Session 3 What are we calculating and why European energy standards related to the EPBD (TC371) New features in EN 15603
Transcription
Session 3 What are we calculating and why European energy standards related to the EPBD (TC371) New features in EN 15603
Session 3 European energy standards related to the EPBD (TC371) New features in EN 15603 “Overall energy use and definition of energy ratings” Laurent SOCAL What are we calculating and why EPBD takes into account the following confort services: • Heating ∙ Ventilation • Domestic hot water ∙ Cooling • Lighting … The objective is to calculate the «energy» required to provide those services: • at a standardised level with standard boundary conditions (climate, use) but taking into account the real system Æ components properties and operating conditions Æ energy performance for certificates and building permits • taking into account actual service level and actual boundary conditions Æ energy audit, recommendations for energy saving measures …also for existing and old systems to show the actual energy performance and the improvement potential Structure of the procedure 2 How is the calculation performed Building energy balance Æ needs = heat to be supplied by systems Technical systems are divided in functional subsystems: • Generation (energy carrier to required service) • Storage (decoupling generation and use of the service) • Distribution (distributing in the building) • Emission (transferring the service from systems to buildings) • Emission control (controlling the transfer of the service into the building) Technical systems energy balance Æ delivered energy by energy carriers what has to be supplied to the building Outside the building, energy and environmental cost of the delivered energy carrier are taken into account by conversion factors Æ primary energy, emissions, costs … global cost of the service Structure of the procedure 3 The role of EN 15603 Building energy balance Building service 1 Technical system losses & aux. energy Building needs Inside the building 2 Final weighting Delivered <--> exported energy ENERGY CARRIER 3 Energy rating (prim. energy, CO2, etc) Outside the building EN 15603: •Defines the calculation structure for steps 1 & 2 & 3 •Deals with common issues (definitions, symbols, …) •Gives calculation procedure and data for step 3 Structure of the procedure 4 New features of prEN 15603:2013 … compared to the previous version EN 15603:2008: •explicit support for national options; •improved set of definitions [2]; •new and improved concepts about assessment boundaries, such as on‐site / nearby / distant [2] •explicit reference modular structure [3] •explicit technical systems modular structure [3] •analysis of possible building partitioning and technical systems zoning •delivered and exported energy balance, including time relation of energy delivery and import •definition of additional performance indicators [2] •option to include non EPBD energy uses •support for an hourly method [4]. Details given in the following presentations [2] – Johann Zirngibl ‐ Fundamental definitions for the assessment of the energy performance [3] – Routing and Modular Structure – Filling the Gaps in the CEN Standards for High Performance Buildings. [4] ‐ Standardized calculation methods in relation to the EPBD Structure of the procedure 5 Why standards ? To enforce a legal requirement you need: •The definition of a property (computable only or also measurable?) •A method to calculate the value of that property (suitable for daily practice) •The required boundary conditions (standard but representative enough of actual use to be meaningful) •The legally binding value (reasonably strict, achievable, verifiable, …) STANDARDS Å Æ REGULATION : Collaboration required 0 °C 20 °C EN Needs Systems Primary Structure of the procedure LAW EP,H,max 50 kWh/m² 6 Can we compare? When comparing several regulations … •Did you define the same property? •Do you use the same calculation method? •Did you set the same boundary conditions? •Did you set the same limit? DIN 20 °C ENEV EP,H,max 50 kWh/m² UNI 20 °C Dlgs… EP,H,max 40 kWh/m² 0 °C 3 °C Structure of the procedure 27 MS … But how many regions? 