Parenthood. The move could
108
trigger not only a shutdown, but if it succeeds, more bills for taxpayers. The Congressional Budget
Office said in a new report on Thursday that cutting off the women’s health organization from federal
money would actually increase public spending by an estimated $130 million over 10 years. … The
office’s math: Halting federal funds to Planned Parenthood would shrink spending by $520 million in
the short run -- but, over the first decade, it would cost taxpayers an additional $650 million.” [The
Washington Post, 9/24/15]
Voted Against Preventing Attempt To Defund Planned Parenthood
Voted Against Preventing Attempt To Defund Planned Parenthood. In September 2015, Katko voted
against a motion that “shields American women’s access to lifesaving health care services from
Republicans’ attempt to defund Planned Parenthood by protecting any organization that provides
women’s health services, such as preventive care and cancer screenings, from being stripped of vital
federal resources to serve America’s families.” A yes vote was a vote against defunding Planned
Parenthood. The resolution failed, 183 to 245. [H.R. 3134, Vote #504, 9/18/15; Democratic Leader –
Motions To Recommit, 9/18/15]
Voted For Establishing Select Committee To Investigate Fetal Tissue Donation In Reponse To
Edited Planned Parenthood Videos
Voted For Establishing Select Committee To Investigate Fetal Tissue Donation. In October 2015,
Katko voted for a bill that would “establish a select investigative subcommittee under the House Energy
and Commerce Committee. The panel would be responsible for investigating and reporting on issues
related to fetal tissue donation, fetal tissue procurement, federal funding for abortion services, and lateterm abortions.” The bill passed 242-184. [H Res 461, Vote #538, 10/07/15; CQ Floor Votes, 10/07/15]
Select Committee Targeting Planned Parenthood Given Broad Jurisdiction To Investigate
Abortion Practices, Including Recommendations To Change Abortion Laws. Although the select
committee was formed in response to videos edited to implicate that Planned Parenthood sold fetus
tissue for profit, “[t]he words ‘Planned Parenthood’ do not appear in the resolution establishing the
special committee. Its jurisdiction is considerably broader, encompassing ‘medical procedures and
business practices used by entities involved in fetal tissue procurement’ and ‘any other relevant
matters with respect to fetal tissue procurement.’ It also permits the committee to probe the subject of
federal funding for abortion providers generally, the practices of providers who perform abortions in
the second and third trimesters, and ‘medical procedures for the care of a child born alive as a result of
an attempted abortion.’ The committee is also empowered to recommend changes in laws or
regulations based on its findings.” [Washington Post, 10/07/15; USA Today, 10/07/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Making It Easier For States To Defund Planned
Parenthood.
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Making It Easier For States To Defund Planned
Parenthood. In September 2015, Katko voted for motion to order the previous question (thus ending
debate and possibility of amendment) on the rule (H Res 444) that would provide for floor consideration
of the bill (HR 3495) that would amend title XIX of the Social Security act to allow states to exclude
medical providers who perform abortions from the state's Medicaid contracts. The motion was agreed to
109
243-182. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 444,
Vote #521, 9/29/15; CQ Floor Votes, 9/29/15]
Voted Against Motion To Protect Women’s Access To Life-Saving Health Services
Voted Against Motion To Protect Women’s Access To Life-Saving Health Services. In September
2015, Katko voted against motion to recommit the Women's Public Health and Safety Act. “The
Democratic Motion to Recommit protects American women’s access to life-saving health care services
from Republicans’ attempt to defund Planned Parenthood by protecting any organization that provides
life-saving health services, such as preventive care and cancer screenings, from being stripped of vital
federal resources to serve America’s families.” The motion was rejected by a vote of 184-242. [HR 3495,
Vote #523, 9/29/15; Democratic Leader – Motions to Recommit, 9/30/15]
Voted Against Bill Making It Easier For States To Defund Planned Parenthood
Voted Against Bill Making It Easier For States To Defund Planned Parenthood. In September 2015,
Katko voted against a bill that would amend title XIX of the Social Security act to allow states to exclude
medical providers who perform abortions from the state's Medicaid contracts. The bill would expand the
exceptions for which a state is not required to provide Medicaid reimbursements, allowing states to deny
non-abortion health care reimbursements to medical providers such as Planned Parenthood. The bill
passed by a vote of 236-193. [HR 3495, Vote #524, 9/29/15; CQ Floor Votes, 9/29/15]
Voted For Protecting Reproductive Health Choices In The Workplace
Voted For A Rule To Bring A Resolution To The Floor Disapproving Of A Law That Would
Prohibit Employers From Discriminating Against Employees Who Use Birth Control. In April 2015,
Katko voted for the adoption of the rule (H Res 231) providing for House floor consideration of the bill
(HR 1732) that would prohibit EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers from finalizing or implementing
the currently proposed rule regarding the definition of the ‘Waters of the United States,’ the fiscal 2016
budget conference report (S Con Res 11) and the joint resolution (H J Res 43) disapproving the District of
Columbia's Reproductive Health Non-Discrimination Amendment Act. The rule was adopted 242-181. [H
Res 231, Vote #181, 4/30/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/30/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill Disapproving Of A Law That Would Prohibit
Employers From Discriminating Against Employees Who Use Birth Control. In April 2015, Katko
voted for the Woodall, R-Ga., motion to order the previous question (thus ending debate and the
possibility of amendment) on the rule (H Res 231) that would provide for House floor consideration of the
bill (HR 1732) that would prohibit EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers from finalizing or
implementing the currently proposed rule regarding the definition of the ‘Waters of the United States,’ the
fiscal 2016 budget conference report (S Con Res 11) and the joint resolution (H J Res 43) disapproving
the District of Columbia's Reproductive Health Non-Discrimination Amendment Act. The motion was
agreed to 241-181. [H Res 231, Vote #180, 4/30/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/30/15]
Voted For A Question To Bring A Resolution To The Floor Disapproving Of A Law That Would
Prohibit Employers From Discriminating Against Employees Who Use Birth Control. In April 2015,
Katko voted for the question of whether the House should consider the rule (H Res 231) that would
110
provide for further House floor consideration of the bill (HR 1732) that would prohibit EPA and the Army
Corps of Engineers from finalizing or implementing the currently proposed rule regarding the definition
of the "Waters of the United States," the fiscal 2016 budget conference report (S Con Res 11) and the
joint resolution (H J Res 43) disapproving the District of Columbia's Reproductive –-Health NonDiscrimination Amendment Act. The question was agreed to consider by a vote of 240-174. Note:
Watson-Coleman, D-N.J., had raised a point of order that the rule would violate clause 426(a) of the
Congressional Budget Act, regarding unfunded mandates. [H Res 231, Vote #179, 4/30/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Repealing Of DC Law Banning Discrimination Based On Contraception Usage.
Voted Against Repealing DC Reproductive Health Non Discrimination Act. In February 2015, Katko
voted against repealing the action of the District of Columbia Council in approving the Reproductive
Health Non-Discrimination Amendment Act of 2014. “The resolution disapproves, and thereby
effectively repeals, the District of Columbia's Reproductive Health Non-Discrimination Amendment Act
of 2014, which is intended to ensure that individuals are protected from discrimination by an employer
because of the individual's or family member's ‘reproductive health decision’ -- including use of
contraception or the planned or intended initiation or termination of a pregnancy.” The bill passed 228 to
192. [HR 596, Vote #194, 4/30/15; CQ House Action Report, 4/29/15]
Opposed Overturning A DC Law Preventing Discrimination Against Workers Over
Contraception Or Abortion, Saying It Could Open The Door To Discrimination. “Hanna and
Katko both split with Republicans on a vote late Thursday to strike down the District of
Columbia’s law that bans workplace discrimination over employees’ reproductive decisions. …
The D.C. council passed the law to prevent employers from discriminating against workers who
seek contraception or family planning services, or who use medical treatments to initiate or
terminate a pregnancy. But House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, called the issue one of
‘religious liberty.’ Some conservatives said the D.C. measure could be interpreted as requiring
churches, or groups that oppose abortion rights, to provide their employees with health coverage
for contraception and abortion. Katko said he thought the House bill could open the door to
discrimination. ‘I am pro-life except in cases of rape, incest or where the life of the mother is in
danger, and will always stand on those principles when I vote on legislation before Congress,’
Katko said. ‘However, the resolution before the House yesterday focused primarily on issues
related to workplace discrimination.’” [Post Standard, 5/03/15]
Voted For Restricting A Woman’s Right To Choose After 20 Weeks, Said He Opposed “Late-Term
Abortion”
Voted For Restricting A Woman’s Right To Choose After 20 Weeks, Including Requiring 48-Hour
Waiting Period For Rape Survivors. In May 2015, Katko voted for “a bill banning abortions after 20
weeks of pregnancy in a party-line vote on Wednesday.” According to The Hill, “But the bill did not
change a provision that allows victims of incest to receive an abortion only if they are under 18 years old
… The new version of the House bill also includes a two-day waiting period for rape victims. Doctors
must also ensure that victims have received medical treatment or counseling during that time.” [HR 36,
Vote #223, 5/13/15; The Hill, 5/13/15; The Hill, 5/11/15]
111
Voted To Ban Abortion After 20 Weeks, Said He Opposed “Late-Term Abortion”. “House
Republicans on Wednesday passed a nationwide ban on abortion in cases where the probable age of the
fetus is 20 weeks or later, imposing criminal penalties on medical providers who violate the law. … The
only exception to the federal law would be where the life of a woman is in danger or in cases of incest and
rape against a minor - as long as it has been reported to law enforcement or a social service agency. …
U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, joined the Republican majority in voting for the abortion ban. ‘I am
pro-life except in instances of rape, incest, and where the life of the mother is threatened,’ Katko said after
the vote. ‘Today’s legislation provides for these exceptions and ensures that abortions are not performed
later than five months into a pregnancy. I voted for this measure because I do not support late-term
abortions.’” [Post Standard, 5/14/15]
Voted Against Adding Exception To Anti-Choice Bill To Protect The Health Of The Woman
Voted Against Adding Exception To Anti-Choice Bill To Protect The Health Of The Woman. In
May 2015, Katko voted against adding a woman’s health exception to a 20-week abortion bill. “U.S. Rep.
Julia Brownley’s attempt to amend a bill calling for a ban on abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy was
defeated Wednesday, and the House went on to pass the ban. The Westlake Village Democrat’s motion
and amendment would have added language to the Pain Capable Unborn Child Protection Act that would
have permitted abortions after 20 weeks if a woman’s health were at risk. It was defeated on a mostly
party-line 181-246 vote.” [H.R. 36, Vote #222, 5/13/15; Ventura County Star, 5/13/15]
Voted For Limiting Women’s Access To Reproductive Services
Voted For Bill Blocking Federal Funding For Abortion, Including Tax Credits For Small
Businesses Providing Healthcare That Includes Abortion Coverage. In January 2015, Katko voted for
the No Taxpayer Funding for Abortion Act, which restricted federal funding for abortions and abortion
coverage. “The House did easily pass H.R. 7, the No Taxpayer Funding for Abortion and Abortion
Insurance Full Disclosure Act of 2015, sponsored by Rep. Chris Smith (R-N.J.). White House advisers
said they would recommend a veto should the bill reach the president’s desk. The Hyde Amendment
already prevents the use of federal funds to pay for abortion, except in cases of incest, rape and life
endangerment of the mother. That is passed every year as part of an appropriations bill, but this bill would
make that permanent law. The House bill would also restrict small businesses from getting an Affordable
Care Act tax credit if they purchase employee health plans that include abortion coverage on the Small
Business Health Options Program, or SHOP exchange.” [HR 7, Vote #45, 1/22/15; Politico, 1/22/15]
Bill Would Give Big Insurance Companies Incentive To Drop Abortion Coverage. “The bill
gives insurers a big incentive to drop abortion coverage from their plans, or risk losing the large pool
of consumers who receive the law's subsidies. Abortion coverage is historically relatively ubiquitous
in health plans, so the effect could be far-reaching.” [National Journal, 1/28/14]
Voted To Prohibit ACA Tax Credits To Women Who Buy Insurance Which Covers Abortion, Or
Pay Out Of Pocket For An Abortion. “Only three Democrats joined 239 Republicans, including
freshman Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, in voting for passage. The bill authored by Rep. Chris Smith, RN.J., would deny federal tax deductions or credits to women who buy health insurance through the
Affordable Care Act that covers abortion, or if they use their own money to pay for an abortion.” [Post
Standard, 1/25/15]
112
Voted Against Voted Against An Amendment Stripping Language From LHHSE Appropriations
Prohibiting Federal Money For Abortion In NIH And FDA Funding
Voted Against Voted Against An Amendment Stripping Language From LHHSE Approps
Prohibiting Federal Money For Abortion In NIH And FDA Funding. In July 2015, Katko voted
against “a Democratic amendment to strip bill language added in the final stages that would make policy
riders in the fiscal 2016 Labor-HHS-Education appropriations bill – including those prohibiting federal
dollars for abortion – applicable to the NIH and FDA funding stream.” The amendment failed, 176 to 245.
[HR 6, Vote #432, 7/10/15; CQ News, 7/10/15]
Voted For Bill Requiring Doctors To Provide Medical Care To Aborted Fetuses That Show Signs
Of Life
Voted For Bill Requiring Doctors To Provide Medical Care To Aborted Fetuses That Show Signs
Of Life. In September 2015, Katko voted for legislation that “amends the federal criminal code to require
any health care practitioner who is present when a child is born alive following an abortion or attempted
abortion to: (1) exercise the same degree of care as reasonably provided to any other child born alive at
the same gestational age, and (2) ensure that such child is immediately admitted to a hospital. The term
‘born alive’ means the complete expulsion or extraction from his or her mother, at any stage of
development, who after such expulsion or extraction breathes or has a beating heart, pulsation of the
umbilical cord, or definite movement of voluntary muscles, regardless of whether the umbilical cord has
been cut.” The bill passed, 248 to 177. [HR 3504, Vote #506, 9/18/15]
Doctors Would Face Up To 5 Years In Prison If They Were Found To Not Follow The
Legislation. “Per the bill, ‘the term ‘born alive’ means the complete expulsion or extraction from his
or her mother, at any stage of development, who after such expulsion or extraction breathes or has a
beating heart, pulsation of the umbilical cord, or definite movement of voluntary muscles, regardless
of whether the umbilical cord has been cut.’ Physicians could face up to five years of prison time for
lack of adherence to this measure and may also face civil suits from women who wish to press
charges.” [Yahoo News, 9/18/15]
President Of The American Congress Of Obstetricians And Gynecologists Called The
Legislation “A Disservice To America’s Women And Gross Legislative Interference Into The
Practice Of Medicine.” “In a statement, Mark S. DeFrancesco, MD, president of the American
Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, called the passage of H.R. 3504 ‘a disservice to
America’s women and gross legislative interference into the practice of medicine, putting politicians
between women and their trusted doctors. This bill and others like it are part of a larger attempt to
deny women access to safe, legal, evidence-based abortion care,’ he said in the statement. ‘We urge
the United States Senate and the President to stand with women and stand up for safe medical care,
by preventing this and other legislation like it to become law.’” [Yahoo News, 9/18/15]
113
Agriculture And Food Safety
 Declared support for the bill making it easier for farmers to hire seasonal
agricultural workers
 Voted for repealing country of origin labeling requirements on meat
Katko declared support for a bill making it easier for farmers to hire seasonal
agricultural workers. He voted to repeal country of origin labeling requirements on
meat.
Declared Support For Bill Making It Easier For Farmers To Hire Seasonal Agricultural Workers
Declared Support For Bill Making It Easier For Farmers To Hire Seasonal Agricultural Workers.
“Katko supports policies such as the Family Farm Relief Act to make it easier for farmers to hire seasonal
agriculture workers, and the Repeal of the Death Tax to relieve family farms of the burden of heavy tax
bills at death.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 4/17/15]
Voted For Repealing Country Of Origin Labeling Requirements On Meat
Voted For Repealing County Of Origin Labeling Requirements On Meat Sold In U.S. In June 2015,
Katko voted for a bill to repeal U.S. country of origin labeling requirements for beef, pork and chicken
that is sold in the United States. The bill passed by a vote of 300-131. [HR 2393, Vote #333, 6/10/15; CQ
Voted Against Requiring GMO Labeling For Companies Requiring Labels In Foreign Countries
Voted Against Requiring GMO Labeling For Companies Requiring Labels In Foreign Countries. In
July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that “would require a U.S. company or subsidiary with
products labeled a containing GMOs (genetically modified organisms) in any foreign country to indicate
the presence of GMOs in the equivalent product sold in the U.S.” The amendment failed, 123-303. [HR
1599, Vote #459, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/23/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Ensure Tribal Sovereignty Under The Safe And Accurate Food
Labeling Act
Voted Against An Amendment To Ensure Tribal Sovereignty Under The Safe And Accurate Food
Labeling Act. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Safe and Accurate Food Labeling
Act of 2015 that would “ensure tribal sovereignty and would guarantee that the bill does not prohibit or
limit the right to cultivate genetically engineered plants on or near tribal lands.” The amendment was
rejected 196-227. [HR 1599, Vote #460, 7/23/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/23/15]
114
Voted Against An Amendment To Prohibit Foods Labeled “Natural” To Contain Genetically
Engineered Plants
Voted Against An Amendment To Prohibit Foods Labeled “Natural” To Contain Genetically
Engineered Plants. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Safe and Accurate Food
Labeling Act of 2015 that would “prohibit foods labeled with the term ‘natural’ to contain genetically
engineered plants.” The amendment was rejected 163-262. [HR 1599, Vote #461, 7/23/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 7/23/15]
Voted For Overriding State Laws And Establishing A Voluntary National Genetically Engineered
Certification Program
Voted For Overriding State Laws Requiring GMO Labeling And Establishing A Voluntary
National Genetically Engineered Certification Program. In July 2015, Katko voted for the Safe and
Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2015, which would “require the Agriculture Department to establish a
voluntary national genetically engineered (GE) food certification program under which food producers
could label their product as including or not including genetically modified ingredients. The program
created under the bill would pre-empt related state and local laws and prohibits mandatory labeling of GE
or non-GE food.” The bill passed 275-150. [HR 1599, Vote #462, 7/23/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/23/15]
Headline: The Hill: “House passes bill blocking states from requiring GMO labels on food.”
“The House on Thursday passed hotly contested legislation that would keep states from issuing
mandatory labeling laws for foods that contain genetically modified organisms, often called GMOs.
The Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2015, which passed 275-150, would instead create a
federal standard for the voluntary labeling of foods with GMO ingredients… Opponents have pushed
back against the legislation, saying it will keep consumers from knowing what’s in their food and stop
FDA from crafting a national GMO-labeling solution.” [The Hill, 7/23/15]
Voted Against Changing The Title Of The Bill From “Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act” To
“Deny Americans the Right to Know Act”
Voted Against Changing Title Of The Bill From “Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act” To “Deny
Americans the Right to Know Act.” In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Safe and
Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2015 that would change the title of the bill to the “Deny Americans the
Right to Know Act.” The amendment was rejected 87-337. [HR 1599, Vote #463, 7/23/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 7/23/15]
Voted For To Reduce Requirements On Restaurant Calorie Disclosures
Voted For To Reduce Requirements On Restaurant Calorie Disclosures. In February 2016, Katko
voted for a bill “that would change the requirement for how restaurants and similar retail establishments
with more than 20 locations must disclose calorie information on their menus. Instead of the current
requirement for businesses to disclose the number of calories in a "standard menu item," businesses could
opt to disclose the number of calories per serving along with the number of servings or disclose the
number of calories per common unit division of the standard menu item. The bill would allow for
115
disclosures to have variations from actual nutrient content, including inadvertent human error, variations
in ingredients and serving size, and other reasonable variations.” The bill passed 266-144. [HR 2017,
Vote #81, 02/24/16; CQ, 2/12/16]
White House: Legislation “Would Reduce Consumers’ Access To Nutrition Information.”
On February 10, 2016, the White House sent out a statement opposing ‘The Common Sense
Nutrition Disclosure Act of 2015.’ “The Administration opposes H.R. 2017, the Common Sense
Nutrition Disclosure Act of 2015. … H.R. 2017 would undercut the objective of providing clear,
consistent calorie information to consumers. If enacted, it would reduce consumers’ access to
nutrition information and likely create consumer confusion by introducing a great deal of
variability into how calories are declared. The legislation also would create unnecessary delays in
the implementation of menu labeling.” [White House Statement, 2/10/16]
Voted Against Amendment That Would Not Have Allowed Restaurants To Only Post Nutritional
Information Online
Voted Against Amendment That Would Not Have Allowed Restaurants To Only Post Nutritional
Information Online. In February 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to the Common Sense
Nutrition Disclosure Act which would “remove the provision in the bill that would allow restaurants or
similar retail food establishments to disclose calorie information solely online if the majority of their
orders are placed by customers who are offsite.” The amendment was rejected 148 to 258. [HR 2017, H
Amdt. 943, Vote #80, 2/12/16; CQ, 2/12/16]
Voted For Amendment That Would Not Punish Restaurants For Human Error In Food
Preparation
Voted For Amendment That Would Have Not Punished Restaurants For Human Error In Food
Preparation. In February 2016, Katko voted for an amendment to the Common Sense Nutrition
Disclosure Act which would “ensures that businesses will not be penalized for inadvertent human error in
preparation or variation of ingredients.” The amendment was accepted 309 to 100. [HR 2017, H Amdt.
942, Vote #79, 2/12/16]
116
Budget Issues
 After declining to take a position on the FY2015 Ryan Budget, Katko declared he
opposed it
 Said debt was immoral, complained nobody was addressing it as he campaigned;
voted against nearly every budget brought to the floor as a congressman.
 Opposed shutting the federal government down, said he would not be the vote that
caused the country to default
Katko spent much of 2014 avoiding taking any discernable position on the FY2015
Ryan Budget, and in the waning days of the the campaign, he declared that he
opposed the budget.
Despite campaigning that his number one issue was the debt, Katko voted against
nearly every budget brought to the floor of the House. While he said the debt was
immoral and attacked congress for raising the debt ceiling, he noted he would not be
the vote that would lead the US to default.
Declared Opposition To The FY2015 Ryan Budget.
Declared Opposition To The FY2015 Ryan Budget. “JK: The Ryan budget: Listen, he has had his
plants going to every single town hall, and I have had tons of people asking me, where do you stand on
the Ryan budget? They want to be able to take that, to show that I support the Ryan budget because I hate
the elderly and I’m going to cut Medicare. Well, it’s not true. I have made it perfectly clear, I am
absolutely against … GR: So you are not for the Ryan budget? JK: No. GR: You don’t support the Ryan
budget? JK: Absolutely not.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse New Times, 10/29/14]
Katko Initially Refused to Take a Position on the Ryan Budget, But Said The “General Concepts”
Were In Line With What He’d Discussed On The Budget
In May 2014, during an interview with the Auburn Citizen Katko refused to take a position on the Ryan
Budget:
THE CITIZEN: Democrats have targeted you looking for a position on (U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan's)
budget proposal being that it is the Republican budget plan and you're a Republican. What are
your views on the plan outlined by Congressman Ryan?
117
KATKO: I will confess that I haven't read the entire thing and I'm not familiar with all the
contours of it. Unless and until I get into Congress, I'm not going to start issuing opinions on
something that is basically a working paper. [Auburn Citizen, 5/15/14]
Katko Doubled Down on Not Taking a Position on the Ryan Budget
In July 2014, Katko continued to refuse to take a position on the Ryan Budget for FY 2015. “I'm
not in Congress and wouldn't have an opportunity to vote on that,” Katko said of the Ryan budget
proposal. [Syracuse Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Said The “General Concepts” Of The Ryan Budget Were What He Discussed As His Budgeting
Mindset. “KATKO: I don’t think you can have a bright-line rule, but I think you have to go and change
the dynamic and change the mindset that it’s okay to have massive debt. I think we have to do everything
in our power to get the debt down and under control. It starts with responsible budget-making. … THE
CITIZEN: Democrats have targeted you looking for a position on (U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan’s) budget
proposal being that it is the Republican budget plan and you’re a Republican. What are your views on the
plan outlined by Congress-man Ryan? KATKO: I will confess that I haven’t read the entire thing and I’m
not familiar with all the contours of it. Unless and until I get into Congress, I’m not going to start issuing
opinions on something that is basically a working paper. The general concepts to me are what I’ve just
discussed. That is reducing the debt and having responsible government spending. I don’t care whose
budget it is or what name is on the budget, that’s what I’m concerned about.” [Interview, The Citizen,
5/15/14]
Called On Congress To “Negotiate A Budget That Meets The Needs Of The American People, And
Address Our Country’s Growing Deficit.” “‘There is no question that we have a heavy agenda ahead of
us this Congress. We need to pass a long-term highway bill, negotiate a budget that meets the needs of the
American people, and address our country’s growing deficit. This legislation will force Members of
Congress to reach across the aisle to negotiate and will ensure that we recommit to addressing the
priorities of the American people,’ concluded Katko.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 10/09/15]
Voted For $1.1 Trillion Bipartisan Budget Agreement To Keep Government Open Through
September 2016
Voted For $1.1 Trillion Overwhelmingly Bipartisan Budget Deal To Keep Government Open
Through September 2016. In December 2015, Katko voted for the omnibus spending package. “The
House on Friday overwhelmingly approved a $1.1 trillion spending package that includes the first major
change approved by Congress to ObamaCare, and keeps the government open through September 2016
… In the end, there was no drama in the 316-113 vote … Only 18 Democrats voted against the spending
bill, while 166 supported it.” [HR 2029, Vote #705, 12/18/15; The Hill, 12/18/15]
Omnibus Bill Would End U.S. Ban On Crude Oil Exports. According to Congressional
Quarterly, “The measure would end the U.S. ban on crude oil exports and would reauthorize
health care and victim compensation programs for 9/11 first-responders.” [CQ, 12/18/15]
118
Omnibus Bill Would Reauthorize 9/11 Responder Compensation Program. According to
Congressional Quarterly, “The measure would end the U.S. ban on crude oil exports and would
reauthorize health care and victim compensation programs for 9/11 first-responders.” [CQ,
12/18/15]
Said He Would Have Voted Against the Murray-Ryan Budget
In July 2014, Katko said that he would have voted against the December 2013 bipartisan budget
commonly known as the Murray-Ryan budget. [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Suggested Support for a Balanced Budget Amendment
In July 2014, Katko told the Post-Standard in an interview that he supports requiring the federal
government not to spend more money than it receives in revenue. [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Said “No One Was Addressing the Budget Deficit”
In February 2014, Katko said he was making the economy and jobs a priority. “No one is addressing the
budget deficit,” Katko said.
“They just keep passing budget after budget with huge debts and huge deficits that if we don’t do
something about it, are going to ensure only one thing: That our children’s future is going to much worse
than ours and we’ve got to do something about that,” Katko continued.
“I think getting our spending under control and our deficit spending and our borrowing from China under
control, unless we do that, we’re going to have a future much worse for our children. I’m concerned about
the future for my children,” Katko said.
“Unless we get it under control, we’re going to have this continuation of this general malaise that we have
in this country. Let’s face it, not many people feel good about the economic situation in our country right
now and that should change. We want it to change and I want it to change and that’s a big thing.” [Auburn
Citizen, 2/18/14]
Attacked Congress for Raising the Debt Ceiling
In February 2014, at a candidate forum in Syracuse hosted by Central New York Conservatives, Inc,
Katko attacked Congress for raising the debt ceiling and said the number one issue in his mind is the
national debt.
“It’s crushing America. We have a $17 trillion debt as Ian (Hunter) mentioned earlier,” he said. “In the
last year alone, they raised the debt ceiling twice. The last time I’m not ever sure they put a cap on it.”
“Basically, what America is offering is a pocket of maxed out credit cards and are doing nothing about it
except borrowing more and spending more and not acknowledging the problem.” [Auburn Citizen, 2/27/14,
2/28/14]
Katko Pleaded Ignorance on the Details of the Fiscal Cliff
119
In July 2014, when asked if he would vote to raise the debt ceiling or raise taxes in order to avoid the
fiscal cliff, Katko said “I don’t know all the details of the fiscal cliff, but I can tell you this much: the debt
is a serious issue and whether or not I’d raise the debt ceiling is something I’d have to determine once I
get there.” [TWC News “Capital Tonight”, 7/3/14]
Said Increasing the Debt was “Immoral”
In April 2014, Katko said, “Our national debt is burgeoning at an unsustainable rate. Raising the debt
without curtailing spending is not fiscally sensible or logical. Delaying huge debts for future generations
is immoral.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Said We Needed to Create More Private Sector Jobs
In April 2014, Katko said, “The economy is still laboring. We need more jobs, especially in the private
sector. All of the programs are there already to facilitate a better economy, but not enough is being done.”
[Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Said Maffei Was Irresponsible with Taxpayer Money
In February 2014 in an op-ed piece published in the Post-Standard, Katko criticized Rep. Maffei for
wasting taxpayer dollars on expensive transportation projects while New York families struggled to make
ends meet.
“Maffei talks a great deal about how all his speculative ideas will improve the Upstate economy. But at
what public cost? And how can a federal government so deep in debt with a pocketful of maxed-out credit
cards ever be able to fund such projects to completion?” Katko wrote.
“Meanwhile, the average Central New York family struggles to make ends meet. We worry about never
ending taxation, rising healthcare costs with no relief in sight, and exorbitant utility bills. Forget about
saving for our children’s college or investing what we will need for our own retirement,” Katko
continued.
“We seem to work more and more but still bring home less and less. And we fear -- perhaps for the first
time in American history - that our children will not end up better off than we are,” Katko wrote. [Katko
Op-ed, Post-Standard, 2/23/14]
Said His Primary Focus Would Be The Debt, Supported An Immediate End To Deficits, But Said
The District Needed More Spending
Said His Primary Focus In Congress Would Be The Debt. “GR: If elected, what kinds of issue areas
would you put most of your attention on? Would it be the debt? Would that be your primary issue? JK: At
least bringing light to it, yes, absolutely, because that really is the future of our country. The other things
that I would like to work on are veterans issues for one, which is a major issue in this country and is
becoming a bigger issue, and several other things, but the debt is primary, job one.” [Interview, Syracuse
New Times, 5/28/14]
120
Said He Supported An Immediate End To Deficits. “Katko is critical of both Republicans and
Democrats for failing to reduce the $17.5 trillion national debt and eliminate annual deficits in the federal
budget. He supports an immediate end to deficit spending, but declined to say whether he will support the
Republican budget blueprint of Rep. Paul Ryan, the House Budget Committee chairman.” [Post Standard,
7/22/14]
Criticized The Debt, Yet Said The District Needed More Spending. “KATKO: I don’t think you can
have a bright-line rule, but I think you have to go and change the dynamic and change the mindset that it’s
okay to have massive debt. I think we have to do everything in our power to get the debt down and under
control. It starts with responsible budget-making. … KATKO: I was just talking to some leaders in
Onondaga County who said that basically, money and funds that they traditionally saw coming into this
district under (former Rep. Jim Walsh) and under (former Rep. Ann Marie Buerkle) just aren’t existent
with Maffei. They just dried up. He’s really not bringing any funds back to the district. I don’t, quite
frankly, know what he’s doing in that regard. But I know one thing for sure: the money’s not coming back
to the district like it used to, that’s for sure. Getting into the majority, it’s just simple math. If you have the
majority of the votes, you have a better chance of get-ting money coming back to the district, which is
going to be important. We need it.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Signed Letter Saying He Wanted To Avoid Another Government Shutdown
Signed A Letter Saying He Wanted To Avoid A Government Shutdown. “Members signing the letter
include: … John Katko, … The letter reads as follows: … With less than two weeks until the September
30 deadline to fund federal government operations, we are writing today to express our strong support for
a funding resolution that will avoid another unnecessary and harmful government shutdown.” [Press
Release, Rep. Costello, 9/23/15]
Said He Would Not Support The Fiscal Brinksmanship That Brought The US Close To Default
Said he Would Not Support The Fiscal Brinksmanship That Brought The US Close To Default.
“But he said he would not support the fiscal brinksmanship that brought the United States close to
defaulting on its debt. ‘I would not let my vote be the one that causes us to default on our debt,’ Katko
said.” [Post Standard, 7/22/14]
Supported Deep Cuts To “Some Agenices, Including The Department Of Education”
Supported Deep Cuts To The Department Of Education. “Here’s a look at where U.S. Rep. Dan
Maffei and challenger John Katko stand on some of the issues in their campaign for the 24th
Congressional District seat. Compiled by Washington correspondent Mark Weiner. JOHN KATKO …
Supports crackdown on waste and fraud at federal agencies and deep spending cuts at some agencies,
including the Department of Education.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Said The Bipartisan Budget Agreement Was “Not Without Flaws,” But “The Best Means Currently
Available”
Said The Bipartisan Budget Agreement Was “Not Without Flaws,” But “The Best Means Currently
Available.” ‘”This bipartisan budget is not without flaws, but I believe that it provides us with the best
121
means currently available to put our country on a path towards a normal, predictable budgeting process.’”
[Press Release, Rep. Katko, 10/28/15]
Voted Against FY16 Democratic Alternative Budget That Invested In Education, Made Healthcare
More Affordable, And Made Medicare More Efficient
Voted Against FY2016 Democratic Alternative Budget Plan. In March 2015, Katko voted against the
Democratic alternative budget that “proposed more investment in education and infrastructure, new taxes
on the wealthiest Americans, and several pet ideas including a higher minimum wage, paid sick leave,
expanded early childhood education and a ban on tax breaks for executives unless they increase their
employees’ wages.” The amendment failed 160 to 264. [H Con Res 27, Vote #139, 3/25/15;
RealClearPolitics, 3/23/15]
Increased Investments In Head Start, Universal Preschool, And College Affordability. “On
education, the Democratic budget would increase investments in Head Start, which provides early
childhood education to low-income children, as well as fund President Obama’s proposal for universal
preschool for children. It would also increase funding aimed at making college more affordable.”
[RealClearPolitics, 3/23/15]
Promoted Obamacare And Made Medicare More Efficient. “While Republicans’ budget fully
repeals Obamacare, turns Medicare into a voucher program and cuts funding to Medicaid, the
Democratic budget promotes Obamacare and maintains Medicare while promoting more efficiency,
Van Hollen said.” [RealClearPolitics, 3/23/15]
Voted Against FY16 Republican Study Committee Budget That Balanced In Six Years, Cut
Retirement Programs, And Called For A Balanced Budget Amendment
Voted Against FY2016 Republican Study Committee Budget. In March 2015, Katko voted against the
Republican Study Committee budget that would cut spending by $7.1 trillion over 10 years. “A
conservative budget released by the House Republican Study Committee (RSC) on Monday would
balance in five years by cutting $7.1 trillion in spending over the next decade. The cuts are much more
than the $5.5 trillion in proposed cuts included in the main House GOP blueprint unveiled last week by
Budget Committee Chairman Tom Price (R-Ga.). The RSC budget, prepared by RSC and Budget
Committee member Marlin Stutzman (R-Ind.), would increase spending for the Pentagon.” The
amendment failed 132 to 294. [H Con Res 27, Vote #138, 3/25/15; The Hill, 3/23/15]
RSC Budget Would Cut FY16 Nondefense Discretionary Spending By $88 Billion Below
Sequestration Levels. “The RSC blueprint would lower nondefense discretionary spending for
domestic programs next year to $405 billion, $88 billion below the baseline set by the 2011 deal.
Altogether, discretionary spending next year would total $975 billion under the RSC’s budget, much
lower than the $1.018 trillion top-line number established by the 2011 law. Over the 10-year window,
the RSC budget would cut nondefense spending by $1.3 trillion and increase defense spending by
$435 billion.” [The Hill, 3/23/15]
RSC Proposed “Aggressive” Budget That Would Balance In Six Years. “Conservative members
of the House Republican caucus outbid their party's official budget Monday, offering a plan to cut
122
planned government spending by more than $7.1 trillion and balance the budget in just six years. The
aggressive plan to cut spending from all areas of government and erase deficits was introduced by the
Republican Study Committee, a group of congressmen organized to push policy to the right.”
[Washington Examiner, 3/23/15]
RSC Budget Balanced By “Cutting More Deeply Into Federal Healthcare And Retirement
Programs.” “The Republican Study Committee on Monday unveiled its plan to cut spending by $7.1
trillion over 10 years, reaching a surplus in six years by cutting more deeply into federal healthcare
and retirement programs as well as domestic agency budgets.” [Reuters, 3/23/15]
RSC Budget Called For Balanced Budget Amendment To The Constitution. “It is the policy of
this resolution that Congress should pass a joint resolution incorporating the provisions set forth in
subsection (b), and send such joint resolution to the States for their approval, to amend the
Constitution of the United States to require an annual balanced budget.” [RSC Budget Proposal,
3/22/15]
Voted Against FY16 Congressional Black Caucus Budget
Voted Against FY16 Congressional Black Caucus Budget. In March 2015, Katko voted against the
Congressional Black Caucus budget that “focuses on increasing economic opportunities through robust
investments in education, infrastructure, affordable housing, domestic manufacturing, small businesses,
and job training. It also protects and enhances social safety net programs…” The amendment failed 120 to
306. [H Con Res 27, Vote #137, 3/25/15; Congressional Black Caucus Website, 3/23/15]
Voted Against FY16 Congressional Progressive Caucus Budget
Voted Against FY16 Congressional Progressive Caucus Budget. In March 2015, Katko voted against
the Congressional Progressive Caucus budget that promised 8.8 million jobs by 2017 and $4 trillion in
deficit reduction. The budget repeals the sequester, cuts taxes for families, closes loopholes for
corporations, reverses pay freezes, expands benefits for federal retirees, and strengthens health care and
retirement programs. The amendment failed 96 to 330. [H Con Res 27, Vote #136, 3/25/15;
Congressional Progressive Caucus Website, accessed 5/06/15]
Voted Against FY16 Budget Amendment Repealing The Affordable Care Act, Slash Pell Grants
And Alter Medicare While Requiring No Offsets For Increased OCO Defense Spending
Voted Against FY16 Budget Amendment To Repeal The Affordable Care Act, Slash Pell Grants
And Alter Medicare While Requiring No Offsets For Increased OCO Defense Spending. In March
2015, Katko voted against a budget alternative known as Price amendment #2 offered as an amendment
on the floor that would repeal the Affordable Care Act, slash Pell grants and alter Medicare while
requiring no offsets for increased OCO defense spending. “Tom Price, R-Ga., also submitted an amended
version that included increased defense funding without requiring cuts in other areas to offset the
spending. Price’s plan increased funding to the Overseas Contingency Operations Fund by $2 billion over
the committee plan, to $96 billion, and requires no offsets. The version that passed out of committee
would have required offsets over $73.5 billion in the OCO fund, which pays for wars and other overseas
123
activities and is not subject to sequester caps.” The resolution passed 219 to 208. [H. Con Res. 27, Vote
#141, 3/25/15; US News and World Report, 3/25/15]
Voted Against FY16 Budget Resolution Repealing The Affordable Care Act, Slash Pell Grants And
Alter Medicare
Voted Against FY16 Republican Budget To Repeal The Affordable Care Act, Slash Pell Grants
And Alter Medicare. In March 2015, Katko voted against the FY16 Republican House budget that
would repeal the Affordable Care Act, slash Pell grants and alter Medicare. “It also includes
parliamentary language, called reconciliation that orders House committees to draft legislation repealing
the Affordable Care Act. Under budget rules, that reconciliation repeal bill cannot be filibustered in the
Senate and would need only a majority vote to pass. The budget would turn Medicaid into block grants to
the states, cutting health care spending for the poor by $900 billion. The food stamp program would also
be turned into block grants and cut by hundreds of billions of dollars. Special education, Pell Grants, job
training and housing assistance would all be cut. Medicare would transition to a system where future
seniors would be encouraged to use government-funded vouchers to purchase insurance in the private
market.” The resolution passed 228 to 199. [H. Con Res. 27, Vote #142, 3/25/15; New York Times,
3/25/15]
Voted Against FY16 GOP Budget Conference Report
Voted Against Republican Conference Report On Budget For Fiscal Year 2016. In April 2015, Katko
voted against a conference report outlining the Republican Congressional budget for fiscal year 2016 and
budget levels for 2017 through 2025. “House and Senate Republicans agreed on a unified budget plan
Wednesday that would allow them to bypass Democrats and send President Barack Obama legislation to
repeal or revise his landmark health-care law. The budget proposal spells out the Republican Party’s
priorities by calling for $5.3 trillion in spending cuts to reach balance in nine years.” An agreement to
pass the Conference Report passed 226 to 197. [S CON RES 11, Vote #183; On Agreeing to the
Conference Report, 4/30/15; Bloomberg, 4/29/15]
Called For $4.1 Trillion In Reductions To Entitlement Programs While War Funding Totaled
$96 Billion. “Of this, $4.1 trillion in reductions would come from programs including entitlements
like Medicare. Discretionary spending in 2016 would be limited to $1.016 trillion, while war funding
would total $96 billion, far above Obama’s request.” [Bloomberg, 4/29/15]
Conference Report Reduced Funding For Pell Grants, Low-Income Housing Assistance
Programs, And Food Stamp Program. “The budget slashes domestic discretionary spending by
trimming away at several major priorities for Democrats. The final bill includes a reduction in funding
for federal Pell Grants and housing programs for low-income earners, and cuts to the Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program, also known as food stamps.” [Washington Post, 4/29/15]
House Republican Budget Would Turn Medicare Into Voucher Program, Denying 402,919
Individuals in NY-24 Access To Medicare’s Guaranteed Benefits. The Republican Budget
Committee “estimates nearly $150 billion in savings by turning Medicare into a voucher program for
anyone 56 years old or younger, an idea previously proposed by Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), the former
Budget Committee chairman. Republicans say their ‘premium support program’ would help control
124
Medicare costs.” The House GOP plan would move Medicare to a voucher program by 2024. There
are 402,919 residents in the NY-24 district under the age of 45. [Politico, 3/17/15; Census, accessed
3/17/15]
House Republican Budget Would Cut Pell Grants, Individuals in NY-24 Received Over $20
Million In Pell Grants in FY 2015. According to New York Times the Republican Budget would
“cut the size of Pell Grants, the popular federal financial aid program for higher education.”
According to USASpending.gov, New York’s Twenty Fourth District received over $20 million in
Pell grant funding in FY2015. [New York Times, 3/17/15; usaspending.gov, accessed 3/17/15]
One-Quarter Of Syracuse University Students Qualified For Federal Pell Grants. “A decade ago,
nearly 70 percent of the university's more than 15,000 undergraduates identified as white; that
percentage is now down to just 55 percent. One-quarter of Syracuse students have low enough
incomes to qualify for federal Pell grants.” [National Journal, 9/29/14]
Constituents In Congressman Katko’s District Are Benefitting From Over $18 Million in
Department Of Veterans Affairs Funding In FY 2015 Alone And The Republican Budget Cut
Veterans Funding Below President’s Request. The budget cuts veterans’ funding below the
President’s request by $1.9 billion for 2016 and $19 billion over ten years, making it more difficult for
the Veterans Administration to provide timely access to quality health care and other benefits and
services. [usaspending.gov, accessed 3/13/15; Committee on the Budget, 3/18/15]
Republican Budget Could Lead To Cuts In Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program. The
House Republican Budget cuts non-defense discretionary programs like the Low Income Home
Energy Assistance Program. By 2025, the budget cuts overall funding for non-defense funding
programs by 25 percent below the amount needed to maintain purchasing power at this year’s level.
[Budget Committee, accessed 3/24/15; Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 4/30/14]
House Republican Budget Would Eliminate Tax Benefits That Provides $802 Million In Relief
To 893,000 New York Families In 2015. In 2015, 893,000 New York families will receive $802
million in tax benefits that would be eliminated after 2017 under the House Republican budgets.
[White House, 3/24/15]
House Republican Budget Would Make It So 2,330 Fewer New York Children Have Access To
Head Start. The House Republican budget proposal, which maintains sequestration levels for
domestic discretionary spending, would make it so 2,330 fewer New York children have access to
Head Start services. [White House, 3/24/15]
House Republican Budget Would Make It So 130,600 Fewer New York Residents Have Access
To Job Training & Employment Services. The House Republican budget proposal, which maintains
sequestration levels for domestic discretionary spending, would deny job training and employment
services for 130,600 New York residents. [White House, 3/24/15]
House Republican Budget Would Increase Prescription Drug Costs For As Many As 353,100
New York Residents. The House Republican budget proposal, which repeals the Affordable Care
Act, would reopen the Medicare prescription drug donut hole. Closing the donut hole helped 353,100
125
New York seniors and people with disabilities save an average of $1,080 in 2014 alone. [White
House, 3/24/15]
Voted For Amendment Allowing Republican Leaders To Fast-Track Stopgap Spending Bill
Voted For Amendment Allowing Republican Leaders To Fast-Track Stopgap Spending Bill. In
September 2015, Katko voted for consideration of an amendment to H.Res.420. “CR Could be FastTracked Under Rule Passed by House …. The House Thursday quietly granted itself a method for
speeding consideration of legislation after the papal visit next week, presumably for a must-pass stopgap
spending bill. The chamber approved an amendment to a rule (H Res 420) that waives the requirement
that two-thirds of lawmakers vote to allow the House Rules Committee to bring a report to the floor the
same day it is advanced out of the panel.” The amendment passed 237 to 187. [H.Res. 420, Vote #498,
9/17/15; CQ News, 9/17/15]
Voted For Short-Term Continuing Resolution To Prevent Government Shutdown.
Voted For Short-Term Continuing Resolution To Prevent Government Shutdown. In September
2015, Katko voted for a motion to concur in the Senate amendment to the bill that would continue funding
the government through Dec. 11, 2015 at an annualized rate of $1,017 trillion, the top-line post-sequester
discretionary spending level for FY 2016 set by the Budget Control Act. It also would fund for Overseas
Contingency Operations at a rate of $74.8 billion, roughly equal to the FY 2015 level. Under the bill,
most programs would be funded at a rate that is 0.21 percent less than their FY 2015 funding level,
although the measure would include increases for certain activities including $700 million in emergency
funding for fighting fire in western states; it would give the VA budget flexibility in constructing a facility
in Denver, and would not defund Planned Parenthood. Further, the measure would extend through Dec.
11 the ban on state taxation of Internet access and the E-Verify employment verification system. The
motion was agreed to by a vote of 277-151. [HR 719, Vote #528, 9/30/15; CQ Floor Votes, 9/30/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Clean Debt Limit Extension That Would Avoid A
Government Default
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Clean Debt Limit Extension That Would Avoid A
Government Default. In October 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of a clean debt limit
extension that would avoid a government default and an increase of interest rates on mortgages, student
loans, credit cards, and car payments. The previous question passed, 241 to 181. A vote against the
previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H.Res. 480, Vote #553, 10/21/15;
Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 10/21/15]
Voted For Debt Limit Bill Forcing Gov’t Shutdown By Only Paying Nation’s Creditors And Social
Security Recipients, Ignoring Military Members And Medicare Recipients
Voted For Debt Limit Bill That Would Only Allow Payments For The Nation’s Creditors And
Social Security Recipients. In October 2015, Katko voted for the Default Prevention Act, a bill that
would force a partial government shutdown by only funding payments towards the nation’s creditors and
Social Security recipients. “With less than two weeks until the federal government is expected to reach its
126
borrowing limit, House Republican leaders are readying a vote on legislation intended to avoid a financial
meltdown should that ceiling be reached. … The Default Prevention Act … would allow the federal
government to keep borrowing above the statutory debt limit for the sole purpose of paying principal and
interest on debt held by the public or the Social Security Trust Fund.” The bill passed, 235 to 194. [HR
692, Vote #557, 10/21/15; Washington Post, 10/16/15]
Bill Criticized For Being A “Cop-Out” And Prioritizing Foreign Bondholders Over Military
Members, Medicare, And Medicaid Recipients. “Democrats oppose the bill, calling it a cop-out that
would pave the way for a partial government shutdown where military members and federal workers
would go without paychecks, doctors and hospitals would go without Medicaid and Medicare
payments, and federal contractors would be hung out to dry. Rep. Sander M. Levin (D-Mich.), ranking
member of Ways and Means, called the bill ‘reckless and indefensible’ last month and doubted
whether the bill could even be implemented under current Treasury systems and procedures. ‘Even if
such prioritization were possible, it would put China and other foreign bondholders before our own
citizens at a time when they can least afford it,’ he said.” [Washington Post, 10/16/15]
Bill Falls “Far Short Of The Needed Debt-Limit Increase.” “With the potential for an
unprecedented federal default two weeks away, House Republicans on Wednesday plan to pass
legislation not to avert disaster, but rather to manage it… Yet with time running out, what the House
will vote on Wednesday and send to the Senate falls far short of the needed debt-limit increase. …
Privately, some Republicans concede the vote is a way for members to seem to oppose default.
Douglas Holtz-Eakin, an economics adviser to Republicans and the former director of the
nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, called it ‘political cover but not a solution of any type.
There’s no way that you can pretend that taking out the Pentagon budget and a huge chunk of the
domestic budget is not going to be damaging,’ he said.” [New York Times, 10/20/15]
HEADLINE: “House GOP Brings Back Debt Ceiling Cop-Out Bill For A Floor Vote This
Week” [Talking Points Memo, 10/19/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Clean Debt Limit Extension
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Clean Debt Limit Extension. In October, 2015, Katko voted
for blocking consideration of a vote on “a clean debt limit extension.” The previous question carried, 244185. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on a clean debt limit bill. [HR 3762 Vote
#566, 10/22/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 10/22/15]
Voted For Motion That Would Have Replaced HR 1314 With Bill Suspending Debt Limit Until
March 2017 And Increasing Discretionary Spending Cap
{Voted For/Voted Against/Voted Present/Did Not Vote On}} Motion That Would Have Replaced
HR 1314 With Bill Suspending Debt Limit Until March 2017 And Increasing Discretionary
Spending Cap. Katko voted for “motion to concur in the Senate amendment to the bill with a modified
Boehner amendment that would replace the bill with legislation that would suspend the debt limit until
March 15, 2017 and increase the discretionary spending cap for fiscal 2016 by $50 billion and for fiscal
2017 by $30 billion, with the increases split equally between defense and non-defense spending.” The
motion passed 266 to 167. [HR 1314, Vote #579, 10/28/15; CQ Billtrack, 11/04/15]
127
Motion Included The Sale Of Oil From The Strategic Petroleum Reserve. “Offsets through
mandatory spending cuts and revenue increases would include increasing premiums companies pay to
the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation to insure private pension plans, the sale of oil from the
Strategic Petroleum Reserve, and changes to the federal crop insurance program. It would prevent an
estimated 52 percent premium increase for certain Medicare beneficiaries and instead provide for a
lower increase, and would make changes to keep the Social Security disability insurance trust solvent
until 2022. Motion agreed to 266-167. Note: A ‘yea’ was a vote in support of the president's position.”
[CQ Billtrack, 11/04/15]
Voted For Amendment Liquidating The Federal Reserve’s Surplus Funds, Redirecting $59.5 Billion
Over Ten Years To The General Fund
Voted For Amendment Liquidating The Federal Reserve’s Surplus Funds, Redirecting $59.5 Billion
Over Ten Years To The General Fund. In November 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the
Fixing America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act introduced by Representatives Randy Neugebauer
(R., Texas) and Bill Huizenga (R., Mich.) which would “liquidate the Fed’s surplus account and transfer it
to the Treasury. Aides to both lawmakers said the provision would generate about $59.5 billion over 10
years.” The amendment passed 354 to 72. [H R 22, Vote #622, 11/05/15; Wall Street Journal, 11/05/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Holding A Hearing For The President’s FY16 Budget
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Holding A Hearing For The President’s FY16 Budget. In
March 2016, Katko voted for blocking consideration of holding a hearing for the Obama Administration’s
fiscal year 2017 budget proposal. “The Democratic Previous Question gives Republicans a third chance to
call for an immediate vote on Budget Committee Ranking Member Chris Van Hollen’s H.R. 624 to
demand a fair hearing on the President’s Budget by demanding that House Republicans hold a Budget
hearing with the Director of the Office of Management and Budget.” [H Res 635, Vote #106, 3/03/16;
OP-ED HEADLINE: “Republicans Shouldn’t Ignore The President’s Budget” [Ed Rogers OpEd, Washington Post, 2/09/16]
HEADLINE: “White House Accuses GOP Lawmakers Of Pulling A Trump” [Politico, 2/05/16]
Voted Against Requiring Report On Treasury’s Plans To Address Federal Deficit To Include
Impact Of Threat Of Default On Economy
Voted Against RequiringReport On Treasury’s Plans To Address Federal Deficit To Include
Impact Of Threat Of Default On Economy. In February 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to
require the report on treasury’s plans to address federal deficit to include the impact of the threat of
default on the economy. The amendment would have required “the report to include the impact the threat
of default would have on the economy, including, but not limited to, the impact on the Gross Domestic
Product (GDP), interest rates, employment, household wealth, and retirement assets.” The amendment
failed 190 to 227. [HR 3442, Vote #74, 2/11/16; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 2/11/16]
128
Bill Required Treasury Secretary To Prepare A Report For Congress About Plans To
Address The Federal Deficit Before Congress Agrees To Raise The Debt Limit. “House
lawmakers Thursday 267-151 passed legislation that would require the Treasury secretary to
appear before Congress prior to raising the debt limit. The Obama administration has threatened a
veto of the bill, which now goes to the Senate. But it picked up support from all 239 Republicans
who voted and 28 Democrats … The legislation (HR 3442), sponsored by Rep. Kenny Marchant,
R-Texas, would require the secretary to come before the Ways and Means Committee when the
nation approaches the debt limit and present a report to Congress on the state of the public debt …
The proposal also would require the secretary to outline the president's plans to reduce the debt
and prepare a subsequent progress report. All the information would be posted publicly on the
Treasury's website.” [Congressional Quarterly News, 2/11/16]
Voted Against Requiring Treasury Secretary’s Report To Include Information On Salary, Wages,
And Impact Of Spending Cuts On Gross Domestic Product
Voted Against Requiring Treasury Secretary’s Report To Include Information On Salary, Wages,
And Impact Of Spending Cuts On Gross Domestic Product. In February 2016, Katko voted against an
amendment to require the treasury secretary’s report to include information on salary, wages, and impact
of spending cuts on gross domestic product. The amendment sought to “require the Treasury Secretary's
report to also include individual salary and wage information, as well as projections of consumer
spending and the impact of spending cuts on gross domestic product.” The amendment failed 171 to 245.
[HR 3442, Vote #73, 2/11/16; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 2/11/16]
Voted For Requiring Treasury Secretary To Notify Congress Whether Treasury Is Able To Pay
Principal And Interest On National Debt If Debt Limit Is Reached
Voted For Requiring Treasury Secretary To Notify Congress If Treasury Is Able To Pay Principal
And Interest On National Debt If Debt Limit Is Reached. In February 2016, Katko voted for an
amendment to require the Treasury Secretary to notify Congress whether Treasury is able to pay principal
and interest on the national debt if the debt limit is reached. The amendment requires “the Secretary of the
Treasury to notify Congress whether it is able to pay only principal and interest on the national debt, as
opposed to other obligations, in the event that the debt limit is reached.” The amendment passed 240 to
176. [HR 3442, Vote #72, 2/11/16; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 2/11/16]
Voted For Requiring Treasury Secretary’s Report To Include Potential Public Health And Safety
Costs Of Failing To Raise Debt Limit
Voted For Requiring Treasury Secretary’s Report To Include Potential Public Health And Safety
Costs Of Failing To Raise Debt Limit. In February 2016, Katko voted for an amendment to require the
Treasury Secretary’s report to include the potential public health and safety costs of failing to raise the
debt limit. The amendment “sought to require the Treasury Secretary's report to also include an economic
forecast of the negative consequences of failing to raise the debt limit, including costs associated with
public health and safety.” The amendment failed 184 to 234. [HR 3442, Vote #71, 2/11/16; On Agreeing
to the Amendment, 2/11/16]
129
Voted For To Block Hearing On President’s Budget With Director Of The Office Of Management
And Budget
Voted For To Block Hearing On President’s Budget With Director Of The Office Of Management
And Budget. In February 2016, Katko voted for a motion to block consideration of a vote on Budget
Committee Ranking Member Chris Van Hollen’s H.R. 6234, which would “demand a fair hearing on the
President’s Budget by demanding that House Republicans hold a budget hearing with the Director of the
Office of Management and Budget.” The previous question carried, 237-180. A vote against the previous
question would call for an immediate vote on Budget Committee Ranking Member Chris Van Hollen’s
H.R. 624. [H Res 618, Vote #85, 02/24/16; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 2/24/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Call On Hearings For President’s Budget
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Call On Hearings For President’s Budget. In February
2016, Katko voted for blocking consideration of H. Res. 619, an ordering of the previous question on HR
2406. “The Democratic Previous Question gives Republicans a second chance to call for an immediate
vote on Budget Committee Ranking Member Chris Van Hollen’s H.R. 624 to demand a fair hearing on
the President’s Budget by demanding that House Republicans hold a Budget hearing with the Director of
the Office of Management and Budget.” The previous question passed, 240 to 178. [H.Res.619, Vote #90,
2/25/16; Democratic Leader-Ordering of Previous Question, 2/25/16]
Voted For The Debt Management and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2015 Which Required Treasury
Department To Report To Congress
Voted For The Debt Management and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2015 Which Required Treasury
Department To Report To Congress. In February 2016, Katko voted for the bill that “requires the
Secretary of the Treasury to provide a report to Congress prior to any date on which the Secretary
anticipates the public debt will reach the statutory limit. The Secretary must appear before the House
Ways and Means Committee and the Senate Finance Committee to submit a report including: the historic,
current, and projected levels of the debt; the drivers and composition of future debt; and how the United
States will meet debt obligations if the debt limit is raised.” The legislation “the Debt Management and
Fiscal Responsibility Act, sponsored by Rep. Kenny Marchant, R-Texas. The bill would require the
Treasury Department to provide reports to Congress and the public detailing the federal government’s
historic, current and projected future debt levels, as well as information about when the debt will reach its
statutory limit.” The bill passed 267 to 151. [HR 3442, Vote #76, 2/11/16; Targeted News Service,
2/12/16]
130
Campaign Finance and Election Law Issues
 Lambasted Maffei for taking money from Washington, DC, saying, “You
are where you get your money from[,]” but, as a congressman, embraced
special interest funding and, according to the Post Standard, “made no
apologies.”
 Supported campaign finance reform, supported finance limits, and
suggested restricting commercials to the final 30 days of a campaign.
Katko lambasted Maffei for taking money from Washington DC, saying, “You are
where you get your money from. Then, as a congressman, he embraced special
interest funding and, according to the Post Standard, “made no apologies.” The
Post Standard ran a story on Katko’s campaign finances dubbing him
“Washington’s New PAC Man.”
Katko said generally he supports campaign finance reform, but opposed public
financing. He noted he would support limiting commercials to the last 30 days of a
campaign, and limiting spending.
Supported Campaign Finance Reform
In July 2014, Katko said that he would like to limit the power of interest groups and Super
PACs in elections, but did not offer any solutions for achieving that goal.
“I think it’s very troubling to see the amount of money it takes to run for Congress,” Katko
said. “It puts a challenger at a distinct disadvantage […] But that being said, I think it will be
difficult to limit this (campaign spending) going forward.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Headline: “Washington’s New PAC Man”
Headline: Washington’s New PAC Man. [Post Standard, 5/12/15]
Headline: Special-interest groups flood Rep. John Katko with campaign cash from
Washington. [Post Standard, 05/08/15]
Contributions
131
Contributions. “Katko said a vast majority of the contributions to his campaign -- 80 percent -- came
from central New Yorkers. He noted that a large portion of the money Maffei received during the
campaign has come from outside of the district. ‘You are where you get your money from,’ he said. ‘I am
central New York and that’s where my money came from.’” [The Citizen, 11/03/14]
Said Maffei’s DC Donations Show “He Is Washington.” “’I get my donations from where I
live; Dan Maffei gets his donations from where he lives,’ added Katko. ‘It says a lot about our
primary interests and priorities. But it also says that Dan Maffei cannot change Washington
because he is Washington.’” [Press Release, Katko For Congress, 10/16/14]
Campaign Finance Watchdog: Committee Assignments Were Meant To Allow Katko To
Boost His Fundraising, Katko Is Playing The Inside Game. “Craig Holman, who advocates
for campaign finance reform for the group Public Citizen in Washington, said it's clear the
PACs want to influence Katko's vote on two key committee posts. ‘He is on two committees
that have a lot of financial interests at stake,’ Holman said. ‘The corporations want to influence
him and, in a sense, get in his pocket. He's now playing the insider game.’ But Holman, of
Public Citizen, said he was surprised to see Katko relied on PACs for such a large percentage
(62 percent) of the cash he received. ‘It helps him because he won't have to work so hard at
fundraising anymore, because these companies are going to throw money at his feet,’ Holman
said. He said Katko's committee assignments were part of a strategic move by House
Republican leaders to boost fundraising for a vulnerable freshman. ‘He is playing the inside
game, and any opponent will attack him for it,’ Holman said. ‘Sixty-two percent is lot of
money to come in from PACs.’” [Post Standard, 5/08/15]
Post Standard: Katko Criticized Special Interest Money During The Campaign, Accepted
It, And “Made No Apologies.” “Now Katko is reaping the same benefits of incumbency that
he once criticized, taking advantage of a campaign finance system where wealthy specialinterest groups line up to donate millions of dollars to influence members of Congress. Katko
makes no apologies for accepting the money, and emphasizes that two-thirds of his donors (not
total cash contributions) are people who either live or work in the 24th District.” [Post
Standard, 5/08/15]
Rejected Maffei’s Proposal To Limit Outside Money
Maffei Challenged Katko To Reject Outside Money, By Donating Half The Amount
Outside Groups Spend To Charity. “U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei asked Republican challenger John
Katko to sign a pledge calling on outside groups that don't disclose their donors to not spend
money on the race, while Katko wants Maffei to agree to a series of debates hosted by
independent groups that would allow the candidates to discuss the issues. … If outside groups
do invest in the race, the pledge states that the candidates would use their own campaign
accounts to donate half of the amount spent on advertising by the group to a charity of their
opponent's choice” [The Citizen, 4/26/14]
Katko Rejected The Pledge, Nonetheless Tried To Hold Maffei To It. “Republican
Congressional candidate John Katko is trying to hold Rep. Dan Maffei to a clean campaign pledge
132
the congressman proposed early in the campaign. … Katko never signed the pledge, saying he
couldn’t afford to follow an aspect of it that called for the equivalent of half of outside money that
came from unnamed sources spent on the race to be donated to charity.” [WVRO, 10/15/14]
Said He Couldn’t Sign The Pledge Due To Monetary Disadvantage. “JK: Sure, this
pledge he is talking about is when he had $900,000 in the bank and I had none and he is
asking me to sign off on something that I couldn’t sign off on. I couldn’t agree to it at
that time.” [Debate Transcript, WVRO, 10/19/14]
Supported Campaign Finance Reform, But Had No Opinion On How To Do So, Except Opposing
Publically-Financed Campaigns
Supported Campaign Finance Reform, But Had No Opinion On How To Do So, Except Opposing
Publically-Financed Campaigns. “Katko has railed against public financing of campaigns. … Katko
said he is undecided on the best way to limit the influence of super PACs and special-interest groups. ‘I
think it’s very troubling to see the amount of money it takes to run for Congress,’ Katko said in July. ‘It
puts a challenger at a distinct disadvantage. Our Founding Fathers probably never envisioned anything
like this. It’s clear everyone is sick of it. But that being said, I think it will be difficult to limit this
(campaign spending) going forward because the Supreme Court has spoken on this issue.’” [Post
Standard, 10/19/14]
Post Standard: Supported “Limit[ing] The Influence” On Interest Groups And Super PACs, But
Was “Undecided” On “Best Way To Achieve That Goal”
Post Standard: Supported Campaign Finance “Limit[ing] The Influence’s On Interest Groups And
Super PACs, But Was “Undecided” On “Best Way To Achieve That Goal.” “Katko said he would
support efforts to limit the influence of Super PACs and special interest groups on elections. But he is
undecided on the best way to achieve that goal.” [Post Standard, 7/22/14]
Supported Campaign Limits, Including Limiting Campaign Commercials To The Last 30 Days;
Acknowledged The Constitutional Difficulties
Proposed Limiting Campaign Commercials Until The Last 30 Days, And Campaign Limits.
“Congressman John Katko, whose district includes Wayne County, spent a very full day visiting and
assisting constituents on Thursday … I would love to. I’d love to have for example, a much shorter term
in the election cycle…like…you can’t run commercials until 30 days before the election. That would
naturally cut down on the amount of money you need to run. I think it would be great! I think that
campaign limits — if you could enforce them somehow — would be great. Anytime you do that you get
into Freedom of Speech issues.” [Wayne County Times Interview, 8/29/15]
Voted For Blocking Constitutional Amendment To Overturn Citizens United
Voted For Blocking Constitutional Amendment To Overturn Citizens United. In January 2015,
Katko voted for blocking a motion to require Congress to vote on a constitutional amendment to overturn
the Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision and promote transparency in our political system. The
133
be considered. [H Res 38, Vote #38, 1/21/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 1/21/15]
Voted For To Block Restoration Of Federal Oversight To Protect The Right To Vote
Voted For To Block Restoration Of Federal Oversight To Protect The Right To Vote. In November
2015, Katko voted for a motion to block consideration of a vote on the “Voting Rights Advancement Act,
which would restore federal oversight to protect the most sacred right and responsibility of American
citizenship; the right to vote.” The previous question carried, 241-178. A vote against the previous
question would call for an immediate vote on the Voting Rights Advancement Act. [H Res 507, Vote
#583, 11/03/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 11/03/15]
Voted For Consideration Of A Constitutional Amendment To Bring Increased Transparency To
Outside Spending In Elections
Voted For Consideration Of A Constitutional Amendment To Bring Increased Transparency To
Outside Spending In Elections. In November 2015, Katko voted for a motion to consider “a
constitutional amendment to bring increased transparency to outside spending in our elections.” The
previous question passed, 245 to 178. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the
amendment to be considered. [H Res 526, Vote #629, 11/17/15; DemocraticLeader.gov, 11/17/15]
134
Criminal Justice
 Supported mandatory minimum criminal sentencings and blamed the softening of
mandatory minimums for an increase in crime
 Opposed marijuana legalization
 Held heroin summits in his district
Katko supported mandatory minimum sentencing and blamed changes softening
them for an increase in crime. Katko opposed marijuana legalization. Katko held
heroin summits in his district.
Supported Mandatory Minimums, Blamed The Softening Of Mandatory Minimums For An
Increase In Crime
Said Mandatory Minimums Had Been Eliminated For Those Trafficking Large Quantities Of
Cocaine. “I’m very much a law-and-order guy and I’m not insensitive to people getting thrown in prison
for long sentences. But if someone is trafficking five kilos of cocaine, that’s hundreds of thousands of
individual doses of cocaine on the street. That person is a huge danger to our country. For them not to
have a mandatory minimum sentence is beyond me. We’ve gotten rid of those. I think we need to start
taking a look again at some of the sentencing guidelines because a lot of them have been watered down
and are leading to crime increases.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Said Softening Mandatory Minimums Led To An Increase In Crime. “I’m very much a law-and-order
guy and I’m not insensitive to people getting thrown in prison for long sentences. But if someone is
trafficking five kilos of cocaine, that’s hundreds of thousands of individual doses of cocaine on the street.
That person is a huge danger to our country. For them not to have a mandatory minimum sentence is
beyond me. We’ve gotten rid of those. I think we need to start taking a look again at some of the
sentencing guidelines because a lot of them have been watered down and are leading to crime increases.”
Blamed An Increase In Violent Crime On Softening Mandatory Minimums And Inaction On
Immigration. “KATKO: I have a huge background in law enforcement. But the big thing that is kind of a
secret that really hasn’t been made public yet is that under the Obama administration, after 20 years of
steady decline in violent crime rates, they’re going back up. I think there’s a direct correlation between
that and their softening of some of the mandatory minimums in drug crimes and also some of the things
they are doing - or not doing - with respect to immigration and other things.” [Interview, The Citizen,
5/15/14]
135
Criticized Sentencing Reforms That Released Prisoners
The Independent Sentencing Commission Made New Guidelines Resulting In Prisoner Release.
“But court records for the Northern District of New York confirm that 47 inmates in the region were part
of the first wave of prisoners with reduced sentences who were released Nov. 1. … The changes are the
result of new sentencing guidelines for most federal drug offenders approved by the independent U.S.
Sentencing Commission in 2014. The commission made the new guidelines retroactive, suggesting that
previous mandatory minimum sentences were too strict and led to over-crowding of federal prisons.”
[Post Standard, 11/22/15]
Said He Didn’t Know How One could “Say Any Gang Member Is Not A Violent Offender.” “He
said several of the inmates released Nov. 1 should not qualify as nonviolent drug offenders. ‘I don’t know
how you can say any gang member is not a violent offender,’ Katko said in an interview. ‘There’s always
a risk they can go back to that kind of activity. These are all high-level drug dealers.’” [Post Standard,
11/22/15]
Said Prison Reform Was “Going Way Below Low-Level Drug Users,” And “Some Of Them Are
Very Violent.” “Katko said many people mistakenly believe federal drug offenders released early as part
of the prison reform effort are low-level dealers or users. ‘They’re going way beyond low-level drug
users,’ Katko said of the reform initiative. ‘The ones being released here are all organized criminals, and
some of them are very violent.’” [Post Standard, 11/22/15]
Questioned Police Militarization After Ferguson
Questioned Police Militarization After Ferguson. “Before Ferguson, the 23-year federal prosecutor
John Katko would have said it was a good idea to give local police surplus military equipment for
protection. After Ferguson, candidate for Congress Katko says, there should be a dialogue about
militarizing the police. In a meeting with The Post-Standard’s editorial board, Katko used the question
about police equipment as an example of an opinion that could be swayed by events and the opinions of
others. In Ferguson, Mo., police last month rode an armored vehicle into a protest over the shooting of
Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager. Katko, who led a task force targeting gangs, said he worried
each time friends and colleagues put on bullet-proof vests and headed out to make an arrest. ‘If they had
to be in armored suits, I’d say absolutely,’ he said. ‘But when I heard the discontent about Ferguson and
the overmilitarization of police, I don’t know if I softened a bit, but I said we need to have that dialogue.’”
Expressed Concern On The Relocation Of A Halfway House To The Federal Bureau Of Prisons
Expressed Concern On The Relocation Of A Halfway House To The Federal Bureau Of Prisons.
“U.S. Congressman John Katko (NY-24) today expressed grave concern for the relocation of a
Residential Reentry Center (RRC) and Home Detention Services, commonly known as a halfway house,
to the City of Syracuse’s Tipperary Hill Neighborhood. Rep. Katko this week outlined his position in a
phone call with the Federal Bureau of Prisons.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 8/24/15]
Touted The Passage of Anti-Human-Trafficking Legislation He Co-Sponsored
136
Touted The Passage Of Anti-Human-Trafficking Legislation He Co-Sponsored. “The U.S. House of
Representatives yesterday passed a series of bipartisan measures to combat human trafficking and provide
much-needed services to human trafficking victims. Rep. Katko served as an original co-sponsor on two
of the bills, HR 350, the Human Trafficking Prevention, Intervention & Recovery Act and HR 460, the
Human Trafficking Detection Act. ‘Human trafficking is a modern-day version of slavery – and as a
former federal organized crime prosecutor, I’ve seen its horrors within the borders of the United States,’
said Congressman Katko. ‘I’m proud to serve as an original co-sponsor on comprehensive legislation to
raise awareness of these heinous crimes, boost protections for domestic human trafficking victims, and
combat exploitations in the United States.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 1/28/15; HR350, 1/28/15;
HR460, 5/14/15]
Spoke At A Former Gang Member’s Graduation, Applauded His Progress
Spoke At A Former Gang Member’s Graduation, Applauded His Progress. “Quante Wright went
from prisoner to college graduate in a matter of three years. A former Brighton Brigade gang member in
Syracuse, N.Y., Wright pleaded guilty to more than a dozen charges, including attempted murder and
selling crack cocaine. … In Wright’s new chapter, he has a surprising supporter. Rep. John Katko, RN.Y., formerly a federal prosecutor, led the task force to incarcerate Wright ten years ago. This year,
Katko sought out Wright only to praise him in a commencement speech at Wright’s graduation, the
Syracuse Post- Standard reported. ‘Quante. Where are you?’ Katko said to the crowd. ‘I want to tell you
I’m very proud of you. Keep it up.’ Wright’s life after prison shows that the transition from prison back to
a regular life is not easy, but is possible. And Katko will be watching for even more achievements from
Wright. ‘I’ll be applauding the loudest,’ Katko said.” [Washington Examiner, 6/15/15]
Said Tougher Legislation Was Needed On Synthetic Marijuana And Was Being Contemplated
Said Tougher Legislation Was Needed On Synthetic Marijuana And Was Being Contemplated. “He
said tougher federal laws are needed to combat synthetic drugs and legislation is in the works, but he
doesn’t think it’s enough to combat this ‘growing epidemic’ in the city of Syracuse and throughout
Central New York. … Katko said legislation is being contemplated, but he wants tougher federal laws. He
plans to meet with senior officials of the Drug Enforcement Administration. ‘Instead of trying to play a
cat-and-mouse game all the time, we need to try and find a more global solution,’ Katko said. ‘We are
taking this seriously.’” [Post Standard, 4/21/15]
Held Heroin Summits In His District Said Heroin Usage Was Not Centered In The Inner Cities And
His Office Could Help By Raising Awareness
Held Heroin Summits In His District. “U.S. Congressman John Katko (NY-24) today announced that
he will host a heroin summit next week where community members will have an opportunity to discuss
the spike in local heroin use with a panel of parents, educators, healthcare providers, law enforcement
officials, and local advocates. … Earlier this year, Rep. Katko held a Listening Session to Initiate a
Community Conversation on Heroin.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 6/23/15]
Said Heroin Was “One Of The Biggest Issues,” And That “You’d Think Drug Addicts Are
Centered In The Inner Cities. Its Not The Case.” “U.S. Rep. John Katko didn’t hesitate when asked
about the impact of the heroin epidemic on com-munities throughout central New York. …‘It’s one of the
137
biggest issues we have,’ he said in a recent interview with The Citizen. ‘What people have to recognize is
that the heroin epidemic in this country is not in the inner cities,’ Katko, R-Camillus, said. ‘In the old
days, you’d see a movie on TV and you’d think drug addicts are centered in the inner cities. It’s not the
case. Heroin has infected high schools throughout the country. West Genesee, Fayetteville-Manlius, all of
them. They all have heroin problems in their high schools. Auburn is no exception.’” [The Citizen,
11/22/15]
Said His Office Could Raise Awareness And Inform Constituents About Heroin. “As for what else
his office can do, Katko said raising awareness and informing constituents about the rise in heroin abuse
is important. ‘It’s an epidemic and it’s not going away,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 11/22/15]
Held A Press Conference On Synthetic Drug Use
Held A Press Conference On Synthetic Drug Use. “U.S. Rep. John Katko is joining forces with local
officials, including Onondaga County District At-torney William Fitzpatrick, to crack down on synthetic
drugs. Katko, R-Camillus, held a press conference Monday with Fitzpatrick to highlight the rise in
synthetic drug use and what steps federal, state and local officials are taking to tackle the problem.” [The
Citizen, 12/16/15]
Supported A Bill To “Increase The Number Of Addicts Medical Professionals Can Treat”
Supported A Bill To “Increase The Number Of Addicts Medical Professionals Can Treat.” “A bill
supported by Katko aims to increase the number of addicts medical professionals can treat. The Recovery
Enhancement for Addiction Treatment Act would also allow nurse practitioners and physician assistants
to treat patients struggling with drug addiction. The Department of Health and Human Services revised
regulations to provide more access to heroin addiction treatment. But Katko and his colleagues are still
pushing the TREAT Act, which has been referred to two committees for review.” [The Citizen, 11/22/15]
Opposed Marijuana Legalization, Calling It A “Gateway Drug”
Opposed Marijuana Legalization, Calling It As A “Gateway Drug.” “Katko, 51, of Camillus, is the
Republican candidate for the 24th Congressional District. He is seeking to unseat Rep. Dan Maffei, 46, a
Syracuse Democrat. In discussing other issues with the editorial board: He opposes legalization of
marijuana. Even though use is an issue being sorted out state by state, he said federal prose-cutors track
large-scale sales. He said despite evidence to the contrary, he knows in his heart that it is a gateway drug.”
Voted Against Motion That Provided Additional Funding For Programs Including Sexual Assault,
Violence Against Women And Missing And Exploited Children
Voted Against Motion That Provided Additional Funding For Programs Including Sexual Assault,
Violence Against Women And Missing And Exploited Children. In June 2015, Katko voted against
motion that would provide an additional $3 million for sexual assault victims assistance within the
Violence Against Women Prevention and Prosecution Programs account and an additional $3 million for
missing and exploited children programs in the Juvenile Justice Programs account. It would decrease
138
funding for the Justice Information Technology Account by $6 million. The amendment failed, 190 to
232. [HR 2578, Vote #296, 6/03/15; CQ, 6/03/15]
Voted For An Amendment That Prohibited The DOJ And DEA From Enforcement Actions Against
Commercial Hemp Growers
Voted For An Amendment That Prohibited The DOJ And DEA From Enforcement Actions Against
Commercial Hemp Growers. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that prohibited the DOJ and
DEA from taking enforcement actions against commercial hemp growers. The amendment passed 289 to
Voted Against Amendment That Proposed Cutting Funding In The Commerce-Justice-Science
Appropriations Bill By 2.48 Percent
Voted Against Amendment That Proposed Cutting Funding In The Commerce-Justice-Science
Appropriations Bill By 2.48 Percent. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that proposed
cutting funding in the Commerce-Justice-Science appropriations bill by 2.48%. The amendment failed
134 to 290. [HR 2578, Vote #292; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15]
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Have Prohibited The Department Of Justice From
Preventing States From Establishing Their Own Rules Governing The Use, Distribution,
Cultivation Or Possession Of Marijuana
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Have Prohibited The Department Of Justice From
Preventing States From Establishing Their Own Rules Governing The Use, Distribution,
Cultivation Or Possession Of Marijuana. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that that
would have prohibited the Department of Justice from preventing states from establishing their own rules
governing the use, distribution, cultivation or possession of marijuana. “Marijuana advocates have their
sights set on legalization after lawmakers approved a number of pot-friendly measures Wednesday in a
government spending bill. The marijuana vote-a-rama was capped off by a provision that would prohibit
the Department of Justice (DOJ) from interfering with state medical marijuana laws. But it’s a marijuana
amendment that was rejected that has pot advocates even more excited. A provision that would have
blocked the Justice Department from interfering with state laws permitting the use of recreational
marijuana came just a few votes shy of passing. The measure would have essentially ended the federal
prohibition on pot, advocates say … An amendment from Reps. Tom McClintock (R-Calif.) and Jared
Polis (D-Colo.) would have blocked the DOJ from interfering with any state marijuana law, including
laws that permit the recreational use of pot. The provision failed, but not before garnering 206 votes, just
a handful shy of the number needed to be approved.” The amendment failed 206 to 222. [HR 2578, Vote
#285; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15; The Hill, 6/03/15]
Voted Against An Amendment That Stopped Use Of Federal Funds To Prevent States From
Establishing Laws Related To Cannibidiol Oil. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that
stopped use of federal funds to prevent states from establishing laws related to cannibidiol oil. “An
amendment by Rep. Suzanne Bonamici, D-Oregon, that would block federal money from being used to
prevent states from allowing the use, distribution, possession, or cultivation of industrial hemp also
passed. So did an amendment from Rep. Scott Perry, R-Pennsylvania, would prevent federal funds from
139
stopping states from implementing laws relating to cannabidiol oil.” The amendment passed 297 to 130.
[HR 2578, Vote #286; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15; NBC News, 6/03/15]
Voted For Amendment To Increase Funding For Mental Health Courts By $2 Million
Voted For Amendment To Increase Funding For Mental Health Courts By $2 Million. In June 2015,
Katko voted for an amendment increasing funding for mental health courts and adult and juvenile
collaborations programs by $2 million in FY 2016. “House Vote 272 Fiscal 2016 Commerce-JusticeScience Appropriations — Mental Health Courts and Adult and Juvenile Collaboration Program Grants.
Lujan Grisham, D-N.M., amendment that would increase funding for mental health courts and adult and
juvenile collaboration program grants by $2 million, which would be offset by a $2 million reduction in
funding for the Justice Department's general administration salaries and expenses account.” The
amendment was adopted 417 to 10. [HR 2578, Grisham Amendment, Vote #272, 6/02/15; CQ Bill
Tracker, 6/02/15]
Voted Against An Amendment Cutting $1 Million From Justice Department
Voted Against An Amendment Cutting $1 Million From Justice Department. In June 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment cutting $1 million from the Justice Department’ general legal activities.
