ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
Transcription
ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
1177 Phenology ofBees (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) in a Transition Area Between the Cerrado and the Amazon Region in Brazil by Carlos Alfredo Lopes de Carvalhol, Florisvaldo Mesquita dos Santosl, Rejane Ferreira Silva2 & Bruno de Almeida Souza3 ABSTRACT The phenology ofbees in a transition area between the Cerrado and the Amazon in the Bico-do-Papagaio region, in the State ofTocantins, Brazil, was studied monthly fram November 1999 to November 2000. The 83 species collected were distributed over the year, and 61.45% occurred in both the rainy and dry periods, while 19.28% only occurred in the rainy or the dry period, respectively. The number of individuaIs captured was 54.37% in the dry period and 45.63% in the rainy period. Bee foraging activity during the daywas greater in the morning (53.18%), than in the afternoon (46.82%). The times ofgreater activitywere from 07:01 to 12:00 hours and fram 13:01 to 17:00 hours, particularly during the intervals fram 09:00 to 11 :00 and from 13:00 to 16:00 hours. KEYWORDS: bees Bico-do-Papagaio region, seasonal activity, flight activity, INTRODUCTION The spatiotemporal abundance patterns of bees on flowers are varied. Floral density, the phenological synchrany of the activity of adults with plant blooming and flower anthesis, and the biogeography ofbees and their food preferences constitute sources of information on the abundance of species in the habitat (Cane & Payne 1993). Studies on bee fauna and their associated flora in the Amazon region have been conducted by different authors, in order to obtain knowledge of the diversity of species of these insects (Morato & Campos 2000; Santos et aI. IUniversidade Federal do Recôncavo da Bahia, 44380-000. Cruz das Almas-BA, Brazil. 2lnstituto Brazil. de Desenvolvimento 3Escola Superior de Agricultura Rural do Estado do Tocantins, "Luiz de ~eiroz", 77000-000, Palmas-TO, USP, 13418-900. Piracicaba-SP, Brazil. 1178 Sociobiology Vol. 50, No. 3, 2007 2004) and on the flora utilized to collect trophic resources (Absy et aI. 1984; Carreira & Jardim 1994; Marques-Souza 1996). The information obtained in this type of study has been more and more useful in environmental diagnoses. Pollinators and other anthophiles play the role ofbioindicator organisms; their presence, abundance, and activity can convey relevant information abolit the status of the environment in which they are found (Kevan 1999). Another current application is concerned with their use as a elimatic monitoring too!, since insects are strongly affected by elimatic variabilities (Gordo & Sanz 2006). Another research component stilllittle studied in connection with bee communities in this region is species phenology, in which their foraging activities are investigated. The temporal variation in number ofindividuals and species may be related to the availability of food sources, degree of socialization, multivoltinism of species, longlife cyeles and intraspecific characteristics (Sakagami et aI. 1967; Michener 1990). Solitary bee species can decrease their activities during one or more periods of the year, while eusocial species remain active throughout the year (Barbola & Laroca 1993; Carvalho 1999). The objective ofthis studywas to obtain information abolit the community ofbees and their seasonal activity in a Transition Area between the Cerrado and the Amazon Region in Brazil. MATERIAL AND METHODS Bees were collected every fifteen days in two trails demarcated in the localities ofEsperantina (5° 20' 1" S; 48° 35' 28" W; 118.88m) and Mulatos (5° 20' 28" S; 48° 29' 12"W; 144.94m), between 11/30/1999 and 11/08/2000, in the municipality ofEsperantina, in the Bico-do-Papagaio region, State of Tocantins, Brazil. The collected specimens were killed with cotton soaked in ethyl acetate, previously placed in different containers. Identification was based on specimens deposited in the Bee Collection of the Entomological