7 How to get together again… Directive 2002/91/CE: only heating and cooling needs calculation was consolidated as EN standard (EN 13790) 1st mandate to CEN Æ delivered in 2007…2008 In the meanwhile, each MS had to develop its own legal requirements, boundary conditions and standards, 2nd mandate to CEN Æ bring standards together again, so… •Define a common frame •Enable to choose national options within that frame •Define a set of default EN options where applicable •Type of options: – National data – Method selection criteria Æ Annex A ‐ NA Æ Annex B ‐ NB Structure of the procedure 8 Example 1: design external temperature (EN 12831) Basic features: •A set of reference locations with temperature θdes,l and elevation zl is given •Adjustment according to heigth Æ a local gradient Gl can be defined nationally •Adjustment according to building time constant Æ a correction factor according to time constant kτ can be defined nationally θ des ,bdg = θ des ,l − (zbdg − zl )⋅ Gl + kτ ⋅τ bdg τbdg National Annex should include for each NSB: •A list of reference location with relevant properties name, θdes,l , zl, G,l , kτ •If no correction with inertia is required/allowed, Æ just set kτ=0 (many) •If no correction with height is required, Æ just set Gl = 0 (Netherland?) zbdg θdes,bdg zl θdes,l, G,l, kτ Location data Structure of the procedure 9 Example 2 : primary energy factors Primary energy factors •Default CEN data given in Annex A •National annex NA can override these values, also adding new lines Æ but it takes seconds to recalculate with new values or EN default values Structure of the procedure 10 … this is what we are calculating …. Structure of the procedure 11 Small existing building? You just calculate it as one single piece …as you would eat a small pastry in one single bite.. = no partitioning required Structure of the procedure 12 Big building, arcade + office + residential? … but what if there is a big cake on the table? You have to eat it slice by slice … Æ Partitioning required for complex buildings! Structure of the procedure 13 High performance The amount of energy involved is so small that any interaction may be relevant. Example domestic hot water losses and cooling… Also localization of gains is relevant. Will Solar gains of the big window in the living facing south effectively heat upstairs north rooms? Thermal zones or even room by room calculation may be required… Structure of the procedure 14 Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4 Apartment 3 Room 5 Room 6 Room 7 Room 8 Apartment 2 Room 9 Room 10 Room 11 Room 12 Apartment 1 Staircas e Room 21 Room 13 Room 14 Room 15 Office 1 Office 2 Room 16 Room 18 Room 17 Arcade, shops Room 19 Room 20 Meeting room Our big cake… 1 building Ð 7 building units + 1 common unheated staircase Ð 21 rooms Structure of the procedure 15 So, what is “partitioning”? For each calculation aspect (building, systems) the need may appear to «partition» the building for that piece of calculation. If and how to split into parts the building depends on the specific aspect being calculated. – Heating needs, domestic hot water needs, ventilation, … – Technical systems calculation – Primary energy allocation and energy performance display … and resulting partitions are not always the same … … and there can be interactions between partitions of the same type or of different types «PARTITIONING» IS THE GENERALISATION OF THE CONCEPT OF «ZONES» Structure of the procedure 16 Is there already partitioning in current standards? In EN ISO 13790 there are already «thermal zones» •A thermal zone is a set of «rooms» that share their losses and gains in a common heat balance. •It is recognised by EN ISO 13790 that it is not always correct to think that all rooms in a big building can be thought to share their losses and gains – «Rooms are grouped into» thermal zones… … = «the building is partitioned into» thermal zones •Next question: shall we take into account interactions between «thermal zones»? Æ EN 13790: adiabiatic (no heat exchange ) or coupled zones? Structure of