“House Vote 273 Fiscal 2016 Commerce-Justice-Science Appropriations — Justice Department General
Legal Activities. Gosar, R-Ariz., amendment that would reduce funding for Justice Department general
legal activities by $1 million, and increase the spending reduction account by $1 million.” The
amendment passed 228 to 198. [H.R. 2578, Gosar Amendment, Vote #273, 6/02/15; CQ Bill Tracker,
6/02/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting The Use Of Funds To Prevent States From Creating Laws That
Authorize Use And Distribution Of Hemp Laws
Voted Against Prohibiting The Use Of Funds To Prevent States From Creating Laws That
Authorize Use And Distribution Of Hemp Laws. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to
the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, that “prohibits the use of
funds to prevent a State from implementing its own State laws that authorize the use, distribution,
possession, or cultivation of industrial hemp.” The amendment passed 282-146. [HR 2578, Vote #280,
6/03/15]
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit Use Of Funds To Compel Journalists To Testify About
Information Obtained From Confidential Sources
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit Use Of Funds To Compel Journalists To Testify About
Information Obtained From Confidential Sources. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the
Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act that “prohibit[s] the use of funds
to compel a person to testify about information or sources that the person states in a motion to quash the
subpoena that he has obtained as a journalist or reporter and that he regards as confidential.” [HR 2578,
Vote #284, 6/03/15]
140
Voted Against Amendment To Ban Federal Money Going To Discriminating Profiling By Law
Enforcement
Voted Against Amendment To Ban Federal Money Going To Discriminating Profiling By Law
Enforcement. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and
Related Agencies Appropriations Act, that “prohibits use of funds for law enforcement agencies that
engage in discriminatory profiling based on gender, race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, or
national origin and also prohibits the use of funds to repeal the December 14 revised profiling guidance
issued by the Department of Justice.” The amendment failed 184-244. [HR 2578, Vote #281, 6/03/15]
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Funding For FBI Salaries And Expenses By $25 Million
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Funding For FBI Salaries And Expenses By $25 Million. In
June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment increasing funding intended for FBI salaries and expenses
by $25 million in the FY 2016. “House Vote 275 Fiscal 2016 Commerce- Justice-Science Appropriations
— FBI. Pittenger, R-N.C., amendment that would increase by $25 million the amount that would be
provided for FBI salaries and expenses, and would be offset by an equal reduction to the Legal Services
Corporation.” The amendment failed 163 to 263. [HR 275, Pittenger Amendment, Vote #275, 6/03/15;
CQ Bill Tracker, 6/03/15
Voted For An Amendment That Prevented The National Institute Of Standards And Technology
From Consulting With The NSA Or CIA To Change Cryptographic Or Computer Standards
Voted For An Amendment That Prevented The National Institute Of Standards And Technology
From Consulting With The NSA Or CIA To Change Cryptographic Or Computer Standards. In
June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that prevented the National Institute of Standards and
Technology from consulting with the NSA or CIA to change cryptographic or computer standards. The
amendment passed 383 to 43. [HR 2578, Vote #290; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15]
Voted Against Restricting Law Enforcement’s Ability To Gather License Plate Information
Voted Against Amendment Restricting Law Enforcement’s Ability To Gather License Plate
Information. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the FY16 Transportation-HUD
Appropriations bill that would bar funds from being used to acquire a camera for the purpose of collecting
or storing vehicle license plate numbers. The amendment was adopted by a vote of 297-129. [HR 2577,
Vote #327, 6/09/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/09/15; Congressional Record, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Reduction In Federal Law Enforcement Grant Funding If It Would
Result In Increase In Crime Or Decrease In Law Enforcement Officers
Voted Against Prohibiting Reduction In Federal Law Enforcement Grant Funding If It Would
Result In Increase In Crime Or Decrease In Law Enforcement Officers. In July 2015, Katko voted
against a motion that would “prohibit the Attorney General from reducing federal law enforcement grants
to states or local governments if the Attorney General determines that such reductions would result in an
increase in the overall crime rate of the state or a decrease in the number of law enforcement officers in
that area.” The motion failed 181-239. [HR 3009, Vote #465, 7/23/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/23/15]
141
142
Defense
 Voted for the FY16 National Defense Authorization Act
 Missed a vote on the FY16 Defense Appropriations Bill
Katko voted for the FY16 National Defense Authorization Act. He missed a vote on
the FY16 Defense Appropriations bill.
Voted For FY16 NDAA; Called For The President To Sign The Act
Voted For FY16 National Defense Authorization Act. In May 2015, Katko voted for the FY16
National Defense Authorization Act “that authorizes $612 billion in government funding for programs at
the Department of Defense.” The bill passed, 269-151. [NBC News, 5/15/15; H.R 1735, Vote #239,
5/15/15]
Bill Allowed Concealed Carry Of Firearms On Military Installations. “The U.S. House passed the
National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for the 2016 fiscal year on Friday, including an
amendment that would allow military base commanders to authorize the concealed carry of firearms
on military installations.” [KVUE, 5/15/15]
Bill Placed Restrictions On President To Transfer Prisoners From Guantanamo Bay. “The
measure would place new restrictions on the ability of the president to transfer prisoners from the
Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, detention center to third-party countries and would continue existing
prohibitions against transferring such detainees to the United States or its territories.” [CQ Floor
Votes, 5/15/15]
Called On The President To Sign The National Defense Authorization Act For FY2016. “Three
upstate New York members of Congress, including U.S. Rep. John Katko, are urging President Barack
Obama to change course and sign a major defense bill -- a measure he recently threatened to veto. Katko,
R-Camillus, joined with U.S. Reps. Chris Gibson and Elise Stefanik to call on Obama to sign the National
Defense Authorization Act for the 2016 fiscal year. ‘Upstate New York is home to Fort Drum and the
174th Attack Wing at Hancock Field,’ the representatives said in a joint statement Wednesday. ‘By failing
to fund the Department of Defense, President Obama puts Fort Drum, New York’s largest single-site
employer and one of the largest training bases in the U.S., at tremendous risk.’” [The Citizen, 10/22/15]
Voted For FY 2016 National Defense Authorization Act, Which Lifted Sequester Caps On Defense
Spending For Two Years
143
Voted For FY 2016 National Defense Authorization Act, Which Lifted Sequester Caps On Defense
Spending For Two Years. In November 2015, Katko voted for suspending the rules and passing the FY
2016 National Defense Authorization Act. The bill provided that, “the annual [defense] spending caps
will be lifted for another two years, the 10-year spending caps created under the Budget Control Act of
2011 remain in place.” The bill passed 370-58. [S 1356, Vote #618, 11/05/15; Vice News, 10/29/15]
FY 2016 NDAA Included $715 Million For Iraqi Forces Fighting ISIS. “Fiscal 2016 Defense
Authorization — Passage…It also would authorize $715 million for security assistance to Iraqi forces
fighting the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL).” [CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
FY 2016 NDAA Included $599 Billion In Discretionary Funding For Defense Programs. “Fiscal
2016 Defense Authorization — Passage… the bill that, as amended, would authorize $599 billion in
discretionary funding for defense programs in fiscal 2016.” [CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
FY 2016 NDAA Included Provisions Restricting The Ability Of The President To Transfer
Prisoners From Guantanamo Bay Detention Center To Third Party Countries. “Fiscal 2016
Defense Authorization — Passage… The measure would place new restrictions on the ability of the
president to transfer prisoners from the Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, detention center to third-party
countries.” [CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
Voted Against Exempting Federal Regulations Aimed At Halting Nuclear Proliferation From New
Rulemaking Requirement
Voted Against A Motion Exempting Federal Regulations Aimed At Halting Nuclear Proliferation
From New Rulemaking Requirement. In February 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would
“would provide exemptions for rules and regulations that stop the proliferation, spread or development of
nuclear weapons” from the new rulemaking requirements in HR 527, under which “the SBA would have
new authority to ensure agencies comply with the law's regulatory review requirements, including by
getting more directly involved with agency reviews of proposed rules. It would expand the ability of small
businesses and other small entities affected by an agency's regulations to legally challenge those rules.”
The motion failed, 182-240. [HR 527, Vote #67, 2/05/15; CQ News, 2/05/15, 2/05/15]
Voted Against Budget Plan That Prohibited Increased OCO Defense Spending Without Offsetting
Cuts
Voted Against Budget Plan That Prohibited Increased OCO Defense Spending Without Offsetting
Cuts. In March 2015, Katko voted against a budget that would set funding for the Overseas Contingency
Operations war funding account at $94 billion in FY2016. This budget plan “would have required offsets
over $73.5 billion in the OCO fund, which pays for wars and other overseas activities and is not subject to
sequester caps.” The amendment failed 105 to 319. [H Con Res 27, Vote #140, 3/25/15; US News,
3/25/15]
Voted Against Cutting OCO Funding For Military Construction Projects
Voted Against Amendment That Prevented Use Of OCO Funds For Defense Military Construction
Projects. In April 2015, Katko voted against the second Mulvaney amendment that prevented the use of
144
funds under the Pentagon’s Overseas Contingency Operations (OCO) account for Defense military
construction projects. “Reps. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), the top Democrat on the House Budget
Committee, and Rep. Mick Mulvaney (R-S.C.), a member of the conservative House Freedom Caucus,
offered an amendment to strike provisions of the bill for military construction projects that use funds from
the Pentagon's war fund, known as the Overseas Contingency Operations account.” The amendment failed
to pass 190 to 231. [HR 2029, Vote #186; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 4/29/15; The Hill, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Amendment That Prevented Use Of OCO Funds For Air Force Construction
Projects. In April 2015, Katko voted against the first Mulvaney amendment that prevented the use of
OCO funds for Air Force construction projects. “Mick Mulvaney, a South Carolina Republican, and Chris
Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat running for Senate, are joining forces to block a series of Pentagon
spending increases that underpin the GOP’s spending strategy this year … they could jeopardize a $38
billion Pentagon boost that GOP leaders used to woo support from defense hawks … Mulvaney and Van
Hollen plan to propose amendments to strike every penny of OCO money not used for war from here on
out, including in Defense and State department bills … The Mulvaney-Van Hollen duo’s test vote
Thursday night showed they still have some support work to do. The three Mulvaney-Van Hollen
amendments would have eliminate $530 million of OCO money that’s supposed to be used for
construction projects on military bases and installations.” The amendment failed to pass 192 to 229. [HR
2029, Vote #185; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 4/29/15; Politico, 4/30/15]
Mulvaney Amendments Cut $530 Million In Funds Under Pentagon’s Overseas Contingency
Operations (OCO) Account For Military Construction Projects. “Mick Mulvaney, a South Carolina
Republican, and Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat running for Senate, are joining forces to block a
series of Pentagon spending increases that underpin the GOP’s spending strategy this year … they could
jeopardize a $38 billion Pentagon boost that GOP leaders used to woo support from defense hawks …
Defense funds were supposed to be frozen below caps laid out in a 2011 deficit-reduction law. But GOP
leadership planned to dole out an extra $38 billion for the Pentagon using OCO, which isn’t subject to the
caps … The three Mulvaney-Van Hollen amendments would have eliminate $530 million of OCO money
that’s supposed to be used for construction projects on military bases and installations.” [Politico,
4/30/15]
Voted Against Amendment That Prevented Use Of OCO Funds For Navy And Marine Corps
Construction Projects. In April 2015, Katko voted against the Van Hollen amendment that prevented the
use of OCO funds for Navy and Marine Corps construction projects. “Mick Mulvaney, a South Carolina
Republican, and Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat running for Senate, are joining forces to block a
series of Pentagon spending increases that underpin the GOP’s spending strategy this year … they could
jeopardize a $38 billion Pentagon boost that GOP leaders used to woo support from defense hawks …
Mulvaney and Van Hollen plan to propose amendments to strike every penny of OCO money not used for
war from here on out, including in Defense and State department bills … The Mulvaney-Van Hollen
duo’s test vote Thursday night showed they still have some support work to do. The three Mulvaney-Van
Hollen amendments would have eliminate $530 million of OCO money that’s supposed to be used for
construction projects on military bases and installations.” The amendment failed to pass 191 to 229. [HR
2029, Vote #184; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 4/29/15; Politico, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Reducing The National Nuclear Security Weapons Activity By $25 Million
145
Voted Against Reducing Atomic Energy Defense By $25 Million And Apply Savings To Deficit
Reduction. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the energy and water development
funding bill that reduce the Atomic Energy Defense Activities National Nuclear Security Administration,
Weapons Activities Account by $25 million and to apply the savings to the spending reduction account.
“The first amendment the National Nuclear Security Administration's Weapons Activities Account for the
W80-4 Life Extension Program by $25,000,000, applying this savings to deficit reduction. This
technology is used in our Long Range Stand Off (LRSO) weapon.” The amendment was rejected 149 to
272. [H.AMDT.181, Vote #204, 4/30/15; Congressional Documents, 5/01/15]
Voted Against Reducing National Nuclear Security Administration Funding By $167 Million
Voted Against Reducing National Nuclear Security Administration Funding By $167 Million. In
April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the energy and water development funding bill that
would apply $167,050,000 to the savings reduction account for the new nuclear arm cruise missile.
“Quigley, D-Ill., amendment that would reduce the National Nuclear Security Administration weapons
activities by $167 million and transfer the same amount to the spending reduction account.” The
amendment was rejected 164 to 257. [H.AMDT.181, Vote #203, 4/30/15; CQ 4/30/15]
Voted Against Reduction In Naval Operations
Voted Against Reducing The Number Of Naval Operation Carriers From 11 To 10. In May 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment reducing from 11 to 10 the statutory requirement for the number of
operational carriers that the U.S. Navy must have. The amendment failed, 60- 363. [HR 1735, Vote #228;
CQ Floor Votes, 5/14/15]
Voted Against Requiring Funding For Replacement Submarines To Come From Navy Accounts
Rather Than Sea-Based Deterrent Fund
Voted Against Amendment Requiring Funding For Replacement Submarines To Come From Navy
Accounts Instead Of Sea-Based Deterrent Fund. In May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that
would “require funding for the Navy's new Ohio-class replacement submarines to come from their
traditional Navy accounts, instead of the Sea-Based Deterrent Fund…” The amendment failed, 43 to 375.
[H.R. 1735, Vote #235, 5/15/15; Congress.gov, accessed 5/26/15]
Amendment Would Transfer Funds From Sea-Based Deterrent Fund To Navy’s Budget. The
amendment would also “[transfer] funds from the Sea-Based Deterrent Fund back into their historic
Navy budget lines.” [Congress.gov, accessed 5/26/15]
Voted Against Striking Provision Placing Limits On Funding Used To Dismantle Nuclear Weapons
Voted Against Striking Provision Placing Limits On Funding Used To Dismantle Nuclear Weapons.
In May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would “strike a section of the bill that would place
limits on the use of funding authorized for the National Nuclear Security Administration in fiscals 2016
through 2020 for dismantlement of nuclear weapons.” The amendment failed, 178-242. [H.R 1735, Vote
#237, 5/15/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/15/15]
146
Voted Against Ensuring Pay Raise For Service Members & That They Were Paid During
Government Shutdown
Voted Against Ensuring A Pay Raise For Servicemembers & To Ensure They Were Paid In Event
Of Government Shutdown. In May 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit that would ensure a
2.3% pay increase for fiscal year 2016 for servicemembers and would ensure that servicemembers are
paid in the event of a government shutdown. [HR 1735, Vote #238, 5/15/15]
Voted For Increasing Funding For Defense Wide Operations
Voted For Increasing Funding For Defense Wide Operations. In June 2015, Katko voted for an
amendment “that would reduce the Army's operation and maintenance funding by $3 million and increase
Defense-wide operations and maintenance by a net $2 million.” The amendment was rejected, 195-237.
[CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote #334, 6/10/15]
Voted For Reducing Funding For Defense Wide Operations
Voted For Reducing Funding For Defense Operation And Maintenance Account By $430 Million.
In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment “that would reduce the Defense-wide operation and
maintenance account by $430 million.” The amendment failed, 117-315. [CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15; HR
2685, Vote #340, 6/10/15]
Voted For Striking Measure To Require Including U.S. Coal For Heating At U.S. Defense
Installations Overseas. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment “that would strike section 8053 of
the bill, which would require the secretary of the Air Force to implement cost-effective facility heating
agreements in the Kasierlautern Military Community in Germany provided that such agreements include
U.S. coal as the base load energy for municipal district heat at U.S. defense installations.” The
amendment passed, 252-179. [HR 2685, Vote #335, 6/10/15]
Voted For Ending Prohibition On Funds For Sea Based Deterrence Fund
Voted For Ending Prohibition On Transferring Funds To Sea Based Deterrence Fund. In June 2015,
Katko voted for an “amendment that would strike section 8122 of the bill, which bars funds from being
transferred to the National Sea Based Deterrence Fund.” The amendment passed, 321-111. [CQ Floor
Votes, 6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote #339, 6/10/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Navy From Divesting Or Transferring Search And Rescue Units From
Marine Corps
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Navy From Divesting Or Transferring Search And Rescue
Units From Marine Corps. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would “prohibit use of
funds by the Navy to divest or transfer any search and rescue units from the Marine Corps.” The
Voted Against Prohibiting Transfer Of Flash-Bang Grenades To Local Law Enforcement
147
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Transferring Flash-Bang Grenades To Local Law
Enforcement. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would “prohibit use of funds to
transfer flash-bang grenades from the Defense Department to local law enforcement agencies.” The
Voted Against Prohibiting Funding For Army Aircraft Combat Uniforms
Voted Against Prohibiting Funds For Army Aircrew Combat Uniforms. In June 2015, Katko voted
against an amendment that would have prohibited the “use of funds to procure any Army aircrew combat
uniforms.” The amendment failed, 51- 378. [HR 2685, Vote #352; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting The Transfer Of Mine-Resistant Ambush Vehicles From The
Department Of Defense To Local Law Enforcement Agencies
Voted Against Prohibiting Department Of Defense From Transferring Mine-Resistant AmbushProtected Vehicles To Local Law Enforcement Agencies. In June 2015, Katko voted against the
prohibition of “funds to transfer mine-resistant ambush-protected vehicles from the Defense Department
to local law enforcement agencies.” The amendment failed, 166-262. [HR 2685, Vote #353; CQ Floor
Votes, 6/11/15]
The Pentagon Has Transferred Mine-Resistant Ambush Protected Vehicles To Law
Enforcement Agencies In Recent Years. “Here at The Watch, we’re looking for the smallest
town in America to acquire an MRAP, or Mine-Resistant Ambush Protected armored personnel
vehicle. For the past few years, the Pentagon has been giving these vehicles to police departments
across the country. The unwieldy behemoths have little real application in domestic police work.
They’re designed for use on a battlefield. (The Pentagon offers no training to police departments
when it gives the vehicles away. And they’ve been known to tip over.)” [Washington Post,
4/18/14]
Voted Against$5 Million For Army Medical Research
Voted Against An Additional $5 Million For Funding Army Medical Research. In June 2015, Katko
voted against “an additional $5 million for the U.S. Army Medical Research and Material Command to
implement congressionally-directed medical research programs and an additional $2 million for the
Operation and Maintenance Army account. It also would provide an additional $2 million for the
Operation and Maintenance Defense-Wide account and reduce funding for that account by $9 million.”
The motion to recommit failed 186-240. [HR 2685, Vote #357; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Did Not Vote On FY16 Defense Appropriations Bill
Did Not Vote On The Fiscal Year 2016 $578.6 Billion Defense Appropriations Bill. In June 2015,
Katko did not vote on legislation to “provide $578.6 billion in discretionary funding for the Defense
department in fiscal 2016. The total would include $490.2 billion in base Defense department funds and
$88.4 billion for the Overseas Contingency Operations account, and would provide that $37.5 billion in
OCO funding be used in support of base budget requirements. The bill would provide roughly $218.8
billion for operations and maintenance, approximately $116.7 billion for procurement, approximately
148
$67.9 billion for research and development and $133.2 billion for military personnel, including a 2.3
percent pay raise. It also would provide roughly $31.7 billion for the Defense Health Program. The
measure would provide $715 million for security assistance to Iraqi forces fighting the Islamic State and
at least $600 million to aid Jordan in its fight against that group. It also would provide $600 million to
continue training and equipping moderate Syrian opposition forces and would appropriate $200 million
for lethal weapons for Ukraine. As amended, the bill would bar use of funds by the National Security
Agency or the Central Intelligence Agency to mandate that a company alter products or services to permit
electronic surveillance of users, except for mandates or requests authorized under the Communications
Assistance for Law Enforcement Act.” The bill passed 278-149. [HR 2685, Vote #358; CQ Floor Votes,
6/11/15]
Bill Added $38 Billion Above The Budget Caps Created By The Sequester. “The House on
Thursday approved this year's spending bill for the Pentagon in a 278-149 vote. Passage of the
$579 billion bill came after the White House threatened a veto of the legislation over insufficient
funding levels and controversial policy riders that would prohibit funds from being used to
transfer detainees imprisoned at Guantanamo Bay to the United States. It also passed despite
heavy opposition among Democrats and some conservatives over the use of a war fund to boost
defense spending next year. Republicans added $38 billion to the war fund to give the Pentagon
spending above the budget caps created by the sequester, but they left the limits in place for
nondefense spending. Democrats and the White House want the sequester lifted in full.” [The Hill,
6/11/15]
Voted Against Shifting $38 Billion From OCO Account To Defense Base Budget
Voted Against Shifting $38 Billion From OCO Account To Defense Base Budget. In October 2015,
Katko voted against a motion that “would transfer $38.3 billion from the Overseas Contingency
Operations (OCO) account to the Department of the Defense based budget by striking the requirement
that the administration treat these funds as emergency war funding.” The motion failed, 186-241. [CQ
Floor Votes, 10/01/15; HR 1735, Vote #531, 10/01/15]
Voted For Defense Authorization Bill
Voted For Defense Authorization Bill. In October 2015, Katko voted for “a conference report to
accompany the National Defense Authorization Act (HR 1735) that would authorize $604.2 billion for
discretionary defense spending, including $515 billion for discretionary spending subject to sequesterreduced spending caps for FY 2016 for the base defense budget and $89.2 billion for the Overseas
Contingency Operations (OCO).” The bill passed, 270-156. [CQ Floor Votes, 10/01/15; HR 1735, Vote
#532, 10/01/15]
Bill Included 1.3 Percent Military Pay Raise. “The bill includes a host of military pay and
benefits authorizations, and would allow Obama to set the 2016 military pay raise at 1.3 percent.”
[Military Times, 10/01/15]
Voted Against Eliminating New Maritime Security Program Funding
149
Voted Against Eliminating $500 Million In New Funding For The Maritime Security Program. In
October 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to strip $500 million in new funding for the Maritime
Security Program. According to Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer, “This amendment would harm America's
national security. Under the program that it seeks to eliminate, the Pentagon reserves capacity on roughly
60 U.S.-flagged commercial ships to ensure the supply and transport of American troops. It is a program
that supports our private sector as well, requiring the Defense Department to contract private commercial
ships rather than building their own. So there was not redundancy, but complementary ability. It is a
program that enhances America's national security by ensuring that our military can depend on U.S.flagged and crewed vessels instead of foreign ones. It is a program that supports important domestic
maritime jobs.” The amendment failed 109 to 306. [HR 702, Vote #545, 10/09/15; Amash Amendment,
10/09/15]
150
Education Issues
 Opposed Common Core
 Proposed NCAA reforms after the NCAA sanctioned Syracuse
University’s men’s basketball program
 Supported school vouchers
 Supported significant cuts to the Department of Education
In 2014, Katko said he opposed national education standards such as Common
Core. He also noted his support for school vouchers and proposed significant cuts
to the federal Department of Education.
Katko proposed a series of NCAA reforms after an investigation caught Syracuse
University’s basketball team cheating in myriad ways including “academic
misconduct” and “failure to follow drug-testing policy”, and the NCAA punished
the men’s basketball team. Katko said his bill was not in response to the sanctions,
but said the NCAA went out of its way to pound on Syracuse’s coach, Jim Boheim.
NCAA
Criticized NCAA Investigations And Suggested An Overhaul Of College Sports
Criticized NCAA Investigations And Suggested An Overhaul Of College Sports. “‘The way they
handle the investigations ... every single one is conducted inconsistently and arbitrarily,’ said Rep. John
Katko, R-New York, at a recent press conference in support of a bill that would establish a presidential
commission to overhaul college sports. ‘I think it’s high time we have an independent panel of people
take a fresh look at what the NCAA has become,’ Katko said.” [CNN, 8/12/15]
NCAA Investigation Found “Academic Misconduct, Extra Benefits, Failure To Follow
The Drug-Testing Policy And Impermissible Booster Activity,” “Impermissible Academic
Assistance,” And, “Failure To Promote An Atmosphere Of Compliance.” “The NCAA said
that the violations, which were self-reported by Syracuse and dated back to 2001, included
academic misconduct, extra benefits, failure to follow the drug-testing policy and
impermissible booster activity. Other violations included impermissible academic assistance
and services, Boeheim's failure to promote an atmosphere of compliance and monitor his staff,
and the school's lack of control over its athletics program.” [ESPN, 3/06/15]
151
Said He Supported NCAA Investigations Of Improper Conduct, But That The Syracuse Sanctions
Were Harmful To Students
Said He Supported NCAA Investigations Of Improper Conduct, But That The Syracuse Sanctions
Were Harmful To Students. “‘A primary objective of the NCAA is to provide outstanding higher
education opportunities for student-athletes. However, this organization has become a multi-billion dollar
industry that does not always seem to have the best interest of its students at heart,’ said Representative
John Katko. ‘While I share the NCAA’s goal of preventing improper conduct in collegiate athletics, its
arbitrary decision-making mechanisms and harsh imposition of sanctions -- such as the ones recently
imposed on Syracuse University -- are harmful to the health, education, and welfare of our students. It is
far time that we demand greater transparency from the NCAA and I applaud Rep. Dent for his steadfast
leadership on this important initiative.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 6/13/15]
Said The NCAA Bill Was Not In Response To Syracuse’s Sanctions, But Said The NCAA Went Out
Of Its Way To “Pound On” Boheim, And Asked The NCAA To Reconsider Its Sanctions Against
Syracuse
Said NCAA Bill Was Not In Response To Syracuse Sanctions. “Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, one of
the bill's authors, said his motivation was not the tough penalties the NCAA levied in March against
Syracuse University, where he went to law school. ‘This isn't about Syracuse University or Jim Boeheim.
This is a pretty serious thing. This is about an organization (NCAA) that needs to get its priorities
straightened out,’ Katko said at a Capitol Hill news conference. In March, the NCAA announced penalties
that stripped SU of 12 men’s basketball scholarships over the next four years and forced the university to
vacate 108 basketball wins. Hall of Fame Coach Jim Boeheim also was suspended for nine games.” [PostStandard, 6/14/15]
… But Said The NCAA Went Out Of Its Way To “Pound On” Boeheim. “Katko, whose
district includes Syracuse, was similarly critical of the NCAA’s March sanctions against the
Syracuse men’s basketball and football teams. The NCAA suspended coach Jim Boeheim for nine
games and reduced the team’s scholarships. Katko said that the NCAA ‘went out of their way to
humiliate and pound on Jim Boeheim.’ He added that the presidential commission would ‘take a
fresh look at what the NCAA has become.’” [Morning Call, 6/12/15]
… And Wrote To The NCAA President Asking For Reconsideration Of The Penalties
Against Syracuse. “U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, has asked NCAA President Mark Emmert
to reconsider the penalties against the Syracuse basketball program. Katko sent a letter to Emmert
that said, ‘While I understand and agree that Syracuse University must take responsibility for any
misconduct, the sanctions imposed by the NCAA do the most harm to students.’ Katko said the
loss of student scholarships for future athletes contradicts the NCAA goal of promoting higher
education opportunities for all students. He said the NCAA used an arbitrary decision-making
process that remains unexplained in this instance. Katko also suggested NCAA standards are not
applied uniformly across the country.” [Post Standard, 4/02/15]
Other
152
Voted For The NCLB Replacement ESSA Education Bill. In December 2015, Katko voted for “The
bill — which passed easily by a margin of 359 to 64, with all the no votes coming from Republicans -would replace No Child Left Behind, the 2002 law that amplified Washington’s role in local classrooms
and launched a national system that held schools accountable based on student test scores. … No Child
Left Behind was due for an overhaul in 2007, but Democrats and Republicans have struggled for eight
years to reach consensus on an update that balances federalism with accountability.” [S1177, Vote #665,
12/02/15; Washington Post, 12/02/15]
ESSA “Largely Dismantle[d] The Federal Accountability System Created By No Child Left
Behind.” “It would largely dismantle the federal accountability system created by No Child Left
Behind, which required schools to demonstrate academic progress as measured by standardized
test scores or face a series of escalating penalties.” [Washington Post, 12/02/15]
ESSA “Significantly Reduce[s] The Legal Authority Of The Education Secretary” By
Barring Him From Influencing State Decisions On Certain Policies, Including The Adoption
Of Common Core. “And it would significantly reduce the legal authority of the education
secretary, who would be legally barred from influencing state decisions about academic
benchmarks, such as the Common Core State Standards, teacher evaluations and other education
policies.” [Washington Post, 12/02/15]
ESSA “Leaves In Place The Complex Funding Formulas Used To Determine Yearly Title 1
Grants.” “The deal leaves in place the complex funding formulas used to determine yearly Title 1
grants, the money the federal government provides to help educate students in high-poverty
schools. It does not allow Title 1 funds to “follow the student” when a low-income student
transfers to another school. The deal also does not allow federal dollars to be used as vouchers for
private school tuition.” [Washington Post, 12/02/15]
Said The ESSA Would Increase Local Control, Prohibit Mandating Common Core, Fight Poverty
Touted That The Education Bill Would Increase Local Control Of Education. “Katko, R-Camillus,
joined 395 of his House colleagues in supporting the Every Student Succeeds Act, which reauthorizes the
Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 and makes reforms to the federal government’s role in
education. … Katko said the bill will give local and state school leaders a bigger role in forming
education policy. ‘Central New York parents, educators and administrators know best when it comes to
educating our children and improving education in our schools,’ he said. ‘We must credit our teachers
with the ability to make decisions on the local level and give them the flexibility they need to teach
students using unique inventive and creative methods reflective of local conditions.’ He added, ‘We can’t
teach students in the city of Syracuse the same way that we teach students in Fulton, in Auburn, in
Palmyra or Fayetteville-Manlius. Each school district -- and each child -- is different. Our education
standards must reflect that.’” [The Citizen, 12/04/15]
Said The Education Bill Would Fight Poverty. “Katko, R-Camillus, joined 395 of his House colleagues
in supporting the Every Student Succeeds Act, which reauthorizes the Elementary and Secondary
Education Act of 1965 and makes reforms to the federal government’s role in education. … The
legislation will also help in the fight against poverty, Katko said. He believes education can play a major
role in combating poverty throughout central New York, especially in Syracuse.” [The Citizen, 12/04/15]
153
Highlighted The Education Bill Prohibited The Federal Government From Mandating Common
Core. “Importantly, the federal government may not mandate or incentivize states to adopt or maintain
any particular set of standards, including Common Core. Katko explained, ‘The Every Student Succeeds
Act significantly scales back the federal government’s role in education, providing greater flexibility so
that decisions on education can be made at the state and local level.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko,
12/02/15]
Supported School Vouchers To Allow Students To Attend Private Schools
Supported School Vouchers To Allow Students To Attend Private Schools. “Shortly after Evelyn’s
question, another attendee asked whether Katko supported vouchers that would allow students to attend
private school. Katko backed the concept. ‘You may not like that,’ Katko said to Evelyn. ‘But I think that
competition in education is a good thing. It makes people better. Now, does it help the city schools? I
don’t know. But we can backstop and help the city schools as well. We have to. We have a moral
obligation to, so we can’t leave them out in the cold.’” [The Citizen, 8/19/14]
Voted For D.C. Private School Voucher Program; Voucher Program Has Been Criticized For Lack
Of Academic Gains, Poor Management
Voted For D.C. Private School Voucher Program. In October 2015, Katko voted for the Scholarships
for Opportunity and Results Act, a bill providing funds for a private school voucher program for K-12
students in the District of Columbia. “House Republicans approved a bill Wednesday to extend the D.C.
Opportunity Scholarship Program, the only federally funded, private school voucher program for K-12
students, through 2021. House Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) authored the bill, which for the first
time would require that some students with vouchers take the same standardized tests in math and reading
administered to public school students in the District.” The bill passed, 240 to 191. [HR 10, Vote #559,
10/21/15; Washington Post, 10/21/15]
Critics Cite Lack Of Academic Gains And Poor Management. “[F]ederal studies have found that
the program does not result in statistically significant academic gains for students. And at a time when
public schools face increasing scrutiny, the private schools that have received millions of federal
voucher dollars have been subject to few quality controls and offer widely disparate experiences,
according to a 2012 Washington Post investigation. A Government Accountability Office report the
following year found that the voucher program was poorly managed.” [Washington Post, 10/21/15]
HEADLINE: “Quality Controls Lacking For D.C. Schools Accepting Federal Vouchers”
[Washington Post, 11/17/12]
Supported Deep Cuts To The Department Of Education
Supported Deep Cuts To The Department Of Education. “Here’s a look at where U.S. Rep. Dan
Maffei and challenger John Katko stand on some of the issues in their campaign for the 24th
Congressional District seat. Compiled by Washington correspondent Mark Weiner. JOHN KATKO …
Supports crackdown on waste and fraud at federal agencies and deep spending cuts at some agencies,
including the Department of Education.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
154
Visited A School And Pushed For Bill Reducing Federal Testing
Visited A School And Pushed For Bill Reducing Federal Testing. “Congressman Katko. ‘Today, I
spoke directly with teachers and students in our community, and I heard them reiterate something I’ve
heard again and again: we cannot teach our students with a one-size-fits-all approach. We need to make
sure that our educators have the tools that they need to teach and train our students to succeed on a local
level.’ In Congress, Rep. Katko is a co-sponsor of the Student Testing Improvement and Accountability
Act, legislation that encourages greater flexibility in education by reducing the frequency of federally
required testing.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 5/29/15]
Opposed National Education Standards Generally, Opposed Common Core, Said Common Core
Wasn’t Working
Said Common Core Was Not Working. “Katko said Common Core is a ‘one size fits all’ approach, and
it’s not working. ‘You cannot teach people in Los Angeles, California the same way you teach them in
Weedsport, New York,’ he said. ‘I think Congress has a role in this. It’s reducing the bureaucracy within
the Department of Education... I think we need to free up these teachers so that they’re not so worried
about teaching kids how to take tests. Instead, we’re teaching them critical skills they need to perform.’”
Opposed National Education Standards, Such As Common Core. “In an interview with The PostStandard, Katko shared his positions on a dozen key issues that will face the Syracuse area’s next member
of the House of Representatives. … He opposes national education standards such as Common Core.”
Opposed National Education Standards. “’To the extent that Washington is dictating how we teach our
children in Syracuse, New York, I object to that,’ Katko said. ‘I don’t think people in Washington or
Mississippi should have the same standards… It’s an example of bureaucrats trying to shove programs
down people’s throats.’” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Introduced A Bill With Rep. Pocan To Encourage Training School Food Service Workers; The Bill
Was Lauded By The NEA President
Introduced A Bill With Rep. Pocan To Encourage Training School Food Service Workers. “Katko,
R-Camillus, and U.S. Rep. Mark Pocan, D-Wisconsin, unveiled the Improving School Nu-trition Training
Act. The measure encourages hands-on training for school food service workers and would ensure that the
sessions are held during work hours. … ‘Nutrition is a key aspect of ensuring the success of students in
central New York and nationwide,’ Katko said in a statement. ‘As the House begins to consider the
reauthorization of the Child Nutrition Act, this legislation sets forth basic provisions to ensure that the
individuals who work to make healthy meals in our schools are trained professionally and properly.’”
NEA President Lauded Katko And Rep. Pocan’s Bill. “Katko and Pocan’s bill seeks to change
that. Their efforts were lauded by Lily Eskelsen Garcia, president of the National Education
Association. ‘The Improving School Nutrition Training Act will ensure food service professionals
155
receive the time and financial support they need to seek adequate professional training and
continue their contribution to the education of the whole child, regardless of the zip code in which
that child lives,’ she said.” [The Citizen, 10/31/15]
Voted For Authorizing STEM Gateway Grants For Women, Minorities, And Low-Income Students
Voted For An Amendment To Authorize STEM Education Grants For Women, Minorities, And
Low-Income Students. In February 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that “would have established a
STEM Gateways program for state education agencies to issue grants for educating girls,
underrepresented minorities and low-income students in the science, technology, engineering and math
fields at elementary schools and secondary schools.” The amendment failed, 204 to 217. [HR 5, Vote #95,
2/26/15; Bangor Daily News, 2/27/15]
Voted Against Decreasing Length Of No Child Left Behind Reauthorization From Six To Three
Years
Voted Against Decreasing Length Of No Child Left Behind Reauthorization From Six To Three
Years. In February 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to decrease the length of the bill's
reauthorization of existing elementary and secondary education law from Fiscal Year 2021 to Fiscal Year
2018. According to Rep. Jared Polis, “Having the Federal education policy in place for long enough for
all of its systems around public education to catch up and create rules, create policies to see the new law
succeed to the extent that it can are absolutely critical for any Federal education law. The worst possible
outcome would be every single 2 or 3 years, this body goes in a radically different direction with regard to
Federal education policy, causing every State, every district, every educator, every principal--instead of
spending time teaching kids and helping educate children in the classroom--studying up on Federal
education policy, trying to fill out new forms, trying to figure out new testing regimes; and, just as they
figure them out, we are going to move the ball again. Whatever the Federal education policy is, it is very
important to have some consistency.” [HR 5, Vote #96, 2/26/15; House Congressional Record, Page
H1255, 2/26/15]
Voted Against Ensuring Textbooks Meet Education Standards
Voted Against An Amendment To Create A Federal Ombudsman For School Textbooks. In
February 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to establish an ombudsman within the Department of
Education to act as a neutral reviewer to ensure that textbooks meet academic standards. “Under Castro's
proposal, students, teachers and administrators could submit complaints to the Department of Education
ombudsman. The ombudsman would not be able to undo state decisions over textbooks, but could help
resolve disagreements over textbook content.” The amendment failed, 182 to 243. [HR 5, Vote #97,
2/26/15; The Hill, 2/26/15]
Voted For Providing Students With Qualified Teaching Aides, Assistants
Voted For An Amendment To Restore Qualification Requirements For Paraprofessional Educators
Like Teachers’ Aides & Assistants. In February 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to restore
paraprofessional qualification requirements in the Student Success Act, “requirements that existed in the
original [No Child Left Behind] NCLB but had been removed from this legislation. Under NCLB, this
156
provision stopped school districts from hiring paras with little experience in education and mandated that
they provide training … ‘We must ensure that paraprofessionals are qualified to provide much-needed
instructional support, support that is often targeted to students who are struggling academically or who
need additional help, such as English learners, or students with disabilities. That support is crucial to
students, parents, and teachers, particularly in communities where resources are scarce and children are
already at a disadvantage,’ said [Illinois Federation of Teachers Secretary-Treasurer Marcia] Campbell.”
The amendment passed, 218 to 201. [HR 5, Vote #98, 2/26/15; IFT, 2/27/15]
Voted For Protecting Teacher Development Funding For High Poverty Areas
Voted For An Amendment To Protect Title II Funding For High Poverty Schools. In February 2015,
Katko voted for an amendment that would delay implementation of the new formula for Title II funding
until the Education secretary determines that the implementation will not reduce funding for schools
serving high percentages of students in poverty. According to the amendment’s sponsor, Rep. Gwen
Moore, “Specifically, the No Child Left Behind title II formula for school districts focuses 65 percent of
funds on students in poverty and 35 percent on the number of students, which is students in poverty
versus just the number of students. The State formula focuses 80 percent of its funding on poverty and 20
percent on student population. H.R. 5 completely upends this … As written, we have strong reasons to
fear that H.R. 5 would result in Federal dollars being siphoned away from States and school districts with
the poorest students and being awarded to States and schools with higher affluence.” The amendment
failed, 185 to 239. [HR 5, Vote #99, 2/26/15; House Congressional Record, Page H1265, 2/26/15]
Voted For Amendment To Ban Funds For The Experimental Program To Stimulate Competitive
Research
Voted For Amendment To Band Funds For The Experimental Program To Stimulate Competitive
Research. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related
Agencies Appropriations Act, that “amendment to prohibit the use of funds to fund any Experimental
Program to Stimulate Competitive Research (EPSCoR) program.” The amendment failed 195-232. [HR
2578, Vote #279, 6/03/15]
The EPSCoR Program Was Funded To Advance Discovery And Knowledge In Scientific Fields.
“The mission of EPSCoR is to assist the National Science Foundation in its statutory function ‘to
strengthen research and education in science and engineering throughout the United States and to avoid
undue concentration of such research and education.’ EPSCoR goals are: a) to provide strategic programs
and opportunities for EPSCoR participants that stimulate sustainable improvements in their R&D capacity
and competitiveness; b) to advance science and engineering capabilities in EPSCoR jurisdictions for
discovery, innovation and overall knowledge-based prosperity.” [National Science Foundation, accessed
8/21/15]
Voted For Amendment Allowing States To Withdraw From Common Core Without Jeopardizing
Federal Funding
Voted For Amendment Allowing States To Withdraw From Common Core Without Jeopardizing
Federal Funding. In July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment allowing states to withdraw from
157
common core without losing their funding. “The first piece of legislation Rep. Lee Zeldin introduced
since his election to Congress was an amendment to an education law that would allow states to withdraw
from the Common Core standards without jeopardizing federal. States are not required under federal law
to adopt the Common Core. Rather, some states that have been recipients of federal grants through
President Obama’s Race To The Top program were required to implement curriculum guidelines that
boost college and career readiness.” The amendment passed, 373 to 206. [HR 5, Vote #410, 7/07/15;
Politoco, 3/03/15]
Voted Against Amendment Requiring The Secretary Of Education To Study The Impacts Of
School Start Times On Student Health
Voted Against Amendment Requiring The Secretary Of Education To Study The Impacts Of
School Start Times On Student Health. In July 2015, Katko voted against requiring the Secretary of
Education to study the impacts of school start times on student health. “The U.S. House of Representative
reconsidered and ultimately passed Wednesday a Republican-backed reauthorization of the Elementary
and Secondary Education Act—though it's far from the measure that President Barack Obama may
eventually sign into law when it's all said and done … Rep. Alan Grayson, D-Fla.: Would require the
Secretary of Education to conduct an assessment of the impact of school start times on student health,
well-being, and performance. Failed 198-228.” The amendment failed, 199 to 228. [HR 5, Vote #412,
7/07/15; Education Week, 7/08/15]
Voted Against Amendment Providing School Dropout Prevention And Grants For Raising
Academic Achievement Levels
Voted Against Amendment Providing School Dropout Prevention And Grants For Raising
Academic Achievement Levels. In July 2015, Katko voted against providing dropout protection and
grants to raise academic achievement. “The U.S. House of Representative reconsidered and ultimately
passed Wednesday a Republican-backed reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education
Act—though it's far from the measure that President Barack Obama may eventually sign into law when
it's all said and done …Rep. Wilson: Would provide for school dropout prevention and reentry and
provide grants to raise academic achievement levels for all students.” The amendment failed, 192 to 237.
[HR 5, Vote #413, 7/07/15; Education Week, 7/08/15]
Voted Against Developing A National Research Strategy That Evaluates Student Learning And
Effective Teacher Preparation
Voted Against Developing A National Research Strategy That Evaluates Student Learning And
Effective Teacher Preparation. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Student Success
Act that would, “develop a national research strategy with respect to elementary and secondary education
that includes advancing—an annual measure of student learning, including a system of assessments;
effective teacher preparation and continuing professional development; education administration; and
international comparisons of education.” The amendment failed 186 to 245. [HR 5, Amendment 35, Vote
#414, 7/08/15]
Voted For Awarding Grants To States To Establish Programs To Recognize Bilingual Students
158
Voted For Awarding Grants To States To Establish Programs To Recognize Bilingual Students. In
July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Student Success Act that would have, “The Secretary of
Education shall award grants to States to establish or improve a Seal of Biliteracy program to recognize
student proficiency in speaking, reading, and writing in both English and a second language.” The
amendment failed 191 to 239. [HR 5, Amendment 39, Vote #415, 7/08/15]
Voted For An Amendment Awarding Grants For Digital Learning Technologies In Rural Schools
Voted For An Amendment Awarding Grants For Digital Learning Technologies In Rural Schools.
In July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Student Success Act that would, “authorize the
issuance of Education Department grants to rural schools for the deployment of digital learning
technologies. Loebsack said educational software and other technology held the promise of ‘vastly
expanding the educational options and opportunities available to students in rural areas,’ providing them
with an advanced education similar to that available for urban students.” The amendment passed 218 to
213. [HR 5, Vote #416, 7/08/15; Albany Herald, 7/12/15]
Voted For Authorizing Funds For Early Childhood Education Scholarships
Voted For Authorizing Funds For Early Childhood Education Scholarships. In July 2015, Katko
voted for an amendment to the Student Success Act that would, “authorize funds for the Secretary of
Education to provide grants for early-childhood education scholarships, professional development and
licensing credentials, or increased compensation for educators who have attained specific qualifications.”
The amendment failed 205 to 224. [HR 5, Vote #417, 7/08/15]
Voted Against Ensuring That Minority And Low-Income Students Are College-Ready
Voted Against Ensuring That Minority And Low-Income Students Are College-Ready. In July 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment to the Student Success Act that would determine, “that the enactment
of this Act, and the amendments made by this Act, will not decrease the college and career readiness of
students who are racial or ethnic minority, students with disabilities, English learners, and low-income
student.” The amendment failed 189 to 241. [HR 5, Vote #418, 7/08/15]
Voted Against Allowing States To Opt Out Of Federal Education Requirements Without Losing
Federal Funds
Voted Against Allowing States To Opt Out Of Federal Education Requirements Without Losing
Federal Funds. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Student Success Act that, “would
have allowed states to opt out of federal requirements entirely without losing federal funds.” The
amendment failed 195 to 235. [HR 5, Vote #419, 7/08/15; Daily Caller, 7/09/15]
Voted For Allowing Parents To Have Their Children Opt Out Of Federally-Required Standardized
Tests
Voted For Allowing Parents To Have Their Children Opt Out Of Federally-Required Standardized
Tests. In July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Student Success Act that, “grants parents the
159
right to opt their children out of federally-required standardized tests.” The amendment passed 251 to 178.
[HR 5, Vote #420, 7/08/15; Daily Caller, 7/09/15]
Voted Against A Substitute Amendment To Overhaul Elementary And Secondary Education
Standards And Funding
Voted Against A Substitute Amendment To Overhaul Elementary And Secondary Education
Standards And Funding. In July 2015, Katko voted against a substitute amendment to the Student
Success Act that would “require states to establish college-and career-ready standards in English, math
and science for grades K-12 and high-quality assessments aligned to those standards. The amendment
would also require state education plans for youth in juvenile institutions, require districts to include
teacher salaries in their calculations for Title I funds and require states and districts to publicly report
progress in making funding equitable. Furthermore, the amendment would reauthorize and modify the
Charter School Program similar to those in HR 5 and create programs for STEM education and literacy
from preschool through grade 12, as well as grants for technology infrastructure and for nongovernmental
entities to develop curricula in various subject matters. Finally, it would authorize grants to states for
high-quality preschool programs and increase authorizations for Native Indian, Hawaiian and Alaska
Native education programs, as well as for the education of homeless children and youth.” The amendment
failed, 187 to 244. [HR 5, Vote #421, 7/08/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/08/15]
Voted Against A Motion To Guarantee Continued Funding For The Individuals With Disabilities
Education Act
Voted Against A Motion To Guarantee Continued Funding For The Individuals With Disabilities
Education Act. In July 2015, Katko voted against a Democratic motion to recommit that “guarantees
continued funding for IDEA [Individuals with Disabilities Education Act], including for students with
autism and cognitive disabilities; and protects children with disabilities from abusive seclusion and
restraint practices, which, according to the GAO, have resulted in severe injury and even death.” The
motion failed, 185 to 244. [HR 5, Vote #422, 7/08/15; Democratic Leader – Motion To Recommit,
7/08/15]
Voted For Student Success Act To Renew And Overhaul No Child Left Behind, Allowing Funding
To Follow Lower-Income Students To Other Schools And Distribute Block Grants To States
Voted For Student Success Act To Renew And Overhaul No Child Left Behind. In July 2015, Katko
voted for the Student Success Act, a bill to “renew and overhaul the 2001 landmark elementary and
secondary education law (PL 107-110) known as ‘No Child Left Behind.’” The bill passed, 218 to 213.
[H R 5, Vote #423, 7/08/15; CQ Synopsis, 7/08/15]
Student Success Act Would Allow Funding To Follow Students From Lower Income Families
To Other Schools, Eliminate And Merge The Funding Of 65 Programs. “Passage of the bill, as
amended, that would reauthorize the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA) and
would make fundamental changes to many of its programs through Fiscal 2019. The bill would allow
Title I funding to follow individual students to other schools, and eliminates more than 65 elementary
and secondary education programs and merges their funding.” [CQ Floor Votes, 7/08/15]
160
Student Success Act Would Distribute New Title 1 Block Grants To States, Allow Them To
Establish Their Own Teach Evaluation Systems Tied To Student Achievement. “The new Title I
block grant would give states greater flexibility in how funds are used. It would also allow states to
establish their own teacher evaluation systems tied to student achievement.” [CQ Floor Votes,
7/08/15]
Student Success Act Would Reauthorize And Expand Charter School Programs, Increase
Parental Choice. “The bill would also reauthorize and expand the charter school program and
includes other provisions to increase parental choice.” [CQ Floor Votes, 7/08/15]
Voted Against Ensuring D.C. Students Be Protected By Civil Rights Laws
Voted Against Ensuring D.C. Students Be Protected By Civil Rights Laws. In October 2015, Katko
voted against requiring voucher students in the District of Columbia be protected by civil rights, age
discrimination, and disability laws, a guarantee not found in the Scholarships for Opportunity and Results
Reauthorization Act. The motion failed, 185 to 242. [H.R. 10, Vote #558, 10/21/15; CQ Floor Votes,
10/21/15]
161
Energy
 Supported, and voted for the Keystone XL pipeline
 Supported keeping the FitzPatrick Nuclear Plant open
Katko supported the Keystone XL Pipeline in his campaign, and voted for the pipeline as a
Congressman. Katko supports keeping the FitzPatrick Nuclear Plant open.
Supported Keeping The FitzPatrick Nuclear Plant Open.
Declared Support For The FitzPatrick Nuclear Plant. “’There is no question that the loss of
FitzPatrick nuclear energy plant would affect not only Oswego County, but our entire Central New York
region,’ said U.S. Representative John Katko at tonight’s rally. ‘Tonight, we heard that message loud and
clear from hundreds of FitzPatrick employees, their families, and community members. We’re here to
support these individuals tonight – and in the future.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 10/05/15]
Contacted Entergy And Government Officials To Try To Keep FitzPatrick Plant Open. “The
company told investors Thursday that it might shutter the unprofitable FitzPatrick nuclear plant in
Oswego County. … U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, and U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., have
contacted Entergy, regulators and Oswego officials. Both have vowed to do what they can to keep the
plant operating, according to their staff.” [Post Standard, 9/13/15]
Said The Keystone XL Pipeline Would Create Jobs And Help National Security
Said The Keystone XL Pipeline Would Create Jobs And Help National Security. “Rep. John Katko,
who voted for the bill, said in an interview Thursday that the Keystone pipeline would be good for the
economy. ‘It’s clear that it’s going to lead to tens of thousands of new jobs. That is a fact,’ he said. ‘And
on top of that, it’s going to allow us to continue to help keep the price of oil competitive.’ Katko, RCamillus, a member of the House Homeland Security Committee, said in addition to the economic
rewards, the project would have national security benefits. ‘From a national security standpoint, it’s good
for us because we’re going to have a huge new quantity of oil coming into our country and being refined
here, which is great,’ he said. The pipeline would also help reduce the transport of highly volatile crude
oil on trains and trucks through the U.S., he said.” [The Citizen, 1/09/12]
Voted For Approving The Keystone XL Pipeline
Voted For Approving The Keystone XL Pipeline. In January 2015, Katko voted for approving the
Keystone XL pipeline. “The House voted Friday to approve the Keystone XL pipeline, seizing on the
momentum from a Nebraska Supreme Court ruling hours earlier that removed the last major legal
162
obstacle to building the politically charged oil project.” The bill passed 266 to 153. [HR 3, Vote #16,
1/09/15; Politico, 1/09/15]
Voted For A Resolution Disapproving Of New Regulations Mandating Steep Cuts In Greenhouse
Gas Emissions From Existing U.S. Power Plants; Said he Opposed EPA Rules On Existing Plants
Voted For A Resolution Disapproving Of New Regulations Forcing Steep Cuts In Greenhouse Gas
Emissions From Existing U.S. Power Plants. In December 2015, Katko voted for a resolution that
would “disapprove of the Environmental Protection Agency emissions rule for existing power plants
issued on Oct. 23, 2015. The resolution provides that the rule will have no force or effect. The EPA rule
sets different emissions targets for 49 states based on their existing energy profile and requires each state
to reduce emissions by a certain amount by 2030. Under the rule, states are required to submit proposed
plans on how to reduce emissions to the EPA by June 2016, with the agency evaluating whether the plans
reduce emissions and are enforceable.” The resolution was adopted by a vote of 242-180: [S J RES 24,
Said He Opposed EPA Clean Power Rules On Existing Plants, But Hoped For Work “To Address
Carbon Emissions In A Bipartisan, Pro-Growth Manner.” “Katko said he opposes applying the
EPA’s clean power rules to existing power plants, but wants to leave the door open to limit greenhouse
gas emissions from new plants. ‘It is vital that we balance economic growth with environmental
protection,’ Katko said in a statement. ‘The goal of reducing emissions is important, but the
administration’s top-down approach has been harmful. The Environmental Protection Agency’s current
carbon emissions regulations overreach will increase the cost of energy for working families in Central
New York.’ Katko added, ‘While I voted to restrict the current regulations, we don’t need to rule out a
future conversation on environmental protection. I hope current and future administrations will work with
Congress to address carbon emissions in a bipartisan, pro-growth manner.’” [Post Standard, 12/03/15]
Voted Against A Resolution Disapproving Of New Regulations Mandating Steep Cuts In
Greenhouse Gas Emissions From Future U.S. Power Plants
Voted Against A Resolution Disapproving Of New Regulations Mandating Steep Cuts In
Greenhouse Gas Emissions From Future U.S. Power Plants. In December 2015, Katko voted against
the passage of a resolution that would “disapprove of the Environmental Protection Agency emissions
rule for new power plants issued on Oct. 23, 2015. The resolution provides that the rule will have no force
or effect. The EPA rule sets specific emission limits for new fossil-fuel electrical power plants, limiting
large new natural-gas-fired turbines to 1,000 pounds of carbon dioxide per megawatt-hour and smaller
turbines to 1,100 pounds of carbon dioxide per megawatt-hour, with the option of averaging emissions
over multiple years to allow for operational flexibility.” The resolution was adopted 235-188. [S J RES
Voted Against Holding Pipeline Owners Liable For Explosions
Voted Against Motion To Require Pipeline Owners, Not Taxpayers, Are Liable For Any Cleanup
Costs Associated With Pipeline Explosion. In January 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit
that would require that natural gas pipeline owners, not taxpayers, are liable for any damages, repair, and
163
clean-up in the wake of a natural gas pipeline explosion. [HR 161, Vote #40, 1/21/15; Democratic Leader
– Motions to Recommit, 1/21/15]
Voted For Expedited Permitting For Natural Gas Pipeline Projects
Voted For Bill To Expedite FERC Permitting For Natural Gas Pipeline Projects. In January 2015,
Katko voted for a bill that “would require the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to approve or deny
a natural gas pipeline project within one year after receiving a completed application. Federal agencies
responsible for issuing permits would have to issue a ruling within 90 days of when FERC issues its final
environmental statement for the project. Under the bill, FERC could extend that period for another 30
days. The bill would provide that if a federal agency does not rule within the required time period, the
permit will be deemed approved 30 days later.” The bill passed, 253 to 169. [HR 161, Vote #41, 1/21/15;
CQ]
Voted Against Prohibiting LNG Exports To State Sponsors Of Terrorism
Voted Against A Motion To Prohibit LNG Exports To State Sponsors Of Terrorism & Ensure LNG
Exports Are On US-Built Ships. In January 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would prohibit
LNG exports to any nation that is a state sponsor of terrorism, or to any nation or corporation that engages
in cyber-attacks against the United States, and would ensure that U.S. flagged and built ships are used to
export LNG. The motion to recommit failed, 175-237. [HR 351, Vote #49, 1/28/15; Democratic Leader –
Motions to Recommit, 1/22/15]
Voted For Requiring Expedited Consideration Of LNG Export Permit Applications
Voted For Legislation To Require Expedited Consideration Of LNG Export Permit Applications. In
January 2015, Katko voted for legislation that “would require the Energy Department to make a decision
on pending applications to export liquefied natural gas within 30 days of the bill's enactment or at the end
of the public comment period, whichever is later. Under the bill, applications would have to publicly
disclose the countries that would receive the proposed exports. It also would authorize the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the circuit where the proposed export facility will be located to exercise original and
exclusive jurisdiction over any civil action pertaining to such applications. The court would be required to
order the Energy Department to approve any applications within 30 days if it finds the agency did not
issue a decision by the bill's deadline.” [HR 351, Vote #50, 1/28/15; CQ]
Voted For FY16 Energy-Water Appropriations Bill Appropriating $35.4 Billion Towards Army
Corps Of Engineers, Department Of Energy And Nuclear Weapons Programs
Voted For FY16 Energy-Water Appropriations Bill Appropriating $35.4 Billion For Army Corps
Of Engineers, Department Of Energy And Nuclear Weapons Programs. In May 2015, Katko voted
for the Energy and Water Development bill, which increased funding to weapons programs, Army Corps
of Engineers projects and nuclear weapons programs. “The House passed its second 2016 appropriations
bill on Friday, this time to fund the Department of Energy and water infrastructure projects. Passed 240177 along party lines, the measure would provide $35.4 billion for the Army Corps of Engineers,
Department of Energy and nuclear weapons programs. The measure provides $1.2 billion more than the
164
current enacted spending level, but $633 million less than what the Obama administration requested.” The
bill passed, 240 to 177. [H.R. 2028, Vote #215, 5/01/15; The Hill, 5/01/15]
Bill Kept Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Site From Being Completely Closed. In May 2015,
Katko voted for the Energy and Water Development bill, which contained funding to ensure that
Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Site remained open. “House Republicans Friday passed the second of
12 spending bills for the upcoming budget year, a $35 billion measure funding the Energy Department
and popular water projects constructed by the Army Corps of Engineers. …The measure includes a
big boost to modernize the U.S. nuclear arsenal and also contains money that would keep the Yucca
Mountain nuclear waste site in Nevada from being completely shuttered, a challenge to Senate
powerhouse Harry Reid, D-Nev., who has been largely responsible for blocking the project in the
past.” The bill passed, 240 to 177. [H.R. 2028, Vote #215, 5/01/15; Associated Press, 5/01/15]
Bill Provided $150 Million Towards Nuclear Waste Disposal Fund. “The House passed its second
2016 appropriations bill on Friday, this time to fund the Department of Energy and water
infrastructure projects. … In total, the measure provides $150 million for the Nuclear Waste Disposal
Program.” [The Hill, 5/01/15]
Bill Cut $279 Million From Renewable Energy Programs. “Fearing an escalation of nuclear
weapons, Rep. John Garamendi, D-Walnut Grove, on Friday voted against HR 2028, a $35.4 billion
appropriations bill that also includes energy and water development projects. The bill passed, 240177. …Meanwhile, renewable energy programs are funded at only $1.7 billion, a cut of $279 million
compared to FY 2015, Garamendi said. The bill also includes language that would weaken the Clean
Water Act in some circumstances.” [Davis Enterprise, 5/03/15]
Bill “Locks In Sequestration.” “The House on Friday passed a spending bill that would boost
funding for the nation’s weapons programs, Army Corps of Engineers projects and nuclear research,
after beating back amendments that would drastically slash funding for various Department of Energy
research programs. …Democrats criticized spending levels and individual policy riders in the bill,
including one that would bar the Obama administration from implementing its National Oceans Policy
and another that would permanently block the White House from moving forward on the so-called
clean water rule. But their main point of contention was the bill's adherence to an overall spending
framework that locks in sequestration.” [CQ Roll Call, 5/01/15]
Bill Contained Rider Allowing Guns To Be Carried On All Corps Of Engineers’ Lands. In May
2015, Katko voted for the Energy and Water Development bill, which contained a rider allowing guns
to be carried on all Corps of Engineers’ Lands. “Some provisions in the House energy and water bill
approved Friday range far afield, such as a so-called legislative ‘rider’ allowing guns to be carried on
all Corps of Engineers' lands. Citing the politically divisive firearms policy, among other reasons, the
White House issued a veto threat against the legislation.” The bill passed, 240 to 177. [H.R. 2028,
Vote #215, 5/01/15; San Jose Mercury News, 5/01/15]
FY16 Water-Energy Appropriations Bill Increasing Funding For Weapons Programs, Army
Corps Of Engineer Projects And Nuclear Research. “The House on Friday passed a spending bill
that would boost funding for the nation’s weapons programs, Army Corps of Engineers projects and
nuclear research, after beating back amendments that would drastically slash funding for various
165
Department of Energy research programs. . . . Nearly all Democrats united to vote against the $35.4
billion spending measure (HR 2028), which advanced by a vote of 240-177 after lawmakers debated
amendments late into the night Thursday and early Friday.” The bill passed, 240 to 177. [H.R. 2028,
Vote #215, 5/01/15; The Hill, 5/01/15]
Voted Against Amendment Reducing Appropriations In FY16 Energy And Water Bill By 11%
Voted Against Amendment Reducing Appropriations In Energy And Water Bill By 11%; National
Nuclear Security Administration And Defense Activities Exempted. In April 2015, Katko voted
against an amendment reducing appropriations in energy and water bill by 11%, with the National
Nuclear Security Administration, Environmental, defense activities and the Defense Nuclear Facilities
Safety Board. “Hudson, R-La., amendment that would reduce funds in the bill by 11 percent across the
board, except for those designated for the National Nuclear Security Administration, Environmental and
Other Defense Activities or Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board.” The amendment failed, 143 to 278.
[H.R. 2028, Vote #205, 4/30/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/30/15]
Amendment Would Have “Slashed Spending By 11.2% Across The Board.” “The House on
Friday passed a spending bill that would boost funding for the nation’s weapons programs, Army
Corps of Engineers projects and nuclear research, after beating back amendments that would
drastically slash funding for various Department of Energy research programs. … Simpson and his
allies were able to hold off a bevy of amendments seeking to drastically shift or cut funding in the bill,
including one from North Carolina Republican Richard Hudson that would have slashed spending by
11.2 percent across the board.” [CQ Roll Call, 5/01/15]
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Funding For Advanced Technology Vehicles
Manufacturing Program
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Funding For Advanced Technology Vehicles
Manufacturing Program. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment eliminating funding for
advanced technology vehicles program. “The House also rejected 171-250 an amendment by South
Carolina Republican Mark Sanford to eliminate funding for the Energy Department's loan guarantee
program for advanced technology vehicle manufacturing. Sanford argued that the program is dated and
has outlived its purpose, but Energy-Water cardinal Mike Simpson, R-Idaho, said zeroing out its funding
would hamper oversight of the $8 billion in loans already doled out.” The amendment failed, 171 to 250.
[H.R. 2028, Vote #206, 4/30/15; CQ Roll Call, 4/30/15]
Republican Rep. Mike Simpson Opposed Eliminating Funding, Believing It Would “Hamper
Oversight Of The $8 Billion In Loans Already Doled Out.” “Sanford argued that the program is
dated and has outlived its purpose, but Energy-Water cardinal Mike Simpson, R-Idaho, said zeroing
out its funding would hamper oversight of the $8 billion in loans already doled out.” [CQ Roll Call,
4/30/15]
Voted Against Appropriating $30 Million In Drought Relief, State Electricity Energy Reliability
And Assurance
166
Voted Against Appropriating $30 Million Towards Drought Relief, State Electricity Energy
Reliability And Assurance. In May 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would increase funding for
drought relief and state electricity energy reliability and assurance by $30 million. The motion failed, 180
to 235. [H.R. 2028, Vote #214, 5/01/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/01/14]
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Use Of Funds To Consider Report Analyzing Life Cycle Of
Green House Gas Emissions And Interactions With LNG
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Use Of Funds To Study Report Analyzing Life Cycle Of Green
House Gas Emissions And Interactions With Liquefied Natural Gas. In May 2015, Katko voted for an
amendment prohibiting funding for the Department of Energy to consider report analyzing the life cycle
of greenhouse gas emissions when making determinations on liquefied natural gas exports. “The chamber
approved 232-172 a provision from Pennsylvania Republican Keith Rothfus that would bar funding for
the Department of Energy to consider a report that analyzed the life cycle of greenhouse gas emissions
when making determinations on liquefied natural gas exports.” The measure passed, 232 to 172. [H.R.
2028, Vote #208, 5/01/15; CQ Roll Call, 5/01/15]
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Use Of Funds To Enforce Energy Efficiency Standards For
Incandescent Light Bulbs
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Use Of Funds To Enforce Energy Efficiency Standards For
Incandescent Light Bulbs. In April 2015, Katko voted for an amendment prohibiting the use of funds
regulate energy efficiency standards for incandescent bulbs. “The House adopted an amendment from
Rep. Michael Burgess (R-Texas) late Thursday night that would prohibit the use of funds to enforce
energy efficiency standards for incandescent light bulbs. The Texan likened the energy conservation
measure to an issue of individual liberty. ‘We should not be forcing these light bulbs on the American
public,’ Burgess said. ‘The bottom line is the federal government has no business taking away the
freedom of Americans to choose what bulbs to put in their homes.’” The amendment passed, 232 to 189.
[H.R. 2028, Vote #207, 4/30/15; The Hill, 5/01/15]
Voted Against Amendment Reducing Appropriations In FY16 Energy And Water Bill By 1%
Voted Against Amendment Reducing Appropriations In FY16 Energy And Water Bill By 1%. In
May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment reducing appropriations in energy and water bill by 1%.
“Blackburn, R-Tenn., amendment that would reduce each amount made available under the act by 1
percent.” The amendment was rejected, 159-248. [H.R. 2028, Vote #210, 5/01/15; CQ Floor Votes,
5/01/15]
Voted For Increasing Funding For Energy Projects By $20 Million
Voted For Amendment To Add $20 Million To Keep Funding For Energy Technology Research At
Current Levels. In April 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the energy and water development
funding bill that would increase funding for Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) by
$20 million and to reduce funding for Departmental Administration by a similar amount. “Earlier in the
evening, California Democrat Eric Swalwell proposed an amendment bumping funding for the Advanced
Research Projects Agency-Energy up $20 million from the $280 million level in the underlying bill, using
167
funds directed toward departmental administrative functions. The measure would keep funding for the
agency, which supports breakthrough energy technology research, at the current level.” The amendment
was rejected 202 to 219. [H.AMDT.178, Vote #202, 4/30/15; Congressional Quarterly News, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Reducing Funding By $45 Million For Fossil Fuel Research
Voted Against Amendment To Decrease Funding For Fossil Energy Research And Development By
$45 Million. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the energy and water development
funding bill that would reduce funding for Fossil Energy Research and Development by $45 million and
to apply the savings to the spending reduction account. “Page 22, line 20, after the dollar amount, insert
“(reduced by $45,000,000)” The amendment was rejected 175 to 246. [H.AMDT.174, Vote #201,
4/30/15; Congressional Quarterly, 4/30/15]
Voted Against End Funding For Renewable Energy
Voted Against Amendment To Cut $3.2 Billion By Eliminating Funding For Renewable Energy
And Decreasing Funding For Nuclear Energy. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the
energy and water development funding bill that would zero out funding for Energy Efficiency and
Renewable Energy, reduce Nuclear Energy by $691,886,000, and zero out funding for Fossil Energy and
to apply the aggregate savings of $2,954,660,000 to the spending reduction account. “REP. TOM
McCLINTOCK, R-Calif, that would eliminate funding for the energy efficiency and renewable energy
program, nuclear energy and fossil fuel research and apply the $3.2 billion savings to the spending
reduction account.” The amendment was rejected 110 to 311. [H.AMDT.172, Vote #200, 4/30/15;
Congressional Quarterly House Action Report, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Ending Funding For Renewable Energy Projects
Voted Against Amendment That Would Have Eliminated Funding For Renewable Energy And
Decreased Funding For Nuclear Energy. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the
energy and water development funding bill that would zero out funding for Energy Efficiency and
Renewable Energy and apply the savings of $1,657,774,000 to the spending reduction account. The
amendment was rejected 139 to 282. [H.AMDT.172, Vote #199, 4/30/15]
Voted For Increased Funding For Renewable Energy Projects And Reduced Funding For Fossil
Fuels
Voted For Amendment That Would Have Increased Funding For Renewable Energy And
Decreased Funding For Fossil Fuel Energy. In April 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to increase
funding for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy by $25,500,000 and to reduce funding for Fossil
Energy by $34,000,000. The amendment was rejected 173 to 248. [H.AMDT.167, Vote #198, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Increased Funding For Fossil Fuels Research While Cutting Renewable Energy
Voted Against Increasing Fossil Energy Research Funding By $50 Million While Cutting
Renewable Energy Funding. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the energy and water
development funding bill that would have increased funding for funding for Fossil Energy Research and
168
Development by $50 million and to reduce funding for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy by a
similar amount. The amendment was rejected 177 to 244. [H.AMDT.164, Vote #197, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Increased Funding For Drought Research And Reducing Funding For Fossil Fuels
Voted Against Amendment That Would Have Increased Funding For Water And Drought Work
While Cutting Fossil Fuel Funding. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the energy and
water development funding bill that would have increased funding for Water and Related Resources by $5
million and reduced funding for Fossil Energy Research and Development by $20 million. “The same
goes for the second amendment Ruiz introduced last week, which moves $5 million away from the study
of fossil fuels and towards the study of drought mitigation in the West via the Bureau of Reclamation.”
The amendment was rejected 172 to 249. [H.AMDT.162, Vote #196, 4/29/15; Desert Sun, 5/02/15]
Voted Against Cutting Funding For Sundry Accounts
Voted Against Cutting Funding For Sundry Accounts. In April 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment to the energy and water development funding bill that would have reduced funding for sundry
accounts and to apply the aggregate savings of $128,920,000 to the spending reduction account. The
amendment was rejected 126 to 295. [H.AMDT.159, Vote #195, 4/29/15]
Voted For Continuing ARPA Goal Of Reducing Imports Of Foreign Energy, Through The
Development Of Energy Efficiency Technology
Voted For Amendment Continuing ARPA Goal Of Reducing Imports Of Foreign Energy, Through
The Development Of Energy Efficiency Technology. In May 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to
the America COMPETES Reauthorization Act of 2015 maintaining greenhouse gas emission goals for
ARPA-E projects. The amendment would strike a provision in the bill that removed Advanced Research
Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) goals for pursuing the development of energy technologies to reduce
foreign energy imports, the reduction of energy-related emissions, including greenhouse gases, and
improvement in the energy efficiency of all economic sectors. The amendment failed, 190 to 232. [HR
1806, Amendment #11, Vote #256, 5/20/15; CQ, 5/20/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Allow Commercial Biofuels Production For Defense Purposes
Voted Against Amendment To Allow Commercial Biofuels Production For Defense Purposes. In
May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment allowing DOE research funds to be used for commercial
biofuels production for defense purposes. “Bonamici, D-Ore., amendment that would remove a provision
in the bill that would bar funds authorized for an Energy Department bioenergy research program from
being used to fund commercial biofuels production for defense purposes.” The amendment failed, 208 to
215. [HR 1806, Amendment #10, Vote #255, 5/20/15; Science Magazine, 5/20/15; CQ]
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Fees On Oil Companies To Bolster The Pipeline And
Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Fees On Oil Companies To Bolster The Pipeline And
Hazardous Materials Safety Administration. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the
169
Transportation, Housing and Urban Development, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2016 that
would have “raised fees on oil companies to increase funding for the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials
Safety Administration, which regulates oil pipelines.” The amendment failed 202 to 222. [HR 2577, Vote
#305, 6/04/15; Scripps Howard Foundation, 6/16/15]
Voted Against Amendment Allowing Energy Department To Verify Scientific Results With
Additional Study
Voted Against Amendment Allowing Energy Department To Verify Scientific Results With
Additional Study. In May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the America COMPETES
Reauthorization Act that would have allowed the Department of Energy to verify scientific results in
climate research through additional research by striking provisions from the bill, which blocked
duplicative projects in climate change research. “The amendment would have struck from the bill
provisions placing added reporting requirements on research funded by the Energy Department and
eliminating duplicative projects in climate change research. Lowenthal said duplicative research projects
were necessary to reproduce and verify previously published science, but the bill provisions would block
such research, and also curtail the Energy Department’s ability to choose to fund projects based on their
merits.” The amendment failed 187 to 236. [HR 1806, H.Amdt. 250, Vote #254, 5/20/15; Portland Press
Herald 5/24/15]
Voted For Bill That Contained Cuts For Scientific And Climate Change Research
Voted For Department Of Energy Cuts Aimed At Limiting Scientific And Climate Change
Research. In May 2015, Katko voted for the America COMPETES Reauthorization Act of 2015, which
contained targeted cuts for Department of Energy funding aimed at limiting scientific and climate change
research. “On Wednesday, the House passed a new iteration of the COMPETES Act that’s nearly
unrecognizable from its original version. Overall spending remains the same, but under Science, Space
and Technology Chairman Lamar Smith, R-Texas, the 2015 reauthorization carries the imprimatur of the
Republican Party, with targeted cuts the GOP calls ‘fiscally responsible’ and Democrats decry as
‘draconian.’ The new version contains language that would bar some Department of Energy climate
science research, dictate research priorities to entities that have typically had more autonomy and ban
certain federally-sponsored research from influencing policy decisions. With passage of the bill
Wednesday night, 217-205, legislation that was once a Democrat-touted achievement has become a
potential selling point for the GOP — transformed so thoroughly that President Barack Obama promised
to veto the latest version and no Democrats supported it.” The bill passed 217 to 205. [HR 1806, Vote
#258; Roll Call, 5/20/15]
Bill Cut Programs To Modernize Energy Grid And Funding For Alternative Fuel Research.
“The White House’s Office of Management and Budget warned Monday evening that it would advise
President Barack Obama to veto the bill, called the COMPETE Re-authorization Act. OMB praised
the investments research and technology but panned cuts to programs focused on energy grid
modernization and alternative fuels. … COMPETES focuses on the Department of Energy and the
National Science Fund, giving each more than $200 million in general research funding increases. But
this comes with serious strings attached. Researchers and the White House claim the bill’s cuts to
alternative energy research hampers growth in a critical field, and the bill bars the Energy Department
170
from setting recommendations for the Environmental Protection Agency based on its own research.”
[Dallas Morning News, 5/20/15]
Bill Eliminated Six Department Of Energy Programs. “The bill would also eliminate six
Department of Energy programs that Alexander's office said were never fully implemented and reform
five others.” [The Hill, 5/20/15]
Bill Sponsor: Legislation Cuts Funding For “Social And Behavioral Science, Redundant
Climate Research, And Subsidies For Private Companies.” “The America COMPETES
Reauthorization Act of 2015, legislation I introduced that the House will consider this week, sets
priorities aimed at stimulating economic competitiveness and growth. Our bill increases funding for
the physical sciences and biology, from which come most of the scientific breakthroughs with the
potential to stimulate new industries and jobs. Funding is cut for lower priority areas, including social
and behavioral science, redundant climate research, and subsidies for private companies.” [The Hill,
Rep. Lamar Smith (R-TX) Op-Ed, 5/18/15]
Bill Prevents Department Of Energy From Conducting New Climate Change Research, Must
Prove That The Research Would Be Unique Before Approval. “Scalise said that Republicans
intend to end funding on ‘programs that don't meet the national interests’ with legislation, passed
Wednesday 217-205, that would focus federal research in biology, chemistry, math and computer
science. But Democrats, who didn't provide a single vote for the bill, said that while there may be a
few questionable research projects funded by the federal government, the Republican-drafted bill
makes deep cuts in vital scientific research and seems intended to block research into climate change.
The bill bars the Department of Energy's Office of Science and Technology from approving new
climate change science research ‘without making a determination that such work is unique and not
duplicative of work by other agencies.’ Avoiding duplication makes sense, particularly at a time of
large deficits and significant other funding priorities, said Rep. Lamar Smith, R-Texas.” [TimesPicayune, 5/20/15]
Bill Cut Funding For The National Science Foundation By 45% And Decreased Geoscience
Funding By 12%. “Known as the America COMPETES Act, the sweeping measure sets priorities for
research programmes at the National Science Foundation (NSF), the Department of Energy and the
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). It has drawn sharp criticism from science
organizations, which say that the plan would limit the agencies’ ability to fund the most promising
research, and from the White House. Some of the most controversial provisions apply to the NSF. The
bill suggests slashing funds for the agency’s social, behavioural and economic-sciences directorate
from US$272.2 million in fiscal year 2015 to $150 million a year in 2016 and 2017 — a 45% cut. And
it calls for a 12% decrease in geoscience funding, to $1.2 billion annually.” [Nature, 5/21/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Restore Funding For Energy And Climate Change Research
Voted Against Amendment To Restore Funding For Energy And Climate Change Research. In May
2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would have restored funding levels for scientific research.
The amendment would have provided for “sustained growth and sensible policies across the scientific
agencies, in keeping with the goals of the original Competes legislation.” “A bill opponent, Rep. Eddie
Bernice Johnson, D-Texas, criticized its flat funding of research and development, politicization of the
scientific grant-making process, and decreased funding of the ARPA-E program for breakthrough energy
171
research.” The motion failed 179 to 239. [HR 1806, Vote #257; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 5/20/15;
Albany Herald, 5/23/15]
Amendment Sponsor LTE: Bill Made “Ideologically Driven Cuts” To Clean Energy And
Climate Change Research. “The chairman, however, is wrong about the way in which research
should be prioritized. Politicians should not make ideologically driven cuts to particular areas of
investigation with which they disagree, such as clean energy, climate research or the social sciences.
Instead, research priorities should be set through the constantly evolving deliberation and debates
within the scientific community and at the individual grant level about the areas that need further
investigation. It is the National Science Foundation’s well-proven, scientific merit-review process, in
which trained experts select the highest quality proposals across all fields of science and engineering,
that ought to guide how we invest. Politicians, most of whom do not possess the same scientific or
technical expertise, are ill-equipped to predict where the next breakthroughs are most likely to occur.
Substituting our judgment for that of scientists would likely result more in missed opportunities than
in new advances for American science and innovation.” [The Hill, Reps. Steny Hoyer (D-MD) and
Eddie Bernice Johnson (D-TX) Letter to Editor, 5/26/15]
Voted Against Requiring A Governor Opting Out Of Clean Power Plan To Include Certification
That Electric Generating Units Contribute To Human-Caused Climate Change
Voted Against Requiring A Governor Opting Out Of Clean Power Plan To Include Certification
That Electric Generating Units Contribute To Human-Caused Climate Change. In June 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment to the Ratepayer Protection Act of 2015. “Amendment sought to require a
Governor wishing to opt out of the Clean Power Plan to include a certification that electric generating
units are sources of carbon pollution that contribute to human-induced climate change; and that the state
or federal plan to reduce carbon emissions from electric generating units would promote national security,
economic growth and public health by addressing human induced climate change through the increased
use of clean energy, energy efficiency and reductions in carbon pollution.” The amendment failed 181 to
245. [HR 2042, H.AMDT.526, Vote #381, 6/24/15]
Voted Against Requiring Governors To Certify That Any Electricity Rate Increases Associated
With Implementing Clean Power Plan To Be Greater Than Any Cost Associated With Weather
Events Associated With Human-Induced Climate Change
Voted Against Requiring Governors To Certify That Any Electricity Rate Increases Associated
With Implementing Clean Power Plan To Be Greater Than Any Cost Associated With Weather
Events Associated With Human-Induced Climate Change. In June 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment to the Ratepayer Protection Act of 2015. “EPA Carbon Emission Rules — Governor
Certification On Weather Events Rush, D-Ill., amendment that would require a governor's certification
that any ratepayer increase associated with implementing a state or federal plan would be greater than any
cost associated with responding to extreme weather events associated with human-caused climate change,
including sea level rise, flooding, frequent and intense storms, frequent and intense wildfires or drought.”