Museum at the Agronomy School ofUniversidade Federal da Bahia, and on taxonomic keys. Some species were forwarded to specialists. The specimens were deposited in the Bee Collection ofInstituto de Desenvolvimento Rural do Estado do Tocantins (Ruraltins) in Palmas-TO; duplicate specimens were Carvalho, C.A. et aI. - Phenology ofBees 1n a Transition Area in Brazil 1179 donated to the Entomological Museum at UFBA's Agronomy School and to the specialists who helped with species identification. Study site characteristics The region where the study was developed has a hot and humid climate, characterized by a mean temperature of25°C, with an annual rainfall index between 1,000-1,800 mm and an annual temperature amplitude between 0.8°C and 3.2°C (Feitosa 1983). The rainfall regime is typically tropical, with two defined seasons: a rainy season beginning in December and-extending unti! Apri!, and a dry season, with scattered rains fram May to December. The typical vegetation in the area is the result of deforestation for the establishment of pastures and other agricultural activities, and mainly comprises shrubby and herbaceous species, also including ruderal vegetation elements. Sampling The trails, appraximately 1,000 meters in length, were traveled in the period fram 05:00 to 18:00 hours by two collectors. This route was traveled twice during the collections (morning and afternoon), tak:ing between 5 and 10 minutes per planto During that period, any bees visiting flowers were captured with an insect neto This bee-collectingmethodology, based on Sakagami et ai. (1967), iswidely used in similar studies (Barbola & Laraca 1993; Carvalho 1999). RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Eighty-three bee species were collected, having their activity distributed over the study period. Two distinct periods were observed, i.e., the rainy period between the months ofDecember and April, and the drought period between May and November (Table 1; Fig. 1). In the rainy period, the highest number of specimens was collectedin March (14.33% of total), while in the dry period the months ofJune (13.52%) and July (13.79%) were important. The number ofbees collected decreased in the months of April and May, probably because this is a transition period between the rainy and dry seasons. ?Vloo-VlZ~3713õ'NÕ27x xxx 92distriburion, xMar xxxxDec xx 3862 32 xx õ' 7 Oet Feb May Ju] Jun o?~nTable 1.xxxNov Sep Apr Jan ~ Aug Temporal '--< •....• x 11 xxTotal 63 2000 xxx 1999 3 4 x x 48721 xxx 1 1 Ox xx 1 x 6 x xx total number ofindividuals colleetedxx by 'peeies, and total nllmber ofbee species (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) in 64 the a transition arca between aq 00 •....• '" •..... x 5' 1 x xx 451 x xx xx xOct ,., :-10 4x 4 xx 12 14 23 x 12000 xxx xx 1999 xxx xMar xxxxx xx n I~ 73 20 17 73xx xxxx 11 3 xxxx,.,x 49 19 5] xx xTotal ,..,. 10 '" '< 19 ,..,., ::> x xx Nov ;r x x 8 Dec Feb Õ 9::>() xx 6 '" '"~ < Jun 2; ~ Jul Jan n Sep Apr Table I.May Aug Temporal disrriburion, total number ofindividuals collected by species, and total nllmber ofbee speeies (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) in a transition area between the ~ Õ5" '" ns:: ~. Cerrado and the Amazon in rhe Bico-do-Papagaio region, State ofTocantins, Brazil: 1999-2000 (conrinlled). Species ao •..... '" O b::I O (fQ b::I >-;j " en rhe o 00 l'-l o õ' Õ O •....• -...] ?~o (fq xxx xx xx xx xFeb C/1 ü xMar x6 x38 x7 Õ 214 48 351 137 96 31n 5Z 3 Dec 11 22 276 23 29 19 328 318 207 Oct 13 230 333 35 Nov l'-lxxx xx 763 3115534 253 793 399 748 672 29 Jun May Jan V> 83 Sep Jul Apr Aug ::» 4 xxx'<x 132 3 x x xx 6 3 xTotal xx 34 I 2000 xx27 2 xxx 1999 xx 10 133 xx 1 xx 4 x Cerrado and the Amazon in rhe Bico-do-Papagaio region, State oETocamins, Brazil: 1999-2000 (cominued). Species x x 54 •....• Carvalho, C.A. et aI. - Phenology ofBees 1n a Transition Rainy period '" '" a. 62825 45 TI. 10 Z '"'" E Õ Z c~00 10 '(3 .~ 30 10 .s 300 '" o 15 150 15 ~'"450 350 25 35 100 50 16 §'(3~4Õ'0.~OÓo...~O-;;; §O 20 200 250 12 Ó ~ 40 C ãi 14 gj O 20 Dry period ____ í"----r- --- -------! 