the procedure 17 Thermal zones Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Space 4 QH,nd,123 = QH,tr,123 + QH,ve,123 – QH,gn,123 ∙ ηH,gn,123 QH,nd,4 = QH,tr,4 + QH,ve,4– QH,gn,4 ∙ ηH,gn,4 This partitioning specifies which parts of the building are assumed to share losses and gains. A finer thermal zoning may be used to facilitate connection with heating system calculation and energy performance indicators expression, as suggested in EN 13790 § 6.3.2.1. A higher count of smaller thermal zones is not always a guarantee of better results if interactions between thermal zones are neglected. The increase in costs due to higher data input complication and calculation time may even result in less significant results Structure of the procedure 18 Room 1 Room 2 Room 3 Room 4 Apartment 3 Room 5 Room 6 Room 7 Room 8 THERMAL ZONE 1 Apartment 2 Room 9 Room 10 Room 11 Room 12 Apartment 1 Staircas e Room 21 Room 13 Room 14 Room 15 Office 1 Room 16 Office 2 THERMAL ZONE 2 Room 18 Room 17 Arcade, shops Room 19 THERMAL ZONE 3 Room 20 Meeting room 1 building Ð 4 Thermal zones «partitions» Ð 21 Rooms Each room «belongs» to 1 heating zone THERMAL ZONE 4 …hierarchy… Structure of the procedure 19 Partitioning criteria Identified possible partitioning criteria Needs calculation •Operating zones: H, C, V Æ set points, use, … •Heating needs balance Æ compensation gains, losses •Cooling needs balance Æ compensation gains, losses •Domestic hot water needs balance Æ per building unit •Ventilation system zones Æ supply, extract, transit Technical systems calculation •Ventilation system zones Æ supply, extract, transit •Heating system zones Æ heating circuits (emission and control) •Domestic hot water system zones •Cooling system zones Æ heating circuits (emission and control) •Lighting Energy performance allocation and display •Building units Structure of the procedure 20 Example Original base Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Space 4 Space 5 Space 6 Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Space 4 Space 5 Space 6 Partition 1 Part a Space 1 Space 2 Part b Space 3 Part A Partition 2 Space 4 Space 5 Part B Space 6 Part C Structure of the procedure 21 Elementary space: the basic logical element Room 1 Room 2 Space 12 Space 1 Space 2 Room 3 Room 4 Space 34 Space 3 Space Space 4A 4A Physical Logical Less details needed Logical More details needed The base of the partition is not necessarily the physical room. Very often partitions can be based on group of rooms (even entire building units or more) Sometimes an finer partition is required and a room shall be split in parts. The base of the partitions is called “elementary space” to avoid confusion with physical rooms. Structure of the procedure 22 Why a common element? Partition 1 – Part a 80 20 Space 1 40 Partition 1 – Part b 100 20 Space 2 30 Space 3 Space 4 30 Space 5 40 Space 6 20+40=60 20+30+30=80 40 Partition 2 Part A Partition 2 Part B Partition 2 Part C In principle, partitioning criteria are independent. If all partitions are based on the same elementary space, it will always be possible to connect the respective part of the calculation. If there is no common element this will be “invented” at calculation time As far as possible partitions shall be kept the same to simplify calculation The “elementary space” can be much larger than 1 room: sometimes 1 building unit Structure of the procedure 23 Sub‐division rule Heating system zone 1 Radiators Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Heating needs balance partition (thermal zone)1 Heating system zone 2 Floor heating Space 4 Space 5 Space 6 Sub‐division rule is needed when the result for an entire partition shall be divided in parts. EXAMPLE: 1 thermal zone 2 heating circuits The calculation of the heating needs was done for the entire building. Operating conditions depend on energy to be delivered If three two different types of systems, the energy need shall be split according to a «sub‐division rule» … or two thermal zones should have been calculated … Structure of the procedure 24 Example Partition 1 – part 1 80 20 Space 1 Partition 1 – part 2 