The amendment failed 182 to 243. [HR 2042, H.AMDT.527, Vote #382, 6/24/15; CQ Billtrack, 6/24/15]
Voted Against Replacing Ability Of Governor To Opt Out Of Clean Power Plan With Requirement
That Public Utility Commissions Issue Reliability Analysis On State Or Federal Carbon Emission
Plans
172
Voted Against Replacing Ability Of Governor To Opt Out Of Clean Power Plan With Requirement
That Public Utility Commissions Issue Reliability Analysis On State Or Federal Carbon Emission
Plans. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to Ratepayer Protection Act of 2015. “EPA
Carbon Emission Rules — Judicial Review of EPA Carbon Rules McNerney, D-Calif., amendment that
would remove the bill's requirements that EPA's rules are to be delayed pending to resolution of all
judicial reviews and instead require a state's public utility commission to conduct an analysis of any state
or federal plan.” The amendment failed 177 to 250. [HR 2042, Vote #383, 6/24/15; CQ Billtrack, 6/24/15]
Voted For Postponing Enforcement Of EPA Carbon Emission Reduction Rules Until Completion
Of All Judicial Challenges
Voted For Postponing Enforcement Of EPA Carbon Emission Reduction Rules Until Completion
Of All Judicial Challenges. In June 2015, Katko voted for “passage of a bill that would postpone the
dates by when states and existing fossil-fuel power plants must comply with current or future EPA rules
to reduce carbon emissions until all judicial challenges are completed, and it allows state governors to opt
out of developing an emissions reduction plan or complying with a federal plan for existing plants if he or
she determines that the requirement would have an adverse effect on electricity ratepayers.” The bill
passed 247 to 180. A “nay” was a vote in support of the president’s position. [HR 2042, Vote #384,
6/24/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/24/15]
Voted Against Ending Prohibition On Using Funds For The Social Cost Of Carbon To Be
Incorporated Into Rulemaking Until A New Working Group Revised Estimates
Voted Against Ending Prohibition On Using Funds For The Social Cost Of Carbon To Be
Incorporated Into Rulemaking Until A New Working Group Revised Estimates. In July 2015, Katko
voted against “an amendment to strike section 437, which prohibits the use of funds for the social cost of
carbon to be incorporated into any rulemaking or guidance document until a new Interagency Working
Group revises the estimates using the discount rates and domestic-only limitation on benefits estimates in
accordance with Executive Order 12866.” The amendment failed 186 to 243. [HR 2822, Vote #400,
7/08/15; H AMDT 571, 7/08/15]
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Have Removed A Limitation In FY 2016 EPA Funding
Bill Updating Ozone Standards So That 85 Percent Of Counties That Do Not Meet Current
Standards Comply
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Have Removed A Limitation In FY 2016 EPA Funding
Bill Updating Ozone Standards So That 85 Percent Of Counties That Do Not Meet Current
Standards Comply. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that struck section 438 from HR
2822, which provided for a limitation on the use of funds regarding ozone standards. Specially, the
amendment would have removed “the bill’s limitation on EPA from updating its ozone standards until
85% of counties that do not meet the current standard come into compliance.” The amendment failed 249
to 180. [HR 2822, H.AMDT.573, Vote #401, 7/08/15; Congressional Quarterly’s House Action Reports,
7/08/15]
173
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Have Prevented Hydraulic Fracturing On Federal
Land
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Have Prevented Hydraulic Fracturing On Federal
Land. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that would remove the bill’s prohibition on
BLM from implementing its final rule governing fracking on federal lands.” Specifically, the amendment
struck “section 439 from the bill which provides for prohibitions regarding hydraulic fracturing.” The
amendment failed 250 to 179. [HR 2822, H.AMDT.576, Vote #402, 7/08/15; Congressional Quarterly’s
House Action Reports, 7/08/15]
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Allow Rules To Consider The Social Cost Of Carbon
Voted Against An Amendment That Would Allow Rules To Consider The Social Cost Of Carbon.
In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to “allow rules to consider the social cost of carbon.”
Specifically, the amendment “prohibits the use of funds for the social cost of carbon to be incorporated
into any rulemaking or guidance document until a new Interagency Working Group revises the
estimates.” The amendment failed 237 to 192. [HR 2822, H.AMDT.580, Vote #403, 7/08/15;
Congressional Quarterly’s House Action Reports, 7/08/15]
Voted For An Amendment That Would Have Prioritized Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Voted For An Amendment That Would Have Prioritized Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions. In
July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would have prioritized reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Specifically, the amendment would “prohibit funds from being used in contravention of an executive
order establishing an integrated strategy towards sustainability in the federal government and making
reduction of greenhouse gas emissions a priority.” The amendment failed 237 to 189. [HR 2822,
H.AMDT.588, Vote #406, 7/08/15; Congressional Quarterly’s House Action Reports, 7/08/15]
Voted For Prohibiting Coal Rules To Go Into Effect If It Harmed Infants, Children, And The
Elderly
Voted For Prohibiting Coal Rules To Go Into Effect If It Harmed Infants, Children, And The
Elderly. In July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that “would prohibit the measure from going into
effect if the Environmental Protection Agency determines it will have a negative impact on vulnerable
populations, such as infants, children, the elderly, and other subsections of the population identified as
vulnerable.” The amendment failed, 180-240. [HR 1734, Vote #456, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/22/15]
Voted For Allowing States To Create Their Own Coal Ash Disposal And Storage Programs
Voted For Allowing States To Create Their Own Coal Ash Disposal And Storage Programs. In July
2015, Katko voted for a bill that “would establish minimum federal standards regarding the disposal and
storage of coal combustion residuals (CCR) that would codify parts of the Environmental Protection
Agency's (EPA) rule regarding coal ash, while superseding other elements of the rule. Additionally, the
bill would permit states to create their own coal ash permit programs, but would provide for EPA
oversight of the bill's standards in cases when a state lacks its own program or fails to meet the standards
set in the bill. It also would provide that coal ash received by manufacturers who intend to use it for other
174
beneficial uses would not to be considered as a receipt of CCR for state permitting purposes.” The
amendment passed, 258-166. [HR 1734, Vote #458, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/22/15]
Bill Would Allow Coal Ash Into Groundwater. “The Republican-led House of Representatives
struck another blow to environmental regulation Wednesday night, passing a bill that will
undercut the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) coal ash regulations, opponents said . . . .
Among the differences, she said, is the fact that the EPA rule prohibits disposing coal ash waste
directly into the water supply, while the House bill does not. In a survey the EPA did of state laws
on coal ash, only five of the 25 states surveyed specifically prohibited disposing of coal ash into
groundwater, Evans said.” [Think Progress, 7/23/15]
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Use Of Funds To Increase Royalties Paid To The United States
For Oil And Gas Produced On Federal Land
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Use Of Funds To Increase Royalties Paid To The United States
For Oil And Gas Produced On Federal Land. In July 2015, Katko voted for amendment to prohibit the
use of funds to increase the rate of any royalty required to be paid to the United States for oil and gas
produced on Federal land, or to prepare or publish a proposed rule relating to such an increase. “Finally,
two amendments aimed to allow dirty energy companies to continue paying below-market rates for fossil
fuels extracted from public lands. An amendment from Rep. Steve Pearce would prohibit any increase in
the royalty rates paid for oil and gas.” The amendment passed, 231 to 198. [HR 2822, Vote #408, 7/07/15;
Huffington Post, 8/11/15]
Voted For Comprehensive Energy Bill Which Authorized Crude Oil Exports; Voted Three Other
Times For Exporting Crude Oil
Voted For Comprehensive Energy Bill Which Authorized Crude Oil Exports. In December 2015,
Katko voted for a bill that “that would revise national energy efficiency standards, require the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission to designate at least 10 corridors across federal lands in the Eastern U.S.
where pipelines could be built, and require the Department of Energy to expedite decisions on
applications to export liquefied natural gas. As amended, the bill would create a permitting process for
cross-border infrastructure projects, allow U.S. export of crude oil, prohibit U.S. officials from imposing
or enforcing restrictions on U.S. crude oil exports, require the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to
satisfy regulatory planning and review requirements, place a filing deadline on judicial cases involving
energy projects on federal lands, require studies on barriers to the export of natural energy resources and
on the shipment of crude oil, and incentivize community solar projects.” The bill passed 249-174. [HR 8,
The North American Energy Security And Infrastructure Act Intended To Bolster The
Strategic Petroleum Reserve. “The bill is a large energy package that supporters say reinvests in
the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, modernizes energy infrastructure against cyber attacks, severe
weather and electro-magnetic pulse, and streamlines the approval process for liquefied natural gas
export projects.” [Washington Examiner, 11/27/15]
175
Voted For Lifting A 40-Year Ban On The Export Of Crude Oil Produced In The U.S. In October
2015, Katko voted for a bill that would allow the export of crude oil produced in the United States by
removing the export ban imposed by the 1975 Energy Policy and Conservation Act. “Most [Democrats],
though, opposed Barton's bill, arguing that its economic impact is overblown and that it will endanger
jobs in the refining sector. They also cite environmental risks in pumping more oil for exports. ‘This
legislation eagerly embraces short-term profits and benefits without understanding — or even considering
— the cost of such a major action,’ Rep. Frank Pallone Jr. (D-N.J.) said.” According to the Wall Street
Journal, “The White House has threatened to veto the bill, saying it ‘is not needed at this time.’” The bill
passed 261 to 159. [HR 702, Vote #549, 10/09/15; The Hill, 10/09/15; Wall Street Journal, 10/09/15]
Voted For Blocking A Motion To Halt Lifting The 40-Year Ban On Crude Oil Exports. In December
2015, Katko voted for blocking a motion to halt lifting a crude oil export ban. According to the
Democratic Leader, “The Democratic Previous Question would stop Republicans from lifting the 40-year
old ban on crude oil exports, protecting vital American refinery jobs and low gas prices from
Republicans’ spectacular special-interest giveaway.” The previous question carried, 244-177. A vote
against the previous question was to prevent lifting the crude oil export ban. [H Res 566, Vote #701,
Voted For An Amendment To Lift Ban On Exporting Oil. In December 2015, Katko voted for an
amendment to the North American Energy Security and Infrastructure Act that would “allow the export of
crude oil produced in the United States by removing the export ban imposed by the 1975 Energy Policy
and Conservation Act. The amendment would prohibit U.S. officials from imposing or enforcing
restrictions on U.S. crude oil exports, and would require separate reports on how lifting the ban will affect
greenhouse gas emissions, national security, and jobs for veterans and women.” The amendment was
adopted 255-168. [HR 8, Vote #664, 12/02/15; CQ Floor Votes, 12/02/15]
Voted Against Eliminating The Prohibition On Awarding Attorneys Fees & Eliminating
Restrictions On The Judicial Review Period Regarding Mining Permits
Voted Against Eliminating The Prohibition On Awarding Attorneys Fees & Eliminating
Restrictions On The Judicial Review Period Regarding Mining Permits. In October 2015, Katko
voted against an “amendment that would remove the portion of the bill regarding judicial review. The
section of the bill that would be removed includes provisions that would limit to 60 days the period in
which civil action could be taken against the federal government regarding a mining permit and that
would prevent the awarding of attorney's fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act.” The amendment
failed, 184-245. [HR 1937, Vote #562, 10/22/15; CQ, 10/22/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Require Proposed Mining Operations Demonstrate Insufficient
Supply Of The Mineral To Be Mined
Voted Against An Amendment To Require Proposed Mining Operations Demonstrate Insufficient
Supply Of The Mineral To Be Mined. In October 2015, Katko voted against an “amendment that would
require proposed mining operations, in order to be covered under the bill, to demonstrate that the
combined capacity of existing domestic mining operations that produce the same mineral is less than 80
percent of the domestic demand for the mineral.” The amendment failed 183-246. [HR 1937, Vote #563,
10/22/15; CQ, 10/22/15]
176
Voted For A Bill To Expedite The Mining Permitting Process, And Restrict Civil Suits Over Mining
Permits
Voted For A Bill To Expedite The Mining Permitting Process, And Restrict Civil Suits Over Mining
Permits. In October 2015, Katko voted for a bill to “streamline the permitting process for new mining on
federal lands. … H.R. 1937 — the National Strategic and Critical Minerals Production Act of 2015 —
which shortens the time for the federal permit process, limits lawsuits against mining permits and gives
states more power in the process.” The bill passed 254-177. [HR 1937, Vote #565, 10/22/15; Duluth
News Tribune, 10/23/15]
The Bill Would Have Designated Mines Of “Strategic And Critical Minerals” As
“Infrastructure Projects.” Passage of the bill that would deem mining operations of ‘strategic and
critical minerals’ as ‘infrastructure projects’ as described in a 2012 presidential order regarding
permitting of infrastructure projects. The bill would define "strategic and critical minerals" as those
that are essential for national defense, energy infrastructure, domestic manufacturing, and for the
nation's economic security. [CQ, 10/22/15]
The Bill Would Have Required “The Lead Agency Responsible For Issuing Mining Permits To
Appoint A Project Lead.” “The bill would require the lead agency responsible for issuing mining
permits to appoint a project lead to coordinate interagency permitting to minimize delays and set
timelines.” [CQ, 10/22/15]
The Bill Would Have “Deem[ed] Requirements Under The National Environmental Policy Act”
Fulfilled If The Lead Agency Determines “Certain Factors Specified In The Bill” Will Be
Addressed By The State Or A Federal Agency. “The bill also would deem requirements under the
National Environmental Policy Act to have been met if the lead agency determines that any state or
federal agency has or will address certain factors specified in the bill, including the environmental
impact and public participation.” [CQ, 10/22/15]
The Bill Would Have “Limit[ed] To 60 Days The Period In Which Civil Action Could Be
Taken” And “Prevent[ed] The Awarding Of Attorney’s Fees.” “The bill also would limit to 60
days the period in which civil action could be taken against the federal government regarding a mining
permit and prevent the awarding of attorney's fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act.” [CQ,
10/22/15]
Voted For Amendment Requiring The EPA To Ensure Natural Gas Vehicles Would Receive Same
Incentives As Electric Vehicles
Voted For Amendment Requiring The EPA To Ensure Natural Gas Vehicles Would Receive Same
Incentives As Electric Vehicles. In November 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Fixing
America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act which would “require the Environmental Protection
Agency's administrator to ensure that preference or incentives provided to electric vehicles would also be
provided to natural gas vehicles, and to revise regulations as necessary to do so.” The amendment passed
246 to 178. [HR 22, Vote #620, 11/05/15; CQ, 11/05/15]
177
Voted Against Amendment Exempting Low-Volume Manufacturers Of Replica Cars From Safety
And Emissions Standards
Voted Against Amendment Exempting Low-Volume Manufacturers Of Replica Cars From Safety
And Emissions Standards. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Fixing
America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act which would “exempt low-volume vehicle manufacturers
of replica cars from safety and emissions standards. It also would include other provisions related to the
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.” The amendment passed 235 to 192. [HR 22, Vote
#621, 11/05/15; CQ, 11/05/15]
Voted For Striking Incentives For Hydropower Operators To Make Energy Efficiency
Improvements
Voted For Striking Incentives For Hydropower Operators To Make Energy Efficiency
Improvements. In December 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that “would strike incentives to
hydropower operators to make energy efficient improvements and would end the requirement that the
Energy Department report on energy savings performance contracts that a federal agency has with
electrical utilities. The bill would create an Energy Security and Infrastructure Modernization Fund paid
for with sales of oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, as well as a program to improve education and
training for energy and manufacturing-related jobs. The amendment would also make a number of
technical corrections.” The amendment passed, 246-177. [CQ Floor Votes, 12/02/15; HR 8, Vote #656,
12/02/15]
Voted Against Keeping Permitting Process Of Pipelines In Place
Voted Against Keeping Permitting Process Of Pipelines In Place. In December 2015, Katko voted
againstan amendment that “would remove the bill's changes to the permitting process of pipelines.” The
amendment failed, 179-244. [CQ Floor Votes, 12/02/15; HR 8, Vote #657, 12/02/15]
Voted For Creating a Permitting Process For Cross-Border Infrastructure Permitting
Voted For Creating a Permitting Process For Cross-Border Infrastructure Permitting. In December
2015, Katko voted for for an amendment that would “create a permitting process including the
Department of Energy, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, and Department of State for cross-border
infrastructure projects, including the import and export of water, petroleum, natural gas, and the
transmission of electricity.” The amendment passed, 263-158. [HR 8, Vote #658, 12/02/15]
Voted Against Continuing To Reduce Energy From Fossil Fuels In Federal Buildings
Voted Against Continuing To Reduce Energy From Fossil Fuels In Federal Buildings. In December
2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that would continue currently enacted targets for reducing
energy from fossil fuels in federal buildings.” The amendment failed, 172-246. [CQ Floor Votes,
12/02/15; HR 8, Vote #659, 12/02/15]
Voted Against Keeping Consumer Protection In Place When Purchasing Energy Star Products Not
Delivering Associated Energy Savings
178
Voted Against Keeping Consumer Protection In Place When Purchasing Energy Star Products Not
Delivering Associated Energy Savings. In December 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that
would remove the bill's provisions that would prohibit lawsuits when consumers purchase Energy Star
products that do not deliver the associated energy savings.” The amendment was rejected, 183-239. [CQ
Floor Votes, 12/02/15; HR 8, Vote #660, 12/02/15]
Voted For Providing Energy Efficiency Grants To Low Income Families
Voted For Providing Energy Efficiency Grants To Low Income Families. In December 2015, Katko
voted for an amendment that would “reauthorize the Weatherization Assistance Program, under the
Energy Conservation and Production Act, and the State Energy Program, under the Energy Policy and
Conservation Act, through FY 2020.” The program provides grants to improve energy efficiency grants in
the homes of low-income families. The amendment failed, 198-224. [CQ Floor Votes, 12/02/15; HR 8,
Vote #661, 12/02/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Incentivize Use Of Local Renewable Thermal Energy And Waste
Heat
Voted Against An Amendment To Incentivize Use Of Local Renewable Thermal Energy And Waste
Heat. In December 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the North American Energy Security and
Infrastructure Act that would “would incentivize local renewable thermal energy and waste heat such as
combined heat and power, and would provide technical assistance to eligible entities to establish
distributed energy systems.” The amendment was rejected 175-247. [HR 8, Vote #662, 12/02/15; CQ
Voted For An Amendment To Require Notification To Land Owners When Federally Owned
Minerals Have Been Leased For Oil And Gas Development
Voted For An Amendment To Require Notification To Land Owners When Federally Owned
Minerals Have Been Leased For Oil And Gas Development. In December 2015, Katko voted for an
amendment to the North American Energy Security and Infrastructure Act that would “would require the
Department of the Interior to notify land owners when federally owned minerals beneath their land have
been leased for oil and gas development.” The amendment was rejected 206-216. [HR 8, Vote #663,
12/02/15; CQ Floor Votes, 12/02/15]
Voted For An Amendment To Repeal An EPA Rule Establishing Efficiency Standards For
Residential Wood Heaters
Voted For An Amendment To Repeal An EPA Rule Establishing Efficiency Standards For
Residential Wood Heaters. In December 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the North American
Energy Security and Infrastructure Act that would “repeal the Environmental Protection Agency's March
2015 rule titled, ‘Standards of Performance for New Residential Wood Heaters, New Residential
Hydronic Heaters and Forced-Air Furnaces,’ which establishes energy efficiency standards for residential
wood heaters.” The amendment was adopted 247-177. [HR 8, Vote #669, 12/03/15; CQ Floor Votes,
12/03/15]
179
Voted Against Clean Energy Development
Voted Against Clean Energy Development. In December 2015, Katko voted against a motion to
“recommit the bill to the Committee on Energy and Commerce with instructions to report back to the
House with an amendment that would remove market barriers that inhibit the development of renewable
energy infrastructure in response to the scientific consensus on climate change.” The motion to recommit
failed 243-180. [HR 8, Vote #671, 12/3/15; CQ Floor Votes, 12/3/15]
180
Environment
 Opposed federal regulation of fracking
 Initially said he “didn’t know” if climate change was “man-made” while
calling for a global agreement to reduce carbon emissions. Subsequently
rejected the claim he didn’t believe climate change was man made, said
he wasn’t sure to “what degree” it was man-made, and acknowledged
human activity was contributing.
 Called for a global solution to climate change
In 2014, Katko said he opposed any federal effort to regulate fracking.
Katko said he didn’t know if climate change was man-made, then when confronted
with his own words, rejected the claim, saying he didn’t know to what extent it was
man made. He has independently said it is man-made. While Katko claimed to
support a global solution to Climate Change, he voted for a resolution which
symbolically rejected the Paris Climate Agreement, a global effort to help solve
Climate Change
Climate Change
July 2014: Said He “Didn’t Know” If Climate Change Was “Man-Made,” Called For A “Global
Agreement On How To Reduce Carbon Emissions.”
July 2014: Said He “Didn’t Know” If Climate Change Was “Man-Made,” Called For A
“Global Agreement On How To Reduce Carbon Emissions.” “’I don’t know if it’s a manmade problem or not,’ Katko said. ‘It certainly seems like there have been a lot of changes in
the climate lately. But if we take unilateral action… you’re not doing much. I think efforts
would be much better to try to get a global agreement on how to reduce carbon emissions.’”
October 2014: Rejected The Claim He Didn’t Believe Climate Change Was Man-Made, Said He
Wasn’t Sure To “What Degree … It Was Man-Made And [To] What Degree … It’s Natural,
Cyclical Changes.” “In an interview Tuesday with The Citizen, Katko rejected the charge that he doesn’t
believe climate change is a man-made problem and reiterated his position on the issue. ‘I’ve absolutely,
positively not said that,’ Katko said. ‘I’ve absolutely said that there is climate change and the only
question is what degree to which it’s man made and what degree to which it’s natural, cyclical changes in
the environ-ment. But clearly man has had an impact on the environment.’” [The Citizen, 10/15/14]
181
… But Acknowledged That “Human Activity Is Contributing To Climate Change.” In response
to the Project Vote Smart Political Courage Test, Katko answered, “Yes,” to the question, “Do you
believe that human activity is contributing to climate change?” [Project Vote Smart, accessed
10/09/15]
Advocated For A “Global Solution” To Climate Change; Supported Federal Regulation Of
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Advocated For A “Global Solution” To Climate Change. “Katko also repeated his calls for a global
coalition to address climate change. He said the U.S. has taken steps, whether it’s through the Clean Air
Act or the Clean Water Act, to address environmental concerns. But he wants to see other nations,
including China and India, to be part of a global solution to the problem.” [The Citizen, 10/15/14]
Supported Federal Regulation Of Greenhouse Gas Emissions. In response to the Project Vote Smart
Political Courage, Katko answered “Yes” to the question, “Do you support the federal regulation of
greenhouse gas emissions?” [Project Vote Smart, accessed 10/09/15]
… But Voted For A Resolution Disapproving Of New Regulations Cutting Greenhouse Gas
Emissions, A Symbolic Rejection Of The Paris Climate Agreement, A Global Effort To Solve
Climate Change
Voted For A Resolution Disapproving Of New Regulations Forcing Steep Cuts In Greenhouse Gas
Emissions From Existing U.S. Power Plants. In December 2015, Katko voted for a resolution that
would “disapprove of the Environmental Protection Agency emissions rule for existing power plants
issued on Oct. 23, 2015. The resolution provides that the rule will have no force or effect. The EPA rule
sets different emissions targets for 49 states based on their existing energy profile and requires each state
to reduce emissions by a certain amount by 2030. Under the rule, states are required to submit proposed
plans on how to reduce emissions to the EPA by June 2016, with the agency evaluating whether the plans
reduce emissions and are enforceable.” The resolution was adopted by a vote of 242-180: [S J RES 24,
House Resolutions Were “To Block” The Paris Agreement. “Hours after President Barack Obama
pushed for an international agreement to combat climate change, the GOP-led House of Representatives
voted to block that effort and demonstrate the President didn't have support in his own country. The
House passed a pair of resolutions, largely along party lines, that would prevent the Environmental
Protection Agency from implementing rules the administration released earlier this year to curb
greenhouse gas emissions.” [CNN 12/01/15]
Fishing
Voted For Considering Bill That Could Create “Dangerous Exemptions From Catch Limits”
Designed To Prevent Overfishing
Voted For Resolution To Consider Bill That Could Create “Dangerous Exemptions From Catch
Limits,” Preventing Overfishing. In May 2015, Katko voted for considering reauthorization of the
182
Magnuson-Stevens Act, which “provide[s] flexibility for fishery managers and stability for fisherman[.]”
U.S. Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska) has proposed several changes to the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery
Conservation and Management Act that he says will give fishery managers more flexibility in rebuilding
fish stocks. He has said the changes will allow fishery managers to address the economic needs of
fishermen. But some fishermen and environmentalists said Young’s proposal creates dangerous
exemptions from catch limits that are designed to prevent overfishing. They point to a recent federal
report that says several economically valuable East Coast fish stocks are rebounding and no longer subject
to overfishing as evidence that the Magnuson-Stevens act is effective in its current form.” The resolution
passed 237 to 174. [H Res 274, Vote #215, 5/21/14; Associated Press, 4/30/15]
Rep. Raul Grijalva: “HR 1335 Would Take Us Back To The Dark Ages By Gutting ScienceBased Requirements To Rebuild Overfished Stocks And Set Annual Catch Limits.” “The U.S.
House Natural Resources Committee today passed a bill to renew the Magnuson-Stevens Act, the
nation’s fundamental fisheries law. The sponsor, Alaska Congressman Don Young, says the law has
kept foreign fishing fleets off America’s shores and sustained healthy fisheries. …’H.R. 1335 would
take us back to the dark ages by gutting science-based requirements to rebuild overfished stocks and
to set annual catch limits,’ said Rep. Raul Grijalva of Arizona, the committee’s top Democrat.”
[Alaska Public Radio, 4/30/15]
Voted For Bill Removing Timeframe Which Allowed For Rebuilding Of Depleted Fishing Stocks
Voted For Bill Removing Timeframe Which Allowed For Rebuilding Of Depleted Fishing Stocks. In
June 2015, Katko voted for the reauthorization of the Magnusen-Stevens Fishery Conservation and
Management Act, to remove the ten-year timeframe, which allowed for the rebuilding of depleted fishing
stocks. “Defying a White House veto threat, the Republican-controlled House on Monday approved a bill
to give regional fisheries managers more power to set local fishing levels in federal waters. The bill,
sponsored by Rep. Don Young, R-Alaska, would remove a 10-year timeframe for rebuilding depleted fish
stocks and allow fisheries managers to consider the economic needs of fishing communities in setting
annual catch limits.” The bill passed 225 to 152. [HR 1335, Vote #267, 6/01/15; Associated Press,
6/01/15]
Alaska Public Radio: Opponents Believed Bill Would Allow Commercial Interests To Push
Managers To Set Too High Of Harvest Levels. “A bill to reauthorize the Magnuson-Stevens Act,
the nation’s primary fishing law, passed the U.S. House this evening, largely on party lines. The
sponsor, Alaska Congressman Don Young, says the bill makes practical revisions to continue a law
that has restored the health of America’s fisheries. … Young’s bill also introduces a controversial
element of flexibility in fisheries management. It would eliminate the mandatory 10-year planning
period for rebuilding depleted stocks. Opponents says that allows for commercial interests to pressure
managers to set harvest levels too high. Young, though, says the rebuilding time frame should vary,
depending on the needs of the species.” [Alaska Public Radio, 6/01/15]
Independent National Research Council: 43-Percent Of Fish Stocks Classified As Overfished
Were “Rebuilt Or Showed Good Progress Toward Rebuilding Within 10 Years.” “A 2013 report
by the independent National Research Council found that federal efforts to rebuild depleted fish
populations have largely been successful, but said pressure to overfish some species remains high and
some fish stocks have not rebounded as quickly as projected. Forty-three percent of fish stocks
183
identified as being overfished were rebuilt or showed good progress toward rebuilding within 10
years, the time limit required by the Magnuson-Stevens law, the report said. Another 31 percent were
on track to rebuild if sharply reduced fishing levels remain in place, the report said.” [Associated
Press, 6/01/15]
Voted Against Motion To Require “Polluters” To Pay For Clean-Up Of Spill Of Toxics Or Oil That
Would Harm Fisheries, Fishing Jobs Or Fishing Communities
Voted Against Motion To Require “Polluters” To Pay For Clean-Up Of Spill Of Toxics Or Oil That
Would Harm Fisheries, Fishing Jobs Or Fishing Communities. In June 2015, Katko voted against a
motion to recommit which would require “polluters” to pay for clean-up of a toxic spill or oil spill that
would harm fisheries, fishing jobs or fishing communities. “The Democratic recommit amendment
protects our fisheries and forces polluters to pay for cleanup of a toxic spill or oil spill that harms
fisheries, fishing jobs, and local fishing communities.” The motion failed 155 to 233. [HR 1335, Vote
#266, 6/01/15; Motion To Recommit, 6/01/15]
Voted For Amendment Requiring Any Plan To Address Salmon Recovery Include Examination Of
Predator Impact, Not Just Water Flow
Voted For Amendment Requiring Any Plan To Address Salmon Recovery Include Examination Of
Predator Impact, Not Just Water Flow. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment requiring any
recovery plan for salmon require that attention be placed on whether predators, not just water flows, have
an impact. “An issue at the heart of our water debates – whether nonnative fish prey heavily on salmon
and steelhead – wriggled through Congress this week. The U.S. House of Representatives approved an
amendment proposed by Rep. Jeff Denham, R-Turlock, that would require attention to this issue in any
recovery plan for salmon or steelhead under the Endangered Species Act … The idea raises concerns in
two camps – environmental groups and bass anglers. The former say predation could be part of the
problem but the biggest need is increased flows in rivers. The latter do not want to lose a fish that is
among the most popular in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and its tributaries.” The amendment passed,
245 to 181. [HR 2578, Amendment #86, Vote #295, 6/03/15; Modesto Bee, 6/05/15]
Voted For Weakening Federal Oversight Of American Financial Institutions Trading Overseas
Voted For Weakening Federal Oversight Of American Financial Institutions Trading Overseas. In
June 2015, Katko voted for final passage of HR 2289, The Commodity End-User Relief Act of 2015. The
bill limited “the CFTC’s authority to regulate cross-border derivatives trading. It would require the
agency to issue rules that allow U.S. firms to carry out trades in the eight largest foreign markets without
U.S. supervision, provided those countries have equivalent oversight.” The bill passed 246 to 171. [HR
2289, Vote #309, 6/09/15; CQ News, 6/09/15]
Voted For Amendment To Protect Hunting & Fishing Rights In Mark Twain National Forest
Voted For Amendment To Protect Hunting & Fishing Rights In Mark Twain National Forest. In
February 2016, Katko voted for amendment to HR 2406. “The U.S. House of Representatives Friday
passed two amendments authored by Congressman Jason Smith, of Missouri’s 8th District, to preserve the
ability of Missourians to freely hunt and fish in the Mark Twain National Forest and other public lands.
184
During passage of H.R. 2406, the Sportsmen’s Heritage and Recreational Enhancement (SHARE) Act,
the U.S. House voted to adopt language offered by Smith on the House floor which prevents the National
Forest Service from physically blocking or locking any access point to the Mark Twain National Forest
for hunters and fisherman…. Smith’s amendments help specifically protect the roughly 1.3 million people
who hunt or fish in the Mark Twain National Forest.” The amendment passed, 232 to 173. [HR 2406,
Vote #95, 2/26/16; The Rolla Daily News, 2/28/16]
Voted Against Removing Requirement That States Approve Federal Fishing Regulations In Waters
Under Jurisdiction Of National Park Service And Office Of National Marine Sanctuaries
Voted Against Removing Requirement That States Approve Federal Fishing Regulations In Waters
Under Jurisdiction Of National Park Service And Office Of National Marine Sanctuaries. In
February 2016, Katko voted against amendment to HR 2406. “An amendment No. 8 printed in House
Report 114-429 to strike language that requires state approval of federal fishing regulations in waters
under the jurisdiction of the National Park Service and the Office of National Marine Sanctuaries.” The
amendment failed, 169 to 236. [HR 2406, Vote #94, 2/26/16]
Other
Opposed Federal Regulation Or Oversight Of Fracking
Opposed Federal Regulation Or Oversight Of Fracking. “Katko opposes any federal effort to oversee
or regulate drilling for natural gas through the process of hydrofracking. He said it’s an issue that should
be left to the states.” [Post Standard, 7/22/14]
Praised The EPA On Brownfield Clean-up Efforts
Praised The EPA On Brownfield Clean-up Efforts. “The EPA effort to revitalize those tracts enjoys
rare bipartisan support. Every congressional district has at least one brownfield, especially in the Great
Lakes and Northeast regions that endured an exodus of manufacturing in the late 20th century. ‘We
absolutely have to get manufacturing back in New York state and the Northeast, and I believe we can do
that, but in the meantime, we’ve got to take care of the sites that some manufacturers and businesses left a
mess,’ said Rep. John Katko, a Republican whose central New York district has been hit hard by the
downturn.” [Environment and Energy Daily, 7/23/15]
Opposed Plan 2014, To Raise Ontario Water Levels
Opposed Plan 2014. “Collins, R-Clarence, and Katko, R-Camillus, are on the opposite side of the issue.
They believe Plan 2014 would have a negative impact on communities along Lake Ontario’s shoreline. In
a letter to leaders of a key House Appropriations subcommittee, the two upstate New York congressmen
urged the panel to include language in the State, Foreign Operations and Related Programs spending bill
that would prevent fed-eral funds from being used to implement Plan 2014.” [The Citizen, 4/04/15]
Plan 2014 Would Raise Ontario Water Levels For The First Time In Fifty Years. “Under
Plan 2014, a proposal put forth in June by the International Joint Commission, management of
water levels in Lake Ontario and the St. Lawrence River would be changed for the first time in
185
roughly 50 years. The plan calls for increasing the 4-foot band of water level that at its peak would
be 6 centimeters or 2.4 inches higher than under existing regulation. That proposed change has
drawn praise from environmental groups and sharp criticism from shoreline property owners and
others.” [Rochester Business Journal, 12/26/14]
Said Plan 2014 Could Have A “Potentially Devastating Impact” On Wayne County’s Shores.
“‘Today’s meeting was yet another opportunity to discuss the potentially devastating impact that Plan
2014 could have on Wayne County’s shoreline, economy, and vast agriculture community,’ said
Congressman Katko, who hosted a similar meeting earlier this year with Wayne County lawmakers and
representatives from the U.S. Department of State and the White House Council on Environ-mental
Quality. ‘I’m appreciative of Representative Collins’ efforts in facilitating this meeting. I recognize the
value of preserving our natural resources and supporting conservation measures, but Plan 2014 could
cause a great loss of shoreline, erosion damage to property, and flooding in Wayne County. It is critical
that we make these points known to stakeholders on a federal level, and that we continue to have an open
dialogue moving forward.’” [Wayne Post, 11/25/15]
Proposed A Task Force To Deal With Owasko Water Quality
Proposed A Task Force To Deal With Owasko Water Quality. “Katko, R-Camillus, proposed
launching a task force to discuss how to improve Owasco Lake’s water quality and other topics, including
concerns about manure runoff and its impact on the lake. ‘We have a problem with the watershed and a
problem with the manure issue,’ Katko said. ‘Maybe we should simply form a task force and sit down and
meet on a regular basis and keep talking through the idea instead of having these hodgepodge meetings.’”
Voted For Prohibiting EPA Regulations That Relied Upon Non-Public Scientific Research,
Limiting EPA’s Ability To Combat Pollution And Climate Change
Voted For Prohibiting EPA Regulations That Relied Upon Non-Public Scientific Research. In March
2015, Katko voted for a bill that “prohibits EPA from proposing, finalizing or disseminating a rule or
other ‘covered action’ unless all scientific and technical information used to decide upon the rule is made
available to the public so the research can be independently analyzed and reproduced.” The bill passed
241 to 175. [HR 1030, Vote #125, 3/18/15; CQ House Action Reports, 3/13/15]
Would Limit EPA’s Ability To Write Regulations To Combat Pollution And Climate Change.
“Critics say the bill would severely handicap the EPA’s ability to write regulations necessary to fight
pollution and climate change and protect the environment and human health, and would require the
EPA to violate patient confidentiality. EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy has criticized the
accusation from the GOP, saying transparency and sound science are among the agency’s priorities.”
[The Hill, 2/27/15]
Voted For Amendment Limiting Water Used To “Flush Fish Diseases Out Of Klamath River”
Voted For Amendment Limiting Water Used To “Flush Fish Diseases Out Of Klamath River.” In
May 2015, Katko voted for an amendment limiting the amount of water released from Lewiston Dam into
the Trinity River, which protects salmon from becoming infected by fish diseases. “An amendment to a
186
House appropriations bill to limit the amount of water sent down the Trinity River has come under fire
from fish and wildlife groups that say the move could lead to a massive fish die-off downstream in the
Klamath River. The amendment, by U.S. Rep. Doug LaMalfa, R-Richvale, would prohibit releasing more
water from Lewiston Dam into the Trinity River in late summer to keep salmon from becoming sickened
by fish diseases. LaMalfa said the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, which controls the dam, should not be
allowed to send more water downstream than allowed under 15-year-old agreement called the ‘Record of
Decision.’” The amendment passed, 228 to 183. [H.R. 2028, Vote #213, 5/01/15; Record Searchlight,
5/07/15]
Amendment Limited Amount Of Water Released From Dam Into Trinity River. “An amendment
to a House appropriations bill to limit the amount of water sent down the Trinity River has come
under fire from fish and wildlife groups that say the move could lead to a massive fish die-off
downstream in the Klamath River. The amendment, by U.S. Rep. Doug LaMalfa, R-Richvale, would
prohibit releasing more water from Lewiston Dam into the Trinity River in late summer to keep
salmon from becoming sickened by fish diseases.” [Record Searchlight, 5/07/15]
Record Searchlight: 2012-2015: U.S. Bureau Of Reclamation Sent Higher Levels Of Colder
Water To “Flush Disease-Causing Pathogens Out Of the River.” “During the past three years, the
bureau has sent higher levels of colder water down the river to flush fish diseases out of the Klamath
River. In the fall thousands of salmon annually swim up the Klamath River, crowding into pools,
where fish diseases can spread in the warmer water conditions. The past three years, the bureau has
used water from the Trinity, which flows into the Klamath, to flush disease-causing pathogens out of
the river, ease fish crowding and lower the water temperature.” [Record Searchlight, 5/07/15]
During Fall, Thousands Of Fish Swim Up Klamath River, Crowding Into Pools, Where Fish
Diseases Spread In Warmer Temperatures. “During the past three years, the bureau has sent higher
levels of colder water down the river to flush fish diseases out of the Klamath River. In the fall
thousands of salmon annually swim up the Klamath River, crowding into pools, where fish diseases
can spread in the warmer water conditions. The past three years, the bureau has used water from the
Trinity, which flows into the Klamath, to flush disease-causing pathogens out of the river, ease fish
crowding and lower the water temperature.” [Record Searchlight, 5/07/15]
Fisheries And Environmental Groups Believed Measure Had Potential To Cause Massive Fish
Die Offs. “An amendment to a House appropriations bill to limit the amount of water sent down the
Trinity River has come under fire from fish and wildlife groups that say the move could lead to a
massive fish die-off downstream in the Klamath River. The amendment, by U.S. Rep. Doug LaMalfa,
R-Richvale, would prohibit releasing more water from Lewiston Dam into the Trinity River in late
summer to keep salmon from becoming sickened by fish diseases. LaMalfa said the U.S. Bureau of
Reclamation, which controls the dam, should not be allowed to send more water downstream than
allowed under 15-year-old agreement called the ‘Record of Decision.’ … The amendment was added
to the Energy and Water Appropriations bill, which the House approved last week.” [Record
Searchlight, 5/07/15]
Pacific Coast Federation Of Fishermen’s Association Believed Fish Kill Would Negatively Affect
West Coast Commercial And Recreational Fishing Industry. “Glen Spain, Northwest regional
director of the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Associations, said a fish kill would also hurt
187
the West Coast commercial and recreational fishing industry. ‘Again, it’s going to affect the economy
of the whole Northern California if we have another fish kill,’ Spain said.” [Record Searchlight,
5/07/15]
Higher Flows Into River Meant Less Water Was Piped Into Powerhouses, Forcing Redding To
Buy More Expensive Electricity Elsewhere. “Higher flows down the Trinity River mean that less
water is piped over the mountains from Lewiston Lake to the Carr Powerhouse at Whiskeytown Lake
and the Spring Creek Powerhouse at Keswick Lake. When those two powerhouses generate less
electricity, Redding Electric Utility has to purchase more expensive power from other sources,
Eastman said. ‘Requiring the Bureau to maintain Trinity flows under the Record of Decision keeps
more water available to all Central Valley Project water recipients, including Redding and agriculture
in the North State,’ he said. REU pays about $6.5 million per year for electricity from the Western
Area Power Administration, which distributes the power, said Barry Tippin, Redding’s assistant city
manager. The city pays hundreds of thousands of dollars more for power if it has to get electricity
from other sources when hydropower generation runs low, he said.” [Record Searchlight, 5/07/15]
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Funds Used To Regulate “Agricultural Activities” Identified As
Exemptions Under Clean Water Act
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Funds Used To Regulate “Agricultural Activities” Identified As
Exemptions Under Clean Water Act. In May 2015, Katko voted for an amendment prohibiting the use
of funds to regulate certain agricultural activities under the Clean Water Act. “LaMalfa, R-Calif.,
amendment that would prohibit funds made available under the act from being used to regulate
agricultural activities identified as exemptions under certain sections of the Clean Water Act.” The
amendment passed, 239 to174. [ H.R. 2028, Vote #212, 5/01/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/01/15]
Voted For Amendment To Block Bureau Of Reclamation From Buying Water To Increase
Instream Flow To Help Fish
Voted For Amendment To Block Bureau Of Reclamation From Buying Water To Increase
Instream Flow To Help Fish. In May 2015, Katko voted for amendment to prohibit the buying of water
for the purpose of enhancing river flow to help fish. “The House briefly debated at about 1:20 a.m. Friday,
and eventually approved along nearly party lines, an amendment by Rep. Tom McClintock, R-Calif., that
would block the Bureau of Reclamation from buying water for the purpose of supplementing river flows
to help fish.” The amendment passed, 228 to 183. [HR 2028, Vote #211, 5/01/15; Associated Press,
5/01/15]
U.S. Bureau Of Reclamation Public Affairs Officer: Major Water Purchases Were Made To
Meet Water Quality Standards. “Rep. Tom McClintock’s amendment to forbid federal agencies
from purchasing water during California’s catastrophic drought in order to release it into rivers to
meet environmental requirements was adopted May1 as part of the House of Representatives’ Fiscal
Year 2016 Energy and Water Appropriations Act. The amendment was adopted on a vote of 226-9,
and final passage of the Appropriations Act on a vote of 230-7. … Public Affairs Officer Erin Curtis
said the agency’s major water purchases in recent years have been on the San Joaquin River in order
to comply with the Vernalis Adaptive Management Plan intended to meet water quality standards at
188
Vernalis, not far from where the Stanislaus River meets the San Joaquin River.” [Calaveras
Enterprise, 5/08/15]
U.S. Bureau Of Reclamation Public Affairs Officer: Bureau Required By Law To Release
Water To Protect Water Quality, Fish And Wildlife. “Curtis noted in an email that the bureau is
required by a variety of environmental laws to release water to protect water quality as well as fish
and wildlife. Among the beneficiaries of those releases are farms and cities that draw water from the
San Joaquin River Delta.” [Calaveras Enterprise, 5/08/15]
Farms And Cities Benefit From Releases. “Among the beneficiaries of those releases are farms and
cities that draw water from the San Joaquin River Delta.” [Calaveras Enterprise, 5/08/15]
Calaveras Enterprise: “Flows From The Stanislaus River Help Dilute Salt Contamination That
Would Otherwise Render Water In the Delta Unusable For Irrigation.” “Rep. Tom McClintock’s
amendment to forbid federal agencies from purchasing water during California’s catastrophic drought
in order to release it into rivers to meet environmental requirements was adopted May1 as part of the
House of Representatives’ Fiscal Year 2016 Energy and Water Appropriations Act. … Flows from the
Stanislaus River help dilute salt contamination that would otherwise render water in the delta unusable
for irrigation and more expensive to treat for drinking water.” [Calaveras Enterprise, 5/08/15]
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Funding For Energy Department’s Climate Models Program
Voted For Amendment Prohibiting Funding For Energy Department’s Climate Models Program.
In May 2015, Katko voted for amendment prohibiting funding for the Energy Department’s climate
models program. “The House has passed an amendment sponsored by Rep. Paul A. Gosar, R-Arizona, to
the Energy and Water Development and Related Agencies Appropriations Act. The amendment would bar
funding for the Energy Department’s Climate Model Development and Validation program. Gosar said
funding Energy’s ‘duplicative and wasteful’ climate modeling effort was not central to Energy’s mission
and was redundant, given an abundance of other global climate models being adopted by other U.S. and
foreign governments and private businesses.” The amendment passed, 224 to 184. [H.R. 2028, Vote #209,
5/01/15; Bangor Daily News, 5/08/15]
CQ Roll Call: Program “Evaluates Predictive Models Of The Earth’s Climate.” “Nearly all
Democrats united to vote against the $35.4 billion spending measure (HR 2028), which advanced by a
vote of 240-177 after lawmakers debated amendments late into the night Thursday and early Friday.
… Lawmakers also approved an amendment 224-184 that would bar funding for a DOE program that
evaluates predictive models of the Earth's climate.” [CQ Roll Call, 5/01/15]
Voted For Undermining The Clean Water Act
Voted For Halting EPA’s Waters Of The United States Rulemaking Relating To Smaller
Waterways That Feed Into Larger Ones. In May 2015, Katko voted for the Regulatory Integrity
Protection Act which “would require the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers to withdraw its Waters of
the United States rule. The rule would define the EPA’s oversight authority over streams, ponds and small
waterways that feed into larger ones...” According to Rep. Donna Edwards, “H.R. 1732 would halt the
current Clean Water rulemaking, and require the agencies to withdraw the proposed rule and restart the
189
rulemaking process. This is after one million public comments, a 208 day comment period, and over 400
public hearings.” The bill passed 261 to 155. [HR 1732, Vote # 219, 5/12/15; The Hill, 4/29/15; Edwards
Press Release, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Issuing Final Clean Water Rules If They Violated Previous
Court Decisions. In May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Regulatory Integrity Protection
Act proposed by Rep. Donna Edwards. According to Edwards, “Under my amendment, the administration
cannot expand the scope beyond those water bodies covered prior to the decisions of the U.S. Supreme
Court in those two cases, and it cannot be inconsistent with Justices Scalia’s and Kennedy’s judicial
opinions in Rapanos. In addition to that, they can’t increase the regulation of ditches.” The amendment
failed 167 to 248. [HR 1732, Vote #217, 5/12/15; Edwards Press Release, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Protecting America’s Waterways To Ensure Safe Drinking Water Supply
Voted Against Protecting America’s Waterways To Ensure Safe Drinking Water Supply. In May
2015, Katko voted against a motion that would “protect the quality of America’s water supply for safe
drinking, particularly in the Great Lakes, which has been affected by harmful algal blooms; drought
mitigation in California and the West; agriculture and irrigation; and flood and coastal storm protection
from wetlands.” The motion failed 175 to 241. [HR 1732, Vote #218, 5/12/15; Democratic Leader,
5/12/15]
Voted For Prohibiting Listing Of Prairie Chicken As Threatened/Endangered
Voted For Prohibiting Listing Of Prairie Chicken As Threatened Or Endangered Species. In May
2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would “prohibit the listing of the lesser prairie chicken as a
threatened or endangered species until 2021. The amendment also would de-list the American burying
beetle as a threatened or endangered species.” The amendment passed, 229-190. [H.R 1735, Vote #236,
5/15/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/15/16]
Voted For Allowing The Speaker Of The House And Senate Majority Leader To Appoint Members
To Committee Reviewing Energy Department Carbon Capture Research Program
Voted For Allowing The Speaker Of The House And Senate Majority Leader To Appoint Members
To Committee Reviewing Energy Department Carbon Capture Research Program. In May 2015,
Katko voted for an amendment that would allow the Speaker of the House and the Majority Leader of the
Senate to appoint members to the STEM Education Advisory Panel and a second advisory committee that
would oversee the Energy Department’s carbon capture and sequestration research program. The
amendment passed 234 to 183. [HR 1806, H.Amdt. 248, Vote #253, 5/20/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/20/15]
Voted For An Amendment That Blocked Funding To Establish National Ocean Policy, A Policy
Initiative Aimed At Increasing Planning And Coordination On Ocean Use
Initiative Aimed At Increasing Planning And Coordination On Ocean Use. In June 2015, Katko
voted for an amendment that blocked funding to establish national ocean policy, a policy initiative aimed
at increasing planning and coordination on ocean use. “The House voted along party lines to attach an
amendment from Rep. Bill Flores (R-Texas) prohibiting the use of funds to establishing the National
190
Ocean Policy, an effort the Obama administration began in 2010 with the aim of improving coordination
and planning. The House has attached the rider to spending bills in the past, driven by Republican
assertions that the policy is akin to ‘zoning the oceans.’” The amendment passed 236 to 190. [HR 2578,
Vote #291, 6/03/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15; Environment & Energy Publishing,
6/04/15]
Voted For Storm Impact Prevention, FEMA Funding
Voted For Storm Impact Prevention, FEMA Funding. In January 2015, Katko voted for a bill “that
would authorize $21 million per year from fiscal 2015-2017 for the National Windstorm Impact
Reduction Program. For each year, it would authorize $5.3 million for the Federal Emergency
Management Agency, $9.7 million for the National Science Foundation, $4.1 million for the National
Institutes for Standards and Technology and $2.3 million for the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration.” The bill passed 381-39. [HR 23, Vote #10, 1/07/15; CQ Votes]
Voted Against Amendment To Increase Funding For Inland Oil Spill Programs By More Than $5
Million
Voted Against Amendment To Increase Funding For Inland Oil Spill Programs. In July 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment to increase funding for inland oil spill programs. The Amendment would
reduce funding for Bureau of Ocean Energy Management by $5,434,000 and to increase funding for
Inland Oil Spill Programs by a similar amount. According to the amendment’s sponsor, Rep. Lois Capps,
“When it comes to oil spills, the damage gets worse by the minute, so ensuring that spill response teams
are properly trained and prepared to respond quickly is essential to minimizing the impacts. This is
precisely why the EPA has jurisdiction over the inland oil spill program. … Despite its scope and
importance, this program has been seriously underfunded for years, and H.R. 2822 only makes things
worse by funding this program at nearly 25 percent less than the President Requested. My amendment
would simply increase funding for this program by 5.4 million, to match the President’s requested amount
of $23.4 million for fiscal year 2016.” The amendment failed, 184 to 243. [HR 2822, Vote #394, 7/08/15;
Bill Summary, Library of Congress, 7/08/15, House Congressional Record, Page H4741, 6/25/15]
Voted Against Striking Provision Allowing Vacant Public Land Grazing Allotments When Existing
Allotment Is Unusable Due To Drought Or Wild Fire
Voted Against Striking Provision Allowing Vacant Public Land Grazing Allotments When Existing
Allotment Is Unusable Due To Drought Or Wild Fire. In July 2015, Katko voted against “an
amendment to strike section 433, which provides for vacant public land grazing allotments when an
existing allotment is unusable due to drought or wildfire.” The amendment failed 178 to 251. [HR 2822,
Vote #399, 7/08/15; H AMDT 570, 7/08/15]
Voted Against Preserving Legal Recourse To Salvage And Reforestation Projects Conducted In
Response To Catastrophic Events
Voted Against Preserving Legal Recourse To Salvage And Reforestation Projects Conducted In
Response To Catastrophic Events. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would “strike
section 203 and Title III from the bill, which impose restrictions on lawsuits. Section 203 prohibits
191
restraining orders, preliminary injunctions and injunctions pending appeal against salvage and
reforestation projects conducted in response to catastrophic events.” The amendment failed, 181 to 247.
[HR 2647, Vote #427, 7/09/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/09/15]
Initiative Aimed At Increasing Planning And Coordination On Ocean Use
Initiative Aimed At Increasing Planning And Coordination On Ocean Use. In June 2015, Katko
voted for an amendment that blocked funding to establish national ocean policy, a policy initiative aimed
at increasing planning and coordination on ocean use. “The House voted along party lines to attach an
amendment from Rep. Bill Flores (R-Texas) prohibiting the use of funds to establishing the National
Ocean Policy, an effort the Obama administration began in 2010 with the aim of improving coordination
and planning. The House has attached the rider to spending bills in the past, driven by Republican
assertions that the policy is akin to ‘zoning the oceans.’” The amendment passed 236 to 190. [HR 2578,
Vote #291, 6/03/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15; Environment & Energy Publishing,
6/04/15]
Voted Against Collaborating With California Officials To Install A Fish Screen To Protect
Migrating Salmon
Voted Against Collaborating With California Officials To Install A Fish Screen To Protect
Migrating Salmon. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would direct federal agencies
to collaborate with the California Department of Water Resources to “help installation of a fish screen at
the Delta Cross Channel Gates to protect migrating salmon.” The amendment was rejected by a vote of
182-236. [HR 2898, Vote #443, 7/16/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/15/15; Sacramento Bee, 7/15/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Provide Funding For Water Recycling And Reuse Projects
Voted Against Amendment To Provide Funding For Water Recycling And Reuse Projects. In July
2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would fund water reclamation programs and water reuse
projects so that the Bureau of Reclamation can investigate additional opportunities to reclaim and reuse
wastewater and naturally impaired ground and surface water. The amendment was rejected by a vote of
179-242. [HR 2898, Vote #445, 7/16/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/15/15]
Voted Against Protecting The Supply Of Water For Drinking And To Fight Wildfires In The
Western United States
Voted Against Protecting The Supply Of Water For Drinking And To Fight Wildfires In The
Western United States. In July 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit that would ensure an
adequate supply of water for safe drinking that is untainted by arsenic, salt, or other toxins which become
concentrated in diminished water supplies, to fight wild fires, and to honor tribal water rights. The motion
was rejected by a vote of 183-239. [HR 2898, Vote #446, 7/16/2015; Democratic Leader – Motions to
Recommit, 7/16/15]
192
Voted For Overriding Legal Protections For Fish And Wildlife To Funnel Additional California
Water To The San Joaquin Valley
Voted For Overriding Legal Protections For Fish And Wildlife To Funnel Additional California
Water To The San Joaquin Valley. In July 2015, Katko voted for a bill that would require that more
water from Northern California be pumped south for agricultural uses in the Central Valley in times of
drought. “The House bill aims to funnel more water to San Joaquin Valley growers by reducing the
amount used to support endangered fish populations … environmental groups and commercial fishermen
called the measure a bid to override legal protections for salmon, migratory birds and other fish and
wildlife. They said it would repeal the settlement of an 18-year lawsuit involving the restoration of the
San Joaquin River, and limit the federal government's ability to protect commercial and tribal fisheries on
the Trinity and Klamath rivers.” The bill passed by a vote of 245-176. [HR 2898, Vote #447, 7/16/15; CQ
Floor Votes, 7/16/15; Los Angeles Times, 7/17/15]
Voted Against Requiring Increased Disclosure On Groundwater Monitoring
Voted Against Requiring Increased Disclosure On Groundwater Monitoring. In July 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment that “would require all inactive surface impoundments follow post-closure
groundwater monitoring standards to meet current public disclosure requirements.” The amendment
failed, 177-244. [HR 1734, Vote #453, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/22/15]
Voted Against Requiring Inactive Hazardous Waste Sites To Follow Groundwater Monitoring
Standards
Voted Against Requiring Inactive Hazardous Waste Sites To Follow Groundwater Monitoring
Standards. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that “would require all inactive surface
impoundments to follow post-closure groundwater monitoring standards in the Environmental Protection
Agency's (EPA) rule.” The amendment failed, 177-245. [HR 1734, Vote #454, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes,
7/22/15]
Voted Against Requiring Alternate Safe Drinking Water Within 24 Hours If Drinking Water Had
Unsafe Coal Pollution Levels
Voted Against Requiring Alternate Safe Drinking Water Within 24 Hours If Drinking Water Had
Unsafe Coal Pollution Levels. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that “would require the
owner or operator of a coal combustion residuals surface impoundment to survey all nearby drinking
water supply wells and to supply an alternative source of safe drinking water within 24 hours if well water
sampling exceeds groundwater quality standards for constituents associated with the presence of coal
combustion residuals.” The amendment failed, 192-231. [HR 1734, Vote #455, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes,
7/22/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Require Criteria To Prevent Toxic Contamination Of
Groundwater And To Protect Water Sources, Including Great Lakes
Voted Against To Require Criteria To Prevent Toxic Contamination Of Groundwater And To
Protect Water Sources, Including Great Lakes. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that
193
“would require implementing agencies to require that all surface impoundment structures meet criteria
sufficient to prevent toxic contamination of ground water and to protect drinking water sources, including
the Great Lakes.” The amendment failed, 184-240. [HR 1734, Vote #457, 3/25/15; CQ Floor Votes,
7/22/15]
Voted For Requiring Hunters’ Access To Federal Lands, Blocking Prohibitions On Ivory
Trafficking And Regulations On Lead In Bullets
Voted For Requiring Hunters’ Access To Federal Lands, Blocking Prohibitions On Ivory
Trafficking And Regulations On Lead In Bullets. In February 2016, Katko voted for a bill that would
allow hunters greater access to federal land managed by the Departments of Interior and Forest Service
while blocking restrictions on the trafficking of elephant ivory, combat regulations on lead contained in
bullets, and prevent the Army Corps of Engineers from restricting firearms on Corps properties. “This bill
would require the Interior Department and the U.S. Forest Service to provide access to lands managed by
those agencies for hunting, fishing, and recreational shooting. … Additionally, the bill blocks the
Administration’s rule to restrict trade in elephant ivory and allows the importation into the U.S. of polar
bear hunting trophies taken prior to when polar bears were listed as threatened under the Endangered
Species Act. The measure also amends the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) to prohibit the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from regulating lead contained in bullets, angling lures, and
other hunting and fishing equipment.” [HR 2406, Vote #101, 2/26/16; Office of the Democratic Whip,
2/23/16]
POTUS: Bill Would Combat Environmental Protections, Restrict Regulations On Firearm
Possession And Hunting And Fishing Activities. “[T]he Administration strongly opposes Title VI,
which would: (1) exclude management decisions from the National Environmental Policy Act, the
cornerstone law guiding environmental protection and public involvement in Federal actions; … (3)
undermine the Wilderness Act of 1964. The Administration also strongly opposes the following: …
Title IV, which would prohibit the Secretary of the Army from promulgating or enforcing any
regulations that would prohibit the possession of firearms at water resources development projects
with limited exceptions; … (5) Title XIV, which would restrict the ability of the Secretaries of the
Interior and Commerce to regulate certain recreational or commercial fishing access to certain waters;
(6) Title XV, which would potentially create public safety issues by restricting the ability of the
Secretary of Agriculture and Forest Service Chief to regulate certain hunting and fishing activities
within the National Forest System…” [Statement of Administration Policy, Executive Office of the
President, 2/24/16]
Voted For Repealing A Rule Which Banned Controversial Hunting Practices In Alaskan Natural
Preserves
Voted For An Amendment To Repeal The National Park Service Rule On Hunting And Trapping
Practices In Alaskan National Preserves. In February 2016, Katkovoted for an amendment which
“would require the National Park Service director to withdraw a 2015 final rule on hunting and trapping
in Alaskan national preserves, and would prohibit the director from issuing a similar rule.” The
amendment was adopted 236-169. [HR 2406, Vote #98, CQ, 2/26/16]
194
Natural Park Service’s Rule “Banned A Handful Of Controversial Hunting Practices On
The 20 Million Acres Of Alaska’s National Preserves.” “Driving a deeper wedge between state
and federal game managers, the National Park Service on Friday banned a handful of controversial
hunting practices on the 20 million acres of Alaska's national preserves where sport hunting is
allowed. Among the “state-authorized practices being prohibited (because they) conflict with
National Park Service law” are: Taking wolves and coyotes (including pups) during the animals’
denning season. Taking black bears with artificial light at den sites. Taking brown or black bears
attracted to bait. Using dogs in black bear hunts. State law currently prohibits using dogs to hunt
big game, with an exception for black bears. … Shooting swimming caribou, a practice primarily
used in the Noatak National Preserve in Northwest Alaska. Currently, state law prohibits taking
big game that is swimming, but hunters may shoot a swimming caribou from a boat under power,
and hunters can also shoot a caribou that has emerged from the water on the shoreline while the
hunter is still in a moving boat. … The new rules, published Friday, override state regulations, and
state officials contend they subjugate the state’s role, established under the Alaska National
Interest Lands Act, as the managing authority of fish and wildlife on all Alaska lands. But the Park
Service countered that the new rules only cement temporary regulations that have been imposed
annually for several years.” [Alaska Dispatch News, 10/23/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Eliminate An Exemption Which Allowed Importing Polar Bear
Trophies Taken In Sport
Voted Against Amendment To Eliminate An Exemption Which Allowed Importing Polar Bear
Trophies Taken In Sport. In February 2016, Katko voted against amendment to HR 2406. “An
amendment No. 3 printed in House Report 114-429 to strike Title III, the exemption to import polar bear
trophies taken in sport.” The amendment failed, 159 to 242. [HR 2406, Vote #93, 2/26/16]
2014: Hunters Who Killed Polar Bears In Canada Were Not Allowed To Import Their Game
Into The United States. “Since 2008, dozens of polar bears have been held in frozen, climatecontrolled conditions in Canada, waiting for the U.S. government to allow them into the country.
There's just one issue: These bears are dead. A complicated series of conservation laws and
disagreements between the governments of Canada and the U.S. have left 41 American polar bear
hunters and their prizes trapped in a bureaucratic limbo over the past six years. Rep. Don Young, RAlaska, who claims to be the only member of Congress to have killed one of the massive mammals
himself, aims to remedy that this week. While the United States outlawed polar bear hunting in the
Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972 (except among Alaskan natives, who are still allowed to hunt
the bears), the practice remains legal in Canada, attracting dozens of American big-game hunters
every year.” [The Atlantic, 2/04/14]
Voted For An Amendment To The STREAM Act That Would Direct Funding For Development In
Distressed Communities
Voted For An Amendment To The STREAM Act That Would Direct Funding For Development In
Distressed Communities. In January 2016, Katko Voted For an amendment to the STREAM Act that
would direct funding for economic development for distressed communities. The amendment would
“direct funds from the abandoned mined lands fund to economically distressed communities to promote
195
economic revitalization, diversification, and development.” The amendment failed, 203-219. [HR 1644,
Voted Against Amendment Aimed At Protecting Drinking Water Quality From Surface Mining
Operations
Voted Against Amendment Aimed At Protecting Drinking Water Quality From Surface Mining
Operations. In January 2016, Katko Voted Against an amendment that “would have prevented the rule in
the underlying bill from being delayed if it protects drinking water quality.” The amendment failed 189 to
223. [HR 1644, Vote #38, 1/12/16; CQ Votes, 1/12/16]
Voted Against Requiring Companies To Report Chemicals That Could Contaminate Public
Drinking Water
Voted Against Requiring Companies To Report Chemicals That Could Contaminate Public
Drinking Water. In February 2016, Katko voted against a motion “that would require any manufacturer
of items that contain chemicals that could contaminate public drinking water to submit data to relevant
state and federal agencies on the product's risks to human health and the environment, including studies
on neurotoxicity and cancer-causing effects. Exposing the public to such items without these studies
would be considered prohibited under a federal toxic substances law.” The motion failed 165-238. [HR
2406, Vote #100, CQ, 2/26/16]
196
Foreign Policy Issues
 Campaigned in support of funding Syrian rebels in 2014, and, in 2015,
voted against funding Syrian rebels.
 Supported the President’s actions against bombing ISIS, called for
ground troops to be considered as a last resort.
 Ventured to the Middle East to report on efforts to constrict fighters from
reaching ISIS.
 Noted he was influenced by Netanyahu, and opposed the Iran Deal
In 2014, Katko attacked Maffei for opposition to funding Syrian rebels, but, in
Congress, he voted against funding Syrian rebels. Katko supported the President’s
actions against ISIS and called for ground troops to be used as a last resort.
In Congress, Katko was named head of a task force that traveled to the Middle
East to address the stream of fighters venturing to ISIS.
Katko cited Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu as influencing him to oppose the
Iran Deal. Katko proposed continued negotiations with Iran while also arguing
Iran breaks every treaty.
ISIS
Voted Against Eliminating Funds To Equip Iraq and Kurdish Military To Fight ISIS
Voted Against Eliminating $715 Million To Equip Iraqi Government And Kurdish Military To
Fight ISIS. In June 2015, Katko voted against against an amendment “to further eliminate the $715
million allocated for equipping the Iraqi government and Kurdish military forces against ISIS.” The
amendment was rejected, 56-375. [The Hill, 6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote #342, 6/10/15]
Voted To Eliminating $600 Million In Funding For Syria Train And Equip Fund; Had Campaigned
Supporting Funding To Train And Equip Rebels
Voted For Amendment That Eliminates $600 Million In Funding For Syria Train And Equip Fund.
In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would “eliminate the $600 million appropriated for the
Syria Train and Equip Fund and transfer the savings to the spending reduction account.” The amendment
failed, 107-323. [H.R. 2685, Vote #343, 6/10/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15]
197
Criticized Maffei For Voting Against A Measure To Provide Assistance To Syrian Rebels. “Katko
also criticized Maffei, D-Syracuse, for voting against a measure that would provide assistance to Syrian
rebels fighting ISIS.” [The Citizen, 10/30/14]
Declared His Support For The McKeon Amendment To Train Syrian Rebels. “President Barack
Obama had requested authorization for $500 million from Congress to train and equip about 5,000
moderate Syrian rebels. The amendment sponsored by Rep. Buck McKeon, R-Calif., passed 273 to 156.
… Republican John Katko, Maffei’s opponent in this year’s election, criticized the congressman after
Wednesday’s vote. Katko said in a statement that he would have voted to pass the amendment.” [Post
Standard, 9/18/14]
2014: Supported The President’s Actions Against ISIS, Suggested Ground Troops As A Last
Resort, But Opposed Them At The Time
2014: Supported Current Efforts Against ISIS. “Katko, R-Camillus, said the threat posed by ISIS is
real. ‘We have to fight them before they come to our soil,’ Katko said. ‘That’s our job as a country. That’s
our job as lead-ers. And those are tough decisions.’ The U.S. is a war-weary nation, Katko said, after
military actions in Afghanistan and Iraq. He supports current steps taken by the U.S. military to combat
ISIS.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Supported The President’s Actions On ISIS, Suggested Ground Troops As A Last Resort. “I didn’t
make it clear, I apologize. I support the president’s action, President Obama’s bipartisan support that he
received to fund the soldiers there. To help them fight themselves and to provide air support. The problem
is, and which concerns me, is it may not be working. ISIS still seems to be doing OK. … And that’s what
we’re doing. I don’t want to do ground troops, unless it is an absolute last resort, and I don’t think we’re
there yet.” [Interview, Syracuse New Times, 10/22/14]
Opposed A Ground War With ISIS. “John Katko (JK): … That’s why I was troubled by Mr. Maffei’s
vote against funding other troops and funding for the air strikes against ISIS in Iraq and Syria. I am
absolutely agreeing with Mr. Maffei as far as not getting into another ground war. But we have to do
something, and sitting there and voting no and doing nothing is not a response.” [Interview, Syracuse
Said Ground Troops Shouldn’t Be Used Against ISIS, Then Said It Should Be Considered. “Just a
few weeks after saying he doesn‘t believe the U.S. should send in ground troops to combat a rising
terrorist group in Iraq and Syria, Republican congressional candidate John Katko is now saying that all
options, including ground forces, should be on the table.” [The Citizen, 9/18/14]
Said He Did Not Believe We Should Commit Ground Troops To Fight ISIS. “‘I think we spent
enough blood and treasure in Iraq that we’ve got to be very careful before we decide to commit ground
troops again, and I don’t think we should,’ Katko said. ‘I think the airstrikes are fine. I think that we
should be doing them. And I think we need to send a proper message to ISIS that we’re not going to
tolerate this type of conduct when you behead one of our journalists to make a point.’” [The Citizen,
9/18/14]
198
Expressed Concern With Screening Procedures In Turkey And Europe That Might Allow Fighters
To Join ISIS
Expressed Concern With Screening Procedures For The Istanbul Airport Which Might Deter ISIS
Troops. “Katko, R-Camillus, chairman of a House task force focused on the travel of terrorists and
foreign fighters, disclosed the pending deal Thursday after meeting with Turkish leaders and touring the
international airport in Istanbul. ‘We know for sure that foreign fighters that come into Turkey, and are
going to Syria, almost exclusively come through this airport,’ Katko said by video from Istanbul. ‘So it’s
very important for us to have a good handle on what they’re doing, screening passengers when they come
in, but more importantly screening them when they are leaving the coun-try.’ He added, ‘Those that have
left the battle in Syria and are heading back home, that’s what we need to know more about.’” [Post
Standard, 5/10/15]
Said He Was Surprised Passengers Were Screened Traveling Within The European Zone. “But
overall, in European nations and Turkey, Katko said not enough is being done to prevent the flow of
foreign fight-ers back to Europe or the U.S. ‘It’s surprising, even after what happened with the Charlie
Hebdo attack (in Paris), that they didn’t think that was like their 9/11 and that they would make the
sweeping reforms that they need,’ he said. ‘They still don’t even screen their passengers when they travel
from country to country within the European zone.’” [The Citizen, 5/12/15]
Voted Against Limiting Funds For Military Action Against ISIS Without Congressional
Authorization Of War
Voted Against Amendment To Limit Funds For Military Action Against ISIS Without
Congressional Authorization Of War. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would
have “halted funding for the war against the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, or ISIS, after March 31, 2016,
unless Congress passes an Authorization for the Use of Military Force. The amendment, an effort to spur
a war authorization debate and vote in Congress, would have given lawmakers nine months to produce an
AUMF before funds get cut off.” The amendment failed, 196-231. [H.R. 2685, Vote #346, 6/11/15;
Huffington Post, 6/11/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Funds For 2001 Authorization For Use Of Military Force Used To
Justify Military Campaign Against ISIS
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Funds For 2001 Authorization For Use Of Military Force
Used To Justify Military Campaign Against ISIS. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment
that would “prohibit use of funds pursuant to the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force after Dec.
31, 2015,” which President Obama cited as “legal justification for unilaterally launching a military
campaign against ISIS.” The amendment failed, 157-270. [H.R. 2685, Vote #347, 6/11/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 6/11/15; Huffington Post, 6/11/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Funds For 2002 Authorization For Use Of Military Force Used To
Justify Military Campaign Against ISIS
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Funds For 2002 Authorization For Use Of Military Force
Used To Justify Military Campaign Against ISIS. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment
199
that would “prohibit use of funds pursuant to the 2002 Authorization for Use of Military Force Against
Iraq,” which President Obama cited as “legal justification for unilaterally launching a military campaign
against ISIS.” The amendment failed, 165-264. [H.R. 2685, Vote #348, 6/11/15; CQ Floor Votes,
6/11/15; Huffington Post, 6/11/15]
Said A Terror Related Arrest Reinforced The Threat Of ISIS
Katko Said A Terror Related Arrest Reinforced The Threat Of ISIS. “A Rochester man‘s arrest for
allegedly planning a New Year’s Eve terrorist attack on a restaurant reinforces that ‘we face a real threat
in combating ISIS,’ U.S. Rep. John Katko said Thursday. ‘Keeping our community safe remains my top
priority,’ Katko, R-Camillus, said in a statement. ‘As chair of the House Homeland Security Committee’s
Foreign Fighter Task Force, I’ve worked to identify and examine the dangers that we face in combating
ISIS. I will continue my efforts as central New York’s representative in Congress to prevent ISIS from
continuing its online recruitment and radicalization, to ensure that local law enforcement is given the tools
to detect and thwart attacks, and to eliminate this ever-evolving global threat.’” [The Citizen, 1/01/16]
Gave “Thoughts And Prayers” To The People Of Parris After The Attack, Said The US Must
“Stand Together With France To Fight ISIS”
Gave “Thoughts And Prayers” To The People Of Paris After The Attack, Said The US Must “Stand
Together With France To Fight ISIS.” “‘My thoughts and prayers are with the people of Paris, as we
mourn the innocent victims of these horrific and coordinated terrorist attacks. We must continue to pray
for their loved ones and for all of the first responders who put their own lives on the line in the aftermath
of these attacks. The news today that ISIS has claimed responsibility is yet another reminder that America
and her allies must stand together with France to fight ISIS, their hateful ideology, and the violence it
incites. As Chairman of both the Foreign Fighter Task Force and the House Homeland Security
Committee’s Subcommittee on Transportation Security, I am all too aware of the lengths to which ISIS
will go to try and inflict terror. We must remain vigilant to combat global terrorism, and recognize that
ISIS is intent on inflicting harm on anyone who opposes their radical beliefs.’” [Press Release, Rep.
Katko, 11/14/15]
Iran
Met With Prime Minister Netanyahu As Part Of A Delegation And Said He Was Influenced By PM
Netanyahu
Met With Al-Abadi And Netanyahu As Part Of A Delegation. “The group traveled to Iraq and met
with Iraqi officials, including Iraqi Prime Minister Haider Al-Abadi. A major topic discussed at the
meetings was the threat posed by the Islamic State, a terrorist group operating in Iraq and Syria. … The
delegation’s trip included a stop in Israel, where the group met with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu.” [The Citizen, 5/12/15]
Said His Thinking On The Iran Deal Was Influenced By Netanyahu. “Katko said he is concerned the
deal failed to include more requirements for real-time nuclear verification, and that it did not address the
fate of four American citizens held as political prisoners in Iran. … The congressman said his thinking on
200
the issue was influenced by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who met with Katko and seven
other House members for two hours during a May visit to Jerusalem.” [Post Standard, 7/21/15]
Said We Turned Our Backs On Israel With The Iran Deal. “Later in the interview, Katko added, ‘I
think we turned our backs to Israel on this one.’” [The Citizen, 8/06/15]
Said He Opposed The Iran Deal Due To Sanctions Relief, Hostages, And Said The Deal “Fails To
Shut Off Iran’s Path To a Nuclear Weapon
Said He Opposed The Iran Deal Due To Sanctions Relief, Lack Of Release Of Held Americans,
Lifting Arms Embargoes, And Said The Deal “Fails To Shut Off Iran’s Path To A Nuclear
Weapon. “’I have had concerns with the Iran Nuclear Agreement from the outset. Since that time, I have
had the opportunity to study the proposed agreement and judge it on its merits, with input from my
constituents across Central New York. Ultimately, there are many aspects of this deal that I simply do not
agree with. Iran remains the largest state sponsor of terrorism in the world. Yet, this deal fails to shut off
Iran’s path to a nuclear weapon. It hands out billions of dollars in sanction relief, but fails to demand the
release of the four Americans still being held hostage in Iran. And, it lifts arms and ballistic missile
embargoes but fails to allow immediate inspection of current and suspected nuclear sites.’” [Press
Release, Rep. Katko, 9/11/15]
Opposed The Iran Deal, Said It “Stinks” And The US Shouldn’t Trust Iran, That Iran Never
Follows Treaties, But Proposed To Continue Negotiations
Raised Funds Off His Opposition To The Iran Deal, Said The Iran Deal “Stinks” And Suggested
The US Should Not Trust Iran. “Katko used some of his strongest language about his opposition to the
Iran deal in a fundraising email he sent to supporters Thursday night. ‘Simply put, this deal stinks,’ Katko
wrote. ‘Iran is the world's largest sponsor of terrorism, is holding four Americans hostage, and regularly
calls for the destruction of America and our ally Israel. Does this seem like a nation we should trust?’”
Said Iran Never Follows Any Treaties. “Later in the interview, Katko added, ‘I think we turned our
backs to Israel on this one.’ … ‘Iran never follows any international treaties and they're still the largest
state sponsor of terrorism in the world," he said. ‘They sponsor Hezbollah, Hamas, the West Bank
terrorist acts, the Gaza Strip, the Golan Heights. All that's Iran backed. They produced IEDs and gave
them to our opponents in Afghanistan and Iraq that led to the deaths of hundreds of Americans and
maimed thousands of others. They're still doing that stuff.’” [The Citizen, 8/06/15]
… But Proposed To Continue Negotiations With Iran Rather Than War Or Approval Of
The Iran Deal. “‘While proponents of this agreement may argue that the only alternative to
approving this deal is war, I disagree. Iran began these negotiations because of economic
sanctions. I believe that continuing diplomatic efforts would result in a better deal – one that
continues to put economic pressure on Iran, demands renunciation of nuclear arms ambitions, and
prioritizes the return of the Americans being held hostage. This administration should be sent back
to the negotiating table.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 9/11/15]
201
Voted For A Resolution Asserting That The President Did Not Provide Information For
Congressional Review Of The Iran Nuclear Deal
Voted For A Resolution Asserting That The President Did Not Provide Information For
Congressional Review Of The Iran Nuclear Deal. In September 2015, Katko voted for a resolution
“asserting that the Obama administration did not provide information required for congressional review of
the Iran nuclear deal… The measure … would find that the review period under the Iran Nuclear
Agreement Review Act has not officially started because the president has not transmitted all so-called
side deals to Congress. Conservative Republicans … assert the mandated 60-day review period cannot
legally be said to have begun since Congress has not had physical access to two separate arrangements
between the International Atomic Energy Agency and Tehran. Specifically, Republicans are objecting to
the absence of a ‘road map’ between Iran and the IAEA that lays out commitments by Tehran to disclose
past and present alleged military research with nuclear dimensions.” The bill passed 245 to 186. [H.Res.
411, Vote #492, 9/10/15; CQ, 9/10/15]
Voted Against A Measure Expressing Congressional Approval Of The Iran Nuclear Deal
Voted Against A Measure Expressing Congressional Approval Of The Iran Nuclear Deal. In
September 2015, Katko voted against “a measure expressing congressional approval of the Iran nuclear
agreement Friday, placing a majority of the chamber on the record against the accord. The measure …
states simply that Congress favors the pact. The bill was likely to fail on the House floor, but in so doing
put Democrats on the record in support of the deal.” The motion failed 169 to 269. [H.R. 3461, Vote
#493, 9/11/15; CQ, 9/14/15]
Voted For The Bill To Prevent The President From Reducing Iran’s Sanctions Until 2017
Voted For The Bill To Prevent The President From Reducing Iran’s Sanctions Until 2017. In
September 2015, Katko voted for a bill that would suspend the President’s authority to reduce, waive, or
suspend sanctions on Iran until January 21, 2017. The bill passed, 247 to 186. [HR 3460, Vote #494,
9/11/15; CQ, 9/11/15; AP, 9/11/15]
Voted For Prohibiting Waiving Iran Sanctions
Voted For Prohibiting Waiving Iran Sanctions Until Iran Pays Legal Terrorism Related Judgment.
In October 2015, Katko voted for to “prohibit the president from waiving sanctions under the Iran Nuclear
Agreement until Iran pays the legal terrorism-related judgment it owes. The president would be required
to certify to Congress that the Iranian government has paid all outstanding judgments before Iran's
sanctions are lifted or its assets released.” The bill passed, 251-173. [CQ Floor Votes, 10/01/15; HR 3457,
Vote #533, 10/01/15]
Voted For A Bill To Restrict The President’s Ability To Lift Sanctions On Iranian And Other
Financial Institutions As Called For By The 2015 Iran Nuclear Agreement.
Voted For A Bill To Restrict The President’s Ability To Lift Sanctions On Iranian And Other
Financial Institutions As Called For By The 2015 Iran Nuclear Agreement. In February 2016, Katko
voted for a bill to “restrict the president's ability to lift sanctions on Iranian and other financial
202
institutions, as called for by the 2015 Iran nuclear agreement, by requiring various certifications to
Congress. Specifically, it would prohibit the president from removing the foreign financial institutions
from the Treasury Department's Office of Foreign Asset Control's list of blocked nationals and persons
until the president submits to Congress a certification that the institutions have not knowingly facilitated a
significant transaction for Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps, a foreign terrorist organization or anyone
sanctioned in connection with Iran's weapons of mass destruction and ballistic-missile programs.” The bill
passed 246 to 181. [H Res 3662, Vote #54, 2/02/16; CQ Floor Votes, 2/02/16]
Other
Said our Foreign Policy was “Inconsistent and Ineffective,” and Displayed Weakness
In April 2014, Katko said, “Our foreign policy is inconsistent and ineffective. We need to show strength
and resolve, not weakness and confusion. We should not be sending troops into every fray, unless directly
tied to our national security or our national interest.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Said It Was Good The Torture Report Was Released, Questioned If That Was The Entirety Of The
Story
Said It Was Good The Torture Report Was Released, Questioned If That Was The Entirety Of The
Story. “Katko said Monday that the brutality and cruelty outlined by the report needed to be made public
so that America can learn from its mistakes. But he said he’s not convinced the public received the full
story in the summary of a five-year Senate Intelligence Committee investigation. ‘It’s pretty clear that
some of these things went further than anyone intended them to go, and it’s a good thing that they’re
being brought to light,’ Katko said. ‘And I’m glad that they’re being brought to light.’ He added, ‘The
question I have is, is this the full story, or is there more to it? From what I understand, they never interviewed any of the participants or those being accused of these things. It’s not clear to me that we have the
whole story.’” [Post Standard, 12/16/14]
Voted For Extending Select Committee Investigation Of Benghazi
Voted For Extending Select Committee Investigation Of Benghazi. In January 2015, Katko voted for a
House Rules package that extended the House select committee investigation into the 2012 attacks on the
U.S. embassy in Benghazi. The resolution passed, 234-172. [H Res 5, Vote #6, 1/06/15]
Extension Set Not Limit On Budget Or Time Frame. “Five Democrats on the select committee
lamented the reauthorization, which set no limit on the committee's budget or time frame, which
means it could last well into the presidential election year.” [New York Times, 1/06/15]
Investigation Estimated To Cost $1.5 Million In 2014. “The House is on track to spend around $1.5
million this year on the Republican-created special committee to further investigate the 2012 attack on
the U.S. diplomatic compound in Benghazi, Libya, according to congressional spending reports.”