1183 Area in Brazil oom _ __ . ._ .m._. ~ i II ,I ! ! I ; I i I i . I I 7i ..j __ l_._..__.._..__ ._._. __ ~ 2~ ~ O> oO:O~ ~ ªa.z8o '" :o ...., '"O> ...., u.. ';:, '":::;: <l: ...., (f) 52 :::;: &J ~ Months Fig. 1. Monthly between disrribmion rhe Cerrado 1999-2000. :;~oo '" <l: :o õ > of bees, number of plants visited, and precipitation and rhe Amazon in the Bico-do-Papagaio in a transition region, 5tare ofTocantins, are a Brazil: 1184 Sociobiology Vol. 50, No. 3, 2007 It was observed that after the activity peaks that occurred in the months of June and July there was a reduction in the number of bees collected, as well as in the number ofbee species and blooming plams. The smallest amoum of precipitation in the Bico-do- Papagaio region occurred in the month of August, which may have influenced the number of blooming pIam species, direcdy imerfering with bee activity. Limited periods of availability offood resources, with a consequem reduction in foraging activity, comrasts with the observed need for a permanem food supply, especially in eusocial bee colonies, in arder to maimain their populations duringthe food scarcity period (Lorenzon et aI. 2003). Consideringthe distribution ofindividuals collected in the rainy and drought periods, a certain balance is observed, with a slight advamage during the drought period (54.37%) (Fig. 2). Similarly, the distribution in number ofbee species was also balanced, with 19.28% found in each period and 61.45% in both (Fig. 3). Among the species collected, 21 showed eusocial behavior, while the other species consisted of solitary, parasitic, and primitive social groups. The variability in social behavior makes it difllcult to imerpret the wide distribution of individuaIs over the year. In addition, according to Sakagami et aI. (1967), the phenology is difllcult to establish when individuaIs are dis- § Rainy period K!l Dry period 45.63 54.37 93.09% 6.91 % Figo 2. Disrriburion = social species = solitary species (%) of rhe number a transirion area berween rhe Cerrado Tocantins, Brazil: 1999-2000. 90.69% = social species 9.31 % = solitary species ofbee individuaIs and rhe Amazon collecred in rhe rainy and dry periods in in rhe Bico-do-Papagaio region, Srare of Carvalho, C.A. et aI. - Phenology ofBees In a Transition Area in Brazil 1185 tributed throughout the year, since it is influenced by ditlerem factors. This characteristic is observed particularly in the tropics. According to Michener (1990), the tropical region may favor the foundation of nests and brood production during all seasons of the year because of mild wimers, According to Roubik (1989), three to eight generations a year can be produced in tropical, solitary bee species where adults occur during most of the year. However, Albuquerque (2001) did not find a relation between climatic characteristics and the annual activity ofbees in the Baixada Maranhense region, State of Maranhão, Brazil, and did not observe clear variation in abundance of individuaIs and species between the dry and rainy periods. The decrease in number of collected individuaIs at a given period of the year may also be associated with the presence of more attractive food sources in the vicinity of the study area (Pedro 1992). Another possible explanation for the fact that these groups of bees have ditlerem distributions over the year has been presemed by Biesmeijer et aI. (2005) and Biesmeijer & Slaa (2006). According to these aurhors, among the characteristics of eusocial bees, the presence of activity throughout the seasons and the exploitation of an ample trophic niche are worth noting, Consequendy, these bees are considered generalists when compared with other oligolectic or non-social species. Despite the difllculties found in imerpretingthe distribution ofindividuals, several authors have reported on the seasonality ofbees, trying to understand à. o Rainy period O Dry period b::l80th periods 19.28% Fig. 3. Distribmion (%) of the number of bee species collected in the rainy and dry periods in a transition area between the Cerrado and the Amazon in the Bico-do-Papagaio region, State of Tocantins, Brazil: 1999-2000. 