100 20 40 Space 2 30 Space 3 Space 4 60 30 40 Space 5 Space 6 40 80 Partition 2 Part B Partition 2 Part A Partition 2 Part C Sub‐division rule: getting the values for the individual spaces (20, 40 and 20) from the 80 that was calculated for the entire partition. This is required only if data shall be passed to another partition based on a different set of spaces Structure of the procedure 25 Distribution rule Recoverable losses Heating needs balance zone 1 Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Recoverable losses Heating needs balance zone 2 Space 4 Space 5 Space 6 A “distribution” rule is needed when the result coming from another partition shall be divided in parts. EXAMPLE: 2 thermal zones Losses from domestic hot water distribution Losses of the domestic hot water distribution is recovered for heating. If only the total losses are known, they shall be «distributed» to the thermal zones Otherwise, location of each pipe should be known with respect to the thermal zones Structure of the procedure 26 Example Partition 1 80 20 Space 1 40 Space 2 60 Partition 2 100 20 30 Space 3 Space 4 30 Space 5 20 60 Partition 2 Part A Space 6 0 80 Partition 2 Part B 40 40 Partition 2 Part C Distribution rule is a short‐cut. Instead of allocating data to individual spaces to group them again, it is allocated directly based on the destination partitioning Structure of the procedure 27 Structuring the data (soft proof) Description of the building and their systems has to be organised hierarchically depending on multiple criteria (calculated service or results needed) •Smallest part part of the This is relevant for building: «(elementary) space» “software proof structure”. •Parts (zones) are groups of spaces Each building element inherits that share the same balance some properties, like equations (i.e. that are temperature, from the calculated together) connected rooms whilst other •Partition is the complete subdivision shall be attributed at element of the original building into a set of level. Own properties shall be parts, according to a specific criteria specified individually in an XML record of the structure, whilst All partitions shall be based on other properties will be found in the same set of elementary spaces to guarantee the possibility the hierarchically connected to communicate data from one higher item partition to another one Æ USER INTERFACE Structure of the procedure 28 Space 1 Apartment 3 Partition 1 Space 2 Partition 2 Apartment 2 Space 3 Staircas e Apartment 1 Space 9 Space 5 Space 4 Partition 4 Partition 3 Office 2 Partition 5 Office 1 Space 6 Partition 6 Arcade, shops Space 7 Space 8 Meeting room Partition 7 If energy calculation is involved, each building unit can often be considered one logical space. Even a complex building can often be represented by a limited number of elementary spaces. At design stage, a room by room calculation is usually required. Structure of the procedure 29 Why and how partitioning in prEN 15603 • prEN15603 does not specify «if» and «when» to partition: this will be a task of specific standards • prEN15603 provides a common frame for partitioning to guarantee for transparent calculation links Without a common frame you can’t guarantee consistency • Dealing with potentially complex buildings and systems, it is much easier to simplify within a comprehensive scheme than adding exceptions later • An analysis of partitioning needs highlights some hidden features • As far as possible, rules will be given to limit partitioning and to synchronize partitions: the easiest way is finding a common partition and handle exceptions with distribution rules. Structure of the procedure 30 Building units Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Space 4 Apartment 3 Space 5 Space 6 Space 7 Building unit 1 Space 8 Space 9 Staircas e Space 21 Space 10 Space 11 Space 12 Apartment 1 Space 13 Space 14 Space 16 Building unit 3 Space 15 Office 2 Building unit 5 Building unit 4 Office 1 Space 17 Space 18 Building unit 6 Arcade, shops Space 19 Energy certificate may refer to individual building units. Building unit 2 Apartment 2 If building