[USA Today, 12/03/14]
Previous House Investigations Into Benghazi Found No Wrongdoing. “Democrats call the
committee a waste of time and money. No questions about the attack are left to answer, they say,
203
particularly after a new House Intelligence Committee report found no wrongdoing by government
agencies.” [USA Today, 12/03/14]
Voted For A Motion To Continue The Benghazi Select Committee
Voted For A Motion To Continue The Benghazi Select Committee. In October 2015, Katko voted for
a motion to table the ruling of the Chair and continue the Select Committee on Benghazi, even after
Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy admitted it was a partisan tactic. The motion failed, 240-183. [Motion,
Vote #536, 10/07/15; Rep. Louise Slaughter, Press Release, 10/07/15; Congressional Record, 10/07/15]
Voted For Prohibiting Funding For START Treaty Until Russia Withdraws From Ukraine
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit Funding To Implement START Treaty Until Russia Withdraws
From Ukraine. In May 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would “bar funds authorized to be
appropriated or otherwise made available for the Defense Department in fiscal 2016 from being used to
implement the New START treaty until the president certifies that Russia's armed forces are ‘no longer
illegally occupying Ukrainian territory,’ as well as certain other certifications.” The amendment was
adopted, 235 to 182. [H.R. 1735, Vote #234, 5/15/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/15/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Ban Spending For Promoting The Cuban Military
Voted Against Amendment To Ban Spending For Promoting The Cuban Military. In June 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies
Appropriations Act, that “prohibits use of funds to facilitate, permit, license, or promote exports to the
Cuban military or intelligence service or to any officer of the Cuban military or intelligence service, or an
immediate family member thereof.” The amendment failed 153-273. [HR 2578, Vote #277, 6/03/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Flights And Maritime Commerce Between The United States And Cuba
Voted Against Prohibiting Flights And Maritime Commerce Between The United States And Cuba.
In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Transportation, Housing and Urban
Development, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2016 that would have prohibited funding to
implement provisions in the bill that would limit economic ties with Cuba by “bar[ring] use of funds to
facilitate new flights originating from the United States that land, or pass through, property confiscated by
the Cuban government,” and “bar[ring] use of funds by the Federal Maritime Commission to issue a
license or certificate for a commercial vessel that docked or anchored within the previous 180 days within
seven miles of a port on property that was confiscated by the Cuban government.” The amendment failed
176 to 247. [HR 2577, Vote #306, 6/04/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/04/15]
Voted Against Ending Spending On Afghanistan Infrastructure Fund Projects
Voted Against Ending Spending On Existing Projects Under Afghanistan Infrastructure Fund. In
June 2015, Katko voted against an “amendment that would strike provisions under the Afghanistan
Security Forces Fund that allows the secretary of Defense to expend funds appropriated for existing
projects under the Afghanistan Infrastructure Fund.” The amendment passed, 233-199. [ CQ Floor Votes,
6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote #341, 6/10/15]
204
Voted For Prohibiting Secretary Of Defense From Waiving Restrictions On Aid For Pakistan
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit Secretary Of Defense From Waiving Restrictions On Aid For
Pakistan. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would disallow “the secretary of Defense, in
consultation with the secretary of State, to waive certain restrictions on aid to Pakistan by certifying in
writing to congressional defense committees that it is in national security interest to do so.” The
Voted Against Prohibiting Funding For Live-Fire Ranges Or Training Courses Within Northern
Marianas Islands
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Funding For Live-Fire Ranges Or Training Courses Within
Northern Marianas Islands. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would “prohibit use
of funds to establish any live-fire range, training course, or maneuver area within the Northern Marianas
Islands.” The amendment failed, 173-256. [H.R. 2685, Vote #349, 6/11/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Voted Against Withdrawing Troops From Iraq
Voted Against Withdrawing Troops From Iraq By The End Of 2015 At The Latest. In June 2015,
Katko voted against a resolution “which would have required Obama to remove the troops within 30 days,
or by the end of 2015 if the administration determined it was not safe to do so within the 30-day
timeframe.” The resolution failed 139 to 288. [H Con Res 55, Vote #370, 6/17/15; Reuters, 6/17/15]
Voted Against Reducing Funding For The Secretary Departmental Operations To Increase
Funding For Insular Affairs By $5 Million
Voted Against Reducing Funding For The Secretary Departmental Operations To Increase
Funding For Insular Affairs By $5 Million. In July 2015, Katko voted against “reduc[ing] funding for
the Office of the Secretary Departmental Operations by 5 million and increase funding for the Insular
Affair by a similar amount.” The amendment failed 183-245. [HR 2822, Vote #395, 7/08/15; H AMDT
549, 7/08/15]
Insular Affairs Coordinates Federal Policy For Island Territories Including American Samoa
And Guam. “The Assistant Secretary for Insular Areas carries out the administrative responsibilities
of the Secretary of the Interior in coordinating federal policy for the territories of American Samoa,
Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. The Assistant
Secretary is also responsible for administering and overseeing U.S. federal assistance to the freely
associated states of the Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands, and the
Republic of Palau under the Compacts of Free Association, as well as providing technical and
financial assistance to all the Insular Areas.” [US Department of Interior, accessed 10/21/15]
205
Gun Issues
 Had his U.S. Attorney’s Office-issued gun stolen from his car and used in a
robbery, double homicide
 The Auburn Citizen reported Katko “stated his support for a bill that would
prevent terrorists from buying guns,” but voted ten times to block such a bill
 Opposed the SAFE Act, said he wanted to prevent it from getting into federal law
 Opposed additional restrictions of gun purchases, including the Manchin-Toomey
bipartisan background check bill, and said gun control laws have not been shown
to reduce crime; Katko promised to work “to improve background check systems”
yet voted to block research on gun violence, and block background check
expansion
 In response to the discovery of a gun runner bringing guns from Georgia to New
York, Katko wrote a bill to increase screenings of airport employee screenings
In 2000, Katko had a gun that was issued to him through the United States
Attorney’s office stolen from his car. The gun was traded for drugs and then used in
a robbery and double homicide on Burt St in Syracuse, New York. The US
Attorney’s office said the gun was issued to Katko after he received credible death
threats and was not the gun that killed two men and injured another.
Katko, who has multiple times referred to himself as a lifelong sportsman and gun
owner, opposed New York’s SAFE Act. He called it a “knee jerk” reaction and said
that gun control laws have not been shown to reduce crime. Katko said he wanted to
prevent principals of the SAFE Act from getting into federal legislation. Katko
noted he opposed the Manchin-Toomey background check bill, and opposed any
additional federal restrictions on the purchase of guns.
Katko proposed increased enforcement of existing gun laws as a response to gun
crime. When he was an Assistant US attorney, Katko only increased his
enforcement of existing gun laws after he was asked to by Syracuse Mayor Miner.
Seventy percent of guns used in crimes in New York State come from out of state. In
response to the discovery of a gun trafficking ring bringing guns through the
Atlanta Airport to New York, Katko sponsored a bill which passed the House which
increases screenings on airport workers.
206
Declined To Discuss His Position On Rep. King’s Bill To Deny Firearms To “Suspected Terrorists,”
Voted Against Rep. King’s Bill, But Said He Supported “A Bill That Would Prevent Terrorists
From Buying Guns.”
Was “Unavailable” To Discuss His Position On Rep. King’s Bill To Deny Firearms To “Suspected
Terrorists.” “The deadliest U.S. mass shooting in nearly three years has some in Congress renewing calls
to pass a bipartisan bill that would prevent legal sales of guns to suspected terrorists. Only two House
members from Upstate New York, and 53 nationwide, have signed on to support the bill authored by Rep.
Peter King, R-Long Island, the dean of New York’s Republican congressional delegation. In fact, only
one other New York Republican - Rep. Dan Donovan of Staten Island - has signed on as a co-sponsor of
the ‘Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act of 2015.’ … Rep. John Katko, RCamillus Katko, a gun rights supporter, has not signed on as a co-sponsor. The Syracuse-area
congressman was not available Friday to discuss his position on the issue.” [Post Standard, 12/06/15]
Auburn Citizen Newspaper: “Katko Also Stated His Support For A Bill That Would Prevent
Terrorists From Buying Guns.” And Noted Rep. King’s Bill. “Katko also stated his support for a bill
that would prevent terrorists from buying guns. U.S. Rep. Peter King, a New York Republican, has
introduced a bill that would prohibit individuals who have provided material support to a terrorist group
or may have ties to terrorism from purchasing firearms.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Voted Ten Times To Block Legislation To Prohibit Suspected Terrorists From Buying Guns
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Prohibiting Suspected Terrorists From Buying Guns. In
December 2015, Katko voted for a motion to order the previous question (thus ending debate and
possibility of amendment) on the rule H Res 539. “The Democratic Previous Question would call for an
immediate vote on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying Firearms and Explosives to
Dangerous Terrorists Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by closing the terrorist gun loophole
and preventing people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.” [H RES 539, Vote #646, 12/1/15;
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Stopping Suspected Terrorists From Buying Firearms. In
December 2015, Katko voted for to block consideration of a vote “to protect the American people by
The previous question carried, 243-179. [Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 2/03/15; H Res 542,
Vote #653, 12/02/15]
On Terrorist Watchlist From Buying Firearms. In December 2015, Katko voted for to block
consideration of a vote to “call for an immediate vote on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying
Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by
The previous question carried, 243-179. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on
Rep. Peter King’s bill. [H Res 546, Vote #666, 12/03/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions,
12/03/15]
207
Voted For To Block Consideration Of A Bill Allowing Those Listed On The Terror Watch List To
Own Firearms. In December 2015, Katko voted for blocking a measure to prohibit an “immediate vote
on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act,
H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by closing the terrorist gun loophole and preventing people on
the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms. The previous question failed 242-178. [H Res 556 Vote #682
Voted For Tabling The Appeal Of The Chair Which Ruled Against Scheduling Vote On A Bill To
Prohibit Those Listed On The Terror Watch List From Purchasing Firearms. In December 2015,
Katko voted for a motion to table the appeal of the ruling of the Chair that the “Pelosi privileged
resolution is out of order. The Pelosi privileged resolution would direct the Speaker to place on the
calendar the Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act (HR 1076), which would
allow the Attorney General to deny the sale or transfer of firearms to individuals suspected of engaging in
or assisting terrorist activities. The motion failed 242-173. [Motion to Table, Vote #688 12/8/15; CQ
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill To Close The Terrorist Gun Loophole. In December
2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of the Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous
Terrorists Act, a bill “to protect the American people by closing the terrorist gun loophole and preventing
people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.” The previous question carried, 236-177. A vote
firearm or explosive to know or suspected terrorists. A no vote would have The previous question carried,
239-175. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on closing the loophole. [H Res 579,
Vote #2, 1/06/16; Democratic Leader – 114th Previous Questions, 1/06/16]
firearm or explosive to know or suspected terrorists. The previous question carried, 241-176. A vote
against the previous question was to force the vote on closing the loophole. [H Res 580, Vote #4, 1/06/16;
Democratic Leader – 114th Previous Questions, 1/06/16]
208
On Terrorist Watchlist From Buying Firearms. In January 2016, Katko voted for consideration of a
vote to “call for an immediate vote on Republican Congressman Peter King’s Denying Firearms and
Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act, H.R. 1076, to protect the American people by closing the
terrorist gun loophole and preventing people on the terrorist watchlist from buying firearms.” The
be considered. [HRes 581, Vote #21, 1/07/16; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 1/07/16]
firearm or explosive to known or suspected terrorists. The previous question carried, 239-175. A vote
against the previous question was to force the vote on closing the loophole. [H Res 583, Vote # 36,
Suggested That “Church” Was Not An Appropriate Venue In Which to Carry A Weapon
Suggested That “Church” Was Not An Appropriate Venue In Which to Carry A Weapon. “Katko
said he left the gun in his truck because he and his wife didn’t feel comfortable taking it into the church.
They were at the church to attend a meeting with other volunteers in the Onondaga County Foster Parent
Program, he said. ‘Clearly not an appropriate venue to be carrying a weapon of any kind,’ he said.” [The
Citizen, 8/28/14]
Opposed Any New Federal Restrictions On The Purchase Of Firearms, Including The ManchinToomey Background Check Proposal
Said He Opposed The Manchin-Toomey Background Check Proposal. “He opposes any new federal
restrictions on the purchase of firearms, including a proposal that failed in the U.S. Senate in April 2013
that would have expanded federal background checks. ‘We have a very robust federal system as it is, and
I have been enforcing gun laws for 20 years,’ Katko said.” [Post Standard, 7/22/14]
Proposed A Tax Rebate For Buying Gun Safes
Proposed A Tax Rebate For Buying Gun Safes. “Katko said he would support and encourage measures
for safe gun ownership, including a tax rebate for individuals who buy gun safes.” [Post Standard,
7/22/14]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Background Checks For Gun Purchases
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Background Checks For Gun Purchases. In October 2015,
Katko voted for to block consideration of a vote “on the bipartisan King-Thompson Public Safety and
Second Amendment Rights Protection Act to strengthen the life-saving background checks that keep guns
out of the wrong hands.” The previous question passed, 244-183. A vote against the previous question
was to force a vote on background checks. [H Res 466, Vote #541, 10/8/15; Democratic Leader –
Previous Questions, 10/23/15]
209
Said He Was Working To “Improve Background Check Systems”
Said He Was Working To “Improve Background Check Systems,” “But Katko, R-Camillus, doesn't
believe Obama's approach is the right one to combat gun violence. Bypassing Congress to implement
these policies is a ‘divisive tactic,’ he said. ‘Meaningful and effective reform will only come if we do
more to improve background check systems, actually identify those individuals who pose threats, improve
access to mental health care and work to counter radical extremism,’ he said. ‘I have and will continue to
work on these types of bipartisan, common sense solutions in Congress so that our nation can come
together and make a difference to protect our communities from gun violence.’” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Called For More To Be “Done To Prevent Gun Violence,” And Said “Law Enforcement Needs
More Support And The Background Check System Should Be Improved. Greater Access To
Mental Health Services Also Should Be A Priority”
“He Does Believe More Needs To Be Done To Prevent Gun Violence,” Said “Law Enforcement
Needs More Support And The Background Check System Should Be Improved. Greater Access To
Mental Health Services Also Should Be A Priority.” “While Katko isn't supportive of Obama's actions,
he does believe more needs to be done to prevent gun violence. Before running for Congress in 2014, he
was a federal prosecutor in Syracuse. From that experience, he learned that local law enforcement
agencies lack the resources to enforce existing laws. To reduce shootings, Katko said local law
enforcement needs more support and the background check system should be improved. Greater access to
mental health services also should be a priority.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
“Doesn’t Dispute That The Rise In Gun Violence Must Be Addressed,” But Disagreed With The
President’s Use Of Executive Authority
“Doesn’t Dispute That The Rise In Gun Violence Must Be Addressed.” But Disagreed With The
President’s Use Of Executive Authority. “U.S. Rep. John Katko doesn't dispute that the rise in gun
violence must be addressed. But he disagrees with President Barack Obama's use of executive authority to
impose policies instead of working with Congress on legislation.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of The Gun Violence Research Act.
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of The Gun Violence Research Act. In February 2016, Katko
voted for blocking consideration of “an immediate vote on Congressman Mike Honda’s Gun Violence
Research Act, H.R. 3926, to lift the ban on gun violence research so we can confront the national gun
violence epidemic.” The previous question passed, 240 to 176. A vote against the previous question
would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 595, Vote #55, 2/03/16; Democratic Leader,
2/03/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Lift Ban On Gun Violence Research
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Lift Ban On Gun Violence Research. In February 2016,
Katko voted for blocking consideration of “Congressman Mike Honda’s Gun Violence Research Act,
H.R. 3926, to lift the ban on gun violence research.” The previous question carried, 237 to 178. [H Res
611, Vote #77, 2/11/16; Democratic Leadership, 2/11/16; HR 3926, 11/04/15]
210
Voted For Designating Gun Violence Research An NSF Priority
Voted For Designating Gun Violence Research An NSF Priority. In February 2016, Katko voted for a
motion that “The House refused, 177-241, to designate gun-violence research as a National Science
Foundation priority, so that science could potentially help reduce gun deaths as it has done for smoking
and highway mortality. A yes vote was to adopt the amendment to HR 3293.” The motion failed, 177 to
241. [H.R. 3293, Vote# 69; St. Louis Post Dispatch, 2/12/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill That Would Lift The Ban On Gun Violence Research
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill That Would Lift The Ban On Gun Violence Research.
In February 2016, Katko voted for blocking consideration of the Gun Violence Research Act, H.R. 3926,
“to lift the ban on gun violence research.” The Gun Violence Research Act will “[g]ive the CDC the
authority to research the causes, mechanisms, prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of injuries with respect
to gun violence; encourage the improvement and expansion of National Violent Death Reporting
Systems; and empower health care providers by not inhibiting a physician or other health care provider
from asking a patient about the possession of a firearm, speaking to a patient about gun safety, or
reporting to authorities a patient’s threat of violence.” The previous question passed, 236 to 178. A vote
against the previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 594, Vote #48,
2/02/16; Democratic Leader, 2/02/16; Rep. Mike Honda Press Release, 11/05/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill To Allow The CDC To Study The Effects Of Gun
Violence
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Bill To Allow The CDC To Study The Effects Of Gun
Violence. In February 2016, Katko voted for blocking consideration of a bill that “would lift a ban on
allowing the Centers for Disease Control to research the causes of gun violence … The CDC’s selfimposed prohibition has been in place since 1996. In the 1990s, the National Rifle Association accused
the CDC of trying to use scientific studies to promote gun control, such as one that found having a gun in
the home increased the odds for injury. Congress later threatened to cut the CDC's budget by the same
amount the CDC was spending on gun violence research. Lawmakers also enacted legislative language
prohibiting the use of funds to ‘advocate or promote gun control.’ The CDC has since then shied away
from pursuing the topic. Republicans have continued to defend the ban.” The previous question passed,
237 to 180. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H. Res.
609, Vote #65; Congressional Record, 2/10/16; The Hill, 11/05/15]
Opposed Any New Federal Gun Control
In July 2014, Katko said that he would oppose any new federal restrictions on the purchase of
firearms, including expanded federal background checks.
“A lot of the gun laws work, and some do not,” Katko said. “But I don’t think additional bans on
guns are going to solve the problem. I am for stepping up enforcement for those people who
illegally obtain guns—criminals—and I will do everything in my power to make sure the New
York SAFE Act never becomes a federal law.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
211
Called The Charleston Shooter A “Knucklehead”; Suggested He Was Part Of A Terrorist Group
Called The Charleston Shooter A “Knucklehead,”; Suggested He Was Part Of A Terrorist Group.
KATKO: … They call it countering violent extremism. That doesn’t just apply to foreign fighters. That
applies to homegrown, U.S. terrorist groups, such as the knucklehead who caused the terrible problems in
Charleston, South Carolina. [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/15]
Supported Gun Safety Measures
In July 2014, Katko said that he would support and encourage measures for safe gun ownership,
such as tax rebates for individuals who buy gun safes. [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Said Gun Control Laws have not Been Shown to Reduce Crime
In April 2014, when asked his thoughts on the Second Amendment and proposed restrictions Katko said,
“I am a lifelong outdoorsman – a hunter and a fisherman – and a gun owner. Limiting the Second
Amendment rights of law-abiding citizens has not been shown to reduce crimes.”
“Criminals are by definition people who will not follow laws. My first-hand experience as a prosecutor
demonstrates that the weapons used in crimes are usually stolen or smuggled guns. We need to work
harder to prevent weapons from getting into criminal hands or those with mental health issues.” [Eagle
Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Ramped Up Gun Prosecutions in Syracuse at Mayor’s Request
In November 2010, Katko said six or seven gun cases have been transferred from state to federal court for
prosecution. That’s more than were transferred all of last year, he said.
The increase came after Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner contacted the U.S. Attorney’s office to request
more aggressive federal prosecution of gun crime. [Post-Standard, 11/10/10]
Had Campaign Booth at Syracuse Gun Show
In April 2014, Katko had a campaign booth at the Syracuse Gun Show held at the New York State
Fairgrounds April 12 – 13. Tables at the expo cost $65 for New York State Arms Collectors Association
members and $75 for non-members. [Syracuse Gun Show, accessed 4/24/14]
212
[John Katko for Congress Facebook, 4/14/14]
Spoke at Wayne County Second Amendment Rights Group Meeting
In April 2014, Katko spoke at the monthly meeting of Wayne County SCOPE (Shooter’s Committee on
Political Education). “Addressed 150 members of Wayne County SCOPE at their monthly meeting last
night at the Palmyra VFW on the importance of our fight,” Katko wrote on his campaign Facebook page.
[John Katko for Congress Facebook, 4/10/14]
Wayne County SCOPE Opposed the SAFE Act
213
In April 2014, Wayne County SCOPE described themselves as “New York State's Second
Amendment defending organization.” The organization staunchly opposed New York’s SAFE Act
and had multiple posts on their Facebook page showing their members protesting the legislation.
They posted a picture to their Facebook of a dummy Gov. Cuomo hanging from a stick and wrote,
“Today, millions of gun owners are criminals due to a ban forced upon us by a raving lunatic
dictator. This tyrant stole our civil rights, constitutional rights, property rights and our dignity.
[…] November 4th is our turn to ban Cuomo from Albany. VOTE HIM OUT!” [Wayne County
SCOPE Facebook, 4/15/14]
Katko Received An A+ Rating From NY SCOPE. “Republican John Katko won in the 24th District
against Democratic incumbent Daniel Maffei. This seat has been going back and forth from Dan Maffei
(in the 25th District before redistricting after the 2010 census), to Republican Ann Marie Burkle, back to
Maffei in the 24th, and now has returned to Republican control. John Katko is A+ rated by SCOPE. He is
a signer of the Candidate Pledge.” [New York Shooters Committee On Political Education Newsletter,
December 2014]
NRA Endorsed Katko
NRA Endorsed Katko. “The National Rife Association ‘s political arm is urging members to support
Republican congressional candidate John Katko in his bid to unseat U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei.” [The Citizen,
10/16/14]
Voted For Consideration Of Bill Providing For $51.4 Billion In Funding For The Departments Of
Justice And Commerce, Resulting In Relaxed Gun Restrictions
214
Voted For Consideration Of Bill Providing For $51.4 Billion In Funding For The Departments Of
Justice And Commerce. In June 2015, Katko voted for a resolution providing for the consideration of
H.R. 2557 and H.R. 2578. According to CQ Bill Track, “A resolution providing for consideration of HR
2577, a bill making appropriations for the Departments of Transportation, and Housing and Urban
Development, and related agencies for the fiscal year ending Sept. 30, 2015, and for other purposes, and
providing for consideration of HR 2578, bill making appropriations for the Departments of Commerce
and Justice, Science and related agencies for the fiscal year ending Sept. 30, 2015, and for other
purposes.” According to the Hill, “The House on Wednesday passed the fourth of a dozen spending bills
for fiscal 2016, funding the Justice and Commerce departments as well as science agencies. Lawmakers
approved the $51.4 billion measure in a 242-183 vote, after adopting amendments regarding gun control,
immigration, U.S.-Cuba relations, Guantánamo Bay and marijuana. Passage of the bill came after the
White House threatened to veto the legislation because of insufficient funding levels, capped by
sequestration, and controversial policy riders that would undermine President Obama’s policy to
normalize relations with Cuba, relax gun restrictions and block funds for the transfer of any detainees at
Guantánamo Bay prison to the United States.” The resolution passed 242 to 180. [H. Res. 287, Vote #268,
6/02/15; CQ Bill Track, 6/01/15; The Hill, 6/03/15]
Appropriations Bill Would Have Relaxed Gun Restrictions. “The House on Wednesday passed the
fourth of a dozen spending bills for fiscal 2016, funding the Justice and Commerce departments as
well as science agencies. Lawmakers approved the $51.4 billion measure in a 242-183 vote, after
adopting amendments regarding gun control, immigration, U.S.-Cuba relations, Guantánamo Bay and
marijuana…. Passage of the bill came after the White House threatened to veto the legislation because
of insufficient funding levels, capped by sequestration, and controversial policy riders that would
undermine President Obama’s policy to normalize relations with Cuba, relax gun restrictions and
block funds for the transfer of any detainees at Guantánamo Bay prison to the United States.” [The
Hill, 6/03/15]
Voted For Underfunding Agencies And Relax Gun Restrictions
Voted For Underfunding Agencies And Relax Gun Restrictions. In June 2015, Katko voted for Justice
and Commerce spending bill that underfunded agencies. “The House on Wednesday passed the fourth of a
dozen spending bills for fiscal 2016, funding the Justice and Commerce departments as well as science
agencies. Lawmakers approved the $51.4 billion measure in a 242-183 vote, after adopting amendments
regarding gun control, immigration, U.S.-Cuba relations, Guantánamo Bay and marijuana. Passage of the
bill came after the White House threatened to veto the legislation because of insufficient funding levels,
capped by sequestration, and controversial policy riders that would undermine President Obama’s policy
to normalize relations with Cuba, relax gun restrictions and block funds for the transfer of any detainees
at Guantánamo Bay prison to the United States.” The amendment failed, 208 to 215. [HR 2578, Vote
#297, 6/03/15; The Hill, 6/03/15]
Voted For An Amendment That Prevented The ATF From Banning Some Forms Of ArmorPiercing Ammunition And Military Style Handguns
Voted For An Amendment That Prevented The ATF From Banning Some Forms Of ArmorPiercing Ammunition And Military Style Handguns. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that
prevented the ATF from banning some forms of armor-piercing ammunition and military style handguns.
215
“The Commerce-Justice-Science appropriations bill, which cruised through the House this week, contains
several provisions directed squarely at the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives’ (ATF)
rule-making authority. Under the measure, the ATF would be prohibited from banning certain forms of
armor-piercing ammunition or blocking the importation of military-style shotguns. Another provision
would block federal agents from creating what critics say is a gun registry … Among them is the ATF’s
proposed — and later withdrawn — ban on certain forms of armor-piercing ammunition used in AR-15
rifles … Eventually, the ATF relented and pulled back the bullet ban, but the agency left the door open to
reconsider the rule in the future. To make sure this doesn’t happen again, Republicans included multiple
provisions, authored by Reps. Richard Hudson (R-N.C.) and Thomas Massie (R-Ky.), in the bill barring
future action.” The amendment passed 250 to 171. [HR 2578, Vote #289, 6/03/15; On Agreeing to the
Amendment, 6/03/15; The Hill; 6/05/15]
Voted Against Exempting Claims By Gun Owners Seeking Monetary Relief On Defective Firearms
Voted Against Exempting Claims By Gun Owners Seeking Monetary Relief On Defective Firearms.
In January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment that “amendment that would exempt claims brought
by a gun owner seeking monetary relief involving the defective design or manufacturing of a firearm.”
The amendment failed, 163-232. [HR 1927, Vote #25, 1/08/16; CQ Floor Votes, 1/08/16]
Voted For Prohibiting Arrests Under State Law Of People Transporting Locked, Unloaded Guns
Voted For An Amendment To Prohibit Arrests Under State Law Of People Transporting Locked,
Unloaded Guns. In February 2016, Katkovoted for an amendment which “would prohibit arrest under
state law of individuals transporting a firearm if they are transporting an unloaded firearm that is stored in
a locked container, secured by a safety device or is not accessible from the vehicle's passenger
compartment. Arrest would require probable cause to believe the person is transporting the firearm in a
manner that is not provided for under standards outlined in the amendment. It also would provide for a
defendant who prevails in asserting the amendment's provisions as a defense in a criminal case to be
awarded reasonable attorney's fees.” The amendment was adopted 239-165. [HR 2406, Vote #96, CQ,
2/26/16]
Voted For Amendment To Not Allow A Person Prohibited From Possessing A Firearm From Using
Public Target Ranges
Voted For Amendment To Not Allow A Person Prohibited From Possessing A Firearm From Using
Public Target Ranges. In February 2016, Katko voted for amendment to HR 2406. “An amendment No.
2 printed in House Report 114-429 to prohibit an individual who is prohibited from possessing a firearm
by the Gun Control Act from using a public target range.” The amendment failed, 161 to 244. [HR 2406,
Vote#92, 2/26/16]
NY SAFE Act
Said He Wanted to Prevent Principals of the SAFE Act from Getting into Federal Legislation
In February 2014, Katko said, “The SAFE Act at the state level is a huge issue. People are upset about it.
One of the things that I want to make sure to get out is that I want to make sure that I do everything I can
216
to ensure that the SAFE Act and the principles of the SAFE Act don’t creep their way into federal
legislation.”
“I fear that if it’s a Democratic-controlled House, that’s exactly what’s going to happen. I’m going to do
everything I can to fight against that,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Opposed the SAFE Act, Called it a “Knee-Jerk” Reaction
In January 2014, Katko, a lifelong hunter and gun owner - who built a reputation for his work prosecuting
Syracuse gangs - said he opposed the New York SAFE Act.
“I’m an avid hunter and I think the SAFE Act is a knee-jerk reaction to a tragedy,” he said. “Criminals
don’t buy guns legally. If we would enforce the laws now, we would be a lot better off.” [Post-Standard,
1/14/14]
Katko Said He “Fully Believes” In Gun Laws, But The SAFE Act Was A “Knee-Jerk Reaction.”
“As a former prosecutor, Katko says he ‘fully believes’ in gun laws. But he views the SAFE Act as a
‘knee-jerk reac-tion’ to the mass shooting in Newtown, Conn.” [The Citizen, 10/28/14]
Vowed To Prevent The SAFE Act “Or Perhaps Even Worse” From Happening Federally. “Even
though he’s seeking federal office, Katko has mentioned the SAFE Act, a gun control law passed by the
state Legislature in 2013 and signed into law by Gov. Andrew Cuomo, on the campaign trail. During an
interview with The Citizen in May, Katko said the SAFE Act is a ‘very big issue for this district.’ ‘I think
these people are really, legitimately concerned about their constitutional rights,’ Katko said. ‘I have to
make sure that, if and when I become congressman, that doesn’t happen federally. It’s my feeling that if
the Democrats were in control of the House and Senate and the presidency, they would have highly
restrictive gun legislation -- something along the lines of the SAFE Act or perhaps even worse. I want to
make sure that doesn’t happen.’” [The Citizen, 10/16/14]
Pledged To Repeal The NY SAFE Act, And Oppose Similar Legislation. The New York Shooters
Committee On Political Education noted Katko had signed their pledge stating: “As a candidate for office
in the state of New York, I pledge to support the Second Amendment and the rights of gun owners,
hunters, and sportsmen in our state. I pledge to support the repeal of the NY SAFE Act and oppose any
similar gun ban legislation at the local, state, and federal level.” [scopeny.org, accessed 10/09/15]
Gun Trafficking And Enforcement
Prosecuted Gun Traffickers As An Assistant US Attorney
Prosecuted A Felon Who Purchased A Weapon From A Gun Trafficking Ring In Georgia. “In April
2003, Katko prosecuted Paul Clemons who pleaded guilty to being a felon in possession of a firearm. He
admitted he paid $600 for a pistol to a gun trafficking operation led by Brian Turner, 25, of Atlanta.
Clemons faced up to 27 months in prison under federal sentencing guidelines, Katko said.” [Associated
Press, 4/29/03]
Prosecuted A Man Charged With Gun Trafficking. “In April 2003, Katko prosecuted Darell Harlow,
the leader of a gun-trafficking ring that federal investigators said sold 50 weapons to street gangs. Harlow
217
pleaded guilty to illegally dealing in firearms, admitting that he had his girlfriend buy 44 guns for him in
Georgia as a straw purchaser from September 1999 to December 2001.” [Associated Press, 4/29/03]
… But Opposed Any New Federal Restrictions On Firearms. “He opposes any new federal
restrictions on the purchase of firearms, including a proposal that failed in the U.S. Senate in April
2013 that would have expanded federal background checks.” [Post Standard, 7/21/14]
Seventy Percent Of Guns Traced In New York In 2014 Came From Out Of State. ATF data
notes that New York law enforcement requested traces on 7,686 firearms, 4,585 of which had an
identifiable state source, and 1,397 of the 4,585 had an origin in New York State. [ATF, 2014]
Ninety Percent Of All Guns Used In New York City Crimes In 2011 Came From Other
States. “Guns from states with weak firearms laws are being used at an ever-increasing rate in city
crimes, Mayor Bloomberg said Wednesday, as he vowed to continue his push for tougher laws
across the country. … The most recent data available show that 90% of all guns used in city
crimes in 2011 came from other states, Bloomberg revealed at a news conference in City Hall.”
[New York Daily News, 7/31/13]
Georgia Tops The List As A Source Of Guns Used In Crimes In Other States. “Georgia tops
the list as a source of guns used in crimes in other states. In 2013, more than 3,000 guns originally
purchased legally in Georgia were confiscated outside the state by police, according to data from
the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms. Florida is a very close second.”
ATF Violent Crime Intelligence Division Chief: Georgia’s Lack Of Gun Safety Laws Allow
Gun Runners To Operate Easier. “’I hate stating negatives, but I think if you take Georgia as a
norm, what you’re going to find is you don’t have restrictions on types of weapons, you don’t
have long waiting periods, you don’t have additional carry permits requires,’ said Special Agent
Kevin O’Keefe, the chief of the ATF’s Violent Crime Intelligence Division. Combine those
qualities with Georgia’s access to interstates, and he says you have an idea of why it’s a popular
state for gun traffickers. ‘Why drive an extra six hours to Miami, when you could stop in Georgia
if you found someone with ID to buy for you,’ O'Keefe said.” [WABE, 5/08/13]
2015: Responded To Traffickers Bringing Guns To New York By Working For Tougher Screenings
For Airport Workers
Katko’s First Subcommittee Hearing Dealt With Employee Screening At Airports After A Gun
Smuggling Ring From Atlanta To New York. “In his first hearing as chairman of the House Homeland
Security Subcommittee on Transportation Security, U.S. Rep. John Katko will lead a review of employee
access control at the nation's airports. Katko, R-Camillus, said Friday that the hearing is in response to
recent arrests in a gun smuggling operation. One of the individuals arrested in the scheme, Mark Quentin
Henry, transported guns on several flights between Atlanta and New York City. He was aided by a Delta
Airlines employee who wasn't required to go through any security checkpoints.” [The Citizen, 2/03/15]
After Gun Smuggling Ring, Wrote Bill Allegedly Closing Security Loopholes With Airport Worker
Screening. “A bill written by Rep. John Katko to close security loopholes exploited by some airport
workers passed the House of Representatives on Tuesday in a unanimous voice vote. … Earlier in the
218
year, airline employees in Atlanta were charged with running a gun smuggling scheme by taking
advantage of their security clearance.” [Post Standard, 10/06/15]
… But Opposed Safer Screening Of Those Who Purchase Guns. “He opposes any new federal
restrictions on the purchase of firearms, including a proposal that failed in the U.S. Senate in April
2013 that would have expanded federal background checks. ‘We have a very robust federal system
as it is, and I have been enforcing gun laws for 20 years,’ Katko said.” [Post Standard, 7/22/14]
Opposed Any New Federal Restrictions On Firearms. “He opposes any new federal restrictions
on the purchase of firearms, including a proposal that failed in the U.S. Senate in April 2013 that
would have expanded federal background checks.” [Post Standard, 7/21/14]
Called For Greater Enforcement Of For Those Who Illegally Obtain Guns. “’A lot of the gun laws
work, and some do not,’ Katko said. ‘But I don’t think additional bans on guns are going to solve the
problem. I am for stepping up enforcement for those people who illegally obtain guns—criminals—and I
will do everything in my power to make sure the New York SAFE Act never becomes a federal law.’”
… But As Prosecutor Only Stepped Up Enforcement After The Syracuse Mayor Requested
It, Katko Stepped Up Gun Prosecutions. “In November 2010, Katko said six or seven gun cases
have been transferred from state to federal court for prosecution. That’s more than were
transferred all of last year, he said. The increase came after Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner
contacted the U.S. Attorney’s office to request more aggressive federal prosecution of gun crime.”
DA: Lax Gun Laws In Other States Lead To Deaths In New York, “No Statute That Really Deals
With Gun Trafficking” Like This, Advocated For A Proposal Sponsored By Sen. Gillibrand. “‘We
are seeing tragedies in Brooklyn every day because of the lax gun laws in other states...how many more
people will have to die?’ Brooklyn District Attorney Ken Thompson said at a press conference
Wednesday. … Thompson said the bust underscores the need for the U.S. Senate to pass a pending bill by
Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand that would make interstate gun trafficking a federal crime. ‘There's no real federal
statute that really deals with this gun trafficking, like what these folks were doing,’ the DA said. ‘We
support Sen. Gillibrand's pending legislation.’” [New York Daily News, 10/14/15]
Katko’s Stolen Gun & Burt Street Murders
Katko’s Gun, Issued by U.S. Attorney’s Office, Stolen from His Car
On April 3, 2000 Katko’s 1989 Chevy EFI pick-up truck was broken into on the 300 block of Marks Ave.
in Syracuse, New York sometime between 7:00 and 10:00 PM. The passenger side window was smashed
in with a rock and among the items stolen was Katko’s Glock model 40, .40 caliber automatic pistol that
was loaded with 9 rounds of ammunition. [Syracuse Police Dept, Case # 00-097007]
The gun was issued through the U.S. Attorney’s office and was on Katko’s Onondaga County pistol
permit. U.S. Attorney Daniel French said, “Firearms are issued to federal prosecutors under very limited
circumstances.” The gun had been issued in December after receiving “a credible death threat.”
219
French said Katko and his wife had been attending an evening meeting at St. Mark’s Episcopal Church
and Katko had left the gun in a locked case under the front seat of his locked car. [Syracuse Herald-Journal,
4/28/00]
NOTE: In the article French declined to mention Katko by name. But the police reports confirm it was
Katko.
Katko’s Gun was Traded for Drugs
According to a follow-up police report, Katko’s stolen gun was traded for drugs. [Syracuse Police Dept, Case #
00-097007]
Katko’s Gun Used in Double Homicide
According to a follow-up police report, Katko’s gun was used in a robbery homicide on Burt St in
Syracuse, New York. [Syracuse Police Dept, Case # 00-097007]
On April 21, 2000, two men were shot and killed during a robbery at 222 Burt. Street. Vernon Griffin, 39,
was dead when police responded to the scene and Henderson Griffin, 62, passed away later that night at
Crouse Hospital. Robert Anderson, 47, was critically injured and taken to University Hospital. The
Griffin’s were not related. [Post-Standard, 4/22/00]
Investigators who recovered the gun said it was used in the robbery but was not involved in the deaths of
the Griffin’s, or the wounding of Anderson. [Syracuse Herald-Journal, 4/28/00]
Home Used as Social Club, Gambling House
According to police reports and neighbors, the home on Burt St., owned and run by Henderson
Griffin, was used as a social club and gambling house in the neighborhood. Griffin had been
ticketed several times for selling alcohol and running games but the tickets were mostly fines.
Griffin had never been to jail.
The home was a popular target for thieves because of the high stakes games that sometimes went
on. [Post-Standard, 4/27/00]
Man Arrested for Murder
On April 26, 2000, Bryan C. Hunter, 21, was arrested on two counts of second-degree murder and
one count each of attempted murder and robbery, Syracuse police said.
Chief Assistant District Attorney Nicholas DeMartino said additional charges against Hunter
would be considered when the case was presented to a grand jury. Charges could be increased to
first-degree murder under the state’s 1995 death penalty statute. [Post-Standard, 4/27/00]
In April 2001, Hunter pled guilty to first-degree robbery and was sentenced to eight years in
prison. [Syracuse Herald American, 4/01/01]
220
Second Man Arrested in Fatal Shooting
On April 27, 2000, Darius Fort, also as Derrick Fort, 26, was arrested and charged with two counts
of murder, and one count each of attempted murder and robbery. [Post-Standard, 4/28/00]
Third Man Arrested in Connection to Shooting
In April 2000, William Jackson, 19, was charged in the double homicide. Jackson faced two
counts of murder, one count of attempted murder and a felony robbery charge. [Syracuse Herald
American, 4/30/00]
Jackson had armed himself with a Glock semiautomatic handgun. [Post-Standard, 5/01/00]
Brothers Arrested on Murder Charges
In July 2000, brothers Shondell Paul, 19, and Tajuan Paul, 22, were arraigned on multiple counts
of murder and robbery in connection with the hold up that resulted in the death of Henderson and
Vernon Griffin.
Additionally, the Pauls faced multiple robbery and weapons charges in connection with a robbery
that occurred at the same gambling house eight days before the fatal holdup. [Syracuse Herald-Journal,
7/24/00]
Twenty-three Count Indictment Opened in Onondaga County Court
On July 24, 2000, a 23-count indictment was opened in Onondaga County Court charging the five
men with second-degree murder under the theory they caused the deaths of both victims during a
felony robbery. All could face maximum penalties of 25 years to life in prison if convicted of
murder. [Syracuse Herald-Journal, 7/24/00]
NOTE: A records request for the case documents is in progress. I have received copies of the
dockets for the cases against each of the five men and am responding to request specific
documents.
Insurance Payment of $820 Paid to Katko by New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance
In June 2000, Katko was paid $820.51 by New York Central Mutual fire insurance company for his gun
that was stolen. [Syracuse Police Dept, Case # 00-097007, 6/20/00]
August 2014 Media Coverage
Katko’s Gun Stolen From Truck and Used in Double Homicide
In April 2000, a handgun issued to Katko by the Department of Justice was stolen from Katko’s car while
Katko was attending a church event with his wife. Three weeks later, the gun was used in a robbery
turned double homicide.
221
The crime took place at an illegal gambling house on Syracuse’s south side. In addition to the two
homicide victims, a third individual was shot in the back but ultimately survived. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Pistol Loaded With Nine Rounds of Ammunition
At the time it was stolen, Katko’s gun, a Glock .40 caliber semi-automatic pistol, was loaded with
nine rounds of ammunition. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Homicide Perpetrator Possessed Katko’s Gun at Time of Arrest
Five days after the murder, police arrested Bryan C Hunter, who went on to plead guilty to one of
the murders. Hunter was in possession of Katko’s stolen gun at the time of arrest, which contained
only two of the initial nine rounds of ammunition.
The investigators who recovered the gun said it was used in the robbery, but determined its bullets
did not kill either of homicide victims.
According to a subsequent police report, the serial number of the gun recovered from Hunter
matched that of the gun Katko reported stolen. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Katko Issued Gun After Threat Were Made on His Life
According to the United States Attorney serving at the time of the incident, Katko was issued his
gun after credible threats were made against his life. [Post Standard, 8/28/14
Likely Violated Federal Policies for Safe Handling and Storage of Government Issued Weapons
In 2014, the Syracuse Post Standard reported that although Katko didn’t break any state or federal gun
laws, he likely violated federal policies for the safe handling and storage of government-issued weapons.
“Katko broke no state or federal gun laws, and he was not disciplined by the Justice Department. But a
review of the case shows he likely violated federal policies for the safe handling and storage of
government-issued weapons,” the paper reported. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
U.S. Marshal’s Service Required Weapons Be Stored in a Manner to Prevent Theft
The paper reported that the U.S. Marshal’s Service policy that Katko was required to abide by
dictated that service weapons be stored in a manner to prevent theft, tampering, or misuse when
not being carried. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Katko Never Disciplined for Incident
According to Executive Assistant U.S. Attorney, John Duncan, Katko was never disciplined or
reprimanded over the stolen gun incident.
222
“It was reviewed, and it was determined that no further action was required,” Duncan said. [Post
Standard, 8/28/14]
Kato Violated Basic Rules of Gun Safety According to Law Enforcement Expert
In 2014, the Post Standard reported that a law enforcement expert said that Katko violated two
basic rules of gun safety by storing the weapon in his vehicle, and failing to secure it with a gun
lock.
“It's no different than for a citizen with a gun permit. The weapon always has to be kept, when not
in your possession, with a gun lock or a barrel lock in a gun safe,” said John DeCarlo, a 34-year
police veteran who now coordinates the police studies program at John Jay College of Criminal
Justice in New York City. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Said His Gun Was Stolen From A “Locked Briefcase” In His “Locked Vehicle.”
“‘Fourteen years ago, I, too, became the victim of a crime. My protective weapon was
stolen from a locked briefcase concealed from view in my locked vehicle.’” [The Citizen,
8/28/14]
… But Reports Said The Gun Was Stolen From A Green Canvas Bag. “Katko told
syracuse.com that the gun was locked in a briefcase under the seat. But reports indicate
that the gun was in a green canvas bag that was stolen from the truck.” [The Citizen,
8/28/14]
Katko Maintained He Did “Nothing Wrong”
When responding to the Post Standard story, Katko maintained that he was the victim of a crime
and that he had done nothing wrong. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
Katko Alleged He Was Never Provided a Gun Lock
In response to the 2014 Post Standard article, Katko’s campaign spokesman said that Katko was
never provided with a gun lock when he received his gun.
223
The chief deputy U.S. Marshal In Syracuse did not recall when his department started using gun
locks. [Post Standard, 8/28/14]
224
Health Care Issues
 Opposed the ACA, and said he wanted it repealed. Also made a campaign pledge
to oppose repeal without a replacement ready. In Congress, he voted against a full
repeal bill; however he did vote for a bill to “gut” the ACA by repealing several
key provisions.
 Supported certain provisions of the ACA, including the wellness provisions,
prohibitions on preexisting conditions, and allowing 26 year olds to stay on
parents’ insurance.
 Advocated for replacing the ACA, but suggested policies indistinguishable from
the ACA.
 Opposed the medical device tax and voted to repeal it in Congress. Cited it as a
factor in the Welch Allyn sale, though that claim was refuted by Welch Allyn. Has
taken$3,250 from Welch Allyn and company executives
 Formed a task force to deal with pediatric mental health, fulfilling a campaign
pledge made to honor his late niece
 Held summits dealing with heroin usage, pursued efforts against synthetic
marijuana. HHS adopted rules similar to a opioid bill he co-sponsored
Katko opposed the ACA and said he wanted it repealed. He pledged to oppose
repeal without a replacement and in Congress voted against fully repealing the
ACA. However, Katko voted for a reconciliation bill to “gut” the ACA by repealing
key provisions. Katko stressed that he remained in opposition to the ACA and
would vote to repeal it if and when a replacement was ready.
Katko supported keeping the wellness provisions, prohibitions on preexisting
conditions, and allowing 26-year-olds to stay on parents’ insurance. He opposed the
Medical Device tax and the HIT tax. Katko proposed replacing the ACA with
policies indistinguishable from the ACA itself; for example, Katko proposed a
replacement which would use tax credits to incentivize individuals to buy private
insurance.
225
Katko has vocally opposed the Medical Device tax, and voted to repeal it. Katko
cited the tax as a cause of Welch Allyn being sold; which was refuted by Welch
Allyn. Katko has taken funds from Welch Allyn.
Katko formed a task force to determine options to increase the availability of
pediatric mental health care. He promised this action during the campaign. His
niece committed suicide within an hour of being discharged from mental health care
without the families consent.
Katko held summits on heroin addiction in the district. The Department of Health
and Human Services adopted rules similar to a bill Katko co-sponsored dealing with
opioid addition.
Opposition To The Affordable Care Act
Said, “I Want To Repeal Obamacare … If And When A Replacement Is Ready, My Vote Will Be
To Repeal Obamacare”
Said, “I Want To Repeal Obamacare … If And When A Replacement Is Ready, My Vote Will Be
To Repeal Obamacare” “Katko said in an interview with The Post-Standard that he broke ranks with his
party to fulfill his campaign promise to repeal the law only if Republicans offered a viable alternative. ‘I
want to repeal Obamacare, but I also want to keep my promise,’ Katko said. ‘If and when a replacement is
ready, my vote will be to repeal Obamacare.’” [Post Standard, 2/05/15]
Opposed the Affordable Care Act
In July 2014, Katko said that he would repeal the Affordable Care Act while keeping some of the more
popular aspects, such as guaranteed coverage for those with pre-existing conditions and allowing children
to stay on their parents’ plans until age 26.
“The bottom line is I think Obamacare needs, at best, a radical surgery,” Katko said. “I think the most
prudent course is to start over in a bipartisan manner. I think both sides need to sit down and agree to keep
good parts that can be fixed, and change others so that we can find a reasonable solution.” [Post-Standard,
7/21/14]
Said He Wanted to See the Affordable Care Act Repealed, Called it a “Train Wreck”
In January 2014, Katko said he opposed the Affordable Care Act and wanted to see it revised or repealed.
“The Affordable Care Act is a train wreck and it’s going to have long-term negative effects on the Central
New York economy,” Katko said. “I think it’s the poster-child for government incompetence.” [PostStandard, 1/14/14]
Syracuse New Times Writer Said Katko Would not Repeal the ACA
In March 2014, Syracuse New Times writer Ed Griffin-Nolan said he had asked Katko if he
thought the Affordable Care Act should be repealed and Katko said no. [Syracuse New Times, 3/19/14]
226
Said If the Affordable Care Act Could Not be Fixed, It Should be Scrapped
In April 2014, Katko said if the Affordable Care Act could not be fixed, it should be repealed and
replaced. “Not only was the rollout of Obamacare seriously flawed, but as time passes it becomes more
and more apparent that the law itself is simply unworkable and the wrong foundation for real health care
reform based on consumer choice,” Katko said.
“If the law cannot be fixed, then it ought to be scrapped and replaced with smaller, workable legislative
initiatives…” he said. [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
…But Supported Keeping the “Strongest Provisions”
In April 2014, Katko said he supported the “strongest provisions” in the ACA like coverage for
pre-existing conditions, extending coverage for dependents under 26, and eliminating the
Medicare “donut hole.”
“If the law cannot be fixed, then it ought to be scrapped and replaced with smaller, workable
legislative initiatives starting with keeping the strongest provisions like pre-existing conditions,
extending dependent coverage, and eliminating the Medicare Part D ‘donut hole,’” Katko said.
[Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Said Problems with the Affordable Care Act Could Not be Fixed
In February 2014 Katko said problems with the Affordable Care could not be fixed. “I’m going to go
through and try and identify the issues and then try and figure out whether or not they can be fixed or not.
My conclusion is that they probably aren’t going to be able to be fixed in its current state,” Katko said.
“You have all these things going out there that I think work against it. I think, in the end, it makes it so
I’m not sure it can be fixed. Should we try and fix it? Sure. I don’t think it can be fixed,” Katko said.
Said There Were “Good Aspects” of the Affordable Care Act
In February 2014, Katko said there were some “good aspects” of the Affordable Care Act. “For example,
I think it’s good that you can keep your kids on the insurance rolls until they’re 26 so they can get out of
school. That’s a good thing,” Katko said.
“There’s other good aspects of it. So let’s find out what some of the good aspects, take some of those
principles and let’s find some legislation that is actually viable,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said the Affordable Care Act was a “Lack of Good Governance”
In February 2014, Katko said, “I’m also concerned about the lack of good governance […] our leaders are
making terrible decisions again and again. Look no further than the Affordable Care Act - Obamacare - to
see what bad governance is.”
227
“It’s clear that no one had any idea what was in that bill and yet they passed it […] To me, that is a prime
example of terrible leadership. It’s not just with [Rep. Maffei]. It’s with others in Washington,” Katko
said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said Maffei Championed the Affordable Care Act
In February 2014, Katko said, “It’s clear that Maffei championed that bill. And then it’s also clear
now that Maffei realizes after seeing what happened to Welch Allyn losing 200 jobs because of
the medical device tax, that he’s running from it now.”
“He votes for it, he touts a bill and then wants to repeal very portions of the bill that he passed,”
Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said the Affordable Care Act was a Product of Gridlock, Poor Leadership
In February 2014, Katko said, “I’m very concerned about poor leadership on both sides of the aisle.
Gridlock and getting nothing done and the Affordable Care Act is a perfect example of that.”
“There’s poor leadership by [President Obama], there’s poor leadership in passing the bill and there’s
poor leadership by our local congressman who after passing the bill now wants to repeal portions of it.
That to me is the ultimate in poor leadership all across the board. The fact that we can’t get anything done
in Washington on both sides, shame on us on both sides,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said President Reagan was a Good Negotiator
In February 2014, Katko said, “But Ronald Reagan was able to get a lot accomplished when he
had a Democratic-controlled House and he had a titan of the Democratic Party in Tip O’Neill (as
Speaker of the House).”
“Ronald Reagan got a lot done and he got it done because he was a good negotiator and he treated
his adversary with respect and he sat down and they just said, ‘Let’s get things done.’ And they
got things done. That, to me, is a principle that’s been lost in politics and it’s gotta change,” Katko
said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Said the Affordable Care Act Would Kill 2.3 Million Jobs
In February 2014, Katko said, “In its current state, [the Affordable Care Act is] a job killer. It’s not a job
creator. The very middle class they say they are trying to help are the ones that are getting screwed on this
the most.”
“The Congressional Budget Office came out and estimated that it’s going to lead to the loss of 2.3 million
jobs. Did anybody anticipate that?” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
PolitiFact: Claim Rated “Mostly False”
In February 2014, PolitiFact rated John Boehner’s claim that the Affordable Care Act was
“expected to destroy 2.3 million jobs” as mostly false.
228
PolitiFact found that Boehner’s use of the word “destroy” was misleading because the
Congressional Budget Office report on the Act was not talking about jobs being eliminated or not
created, but was referring to workers who decide to leave the workforce on their own.
The CBO estimated that Obamacare would “reduce the total number of hours worked, on net, by
about 1.5 percent to 2.0 percent during the period from 2017 to 2024, almost entirely because
workers will choose to supply less labor — given the new taxes and other incentives they will face
and the financial benefits some will receive.”
“It can be easy to miss the distinction between jobs and workers […] But Boehner’s statement
remains flawed. We rate the claim Mostly False,” PolitiFact concluded. [PolitiFact, 2/04/14]
Said there were Constitutional Issues with the Affordable Care Act
In February 2014, Katko said there were constitutional issues with the implementation of the Affordable
Care Act.
“You’ve got President (Barack) Obama, who is on his own repealing or delaying implementation of major
portions of this bill. This was legislation that was passed by Congress. And he, on his own, is delaying
certain portions of that bill without congressional approval. That’s a separation of powers argument. It’s a
constitutional argument,” Katko said. [Auburn Citizen, 2/18/14]
Replacing The Affordable Care Act, Keeping Provisions
Voted Against Motion To Prohibit 56th Republican Vote To Repeal The ACA
Voted Against Prohibiting 56th Republican Vote To Repeal The ACA. In February 2015, Katko voted
against a motion that would prohibit Republicans 56th vote to repeal the Affordable Care Act. The motion
to recommit failed, 179 to 241. [HR 596, Vote #57, 2/03/15; Democratic Leadership Summary, 2/03/15]
Voted Against A Full Repeal Of The ACA
Voted Against A Full Repeal Of The ACA. In February 2015, Katko voted against repealing the ACA.
“The House voted … to abolish the 2010 health care law in Congress’ first repeal vote of the year … The
House has voted more than 50 times to roll back all or portions of the law.” The bill passed 239 to 186.
[HR 596, Vote #58, 2/03/15; CQ News, 2/03/15]
Vote Was Republicans 56th Attempt To Repeal Affordable Care Act. “In Tuesday’s repeal effort
by House Republicans — their first of this Congress and their 56th overall — it became clear that they
had succeeded at one thing: They had bored even themselves into a slumber.” [Washington Post,
2/03/15]
Voted For A Reconciliation Bill To “Gut” The Affordable Care Act
Voted To “Gut Obamacare” By Repealing Key Sections Of The Law. In October 2015, Katko voted
for a “budget reconciliation bill that seeks to gut Obamacare by repealing key sections of the law,
229
including the individual and employer mandate and the so-called ‘cadillac’ tax, which targets high-end
employer-sponsored health plans. In addition, it would block funding for Planned Parenthood for one year
and divert that spending to other women’s health programs.” The bill passed 240-189. [HR 3762, Vote
#568, 10/23/15; Washington Post, 10/23/15]
Voted Against A Reconciliation Bill To “Repeal Much” Of The Affordable Care Act That Some
Described As A “Repeal” Bill
Voted Against A Reconciliation Bill To “Repeal Much” But Not “Entirely Dismantle The
Affordable Care Act.” In January 2016, Katko voted against “legislation that would repeal much of
ObamaCare, the first such measure to reach his desk since it became law in 2010. … The legislation does
not repeal all of ObamaCare, because the reconciliation rules forced Republicans to choose certain
elements to eliminate.” The bill passed 240-181. [HR3762, Vote #6, 1/06/16; The Hill, 1/08/16]
The Legislation Would “Repeal Much Of Obamacare”. “President Obama on Friday vetoed
legislation that would repeal much of ObamaCare, the first such measure to reach his desk since it
became law in 2010. Obama used his veto pen without fanfare on a legislative package rolling
back his signature healthcare law and stripping federal funding from Planned Parenthood.”
The Legislation Would Have Repealed Medicaid Expansion, Insurance Subsidies, The
Individual mandate, “As Well As A Litany Of Taxes.” “The bill still attacks core parts of the
law, including an expansion of Medicaid and federal subsidies to help people purchase health
insurance. It also scraps mandates on individuals to buy insurance and employers to provide it, as
well as a litany of taxes, including levies on medical devices and high-cost plans, known as the
‘Cadillac Tax.’” [The Hill, 1/08/16]
The Legislation “Would Retain The Requirement That Insurers Offer Coverage … Without
Regard To … Pre Existing Conditions. Also Untouched Would Be The Revisions In
Medicare.” “The measure wouldn’t entirely dismantle the Affordable Care Act. For example, it
would retain the requirement that insurers offer coverage and set premiums without regard to
someone’s pre-existing conditions. Also untouched would be revisions in Medicare that reward
the value of procedures, rather than the volume of procedures and reduce excessive provider
payments.” [Bloomberg, 1/06/16]
The Legislation Would Have Defunded Planned Parenthood. “President Obama on Friday
vetoed legislation that would repeal much of ObamaCare, the first such measure to reach his desk
since it became law in 2010. Obama used his veto pen without fanfare on a legislative package
rolling back his signature healthcare law and stripping federal funding from Planned Parenthood.”
Fox News Headline: “Congress Sends Health Law Repeal To Obama's Desk For First
Time.” [Fox News, 1/06/16]
CNN Headline: “House Sends Obamacare Repeal Bill To White House.” [CNN, 1/06/16]
Speaker Ryan: HR3762 A “Bill That Repeals Obamacare.” “For five years, Senate Democrats
have blocked our efforts to repeal Obamacare. That ends today. With this vote, we are keeping a
230
promise and putting a bill that repeals Obamacare and defunds Planned Parenthood on the
president’s desk.” [Press Release, Speaker Ryan, 1/06/16]
Auburn Citizen Newspaper: Katko Pledged To Vote Against Any Effort To Repeal The ACA
Unless There Is An Alternative. “U.S. Rep. John Katko pledged to vote against any effort to repeal the
Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, unless there's an alternative measure ready to replace the
law. On Wednesday, Katko, R-Camillus, once again followed through on his promise. The House of
Representatives approved legislation that would repeal key parts of the 2010 health care law and defund
Planned Parenthood for one year.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Auburn Citizen Newspaper: Katko “Once Again Followed Through On His Promise” To Oppose
ACA Repeal Efforts Without An Alternative. “U.S. Rep. John Katko pledged to vote against any effort
to repeal the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, unless there's an alternative measure ready
to replace the law. On Wednesday, Katko, R-Camillus, once again followed through on his promise. The
House of Representatives approved legislation that would repeal key parts of the 2010 health care law and
defund Planned Parenthood for one year.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Voted Against Overriding The President’s Veto Of A Bill To Repeal The Affordable Care Act And
Block Funding Of Planned Parenthood For A Year.
Voted Against Overriding The President’s Veto Of A Bill To Repeal The Affordable Care Act And
Block Funding Of Planned Parenthood For A Year. In February 2016, Katko voted against overriding
the President’s veto of a bill to “repeal portions of the 2010 health care law and block federal funding for
Planned Parenthood for one year. The bill would zero-out the law's penalties for noncompliance with the
law's requirements for most individuals to obtain health coverage and employers to offer health insurance.
The bill would scrap in 2018 the law's Medicaid expansion, as well as subsidies to help individuals buy
coverage through the insurance exchanges. It also would scrap certain taxes included in the law, including
the tax on certain high-value employer-sponsored health insurance plans.” The override required a twothirds majority to pass, but failed 241 to 186. [H R 3762, Vote #53, 2/02/16, 2/02/16; CQ Floor Votes,
2/02/16]
Voted For Increasing Definition Of Full-Time Under Affordable Care Act
Voted For Increasing Definition Of Full-Time From 30 Hours To 40 Hours Under Affordable Care
Act. In January 2015, Katko voted for a bill that would lengthen the Affordable Care Act’s definition of a
full-time work week to 40 hours from 30 hours. “The House will vote again on Thursday to lengthen
Obamacare’s full-time workweek definition to 40 hours, but the Senate has work to do before it can hope
to get its first anti-Obamacare bill to the president’s desk.” The bill passed, 252-172. [HR 30, Vote #14,
1/08/15; Politico, 1/08/15]
Bill Would Increase Deficit By $53.2 Billion And Cut Healthcare For About 1 Million Workers.
“The independent Congressional Budget Office said Wednesday that the House’s bill would
add $53.2 billion to the deficit from 2015 to 2025. That’s because fewer businesses would pay fines
and because some of the employees who would have been covered at work will instead get subsidies
to buy plans on the Obamacare exchanges. The CBO estimated that about 1 million people would lose
their work-based coverage, a fact that Democrats intend to highlight.” [Politico, 1/08/15]
231
Voted For Repeal Of IPAB—Medicare Cost-Control Board—Which CBO Said Would Result In
Higher Medicare Spending
Voted For Eliminating Medicare Cost-Control Board. In June 2015, Katko voted for the Protecting
Seniors’ Access to Medicare Act of 2015. “The House easily passed a repeal of Obamacare's Independent
Payment Advisory Board, with a handful of Democrats voting with Republicans against a part of the law
aimed at checking the growth of Medicare spending. The Independent Payment Advisory Board has never
been used. It consists of 15 members and was included in the law to control the rate of Medicare growth
and to help the program come up with savings. The law said the board would make savings
recommendations if Medicare spending was projected to exceed a certain target rate, but so far, spending
hasn't grown fast enough to trigger the IPAB. The 244-154 vote occurred days before an expected
Supreme Court ruling on the legality of Obamacare subsidies.” The bill passed, 244-154. [HR 1190, Vote
#376, 6/23/15; National Journal, 6/23/15]
Bill Repealed Independent Payment Advisory Boards. “H.R. 1190 would repeal the provisions of
the Affordable Care Act (ACA) that established the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB)
and that created a process by which the Board (or the Secretary of the Department of Health and
Human Services) would be required under certain circumstances to modify the Medicare program to
achieve specified savings.” [Congressional Budget Office, 6/11/15]
Congressional Budget Office: Elimination Of Board Would “Probably Result In Higher Spending
For The Medicare Program In The Years 2022 Through 2025.” “CBO estimates that enacting H.R.
1190 would not have any budgetary impact between 2015 and 2021, but would increase direct spending
by $7.1 billion over the 2022-2025 period. That estimate is extremely uncertain because it is not clear
whether the mechanism for spending reductions under the IPAB authority will be triggered under current
law for most of the next ten years; under CBO’s current baseline projections such authority is projected to
be triggered in 2025. However, given the uncertainty that surrounds those projections, it is possible that
such authority would be triggered in more than one of those years; taking into account that possibility,
CBO estimates that repealing the IPAB provision of the ACA would probably result in higher spending
for the Medicare program in the years 2022 through 2025 than would occur under current law. CBO’s
estimate represents the expected value of a broad range of possible effects of repealing the provision over
that period.” [Congressional Budget Office, 6/11/15]
Bill Offset By Cuts To Prevention And Public Health Fund. “The House easily passed a repeal of
Obamacare's Independent Payment Advisory Board, with a handful of Democrats voting with
Republicans against a part of the law aimed at checking the growth of Medicare spending. …Although
only 11 Democrats ended up voting for the repeal, others might have done so if the bill wasn't offset by
cuts to Obamacare's Prevention and Public Health Fund.” [National Journal, 6/23/15]
Fund Trained More Primary-Care Doctors. “The graph that my subconscious came up with
charted all the cuts to the Prevention and Public Health Fund. That's a $15 billion Obamacare program
initially meant to — you guessed it — fund prevention and public health activities. This has included
everything from training more primary-care doctors to supporting healthy corner stores. The funds are
not earmarked for any specific activity. Instead, they get doled out each year. And that has made the
232
Prevention Fund a prime target for legislators looking to pay for other health-care activities.”
[Washington Post, 4/19/13]
Said Fixing The ACA Was A Necessity, Said It If Wasn’t Fixed In His Term, Voters Should “Throw
Me Out”
Citizen, 12/02/14]
Said That If The Affordable Care Act Isn’t ‘Fixed’ In His Term, “Then It Is Time For You To
Throw Me Out.” “GR: A question now about the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare. Mr. Katko, you
brought this up a little while ago, and this question is for you. It’s extremely unlikely that there will be
any chance of a significant revision of this legisla-tion during what would be your first term in Congress.
So why then is changing this law an apparent pillar of your campaign? JK: We could never account in its
mediocrity, we could never account in its bad bills. It has to be addressed, and if two years from now I
would come back to you and nothing’s done, then it is time for you to throw me out. We have to start
working on these types of things. We can’t accept ... your premise is what’s wrong with Washington.
When you sit there and say it is extremely unlikely.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse New Times, 10/29/14]
Reiterated His Desire To Repeal And Replace The ACA
Reiterated His Desire To Repeal And Replace The Affordable Care Act. “Katko said in an interview
with The Post-Standard that he broke ranks with his party to fulfill his campaign promise to repeal the law
only if Republicans offered a viable alternative. ‘I want to repeal Obamacare, but I also want to keep my
promise,’ Katko said. ‘If and when a replacement is ready, my vote will be to repeal Obamacare.’” [Post
Standard, 2/05/15]
Suggested The GOP Plan To Replace The ACA Would Privatize Insurance, Replace Health
Insurance Exchanges With Tax Credits, Replace Insurance Subsidies With Tax Incentives
Suggested The GOP Short Term Replacement For The ACA Would Privatize Insurance, And
Replace Health Insurance Exchanges With Tax Credits. “Katko said Republicans have been working
on a short-term plan for revisions to the Affordable Care Act while working on a longer-term solution.
‘The short-term gap would be bridged by basically privatizing the insurance, and basically replacing
exchanges with substantial tax credits to individuals who bought health insurance,’ Katko said. He said
Republicans also would like to increase competition among health insurers by allowing companies to sell
policies across state lines.” [Post Standard, 7/21/15]
Said The GOP Plan To Replace The Affordable Care Act Would Replace Subsidies With Tax
Incentives. “KATKO: Yes. There was an editorial in the Wall Street Journal about a month ago from
(U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan) and some others providing a conceptual framework. And since then, we’ve had
meetings with Paul Ryan and with the gen-eral counsel -- some of the folks who argued the Supreme
233
Court case on Obamacare. There is a plan developing into place as an alternative to Obamacare if the
Supreme Court rules against Obama on this. It’s going to be more mar-ket-based -- interstate competition,
replacing subsidies with tax incentives to get insurance. Incentivizing instead of mandating. It’s going to
be market-based. They’re calling it kind of an off-ramp to Obamacare. It’s taking shape. Paul Ryan has
been working very hard on it. I think that will be coming out very soon.” [The Citizen, 4/20/15]
Called For “Market Based Changes” To The ACA That “Ensure Individuals And Families In Our
Community Have Access To Health Care.” “‘Although I did not support today’s legislation, I have and
will continue to support comprehensive, market-based changes to Obamacare while still working to
maintain the aspects of the law that ensure individuals and families in our community have access to
health care,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 1/06/16]
Proposed Replacing The ACA With A System That Offers Tax Credits To Incentivize People To
Buy Insurance From The Private Market
Proposed Replacing The Affordable Care Act With A System Which Offers Tax Credits To
Incentivize People To Buy Insurance From The Private Market. “‘Getting government out of the
way,’ he said in an interview Friday. ‘Getting government out of the business of health care, I think, it’s a
big thing and returning it back to a private setting with certain incentives and certain credits and what
have you to let the marketplace handle it, but provide an ability for people that couldn’t afford insurance
to somehow afford insurance and incentivize them to do that.’” [The Citizen, 2/11/15]
Called For Incentives For People To Buy Insurance, But Not By “Having A Gun To Their Head.”
“‘Getting government out of the way,’ he said in an interview Friday. ‘Getting government out of the
business of health care, I think, it’s a big thing and returning it back to a private setting with certain
incentives and certain credits and what have you to let the marketplace handle it, but provide an ability for
people that couldn’t afford insurance to somehow afford insurance and incentivize them to do that.’
Katko said, in a rebuke of Obamacare, that ‘this insurance by having a gun to your head is not the way to
go.’” [The Citizen, 2/11/15]
Said A Replacement For The ACA Must Maintain Universal Coverage, Keep “Wellness
Provisions,” “The 26 Year Old Policy”, And “Portability From Pre-Existing Conditions”
Said A Replacement For The ACA Must Maintain Universal Coverage, Keep Wellness Provisions,
The 26 Year Old Policy, And Portability From Pre-Existing Conditions. “JK: No, I don’t think I’m
talking about repealing the bill. I’m talking about fixing it. I think there’s great portions of Obamacare,
there’s great principles. First of all, everyone has health insurance. No matter what happens, we have to
make sure everyone has health insurance. And we have to take a look at some of the great provisions, like
the wellness provisions in there, and the 26-year old policy and portability from pre-existing conditions.
Those are all good things, and there’s a lot of good things in Obamacare.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse
Called For Repealing HIT Tax
234
Said He Would Restore The $700 Billion In Medicare Cost Savings From The ACA
Said He Would Restore The $700 Billion In Medicare Cost Savings From The Affordable Care Act.
“Along with the focus on Social Security, Katko also said he would aim to restore more than $700 billion
in cuts made to Medicare as a result of the Affordable Care Act. The cuts, as Politifact has highlighted in
its multiple fact checks, don’t impact benefits or the program. But Republicans have used the cuts to rail
against the Affordable Care Act.” [The Citizen, 9/16/14]
Voted For To Require Regulations and Rule Changes In The Affordable Care Act Must Be Subject
To Congressional Approval
Voted For To Require Regulations and Rule Changes In The Affordable Care Act Must Be Subject
To Congressional Approval. In July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would require “rule and
regulations under the Affordable Care Act to be subject to the congressional approval process established
in the bill.” The amendment passed, 242-167. [HR 427, Vote #474; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
Amendment Was To REINS Act Which Would Give “Congress The Final Say Over All Major
Regulations.” “The controversial regulatory reform bill, which the House will vote on later this week,
would give Congress the final say over all major regulations. […] The regulatory reform measure
would give Congress final say over any rule with an annual economic impact of $100 million or more.
Federal agencies would be required to submit major rules to Congress for approval before they could
take effect. This would all but guarantee Republicans the ability to block dozens of controversial rules
from the Obama administration and drastically slow the pace of regulations.” [The Hill, 7/27/15]
Medical Device Tax
Voted For To Place A Moratorium On The Medical Device Tax
Voted For Motion Agreeing With Senate Amendment To Place A Moratorium On Health Care
Reform’s Medical Device Tax. In December 2015, Katko voted for to concur with a Senate amendment
to a tax package that included a two year moratorium on the 2.3 percent medical device tax implemented
under the Affordable Care Act. The amendment passed, 318-109. [HR 2029, Vote #703, 12/17/15; Med
Device Online, 12/17/15]
Voted For Ending Medical Device Tax
Voted For Repeal Of Medical Device Tax Under The Affordable Care Act. In June 2015, Katko
voted for repealing the medical device tax implemented under the Affordable Care Act. “The House
defied a White House veto threat and voted Thursday to abolish a tax on medical device makers as a
group of Democrats uncharacteristically joined Republicans in moving to kill part of President Barack
Obama's health care law … The Republican-led House has voted more than 50 times since 2011 to void
all or part of Obama's health care overhaul, usually along party lines.” The bill passed 280 to 140. [HR
235
Called For Repealing The Medical Device Tax
Blamed The Medical Device Tax For Wellch Allyn’s Sale, Contradicted By Welch Allyn
Said The Medical Device Tax Was Harming The Industry, Blamed It For Welch Allyn’s Sale To A
Chicago Firm. “In a speech Wednesday on the House floor, Katko blamed the tax for Welch Allyn’s sale
to a Chicago firm in a deal worth more than $2 billion. ‘These manufacturers are now competing with one
arm tied behind their back because of this onerous tax,’ Katko said. ‘This morning was another great
example of that, because I got word that the largest medical (device) manufacturer in my district, Welch
Allyn, was just bought out.’” [Post Standard, 6/17/15]
Welch Allyn President Said The Medical Device Tax Was Not The Reason For The Sale To
A Chicago Firm. “But the CEO of Hill-Rom, the firm buying Welch Allyn, said the tax had
nothing to do with the acquisition. ‘The medical device tax has been in effect for three years and
nobody in the industry is in favor of it, but I don’t think it had any impact on the decision,’ said
John Greisch, president and CEO of Hill-Rom. Greisch and Welch Allyn President and CEO
Stephen Meyer said the $2.05 billion acquisition by Hill-Rom was driven by a need for both
companies to compete more effectively on a global scale.” [Post Standard, 6/17/15]
Welch Allyn Blamed Job Cuts On The Medical Device Tax, Later Said It Was Not Due To
The Tax. “In Central New York, medical device manufacturer Welch Allyn initially blamed the
tax as a factor behind its 2012 decision to lay off 10 percent of its global workforce, including 45
at its headquarters in Skaneateles Falls. But President and CEO Steve Meyer later said those job
cuts were driven by the need to prepare for larger cost pressures in the health care industry and
company plans to increase sales in emerging markets.” [Post Standard, 6/17/15]
Katko Accepted $2,650 In Donations From Welch Allyn And Its Corporate Board During 2015.
FEC data shows that Katko accepted two $1,000 donations from Wellch Allyn’s PAC, and two personal
donations from board members Eric and William Allyn of $250 and $375 respectively. [FEC.gov,
accessed 10/21/15]
Said The Medical Device Tax Limited Growth, Called For Repeal. “U.S. Rep. John Katko, who voted
for the tax package, said the medical device tax has limited growth and prevented companies from
expanding and adding employees. ‘Repealing this tax is critical to allowing our regional businesses to
invest, to grow and to prosper,’ Katko, R-Camillus, said. ‘Today’s bipartisan legislation places a two-year
pause on this significant tax burden, which is a critical first step forward in eliminating this harmful tax
altogether.’” [The Citizen, 12/18/15]
Claimed Freezing The Medical Device Tax Would Create Jobs Specifically At Welch Allyn. “‘The
medical device tax is going to be on the shelf for at least two years in this budget,’ Katko said. ‘And that
236
is going to create jobs at Welch Allyn and other places in central New York. I am absolutely positive of
that.’” [The Citizen, 12/17/15]
Other
Formed A Task Force To Improve Pediatric Mental Health Care, Fulfilling A Campaign Promise
Inspired By His Niece’s Suicide
Formed A Task Force To Improve Pediatric Mental Health Care. “Following through on a pledge he
made on the campaign trail, U.S. Rep. John Katko is teaming with Assemblyman Bill Magnarelli to
establish a six-month task force that will explore ways to improve access to pediatric mental health care in
central New York.” [The Citizen, 4/07/15]
Pledged A Task Force To Address Adolescent Mental Health, A Personal Cause After His Niece’s
Suicide. “Following through on a campaign pledge, U.S. Rep. John Katko is tackling an issue of personal
importance and one he believes will be beneficial for central New Yorkers. One of Katko ‘s 11 priorities
for his first term in Congress is the creation of an adolescent mental health care task force -- an idea he
first floated during a speech in October at the National Alliance on Mental Illness Educational Conference
in Syracuse. Having a center that could handle both inpatient and outpatient cases would help individuals
who now go to facilities in other New York cities or outside of the state, Katko, R-Camillus, said. When
Katko first announced his efforts in October, he shared a story about his niece Holly, who struggled with
mental illness and attempted suicide. From that experience, Katko said he realized central New York
lacks the resources to assist children with mental health issues. ‘After each episode, I remember going to
the hospital on several occasions with my brother and sister-in-law,’ Katko said in October. ‘As these
instances became more and more severe -- it was miraculous that she was surviving these attempts -- they
would do inpatient for her. But we learned very quickly inpatient treatment for pediatric mental illness is
very scarce in the Syracuse area.’ Holly, who was also Katko’s goddaughter, committed suicide in 2012.
She killed herself after being released from the Comprehensive Psychiatric Emergency Program in
Syracuse, where she was taken against her will by Katko. Katko was the last person to see her alive. ‘She
was my godchild,’ he said in his speech. ‘I loved her, we all loved her and it’s devastated our family. It’s
devastated my three boys.’” [The Citizen, 2/19/15]
Called For Investments To Expand Access To Mental Health Services In Communities And
Schools. “Rep. Katko also focused today increasing mental health services in Central New York schools.
‘I’ve made it a priority to expand access to mental and behavioral health services in our community, and
especially in our schools,’ Katko continued. ‘Investing in preventative mental health will improve youth
mental health treatment in our community, and give these young people a better future.’” [Press Release,
Rep. Katko, 5/29/15]
Held Heroin Summits In His District, HHS Adopted Rules On Opioid Addiction Similar To A
Katko Bill
Held Heroin Summits In His District. “U.S. Congressman John Katko (NY-24) today announced that
he will host a heroin summit next week where community members will have an opportunity to discuss
the spike in local heroin use with a panel of parents, educators, healthcare providers, law enforcement
237
officials, and local advocates. … Earlier this year, Rep. Katko held a Listening Session to Initiate a
Community Conversation on Heroin.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 6/23/15]
HHS Adopted Changes To Rules Regarding Opioid Addiction Similar To A Katko Bill.
“Congressmembers Brian Higgins (NY-26), Paul Tonko (NY-20), Richard Hanna (NY-22) and John
Katko (NY-24) applauded an announcement by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
(HHS) of plans to revise rules related to the treatment of opioid addiction. Changes proposed by HHS are
similar to provisions included in the Recovery Enhancement for Addiction Treatment, or TREAT Act
(HR 2536), introduced by Higgins, Tonko, Hanna and Katko earlier this year.” [Press Release, Rep.
Higgins, 9/21/15]
Promoted Treatment And Attention To Combat Heroin. “To tackle the heroin epidemic, Katko said
the focus should be on awareness, suppression and treatment. On treatment, he said it’s the most alarming
part of the discussion because there are individuals who want to get treated, but they can’t get into a
facility or program. ‘There’s something we need to look into with that,’ he said. ‘We have to find funding
somehow for that.’ Katko pledged to work with members of both parties to address the heroin epidemic.
He said it’s not a conservative versus liberal issue, but it’s a topic that doesn’t get enough attention. ‘I
think if it’s talked about enough, it may get cross appeal,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 2/21/15]
Announced A Grant To Combat Substance Abuse In Syracuse
Announced A Grant To Combat Substance Abuse In Syracuse. “U.S. Congressman John Katko (NY24) today announced that the Syracuse Youth Substance Abuse Prevention Coalition (YSAP) will receive
$125,000 in federal funding to continue its work in the City of Syracuse to prevent youth substance use.
The Prevention Network will be the fiduciary agent for this grant.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 9/16/15]
Favored Internment For People Exposed To Ebola
Katko Favored Internment For People Exposed To Ebola. “Katko also came out in support of
mandatory quarantines ‘The ultimate idea of having to quarantine these individuals I think is a necessary
step because we don’t know for sure what we have yet,’ he said. ‘We have a doctor who came back from
there who was found to be stricken with Ebola. Whether or not it’s ultimately necessary after further
research and testing remains to be seen. But I’d rather play it safe than not.’” [The Citizen, 10/27/14]
Advocated For Tax Incentives To Move People Off Public Assistance Into Work
Advocated For Tax Incentives To Move People Off Public Assistance Into Work. “KATKO: … As
far as an overall tax reform package, I think we need to incentivize people to get off of public assistance
and get into the workforce. And for that portion of the public that want to get in the work stream, a lot of
them are going to be taking minimum wage jobs. I think we should have some incentive for individuals
that are currently on public assistance to go out and getting a job. If they get that job, especially minimum
wage jobs, incentivizing them to keep that job and stay off of public assistance. I think the way to do that
is give them tax incentives.” [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/14]
Lauded The 21st Century Cures Act
238
Lauded The 21st Century Cures Act. “U.S. Representative John Katko (NY-24) today announced that
the U.S. House of Representatives passed the bipartisan 21st Century Cures Act, H.R. 6, patient-centered
legislation that he co-sponsored which invests in science and research to support medical innovation and
life-saving treatments, therapies, and cures for chronic conditions. ‘Far too many in our community
personally suffer with chronic medical conditions or have family members or loved ones who desperately
seek a cure for diseases like Parkinson’s, Multiple Sclerosis, Alzheimer’s, rare forms of cancer, and
diabetes,’ said Rep. John Katko. ‘That’s why I supported today’s legislation to facilitate new research
initiatives and develop safe treatments and therapies.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 7/10/15]
Supported Reauthorization Of The Zadroga Act For 9/11 Responders
Supported Reauthorization Of The Zadroga Act. “Katko said the hearing was an opportunity to pay
tribute to the lives lost and honor first responders and volunteers who are battling 9/11-related illnesses.