1186 Sociobiology Vol. 50, No. 3, 2007 the species dynamics in different ecosystems (Albuquerque Barros et aI. 2002). & Rêgo 1989; In a "caatinga" vegetation of the State ofBahia, Aguiar & Zanella (2005) observed the occurrence of a higher number of active bee species during the rainy season when compared to the dry season. They also observed that the number of active bees was relatively high in the initial part of the dry season, decreasing in the subsequent months. The opposite situation was observed in the initial period of the rainy season, possibly because those were transition periods. In the south of Brazil, Sakagami et aI. (1967) found an intermediate phenological pattern between temperate and tropical climates. In a study conducted in a humid tropical climate area of Costa Rica, Heithaus (1979) observed species of all families throughout the year, although seasonal species were found to be active either in the dry ar in the wet season. Aguiar & Martins (1997) studied the phenology ofbees in São João do Carirí-Paraíba, Brazil, and found a seasonal pattern with greater abundance of species and individuaIs in the rainy period, with a decrease in the low precipitation period. In the species Ceblurgus longipalpis, Aguiar & Martins (1994) observed that adult individuaIs would appear during the rainy season, in synchrony with the greater abundance of their associated flora. When the foraging activities ofbees were analyzed througholit the day, it was observed that 53.18% of the individuaIs were collected in the morning (05:00 to 12:00hours), while46.82%werecapturedin theatternoon (12:01 to 18 :00 hours). Albuquerque & Mendonça (1996) observed ahigher frequency of foraging individuaIs on flowers in the morning during most of the year. The times with the most activitywere from 07:01 to 12:00 hours in the morning and from 13:01 to 17:00 hours in the atternoon, with emphasis on the intervals from 09:00 to 11 :00 and from 13:01 to 16:00 hours. The times with the least activitywere from 05:00 to 06:00 and from 17:01 to 18:00 hours (Fig. 4). There was a progressive reduction in the number of individuaIs collected in the period from 11:01 to 13:00 hours, which might be associated with high temperature ar the collection of other resources out of the trail, such as water (Carvalho 1999). Carvalho, C.A. et aI. - Phenology ofBees In a Transirion Area in Brazil 1187 Several authors cited by Pereboom & Biesmeijer (2003) reported that bee species from tropical and subtrapical regions are subject to high ambient temperatures and heat production fram flight and foraging activities. This kind of information has pravided support to several studies, including those that focus on the life history of bees, foraging ecology, niche division, and biogeographic distribution patterns of species. These results are similar to those found by other authors, such as Pedro (1992), who observed the highest frequency ofindividuals between 10:00 and 14:00 hours, while the lowest frequency was observed between 16:00 and 18:00 hours; Aguiar & Martins (1994), who observed the flower-visiting activity of C. longipalpis to be about 08:00 hours, extending up to the time when the flowers remained viable, around 15 :00 hours; and Carvalho (1999), who observed the greatest flight activity by hourly interval between 09:00 and 10:00 hours and between 13:00 and 14:00 hours. The reduction in flower visitation throughout the day could be also related to the etlect of previous visitations made by other bees to those flowers, ~ oN rá:i oC;:..:.o?, 'éó &:i ái &:i r:..: .9 ~ 700 300 400 o 500 100 200 O I 600 .z~Õ-o:~-ooc: , ~ ~o ~ , , 555 Fig. 4. Distribution of rhe number ofbees collecred on flowers by hourly interval in a transirion area berween rhe Cerrado and rhe Amazon in rhe Bico-do-Papagaio region, 5rare ofTocantins, Brazil: 1999-2000. 