Manila Cavite Toll Expressway (MCTE)

Implemented, On-going, and Future
TRANSPORT PROJECTS
In
CAVITE-LAGUNA AREA
Population Projection, 2010-2030
9,000
MM
Cavite
Laguna
Total
8,000
Population (1000)
JICA Assisted
Feasibility Study and Implementation Support on the CALA
East-West National Road Project for the DPWH
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
2030
2040
Year
Existing Road Network
Metro Manila Skyway (MMS)
PNCC
P.T. Citra Lamturo Bong Persada of Indonesia
CITRA Metro Manila Tollway Corporation (CMMTC)
Implemented MMS Stage 1: Pasay Road – Bicutan Skyway 9.3 kms
Magallanes – Alabang – 13.4 kms
(Widening and Improvement)
Proposed MMS Stage 2: Bicutan – Alabang Skyway – 7.0 kms
Manila Cavite Toll Expressway (MCTE)
PEA
Renong of Malaysia
Manila Cavite Tollway Corporation (MCTC)
33
Daang Hari Road
DPWH Region IV-A Southern Tagalog Region
and DPWH NCR Metro Manila
Molino Boulevard
Manila Cavite Toll Expressway (MCTE) Extension
DPWH Region IV-A Southern Tagalog Region
X
PEA
Renong Group of Malaysia
Manila Cavite Tollway Corporation
PEA
Partner ?
Concessionaire ?
C5 Expressway
Metro Manila Skyway Extension, Stage 2
(A component of Manila Cavite Toll Expressway (MCTE)
PNCC
PEA
X
Renong Group of Malaysia
MMS Stage 2: Bicutan, Sucat Skyway 3.2 kms
Manila Cavite Tollway Corporation
PEA
P.T. Citra Lamturo Bong Persada
Citra Metro Manila Tollway corporation (CMMTC)
● DPWH to construct substructure
● CMMTC to construct superstructure and toll operation
Partner ?
Concessionaire ?
SLE Extension to
Sto. Tomas, Batangas and Alabang Viaduct
PNCC
STAR, Phase II
X
Hopewell Crown
Concessionaire?
PNCC
NDC
Concessionaire
SIDC
Implemented STAR Stage 1: Sto. Tomas-Lipa – 22 kms
Committed STAR Stage 2: Lipa-Batangas – 20 kms
MOA for Stage 2
DPWH
TRB
SIDC
● DPWH construct to 2 lane highway P1.38B
● SIDC – upgrade to 4 lane tollway road facility and toll operation
34
SLE Extension Calamba-Lucena
PNCC
North – South (CALABARZON Expressway)
X
Hopewell Crown
Concessionaire?
PEA
Partner ?
Concessionaire
35
East - West
LRT 1: Extension to Cavite
Traffic Management
Pala-Pala Interchange
The Overall Road Network Plan
36
“A planner must strive to expand
choice and opportunity for all persons,
recognizing a special responsibility to
plan for the needs of the disadvantage
groups and persons, and must urge the
alteration of policies, and decisions
which oppose such needs”
CALA East-West National Road Project
First Stakeholders’ Meeting
-American Institute of Certified Planners(AICP) Code
Stakeholders’ Meeting
JICA Policy on ESC
Stakeholders’meeting is a specific form of Participatory Rapid
Appraisal (PRA) a research technique developed in the late
1970s and early 1980s by researchers in international
development as an alternative and complement to conventional
sample surveys.
Democratic decisiondecision-making is
indispensable for environmental and social
considerations, and, in order to achieve an
appropriate decisiondecision-making process, it is
important to ensure stakeholder
participation, information transparency,
accountability, and efficiency in addition to
respect for human rights.
PRA is a way of learning from , and with, community members
to investigate, analyze, and evaluate constraints and
opportunities, and make informed and timely decisions
regarding development projects.
Main Study Flow
Participatory Rapid Appraisal (PRA) is an intensive,
systematic but semi-structured learning experience
carried out in a community by multi-disciplinary team
which includes community members.
It can be used for :
• needs assessment
• feasibility studies
• identifying priorities for development
• implementing development activities
where new information needs to be
collected
• monitoring and evaluating development
activities
37
It requires attitudes favoring:
• participation
• respect for community members
• interest on what they know, say, show
and do
• patience, not rushing, and
not interrupting
• listening, not lecturing
• humility
• methods which empower community
members to express, share, enhance,
and analyze their knowledge
JICA CALA F/S
Participatory Rapid Appraisal
EIS Process
Preparation of Alternative Scenarios
Social & Environmental Constraints
- socially vulnerable facilities/areas
- protection and constrained areas
Assessment of Alternative Scenarios
-IEE Study for alternatives
-Social Assessment
∆: 1st STM
Letter of intent
Formulation of Optimum Project Plan
Resettlement Framework
Scoping process
EIA Study
Feasibility Study
Preliminary RAP
Preparation of
EIS document
Submission of
EIS document
ECC acquisition
Detailed Design
-Finalization of ROW
Parcellary survey
-set of cut-off date
Detailed EMMP
Complete RAP
Preparation of resettlement
Construction
Land acquisition & resettlement
Operation & Maintenance
Monitoring & evaluation
Implementation
of EMMP
∆: 3rd STM
∆: 8th STM
Video Segment of a Barangay Consultation
Overall Schedule of Environmental & Social Considerations
Task
Main Study Items
Preparation of survey implementation
Verification of prerequisite and
preparation of transport network
development
1
2
Main Tasks of ESC
Explanation on project and
study process
Explanation on procedures of
stakeholder meetings
March 17
Preparation of the Environmental Impact Statement of the
Proposed Urdaneta Bypass Road Project
Review of necessary
environmental process
• Collection of baseline data
• Initial social assessment
• Preparation of draft scoping
•
Assessment of alternative scenarios
and selection of the optimum scenario
Schedule
•
•
3
Stakeholders’
Stakeholders’ Meeting
•
•
ESC study (IEE level) of
alternatives
Social assessment of
alternatives
Confirmation on principle of
preparation of scenarios
ESC study (IEE level)
• Impacts to the area in case of
zero option
July
Outline of alternatives
Alternative measure in zero
option
• Scope and methodologies for
ESC study (EIA level)
October
•
•
4
Formulation of the Optimum Project
Plan
Environmental and social
evaluation on alternative routes
Preparation of Resettlement
Framework
• ESC study (EIA level)
• Support of EIS process
•
•
•
•
Overall Schedule of Environmental & Social Considerations
Task
5
Main Study Items
Feasibility Study of EastEast-West Road
and its Affiliated Works
Main Tasks of ESC
Stakeholders’
Stakeholders’ Meeting
Schedule
ESC study (EIA level)
• Preparation of Resettlement
Action Plan (RAP)
• Support of EIS Process
•
Results of the ESC study
Overall evaluation on project
validity
• Mutual consent on optimum
project
March 2006
Outline of F/S
FollowFollow-up of the ESC study
Explanation of resettlement
policy
May
Progress of F/S
Explanation of framework of
RAP
July
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Outline results of F/S
Mutual consent on framework
of RAP
September
38