He came out in support of reauthorizing the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act, a law
which established a program to aid workers who have illnesses caused by their work at ground zero. The
Zadroga Act is set to expire at the end of the month.” [The Citizen, 9/12/15]
Authored Legislation For A Mesothelioma Registry After Meeting With Victims
Authored Legislation For A Mesothelioma Registry After Meeting With Victims. “Katko, RCamillus introduced the Mary Jo Lawyer Spano Mesothelioma Patient Registry Act, a bill which would
create a voluntary registry to collect information about mesothelioma patients. … Katko’s office said he
met with Meg Meccarielo, Spano’s sister who has also been diagnosed with the disease, and Elizabeth
Lawyer, Spano’s mother. They urged Katko to support the creation of a national mesothelioma patient
registry.” [The Citizen, 7/30/15]
2015: Said His Health Insurance Tripled In Price
Said His Health Insurance Tripled In Price From Three Years Ago. “The cost of health insurance
also is a concern for Katko. He cited his own health care as an example. He’s paying triple what he paid a
few years ago for health insurance coverage.” [The Citizen, 2/11/15]
Justice Department: Most Enrollees Of Their Health Care Plan Pay Only One Fourth Of The
Premium. “Most enrollees pay only one-fourth of the health benefit premium. The employee
contribution for health insurance premiums are made on a pretax basis.” [Justice.gov, accessed
10/15/15]
Criticized That The Cost Of Health Insurance Increased With Age
Criticized That The Cost Of Health Insurance Increased With Age. “Katko said the system seems to
penalize individuals as they get older by increasing their health insurance costs. ‘What effect does that
have on people who are retired?’ he said. ‘What’s their insurance going to be?’ It’s one of many reasons
why he feels Obamacare is a disaster.” [The Citizen, 2/11/15]
Voted For Reauthorizing CHIP & Reforming Medicare Fee Payments For Doctors
239
Voted For Allowing Reform To Medicare Fee Payments For Doctors & To Reauthorize Children’s
Health Insurance Program (CHIP). In March 2015, Katko voted for a bill to provide permanent
solution for paying doctors that treat Medicare patients and reauthorize the CHIP program for an
additional two years. “The Senate on Tuesday overwhelmingly approved sweeping changes in the
way Medicare pays doctors, clearing the bill for President Obama and resolving an issue that has
bedeviled Congress and the Medicare program for more than a decade. The 92-to-8 vote in the Senate,
following passage in the House last month by a vote of 392 to 37, was a major success for Republicans,
who devised a solution to a complex policy problem that had frustrated lawmakers of both parties. Mr.
Obama has endorsed the bill, saying it ‘could help slow health care cost growth.’ The bill, drafted in the
House in negotiations between Speaker John A. Boehner and Representative Nancy Pelosi, the
Democratic leader, also extends the Children’s Health Insurance Program for two years, through 2017.
Without action by Congress, doctors would have faced a 21 percent cut in Medicare fees.” The bill
passed, 392 to 37. [HR 2, Vote #144, 3/26/15; NY Times, 4/14/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Funds For Medical Marijuana
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Funds For Medical Marijuana. In June 2015, Katko voted
against an amendment to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act that
“prohibits the use of funds in the bill to supersede State law in those States that have legalized the use of
medical marijuana.” The amendment passed 242 to 186. [HR 2578, Vote #283, 6/03/15]
Voted Against An Amendment Which Would Make NIH And Cures Innovation Fund
Discretionary
Voted Against An Amendment Which Would Make NIH And Cures Innovation Fund
Discretionary. In July 2015, Katko voted against an “amendment that would change the mandatory
funding for the new National Institute of Health and Cures Innovation Fund to an authorization of
discretionary appropriations.” The amendment failed, 141 to 281. [HR 6, Vote #431, 7/10/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 7/10/15]
Voted For Providing $9.3 Billion For Medical Research And Revamp Of The Drug And Medical
Device Evaluation Process
Voted For Providing $9.3 Billion For Medical Research And Revamp Of The Drug And Medical
Device Evaluation Process. In July 2015, Katko voted for a bill that “would provide $9.3 billion for the
National Institutes of Health and Food and Drug Administration over five years while revamping aspects
of the FDA's drug and medical device evaluation processes. The cost would be fully offset, and the
measure also would reauthorize NIH for three years.” The bill passed with strong bipartisan support, 344
– 77, and then referred to the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions. [HR 6, Vote
#433, 7/10/15; CQ News, 7/10/15]
Voted For Ensuring Transparency And Accountability, Removal Of Terminated Providers For
Medicaid And CHIP
Voted For Ensuring Transparency And Accountability, Removal Of Terminated Providers For
Medicaid And CHIP. In March 2016, Katko voted for a bill that would improve transparency and
240
accountability for Medicaid and CHIP providers by instituting improved disclosure requirements. “The
bill would create additional requirements for Medicaid and CHIP, like data reporting… The legislation …
will increase the efficiency of the Medicaid program by creating a searchable database that is more patient
friendly. It would provide beneficiaries served under the Medicaid fee-for-service or primary care case
management programs with a directory of physicians participating in the program so those patients can
receive the most up to date information and are able to find doctors who accept Medicaid more quickly
and efficiently.” [HR 3716, Vote #105, 3/02/16; Office of the Democratic Whip, 3/02/16]
The President Supported Bill, Cited Improved Ability Of States To Identify Terminated
Providers. “H.R. 3716 would improve the ability of States to identify health care providers who have
been terminated from participating in Medicare or in another State's Medicaid or CHIP program. The
Affordable Care Act requires that State Medicaid programs terminate participation of health care
providers that have been terminated by Medicare or another State Medicaid program. This legislation
would improve States' ability to fulfill this requirement by codifying this requirement in CHIP,
requiring providers participating in Medicaid and CHIP managed care to enroll with the State, and
increasing required reporting, sharing of information, and standardization of documentation of reasons
for termination.” [Statement of Administration Policy, Executive Office of the President, 3/01/16]
Bill Would Save $28 Million Over Ten Years. “The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates
that the bill would reduce direct spending by $28 million over the next ten years.” [Office of the
Democratic Whip, 3/02/16]
241
Homeland Security
 Has sponsored two bills which were signed into law dealing with the TSA.
 Was named to head a task force to combat terrorist travel to ISIS
Katko has authored two bills on the TSA which have been signed into law. He has also
authored a bill, which passed the House, to increase airport worker screenings.
Katko was named to head a task force which ventured to the Middle East to further efforts
to stem the flow of fighters to ISIS.
Sponsored Two TSA Bills Which Were Signed Into Law
Sponsored Two Bills Signed Into Law, Was The Only Freshman To Do So. “For the second time in a
week, a bill sponsored by U.S. Rep. John Katko has been signed by President Barack Obama. … This is
the second Katko-sponsored bill to be approved by Congress and signed by President Obama. In the 114th
Congress, he is the only freshman member who has had two bills signed into law.” [The Citizen,
10/02/15]
The President Signed Katko’s Gerardo Hernandez Airport Security Act. “The White House
said Obama signed the measure, known as the Gerardo Hernandez Airport Security Act, into law
on Thursday afternoon.” [The Hill, 9/25/15]
The President Signed Katko’s HR719. “For the second time in a week, a bill sponsored by U.S.
Rep. John Katko has been signed by President Barack Obama. The Transportation Security
Administration Office of Inspection Accountability Act, H.R. 719, was the vehicle for a short-term
spending bill approved by Congress Wednesday.” [The Citizen, 10/02/15]
Asked “Two Agencies To Work Together To Develop An Accurate Cost Estimate” For TSA
Screener Privatization; Said He Was “Not Going To Tolerate Any More Delays In Getting The
Accurate Cost Estimates”
Asked “Two Agencies To Work Together To Develop An Accurate Cost Estimate” For TSA
Screener Privatization; Said He Was “Not Going To Tolerate Any More Delays In Getting The
Accurate Cost Estimates.” “U.S. Rep. John Katko is asking two federal agencies to work together to
develop an accurate cost estimate comparison for the Transportation Security Administration ‘s screeners
and private screening firms. … ‘I am not going to tolerate any more delays in getting the accurate cost
estimates,’ he said. While Katko’s questions focused mainly on the financial side of the program, he also
expressed concerns about security issues involving screeners at airports.” [The Citizen, 11/17/15]
242
Named To A Task Force On Combatting Terrorist Travel, Traveled To Europe And The Middle
East To Stem The Flow Of Fighters To ISIS,
Was Named To Head A Task Force On Combatting Terrorist Travel. “Today, U.S. Rep. Michael
McCaul (TX-10), chairman of the Committee on Homeland Security, and U.S. Rep. Bennie Thompson
(MS-2), ranking member of the Committee on Homeland Security, announced the creation of a bipartisan
“Task Force on Combating Terrorist and Foreign Fighter Travel” in response to the threat from extremists
fighting overseas and the danger they pose to the United States. Rep. John Katko (NY-24) was named the
Republican Lead for the Task Force.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 2/25/14]
Traveled To Europe And The Middle East To Stem The Flow Of Fighters To ISIS. “Early this
Congress, I was put in charge of a bipartisan Task Force on Combating Terrorist and Foreign Fighter
Travel charged with answering these questions. To gain perspective on this multifaceted global threat, our
task force recently traveled to Iraq, Israel, Turkey and Ger-many, where I spoke directly with officials in
each of these countries about the flow of foreign fighters to Syria and Iraq and recent threats and attacks
against the United States.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Post Standard, 5/31/15]
House Passed A Bill Containing Visa Recommendations From Task Force Katko Chaired; He
Advocated For Information Sharing Regarding The Visa Waiver Program
The House Passed A Bill Containing Visa Recommendations From A Task Force Chaired By
Katko. “A bill approved Tuesday by the House of Representatives to reform the visa waiver program
contains recommendations from a task force led by U.S. Rep. John Katko. According to Katko, RCamillus, the legislation sponsored by U.S. Rep. Candice Miller includes recommendations outlined in a
report released in September by the House Homeland Security Committee’s Task Force on Combating
Terrorist and Foreign Fighter Travel. Katko chaired the panel, which spent six months reviewing the
threats posed by foreign fighters.” [The Citizen, 12/09/15]
Said “The Problem With The Visa Waiver Program Is Information,” And Advocated For
Information Sharing. KATKO: … The problem with the visa waiver program is information. It is not on
our side of the pond, but the other side. When you have a visa waiver into another country, you are
entering a contract that you will do information sharing at a level that makes you feel OK about the
information that you are receiving regarding the travelers. Anybody who takes part in the visa waiver
program has to fill out the electronic survey online and that is run against the terrorist database. It is not so
much the system, but we are getting information from other countries, and the other countries need to step
up the game as far as how they gather information and where they put it. For example, entering it in
Interpol is one of the recommendations of the task force report, and doing things like that would really
help. The visa waiver program is a good idea because, in the end, it is really an information enhancer and
security enhancer as long as the other countries that we’re working with give you the proper information
to screen the passengers. [CNN, 11/20/15]
Touted The Economic Impact Of The Visa Waiver Program. KATKO: Well, first of all, recognize
what the visa program does. It generates billions of dollars of business in the United States, and also
generates about one million jobs in the United States. [CNN, 11/20/15]
243
Accused Turkey Of Supporting ISIS by “Basically Turn[ing[ A Blind Eye To Their Borders”
Because “They Figured ISIS Would Be Great; Falsely Used Turkey As An Example Of A EU
Country
Said That Turkey “Basically Turned A Blind Eye To Their Borders” Because “They Figured ISIS
Would Be Great.” KATKO: … But there’s still a lot of countries in the EU that are not doing that and
we have to work with them to educate them. Turkey, for example, when this whole phenomenon with
ISIS started a few years ago, basically turned a blind eye to their borders because they didn’t like the
Assad regime in Syria. They figured ISIS would be great because they could take them out. Now they
found out, ‘Wait a minute, ISIS is doing attacks against us, too.’ Now they’re trying to put the genie back
in the bottle and secure the borders. It’s been very difficult for them to do so. [Interview, The Citizen,
10/04/15]
Used Turkey As An Example Of An EU Country. KATKO: … But there’s still a lot of countries in the
EU that are not doing that and we have to work with them to educate them. Turkey, for example, when
this whole phenomenon with ISIS started a few years ago, basically turned a blind eye to their borders
because they didn’t like the Assad regime in Syria. [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/15]
As Of January 2016 Turkey Was Not A Member Of The European Union. Accessed in
January 2016, the European Union website listed its 28 member states, and did not include
Turkey. [European Union Website, accessed 1/20/16]
Noted That Blocking ISIS Fighter Reentry Into The West “Ignores The Fact” That They Are
“Attempting To Provide Criminal Support To Terrorists And They Should Be Prosecuted For
That.”
Noted That Blocking ISIS Fighter Reentry Into The West “Ignores The Fact” They Are
“Attempting To Provide Criminal Support To Terrorists And They Should Be Prosecuted For
That.” KATKO: … You hear a lot of talk, as an aside, people saying, ‘Let them go. Don’t let them back
in the country.’ Well, that’s only the ones that we know of you could even do that for. That ignores the
fact that we have providing material support for a terrorist group as a criminal law. Anybody that’s even
attempting to go over to join ISIS is attempting to provide criminal support to terrorists and they should
be prosecuted for that. [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/15]
Rejected Donald Trump’s Proposal To Ban Muslims, Calling It “Offensive And Divisive”
Rejected Donald Trump’s Proposal To Ban Muslims, Calling It “Offensive And Divisive.” “U.S.
Rep. Richard Hanna on Tuesday condemned fellow Republican Donald Trump for suggesting Muslims
should be banned from traveling to the United States. … Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, was among those
who criticized Trump. ‘Instead of presenting a strategy, Donald Trump has focused on making offensive
and divisive re-marks which do nothing to keep Americans safe and are contrary to our nation’s values,’
Katko said.” [Post Standard, 12/09/15]
Questioned Why San Bernadino Shooters Weren’t On The Terror Watch Lists; Criticized The
Terror Watch Lists
244
Questioned Why San Bernadino Shooters Weren’t On The Terror Watch List. “Those examples,
Katko said, prompt him to ask about the TSA’s methods: ‘I am deeply concerned that we are failing to
identify the real and current threats, while placing innocent Americans on lists that restrict their freedom
of movement and travel.’ … Katko, chairman of the House Homeland Security Subcommittee on
Transportation Security, asked two top counterterrorism officials to answer questions about the federal
watch lists within 12 days.” [Post Standard, 12/13/15]
Said He Worried Terror Watch lists Fail To Address Security Vulnerabilities. “He said he’s worried
that the watch lists, in their current form, fail to address security vulnerabilities. ‘We cannot rely on
inaccurate data, and we must make sure if someone is placed on a no fly list, that they actually pose a
security risk,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 12/12/15]
Said Technology Companies Were “Not Going To Want To” Help Monitor Terrorist Behavior On
Their Websites
Said Technology Companies Were “Not Going To Want To” Help Monitor Terrorist Behavior On
Their Websites. KATKO: … We also need to work with the technology experts at these companies and
ask them to help us find a way to be able to monitor this terrorist behavior on their websites. They’re not
going to want to do that willingly, for the most part. See if there’s legal ways we can compel them to
provide the technology. [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/15]
Said He Was Working To “Actually Identify Those Individuals Who Pose Threats, Improve Access
To Mental Health Care And Work[ing] To Counter Radical Extremism.” “But Katko, R-Camillus,
doesn't believe Obama's approach is the right one to combat gun violence. Bypassing Congress to
implement these policies is a ‘divisive tactic,’ he said. ‘Meaningful and effective reform will only come if
we do more to improve background check systems, actually identify those individuals who pose threats,
improve access to mental health care and work to counter radical extremism,’ he said. ‘I have and will
continue to work on these types of bipartisan, common sense solutions in Congress so that our nation can
come together and make a difference to protect our communities from gun violence.’” [The Citizen,
1/06/16]
Announced The Passage Of A Cybersecurity Bill With An Amendment He Sponsored
Announced Passage Of A Cybersecurity Bill With An Amendment He Sponsored Aiding Privacy
Concerns. “The U.S. House of Representatives today passed H.R. 1731, the National Cybersecurity
Protection Advancement Act, which includes an amendment introduced by U.S. Rep. John Katko (NY24) and a bipartisan group of colleagues to ensure adequate privacy protections are put in place. Today’s
legislation encourages information sharing between the private sector and the federal government on
cyber-related incidents. However, because the definition of ‘incident’ is broad, it could be interpreted to
allow the sharing and use of information unrelated to cyber-crimes. By specifically defining “incident,”
Katko’s amendment ensures that information obtained by the government in collaboration with private
entitles may only be used in relation to an actual cyber-crime.” [Press Release, 4/23/15]
Said He Was Concerned Surface Transit Lacked Adequate Security
245
Said He Was Concerned That Surface Transit Lacked Adequate Security. “U.S. Rep. John Katko
delivered a sobering assessment of the United States ‘ surface transportation security. Mass transit,
particularly trains, is vulnerable to a terrorist attack. ‘The difference between the rails and airports are
airports have a tremendous amount of scrutiny to them right now, a tremendous amount of security,’
Katko, R-Camillus, said. ‘I am concerned that the surface transportation system is lacking in the amount
of security that it needs.’” [The Citizen, 9/18/15]
Said The Threat Of Terrorism Cost Central New York Jobs
Said The Threat Of Terrorism Cost Central New York Jobs. “A first step in restoring faith and
confidence in our economy is addressing threats to our national security. Looming terrorist activity
inhibits growth and reduces consumer confidence and will ultimately cost Central New York jobs.” [Rep.
Katko Op-Ed, Post Standard, 5/31/15]
April 2015: Said He Would Not Vote To Reauthorize The PATRIOT Act In Its Current Form
April 2015: Said He Would Not Vote For The PATRIOT Act Renewal In Its Current Form Due To
Wiretapping Provisions. “From that seat he’ll have to review sections of the post-9/11 national security
law known as the Patriot Act. Section 215 of that law has been cited by both the Bush and Obama
administrations to justify their collection of data on U.S. Citizens’ phone calls and emails. It expires in
June. Will Katko vote to renew that provision? ‘Not in its current form,’ Katko answered. ‘I don’t agree
with it. I’m concerned from a privacy standpoint. I’ve been doing wiretaps for 20 years (as a federal
prosecutor). We got a court order for everything we needed and we had to prove to a judge why we
needed it. I don’t think you can just throw out that standard. Of course we have to balance the privacy
issues with the national security issues, and I’m not sure the first round of the Patriot Act did that well
enough.’ Katko said he hasn’t seen proposed language yet, but would like to see ‘substantial safeguards
on how they use the information.’” [Syracuse New Times, 4/08/15]
Held A Hearing, And, As A Result, Authored A Law To Enhance Screening Procedures For
Airport Workers
Questioned TSA Head On Aviation Employee Screening Procedures. “The newly minted head of the
Transportation Security Administration testified at a House Homeland Security Committee meeting
Wednesday and faced questions from U.S. Rep. John Katko on what he believes needs to be done to
strengthen employee access controls at U.S. airports. … Katko, who chairs the House Homeland Security
Subcommittee on Transportation Security, said the gun ring and other illegal activity involving aviation
employees exposed a ‘gaping hole in security.’” [The Citizen, 7/30/15]
Sponsored Legislation Which Passed Calling For TSA Investigators To Spend Half Their Time On
Criminal Investigations. “A package of bills aimed at increasing transparency and cutting waste at the
Department of Homeland Security includes legislation sponsored by U.S. Rep. John Katko that was
approved by the House of Representatives in February. Under Katko’s bill, criminal investigators for the
Transportation Security Administration would be eligible for premium pay and other benefits if they
spend at least half their work time on criminal cases. Right now, there is no minimum requirement in
place and it’s unknown if the agency’s investigators spend at least 50 percent of their time on criminal
cases.” [The Citizen, 3/27/15]
246
Announced The Passage Of HR3102, A Bill To Increase Screening Of Airport Workers. “The U.S.
House of Representatives tonight passed H.R. 3102, the Airport Access Control Security Improvement
Act of 2015, legislation introduced by U.S. Representatives John Katko (R-NY-24) and Kathleen Rice
(D-NY-04), Chairman and Ranking Member of the House Committee on Homeland Security’s
Transportation Security Subcommittee. … H.R. 3102 comes in response to several recent incidents in
which airport and airline employees used their security credentials to bypass security screening and
transport prohibited items, including illegal drugs and guns, into secure areas of airports and onto
commercial flights. The legislation will streamline and strengthen the Transportation Security
Administration’s (TSA) screening procedures for airport and airline employees by requiring the TSA
Administrator to establish a risk-based, intelligence-driven screening model that subjects employees to
more frequent, more randomized security screenings and minimizes the number of employee entry and
exit points.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 10/07/15]
Pushed For Tighter Criminal Screening of Aviation Employees. “In June, a report released by the
Department of Homeland Security Inspector General’s office made headlines. The report found 73 U.S.
aviation employees had potential ties to terrorism. For Katko, it was another sign of employee screening
woes at airports across the country. He signed a letter that was sent to TSA urging them to address
vulnerabilities in its aviation employee vetting process. But he didn’t stop here. One week later, he
introduced a bill, the Improved Vetting for Aviation Workers Act, which aims to strengthen worker
screening. A key provision in the bill would enhance TSA’s criminal background check capabilities.”
Called For Tighter Screening On Airport Employees The TSA Cited Cost Concerns. “U.S. Rep.
John Katko introduced a bill Friday to close airport security loopholes, five months after the TSA said it
cannot afford to provide physical screenings of all airport workers with access to secure areas. Katko, RCamillus, said his ''Airport Access Control Security Improvement Act" is a response to a series of security
breaches at airports nationwide involving airline and airport employees. … ‘It is clear from this, and other
incidents at airports nationwide, that there are gaps in employee vetting and screening procedures which
must be addressed to protect the traveling public,’ Katko said in a statement Friday.” [Post Standard,
7/17/15]
Katko Reintroduced A Bill To Require Airports Have Security Response Plans, Bill Was Signed
Into Law. “The Gerardo Hernandez Airport Security Act sponsored by U.S. Rep. John Katko was signed
into law Thursday by President Barack Obama. It is the first Katko-sponsored bill to become a law. The
measure requires the Transportation Security Administration to ensure airports and other mass transit
hubs have plans in place to respond to security incidents. Katko, R-Camillus, reintroduced the bill in
February after he chaired his first House Homeland Security Subcommittee on Transportation Security
hearing.” [The Citizen, 9/25/15]
Said The Sharm El Sheik Metrojet Bombing Highlighted The Vulnerabilities Of Airport Employee
Screening Procedures
Said The Sharm El Sheik Metrojet Bombing Highlighted The Vulnerabilities Of Airport Employee
Screening Procedures. KATKO: … But better screening and vetting of the employees at airports and
recognizing that right now the employees at the airports are much less scrutiny than the people who visit
247
the airports. We have to change that. And given the fact of what happened in Sharm el Sheikh looks like it
was done with the help of employees of the airport, goes to show you that one of the great vulnerabilities
that nobody is paying attention to is employees at the airports. We have 9,000 of them at airports
nationwide, and they are not getting the scrutiny they need. [CNN, 11/20/15]
Voted Against Motion To Block Elimination Of Regulations That Prevent Terrorism And Crime,
Protect Wages
Voted Against Motion To Block Elimination Of Regulations That Prevent Terrorism And Crime,
Protect Wages. In January 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would block Republicans from
eliminating regulations that help prevent terrorism and crime, protect wages and gender pay equity, save
taxpayer dollars, help small businesses, and prevent discrimination. The motion failed 245 to 180. [HR
185, Vote #27, 1/13/15; Motion To Recommit, 1/13/15]
Voted Against Protecting Department Of Homeland Security Regulations From Significant Delays
Voted Against Protecting Department Of Homeland Security Regulations From Significant Delays.
In January 2015, Katko voted against an amendment exempting rules issued by the Department of
Homeland Security from the bill’s burdensome requirements. The amendment failed 242 to 176. [HR 185,
Amendment No. 3, Vote #25, 1/13/15, CQ Floor Votes, 1/13/15]
Voted Against A Motion To Loosen Restrictions On Individuals Who Finance Terrorism
Voted Against A Motion To Loosen Restrictions On Individuals Who Finance Terrorism. In January
2015, Katko voted against a motion that would disqualify anyone convicted of providing financial
assistance to terrorist organizations or state sponsors of terrorism from regulatory relief under the
underlying bill, the Promoting Job Creation and Reducing Small Business Burdens Act. “But House
members also took up a narrower measure that would slow enforcement of Dodd-Frank requirements and
weaken other regulations on financial services companies.” The motion failed 183 to 242. [HR 37, Vote
#37, 1/14/15; Motion to Recommit, 1/14/15; CQ Floor Votes, 1/14/15; New York Times, 1/13/15]
Four Times Voted Against Clean DHS Funding Bill
January 2015: Voted Against Clean DHS Funding Bill. In January 2015, Katko voted against a motion
that would allow a clean version of the Homeland Security funding bill—without amendments defunding
Obama’s executive order on immigration—to pass, removing the threat of shutdown for the Department.
The measure failed 244 to 184. [HR 240, Vote #34, 1/14/15]
February 2015 #1: Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Clean Department Of Homeland Security
Funding Bill. In February 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of a motion to “force a vote on
clean legislation to provide long-term funding for the Department Homeland Security, without radical,
anti-immigrant riders.” The previous question passed, 242 to 183. A vote against the previous question
would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H.RES.100, Vote #71, 2/11/15; Democratic Leadership
Summary, 2/11/15]
248
February 2015 #2: Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Clean DHS Funding Bill. In February 2015,
Katko voted for blocking consideration of a motion to force a clean vote on the DHS funding bill without
anti-immigration riders. The previous question passed, 232 to 164. A vote against the previous question
would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 101, Vote #77, 2/12/15]
February 2015 #3: Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Clean DHS Funding Bill. In February 2015,
Katko voted for blocking consideration of a motion to force a clean vote on the DHS funding bill without
anti-immigration riders. The previous question passed, 241 to 181. A vote against the previous question
would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 121, Vote #86, 2/25/15]
Voted For Bill Funding Department Of Homeland Security
Voted For Bill To Fund Department Of Homeland Security. On March 3, 2015, Katko voted for a bill
to fund the Department of Homeland Security. “The House of Representatives passed a bill on Tuesday
funding the Department of Homeland Security through the end of September, effectively ending a
congressional standoff that nearly shut the department down at the end of last week. The bill, identical to
a measure that cleared the Senate last Friday, passed by a margin of 257 to 167, with 75 Republicans and
182 Democrats voting in favor.” [HR 240, Vote #109, 3/03/15; CBS, 3/03/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Clean, Long-Term DHS Funding Bill
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Clean, Long-Term Department of Homeland Security
Funding Bill. In February 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of the Department of Homeland
Security Appropriations Act of 2015, a bill long-term funding bill. “The Democratic Previous Question
would force a vote on legislation to provide long-term funding for Homeland Security, without radical,
anti-immigrant riders. This is the fifth opportunity for House Republicans to vote for a clean DHS funding
bill.” The previous question passed, 240 to 183. A vote against the previous question would have allowed
the bill to be considered. [H Res 129, Vote #100, 2/27/15; Democratic Leader, 2/27/15]
Voted Against Clean, Long-Term Department Of Homeland Security Appropriations Bill. In
February 2015, Katko voted against considering a clean, long-term Department of Homeland Security
funding bill approved by the Senate and instead voted to disagree with the Senate amendments and
request a conference committee. “The House passed a measure along party lines Friday afternoon to go to
conference with the Senate to hash out the differences between their long-term bills. Majority Leader
Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) later announced a motion to agree. But Senate Democrats, who insist on a
clean bill, are expected to block plans for a conference on Monday.” The motion passed, 228 to 191. [HR
240, Vote #102, 2/27/15; Washington Post, 2/28/15]
Voted For Clean, Full-Year DHS Funding Bill. In February 2015, Katko voted for a motion to instruct
members of a conference committee to accept a clean, long-term Department of Homeland Security
appropriations bill approved by the Senate. According to the motion’s sponsor, Rep. Roybal-Allard, “my
motion would instruct the conferees to recede to the Senate position, which is the responsible position of
providing a full-year funding for the Homeland Security Department ... Let the House, like the Senate, do
the right thing and send this bill to the President. I urge my colleagues to vote for this motion to instruct
conferees to bring back a clean, full-year, bipartisan funding bill for this Nation's homeland security.”
[HR 240, Vote #105, 2/27/15; House Congressional Record, Page H1485, 2/27/15]
249
Voted For Stalling Three Weeks On Passing Long-Term Funding For Department Of Homeland
Security
Voted For Stalling Three Weeks On Passing Long-Term Funding For Department Of Homeland
Security. In February 2015, Katko voted for continuing FY2015 funding levels for the Department of
Homeland Security for three weeks. “Earlier in the day, the House collapsed in failure when a last-ditch
attempt to fund the agency for an additional three weeks died at the hands of most Democrats and dozens
of Republicans who voted against it.” The resolution failed, 203 to 224. [H J Res 35, Vote #104, 2/27/15;
Washington Post, 2/28/15]
Vote Highlighted Lack Of House Republican Unity. “The defeat was a major blow to Speaker John
A. Boehner (R-Ohio), whose struggles to get unruly members to fall in line have continued in the new
Congress. More broadly, it was an early black eye for the unified Republican majority that had vowed
to govern effectively.” [Washington Post, 2/28/15]
Vote Was A “Humiliating Setback” For Speaker Boehner. “The accord was reached after a
stunning and humiliating setback for Speaker John A. Boehner and his leadership team earlier Friday,
when the House voted against their original plan to extend funding for the department for three weeks
— a position that Mr. Boehner had considered a fail-safe. More than 50 House Republicans defected,
voting against the bill.” [New York Times, 2/28/15]
Voted For Last Minute Stop Gap Measure To Prevent DHS Shutdown
Voted For Extending Funding For Department Of Homeland Security By One Week. In February
2015, Katko voted for a motion to suspend the rules and concur with a Senate amendment to extend
FY2015 funding levels for the Department of Homeland Security by one week. “Congress managed at the
last minute on Friday night to avert a partial shuttering of the Department of Homeland Security, passing
a one-week funding measure for the agency. President Obama signed it shortly before the midnight
deadline … After the House bill went down, the Senate sought to pull DHS back from the brink by
swiftly passing the one-week bill by a voice vote. The House followed suit shortly thereafter, voting 357
to 60 in favor of it.” [HR 33, Vote #106, 2/27/15; Washington Post, 2/28/15]
NOTE: 174 Democrats voted in favor of this motion.
Voted For Strengthening Cyber Threat Programs
Voted For Encouraging Private Sector To Share Cyber Threat Data With Department of
Homeland Security. In April 2015, Katko voted for the passage of the bill, as amended, that would
promote the voluntary sharing of information about cyber threats among private companies and between
the private sector and federal government. The bill would provide liability protections to companies that
share cyber threat information. It would also establish the Homeland Security Department's National
Cybersecurity and Communication Integration Center as the lead federal agency in receiving and
exchanging cyber threat information with other federal agencies and private companies. The provisions of
the bill would sunset after seven years. The bill passed by a vote of 355-63. [HR 1731, Vote #173,
4/23/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/23/15]
250
Voted Against Prioritizing Protecting Infrastructure, Jobs And Health Information In Cyber
Threat Intelligence Sharing Programs. In April 2015, Katko voted against the Israel, D-N.Y., motion to
recommit the bill to the House Homeland Security Committee with instructions to report back with an
amendment that would clarify the protection of infrastructure, jobs and health information from
cyberattacks. The amendment would direct the secretary of Homeland Security conduct ongoing riskinformed outreach to the owners and operators of at-risk critical infrastructure. The motion was rejected
by a vote of 180-238. [HR 1731, Vote #172, 4/23/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/23/15]
Voted For Requiring Homeland Security Department Issue Report On Civil Liberties’ Impact Of
Programs Created Under Cyber Threat Intelligence Sharing Bill. In April 2015, Katko voted for the
Jackson Lee, D-Texas, amendment that would require the Homeland Security Department to issue a
report to Congress on the best means for aligning federally funded cybersecurity research and
development with private sector efforts to protect privacy and civil liberties while also protecting the
nation's critical infrastructure. The amendment was adopted by a vote of 405-8. [HR 1731, Vote #171,
4/23/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/23/15]
Voted For Encouraging Private Sector To Share Cyber Threat Data With Federal Intelligence
Agencies. In April 2015, Katko voted for the passage of the bill to promote the voluntary sharing of cyber
threat information among private companies and between the private sector and federal government. The
bill would provide liability protections to companies that share cyber threat information and would require
that all personally identifiable information be removed from information that is shared. It would also
establish a Cyber Threat Intelligence Integration Center within the director of National Intelligence’s
Office. As amended, the provisions of the bill would sunset after seven years. The bill was passed by a
vote of 307-116. [HR 1560, Vote #170, 4/22/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/22/15]
Voted Against Prioritizing Terrorist & Foreign Threats To Military Assets In Cyber Threat
Intelligence Sharing Programs. In April 2015, Katko voted against the Rice, D-N.Y., motion to
recommit the bill to the House Select Intelligence Committee with instructions to report back with an
amendment that would add language to clarify that appropriate agencies prioritize the sharing of cyber
threat indicators regarding known terrorist organizations and attempts to steal U.S. military technology by
state-sponsored computer hackers. The motion was rejected by a vote of 183-239. [HR 1560, Vote #169,
4/22/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/22/15]
Voted Against Sunset Protecting Cyber Networks Act After Seven Years. In April 2015, Katko voted
against the Mulvaney, R-S.C., amendment that would sunset the provisions of the bill after seven years.
The amendment was adopted by a vote of 313-110. [HR 1560, Vote #168, 4/22/15; CQ Floor Votes,
4/22/15]
Voted For Weakening Cybersecurity, Even For Veterans
Voted For Allowing DHS To Share Cyberthreat Information With Private Entities. In April 2015,
Katko voted for a rule to allow consideration of a bill “that would promote voluntary sharing of
information about cyberthreats among private companies and between the private sector and federal
government and the bill (HR 1731) that would allow the Homeland Security Department to share the
251
cyberthreat information it gathers with private sector entities.” The resolution passed, 238-182. [HRes
212, Vote #164, 4/22/15; CQ News, 4/22/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Protecting Veterans’ Personal Information From Cyber
Attacks. In April 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of a bill to protect veterans’ personal
information from cyber-attacks. The bill “would promote voluntary sharing of information about
cyberthreats among private companies and between the private sector and federal government and the bill
(HR 1731) that would allow the Homeland Security Department to share the cyberthreat information it
gathers with private sector entities.” The previous question passed, 237-179. A vote against the previous
question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [HRes212, Vote #163, 4/22/15; CQ News,
4/22/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Prevent Funds From Being Used To Build, Renovate, Or Expand
Detainee Housing Facilities In Guantanamo Bay
Voted Against An Amendment To Prevent Funds From Being Used To Build, Renovate, Or Expand
Detainee Housing Facilities In Guantanamo Bay. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment
that would prevent from being used to build, renovate, or expand housing facilities for detainees in
Guantanamo Bay. The amendment failed to pass 167 to 254. [HR 2029, Vote #187; On Agreeing to the
Amendment, 4/30/15; Section 512 of HR 2029; CQ, Bill Track]
Voted For Reining In Government Surveillance Of American Citizens
Voted For NSA Surveillance Reform. In May 2015, Katko voted for the USA FREEDOM Act “which
would prevent the NSA from collecting bulk metadata about the phone numbers people dial and when
their calls are placed … The bill would require the NSA to obtain a court order to look at data, which
would be held by phone companies. It would also be required to ask for a ‘specific selection term,’ so that
records could not be collected in bulk. It would place limits on other types of data collection as well, add
new transparency measures to make more information public and create a special team of experts to
weigh in on some unique cases before the secretive federal court that oversees intelligence programs.”
The bill passed 338 to 88. [HR 2048, Vote #224, 5/13/15; The Hill, 5/13/15]
Voted For Increasing Restrictions On Transfer Of Guantanamo Detainees To U.S.
Voted For Increasing Restrictions On Transferring Guantanamo Detainees To The U.S. & Forbid
Building New Facilities On Us Soil. In May 2015, Katko voted for “lengthen[ing] to two years the bill's
restrictions on the transfer of detainees from Guantanamo Bay, Cuba to the U.S. and on construction or
modification of facilities in the U.S. to house Guantanamo detainees. It also would prohibit transfers of
detainees to Yemen and bar the Defense secretary from using a national security waiver to transfer
prisoners to combat zones.” The amendment passed, 243-180. [HR 1725, Vote #230; CQ Floor Votes
5/14/15]
Voted Against Closing Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp By 2017
Voted Against Closing Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp By 2017. In May 2015, Katko voted against
“a framework for closing the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, by Dec. 31, 2017. The
252
amendment would remove restrictions in the bill against transferring Guantanamo Bay, Cuba detainees to
the U.S., constructing or modifying any facility in the U.S. to house a Guantanamo Bay detainee, and
transferring detainees to a combat zone.” The amendment failed, 174-249. [HR 1735, Vote #231; CQ
Floor Votes 5/14/15]
Measure Would Have Maintained Current Ban Against Transferring Detainees To The US And
Prohibiting Facilities To House Detainees On US Soil. “The legislation maintains the current ban
against transferring Guantánamo Bay detainees to the U.S. It also prohibits building facilities to house
detainees on U.S. soil.” [The Hill, 5/14/15]
Voted For Including Border Security Activities In Preferred Applications For Defense Department
Property Transfers
Voted For Amendment To Include Border Security Activities In Preferred Applications For
Defense Department Property Transfers. In May 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would
“amend current law to include border security activities to the list of preferred applications the Defense
Department considers when transferring excess property to other federal agencies.” The amendment was
adopted, 253 to 166. [H.R. 1735, Vote #232, 5/14/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/14/15]
Voted Against An Amendment Banning The Transfer Or Release Of Prisoners From Guantanamo
Bay
Voted Against An Amendment Banning The Transfer Or Release Of Prisoners From Guantanamo
Bay. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related
Agencies Appropriations Act, that would “strike section 527 from the bill which prohibits use of funds to
transfer, release, or assist in the transfer or release to or within the U.S., its territories, or possessions
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed or any other detainee who is not a U.S. citizen or a member of the Armed
Forces of the U.S. and is or was held on or after June 24, 2009, at the U.S. Naval Station, Guantanamo
Bay, Cuba, by the Department of Defense.” The amendment failed 170-256. [HR 2578, Vote #276,
6/03/15]
Voted Against Striking Prohibition On Funds For Transferring Guantanamo Bay Detainees
Voted Against Striking Prohibition On Funds Being Used To Transfer Guantanamo Bay Detainees
To the U.S. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that would strike section 8100 of the bill,
which bars funds from being used to transfer or release within the United States, or its territories, Khalid
Sheikh Mohammed or any other detainee held at U.S. Naval Station, Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.” The
amendment was rejected, 174-257. [CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote #336, 6/10/15]
Voted Against Striking Prohibition On Funds To Construct Any Facility In U.S. To House
Guantanamo Detainees. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that would strike section
8101 of the bill, which bars funds from being used to construct, acquire or modify any facility in the
United States, or its territories, to house Guantanamo Bay detainees for purposes of imprisonment.” The
amendment was rejected, 173-259. [CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote #337, 6/10/15]
253
Voted Against Striking Prohibition On Funds Being Used To Transfer Detainee From Guantanamo
Bay To Home Country Or Any Other Foreign Country. In June 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment “that would strike section 8102 of the bill, which bars funds from being used to transfer any
individual detained at U.S. Naval Station, Guantanamo Bay, Cuba to the custody or control of the
individual's home country or any other foreign country except in accordance with the fiscal 2014 defense
authorization act.” The amendment was rejected, 181-251. [CQ Floor Votes, 6/10/15; HR 2685, Vote
#338, 6/10/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Funding For Defense Counsel For Foreign Detainees At Guantanamo
Bay
Voted Against Prohibiting Funding For Defense Counsel For Foreign Detainees At Guantanamo
Bay. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to “prohibit use of funds to provide for defense
counsel for any foreign detainee at the Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, detention facility.” The amendment
failed, 133-297. [HR 2685, Vote #355; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Voted Against Ending Warrantless “Backdoor” Surveillance
Voted Against Ending Backdoor Surveillance Of Americans. In June 2016, Katko voted against
restricting the use of “funds to query a collection of foreign intelligence information acquired under
Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 using a United States person identifier.
The amendment also would bar use of funds by the National Security Agency or the Central Intelligence
Agency to mandate that a company alter products or services to permit electronic surveillance of users,
except for mandates or requests authorized under the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement
Act.” The amendment passed, 255-174. [HR 2685, Vote #356; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Amendment Would End Spying On American Citizens Whose Data Was Incidentally
Collected During Foreign Surveillance. “The House passed legislation Thursday that would
prevent the NSA from spying on American citizens whose data was incidentally collected during
foreign dragnets, marking the second year in a row that the lower chamber has put the kibosh on
backdoor domestic spying. Sponsored by Reps. Thomas Massie, R-Ky., and Zoe Lofgren, DCalif., the amendment to the Department of Defense spending bill was approved in a 255-174 vote
across party lines.” [Intercept, 6/12/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Remove Additional Restrictions On Closing Guantanamo Bay
Detention Camp
Voted Against Amendment To Remove Additional Restrictions On The Closure Of Guantanamo
Bay. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would strike four sections of the Intelligence
Authorization Act which add new restrictions to prevent the Obama Administration from closing the
Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp. The amendment failed 176 to 246. [HR 2596, Vote #367, 6/16/15; CQ
Voted Against Increasing Airport And Cyber Security
254
Voted Against Motion To Require Communication Across The National Intelligence Community
To Increase Airport And Cyber Security. In June 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would add
language to the Intelligence Authorization Act to “deter terrorist attacks, and strengthen America’s
cybersecurity by requiring intelligence agencies to share with the Transportation Safety Administration
the latest info on terrorist attempts to thwart airport security and who’s on the terrorist watch list; and foil
and counter state-sponsored cyberattacks by China, Russia, and others that resulted in OPM hacks, and
theft of personal health information of 80 million Americans from Anthem Health and Blue Cross Blue
Shield.” The motion failed 183 to 240. [HR 2596, Vote #368, 6/16/15; Democratic Leader, 6/16/15]
Voted For FY2016 Intelligence Authorization Bill
Voted For Fiscal Year 2016 Intelligence Authorization Act. In June 2015, Katko voted for the
Intelligence Authorization Act. Rep. Adam Schiff, ranking member on the Select Committee on
Intelligence said in a release, “several issues remain unresolved, causing me to vote against the bill. It was
my hope that we would have been able to strip restrictions on closing the Guantanamo Bay prison and
preclude the use of OCO funds to augment the artificial budget caps set for national security, but
unfortunately, we were not able to do so. I will continue to work hard to fix these issues as this bill
progresses — the American people deserve nothing less.” The bill passed 247 to 178. [HR 2596, Vote
#369, 6/16/15; Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence – Democratic Office, 6/16/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting The Export-Import Bank From Financing Entities Designated As State
Sponsors Of Terrorism
Voted Against Prohibiting The Export-Import Bank From Financing Entities Designated As State
Sponsors Of Terrorism. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment, “that would prohibit
the Export-Import Bank from providing financing to an entity designated a state-sponsor of terrorism by
the secretary of State.” The amendment failed 183-244. [HR 22, Vote #614, 11/04/15; CQ, accessed
1/07/16]
Voted For The FY16 Intelligence Authorization Act
Voted For The FY16 Intelligence Authorization Act. In December 2015, Katko voted for a motion to
suspend the rules and pass the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2016 to “authorize
appropriations for fiscal year 2016 for intelligence and intelligence-related activities, including the Office
of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), the National
Security Agency (NSA), the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the Department of Defense, the
Department of State, and the Department of Homeland Security. The bill would provide authorizations for
fighting terrorism, activities in Iraq and Afghanistan, countering the proliferation of weapons of mass
destruction, investments in information technology enterprises, surveillance and reconnaissance, and
cyber defense. The classified annex, which specifies the funding levels and personnel ceilings for each
intelligence program, is only available to members.” The motion was agreed to by a vote of 364-58. [H R
Refugees
255
Voted To Suspend The Acceptance Of Syrian Refugees, Was Criticized In An Op-Ed Over The
Vote
Voted To Suspend The Acceptance Of Syrian Refugees. In November 2015, Katko voted for a bill
“that would suspend the program allowing Syrian and Iraqi refugees into the U.S. until key national
security agencies certify they don't pose a security risk.” The bill passed the House 289-137. [HR4038,
Vote #643, 11/19/15; CNN, 11/19/15]
Said He Supported Accepting Syrian Refugees, But Only After “A More Rigorous Screening
Program.” “U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, a member of the House Homeland Security
Committee, said Monday that he supports accepting Syrian refugees - but only after the United
States sets up a more rigorous screening program. ‘It’s a huge issue,’ Katko said. ‘We’re a land of
immigrants. But it’s a real problem because both ISIS and al-Qaida have said they want to
infiltrate the West through the refugees. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t take them.’ The House
voted overwhelmingly Thursday to erect fresh hurdles for Syrian and Iraqi refugees trying to enter
the United States.” [Post Standard, 11/22/15]
Called For A “Very Thorough” Vetting Process For Syrian Refugees. “As an increasing
number of elected leaders and politicians speak out against allowing thousands of Syrian refugees
into the United States, U.S. Rep. John Katko is taking a different approach. Katko, R-Camillus,
said Monday that he doesn’t have a problem with allowing Syrian refugees into the U.S., but there
must be a ‘very thorough’ vetting process.”
Called For Refugee Screening Procedures Like Those Used On Sudanese Refugees, But Said
America Does Not Have “An Intelligence Apparatus In Syria.” “Katko, R-Camillus, said
Monday that he doesn’t have a problem with allowing Syrian refugees into the U.S., but there
must be a ‘very thorough’ vetting process. He recalled a conversation he had with one of the ‘Lost
Boys,’ a group of children who fled Sudan during the country’s civil war. Before the Lost Boy
could enter the United States, he was subjected to an extensive review. ‘He said even though his
parents were gone, he was by himself and he was still young, they vetted him thoroughly over a
long period,’ Katko said. ‘They went back event to his tribe and went back to his village to vet
him before they allowed him to come to the United States. We need that type of vetting with
respect to Syrian refugees, and we cannot cut corners.’ The challenge is that the U.S. doesn’t have
an intelligence apparatus in Syria. That will take time to establish, he said.” [The Citizen,
11/16/15]
Leferve: Katko’s Vote To Halt Syrian Refugees “Xenophobic And Anti-Immigrant.”
“Following the attacks in Paris, many at the Peace Council feared that we would see an upsurge in
Islamaphobia and xenophobic anti-immigrant actions. Unfortunately, these fears have been
realized, as symbolized by Rep. John Katko’s vote to halt the resettlement of Syrian refugees to
the U.S. Katko joins politicians who stand on the wrong side of history by stoking fear of
refugees, including pre-decessors who tried to halt the flow of refugees from Vietnam and, before
that, from Nazi Germany.” [Amelia Leferve Op-Ed, Post Standard, 11/29/15]
Voted For To Block Vote On Secure Refugee Process Act
256
Voted For To Block A Vote On The Secure Refugee Process Act. In November 2015, Katko voted for
to block a vote “on the House Democrats’ tough alternative refugee legislation, the Secure Refugee
Process Act.” The Secure Refugee Process Act would have required the Secretary of Homeland Security
and five federal agencies to verify the identity of all refugee applicants and would have required the
Secretary of Homeland Security to certify that all relevant Federal immigration laws had been complied
with. The Previous Question passed in the House, 243 - 182. [H Res 531, Vote #638, 11/19/15; Previous
Question, 11/19/15; Democratic Staff Of The Committee On Homeland Security Press Release, accessed
2/02/16]
Voted Against Removing Requirement For FBI Director – In Addition To DHS Secretary – To
Certify Each Syrian Refugee Is Not A Security Risk From Harsh Refugee Overhaul Bill
Voted Against Removing Requirement For FBI Director – In Addition To DHS Secretary – To
Certify Each Syrian Refugee Is Not A Security Risk From Harsh Refugee Overhaul Bill. In
November 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit the American SAFE Act to the Committee on
the Judiciary with instructions to report back to the House with an amendment that would “require the
secretary of Homeland Security to verify the identities and biographic information of Iraqi and Syrian
refugees and certify that the individual is not a threat to the security of the United States, but would not
require that the director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the director of National Intelligence
conduct background checks or concur in this certification.” The motion was rejected by a vote of 180-244.
[H R 4038, Vote #642, 11/19/15; CQ Floor Votes, 11/19/15]
Voted For Increasing Visa Requirements On Individuals From Syria, Iran, Sudan, And Iraq
Voted For Increasing Visa Requirements On Individuals From Syria, Iran, Sudan, And Iraq. In
December 2015, Katko voted for to “suspend the rules and pass the bill that would prohibit individuals
who have been to specified nations, including Syria, Iran, Sudan, and Iraq, from entering the United
States unless they were interviewed by U.S. officials and obtained a regular visa, even if the individuals
arrived from countries that participate in the Visa Waiver Program. The bill would also update
requirements for countries to participate in the Visa Waiver Program; would require fraud-resistant
electronic passports, biographic and biometric information; and would require participation in the
program's electronic collection of information on all additional countries where an applicant has or had
citizenship.” The bill passed 407-19. [HR 22, Vote #679, 12/8/15; CQ Floor Votes, 12/8/15]
The New Restrictions Would Deny Individuals Who Qualify For Visa-Free Entry If They Have
Visited Iraq, Syria, And Other Terror Hotspot Countries. “Under the legislation, citizens from
countries that qualify for the program would be denied visa-free entry to the U.S. if they have visited
Iraq, Syria or other countries deemed to be terror hotspots in the last five years, or if they are citizens
of those countries. Those individuals would instead have to pass through a more stringent security
process.” [The Hill, 12/8/15]
257
House Administration
 Voted for John Boehner for Speaker; Democrats criticized him for supporting
Speaker Ryan
 Voted to freeze congressional pay
Katko voted for Boehner for speaker. And Katko voted to freeze congressional pay.
Voted For Limiting Power Of OCE And House Ethics In Investigating Members
Voted For Limiting Power Of OCE And House Ethics In Investigating Members. In January 2015,
Katko voted for a House Rules package that contained a rules change that would help members under
ethics investigations by the Office of Congressional Ethics and House Ethics Committee. “In one of its
first actions of the new year, the House of Representatives on Tuesday approved rules changes that could
give lawmakers a new defense against ethics investigations. The new language, added Monday night to
the sections that establish the House Ethics Committee and the independent Office of Congressional
Ethics, says the two bodies ‘may not take any action that would deny any person any right or protection
provided under the Constitution of the United States.’ The language also states that a person subject to a
review by the Office of Congressional Ethics ‘shall be informed of the right to be represented by counsel
and invoking that right should not be held negatively against them.’ … ‘Clearly (the new language) was
put in there to allow members of Congress to restrain certain activities of the ethics committees based on
their own interpretation of what the Constitution means,’ said Craig Holman of the watchdog group
Public Citizen.” The resolution passed, 234-172. [H Res 5, Vote #6, 1/06/15; USA Today, 1/06/15]
Voted For John Boehner For Speaker Of The House; Was Criticized For Supporting Speaker Ryan
Voted To Make John Boehner Speaker Of The House. In January 2015, Katko for John Boehner to be
Speaker of the House. John Boehner received 216 votes, and Nancy Pelosi received 164 votes. [Election
to the Speaker, Vote #2, 1/06/15]
Criticized By Democrats For Supporting Ryan For Speaker. “When U.S. Rep. John Katko voted for
new House Speaker Paul Ryan, it put an end to what he de-scribed as a ‘chaotic’ situation. It also gave
Democrats seeking to unseat Katko, R-Camillus, ammunition to attack the incumbent in the 24th
Congressional District race.” [The Citizen, 11/01/15]
Voted For Ryan For Speaker Of The House
258
Voted To Make Rep. Ryan Speaker Of The House. In October 2015, Katko for Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI)
to be Speaker of the House. Paul Ryan received 236 votes, Nancy Pelosi received 184 votes, and Daniel
Webster received 9 votes. [Election to the Speaker, Vote #581, 10/29/15]
Said He Wasn’t Letting The “Chaos” Of The GOP Leadership Scramble Affect His Work;
Downplayed The Chaos
Said He Wasn’t Letting The “Chaos” Of The GOP Leadership Scramble Affect His Work. “‘Now
you’re hearing all these different names, all these different scenarios,’ Katko said by phone. ‘Everyone is
kind of waiting to see if Paul Ryan is going to jump in the race. So, it’s kind of chaotic.’ For now, Katko
said he’s not letting that chaos affect his work. And he doesn’t believe it’s impacting the House’s agenda.
Votes are being held as planned. On Thursday, the same day of McCarthy’s announcement, Katko held
his seventh hearing as chairman of the House Homeland Security Subcommittee on Transpor-tation
Security. The following day, he announced he’s supporting a bill to prevent future government
shutdowns. Katko acknowledged it can be challenging to get things done in the current environment, but
he feels members are doing a good job of balancing their work with the House leadership discussions.”
Katko Downplayed The Republican Caucus’ Leadership Turnover As “Inside Baseball.” “Katko
said it was ironic that the House Freedom Caucus, as a result of its pressure on McCarthy, ended up
prolonging how long Boehner will stay on the job as speaker. ‘So they succeeded at nothing,’ Katko said.
Katko declined to say whether he would have supported McCarthy for the speaker's job, or who he will
back now that McCarthy has withdrawn. ‘This is all inside baseball in Washington,’ Katko said. ‘We still
have a leader. I want to worry about governing and let this sort itself out.’” [Post Standard, 10/08/15]
Said The Freedom Caucus “Succeeded At Nothing” By Pressuring McCarthy
Said The Freedom Caucus “Succeeded At Nothing” By Pressuring McCarthy. “U.S. Rep. John
Katko, R-Camillus, said McCarthy’s announcement in a private meeting of House Republicans was as
unexpected as House Speaker John Boehner’s decision last month to step down at the end of October. ‘It
was almost like Groundhog’s Day,’ Katko said in an interview after the GOP meeting at the Capitol.
‘With Boehner, it went from sublime to surreal in a flash of a second. And the same thing happened
today.’ … Katko said it was ironic that the House Freedom Caucus, as a result of its pressure on
McCarthy, ended up prolonging how long Boehner will stay on the job as speaker. ‘So they succeeded at
nothing,’ Katko said.” [Post Standard, 10/09/15]
Sponsored A Bill To Prevent Congress From Taking Recess Until It Passed A Budget Funding The
Government; Said “As Lawmakers, We Have A Duty To Ensure That The Government Is Funded
And Continues To Run”
Sponsored A Bill To Prevent Congress From Taking Recess Until Congress Passed A Bill Funding
The Government. “U.S. Rep. John Katko emerged Friday as the lead Republican sponsor of a bill that
could force members of Congress to stay on the job in order to avert a government shutdown. … If
Congress comes within 24 hours of allowing a shutdown, any member of Congress would be allowed to
offer a simple 30-day short-term funding bill, with no amendments allowed, according to their House
resolution. The measure also would prevent members of Congress from taking a recess during the ensuing
259
30-day period, and would cut government travel funds that House members used to travel back home. The
restrictions would stay in effect until Congress passed a bill funding the federal government for the
remainder of the fiscal year.” [Post Standard, 10/11/15]
Said It Was OK To Debate, But “As Lawmakers, We Have A Duty To Ensure That The
Government Is Funded And Continues To Run.” “Katko, R-Camillus, has signed on as the lead
Republican cosponsor of legislation that aims to prevent future government shutdowns. … ‘It is OK to
have a debate, but as lawmakers, we have a duty to ensure that the government is funded and continues to
run,’ Katko said. ‘That’s why I’ve introduced bipartisan legislation this week which would move us away
from governing from crisis to crisis.’” [The Citizen, 10/09/15]
Voted For Blocking Requirement That Legislative Text Be Posted In Accordance With House Rules
Voted For Blocking Requirement That Text Legislative Text Be Posted In Accordance With House
Rules. In January 2015, Katko voted for blocking requirement that legislative text be posted in
accordance with House rules. “House Rules require a bill to be posted for 3 days so it can be read before it
comes to the floor, and the Republican Leadership has made this particular rule sacrosanct above all
others. However, on HR 7 the Republican Leadership filed the bill late on the night before the vote the
following morning, in direct violation of this Rule and their principles. The Democratic Previous
Question would eliminate the waiver of this very important Rule that provides transparency for both the
public and Members who must vote on legislation.” The previous question carried, 239-183. A vote
against ordering the previous question would have eliminated the waiver of the House rule. [H Res 42,
Vote #42, 1/22/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 1/21/15]
Voted For FY16 Legislative Branch Budget With Congressional Pay Freeze
Voted For FY2016 Legislative Branch Budget That Extended Congressional Pay Freeze. In May
2015, Katko voted for the bill that would provide $3.3 billion for legislative branch operations, excluding
Senate operations, in fiscal 2016. “[The] annual legislative branch spending bill … [included] language
extending the congressional salary freeze for a seventh consecutive year.” The bill was passed by a vote
of 357-67. [HR 2250, Vote # 247, 5/19/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/19/15; Roll Call, 5/20/15]
Voted For Amendment To Cut Legislative Branch Budget By 1 Percent. In May 2015, Katko voted
for the Blackburn, R-Tenn., amendment that would cut funding under the bill by one percent for all
accounts except for the Capitol Police, the Sergeant at Arms, and the Architect of the Capitol's Capitol
Police buildings, grounds and security account. The amendment was rejected by a vote of 172-250. [HR
2250, Vote # 246, 5/19/15; CQ Floor Votes, 5/19/15]
Voted For Amendment To Block Funding For Exchange Program To Promote American-Style
Democracy In Post-Soviet Countries. In May 2015, Katko voted for the Ratcliffe, R-Texas, amendment
that would “block funding for the Open World Leadership Center, a program begun in 1999 and intended
to educate politicians from the former Soviet Union about democracy in the U.S.” The amendment was
adopted by a vote of 224-199. [HR 2250, Vote # 245, 5/19/15; Albany Herald, 5/19/15]
Voted For Delaying A Resolution That Would Require Removal Of All Confederate Symbols From
The House
260
Voted For Delaying A Resolution That Would Require Removal Of All Confederate Symbols From
The House. In June 2015, Katko voted for delaying a “privileged resolution that would require the
Speaker of the House to remove all symbols of the Confederacy from the House wing of U.S. Capitol and
donate such symbols to the Library of Congress.” The motion passed 240-184 [HR 341, Vote #385,
6/25/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/25/15]
The Hill: House Delays Floor Vote On Removing Confederate Symbol From Capitol. “The
House referred a resolution on Thursday that would remove symbols of the Confederacy from the
Capitol and adjacent office buildings to the committee level for possible later consideration. …
[Democratic Rep. Bennie] Thompson’s resolution is privileged, which forces the House to expedite its
consideration. The House vote on Thursday of 240-184 sends his resolution to the House
Administration Committee for further review, instead of immediately voting on the measure.
Democrats uniformly opposed the move to delay consideration, while all but one Republican voted in
favor. [The Hill, 6/25/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Removing Any State Flag Containing The Confederate Battle
Flag From US Capitol Grounds
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Removing Any State Flag Containing The Confederate Battle
Flag From US Capitol Grounds. In July 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of a vote to “call
for an immediate vote on Leader Pelosi’s privileged resolution to remove any state flag containing the
Confederate Battle flag from the U.S. Capitol grounds.” The previous question carried, 238-185. The
previous question passed, 238 to 185. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to
be considered. [H RES 355, Vote #425, 7/09/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 7/09/15]
Voted For Referring A Motion To Remove Any State Flag Containing The Confederate Battle Flag
From US Capitol Grounds To The House Administration Committee
Voted For Referring A Motion To Remove Any State Flag Containing The Confederate Battle Flag
From US Capitol Grounds To The House Administration Committee. In July 2015, Katko voted for a
motion to refer a privileged resolution to “remove any state flag containing the Confederate Battle flag images of hate and division in our nation's history that deserve to be stored in a museum and not displayed
in a place of honor in the United States Capitol” to the House Administration Committee. The motion
passed, 238 to 176. [H RES 355, Vote #426, 7/09/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/09/15; Democratic Leader –
Previous Questions, 7/09/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration On An Immediate Vote For A Resolution To Remove Any State
Flag Containing The Confederate Battle Flag From The U.S. Capitol Grounds
Voted For Blocking Consideration On An Immediate Vote For A Resolution To Remove Any State
Flag Containing The Confederate Battle Flag From The U.S. Capitol Grounds. In July 2015, Katko
voted for blocking consideration “for an immediate vote on Leader Pelosi’s privileged resolution to
remove any state flag containing the Confederate Battle flag from the U.S. Capitol grounds.” A vote
against the previous question was to force the vote on removing state flags containing the Confederate
261
battle flag from the U.S. Capitol grounds. The motion to order the previous question passed, 242 to 185.
[H Res 350, Vote #429, 7/09/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 7/09/15]
262
Immigration and Border Issues
 Said all undocumented immigrants are “criminals,” blamed an increase on crime
on inaction on securing the border
 Said the weakest point of the immigration system was a law intended to reduce
human trafficking by allowing unaccompanied minors to have deportation
hearings; proposed repealing the law
 Opposed the bipartisan 2013 immigration reform bill; opposed any pathway to
citizenship
Katko said all undocumented immigrants were “criminals.” Katko blamed an
increase in violent crime, in part, on lack of action on immigration.
Said the weakest point of the immigration system was a law intended to reduce
human trafficking by allowing unaccompanied minors to have deportation
hearings; proposed repealing the law.
Katko opposed the bipartisan 2013 immigration reform bill because he opposes a
pathway to citizenship.
Said All Undocumented Immigrants Were “Criminals,” Said An Increase In Violent Crime Was
Due To Inaction On Immigration And Softening Drug Crime Penalties
Said All Undocumented Immigrants Were “Criminals.” “As far as the other issues, it’s a sticky issue immigration reform. People that are involved in crimes, sorry, there is no path to citizenship for them in
my mind. We have to deal with the reality that the people that are here are here illegally. They’re here
breaking the law. They’re criminals. By design, our laws say they’re criminals. We can’t just look away
from that. But we’ve also got to realize that the reality is 11 million people you’re not going to put on
buses and ship out of the country. It’s going to be hard to do that.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Blamed An Increase In Violent Crime On Softening Mandatory Minimums In Drug Crimes And
Inaction On Immigration. “KATKO: I have a huge background in law enforcement. But the big thing
that is kind of a secret that really hasn’t been made public yet is that under the Obama administration,
after 20 years of steady decline in violent crime rates, they’re going back up. I think there’s a direct
correlation between that and their softening of some of the mandatory minimums in drug crimes and also
some of the things they are doing - or not doing - with respect to immigration and other things.”
263
Advocated Deporting Unemployed Undocumented Immigrants
Advocated Deporting Unemployed Undocumented Immigrants. “KATKO: … Number three, those
individuals that are not leading productive lives here, that aren’t employed, I don’t think they have a right
to stay here.” [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/14]
Said The Weakest Point In The Immigration System Was Unaccompanied Minors Were Allowed
Deportation Hearings To Reduce Human Trafficking, Suggested Repealing The Law To Deport
Children Faster
Said The Weakest Point In The American Immigration System Was That Unaccompanied Minors
Were Allowed To Have Deportation Hearings To Cut Down On Human Trafficking. “But now,
Katko said, smugglers target the weakest point in a U.S. immigration system that allows unaccompanied
mi-nors from Central America to have deportation hearings under a law aimed at cutting down on human
trafficking. ‘They are simply trying to take advantage of us and our generosity as a country,’ Katko said.
‘If we had more secure borders, we wouldn’t be having this problem.’” [Post Standard, 7/10/14]
Suggested Deporting Children From Non-Contiguous Countries Home Faster. “Katko, 51, of
Camillus, is the Republican candidate for the 24th Congressional District. He is seeking to unseat Rep.
Dan Maffei, 46, a Syracuse Democrat. In discussing other issues with the editorial board: … He also said
one solution is to change the law to be able to ship children from non-contiguous countries home right
away.” [Post Standard, 9/11/14]
Opposed Housing Immigrant Children Awaiting Deportation In Syracuse
Opposed Housing Immigrant Children Awaiting Deportation In Syracuse. “But his Republican
opponent, John Katko, says the growing crisis on the southwest border is the result of President Barack
Obama’s ‘failed immigration policy’ and that shipping children to Syracuse is not one of the solutions.
Katko, a former federal prosecutor from Camillus, said the proposal could be a ‘logistical nightmare.’ He
said those awaiting deportation should not be moved around the United States, and instead the Obama
administration needs to focus on securing the southwest border. ‘I think we need to take a step back to see
how this happened,’ said Katko, who served as a special prosecutor for the Justice Department in El Paso,
Texas, in 1995 and 1996, assigned to a secure border initiative. When you have robust enforcement at the
border, the smugglers take note,’ Katko said. ‘When people were caught (in the 1990s) they were
immediately sent back.’” [Post Standard, 7/10/14]
Katko Said He “Wasn’t Sure” If Boehner Should Have Allowed a Vote on Immigration Reform
In July 2014, when asked by TWC News’ Liz Benjamin on “Capital Tonight” whether he thought
Speaker Boehner should have allowed a vote on immigration reform, Katko said “I’m not sure a vote is
the right term to use…” [TWC News “Capital Tonight”, 7/3/14]
Katko Opposed Comprehensive Immigration Reform
In April 2014, New York conservative blogger Lonely Conservative wrote that Katko does not support
comprehensive immigration reform.
264
“I spoke to Mr. Katko a few months ago and asked him about immigration reform. He said (I’m
paraphrasing) ‘We shouldn’t reward people who break the law,’” he wrote. [Lonely Conservative,
4/19/14]
Called For Action On Immigration, Opposed A Path To Citizenship
Called For Action On Immigration, Suggested He Opposed A Path To Citizenship, But Would
Potentially Support “Some Sort Of Resident Status.” “John Katko (JK): … If you look at immigration
itself from a policy standpoint, we have to do something. There are multiple layers. Seasonal labor help we’ve got to streamline the process so you can get in and out of here quickly. People that are in the United
States illegally, are committing crimes, are not leading productive lives - I don’t think there is a place for
them here; they should be deported. The millions of American’s who are here illegally, but are otherwise
leading productive lives - we can’t ship them out of here, but just giving them a blank amnesty like he did
is probably not a good idea. I think maybe giving them some sort of resident status, I’d be happy to talk
about that. I just don’t know if you reward them with a path to citizenship when they are here illegally.”
[Interview, Syracuse New Times, 1/07/15]
Opposed A Path To Citizenship. “Here’s a look at where U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei and challenger John
Katko stand on some of the issues in their campaign for the 24th Congressional District seat. Compiled by
Washington correspondent Mark Weiner. JOHN KATKO … Opposes a bipartisan immigration reform
bill that passed the U.S. Senate by a 68-32 vote in June 2013. Disagrees with provision to provide a path
to citizenship for the 11 million immigrants in the United States without legal status, but does not want to
deport law-abiding, productive workers.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Said He Opposed The Bipartisan Immigration Reform Bill Due To The Pathway To Citizenship.
“Katko said he would support a bipartisan immigration reform bill in Congress, but not the one passed by
the U.S. Senate by a 68-32 vote in June 2013. He disagrees with the bill’s provision to provide a path to
citizenship for 11 million immigrants in the U.S. without legal status.” [Post Standard, 7/10/14]
Advocated Waiting Until The Borders Were Truly Secured To Reform Immigration
Advocated Waiting Until The Borders Were Truly Secured To Reform Immigration. “Once you
have border security and true border security, then you implement the reforms. The reforms have to take
into mind the agricultural issues. There’s got to be a better way for individuals who want to come in here,
work hard and then go back to their countries during farming seasons to take advantage of the labor here.
There’s got to be a way to do that for our farmers. And farmers have to stop being policemen and let them
be businessmen again. There’s got to be something about that.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Said Immigration Reform Must Address Seasonal Labor Help For Agriculture
Said Immigration Reform Must Address Seasonal Labor Help For Agriculture. “KATKO: …We
absolutely need comprehensive immigration reform and it's high time that both Democrats and
Republicans get off the sidelines and have the guts to do it. … Number two, it has to take into
consideration seasonal labor help. Streamline the process and make it much less expensive for people to
use seasonal labor help. You can control the seasonal labor help. … The seasonal labor help is so
265
important to agricultural aspects of our district — dairy farmers, apple farmers. It's critically important for
them and their survival.” [The Citizen, 9/30/14]
Said He Helped Clean The Migrant Labor Camps For His Father-In-Law
Said He Helped Clean The Migrant Labor Camps For His Father-In-Law. “Host: What are some of
the things you’re hearing about agriculture? Katko: Well, a lot of it has to do with the labor issues. Its
amazing, with the immigrant labor issues, and that’s one of the things I’m trying hard to work on. My
father-in-law was a lifelong potato farmer in the southern tier. … and so I’ve been going down there, and
I did everything from clean the migrant camps and get them ready to go for the season and everything. So
I really understood the need for good quality seasonal labor.” [Finger Lakes Morning News Interview,
7/31/14]
Said Dairy And Apple Farmers Use Undocumented Immigrants Due To Red Tape
Said Dairy And Apple Farmers Use Undocumented Immigrants For Labor Due To Red Tape,
Advocated Making It Easier. “KATKO: … The seasonal labor help is so important to agricultural
aspects of our district -- dairy farmers, apple farmers. It’s critically important for them and their survival.
They’re at the point now where they just throw up their hands and a lot of them take illegal aliens because
they can’t possibly handle all of the bureaucratic red tape. We need to streamline that process for them
and make it better for them.” [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/14]
Said He Opposed The President’s Actions On Immigration, But Would Vote To Keep DHS Open,
As He Couldn’t See How Defunding DHS Would Enforce Immigration Laws
Said He Opposed The President’s Actions On Immigration, But Would Vote To Keep DHS Open.
“‘We will be voting in support today of legislation to fund DHS for the remainder of Fiscal Year 2015.
While we strongly disagree with the unilateral actions that President Obama has taken, we believe the
courts - not cutting off funding for the entire Department - is the most effective way to stop his actions.
We support the federal lower court decision that put an injunction on the executive actions taken by the
President, and we believe it should be upheld. Furthermore, moving forward, we hope to work in a
bipartisan way to reform our broken immigration system through legislative action. However, DHS is
critical to our national security - ISIS is a real threat to America, and we must provide full funding to keep
New York and our country safe. We urge the rest of our colleagues to join us in supporting legislation to
fund DHS.’” [Joint Press Release, Rep. Katko, 3/03/15]
Questioned How Defunding Homeland Security Would Help Enforce Immigration Laws. “Katko,
who split with his party in January to oppose blocking funding for one of Obama’s immigration executive
orders, added that it’s unclear ‘how defunding the Department of Homeland Security brings us any closer
to enforcing our immigration laws.’” [The Citizen, 2/27/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Homeland Security Bill Without Stopping Immigration
Changes
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Homeland Security Funding Bill Without Language Stopping
Immigration Changes. In January 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of a bill that “would
266
prevent Republicans from endangering national security and fund the Department of Homeland Security
for the rest of the year, bringing forward the bipartisan Homeland Security appropriations bill for a clean
vote without Republicans’ anti-immigrant amendments.” The motion failed 242 to 181. A vote against the
previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 27, Vote #20, 1/13/15; 114th
Previous Questions]
Voted For Restarting Deportations Of Undocumented Families
Voted For Amendment To Defund Immigration Executive Order. On January 14, 2015, Katko voted
for an amendment to defund President Obama’s executive action on immigration. “One of the
amendments would choke off funding for Obama’s executive action announced in November, which
would allow some illegal immigrants to stay in the country and obtain work permits.” The amendment
was adopted 237 to 190. [HR 240, Vote #29, 1/14/15; The Hill, 1/14/15]
Voted Against Restarting Deportations Of DREAMers
Voted Against Amendment To End Deferred Action For Childhood Arrivals. On January 24, 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment to the Department of Homeland Security funding bill that would end a
program to suspend the deportation of DREAMers. “A second amendment would halt the Deferred
Action for Childhood Arrivals Program (DACA), which lifts deportation for some illegal immigrants who
came to the United States as children.” The amendment was adopted 218 to 209. [HR 240, Vote #30,
1/14/15; The Hill 1/14/15]
Voted For Restarting Deportations Of Undocumented Families And DREAMers
Voted For Bill Restarting Deportations Of Undocumented Families And DREAMers. In January
2015, Katko voted for a federal funding bill that defunded President Obama’s executive action on
immigration and ended a program that halted the deportation of some illegal immigrants who came to the
United States as children. “Democrats rallied against the bill, which would fund the Department of
Homeland Security (DHS) through September, after Republicans adopted a series of contentious
amendments that take aim at facets of Obama’s immigration policy. One of the amendments would choke
off funding for Obama’s executive action announced in November, which would allow some illegal
immigrants to stay in the country and obtain work permits. A second amendment would halt the Deferred
Action for Childhood Arrivals Program (DACA), which lifts deportation for some illegal immigrants who
came to the United States as children.” The bill passed 236 to 191. [HR 240, Vote #35, 1/14/15; The Hill,
1/14/15; CQ Floor Votes, 1/14/15]
Voted For Amendment To Defund Immigration Executive Order. In January 2015, Katko voted
for an amendment to defund President Obama’s executive action on immigration. “One of the
amendments would choke off funding for Obama’s executive action announced in November, which
would allow some illegal immigrants to stay in the country and obtain work permits.” The amendment
was adopted 237 to 190. [HR 240, Vote #29, 1/14/15; The Hill, 1/14/15]
Voted Against Amendment To End Deferred Action For Childhood Arrivals. In January 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment to the Department of Homeland Security funding bill that would
end a program to suspend the deportation of DREAMers. “A second amendment would halt the
267
Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program (DACA), which lifts deportation for some illegal
immigrants who came to the United States as children.” The amendment was adopted 218 to 209. [HR
240, Vote #30, 1/14/15; The Hill 1/14/15]
Voted For Amendment To Defund President Obama’s Executive Actions On Immigration. In
January 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Department of Homeland Security funding bill that
would defund President Obama’s executive action on immigration. The amendment further barred
funding for any substantially similar policies issues after January 9, 2015 and declared that such
immigration policies had no statutory or constitutional basis. The amendment was adopted 237 to 190.
[HR 240, Amendment No. 1, Vote #29, 1/14/15]
Voted For Bill Providing More Than $47 Billion For Department Of Homeland Security Funding.
In January 2015, Katko voted for a federal funding bill providing $47.8 billion for Homeland Security in
FY 2015. The bill also included $12.6 billion for Customs and Border Protection, $6.3 billion for
Immigration and Customs Enforcement, $10 billion for the Coast Guard, and $10.8 billion for the Federal
Emergency Management Agency. The bill passed 236 to 191. [HR 240, Vote #35, 1/14/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 1/14/15]
Voted For Anti-Immigrant Amendment Putting Interests Of Legal Aliens Above Undocumented
Immigrants
Voted For Anti-Immigrant Amendment Putting Interests Of Legal Aliens Above Undocumented
Immigrants. In January 2015, Katko voted for an anti-immigrant amendment imploring the Obama
Administration to stop putting the interests of legal aliens behind those who arrived illegally. It also
encouraged the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services to use available funds to improve services and
the benefits application process for legal immigrants. The amendment was adopted 260 to 167. [HR 240,
Amendment No. 5, Vote #33, 1/14/15; CQ Floor Votes, 1/14/15]
Voted For Anti-Immigrant Amendment Discouraging Policies To Promote Hiring Of
Undocumented Immigrants
Voted For Anti-Immigrant Amendment Discouraging Policies To Promote Hiring Of
Undocumented Immigrants. In January 2015, Katko voted for an anti-immigrant amendment imploring
the Obama Administration not to pursue policies making it economically advantageous to hire illegal
immigrants. The amendment was adopted 253-171. [HR 240, Amendment No. 4, Vote #32, 1/14/15; CQ
Voted For Anti-Immigrant Amendment That Would Discourage Victims From Reporting Abuse
Voted For Anti-Immigrant Amendment That Would Discourage Victims From Reporting Abuse. In
January 2015, Katko voted for an anti-immigrant amendment that purports to prioritize immigration
enforcement actions against illegal immigrants convicted of violent or sexually-oriented offenses.
However, the Conference of Catholic Bishops stated that this amendment “would discourage many
[domestic violence] victims from reporting abuse.” The amendment was adopted 278-149. [HR 240,
Amendment No. 3, Vote #31, 1/14/15; Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi, Floor Remarks, 1/14/15; CQ
268
Voted Against Removing Provision Encouraging Defense Department To Allow DREAMers To
Serve In Military
Voted Against Removing Provision Encouraging Defense Department To Allow DREAMers To
Serve In Military. In May 2015, Katko voted against removing an amendment to the Defense
Authorization bill that “would encourage the Pentagon to consider allowing immigrants brought to the
country as children to [serve in the military].” [HR 1735, Vote #229, 5/14/15; NPR, 5/13/15]
Headline: Alabama Media: “Rep. Mo Brooks amendment passes; keeps DREAMers out of
military.” [Alabama Media, 5/14/15]
Voted Against Amendment Blocking Funding For Cities That Neglect To Fully Participate In
Reporting Names To Federal Immigration Officials
Voted Against Amendment Blocking Funding For Cities That Neglect To Fully Participate In
Reporting Names To Federal Immigration Officials. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment
to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act of 2016 blocking funds to
cities “The House also voted 227-198 for an amendment that would block certain federal funds to
localities that refuse to report names to federal immigration authorities. That's become an issue in recent
months as localities refused to participate in a federal program that turns over the names of people picked
up for crimes to federal immigration authorities.” the amendment passed, 227 to 198. [HR 2578,
Amendment #84, Vote# 294, 6/03/15; AP 6/03/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Prevent DOJ From Using Its Funds To Defend President Obama’s
Executive Orders On Immigration In Pending Legal Battle
Voted Against Amendment To Prevent DOJ From Using Its Funds To Defend President Obama’s
Executive Orders On Immigration In Pending Legal Battle. In June 2015, Katko voted against and
amendment preventing the Department of Justice from using its funds to defend President Obama’s
executive orders on immigration in a pending legal battle. “House Republicans just went after President
Barack Obama’s executive actions on immigration – again. The GOP-led chamber voted Wednesday to
block the Justice Department from being able to defend itself in a legal battle that has put Obama’s
sweeping and controversial immigration actions on hold. The measure, written by conservative
immigration firebrand Rep. Steve King of Iowa, was an amendment to the overall funding bill for DOJ.
As he spoke about his measure, King noted that the House has voted multiple times to restrain Obama’s
legal authority on immigration and dismissed the actions as ‘unconstitutional executive amnesty.’