1188 Sociobiology Vol. 50, No. 3, 2007 exhausting potential fonts of resources. Thus, WilIiams (1998) cited several srudies that indicate the rejection of flowers with low nectar reserves by Apis mellifira and Bombus spp. foragers. Gonçalves & others (1996) observed that meliponines were more active in the morning (08:00 to 10:00 hours), whileA. mellifira was more abundant between 11 :00 and 15:00 hours. The peak activity of Melipona species observed by Sommeijer & others (1983) aiso occurred in the morning, around 08:00 hours, the period with the highest polIen collection intensity. Ir is important to point out the existence ofvariation in this activitywithin the same genus, as observed for M asilvai by Souza & others (2006), in which the peak offlight activityto colIect resources occurred in the period comprised between 10:01 and 15:00 hours, with polIen colIection concentrated in the morning. InM scutellaris, however, Pierrot & Schlindwein (2003) observed greater foraging activity in the first four hours of observation, beginning at 05:00 hours. In addition, this period concentrated 90% of alI polIen colIections made during the day. Knowledge about this variation in flight activity displayed by various bee species is important as it generates information that can be used in pollinator management programs and biology srudies, as welI as in studies on the genetic potential of the colony and on foraging behavior, among others (Hilário et alo 2000). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank the Director of the "Instituto de Desenvolvimento Rural do Estado do Tocantins" - RURAL TINS; the Association ofBeekeepers from Bico-do- Papagaio region - ABIP A; and the taxonomists J.M.E Camargo and S.R.M. Pedra (Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil), E.A.B. Almeida and EA. Silveira (Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil), E Zanella (Universidade Federal da Paraíba, Brazil) and G.A.R. Melo (Universidade Federal do Paraná, Brazil) for the valuable identification of the bees. C.A.L. Carvalho and B.A. Souza thanks CNPq Research felIowship for partial support. REFERENCES Absy, M.L.J.M.F. Camargo, W.E. Kerr & L.P.A. Miranda 1984. Espécies de plantas visitadas por Meliponinae (Hymenoptera, Apoidea), para coleta de pólen na Região do Médio Amazonas. Rev Bras Biol44: 277-237. Carvalho, C.A. et aI. Aguiar, C.M.L. & C.E Martins Phenology of Bccs In a Transition Arca in Brazil 1994. Fenologia longipalpis Urban e Moure, 1993 (Hymenoptera, Biol9: 125-131. e preferência alimentar Halictidae, Dufoureinae). 1189 de Ceblurgus Rev Nordest Aguiar, C.M.L. & C.E Martins 1997. Abundância relativa, diversidade e fenologia de abelhas (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) na caatinga, São João do Cariri, Paraíba, Brasil. Iheringia Série Zoologia 83: 151-163. Aguiar, C.M.L. & EC.v. Zanella 2005. Estrutura de comunidade de abelhas (Hymenoptera: Apoidea: Apiformis) de uma área na margem do domínio da caatinga (Itatim, BA). Neotrop Entomol34: 15-24. Albuquerque, P.M.C., R.G. Ferreira, M.M.C. Rêgo, C.S. Santos & C.M.S. Brito 2001. Levantamento da fauna de abelhas silvestres (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) na região da "baixada maranhense": Vitória do Mearim, MA, Brasil. Acta Amaz 31: 419-430. lbuquerque, P.M.C., & ].A.C. Mendonça 1996. Anthophoridae (Hymenoptera: Bora associada em uma formação de cerrado no município de Barreirinhas, Acta Amaz 26: 45-54. Apoidea) e MA, Brasil. lbuquerque, P.M.C. & M.M.C. Rêgo 1989. Fenologia das abelhas visitantes de murici (Brysonima crassiftlia, Malpighiaceae). BoI Mus Para Emilio Goledi Ser Zool 5: 163- 178. Barbola, 1.E & S. Laroca 1993. A comunidade de Apoidea (Hymenoptera) da Reserva Passa Dois (Lapa, Paraná, Brasil): L Diversidade, abundância relativa e atividade sazonal. Acta Biol Paran22: 91-113. Barros, T.F., C.A.L. Carvalho, N.M. Brito, O.M. Marques,].B.A. Costa, c.F.B. Damasceno, L.R.C. Passos E.S.P. Santos 2002. Abelhas visitantes de Bores de Pimpinella anisum L. Magistra 14: 55-60. Biesmeijer,].C.,E.]