unit 1, 2 and 3 are sold or rented, is it correct to give the same energy performance for all of them? Space 20 Meeting room Building unit 7 Structure of the procedure 31 Building operating conditions Operating zone 1 Space 1 Space 2 20 °C 26 °C 50% RH n = 0,5 20 °C 26 °C 50% RH n = 0,5 Op. zone 2 Space i Op. zone 3 20 °C 26 °C 60% RH n = 2,0 16 °C 24 °C 50% RH n = 0,2 Space n Building operating conditions may differ from space to space depending on the use of each space even within the same building unit School = office + classrooms + sports hall + meeting room Some spaces may not get all service Æ other indicators? (Example: no cooling, no ventilation, …) Operating conditions are linked to space category Structure of the procedure 32 Building category ? Space 1 Space 2 Space 3 Apartment 3 Space 5 Space 6 Space 7 Space 4 Residential Space 8 Apartment 2 Space 9 Staircas e Space 10 Space 11 It is more appropriate to consider "space categories". Space 12 Apartment 1 Space 21 Space 13 Space 14 Space 16 Space 17 Arcade, shops Space 19 Space 15 Office 2 Offices Office 1 EPBD directive lists "building categories“ (admin. ref. For EP?) Space 18 Commercial Space 20 Meeting room Conference center “Space category” determines default operating conditions. Operating conditions are a property of individual spaces, not of the building as a whole. Structure of the procedure 33 Ventilation zones Space 1 SUPPLY Space 2 Space 3 Space 4 . EXTRACT This partitioning specifies in which spaces air is: naturally ventilated just by airing naturally ventilated through ducts or openings Supplied, extract or transiting because of mechanical ventilation systems Structure of the procedure 34 S 1 S 2 S 4 S 3 A 3 S 5 S 6 A 2 S 9 VZ 1 S 7 S 8 S 11 S 12 AIR S 10 A 1 SC S 21 S 13 O 1 VZ 2 S 14 SUP EXT S 16 S 15 VZ 3 O 2 SUP EXT When ventilation is involved, it has to be specified which are supply, extract, supply and extract transit rooms… S 18 S 17 VZ 4 AS AIR S 19 S 20 MC SUP EXT VZ 5 EXT SUP Structure of the procedure S 1 R S 2 A 3 S 5 R S 6 A 2 S 9 SC S 21 R O 1 R HZ 1 R S 10 S 11 R R S 14 S 13 HZ 2 FC S 16 FC S 19 FC AS R S 8 S 7 R A 1 S 4 S 3 R 35 Heating systems zones R S 12 R O 2 S 15 The AHU is a considered as a heating zone as well FC S 18 S 17 FC FC S 20 MC HZ 3 AHU Structure of the procedure GEN 36 S 1 S 2 S 3 S 4 S 6 S 7 S 8 S 10 S 11 S 12 A 3 S 5 A 2 S 9 A 1 SC S 21 O 1 S 14 S 13 CZ 1 FC S 16 FC S 19 FC AS O 2 S 15 Cooling systems zones The AHU is a considered as a cooling zone as well FC S 18 S 17 FC FC S 20 MC CZ 2 AHU CHL Structure of the procedure 37 Will it be complicated? • Sometimes buildings are complicated… • The standard shall be designed to handle the worst case worth dealing with • In most cases, residential sector, no complicated partitioning is expected A possible minimum requirement could be having a partitioning at least by building unit Æ See next slide Structure of the procedure 38 Example: 12 flats, centralised system Is it correct to give one single EP value for the whole building ? B.u. Floor Net area Gross volume m² m³ kWh/m² % 1 1 82,4 324,5 232,1 92,6 2 1 65,6 258,3 245,8 98,1 3 1 72,8 286,7 254,0 101,4 4 1 89,6 352,8 239,8 95,7 5 2 82,4 309 154,8 61,8 6 2 65,6 246 197,2 78,7 7 2 72,8 273 204,8 81,7 EPHW 8 2 89,6 336 159,8 63,8 For old buildings exposed surface is important. 9 3 82,4 324,5 321,5 128,3 For new buildings solar gains can make strong differences 10 3 56,8 223,7 353,4 141,0 11 3 61,6 242,6 363,5 145,0 12 3 89,6 352,8 326,5 130,3 911,2 3.530 250,6 100 The table was obtained with a calculation with 12 spaces = 12 building units Directive 2012/27/EU asks for metering… Total building Structure of the procedure 39 A simple and innocent formula… EP = ∑ ( fP; del; cr, i ⋅ E del; cr, i ) − ∑ ( fP; exp; cr, i ⋅ E exp; cr, i ) i Energy performance i Weighted delivered energy Weighted exported energy The same formula applies also for a number of other possible metrics •Non renewable, renewable, total primary energy •Emissions (CO2 emission factors) •Costs (specific cost or revenue) •Policy factors •… Structure of the procedure 40 CAN THIS BE NZEB? 6 MWh el -15 