Obama’s directive was the epicenter of a battle over Homeland Security, pushing the department’s
funding to the brink before Republicans capitulated on their demands to defund Obama’s actions.” The
amendment passed 222 to 204. [HR 2578, Vote #293, 6/03/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15;
Politico, 6/03/15]
Voted For Withholding Federal Law Enforcement Grant Funding From State And Local
Governments That Do Not Comply With Federal Immigration Laws
269
Voted For Withholding Federal Law Enforcement Grant Funding From State And Local
Governments That Do Not Comply With Federal Immigration Laws. In July 2015, Katko voted for a
bill that would “withhold certain federal law enforcement grants to state and local governments that bar
their officials from taking certain immigration-related actions, such as gathering or maintaining
information on the immigration or citizenship status of individuals or sharing such information with
federal immigration authorities.” The bill passed 241-179. [HR 3009, Vote #466, 7/23/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 7/23/15]
Headline: The Hill: “Democrats slam sanctuary city legislation, labeling it ‘The Donald Trump
Act.’” [The Hill, 7/22/15]
Headline: Politico: “GOP picks a fight over immigration.” [Politico, 7/23/15]
Northern Border
Introduced A Bill On Canadian Border Security, Called A Reservation A Smuggling Route And
Was Met With Hostility From The Mohawks
Introduced A Bill On Canadian Border Security. “Rep. John Katko (NY-24) today announced his
introduction of bipartisan legislation to ensure adequate safeguards are put in place to secure the northern
border. The bill (H.R. 455) would require the Department of Homeland Security to conduct a northern
border threat analysis.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 1/22/15]
Introduced A Bill For A Security Study Of The US’ Norther Border, Calling Akwesasne Territory
A Prime Smuggling Route. “Rep. John M. Katko, a first-term Republican congressman from Syracuse,
who in January introduced a bill that calls for a security study of the United States’s northern border, has
referred to the Akwesasne territory as a ‘prime smuggling route’ and said his colleagues are concerned
about terrorists making their way over the border through the territory.” [Malone Telegram, 3/16/15]
The Mohawks Decried Katko’s Bill, Saying It Reflected Katko’s Misunderstanding. “The
Mohawks dispute this characterization of their territory and say they have made great strides
toward securing the border. For them, it is the element of local control that is so important. They
live and work and return to the territory from lives and livelihoods lived in cities and regions
across the U.S. They return to Akwesasne because it is home and they protect it because it is
home, according to tribal leaders. … Katko’s proposed legislation was met with a sharp response
from the tribal councils that govern both the Canadian and American sides of the territory. The
Mohawk Council of Akwesasne, which governs the Canadian side, released a statement
responding to the bill, saying that it already has been working with the Canadian and U.S.
governments to ensure security at the border. ‘Mr. Katko’s bill is reflective of his lack of true
understanding of the Canadian-U.S. border and the amount of border security work that has
already transpired and continues to be conducted on a daily basis with all major parties involved,’
the statement read, in part.” [Malone Telegram, 3/16/15]
Passed A Bill Through The House Requiring Study Of The Norther Border, Was Mocked By The
Canadian National Post Over The Bill
270
Passed A Bill Through The House Requiring Study Of The Northern Border. “The House of
Representatives on Wednesday unanimously approved Rep. John Katko’s bill aimed at beefing up
security along the U.S. border with Canada. Katko’s Northern Border Security Review Act requires the
Department of Homeland Security to conduct a new threat analysis along the border with Canada,
examining potential threats from ter-rorism and criminal activity.” [Post Standard, 11/01/15]
Canadian National Post Compared Katko’s Bill To Study Security On The Canadian Border To
Gov. Walker’s “Plan To Put A Wall On The Canadian Border” In An Article Mocking Both.
“Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker was ridiculed for rolling out a plan to put a wall on the Canadian border.
But less than two months later, the U.S. Congress has passed a new act designed to stop terrorists and
criminals from slipping over from the Great White North. ‘I’ve seen first-hand the issues that our nation
faces countering violent drug trafficking, organized crime and potential terrorist acts,’ said the bill’s
sponsor, John Katko, a Republican Congressman from New York. … Katko, whose congressional district
borders Canada, was elected last year in part on a promise to beef up security on what the United States
officially refers to as its ‘Northern Border.’ ‘It is one of the least recognized threats to our national
security ... it is scary,’ he said in an October 2014 debate. … A wall, if built, would certainly be a
mammoth undertaking: 54 times longer than the Berlin Wall, 62 times longer than Hadrian’s Wall and 34
times longer than the militarized border between North and South Korea. But, notably, it would only be
one-third as long as the total measured length of the Great Wall of China.” [National Post, 10/30/15]
271
Labor and Working Families
 Opposed the effort to raise the minimum wage to $10.10, and to $15, proposed
incremental increases in the minimum wage to an unspecified rate
 Touted the endorsement of his cousin, the former president of a Teamsters local,
which no longer existed
 Voted to block NLRB Rules on Union Elections
 Said he wanted to fight poverty and suggested generic Republican growth policies
to do so, compared his Washington, DC internship to poverty.
 Had an affinity for government-based jobs programs, including lauding a navy
contract benefiting a factory in the district, the possibility of increased UAV
training benefiting a base in his district, and the US Army Corps of Engineers
dredging the port of Oswego
Katko opposed raising the minimum wage to $10.10, opposed raising it to $15,
supported incremental increases in the minimum wage to an unspecified level.
Touted the endorsement of his cousin, a former president of a now-non-existent
Teamster’s Local as a labor endorsement. The endorsement was decried as a sham
by the Teamsters.
In Congress, Katko voted to block the implementation NLRB rules on union
elections.
Katko said he wanted to fight poverty and advocated reducing regulations, tax
reform, and healthcare reform to do so. He also compared his DC internship to
poverty noting, “That semester in Washington, I got a little taste of what poverty
was like, and it’s not pretty.”
Katko lauded a Navy contract benefiting a Lockheed factory in Salina. Katko has
accepted $8,000 from Lockheed Martin in 2015.
Opposed Raising the Minimum Wage, But Supported Incremental Increases To An Unspecified
Level
272
In a July 2014 interview, Katko told the Post-Standard that he opposed President Obama’s proposal to
raise the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 per hour.
“Those are the people who are trying to get off public assistance and get into the workforce,” Katko said,
referring to a CBO report which found that a higher minimum wage could result in the loss of 500,000
jobs. “I would rather give individuals in that tax bracket a tax incentive to work (such as a tax rebate).”
[Post-Standard, 7/21/14] it part of the bullet, or functional like a
Opposed Increasing The Minimum Wage To $10.10 Per Hour, Supported Incremental Increases In
The Minimum Wage. “Here’s a look at where U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei and challenger John Katko stand on
some of the issues in their campaign for the 24th Congressional District seat. Compiled by Washington
correspondent Mark Weiner. JOHN KATKO … MINIMUM WAGE Opposes President Barack Obama’s
proposal to raise the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 per hour. Supports unspecified
incremental increases over time.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Opposed Raising The Minimum Wage To Fifteen Dollars Per Hour. “Katko Opposes $15 Wage …
Congressman John Katko is weighing in on the fight to raise the minimum wage in NY State. The
governor has been pushing for the minimum wage to reach $15 an hour, but critics say it will cost hours
and jobs for workers at small businesses. Congressman Katko warns of the same thing.” [WSYR,
3/10/16]
Katko Opposed the Paycheck Fairness Act
In July 2014, the Post-Standard reported “Katko opposes the Paycheck Fairness Act, a bill in Congress
that that would require employers to demonstrate that wage differences among employees are based on
factors other than gender.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Proposed “Parental Savings Accounts” As An “Alternative” To Parental Leave Proposals
Opposed “A Current Proposal” For Family Leave As A Tax. “A current proposal on the federal level
would implement new taxes and regulations on working families and small businesses to fund a
government-run, one-size-fits-all paid leave program. Nearly every American, regardless of their income
or need for family leave, would see an additional tax taken out of their paycheck to form another
government trust fund. This misguided proposal even taxes the working poor struggling with every-day
expenses. It taxes Americans who are nearing retirement and have already raised their families. Every
business, large and small, would be subject to a new payroll tax. This plan is an empty promise. It taxes
the very families it claims to help and is fiscally unsustainable.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post
Standard, 4/18/16]
Said He Proposed “Parental Savings Account[s]” As A “Flexible” Plan. “In Congress, I've introduced
bipartisan legislation to provide a compromise that both sides can get behind. The plan, which is entirely
optional, allows men and women to create a Parental Savings Account. Just like a health savings account,
Americans can choose to affordably contribute money, tax-free, to support their family during the first
year of parenthood. Funds can be withdrawn and spent on childcare, doctor's visits, diapers or simply to
pay the rent or mortgage. It covers more than just the 12 weeks of leave provided under federal law and
helps to ease the financial burden during the first year of parenthood. Americans who choose to
273
participate, but do not end up starting a family, are able to roll unused funds into a retirement account or
college savings plan.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post Standard, 4/18/16]
Suggested An Example Of An Individual Saving 5.475% Of Their Income For Parental Leave
Seemingly Intending It To Seem Positive. “My proposal is personalized and flexible to meet the
financial needs of all working parents. For example, if an individual who earns just $20,000 per year
chose to contribute $3 per day for just over one year, that person would save more than enough for 13
weeks of paid maternity or paternity leave.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post Standard, 4/18/16]
Said Business Were “Given The Option Of Contributing Into Parental Savings Accounts To Help
Support Their Employees.” “Under my plan, small businesses are given the option of contributing into
parental savings accounts to help support their employees. One Central New York mother and business
owner recounted her experience of raising three young children while simultaneously running her family's
24/7 business. She shared her difficult decision to leave her children at home after only a few weeks and
how she has seen many of her employees do the same. As a small business owner, she is unable to
provide her staff with paid family leave, but she, and several other local business owners, fully supports
an option to provide employees with a tool for saving.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post Standard,
4/18/16]
Said, “We Will Not Strengthen Families, Or Our Economy By Increasing Taxes.” “We will not
strengthen families, or our economy, by increasing taxes on hardworking Central New Yorkers and local
small businesses. My plan supports families by providing a flexible, individualized, affordable vehicle for
savings without placing a burden on businesses.” [Rep. Katko Op-Ed, Syracuse Post Standard, 4/18/16]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Paid Sick Leave Proposal
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Allowing Workers In Businesses With 15 Or More
Employees To Accrue Up To Seven Sick Days A Year. In October 2015, Katko voted for consideration
of H. Res. 491, an ordering of the previous question on HR 1090 to call for an immediate vote on the
Healthy Families Act. “The Democratic Previous Question on the Rule providing for the consideration of
H.R. 1090, So-Called ‘Retail Investor Protection Act,’ would call for an immediate vote on the Healthy
Families Act, which would allow workers in businesses with 15 or more employees to earn up to seven
job-protected sick days each year.” The previous question carried 242 to 185. [H.Res.491, Vote #570,
10/27/15; Democratic Previous Question, HR 1090, 10/27/15]
Huffington Post: Healthy Families Act “Would Allow Workers At Larger Employers To Accrue
Up To Seven Sick Days Per Years.” “To address the private sector, Obama will begin stumping for
the Healthy Families Act, a Democratic proposal in Congress that would allow workers at larger
employers to accrue up to seven sick days per year. Such laws tend to draw heavy opposition from
employer lobbies, and the proposal is all but certain to fail while Republicans control both the House
and Senate.” [Huffington Post, 1/14/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Prevent Funds From The FAST Act From Being Used To
Enforce Prevailing Wage Requirements For Public Transportation Projects
274
Voted Against An Amendment To Prevent Funds From The FAST Act From Being Used To
Enforce Prevailing Wage Requirements For Public Transportation Projects. In November 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment to prevent funds from the FAST Act from being used to enforce of
prevailing wage requirements in each state for public transportation projects. The amendment would have
required “that none of the funds made available by this Act may be used to implement, administer, or
enforce the prevailing rate wage requirements of the Davis-Bacon Act.” The amendment failed 188 to
Amendment Would Have Cut Off Federal Grant Funding To Implement, Administer Or
Enforce Prevailing Wage Requirements. “Republicans and Democrats also sparred over an
amendment sponsored by several Republicans including Rep. Steve King of Iowa, that would have
cut off federal grant funding to implement, administer or enforce the prevailing wage requirements
of the Davis-Bacon Act. His amendment was rejected 188-238.” [Congressional Quarterly News,
11/5/15]
Endorsed By A Former Teamsters Local President, Who Was Katko’s Cousin, The Teamsters
Decried The Endorsement As A Sham
Announced The Endorsement Of A Longtime Friend And Former President Of A Now-Nonexistent
Union Local. “Katko, R-Camillus, announced at a press conference held at his campaign office in
Syracuse that he has been endorsed by Timothy Hogan, former president of the International Brotherhood
of Teamsters Local 182. But Local 182 no longer exists. The union merged this year with Albany-based
Teamsters Local 294. … Despite the status of Local 182, Hogan said he first endorsed Katko, a longtime
friend, in April -- prior to the Local 182-Local 294 merger.” [The Citizen, 8/07/14]
Hogan Is Katko’s Cousin. “Hogan, in an interview Wednesday, at first said he was Katko’s cousin,
but later clarified to say only that their relatives are connected. The two grew up together and were
schoolmates who often saw each other at family functions. Katko’s late uncle, John O’Connor, was
married to Hogan’s aunt, Eleanor O’Connor.” [Post Standard, 8/07/14]
Teamsters Local 294 President Said The Local 194 Endorsement Was A Sham, Unofficial
Endorsement. “Teamsters Local 182 of Utica endorsed Katko in April, before it disbanded and merged
May 1 with Local 294 in Alba-ny, according to Erin O’Connor, speaking for the Katko campaign. Central
New York labor leaders and Teamsters officials are calling it a ‘sham endorsement’ because the newly
merged union local endorsed Maffei, the Syracuse Democrat. John Bulgaro, president of Teamsters Local
294, said the 5,200-member local has been unequivocal in its support of Maffei. Bulgaro said that
Timothy Hogan, the former president of the defunct Local 182 from Utica, made what amounts to an
unofficial endorsement of his cousin, Katko.” [Post Standard, 8/07/14]
Voted For Reauthorizing Indian And Native American Housing Programs
Voted For Reauthorizing Indian And Native American Housing Programs. In March 2015, Katko
voted for reauthorizing Indian and Native Hawaiian housing programs. “This bill reauthorizes a number
of Indian and Native Hawaiian housing programs through FY 2019, including the Indian Housing Block
Grant Program (IHBG), which it modifies to provide for multi-year housing plans and to allow tribes to
meet program requirements more efficiently. It also establishes a set-aside for housing for Native
275
American veterans within Veterans Affairs (VA) Department housing programs and creates a
demonstration program to leverage private investment in affordable Indian housing.” The bill passed 297
to 98. [HR 360, Vote #130, 3/23/15; CQ House Action Reports, 3/20/15]
Voted For Amendment That Would Strike Provision Turning Medicare Into Premium Support
System, Would Include Paid Sick Leave Provision
Voted For Amendment That Would Strike Provision Turning Medicare Into Premium Support
System, Would Include Paid Sick Leave Provision. In April 2015, Katko voted for a motion to instruct
that would ask the House agree with the Senate in favoring paid sick leave and preventing Medicare from
becoming a voucher program. “In the House, Van Hollen, who’s running for Senate in the Old Line State,
said he wants the House to vote on at least two things: the right for workers to earn paid sick leave and
another that would bar Medicare from being turned into a voucher program, a GOP aspiration.” The
motion failed 187 to 239. [H. Con Res. 11, Vote #153, 4/14/15; Motion to Instruct Conferees, 4/14/15;
Politico, 4/14/15]
Voted For Blocking Implementation Of Union Election Rules Set By NLRB
Voted For Blocking Implementation Of Union Election Rules Set By NLRB. In March 2015, Katko
voted for blocking new election rules the National Labor Relations Board put in place for union elections.
“The National Labor Relations Board’s new rules governing representation elections went into effect
April 14. The rules block certain litigation ahead of union certification elections, set new timelines for
pre-election and postelection hearings, allow parties to file documents electronically and require
employers to disclose employees’ phone numbers and email addresses to union organizers. The NLRB
and unions say the new rules modernize regulations and delay frivolous lawsuits.” The resolution passed
232 to 186. [S J Res 8, Vote #128, 3/19/15; CQ News, 4/30/15]
President Obama Said He Would Veto Measure. The measure “is highly unlikely to become law,
as the White House has vowed to veto the measure.” [International Business Times, 3/19/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Enforcement Of Prevailing Wage Requirements For VA Construction
Projects
Voted Against Prohibiting Enforcement Of Prevailing Wage Requirements On VA Construction
Projects. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would prohibit using funds for the
enforcement of prevailing wage requirements laid out by the Davis-Bacon Act. The Davis-Bacon Act
requires contracts working on federally funded construction projects to pay workers the prevailing wage
in whichever jurisdiction a construction project is taking place. The amendment failed to pass 186 to 235.
[HR 2029, Vote #191; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Preventing VA Employees From Performing Union Related Activities While At
Work
Voted Against Preventing VA Employees From Performing Union Related Activities While On The
Job. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would prevent VA employees from
performing union related activities while on the job. The amendment’s sponsor, Rep. Jody Hice (GA-10)
276
claimed that the practice known as official time wastes taxpayer dollars and said “The Department of
Veterans Affairs is one of the agencies with the most egregious use of official time. This agency is
singlehandedly responsible for almost one-third of all the reported official time usage in the entire Federal
Government.” The amendment failed to pass 190 to 232. [HR 2029, Vote #190; On Agreeing to the
Amendment, 4/30/15; Congressional Record, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting VA Contracts With Employers Who Have Violated Labor Laws
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Use Of Federal Funds For Contracts With Employers Who
Have Previously Violated The Fair Labor Standards Act. In April 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment that would have prohibited the use of federal funds for contracts with employers who have
previously violated the Fair Labor Standards Act. The amendment failed to pass 186 to 237. [HR 2029,
Vote #189; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Federal Contracts With Employers Who Have Violated Labor Laws
Voted Against Amendment To Prohibit Contracts Be Awarded To Employers That Have
Previously Violated The Fair Labor Standards Act. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment
to the FY16 Transportation-HUD Appropriations bill that would bar funds from being used to enter into a
contact with any individual who has willfully or repeatedly violated the Fair Labor Standards Act. The
amendment was rejected by a vote of 182-243. [HR 2577, Vote #324, 6/09/15; Congressional Record,
6/09/15]
Voted Against Prohibiting Funding Contractors Who Have Violated The Fair Labor Standards Act
Voted Against Prohibiting Funding To Contractors Who Violate The Fair Labor Standards Act. In
June 2015, Katko voted against a prohibition on the “use of funds for contractors that willfully and
repeatedly violate the Fair Labor Standards Act. The prohibition would last for five years.” The
amendment failed, 187-242. [HR 1735, Vote #354; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Said He Wanted To Fight Poverty, Suggested Reducing Regulations, Tax Reform, Healthcare
Reform
Said He Wanted To Fight Poverty, Suggested Regulatory Relief, Tax Reform, Healthcare Reform.
“I have been a member of Congress a little over seven months. Members of both parties spend most of
their time focusing on the middle class - the economic backbone of our country. While I embrace the fight
for the current middle class, I would like to help more Central New York families living in poverty get
there. … In Congress, I am working to make the overarching reforms pivotal to our fight against poverty.
Some federal anti-poverty initiatives have helped - but alongside these services, I’m fighting for progrowth policies to help small businesses and create 21st century manufacturing jobs. We have a lot of
work to do in Washington - regulatory relief, tax reform and health care restructuring included - but we
have taken some key bipartisan steps in my first few months.” [Katko Op-Ed, Post Standard, 7/19/15]
Compared His Washington DC Internship To Poverty
277
Compared His Washington DC Internship To Poverty. “JK: Well, I don’t know if I could call it
poverty, but when I was in college I took an internship in Washington and I lit-erally had no money, and I
remember - I have never told this - but I remember going to blood banks around the city once a weekend
to get $25 for a pint of blood because I needed money to survive. So it would give me a little taste of what
it is like, but I grew up in a happy middle-class family. That semester in Washington, I got a little taste of
what poverty was like, and it’s not pretty.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse New Times, 10/29/14]
Lauded A Navy Contract Benefiting A Lockheed Martin Factory In Salina, Took $8,000 From
Lockheed Martin
Lauded A Navy Contract Benefiting A Factory In Salina. “‘This funding will ensure that the Navy
gets the important, upgraded technology that it needs while maintaining our strong workforce at the
Syracuse Lockheed Martin operation.’ Most of the work associated with the contract will be completed at
the company’s plant in Salina. Katko supported the Navy’s funding request for the second phase of
SEWIP.” [The Citizen, 7/17/15]
Received $8,000 From Lockheed Martin In 2015. FEC data shows that Katko accepted eight
$1,000 donations from Lockheed Martin’s PAC during 2015. [FEC.gov, accessed 10/21/15]
At A Lobbyist’s Behest, Required The DOD To Report On A Shortage Of UAV Pilots In The Hopes
That It Would Create Jobs At Hancock Field
Sponsored Amendment To The NDAA To Require A Report On The Shortage Of Drone Pilots.
“The House passed a $612 billion defense authorization bill Friday that includes an amendment from U.S.
Rep. John Katko to address the military’s shortage of drone pilots. Katko’s amendment to the National
Defense Authorization Act for fiscal 2016 requires the Department of Defense to report to Congress on
how it is addressing the pilot shortage.” [Post Standard, 5/17/15]
Said He Hoped Requiring The Defense Department To Write A Report Would Create Jobs At
Hancock Field. “‘If left unaddressed, the current shortage of pilots will have a significant impact on the
future of our Air Force,’ Katko said Friday. ‘The amendment that I submitted will allow the Department
of Defense to adequately study this growing problem, and help ensure that the critical training and
operational needs of our military are met. It is my hope that this process will result in an increase of jobs
and training at Hancock Field.’” [Post Standard, 5/17/15]
CenterState CEO Lobbied Katko To Propose The NDAA Amendment. “CenterState CEO, an
economic development organization based in Syracuse, said Friday that it had lobbied Katko to
sponsor the amendment.” [Post Standard, 5/17/15]
Announced The Army Corps Of Engineers Would Dredge The Port Of Oswego
Announced The US Army Corps Of Engineers Would Dredge The Port Of Oswego. “U.S.
Congressman John Katko (NY-24) today announced that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers will provide
funding for vital dredging at the Port of Oswego. The recently allocated funds will allow the harbor of the
Port of Oswego to be sufficiently dredged to its functional channel depths.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko,
3/23/15]
278
Army Corps Of Engineers Began Dredging Oswego In 2014. “In 2014, the Army Corps of
Engineers began dredging of the Port of Oswego in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy. The
recently completed dredging brought Oswego Harbor back to pre-storm conditions, removing
large deposits of sediment which had rendered shipping lanes unusable. For the current fiscal year,
$1.285 million dollars has been allotted for further dredging of the Port of Oswego to bring the
harbor to its functional channel depths. Additionally, work to restore the detached Oswego
Breakwater will begin this summer to repair impact from Hurricane Sandy.” [Press Release, Rep.
Katko, 3/23/15]
Met With The Mayor Of Syracuse To Discuss Water Infrastructure
Met With Syracuse Mayor To Discuss Water Infrastructure. “Infrastructure was a hot topic during a
meeting Tuesday between U.S. Rep. John Katko and Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner. Katko, RCamillus, met with Miner in his Washington office and discussed Syracuse ‘s infrastructure needs,
including repairs to the city’s water lines.” [The Citizen, 3/18/15]
Headlined A Tourism Roundtable, Discussed Transportation
Headlined A Tourism Roundtable, Discussed Transportation. “U.S. Rep. John Katko headlined a
travel and tourism roundtable at the War Memorial Arena in Syracuse. Attendees included Syracuse
Crunch owner Howard Dolgon, Cayuga County Office of Tourism Executive Director Meg Vanek and
representatives from Syracuse-area hotels. While the discussion focused on modernizing Syracuse
Hancock International Airport and attracting international tourists to the region, it shifted to the future of
Interstate 81 when Tony Mangano, owner of the Ramada Syracuse hotel, raised the issue in a question to
Katko.” [The Citizen, 5/27/15]
Called For Increasing Vocational Training And Tax Credits To Help Companies Train New Hires
Called For Increasing Vocational Training, And A Tax Credit To Help Companies Train New
Employees. “Katko’s seven-point jobs agenda highlights his support for increased vocational training
programs to help local manu-facturing companies and tax credits to help companies train new
employees.” [The Citizen, 9/24/14]
Criticized Maffei For The Stimulus, Said Little Reached Central New York
Criticized Maffei For The Stimulus, Said Little Reached Central New York. “‘In February 2009,
shortly after taking office the first time, Dan Maffei championed Barack Obama’s $787 billion stimulus
bill to pay for the very kinds of projects he’s now proposing,’ Katko said. ‘Unfortunately, little found its
way back to central New York then, except for billions of dollars in new debt.’” [The Citizen, 6/24/14]
Declared His Intent To Support Fort Ontario And The Safe Haven
Declared His Intent To Support Fort Ontario And The Safe Haven. “Katko’s priorities include: …
Supporting Central New York tourism efforts such as the Harriet Tubman House in Cayuga County as
well as Fort Ontario and the Safe Haven in Oswego County.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 2/17/15]=
279
Voted Against Exempting Rules Resulting In Net Job Creation From Significant Delays
Voted Against Exempting Rules Resulting In Net Job Creation From Significant Delays. In January
2015, Katko voted against an amendment exempting rules resulting in net job creation from the bill’s
burdensome requirements. The amendment failed 247 to 178. [HR 185, Amendment No. 2, Vote #24,
1/13/15; CQ Floor Votes, 1/13/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Career Education In Manufacturing
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Career Education In Manufacturing. In February 2015, Katko
voted for to block consideration of a vote to provide career education in manufacturing to help students
prepare for 21st century manufacturing jobs. The previous question carried, 242-176. A vote against the
previous question was to force the vote on career education in manufacturing. [H Res 70, Vote #54,
280
LGBT Issues
 Said marriage equality was a states’ rights issue
In 2014 Katko said that marriage equality was a states’ rights issue.
Said That Marriage Equality was a States’ Rights Issue
In July 2014, Katko said that the federal government shouldn’t have a say in same-sex marriage: “I think
it’s a state’s rights issue,” Katko said. “I don’t think the federal government has any role in this, other
than ensuring that people are not discriminated against.” [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Voted Against Preventing Discrimination Based On Sexual Orientation Or Gender Identity Among
Federal Contractors
Voted Against Preventing Discrimination Based On Sexual Orientation Or Gender Identity. In
January 2016, Katko voted against a motion that would “exempt from the bill's provisions any rule that
prohibits discrimination by federal contractors or subcontractors on the basis of sex, sexual orientation, or
gender identity.” The motion to recommit failed, 178-239. [HR 1155, Vote #19, 1/07/16; CQ Floor Votes,
1/8/15]
Voted For Weakening LGBT Discrimination Protections In Federal Contracts
Voted For Amendment To Ensure Enforcement Of LGBT Discrimination Protections In Federal
Contracts. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the FY16 Transportation-HUD
Appropriations bill that would bar funds from being used in contravention of an executive order
prohibiting federal contractors from discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity
against their employees or those seeking employment. The amendment was adopted by a vote of 241-184.
[HR 2577, Vote #326, 6/09/15; Congressional Record, 6/09/15]
281
Regulatory Reform
 Voted to rollback the bipartisan Dodd-Frank Wall Street reforms
 Voted to hamstring agencies responsible for consumer protections
Katko voted for a bill to block or delay a number of Dodd-Frank Wall Street
regulations. He voted to delay aspects of Dodd-Frank, including the Volcker rule.
Katko against protecting consumer safety regulations from unnecessary delay. He
also voted for weakening the Consumer Protection Financial Bureau.
Commerce And Consumer Protections
Voted For Bill Regulating Commercial Space Ventures, Exempting Industry From Passenger
Safety Regulations For 10-Years
Voted For Bill Regulating Commercial Space Ventures, Exempting Industry From Passenger
Safety Regulations For 10-Years. In May 2015, Katko voted for the SPACE Act of 2015, a bill to
regulate the commercial space industry. “Led by House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R., Calif.),
senior Republican lawmakers supported the bill to extend and update federal protection for commercial
launches from some potential liability involving property damage or personal injuries and fatalities on the
ground. The legislation, which also effectively bars the Federal Aviation Administration from closely
regulating fledgling space-tourism ventures for up to 10 more years, garnered widespread support from
closely held companies and industry leaders.” The measure passed 284 to 133. [HR 2262, Vote #262,
5/21/15; Wall Street Journal, 5/21/15]
Voted For “Dramatically” Restricting Government’s Ability To Enact New Safety Standards
Voted For “Dramatically” Restricting Government’s Ability to Enact New Safety Standards. In
January 2015, Katko voted for restricting the government’s ability to enact new regulations or safety
standards. “The House passed a measure Tuesday to dramatically restrict the government's ability to enact
any significant new regulations or safety standards, potentially hamstringing the efforts of every federal
agency, from financial regulators to safety watchdogs. …The primary way the bill would work is by
making just about every step an agency takes on a major new rule subject to numerous legal challenges. It
does that by defining major rules as ones that have direct costs of more than $100 million or indirect costs
above $1 billion, or would have significant costs for just about anyone, including government. Then it
requires that for any such rule, agencies must make public their cost-benefit analyses of the new
regulation and choose the cheapest option.” The bill passed 250 to 175. [HR 185, Vote #28, 1/13/15;
Huffington Post, 1/13/15; CQ Floor Votes, 1/13/15]
282
Law Professor: “Irresponsible Reform: The House Favors Extreme Legislation That Would
Delay Public Protections by Ten Years or More.” [Center For Progressive Reform Blog, 1/13/15]
Voted Against Protecting Public Health And Safety Regulations From Significant Delays
Voted Against Protecting Public Health And Safety Regulations From Significant Delays. In January
2015, Katko voted against an amendment exempting public health and safety regulations from the bill’s
burdensome requirements on creating new rules. “The House has rejected an amendment sponsored by
Rep. Gerald E. Connolly, D-Va., to the Regulatory Accountability Act (H.R. 185) … Connolly said the
exemption was needed to ensure that regulations needed to protect food and drug safety and air and water
quality can move forward promptly.” The amendment failed 178 to 248. [HR 185, Amendment No. 4,
Vote #26, 1/13/15; Albany Herald, 1/16/15]
Voted Against Exempting FDA Consumer Protections From Greater Regulatory Review And Legal
Challenges
Voted Against Exempting FDA Consumer Protections From Greater Regulatory Review And Legal
Challenges. In February 2015, Katko voted against Jackson Lee of Texas Part A Amendment No. 6, an
amendment to the Small Business Regulatory Flexibility Improvements Act of 2015 that “sought to
exempt from the bill all regulations issued by the Food and Drug Administration relating to consumer
safety, including those issued pursuant to the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act.” HR 527 was a bill
under which “the SBA would have new authority to ensure agencies comply with the law's regulatory
review requirements, including by getting more directly involved with agency reviews of proposed rules.
It would expand the ability of small businesses and other small entities affected by an agency's regulations
to legally challenge those rules.” The amendment failed 184 to 234. [HR 527, Vote #66, 2/05/15;
Thomas.loc.gov, 2/05/15; CQ News HR 527 Coverage, 2/05/15]
Voted For Mandating Private Sector Input On Federal Agency Rules, Expand Judicial Review,
And Restrict CFPB Funding
Voted For Mandating Private Sector Input On Federal Agency Rules, Expand Judicial Review,
And Restrict CFPB Funding. In February 2015, Katko voted for the Unfunded Mandates Information
and Transparency Act of 2015. “in a new GOP attempt to roll back federal regulations, the House passed
a measure Wednesday aimed at limiting agency rules that impose unfunded mandates. Lawmakers
approved the bill 250-173, after adding a provision that would restrict funding for the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau…The main part of the bill (HR 50) would expand and modify the 1995 Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act (PL 104-4) that requires all federal agencies to consult with the private sector when
developing rules... The measure would extend judicial review of agency rules and permit a court to stay,
enjoin or invalidate a rule if an agency fails to complete the required UMRA analysis or adhere to the
regulatory principles.” The bill passed 250 to 173. [HR 50, Vote #64, 2/04/15; CQ News, 2/04/15]
Coalition For Sensible Safeguards: “The Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency
Act Lets Big Business Write The Rules.” “But the Coalition for Sensible Safeguards (CSS) says the
bill would give businesses special access to regulators and block hypothetical future rules without the
public knowing. ‘The Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency Act lets big business write
283
the rules,’ Katherine McFate, president of the Center for Effective Government and CSS co-chair, said
in a statement. ‘It doesn’t improve or streamline the regulatory process, which is already plagued by
hurdles and delays. This act would make it even more difficult for agencies to implement laws enacted
by Congress.’” [The Hill, 1/30/15]
HR 50 Cut CFPB Funding By $36 Million. “Limits the total budget authority which the Consumer
Financial Protection Bureau may request from the Federal Reserve to $550 million in FY 2016. This
limitation is needed to ensure that the CFPB will comply with the requirements contained elsewhere
within HR 50 without increasing their drawdown of funds from the federal reserve, which would
otherwise add a direct spending cost to the bill. The limitation is set at $36 million below the CBO
baseline projection for CFPB Budget Authority in FY 2016.” [HR 50, Amendment #4, 2/04/15]
Voted Against Exempting From Requirement For Congressional Approval Rules That Would
Increase Jobs
Voted Against Exempting From Requirement For Congressional Approval Rules That Would
Increase Jobs. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that “would exempt rules that the Office
of Management and Budget determined would increase jobs from the congressional approval process
established in the bill.” The amendment failed, 163-246. [HR 427, Vote #475; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
would give Congress the final say over all major regulations. […]The regulatory reform measure
Voted Against Exempting From Requirement For Congressional Approval Rules Governing
Pipelines Carrying Natural Gas and Hazardous Materials
Voted Against Exempting From Requirement For Congressional Approval Rules Governing
Pipelines Carrying Natural Gas and Hazardous Materials. In July 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment that “would exempt rules intended to ensure the safety of natural gas or hazardous materials
pipelines from the Congressional approval process outlined in the bill.” The amendment failed, 166-244.
[HR 427, Vote #476; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
284
Voted Against Exempting Public Health And Safety Regulations From Congressional Approval On
Major Rule Changes
Voted Against Exempting Public Health And Safety Regulations From Congressional Approval On
Major Rule Changes. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that “would exempt rules
pertaining to public health and safety from the Congressional approval process outlined in the bill.” The
amendment failed, 166-242. [HR 427, Vote #477; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
Voted Against Exempting Product Safety Regulations Intended To Protect Children Under Two
From Congressional Approval On Major Rules Changes
Voted Against Exempting Product Safety Regulations Intended To Protect Children Under Two
From Congressional Approval On Major Rules Changes. In July 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment that “would exempt rules pertaining to the safety of any product designed for children under
two from the Congressional approval process outlined in the bill.” The amendment failed, 167-243. [HR
427, Vote #478; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
Voted Against Exempting Safety Regulations For Nuclear Reactors From Congressional Approval
On Major Rule Changes
Voted Against Exempting Safety Regulations For Nuclear Reactors From Congressional Approval
On Major Rule Changes. In July 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that “would exempt any rule
relating to nuclear reactor safety standards from the Congressional approval process outlined in the bill.”
The amendment failed, 167-241. [HR 427, Vote #479; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
285
Voted Against Exempting Rules Changes Regarding Availability Of Medication & Healthcare
Management For Veterans From Requirement For Congressional Approval
Voted Against Exempting Rules Changes Regarding Availability Of Medication & Healthcare
Management For Veterans From Requirement For Congressional Approval. In July 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment that “would exempt rules issued by the Veterans Affairs Department relating
to the availability of medication and healthcare management for veterans from the Congressional approval
process outlined in the bill.” The amendment failed, 167-239. [HR 427, Vote #480; CQ Floor Votes,
7/28/15]
Voted For An Amendment To Require Agencies To Publish Data On Proposed Executive Branch
Rules
Voted For An Amendment To Require Agencies To Publish Data On Proposed Executive Branch
Rules. In July 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the REINS Act that would “require agencies to
publish information online on which [an executive branch] rule is based, including data, scientific and
economic studies, and cost-benefit analyses, and make such information publically accessible.” The
amendment was adopted 250-159. [HR 427, Vote #473, 7/28/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/28/15]
Voted Against Motion To Protect The Regulatory Process For Social Security And Medicare
Voted Against Motion To Protect The Regulatory Process For Social Security And Medicare. In
July 2015, Katko voted against a motion to exempt rulemaking for Social Security and Medicare from the
Regulations from the Executive in Need of Scrutiny (REINS) Act which would require congressional
approval for new rules written by federal agencies. The motion failed 167 to 241. [HR 427, Vote #481,
7/28/15; Motion to Recommit, 7/28/15]
Voted For Bill To Stifle Government’s Ability To Enact Rules To Protect Americans
Voted For Bill To Stifle Government’s Ability To Enact Rules To Protect Americans. In July 2015,
Katko voted for the Regulations from the Executive in Need of Scrutiny (REINS) Act, “a bid to roll back
the executive branch's rulemaking authority … Democrats fear the legislation would pave the way for
Republicans to block what they believe to be much-needed public health and environmental protections.
Rep. Hank Johnson (D-Ga.) said the REINS Act is a ‘gift to the economic elites’ that would ‘stop all
future regulations.’” The bill passed 243 to 165. [HR 427, Vote #482, 7/28/15; The Hill, 7/28/15]
286
Voted For Requiring Federal Courts To Impose Monetary Sanctions On Parties That File Frivolous
Lawsuits
Voted For Requiring Federal Courts To Impose Monetary Sanctions On Parties That File Frivolous
Lawsuits. In September 2015, Katko voted for a bill that “would change federal rules governing civil
lawsuits to require federal courts to impose sanctions on parties that file frivolous civil lawsuits. The
sanctions would need to include monetary payments to the other party to cover the other party’s attorney
fees and costs. The bill also would eliminate the so-called ‘safe harbor’ clause by removing the ability of
parties to withdraw of correct claims considered frivolous within 21 days of firing.” The bill passed 241
to 185. [HR 758, Vote #501, 9/17/15; CQ, 9/17/15]
Voted Against Amendment Removing Automatic Project Approval In Absence Of Agency Decision
Within 90 To 120 Days
Voted Against Removing Automatic Project Approval In Absence Of Agency Decision Within 90
To 120 Day Deadline. In September 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that would remove the
bill’s provision that would automatically approve any project for which the reviewing agency does not
make a decision within the bill’s deadlines.” The bill stipulated a deadline of between 90 and 120 days.
The amendment failed, 173 to 237. [HR 348, Amendment #5 Vote #511, 9/25/15; CQ, 9/25/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Bar RAPID Act From Affecting Permitting Projects That Could Be
Terror Targets, Critical Infrastructure
Voted Against Amendment To Bar The Bill From Affecting Permitting Projects That Could Be
Terror Targets, Critical Infrastructure. In September 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the
Responsibly And Professionally Invigorating Development (RAPID) Act of 2015 that would “bar the
bill's provisions from affecting permitting projects that could be a potential target for a terrorist attack or
that involve chemical facilities and other critical infrastructure.” The amendment failed 176 to 232. [HR
348, Vote #515, 9/25/15; CQ, 9/25/15]
RAPID Act Would Modify Environmental Review For Federally Funded Projects And Permits
By Setting Deadlines On Agency Reviews, Limiting Grounds For Civil Actions Against
Approvals. “The Responsibly And Professionally Invigorating Development (RAPID) Act “modifies
the environmental review process for federally funded projects and for federal permits for private
projects by setting deadlines on agency reviews, and by limiting the grounds for civil actions filed
against an environmental review or permit approval.” [CQ, 9/18/15]
Voted Against Amendment To State That Nothing In RAPID Act Would Limit Agencies From
Public Comment Or Participation In Decision-Making
Voted Against Amendment To State That Nothing In RAPID Act Would Limit Agencies From
Public Comment Or Participation In Decision-Making. In September 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment to the Responsibly And Professionally Invigorating Development (RAPID) Act of 2015
which would “state that nothing the bill would limit agencies from allowing public comment or
287
participation in the decision-making process.” The amendment failed 176 to 232. [HR 348, Vote #516,
9/25/15; CQ, 9/25/15]
RAPID Act Would Modify Environmental Review For Federally Funded Projects And Permits
By Setting Deadlines On Agency Reviews, Limiting Grounds For Civil Actions Against
Approvals. The Responsibly And Professionally Invigorating Development (RAPID) Act “modifies
the environmental review process for federally funded projects and for federal permits for private
projects by setting deadlines on agency reviews, and by limiting the grounds for civil actions filed
against an environmental review or permit approval.” [CQ, 9/18/15]
Voted For Bill Aimed At Improving Attorney Accountability And Reducing Lawsuit Abuse
Voted For Bill Aimed At Improving Attorney Accountability And Reducing Lawsuit Abuse. In
September 2015, Katko voted for the Lawsuit Abuse Reduction Act of 2015. The bill “would change
federal rules governing civil lawsuits to require federal courts to impose sanctions on parties that file
frivolous civil lawsuits. The sanctions would need to include monetary payments to the other party to
cover the other party’s attorney fees and costs. The bill also would eliminate the so-called ‘safe harbor’
clause by removing the ability of parties to withdraw of correct claims considered frivolous within 21
days of firing.” The bill passed 241 to 185. [HR 758, Vote #501, 9/17/15; CQ, 9/17/15]
Democratic Rep. Frankel: Bill Reinstates Procedural Rules; Strips Ability Of Federal
Judges To Impose Sanctions Deemed Appropriate To Bring Frivolous Lawsuits. “This
misguided bill would reinstate procedural rules that failed thirty years ago, stripping federal judges
of the ability to impose the sanctions they deem appropriate for bringing frivolous lawsuits.
During the ten years the old rules were in effect, judges completely lost their discretion about
whether or not to impose sanctions on attorneys and were forced to issue harsh penalties for even
the smallest infractions. Heavy punishments under the old system lead to endless motions that
clogged our already burdened legal system, preventing access to justice.” [Rep. Lois Frankel
Statement, 9/22/15]
Voted Against Ensuring Enforcement Of Laws Protecting Human Health, Environment, Or Public
Safety
Voted Against A Motion To Ensure Enforcement Of Laws And Regulations Necessary To Protect
Human Health, Environment, Or Public Safety. In October 2015, Katko voted against a motion to
ensure nothing in HR 702, a bill that would allow for the export of crude oil, would prevent the
“enforcement of federal laws that protect human health, the environment, and public safety.” The motion
failed 179 to 242. [HR 702, Vote #548, 10/09/15; Motion to Recommit, 10/09/15]
Voted For U.S. Government’s Oversight Of Internet’s Naming And Addressing System Over To
The International Community
Voted For U.S. Government’s Oversight Of Internet’s Naming And Addressing System Over To
The International Community. In June 2015, Katko voted for a motion to suspend the rules and pass a
bill, the Domain Openness Through Continued Oversight Matters (DOTCOM) Act of 2015. “The
DOTCOM Act would allow the U.S. government to transfer its power to oversee the Internet's naming
288
and addressing system — what turns www.google.com into a viewable Web page — over to the
international community. While this might sound like giving the Internet to America's rivals, Washington
actually ceded those powers long ago, and it retains them in name only. Today, that managing function is
performed by a nonprofit called the International Corporation for Names and Numbers, or ICANN.” The
bill passed, 378 to 25. [HR 805, Vote #377, 6/23/15; Washington Post, 7/21/15]
Voted For To Set New Standard On Deciding “Whether Certain Lawsuits Are Heard In Federal
Instead Of State Court”
Voted For To Set New Standard On Deciding “Whether Certain Lawsuits Are Heard In Federal
Instead Of State Court.” In February 2016, Katko voted for ‘The Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act’,
which “would set a new, national standard for deciding whether certain lawsuits are heard in federal
instead of state court because an in-state co-defendant should not have been joined to the case. The bill
would require district courts to deny motions to send a lawsuit back to state court because a defendant is
from the same state as a plaintiff if: there was fraud in the pleading of jurisdictional facts in relation to the
co-defendant joined to the lawsuit, it is not plausible that state law would impose liability against the codefendant, state or federal law bars claims against the co-defendant, or if there is no good faith intention
to seek a judgment against the co-defendant.” The bill passed, 229 to 189. [HR 3624, Vote #89, 02/24/16;
CQ, 2/25/16]
Legislation Would “Make It More Difficult For Americans To Enforce Their Rights In State
Courts.” On February 23, 2016, the Center for Justice and Democracy sent a group letter to
Speaker Ryan and Leader Pelosi opposing ‘The Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act.’ “The House
will soon be voting on H.R. 3624, the ‘Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act.’ “This bill would upend
long established law in the area of federal court jurisdiction, place unreasonable burdens on the
federal judiciary, and make it more difficult for Americans to enforce their rights in state courts.
… H.R. 3624 would undermine this fundamental precept and force state cases into federal court
when they don’t belong there. The bill would do this by transforming the centuries-old concept
called ‘fraudulent joinder,’ which is a way to defeat complete diversity i.e., when non-diverse
defendants are in case.” [Center for Justice and Democracy, 2/23/16]
Voted Against Motion Exempting Cases Where Plaintiff “Seeks Relief In Connection With The
Sexual Abuse And Exploitation Of A Minor” From Lawsuit Reform Bill
Voted Against Motion Exempting Cases Where Plaintiff “Seeks Relief In Connection With The
Sexual Abuse And Exploitation Of A Minor” From Lawsuit Reform Bill. In February 2016, Katko
voted against “motion to recommit the ‘Fraudulent Joinder Prevention Act’ to the Judiciary Committee
with instructions to report it back immediately with an amendment that would exempt from the bill cases
in which the plaintiff seeks relief in connection with the sexual abuse and exploitation of a minor.” The
motion failed, 180 to 239. [HR 3624, Vote #88, 02/24/16; CQ, 2/25/16]
Voted Against Amendment Exempting Cases In Which Plaintiffs Seek Compensation Because Of
Bad Faith Of Insurer
289
Voted Against Amendment Exempting Cases In Which Plaintiffs Seek Compensation Because Of
Bad Faith Of Insurer. In February 2016, Katko voted against an amendment “that would exempt cases
in which plaintiffs seek compensation because of the bad faith of an insurer” from Fraudulent Joinder
Prevention Act. The amendment failed, 178 to 237. [HR 3624, Vote #87, 02/24/16; CQ Floor Vote 87,
2/25/16; CQ Floor Votes 89, 2/25/16]
Voted Against Amendment To Fairness In Class Action Litigation Act To Protect Privacy Of
Asbestos Exposure Victims.
Voted Against Amendment To Fairness In Class Action Litigation Act To Protect Privacy Of
Asbestos Exposure Victims. In January 2016, Katko Voted Against an amendment to the Fairness in
Class Action Litigation Act that that would “require asbestos trusts to provide a report available to the
public regarding demands received and payments made, and would repeal the requirement that the report
contain the personal information of people paid by the trust.” The amendment was rejected in Committee
of the Whole by a vote of 179-222. [H R 1927, Vote #31, 1/08/16; CQ Floor Votes, 1/08/16]
Voted Against Amendment To The Fairness In Class Action Litigation Act To Allow Plaintiffs
Access To Information Held In Trusts.
Voted Against Amendment To The Fairness In Class Action Litigation Act To Allow Plaintiffs
Access To Information Held In Trusts. In January 2016, Katko Voted Against an amendment to the
Fairness in Class Action Litigation Act that would “allow litigants in a pending class action suit to access
information held in a trust that is directly related to a plaintiff's claim for asbestos exposure.” The
amendment was rejected in Committee of the Whole by a vote of 174-228. [H R 1927, Vote #30, 1/08/16;
Voted Against Amendment To Remove Anti-Consumer Rights Provisions From Bill Tightening
Class Action Lawsuit Requirements.
Voted Against Amendment To Remove Anti-Consumer Rights Provisions From Bill Tightening
Class Action Lawsuit Requirements. In January 2016, Katko Voted Against an amendment to the
Fairness in Class Action Litigation Act. The original bill would “eliminate most consumer class actions
by forcing consumers to prove that they’ve each suffered the exact same type and scope of injury from a
company in order for their case to be certified—and move forward as a group—in court.” The amendment
would eliminate the same "scope" of injury clause from the bill. The amendment was rejected in
Committee of the Whole by a vote of 177-223. [H R 1927, Vote #29, 1/08/16; CQ Floor Votes, 1/08/16;
The Hill, 10/07/15]
Voted For Amendment Exempting Lawsuits Involving Fraudulent College And Universities Claims
From Bill Tightening Class Action Lawsuit Requirements.
Voted For Amendment Exempting Lawsuits Involving Fraudulent College And Universities From
Bill Tightening Class Action Lawsuit Requirements. In January 2016, Katko Voted For an amendment
to the Fairness in Class Action Litigation Act that would “exempt claims against institutions under Title
IV of the Higher Education Act, education loan institutions as defined by section 221 of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986, or educational institutions as defined by chapter 33 of Title 38 United States
290
Code.” The amendment was rejected in Committee of the Whole by a vote of 177-223. [H R 1927, Vote
#28, 1/08/16; CQ Floor Votes, 1/08/16]
Voted For Amendment Exempting Equal Pay Lawsuits From Bill Tightening Class Action Lawsuit
Requirements.
Voted For Amendment Exempting Equal Pay Lawsuits From Bill Tightening Class Action Lawsuit
Requirements. In January 2016, Katko Voted For an amendment to the Fairness in Class Action
Litigation Act that would “exempt a pay equity claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act or the Fair
Labor Standards (Equal Pay) Act.” The amendment was rejected in Committee of the Whole by a vote of
177-224. [H R 1927, Vote #27, 1/08/16; CQ Floor Votes, 1/08/16]
Voted Against Exempting Housing Discrimination Lawsuits From Bill Tightening Class Action
Lawsuit Requirements.
Voted Against Exempting Housing Discrimination Lawsuits From Bill Tightening Class Action
Lawsuit Requirements. In January 2016, Katko Voted Against an amendment to the Fairness in Class
Action Litigation Act that would “exempt claims under the Fair Housing Act or the Equal Credit
Opportunity Act.” The amendment was rejected in Committee of the Whole by a vote of 172-229. [H R
Voted Against Amendment To Protect Child Victims Of Asbestos From Having Personal
Information Exposed
Voted Against Amendment To Protect Child Victims Of Asbestos From Having Personal
Information Exposed. In January 2016, Katko voted against motion to recommit that would exempt
claimants exposed to asbestos as a child in a school environment from having their personal information
exposed in quarterly reporting by asbestos trusts. The motion failed, 178-239. [HR 1927, Vote # 32,
1/8/16; Democratic Leader – Motions To Recommit, 1/8/16]
Voted For Passage Of A Bill That Imposes Limits On Class Action Lawsuits And Institute New
Requirements For Compensating Asbestos Victims
Voted For Passage Of A Bill That Imposes Limits On Class Action Lawsuits And Institute New
Requirements For Compensating Asbestos Victims. In January 2016, Katko Voted For passage of the
Fairness in Class Action Litigation and Furthering Asbestos Claim Transparency Act of 2016, a bill that
would “prohibit federal courts from certifying proposed classes of individuals for a class-action lawsuit
unless each member of the class has suffered the same type and degree of injury. Additionally, the bill
would require quarterly reports by asbestos trusts including claims made against the trusts and payouts
made by the trusts for asbestos-related injuries.” The bill passed 211-188. [HR 1927, Vote # 33, 1/8/2016;
Roll Call, 1/8/16]
Voted Against Bill Ensuring NSF Grant Funding Is Determined By NSF Merit Review Criteria
291
Voted Against Bill Ensuring NSF Grant Funding Is Determined By NSF Merit Review Criteria. In
February 2016, Katko voted against the “Johnson, D-Texas, amendment that would provide for the bill's
requirement that the National Science Foundation (NSF) determine that a grant is worthy of federal
funding to be fulfilled by having met the NSF’s merit review criteria.” The amendment failed, 181 to 235.
[H.R. 3293, Amendment #1, Vote #68; CQ, 2/10/16]
Voted For A Bill To Require Funding For The National Science Foundation Be Justified In Writing
Or Reaffirmed
Voted For A Bill To Require Funding For The National Science Foundation Be Justified In Writing
Or Reaffirmed. In February 2016, Katko voted for a bill to require funding for the national science
foundation be justified in writing or reaffirmed. The bill “directs the National Science Foundation (NSF)
to award federal funding for basic research and education in the sciences through a new research grant or
cooperative agreement only if it makes an affirmative determination, justified in writing, that the grant or
agreement promotes the progress of science in the United States, is worthy of federal funding, and meets
certain other criteria.” The bill passed 236 to 178. [HR 3442, Vote #70, 2/10/16; On Passage, 2/10/16]
Bill Required Written Justification For Each Grant Awarded To The National Science
Foundation And Proof Of How The Research Could Benefit The Public And The Economy.
“Limits on NSF Grants--HR 3293, Scientific Research in the National Interest Act. The bill allows
the National Science Foundation (NSF) to award grants or enter into cooperative agreements for
basic research and science education only if it determines that the grant or cooperative agreement
promotes the progress of science in the United States and is consistent with the NSF's mission, is
worthy of federal funding and is in the national interest as specified by the bill, and a written
justification detailing those determinations accompanies the public announcement of the award.
Supporters of the bill say it is needed to properly account for scarce federal research dollars and
that it essentially codifies the NSF's policy requiring clear, non-technical explanations of each
research grant and how the grant supports the public interest.” [Congressional Quarterly's House
Action Reports, 2/05/16]
Prominent Scientists Noted That Scientific Studies Do Not Always Provide Immediate
Economic Value But Can Lead To Long-Term Research Developments. “On February 10th,
the House passed a bill requiring the NSF to certify the usefulness of its grants; one of the possible
criteria was economic. ‘I think there’s a misunderstanding between some members of congress
and the research community that every grant that’s given out should have some economic potential
benefit,” said Bill Andresen, associate vice president for federal relations at the University of
Pennsylvania. “And that’s just not the way science works.’ Not only is some science valuable in
non-economic ways, but when research does have an economic impact you can’t always know it
ahead of time. Studies of eagles ended up leading to advances in contact lenses, said Andrese.
NSF director France Cordova points to NSF funding for digital libraries that helped lead to
Google.” [Marketplace, 2/22/16]
Financial Regulation
Voted Against Amendment To Allow Department Of Labor To Adopt Fiduciary Rule Regarding
Investment Advisors
292
Voted Against Amendment To Allow Department Of Labor To Adopt Fiduciary Rule Regarding
Investment Advisors. Katko voted against amendment to HR 1090. “H.AMDT.732 to H.R.1090
Amendment sought to allow the Department of Labor to complete and adopt a rule to require that
investment advisers act solely in the best interests of the workers and retirees who rely upon them in
making financial decisions regarding their retirement.” The amendment failed 184 to 246. [HR 1090,
Vote #574, 10/27/15]
Voted Against Bill To Prevent Department Of Labor From Issuing Fiduciary Rule “Setting
Standards Of Conduct For Brokers And Dealers Of Securities”
Voted Against Bill To Prevent Department Of Labor From Issuing Fiduciary Rule “Setting
Standards Of Conduct For Brokers And Dealers Of Securities.” Katko voted against HR 1090, the
Retail Investor Protection Act. “H.R. 1090 would prohibit the Secretary of Labor from finalizing a
regulation related to certain investment advisors until the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
issues a final rule setting standards of conduct for brokers and dealers of securities. The regulation that
would be delayed by the bill will define the circumstances under which an individual is considered to be a
fiduciary when providing investment advice to employee retirement and other benefit plans and their
participants. Under current law, the SEC is authorized to develop regulations that establish the same
standards of conduct for brokers and dealers that are already in place for investment advisors when
providing advice to persons who use the information for personal reasons.” [HR 1090, Vote #575,
10/27/15; Congressional Budget Office, 10/21/15]
Bill Did Not Direct Securities And Exchange Commission To Issue Fiduciary Rule; Commission
Had Not Proposed Rule. “Because the bill would not direct the SEC to issue a rule on standards of
conduct, CBO expects that implementing H.R. 1090 would not affect the SEC’s workload or its costs.
Enacting H.R. 1090 would not affect direct spending or revenues; therefore, pay-as-you-go procedures
do not apply.” [HR 1090, Vote#575, 10/27/15; Congressional Budget Office, 10/21/15]
TIME Money, Ian Salisbury Opinion: Bill Did Not Prohibit Instituting Of Fiduciary Standard,
But Required Department Of Labor To Defer To Securities And Exchange Commission’s
Parallel Efforts. “To be sure, the mechanics get a bit more complicated: Tuesday’s bill technically
doesn’t nix the fiduciary standard. It requires the Labor Department to defer to the Securities and
Exchange Commission’s parallel efforts. There is some merit to that: It is certainly possible to quibble
about the Labor Department’s proposal. But given the fact that many of the same lawmakers who
voted for latest bill have also fought to squelch the S.E.C.’s own efforts, it seems unlikely their
objections are purely a matter of defending bureaucratic jurisdiction.” [TIME Money, Ian Salisbury
Opinion, 10/28/15]
TIME Money, Ian Salisbury Opinion: Bill Preventing Rule To Protect Retail Investors Was “In
True, It-Can-Only-Happen-In-Washington-Style.” “On Tuesday, the House passed, ‘The Retail
Investor Protection Act.’… Confused? You should be. In true, it-can-only-happen-in-Washingtonstyle, the Act actually prevents the Department of Labor from implementing a rule retail investor
advocates have been promoting for close to a decade. As Morningstar analyst and long-time industry
watcher John Rekenthaler recently lamented, ‘George Orwell would be amused.’” [TIME Money, Ian
Salisbury Opinion, 10/28/15]
293
Voted Against Blocking Benefits For Those Convicted Of Assisting Terrorists
Voted Against A Motion To Prohibit Individuals & Entities Assisting Terrorist Groups From
Receiving Benefits Under Wall Street Bill. In January 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit
that would prohibit any person or financial entity that has been convicted of providing assistance to
terrorist groups or state sponsors of terrorism from receiving the benefits of Republicans’ wall-street
giveaway bill. The motion failed, 183-242. [HR 37, Vote #36, 1/14/15; Democratic Leader – Motions to
Recommit, 1/14/15]
Voted For Bill To Deregulate Wall Street
Voted For Bill To Deregulate Wall Street. In January 2015, Katko voted for legislation that combined
the text from eleven bills and would roll back or delay a number of regulations in the Dodd-Frank
financial reform law. “The most serious attack of the bunch came in the form of a partial two-year delay
of the Volcker Rule, which would ban banks from speculating in securities markets with taxpayer money.
The bill would have allowed Citigroup and JPMorgan Chase to hold onto almost $50 billion in risky
corporate debt packages known as collateralized loan obligations through 2019.” The bill passed, 271 to
154. [HR 37, Vote #37, 1/14/15; Huffington Post, 1/10/14]
Voted Against Loosening Restrictions On Individuals Who Finance Terrorism. In January 2015,
Katko voted against a motion that would disqualify anyone convicted of providing financial assistance
to terrorist organizations or state sponsors of terrorism from regulatory relief under the underlying bill,
the Promoting Job Creation and Reducing Small Business Burdens Act. The motion failed 183 to 242.
[HR 37, Vote #37, 1/14/15; Motion to Recommit, 1/14/15]
Voted For Weakening Wall Street Reform
Voted For Weakening Wall Street Reform And Roll Back Rules Limiting Risky Bank Investments.
In January 2015, Katko voted for a bill “to relax some requirements under the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial
regulatory law. The measure would delay until July 2019 a provision of the law’s Volcker Rule intended
to limit risky investments by banks, and make other changes.” The vote failed to reach a 2/3 majority, 276
to 146. [HR 37, Vote #9, 1/7/15; Bloomberg, 1/7/15]
Voted For Weakening CFPB
Voted For Limiting Funding For Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. In April 2015, Katko voted
for a bill that limited funding for the CFPB. “Passage of the bill that would formally establish three
advisory boards with which the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) that must consult on
matters regarding small businesses, credit unions and community banks. The measure is offset by limiting
funding for the CFPB in future years. As amended, the bill would encourage the CFPB to ensure the
participation of veteran-owned small-business concerns as members of the Small Business Advisory
Board.” The bill passed 235-183. [HR 1195, Vote #167, 4/22/15; CQ News, 4/22/15]
Voted Against Measure To Prohibit Individuals Or Companies Convicted Of Predatory Lending
From Serving On CFPB Boards. In April 2015, Katko voted against a motion that protected military
294
bases and veterans from predatory lenders. The motion would “prohibit individuals from serving as
members of the any of the advisory boards if within the last ten years they have been employed or acted
as an agent of a company whose been subject to a state or federal enforcement action for predatory
lending or fraud against veterans or servicemembers.” The motion was rejected, 184-234. [HR 1195, Vote
#166, 4/22/15; CQ News, 4/22/15]
Voted For Requiring Minority And Women Owned Small Business Representatives On Small
Business Advisory Council. In April 2015, Katko voted for an amendment “that would require the
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to include representatives of minority- and women-owned smallbusiness concerns as members of the Small Business Advisory Board.” The amendment was passed 244173. [HR 1195, Vote #165, 4/22/15; CQ News, 4/22/15]
Voted For Considering Bill Establishing Small Business, Credit Union, and Community Bank
Advisory Boards On House Floor. In April 2015, Katko voted for considering a bill establishing a small
business advisory board, credit union advisory council, and community bank advisory council as a part of
the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. The rule was adopted, 242-182. [HRes 200, Vote #155,
4/15/15; CQ Votes, 4/15/15]
Voted For Consideration Of Bill Restricting Ability Of Commodity Futures Trading Commission
To Regulate Wall Streets’ Banks Overseas Trades
Voted For Consideration Of Bill Restricting Ability Of Commodity Futures Trading Commission
To Regulate Wall Streets’ Banks Overseas Trade. In June 2015, Katko voted for the consideration of a
bill reauthorizing the Commodity Futures Trading Administration. “The U.S. House of Representatives
passed legislation to curb the power of the nation’s top derivatives regulator, advancing the measure over
Democrats’ objections and in the face of a veto threat from President Barack Obama. The Republican-led
House on Tuesday voted 246-171, mostly along party-lines, for a bill that would renew the
responsibilities of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission while limiting its ability to regulate Wall
Street banks’ overseas trades. It also would force the CFTC to do more cost-analysis of its rules, a key
requirement that could stall the agency’s work.” The resolution passed 243 to 182. [H. Res. 288, Vote
#274, 6/03/15; Bloomberg News, 6/09/15]
Bloomberg News: Bill Would Force CFTC To Conduct Additional Cost Analysis Of Its Rules,
“A Key Requirement That Could Stall The Agency’s Work.” “The U.S. House of Representatives
passed legislation to curb the power of the nation’s top derivatives regulator, advancing the measure
over Democrats’ objections and in the face of a veto threat from President Barack Obama. The
Republican-led House on Tuesday voted 246-171, mostly along party-lines, for a bill that would
renew the responsibilities of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission while limiting its ability to
regulate Wall Street banks’ overseas trades. It also would force the CFTC to do more cost-analysis of
its rules, a key requirement that could stall the agency’s work.” [Bloomberg News, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Measure To Protect The Rights Of Veterans To File Lawsuits If Their Mortgages
Violate Anti-Predatory Lending Laws
295
Voted Against Measure To Protect The Rights Of Veterans To File Lawsuits If Their Mortgages
Violate Anti-Predatory Lending Laws. In November 2015, Katko voted against a Democratic Motion to
Recommit which would “protect veterans and members of the Armed Forces by preserving their right to
file a lawsuit if their mortgages violate anti-predatory lending laws; and prevent mortgage brokers from
receiving bonuses for steering servicemembers or veterans into mortgages that are more expensive than
what they qualify for under their credit profile.” The motion to recommit failed in the House, 184 - 242.
[HR 1210, Vote #635, 11/18/15; Motion to Recommit, 11/18/15]
Voted For Legislation That Would Provide Legal Protections For Lenders Who Issue Predatory
Loans
Voted For Legislation That Would Provide Legal Protections For Lenders Who Issue Predatory
Loans. In November 2015, Katko voted for legislation that would prevent borrowers from filing claims
against holders of loans that contain abusive and harmful terms. “Under the bill, depository institutions
that hold a loan in portfolio would receive a legal safe harbor even if the loan contains terms and features
that are abusive and harmful to consumers. The bill would limit the right of borrowers to file claims
against holders of such loans and against mortgage originators who directed them to the loans, the White
House said.” The bill passed the House, 255 - 174. [HR 1210, Vote #636, 11/18/15; Housing Wire,
11/18/15]
Voted For Legislation That Would Revoke The CFPB’s Guidance On Auto Lending
Voted For Legislation That Would Revoke The CFPB’s Guidance On Auto Lending. In November
2015, Katko voted for legislation which “would revoke 2013 auto lending guidance from the CFPB. The
guidance suggests lenders should either impose limits on or eliminate dealerships’ ability to adjust, on a
case-by-case basis, the amount of compensation they keep for arranging a consumer auto loan, a
discretionary practice that the CFPB says can lead to discriminatory loan pricing.” The bill passed the
House, 332 - 96. [HR 1737, Vote # 637, 11/18/15; Automotive News, 11/18/15]
Voted For Bill To Undercut The Federal Reserve’s Ability To Independently Set U.S. Monetary
Policy
Voted ForBill To Undercut The Federal Reserve’s Ability To Independently Set U.S. Monetary
Policy. In November 2015, Katko Voted Forthe Fed Oversight Reform and Modernization (FORM) Act,
a bill that would direct the Federal Reserve to be “more open in communicating monetary policy
decisions and require it to use a mathematical rule in deciding on interest rates… Under the bill, the Fed
would be required to use a formula to set interest rates but would be allowed to deviate from that strategy
if economic conditions warranted a change. The Fed’s chosen formula would be subject to a review by the
Government Accountability Office, and the GAO would be required to audit the Fed anytime the central
bank chose to make changes to its rule.” The bill passed by a vote of 241-185. [H R 3189, Vote #641,
11/19/15; Associated Press, 11/19/15]
Voted For Reducing Transparency Of Firms That Offer Stock Options
296
Voted For Reducing Transparency Requirements For Firms That Offer Stock Options. In February
2016, Katko voted for a bill that “would reduce the disclosure burden on firms that offer stock options to
their employees.” The bill passed 265 to 159. [HR 1675, Vote #61, 2/03/16; Business Wire, 2/04/16]
Voted Against Excluding Individuals Convicted Of Securities-Related Crimes From Reduced
Disclosure Over Employee Stock Options
Voted Against Excluding Individuals Convicted Of Securities-Related Crimes From Reduced
Disclosure Over Employee Stock Options. In February 2016, Katko voted againsta motion that would
have, “prohibit[ed] individuals convicted of felonies or misdemeanors involving securities from making
use of the exemptions or other authorities that would be provided under the bill.” The underlying bill,
“would reduce the disclosure burden on firms that offer stock options to their employees.” The motion
failed 184 to 241. [HR 1675, Vote #60, 2/03/16; CQ Floor Votes, 2/03/16; Business Wire, 2/04/16]
Voted For Amendment Narrowing The Exemption From XBRL Reporting Requirements To
Businesses With Total Gross Revenues Of Less Than $1 Billion.
Voted For Amendment Narrowing The Exemption From XBRL Reporting Requirements To Only
“Emerging Growth Companies.” In February 2016, Katko voted for an amendment “narrow[ed] the
underlying bill’s exemption from XBLR requirements to only ‘Emerging Growth Companies’ and only
for a period of three years, while permitting such companies to elect to use XBLR for such reporting.”
The amendment failed 173 to 248. [HR 1675, Vote #59, 2/03/16; Daily Whip, 2/03/16; CQ Floor Votes,
2/03/16]
XBRL Is A Financial Reporting Language Provides Faster And More Efficient Reporting For
Compliance, Performance, And Business Reports. “In a nutshell, XBRL provides a language in
which reporting terms can be authoritatively defined. Those terms can then be used to uniquely
represent the contents of financial statements or other kinds of compliance, performance and business
reports. XBRL lets reporting information move between organisations(sic) rapidly, accurately and
digitally.” [XBRL.org, accessed 3/09/16]
“Emerging Growth Companies” Are Companies With Gross Annual Revenues Less Than $1
Billion. “An ‘emerging growth company’ is defined in the Securities Act and the Exchange Act as an
issuer with “total annual gross revenues” of less than $1 billion during its most recently completed
fiscal year.” [Securities and Exchange Commission, 12/21/15]
Voted For Limiting The Exemption From XBRL Reporting For Emerging Growth Companies To
Companies That Are First Required To File With The SEC After The Bill’s Enactment
Voted For Limiting The Exemption From XBRL Reporting For Emerging Growth Companies To
Companies That Are First Required To File With The SEC After The Bill’s Enactment. In February
2016, Katko voted for an amendment that would “limit the exemption under the bill for emerging growth
companies and companies with annual revenues of less than $250 million from the current requirement
for companies to use eXtensible Business Reporting Language (XBRL), an interactive data format, for
filing financial statements with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Specifically, the amendment
297
would limit the exemption to issuers that are first required to file financial statements after the bill's
enactment.” The amendment failed 194 to 221. [HR 1675, Vote #58, 2/03/16; CQ Floor Votes, 2/03/16]
XBRL Is A Financial Reporting Language Provides Faster And More Efficient Reporting For
Compliance, Performance, And Business Reports. “In a nutshell, XBRL provides a language in
which reporting terms can be authoritatively defined. Those terms can then be used to uniquely
represent the contents of financial statements or other kinds of compliance, performance and business
reports. XBRL lets reporting information move between organisations(sic) rapidly, accurately and
digitally.” [XBRL.org, accessed 3/09/16]
Voted Against Amendment Directing Securities And Exchange Commission (SEC) To Study
Prevalence Of Employee Ownership Plans In Companies That Include Social Benefit
Voted Against Amendment Directing Securities And Exchange Commission (SEC) To Study
Prevalence Of Employee Ownership Plans In Companies That Include Social Benefit. In February
2016, Katko voted against an amendment that would have “direct[ed] the Securities and Exchange
Commission to study and report to Congress on the prevalence of employee ownership plans within
companies that include a flexible or social benefit component in their articles of incorporation, as
permitted by relevant state laws.” The amendment failed 180 to 243. [HR 1675, Vote #57, 2/03/16; CQ
Voted For Preventing Bank Regulators From “Requesting Or Ordering Banks” To Close Customer
Accounts Involved In Ongoing Law Enforcement Investigations.
Voted For Preventing Bank Regulators From “Requesting Or Ordering Banks” To Close Customer
Accounts Involved In Ongoing Law Enforcement Investigations. In February 2016, Katko voted for a
bill to “limit regulators’ ability to request shutting off bank accounts associated with businesses suspected
of fraud. Passed largely along party lines by a vote of 250-169, the bill would prevent banking regulators
from requesting or ordering banks to close specific customer accounts unless the reason isn’t based solely
on reputation.” The bill passed 250 to 169. [H. 766, Vote #63; The Hill, 2/04/16]
Voted Against Motion Ensuring Financial Institutions Haven’t Broken The Law By Taking
Advantage Of Service Members Or Abusing Mortgage Market
Voted AgainstMotion Ensuring Financial Institutions Haven’t Broken The Law By Taking
Advantage Of Service Members Or Abusing Mortgage Market. In February 2016, Katko voted
against a motion that would have prevented the Financial Institution Customer Protection Act of 2016
from taking effect until it had been certified that financial institutions covered by bill haven’t broken the
law, taken advantage of service members or perpetrated abuses in the mortgage market during the
previous five years. The motion failed, 177 to 240. [H.R. 766, Vote #62; Congressional Record, 2/04/16]
Housing Regulations
Voted For Weakening Regulations On Mortgage Lenders
298
Voted For A Bill That Changed The Definition Of A Qualified Mortgage Under The Truth In
Lending Act. In April 2015, Katko voted for the Mortgage Choice Act. “The bill excludes insurance paid
at closing into escrow, as well as fees paid for related services to lender-affiliated companies, from the 3%
cap on points and fees imposed on ‘qualified mortgages’ by redefining ‘points and fees’ under the Truth
in Lending Act. The measure is intended to clarify conflicting definitions under current law and thereby
ensure that mortgage loans to low- and middle-income borrowers remain affordable.” The bill passed, 286
to 140. [HR 685, Vote #152, 4/14/15; CQ, 4/10/15]
Bill They Voted On Would “Weaken Regulations On Mortgage Lenders.” “Ranking second
behind the Chamber was the National Association of Realtors. The group spent $7.7 million lobbying
on issues like flood insurance premiums, which have risen sharply in the past few years. NAR
also lobbied for the Mortgage Choice Act, a bill that would weaken regulations on mortgage lenders
enacted following the 2007 collapse of the housing market. The Mortgage Choice Act passed in the
House of Representatives on April 14.” [Huffington Post, 4/23/15]
Voted Against Preventing Those Convicted Of Mortgage Fraud And Predatory Lenders From
Providing Loans To Homeowners
Voted Against Preventing Those Convicted Of Mortgage Fraud And Predatory Lenders From
Providing Loans To Homeowners. In April 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would prevent
those convicted of mortgage fraud and predatory lenders from providing loans to homeowners. “No
person or lender that has been found to have engaged in unfair, deceptive, predatory, or abusive lending
practices, or convicted of mortgage fraud under Federal or relevant State law may make use of the
amendments made by this Act ” The motion failed 184 to 239. [HR 650, Vote #150, 14/14/15; Motion to
Recommit, 4/14/15]
Voted For Weakening Wall Street Reform For Mortgage Lenders
Voted For Weakening Aspects Of Wall Street Reform Allowing Mortgage Lenders To Disclose Less
Information To Borrowers. In April 2015, Katko voted for legislation that would roll back regulations
in the Wall Street reform law. “Regulations from the Dodd-Frank Act that went into effect in early 2014
tightened requirements and restrictions on ‘high-cost’ loans. For example, if the interest rate and fees on
loans reach a certain level, lenders have to verify a borrower’s ability to repay loans and disclose
consequences of default and loan terms … the Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing Act of 2015.
HR 650 would raise the threshold for which loans are considered ‘high cost,’ from 8.5 percent above the
average rate to 10 percent above the average rate. President Obama has threatened to veto it if it passes
both houses. The change may seem minor, but the higher threshold would mean the lender has to do less
work and disclose less information to borrowers. The majority of loans on manufactured homes carry
high interest rates, especially compared with a typical mortgage.” The bill passed, 263 to 162. [HR 650,
Vote #151, 4/14/15; Seattle Times Editorial, 4/14/15]
Voted Against An Amendment That Prevented The Department Of Justice From Enforcing
Disparate Impact Claims Under The Fair Housing Act
Voted Against An Amendment That Prevented The Department Of Justice From Enforcing
Disparate Impact Claims Under The Fair Housing Act. In June 2015, Katko voted against an
299
amendment that prevented the department of justice from enforcing disparate impact claims under the Fair
Housing Act. “Housing discrimination claims: The House has passed an amendment sponsored by Rep.
Scott Garrett, R-N.J., to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act (H.R.
2578). The amendment would bar funding for Justice Department enforcement actions under the Fair
Housing Act that rely on the theory of disparate impact to allege racial and other forms of discrimination
by mortgage lenders, landlords, and home insurers. Garrett said the threat of prosecution for treating
various classes of homeowners and renters differently, based on their economic status, would impede the
ability ‘for lenders to make rational economic decisions about risk’ rather than based on the possibility
that the Justice Department will consider their actions discriminatory.” The amendment passed 232 to
196. [HR 2578, Vote #287, 6/03/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 6/03/15; Citizen-Times, 6/05/15]
Voted Against An Amendment That Barred Funding For The Private Enforcement Initiative Of
The Fair Housing Initiatives Program
Voted Against An Amendment That Barred Funding For The Private Enforcement Initiative Of
The Fair Housing Initiatives Program. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the
Transportation, Housing and Urban Development, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2016 that
would “bar funds from being used for the Private Enforcement Initiative of the Fair Housing Initiatives
Program.” The amendment passed 224 to 198. [CQ Floor Votes, 6/04/15; HR 2577, Vote #307, 6/04/15]
National Council On Independent Living: PEI Grantees Are “Critical” To Enforcement Of The
Fair Housing Act. “PEI grants support local, private fair housing groups’ testing, complaint intake, and
investigation efforts. PEI grantees are critical to enforcement efforts for the Fair Housing Act. Disabilityrelated complaints is the largest category of Fair Housing complaints. To remove funding for the PEI
program would damage Fair Housing enforcement in many communities. This harms people with
disabilities when fair housing enforcement is not readily available in communities.” [NCIL, 6/05/15]
Voted For Amendment Barring Implementation Of Housing Rule Meant To Combat Housing
Segregation
Voted For Amendment Barring The Implementation Of Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing
Rule. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Transportation, Housing and Urban
Development, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2016 that would “ bar funding for HUD to
implement, enforce or administer the proposed Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule.” The
amendment passed 229 to 193. [HR 2577, Vote #311, 6/09/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/09/15]
Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule Self Purports To Combat Segregation. According to the
Federal Register, the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule “[e]stablish[es] an approach to
affirmatively further fair housing that calls for coordinated efforts to combat illegal housing
discrimination, so that individuals and families can make decisions about where to live, free from
discrimination, with necessary information regarding housing options, and with adequate support to make
their choices viable.” [Federal Register, 7/19/13]
Voted Against Weakening Housing Discrimination Protections
300
Voted Against Amendment To Bar HUD From Enforcing Regulation Combating Discrimination In
the Housing Market. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to the FY16 Transportation-HUD
Appropriations bill that would bar funds from being used by HUD to administer a federal regulation that
dictates, “If the policies of governmental agencies, banks or private real estate companies unjustifiably
perpetuate segregation, regardless of their intent, they could be found in violation of the Fair Housing
Act.” The amendment was adopted by a vote of 231-195. [HR 2577, Vote #323, 6/09/15; Propublica,
1/21/15]
Voted For Baring Use Of Funds In Violation Of HUD Regulations On Assistance To Non-Citizens
Voted For Baring Use Of Funds In Violation Of HUD Regulations On Assistance To Non-Citizens.
In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to a DOT and HUD appropriations bill that would “bar
funds from being used in violation of HUD regulations relating to restrictions on assistance to noncitizens. “ The amendment was adopted 244-181. [HR 2577, Vote #319, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted For Baring Use Of Funds For Providing Need-Based Housing For Unauthorized Aliens
Voted For Baring Use Of Funds For Providing Need-Based Housing For Unauthorized Aliens. In
June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to a DOT and HUD appropriations bill that would “bar funds
from being used to provide financial assistance in contravention of section 214 (d) of the Housing and
Community Development Act of 1980, regarding non-citizen eligibility for need-based housing.” Section
214 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1980 states that “only certain categories of
noncitizens are eligible for benefits under the housing programs covered by Section 214. Unauthorized
aliens are not eligible for benefits under Section 214.” The amendment was adopted 246 to 180. [HR
2577, Vote #320, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15; CRS, 1/23/12]
Voted Against A Motion To Allow Home Buyers To Seek Court Remedy Against Predatory
Practices
Voted Against A Motion To Allow Home Buyers To Seek Court Remedy Against Predatory
Practices. In October 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would “protect the rights of
servicemembers, seniors, and students to seek a court remedy against predatory practices in the homebuying process.” The motion failed, 185-240. [HR 3192, Vote #539, 10/07/15; Democratic Leader –
Voted For Delaying Implementation Of Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Rules For Home
Buyers
Voted For Delaying Implementation Of Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Rules For Home
Buyers. In October 2015, Katko voted for a bill that would “delay implementation of the Consumer
Financial Protection Bureau's rules regarding lender disclosures to consumers applying for home
mortgage loans until Feb. 1, 2016. Enforcement of the rules and lawsuits against lenders would be
prohibited as long as the lender makes a good-faith effort to comply with the rules.” The bill passed 303121. [HR 3192, Vote #540, 10/07/15; CQ Floor Votes, 10/07/15]
301
Voted Against Allowing HUD To Continue An FHA Program Automating An Alternative Credit
Rating System For Borrowers With Insufficient Credit Histories.
Voted Against Allowing HUD To Continue An FHA Program Automating An Alternative Credit
Rating System For Borrowers With Insufficient Credit Histories. In February 2016, Katko voted
against an amendment that would “allow the Housing and Urban Development Department to continue a
Federal Housing Administration pilot program for an automated process to provide alternative credit
rating information to help determine creditworthiness of borrowers with insufficient credit histories.” The
amendment was rejected, 181 to 239. [H R 3700, Vote #51, 2/02/16, 2/02/16; CQ Floor Votes, 2/02/16]
Voted For Exempting Public Housing Agencies From Requirement For At Least One Board
Member Receiving Housing Assistance If They Have A Resident Advisory Board.