. Slaa, M.S. Castro, B.F. Viana,A.M.P. Kleinerr & Y.L. Imperatriz-Fonseca 2005. Connectance ofbrazilian social bee - food plant networks is inBuenced by habitat, but not by latitude, altitude or network size. Biota Neotfopica 5: 1-9. Biesmeijer, ].c. & E.]. Slaa 2006. The structure of eusocial bee assemblages in Brazil. Apidologie 37: 240-258. Cane,]. &]. Payne 1993. A regional, annual and seasonal variation in pollinator guilds: trisect traits ofbees (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) underlie their patterns of abundance at Vaccinium ashei (Ericaceae). Ann Ent Soc Am 86: 577-588. Carreira, L.M.M. & M.A.G.Jardim 1994. Análise polínica dos méis de alguns municípios do estado do Pará. Boi Mus Para Emílio Goeldi Sér Bot 10: 83-89. Carvalho, c.A.L. 1999. Diversidade de abelhas (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) no município de Castro Alves-BA [Ph.D Thesis]. Piracicaba (SP): Universidade de São Paulo. 104p. Feitosa, A.C. 1983. O Maranhão primitivo: uma tentativa de reconstituição. São Luís, Augusta. 142p. Apidae) e Gonçalves, S.].M., M. Rêgo & A. Araújo 1996. Abelhas sociais (Hymenoptera: seus recursos Borais em uma região de mata secundária, Alcântara, MA, Brasil. Acta Amaz 26: 55-68. 1190 Sociobiology Vol. 50, No. 3, 2007 Gordo, O. & J.J. Sanz 2006. Temporal trends in phenology of rhe honey bee Apis mellifera (L.) and the small white Pieris rapae (L.) in the Iberian Peninsula (1952-2004). Ecol Entomol3l: 261-268. Heithaus, E.R. 1979. Community structure of neotropical flower visiting bees and wasps: diversity and phenology. Ecology 60: 190-202. Hilário, S.D., v.L. Imperatriz-Fonseca & A.M.P. Kleinert 2000. Flight activity and colony strength in the stingless bee Melipona bicolor bicolor (Apidae, Meliponinae). Bio160: 299-306. Kevan, P.G. 1999. Pollinators as bioindicators of the stare ofthe environment: Rev Bras species, activity and diversity. Agric Ecosyst Environ 74: 373-393. Lorenzon, M.C.A. C.A.R.Matrangolo & J.H. Schoereder 2003. Flora visitada pelas abelhas eussociais (Hymenoptera, Apidae) na Serra da Capivara, em Caatinga do sul do Piauí. Neotrop Entomol32: 27-36. Marques-Souza, A.C. 1996. Fontes de pólen exploradas porMelipona compressipes manaosensis (Apidae: Meliponinae), abelha da Amazônia CentraL Acta Amaz 26: 77-86. Michener, C.D. 1990. Classification of the Apidae (Hymenoptera). Univ Kansas Sci Bul 54: 75-164. Morato, E.E & L.A.O. Campos 2000. Efeitos da fragmentação florestalsobrevespas solitárias em uma área da Amazônia CentraL Rev Bras Zoo117: 429-444. Pedro, S.R.M.1992. Sobre as abelhas (Hymenoptera, e abelhas Apoidea) em um ecossistemade cerrado (Cajuru, NE do Estado de São Paulo): composição, fenologia e visita às flores [MSc. ThesisJ Ribeirão Preto (SP): Universidade de São Paulo. 200p. Pereboom, J.J.M. & J.c. Biesmeijer 2003. Thermal consrraints for stingleess bee foragers: the importance ofbody size and coloration. Oecologia 137: 42-50. Pierrot, L.M. & C. Schlindwein 2003. Variation on daily flight activity and foragingpatterns in colonies of uruçu - Melipona scutellaris Latreille (Apidae, Meliponini). Zoo120: 565-571. Roubik, D.W. 1989. Ecology and natural history of tropical bees. Cambridge: University Press, 514p. Sakagami, S.E, S. Laroca (PR), South Brazil253-91. & J.S. Moure 1967. Wild bees biocenotics preliminary report. J Fac Sci Hokkaido Santos, EM., C.A.L. Carvalho & R.E Silva 2004. Diversidade Rev Bras Cambridge in São José dos Pinhais Univ Ser Zoology 19: de abelhas (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) em uma área de transição Cerrado-Amazônia. Acta Amaz 34: 319-328. Sommeijer, M.]., G.A. Rooy, W. Punt & L.L.M. Bruijn 1983. A comparative studyofforaging behavior of pollen resources of various stingless bee (Hymenoptera, Meliponinae) and honeybees (Hymenoptera, Apidae) in Trindad, West-Indies. Apidologie 14: 205224. Souza, B.A., c.A.L. Carvalho & R.M.O. Alves 2006. Flight activity of Melipona asilvai Moure (Hymenoptera: Apidae). BrazJ Bio166: 731-737. Williams, C.S. 1998. The identity of the previous visitor influences nectar-collecting bees. Anim Behav 56: 673-681. flower rejection by