MWhprim 15 MWh oil THIS WILL NOT BE A NZEB IF MULTIPLE REQUIREMENTS ARE SET (ALSO NEEDS) 16,5 MWhprim 1,5 MWhprim … BUT IT CAN BE CLASS A INDEED … Looks like a PEB (Plus energy building…) 4,0 MWh el 2,0 MWh el According to the yearly balance this is a Positive Energy Building… 42 - 10 MWhprim 5 MWhprim - 5,0 MWhprim 26/07/2013 CAN THIS REALLY BE PEB? 0,5 MWh el -1,25 MWhprim 3,5 MWh el - 8,75 MWhprim 1,5 MWh el 3,75 MWhprim 0,5 MWh el 1,25 MWhprim … but this is because a summer surplus overcompensates the winter deficit… So during winter non renewable resources have to be used. 43 2,5 MWhprim - 7,5 MWhprim 26/07/2013 Support by prEN 15603:2013 New features of EN 15603: •Explicit support of national options to allow inclusion/exclusion of exported energy from the rating. •Explicit consideration of the timing of delivered / exported energy flows Structure of the procedure 44 Yearly balance OFF‐SITE ON‐SITE 0 kWh 1220 kWh EEPus,el 590 kWh Edel,el,grid Edel,el EPB Electricity uses 590 kWh Edel,el,rdel GRID 590 kWh Eexp,el,tmp 600 kWh EnEPus,el 630 kWh Epr,el,used,EPus Non‐EPB Electricity uses 340 kWh Eexp,el,used,nEPus 1660 kWh 340 kWh Eexp,el Eexp,el,used,nEPus 1030 kWh 690 kWh Eexp,el,nused 100 kWh Eexp,el,grid OUTSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Epr,el In‐site electric generation INSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Structure of the procedure 45 Definition of balance items z z z z z z z z z EEPus,el is the electricity used to provide EPBD services in the calculation step Epr,el is the on-site electricity produced in the calculation step Epr,el,used,EPus is the produced on-site electricity that is used to provide EPBD services in the calculation step Its value is the minimum of Epr,el and EEPus,el Edel ,el is the electric energy that has to be delivered by the grid in the calculation step Eexp,el is the on-site electricity produced in excess of that used for EPBD services in the same calculation step Æ Only one of Eexp,el and Edel,el can be different than zero Eexp,el,nEPus is the on-site produced electricity that is exported for on-site immediate use in the same calculation time step Eexp,el,tmp is the on-site produced electricity is exported to the grid in a calculation time step and will be used as Edel,el,rdel for EPBD uses in a different calculation step Æ the energy cost of accepting and giving back the electricity can be taken into account on this item. Eexp,el,grid is the electricity finally exported. Edel,el,grid is the net yearly electric energy delivered by the grid The phisical meaning of Eexp,tmp and Erdel is correct for hourly calculation intervals. For monthly intervals it doesn’t take into account day/night compensation. 46 Aggiornamento sulle norme tecniche per il calcolo della prestazione energetica 26/07/2013 Monthly details Time‐step balance (monthly as an example) Yearly total JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC EPBD uses non EPBD uses Produced electricity EPBD Used electricity Exported electricity kWh kWh kWh kWh 1.220 600 1.660 630 1.030 250 200 150 80 20 30 50 40 20 50 150 180 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 40 60 80 120 160 200 240 240 200 160 100 60 40 60 80 80 20 30 50 40 20 50 100 60 0 0 0 40 140 170 190 200 180 110 0 0 Exported for non EPBD uses kWh 340 0 40 50 50 50 50 0 0 Exported non used Delivered Yearly temporary exp Temporary exported Redelivered Grid exported Grid delivered kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh 690 590 590 0 0 210 140 0 70 0 0 90 0 120 140 150 130 0 0 0 0 60 0 0 50 0 120 590 0 0 210 140 0 0 0 0 0 70 0 0 0 0 0 0 77 0 13 0 103 120 128 111 0 0 0 0 17 20 22 19 0 0 0 0 51 0 9 0 0 50 0 0 0 120 0 0 590 100 0 0 0 50 50 Structure of the procedure 47 Monthly details: EPB uses and production 250 200 150 100 50 0 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG E..EPus,el,t SEP OCT NOV DEC E..pr,el,t Surplus production in summer, deficit in winter Structure of the procedure 48 Temporary exported and redelivered 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 ‐50 ‐100 ‐150 ‐200 JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN Temporary exported JUL AUG SEP OCT Redelivered NOV DEC The summer surplus is temporary exported to be redelivered in winter Structure of the procedure 49 Possibile uses of the produced electricity OFF‐SITE ON‐SITE 0 kWh 1220 kWh EEPus,el 590 kWh Edel,el,grid Edel,el EPB Electricity uses 590 kWh Edel,el,rdel GRID 590 kWh Eexp,el,tmp 600 kWh EnEPus,el 630 kWh Epr,el,used,EPus Non‐EPB Electricity uses 340 kWh Eexp,el,used,nEPus 1660 kWh 340 kWh Eexp,el Eexp,el,used,nEPus 1030 kWh 690 kWh Eexp,el,nused 100 kWh Eexp,el,grid OUTSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Structure of the procedure Epr,el In‐site electric generation INSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY 50 July balance OFF‐SITE ON‐SITE 0 kWh 50 kWh 0 kWh Edel,el,grid EEPus,el Edel,el EPB Electricity uses 0 kWh Edel,el,rdel GRID 120 kWh Eexp,el,tmp 50 kWh EnEPus,el 50 kWh Epr,el,used,EPus Non‐EPB Electricity uses 50 kWh Eexp,el,used,nEPus 240 kWh Eexp,el 50 kWh Eexp,el,used,nEPus 190 kWh 140 kWh Eexp,el,nused 20 kWh Eexp,el,grid OUTSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Epr,el In‐site electric generation INSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Structure of the procedure 51 January balance OFF‐SITE ON‐SITE 0 kWh 250 kWh 210 kWh Edel,el,grid EEPus,el Edel,el EPB Electricity uses 210 kWh Edel,el,rdel GRID 0 kWh Eexp,el,tmp 50 kWh EnEPus,el 40 kWh Epr,el,used,EPus Non‐EPB Electricity uses 0 kWh Eexp,el,used,nEPus 40 kWh Eexp,el 0 kWh Eexp,el,used,nEPus 0 kWh 0 kWh Eexp,el,nused 0 kWh Eexp,el,grid OUTSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Structure of the procedure Epr,el In‐site electric generation INSIDE THE ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY 52 National options… Primary energy balance Primary energy for Epr,el Delivered fP,del ,el Exported for non EPBD uses f P,exp,el ,us ed,nEPus Temporary exported fP,exp,el ,tmp Grid exported f P,exp,el ,gri d TOTAL Total Actual Renewable Non renew kWh fP,ren kWh fP,nren kWh f P,tot kWh 1.660 1,00 1.660 0,00 0 1,00 1.660 590 0,00 0 2,50 1.475 2,50 1.475 340 0,00 0 2,50 ‐850 2,50 ‐850 590 0,00 0 2,50 ‐1.475 2,50 ‐1.475 100 0,00 0 2,50 ‐250 2,50 ‐250 1.660 ‐1.100 560 Grid exported evaluated as delivered – all fp set to 2,50 Primary energy balance Primary energy for Epr,el Delivered fP,del ,el Exported for non EPBD uses f P,exp,el ,us ed,nEPus Temporary exported fP,exp,el ,tmp Grid exported f P,exp,el ,gri d TOTAL Total Actual Renewable Non renew kWh fP,ren kWh fP,nren kWh f P,tot kWh 1.660 1,00 1.660 0,00 0 1,00 1.660 590 0,00 0 2,50 1.475 2,50 1.475 340 0,00 0 2,50 ‐850 2,50 ‐850 590 0,00 0 2,50 ‐1.475 2,50 ‐1.475 100 0,00 0 0,00 0 0,00 0 1.660 ‐850 810 Grid exported neglected, temporary exported still taken into account Structure of the procedure 53 National options… Primary energy balance Primary energy for Epr,el Delivered fP,del ,el Exported for non EPBD uses f P,exp,el ,us ed,nEPus Temporary exported fP,exp,el ,tmp Grid exported f P,exp,el ,gri d TOTAL Total Actual Renewable Non renew kWh fP,ren kWh fP,nren kWh f P,tot kWh 1.660 1,00 1.660 0,00 0 1,00 1.660 590 0,00 0 2,50 1.475 2,50 1.475 340 0,00 0 2,50 ‐850 2,50 ‐850 590 0,00 0 0,00 0 0,00 0 100 0,00 0 0,00 0 0,00 0 1.660 625 2.285 Grid exported and temporary exported all neglected Primary energy balance Primary energy for Epr,el Delivered fP,del ,el Exported for non EPBD uses f P,exp,el ,us ed,nEPus Temporary exported fP,exp,el ,tmp Grid exported f P,exp,el ,gri d TOTAL Total Actual Renewable Non renew kWh fP,ren kWh fP,nren kWh f P,tot kWh 1.660 1,00 1.660 0,00 0 1,00 1.660 590 0,00 0 2,50 1.475 2,50 1.475 340 0,00 0 0,00 0 0,00 0 590 0,00 0 0,00 0 0,00 0 100 0,00 0 0,00 0 0,00 0 1.660 1.475 3.135 Also non EPBD uses not considered = only syncronous EPBD uses taken into account Structure of the procedure 54 Possible further developments A: Renewable primary energy export B: Decrease in non renewable primary energy delivery EP,ren EP,nren ASSESSMENT BOUNDARY Option “B” is the most popular until now. If a building has to be rated as part of a cluster, option “A” is more appropriate Structure of the procedure 55