Voted For Exempting Public Housing Agencies From Requirement For At Least One Board
Member Receiving Housing Assistance If They Have A Resident Advisory Board. In February 2016,
Katko voted for an amendment that would “exempt certain public housing agencies from a requirement
that their boards of directors include at least one member who directly receives public housing agency
assistance, if the public housing agency establishes an advisory board of at least six public housing
residents.” The amendment was adopted by a vote of 236 to 178. [H R 3700, Vote #50, 2/02/16, 2/02/16;
Native American Lands Regulations
Voted Against Protecting Native American Sacred Lands
Voted Against Protecting Native American Sacred Lands. In October 2015, Katko voted against a
motion “that would ensure that nothing in the bill would contravene the authority of the president to avoid
adversely affecting the physical integrity of any site identified as sacred by virtue of established religious
significance to, or ceremonial use by, and Indian religion.” The motion failed 184-239. [HR 538, Vote
#543; CQ Floor Votes, 10/8/15]
Voted For The Native American Energy Act Which Would Reduce Federal Regulations On The
Development Of Native American Land
Voted For The Native American Energy Act Which Would Reduce Federal Regulations On The
Development Of Native American Land. In October 2015, Katko voted for for a bill that “would reduce
federal regulations on the development of Indian lands to expedite the development of energy. As
amended, the bill would allow state, tribe, and local governments in an affected area to continue to
comment on an environmental impact statement. Further, the bill would create a demonstration project
with Indian tribes to perform administrative, management, and other functions of programs of the Tribal
Forest Protection Act.” The bill passed 254-173. [HR 538, Vote #544; CQ Floor Votes, 10/8/15]
Republicans Argued That The Bill Would Allow Native Americans To Develop Reservations
Easier. “Young says the bill would cut red tape to help Native people develop their own
resources. On the House floor before the vote, the Alaska Republican argued the bill would also
deter frivolous lawsuits, in part by shortening the timeline for legal challenges. ‘The judicial
review provision is crucial for Alaska natives, whose ability to develop their own settlement lands
302
has been abused by special interest groups filing lawsuits,’ he said.” [Alaska Public Radio
Network, 10/9/15]
Voted Against Legislation To Exempt Tribal Governments And Tribally-Owned Gaming Facilities
From The National Labor Relations Act
Voted Against Legislation To Exempt Tribal Governments And Tribally-Owned Gaming Facilities
From The National Labor Relations Act. In November 2015, Katko voted against legislation that
would exempt tribal governments and tribally-owned gaming facilities from the National Labor Relations
Act, thus preventing tribal employees from organizing labor unions. “The Act would insulate tribes from
union organizing efforts by providing tribes with the same exemption from the NLRA that state and
municipal governments enjoy.” The bill passed the House, 249 - 177. [HR 1694, Vote #633, 11/17/15;
National Law Review, 6/16/15]
Voted For Native American Tribes Having The Right Of First Refusal On Purchasing Land Along
The Red River
Voted For Native American Tribes Having The Right Of First Refusal On Purchasing Land Along
The Red River. In December 2015, Katko voted for an amendment “that would allow Indian tribes to
have the right of first refusal on purchasing lands. The amendment would require land to be sold at fair
market value instead of $1.25 per acre as under the bill.” The amendment passed 246-183. [HR 2130,
Voted For Selling 30,000 Acres Of Federal Lands Along The Red River
Voted For Selling 30,000 Acres Of Federal Landl Along The Red River. In December 2015, Katko
voted for a bill “that would require the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to sell roughly 30,000 acres
of federal land along the Red River on the border between Texas and Oklahoma to current and adjacent
landowners. The bill would require the BLM to sell at $1.25 per acre, with no cap on the amount an
individual can buy. After the boundary between public and private land is settled, BLM would be required
to sell the remaining federal land along the Red River at no less than fair market value, with adjacent
landowners given the right of first refusal.” The bill passed 253-177. [HR 2130, Vote #686, 12/8/15; CQ
Other
Voted For Requiring Agency Rulemakers To Consider Low-Income Populations
Voted For Requiring Agency Rulemakers To Consider Low-Income Populations. In January 2015,
Katko voted for an amendment “that would require agencies to review the potential effects of new rules
on low-income populations.” The amendment passed 254 to 168. [HR 185, Vote #23, 1/13/15; The Hill,
1/13/15]
Voted For Increasing Review Of SBA Regulations, Expand Right To Challenge New Rules
303
Voted For Increasing Review Of SBA Regulations, Expand Right To Challenge New Rules. In
February 2015, Katko voted for the Small Business Regulatory Flexibility Improvements Act of 2015 to
“give the Small Business Administration more authority to ensure federal agencies grant small businesses
flexibility in following regulations… Under the bill, the SBA would have new authority to ensure
agencies comply with the law's regulatory review requirements, including by getting more directly
involved with agency reviews of proposed rules. It would expand the ability of small businesses and other
small entities affected by an agency's regulations to legally challenge those rules.” The bill passed 260 to
163. [HR 527, Vote #68, 2/05/15; CQ News, 2/05/15]
Voted For Consideration Of Bill Opposed By Trucker Safety Groups That Eliminated Industry
Safety Regulations
Voted For Consideration Of Appropriations Bill Providing For $55 Billion In Funding For The
Departments Of Transportation, And Housing And Urban Development. In June 2015, Katko voted
for a resolution providing for the consideration of H.R. 2557 and H.R. 2578. According to CQ Bill Track,
“A resolution providing for consideration of HR 2577, a bill making appropriations for the Departments
of Transportation, and Housing and Urban Development, and related agencies for the fiscal year ending
Sept. 30, 2015, and for other purposes, and providing for consideration of HR 2578, bill making
appropriations for the Departments of Commerce and Justice, Science and related agencies for the fiscal
year ending Sept. 30, 2015, and for other purposes.” According to the Hill, “The House is scheduled to
vote Tuesday on a $55 billion Republican funding bill for the departments of Transportation, and Housing
and Urban Development. The measure, which is known as THUD, provides $55.3 billion in funding the
departments of Transportation, and Housing and Urban Development, which is a $1.5 billion increase
over the agencies' current 2015 spending levels.” The bill passed 242 to 180. [H. Res. 287, Vote #268,
6/02/15; CQ Bill Track, 6/01/15; The Hill, 6/09/15]
Appropriations Bill Opposed By Trucker Safety Groups For Eliminating Industry Safety
Regulations. “President Obama is threatening to veto a $55 billion Republican funding bill for the
departments of Transportation, and Housing and Urban Development. The White House said Tuesday
that Obama would reject the measure, which is known as THUD, on the grounds that it underfunds
federal transportation and housing programs, and includes a number of policy riders involving travel
restrictions between the U.S. and Cuba, and truck driver scheduling. … Truck safety groups have
accused GOP lawmakers of using the appropriations process to undo a series of trucking regulations
they say makes U.S. roads safer, including limits on the length and weight of trucks. Trucking
companies have opposed these limits for years.” [The Hill, 6/02/15]
Voted For Requiring Federal Agencies To Post Data And Cost-Benefit Analysis Relating To
Federal Rule Changes Online
Voted For Requiring Federal Agencies To Post Data And Cost-Benefit Analysis Relating To
Federal Rule Changes Online. In November 2015, Katko voted for an amendment, “that would require,
for each publication in the Federal Register related to a rule that would be required under the measure, the
inclusion by the agency of information on which the rule is based, including data, studies and cost-benefit
analyses. It also would need to identify how the public can access the information online.” The
amendment passed 236-192. [HR 22, Vote #617, 11/04/15; CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
304
Voted Against Removing Requirement That Federal Agencies File Monthly Rule-Making Status
Reports
Voted Against Removing Requirement That Federal Agencies File Monthly Rule-Making Status
Reports. In January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment that would remove from HR 712, the
Sunshine for Regulatory Decrees and Settlements Act, the requirement that federal agencies file monthly
status reports of their rule-making activities. “The bill is intended to limit special interest groups’ ability
to push federal agencies to adopt rules through litigation by prohibiting the same-day filing of complaints,
pre-negotiated consent decrees and settlement agreements in cases seeking to compel agency action …
The White House said this week that the president would veto both bills because they would limit
authority federal agencies have to issue rules.” The amendment failed 174-244. [HR 712, Vote #8,
1/07/16; CQ, 1/07/16; The Hill, 1/07/16]
Voted Against Exempting Rules The OMB Determines Would Create Jobs From Actions That May
Delay The Rulemaking Process
Voted Against Exempting Rules The OMB Determines Would Create Jobs From Actions That May
Delay The Rulemaking Process. In January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to HR 712, the
Sunshine for Regulatory Decrees and Settlements Act, proposed by Rep. Hank Johnson. When
introducing the amendment Johnson said, “H.R. 712 would significantly delay and possibly stop the
Federal rulemaking process by making it easier for regulated industries and well-funded antiregulatory
entities to delay or prevent agency action and prohibiting any rule from being finalized until certain
information is posted online for 6 months. This assault on the regulations is based on the false premise
that Federal regulation stifles economic growth and job creation. My amendment confronts this fallacious
assumption by excepting from H.R. 712 all rules that the Office of Management and Budget determines
would result in net job creation.” The amendment failed 175-242. [HR 712, Vote #7, 1/07/16;
Congressional Record, 1/07/16]
Voted For Exempting Claims Seeking Monetary Relief Under Civil Rights Act
Voted For Exempting Claims Seeking Monetary Relief Under Civil Rights Act. In January 2016,
Katko voted foran amendment that “would exempt claims seeking monetary relief under Title VII of the
Civil Rights Act.” The amendment failed, 163-221. [HR 1927, Vote #24, 1/08/16; CQ Floor Votes,
1/08/16]
Voted For Exempting Claims Against Perpetrator Of Terrorist Attack By Victims Of Attack
Voted For Exempting Claims Against Perpetrator Of Terrorist Attack By Victims Of Attack. In
January 2016, Katko voted for an amendment that “would exempt claims against the perpetrator of a
terrorist attack by victims of the attack.” The amendment failed, 158-211. [HR 1927, Vote #23, 1/08/16;
Voted For Establishing “Cut-Go” To Require Agencies To Repeal Existing Rules Before Issuing
New Ones
305
Voted For Establishing “Cut-Go” To Require Agencies To Repeal Existing Rules Before Issuing
New Ones. In January 2016, Katko voted fora bill that “would establish a nine-member commission to
review existing federal regulations and identify regulations that should be repealed on the basis of
reducing costs on the U.S. economy. The commission would identify those regulatory policies that should
be repealed immediately, and would set up a "Cut-Go" system that would require agencies to repeal
existing rules to offset costs before issuing a new rule. The measure, as amended, would require the
commission to review a rule or regulation's unfunded mandate, whether the rule or regulation limits or
prevents government agencies from adopting technology to improve efficiency, and the rule or
regulation's impact on wage growth, when determining if the rule or regulation should be repealed.” The
bill passed, 245-174. [HR 1155, Vote #20, 1/07/16; CQ Floor Votes, 1/07/16]
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt FDA Consumer Safety Rules From The SCRUB Act
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt FDA Consumer Safety Rules From The SCRUB Act. In
January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to the Searching for and Cutting Regulations that are
Unnecessarily Burdensome (SCRUB) Act that would “exempt rules issued by the Food and Drug
Administration concerning consumer safety.” The amendment was rejected 173-245. [HR 1155, Vote
#18, 1/07/16; CQ Floor Votes, 2/02/16]
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt DHS Rules From The SCRUB Act
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt DHS Rules From The SCRUB Act. In January 2016,
Katko voted against an amendment to the Searching for and Cutting Regulations that are Unnecessarily
Burdensome (SCRUB) Act that would “exempt rules issued by the Homeland Security Department.” The
amendment was rejected 173-244. [HR 1155, Vote #17, 1/07/16; CQ Floor Votes, 2/02/16]
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt Rules Issued In Response To Emergencies From The
SCRUB Act
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt Rules Issued In Response To Emergencies From The
SCRUB Act. In January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to the Searching for and Cutting
Regulations that are Unnecessarily Burdensome (SCRUB) Act that would “exempt rules issued in
response to an emergency.” The amendment was rejected 176-239. [HR 1155, Vote #16, 1/07/16; CQ
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt Veterans’ Affairs Department Rules From The SCRUB
Act
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt Veterans’ Affairs Department Rules From The SCRUB
Act. In January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to the Searching for and Cutting Regulations
that are Unnecessarily Burdensome (SCRUB) Act that would “exempt rules issued by the Veterans'
Affairs Department.” The amendment was rejected 176-241. [HR 1155, Vote #15, 1/07/16; CQ Floor
Votes, 2/02/16]
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt Rules Issued By Independent Establishments From The
SCRUB Act
306
Voted Against An Amendment To Exempt Rules Issued By Independent Establishments From The
SCRUB Act. In January 2016, Katko voted against an amendment to the Searching for and Cutting
Regulations that are Unnecessarily Burdensome (SCRUB) Act that would “exempt rules issued by
independent establishments from the bill's provisions.” The amendment was rejected 172-244. [HR 1155,
307
Senior’s Issues
 Said he would oppose any budget that cut Medicare or Social Security and
opposed the Ryan Plan for Medicare Vouchers, but suggested cutting Social
Security and Medicare for younger people
 Lauded the Doc-Fix as proof Congress could get something done
In a 2014 debate, Katko declared, “I am going to vote ‘no’ against any budget that
has cuts to Medicare or Social Security, period.” Katko opposed the FY2015 Ryan
Plan for Medicare vouchers. However, Katko has proposed at least partially
privatizing Social Security and proposed cuts for Social Security and Medicare for
younger people.
Katko has lauded the Doc-Fix legislation as proof Congress could get things done.
Entitlements
Opposed The FY15 Ryan Plan For Medicare Vouchers Or Cutting Retiree Benefits Under Any
Circumstance
Opposed The FY15 Ryan Plan For Medicare Vouchers Or Cutting Retiree Benefits Under Any
Circumstance. “Here’s a look at where U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei and challenger John Katko stand on some
of the issues in their campaign for the 24th Congressional District seat. Compiled by Washington
correspondent Mark Weiner. JOHN KATKO … MEDICARE Opposes Rep. Paul Ryan’s plan that
encourages future recipients under age 55 to buy private health insur-ance using government-funded
vouchers. He says benefits should not be reduced for current retirees or those nearing retirement under
any circumstances. He is open to the idea of reducing costs by cutting future benefits for younger peo-ple
entering the workforce.” [Post Standard, 11/02/14]
Suggested At Least Partially Privatizing Social Security, And Incentivizing Private Retirement
Accounts For Younger Workers
Supported At Least Partial Social Security Privatization. In response to the Project Vote Smart
Political Courage, Katko answered “Yes” to the question, “Do you support allowing individuals to divert
a portion of their Social Security taxes into personal retirement accounts?” [votesmart.org, accessed
10/09/15]
Suggested Incentivizing Private Retirement Accounts For Younger Workers, While Suggesting
That Those At Or Near Retirement Shouldn’t Be Subject To Change. “Katko expressed support for
changes that would impact those who are younger and have time to plan for retirement. He said giving
308
these individuals incentive to have separate accounts to save up money for retirement is a ‘good thing.’
But he reiterated that individuals who are at or near retirement shouldn’t be subjected to any changes.”
Said There Was A Moral Obligation To Fund Medicare And Social Security, But Opposed Raising
Taxes To Do So, But Wouldn’t Rule Out Raising Taxes To Do So
Said There Was A Moral Obligation To Fund Medicare, Social Security. “Also, Medicare and Social
Security funding are serious concerns. We have a moral obligation to keep our promises to the citizens
made by our predecessor administrations. These problems will not be wished away or disappear by
themselves.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Opposed Raising Taxes For Entitlements, Refused To Specify What Age Groups Would See
Diminished Entitlements. “’I don't favor anything that raises taxes,’ Katko said. He said ‘anyone at or
near retirement age should not face cuts’ in their benefits. He would not specify what age groups would
be acceptable for diminished or changed benefits.” [Syracuse Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Said He Would Never Say Never To Raising Taxes For Entitlements. “GR: So you have brought up a
few ‘third rails’ in American politics: You’ve mentioned your openness to thinking about the entitlement
programs. The other one of course is taxes. So are you open to thinking about different kinds of revenue
sources that might help to fix this problem? JK: I am never going to say never to anything, but I don’t
think that it should even be remotely discussed unless we’re in a crisis mode. I don’t want it to be said
that at the end of this discussion, I meant to say higher taxes. No way! I think that has always been the
easy way out. The hard way out is to roll up our sleeves like our forefathers did and make the tough
decisions.” [Interview, Syracuse New Times, 5/28/14]
Promised To Vote No On Any Budget That Cut Medicare Or Social Security, But Proposed Cutting
Medicare And Social Security For Young People To “Fix” The Programs
Said He Would Vote No On Any Budget That Had Cuts To Medicare Or Social Security. “John
Katko (JK): … I would vote ‘no’ on principles, on that budget, which included ... I would have the
courage to stand against my party. Let me finish, Mr. Maffei, and calm down. I am going to vote ‘no’
against any budget that has cuts to Medicare or Social Security, period.” [Debate Transcript, Syracuse
Proposed Cutting Medicare And Social Security For Young People. “One of the fun-damental things I
think is important is that if you have planned your life and your budgets around Medicaid or Medicare or
Social Security, in particular, you can’t go and on the eve of someone retiring, on the eve of someone
taking advantage of those programs, to yank the rug out from underneath them. … Maybe it’s doing
something with the benefits for people coming into the system early on so that they know, 30 years down
the road, things aren’t going to be like what they were for my parents, so I’ll be able to plan for that.
Maybe that’s what we need to do. But if we don’t start doing that soon, I’m concerned that those
programs are going to go away.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Said He Wanted To Fix Entitlements By Cutting Them. “Maybe it’s doing something with the benefits
for people coming into the system early on so that they know, 30 years down the road, things aren’t going
to be like what they were for my parents, so I’ll be able to plan for that. Maybe that’s what we need to do.
309
But if we don’t start doing that soon, I’m concerned that those programs are going to go away. … If we
kept going on that course, they would ensure that those programs wouldn’t be here because they’re not
sustaina-ble long-term. We want to fix them and make sure they are sustainable long-term. That’s the only
difference. And using scare tactics like we want to throw grandma out in a snow bank, that’s immoral
because that’s not what we’re trying to do. We’re trying to fix it so, long term, the people that need these
programs have them.” [Interview, The Citizen, 5/15/14]
Criticized The Great Society, Said Real Change Won’t Come From Washington Money
Criticized The Great Society, Said Real Change Won’t Come From Washington Money. “President
Barack Obama has called for a ‘massive investment in urban communities.’ But since the creation of the
Great Society by President Lyndon Johnson in the 1960s with his declaration of the war on poverty and
the resulting influx of new federal departments and programming, things have gotten worse, not better.
Real change won’t come from Washington money ... it hasn’t yet. Real change must come from within
our own community.” [Katko Op-Ed, Post Standard, 7/19/15]
Opposed Making Social Security A Voucher System
Said He Opposed Making Social Security A Voucher System. “Katko’s pledge includes six main
points. While it’s lacking specifics, he vowed to protect retirement security, supports legislation to
preserve Social Security and opposes making Social Security a voucher system.” [The Citizen, 9/16/14]
Said He Would Restore The $700 Billion In Medicare Cost Savings From The ACA
Said He Would Restore The $700 Billion In Medicare Cost Savings From The Affordable Care Act.
“Along with the focus on Social Security, Katko also said he would aim to restore more than $700 billion
in cuts made to Medicare as a result of the Affordable Care Act. The cuts, as Politifact has highlighted in
its multiple fact checks, don’t impact benefits or the program. But Republicans have used the cuts to rail
against the Affordable Care Act.” [The Citizen, 9/16/14]
Lauded The Doc Fix Bill, Said It Proved Congress Could Get Things Done
Lauded The Doc Fix. “With feedback from the vast infrastructure of local doctors, hospitals, and
healthcare centers in NY-24, Katko supported passage of a significant bipartisan compromise to
permanently replace the flawed Medicare Sustainable Growth Rate (SGR) formula with a more stable,
long-term physician payment system that rewards quality care.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 4/17/15]
Lauded The Doc Fix As Proof Congress Could Get Things Done. “‘I commend my colleagues on both
sides of the aisle for their commitment to improving access to care for those dependent on Medicare,” said
Rep. Katko. ‘This legislation will ensure Central New York seniors can access their doctors and will
improve their quality of care.’ Since 2003, the SGR formula has been ignored and overridden by
Congress with a so-called ‘Doc Fix’ on 17 separate occasions, freezing physician payment rates each year
and adding more spending and new programs. H.R. 2 reforms the Medicare payment system by
encouraging high-quality patient care while providing protections for hospitals. ‘Today’s legislation is not
only a historic landmark for the American healthcare system but also a sign that Congress is still capable
of working in a bipartisan manner to get things done.’” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 3/27/15]
310
Voted For Jeopardizing Social Security
Voted For Jeopardizing Social Security. In January 2015, Katko voted for a House Rules package that
contained a provision that could threaten benefit cuts to Social Security. The provision would block
Congress from redirecting payroll tax revenue from Social Security to the Social Security disability
program to help keep the program afloat. The provision would block a transfer unless it was part of a
larger plan to address Social Security’s finances through benefit cuts or tax increases. The resolution
passed, 234-172. [H Res 5, Vote #6, 1/06/15; Politico, 1/20/15]
Eleven Million Recipients Of Disability Benefits Faced A 19 Percent Benefit Cut. “The GOP’s
immediate target is Social Security’s sprawling disability insurance program, which has grown at a
pace far beyond its revenues and will exhaust its trust fund reserves by December 2016, threatening a
19 percent cut in benefits.” [Politico, 1/20/15]
Eleven Million People Receive Disability Benefits. “About 11 million people get disability benefits,
nearly 40 percent more than a decade ago.” [Associated Press, 1/07/15]
Other
Said He Would Assist Meals On Wheels. “Katko also said he would fight tax increases and support progrowth policies in Congress. And he would assist Meals on Wheels and other programs available for
seniors.” [The Citizen, 9/16/14]
Voted Against Measure To Prevent Financial Companies That Harm Seniors From Using Any
Emergency Lending Program Established By The Federal Reserve
Voted Against Measure To Prevent Financial Companies That Harm Seniors From Using Any
Emergency Lending Program Established By The Federal Reserve. In November 2015, Katko voted
against for a Democratic Motion to Recommit that “would ensure that financial companies found to
engage in activity that harms seniors’ financial health and stability are prevented from participating in any
emergency lending program or facility established by the Federal Reserve.” The motion to recommit
failed in the House, 182 - 242. [HR 3189, Vote #640, 11/19/15; Motion to Recommit, 11/19/15]
311
Small Business
 Voted to protect the requirement that agencies provide regulatory cost-benefit
analysis at congressional request
Katko voted against eliminating the requirement that agencies provide regulatory
cost-benefit analysis at Congressional request.
Supported The Small Business Tax Relief Act And The Small Business Regulatory Flexibility
Improvements Act
Declared Support For The Small Business Tax Relief Act And The Small Business Regulatory
Flexibility Improvements Act. “In addition to taking key votes to reform Obamacare and providing
outspoken support for repealing the Medical Device tax, Rep. Katko has supported legislation to make
doing business easier, including the Small Business Tax Relief Act and the Small Business Regulatory
Flexibility Improvements Act.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 4/17/15]
Voted Against Repealing Statutory Changes Of Bill If Less Than 5% GDP Growth In First Year
After Enactment
Voted Against Repealing Statutory Changes Of Bill If GDP Growth Remained Under 5% First
Year After Enactment. In February 2015, Katko voted against Connolly of Virginia Part C Amendment
No. 3, an amendment to the Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency Act of 2015 that would
“provide that in the event that the average annual rate of real gross domestic product (GDP) growth
remains below 5 percent over the first four calendar quarters occurring after the date of enactment of H.R.
50, then the statutory changes made by the bill would be repealed.” HR 50 itself “would expand and
modify the 1995 Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (PL 104-4) that requires all federal agencies to consult
with the private sector when developing rules... The measure would extend judicial review of agency rules
and permit a court to stay, enjoin or invalidate a rule if an agency fails to complete the required UMRA
analysis or adhere to the regulatory principles.” The amendment failed 173 to 249. [HR 50, Vote #62,
2/04/15; Congress.gov, 2/04/15; CQ News HR 50 Coverage, 2/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Requirement That Agencies Provide Regulatory CostBenefit Analysis At Congressional Request
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Requirement That Agencies Provide Regulatory CostBenefit Analysis At Congressional Request. In February 2015, Katko voted against Cummings of
Maryland Part C Amendment No. 2, an amendment to the Unfunded Mandates Information and
Transparency Act of 2015 that would “strike section 12 of the bill, which would require Federal agencies
to conduct a retrospective cost-benefit analysis of any regulation at the request of the Chairman or
312
Ranking Member of a Congressional Committee.” The amendment failed 179 to 245. [HR 50, Vote #61,
2/04/15; Congress.gov, 2/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Striking Provision In Bill Which Allowed SBA’s Chief Counsel
Authority To Set Small Business Size Qualifications
Voted Against Amendment Striking Provision In Bill Which Allowed SBA’s Chief Counsel To Set
Size Small Business Size Standards. . In February 2015, Katko voted against Schrader of Oregon Part A
Amendment No. 4, an amendment to the Small Business Regulatory Flexibility Improvements Act of
2015 that would strike a provision in the bill that would provide the Small Business Administration's chief
counsel with authority to set size standards for small businesses and approve such standards. The
amendment failed 184 to 234. [HR 527, Vote #65, 2/05/15; CQ]
313
Tax Issues
 Campaigned saying he had no intent to cut taxes for billionaires, but voted to
repeal the estate tax.
 Called for cutting taxes for corporations
 Called for unspecified tax reforms, including reducing loopholes
Katko campaigned saying he had no intent to cut taxes for billionaires, but voted to
repeal the estate tax. The estate tax effects the top .2% of estates, roughly six
thousand families in the country.
Katko called for reducing the corporate income tax.
Katko has advocated for unspecified tax reform.
Estate Tax
Voted For Repealing Federal Estate Tax
Voted For Repealing Estate Tax. In April 2015, Katko voted for repealing the estate tax. “The measure
also would repeal the generation-skipping transfer tax and reduce the top marginal rate for the federal gift
tax from 40 percent to 35 percent.” The bill passed, 240-179. [HR 1105, Vote #161, 4/16/15; CQ News,
4/16/15]
USA Today: “Repealing Estate Tax Would Reward .2%.” “Of the nearly 3 million Americans
who die every year, only about two-tenths of 1% have enough assets to qualify. It's a rather exclusive
group. This isn't to disparage people who worked hard enough (or, in some cases, were lucky enough)
to have estates that big. It's just that, at a time when income inequality is one of the nation's most
vexing problems, the 0.2% hardly need extra help from Congress.” [Editorial, USA Today, 4/16/15]
CBPP: “Roughly 2 Of Every 1,000 Estates Face The Estate Tax.” “Today, 99.8 percent of estates
owe no estate tax at all, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation.[3] Only the estates of the
wealthiest 0.2 percent of Americans -- roughly 2 out of every 1,000 people who die -- owe any estate
tax. (See Figure 1.) This is because of the tax's high exemption amount, which has jumped from
$650,000 per person in 2001 to $5.43 million per person in 2015.” [CBPP, “10 Facts You Should
Know About The Federal Estate Tax,” 3/23/15]
314
Bill Impacted Fewer Than 6,000 Families. “This tax is levied on the portion of estates exceeding
$5.43 million per person or $10.86 million per married couple, and because of those exemption levels,
it affects less than 1 percent of estates, or fewer than 6,000 families in 2014.” [Philadelphia Inquirer,
4/19/15]
Bill Would Add $269 Billion To National Debt. “Voting 240 for and 179 against, the House on
April 16 passed a GOP-sponsored bill (HR 1105) that would permanently repeal the federal estate tax
in a way that would add $269 billion to national debt through fiscal 2025.” [Albuquerque Journal,
4/19/15]
Politifact: False – “Estate Tax ‘In Many Cases’ Forces Family Farmers And Small Business
Owners To Sell Their Holdings. “The U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates only 6 tenths of 1
percent of estates with farms qualified for the tax in 2013. The nonpartisan Tax Policy Center
estimates that there were 20 small, closely held farms and businesses that were subject to the tax that
year. It’s unknown how many of them, if any at all, were sold to pay the levy. So Hurt’s statement
comes up empty. We rate it False.” [Politifact, 5/03/15]
Voted For Considering Estate Tax Repeal On House Floor. In April 2015, Katko voted for
considering a bill repealing the federal estate tax on the House floor. The rule was adopted, 242-182.
[HRes 200, Vote #155, 4/15/15; CQ Votes, 4/15/15]
Said He Had No Intention Of Tax Breaks For Billionaires, Said Repealing The Estate Tax Helped
Family Farms And Small Businesses, That Those Who Pay The Estate Tax Are Usually Farmers Or
Small Businesspersons
Said He Had No Intention Of Tax Breaks For Billionaires. “KATKO: … One of the things that drives
me nuts: I have never once said anything about tax breaks for billionaires. I have no idea what the heck
they are talking about. I have never mentioned that and I have no intention of doing that.” [Interview, The
Citizen, 10/04/14]
Said Repealing The Estate Tax Helped Family Farms And Small Businesses. “The House of
Representatives passed the estate tax repeal bill by a vote of 240-179. The measure was supported by 233
Republicans, including all of New York’s GOP members, and seven Democrats. … ‘Family farms and
small businesses are a critical driver of economic growth in central New York,’ Katko said. ‘Many of
these families and small business owners have worked hard for years to pass on opportunity to their
children -- and today’s legislation will prevent them from being penalized at death by onerous tax
regulations.’” [The Citizen, 4/17/15]
Said Those Affected By The Estate Tax Are Often Small Family Farmers Or Small Businessmen.
“Currently, if an individual’s assets exceed the specified federal exemption amount at his or her death,
these assets are taxed at a rate of 40% before they can be passed on to surviving family members. For
Central New Yorkers, these “assets” are often a small business or family farm – and a death tax bill only
makes a family’s loss even more devastating.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 4/16/15]
Other
315
Voted Against Closing Corporate Inversion Tax Loophole To Fund Investments In U.S.
Transportation Infrastructure
Voted Against Closing Corporate Inversion Tax Loophole To Fund Investments In U.S.
Transportation Infrastructure. In July 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit that “would
help improve America’s roads, bridges, and highways by stopping corporations that seek to avoid paying
their fair share of taxes by moving their business address to another country. Instead, those reclaimed
resources will be invested in much-needed American transportation infrastructure improvements.” The
motion was rejected by a vote of 185-244. [HR 3038, Vote #440, 7/15/2015; Democratic Leader –
Supported Lowering Corporate Income Tax Rates
In a July 2014 interview, Katko told the Post-Standard that he supports closing tax loopholes for
businesses while lowering corporate income tax rates. He declined to specify which loopholes he would
close or what corporate tax rate he would support. [Post-Standard, 7/21/14]
Said the Tax System had Too Many Loopholes, was Too Complex
In April 2014, Katko said, “We also need to address the tax codes. The codes have too many loopholes
and are far too complex. While we all have an obligation to pay fair taxes, we shouldn’t need to be a CPA
to file our personal taxes.” [Eagle Bulletin, 4/09/14]
Said Some Corporations, Including General Electric, Would Pay “A Heck Of A Lot More Taxes”
By Closing Loopholes
Said He Wanted To Raise Taxes On General Electric “A Heck Of A Lot” By Closing Loopholes.
“KATKO: … As a matter of fact, my tax proposal to lower the tax rate for businesses, especially
manufacturers and small businesses, would be coupled with closing the loopholes so some corporations
would pay a heck of a lot more taxes than they are currently paying. For example, General Electric. That’s
only fair.” [Interview, The Citizen, 10/04/14]
Advocated Making The Research And Experimentation Tax Credit Permanent
Advocated Making The Research And Experimentation Tax Credit Permanent. “Katko, R-Camillus
also endorsed making the Research and Experimentation Tax Credit permanent and offering tax
incentives to companies who promote flexibility in the workforce by allowing employees to telecommute
or work flexi-ble hours.” [The Citizen, 9/24/14]
Said He Would “Never … Say Never” With Respect To Raising Revenue For Entitlements, Said It
Shouldn’t Be “Remotely Discusses Unless We’re In A Crisis Mode”
Said He Would Never Say Never To Raising Taxes For Entitlements. GR: So you have brought up a
few ‘third rails’ in American politics: You’ve mentioned your openness to thinking about the entitlement
programs. The other one of course is taxes. So are you open to thinking about different kinds of revenue
sources that might help to fix this problem? JK: I am never going to say never to anything, but I don’t
316
think that it should even be remotely discussed unless we’re in a crisis mode. I don’t want it to be said
that at the end of this discussion, I meant to say higher taxes. No way! I think that has always been the
easy way out. The hard way out is to roll up our sleeves like our forefathers did and make the tough
decisions. [Interview, Syracuse New Times, 5/28/14]
Voted Against Preventing Tax Deductions For Executive Bonuses Exceeding $1 Million
Voted Against Preventing Tax Deductions For Executive Bonuses Exceeding $1 Million. In January
2015, Katko voted against a motion that would prevent companies from claiming tax deductions for
executive bonuses exceeding $1 million if they failed to give lower level employees raises to match
increases in the cost of living. The motion failed, 168-243. [H Res 5, Vote #5, 1/06/15; CQ Floor Votes,
1/06/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill Preventing U.S. Corporations From Moving Overseas To
Dodge Paying Taxes. In January 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of the Stop Corporate
Expatriation and Invest in America’s Infrastructure Act, a bill that would prevent U.S. corporations from
moving overseas to dodge taxes. “The second is an infrastructure bill that would stop corporations from
relocating abroad and redirect tax money lost through these so-called inversions to infrastructure projects
in the U.S. That money would be sent to the highway trust fund.” The previous question passed, 239 to
168. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 5, Vote
#4, 1/06/15; Politico, 1/05/15; Congressional Record, 1/06/15]
Voted Against Preventing Giving Tax Benefits To Those Convicted Of Tax Fraud
Voted Against Preventing Giving Inheritance Tax Benefits To Those Convicted Of Tax Evasion Or
Fraud. In April 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit that would have prevented giving
inheritance tax benefits to those convicted of tax evasion or fraud. The motion “would disqualify from the
bill's provisions individuals convicted of attempting to evade the gift tax or before the bill's enactment
engaged in a transaction with intent to evade the estate tax.” The motion failed, 186-232. [HR 1105, Vote
#160, 4/16/15; CQ Votes, 4/16/15]
Voted For Permanently Allowing Taxpayers To Deduct State And Local Sales Taxes
Voted For Permanently Allowing Taxpayers To Deduct State And Local Sales Taxes. In April 2015,
Katko voted for a bill “that would make permanent the ability of taxpayers to deduct state and local sales
taxes in lieu of state and local income taxes, which expired at the end of 2014. The measure would be
effective for tax years beginning with 2015.” The bill passed, 272-152. [HR 622, Vote #159, 4/16/15; CQ
News, 4/16/15]
Bill Not Paid For, Would Add $42 Billion To National Debt. “Because the bill is not paid for, it
would add $42 billion to national debt through fiscal 2025.” [Albuquerque Journal, 4/19/15]
Voted For Considering State And Local Sales Tax Deduction Fairness Act On House Floor. In April
2015, Katko voted for considering the State and Local Sales Tax Deduction Fairness Act of 2015 on the
House floor. The rule was adopted, 242-182. [HRes 200, Vote #155, 4/15/15; CQ Votes, 4/15/15]
317
Voted Against Requiring State & Local Tax Deduction Legislation To Not Increase Deficit Or
Delay Comprehensive Tax Reform
Voted Against Requiring State & Local Tax Deduction Legislation To Not Increase Deficit Or
Delay Comprehensive Tax Reform. In April 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would prevent
deficit increases or delays in overall tax reform as a result of state & local tax deduction legislation. The
motion also provided a one year extension of a state and local sales tax deduction rather than a permanent
extension to make sure Congress could perform fiscally responsible tax extensions. The motion failed,
179-243. [HR 622, Vote #158, 4/16/15; CQ News, 4/16/15]
Voted For Making Individuals With Delinquent Tax Debt Ineligible For Federal Employment
Voted For Making Individuals With Severely Delinquent Tax Debt Ineligible For Federal
Employment. In April 2015, Katko voted for a bill that would make individuals with “seriously
delinquent tax debt” ineligible for federal employment, and would include existing federal employees.
The bill failed, 266-160. A two thirds majority was required to pass the bill, under suspension of the rules.
[HR 1563, Vote #157, 4/15/15; CQ News, 4/15/15]
Bill Opponents Noted That Tax Compliance Rate Was 97 Percent For Civil Servants.
“Opponents noted in debate that the tax compliance rate for civil servants was 97 percent in 2014,
compared to 95 percent for House members and their staffs and 91 percent for the public at large.
Civil servants owed $1.14 billion in delinquent taxes last year.” [Bakersfield Californian, 4/18/15]
Voted For Research Tax Credits
Voted For Permanent Research And Tax Development Tax Credit. In May 2015, Katko voted for the
American Research Competitiveness Act of 2015. “H.R. 880, the American Research and
Competitiveness Act of 2015 (Brady) to simplify and make the research & development tax credit
permanent.” The bill passed 274 to 145. [HR 880, Vote #260, 5/20/15; Roll Call, 5/01/15]
Voted Against Extending Research Tax Credit By Two Years And Preventing Deficit Increase. In
May 2015, Katko voted against a motion to recommit with instructions for the American Research Act of
2015. “Motion to recommit the bill to the House Ways and Means Committee with instructions to report
back immediately with an amendment that would remove the bill's proposal to make permanent the
research and development tax credit that expired at the end of calendar year 2014, and change the way
elements of the credit are calculated. The bill would replace those provisions with language that would
extend the credit for two years and would state that the bill shall not result in increasing the deficit or
delaying or weakening efforts to adopt a permanent extension of the research credit in a ‘fiscally
responsible manner.’” The motion failed, 181-240. [HR 880, Vote #259, 5/20/15; CQ, 5/22/15]
Voted Against Motion To Analyze Long-Term Impact Of Special Interest Tax Loopholes
Voted Against Motion To Analyze Long-Term Impact Of Tax Loopholes. In February 2016, Katko
voted against on the motion to recommit on legislation to analyze “the long-term impact that tax
loopholes abused by special interests have on American businesses, American workers, and our
economy.” The motion failed, 179 to 238. [HR 3442, Vote #75, 2/11/16; Democratic Leader, 2/11/16]
318
Trade
 Supported the Export-Import Bank and signed the discharge petition to bring the
reauthorization bill to the floor for a vote; however, he voted to block
consideration of the reauthorization bill
 Voted against Trade Promotion Authority, said he was leaning towards voting
against the Trans Pacific Partnership
Katko supported the Export-Import Bank reauthorization, and though he voted to
block the bill from consideration, he signed the discharge petition to bring the
reauthorization bill to the floor for a vote.
Katko voted against Trade Promotion Authority and has said he is leaning towards
voting against the Trans Pacific Partnership.
Export-Import Bank
Signed The Discharge Petition On The Export-Import Bank, Said It Was A “Good Bill;”
Acknowledged The Delay In Reauthorization Was Costing Jobs
Signed The Discharge Petition On The Export-Import Bank, Said It Was A “Good Bill.” “U.S. Rep.
John Katko was one of the Republicans who signed the discharge petition. At the time, he said there were
central New York manufacturers urging him to reauthorize the Export-Import Bank. ‘It’s a good bill and
it’s a bank that makes a profit and businesses are paying into it,’ he said in October. ‘I think we have to do
it to try and get things moving again. Again, it’s about governing. It’s not about stopping things. It’s about
moving things.’” [The Citizen, 12/02/15]
Signed The Discharge Petition For The Bill Reauthorizing The Export-Import Bank, Noting That
The Delay In Reauthorization Was Costing Jobs. “More than 40 Republicans, including nearly all of
New York ‘s House GOP delegation, joined Democrats in signing a discharge petition that will force a
vote later this month on legislation to reauthorize the Export-Import Bank. … ‘It was held up in
committee for a year and a half,’ he said. ‘Meanwhile, GE, who has jobs in eve-ryone’s district in upstate
New York, as an example, was starting to cut jobs in this country and they were going to cut a lot more.
They need it.’ If GE cuts jobs, Katko said that would have an impact on smaller businesses that provide
parts and supplies to the large corporation.” [The Citizen, 10/14/15]
Said He Supported The Export-Import Bank And Didn’t View It As “Corporate Welfare”
319
Said He Supported The Export-Import Bank And Didn’t View It As “Corporate Welfare.” “It has
been more than a month since the Export-Import Bank’s authorization expired. The agency, which
provides American exporters with credit and other financial resources, won’t be able to provide services
to U.S. companies until Congress reauthorizes its charter. Some members of Congress oppose
reauthorizing the Export-Import Bank. But U.S. Rep. John Katko believes the bank is a necessity. ‘I am
for the Ex-Im Bank,’ he said in an interview Tuesday. ‘I think a lot of individuals think that it’s corporate
welfare, but I don’t see it that way.’” [The Citizen, 8/05/15]
Signed Discharge Petition To Bring Reauthorization Of The Export-Import Bank To The Floor
Signed A Discharge Petition To Bring Reauthorization Of The Export-Import Bank To The Floor.
“More than 40 Republicans, including nearly all of New York's House GOP delegation, joined Democrats
in signing a discharge petition that will force a vote later this month on legislation to reauthorize the
Export-Import Bank. … One of the Republicans who signed the petition was U.S. Rep. John Katko. He
has stated his support for the bank in the past and disagrees with critics who say it's corporate welfare.
Katko, R-Camillus, said in an interview Friday that the bank's reauthorization should go to the House
floor for a vote. ‘It was held up in committee for a year and a half,’ he said. ‘Meanwhile, GE, who has
jobs in everyone's district in upstate New York, as an example, was starting to cut jobs in this country and
they were going to cut a lot more. They need it.’” [The Citizen, 10/14/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Re-Authorize Export-Import Bank
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Re-Authorize Export-Import Bank. In March 2015,
Katko voted for blocking consideration of a bill to “force an immediate vote to re-authorize the ExportImport Bank, a self-funded agency that provides certainty and support to American businesses and creates
American jobs.” The previous question passed 233 to 181. A vote against the previous question would
have allowed the bill to be considered. [H Res 152, Vote #126, 3/19/15; 114th Congress Previous
Questions, 3/19/15]
Voted For Blocking Vote On Reauthorization of Export-Import Bank
Voted For Blocking Vote On Immediate Reauthorization Of Export-Import Bank. In June 2015,
Katko voted for blocking a vote to re-authorize the Export-Import bank. Congressional Republicans failed
to take action and the bank’s charter expired. [H Res 319, Vote #371, 6/17/15; USA Today, 7/01/15;
House Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, accessed 7/8/15]
Voted For Consideration Of Bill To Re-Authorize The Export-Import Bank
Voted For Consideration Of Bill To Re-Authorize The Export-Import Bank. In June 2015, Katko
voted for consideration of a bill to re-authorize the Export-Import Bank. “The Democratic Previous
Question would force a vote to re-authorize the Ex-Im Bank, ending Republicans’ needless crisis.” The
previous question passed 243 to 181. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to
be considered. [H.Res. 333, Vote #379, 6/24/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Renewing The Export-Import Bank
320
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Renewing The Export-Import Bank. In July 2015, Katko voted
for to block consideration of an “amendment to reauthorize the Export-Import Bank.” The previous
question carried, 242-180. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on reauthorization of
the Export-Import Bank. [H Res 388, Vote #483, 7/29/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions,
7/29/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Export-Import Bank Reauthorization
Voted For Blocking Consideration Export-Import Bank Reauthorization. In September 2015, Katko
voted for blocking consideration of a vote to reauthorize the Export-Import Bank. The previous question
carried, 238-179. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on Export Import Bank
Reauthorization. [HR 420, Vote #497, 9/17/15; Congressional Record, 9/17/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration To Re-Authorize The Ex-Im Bank.
Voted For Blocking Consideration To Re-Authorize The Ex-Im Bank. In September 2015, Katko
voted for to block consideration of a vote to “re-authorize the Export-Import Bank, a self-funded agency
that provides certainty and support to American businesses of all sizes that are eager to compete in the
global market.” The previous question carried, 243-183. A vote against the previous question would call
for an immediate vote to re-authorize the Ex-Im Bank. [H Res 421, Vote #502, 9/17/15; Democratic
Leader – Previous Questions, 9/17/15]
Voted For Blocking Reauthorization Of The Ex-Im Bank
Voted For Blocking Reauthorization Of The Ex-Im Bank. In September 2015, Katko voted fora
motion to block consideration of a vote to “re-authorize the Export-Import Bank, a self-funded agency
that provides certainty and support to American businesses of all sizes that are eager to compete in the
global market.” The previous question carried, 243-183. A vote against the previous question would call
for an immediate vote to re-authorize the Ex-Im Bank. [H Res 421, Vote #502, 9/17/15; Democratic
Voted For Block Reauthorization Of Export-Import Bank
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Reauthorizing The Export-Import Bank. In October 2015,
Katko voted for to block consideration of a vote to reauthorization of the Export-Import Bank. The
previous question carried, 237-180. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on
reauthorizing the Export-Import Bank. [H RES 449, Vote #529, 10/01/15; Democratic Leader, Previous
Questions, 10/01/15]
Voted For Bringing A Bill To Reauthorize The Export-Import Bank To The Floor
Voted For Bringing A Bill To Reauthorize The Export-Import Bank To The Floor. In October 2015,
Katko voted for a “motion to discharge from the House Rules Committee and bring to the House floor the
rule (H Res 450) that would provide for House floor consideration of the bill (HR 597) that would
reauthorize the Export-Import Bank through fiscal 2019.” The motion carried 246-177. [HR 597, Vote
#569, 10/23/15; CQ 10/23/15]
321
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Re-Authorization Of Export-Import Bank
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Re-Authorization Of Export-Import Bank. In October 2015,
Katko voted for consideration of the re-authorization of the Export-Import Bank of the United States.
“Providing for the consideration of the bill (H.R. 597) to reauthorize the Export-Import Bank of the
United States, and for other purposes.” The ordering of the previous question carried, 271 to 158.
[H.Res.450, Vote #572, 10/27/15]
Voted For Bill To Re-Authorize The Export-Import Bank
Voted For Bill To Re-Authorize The Export-Import Bank. In October 2015, Katko voted for HR 597.
“Lawmakers are trying to complete work on a long-term bill by Nov. 20, the date the current
authorization expires. Backers of the Ex-Im Bank see attaching its reauthorization (HR 597) to the
highway bill to be the best chance of renewing its charter that expired at the end of June.” The bill passed
313 to 118. [HR 597, Vote #576, 10/27/15; CQ News, 11/5/15]
Bill Was Advanced To Vote By The Little-Used Discharge Petition That Forced House To vote
On The Legislation Against The Wishes Of Party Leadership. “If Republicans aren’t already
divided enough, several dozen party members have signed a petition that will force the House to vote
on whether to revive a controversial government-run bank that helps big American companies sell
goods overseas. Some 41 Republicans signed a so-called discharge petition in an effort to fully reopen
the Export-Import Bank. They joined ranks with nearly all Democrats to meet the 218-vote threshold
required to allow a bill to reach the House floor…. A discharge petition is an obscure technique used
to force a vote on an issue against the wishes of party leadership. They are rarely used and rarely
succeed.” [MarketWatch, 10/09/15]
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Financing Set-Aside For Small Businesses By Ex-Im Bank,
Absence Of Increase Would Temporarily Bar Issuing Guarantees
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Financing Set-Aside For Small Businesses By Ex-Im Bank,
Absence Of Increase Would Temporarily Bar Issuing Guarantees. In November 2015, Katko voted
against an “amendment that would increase by five percent each fiscal year for four years the percent of
financing available to the Export-Import Bank that it is required to set aside for small businesses. Absent
an increase in the set-aside, the bank would be temporarily barred from issuing guarantees, insurance or
credit more than $100 million benefitting one person.” The amendment failed, 121 to 303. [H.R. 22,
Amendment #73, Vote #607, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Prohibiting Ex-Im Bank From “Guaranteeing, Insuring Or Extending
Credit” In Transactions Absent Competition From Foreign Credit Agencies
Voted Against Amendment Prohibiting Ex-Im Bank From “Guaranteeing, Insuring Or Extending
Credit” In Transactions Absent Competition From Foreign Credit Agencies. In November 2015,
Katko voted against an “amendment that would prohibit the Export-Import Bank from guaranteeing,
insuring or extending credit involving transactions that do not meet competition from foreign export
322
credit agencies.” The amendment failed, 117 to 309. [H.R. 22, Amendment #74, Vote #608, 11/04/15;
CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Requiring Ex-Im Financing Recipients Of $10 Million Or More To
Have Been Denied By Private Sector At Least Twice
Voted Against Amendment Requiring Ex-Im Financing Recipients Of $10 Million Or More To
Have Been Denied By Private Sector At Least Twice. In November 2015, Katko voted against an
“amendment that would require recipients of Export-Import Bank financing of more than $10 million to
have been denied financing at least twice by the private sector. It also would institute penalties for
inaccurate claims made by financing recipients about the availability of competing foreign export
financing or private sector financing.” The amendment failed, 124 to 302. [H.R. 22, Amendment #75,
Vote #609, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Prohibiting Ex-Im Financing Of Foreign Companies If Receiving
Foreign Government Support From Country With Sovereign Wealth Fund Value Of $100 Million
Or More
Voted Against Amendment Prohibiting ExIm Financing Of Foreign Companies If Receiving
Foreign Government Support From Country With Sovereign Wealth Fund Value Of $100 Million
Or More. In November 2015, Katko voted against an “amendment that would prohibit the Export-Import
Bank from providing financing to foreign companies that benefit from support from a foreign government
if the foreign government's sovereign wealth funds have a value of more than $100 billion.” The
amendment failed, 116 to 308. [H.R. 22, Amendment #76, Vote #610, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Treasury Department Loss Guarantee For Ex-Im Bank
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Treasury Department Loss Guarantee For Ex-Im Bank. In
November 2015, Katko voted against an “amendment that would eliminate the Treasury Department's
guarantee of losses at the Export-Import Bank.” The amendment failed, 117 to 308. [H.R. 22, Amendment
#77, Vote #611, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Limiting Ex-Im Bank Single Sector Credit Exposure To 20 Percent,
Prohibit Single Person From Benefiting From More Than 10 Percent
Voted Against Amendment Limiting Ex-Im Bank Single Sector Credit Exposure To 20 Percent,
Prohibit Single Person From Benefiting From More Than 10 Percent. In November 2015, Katko
voted against an “amendment that would require the Export-Import Bank's credit exposure in a single
industrial sector to be limited to 20 percent of the bank’s total credit exposure. It also would prohibit the
bank from issuing financing in a fiscal year if doing so would result in a single person benefitting from
more than 10 percent of the total dollar amount of the bank's credit assistance in the fiscal year.” The
amendment failed, 114 to 314. [H.R. 22, Amendment #78, Vote #612, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against Allowing Companies To Appeal Directly To Ex-Im Board Of Directors Regarding
Economic Harm Caused By The Bank’s Transactions
323
Voted Against Allowing Companies To Appeal Directly To Ex-Im Board Of Directors Regarding
Economic Harm Caused By The Bank’s Transactions. In November 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment, “that would allow companies to appeal directly to the Export-Import Bank's board of
directors regarding an allegation that the company would suffer economic harm from a proposed bank
transaction.” The amendment failed 129-298. [HR 22, Vote #616, 11/04/15; CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
Voted Against Requiring The Export-Import Bank To Use Fair Value Accounting Principles In
Financial Statements
Voted Against Requiring The Export-Import Bank To Use Fair Value Accounting Principles In
Financial Statements. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment, “that would require
financial statements of the Export-Import Bank to be in accordance with fair value accounting principles.”
The amendment failed 133-295. [HR 22, Vote #615, 11/04/15; CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
Voted Against Prohibiting The Export-Import Bank From Providing Financing To A Foreign
Borrower Without The US Company Guaranteeing The Loan Be Repaid
Voted Against Prohibiting The Export-Import Bank From Providing Financing To A Foreign
Borrower Without The US Company Guaranteeing The Loan Be Repaid. In November 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment, “that would prohibit the Export-Import Bank from providing financing to a
foreign borrower in connection with the export of goods or services by a U.S. company without a
guarantee from the company of repayment by the foreign borrower, and a pledge of collateral, in certain
percentages specified in the measure. It also would require that the guarantee be senior to any other
obligation. Small businesses would be exempt.” The amendment failed 115-313. [HR 22, Vote #613,
11/04/15; CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
Trans-Pacific Partnership
Objected To The Lack Of Transparency Surrounding The Trans-Pacific Partnership. “Freshman
Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus, said he objected to ceding authority to the president when details of the
Trans-Pacific Partnership remain unknown. ‘If the United States is going to enter into a complex trade
deal that involves a number of different nations, the American public deserves to know what is in the deal,
and to be sold on its merits by the president and others involved in the negotiations,’ Katko said.
‘Unfortunately, this simply has not happened. Despite the importance of this agreement, far too little
detail has been provided by the president.’” [USA Today, 6/12/15]
Said He Was Leaning Against Voting For The TPP. “U.S. Rep. John Katko told reporters Friday that
he's leaning against voting for the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a major trade deal between the United States
and 11 other countries, including Australia and Japan. Katko, R-Camillus, said he's concerned about the
trade agreement's impact on central New York and losing jobs overseas. ‘I'm not sure that this is the best
deal for central New York," Katko said. "I'm leaning that way. I'll see what I turn out on, but I'm leaning
towards no.’” [The Citizen, 4/29/15]
Said He Was Concerned With Giving President Obama Fast Track Authority. “One concern
mentioned by those on both sides of the aisle is giving President Barack Obama too much power by
granting him "fast-track" authority. … Katko said giving Obama that power is a concern. ‘I think that's
324
not a good thing on trade deals,’ he said. ‘Quite frankly, if you have a good president, it's OK. But if you
have a president like we have now who doesn't know how to make a deal, that's not a good thing.’” [The
Citizen, 4/29/15]
Voted For Floor Consideration Of TPA
Voted For Adopt The Rule For Floor Consideration Of TPA. In June 2015. Katko voted for the
“Adoption of the rule (H Res 305) that would provide for House floor consideration of the Senate
amendment to a package (HR 1314) of Trade Promotion Authority and Trade Adjustment Assistance
legislation and provide for floor consideration of the Senate amendments to a customs enforcement
measure (HR 644).” The rule was adopted 217-212. [H. Res. 305, Vote #359; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
Voted Against Granting President Trade Promotion Authority
Voted Against Senate Amendment To Provide Trade Promotion Authority For Trade Agreements
Negotiated By The Administration. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would
provide Trade Promotion Authority (TPA) for trade agreements negotiated by the administration, under
which they would be considered by Congress under expedited procedures without amendment. However,
due to Congress rejecting Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA) in the vote immediately preceding, votes
in favor of TPA were rendered largely irrelevant. “Republicans moved quickly to hold a vote on Trade
Promotion Authority, but even though the bill received a majority of votes, it will not go to the president's
desk because it does not match the Senate-passed package.” The amendment passed 219 to 211. [HR
1314, Vote #362, 6/12/15; The Atlantic, 6/12/15]
Voted Against Granting Trade Promotion Authority
Voted Against Concurring In Senate Amendment To Grant The President Trade Promotion
Authority. In June 2015, Katko voted against Trade Promotion Authority (TPA). “The House on
Thursday took the first step toward resuscitating the White House’s trade agenda by passing legislation
granting President Obama fast-track authority … This is the second time in a week the House has voted to
approve the controversial fast-track bill. On Friday, the House voted 219-211 in favor of fast-track, which
would make it easier for Obama to complete a sweeping trans-Pacific trade deal … House Democrats
have historically favored TAA, but they voted against it on Friday to kill fast-track, which is deeply
opposed by unions and other liberal groups.” The amendment passed 218 to 208. [HR 2146, Vote #374,
6/18/15; The Hill, 6/18/15]
Other
Said He Wasn’t Sure About The Economic Effects Of NAFTA
Said He Wasn’t Sure About The Economic Effects Of NAFTA. “Katko's view is based on the impact
previous trade agreements had on central New York. He mentioned the North American Free Trade
Agreement, a trade deal reached in the mid-1990s between the U.S., Canada and Mexico, and how that
affected the local economy. ‘I've looked at what's happened to the manufacturing base since NAFTA and
it hasn't been pretty,’ he said. ‘Some people say it wasn't because of NAFTA. It was just because of
economic conditions worldwide. I don't necessarily subscribe to that.’” [The Citizen, 4/29/15]
325
Tentatively Supported Lifting The Cuba Embargo And Doing Business With Cuba If The Human
Rights Issues Get “Settled”
Tentatively Supported Lifting The Cuba Embargo And Doing Business With Cuba If The Human
Rights Issues Get “Settled”. “John Katko (JK): … I understand what he did with Cuba, but my biggest
concern is that America is a leader, a watchdog for human rights. Cuba still has substantial human rights
problems. By opening up the ties to Cuba, a lot of people argue, we are saving the communist regime
because they are in dire economic straits. Is that the right thing to do? I don’t know. Nothing we have
done is going to address the human rights issues they still have. From that standpoint, I am concerned.
From a business standpoint, I have heard from business leaders that this could be a great thing. I am still
sorting it out in my mind because it came out of nowhere, but the thing that keeps ringing true to me is the
human rights issues. If we get those settled, I say let’s do business.” [Interview, Syracuse New Times,
1/07/15]
Voted Against Amendment Reducing Funding For International Trade Administration By $312
Million; Opposed By Republican Rep. For Degrading Ability To Fight Against “Unfair Subsidies
Given By Foreign Governments”
Voted Against Amendment Reducing Funding For International Trade Administration By $312
Million. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment which would cut funding to the International
Trade Administration by $312 million in FY 2016. “House Vote 270 Fiscal 2016 Commerce-JusticeScience Appropriations — International Trade Administration. McClintock, R-Calif., amendment that
would reduce funding for the International Trade Administration by $312 million, with an increase of the
same amount to the spending reduction account.” [H.R. 2578, McClintock Amendment, Vote #270,
6/02/15; CQ Bill Track, 6/26/15]
Texas Republican Rep. Opposed Amendment Saying Cut Would Degrade “Ability To Fight
Against ‘Unfair Subsidies Given By Foreign Governments To Their Businesses That Cause
American Workers To Lose Their Jobs.” “Funding trade promotion: The House has rejected an
amendment sponsored by Rep. Tom McClintock, R-Calif., to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and
Related Agencies Appropriations Act (H.R. 2578). The amendment would have eliminated $312
million of funding for trade promotion programs at the government’s International Trade
Administration. McClintock said trade promotion was the proper responsibility of private businesses,
both individually and in trade associations, and taxpayers should not pay for the profits of private
businesses. An amendment opponent, Rep. John Abney Culberson, R-Texas, said the funding cut
would degrade the International Trade Administration’s ability to fight against “unfair subsidies given
by foreign governments to their businesses that cause American workers to lose their jobs.” The vote,
on June 2, was 154 yeas to 263 nays.” [Citizens-Times, 6/05/15]
Voted For Amendment To Increase Funding To Program That “Helps U.S. Manufacturing Firms
Capitalize on Business Opportunities And Make Them More Competitive In Global Markets
Voted For Amendment To Increase Funding For Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership
By $11 Million. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment increasing funding for the National
Institute of Standards and Technology’s Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership program by $11
326
million in FY 2016. “House Vote 271 Fiscal 2016 Commerce-Justice-Science Appropriations —
Manufacturing Extension Partnership. Esty, D-Conn., amendment that would increase funding for the
National Institute of Standards and Technology's Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership program
by $11 million and reduce funding for federal prison system buildings and facilities by $31 million.” The
amendment failed 213 to 214. [H.R. 2578, Esty Amendment, Vote #271, 6/02/15; CQ Bill Tracker,
6/02/15]
Politifact: Program “Helps U.S. Manufacturing Firms Capitalize On Business Opportunities And
Make Them More Competitive In The Global Markets.” During the 2008 presidential campaign,
Barack Obama promised to double funding for the Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership, a
program run by the U.S. Commerce Department that helps U.S. manufacturing firms capitalize on
business opportunities and make them more competitive in the global markets.” [Politifact, 9/30/11]
Program Provided Business Information And Resources To U.S. Manufacturing Firms. “The
Hollings Manufacturing Extensions Partnership is part of the National Institute of Standards and
Technology, which in turn falls under the U.S. Department of Commerce. The partnership, which consists
of federal, state and local organizations, provides business information and resources to U.S.
manufacturing firms to make them more competitive in the global markets.” [Politifact, 11/06/09]
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit Funds For Trade Agreement Negotiations Where The Terms
Are Confidential
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit Funds For Trade Agreement Negotiations Where The Terms
Are Confidential. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Commerce, Justice, Science, and
Related Agencies Appropriations Act that “prohibit[s] the use of funds to negotiate or enter into a trade
agreement whose negotiating texts are confidential.” The amendment failed 27-399. [HR 2578, Vote
#282, 6/03/15]
Voted For Extending African Growth And Opportunity Act & Renewing Generalized System Of
Preferences, Both Of Which Increase Trade With Developing Countries
Voted For Bill To Extend African Growth And Opportunity Act And Renew Generalized System
Of Preferences. In June 2015, Katko voted for a bill that would “provide a 10-year extension of the
African Growth and Opportunity Act, renew the Generalized System of Preferences and extend certain
programs dealing with duty-free treatment of Haitian textiles and apparel… The bill would provide offsets
dealing with customs user fees, payment of corporate estimated taxes and penalties for businesses that fail
to file correct tax and income information.” The motion was agreed to, 397-32. [H.R. 1295, Vote #345,
6/11/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/11/15]
AGOA Lowers U.S. Tariffs On Exports For African Countries. “The AGOA lowers U.S. tariffs
on exports for beneficiary African nations to promote more long-term economic development, trade
and investment.” [AGOA Website, 4/16/15]
GSP Provides Duty-Free Importation Of Goods From Developing Nations. “The GSP, on the
other hand, provides duty-free importation of more than 5,000 products from developing nations. The
327
GSP expired in 2013, but the AGOA Extension and Enhancement Act would extend the program
through 2017.” [AGOA Website, 4/16/15]
Voted For Extension Of Trade Adjustment Assistance
Voted For Extension Of Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA). In June 2015, Katko voted for a
“motion to concur in the Senate amendment to the bill that would provide Trade Promotion Authority for
trade agreements negotiated by the administration, under which they would be considered by Congress
under expedited procedures without amendment, and would extend Trade Adjustment Assistance
programs to help displaced U.S. workers. The portion of the Senate amendment covered by the division
would reauthorize, through June 30, 2021, trade adjustment assistance programs and alternative trade
adjustment assistance for workers laid off because of the impact of foreign competition. Offsets would
include an extension of certain customs fees and prevention of certain taxpayers with high levels of
foreign income from receiving the refundable portion of the child tax credit.” The motion failed 126-302.
[HR 1314, Vote #361; CQ Floor Votes, 6/12/15]
NYT: TAA Failing Would Cripple President Obama’s Trade Agenda. “Hours after President
Obama made a dramatic, personal appeal for support, House Democrats on Friday thwarted his
push to expand trade negotiating power — and quite likely his chance to secure a legacy-defining
accord spanning the Pacific Ocean. In a remarkable blow to a president they have backed so
resolutely, House Democrats voted to end assistance to workers displaced by global trade, a
program their party created and has supported for four decades. That move effectively scuttled
legislation granting the president trade promotion authority — the power to negotiate trade deals
that cannot be amended or filibustered by Congress.” [New York Times, 6/12/15]
Voted For Amendment To Restrict Currency Manipulation
Voted For Concurring In Senate Amendment On Currency Manipulation To Trade Facilitation
and Trade Enforcement Act. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that would “establish a
center for coordinating federal government efforts to protect intellectual property from infringement,
automate the processing of certain trade documents by the Customs and Border Protection agency, and
establish processes for investigating whether foreign countries are directly or indirectly manipulating their
currency to subsidize their exports … A bill opponent, Rep. Sander M. Levin, D-Mich., said its currency
manipulation provisions had no substance and would not be enforceable, thereby putting millions of jobs
at risk due to other countries using their undervalued currencies to undercut American companies.” The
amendment passed 240 to 190. [HR 644, Vote #363, 6/12/15; Citizen-Times, 6/19/15]
Voted For Adopting A Rule To Extend Trade Adjustment Programs And The African Growth
Opportunity Act
Voted For Adopting A Rule In Order To Concur Senate Amendment To Extend TAA Programs
And AGOA. In June 2015, Katko voted for the “adoption of the resolution (H Res 338) that would make
in order a motion to concur in the Senate amendment to the bill (HR 1295) that would extend Trade
Adjustment Assistance (TAA) programs that help U.S. workers harmed by trade agreements until 2021
and the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) through FY 2025.” The rule was adopted 251-176.
[H. Res. 338, Vote #386, CQ Floor Votes, 6/25/15]
328
Voted For Reauthorizing TAA And Extending AGOA, The Generalized System Of Preferences
And The Preferential Duty Treatment For Haiti
Voted For Reauthorizing The Trade Adjustment Assistance Program And Extending AGOA, The
Generalized System Of Preferences And The Preferential Duty Treatment For Haiti. In June 2015,
Katko voted for a trade preferences bill that would reauthorize the Trade Adjustment Assistance program.
“The House Thursday finally sent President Barack Obama a bill to reauthorize the Trade Adjustment
Assistance program, which had become a casualty of a protracted fight between the White House and
congressional Democrats over fast track. The 286-138 vote on the trade preferences bill (HR 1295)
included 175 Democrats, many of whom earlier this month voted against trade assistance, or TAA,
measure as part of their strategy to block fast-track Trade Promotion Authority. In the end, only six
Democrats voted against TAA. … The trade preferences bill includes the African Growth and
Opportunity Act, known as AGOA, and the Generalized System of Preferences that provides developing
nations access to the U.S. market through the duty-free treatment of exports. It also includes preferential
duty treatment for certain goods from Haiti. The bill also includes a House-passed provision that would
replace a $700 million cut to Medicare in 2024, originally proposed to help pay for TAA.” The bill
passed, 286 to 138. [HR 1295, Vote #388, 6/25/15; CQ News accessed 8/20/15]
Voted For Stripping Out Provisions In The Customs Enforcement Bill Protecting American
Workers From Currency Manipulation
Voted For Stripping Out Provisions In The Customs Enforcement Bill Protecting American
Workers From Currency Manipulation. In December 2015, Katko voted for a motion that the House
insist on the House amendment to the Senate amendment and request a conference on the Trade
Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act (HR 644). The House amendment did not include language
“combat currency manipulation… [by] directing the Department of Commerce to slap duties on goods
that have unfairly benefited from undervalued currency.” The motion was agreed to by a vote of 252-170.
[H R 644, Vote #652, 12/1/15; Congressional Record, 12/01/15]
Voted For Investigating Currency Manipulation By Foreign Governments
Voted For Investigating Currency Manipulation By Foreign Governments And Public Entities. In
December 2015, Katko voted for a motion requiring the United States Trade Representative “to
investigate currency manipulation by foreign governments and public entities and specifies the
methodology with which the Trade Representative determines currency manipulation.” The motion was
rejected, 193-232. [CQ Floor Votes, 12/02/15; HR 644, Vote #655, 12/02/15]
Voted Against A Motion In Support OF A Customs Bill
Voted Against A Motion In Support Of A Customs Bill To Honor American Workers, Address
Human Trafficking, And Protect The Environment. In December 2015, Katko voted against a motion
to “challenge Republicans to support a Customs Bill that honors American workers, addresses human
trafficking, and protects our environment.” The motion failed, 172-239. [HR 644, Vote #692, 12/11/15;
Democratic Leader – Motions to Recommit, 12/11/15]
329
Voted For Strengthening Trade Enforcement, Protecting Intellectual Property, And Closing
Loophole On Goods Made With Child Labor
Voted For Strengthening Trade Enforcement. In December 2015, Katkovoted for the Conference
Report to the Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act of 2015. “The Conference Report facilitates
trade by strengthening trade enforcement, including provisions to guard against evasion of anti-dumping
and countervailing duty laws, protect intellectual property against piracy, and target sources of unfair
trade and provisions streamlining the flow of legitimate trade by modernizing Customs operations and
reducing paperwork. Also, it closes a loophole in current law that allows the importation of products
made using child or forced labor.” [HR 644, Vote #693, 12/11/15; The Daily Whip, 12/11/15]
Voted For Conference Report On Trade Bill That Would Barr The Inclusion Of Climate
Change Provisions In Fast Track Trade Deals. In December 2015, Katko voted for the
Conference Report to the Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act of 2015. The Conference
Report contained language that “would single out greenhouse gas emission provisions as being
ineligible for inclusion in a trade deal, raising concerns about its impact on efforts to protect the
environment in trade deals as called for in the May 10, 2007, Agreement setting out Democratic
priorities for trade negotiations.” The report passed, 256-158. [HR 644, Vote #693, 12/11/15; The
Daily Whip, 12/11/15]
330
Transportation Issues
 Said he was committed to being a strong voice of leadership for the I-81
reconstruction, but refused to support any option.
 Said he was open to raising the gas tax as a last resort after having attacked
Maffei for secretly plotting to raise the gas tax.
 Said the transportation bill is something that has “gotta get done”
Katko requested a position on the Transportation Committee to have a voice on the
I-81 rebuilding project. He said he wanted to be a strong voice for the I-81 project,
and offer leadership; but he has refused to advocate for any particular option for
the project.
Katko attacked Maffei for secretly plotting to raise the gas tax to fund his
infrastructure plan. After the election, Katko said he was open to raising the gas tax
as a last resort to fund infrastructure.
Katko said, “The transportation bill, for example, this year. It’s gotta get done.”
Katko did not object to an amendment that eliminated the High Density States
Program from the highway bill. The amendment would have cut $12 million from
Centro, a cut Centro Officials called “very devastating.” Katko claimed he declined
to object to the bill in order to make it easier for the funding to be restored in
Conference Committee, while Rep. Hanna said he was “disappointed” that no one
objected, and Katko’s critics attacked him for the cut. The funding was restored in
the final bill, and Katko called the continuation of the funding a win for Central
new York.
2015 Highway Bill And Centro Funding
Did Not Object To An Amendment Eliminating The High Density States Program On The House
Floor, Claimed He Declined To Do So To As A Political Calculation, And Distributed Emails
Against The Amendment; Rep. Hanna Was “Disappointed” No One Objected
Did Not Object To Eliminating The High Density States Program On The House Floor. “Here’s the
back story: U.S. Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler, R-Washington, sponsored an amendment to the highway bill
that would eliminate the High Density States Program. The program provides federal funding to states,
including New York, with high populations and heavy mass transit use. The amendment was approved by
331
voice vote. No one objected to the measure on the House floor. After the highway bill’s passage,
Democrats criticized Katko, R-Camillus, for failing to speak out against Herrera Beutler’s amendment.”
Said He Decided To Allow A Voice Vote On High Density States Funding As A Political
Calculation. “Ultimately, Katko decided it would be better to allow a voice vote rather than force
a roll call vote on the amendment. He believes it would’ve received bipartisan support from
representatives who live outside of the Northeast -- the region that benefits most from the funding
-- and that strong showing would’ve been tough to overcome in final negotiations.” [The Citizen,
11/15/15]
Rep. Hanna Was “Disappointed” That No One Objected To The Elimination Of The High
Density States Program. “The U.S. House of Representatives ‘ approval of a long-term federal
transportation funding bill Thursday could mean an $820 million cut in funding for the state’s
public transportation systems. … ‘Congressman Hanna is deeply disappointed that this
amendment passed and was done so in the middle of the night with no one present to object to it,’
said Renee Gamela, Hanna’s communications director.’” [Observer-Dispatch, 11/07/15]
House Amendment Would Have Cut $12 Million From Centro; Centro Official Called Said “It
Would Be Very Devastating For Us.” “The House of Representatives approved a long-term highway
bill Thursday that strips billions in public transportation funding from New York and six other
Northeastern states. A last-minute amendment, approved by a voice vote Wednesday night, would
effectively cut off $820 million over six years in public transportation aid to New York state. Centro,
which provides public bus service in Central New York, would lose about $12 million in aid during the
same period – forcing potentially steep cutbacks for a struggling urban transportation system. ‘It would be
very devastating for us,’ said Rick Lee, Centro's deputy executive director, noting that such a large loss of
aid would force operating budget cuts and delay the replacement of old, high-mileage buses.” [Post
Standard. 11/05/15]
Claimed “He Distributed 50 Emails Written By Centro” To Oppose The Program. “Contrary to
claims made by his opponents, Katko said he did take action and tried to block the amendment. He
distributed 50 emails written by Centro to encourage his colleagues to oppose the elimination of the High
Density States Program.” [The Citizen, 11/15/15]
Claimed The Transportation Bill, As Passed The House Provided Stability, Flexibility, And
“Protects Current Highway Funding Formulas”
Claimed The Transportation Bill, As Passed The House, “Provides Central New York With The
Stability And Flexibility That We Need To Make Long-Term Investments In Our Infrastructure.”
“‘Our state and local governments need predictability as we move forward to plan for local projects like
the I-81 rebuild,’ said U.S. Rep. John Katko. ‘After 35 short-term extensions to federal highway
programs, this fiscally-responsible bill provides Central New York with the stability and flexibility that
we need to make long-term investments in our infrastructure.’”
Claimed The Transportation Bill “Protects Current Highway Funding Formulas To Ensure That
States Like New York Don’t Lose Out On Funding Due To New Means Of Allocating Money.”
332
“Representative Katko also advocated for the following items included in the bill, which will be of benefit
to CNY: … Protects current highway funding formulas to ensure that states like New York don’t lose out
on funding due to new means of allocating money.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 11/06/15]
Claimed Credit For Passing A Long Term Highway Bill
Claimed Credit For Passing A Long-Term Highway Bill. “He said passing a long-term highway bill
was one of his first campaign pledges. And in his first year in Congress -- and in his first year on the
House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee -- the House finalized a six-year highway funding
measure. ‘We’ve got the first long-term funding bill in close to a decade and I was a big part of that,’ he
said. ‘So, you want to criticize me about things? Go ahead. But let’s give me credit for the things that
happened, too. And we got this bill across the finish line. It’s not over with respect to Centro.’” [The
Citizen, 11/15/15]
Voted For The Five Year Transportation Bill; Which Also Reauthorized The Export-Import Bank;
Touted The Bill And Its Impact On New York, I-81
Voted For The Five Year Transportation Bill; Which Also Reauthorized The Export-Import Bank.
In December 2015, Katko voted for “a bill to spend up to $325 billion on transportation projects on
Thursday after a weeklong vote-a-rama and an intense debate about federal gas taxes. The measure also
includes a reauthorization of the controversial Export-Import Bank's charter, which has been held up in
Congress since it expired in June. The extension, which was included in the Senate's highway bill and left
unchanged by the House, reauthorizes the bank's expired charter until 2019. The House voted to approve
the bill in a 363-64 vote. It calls for spending $261 billion on highways and $55 billion on transit over six
years. The legislation authorizes highway funding for six years, but only if Congress can come up with a
way to pay for the final three years.” [HR 22, Vote #673 12/03/15; USA Today, 12/03/15]
Claimed “Continued Funding For Centro” In The Transportation Bill Was A Win For Central
New York. “Katko, R-Camillus, a member of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee,
served on the conference committee which negotiated the final highway bill agreement. ‘Today’s
legislation includes significant wins for central New York, including the designation of Interstate 81 as a
high priority corridor, continued funding for Centro and the overall stability that our community needs to
plan for long-term investment in our infrastructure,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 12/04/15]
Claimed The “Designation Of Interstate 81 As A High Priority Corridor” And Funding Stability
Were Wins For Central new York In The Transportation Bill. “Katko, R-Camillus, a member of the
House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, served on the conference committee which
negotiated the final highway bill agreement. ‘Today’s legislation includes significant wins for central
New York, including the designation of Interstate 81 as a high priority corridor, continued funding for
Centro and the overall stability that our community needs to plan for long-term investment in our
infrastructure,’ he said.” [The Citizen, 12/04/15]
Said Regarding The Highway Bill, “We Delivered And Delivered Big Time.” “The diverse crowd of
central New York leaders all agree: The $305 billion highway bill approved by Congress this week will
provide a much-needed boost to the region. … ‘We delivered and delivered big time,’ he said.” [The
Citizen, 12/04/15]
333
Touted I-81’s Designation As Placing It “At The Top Of The Heap” For Funding. “As a member of
the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, Katko, R-Camillus, said he advocated for the
designation, which will place I-81 ‘at the top of the heap’ for funding and during the project’s
environmental review period. ‘It might be a more expedited process,’ he said. ‘I think we’re excited about
that and the unions are definitely excited about that. The quicker we get this project going, the quicker we
get people back to work in central New York.’” [The Citizen, 12/04/15]
Pledged To Ensure The Highway Bill Included Funding For The High Density States Program;
Faced Criticism For “Not Doing Enough To Prevent The Amendment
Pledged To Ensure Highway Bill Included Funding For The High Density States Program; Faced
Criticism For “Not Doing Enough To Prevent The Amendment.” “Members of the House and Senate
are now working to negotiate a final agreement. U.S. Rep. John Katko and U.S. Sen. Chuck Schumer,
both of whom serve on the conference committee, have pledged to ensure the final version of the highway
bill includes funding for the High Density States Program. The issue has political ramifications. Katko, RCamillus, has been criticized by Democrats for not doing enough to prevent the amendment from being
included in the House’s version of the highway bill. (Katko is a member of the House Transportation and
Infrastructure Committee.)” [The Citizen, 11/29/15]
Said People Told Him He Was “Nuts” For Advocating For A Long Term Highway Bill
Said People Told Him He Was “Nuts” For Advocating For A Long Term Highway Bill. “Securing a
multi-year surface transportation measure was one of Katko’s top priorities. He recalled people telling
him he was ‘nuts’ to say that he wanted to be elected to Congress and pass a long-term highway bill,
which hasn’t been done in more than a decade. ‘It is something I’m very excited about,’ he said.” [The
Citizen, 12/04/15]
Interstate 81
Opposed Additional Spending for I-81 Project in Syracuse
wanting additional funding for a more extensive construction project on Interstate 81 that runs through
downtown Syracuse.
“Maffei held his first invitation-only ‘study session’ to brainstorm creative plans on digging up Interstate
81 through downtown Syracuse. You may recall that Maffei previously criticized the state Department of
Transportation’s presented options - estimated to cost between $650 million and $900 million - as
‘unsatisfactory’, instead encouraging planners to reconsider more extensive alternatives that would cost
taxpayers more than double the others,” Katko wrote. [Katko Op-ed, Post-Standard, 2/23/14]
Said He Was Committed To Being A Strong Voice On I-81 Reconstruction, But Refused To Take A
Position
334
Said He Was Committed To Being A Strong Voice On The Reconstruction Of I-81. “‘I had the
privilege of speaking directly with Secretary Foxx on local projects of importance, and I appreciate his
willingness to learn more about the infrastructure needs of our region,’ Katko said. ‘I am committed to
providing a strong voice for central New York on local infrastructure projects -- and especially on the
reconstruction of Interstate 81.’” [The Citizen, 9/24/15]
Pushed For Multiple Options For I-81 In Report, Was Pleased Multiple Options Were Outlined In
Report. “U.S. Rep. John Katko, who pushed for the scoping report to include several options for I-81
project, said he’s pleased ‘a variety of reasonable alternatives’ were outlined in the document.” [The
Citizen, 4/29/15]
Said The I-81 Project Needed Leadership, But He Wasn’t Advocating Any Particular Option. “Yes.
Everybody thinks it’s a political hot potato. I don’t think it’s a political hot potato. You need some leadership in this area. If we hadn’t stood up, we would’ve been stuck with two options and I think a lot of
people would’ve been upset. I’m not advocating for any particular one, but I don’t think, at this early
stage, you can cut out entire categories of options like they were thinking of doing.” [The Citizen,
4/20/15]
Other
Called For Investments In Existing Transportation Infrastructure
Called For Investments In Existing Transportation Infrastructure. “Just hours after the state
Department of Transportation closed a bridge on Route 34 in the town of Brutus due to a crack in the
bridge’s beam, Republican congressional candidate John Katko called for investments in existing
infrastructure.” [The Citizen, 7/17/14]
Accused Maffei Of Secretly Plotting To Raise The Gas Tax, After The Election Said He Was Open
To Raising The Gas Tax As A “Last Resort”
Accused Maffei Of Secretly Plotting To Raise The Gas Tax. “John Katko, the Republican candidate
for Congress, stood in front of a gas station Wednesday to call on opponent Rep. Dan Maffei, D-Syracuse,
to oppose what he called growing efforts in Washington to raise the federal gas tax. Katko brought in a
few issues to make his point, but Maffei said he is working toward the same goal. Maffei has always
opposed an increase in the gas tax, spokesman Kane Miller said. First, Katko asked how Maffei intends to
pay for the ‘grandiose’ infrastructure plan he released last week. ‘One can only conclude that he is
privately for raising the taxes to get revenue to pay for this grandiose scheme,’ Katko said.” [Post
Standard, 7/02/14]
Said He Was Open To Raising The Gas Tax As A “Last Resort” To Fund Infrastructure. “Host:
you’re not ruling out then, a possible little tax increase to pay for that, necessarily? Katko: Well I mean,
let me put it this way, it’s a last resort for me. And it always has been and always will be. And I don’t
think that we should start a conversation by saying lets tax something. Let’s figure out how we can get
funds without having to do that and the gas tax is a hot issue right now. The bottom line is you have to be
mindful of the fact that we do have a crumbling infrastructure. We have an infrastructure that needs a lot
of work.” [WSYR Interview, 2/03/15]
335
Said He Looked Forward To Shaping The Highway Bill, Said The Transportation Bill Had To Get
Done
Said He Looked Forward To Shaping The Highway Bill. “Katko said serving on the panel will also
benefit the Port of Oswego. And he’s looking forward to having a voice in shaping the highway
transportation bill, which will be one of the key legislative items the committee tackles in 2015.” [The
Citizen, 12/14/14]
Citizen, 12/02/14]
Criticized Maffei For Not Proposing To Fix Existing Bridges Despite Maffei’s Plan To Do So
Criticized Maffei For Not Proposing To Fix Existing Bridges Despite Maffei’s Plan To Fix Existing
Bridges. ‘Last month, as part of a new infrastructure spending spree, Dan Maffei announced plans to
spend billions on a faster train across upstate and to develop a new ‘intermodal’ Erie Canal,’ Katko said in
a statement. ‘Today a key link for northern Cayuga County over that very canal was closed due to a major
structural problem, cutting residents and small businesses off from direct access to the New York State
Thruway, Weedsport and Auburn. ‘Before we throw billions of dollars borrowed against our children’s
and grandchildren’s future at dream projects that don’t yet exist, we ought to invest what’s needed to
maintain and improve the vital infrastructure we already have.’ … While Maffei, D-Syracuse, did propose
higher speed rail and Erie Canal improvements, he also included bridge and highway repairs in his plan.
Criticized Maffei For Voting Against The Lowering Gasoline Prices To Fuel An America That
Works Act
Criticized Maffei For Voting Against The Lowering Gasoline Prices To Fuel An America That
Works Act. “The Republican bill was called the ‘Lowering Gasoline Prices to Fuel an America That
Works Act.’ … ‘That’s a long name, I know, but the bottom line is, it was intended to try and get gas
prices under control and he voted against it,’ Katko said. Katko said the bill would open offshore drilling
locations previously opposed by the Obama administration, eliminate red tape with onshore production
and access National Petroleum Reserve deposits in Alaska.” [Post Standard, 7/02/14]
Opposed High Speed Rail Project in Upstate New York
supporting a costly high speed rail project across Upstate New York.
“Wasn’t it just two years ago during his last campaign that Maffei championed spending $4 billion in
federal tax dollars on a high-speed train across Upstate? Maffei called that project a needed ‘lifeline’ that
336
would help all of us in Central New York feel less ‘isolated.’ The AP reported last week that the project
could end up costing as much as $6.2 billion - and that’s before a shovel has even hit the ground,” Katko
New York was a Federally Designated Corridor for Hi-Speed Rail, Eligible for Federal Aid
New York was one of 11 designated corridors for high-speed rail, making it eligible for billions of
dollars in federal aid to carry out the project.
In 2009 as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, Congress made $8 billion
available for high speed rail projects. Congress make an additional $2.1 billion available through
appropriations in FY 2009 and 2010, bringing the total to $10.1 billion. [Post-Standard, 2/28/14;
Federal Railroad Administration, accessed 5/22/14]
As of May 2014, New York has received $3.1 billion in stimulus funding for transportation
projects. [Recovery.gov, 5/01/14]
Voted Against Authorizing $750 Million For Positive Train Control
Voted Against Amendment To Authorize $750 Million In Positive Train Control That Could Have
Prevented Amtrak Collision. In May 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to authorize $750
million in positive train control. “House Democrats wanted increased funding for an automated train
control system that could have prevented last week's deadly Amtrak crash included in a surface
transportation bill being voted on Tuesday. . . . A spokesman for House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi
(D-Calif.) said Democrats were offering a motion to recommit on the road and transit measure that the
House is voting on Tuesday that would boost the federal government's funding for the automated train
control system to $750 million.” [The Hill, 5/19/15; HR 2353, Vote #248, 5/19/15]
Voted Against Eliminating Discretionary Funding For Essential Air Service Program
Voted Against Amendment Eliminating Discretionary Funding For Essential Air Service Program.
In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would eliminate discretionary funding for the
Essential Air Service (EAS) program and increase the spending reduction account by $155 million, the
amount that the underlying bill would provide in discretionary funding for the EAS program. The
amendment, failed 166 to 255. [HR 2577, Amendment #8, Vote #298, 6/04/15; CQ, 6/04/15]
Voted For $3 Million In Additional Funding For Federal Railroad Safety
Voted For Additional $3 Million In Additional Funding For Federal Railroad Safety. In June 2015,
Katko voted for an amendment that would “reduce by $3 million funding for the Federal Aviation
Administration's operations account, with the reduction targeted at funding for staff offices, and provide
an additional $3 million for the Federal Railroad Administration's safety and operations account.” The
amendment failed 184 to 230. [HR 2577, Vote #308, 6/04/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/04/15]
Voted For Preventing Local Officials From Working With The Department Of Transportation To
Reduce Motorcycle Fatalities
337
Voted For Preventing Local Officials From Working With The Department Of Transportation To
Reduce Motorcycle Fatalities. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the Transportation And
HUD Appropriations Bill that would remove language from the bill that would allow the Transportation
secretary to engage in activities with states and state lawmakers to consider proposals related to reducing
motorcycle fatalities. The amendment passed, 235 to 189. [HR 2577, Amendment #9, Vote #299, 6/04/15;
CQ, 6/04/15]
Voted Against Increasing Insurance Requirements For Commercial Vehicles To Guard Against
Worst Case Scenario Incidents
Voted Against Amendment Increasing Insurance Requirements For Commercial Vehicles. In June
2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would remove a section of the bill that would bar funds
from being used to develop, issue or implement regulations that increase the minimum financial
responsibility for transporting passengers or property by commercial motor vehicles. The amendment
failed, 176 to 247. [HR 2577, Amendment #16, Vote #301, 6/04/15; CQ, 6/04/15]
Voted Against Increasing Safety Funding By Nearly $17 Million For Existing Rail Lines
Voted Against Increasing Safety Funding By Nearly $17 Million For Existing Rail Lines. In June
2015, Katko voted against an amendment increasing funding for the Federal Railroad Administration’s
safety and operations account by $16,930,000 in order to improve safety on existing rail lines and reduce
funding for FRA capital investment grants by $83 million. “The U.S. House on Thursday rejected an
effort by Rep. Scott Garrett to use some money earmarked for new transit projects to improve safety on
existing lines instead. By a vote of 266-160, the House defeated Garrett's attempt to amend the
transportation spending bill and transfer $17 million to the Federal Railroad Administration's safety
account from the funds earmarked for new construction.” The amendment failed, 160 to 266. [HR 2577,
Amendment #18, Vote #302, 6/04/15; NJ.com 6/05/15]
Voted Against Amendment That Slashed More Than $280 Million In Funding For Amtrak
Voted Against Amendment That Slashed More Than $280 Million In Funding For Amtrak. In June
2015, Katko voted against an amendment cutting $288 million in Amtrak operating grants. “The House
on Thursday rejected a conservative lawmaker’s push to impose steep cuts on Amtrak’s budget a month
after a fatal derailment near Philadelphia. The annual appropriations measure for the Department of
Transportation contains $1.13 billion for Amtrak, down from the current $1.4 billion level. Rep. Mo
Brooks (R-Ala.) offered two amendments to slash Amtrak funding further. His first proposal, rejected
143-283 with 99 Republicans in opposition, would eliminate all $288.5 million for Amtrak operating
grants.” The amendment failed, 190 to 232. [HR 2577, Amendment #20, Vote #303, 6/04/15; The Hill,
6/04/15]
Voted Against Amendment Blocking Funding For Orlando To Miami Passenger Rail Line Through
Indian River County
Voted Against Amendment Blocking Funding For Orlando To Miami Passenger Rail Line Through
Indian River County. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to a Department of
338
Transportation and Department of Housing and Urban Development appropriations bill that would “bar
funding for the Transportation Department to finance a new passenger rail project that runs from Orlando
to Miami through Indian River County, Fla.” The amendment was rejected 163-260. [HR 2577, Vote
#313, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Decreasing Funding For Transportation, Housing And Urban Development By One
Percent
Voted Against Decreasing Funding For Transportation, Housing and Urban Development By One
Percent. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would “reduce spending by 1 percent to
all accounts,” in the Transportation, Housing and Urban Development, and Related Agencies
Appropriations Act, 2016. The amendment failed 163 to 259. [HR 2577, Vote #310, 6/09/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Baring Funding For Rule Meant To Reduce The Probability Of Train Accidents
Involving Trains Carrying Flammable Liquids
Voted Against Baring Funding For Rule Meant To Reduce The Probability Of Train Accidents
Involving Trains Carrying Flammable Liquids. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment
barring funding for a rule that is “designed to reduce the consequences and, in some instances, reduce the
probability of accidents involving trains transporting large quantities of flammable liquids.” The
amendment failed 136 to 286. [HR 2577, Vote #312, 6/09/15; CQ Floor Votes, 6/09/15; Federal Register,
5/08/15]
Voted Against Funding For Positive Train Control
Voted Against Motion Authorizing $6 Million For Positive Train Control Systems, Technology That
Could Have Prevented Deadly 2014 Amtrak Crash. In June 2015, Katko voted against a motion to
recommit the FY16 Transportation-HUD Appropriations bill. “[The motion] intended to help give Amtrak
funds to pay for positive train control technology, a safety upgrade that the National Transportation Safety
Board said could have prevented the May 12 derailment of a passenger train near Philadelphia that killed
8 and injured more than 200. The motion offered a $6 million increase in capital and debt service grants to
Amtrak, offset by a decrease in the Office of Lead Hazard Control and Healthy Homes Information
Technology Fund.” The motion was rejected by a vote of 181-244. [HR 2577, Vote #328, 6/09/15;
Congressional Quarterly News, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Bar Funding On The Amtrak Route With The Highest Loss Per
Rider—New Orleans To LA
Voted Against Amendment To Bar Funding On The Amtrak Route With The Highest Loss Per
Rider—New Orleans To LA. In June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to a Department of
Transportation and Department of Housing and Urban Development appropriations bill that would “bar
funding for Amtrak on the route with the highest loss, measured by the loss per rider. It would eliminate
the ‘Sunset Limited’ line from New Orleans to Los Angeles” The amendment was rejected 205-218. [HR
2577, Vote #314, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
339
Voted Against An Amendment To Bar Funding For Any Amtrak Route With Operating Costs
Exceeding Twice Its FY 2014-18 Five Year Plan Funding
Voted Against An Amendment To Bar Funding For Any Amtrak Route With Operating Costs
Exceeding Twice Its FY 2014-18 Five Year Plan Funding. In June 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment to a Department of Transportation and Department of Housing and Urban Development
appropriations bill that would “bar funding for Amtrak to operate any route for which the operating costs
exceed two times its revenues based on Amtrak’s FY 2014-18 Five Year Plan from April 2014.” The
amendment was rejected 186-237. [HR 2577, Vote #315, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Requiring The FAA To Allow Bob Hope Airport To Impose Curfew
Voted Against Requiring The FAA To Allow Bob Hope Airport To Impose Curfew. In June 2015,
Katko voted against an amendment to a Department of Transportation and Department of Housing and
Urban Development appropriations bill that would “require the Federal Aviation Administration to allow
the Bob Hope Airport in Burbank, Calif., to impose a curfew on flights.” The amendment was rejected
157-266. [HR 2577, Vote #316, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Blocking DOT From Financing Rail Projects With Top Speeds Under 150MPH
Voted Against Blocking DOT From Financing Rail Projects With Top Speeds Under 150MPH. In
June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to a DOT and HUD appropriations bill that would “bar
funding for the Transportation Department to authorize exempt facility bonds to finance passenger rail
projects that cannot attain the speech[sic] of 150 mph.” The amendment was rejected 148-275. [HR 2577,
Vote #317, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted Against Blocking DOT Funding For Making Loans Over $600 Million For Rail Projects
Voted Against Blocking DOT Funding For Making Loans Over $600 Million For Rail Projects. In
June 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to a DOT and HUD appropriations bill that would “bar
funding for the Transportation Department to make a loan under the Railroad Revitalization and
Regulatory Reform Act that exceeds $600 million.” The amendment was rejected 134 to 287. [HR 2577,
Vote #318, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted For Providing Preferential Funding To East Coast Transit Projects
Voted For Amendment Requiring Grant Funding To The Northeast Corridor Match The Line’s
Prior Year Profits Before Amtrak Funding Can Be Distributed To Other Parts Of The Country. In
June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the FY16 Transportation-HUD Appropriations bill that
prohibit the use of funds for Amtrak capital grants may be used for projects off the Northeast Corridor
until the level of capital spending by Amtrak for capital projects on the Northeast Corridor during fiscal
year 2016 equals the amount of Amtrak’s profits from Northeast Corridor operations during FY 2015.
The amendment was rejected by a vote of 199-227. [HR 2577, Vote #322, 6/09/15; Congressional
Record, 6/09/15]
Voted For Prohibiting Transit Grant Funding Be Used For Usability Upgrades
340
Voted For Amendment To Prohibit New Start Grant Funding Be Used For Upgrades To Improve
Usability Of Transit Projects. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to the FY16 TransportationHUD Appropriations bill that would bar funds from being used to carry out any enrichment for any New
Start grant request, including improvements to a transit project like a sidewalk, paths, plazas, lighting, and
signage. The amendment was rejected by a vote of 212-214. [HR 2577, Vote #325, 6/09/15; CQ Floor
Votes, 6/09/15; Congressional Record, 6/09/15]
Voted Against FY16 THUD Appropriations Bill Cutting Amtrak Funding, Housing Assistance &
Rehabilitation
Voted Against FY16 Transportation-HUD Appropriations Bill That Slashed Amtrak Funding By
$242 Million, Cut Housing Assistance & Rehabilitation. In June 2015, Katko voted against the FY16
Transportation-HUD Appropriations. “[The bill] cut Amtrak's budget by $242 million … falls short of
Obama's request for housing subsidies for the poor, which the administration says is lengthening waiting
lists for rent vouchers … cut funding to rehabilitate housing projects by almost $200 million to $1.7
billion, and would offer just $20 million to Choice Neighborhoods grants to help cities rebuild poor
neighborhoods, a 75 percent cut from current spending … The measure also seeks to reverse Obama
administration steps to greatly ease travel restrictions to Cuba.” The bill passed by a vote of 216-210. [HR
Voted For Baring Funds From Being Used By The FAA For Bio-Data Assessment In Air Traffic
Control Specialist Hiring.
Voted For Baring Funds From Being Used By The FAA For Bio-Data Assessment In Air Traffic
Control Specialist Hiring. In June 2015, Katko voted for an amendment to a DOT and HUD
appropriations bill that would “bar funds from being used by the Federal Aviation Administration for the
bio-data assessment in the hiring of air traffic control specialists.” The amendment was adopted 240-186.
[HR 2577, Vote #321, 6/09/15; CQ Summary, 6/09/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration On A Vote To Re-Authorize A Long-Term Transportation Bill
And To Crack Down On Corporations That Avoid Taxes By Moving Overseas
Voted For Blocking Consideration On A Vote To Re-Authorize A Long-Term Transportation Bill
And To Crack Down On Corporations That Avoid Taxes By Moving Overseas. In July 2015, Katko
voted for blocking consideration on “a vote to re-authorize a long-term Transportation Bill that provides 6
years of funding so states and localities can address critical infrastructure needs. The bill would also stop
corporations that seek to move abroad to avoid paying their taxes and use that money for transportation
improvements here in America.” A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on the longterm Transportation bill and the crackdown on corporations that move overseas to avoid paying taxes. The
motion to order the previous question passed, 245 to 182. [H Res 362, Vote #438, 7/15/15; Democratic
Voted For $8.1 Billion Short-Term Highway Funding Extension
341
Voted For $8.1 Billion Short-Term Highway Funding Extension. In July 2015, Katko voted for a bill
that “would reauthorize federal-aid highway and transit programs through Dec. 18, 2015 and would
transfer $8.1 billion in funding from the Treasury to the Highway Trust Fund to cover projected trust fund
shortfalls over that time. The measure completely offsets the cost of the proposed funding transfer by
extending for two years the current budgetary treatment of Transportation Security Administration (TSA)
fees as mandatory savings and through several tax compliance provisions.” The bill passed by a vote of
312-119. [HR 3038, Vote #441, 7/15/15; CQ Floor Votes, 7/15/15]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Long Term Transportation Bill
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of A Long Term Transportation Bill. In July 2015, Katko voted
for to block consideration of a vote to “re-authorize a long-term Transportation Bill that provides 6 years
of funding so states and localities can address critical infrastructure needs.” The previous question carried,
239-167. A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on a long term transportation bill. [H
Res 369, Vote #450, 7/22/15; Democratic Leader – Previous Questions, 7/22/15]
Bill Would Also Target Corporations Moving Abroad To Avoid Paying Taxes, Instead
Reinvest Money In Transportation Improvements. The bill also intended to “stop corporations
that seek to move abroad to avoid paying their taxes and use that money for transportation
improvements here in America.” A vote against the previous question was to force the vote on a
bill to stop corporations moving abroad to avoid paying taxes. [H Res 369, Vote #450, 7/22/15;
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Long-Term Transportation Bill That Would Fund Domestic
Infrastructure By Prohibiting Corporations From Moving Overseas To Avoid Taxes
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Long-Term Transportation Bill That Would Fund Domestic
Infrastructure By Prohibiting Corporations From Moving Overseas To Avoid Taxes. In July 2015,
Katko voted for to block consideration of a vote to “re-authorize a long-term Transportation Bill that
provides 6 years of funding so states and localities can address critical infrastructure needs. The bill
would also stop corporations that seek to move abroad to avoid paying their taxes and use that money for
transportation improvements here in America.” The previous question carried, 240-167. A vote against
the previous question was to force the vote on long-term transportation funding. [H Res 380, Vote #470,
Voted For Three Month Funding Patch For The Highway Trust Fund And Veterans Affairs
Department
Voted For Three Month Funding Patch For The Highway Trust Fund And Veterans Affairs
Department. In July 2015, Katko voted for “a three-month extension of highway funding Wednesday,
just two days before the Highway Trust Fund was set to run out of money to help states build roads,
bridges, and mass transit projects.” The bill “also would authorize the Veterans Affairs Department (VA)
to use $3.4 billion to pay for veteran care through non-VA providers and instruct the VA to consolidate all
non-VA programs into a single program.” The bill passed 385 to 34. [HR 3236, Vote #486, 7/29/15; USA
Today, 7/29/15; CQ, 7/29/15]
342
Voted For Amendment To Expand Congestion Mitigation And Air Quality Improvement Program
To Include Projects Like Bikeshare & Carpool Programs
Voted For Amendment To Expand Congestion Mitigation And Air Quality Improvement Program
To Include Projects Like Bikeshare & Carpool Programs. In November 2015, Katko voted for an
amendment “that would expand the eligibility of the Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality Improvement
program to include projects that use innovative mobility technologies to provide alternatives to driving
alone, such as bikeshare and carpool programs, that are shown to reduce vehicle miles travelled or
improve air quality.” The amendment failed, 181 to 237. [HR 22, Vote #586, 11/03/15; CQ, 11/03/15]
Voted For Amendment To Allow States To Permit 6-Axle Trucks In Excess Of 80,000 Lbs To Drive
On Interstate Highways
Voted For Amendment To Allow States To Permit 6-Axle Trucks In Excess Of 80,000 Lbs To Drive
On Interstate Highways. In November 2015, Katko voted for an amendment “that would allow states to
permit trucks on their interstate highways that exceed the current weight limit of 80,000 pounds. Trucks
would need to be equipped with a sixth axle and could not exceed a gross weight of 91,000 pounds.” The
amendment failed, 187 to 236. [HR 22, Vote #588, 11/03/15; CQ, 11/03/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Establish National Advisory Committee On Travel And Tourism
Infrastructure
Voted Against Amendment To Establish National Advisory Committee On Travel And Tourism
Infrastructure. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “that would require the
establishment of a National Advisory Committee on Travel and Tourism Infrastructure to advise the
Transportation secretary on infrastructure issues and funding needs related to the use of the intermodal
transportation network in facilitating travel and tourism, identify critical transportation facilities and
corridors, and other duties.” The amendment passed, 216 to 207. [HR 22, Vote #589, 11/03/15; CQ,
11/03/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Require Transportation Secretary To Conduct Reviews Of Pipeline
Transportation Infrastructure Project If Requested By State Or Tribe
Voted Against Amendment To Require Transportation Secretary To Conduct Reviews Of Pipeline
Transportation Infrastructure Project If Requested By State Or Tribe. In November 2015, Katko
voted against an amendment “that would require the Transportation secretary to conduct a safety review
of pipeline transportation infrastructure project if requested by a state or tribal government.” The
amendment failed, 160 to 263. [HR 22, Vote #590, 11/03/15; CQ, 11/03/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Require State And Regional Transportation Proposals To
Include Project Criteria And Descriptions Developed By States Rather Than Federal Government
Voted Against An Amendment To Require State And Regional Transportation Proposals To
Include Project Criteria And Descriptions Developed By States Rather Than Federal Government.
In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to require state and regional transportation
343
proposals to include project criteria and descriptions that states developed instead of the federal
government. The “Amendment sought to require State and regional transportation plans to include project
descriptions and to score projects based on criteria developed by the State or the region, not the Federal
Government.” The amendment failed 171 to 252. [HR 22, Vote #599, 11/04/15; On Agreeing to the
Amendment, 11/04/15]
Amendment Was Part Of Transportation Bill Aimed At Improving Roadways And
Infrastructure. “Congressional negotiators clinched a deal on Tuesday for a five-year, roughly
$300 billion transportation bill that would inject badly needed investments into the nation’s
deteriorated highways and other infrastructure and also reopen the Export-Import Bank.” [New
York Times, 12/1/15]
Bill Did Not Raise The Gas Tax; Used Funds From The Federal Reserve And Back Taxes.
“Instead of raising the 18.4 cents per gallon gas tax, the bill relies on a variety of short-term
financing provisions, including a requirement that the federal government use private collection
agencies to recoup certain outstanding taxes, a provision that would allow the government to deny
new passports to individuals owing more than $50,000 in back taxes, and the sale of 66 million
barrels of oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. The sale of oil is projected to generate $6.2
billion over 10 years, effectively pricing the oil at more than double the current price per barrel.
Some of the money will come from the Federal Reserve. The bill cuts the Fed’s annual dividend
payments to large commercial banks, redirecting that money to highway construction. It also
drains money from the Fed’s rainy-day fund.” [New York Times, 12/1/15]
Voted For Amendment That Would Have More Equitably Divided Transportation Money For U.S.
Territories
Voted For Amendment That Would Have More Equitably Divided Transportation Money For U.S.
Territories. In November 2015, Katko voted for an amendment that “was an attempt to distribute
territorial highway funds more equitably among the islands. That, by using objective benchmarks like
highway miles, population and traffic to allocate a limited pot of money—currently about 40-million
dollars, divided 10-percent each for the NMI and American Samoa, 40-percent each for Guam and the
VI.” The amendment failed, 113 to 310. [HR 22, H Amdt. 766, Vote #593, 11/03/15; PNC News,
11/06/15]
Voted Against Amendment That Would Have Banned Funding For Landscaping In Transportation
Projects
Voted Against Amendment That Would Have Banned Funding For Landscaping In Transportation
Projects. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment “to repeal the authority of the Secretary
of Transportation to approve as part of the construction of federal-aid highways the costs of landscape and
roadside development.” “Representative Vicky Hartzler, Republican of Missouri, wanted an amendment
that would prohibit the use of federal highway money for ‘landscaping and beautification.’ ‘We should
spend our federal highway dollars to improve our roads and bridges, not plant flowers,’ Ms. Hartzler
declared. Noting that between 1992 and 2013 about $1.3 billion was spent on landscaping, while 61,000
bridges were classified as structurally deficient, she added, ‘This is outrageous.’” The amendment failed,
172 to 255. [HR 22, H Amdt. 769, Vote #594, 11/04/15; New York Times, 11/05/15]
344
Voted Against Amendment Providing For States To Allow Livestock Hauling Vehicles Up To
95,000 Pounds With Permit Costs Limited To $200
Voted Against Amendment Providing For States To Allow Livestock Hauling Vehicles Up To
95,000 Pounds With Permit Costs Limited To $200. In November 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment to the Fixing America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act which would “provide for states
to allow, by special permit, the operation of vehicles with a gross weight up to 95,000 pounds for hauling
livestock. The cost of a permit could not exceed $200 annually.” The amendment was rejected, 185 to
240. [H R 22, H Amdt 771, Vote #595, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted For Amendment Requiring Transportation Projects In Excess of $2.5 Billion To Establish
Measures To Identify Potential Cost Overrun Causes
Voted For Amendment Requiring Transportation Projects In Excess of $2.5 Billion To Establish
Measures To Identify Potential Cost Overrun Causes. In November 2015, Katko voted for an
amendment to the Fixing America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act which would “require
transportation ‘megaprojects’ - those estimated to cost at least $2.5 billion - that receive federal financial
assistance to establish a peer review group and a comprehensive risk management plan to identify and
monitor elements that could result in cost overruns or project delays.” The amendment was rejected, 169
to 257. [H R 22, H Amdt. 773, Vote #596, 11/04/15; CQ, 11/04/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Establish Program To Allow Companies To Contribute To
Roadside Maintenance & Receive Public Thanks Through Roadside Corporate Logos Made Of
Live Plants
Voted Against An Amendment To Establish Program To Allow The Use Of Live Plant Materials
For Road Side Maintenance. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to establish a
program to allow the use of live plant materials for road side maintenance. The amendment sought to “to
establish a program to permit the use of live plant materials for road side maintenance.” The amendment
failed 173 to 255. [HR 22, Vote #600, 11/04/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 11/04/15]
Amendment Would Have Allowed Companies To Contribute To Roadside Maintenance And
Receive Public Thanks Through Roadside Corporate Logos Made Of Live Plants; Critics
Labeled It Highway Commercialization. “Under an amendment offered by Rep. Duncan
Hunter, 10 states would be allowed to let companies contribute to roadside maintenance and be
publicly thanked by setting up corporate logos made of live plant materials. The California
Republican said the proposal would save his state millions of dollars annually in roadside
maintenance costs and free up funds for other highway projects. DeFazio objected, saying the step
would commercialize federal highway right-of-ways and open the door to additional advertising
on interstate roads. Hunter expressed surprise. ‘This is one of those things that I thought
everybody would enjoy,’ he said. ‘It's environmentally friendly, it uses plants and flowers, and it
doesn't cost anybody anything. This is one of those deals that I'm surprised is opposed by any
member.’ The amendment was rejected 173-255, with 121 Republicans and 134 Democrats
opposed.” [CQ Weekly, 11/13/15]
345
Voted Against An Amendment To Standardize Meal And Rest Break Laws For The Motor Carrier
Industry Across All States
Voted Against An Amendment To Standardize Meal And Rest Break Laws For The Motor Carrier
Industry Across All States. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to standardize meal
and rest break laws for the motor carrier industry across all states. The “Amendment clarifies the intent of
Congress and ensures that the motor-carrier industry can operate under one standard when engaging in
commerce and pre-empts a patchwork of 50 different state meal and rest break laws to provide certainty
for regional carriers doing business.” The amendment passed 248 to 180. [HR 22, Vote #601, 11/04/15;
On Agreeing to the Amendment, 11/04/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Require Local Transit Organizations To Have A 1:1 Debt To
Equity Ratio In Order To Qualify For Federal Funding
Voted Against An Amendment To Require Local Transit Organizations To Have A 1:1 Debt To
Equity Ratio In Order To Qualify For Federal Funding. In November 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment to require local transit organizations to have a 1:1 debt to equity ratio in order to qualify for
federal funding. The amendment sought to “require local transit entity to have a debt to equity ratio of at
least 1:1 in order to be eligible for federal funds.” The amendment failed 116 to 313. [HR 22, Vote #603,
11/04/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 11/04/15]
Voted Against An Amendment To Commission A Study On The Safety Of Intrastate Teen Truck
Drivers
Voted Against An Amendment Commission A Study On The Safety Of Intrastate Teen Truck
Drivers. In November 2015, Katko voted against an amendment to replace the graduated commercial
driver’s license program language in the FAST act with a study on the safety of intrastate teen truck
drivers. The “Amendment sought to strike the graduated commercial driver's license program language in
the bill and replace it with a study on the safety of intrastate teen truck drivers.” The amendment failed
181 to 248. [HR 22, Vote #604, 11/04/15; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 11/04/15]
Amendment Sought To Eliminate Pilot Program From The Bill That Would Allow
Commercially Licensed Drivers To Drive Large Trucks On Interstate Highways At The Age
Of 19 ½ Years; Current Minimum Age For Truck Drivers Was 21 Years. “Voting 181 for
and 248 against, the House on Nov. 4 refused to strip HR 22 (above) of a pilot program that would
allow commercially licensed drivers as young as 19 ½ years to operate large trucks on the
Interstate Highway System. The existing minimum age for truck drivers on interstates is 21 years.
Amendment sponsor John Lewis, D-Ga., said ‘young drivers may not have the experience needed
to handle heavy, dangerous vehicles. Some follow too closely. Others go too fast and don't check
their mirrors. Young drivers can use their brakes too much, and that is a real danger when
handling an 80,000-pound truck.’” [Oshkosh Northwestern, 11/30/15]
Voted Against Requiring Additional Information Be Displayed On Used Cars For Sale And Making
Vehicle Safety Databases More Publicly Accessible
346
Voted Against Requiring Additional Information Be Displayed On Used Cars For Sale And Making
Vehicle Safety Databases More Publicly Accessible. In November 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment, “that would require the Transportation secretary to make the National Highway Traffic
Safety Administration's vehicle safety databases more publicly accessible and require certain additional
information regarding vehicle history to be displayed on used cars for sale.” The amendment failed 176251. [HR 22, Vote #619, 11/05/15; CQ, accessed 1/07/16]
Voted For Amendment Reauthorizing Surface Transportation Programs For Six Years, Turning It
Into A Block Grant Program And Changing Environmental Reviews
Voted For Amendment Reauthorizing Surface Transportation Programs For Six Years, Turning It
Into A Block Grant Program And Changing Environmental Reviews. In November 2015, Katko
voted for an amendment to the Fixing America's Surface Transportation (FAST) Act to adopt “the
amendments adopted in the Committee of the Whole, including an amendment consisting of the text of
the surface transportation reauthorization measure (HR 3763) approved by the House Transportation and
Infrastructure Committee, with modifications. That amendment would reauthorize surface transportation
programs for six years, with policy provisions including those that would change the Surface
Transportation Program into a block grant program, create a new grant program for nationally significant
freight and highway projects, and make a number of changes to the environmental review process. .
Another amendment would liquidate the Federal Reserve's surplus funds and redirect that money to the
General Fund. The House amendments did not affect a Senate move to reauthorize the Export-Import
Bank.” The amendment passed 363 to 64. [H R 22, Vote #623, 11/05/15; CQ, 11/05/15]
Voted For A Motion For House To Go To Conference With Senate On Six-Year Authorization Of
Surface Transportation Programs
Voted For A Motion For House To Go To Conference With Senate On Six-Year Authorization Of
Surface Transportation Programs. In November 2015, Katko voted for a motion that “the House insist
on the House amendment to the Senate amendment and request a conference on a bill (HR 22) that would
provide a six-year authorization of surface transportation programs.” The amendment passed 371 to 54.
[H R 22, Vote #624, 11/05/15; CQ, 11/05/15]
347
Veterans
 Hired a veteran as a constituent service staffer
 Announced a bill to assist victims of Agent Orange
 Missed a vote on a bill to help prevent veteran suicide
Katko hired a veteran as a constituent service staffer through the Congressional
Wounded Warrior Project.
Katko introduced a bill to assist and compensate victims of Agent Orange.
Katko missed a vote on a bill to help prevent veteran suicide.
Awarded Medals To A Vietnam Veteran, Teared Up, Said It Was “The Highest Honor I’ve Ever
Had As A Congressman”
Awarded Medals To A Vietnam Veteran, Teared Up, Said It Was “The Highest Honor I’ve Ever
Had As A Congressman.” “Auburn native Gary K. Janis was 24 years old when he was in the Vietnam
War. … Now 72, Janis has finally been recognized for his service in the U.S. Army during a ceremony
Thursday morning at Hancock Field Air National Guard Base. … Katko and the U.S. Army officials from
the 27th Infantry Brigade also presented Anthony Tangretti, a resident of Syracuse, with several awards
and medals for his service in World War II. ‘That was the highest honor that I’ve ever had as a
congressman,’ said Katko, tears in his eyes, after he pinned the Bronze Star on Janis’ jacket. ‘The people
of this nation are forever grateful.’” [The Citizen, 10/16/15]
Hired A Veterans Constituent Service Staffer From The Congressional Wounded Warrior Project
Hired A Veterans Constituent Service Staffer From The Congressional Wounded Warrior Project.
“A participant in the Congressional Wounded Warrior Program will be joining U.S. Rep. John Katko’s
staff. Katko, R-Camillus, announced Wednesday that his office has been selected to participate in the
initiative. The Wounded Warrior fellow will serve as a veterans constituent case worker in the Syracuse
district office.” [The Citizen, 6/25/15]
Announced A Bill To Assist And Compensate Victims Of Agent Orange
Announced A Bill To Assist And Compensate Victims Of Agent Orange. “Joined by a number of
Vietnam veterans and local veterans outreach groups today at the Onondaga County War Memorial, U.S.
Rep. John Katko (NY-24) announced legislation that he will introduce in the U.S. House of
348
Representatives creating a task force to explore ways to help provide care and compensation for veterans
who have been exposed to Agent Orange.” [Press Release, Rep. Katko, 9/16/15]
Did Not Vote On Bill To Help Prevent Veteran Suicide
January 12, 2015, 7:00PM: Did Not Vote On Bill To Help Prevent Veteran Suicide. In January 2015,
Katko did not vote on a bill that would “designed to launch new community outreach efforts and recruit
more psychiatrists to slow the nation's estimated 22 veterans suicides each day … The Clay Hunt Suicide
Prevention bill, named for a Marine veteran activist who took his own life in 2011, would require an
annual evaluation of VA suicide prevention programs, to determine which are working and which need to
be replaced. It would mandate a new website better detailing the department's many mental health
resources, and create new peer support programs for veterans outreach. Supporters say both of those are
relatively simple changes which could produce immediate aid for veterans in crisis. The measure would
also start a pilot program to repay student loans of psychiatry students, helping VA officials more quickly
fill those specialty vacancies.” The bill passed 403 to 0. [HR 203, Vote #17, 19:00 1/12/15; Military
Times, 1/12/15]
January 12, 2015, 9:50AM: Tweeted “Our District Office Is Up And Running In Syracuse!”
With A Picture Of Himself Hanging A Sign. “Our district office is up and running in Syracuse!
#NY24” [Rep. John Katko Twitter, 1/12/15]
NOTE: The tweet has been saved to the drive.
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Accelerate Skills Training For US Veterans.
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of Bill To Accelerate Skills Training For US Veterans. In
February 2015, Katko voted for blocking consideration of H.R. 344, a bill to “to carry out a five-year pilot
program (to be known as the Veterans Manufacturing Employment Program) to award competitive grants
to three states for the establishment and administration of a State Manufacturing Employment Program to
make grants to manufacturing employers and labor-management organizations that provide training, onjob training, apprenticeships, and certification classes to eligible veterans.” The previous question passed,
242 to 183. A vote against the previous question would have allowed the bill to be considered.
[H.RES.78, Vote #59, 2/04/15; CRS Summary, 1/14/15]
Voted For Amendment To Increase Veterans Affairs Department Budget By $1.5 Billion
Voted For Amendment To Increase Veterans Affairs Department Budget By $1.5 Billion. In April
2015, Katko voted for the Dent, R-Pa., point of order that the Bishop, D-Ga., amendment addresses
sections of the bill that have not yet been read, and is consequently out of order. The Bishop amendment
would increase various spending levels in accounts within the Veterans Affairs department. The ruling of
the chair was sustained by a vote of 237-180. [HR 2029, Vote #178, 4/29/15; CQ Floor Votes, 4/29/15;
Congressional Record, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Allowing VA Doctors To Discuss Medical Marijuana As Treatment Option For
Veterans
349
Voted Against Amendment To Allow VA Doctors To Talk To Patients About Medical Marijuana
As A Treatment Option. In April 2015, Katko voted against an amendment that would allow doctors at
the VA to talk to patients about the use of medical marijuana as a treatment option. “The House rejected a
proposal Thursday to allow doctors at Department of Veterans Affairs hospitals to discuss the use of
medical marijuana with patients … Medical marijuana is legal in more than 30 states and the District of
Columbia. But VA doctors are prohibited from completing patient forms seeking recommendations or
opinions regarding medical marijuana to treat conditions like post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) …
Lawmakers from both parties argued veterans should at least be able to receive recommendations from
their doctors about the drug's merits. They stressed the amendment wouldn't force doctors to recommend
medical marijuana or authorize marijuana possession at VA facilities.” The amendment failed to pass 210
to 213. [HR 2029, Vote #188; On Agreeing to the Amendment, 4/30/15; The Hill, 4/30/15]
Voted For Underfunding VA Programs
Voted For MilCon-VA Appropriations Bill That Underfunded VA By More Than $1 Billion,
Impacting 70,000 Veterans. In April 2015, Katko voted for legislation that would underfund the VA and
impact veterans’ health care, medical research, education, and cemeteries. “Addressing the Democrats at a
closed-door caucus meeting in the Capitol Wednesday, VA Secretary Robert McDonald warned the
lawmakers that the GOP's $77 billion bill funding the department and military construction projects in
fiscal 2016 falls short of the resources needed to provide health and other services to the nation's veterans.
Relaying McDonald's message, Rep. Xavier Becerra (Calif.), chairman of the Democratic Caucus, said
the GOP's bill would scale back health benefits for roughly 70,000 veterans, while also denying funds for
medical research, education and veterans’ cemeteries … Passed with bipartisan support by the House
Appropriations Committee last week, the bill provides a 5.6 percent increase for the VA over 2015 levels,
but falls more than $1 billion shy of the figure President Obama had included in his 2016 budget request.”
The bill passed 225 to 163. [HR 2029, Vote #193, 4/30/15; The Hill, 4/29/15]
Voted Against Amendment To Increase VA Funding For Veterans Medical Services By $15
Million. In April 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would have added $15 million to VA
funding for veterans medical services. The motion failed 181 to 236. [HR 2029, Vote #192, Motion to
Recommit with Instructions, 4/30/15]
Voted Against Allowing The Department of Veterans Affairs To Immediately Suspend Employees
Without Pay For Threatening Public Health Or Safety
Voted Against Allowing The Department of Veterans Affairs To Immediately Suspend Employees
Without Pay For Threatening Public Health Or Safety. In July 2015, Katko voted against an
amendment granting the Veterans Affairs Department the authority to suspend without pay any employee
whose performance or misconduct threatens public health and safety. Rep. Mark Takano, sponsor of the
amendment in the nature of a substitution said during debate on the House floor, “My substitute would
mean that, if a VA employee's behavior threatened veterans' health or safety, VA could immediately fire
that employee. Current law only allows VA to ask such an employee to leave work while still receiving
pay. My substitute would also cap paid administrative leave at 14 days so VA employees would not sit at
home and collect a paycheck while fighting a disciplinary action. My substitute would shield our bold VA
whistleblowers by protecting existing laws and requiring the VA to backpay any whistleblower unjustly
350
fired for reporting wrongdoing.” The substitute amendment failed, 191 to 233. [HR 1994, Vote #487,
7/29/15; H.Amdt.693, 7/29/15]
Voted Against Protecting Whistleblowers At The Department Of Veterans Affairs
Voted Against Protecting Whistleblowers At The Department Of Veterans Affairs. In July 2015,
Katko voted against a motion to protect VA whistleblowers “who strive to ensure public health and
safety, and are willing to expose discrimination and malfeasance, from being fired at will.” The motion
failed 184 to 241. [HR 1994, Vote #488, 7/29/15; Democratic Leader – 114th Congress Motions to
Recommit, 7/29/15]
Voted For Cutting Workplace Protections For Department Of Veterans Affairs Employees
Voted For Cutting Workplace Protections For Department Of Veterans Affairs Employees. In July
2015, Katko voted for a bill cutting “workplace protections for Department of Veterans Affairs employees
and extend their probationary period, making it easier to fire new staffers … In a statement the day before
the vote, the White House said the legislation would create ‘a disparity in the treatment of one group of
career civil servants. The centerpiece of the bill is a provision that allows a VA employee to be removed
from Federal service or demoted without the opportunity to appeal that decision to the full Merit Systems
Protection Board’ (MSPB), as most other federal workers can.” The bill passed 256 to 170. [HR 1994,
Vote #489, 7/29/15; Washington Post, 7/29/15]
Voted For Legislation To Offer A Percentage Of Construction Jobs Related To Federal
Transportation Projects To Veterans
Voted For Legislation To Offer A Percentage Of Construction Jobs Related To Federal
Transportation Projects To Veterans. In November 2015, Katko voted for legislation requiring “states
to offer a percentage of construction jobs related to transportation projects to veterans.” “The measure,
which is sponsored by Reps. Mike Fitzpatrick (R-Pa.), Cheri Bustos (D-Ill.) and Don Young (R-Alaska),
calls for states that receive federal money for transportation projects to included veteran-owned
businesses in their contracting processes. The sponsors said the measure, which has been dubbed the
‘Fairness to Veterans for Infrastructure Investment Act’ (H.R. 1694), would ‘level the playing field in
federal contracting for veteran-owned businesses by providing veterans access to existing preferences
authorized for transportation projects.’” On a “motion to suspend the rules and pass” by a 2/3 vote, the
bill passed the House, 285 - 138. [HR 1694, Vote #631, 11/17/15; The Hill, 4/08/15]
351
Women’s Issues
 Campaigned against the Paycheck Fairness Act and voted to block the legislation
as a congressman
 Pushed for Harriet Tubman to appear on a bill
In 2014 Katko said he opposed the Paycheck Fairness Act, suggesting the bill would
lead to lawsuits, and somehow discourage employers from hiring women. As a
congressman, he voted to block consideration of the bill.
Katko pushed for Harriet Tubman to appear on a bill of currency, before the
Treasury announced a woman would appear on a redesign of the $10 bill.
Equal Pay
Opposed The Paycheck Fairness Act Because It Could Lead To Lawsuits. “Katko has said he does
not oppose equal pay for women, but he does oppose the legislation in Congress. He said the legislation
could impose costly new regulations for businesses and be a ‘boon to trial lawyers, eager to profit from
huge class-action lawsuits.’” [Post Standard, 10/05/14]
Criticized The Paycheck Fairness Act For Regulations, Making It More Difficult For Employers To
Pay By Merit, For Suits, Discouraging Hiring Women. “His so-called Paycheck Fairness Act would
unintentionally harm working women by taking away some of the freedoms and choices women currently
enjoy. It seeks to equalize wages through onerous and costly new regulations, harming take-home pay and
benefits. It would make it more difficult for employers to pay workers according to their merit. It would
be a boon to trial lawyers, eager to profit from huge class-action lawsuits. And it would affect paycheck
privacy and actually discourage companies from hiring female candidates over male job-seeking
competitors. Let me be clear. This legislation is seriously flawed.” [Katko Op-Ed, Post Standard, 9/18/14]
Advocated For Updating Tax And Retirement Laws To Allow Women To Keep More, Not Penalize
Women For Time Off, Promote Job Training, Concentrate On Workplace Flexibility. “We need real
solutions that provide women and men better work opportunities and grow the American economy.
Women have transformed our economy, but our laws have not kept pace with that change. We need to
update our tax and retirement laws so women can keep more of what they earn and don’t penalize them
for taking time off or reducing work hours to raise children or care for aging parents. We need to invest in
job training and skill development and to concentrate on workplace flexibility needs.” [Katko Op-Ed, Post
Standard, 9/18/14]
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of The Paycheck Fairness Act
352
Voted For Blocking Consideration Of The Paycheck Fairness Act
Voted Against Motion That Would Have Protected “Women’s Rights To Equal Wages” By
Excluding Claims Of Employment Discrimination From Bill
Voted Against Motion That Would Have Protected “Women’s Rights To Equal Wages,” By
Excluding Claims Of Employment Discrimination From Bill. In September 2015, Katko voted against
on Democratic motion to recommit with instructions HR 758. “The Democratic Motion to Recommit
protects women’s right to demand equal wages, by excluding claims of employment discrimination from
the underlying bill that raises new obstacles for Americans to seek remedy in the courts.” The motion to
recommit failed 179 to 239. [HR 758, Vote #500, 9/17/15; Democratic Motion to Recommit, HR 758,
9/17/15]
Other
Joined Sen. Gillibrand To Discuss Sexual Assault On College Campuses
Joined Sen. Gillibrand To Discuss Sexual Assault On College Campuses. “In Syracuse, Gillibrand
was joined by U.S. Rep. John Katko, R-Camillus; Syracuse Police Chief Frank Fowler; and sexual assault
survivors and their advocates at Syracuse University, where she led a discussion about sexual assault on
college campuses. She led similar events at the University of Buffalo and the University of Rochester.”
Pushed For Tubman To Appear On A Bill
Pushed For Tubman To Appear On Currency. “Katko introduced a bill to put Tubman on currency
earlier this month, and the U.S. Treasury Department announced last week that a notable woman will be
353
added to the $10 bill. The announcement did not specify any particular woman, but Katko again pushed
for Tubman following the Treasury’s announcement.” [The Citizen, 6/24/15]
Voted Against Protecting Women’s Medical Privacy
Voted Against Prohibiting Violation Of Medical Privacy Regarding Choice Of Health Insurance
Coverage, Including Coverage For Victims Of Rape Or Incest. In January 2015, Katko voted against a
motion to recommit that would prohibit any violation of the medical privacy of a woman regarding her
choice of health insurance coverage, and in particular the very sensitive privacy needs of those who are
victims of rape and incest. In contrast, the underlying bill goes so far as to restrict a woman’s own private
funds under her health insurance coverage for abortion services. [HR 7, Vote #44, 1/22/15; Democratic
Leader – Motions to Recommit, 1/22/15]
Voted Against Exempting Federal Protections Against Sexual And Domestic Abuse From
Additional Legal Challenges
Voted Against A Motion Exempting Federal Protections Against Sexual And Domestic Abuse From
Weakening Provisions. In February 2015, Katko voted against a motion that would “recommit the bill to
the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee with instructions to report it back immediately
with an amendment that would limit the provisions of the bill from affecting federal regulations
concerning victims of domestic violence and sexual assault.” HR 50 itself “would expand and modify the
1995 Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (PL 104-4) that requires all federal agencies to consult with the
private sector when developing rules... The measure would extend judicial review of agency rules and
permit a court to stay, enjoin or invalidate a rule if an agency fails to complete the required UMRA
analysis or adhere to the regulatory principles.” The motion failed, 184-239. [HR 50, Vote #63, 1/06/15;
CQ Floor Votes, 2/04/15; CQ News HR 50 Coverage, 2/04/15]
Coalition For Sensible Safeguards: “The Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency
Act Lets Big Business Write The Rules.” “But the Coalition for Sensible Safeguards (CSS) says the
bill would give businesses special access to regulators and block hypothetical future rules without the
public knowing. ‘The Unfunded Mandates Information and Transparency Act lets big business write
the rules,’ Katherine McFate, president of the Center for Effective Government and CSS co-chair, said
in a statement. ‘It doesn’t improve or streamline the regulatory process, which is already plagued by
hurdles and delays. This act would make it even more difficult for agencies to implement laws enacted
by Congress.’” [The Hill, 1/30/15]
Voted For Creating Commemorative Coin To Help Fund Breast Cancer Research
Voted For Creating Commemorative Coin To Help Fund Breast Cancer Research. In July 2015,
Katko voted for a bill that would require the Treasury Department to mint and issue legal tender coins in
2018. “The bill, which passed 421-9, would create a pink commemorative coin in 2018 and donate
proceeds from the coin sales to the Breast Cancer Research Foundation.” [HR 2722, Vote #442, 7/15/15;
CQ Floor Votes, 7/15/2015; The Hill, 7/15/15]
354
Appendix I – Campaign Finance
 2016 Cycle: raised $1,365,673.18 through the first quarter of 2016, spent
$418,398.86, and had $1,100,020.97on hand
 2016 Cycle: through the first quarter of 2016, 63.2 Percent Of Katko’s
Itemized have Been From Outside New York State
 2014: Raised $776,432 in donations, Loaned himself $45,000
 2014: Accepted $107,000 in donations from leadership PACs
Through the first quarter of 2016, Katko raised $1,365,673.18, spent $418,398.86,
and had $1,100,020.97 cash on hand
In 2014 Katko raised $776,432 in donations and loaned himself $45,000. He spent
$580,443 and was left with $247,431 cash on hand. The campaign ended the cycle
$45,000 in debt to Katko.
2016 Campaign
Top Donors By Industry Sector For The 2016 Cycle
Industry
Leadership PACs
Candidate Committees
Air Transport
Insurance
Lawyers/Law Firms
Securities & Investment
Real Estate
Lobbyists
Railroads
Beer, Wine & Liquor
Transportation Unions
Republican/Conservative
Building Trade Unions
PAC
Individual
$86,951.00
$0.00
$32,000.00
$0.00
$27,000.00
$2,000.00
$22,500.00
$250.00
$4,500.00 $13,413.00
$1,000.00 $15,850.00
$5,000.00 $11,500.00
$500.00 $15,950.00
$13,500.00
$0.00
$13,000.00
$0.00
$13,000.00
$0.00
$13,000.00
$0.00
$12,500.00
$0.00
355
Total
$86,951.00
$32,000.00
$29,000.00
$22,750.00
$17,913.00
$16,850.00
$16,500.00
$16,450.00
$13,500.00
$13,000.00
$13,000.00
$13,000.00
$12,500.00
Oil & Gas
Automotive
Retired
Electric Utilities
Crop Production & Basic Processing
Health Professionals
General Contractors
$11,000.00
$8,000.00
$0.00
$7,500.00
$7,000.00
$3,000.00
$6,000.00
$0.00
$2,000.00
$9,304.00
$1,250.00
$1,000.00
$5,000.00
$1,750.00
$11,000.00
$10,000.00
$9,304.00
$8,750.00
$8,000.00
$8,000.00
$7,750.00
[Center for Responsive Politics, accessed 10/19/15]
Received $11,000 From The Sugar Industry. According to FEC records, Katko received $11,000 in
donations from Sugar interests between June 30 and September 15, 2015. [FEC.gov, accessed 10/19/15]
Received $82,998 From Air Travel And Air Travel Security Interests. According to FEC Records,
Katko received $82,998 in donations from Air Travel and Air Travel security interests in the first three
quarters of 2015. [FEC.gov, accessed 10/19/15]
Below is a table of air travel and air travel security interest donations Katko has received.
Contributor Name
AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION PAC
State
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
Receipt
Date
12/30/2015
3/31/2015
5/8/2015
6/26/2015
9/30/2015
3/7/2016
12/30/2015
Amount
$ 1,500.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
AIRCRAFT OWNERS AND PILOTS ASSOCIATION
POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
MD
5/8/2015
$ 1,000.00
AIRCRAFT OWNERS AND PILOTS ASSOCIATION
MD
6/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
AIRLINES FOR AMERICA (A4A) POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
DC
6/24/2015
$ 1,000.00
DC
5/28/2015
$ 2,500.00
DC
3/7/2016
$ 1,000.00
ALLIED PILOTS ASSOCIATION POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
TX
4/27/2015
$ 1,000.00
ALLIED PILOTS ASSOCIATION POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
TX
9/29/2015
$ 1,000.00
AIRPORTS COUNCIL INTERNATIONAL-NORTH AMERICA
PAC
AIRPORTS COUNCIL INTERNATIONAL-NORTH AMERICA
PAC
356
Contributor Name
Receipt
State Date
Amount
AMERICAN AIRLINES POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
DC
4/27/2015
$ 1,000.00
DC
DC
6/24/2015
11/23/2015
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF AIRPORT EXECUTIVES
VA
5/28/2015
$ 1,000.00
ATLAS AIR WORLDWIDE HOLDINGS, INC. POLITICAL
ACTION COMMITTEE
NY
6/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
BAE SYSTEMS INC. POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE (BAE
SYSTEMS USA PAC)
VA
3/25/2015
$ 1,000.00
CONTINENTAL AIRLINES INC EMPLOYEE FUND FOR A
BETTER AMERICA PAC
TX
8/11/2015
$ 1,000.00
DELTA AIR LINES POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
DRIVE COMMITTEE TEAMSTERS
DRIVE COMMITTEE TEAMSTERS
DC
DC
DC
6/24/2015
6/29/2015
6/30/2015
$ 2,500.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
EMPLOYEES OF NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORPORATION
PAC (ENGPAC)
VA
6/7/2015
$ 3,000.00
PAC (ENGPAC)
VA
5/8/2015
$ 1,000.00
PAC (ENGPAC)
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL PAC
VA
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
6/15/2015
1/5/2015
3/9/2015
6/15/2015
6/30/2015
7/16/2015
3/25/2015
7/16/2015
3/9/2015
3/9/2015
$ 1,000.00
$ 2,000.00
$ 1,917.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 500.00
$ 500.00
$ 78.00
$ 3.00
JETBLUE AIRWAYS CORPORATION CREWMEMBER GOOD
GOVERNMENT FUND (JETBLUE PAC)
NY
2/5/2015
$ 1,000.00
357
Contributor Name
Receipt
State Date
Amount
LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATION EMPLOYEES'
VA
3/12/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
3/31/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
5/4/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
5/8/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
5/15/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
6/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
7/18/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
9/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
3/25/2016
$ 1,000.00
VA
VA
VA
VA
10/28/2015
12/22/2015
3/16/2016
5/28/2015
$ 1,000.00
$ 2,500.00
$ 1,500.00
$ 1,000.00
NATIONAL AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLERS ASSOCIATION
PAC
DC
1/8/2015
$ 5,000.00
PAC
DC
6/15/2015
$ 1,000.00
PAC
DC
6/24/2015
$ 1,000.00
DC
9/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
DC
3/25/2016
$ 1,000.00
DC
12/31/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
6/29/2015
$ 2,500.00
MORPHOTRUST USA INC. PAC
PAC
PAC
PAC
NATIONAL BUSINESS TRAVEL ASSOCIATION DBA
GLOBAL BUSINESS TRAVEL ASSOCIATION PAC (NBTA
PAC)
358
Receipt
State Date
Amount
OH
10/30/2015
$ 2,500.00
OH
3/31/2015
$ 1,000.00
OH
3/31/2016
$ 1,000.00
PINKERTON, SHARON; AIRLINES FOR AMERICA SVP
POLICY
PROFESSIONAL AVIATION SAFETY SPECIALISTS PAC
DC
DC
6/25/2015
12/4/2015
$ 500.00
$ 1,500.00
RAYTHEON COMPANY POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTTEE
VA
VA
6/15/2015
2/10/2016
$ 2,500.00
$ 2,000.00
VA
3/31/2015
$ 1,000.00
VA
VA
5/8/2015
2/10/2016
$ 1,000.00
$ 500.00
SALTZMAN, JOSHUA M.; AIRLINES FOR AMERICA VICE
PRESIDENT
DC
5/28/2015
$ 250.00
SALTZMAN, JOSHUA M.; AIRLINES FOR AMERICA VICE
PRESIDENT
SOUTHWEST AIRLINES CO. FREEDOM FUND
DC
TX
6/11/2015
5/28/2015
$ 250.00
$ 500.00
SOUTHWEST AIRLINES PILOTS' ASSOCIATION POLITICAL
ACTION COMMITTEE (SWAPA PAC)
TX
5/28/2015
$ 1,000.00
THE BOEING COMPANY POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
VA
4/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
TRANSPORT WORKERS UNION PAC
TRANSPORTATION TRADES DEPARTMENT, AFL-CIO PAC
U.S. TRAVEL ASSOCIATION PAC
U.S. TRAVEL ASSOCIATION PAC
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC. PAC
VA
VA
DC
DC
DC
DC
GA
GA
GA
GA
5/30/2015
11/24/2015
12/14/2015
12/4/2015
6/26/2015
2/16/2016
3/16/2016
9/29/2015
9/29/2015
9/4/2015
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 1,000.00
$ 2,000.00
$ 2,500.00
$ 2,500.00
$ 5,000.00
$ 2,000.00
$ 1,500.00
$ 1,000.00
Contributor Name
NETJETS ASSOCIATION OF SHARED AIRCRAFT PILOTS
PAC; NJASAP PAC
PAC; NJASAP PAC
PAC; NJASAP PAC
359
Contributor Name
Receipt
State Date
GA
5/15/2015
Amount
$ 500.00
UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION POLITICAL
ACTION COMMITTEE
DC
3/11/2015
$ 2,500.00
ACTION COMMITTEE
DC
6/24/2015
$ 2,500.00
DC
9/29/2015
$ 1,000.00
OH
3/16/2016
$ 2,500.00
OH
12/22/2015
$ 2,500.00
UNITED TRANSPORTATION UNION POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
OH
6/3/2015
$ 1,000.00
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
OH
6/29/2015
$ 1,000.00
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
OH
6/29/2015
$ 1,000.00
OH
9/30/2015
$ 1,000.00
ACTION COMMITTEE
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
COMMITTEE (UTU PAC)
OH
11/23/2015 $ 1,000.00
TOTAL $121,498.00
Geographic Breakdown Of Itemized Contributions
Amount
% Of Total
$1,289,830.00
100.0%
Total
$474,861.00
36.8%
NY
$91,650.00
7.1%
NYC
$814,969.00
63.2%
Not NY
$310,318.00
24.1%
DC
$54,650.00
4.2%
MD
$169,351.00
13.1%
VA
$534,319.00
41.4%
DC+MD+VA
April 2016: 63.2 Percent Of Katko’s Itemized have Been From Outside New York State. According
to FEC data, 63.2 percent of Katko’s itemized donations came from donors outside New York State.
360
Disbursements
The following is a table analyzing the category and state origin of Katko’s disbursements.
Category
Total
Food/Bev
Catering
Fundraising
Consulting
Travel
Printing
Postage
Amount
$209,540.00
$18,083.00
$4,861.00
$44,600.00
Category
Total
NY
DC
MD
Amount
$209,540.00
$122,791.00
$25,653.00
$1,922.00
$6,244.00
$11,744.00
$5,771.00
$54,548.00
VA
DC+MD+VA $82,123.00
The following is a table of notable disbursements:
Payee Name
Purpose
City
CONSERVATIVE
PARTY OF NEW YORK
STATE
OSWEGO COUNTY
REPUBLICAN
COMMITTEE
SYRACUSE STAGE
CONGRESSIONAL
INSTITUTE
BOBBY VANS
STEAKHOUSE
BOBBY VANS
STEAKHOUSE
CAPITAL GRILLE
CAPITAL GRILLE
EVENT TICKETS
EVENT TICKETS
CAPITAL GRILLE
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
Amount
BROOKLYN
State Payment
Date
NY
5/20/2015
OSWEGO
NY
4/30/2015
$275.00
EVENT TICKETS
SYRACUSE
NY
EVENT
ALEXANDRIA VA
TICKETS/MEALS
FOOD/BEVERAGE WASHINGTON DC
1/30/2015
1/14/2015
$1,000.00
$1,127.00
7/14/2015
$3,434.00
8/5/2015
$202.00
FOOD/BEVERAGE
EVENT
CATERING
EVENT
CATERING
FOOD/BEVERAGE
FOOD/BEVERAGE
FOOD/BEVERAGE
FOOD/BEVERAGE
FOOD/BEVERAGE
FOOD/BEVERAGE
WASHINGTON DC
WASHINGTON DC
6/3/2015
7/14/2015
$575.00
$1,916.00
WASHINGTON DC
8/5/2015
$765.00
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
5/16/2015
6/23/2015
4/27/2015
7/14/2015
7/18/2015
9/4/2015
$220.00
$225.00
$200.00
$372.00
$580.00
$444.00
361
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
$1,500.00
CAPITOL HILL CLUB
DEL FRISCO'S
THE
CONGRESSIONAL
CLUB
CASA LUCA
9/21/2015
4/27/2015
3/12/2015
$1,120.00
$2,249.00
$515.00
WASHINGTON DC
8/5/2015
$358.00
KITCHEN 550
SONNIER & CASTLE
THE NEW YORK
PALACE
EVENT
CATERING
FOOD/BEVERAGE
FOOD/BEVERAGE
TRAVEL
WASHINGTON DC
NEW YORK
NY
NEW YORK
NY
7/14/2015
1/30/2015
7/14/2015
$531.00
$2,000.00
$376.00
Took $83,000 From The Same PACs as Maffei
The following is a table of the overlap between the first three quarters of Katko’s 2016 Cycle and Maffei’s
2014 Cycle PAC Contributions.
Aggregate To
Katko 2016
Cycle
$8,000.00
$5,000.00
$5,000.00
$5,000.00
$5,000.00
$4,500.00
$4,000.00
$4,000.00
$3,500.00
$3,500.00
$3,000.00
$3,000.00
$2,500.00
Entity
NATIONAL AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLERS
ASSOCIATION PAC
EXELON CORPORATION POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE (EXELON PAC)
HARRIS CORPORATION POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE OF THE AMERICAN
ASSOCIATION OF ORTHOPAEDIC SURGEONS
NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY POLITICAL
ACTION COMMITTEE
RAYTHEON COMPANY POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTTEE
Aggregate To
Maffei 2014
Cycle
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$10,000.00
$7,500.00
$6,000.00
$5,000.00
GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE (GEPAC)
ANHEUSER-BUSCH COMPANIES INC. POLITICAL
ACTION COMMITTEE
EMERGENT BIOSOLUTIONS INC EMPLOYEES PAC
$3,000.00
MVP HEALTH CARE INC FEDERAL PAC
AMERICAN COUNCIL OF ENGINEERING COMPANIES
(ACEC/PAC)
DEALERS ELECTION ACTION COMMITTEE OF THE
NATIONAL AUTOMOTIVE DEALERS ASSOCIATION
$7,000.00
$3,000.00
362
$4,000.00
$2,000.00
$7,500.00
$2,500.00
AETNA INC. POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
$2,500.00
$2,500.00
DIRECTV GROUP, INC. FUND - FEDERAL (DIRECTV
PAC)
THE BOEING COMPANY POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
AMERICAN HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION PAC
AMERICAN AIRLINES POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
CSX CORPORATION GOOD GOVERNMENT FUND
$1,000.00
U.S.-CUBA DEMOCRACY POLITICAL ACTION
COMMITTEE
EXPRESS SCRIPTS INC. POLITICAL FUND (A/K/A
EXPRESS SCRIPTS PAC)
NEA FUND FOR CHILDREN AND PUBLIC EDUCATION
$1,000.00
AMERICAN BANKERS ASSOCIATION PAC (BANKPAC)
BLUEPAC - BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD ASSOCIATION
PAC
PROFESSIONAL AVIATION SAFETY SPECIALISTS PAC
$3,500.00
$3,000.00
$2,000.00
$2,000.00
$2,000.00
$2,000.00
$2,000.00
$1,500.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$1,000.00
$500.00
$83,000.00
$6,000.00
$5,000.00
$2,000.00
$2,000.00
$1,000.00
$7,000.00
$2,500.00
MICROSOFT CORPORATION POLITICAL ACTION
$2,000.00
COMMITTEE
COOK GROUP INC PAC
$1,000.00
FLUOR CORPORATION POLITICAL ACTION
$1,000.00
COMMITTEE (FLUOR PAC)
INTERNATIONAL PAPER POLITICAL ACTION
$1,000.00
COMMITTEE (IP-PAC)
MINN-DAK FARMERS COOPERATIVE SUGAR PAC
$1,000.00
(MDSPAC)
SNAKE RIVER SUGAR COMPANY POLITICAL ACTION
$1,000.00
COMMITTEE
WILLIAMS AND JENSEN, PLLC POLITICAL ACTION
$500.00
COMMITTEE
TOTAL
2016 Q1 Campaign Finance Filings
In April 2016, Katko reported $276,640.00 in contributions, $61,451.08 in expenditures, $1,100,020.97 cash on hand, and zero
debt.
Column A
This Period
363
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
6. Net Contributions (other than loans)
(a) Total Contributions (other than loans)
(b) Total Contribution Refunds
(c) Net Contributions (6(a) - 6(b))
276640.00
1369398.18
0.00
3725.00
276640.00
1365673.18
61451.08
420384.00
0.00
1985.14
61451.08
418398.86
7. Net Operating Expenditures
(a) Total Operating Expenditures
(b) Total Offsets to Operating Expenditures
(c) Net Operating Expenditures
8. Cash on Hand at Close of Reporting Period
1100020.97
9. Debts and Obligations Owed TO the Committee
0.00
Itemize all on SCHEDULE C or SCHEDULE D
10. Debts and Obligations Owed BY the Committee
0.00
In January 2016, Katko reported $281,414.90 in contributions, $60,634.17 in expenditures, $885,897.52 cash on hand, and zero
debt.
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
364
281414.90
1092758.18
0.00
3725.00
281414.90
1089033.18
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
60634.17
358932.92
199.79
1985.14
60434.38
356947.78
885897.52
0.00
0.00
In October 2015, Katko reported $191,134.31 in contributions, $62,905.45 in expenditures, $664,307.71 cash on hand, and
$452.06 in debt.
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
194859.31
805788.66
3725.00
3725.00
191134.31
802063.66
62905.45
294264.44
0.00
1785.35
62905.45
292479.09
664307.71
365
Column B
Column A
Election
This Period
Cycle-To-Date
0.00
452.06
[FEC.gov, filed 10/15/15]
Received Contributions From The NEA, And The Office Of The Commissioner Of Major League
Baseball. Katko For Congress’ FEC Report noted contributions from The NEA Fund for Children and
Public Education, and the Office of the Commissioner of Major League Baseball PAC. [FEC.gov, filed
10/15/15]
44.2% Of Itemized Contributions Came From New York State. Accessed in October 2015, Katko For
Congress’ FEC report noted itemized contributions totaling $143,092 from New York sources, and
$180,833.09 from sources outside of New York State. [FEC.gov, filed 10/15/15]
Katko Raised $143,883 In Itemized Contributions From DC, Maryland And Virginia. Accessed in
October 2015, Katko For Congress’ FEC report noted itemized contributions totaling $143,883.09 from
DC, Maryland, and Virginia. [FEC.gov, filed 10/15/15]
35.9% Of Contributions Came From Individuals. Accessed in October 2015, the FEC website noted
that 32.2% of Katko’s contributions were itemized individual contributions, and 3.7% were unitemized
individual contributions. [FEC.gov, accessed 10/15/15]
In July 2015, Katko reported $311,447.69 in contributions, $64,315.83 in expenditures, $474,989.27 cash on hand, and
$452.06 in debts.
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
366
311447.69
610929.35
0.00
0.00
311447.69
610929.35
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
64315.83
231358.99
0.00
1785.35
64315.83
229573.64
474989.27
0.00
452.06
Received Donations From Teamsters DRIVE, Laborers International Union, Sen. McConnell.
Katko For Congress’ FEC Report noted contributions from Teamsters Drive, the Laborers International
Union, and Sen. McConnell’s Bluegrass Committee. [FEC.gov, filed 7/15/15]
32.8% Of His Itemized Contributions Came From New York. Katko For Congress’ FEC report noted
itemized contributions totaling $99,405 from New York sources, and $203,679 from sources outside of
New York. [FEC.gov, filed 7/15/15]
In April 2015, Katko reported $286,601.66 in contributions, $66,556.97in expenditures, $225,892.41cash on hand, and $452.06
in debts.
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
367
286601.66
299481.66
0.00
0.00
286601.66
299481.66
Column A
This Period
Column B
Election
Cycle-To-Date
67321.97
167043.16
765.00
1785.35
66556.97
165257.81
225892.41
0.00
452.06
62% Of Fundraising During His First Quarter In Congress Was From PACs, After Criticizing
Previous Opponent For Taking Mostly Outside Money. “The PAC money accounted for 62 percent of
the total Katko’s campaign raised during his first three months in Con-gress, according to a Post-Standard
analysis of reports filed with the Federal Election Commission. … During his 2014 campaign, Katko
criticized his opponent, Rep. Dan Maffei, for taking most of his campaign cash from donors outside of
Central New York. Katko called Maffei, D-Syracuse, a Washington insider who had lost touch with
voters in Onondaga, Cayuga, Oswego and Wayne counties.” [Post Standard, 5/12/15]
Raised $177,672 From PACs During First Quarter In Washington, More Than All But Two Of New
York’s Congresspeople. “By April 1, Katko’s haul from PACs, most located outside of his 24th
Congressional District, totaled $177,672. The PAC money accounted for 62 percent of the total Katko’s
campaign raised during his first three months in Con-gress, according to a Post-Standard analysis of
reports filed with the Federal Election Commission. Katko, R-Camillus, raised more PAC money in the
quarter than all but two of New York’s 27 House members, the FEC records show.” [Post Standard,
5/12/15]
31.4% Of His Itemized Contributions Came From New York. Katko For Congress’ FEC report noted
itemized contributions totaling $94,715 from New York sources, and $206,936 from sources outside of
New York. [FEC.gov, filed 4/14/15]
Received Contributions From Jeb Bush, Koch Industries, Boehner, McCarthy, Scalise, Kline. Katko
For Congress’ FEC Report noted contributions from Bush, Koch, Boehner, McCarthy, Scalise, Kline or
their associated entities. [FEC.gov, filed 4/14/15]
2014 Campaign
368
2014: Raised $776,432, loaned Himself $45,000 and Ended with $247,431 Cash on Hand
In 2014, Katko raised $776,432 in donations and loaned himself $45,000. He spent $580,443 and was left
with $247,431 cash on hand. The campaign ended the cycle $45,000 in debt to Katko. [FEC, 11/13/14]
2014: Accepted Over $100,000 from Republican Leadership PACs
In 2014, Katko accepted $107,000 in donations from republican leadership PACs. [Center for Responsive
Politics, accessed 11/14/14]
He received donations from members of Congress such as Andy Harris, Cathy McMorris Rodgers, Sean
Duffy, Eric Cantor, Steve Scalise, John Boehner, Darrell Issa, Randy Neugebauer, Kevin McCarthy,
James McGovern, Patrick McHenry, Greg Walden, Patrick Tiberi, Kieth Rothfus, Steve Stivers, Fred
Upton, Tom Price, and Lynn Westmoreland. [FEC, accessed 11/14/14]
2014: Accepted Over $41,000 from Lawyers and Law Firms
In 2014, Katko accepted $41,775 in donations from lawyers and lawfirms. [Center for Responsive Politics,
accessed 11/14/14]
2014: Accepted Over $30,000 from the Real Estate Industry
In 2014, Katko accepted $30,875 in donations from the real estate industry. [Center for Responsive Politics,
accessed 11/14/14]
2014: Accepted Nearly $18,000 from Securities and Investments
In 2014, Katko accepted $17,900 in donations from securities and investments. [Center for Responsive Politics,
accessed 11/14/14]
2014: Accepted Over $13,000 from the Commercial Banking Industry
In 2014, Katko accepted $13,500 in donations from the commercial banking industry. [Center for Responsive
Politics, accessed 11/14/14]
2014: Accepted $11,000 from Health Professionals
In 2014, Katko accepted $11,000 in donations from health professionals. [Center for Responsive Politics,
accessed 11/14/14]
2014: Accepted Over $7,000 from the Insurance Industry
In 2014, Katko accepted $7,625 in donations from the insurance industry. [Center for Responsive Politics,
accessed 11/14/14]
369
Q1 2014: Five Donors Maxed Out Their Donations to Katko
In the first fundraising quarter of 2014, raised $60,650 in donations from 40 donors, five of which maxed
out their donations to Katko’s campaign, donating $2,600 for the primary and general elections.
Contributor’s Name
Roger L. Burdick
Roger L. Burdick
Shirley Burdick
Shirley Burdick
Roy H. Gibson
Roy H. Gibson
Bruce A. Kenan
Bruce A. Kenan
Linda H. Kenan
Linda H. Kenan
Employer
Burdick Automotive
Burdick Automotive
Info Requested
Info Requested
Roy H. Gibson Farms, Inc.
Roy H. Gibson Farms, Inc.
Pyramid Development
Pyramid Development
Info Requested
Info Requested
Occupation
Executive
Executive
Info Requested
Info Requested
Farmer
Farmer
Executive
Executive
Info Requested
Info Requested
Date
Amount
3/26/2014 $2,600.00
3/26/2014 $2,600.00
3/26/2014 $2,600.00
3/26/2014 $2,600.00
2/14/2014 $2,600.00
2/14/2014 $2,600.00
3/22/2014 $2,600.00
3/22/2014 $2,600.00
3/22/2014 $2,600.00
3/22/2014 $2,600.00
TOTAL: $26,000.00
[FEC, 4/13/14]
Roger Burdick Owned Largest Automotive Group in Central NY
In 2014, Roger Burdick was an executive of Driver’s Village, the largest automotive group in
central NY with 21 new car franchises, over 700 hundred pre-owned vehicles, and 12 dealerships
located under one roof. Driver’s Village was also home to many retail shops, services and local
organizations, such as a martial arts studio, a restaurant, an insurance agency, a conference center,
a chamber of commerce and a children’s art studio. [Driver’s Village, accessed 4/23/14]
Burdick was a Long Time Republican Donor
Since 1999, Burdick has donated $44,140 to national and congressional Republican
campaigns and organizations such as Ann Marie Buerkle for Congress, Matt Doheny for
Congress, the Republican National Committee, the National Republican Congressional
Committee, and Romney Victory, Inc. [FEC, accessed 4/23/14]
Burdick has also donated $30,550 to Republican and Independent state level candidates.
[Follow the Money, accessed, 4/23/14]
Bruce Kenan Owned Shopping Center Development Group
In 2014, Bruce Kenan was an executive of Pyramid Companies, the largest privately owned
developer of shopping centers in the Northeast. The company describes itself as “one of the
largest, most innovative, privately held developer of destination centers in America.” [Pyramid,
accessed 4/23/14]
Pyramid led the development of Destiny USA in Syracuse. [Auburn Citizen, 4/13/14]
370
Kenan was a Long Time Political Donor
Since 1997, Kenan has donated $97,400 to national and congressional campaigns and
organizations for Republicans and Democrats such as Kirsten Gillibrand for Senate,
Friends of Hilary Clinton, the NY Republican Federal Campaign Committee, Romney for
President, the Republican National Committee, Ann Marie Buerkle for Congress, and
Friends of Dan Maffei. [FEC, accessed 4/23/14]
Kenan has also potentially donated at least $137,958 to state level candidates and
campaigns. [Follow the Money, accessed, 4/23/14]
A John Katko in North Carolina Donated to Campaign
In March 2014, a John Katko who lives in Charlotte, NC donated $250 to Katko’s campaign. It is
unconfirmed if they are related. [FEC, 4/13/14]
NOTE: A Nexis public records search performed on April 24, 2014 showed that Katko’s parents are
Andrew and Marylou Katko living in Syracuse, NY. A March 2014 article in the Post-Standard reported
that a Mary Lou Katko was John Katko’s mother.
2014 Campaign Finance Summary
Katko’s campaign raised $1,029,766 in 2014, including a $45,000 loan from Katko
Katko’s campaign spent $1,017,697 in 2014.
371
Auburn Office
FEC Records Do Not Show Disbursements For Rent For His Auburn Campaign Office, Which He
Announced Plans For In June 2014, Opened It In September 2014
June 2014: Said He Planned To Have A District Office In The Same Building As The Galbato Law
Firm. “At a town hall meeting Tuesday night, Katko, R-Camillus, was asked whether he would keep a
district office in Cayuga County if he is elected to represent the 24th Congressional District. ‘I already
have it picked out, so yes,’ he said. Katko said his Auburn district office, if he wins, will be located in
what was the Crosman Building, which is now home to the Galbato Law Firm. The building is located at
the corner of Genesee and North streets in downtown Auburn.” [The Citizen, 6/10/14]
September 2014: Opened Campaign Office At 71 Genesee, In The Same Building As The Galbato
Law Firm. “Katko, R-Camillus, hosted a ribbon-cutting ceremony Friday outside of his Auburn office.
The campaign headquarters, located at 71 Genesee St., is in the same building that houses the Galbato
Law Firm. … At a Moravia town hall meeting in June, Katko said he had a site selected — the 71
Genesee St. building — for his district office if he defeats U.S. Rep. Dan Maffei in the general election. ”
Galbato LLC Owns 71 Genesee St. Accessed in October 2015, Cayuga County Property Records
noted that Galbato LLC owned the real property at 71 Genesee St, Auburn NY. [cayugacounty.us,
accessed 10/16/15]
FEC Data Shows No Disbursements From Katko For Congress To Galbato LLC. FEC data
do not include any payments from Katko for Congress to Galbato LLC. [fec.gov, accessed
10/14/15]
FEC Records Show Disbursements For Rent For His Syracuse Office
372
FEC Data Shows Payments From Katko For Congress To DB&J Enterprises For Office Rent In
Syracuse. Katko For Congress FEC filings note payments to DB&J enterprises for office rent in Syracuse
at 709 Erie Blvd W. [FEC.gov, accessed 10/16/15]
Turned His Auburn Campaign Office Into A District Office, Paid Rent From His Office Accounts
November 2014: Said He Planned To Turn His Auburn Campaign Office Into His District Office.
“Once the transition is complete, Katko plans to turn his Auburn campaign office into his district office.
The space is located at 71 Genesee St., near the corner of Genesee and North streets, and is inside a
building that also houses the Galbato Law Firm.” [The Citizen, 11/07/15]
January 2015: Announced District Office At 71 Genesee. “As Rep.-elect John Katko prepares for his
official swearing-in on Tuesday, he has revealed where his offices will be located in the 24th
Congressional District and announced a collection of new staff hires. … The Auburn office will be at 71
Genesee St. inside the same building that houses the Galbato Law Firm. The office is in a prime location
at the corner of Genesee and North streets in downtown Auburn.” [The Citizen, 1/02/15]
Q1 2015: Katko’s Office Paid Three Payments Of $550 To GALBATO LLC For Rent.
According to the Clerk of the House’s Statement of Disbursement for The First Quarter of 2015,
Katko’s office paid three payments of $550 for “rent” to Galbato LLC. [2015 Q1 U.S. House
Statement of Disbursements, accessed 10/08/15]
373
Appendix II – Paid Media Summary
The following outlines paid media from the 2014 campaign cycle.
NOTE: Video of the ads below is available from the DCCC Research Department.
2014 Election
America Unity PAC: “Rudy”
America Unity PAC
“Rudy”
10/29/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
RUDY GIULIANI: America needs strong leaders. That’s why I’m proud to endorse John Katko for
Congress. As a federal prosecutor, John dedicated his career to fighting crime and stopping gang violence.
He understands we need strong leadership and peace through strength to keep America safe. And he’ll
fight to control wasteful spending and make government more efficient and effective. On November forth,
please support John Katko for Congress.
V.O.: American Unity PAC is responsible for the content of this advertising.
House Majority PAC: “Consider”
House Majority PAC
“Consider”
10/13/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
V.O.: Before you vote, consider where John Katko stands. John Katko opposes a women’s right to
choose. He supports letting employers deny women access to birth control. And John Katko even opposes
the Paycheck Fairness Act, which ensures women doing the same work get paid the same as men. John
Katko: anti-choice, restricting access to birth control, and against equal pay for women. John Katko is too
conservative for New York.
House Majority PAC is responsible for the content of this advertising.
House Majority PAC: “Force”
House Majority PAC
“Force”
374
10/27/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
V.O.: Some right wing politicians try to force their views on everyone else, like John Katko. John Katko
opposes a woman’s right to choose. He’ll let employers deny women access to birth control. John Katko
would even let employers pay women less than men for the same work. Against the right to choose,
restricting access to birth control, and against equal pay for women. Those are John Katko’s beliefs, and
he wants to force them on you.
House Majority PAC is responsible for the content of this ad.
Katko for Congress: “Family” (Radio)
Katko for Congress
“Force”
4/30/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
KATKO: I’m John Katko. My wife Robin and I are just like any other family, juggle work and home life,
caring for aging parents, and raising three boys. We were born here, grew up here, and chose to raise our
sons in Central New York. For too long now our region has struggled to keep up. It’s time we had a
Congressman to lead the charge to get ahead.
I’m John Katko, candidate for Congress, and I approve this message. Join my fight at
JohnKatkoForCongress.com.
V.O.: Paid for by the Katko for Congress Committee.
Katko for Congress: “Introduction” (Radio)
John Katko for Congress
“Introduction”
4/30/2014
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
KATKO: I’m John Katko. It’s plain to see that Washington just isn’t working. Massive debt and
unsustainable spending, gridlock and threatened default, uncertainty that’s left companies unwilling to
hire new employees. I’m not a professional politician schooled in the failed ways of Washington. I’m a
former prosecutor, skilled in getting the job done right, together, the first time.
375
I’m John Katko, candidate for congress, and I approve this message. Join me in my fight at
johnkatkoforcongress.com
V.O.: Paid for by the Katko for Congress Committee.
Katko for Congress: “Courage”
John Katko for Congress
“Courage”
8/27/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
KATKO: I’m John Katko, and I approve this message.
BEBETTE YUNIS: I’ve known John Katko for twenty two years. What stands out most about John to me
is his personal courage, on the US-Mexico border, and right here at home. Getting violent criminals and
illegal drugs off our streets, protecting our families: that courage, that commitment will go to Congress
with him. It’s the courage to do what’s right, no matter what.
Katko for Congress: “There for All of Us”
Katko for Congress
“There For All of Us”
9/9/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT
KATKO: I’m John Katko, and I approve this message.
APPREONA SULLIVAN: I live my whole life in a neighborhood most people try to avoid. But not John
Katko. He went after the drug traffickers and violent gangs. He made our family safer. And John Katko’s
been my personal mentor, inspiring me to pursue a career in criminal justice. He’s been there for me,
every step of the way. In Congress, John Katko will be there, for all of us.
Katko for Congress: “Robin”
Katko for Congress
“Robin”
10/1/14
0:30
TRANSCRIPT

Research Book

Transcription

Similar documents

w hile you have been busy taking care of your family

Cable Dahmer Chevrolet

POLCO ELGL Demo

2016 Park Brochure

award-Winning Family Fun!

Children`s Halloween Costume Party

The 15th Amendment

President Johnson and the Right to Vote (re Selma), undated

This interactive internet scavenger hunt is a engaging and

View entry - North Carolina Press Association